Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech...

25
Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball University of Oxford Konrad Banaszek Nicolaus Copernicus University Toruń, Poland Alex Lvovsky University of Calgary Squeezing eigenmodes in parametric down- conversion National Laboratory for Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics, Toru ń, Poland

Transcript of Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech...

Page 1: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Entanglement-enhanced communication overa correlated-noise channel

Entanglement-enhanced communication overa correlated-noise channel

Andrzej DraganWojciech Wasilewski

Czesław RadzewiczWarsaw University

Jonathan BallUniversity of Oxford

Konrad BanaszekNicolaus Copernicus University Toruń, Poland

Alex LvovskyUniversity of Calgary

Squeezing eigenmodesin parametric down-conversion

Squeezing eigenmodesin parametric down-conversion

National Laboratory for Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics, Toruń, Poland

Page 2: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

All that jazzAll that jazz

Sen

der

Receiv

er

Mutual information:

Channel capacity:

Page 3: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Depolarization in an optical fibreDepolarization in an optical fibre

Photon in a polarization state

H

V

H

V

1/2

1/2

1/2

1/2

2

1

Independently of the averaged output state has the form:

Capacity of coding in the polarization state of a single photon:

Random polarization transformation

Page 4: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Information codingInformation coding

H

H

V

VSender:

Probabilities of measurement outcomes:

H&H, V&V

H&V, V&H

2/3

2/3

1/3

1/3Capacity per photon pair:

Page 5: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Collective detectionCollective detection

Probabilities of measurement outcomes:

2&0, 0&2

1&1

1

1/2

1/2

Capacity:

Page 6: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Entangled states are useful!Entangled states are useful!

Probabilities of measurement outcomes:

2&0, 0&2

1&1

1

1

Capacity:

Page 7: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Proof-of-principle experimentProof-of-principle experiment

2&0, 0&2

1&1

1

1

Entangled ensemble:

2&0, 0&2

1&1

1

1/2

1/2

Separable ensemble:

These are optimal ensembles for separable and entangled inputs (assuming collective detection), which follows from optimizing the Holevo bound.

J. Ball, A. Dragan, and K.Banaszek,Phys. Rev. A 69, 042324 (2004)

Page 8: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Source of polarization-entangled pairsSource of polarization-entangled pairsP. G. Kwiat, E. Waks, A. G. White, I. Appelbaum, and P. H. Eberhard, Phys. Rev. A 60, R773 (1999)

For a suitable polarization of the pump pulses, the generated two-photon state has the form:

With a half-wave plate in one arm it can be transformed into:

or

Page 9: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Experimental setupExperimental setup

K. Banaszek, A. Dragan, W. Wasilewski, and C. Radzewicz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 257901 (2004)

Triplet events:

D1 & D2 D3 & D4

Singlet events:

D1 & D3 D2 & D3 D2 & D3 D2 & D4

Page 10: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Experimental resultsExperimental results

Page 11: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Dealing with collective depolarization

Dealing with collective depolarization

1) Phase encoding in time bins: fixed input polarization, polarization-independent receiver.

J. Brendel, N. Gisin, W. Tittel, and H. Zbinden, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2594 (1999).

2) Decoherence-free subspacesfor a train of single photons.

J.-C. Boileau, D. Gottesman, R. Laamme,D. Poulin, and R. W. Spekkens, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 017901 (2004).

Page 12: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

General scenarioGeneral scenario

Physical system:

• arbitrarily many photons

• N time bins that encompass two orthogonal polarizations

• How many distinguishable states can we send via the channel?

• What is the biggest decoherence-free subspace?

Page 13: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Mathematical modelMathematical model

General transformation:

where:

– the entire quantum state of light across N time bins– element of U(2) describing the transformation of the polarization modes in a single time bin.– unitary representation of in a single time bin

We will decompose with

and

Page 14: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Schwinger representationSchwinger representation

...

Ordering Fock states in a single time bin according to the combined number of photons l:

Here is (2j+1)-dimensional representation of SU(2). Consequently has the explicit decomposition in the form:

Representation of

...

Page 15: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

DecompositionDecomposition

Decomposition into irreducible representations:

Integration over removes coherence between subspaces with different total photon number L. Also, no coherence is left between subspaces with different j.

tells us:

• how many orthogonal states can be sent in the subspace j

• dimensionality of the decoherence-free subsystem

Recursion formula for :

J. L. Ball and K. Banaszek,quant-ph/0410077;Open Syst. Inf. Dyn. 12, 121 (2005)

Biggest decoherence-free subsystems have usually hybrid character!

Page 16: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

QuestionsQuestions

• Relationship to quantum reference frames for spin systems [S. D. Bartlett, T. Rudolph, and R. W. Spekkens, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 027901 (2003)]

• Partial correlations?

• Linear optical implementations?

• How much entanglement is needed for implementing decoherence-free subsystems?

• Shared phase reference?

• Self-referencing schemes? [Z. D. Walton, A. F. Abouraddy, A. V. Sergienko, B. E. A. Saleh, and M. C. Teich, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 087901 (2003)]

• Other decoherence mechanisms, e.g. polarization mode dispersion?

Page 17: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Multimode squeezingMultimode squeezing

Single-mode model:

SHG

PDC

Brutal reality (still simplified):

[See for example: M. Matuszewski, W. Wasilewski, M. Trippenbach, and Y. B. Band,Opt. Comm. 221, 337 (2003)]

Page 18: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Perturbative regimePerturbative regime

Schmidt decomposition for a symmetric two-photon wave function:

C. K. Law, I. A. Walmsley, and J. H. Eberly,Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 5304 (2000)

We can now define eigenmodes which yields:

The spectral amplitudes characterize pure squeezing modes

The wave function up to the two-photon term:

W. P. Grice and I. A. Walmsley, Phys. Rev. A 56, 1627 (1997);T. E. Keller and M. H. Rubin, Phys. Rev A 56, 1534 (1997)

Page 19: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Decomposition for arbitrary pump

Decomposition for arbitrary pump

As the commutation relations for the output field operators must be preserved, the two integral kernels can be decomposed using the Bloch-Messiah theorem:

S. L. Braunstein, quant-ph/9904002;see also R. S. Bennink and R. W. Boyd,Phys. Rev. A 66, 053815 (2002)

Page 20: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Squeezing modesSqueezing modes

The Bloch-Messiah theorem allows us to introduce eigenmodes for input and output fields:

which evolve according to

• describe modes that are described by pure squeezed states

• tell us what modes need to be seeded to retain puritySome properties:

• For low pump powers, usually a large number of modes becomes squeezed with similar squeezing parameters

• Any superposition of these modes (with right phases!) will exhibit squeezing

• The shape of the modes changes with the increasing pump intensity! This and much more in a poster by Wojtek

Wasilewski

Page 21: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

The EndThe End

Page 22: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

TheoryTheory

Everything that emerges are Werner states

One-dimensional optimization problem for the Holevo bound

What about phase encoding?

Page 23: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Recursion formulaRecursion formula

Decompostion of the corresponding su(2) algebra:

If we subtract one time bin:

N bins, L photons

N-1 bins, L′ photons

......

L–L′photons

Page 24: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Direct sumDirect sum

The product of two angular momentum algebras has the standard decomposition as:

Therefore the algebra for L photons in N time bins can be written as a triple direct sum:

Page 25: Entanglement-enhanced communication over a correlated-noise channel Andrzej Dragan Wojciech Wasilewski Czesław Radzewicz Warsaw University Jonathan Ball.

Decoherence-free subsystems

Decoherence-free subsystems

Rearranging the summation order finally yields:

Underlined entries with correspond to pure phase encoding (with all the input pulses having identical polarizations)– in most cases we can do better than that!