Centre Alexandre Koyré

11

Click here to load reader

Transcript of Centre Alexandre Koyré

Page 1: Centre Alexandre Koyré

!

!

!"#$%"&'(")*#+%"&,-.%/!!

!"#$%&'(!)%*+',('-.'/&#0'(%*1(23&3/'0("#$%!&'(#)*+(,!-%.!/$0$1!!!!

0-%& 1-2"&."*%1&#-34&'2.&5*6*#&6*1&7""#& 8-#1$%98$:#;& *& %"1"*%86& $"*2&-<& =18:"#8"& 1$9+:"1>& :#& $6"&

!"#$%"&,-.%/4& $6*$& 8-2?%:1"1& $-+*.&@:86"(&'%2*$$"& AB:1$-%.&-<& "8-#-2:81& *#+& 1$*$:1$:814& 18"#*%:-1C&

*#+&*&$"#$6&-<&D6&5&1$9+"#$1&-%&?-1$E+-81F&G6"&$"*2>1&%"1"*%86&<-891&:1&-#&=!(:2*$"&86*#;"4&H)?"%$:1"&

*#+& <9$9%"1>F& I"& *%"& 89%%"#$(.& +"J"(-?:#;& 1$9+:"1& -#& 1"J"%*(& *1?"8$1& -<& $6"& 8(:2*$"& 86*(("#;"&K&

?%-+98$:-#&-<&L#-3("+;"4&2-+"(1&*#+&2-+"(:#;&?%*8$:8"14&18"#*%:-14&")?"%$:1"4&:#$"%*8$:-#1&-<&M8:"#8"&

*#+&D-(:8.4&*#*(.1:1&-<&8(:2*$"&*%"#*14&N-%$6EM-9$6&%"(*$:-#16:?1&*#+&;"-?-(:$:8*(& 1$*L"14& %-("&-<& $6"&

NOP>14&?"%8"?$:-#&-<&$6"&8(:2*$"&Q9"1$:-#&:#&?97(:8&1?*8"14&"$8F!!!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!!"#$%&'&($

$)*+,-$./,0&#$

Atmospheric chemistry

Climate and pollutions

Geoengineering

!

1'/,-234'5$.67752$

NGO’s

Adaptation and development

North-South relationships

$!((5$8&+(59,5(!

Sustainable cities

Communicational innovation

Sustainable development

!:*;<(5$86,;;5"32$

Climate modelling IPCC

Controversies

$!+&2'&$=3/>?&@$

Global assessment Earthwatch

UNEP

!

A&/,(5$B3,>'32$

Public problem

Media

Museum and popularization

$B59&-2,&($8/5C-"D';$

Antarctica Scientific images

Environmentalism

!

$

E;30,5$F,5,;;5G.;&(>'&/0$

Limits to growth Global modelling

History of environmental thought

!"#$%&'!()*+#!

Globalization

Energy Mitigation

!!6/3/5$F,&/0G1/*2&2$

Forests

Climate regime Ethics!

H>239/5$IJJK$L$!%M1N$

Page 2: Centre Alexandre Koyré

"#$%&'!()*+#!!!

,$)-./01!2!34+5$4'6$*'+1!7!#1#(3.!7!%'*'3$*'+18!&

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#&9!:#! ;34+5$4<! #*! 4#! ;4+)$4<! &$1=! 4#=! =)'#1)#=! #*! 4#=! >+4'*'?@#=! &@! )4'%$*8! :$!)+1=*(@)*'+1! &#! 4A$(B1#! )4'%$*'?@#! #1! C($1)#,! #1! -44#%$31#! #*! $@! 1'D#$@!#@(+>E#18!/'(#)*(')#!2!-%.!/$0$1,!&'(#)*(')#!&#!(#)0#()0#!$@!FGHI!#*!&'(#)*(')#!$&J+'1*#!&@!F-K8!L1'*E!&#!(#)0#()0#!2!F#1*(#!K+.(E,!FGHIMLNH!OPQR8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!F+1=*(@)*'+1!&#!4A$(B1#!)4'%$*'?@#!#1!T@(+>#!#1*(#!>+4'*'?@#=,!=$D+'(=,!#*!&'=)+@(=8!!

S!U(3$1'=$*'+1!&#!4A#V>#(*'=#!W)4'%$*'?@#X!&$1=!&'YYE(#1*=!>$.=!S!'1=*'*@*'+1=,!$>>(+)0#=,!9!)'D')!#>'=*#%+4+3'#=!Z8!

S![1#(3'#!#*!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!2!9!5+@?@#*=!Z!#*!=)E1$('+=!E1#(3E*'?@#=!#*!4$!&EY'1'*'+1!&#=!+>*'+1=!&#!(E&@)*'+1!&#=!E%'=='+1=8!

S!\+@D#(1$1)#! &@! )0$13#%#1*! )4'%$*'?@#!2! D#(=! @1! 1+@D#4! +(&(#! 9!)+=%+>+4'*'?@#!Z! +@! @1! 1+@D#$@! (]4#! &#=! [*$*=^1$*'+1!_!!

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"&

S![*@&#=! &#! I)'#1)#=! `+4'*'?@#=! $@!U**+^I@0(^a1=*'*@*! &#! 4$! C(#'#!L1'D#(='*b*! c#(4'1,! /'>4]%#! WE?@'D$4#1*! c-FdPX! =+@=! 4$!&'(#)*'+1!&#!-)0'%!c(@11#13($5#(!#*!T4%$(!-4*D$*#(8!!

S!N$=*#(!&#!H#)0#()0#!&#!4ATeTII,!+5*#1@!$@!F#1*(#!K+.(E!%#1*'+1!e'=*+'(#!&#=!I)'#1)#=,!"#)01'?@#=!#*!I+)'E*E=!$D#)!4$!%#1*'+1!"(B=!c'#1!=+@=!4$!&'(#)*'+1!&#!N%#!-%.!/$0$18!

S!-=='=*$1*!>$(4#%#1*$'(#!$@>(B=!&@!&E>@*E!&@!c@1&#=*$3!e$($4&!CHaTIT!W+)*8!fRRg!S!+)*8!fRRfX8!

S!-=='=*$1*!h!4$!(#)0#()0#!$@>(B=!&#!N8!c$0('!i'4%$6!h!4$!I$5$1)'!L1'D#(='*.,!a=*$15@4!W+)*8!fRRj!S!$D('4!fRRkX8!!

T-9%1"1&

S!c+@(='#(!&#!4$!9!I*@&'#1=*'Y*@13!&#=!/#@*=)0#1!l+4m#=!Z!WfRRf!S!fRRQX8!S!-44+)$*$'(#!&#!H#)0#()0#!&@!FGHI!W+)*8!fRRQ!S!+)*8!fRRnX8!!

D%-U"$1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!`$(*')'>$*'+1!h!@1!>(+J#*!'1*#(&'=)'>4'1$'(#!#V>4+($*+'(#!Y'1$1)E!>$(!4Aa1=*'*@*!&#=!I)'#1)#=!&#!4$!F+%%@1')$*'+1!&@!FGHI!WaIFFX,!$))#>*E!#1!$D('4!fRRn!2!9!:$!)+1=*(@)*'+1!&#=!)0$13#%#1*=!)4'%$*'?@#=!)+%%#!>(+54B%#!>@54')!#1!C($1)#!2!?@#44#!>4$)#!>+@(!4#=!)+1*(+D#(=#=!_!Z8!

S!`$(*')'>$*'+1,! #1! )+44$5+($*'+1!$D#)! 4$!F'*E!&#=! I)'#1)#=,! h!@1#!9!F+1YE(#1)#!&#! )'*+.#1=! =@(! 4#=! )0+'V!>+4'*'?@#=!>+@(!4@**#(! )+1*(#! 4#! )0$13#%#1*! )4'%$*'?@#!Z,! )+%>+=$1*#! Y($1o$'=#! &A@1#! )+1=@4*$*'+1! '1*#(1$*'+1$4#! Wp+(4&!p'&#! l'#q=X!'%>4'?@$1*! kP!>$.=,! )++(&+11E! >$(! 4#! /$1'=0! c+$(&! +Y! "#)01+4+3.8! "($D$'4! &A+(3$1'=$*'+1! #*! &#! (#)0#()0#! =@(! )#**#!)+1=@4*$*'+1!>$(*')'>$*'D#8!!!

D97(:8*$:-#1&

S!-.m@*,! I8,! 9!:$! )+1=*(@)*'+1! &@! )0$13#%#1*! )4'%$*'?@#! )+%%#! >(+54B%#! >@54')!7! &E5$*! %E&'$*'?@#! #*! #V>#(*'=#!)4'%$*'?@#!#1!C($1)#!#*! #1!-44#%$31#!Z,!&$1=! I8!c#44$4!$#!&23! W&'(8X!2!"&4.5/1! $67$/#18! 1&4.5/1!7/.%&'$1!9! 4$/1!0$!'.+4$&+6!:.0$1! 0$! ;.'1#/+;#5.'! 0$! 2<&;#+&25#=! 7.25#5>+$!?,! c(@V#44#=,! `@54')$*'+1=! &#=! C$)@4*E=! @1'D#(='*$'(#=! I$'1*^:+@'=,! fRRn! Wh!>$($r*(#X8!S!/$0$1,!-8,!-.m@*,! I8,!\@'44#%+*,!e8,!K+()6$m,!-8,!9!:#=!$(B1#=! )4'%$*'?@#=!2! Y+(@%=!&@! Y@*@(!+@! Y+'(#=!$@V!>$4$5(#=!_! :$!)+1YE(#1)#!&#!`+61$1!Z,!($>>+(*!&#!(#)0#()0#!&@!F#1*(#!-4#V$1&(#!K+.(E,!fRRn8!T1!4'31#!2!s0**>2MMqqq8m+.(#8)1(=8Y(t!

S!-.m@*,! I8,! 9! :#! 34+5$4! #*! 4#! 4+)$4! &$1=! 4#=! =)'#1)#=! #*! 4#=! >+4'*'?@#=! )4'%$*'?@#=! Z,! $(*')4#! >(E=#1*E! &$1=! 4#! )$&(#! &#=!9!(#1&#6^D+@=!Y($1)'4'#1=!&@!&ED#4+>>#%#1*!=+@*#1$54#!Z!+(3$1'=E=!#1!$D('4!fRRO!>$(!4Aa&&(',!fRRO8!T1!4'31#!2!s0**>2MMqqq8'&&('8+(3t!!

@/2-:%"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!NE%+'(#!&#!/'>4+%!W-44#%$31#X!2!9!\4+5$4#!H'='m+3#=#44=)0$Y*!_!u@(!K+1=*(@m*'+1!D+1!\4+5$4'*b*,!H'='m+!@1&!1$*'+1$4#(!a&#1*'*b*! '1!K4'%$&'=m@(=,! ^q'==#1=)0$Y*!@1&!S>+4'*'m!Z! WI+)'E*E!34+5$4#!&@! ('=?@#!_!\4+5$4'*E,! ('=?@#!#*! '&#1*'*E!1$*'+1$4#!&$1=!4#!&'=)+@(=!)4'%$*'?@#!$44#%$1&X8!

S!NE%+'(#!&#!N$=*#(!WC($1)#X!2!9![*@&#!)+%>$($*'D#!&#=!(#4$*'+1=!#1*(#!=)'#1)#=!#*!>+4'*'?@#=!&@!)4'%$*!#1!C($1)#!#*!#1!-44#%$31#8!:$!)$1')@4#!fRRj!#1!C($1)#!#*!4#=!'1+1&$*'+1=!fRRf!#1!-44#%$31#!Z8!!@.'#&;#!9!I*#Y$1!F'0$1!-.m@*,!FGHI,!fv,!(@#!/$%#=%#,!vPRgj!`$('=!S!F+@(('#4!2!=8$.m@s$*t3%$'48)+%!S!"E48!2!RQ!fv!Og!nf!Rg

!

Page 3: Centre Alexandre Koyré

A=B51!C/50&)!!

!

,$)-./01!2!$*%+=>0#(')!)0#%'=*(.!7!)4'%$*#!)0$13#!!$1&!>+44@*'+1=!7!3#+#13'1##('138!

&

&

&

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#&

9!:$! )0'%'#! &#! 4A$*%+=>0B(#! #1*(#! =)'#1)#! #*! =+)'E*E,! &#>@'=! 4#! %'4'#@! &@! ww#! ='B)4#!7! )0'%'#! &#! 4A$*%+=>0B(#! #*!

)0$13#%#1*=!)4'%$*'?@#=!7!)0'%'#!&#!4A$*%+=>0B(#!#*!>(+J#*=!&#!3E+'13E1'#('#8!Z!

/'(#)*(')#=!2!-%.!/$0$1,!F#1*(#!-4#V$1&(#!K+.(E!7!I+>0'#!\+&'1^c##m%$11,!I#(D')#!&A-E(+1+%'#!Wa`I:X8!

-44+)$*$'(#!&#!H#)0#()0#!&@!\aI!9!F4'%$*!#1D'(+11#%#1*!=+)'E*E!Z,!x$1D'#(!fRRn^fRgf8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!e'=*+'(#!#*!'%>4')$*'+1=!>+4'*'?@#=!&#!4$!)0'%'#!$*%+=>0E('?@#!&#>@'=!4#!%'4'#@!&@!ww#!='B)4#8!

S!U6+1#!#*!)0'%'#!$*%+=>0E('?@#8!

S!:'#1=!0'=*+('?@#=!&#!4$!)0'%'#!$*%+=>0E('?@#!$@!)4'%$*!7!'1*E3($*'+1!&#!4$!)0'%'#!&$1=!4#=!%+&B4#=!$*%+=>0E('?@#=8!

S![*@&#=! &#=! >(+J#*=! &#! (#)0#()0#! #1! 3E+'13E1'#('#! >+@(! 4#! *($'*#%#1*! &#=! >(+54B%#=! &#! >+44@*'+1=! #*! &#=! D$('$*'+1=!)4'%$*'?@#=!2!5@&3#*=,!(E34#%#1*$*'+1=,!#1J#@V!&A@1!&E5$*!=@(!4$!3E+'13E1'#('#8!

!

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"&

S!N$=*#(!(#)0#()0#!:U`eaII,!9!e'=*+'(#!#*!`0'4+=+>0'#!&#=!I)'#1)#=!Z,!`$('=!laa8!

S!N$=*#(!(#)0#()0#!9!`0.=')+^)0'%'#!&#!4A$*%+=>0B(#!#*!)4'%$*!Z,!F4#(%+1*^C#(($1&!a8!

!

@/2-:%"1&+"&V"86"%86"&K&

S!9!p'4=+1!#*!4$!)0$%5(#!h!5(+@'44$(&!#1*(#!gOnP!#*!gngf8!\#1B=#!&#!4A'1=*(@%#1*,!)+1*#V*#!E>'=*E%+4+3'?@#,!(#4$*'+1=!$@V!$@*(#=!*($D$@V!&#!4AE>+?@#!Z!W&'(#)*'+1,!G$&'1#!&#!F+@(*#1$.X8!

S!9![*@&#!#*!%+&E4'=$*'+1!&#=!)+1&'*'+1=!&#!%E4$13#=!&A$E(+=+4=!=@(!4$!6+1#!%E&'*#(($1E#11#!Z!W&'(#)*'+1,!\@.!F$@*#1#*X8!

!

@.'#&;#!9!(#3'=5('&$.s$*t.$0++8Y(!

!!

!

Page 4: Centre Alexandre Koyré

@D/51#.7D$!C+%%$#!!!

,$)-./01!2!G\UA=!$1&!'1*#(1$*'+1$4!=+4'&$('*.!7!$&$>*$*'+1!$1&!&#D#4+>%#1*!7!G+(*0^I+@*0!(#4$*'+1=0'>=!&

!

&

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#&

9!F0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#,!UG\!!#*!>$.=!4#=!%+'1=!$D$1)E=!2!#V>#(*'=#!=)'#1*'Y'?@#!#*!#1J#@V!>+4'*'?@#=!Z!

-44+)$*$'(#!&#!H#)0#()0#!a4#!&#!C($1)#!WU)*+5(#!fRRn^fRgfX!

/'(#)*(')#!2!-%.!/$0$1,!&'(#)*(')#!&#!(#)0#()0#!$@!FGHI!#*!&'(#)*(')#!$&J+'1*#!&@!F-K!

L1'*E!&#!(#)0#()0#!2!F#1*(#!-4#V$1&(#!K+.(E,!FGHIMLNH!OPQR!

[?@'>#!9!F0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#,!#V>#(*'=#!#*!Y@*@(=!Z8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!:#!(]4#!&#=!UG\!&$1=!4$!3+@D#(1$1)#!)4'%$*'?@#!%+1&'$4#!#*!4#@(!%+&#!&A+(3$1'=$*'+1!#1!(E=#$@V!*($1=1$*'+1$@V8!

S!:#!&'$4+3@#!E%#(3#1*!#1*(#!UG\!#1D'(+11#%#1*$4#=!#*!UG\!0@%$1'*$'(#=M&ED#4+>>#%#1*8!

S!F+%%#1*!4#!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!(#)+1Y'3@(#!4#=!=*($*E3'#=!#*!%+&#=!&A$)*'+1!&#=!UG\8!!

S!:A'%>$)*!&@!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!&$1=!4$!=*($*E3'#!#*!4#=!$)*'+1=!)+1&@'*#=!9!')'!Z!#*!9!4h^5$=!Z,!#*!4#@(!$(*')@4$*'+1!&$1=!@1#!>(+54E%$*'?@#!4+)$4M34+5$48!

&

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"!

S![*@&#=!2! &'>4]%E! &#! 4A[)+4#! =@>E('#@(#! &#! )+%%#()#! &#! G$1*#=! W-@&#1)'$X,! N$=*#(! f! #1! H#4$*'+1=! '1*#(1$*'+1$4#=! h!4Aa1=*'*@*!&#=!H#4$*'+1=!a1*#(1$*'+1$4#=!#*!I*($*E3'?@#=!WaHaIX8!

S!-&%'1'=*($*#@(!#*!)0#Y!&#!%'=='+1!>+@(!NE&#)'1=!&@!N+1&#!W-Y30$1'=*$1,!`$m'=*$1X8!

S!a1*#(D#1$1*! #1! N$=*#(! f! 9!-)*'+1! '1*#(1$*'+1$4#! $==+)'$*'D#! #*! )++>E($*'+1! &E)#1*($4'=E#!Z! h! 4AaHaI,! %+&@4#!9!F0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!#*!=+4'&$('*E!'1*#(1$*'+1$4#!Z8!

&

@/2-:%"1&+"&%"86"%86"!

NE%+'(#! &#!N$=*#(! f!h! 4AaHaI!2! 9!:#! )0$13#%#1*! )4'%$*'?@#!2! @1! 1+@D#$@! )+1*#V*#! >+@(! 4#=!U(3$1'=$*'+1=! &#! I+4'&$('*E!a1*#(1$*'+1$4#!Z!

&

D97(:8*$:-#!

-%.!/$0$1! $1&! F0('=*+>0#! c@YY#*,! 9!T1D'(+1%#1*$4! G\UA=! '1! *0#! H$'='13!/#5$*#! +Y! F4'%$*#! F0$13#!Z,! 5'!N$(*.! `8! $1&!/#D$@V!I8,!".;5&2!:.4$:$'#1!&'0!7+E25;!&;#5.'3!F$11.'1!%/.:!$'45/.':$'#&2!511+$1,!`@54')$*'+1=!&@!FTCHTI,!`($3@#8!

!

@.+//5$2!9!)5@YY#*s$*t.$0++8Y(!

!

Page 5: Centre Alexandre Koyré

(''$!G&B'$E5$'!!

!

!

,$)-./01!2!=@=*$'1$54#!&#D#4+>%#1*!H!)+%%@1')$*'+1$4!'11+D$*'+1!H!=@=*$'1$54#!)'*'#=8!

!

!

!

!

!

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#!9!:#!&ED#4+>>#%#1*!&@($54#!)+%%#!'11+D$*'+1!)+%%@1')$*'+11#44#!Z!

FGL!vg#!=#)*'+1!h!4AL1'D#(='*E!`$('=!gj8!

-44+)$*$'(#!&#!H#)0#()0#!Hf/I!a4#!&#!C($1)#!WU)*+5(#!fRRv^fRgRX!

/'(#)*#@(=!2!/+%'1'?@#!F$((#,!=+)'+4+3@#,!>(+Y#==#@(!&#=!@1'D#(='*E=!#1!I)'#1)#=!&#!4Aa1Y+(%$*'+1!#*!&#!4$!F+%%@1')$*'+1!W`$('=!gj,!:$5I')X!#*!-%.!/$0$1!W$==+)'E#X!&'(#)*(')#!&#!(#)0#()0#!$@!FGHI,!&'(#)*(')#!$&J+'1*#!&@!F-K8!

L1'*E=! &#! (#)0#()0#!2! F#1*(#! -4#V$1&(#! K+.(E,! FGHIMLNH!OPQR! #*! 4#! :$5I'),! 4$5+($*+'(#! @1'D#(='*$'(#! &#! (#)0#()0#! #1!=+)'+4+3'#!&#=!@=$3#=!W`$('=!gjX,!FGHIMLNI!fPPj8!

&

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"!`+@(!$>>(+)0#(!4$!*0E%$*'?@#!&#!4$!D'44#!#*!&@!&ED#4+>>#%#1*!&@($54#!&$1=!4#!)$&(#!&#=!I)'#1)#=!&#!4A'1Y+(%$*'+1!#*!&#!4$!)+%%@1')$*'+1!W4#=!IaFX,!1+@=!*($'*+1=!4#!&ED#4+>>#%#1*!&@($54#!)+%%#!'11+D$*'+1!)+%%@1')$*'+11#44#!?@'!=#!%$1'Y#=*#!&$1=! 4#=! (E)'*=,! 4#=! #V>+='*'+1=,! 4#=! %E&'$=,! 4#=! &'=)+@(=! W+5J#*=! &#=! IaFX8! G+@=! $1$4.=+1=! 4$! Y$o+1! &+1*! =#! Y+(3#1*! )#=!1+@D#44#=!1+*'+1=,!)+%%#1*!=#!=*(@)*@(#1*!4#=!(#>(E=#1*$*'+1=!=+)'$4#=,!)+%%#1*!#44#=!=#!&'YY@=#1*,!&#!?@#44#=!%$1'B(#=!+1!'1Y+(%#,!+1!=#1='5'4'=#!4#!>@54')!h!)#**#!?@#=*'+18!

a1=)('D$1*! 1+*(#! *0B=#! #1! IaF! 1+@=! $D+1=! $'1='! >('D'4E3'E! 4yE*@&#! &#! ?@$*(#! %+.#1=! &#! )+%%@1')$*'+1!2! 4#=! ($>>+(*=!+YY')'#4=,!4#=!=+1&$3#=!&y+>'1'+1,!4#=!%E&'$=!W>(#==#!E)('*#X!#*!4#=!#V>+='*'+1=!=)'#1*'Y'?@#=!#*!*#)01'?@#=8!

G+@=!$D+1=!(#*#1@!&#@V!+5J#*=!2!4$!%+5'4'*E!&+@)#!WlE4'5!#*!*($%=X!#*!4$!&#1='Y')$*'+1!@(5$'1#!W"+@(=!#*!E)+^?@$(*'#(=X8!F#=!&#@V!+5J#*=!)$($)*E('=#1*!>$(*')@4'B(#%#1*!#1! (E3'+1! a/C! 4$!D'44#!&#!&#%$'1!#*!&@!&ED#4+>>#%#1*!&@($54#!>$(! 4#@(! Y+(*#!D'='5'4'*E!&$1=! 4#=!%E&'$=8! a4=! J+@#1*!@1!(]4#!>(E>+1&E($1*!=@(! 4#=!(#>(E=#1*$*'+1=!=+)'$4#=!#1!>#(%#**$1*!1+*$%%#1*!&#!(#?@$4'Y'#(!#*!(E0$5'4'*#(!4A@(5$'18!

!

H(/2"#$1&+"&7:7(:-;%*?6:"&

S!\$31#5'#1,! -8,! `$('=,! T8,! 9! :$! 1@%E('=$*'+1! &#! 4$! %E%+'(#! &@! 3E1+)'&#! 1$6'! &#=! J@'Y=! &AT@(+>#,! #1*(#! ;>(+J#*=!&#=)#1&$1*=<! #*! ;>(+J#*=! $=)#1&$1*=<!Z,! >8! fPg^fQv! 5'! \HN`! W\(+@>#! &#! (#)0#()0#! =@(! 4#=! %@=E#=! #*! 4#! >$*('%+'1#X,!I&#/5:.5'$!$#!:.'05&251&#5.',!`$('=!4Ae$(%$**$1,!)+448!9!-&%'1'=*($*'+1,!$%E1$3#%#1*!&@!*#(('*+'(#!Z,!fRRO,!fOO!>8!

S!\$31#5'#1,!-8,!@.::+'5;&#5.'!$#!0=4$2.77$:$'#!0+/&E2$!9!2&!4522$!0$!0$:&5'!;.::$!$'J$+,!5'!$)*#=!&#=!&+)*+('$4#=!fRRn!&#!4$!ICIaF!WI+)'E*E!C($1o$'=#!&#=!I)'#1)#=!&#!4Aa1Y+(%$*'+1!#*!&#!4$!F+%%@1')$*'+1X!9!/'D#(='*E!&#=!$>>(+)0#=,!=>E)'Y')'*E!&#=! +5J#*=! #*! &#=! %E*0+&+4+3'#=! #1! I)'#1)#=! &#! 4A'1Y+(%$*'+1! #*! &#! 4$! )+%%@1')$*'+1!Z,! fv^fO! %$(=! fRRn,! LCH! &#=!I)'#1)#=!&#!4$!)+%%@1')$*'+1!WaFNX!&#!4A@1'D#(='*E!I*#1&0$4^\(#1+54#!j,!fRRn,!h!>$($r*(#8!

S!\$31#5'#1,!-8,!9!:#!(#*+@(!h!4$!D'44#!Z,!I/51:$!K!50=$1,!1z!f,!fRRn,!h!>$($r*(#8!

!

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"!S!fRRP!2![?@'D$4#1)#!/T-8!

S!fRRg^fRRj!2!/TII!9!F+1)#>*'+1!#*! (E$4'=$*'+1!&A#V>+='*'+1=!h!)$($)*B(#!=)'#1*'Y'?@#!#*! *#)01'?@#!Z,!L1'D#(='*E!`$('=!gj8!I@J#*!&@!%E%+'(#!2!9!:$!5+(1#! '1*#($)*'D#!$^*^#44#! Y$'*!ED+4@#(! 4A#V>+='*'+1!=)'#1*'Y'?@#!_!/#@V!E*@&#=!&#!)$=!2! 4$!F'*E!&#=!I)'#1)#=!#*!&#!4Aa1&@=*('#!#*!4$!\($1&#!\$4#('#!&#!4A[D+4@*'+1!Z,!%#1*'+1!"(B=!c'#1!$D#)!YE4')'*$*'+1=!&@!J@(.8!

S!gnnv^fRRR!2!%$r*('=#!&A'13E1'#@(!%$r*(#!#1!3#=*'+1!#*!%$1$3#%#1*!&#!4$!F@4*@(#!h!4AaL`!/#1'=!/'&#(+*!&#!/'J+18!

S!gnnQ^gnnv!2!&'>4]%#!@1'D#(='*$'(#!&#!"#)01+4+3'#!a1Y+^F+%!9!NE*'#(=!&@!4'D(#!#*!&#!4$!)+1=#(D$*'+1!Z,!+>*'+1!9!N@=E#=!Z!h!4AaL"!&#!/'J+18!

!

H)?/%:"#8"&?%-<"11:-##"(("&%/8"#$"!F0$(3E#! &AE*@&#=! >+@(! C($1)#! "#4#)+%! W1@%E('=$*'+1! &@! >$*('%+'1#X! #*! 4#! :$5I')! W@=$3#=! &@! G#*$(*X,! >+@(! 4$! F'*E! &#=!I)'#1)#=!#*!&#!4Aa1&@=*('#!W&'=>+='*'Y=!'1*#($)*'Y=,!>+(*$'4!p#5,!>(+3($%%#=!&A$1$4.=#!#*M+@!&A#V>4+'*$*'+1!&A#V>+='*'+1=X8!

!

@.+//5$2!9!$11#83$31#5'#1s$*t3%$'48)+%!

!

!

Page 6: Centre Alexandre Koyré

"$E&1#5&'!L5';$'#!G/$41:MD2!!!

,$)-./01!2!-1*$()*')$!7!=)'#1*'Y')!'%$3#=!7!#1D'(+1%#1*$4'=%8!!!G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#!a%$3#=!#*!D'='+1=!$**$)0E=!h!4$!)+1=*'*@*'+1!&@!(E3'%#!#1D'(+11#%#1*$4!#1!-1*$()*'?@#!>#1&$1*!4$!&#@V'B%#!%+'*'E!&@!ww

#!='B)4#8!

/'(#)*(')#!2!-%.!/$0$1,!&'(#)*(')#!&#!(#)0#()0#!$@!FGHI,!&'(#)*(')#!$&J+'1*#!&@!F-K8!L1'*E!&#!(#)0#()0#!2!F#1*(#!K+.(E,!FGHIMLNH!OPQR8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&S!e'=*+'(#!&#!4A#V>4+($*'+1!>+4$'(#!#*!4A'1=*$@($*'+1!&#=!=)'#1)#=!#1!-()*'?@#!#*!-1*$()*'?@#8!S!:'#1=!#1*(#!4A#V>4+($*'+1!=>$*'$4#,!4A#V>4+($*'+1!>+4$'(#!#*!4A#V>4+($*'+1!+)E$1'?@#8!S!H]4#!&#=!=)'#1)#=!#*!&@!&+%$'1#!)@4*@(#4!>+@(!4#=!&'=)+@(=!&#!4A#1D'(+11#%#1*$4'=%#!#1!-1*$()*'?@#8!S!9!e'=*+'(#!D'=@#44#!Z!#*!!(]4#!&#=!'%$3#=!=)'#1*'Y'?@#=!#1!=)'#1)#=8!S![D+4@*'+1! &#=! E)0#44#=! *#%>+(#44#=! #*! =>$*'$4#=! &@! =$D+'(! #1! =)'#1)#=! &#! 4$! "#((#! #*! #1! =)'#1)#! #1D'(+11#%#1*$4#=!W%')(+M%$)(+,!4+)$4M34+5$4,!)+@(*#!&@(E#M4+13@#!&@(E#X8!S!e'=*+'(#!#*!E>'=*E%+4+3'#!&#!*#)01+4+3'#=!&#!*E4E&E*#)*'+1!#*!*E4E+5=#(D$*'+18!!

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"&S!/TL\!-(*=!&@!=>#)*$)4#!W:.+1!aaX8!S!:')#1)#!a1Y+(%$*'+1!#*!F+%%@1')$*'+1!W:.+1!aaX8!S!N$r*('=#!a1Y+(%$*'+1!#*!F+%%@1')$*'+1!W:.+1!aaX8!S!/'>4+%^K@4*@(q'==#1=)0$Y*4#(!WN#&'#1X!WL1'D#(='*E!&#!c$@0$@=,!p#'%$(X8!S!N$=*#(!&#!(#)0#()0#!#1!0'=*+'(#!&#=!=)'#1)#=!WTeTIIX,!!S!/+)*+($1*!#1!0'=*+'(#!&#=!=)'#1)#=!WTeTIIX!W$44+)$*$'(#!&#!(#)0#()0#!&@!FGHI!>+@(!f!$1=!d!g!$1X,!U)*+5(#!fRRv^fRgR8!!!

@/2-:%"1&+"&%"86"%86"&S!NE%+'(#! &#! /'>4+%! Wp#'%$(,! -44#%$31#X! #*! &#! N$r*('=#! W:.+1,! C($1)#X!2! 9! p'==#1,! c'4&,! U5J#m*!2! u@(! T>'=*#%+4+3'#!q'==#1=)0$Y*4')0#(! c'4&#(!Z! W9!a%$3#,! I$D+'(,! U5J#*!2! I@(! 4AE>'=*E%+4+3'#! &#=! '%$3#=! =)'#1*'Y'?@#=!Z,! =+@=! 4$! &'(#)*'+1! &#!`(+Y8!/(8!c#(10$(&!I'#3#(*X8!S!NE%+'(#! &#!N$=*#(! W`$('=,! C($1)#X!2! 9!N+&B4#=! D'=@#4=! #1! =)'#1)#=! &#! 4$! "#((#!2! 4#! )$=! &@! &('Y*! )+1*'1#1*$4! Z! W=+@=! 4$!&'(#)*'+1!&A-%.!/$0$1X8!!

D97(:8*$:-#1&&S!9!T>'=*#%'=)0#! "+>+3($Y'#18! C+*+3($Y'=)0#! @1&! ($&$(*#)01'=)0#! p$0(1#0%@13=(b@%#!Z,! &$1=! L$/-&'0#$! C520$/3! N5$!O/&B$'!0$/!C520-511$'1;D&%#,!a13#5+(3!H#')04#,!I*#YY#1!I'#3#4!#*!-)0'%!I>#4*#1!W&'(8X,!c#(4'1,!K$&%+=!fRRv,!>8!fQj^fvn8!

(E1#/&;#9! PD51! &/#5;2$! 051;+11$1! #D$! ;.'1#/+;#5.'! &'0! 25:5#1! .%! 1;5$'#5%5;! 7$/;$7#5.'3! PD$! $6&:72$1! .%! /&0&/! &'0!

7D.#.B/&7D)!&22.-!#.!15'B2$!.+#!17$;5%5;!$751#$:5;!051;.'#5'+5#5$1!5'!#D$!;.'1#/+;#5.'!.%!1;5$'#5%5;!7$/;$7#5.'3!PD$!#$/:!

Q$751#$:5;! #.7.B/&7D)R! 51! %+/#D$/:./$! 5'#/.0+;$0! #.! +'0$/25'$! #D$! ;.'1#5#+#5.'&2! /.2$! .%! #$;D'.2.B)! 5'! #D$!

;.'1#/+;#5.'!.%!1;5$'#5%5;!7$/;$7#5.'3!O5'&22)8!#D$!$751#$:5;!25:5#1!&'0!E25'0!17.#1!&/$!50$'#5%5$0!E)!$672./5'B!#D$!%/.'#5$/!

/$B5.'1!.%!:.0$/'!#$;D'.2.B)3!

S!9!p'==#1=5'4&#(,! c'4&#(q'==#1!2! u@(! T>'=*#%+4+3'#! &#(! 5'4&3#5#1&#1! l#(Y$0(#1!Z,! &$1=! S;.'5;! #+/'!?8! T.0$/'$8!

,+2#+/-511$'1;D&%#25;D$1! U&D/E+;D8! U&D/B&'B! V,! e#43$! N'**#(5$@#(! #*! L4(')0! "($3$*=)01'3! W&'(X,! \($6,! a11=5(@)m,! p'#1,!I*@&'#1D#(4$3!fRRv,!>8!jQ^kn8!

(E1#/&;#9!PD51!7&7$/!1+BB$1#1!#D&#!:.0$/'!1;5$'#5%5;!5:&B$1!D&4$!#.!E$!&'&2)1$0!.'!#D$!B/.+'01!.%!#D$5/!;.'1#/+;#5.'!

7/.;$113!PD$!;.:7&/51.'!.%!")'#D$#5;!(7$/#+/$!A&0&/!-5#D!7D.#.B/&7D)!&22.-1!#.!+'0$/25'$!&#!2$&1#!#-.!#D5'B19!W3!$&;D!

:$05+:!7/.0+;$1!5#1!.-'!17$;5%5;!$;.'.:)!.%!4515E525#5$1!&'0!5'4515E525#5$1!&'0!V3!&'!&'&2)151!.%!#D$!Q&'&$1#D$#5;R!X.'$1!

.%!:$05&!;&'!E$!:&0$!7/.0+;#54$!%./!&!;/5#5;&2!/$&05'B!.%!;.'#$:7./&/)!1;5$'#5%5;!5:&B$13!

S!9!/$=! %+&#44'#(*#! -1*4'*6! &#(! T(&#8! u@(! \#=)0')0*#! &#(! N+&#44'#(@13==*($*#3'#1! &#(! K+1*'1#1*$4D#(=)0'#5@13!Z,! &$1=!L51+$22$!T.0$22$,!a13#5+(3!H#')04#,!I*#YY#1!I'#3#4!#*!-)0'%!I>#4*#1!W&'(8X,!N{1)0#1,!p'40#4%!C'1m!fRRO,!>8!ggv^gjQ8!

(E1#/&;#9!PD51!7&7$/!051;+11$1! #D$!#D$./)!.%!;.'#5'$'#&2!0/5%#!&'0!#D$!:&#$/5&2!&17$;#1!.%!1;5$'#5%5;!:.0$225'B3!(2%/$0!

Y$B$'$/<1! #D$./)! ;&'! E$! /$-/5##$'! &1! &! ;/5#5;&2! :$05&! D51#./)3! N$'5$/1! &'0! 1+77./#$/1! >+$1#5.'$0! 25*$-51$! #D$!

$751#$:5;! E.+'0&/5$1! .%! $&;D! :.0$225'B! :$05+:3! PD$! B2.E$8! #D$! :&7! &'0! #D$! ;.:7+#$/! -$/$! ;$'#/&2! #.! #D$1$!

051;+115.'13!S#!51!&/B+$0!#D&#!#D$!1D5%#!%/.:!Z+;2505&'!#.!17D$/5;&2!B$.:$#/)![&'0!#D$/$%./$!%/.:!#D$!:&7!&'0!#D$!B2.E$!

#.!#D$!;.:7+#$/\!-&1!%+'0&:$'#&2!%./!#D$!&;;$7#&';$!.%!#D$!#D$./)!.%!;.'#5'$'#&2!0/5%#3!

!@.'#&;#!2!I#5$=*'$1!l8!\(#D=%{04,!FGHI,!fv,!(@#!/$%#=%#,!vPRgj!`$('=!F+@(('#4!2!3(#D=%@#04s$*t&$%#=%#8)1(=8Y(!S!"E48!2!Rg8kP8QP8nQ8kn!

!

Page 7: Centre Alexandre Koyré

]=2^'$!G+522$:.#!!

,$)-./01!2!)4'%$*#!%+&#44'13!7!a`FF!7!)+1*(+D#(='#=8!

!

G6R1"&

9!:$!%+&E4'=$*'+1!&@!)4'%$*!#1!C($1)#!&#=!$11E#=!gnvR!$@V!$11E#=!fRRR8!e'=*+'(#,!>($*'?@#=,!#1J#@V!>+4'*'?@#=!Z,!=+@*#1@#!#1!&E)#%5(#!fRRv8!

/'(#)*(')#!2!-%.!/$0$1,!F#1*(#!-4#V$1&(#!K+.(E8!

F+1*($*!>+=*&+)*+($4!Y'1$1)E!>$(!Hf/I!|4#^&#^C($1)#,!(E=#$@!Y($1)'4'#1!&#!H#)0#()0#!=@(!4#!/ED#4+>>#%#1*!=+@*#1$54#8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!e'=*+'(#!&#!4$!%+&E4'=$*'+1!1@%E('?@#!&@!)4'%$*8!

S![*@&#! &#=! >($*'?@#=! &#! %+&E4'=$*'+1,! #1! (#4$*'+1! $D#)! 4#=! )@4*@(#=! '1=*'*@*'+11#44#=! &#=! )#1*(#=! &#! (#)0#()0#8![>'=*E%+4+3'#!&#!4$!%+&E4'=$*'+1!#*!&#=!='%@4$*'+1=!1@%E('?@#=!&@!)4'%$*8!

S!:A#V>#(*'=#! )4'%$*'?@#!7! 4$! >$(*')'>$*'+1! &#=! )+%%@1$@*E=! =)'#1*'Y'?@#=8! H#4$*'+1=! ! #1*(#! =)'#1)#! #*! >+4'*'?@#! &$1=! 4#!9!(E3'%#!)4'%$*'?@#!Z8!

S!U>'1'+1!>@54'?@#,!&E5$*!>@54'),!)+1*(+D#(=#=!#*!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#8!

!

D%-U"$1&+"&%"86"%86"&"#&8-9%1&

S!`$(*')'>$*'+1!h!@1!>(+J#*!'1*#(&'=)'>4'1$'(#!#V>4+($*+'(#!Y'1$1)E!>$(!4Aa1=*'*@*!&#=!I)'#1)#=!&#!4$!F+%%@1')$*'+1!&@!FGHI!WaIFFX,!$))#>*E!#1!$D('4!fRRn!2!9!:$!)+1=*(@)*'+1!&#=!)0$13#%#1*=!)4'%$*'?@#=!)+%%#!>(+54B%#!>@54')!#1!C($1)#!2!?@#44#!>4$)#!>+@(!4#=!)+1*(+D#(=#=!_!Z!

S!`$(*')'>$*'+1,! #1! )+44$5+($*'+1!$D#)! 4$!F'*E!&#=! I)'#1)#=,! h!@1#!9!F+1YE(#1)#!&#! )'*+.#1=! =@(! 4#=! )0+'V!>+4'*'?@#=!>+@(!4@**#(! )+1*(#! 4#! )0$13#%#1*! )4'%$*'?@#!Z,! )+%>+=$1*#! Y($1o$'=#! &A@1#! )+1=@4*$*'+1! '1*#(1$*'+1$4#! Wp+(4&!p'&#! l'#q=X!'%>4'?@$1*! kP!>$.=,! )++(&+11E#! >$(! 4#! /$1'=0! c+$(&! +Y! "#)01+4+3.8! "($D$'4! &A+(3$1'=$*'+1! #*! &#! (#)0#()0#! =@(! )#**#!)+1=@4*$*'+1!>$(*')'>$*'D#8!

!

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"&

S![*@&#=!&#!>0.='?@#!h!4AL1'D#(='*E!`$('=!wa,!U(=$.8!

S!"0B=#!&#!j#!).)4#!&#!)0'%'#!1@)4E$'(#!h!4AL1'D#(='*E!`$('=!wa8!

S!x+@(1$4'=*#!=)'#1*'Y'?@#8!

S!/T-!&A0'=*+'(#!&#=!=)'#1)#=!WTeTIIX8!

S!"0B=#!&A0'=*+'(#!&#=!=)'#1)#=!WTeTII,!=+@*#1$1)#!&E)#%5(#!fRRvX8!

!

D97(:8*$:-#1!

S!/$0$1^/$4%#&')+,! -8,! \@'44#%+*,! e8,! 9!F0$13#%#1*! )4'%$*'?@#!2! /.1$%'?@#=! =)'#1*'Y'?@#=,! #V>#(*'=#,! #1J#@V!3E+>+4'*'?@#=!Z,!I+)'+4+3'#!&@!*($D$'4,!1z!kO,!>8!kgf^kjf,!fRRQ8!

S!\@'44#%+*,!e8,!9!:#=!%+&B4#=!1@%E('?@#=!&#!)4'%$*!Z,!5'8!/$0$1^/$4%#&')+,!-!W&'(8X,!F$1!:.0^2$1!0+!%+#+/,!:$!/E)+@D#(*#,!)+448!9!H#)0#()0#=!Z,!fRRv8!

S!\@'44#%+*,! e8,! 9!:$! %+&E4'=$*'+1! &@! )4'%$*! #1! C($1)#! &#=! $11E#=! gnvR! $@V! $11E#=! fRRR8! e'=*+'(#,! >($*'?@#=,! #1J#@V!>+4'*'?@#=!Z,!*0B=#!&#!&+)*+($*,![)+4#!&#=!e$@*#=![*@&#=!#1!I)'#1)#=!I+)'$4#=,!`$('=,!fRRv8!

S!/$0$1,! -8,! \@'44#%+*,! e8,! 9!F4'%$*#! F0$13#2! I)'#1*'Y')! /.1$%')=,! TV>#(*'=#! $1&! `+4'*')$4! F0$44#13#=!Z,! '1! ";5$';$! &'0!".4$/&5'#)8!`$($&#'=#,!F8!W&'(8X,!H+@*4#&3#,!G#q!i+(m,!fRRO8!

S!\@'44#%+*,!e8,!9!F+%%#1*!ED$4@#(!@1!%+&B4#!&#!)4'%$*!_!F'()@4$*'+1=!#*!&'$4+3@#=!#1*(#!='%@4$*'+1=!#*!+5=#(D$*'+1=!&$1=!4#=!>($*'?@#=!&#=!%+&E4'=$*#@(=!Z,!A$4+$!0<('#D/.7.2.B5$!0$1!@.''&511&';$1,!D+48!f,!fRRn,!h!>$($r*(#8!

S!\@'44#%+*,!e8,!9!l$4'&$*'+1!$1&!U*0#(!a1*#($)*'+1=!5#*q##1!N+&#4=!$1&!U5=#(D$*'+1!/$*$!'1!F4'%$*#!N+&#4'138!I)'#1*'=*A=!`($)*')#=!$1&!;c+**+%!^!L>!T>'=*#%+4+3.<!:#==+1=!Z,!>(E=#1*E!h!l'#11#!h! 4$!j

#!)+1YE(#1)#! '1*#(1$*'+1$4#!&#! 4AT@(+>#$1!

I+)'#*.!Y+(!*0#!e'=*+(.!+Y!I)'#1)#,!#1!)+@(=!&#!=+@%'=='+1!h!"#+05$1!5'!]51#./)!&'0!ID52.1.7D)!.%!T.0$/'!ID)15;1,!fRRn8!

!

@.'#&;#!2!3@'44#%+*s$*t&$%#=%#8)1(=8Y(!

!

Page 8: Centre Alexandre Koyré

!

(B&#D&!,./;X&*!!!

,$)-./01!2!34+5$4!$==#==%#1*!7!T$(*0q$*)0!7!LGT`8!&

&

&

&

&

&

&

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#!

9!:A#V>#(*'=#!#1D'(+11#%#1*$4#!34+5$4#!&@!`GLT!W>(+3($%%#!&#=!1$*'+1=!@1'#=!>+@(!4A#1D'(+11#%#1*X!Z8!

/'(#)*(')#!2!-%.!/$0$1,!&'(#)*(')#!&#!(#)0#()0#!$@!FGHI!#*!&'(#)*(')#!$&J+'1*#!&@!F-K8!

L1'*E!&#!(#)0#()0#!2!F#1*(#!-4#V$1&(#!K+.(E8!

C'1$1)#%#1*!2!5+@(=#!&+)*+($4#!&@!3+@D#(1#%#1*!%+1E3$=?@#,!1+D#%5(#!fRRv^fRgR8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!e'=*+'(#!&@!`GLT!#*!#1!>$(*')@4'#(,!)#44#!&@!>4$1!D'3'#8!:$!%'=#!#1!>4$)#!&#!4AED$4@$*'+1!#1D'(+11#%#1*$4#!'1*E3(E#8!

S!F+1=*'*@*'+1! &#=! #V>#(*'=#=! 34+5$4#=!2! )+%>$($'=+1! #1*(#! 4A#V>#(*'=#! >(+>(#%#1*! )4'%$*'?@#,! 4A#V>#(*'=#!#1D'(+11#%#1*$4#!34+5$4#!#*!4$!%'=#!#1!>4$)#!&#!4A#V>#(*'=#!5'+&'D#(='*EM=#(D')#=!E)+=.=*E%'?@#=8!a`FFM\TUMa`cI8!

S![*@&#!&#=!>(+54E%$*'?@#=!9!#1D'(+11#%#1*!Z!#*!9!&ED#4+>>#%#1*!Z!&$1=!4#!)$&(#!&#=!G$*'+1=^L1'#=!2!4'#1=!#1*(#!`GLT!#*!`GL/,!4A+('3'1#!#*!4#=!#YY#*=!&#!4A$(*')@4$*'+1!&#=!&#@V!)+1)#>*=8!

S!:#!(]4#!&#=!#V>#(*=!&$1=!4#=!$(B1#=!'1*#(1$*'+1$4#=8!

!

@/2-:%"1&+"&%"86"%86"&&

S!N$'*('=#!&#!>0'4+=+>0'#!9!>+4'*'?@#!&#!4$!1$*@(#!Z,!L1'D#(='*E!&#!G')#!I+>0'$!-1*'>+4'=8!

S!N$=*#(!&#!I)'#1)#!`+4'*'?@#!9!\$=*+1!H')0$(&!2! #1*(#!>#(=>#)*'D#!%E%+('#44#!#*!$>>+(*! *0E+('?@#!Z,!L1'D#(='*E!`$('=!g!`$1*0E+1^I+(5+11#8!

!

@.'#&;#!2!$3$*0$8m+()6$ms$*t3%$'48)+%!

!

!!!!!!!!!

!

Page 9: Centre Alexandre Koyré

!

T&/5'$!".5;D.#!!

!

,$)-./01!2!>@54')!>(+54#%!7!%#&'$!7!!%@=#@%!$1&!=)'#1)#!)#1*#(8!&

&

&

&

&

&

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#!

9!:#=! %@=E#=! &#! =)'#1)#=! Y$)#! $@V! )0$13#%#1*=! )4'%$*'?@#=8! WH#X)+1Y'3@($*'+1! &A@1! >(+54B%#! >@54')! #*! ED+4@*'+1! &@!)0$%>!%@=E$48!Z!

/'(#)*#@(=!2!iD#=!\'($@4*,!>(+Y#==#@(!&@!N@=E@%!1$*'+1$4!&Ae'=*+'(#!G$*@(#44#!7!-4$'1!:#3$(&#6,!>(+Y#==#@(!&#=!L1'D#(='*E=,!LNH!-/TC,!L1'D#(='*E!&#!`(+D#1)#^aGH`8!

L1'*E!&#!(#)0#()0#!2!N@=E@%!G$*'+1$4!&Ae'=*+'(#!G$*@(#44#,!LNH!fRO,!`$4+)8!

/+)*+($1*#! $==+)'E#! $@! F#1*(#! K+.(E,! FGHIMLNH! OPQR,! %#%5(#! &@! 3(+@>#! &#! (#)0#()0#! &'('3E! >$(! -%.! /$0$1! =@(!9!F0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#,!#V>#(*'=#!#*!Y$5(')$*'+1!&#=!Y@*@(=!Z8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!:#!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!)+%%#!>(+54B%#!>@54')8!

S!:#!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!&$1=!4#=!%$==!%E&'$=8!

S!:#=!)+1*(+D#(=#=!#*!?@#=*'+1=!&#!=+)'E*E!&$1=!4#=!%@=E#=!#*!)#1*(#=!&#!=)'#1)#=8!

S![&@)$*'+1!$@V!=)'#1)#=,!h!4A#1D'(+11#%#1*!#*!$@V!?@#=*'+1=!=+)'$4#%#1*!D'D#=8!

!

D97(:8*$:-#&

I+')0+*,! N8,! 9!}@#44#! E&@)$*'+1! h! 4$! )'*+.#11#*E! &$1=! 4#=! #V>+='*'+1=! =)'#1)#=! #*! =+)'E*E!_! :y#V#%>4#! &@! )0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!Z,!(1#$/,!1z!kQ,!>8!vg^nP,!fRRO8!

!

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"&

S!C+(%$*'+1!2! E4BD#! &#! 4A[)+4#! G+(%$4#! I@>E('#@(#! &#! F$)0$1! &#! fRRf! h! fRRv,! &E>$(*#%#1*! &#! 5'+4+3'#8! :$@(E$*#! &#!4A-3(E3$*'+1!I)'#1)#=!&#!4$!l'#!#*!&#!4$!"#((#!#1!fRRP8!

N$=*#(!#1!e'=*+'(#!#*!I+)'+4+3'#!&#=!=)'#1)#=,!F#1*(#!K+.(E,!fRRP^fRRv8!

N$=*#(!#1!N@=E+4+3'#!#*!NE&'$*'+1!&#=!I)'#1)#=,!fRRQ^fRRv8!

S!-)*@#44#%#1*! $44+)$*$'(#!&#! (#)0#()0#! $@!N@=E@%!G$*'+1$4! &Ae'=*+'(#!G$*@(#44#! W$44+)$*'+1!%'1'=*E('#44#,! +)*! fRRv^+)*!fRgRX8!

!

@/2-:%"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

NE%+'(#!&#!N$=*#(!f,!e'=*+'(#!#*!I+)'+4+3'#!&#=!I)'#1)#=,!F#1*(#!K+.(E!2!9!:#!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#!&$1=!4#=!#V>+='*'+1=,!#1J#@V,!+5J#)*'Y=!#*!&'YY')@4*E=!Z8!

!

@.'#&;#!9!N$('1#!I+')0+*,!N@=E@%!G$*'+1$4!&Ae'=*+'(#!G$*@(#44#!

/E>$(*#%#1*!&#=!\$4#('#=,!jQ,!(@#!\#+YY(+.!I$'1*!e'4$'(#,!F`!ff,!

vPRRP!`$('=!

"#4!2!djj!WRXg!kR!vn!Pk!nn!

T^%$'4!2!=+')0+*s$*t%1018Y(!

I'*#!q#5!2!qqq8=+')0+*8)+%!

Page 10: Centre Alexandre Koyré

(+/./$!L5&/0_@/=#&#!!

!

,$)-./01!2!Y+(#=*=!7!)4'%$*#!(E3'%#!7!#*0')=8!&

&

&

&

&

&

&

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#!

9!:#=!Y+(~*=!&$1=!4#!(E3'%#!)4'%$*'?@#!2!#1J#@V!#1D'(+11#%#1*$@V,!3E+>+4'*'?@#=!#*!E*0'?@#=!Z8!

/'(#)*(')#!2!-%.!/$0$18!

L1'*E!&#!(#)0#()0#!2!F#1*(#!K+.(E!WTeTIIMFGHIMNGeGX,!LNH!OPQR8!

[?@'>#!2!9!F0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#,!#V>#(*'=#!#*!Y@*@(=!Z8!

-44+)$*'+1!&#!(#)0#()0#!TeTII,!+)*+5(#!fRRn!S!+)*+5(#!fRgf8!

!

G6R2"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!e'=*+'(#!&#=!#1J#@V!Y+(#=*'#(=!&$1=!4#=!1E3+)'$*'+1=!'1*#(1$*'+1$4#=!#*!%E*0+&+4+3'#=!$==+)'E#=8!

S!TV>#(*'=#!Y+(#=*'B(#!&$1=!4#!(E3'%#!)4'%$*'?@#,!)++>E($*'+1!#1*(#!$)*#@(=!0E*E(+3B1#=!#*!3#=*'+1!&#!)+1*(+D#(=#=8!

S!T1J#@V! E*0'?@#=!2! *0E+('#=! %+($4#=! #*! J@=*'Y')$*'+1! >$(! 4#=! $)*#@(=,! =*$*@*! E*0'?@#! &#=! Y+(~*=,! (E>$(*'*'+1! &#=!(#=>+1=$5'4'*E=,!&#=!)+�*=!#*!&#=!5E1EY')#=8!

S!F0$13#%#1*=!)4'%$*'?@#=,!$)*'D'*E=!0@%$'1#=!#*!&@($5'4'*E!&#=!E)+=.=*B%#=!Y+(#=*'#(=8!

!

!9%%:89(92&S:$*"&

S!N$=*#(!g!9!I+)'E*E,!0+%%#=,!*#)01+4+3'#=!Z,!%#1*'+1!`0'4+=+>0'#,!L1'D#(='*E!\(#1+54#!f!WfRRf^fRRQX8!

S!:')#1)#!9!c'+4+3'#!3E1E($4#!Z,!L1'D#(='*E!\(#1+54#!g!WfRRQ^fRROX8!

S!N$=*#(!f!9!e'=*+'(#!&#=!I)'#1)#=,!"#)01+4+3'#=!#*!I+)'E*E=!Z,!F#1*(#!K+.(E,!TeTII!WfRRO^fRRnX8!

S!NE&'$*'+1!=)'#1*'Y'?@#,!-==+)'$*'+1!:#=!`#*'*=!/E5(+@'44$(&=!a/C!W&#>@'=!fRROX8!

!

@/2-:%"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!`(+J#*!&#!(#)0#()0#,!N$=*#(!g!`0'4+=+>0'#!2!`!Z'#/$!;.D=/$';$!$#!;.'#$1#&#5.'!9!2&!2=B5#5:5#=!:./&2$!0$1!'./:$1!1.;5&2$1!a!

=+@=!4$!&'(#)*'+1!&#!x8^i8!\+YY'8!

S!NE%+'(#,!N$=*#(!f!e'=*+'(#!&#=!I)'#1)#=,!"#)01+4+3'#=!#*!I+)'E*E=!2!9!F&!2+##$!;.'#/$!2&!0=%./$1#&#5.'!&+!1$5'!0+!/=B5:$!

;25:&#5>+$3! @._;.'1#/+;#5.'! 7.25#5>+$! $#! 1;5$'#5%5>+$! 0<+'! .EJ$#! 0$! '=B.;5&#5.'3! A$;.'%5B+/&#5.'! 0$1! $'J$+6!a! =+@=! 4$!&'(#)*'+1!&y-8!/$0$1!/$4%#&')+8!

!

@.'#&;#&K!$D'$(&s$*t#0#==8Y(!!

!

Page 11: Centre Alexandre Koyré

Z2.05$!L5$522$!C2&';D&/0!!!

,$)-./01!2!4'%'*=!*+!3(+q*0!7!34+5$4!%+&#44'13!7!0'=*+(.!+Y!#1D'(+1%#1*$4!*0+@30*8!&

&

&

&

&

&

G6R1"&"#&?%/?*%*$:-#!

9!N+&B4#=!%$*0E%$*'?@#=!34+5$@V,!&@!&E5$*!=@(!4$!)(+'==$1)#!h!4AE)+1+%'#!&@!)0$13#%#1*!)4'%$*'?@#8!Z!

/'(#)*(')#!2!-%.!/$0$1!

L1'*E!&#!(#)0#()0#!2!F#1*(#!-4#V$1&(#!K+.(E!

!

0-%2*$:-#&

S![*@&#=!&#!%$*0E%$*'?@#=,!L1'D#(='*E!&#!C($1)0#^F+%*E,!TGI!&#!F$)0$18!-3(E3$*'+1!fRRR8!

S!/TL\!&#!`0'4+=+>0'#,!L1'D#(='*E!&#!C($1)0#^F+%*E,!gnnn8!

S!/T-!&Ae'=*+'(#!&#=!I)'#1)#=,!TeTII,!fRRf8!

S!:')#1)#!&Ae'=*+'(#,!`$('=!laa,!fRRj8!!

-1)'#11#!5E1EY')'$'(#!&#!4$!c+@(=#!&#!/+)*+($*!>+@(!a13E1'#@(!&@!FGHI!WfRRf^fRRPX8!

-)*@#44#%#1*!#1=#'31$1*#!$@!4.)E#^THT-!"+@4+@=#!:$@*(#)!&#!l$@)(#==+18!

!

G6/2*$:Q9"1&+"&%"86"%86"&

S!e'=*+'(#!&#!4$!>#1=E#!E)+4+3'=*#!#*!&#=!&E5$*=!$@*+@(!&#=!4'%'*#=!&#!4$!>4$1B*#,!gnkP^gnvR!W&E%+3($>0'#!7!(#==+@()#=!7!>+44@*'+1X8!

S!e'=*+'(#!&@!F4@5!&#!H+%#!#*!&#=!%+&B4#=!p+(4&8!!

S![>'=*E%+4+3'#!&#=!%+&B4#=!%$*0E%$*'?@#=!34+5$@V!7!$(*')@4$*'+1!#1*(#!>+='*'+11#%#1*=!>+4'*'?@#=!#*!)+1=*(@)*'+1!&#!%+&B4#=8!!

S!`(+54E%$*'?@#=!&#!!4$!)(+'==$1)#!#*!&#!4$!&E)(+'==$1)#8!

&

D97(:8*$:-#1&

S!9!F(+'==$1)#!+@!=*$5'4'*E!_!:A#1*(#>('=#!&@!F4@5!&#!H+%#!#*!4#!&E5$*!$@*+@(!&#=!%+&B4#=!Z,!'1!F$1!T.0^2$1!0+!%+#+/8!E&'*E!>$(!-%.!/$0$1,!:$!/E)+@D#(*#,!`$('=,!fRRv8!

S!9!p0#1!%+&#44'13!*#)01+4+3'#=!=@>>+(*!D'='+1=!+Y!*0#!q+(4&!2!$1!+D#(D'#q!+Y!*0#!�4'%'*=!*+!3(+q*0A!&#5$*#!Z,!@$'#&+/+1,!$@*+%1#!fRRn,!h!>$($r*(#8!!

!!

@.'#&;#!9!#4+&D5s$*t0+*%$'48)+%!

!

!

!

!

!