rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4...

13
,la nr:rnooqdowiu ralornr:dlJrnr:r6nfirirnrounsriorrrtunla'on!: 3rr fDrludul.l|lun Infl 210ll.|lnon!:ltt l'toouttnsn t: lnnt I rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oor"trilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z j ,. % lln3flltn:nlu lttndlllllnt lu{n t f, I %Harlltnoo | 2lln: ] o/o {l{lliion!: lt.rudnr?lln!a :linfuluiud e rs.rnr:rmeol nr:lidr:n:nrolryr6orrrnrh{n!{ri t "z iunjn'onl:niuiti rrrirrriniuiufi s towrrrnoor nr:liarrn:artrlcrdu!,r!nrludolrld nrrn6oln:ar:dl sdrlnc t% lnsrtrrn:arolt6uttrrtnrl dnlr{i'nnrnr: duodr rnrr x rirtiiiur:nirriirioe doufla:i:rrfiaiu'u1uiqfi atsmrrnoor nr:liri]rl:crh cr:arnrurn6o tn/nctfinla1u?nt&u I 4mr8% flr:o:ntomdsnarnr:dr odrro:I r.az 4o/o t teli1u!u1't 2szdurrldonl;nir:ifi rirnrnn'luiiuu:ntornrnnnol tm:i:rrn'niuluiuff s (n-lurn.:lunr:r,:fit ua::)

Transcript of rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4...

Page 1: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

,la

nr:rnooqdowiu ralornr:dlJrnr:r6nfirirnrounsriorrrtunla'on!: 3rr

fDrludul.l|lun Infl 210ll.|lnon!:ltt l'toouttnsn t: lnnt I

rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oor"trilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli zj , .% lln3flltn:nlu lttndlllllnt lu{n t f, I %Harlltnoo | 2lln: ] o/o {l{lliion!: lt.rudnr?lln!a

:linfuluiud e rs.rnr:rmeol nr:lidr:n:nrolryr6orrrnrh{n!{ri t "z iunjn'onl:niuitirrrirrriniuiufi s towrrrnoor nr:liarrn:artrlcrdu!,r!nrludolrld nrrn6oln:ar:dl

sdrlnc t% lnsrtrrn:arolt6uttrrtnrl dnlr{i'nnrnr: duodr rnr r x rirtiiiur:nirriirioe

doufla:i:rrfiaiu'u1uiqfi a tsmrrnoor nr:liri]rl:crh cr:arnrurn6o tn/nctfinla1u?nt&u I

4mr8% flr:o:ntomdsnarnr:dr odrro: I r.az 4o/o t teli1u!u1't 2sz durrldonl;nir:ifi

rirnrnn'luiiuu:ntornrnnnol tm:i:rrn'niuluiuff s (n-lurn.:lunr:r,:fit ua: :)

Page 2: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

9 9 E F F F F F EE F F E ; . € . . 8 . . F ' . F . . 5 . € . € . . F . F

c c c F - F e s €s E 3 5 s. . i . .F.€..F.€-.F.€.€..E

€ " . E' _ - F e 9 9 9 -F F F 5 5 F . = , E . 8 . . 8 . . E . . = . . 5 . . F . . F

= F f : ; l :

s F t s r " . E F - F ' ? ? ' ? ' ?F - ? i > r = r = . . - F F i r c s 6. . ._ _., . . i .+ . .= -5.€.,

o ' 5 - E - E - E . !F o e o E 9 F G a c =. i : F b = = . 3 , 3 F E F E E E E

T:G

EI "--S " - - S * i a i .

a ; ; ; t + += F F

= = : = F L t : :r + o \ o s o : e i i

S s s s s s s s s s s : + ; F* - d - - - r - : - e : t

= v 1 q a o o o t i G * ) - !. 5 A A ; A Z Z e ' € ' e 'E E : E . . i

i " =5 'c'

-a

q

-e

..3

.F=

-a

=

_f

Page 3: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

t: !a f- r? !: te r- !a ra ta !- r: r: r- !e

{a !: ': _r -2 _: !- [: r- != r= !- te r- t-

r= f- r: != f: r- fa ta {l !a r- r- t: r: It

frE

E- " - " - " t s s ; "; : : ; # + *

l G . G r F r c = ! : IE E E E t E E *+ + + + + + + s - S S d

5 "-- S s s S S S :e :Q S - s - F- - { - : - : - - =l v l r a Y t t l i= = = t. a a a 6 a 6 6 6 I g E b t b \ r

fl.E -.*H . F

--

\t

.F=

=

'ri

a

L

Page 4: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

l 0

f l - l : nnDln l t r ; l t t l l l t !dar i t0nt l taan a l

t. rnlornr:6rinrriqorr4ido.: 1z'l owlmr4oe;

riuinyrnorrrnirrdrlonuJdonudrfi qorrqi#o{ (27 ornrsnl4sd) nr|irnr:l{

ar:n;nrsIrytfi o!r!nrltt,i'alr,ki' : z fl fi lrl6uurioufi qn nr:l{nr: n:arolq16ulunrhry'otld

tvo Hc;uneo ltdz 46/o uasnrrl#ar:nrarsluds!r!nrlrr"i'ollld z x inr:rfinfirirnrnrlod nrr

1{sr:c::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::nrulqrdurr!nrhdnlvld t"z nalrn6o | !ax 2vo ra--rntf--alu Iufounrnr!-rdn!,ld'

tq" in r: rfinfirirn r,r runorr nr:ldrirrj:; rfinr:rfinf,rirn ral rnfiqn rnrni runrnr:rrfi l)

narsriirrrjoufi onr fionudlfi rlinuriqorr4i#or ru'i nr:ldar:a;arulvr60!r!- - i . - i - - J " z ; .n rl!,id}{ei J"" in r:ln-e: riulu iui 5 no In r:rndorrrori: rrfrqiuiosr t-toe" ro rn-ufifrry ri lu

nr:l#cr:o;arulryl6s!ruar1rlda1r,lf t lov z z" uornr:l{mrnrorolrytiulrunrltlry-alr{d ty.- i . - ;flflllnno l 2l rnr 4 % rJirnnlu lu-rl1r 4 ro{nr:rnao.|lrosfi:rrinfuir nnl{ (ll-20%) urilj

runniruran-n-n'rnr:1dar:nlnrul,nfi s!unrh,l-n1l,ld' : x lacnr:1{;1 :crhi:rrfiodulu- A - - i ;iuii I torn r:rnnourovi: ufrniurrnfr {n( :o<oq ot tn rvrfi 2 unv n r:- r rfi lt

nar:rirrfi onrd6onudlfir:hrrfiqorrnirio.r nndrilirlirrlr sorob solids (ss)

onnrrHndooltnn r:f rn r: indoun rrrfi:-rfnu r lnui ss orilurilrs.ls-t.szs"^uasrioitntr

irnr urin rr ao-n- rr j rlnii rirhiin r rlunnn nriu (n r: rrfi 5,

nr:r fi sulJordi!rsln:nluriu:nirr nr-ir lunr:ldlsldo!rrrnr1!daly',i z N niad . r l A - t a F i r

t% Hdrrndo | 2 J nfli 4olo nain r:liri r n r: rhrinu rfi qorr4irio r ff irrunr:frhrr:nldnnnr

rf;nriooriounr:16rfnsr rirunr:1iar:nrnrrlqr60rrrlnrhin}{dlrn,Ivoi;!rorn:nfi. . y ; J . . .lnlr:nldrriulni ndltunnd |ldun rradcilurlnririrro rn r:rnoo:1n r:Nfi s)

Page 5: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

l l

z. rarornrrrfi r:"nurff qul4i 5 ornrrnriua

rrorsrirrdorffdonrd6onldrriuinuriqarr4i s orarrqn16oa nu.jr nr:1{cr:n:nroffiriurnrtrlor1116olrrnrh"i'olyliinr:uliuuurJn.rfifirriooiqnuar1riinrurLnnirurrs6sr-

. , i - - - : ; ! , -lrasnl:lililrn r:lnnddtntaiuniltriiull:aro.!ntrrffioo!lnginr:rfinffritntoltniqn 1nrrfi :uaen't:1tfr 6)

ror:;rirrtjoufi{onr a'onudrr4rnr:rfi l inyriqarrql- s orerrvnrfluc yruir nr:1dar:ncnrulvr60!ujnr1lt.i'a1,ki' t un; z"t" Iii: rrfiodunoon n r: rnd o r( oeo ronriufifi-r) rilu

nrrldarrcvarulryt6orurnrlrdalr,ld :"2" locnr:ldarravarulv16urrn r1llda1r,lf rx rar- i "rno-o t 2I uol+ y. inr:rfrn:rfiurioo 1t-toz) ttdlrjttnnit.rvtrla6n-6lnt:l#er:a;aro lryr6ulru

. , : , , -nl l ! .rd lr in l | |d12 % {arnl: lautl l :ctt ! ' rrrn^niulua'ui t? 1o!nr:rnooirraci:trf infu!rn

(z t-rox) (nud n uor n'r:rrd r)

rnl:vrirrdJonr 6onld, rfirfiqorr4l- s o.:errlorioa lniirili ilrot solubte sotids

(ss) oqalf;ndodntniqriounr:r6l:"ngt lnui "s o{ludrl r.ss-r.stsx lo;rlnri.r:nhiinrrlj

unnnt.tnu1|ltflnn (nttlilYr8)

nr:ri6ouurlarrJilrarn:ni'hm:nld ornnr:r6l:-nurffoolr4i s ornrr,uar4oa lttt'ir

lurlndrirlornr:rnno.:i i!roto:nilrrr:nldanorrrnriounr:r6l:-nrr un:4ndril1u'

un nironrr nin' (nr:rlfi g)

t

Page 6: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

6

5

4

(E2

1

0

- A

a

'|

n

l 2

-frir

{-sustz

-*- sMs2%

-J<- sMst%

jlFsusr*rn6or"z

{- sus ty"rna'oz%

-l- sr.,tsry"andory"

7 - SltstV,rndalvn

c'lu'lu'lu

tuit n"uuunrrrn-oflrin ralufirr:nirrff onuJfionrrirfiqorr 4i#o r rudoirnr:iirnr:a:nrolvrdslurnrludo'h{d lsrr.ts) uac svs flclrrn6onruuildrrir,rl 1n:uuu :: Ai,rT niulru I :

3IUln'�lAl1,!)

I

3 4

nlu.lll.ltl

+ i l

{- sust.z,-d- sr,lszy"

*- st'.ls:.2"

rr(- sust*rroa'oty"

* sust./,lrnn'ozy"

* st"lsty"rn6ol%

- sMSlo/o+tnao4%

nrrid: n"uuunr:rfin:rfffirlc irriionr 6onudrfiqvn4irior dodrnr:{r slrs un: st',ts

nnrrndonlruirriuitll (n;uuu o : hji:r nctuu q: fi:r lt - qo x)

Page 7: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

l l

6

5

3

2

1

0

-a-ih

_|-sx{st{

-- sM9%

+ sr,{s,{

* sMsrtt{nislra

_a- sMirta,rnftt%

_-F sMslt(nn6'ot%

-svsl'rm664a\! \b \$ q,s .p +

irrn$5r

nujif n:uuunrrriaiirirnrnfiqorr4i s o.rarrrnriur rioi rn r: {lar:a: nrols16orrrnr'luinlrli (sMs) ndi sMs Harunn'on2rrlriu{udr{.t (n![ul.r 0 : !ji:r ncuuu I = i:r r r - 40o/o\

3

z5

2

1.5

,|

0.5

0

-{- ir

+ susl%

+sl{ga

+s s*

* suyrgrniorx

* sustrrnior*

-l- $rsl%ano'sltl

-srstNnoftg0 1 2 3 4 91011 12 t3 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 n 8 24 25 6 n 28

i n

; . ; J!]!i4 Rruu nr:lfinl;orrfiqorr4i s orarrariua riorirnr:ril sus un: sMs nnrrndonrrn

rirriuirq lnluuu o : !ii:r n:uuu l: i:r:r -qoyo)

Page 8: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

t4

nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm

woriua)

t l t l , nrrd60urrrla!fifir'lulllf lm'lR'lttnflot

ri.tuftir

SMS I%

SMS 27o

SMS 3%

St'lS tY. * tn6o t "Z

SIr S t"Z + rna'o z "1"

sus t"z + m6o : "z

srras tz + ma'o I Y"

3 c U

4.5b 4.

5a 5a

5a 4c

5a 4.5b

5a 4.5b

5a 5a

2d 2A

4c 3c

5c 4b

4c lc

4c 3c

4.5b 3.75b

5a 4b

ld td ld

4b 3.75b 3.75b

5a 5a 5a

3.7sb 3.15h 3.15b

4c 4b 4b

lb

5^

5a

5a

5a

5a

5a

F - test (0.01)

c.v.% 4.47 6.79 4.87 5.6 5.28 7.54 7.54

.* drndoinrurmneirrriurrain' fi ::n'lnlu16oriu s9 "/"

* d rndu'lJurnirrdrrrrn6n- i::n'u: rlris iu gg "t"

n'rlnr,rn r!e2uofl!llflrounu lufln!r (column) rfiurriu raa{.irlriin:rrrrnnir.rn'unrrAdirdo

irn:rrririrrtioloaii ouncao s Multipl€ Rnnse Test (Dle{RD d 99 %

L

Page 9: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

,, '-l

lflttd4 nr!nrttuuri.lrGq:]tlorraa:nirijoudrlom 6onld: fi qurlirio.l

n1:'tl

-r i r n j r i r o o o osMs l% 0 0 0 0

SI\'S 2% 0 0 0 0

sMs3% 0 0 0 0

sMs lo /o+nAo l% o o o o

susrvo.mdozx o o o o

str,ts lozo+rn6o:x 0 0 0 0

sttls t%+rnf,oqv. 0 0 0 o

RlJtfttll'l

- ! i .'lrr t!1,11fl1:flaoo{

2b 2.5b

2.25b 2.25b

lc lc

2b 1.25ab

2b 3b

2.25b 3b

2b 2.'�t5b

F -t€st(0.01)

c.v. % [.42 22.21

*t dnsdoin'rrlrnnirfru r{an^6 fi :;dlnrut6oriu s97"

*rirrqdslti[nnirrtiunxadn-fi :cn-!nrrudoiussx

f:rardnrudlgdnu:trrisuduluanui (*lumn) t6orriu lanl'i.rlriinrrlunniutiurrmiido

irnrr:ridtrqdulauii ounc$ s Mulliple Range Test ( Dli'{RT} i ll %

,38pt Jr36fl.UrBuLBt4LLr{F

,n$l.llLu c|tr8l{unLr

#r"?::":::::::.e l3'lf Yl!9.o l{!,1fi0{.r {torr.fjrdXY tr4lJl Ir r' tr'^r

s$Aotc 6'rhg

Page 10: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

t 7

=

;

ed

.,i 6 'F

- F = a' q i :

.,F ,€ ;

; ! q =

."8 rZ F- G - c g

Vi

so

I

. 9 a a . g€ { , A A p i c r . A{ n + s

: S , 3 , x 5 5 5 es d ( . !

- , q . e e n R l 6= ;- " ' + { * q

e F d 3 3 3 . : . x

* F , X , A { . X , : , x

f f F . ; i n F , f , 5 , A

R p n i f i { f i a . . x

a R , x . x 3 . : , * , :* 4 3 * E * , . x x

^ r : n h

o . X . oN r : 6 h

€ a e a e , f , * a

€ , : e , E , x a * , A

€ , 3 , f i , 3 3 * f i a

6 . q 6 6

4 d 6 d

6 h q ! x

- v i ' i t i 6 h f i , ) i

- a 6 a

- a A z z z z z z

-=

=

Page 11: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

l 8

;

,

(q

- , a q -

. F t J-rF 'q a

E : c 4- 7 Z l

F . e

F F ' S

. , = - ! d E

-a. -c g.t(-t

€ 3 - q E A 1 1 1^ i -

d c . {

6 x . : , { : : ; i

G d - 6 d . . ! . . ! . . !. i o d o

d o 6 o o c j d c j

o o o d

9 c a . d d d ! 1

q 6 d d 6 6 d l l

6 0 6 Y )

d d d f i. . i o o o o o o +

: l 6 d 6

;: o o oR - o o

lc lrc 16 nc

+ + + +

'l .it aF > > >' = a a a

-a

.E

=

=

.F=

F1'!F

a

Page 12: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

l9

nr:rrfi 8 uanl irlrar *luble sotids fiqotflti 5 owrrrynriua

illt:ll rliuw ssiufirirfrnr:rano.r

28l4

riruftirsMs l%

sMs 2%

sMs 190

St'rS to/o + rnis t Yo

sMs tozo + rn6o 2 %

svs t%+ n6o: %

sus tx+ m6o + x

7.85

7.85

7-85

7.85

7.85

7.45

7.85

7.85

6.95

7.58

7.58

7.65

7.80

7.25't.2n

7_35

6.95

7.to't.75

7.35

1.45

7.58

7.33

1.45

F - test (0.0 | )

c.v. o/. 3.99 3.42

.* drrnduinlurnnirtriuntair' fi ::nitn:u6ori syz"

ns n'ar6ulriurniHf,unrrdii^ ir!drtfl 'n!rioliu qg%. ;ir-2.nrrin r!d2uo'n!: rx iioutillu nnlri lc,olurnny riu.xi! lca.t.jr'h;in:rtrurnir,rtiu nxnn-n'rio

irn:r:irirrrl6s'lqui; nuncan s Multiple Ranse Test (DMRT) fi 99 %

L

Page 13: rrRR.rrcoorrw'ir uJ6oortrilfi&rfluiuiirjrdrucr:a:arallfioullrr'llinlrli z · 2017-10-12 · t4 nr:rfi3 nruuunr:r duuurJorfifirrolrtou:nirrfirJonula'onu,{rfiqur4i#ol (zr orm woriua)

20

nrNfi q rnn oiriuinrnfilnrr:rlC fiqonr4i s omrrvnrior

t llnlt rulofrfudnrnfi lnor:nld

?lllltlryt'lR1: t4ioot

2814

riruftirsMs l%

sMs 2%

sMs 3%

St,tS t"Z + m6s t .zo

SUS touo * rn6o u Z

St',tS t"Z + rn6o I "z

sus t"z + n6o +x

0.075

0.075

0.075

0.075

0.075

0.o75

0.015

0.075

0.048

0.M6

0.053

0.058

0,054

0.065

0.0.t6

0.053

0.049

0.(xl

0.M2

0.048

0.{xl

0.038

o.u7

o_M2

F - test (0,01)

c.v.6tr t9.22 30.t4

t i 4 - - i -*. rillsdulnrrxtlinil{d nl.!fld6' fr:rd!fl'l ullioriu 99./"

^ rirrs6ulliuanirrfiu rrfl66 fi :yo'lnrrlrCoriu ps"h

franrfirudrudor:niouriulunarri (column) 6u:rir.r lrn.r'jrliinrrurnnilrfirrt{dni6or'rnrr;ririrrqf,ulaoii Duncar 's Mulriple Range T€st (DI&T) fi 99 %