hsfisoWA>Q 24X;Csafety/3_Nakamura_20200114.pdf · ¡ ¡ v`Yp GJwUd 20 2020#1014- \ E g ¡ ¡ T v`...
Transcript of hsfisoWA>Q 24X;Csafety/3_Nakamura_20200114.pdf · ¡ ¡ v`Yp GJwUd 20 2020#1014- \ E g ¡ ¡ T v`...
hsfisoWA>Q_� 24X;C
12020� 1(14& � ?�0gjeprHhsfiso:�WA`_<;CV��X�^5[I
2020� 1( 14&+��� ��D
&)���24@1-,tJAEAu� 24gris �*3�
hsfisoWA>Q_� 24X;C
.v #WBPESAVhsfisoWAQ_�NX246X%G]^'$ �aL�RKSTMZPSF �]^"=a/P�OZQF
STPE��Y�W��6��X89U,#PEJAEAX!8a�7Q_\XUYJ^ZRbF
H�������������� ������I
&)�������� ? ldqscjmgnks
SZQTZWF64@L�&(G19
22020� 1�14� �5��#RUPXY:SZQTZW0�F6ML219E��G�K,I;
1. H?JFSZQTZWEH
2. SZQTZWF6ML�&(FB<CSZQTZW&(G+�E�&(G.#FB<CSZQTZWN0�@L-�OZVFB<C
3. SZQTZW&(G"!��8�'�)� ��$8�[1F\� F64>A&(�G&(G��7�6*N3F>A&(�� ����DG�/SZQTZW&(G.#�/
4. =MKFSZQTZW&(G19
% �
�¡��¡��mh�� �MP�dr
32020# 16144 �i��I�����v�¡��¡�a�m��edr��&���S�w
l���3_{�/����/")Dg�Ost )Et/�jt /�k�58t /�TU5lt Q�VN
Ø ��A�0��x Z��/"W%q�9g
Ø H�/��n> ;��@���,[�kK 7�):`�z}��(L�a-=
Ø �05�/")Dg|�?/��Y�<u�������L�X*�t�u�������7�DG��Ff�cR�:^��t�����h�Ff���.y����G]|'���;��\o��!���
l ~~��tKp+2��J����¡��¡��CB�$�t �MP�FE��&�dr�1G�b��
£¢����
�¡��¡���
������w^Zp���?CxUb
42020� 1,14+ ��[��<�����d������Tw^��VUbu��x��H{e
l��?Cyc'�"9WxAOIXw:-x3��5>u2>�cqx3�w_�ntcf�gy�$w1z�cDx�tx%�ucqx�a�Ki�
l'�"9Wyc6!k&�nvlt}'�m�h�Ø � PWRM2=;��7E@*�(�^`J42��
&�SGj~ \x'�"9W��2'�
l.8)wNBm�r'�"9W�.�Q;#9�FP�y6!k&�p�u'�x�L"�;o�
Ø 6!&�� ����������SA�Ø d]oY|�e/Lx��
����c8)PREcRPVD�0 �GcRCVcRB
2�������w^����?Cwsgt?CxF�u��?CxS<�1/2�
��
T
��}���oa\ju��IKpYb
52020# 13141 ��_��F~�|��e��}���X�oavuZYbm�%p�tOqf
l��IKp��5Um�0TFØ IKYbm'R(p5U��dy���x��|}�Ø C�D[w6.��WjuC8n�cV�rT>p5U
SA2p!+E�pP)�=$d��d��dA dL�Ø S4���p/���dPRAL��5UdS4���p`G�
l ��}���iavu|�xxz|����SA�D[p�Ø @&p-]JØ ?Q���p,���dFCIdMCCIdL�Ø ;��9Hm<Hd�7d=$�"d���(dL�
Ø :NBGØ �� �^*%p�����hsp����{�?��
2���}���oavu��IKokglIKpM�m��IKpTF�2/2�
18/285&��"*����'��
62020 1 14� ������03.67�18/285��&�+*���%�'�)�(�
l SA��-84!� SA��'�
2;18/285&�+*����&#�$
18/285,��"*��-8491/2:
u�sv�~`PLYg� 68aEQ
72020� 1$14" � N��4twq��Tu�sv�~C`PigFEQ]��a�f?cU
l q}kknqx�y�SA�Cbu�sv�~Cj�WØ SAa M7j!�B'\XgSAB'p�zj�3
l B'p�z`.dehg�AØ LP �<�]RK0:�PRA�!q{�m�IB'� THALES, MAAP
Ø BE � a#;��'�,J5D>� MELCOR, ASTEC, SAMPSON
Ø �*A 1�2HaD>B'� �l=��S_^� Kiche, ART
Ø CFD5 ����9Oa�+�/�2H�D>B'� JUPITER
l u�sv�~PL2H�x�@|wo�rØ TMI� �&aSA2H68a�(
2�u�sv�~`Pig� 68`ZV[u�sv�~jCYgB'p�z�2/2�
B'p�za
�� )%-aG0�
������{idu���OS|`l
82020" 18146 ��eK�����n������_ {i��b`lx�%|��X}o
l n�g9�������H29"98266�o { &tv��X}
l �\�>{cu�(�|/��Yq������OSIRID, IAEmzynF5���|'H+0|v�|�<�.�*Z|hL�$E�C=� V�>�oØ C=B VmSFPr�|F5��tmF5������tmUØ SA����MAAPmSAMPSON�|W#��{��E�HD|+041
l ������_ {i�tv�QMzOS�^K��~�JAEA CLADSmzyØ F5P2,�|A?aMz]7
Ø @3����JpvF5���|G'_
Ø Cs|f:[kw|Cs�NUm��,�Ø 1Fr�-�s�v����|�<mmU
3�������OS|IH;�j�R!T����Lj)�1F�$E{idtvOS
������tb_m|!�DGu[d
92020& 1014. !�`��@�����g������Ytb}|][dq�)u�{Pxh
!�DG����
l FP� (u�;srØ VERDON-2�v�-5"e��CEA�t�ojfVICTORIA2����K�~?in%UWIHtz|FP� (tbm|�;L'u3X
Ø ��<��M�FP� V1���CHEMKEquaA�%U\q^'\~R*�S�
l THALES2���tz|"5V1Ø �/QW���u4Jq$��%UWIp-�lnFP� P+DBt�ok�
l 7C������uc��9CwuFT,��t|�EBDGØ CIGMA: 36 u7C8�y:�,�f2N#���tbm|
ZOW;"e �� CFD���3Xq���aAØ PONTUS: ���������"e
Ø ARES: ����������"e
3�������DGu>=��uDGu��JAEA� �1/2�
�§��§¡�]W~���DG�Tb
102020" 1.14- ��Y��@���¢¦x�§��§¡S��]��UTb��&���J�y
3ª�§��§¡DG�>=��DG��¨JAEA© ¨2/2©
����E!�DG�¦�§
l FP���]~�DGØ SAQ0�§�¨THALES-2wMAAPwSAMPSON©�*L�B'~Ø TeRRaPK�cü �¥¦¨B©{Cs��z���A%a«3)ZI ��/+�§ ¦�PC}wCsI�B2O3�^�|��5M4�7�
ü �`6C}�CsI�wX_�4��BM4{��~%a�1RwwH
Ø 3)FP�<?��(��]~��2�DGü 8:O`����¥�£6C(�
ü ��¥�£���;$ �FN� ���6C(�
ü Cs���[�£��¡/���C(�ü CsOH���¦¤�\O`�����C
hmuvdjmqkodnrtdefdgmpmiumdiqldvgiqusrtv3)ZI« V,��9#�Z
-8+.83#��!' ���$��
112020� 1�14� ��� ��,/*47�-8+.83��#�('���"��$�&�%
3;-8+.83��$��
��$��$�9CRIEPI:�5+)��,7.89NRRC: ��6802/1
-8+.83#��!' ���$��
122020� 1�14� ��� ��,/*47�-8+.83��#�('���"��$�&�%
3;-8+.83��$��
��$��$�9CRIEPI:�5+)��,7.89NRRC: ��6802/1
v�tw��_LGXg��36`DO
132020� 1#14! ��I��/uyr��Rv�tw��B_LigEDO]��`�f<cS
9�`�
n *_TMI���MP:�2_SA36V� WhP36�%aP,>K1WhZA$p�|_N5Wh[Tg
l SOARCA36~�smn{�2012�b\�Ø NRCØ �?�� q��)(PWR)]}�x�{�)(BWR)Ø MELCORp�|_dg SA`"HB�best estimate�
ü 4Q`SAr�o�t\Pv�tw���.���J�j-�2_B
l MAAP – MELCOR Crosswalk Phase 1 Study�2014�b\�Ø EPRIPq�zlk�736�(SNL)PNRCPDOEP8Ø 1F���P1�&j�FØ 0^g�z�Ue�(Whg=%`�]Y`@�jC;_ $
3�v�tw��36`-+�`36`��'��
gtehtoVHDR[� 67WAK
142020! 1+14) � F��5fjdpsMgtehto@�VH][BAKT�#W�Z;XN
3wgtehto67W32�I/H8^CVQS67��
1F�'VH][�I��67uvn OECD/NEA ���(?� ���uCSNIv
�'W�-T94rt`sbbqtluWGAMAvl SAREFu2013,�2016v
Ø 1F�'#W� 67.>VHR[�:�G�bqtlØ �'OY$Y\[� 67AKL1FW� U"1V%<U67AKW&�TJ�P^�(
l BSAFu2012�2018vØ 1F�'E VHR[SActkmsinta=-Ø BSAF: 2012�L 8_� xx CSNI��*Ø BSAF-2: 2015�L11_� uCSNI��*�0��v
������xgcs� �JOy^k
152020( 16144 �e��G�����m������\xg��`^kv�*y��V{n
3�������JOyED�h=gQ�bxrtJO��
1F�2xg���h �JO��l X �n OECD/NEA/ CSNI/ WGAMAl ARC-F�2019�� - BSAFy*W
Ø mL'P����Hj.y��?)%o}z;T"��-�y�9nA) SA���Z9x}�1F�2yd&v1#,BayNY/�y}�]Uw0!B) ��?)%|;T"�y�e_:Qp~+t����-�yiSvRFC) >�^ky5K�v$8yf7������y<[
l PreADES�2017�2020lCSNI�Ø mA3���y�9xgs���IJOn
l TCOFF�2019�lNEA���M�����NSC��Ø m1F�2d&����\x�uq
A3���vFPy@��C,yZ5x���������n
{�y|��hUSdp$�DFiPX
162020( 13140 $�T��Cz~w��[{�y|��N�hUqpQPXf�)i�oKk\
3�{�y|��DFi@>�W8UGrRhceDF��
OECD/NEA�W��DF��g�� �W7<�X ISP j�+n OECD/NEA/CSNI
Ø TMI�/�1979��VØ SA1hA!.�r^{�y|��N�h_ap�E`bi;r�p
l OECD-LOFT �1983-'89ZHNRC� 2�i�oKkØ [' PWR�%=OY�i- =*`niFP.�r6M\
l BIP �2007-'14Zu�}AECL�Ø [�sJ,�OYRTFiL4rB]e�sJ�#��xtv�\
l STEM �2011-'19Z�IRSN�Ø [EPICUROYZGr�BceZ�sJl���s�i,�iDF\
l THAI �2007-'19Z?GRSG�Ø [THAI%YhmpZ5I&��i"9�:J,�l{�y|��iDF\
u�sv�{cQN^i��=AdKT
172020 1,14* ��P��;twq|�Xu�sv�{JcQjiLKTa�"d�hGeY
3�u�sv�{=Ad98�R1QCkMc]_=A��
�� bZ] ECcfi�R �=A��b��
y~�s IRSNl PHEBUS FP=Az�p~{�1988-2010�
Ø PWR0&�E`%�]_5�3e.7([gdFP?I$�Ø ECWEdFa c�)
l �Ru�sv�{z�p~{ ISTP�2005-'10�Ø 4@d��-�U� (a) }mF��W(c) B�`d7(/dO6W
(b) B4C�#/d!SW (d) V4`d5�7([gdFP'�sls PSIl ARTIST�Uz�rnox�2003-'11�
Ø PWRdH2<:��6D\SA+dV4�V�`>%]_RdFP$�
}�{~��hSPbo��>@iIW
182020# 1.14- ��Q�:|�z��Z}�{~��H�hSqoJIWf�$i�nDk[
3�}�{~��>@i97�U1SArMhac>@��
�� g\a EChmo�U��>@��g�
ECl SARNET���1S��IRSNY2004��
Ø 18v�431S�BYv��YVYs��r�l�_��Ø 2013#YNUGENIA�Gen.-IIY-III4r&]EU��x���hDNjpc
l ASTECy��iR;��IRSNf8GRSi��Y SAG/y���Ø 2"eiG/�����u��fadG/1Ei)�
l SA>@hSbo2"����K ERMSARØ }�{~��r�l�+i>@;F
Ø }�{~��>@i;F�2019��5,' 0( XY PHEBUS XG/Y �tCi{w���xT�Y3<�*!%6LH�i�?^`YCsi���=�JAEA�YA 11�
SAMPSONhO\
� �� ��jgw��RT�cn
192020" 1:146 �h��N�����q� �� �`�j��ecn}�%���X�r
3£� �� �RT�KJ�����|�B^
q���������8�A \M+I2�r RT�i���
l � �� �RTZ�F���E) ¥¥ 2017"�_UØ 3z�WG¤ FP�op���� �`p.[cn/�
l PHEBUS�o����� �]>Ø PHEBUS FP������¡�IRSN¢�d@��9� >pFP2��jw�'���;�fv{p5x~.[Zk��DW�Q0w
Ø +?��¤ q�38�A \M+I2�]7��1,r¡6<�����b 2018"10:¢
l 1F|�FP !�B^Ø 1F�38�FP2��zs{p&=.[|��G|u~tyx���/�}#H�C���p�%Y*w�u5x~.[cn�4L�a��
Ø +?��¤ qS V����Pl-�#H�C8�O(w�uA \M+I�$mr ¡�b 2019" 9:¢
�¡��¡�v`Yp���GJwUd
202020# 1014- ��\��E���� g�¡��¡�T�v`��VUdt�%w��Mzh
3¤�¡��¡�GJwBA
�¡��¡�GJwRE4S¢1/2£
SARNET
l SARP¢Severe Accident Research Prioritiesf2013£Ø SAGJUdw*Ct��������m
Ø 1F�)w4S�Xorf�¡�t�[<tw�����2��,
Ø OECD/NEAwWGAMAK�a5`w8�t{��
l SARPR¢Severe Accident Research Priority Rankingf2019£
Ø NUGENIA TA2/SARNETw155`w _�v}�SARPwQFn
Ø 35Ud¥ In-Vessel�)Z"f 3L��H'¢.1f/1£���fFP( tIO&�f �D9z@+�¡�sw�)f;RPf ?���¡��¡�f K
Ø �lu6x=ikfSA%w^1���� �v�Udk�j~�q
Ø �¡��¡�v�8�wUd¢FPw( |IOv�BW£¥�¡��¡�yw]�b�7¢(!N>!w$cfK£fe:��f3L�����fw�$cfK
Annals of Nuclear Energy 74(2014)4
ERMSAR2019, Prague, Log No.: 098
y�vz��eSM]l�:=fJT
212020� 1(14% �Q��5x{u��Xy�vz��H�eSnlKJTc��f�kBgY
3�y�vz��:=f43y�vz��:=fF5+G�2/2�
�����
l Q�eil��~�{�f��Ø 1/ Q�V*2#Q�V.��Q�
l 1.���~�{��1/ Q��Ø SAeS]lIAd C�{�f?��2013�Ø X1.��H��8 CU���6�{�2017 �1.�RM 2017�
28����'YØ SAfN�e�`b4ml-WdSA4Lo@O<eD\b;\V^mjeS]l+Gf�P0VD)t�~h�}�R7>f43c��whJTf)e�aZ_��qr�|p�[>o�$
Ø ����s� 2020�f&f��o9!\b"Ef�,�
http://www.aesj.or.jp/~thd/committee/TH-RM/TH-RM_r.pdf
�®��®¥�e_w���HM�Zi
222020! 14141 ��b��E���¨k�®��®¥Y�e��[Zi}�%���P�l
l TMI�/¯1979°o�40!�Q{Ø B\�CW}j��OI~Y�]w��®��®¥HM�jSAHM}ST��ozj&U�'v{�;�`���jB\�¦�ª��`���x
l 1F�/6W2�h��JF�hØ . (A^���#)jL�,�j��+ £®ª�DF¯g90���©¡����°��P��{n�j�%j*8p5$t��
l �®��®¥HM�ZiØ OECD/NEA BSAF£¬����|�j1F�/�W7R8��q~��zqpV��jSAW7�® ¯B\CW°�nr�>�ZipK�t�x
Ø �%jOECD/NEA ARK-F£¬������v�¢�¬®��£������jSAB\�3~�CW�W7O"�-�p5$t��
Ø xyuj��Yj��(��Yjf@j��G<NjHMpe������cU~:X�d��{��u{jI���=aD(p����s}p¤��|m�jt�~��§«�p?����
4±n����®��®¥HM�Zi
9?7:?<-��(3����.��
232020� 1 14� ������8;6=>�9?7:?<��-�53���,�.�2�1�
%��� 2#,"%&!0')
%��!)*$4/�+(