Raport o stanie projektu FAIR przedstawiony w oparciu o folie
prof.W. Henninga, dyrektora GSI, oraz H. Wenningera kierujcego
pracami STI i H.-F Wagnera kierujcego pracami AFI Reinhard Kulessa
UJ Warszawa 11 stycznia 2006 r.
Slide 2
The International Committee Structure for FAIR PAC QCD
E.Chiavassa PAC NUSTAR R.Casten PAC APPA D.Schwalm TAC Yanglai Cho
Observers: FAIR Project Cost Review Groups Core-E D.Plane Core-A W.
Bartels Full Cost Structure Group B. Brandt AFI Working Group
Administrative and Funding Issues H.F.Wagner Legal Working Group
U.B. Jahn STI Working Group Scientific + Technical Issues Horst
Wenninger ISC International. Steering Committee H.Schunck
Slide 3
FAIR Technical & Scientific Status November 2005 Initial
scientific programme defined (based on CDR, LoI's (June 04), and
Technical Proposals submitted January 2005 and evaluated by PAC's /
TAC and STI): ~70 international workshops (post CDR) 2100
international scientists as authors of the proposals 2003-2004 ~
8,4 M (national) & ~ 12,6 M (internationa l) effort 2005 ~ 80
FTE (national) und ~ 120 FTE (international) STI & PAC/TAC
reviews performed (60 international members) STI Recommendations
completed see presentation by STI Chair H. Wenninger Accelerator
development underway (R&D and proto-typing) Draft Technical
Reports / Draft Cost Book available & under evaluation
(TAC/miniTAC's und STI); project definition and T(D)R by mid-March
2006); cost reviews by CORE-E & A and mini-TAC's 3(6) consortia
(& bilateral MoUs) for R&D and construction of the
accelerators 2003-2004 ~ 18,9 M (national) and ~ 0,8 M
(international) effort 2005 ~ 100 FTE (national) und ~ 20 FTE
(international) see presentation by STI Chair H. Wenninger
Comprehensive civil construction and building pre-planing performed
(Eng.-Co. BUNG) 'Offenlegung & Brgerversammlung' of Civil
Construction Plan (Nov.3, 2005) Final version T(D)R underway, based
on new layout (and staging) Regulatory and legal processes
initiated, environmental impact study completed: 20 regulatory
procedures (of these 9 concluded in the meantime) 8 environmental
impact studies (UVS) radiation safety study completed and
preliminary approval received Development of organisational, cost
and management structure see presentation by AFI CHAIR H-F. Wagner
T(D)R in March 2006, with cost, schedule and overall project
definition
Slide 4
24 November 2005FAIR STI - ISC Berlin4 FAIR Scientific and
Technical Issues working group Mandate Accompany preparations of
FAIR Technical Design Reports Evaluate the advancement of
prototyping of critical components Present the three phases of FAIR
project realisation scientific goals and costs of each realisation
step Explore cost of construction and operation of the facility
Cost-book: material / personnel /risk budget Resource loaded
schedule with milestone/critical path/ AFI complements for legal -
financial issues, procedures, contracts,..
Slide 5
PAC on Nuclear Structure and Nuclear Astrophysics (NUSTAR-PAC):
667 users 1.) Low Energy Branch (LEB) High-resolution In-Flight
Spectroscopy (HISPEC)/ Zs.Podolyak/ Surrey Decay Spectroscopy with
Implanted Ion Beams (DESPEC)+ B. Rubio Valencia Precision
Measurements of very short-lived Nuclei using an Advanced Trapping
System for highly-charged Ions (MATS)K.Blaum Mainz LASER
Spectroscopy for the Study of Nuclear Properties (LASPEC)P.
Campbell Manchester Neutron Capture Measurements (NCAP)M.Heil FZK
Antiprotonic Radioactive Nuclides (Exo+pbar)M. Wada Riken 2.) High
Energy Branch (R3B) A Universal Setup for Kinematical Complete
Measurements of Reactions with Relativistic Radioactive Beams
(R3B)T. Aumann GSI 3.) Ring Branch (STORIB) Study of Isomeric
Beams, Lifetimes and Masses (ILIMA)Y.Novikov SPNPI Exotic Nuclei
Studied in Light-Ion Induced Reactions at the NESR Storage Ring
(EXL)M. Chartier Liverpool Electron-Ion Scattering in a Storage
Ring (e-A Collider) (ELISe)H. Simon GSI Antiproton-Ion Collider: A
Tool for the Measurement of Neutron and Proton rms radii of Stable
and Radioactive Nuclei (AIC)R. Krcken TUM Technical Proposals
Slide 6
PAC on Quantum Chromo Dynamics (QCD-PAC): 909 users ASSIA Study
of Spin-dependent Interactions with AntiprotonsR.Bertini Torino
(90) CBM Compressed Baryonic Matter ExperimentP.SengerGSI (294)
PANDA Strong Interaction Studies with AntiprotonsU.WiednerTSL
Uppsala (348) PAX Antiproton-Proton Scattering Experiments with
PolarizationF.RathmannFZJ (177) PAC on Atomic Physics, Plasma
Physics and Applications (APPA-PAC) 578 users Laser Cooling of
Highly Charged Ions at SIS 100/300U. SchrammLMU FLAIR - A Facility
for Low-energy Antiproton and Ion ResearchE. Wiedman Tokyo SPARC
Stored Particles in Atomic physics ResearchR. SchuchStockholm
HEDGEHOB: High Energy Density matter Generated by Heavy-iOn Beams(
LAPLAS, HIHEX)D. Varentsov Darmstadt BIOMAT Applications of
Relativistic Ions in Radiobiology M. Durante Napoli and Space
Research/ Materials Research with Relativistic Heavy Ion Beams S.
KlaumnzerHMI WDM Radiative Properties of Warm Dense MatterF. B.
RosmejMarseille Technical Proposals
Slide 7
Slide 8
FAIR layout summer 2005
Slide 9
FAIR Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research: New Layout 100 m
UNILAC SIS 18 SIS 100/300 HESR Super FRS NESR CR RESR GSI today
Future Facility ESR
Slide 10
SIS100/300 Underground Tunnel 5 m -24 m Tunnel in Open-Pit
Construction Tunnel Drilling Machine
Slide 11
2004 2005 2006 Contract(s) Development Contract(s) Negotiations
Closing PAC's Technical Committees: PAC's & TAC Signing of MoU
Phase I Governed by MoU Phase II Governed by Contracts The ISC-FAIR
International Working Groups MoU Proposals / TR's LoI's (2100
authors) T(D)R (March 06) Evaluation by Advisory Committees (March
05) Cost Review by CORE group (Fall 05) Project Definition in
2005
Slide 12
Path of Evaluation ( both Investment and Operation cost )
Experiments: LoI PAC i TP PAC i TDRs CORE E Accelerator +
Infrastructure Projects:
Slide 13
Core Groupe E for Experiments CORE E Members: Wulfrin Bartel,
chair (ex DESY) large experiments H.G. Ritter LBLdetector systems,
electronics J.Simpson CCLRCgamma ray Detection A.Vacchi INFN
Triestesilicon detectors I.Lazarus CCLRCdetectors, exp.systems
H.J.Hilke ex-CERNexperiments, detectors P.Lazeyras ex-CERNgeneral
detector systems First Meeting scheduled May 30/31, job to be
finished by September 15, 2005
Slide 14
E-CORE Evaluation
Slide 15
EXAMPLE E-CORE evaluation of PANDA
Slide 16
PANDA Cost according to E-CORE
Slide 17
E- CORE cost table for all reviewed major FAIR experiments
Experiment Cost [k]UncertaintyRemarks MATS 253710 % Low risk LASPEC
59110 % Low risk SPARC Low risk Laser 109215 %Manpower NESR 550515
%Manpower R3B Manpower!! Phase I 1460020 %R & D Phase II 935520
%R & D PANDA 4883925 %Add 8818 k (risk) low prices, R&D
Manpower? CBM 6052020 %55950k down grade Manpower!!, R&D ILIMA
190215 %Manpower HISPEC/ DESPEC 1627720 %Manpower
Slide 18
Three stages according to fields of science: Three stages
according to fields of science: Stage 1: Radioactive beam physics
Nuclear structure and nuclear astrophysics Atomic physics studies
with highly charged/radioactive ions & plasma physics Stage 2:
Proton-antiproton physics QCD studies with protons and antiprotons
Precision studies with antiproton beams addressing fundamental
symmetries and interactions Stage 3 Full facility capability &
all research programs Full parallel operation of up to four
research programs Full energy and luminosity for nuclear collisions
program at CBM Precision QCD Studies at PANDA up to 15 GeV/c Plasma
research (full gain factor in power density: ~400) Atomic reaction
studies with fast beams
Slide 19
Next Steps: from today until March 2006 - Follow up on the
ideas on lowering the cost for the machine facilities -Get Draft of
Technical Report by end of the year -Get FAIR Cost Book validated
by AFI - Open new FAIR Project Division at GSI ( FAIR Technical
Director ) - Form further FAIR-Consortia with countries and
laboratories now: - On the way: HESR Sweden+FZJ+GSI, - NESR
Spain+GSI, - CR China+GSI, - LEB KVI+GSI - In preparation:
France+GSI, Italy+GSI, UK+GSI, Russia+GSI, CERN+GSI,
India+GSI,..... - Publish final FAIR Technical+Administrative
Report for Spring 2006
Slide 20
.......Strengthening the FAIR work force Personnel: Total GSI
working for FAIR FTE 72 New recruits 2005 for FAIR FTE 43
Slide 21
Administrative Issues Legal Structure Basic legal structure of
a future FAIR Limited Liability Company: Convention Articles of
Association By Laws Organs: Shareholders Assembly, Supervisory
Board, Managing Directors
Slide 22
Administrative Issues: Convention Convention was discussed in
detail three times Open at this moment: Germany has to clarify how
VAT for external contributions will be handled. F definitely will
not pay VAT. Handling of decommissioning. Details of In-kind
contributions: Paper by GSI very narrow to XFEL-paper. Transfer of
shares: seeking for joint position of D, F, I. Reaction of F, I is
missing so far. Transition from present GSI to FAIR: Paper with
details of GSI for next meeting. Things will be cleared at next
meeting January 16 Convention will then be ready on the level of
AFI to be submitted to ISC in spring
Slide 23
Administrative Issues: AoA Articles of Association discussed
once in full length. Not ready for submission to ISC Points of
interest for ISC: Voting rights Shares for construction and
operation different. Calculation of mix? Voting separated according
to special topics? Amount of majorities for voting on specific
subjects Final catalogue of responsibilities for shareholders
assembly and supervisory board
Slide 24
Administrative Issues: By-laws By-laws were not discussed yet
They will regulate the day by day business of the company Will be
tackled not before spring
Slide 25
Bonn, 22.11.2005 The International Facility for Antiproton and
Ion Research (FAIR) - Key points of the German position - Germany
strongly affirms its commitment to FAIR as an international
research facility in Darmstadt with a great long-term scientific
impact, in particular for Europe. FAIR will provide the European
and international science community with a worldwide unique and
innovative accelerator system to perform forefront research in
different areas especially concerned with the basic structure of
matter. The establishment of the international Facility for
Antiproton and Ion Research represents an important element of the
European Research Area. Germany greatly appreciates the high
interest and engagement of the international partners in the
preparation of FAIR. Due to this, significant progress in the
scientific, technical and administrative preparation of the project
following the signing of the Memorandum of Understanding on the
preparatory phase in 2004/05 has been reached. For Germany some key
points are essential in the further negotiations with its partners.
1) We should maintain the already reached momentum to start the
construction of FAIR swiftly to ensure the completion of the
facility in 2014. 2) This requires the creation of an efficient
scientific, technical and organisational unit, which will be
supported by Germany and its international partners in fair
partnership. 3) Departing from the position Germany has put forward
in the past, we are now seeking to establish an independent FAIR
Company for constructing and operating the facility alongside the
GSI for legal and general science policy reasons. This will not
affect the rights and obligations of the international partners as
discussed in AFI and ISC. We are just in discussion with our
Finance Ministry on that matter.