Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff...

40

Transcript of Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff...

Page 1: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

A�i �L?�i?|�L?@* Ahi@|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@*�|) �?

��t�?itt �)U*i �?@*)t�tG #Lit �| �hi@|i

#�t|Lh|�L?tq �

w@�hi?Ui a� ��h�t|�@?L|@?_ +�U�@h_ �� AL__}

#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff

Devwudfw

cQr*1 Vr vd|v rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqvlvwhqw zlwk srvwzdu XV

vhdvrqdo dqg exvlqhvv f|foh gdwd1

MHO Qxpehuv= F3/ H31

�Wkh dxwkruv wkdqn U1 Dqwrq Eudxq/ Pduwlq Hlfkhqedxp/ Sklols Iudqvhv/ Hulf Jk|vhov/Fkduohv Sorvvhu/ Wrp Vdujhqw/ Fkulvwrskhu Vlpv/ Pdun Zdwvrq/ dqg dq dqrq|prxv uhihuhh irukhosixo frpphqwv dqg glvfxvvlrqv1 Wkh �uvw dxwkru dfnqrzohgjhv wkh �qdqfldo dvvlvwdqfh ri wkhQdwlrqdo Vflhqfh Irxqgdwlrq1

|Qruwkzhvwhuq Xqlyhuvlw|/ QEHU dqg wkh Ihghudo Uhvhuyh Edqnv ri Fklfdjr dqg Fohyhodqg1}Fruuhvsrqglqj dxwkru= f2r Ulvn Pdqdjhphqw Ghsduwphqw/ Ihghudo Uhvhuyh Edqn ri Plq0

qhdsrolv/ S1R1 Er{ 5<4/ Plqqhdsrolv/ PQ 887;3035<41 Whohskrqh= 945053708;971 Id{= 945053708<381 Hpdlo= glfn1wrggCpsov1iue1ruj1

Page 2: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

�� W?|hL_�U|�L?

w@h}ic hiU�hh�?} ti@tL?@* 4L�i4i?|t @hi @ ThL4�?i?| ui@|�hi Lu 4@?) iUL?L4�U _@|@ tih�itct�U� @t B#�c �L�ht �Lh!i_c @?_ UL?t�4T|�L?� 6Lh 4@?) �@h�@M*itc ti@tL?@* ��U|�@|�L?t@hi i�i? *@h}ih |�@? M�t�?itt U)U*i ��U|�@|�L?t� #itT�|i |��tc UL?�i?|�L?@* M�t�?itt U)U*i@?@*)t�t t�4T*) T�|t ti@tL?@*�|) L�| Lu t�}�| @?_ L�| Lu 4�?_G |�i _@|@ @hi ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_@| |�i tL�hUic @?_ @ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t @hi �ti_ uLh |�i @?@*)t�t� W? igiU|c Th��@|i @}i?|t @hi|hi@|i_ @t |�L�}� |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ @hi ��@| |�i) tii @?_ U�LLti� A��t T@Tih�t 4L|��@|i_ M) @ UL?Uih? |�@| UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui 4@)c M) _�tU@h_�?} �?uLh4@|�L? @ML�||�i ti@tL?@*c _�t|Lh| |�i @?@*)t�t Lu M�t�?itt U)U*it�

�?i U@? _itUh�Mi �i**�tTiU��i_ iUL?L4�U i?��hL?4i?|t ���U� h@|�L?@*�3i |�i UL?�i?|�L?@*|hi@|4i?| Lu ti@tL?@*�|)� i �**�t|h@|i |��t ��|� @ t�4T*i i @4T*i� OL�i�ihc �| �@t |�hii �ih)hit|h�U|��i ui@|�hitG E�� ti@tL?@*�|) �t TihuiU|*) uLhiU@t|@M*i @?_ i?|iht |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!t@__�|��i*)( E��� ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| �t @UUL4T*�t�i_ M) hi}hitt�L? L? ti@tL?@* _�44�it( @?_E���� |�i LT|�4@* TL*�U�it Lu @}i?|t @hi *�?i@h �? |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!t� A�ihi �t �?��iht@*@}hii4i?| |�@| ?L?i Lu |�iti ui@|�hit �L*_ i @U|*) �? hi@*�t|�U @TT*�U@|�L?t� 5|�**c �? ��@|A�L4@t 5@h}i?| E�b.H� U@**t RiUL?L4�t|t< @?U�i?| ��?U��c UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui �4T*�U�|*)@tt�4it |�i UL?_�|�L?t @hi t@|�t�i_ @t @ hL�}� @TThL �4@|�L?� W? |��t T@Tihc �i _i��ti @?_@TT*) @ 4i|�L_ |L t|�_) |�i ^�@*�|) Lu |�@| @TThL �4@|�L?�

i Mi}�? M) UL?t|h�U|�?} @ ti@tL?@* M�t�?itt U)U*i 4L_i* |�@| U@T|�hit MhL@_ ui@|�hitLu N5 ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ @?_ �?@_��t|i_ 4@UhLiUL?L4�U _@|@� `i |�i? �ti |�i 4L_i* |L}i?ih@|i @h|��U�@* _@|@ |�@| �i |hi@| @t �u |�i) �ihi |�i |h�i N5 ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ _@|@�A�iti _@|@ @hi ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ �t�?} @ �iht�L? Lu |�i 4i|�L_ �ti_ M) |�i N5 }L�ih?4i?|�A�i _@|@ @hi |�i? }��i? |L @ �)TL|�i|�U@* @?@*)t|c ��L t|�_�it |�i4 �t�?} |�i UL?�i?|�L?@*Th@U|�Ui� W? T@h|�U�*@hc |�i @?@*)t| @TT*�it |�i OL_h�U! @?_ �hitUL|| E�bb.� EO�� �*|ih |L |�i@h|��U�@* _@|@ @?_ UL4T�|it �@h�L�t tiUL?_ 4L4i?|t�� A�i @?@*)t| UL?t|h�U|t @? @ti@tL?@*4L_i*c T@h@4i|ih�3it �| �t�?} t|@?_@h_ U@*�Mh@|�L? 4i|�L_tc @?_ |�i? UL4T�|it |�i 4L_i*<tM�t�?itt U)U*i �4T*�U@|�L?t� i t�L� |�@| |�i tiUL?_ 4L4i?| ThLTih|�it �? |�i E@h|��U�@*�_@|@ 4@|U� |�Lti Lu |�i @?@*)t|<t 4L_i* �ih) U*Lti*)� i �?|ihThi| |��t @t �?_�U@|�?} |�@|c�? L�h 4L_i*c |�i @?U�i?| ��?U� �t �ih��i_�

6Lh |�i �4T*�U@|�L?t Lu L�h 4L_i* |L Mi Lu hi*i�@?Ui |L @TT*�i_ �Lh!c �| �t Uh�|�U@* |�@|�| Mi i4T�h�U@**) Uhi_�M*i� i |��t _i�L|i @ UL?t�_ih@M*i TLh|�L? Lu |�i T@Tih |L i T*@�?�?}@?_ _iui?_�?} |�i 4L_i*<t UL?t|h�U|�L?� A�i _i}hii |L ���U� ti@tL?@*t @hi uLhiU@t|@M*i �tT@h|�U�*@h*) �4TLh|@?| |L |�i L�|UL4i Lu L�h @?@*)t�t Etii �*Lttih E�b.b�� @?_ �t @*tL ��}�*)UL?|hL�iht�@* Etiic i�}�c 6h@?titc OLi!c @?_ �@@T E�bb.�c O)**iMih}c aLh}i?ti?c @?_ 5Lhi?ti?

4Wr lqvxuh urexvwqhvv/ zh uhshdw rxu dqdo|vlv zlwk wkh KS �owhu uhsodfhg e| wkh �uvw0gl�huhqfh�owhu1 Rxu edvlf frqfoxvlrqv duh qrw vxevwdqwlyho| d�hfwhg e| wklv fkdqjh1

Page 3: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

E�bb���� �t @ hit�*|c �i T@) T@h|�U�*@h @||i?|�L? |L |��t �tt�i�A�i T*@? Lu |�i T@Tih �t @t uL**L�t� A�i �ht| tiU|�L? Mi*L� Thiti?|t @ �ih) t�4T*i i @4T*i

|L �**�t|h@|i @ ti| Lu hit|h�U|�L?t L? @ 4L_i* @?_ _@|@ |�@| h@|�L?@*�3i |�i UL?�i?|�L?@*|hi@|4i?| Lu ti@tL?@*�|)� i �?_�U@|i |�ihi ��@| u@U|Lht @hi *�!i*) |L *i@_ |L _�t|Lh|�L?tctL |�@| �i 4@) Mi 4�?_u�* Lu |�i4 @t �i UL?t|h�U| |�i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* �ti_ �? |�i 4@�?@?@*)t�t� 5iU|�L? � _itUh�Mit |�@| 4L_i*� 5iU|�L? e _�tU�ttit �L� �i U�Lti �@*�it uLh �|tT@h@4i|iht� 5L4i TL�?|t Lu TL|i?|�@* �?_iTi?_i?| �?|ihit| i4ih}i �? |��t _�tU�tt�L?c t�U�@t |�@| |�i ti@tL?@* T@||ih? �? �L�ht �Lh!i_ @?_ ThL_�U|���|) �t �ih) ti?t�|��i |L �L� �L�ht�Lh!i_ @hi 4i@t�hi_� 5iU|�L? D ThL��_it i��_i?Ui L? |�i }LL_?itt�Lu��| Lu L�h ti@tL?@*4L_i*� 5iU|�L? S _itUh�Mit |�i 4L_i*t it|�4@|i_ M) |�i �)TL|�i|�U@* @?@*)t| ��L @TT*�it|�i UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui� 5iU|�L? . Thiti?|t L�h M@t�U hit�*|t @?_ _itUh�Mit �L� �i** |�i@?@*)t| �t�?} |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui �t @M*i |L �?_iht|@?_ |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i ThLTih|�itLu |�i _@|@� 5iU|�L? H Thiti?|t UL?U*�_�?} hi4@h!t�

2� �L?�i?|�L?@* �h@U|�Uic @?_ `�ihi W| �@? BL hL?}

i _itUh�Mi @? i?��hL?4i?| �? ���U� |�i �4T*�U�| @tt�4T|�L?t �?_ih*)�?} |�i UL?�i?|�L?@*|hi@|4i?| Lu ti@tL?@*�|) @hi i @U|*) |h�i� i |�i? ��}�*�}�| |�i |�hii hit|h�U|��i ui@|�hit�? |�i i @4T*i |�@| �ihi ?L|i_ �? |�i �?|hL_�U|�L?c @?_ TL�?| L�| ��) |�i) @hi �?*�!i*) |LMi t@|�t�i_ �? Th@U|�Ui� A��t 4L|��@|it |�i @?@*)t�t �? |�i hi4@�?_ih Lu |�i T@Tihc ���U�@M@?_L?t i?��hL?4i?|t �? ���U� |�iti ui@|�hit @hi t@|�t�i_ i @U|*)�

2��� � 5�4T*i �L_i*

W? |�i 4L_i*c UL?t�4T|�L?c �|c @?_ |�i Mi}�??�?} Lu Tih�L_ t|LU! Lu U@T�|@*c g|c tL*�i |�iuL**L��?} ThLM*i4G

4@ .f

"[

|'f

q| *?E�|�c E2���

t�M�iU| |LGt| ' �| ng|n� � E�� B�g|c t| ' e%|gk

| c E2�2�

��ihi .f _i?L|it |�i _@|i f UL?_�|�L?@* i TiU|@|�L?c gf �t }��i? @?_c

%| ' %?r| n %_|

%?r| ' 4%?r|3� n 0|c 0| � �Efc j2�c E2���

%_| ' �rc | L__

%_| ' rc | i�i?�

2

Page 4: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

Oihic kc 4c q 5 Efc ��� i |��?! Lu |�i |�4i Tih�L_ �? |�i 4L_i* @t Mi�?} S 4L?|�tc tL |�@| �|�t @ t�4T*i 4L_i* Lu ti@tL?@*�|)� `�i? B ' �c |�i? |�i i^��*�Mh��4 t|LU! Lu U@T�|@* uLh |��t4L_i* i�L*�it @t uL**L�tG

*?g|n� ' *?kq n k *?g| n %?r| n %_| c E2�e�

}��i? gf @?_ uLh | ' fc �c 2c ��� � ,^��*�Mh��4 t| @?_ �| @hi uL�?_ M) t�Mt|�|�|�?} |�ii^��*�Mh��4 U@T�|@* t|LU! �?|L E2�2��

A�i U@T�|@* t|LU! |�@| tL*�it E2�e� U@? Mi i Thitti_ @t |�i t�4 Lu ��@| �| �L�*_ Mi �u|�ihi �ihi ?L ti@tL?@*c T*�t @ T�hi ti@tL?@* |ih4c @u|ih |@!�?} ?@|�h@* *L}t� 5TiU��U@**)c

*?g| ' *?g?r| n _g| E2�D�

��ihi g?r|n�c | ' fc �c 2c ���c tL*�it E2�e� ��|� %_| � f @?_ *L}g?r

f' *L}gf � _g

f� �*tLc

_g| ' ��

� n k%_| c | ' fc�c ��� �

AL �ih�u) |�@| E2�D� �t @ �@*�_ _iUL4TLt�|�L? Lu *?g|c �| �t t��U�i?| |L UL?�h4 |�@| _g|n� 'k_g| n %_| uLh | ' fc �c 2c ��� �

i U@? LM|@�? @ t�4�*@h _iUL4TLt�|�L? uLh }hLtt L�|T�|c t|c M@ti_ L? |�i ThL_�U|�L?u�?U|�L?c E2�2�G

*? t| ' *?t ?r| n _t| c E2�S�

��ihi

_t| ' %_| n k_g| c

*?t ?r| ' %?r| n k *?g?r

| �

Oihic t ?r| �t |�i *i�i* Lu L�|T�| |�@| �L�*_ LUU�h �u |�ihi �ihi ?L ti@tL?@*� �U|�@* L�|T�|

�t |��t |ih4c T*�t @ ti@tL?@* _�44)c @u|ih |@!�?} *L}t�

2�2� �L?�i?|�L?@* �h@U|�Uic +@|�L?@*�3i_

i ?L� _itUh�Mi @ t|)*�3i_ hiThiti?|@|�L? Lu UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui �? |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i*�|ih@|�hi� �L?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i |hi@|4i?| Lu q �? |�@| *�|ih@|�hic �i t�4T*) @tt�4i |�i@?@*)t| !?L�t �|t |h�i �@*�i ��|�L�| �@��?} |L it|�4@|i �|� i @*tL @tt�4i |�i @?@*)t|!?L�t |�i M@t�U t|h�U|�hi Lu |�i 4L_i*� i t�TTLti |�i @?@*)t| !?L�t |�i |h�i �@*�i Luk MiU@�tic t@)c |�i t�@hi Lu �?UL4i i@h?i_ M) U@T�|@* �? |�i iUL?L4) �t T�M*�t�i_ �? @

Page 5: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

ti| Lu ?@|�L?@* �?UL4i @UUL�?|t� A�i T@h@4i|iht Lu |�i |�4i tih�it hiThiti?|@|�L? Lu %?r| �tit|�4@|i_ M@ti_ L? |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@�

i t�TTLti |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| �? |��t iUL?L4) UL4T�*it LMtih�@|�L?t L? g| @?_ t|�

�iuLhi ThL��_�?} |�i _@|@ |L |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i @?@*)t|c ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| �t U@hh�i_ L�|M) �ht| UL4T�|�?} |�i hit�_�@*t uhL4 @ *i@t| t^�@hit hi}hitt�L? Lu *? g| @?_ *?t| L? ti@tL?@*_�44�itc @?_ |�i? @__�?} M@U! |�i t@4T*i @�ih@}it Lu |�i h@� _@|@� `�|� |��t ti@tL?@*@_��t|4i?| ThLUi_�hi E@TT*�i_ �? @ *@h}i t@4T*i Lu _@|@� |�i _@|@ @�@�*@M*i |L |�i @?@*)t|@hi *?g?r

| @?_ *?t ?r| �

`�|� |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ �? �@?_c �i t�TTLti |�i @?@*)t| uL**L�t UL?�i?|�L?@*Th@U|�Ui M) UL4T�|�?} |iU�?L*L}) t�LU!t @t *? t ?r

| �k *?g?r| ��L|i |�@| |��t ThL_�Uit i @U|*)

%?r| �`�|� @ *@h}i t@4T*i Lu _@|@c |�i @?@*)t| U@? |�i? �?_ 4 @?_ j �? E2��� M) �t�?} t|@?_@h_hi}hitt�L? @?@*)t�t�

O@��?} U@*�Mh@|i_ |�i 4L_i*c |�i @?@*)t| UL4T@hit |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i ThLTih|�it Lu |�i4L_i* ��|� |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i ThLTih|�it �? |�i Eti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_� _@|@� W? |��t i @4T*ic|�i @?@*)t| �?_t |�@| |�i 4L_i* @?_ |�i _@|@ 4it� i @U|*)� A��t �t |h�ic ��i|�ih Lh ?L| |�iti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ @?_ *L}}i_ _@|@ @hi ML|� O� �*|ihi_�

2��� �L|i?|�@* ��|u@**t uLh �L?�i?|�L?@* �h@U|�Ui

W? |�i i @4T*ic |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ @�@�*@M*i |L |�i @?@*)t|c |L}i|�ih ��|� |�i�4T*�i_ �@*�it uLh |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!t @?_ T@h@4i|ihtc tL*�i |�i |h�i 4L_i*� A�i i @4T*ih@|�L?@*�3it UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui TihuiU|*)� ��|c t�L�*_ |�iti �4T*�U@|�L?t Lu |�i i @4T*iMi |@!i? tih�L�t*)q

W? Th@U|�Uic ?L?i Lu |�i |�hii Uh�U�@* ui@|�hit Lu |�i i @4T*i Eui@|�hit E���E���� ��}�*�}�|i_�? |�i �?|hL_�U|�L?� @hi *�!i*) |L Mi t@|�t�i_� 6Lh i @4T*ic t�TTLti ti@tL?@*�|) _�_ i?|ih@__�|��i*) �? |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!tc @t �? E��c M�| |�@| |�i ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?| �ihi ?L|TihuiU|*) Thi_�U|@M*i� W? |��t U@tic @}i?|t 4�t| }�itt ��i|�ih @ }��i? 4L�i4i?| �? i L}i?L�tt�LU!t hi�iU|t @ U�@?}i �? |�i ti@tL?@* Lh ?L?ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?|c uLhU�?} |�i4 |L hitTL?_|L @?) 4L�i4i?|c ti@tL?@* Lh ?L?ti@tL?@*c @t |�L�}� �| hi�iU|t @ 4� |�hi Lu ML|�� 5Lc |�iti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ �iht�L? Lu @}i?|t< UL?t�4T|�L?c �?�it|4i?|c i4T*L)4i?|c i|U�c _iU�t�L?t��** Mi @ u�?U|�L?c �? T@h|c Lu |�i ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?| Lu |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!t�2

�L?t�_ih |�i hL*i Lu |�i ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| ThLUi_�hi� ��h @?@*)t�t Lu |�i _�44)ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| 4i|�L_ i T*L�|t �|t ThLTih|�it Lu �_i4TL|i?U) E��i�c �d�E%�o ' �E%�c��ihi � �t |�i �*|ih @?_ % _i?L|it |�i h@� _@|@� @?_ *�?i@h�|) E�E% n +� ' �E%� n �E+����

5Vhh Jk|vhov +4<;;,/ Sorvvhu +4<:<, dqg Vdujhqw +4<;:/ ss1 6690675, iru ixuwkhu glvfxvvlrq16Iru d glvfxvvlrq ri wkh lghpsrwhqf| dqg olqhdulw| ri wkh gxpp| vhdvrqdo dgmxvwphqw sur0

fhgxuh/ vhh Oryhoo +4<96,1

e

Page 6: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

A�iti ThLTih|�it @hi @| Mit| L?*) @TThL �4@|i*) |h�i ��i? @ ThLUi_�hi *�!i |�i L�U�@* �i?t�tj��� ThLUi_�hi �t @TT*�i_�

6�?@**)c �?*�!i E2�e�c |�i TL*�U) h�*it |�@| tL*�i 4L_i*t @?@*)3i_ �? Th@U|�Ui @hi ?L|i @U|*) *�?i@h� �| |�i �ih) *i@t|c �i U@? i TiU| ULi�U�i?|t L? i?_L}i?L�t �@h�@M*it |L�@h) ��|� |�i ti@tL?t� Wu @}i?|t< _iU�t�L? h�*it �ihi @ ?L?*�?i@h u�?U|�L? Lu |�i ti@tL?@*@?_ ?L?ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?|tc |�i? UL?�i?|�L?@* ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| ThLUi_�hit �L�*_ ?L|tiT@h@|i |�i�h _iU�t�L?t �?|L @ T@h| i U*�t��i*) hi*@|i_ |L |�i ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?| @?_ @ T@h|i U*�t��i*) hi*@|i_ |L |�i ?L?ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?|� �? i @4T*i �t UL?t�4T|�L?c �|c �? |�i4L_i* iUL?L4) _itUh�Mi_ @ML�i� W| �t ?L| @ *�?i@h Lh *L}�*�?i@h u�?U|�L? Lu |�i i L}i?L�tt�LU!t� �t @ hit�*|c �| _Lit ?L| �@�i |�i i @U| _iUL4TLt�|�L? _iT�U|i_ �? E2�D� Lh E2�S��

A�iti Uh�|�U�t4t Lu |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui @hi ?L| UL?U*�t��i MiU@�ti |�i UL?t�_ih@�|�L?t h@�ti_ @ML�i 4@) ?L| Mi ^�@?|�|@|��i*) �4TLh|@?|�e �*|�L�}� |�i�h TLt�|�L? �t ?L|�?��iht@**) @UUiT|i_c �@ht!) @?_ ��hL? E�bHb� @h}�i |�@| |�i ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?| �? 4@?)4@UhLiUL?L4�U |�4i tih�it U@? Mi �i** hiThiti?|i_ M) _i|ih4�?�t|�U t��u|t �? UL?t|@?| |ih4t�+i}@h_�?} |�i ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| �*|ihc �*i�i*@?_ @?_ A�@L E�b.S�c @**�t E�b.e�c @?_vL�?} E�bSH� @h}�i |�@| |�i �i?t�t j��� ThLUi_�hi �t ?i@h*) *�?i@h�D �*tLc ���*i ?L| i �@U|*) �_i4TL|i?|c |�i ThLUi_�hi 4@) Mi ?i@h*) tL� 6�?@**)c �| �@t Mii? ?L|i_ |�@| |�i_iU�t�L? h�*it |�@| tL*�i 4@?) 4L_ih? 4@UhLiUL?L4�U 4L_i*t @hi �ih) U*Lti |L *�?i@h Etii��h�t|�@?L �bbf�� �i@h _�44) ti@tL?@*�|) T*�t ?i@h *�?i@h _iU�t�L? h�*it T*�t @ ti@tL?@*@_��t|4i?| ThLUi_�hi |�@| �t ?i@h*) *�?i@h @?_ �_i4TL|i?| �L�*_ Thit�4@M*) �4T*) *�||*i_�t|Lh|�L?�

�� ��h 5i@tL?@* �L_i*

A��t tiU|�L? Thiti?|t |�i 4@�? ti@tL?@* 4L_i* �ti_ �? L�h @?@*)t�t� i Mi}�? M) Thiti?|�?}L�h @tt�4T|�L?t L? Thiuihi?Uit @?_ |iU�?L*L})� i |�i? _�tU�tt |�i |�4i tih�it hiThiti?|@�|�L?t uLh |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!t�

7Zh zlvk wr gl�huhqwldwh wklv ghihqvh ri vwdqgdug sudfwlfh iurp Kdqvhq dqg Vdujhqw +4<<6,dqg Vlpv +4<:9,*v ghihqvh1 Wkh| hpskdvl}h wkdw prgholqj vhdvrqdolw| h{solflwo|/ exw zlwk dqlqfruuhfw vshfl�fdwlrq ri wkh vhdvrqdo/ dovr ohdgv wr glvwruwlrqv1 Wkhvh glvwruwlrqv/ wkh| dujxh/fdq h{fhhg wkrvh wkdw dulvh iurp wkh vwdqgdug sudfwlfh1 Zh gr qrw frqvlghu wkhlu dujxphqw lqwklv sdshu1 Exw/ zh ylhz lw dv srwhqwldoo| frpsohphqwdu| wr rxu �qglqj wkdw wkh glvwruwlrqv lqvwdqgdug sudfwlfh pd| eh vpdoo1

8Jk|vhov/ Judqjhu dqg Vlnorv +4<<9, dujxh wkdw wkhuh lv d vhqvh lq zklfk wkh [044 lv qrw vrforvh wr olqhdu1 Dv qrwhg e| d uhihuhh/ wkh qrqolqhdulw| lq wkh Fhqvxv [44 surfhgxuh uh�hfwv/lq sduw wkdw lw lqyroyhv d vhtxhqfh ri glvfuhwh ghflvlrqv +zkhwkhu wr dgmxvw ru qrw/ zkhwkhu wrdgmxvw pxowlsolfdwlyho| ru dgglwlyho|/ hwf1,1

D

Page 7: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

A�i Thiuihi?Uit Lu |�i hiThiti?|@|��i �L�ti�L*_ @hi @t uL**L�tG

.f

"[

|'f

q| d�| *?E�|� n *?EA � ?|�o c f q �c E����

��ihi ?| _i?L|it �L�ht �Lh!i_c �| �t @ |@t|i t�LU! ThLUitt ��Lti |�4i tih�it hiThiti?|@|�L?�t Thiti?|i_ Mi*L� @?_ A �t |�i |�4i i?_L�4i?|�

�ih U@T�|@ L�|T�|c t|c �t ThL_�Ui_ ��@ |�i �LMM�#L�}*@t ThL_�U|�L? u�?U|�L?

t| ' gk| E5|?|�

�3kc E��2�

��ihi 5| �t @? @}}hi}@|i t�LU! |L |iU�?L*L}) @?_ f k �� A�i |iU�?L*L}) t�LU! �@t |�ihiThiti?|@|�L?

5| ' 5|3�eb|c E����

@?_ |�i |�4i tih�it 4L_i* uLh b| �t _itUh�Mi_ Mi*L��W?�it|4i?| ThL�iU|t hi^��hi uL�h ^�@h|iht |L UL4T*i|i� �hL�iU|t t|@h|i_ �? Tih�L_ |c 7|c

UL?|h�M�|i |L |�i i�L*�|�L? Lu |�i U@T�|@* t|LU! @t uL**L�tG

g|ne � E� � B�g|n� ' 7|c f B �c E��e�

��ihic @t �? |�i Thi��L�t tiU|�L?c B _i?L|it |�i _iThiU�@|�L? h@|i L? U@T�|@*� �ih�L_ | t|@h|thi^��hi |�i @TT*�U@|�L? Lu /fc|7| hitL�hUit �? |�i U�hhi?| ^�@h|ih( /�c|7| �? |�i ?i | ^�@h|ih(/2c|7| �? |�i uL**L��?} ^�@h|ih @?_ /�c|7| �? |�i �?@* ^�@h|ih Lu |�i ThL�iU|� i �ti |�i|�4i t�MtUh�T|t �? |�i /�c|<t |L @UUL44L_@|i ti@tL?@* �@h�@|�L?c @t _�tU�tti_ Mi*L�� AL|@*�?�it|4i?| �? Tih�L_ | �t |�i t�4 Lu hitL�hUit hi^��hi_ M) ThL�iU|t t|@h|i_ �? |�i U�hhi?| @?_Thi��L�t |�hii ^�@h|ihtG

U| ' /fc|7| n /�c|3�7|3� n /2c|327|32 n /�c|3�7|3�� E��D�

A�i @}}hi}@|i hitL�hUi UL?t|h@�?| �tG

t| � �| n U| nC|c E��S�

��ihi C| _i?L|it }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L?� i @_LT| @ 4L_��i_ �iht�L? Lu ��h�t|�@?L @?_,�U�i?M@�4<t E�bb2� 4L_i* Lu C|G

C| ' }|5|� E��.�

i ?L� _�tU�tt |�i |�4i tih�it hiThiti?|@|�L? Lu }| @?_ |�i L|�ih i L}i?L�t t�LU!tc �|@?_ b|� A�i UL?t�_ih@|�L?t i4T�@t�3i_ �? |�i �?|hL_�U|�L? t�}}it| |�@| �i 4�t| Mi �i �M*i

S

Page 8: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

hi}@h_�?} |�i _i}hii Lu Thi_�U|@M�*�|) �? |�i ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?| Lu |�iti �@h�@M*it� A�i |�4itih�it hiThiti?|@|�L?t �ti_ �? �@ht!) @?_ ��hL? E�bHb� t��| L�h T�hTLtitG

*?%| ' %_| n %?_| c E��H�

uLh % ' �c bc }� W? E��H�c %_| �t @ _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti^�i?Ui Lu ti@tL?@* _�44�it ��|� Tih�L_ec @?_ %?_| �t |�i uL**L��?} 3ihL�4i@? UL�@h�@?Ui t|@|�L?@h) ThLUittG

E� � ��u� �2u2�E�� wue�%?_| ' 0|c E��b�

��ihi 0| �t @ 4i@?�3ihLc �?_iTi?_i?| @?_ �_i?|�U@**) _�t|h�M�|i_ �Lh4@* �@h�@M*i ��|� �@h��@?Ui j2� Oihic u _i?L|it |�i *@} LTih@|Lh� A�i hiThiti?|@|�L? uLh %?_| �? E��b� @**L�t uLh@? �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?| ��i? w 9' f� i U@** E��H��E��b� L�h M@ti*�?i t�LU!

4L_i*� A�i �iht�L? Lu L�h 4L_i* |�@| �?ULhTLh@|it |��t hiThiti?|@|�L? Lu |�i t�LU!t �t U@**i_|�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*�

AL }�@h_ @}@�?t| M�@t �? u@�Lh Lu 4L_i*t ��|� _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|)c �i @*tL UL?t�_ih@? @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i* �? ���U� @** ti@tL?@*�|) �t uLhUi_ �?|L |�i �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U T@h|Lu ,? %|� W? |�@| 4L_i*c %_| �t t�4T*) @ UL?t|@?| uLh @** | @?_ %?_| �@t @ ��}��Lh_ih @�|Lhi�}hitt��i hiThiti?|@|�L?� �L_��U@|�L?t Lu L�h M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* |�@| �?ULhTLh@|i |��thiThiti?|@|�L? uLh L?i Lh @** Lu |�i t�LU!t )�i*_ L�h @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t�

A�i i?_L}i?L�t �@h�@M*it Lu |�i 4L_i* 4@ �4�3i E���� t�M�iU| |L |�i �@h�L�t UL?t|h@�?|t_itUh�Mi_� A�i 4i|�L_ �i �ti |L @TThL �4@|i |�i 4L_i*<t tL*�|�L? ULhhitTL?_t |L |�i L?i�4T*i4i?|i_ M) �h@�? @?_ ,�@?t E�bbD�� W| �t �4TLh|@?| |L i4T�@t�3i |�@|c @*|�L�}� L�htL*�|�L? 4i|�L_ �t M@ti_ L? *�?i@h�3@|�L?c �| _Lit ?L| uLhUi |�i tL*�|�L? |L *�?i@h*) _iUL4TLti�?|L |�i t�4 Lu ti@tL?@* @?_ ?L?�ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?|t� ��h 4L_i* tL*�|�L? ThLUi_�hi E*L}�� *�?i@h�3it @hL�?_ |�i 4L_i*<t ti@tL?@**) �@h)�?} t|i@_) t|@|i }hL�|� T@|��S A��tc |�itL*�|�L? |@!it |�i uLh4 Lu uL�h _�t|�?U| _iU�t�L? h�*itc L?i uLh i@U� ti@tL?� W? Th�?U�T*ic|��t �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� @ *�?i@h _iUL4TLt�|�L?c �u @** |�i ti@tL?@* �@h�@|�L? @TTi@hi_ �? |�iUL?t|@?| |ih4t� OL�i�ihc |�i tL*�|�L? 4i|�L_ @*tL Tih4�|t ti@tL?@* �@h�@|�L? |L @TTi@h�? t*LTi |ih4tc �? ���U� U@ti |�i _@|@ U@??L| Mi *�?i@h*) _iUL4TLti_ �?|L ti@tL?@* @?_?L?ti@tL?@* T@h|t�

e� �@h@4i|ih�3�?} |�i 5i@tL?@* �L_i*

A��t tiU|�L? _�tU�ttit �L� �i T�U!i_ |�i T@h@4i|ih �@*�it uLh L�h ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t� A�ihi@hi |�L |)Tit Lu T@h@4i|ihtc |�Lti |�@| �@h) ��|� |�i ti@tL?t @?_ |�Lti |�@| _L ?L|� 6Lh

9Rxu phwkrg lv vlplodu wr wkh rqh lpsohphqwhg e| Eudxq dqg Hydqv +4<<8,1

.

Page 9: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

|�i *@||ihc �i t�4T*) @_LT| |�i �@*�it �? ��h�t|�@?L @?_ ,�U�i?M@�4 E�bb2�G A ' ��SbcB ' �f2�c q ' ��f�3f�2Dc @?_ k ' f��e� A�i�h h@|�L?@*i uLh U�LLt�?} |�iti T@h@4i|ih �@*�it@TT*�it �? L�h UL?|i | |LL� A�i ti@tL?@* T@h@4i|iht � |�i |�4i�|L�M��*_ �i�}�|t @?_ |�Lti|�@| _itUh�Mi |�i |�4i tih�it hiThiti?|@|�L?t Lu |�i i L}i?L�t t|LU�@t|�U ThLUittit � 4�t| Miit|�4@|i_ �t�?} ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ _@|@� A�i _@|@ |�@| �i �ti @hi _itUh�Mi_ �? |�i �ht|t�MtiU|�L? Mi*L��

A�i tiUL?_ t�MtiU|�L? it|�4@|it L�h M@ti*�?i t�LU! 4L_i*t� ��h TL�?| it|�4@|it @|�|h�M�|i 4�U� Lu |�i ti@tL?@* 4L�i4i?|t �? |�i |@t|i @?_ |iU�?L*L}) t�LU!t |L _i|ih4�?�t|�U_�44�it� i _�tU�tt |�i �?|ihThi|@|�L? Lu |�i |i4TLh@* T@||ih? Lu |�iti _�44�itc ���U��i �?_ T*@�t�M*i� W?_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|) T*@)t @ hi*@|��i*) 4Lhi �4TLh|@?| hL*i �? |�i}L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? t�LU! ThLUitt�

A�i _�tU�tt�L? �? tiU|�L? 2 t�}}it|t |�@| L�h M@ti*�?i TL�?| it|�4@|it 4@) |�*| L�h hi�t�*|t �? u@�Lh Lu |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui L? ti@tL?@*�|)� AL �?LU�*@|i L�hti*�it @}@�?t|M�@t �i �?_ih|@!i @? @__�|�L?@* it|�4@|�L? i ihU�ti �? |�i |��h_ t�MtiU|�L? Mi*L�� A�ihic�i it|�4@|i L�h @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i*tc ���U� @hi T�hi*) �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U @?_ ���U� i �U*�_i _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|) @*|L}i|�ih� A�iti 4L_i*t @hi t�M�iU|i_ |L t|@|�t|�U@* |it|t�? �TTi?_� �� A�i |it|t hi�iU| |�i @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i* �? |�i U@ti Lu |�i |@t|i @?_|iU�?L*L}) t�LU!tc M�| _L ?L| hi�iU| �| �? |�i U@ti Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} t�LU!�. i�?|ihThi| |�i L�|UL4i Lu |��t |it| @t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i ?L|�L?c t�}}it|i_ M) L�h M@ti*�?it�LU! 4L_i* it|�4@|�L? hit�*|tc |�@| _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|) �t �4TLh|@?| �? |�i |@t|i @?_|iU�?L*L}) t�LU! ThLUittit� 5|�**c hLM�t|?itt UL?t�_ih@|�L?t *i@_ �t |L �ti ML|� L�h M@ti*�?i@?_ @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i*t �? |�i @?@*)t�t hiTLh|i_ �? *@|ih tiU|�L?t�

A�i �?@* t�MtiU|�L? Mi*L� it|�4@|it |�i |�4i�|L�M��*_ �i�}�|t Lu L�h ti@tL?@* 4L_i*�A�iti @hi ti*iU|i_ |L i?t�hi |�@| |�i 4L_i* hiT*�U@|it |�i LMtih�i_ ti@tL?@* T@||ih? �?�?�it|4i?|� A�i hit�*|�?} it|�4@|i_ �i�}�|t @hi UL?t�t|i?| ��|� 4�UhLiUL?L4�U i��_i?Ui L?�?�it|4i?| ThL�iU|t�

e��� A�i N5 #@|@

`�|� L?i i UiT|�L?c �i �ti |�i ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ ^�@h|ih*) _@|@ UL4T�*i_ M) �@ht!)@?_ ��hL? E�bHb� uLh |�i Tih�L_ �beS�HD� A�i i UiT|�L? �t |�i _@|@ L? |L|@* �L�ht �Lh!i_�i @h}�i �? �TTi?_� � |�@| |�i �@ht!) @?_ ��hL? _@|@c M@ti_ L? |�i it|@M*�t�4i?|

t�h�i) uLh |�i Tih�L_ �bSe�HDc @hi 4�t*i@_�?} uLh |�i T�hTLti Lu �?_iht|@?_�?} ti@tL?@*

:Zlwkrxw ixuwkhu uhvwulfwlrqv/ ghvfulplqdwlqj ehwzhhq lqghwhuplqlvwlf dqg ghwhuplqlvwlf vhd0vrqdolw| lv qrw srvvleoh lq d �qlwh gdwd vhw1 Lq rxu whvw zh lpsrvh wkh uhvwulfwlrqv wkdw wkhlqghwhuplqlvwlf dqg ghwhuplqlvwlf prghov duh sduwlfxodu sdudphwulf uhsuhvhqwdwlrqv ri wkh gdwd1Zlwk wkhvh dgglwlrqdo uhvwulfwlrqv/ rxu whvw lv d phdqlqjixo rqh1 Iru ixuwkhu glvfxvvlrq/ vhhDsshqgl{ E1

H

Page 10: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

��U|�@|�L?t� i U*@�4 |�ihi |�@| @ Mi||ih 4i@t�hi Lu �L�ht �Lh!i_ �t |�i L?i M@ti_ L?@ t�h�i) Lu �L�ti�L*_tc @?_ @_��t|i_ uLh �Lh!uLhUi UL4TLt�|�L? M) B@h) O@?ti? E�bb���O@?ti?<t ^�@h|ih*) i�U�i?U) �L�ht _@|@ t|@h| �? �bDD @?_ �ihi UL?�ih|i_ �?|L Tih U@T�|@|ih4t M) _���_�?} M) |�i TLT�*@|�L? @}i_ 2f�SD� A�i L|�ih _@|@ �ti_ �? |��t @?@*)t�t �ihi@*tL UL?�ih|i_ �?|L Tih U@T�|@ |ih4t �? |��t �@)� 6�?@**)c |�i �?�it|4i?| _@|@ tih�it |�@| �iUL?t|h�U| uhL4 |�i �@ht!)���hL? _@|@ ti| ULhhitTL?_t |L M�t�?itt � i_ �?�it|4i?|c ���*i|�i UL?t�4T|�L? _@|@ ULhhitTL?_t |L UL?t�4T|�L? Lu ?L?_�h@M*it @?_ tih��Uit�

e�2� �@ti*�?i 5�LU! �L_i*t

B��i? |�i @ti@tL?@* T@h@4i|ih �@*�it |@!i? uhL4 ��h�t|�@?L @?_ ,�U�i?M@�4 E�bb2� @?_|�i i^�@|�L?t Lu L�h 4L_i*c �i �ti |�i _@|@ |L UL4T�|i @? �4T*�i_ |�4i tih�it uLh i@U� LuL�h i L}i?L�t t�LU!t� i |�i? �ti |�iti |�4i tih�it |L it|�4@|i L�h M@ti*�?i |�4i tih�ithiThiti?|@|�L?c E��b�c uLh i@U� i L}i?L�t t�LU! ThLUitt� W? i@U� U@tic �i it|�4@|i 4L_i*E��H��E��b� �? |�L t|iTt� A�i �ht| t|iT �?�L*�it hi}hitt�L? L? ti@tL?@* _�44�it� A�i tiUL?_t|iT �|t 4L_i* E��b� |L |�i �||i_ _�t|�hM@?Uit uhL4 |�i t|iT�L?i hi}hitt�L? �t�?} t|@?_@h_|�4i tih�it 4i|�L_t�

e�2��� A@t|i 5�LU!t

�L?t�_ih |�i |@t|i t�LU! �ht|� AL UL4T�|i |�i �4T*�i_ |�4i tih�it uLh |�i |@t|i t�LU!c �i�ti_ |�i �?|h@|i4TLh@* �ht|�Lh_ih UL?_�|�L? ULhhitTL?_�?} |L |�i �L�ht _iU�t�L?� W? |ih4tLu |�i �@h�@M*it _i�?i_ �? |�i Thi��L�t tiU|�L?c |��t �t i Thitti_ @t

�| '�|?|

t|EA � ?|�E� � k��

A�i *L}@h�|�4 Lu |�i |@t|i�t�LU! _@|@ �t _�tT*@)i_ �? 6�}�hi �@� �L|i �L� |�i *@t| ui�LMtih�@|�L?t h�ti t�Mt|@?|�@**)c @t |�L�}� |�i) �ihi _h@�? uhL4 @ _�gihi?| TLT�*@|�L? |�@?|�i ThiUi_�?} LMtih�@|�L?t� �iU@�ti Lu |��tc @?_ �? Lh_ih |L @�L�_ �tt�it Lu TL|i?|�@* ?L?�t|@|�L?@h�|)c �i _hLTTi_ |�i *@t| H LMtih�@|�L?t uLh T�hTLtit Lu it|�4@|�?} @ |�4i tih�ithiThiti?|@|�L? uLh |�iti tih�it� i @*tL _hLTTi_ |�i �ht| �2 LMtih�@|�L?tc |L 4@�?|@�? UL?�t�t|i?U) ��|� |�i Tih�L_t Lu @TT@hi?| t|@|�L?@h�|) Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?| t�LU! tih�it Etii Mi*L���

A�i -2 Lu |�i hi}hitt�L? Lu |�i *L}�|@t|i t�LU! L? _�44�it �t f�D.c t�}}it|�?} |�@||�i _�44) �@h�@M*it @UUL�?| uLh 4Lhi |�@? Df TihUi?| Lu |�i �@h�@|�L? �? |�i |@t|i t�LU!�i |it|i_ |�i �L�?| ?�** �)TL|�it�t |�@| @** |�i _�44�it @hi i^�@*� A�i hit�*|�?} |it|

t|@|�t|�Uc �Dbc �t @ hi@*�3@|�L? uhL4 @ ����t^�@hi ��|� |�hii _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 �?_ih |�i

b

Page 11: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

?�** �)TL|�it�t�H A��tc |�i ?�** �)TL|�it�t �t L�ih��i*4�?}*) hi�iU|i_� A��t i��_i?Ui �tUL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i �)TL|�it�t |�@| |�ihi �t @? �4TLh|@?| _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@* �? |�i _@|@�b

�@?i* � Lu A@M*i � hiTLh|t |�i it|�4@|�L? hit�*|t uLh |�i |@t|i t�LU! 4L_i*� �L|i |�@||�i T@h@4i|ih �?_i �?} |�i �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*c wc �t ?L| t�}?��U@?|*) _�gihi?| uhL43ihL� i ?L?i|�i*itt hi|@�? |�i TL�?| it|�4@|i Lu w �? L�h M@ti*�?i t�LU! 4L_i*��f A�i|@t|i _�44�it @TTi@h |L �@�i @ hi@tL?@M*i �?|ihThi|@|�L?� A�i) �4T*) |�@| |�i hi*@|��iThiuihi?Ui uLh UL?t�4T|�L? �iht�t *i�t�hi �t @*4Lt| UL?t|@?| �? ^�@h|iht � @?_ 2� A�ihi �t @t��u| �? u@�Lh Lu *i�t�hi �? ^�@h|ih |�hiic @?_ |�i? @ t|hL?}ih t��u| M@U! |L UL?t�4T|�L? �?|�i uL�h|� ^�@h|ih� i �?|ihThi| |�i t��u| �? u@�Lh Lu *i�t�hi �? ^�@h|ih |�hii @t @ Thiuihi?UiuLh �@U@|�L?t �? |�i t�44ihc @?_ |�i t��u| �? u@�Lh Lu UL?t�4T|�L? �? |�i uL�h|� ^�@h|ih @thi�iU|�?} |�i igiU|t Lu |�i ��?|ih �L*�_@) ti@tL?�

e�2�2� AiU�?L*L}) 5�LU!t

AL UL4T�|i |�i |iU�?L*L}) t�LU! tih�itc b|c �i �ti_ |�i 4L_i*<t ThL_�U|�L? u�?U|�L?G

b| ' *? 5| � *? 5|3�c *? 5| 'd*? +| � k *? &| � E�� k� *??|o

� � k�

6Lh |��t U@*U�*@|�L?c �i �ti_ L�h �@*�i Lu k ' f��ec |�i igiU|��i �L�ti�L*_ �L�ht tih�it uLh?|c @?_ �@ht!) @?_ ��hL?<t B�� tih�it uLh +|� 6Lh &| �i �ti_ ��h�t|�@?L<t E�bHH� U@T�|@*t|LU! tih�it���

A�i b| |�4i tih�itc }h@T�i_ �? 6�}�hi �Mc t�@hit tL4i ui@|�hit Lu |�i |@t|i t�LU! tih�it�W| tii4t |L Mi t|hL?}*) ti@tL?@* M�| L|�ih��ti U@? Mi ��i�i_ @t TL|i?|�@**) t|@|�L?@h) i UiT|?i@h |�i i?_t Lu |�i t@4T*i� `i �ti_ |�i t@4i |�4i �?|ih�@* @?_ iUL?L4i|h�U 4i|�L_ @t uLh

;Wkh whvw zdv lpsohphqwhg lq UDWV xvlqj wkh Qhzh|0Zhvw surfhgxuh iru dgmxvwlqj iru khw0hurvfhgdvwlflw| dqg iru dxwrfruuhodwlrq xs wr rughu 91 Iru wklv/ zh xvhg wkh UREXVWHUURUVrswlrq zlwk GDPS@4 dqg ODJV@9 lq wkh UDWV uhjuhvvlrq surfhgxuh/ OLQUHJ1

<Wkhuh lv hylghqfh wkdw wkh U5 vwdwlvwlf pd| vsxulrxvo| lq�dwh wkh lpsruwdqfh ri ghwhuplqlvwlfvhdvrqdov +Iudqvhv/ K|oohehuj/ dqg Ohh 4<<8,1 Wr dyrlg ehlqj plvohg e| wklv srvvlelolw|/ zh wdnhwzr vwhsv1 Iluvw/ dv hpskdvl}hg deryh/ zh uhshdw rxu dqdo|vlv zlwk sxuho| lqghwhuplqlvwlfuhsuhvhqwdwlrqv iru wkh h{rjhqrxv vkrfnv1 Vhfrqg/ Dsshqgl{ E ghyhorsv dgglwlrqdo vwdwlvwlfv irudvvhvvlqj wkh lpsruwdqfh ri d ghwhuplqlvwlf frpsrqhqw lq vhdvrqdolw|1

43Lq fdofxodwlrqv qrw uhsruwhg khuh/ zh yhul�hg wkdw vhwwlqj wr }hur doo lqvljql�fdqw frh�flhqwvlq hvwlpdwhv ri htxdwlrq +61<, iru � +dqg dovr iru �, grhv qrw vljql�fdqwo| fkdqjh rxu uhvxowv rqwkh h�hfwv ri vwdqgdug exvlqhvv f|foh sudfwlfh1

44Vwulfwo| vshdnlqj/ wklv fdslwdo vwrfn vhulhv lv lqdssursuldwh iru edfnlqj rxw d vhdvrqdo whfk0qrorj| vkrfn/ ehfdxvh lw lv frqvwuxfwhg iurp vhdvrqdoo| dgmxvwhg gdwd1 Wkh vkrfn vhulhv zhfrqvwuxfw pd| wkxv h{djjhudwh wkh vhdvrqdolw| lq surgxfwlylw|/ dowkrxjk zh eholhyh wkh h�hfw lvvpdoo ehfdxvh vhdvrqdo yduldwlrqv lq wkh fdslwdo vwrfn duh suredeo| yhu| vpdoo1

�f

Page 12: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

|�i |@t|i t�LU! |L it|�4@|i |�i M@ti*�?i t�LU! 4L_i*c E��H��E��b�� A�i -2 �? |�i �ht|�t|iThi}hitt�L? �t f�HHc t�}}it|�?} |�@| |�i ti@tL?@* _�44�it i T*@�? @ML�| HH TihUi?| Lu |�i|L|@* �@h�@|�L? �? |�i }hL�|� h@|i Lu |iU�?L*L})� i @}@�? |it|i_ |�i �L�?| ?�** �)TL|�it�t|�@| @** |�i _�44�it @hi i^�@*� A�i hit�*|�?} |it| t|@|�t|�Uc SS.c �t @ hi@*�3@|�L? uhL4 @ ����t^�@hi ��|� |�hii _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 �?_ih |�i ?�** �)TL|�it�t� A��t �t @ t|hL?} hi�iU|�L?@?_ �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i ?L|�L? |�@| |�ihi �t @? �4TLh|@?| _i|ih4�?�t|�U UL4TL?i?| �? |�i|iU�?L*L}) ti@tL?@*�

A�i hit�*|t �? �@?i* � Lu A@M*i � t�}}it|c @t �? |�i U@ti Lu |�i |@t|i t�LU! tih�itc |�@| |�iti@tL?@* �? |iU�?L*L}) �t Th�4@h�*) _i|ih4�?�t|�U� AL tii |��tc ?L|i |�@| w �t ?L| t|@|�t|�U@**)_�gihi?| uhL4 3ihL� A�i hit�*|t |�ihi t�L� |�@| |�i L|�ih @�|Lhi}hitt��i ULi�U�i?|t @hi @*tL?L| t|@|�t|�U@**) _�gihi?| uhL4 3ihL� �L?i|�i*ittc uLh L�h M@ti*�?i t�LU! 4L_i* uLh |iU�?L*L})}hL�|� �i �ti |�i TL�?| it|�4@|it �? �@?i* ��

A�i it|�4@|i_ ^�@h|ih*) _�44�it �? �@?i* � Lu A@M*i � �?_�U@|i |�@| |iU�?L*L}) }hL�|�|�h?t t�@hT*) ?i}@|��i �? |�i �ht| ^�@h|ihc hiML�?_t t�Mt|@?|�@**) �? |�i tiUL?_ ^�@h|ihc @?_|�i? UL?|�?�it @| @ 4L_ih@|i T@Ui �? ^�@h|iht � @?_ e� A�i �ht| ^�@h|ih T*�?}i �? |iU�?L*L})�@t Mii? *�?!i_ |L ��?|ih �i@|�ih E�@hhL �bbfc T�2.����2 ��ih@**c |�i ti@tL?@* T@||ih? Lu_�44�it tii4t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i �?|ihThi|@|�L? Lu b @t @? i L}i?L�t |iU�?L*L}) ThLUitt���

e�2��� BL�ih?4i?| �L?t�4T|�L? 5�LU!t

i �ti_ L�h 5| _@|@ @?_ �@ht!) @?_ ��hL?<t C| _@|@ |L UL?t|h�U| }| �t�?} E��.�� A�i }|_@|@ @hi }h@T�i_ �? 6�}�hi �U� +i}hitt�L? @?@*)t�t t�L�t |�@| ti@tL?@* _�44�it i T*@�?hi*@|��i*) *�||*i E|�i -2 �t �2 TihUi?|� Lu |�i |L|@* �@h�@|�L? �? }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?}� `�i?�i |it|i_ |�i ?�** �)TL|�it�t |�@| |�i _�44�it �? i@U� ^�@h|ih @hi �_i?|�U@*c �i LM|@�?i_ @|it| t|@|�t|�U Lu 2bc ���U� �t @ hi@*�3@|�L? uhL4 @ ����t^�@hi _�t|h�M�|�L? ��|� |�hii _i}hiitLu uhii_L4 �?_ih |�i ?�** �)TL|�it�t� �t MiuLhic �i hi�iU| |�i �)TL|�it�t |�@| |�ihi �t ?L_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*� OL�i�ihc �i _L tL *itt 4@tt��i*) |�@? MiuLhi� A��t �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|�|�i ?L|�L? |�@| |�i _i|ih4�?�t|�U UL4TL?i?| Lu |�i ti@tL?@* �? }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? �thi*@|��i*) t4@**ih |�@? �| �t �? |�i L|�ih t�LU! tih�it�

A�i M@ti*�?i }L�ih?4i?| t�LU! 4L_i* �t t�L�? �? �@?i* � Lu A@M*i �� W? |��t 4L_i*c |�ihi�t hi*@|��i*) 4Lhi i��_i?Ui Lu tih�@* ULhhi*@|�L? �? |�i �||i_ _�t|�hM@?Uit E|�i " t|@|�t|�U �@tt�}?��U@?Ui *i�i* f�fb�c M�| �| �t @_i^�@|i uLh L�h T�hTLtit�

45Wkh lpsruwdqfh ri zlqwhu zhdwkhu dv dq h{sodqdwlrq ri wkh �uvw txduwhu gls lq surgxfwlylw|kdv ehhq fkdoohqjhg +Ehdxolhx dqg Plurq 4<<4,1

46Zkhq � lv frpsxwhg xvlqj wkh Eduvn|0Plurq krxuv zrunhg gdwd/ wkh lqwhusuhwdwlrq ri wkhuhvxow dv h{rjhqrxv whfkqrorj| lv pruh sureohpdwlf1 Lq Dsshqgl{ D zh dujxh wkdw wkh sureohpvvwhp ixqgdphqwdoo| iurp wkh idfw wkdw wkhlu krxuv zrunhg gdwd duh lqdssursuldwh lq wkh suhvhqwfrqwh{w1

��

Page 13: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

e��� �*|ih?@|��i 5�LU! �L_i*t

W? |��t tiU|�L?c �i it|�4@|i L�h @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i*tc ���U� tTiU�u) |�@| @** ti@tL?@*�|)�t �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U� i _L |��t M) �||�?} @�|Lhi}hitt��i hiThiti?|@|�L?tc ��|� UL?t|@?| |ih4tM�| ?L _�44�itc |L i@U� t�LU! tih�itc �t�?} |�i t@4i _@|@ @?_ |�4i Tih�L_ @t MiuLhi� W?ti*iU|�?} |�i *@} *i?}|� uLh |�iti hiThiti?|@|�L?tc �i �ti_ |�i 5U��@h3 E�b.H� Uh�|ih�L?�AL UL?tih�i tT@Uic �i _L ?L| hiTLh| L�h hit�*|t �? _i|@�*� A�i 5U��@h3 Uh�|ih�L? ti*iU|i_*@} *i?}|�t Lu Hc Hc @?_ bc hitTiU|��i*)c uLh |�i |@t|i t�LU!c |�i |iU�?L*L}) t�LU!c @?_ |�i}L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? t�LU!c @*|�L�}� @ e�*@} tTiU��U@|�L? uLh |iU�?L*L}) �@t @ U*LtitiUL?_� �t i TiU|i_c |�i ULi�U�i?|t L? ti@tL?@* *@}t �? |�iti @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t �ihi }i?ih@**)TLt�|��i @?_ t|@|�t|�U@**) t�}?��U@?|� �L?�i?|�L?@* }LL_?itt�Lu��| 4i@t�hit t�}}it| |�@||�iti �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U 4L_i*t �| |�i _@|@ @ML�| @t �i** @t L�h M@ti*�?i t�LU!t 4L_i*t�

OL�i�ihc u�h|�ih |it|t i iU�|i_ �? �TTi?_� � _iU�t��i*) hi�iU| |�i @*|ih?@|��i t�LU!4L_i* uLh |@t|i t�LU!t� A�i @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i* �t }i?ih@**) @*tL hi�iU|i_ uLh |�i |iU��?L*L}) t�LU!tc @*|�L�}� ?L| M) @** |�i |it|t� 6�?@**)c �i UL�*_ ?L| hi�iU| |�i @*|ih?@|��i t�LU!4L_i* �t�?} }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? t�LU!t� W? *�}�| Lu |�iti �?_�?}t @?_ L�| Lu UL?Uih?uLh hLM�t|?ittc �i @?@*)3i @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t �? ���U� |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!t @hihiThiti?|i_ M) |�i @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i*t�

e�e� A�4i�|L����*_ i�}�|t

A�i L?*) T@h@4i|iht |�@| hi4@�? |L Mi it|�4@|i_ @hi |�i |�4i�|L�M��*_ �i�}�|t� ��h t|h@|i})uLh _L�?} |��t �t |L 4@|U� |�i t|i@_) t|@|i ti@tL?@* 4L�i4i?|t �? |�i 4L_i*<t �?�it|4i?| _@|@��|� |�i @?@*L}L�t 4L�i4i?|t �? |�i _@|@� W? |�i 4L_i* @?_ |�i _@|@c |�iti 4L�i4i?|t @hiU�@h@U|ih�3i_ M) uL�h ?�4Miht� W? |�i 4L_i*c |�iti @hi |�i uL�h �@*�it Lu *L}}i_c O���*|ihi_�?�it|4i?| |�@| LUU�h �? |�i ?L?t|LU�@t|�U t|i@_) t|@|i Lu |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*��e

47E| qrq0vwrfkdvwlf vwhdg| vwdwh/ zh phdq wkh prgho yduldeohv dorqj d ghwhuplqlvwlf jurzwksdwk lq zklfk doo vkrfn lqqrydwlrqv duh khog htxdo wr wkhlu xqfrqglwlrqdo phdq ri }hur1Wr frpsxwh wkh prgho*v lpsolfdwlrqv iru KS0�owhuhg/ orj lqyhvwphqw lq qrqvwrfkdvwlf vwhdg|

vwdwh/ zh surfhhg dv iroorzv1 Ohw j+O, ghqrwh wkh odj0rshudwru uhsuhvhqwdwlrq ri wkh KS �owhudv ghulyhg lq/ vd|/ Nlqj dqg Uhehor +4<<6,1 Khuh/ O lv wkh odj rshudwru/ vr wkdw Om{w � {w�m1Wkhq/ frpsxwh wkh zhljkwv/ jm / lq wkh wzr0vlghg/ lq�qlwh0rughuhg h{sdqvlrq/ j+O, @

Sm jmO

m1Ohw lw/ iru w @ �4> ===>4 ghqrwh wkh wzr0vlghg/ lq�qlwh vhtxhqfh ri orj/ vfdohg lqyhvwphqw1 Wklvlv frqvwuxfwhg iurp irxu vhdvrqdo qxpehuv/ rqh iru hdfk txduwhu lq wkh |hdu/ uhshdwhg lq hdfk|hdu1 Jlyhq wkh vlpsoh sdwwhuq lq lw dqg wkh jm*v/ lw lv vwudljkwiruzdug wr frpsxwh j+O,lw1 Wklvlv dovr d grxeo| lq�qlwh vhtxhqfh/ frqvwuxfwhg iurp irxu qxpehuv/ rqh iru hdfk vhdvrq lq wkh|hdu1 Wklv jlyhv xv KS0�owhuhg/ orj vfdohg lqyhvwphqw1 Wr xqgr wkh h�hfwv ri wkh vfdolqj/ zh dggwkh KS �owhu ri wkh orjjhg vfdoh yduldeoh/ hydoxdwhg lq qrqvwrfkdvwlf vwhdg| vwdwh/ wr rewdlq wkhuhvxow wkdw zh vhhn1

�2

Page 14: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

W? |�i _@|@c |�i uL�h ?�4Miht @hi |�i @�ih@}i TihUi?|@}i _i��@|�L? Lu *L} �?�it|4i?| uhL4�|t O��|hi?_ �? i@U� ^�@h|ih� A�i *@||ih @hi i ��M�|i_ �? |�i hL� Lu A@M*i 2 @ttLU�@|i_��|� �?�it|4i?|c U� A�@| hL� �?_�U@|it |�@| *L}}i_ �?�it|4i?| �t @ML�| b TihUi?| Mi*L� �|tO��|hi?_ �? |�i �ht| ^�@h|ih @?_ @ML�| � TihUi?| @ML�i �? |�i L|�ih |�hii ^�@h|iht�

AL �4T*i4i?| L�h t|h@|i}) �i �@�i |L _h@t|�U@**) hi_�Ui |�i ?�4Mih Lu uhii T@h@4i|iht�? |�i |�4i�|L�M��*_ �i�}�|tc i/�c|j� i hi_�Ui |�i ?�4Mih Lu T@h@4i|iht |L uL�h M) �4TLt�?}|�i uL**L��?} hit|h�U|�L?tG

/�c| ' /� � fc uLh � ' �c 2c �c @** |

� ' /fc| n /� n /2 n /�c �u | �t ?L| �? |�i �ht| ^�@h|ih Lu @ )i@h

/fc| � f uLh @** |�

A�i �i�}�|t �? t|@}it �c 2 @?_ � @hi @**L�i_ |L Mi _�gihi?|c M�| |�i) _L ?L| _iTi?_ L? |�i^�@h|ih Lu |�i )i@h �? ���U� |�i ThL�iU| �@t t|@h|i_��D A�i L?*) �i�}�| |�@| �t @**L�i_ |L�@h) ��|� |�4i �t /fc|� i �ti_ @ ?L?*�?i@h i^�@|�L? tL*��?} hL�|�?i |L �?_ �@*�it Lu |�i uL�hU�L�Ui �@h�@M*it |L ��| |�i uL�h |@h}i|t�

A�i |�4i�|L�M��*_ �i�}�|t LM|@�?i_ M) |��t ThLUi_�hic t�L�? �? A@M*i �c _�gih t�}?���U@?|*) uhL4 |�i � i_ �i�}�| Lu f�2D �ti_ M) k)_*@?_ @?_ �hitUL|| E�bH2� �? |�i�h Lh�}�?@*|�4i�|L�M��*_ 4L_i*� �Lt| �4TLh|@?|*)c L�h �i�}�|t _�tT*@) |�i t*L� t|@h|��Tc Lh |�4i�|L�T*@?c ThLTih|) ��}�*�}�|i_ M) ��h�t|�@?L @?_ AL__ E�bbS�� A�@| �tc |�i hitL�hUi ULt| Lu|�i �ht| t|@}i Lu @ ThL�iU| �t 4�U� *L�ih |�@? |�i t�Mti^�i?| t|@}it� 5ii ��h�t|�@?L @?_AL__ uLh @ hi��i� Lu |�i 4�UhLiUL?L4�U i��_i?Ui L? �?�it|4i?| ThL�iU|tc ���U� u@�Lht |��ttTiU��U@|�L?� �?L|�ih ui@|�hi Lu |�i it|�4@|i_ �i�}�|t �t |�@| |�i ULt| Lu t|@h|�?} @ ThL�iU|�? |�i �ht| ^�@h|ihc |�L�}� t|�** *L�c �t ��}�ih |�@? �? L|�ih ^�@h|iht� i UL?�iU|�hi |�@| |��tui@|�hi Lu |�i �i�}�|t �t �4TLh|@?| �? 4@|U��?} |�i _@|@ MiU@�ti �| �i*Tt Lgti| |�i _�t�?Ui?�|��i |L �?�it| �? |�i 4L_i*<t �ht| ^�@h|ih @h�t�?} uhL4 |�i ti@tL?@**) *L� t|@|i Lu |iU�?L*L})�? |�@| ^�@h|ih� W| _Lit tL �? |�L �@)t� 6�ht|c uLh @ � i_ ti@tL?@* T@||ih? Lu t|@h|tc |�i�?Uhi@ti �@t @ _�hiU|c TLt�|��i igiU| L? �ht| ^�@h|ih �?�it|4i?|� 5iUL?_c M) h@�t�?} |�i |L|@*hitL�hUi hi^��hi4i?| Lu ThL�iU|t t|@h|i_ �? |�i �ht| ^�@h|ihc �| Uhi@|it @? �?Ui?|��i |L T�t�t|@h|t �?|L L|�ih ^�@h|iht� A��t �@t |�i igiU| Lu t��u|�?} |�i 4Lhi hitL�hUi �?|i?t��i t|@}itLu �?�it|4i?| ThL�iU|t |L�@h_t |�i �ht| ^�@h|ih�

48Vrph vruw ri yduldwlrq lq wkh $l>w*v e| vwdjh ri surmhfw/ l> lv qhfhvvdu| lq rxu prgho/ wrdffrpprgdwh wkh vhdvrqdo yduldwlrq lq lqyhvwphqw1 Lw lv hdvlo| yhul�hg wkdw li wkh zhljkwv glgqrw ydu| zlwk l/ wkhq hyhq li vwduwv h{klelwhg d vhdvrqdo sdwwhuq/ vwhdg| vwdwh lqyhvwphqw zrxogqrw1

��

Page 15: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

D� ,4T�h�U@* ,�@*�@|�L? Lu |�i �@ti*�?i 5i@tL?@* �L_i*

6Lh L�h @?@*)t�t |L Mi Uhi_�M*ic �| �t ?iUitt@h) |�@| |�i 4L_i* �ti_ hiThiti?| @ hi@tL?@M*i@Mt|h@U|�L? Lu hi@*�|)� W? T@h|c |��t hi^��hit |�@| |�i *@�t Lu 4L|�L? Lu |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!t�T@h|�U�*@h*) |�i�h _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?|��@�i @ T*@�t�M*i �?|ihThi|@|�L?� A�iThi��L�t tiU|�L? @h}�it |�@| |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* T@ttit |��t |it|� A��t tiU|�L? i�@*��@|it |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* �? |ih4t Lu �|t @M�*�|) |L @UUL�?| uLh �@h�L�t �ht| @?_ tiUL?_4L4i?| ThLTih|�it Lu |�i _@|@� i @h}�i |�@| |�i 4L_i* @}@�? _Lit hi@tL?@M*) �i**�

D��� 6�ht| �L4i?|t

i UL?t�_ih |�L |)Tit Lu �ht| 4L4i?|t� A�i �ht| 4i@t�hit |�i tU@*i L�ih |�i ti@tL?t Lu�@h�L�t �@h�@M*it Lu �?|ihit|� A�i tiUL?_ 4i@t�hit @�ih@}i _i��@|�L?t uhL4 |hi?_ L�ih |�iti@tL?t�

A@M*i e hiTLh|t 4i@t�hit Lu tU@*i� A�i h�}�| t�_i t�L�tc uLh |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*c|�i ?L?�t|LU�@t|�U t|i@_)�t|@|i �@*�it Lu �L�ht �Lh!i_ @?_ |�i h@|�Lt Lu �?�it|4i?|c UL?�t�4T|�L?c U@T�|@* t|LU! @?_ }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} |L L�|T�|� A�i *iu| T@?i* hiTLh|t |�iULhhitTL?_�?} t|@|�t|�Utc LM|@�?i_ M) hi}hitt�?} |�i N5 _@|@ L? ^�@h|ih*) _�44�it� E i _L?L| hiTLh| i4T�h�U@* hit�*|t uLh |�i U@T�|@* |L L�|T�| h@|�Lc t�?Ui �i _L ?L| �@�i ti@tL?@**)�?@_��t|i_ _@|@ L? |�i U@T�|@* t|LU!�� `�|� L?i i UiT|�L?c |�i 4@|U� Mi|�ii? 4L_i* @?__@|@ �t }LL_� A�i i UiT|�L?@* U@ti �t |�i �?�it|4i?| |L L�|T�| h@|�Lc ���U� �t ��}�ih �? |�i4L_i* |�@? �? |�i _@|@� �h�4@h�*)c |��t hi�iU|t |�i @Mti?Ui Lu _�h@M*i }LL_t T�hU�@tit uhL4|�i �@ht!)���hL? �?�it|4i?| _@|@�

A�i h�}�| t�_i Lu A@M*i D hiTLh|tc uLh |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*c |�i TihUi?| _i��@|�L?c�? ?L?�t|LU�@t|�U t|i@_) t|@|ic Lu |�i �?_�U@|i_ �@h�@M*it uhL4 |�i�h O� |hi?_ �@*�it� A�i*iu| t�_i hiTLh|t |�i i4T�h�U@* @?@*L}c ULT�i_ uhL4 A@M*i 2 uLh i@ti Lu UL4T@h�tL?� �L|i|�@| |�i �?�it|4i?| ?�4Miht *�?i �T i @U|*)� A�@| t�4T*) hi�iU|t L�h 4i|�L_ uLh ti*iU|�?}|�i |�4i�|L�M��*_ �i�}�|t� �Lhi t�}?��U@?|*)c |�i 4L_i* U@T|�hit 4@?) Lu |�i L|�ih M@t�Uui@|�hit Lu |�i ti@tL?@* _@|@� 6Lh i @4T*ic L�|T�| �t �i@! �? |�i �ht| ^�@h|ih @?_ t|hL?} �?|�i uL�h|�c |�i �L*@|�*�|) Lu |�i ti@tL?@* UL4TL?i?| Lu UL?t�4T|�L? hL�}�*) 4@|U�it |�@| LuL�|T�|c |�Lti |�L �@h�@M*it @hi ��}�*) ti@tL?@**) ULhhi*@|i_c @?_ �L�ht �Lh!i_ _�Tt �? |�i|��h_ ^�@h|ih�

D�2� 5iUL?_ �L4i?|tG A�i 5i@tL?@* �)U*i

A@M*i S hiTLh|t �@h�L�t tiUL?_ 4L4i?| ThLTih|�it Lu ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ N5 _@|@ E�@?i*�� @?_ Lu L�h M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* E�@?i* ��� A�i tiUL?_ 4L4i?| ThLTih|�it Lu N5ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ _@|@ �ihi LM|@�?i_ M) *L}}�?} |�i _@|@c O� �*|ih�?} |�i4c @?_ |�i?

�e

Page 16: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

UL4T�|�?} |�i tiUL?_ 4L4i?|t t�L�?� 6Lh L�h M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*c |�i hit�*|t �ihiUL4T�|i_ M) @TT*)�?} |�i t@4i |h@?tuLh4@|�L?t |L @ t)?|�i|�U _@|@ ti| Lu 2cfff LMtih�@|�L?t}i?ih@|i_ uhL4 L�h M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*�

A�i 4L_i* �@t ML|� t|hi?}|�t @?_ �i@!?ittit� �? |�i t|hi?}|� t�_ic ?L|i |�@| |�i L�ih@**�L*@|�*�|) Lu L�|T�| �? |�i 4L_i* @?_ |�i _@|@ @hi U*Ltic @hL�?_ ��D���H TihUi?|� A��t �t @T*�t uLh |�i 4L_i*c t�?Ui |�i L�ih@** �L*@|�*�|) Lu L�|T�| T*@)i_ ?L _�hiU| hL*i �? ti*iU|�?} |�i4L_i* T@h@4i|ih �@*�it� �L|i @*tL �L� UL?t�4T|�L? �t hL�}�*) @t �L*@|�*i @t L�|T�|c ML|� �?|�i 4L_i* @?_ |�i _@|@� A�i �L*@|�*�|) Lu ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ UL?t�4T|�L?c _�tU�tti_ M)B�)ti*t E�bbeM�c t�L�t �L� |�i ti@tL?@* U)U*i _�giht �? tL4i �4TLh|@?| hitTiU|t uhL4 |�iM�t�?itt U)U*i� � !i) ui@|�hi Lu |�i *@||ih �t |�@| UL?t�4T|�L? �t UL?t�_ih@M*) t4LL|�ih |�@?�?UL4i @?_ L�|T�| Etii Mi*L� uLh u�h|�ih _�tU�tt�L?�� Bi?ih@**)c |�i @MtL*�|i @?_ hi*@|��i@4L�?|t Lu �L*@|�*�|) �? |�i 4L_i* �@h�@M*it @hi �? *�?i ��|� |�i _@|@�

A�i 4L_i* _Lit hi@tL?@M*) �i** L? _)?@4�Ut� �L|i �L� �| U@T|�hit |�i Tiht�t|i?Ui �?L�|T�| @?_ |�i u@U| |�@| ThL_�U|���|) *i@_t �L�ht M) |�L ^�@h|iht�

� t�Lh|UL4�?} Lu |�i 4L_i* �t |�@| �| L�iht|@|it |�i UL?|i4TLh@?iL�t ULhhi*@|�L?t Mi�|�ii? ThL_�U|���|) @?_ �L�ht @?_ Mi|�ii? }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} @?_ L�|T�|� i @hi *ittUL?Uih?i_ @ML�| |�i *@||ihc MiU@�ti |�i }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} t�LU! T*@)t @ hi*@|��i*) t4@**hL*i �? |�i 4L_i* _)?@4�Ut�

D��� 5iUL?_ �L4i?|tG A�i ��t�?itt �)U*i

i ?L� i�@*�@|i |�i 4L_i*<t @M�*�|) |L @UUL�?| uLh M@t�U M�t�?itt U)U*i u@U|t� A�i hit�*|t �?A@M*i . @**L� �t |L UL4T@hi |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i �4T*�U@|�L?t Lu |�i 4L_i* E�@?i* �� ��|� |�i_@|@ E�@?i* ��� A�i M�t�?itt U)U*i ThLTih|�it Lu N5 _@|@ �ihi LM|@�?i_ M) �ht| ti@tL?@**)@_��t|�?} L�h _@|@ Etii tiU|�L? ��@� �t�?} @ t|@?_@h_ ThLUi_�hic |�i? *L}}�?} �|c O� �*|ih�?}�|c @?_ UL4T�|�?} |�i tiUL?_ 4L4i?|t t�L�?��S A�i hit�*|t hiti4M*i |�Lti hiTLh|i_ �? |�ii �t|�?} M�t�?itt U)U*i *�|ih@|�hi Etiic uLh i @4T*ic �LL*i) @?_ �hitUL|| E�bbD����. �@?i* �hiTLh|t |�i @?@*L}L�t t|@|�t|�Utc UL4T�|i_ uhL4 2cfff t)?|�i|�U _@|@ LMtih�@|�L?t }i?ih@|i_�t�?} L�h M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*�

A�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* �@t t�Lh|UL4�?}tc @t �i** @t t�UUittit� A�h?�?} |L |�i t�U�Uittitc ?L|i |�@| |�i 4L_i* U@T|�hit �? @ hL�}� �@) |�i hi*@|��i �L*@|�*�|) @?_ _)?@4�U

49Zh vhdvrqdoo| dgmxvwhg wkh gdwd xvlqj Hvwlpd*v UDWV6;9{ H][44 lpsohphqwdwlrq ri wkhXV jryhuqphqw*v Fhqvxv [44 pxowlsolfdwlyh surfhgxuh1

4:Wkhuh lv rqh vhqvh lq zklfk wkh uhvxowv duh gl�huhqw1 Wkh yrodwlolw| uhsruwhg iru rxwsxw/517 shufhqw/ lq Wdeoh : lv juhdwhu wkdq wkh xvxdo hvwlpdwh ri derxw 5 shufhqw uhsruwhg lq wkholwhudwxuh1 Wklv ohdgv wr d uhodwlyho| orz hvwlpdwh iru wkh uhodwlyh yrodwlolw| ri krxuv zrunhg wrrxwsxw1 Suhvxpdeo|/ wkh kljk hvwlpdwh iru wkh yrodwlolw| ri rxwsxw uh�hfwv wkh sulfh lqgh{ +wkhFSL, xvhg wr frqyhuw qrplqdo JQS wr uhdo JQS lq wkh Eduvn|0Plurq gdwd1

�D

Page 17: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

ULhhi*@|�L?t Lu 4Lt| Lu |�i �@h�@M*it� �*tLc �| �t ^��|i t�UUittu�* �? U@T|�h�?} |�i _)?@4�UULhhi*@|�L? Lu �L�ht �Lh!i_ @?_ ThL_�U|���|)� W? ML|� |�i 4L_i* @?_ |�i _@|@c |�i UL?�|i4TLh@?iL�t ULhhi*@|�L? �t ^��|i *L�� A�i 4L_i* hit�*| �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i @h}�4i?|�? ��h�t|�@?L @?_ ,�U�i?M@�4 E�bb2�c ��L U*@�4 |�@| @ M�t�?itt U)U*i 4L_i* ��|� 4�*|�T*it�LU!t �t ?ii_i_ |L 4@|U� |�i LMtih�i_ *L� ULhhi*@|�L? Lu ThL_�U|���|) @?_ L�|T�|� A�iu@U| |�@| ThL_�U|���|) *i@_t �L�ht �Lh!i_ �? |�i 4L_i*c @t �| _Lit �? |�i _@|@c hi�iU|t |�i|�4i�|L�T*@? t|h�U|�hi Lu |�i �?�it|4i?| �i�}�|t� A��t �t _�tU�tti_ @| *i?}|� �? ��h�t|�@?L@?_ AL__ E�bbS��

�L� UL?t�_ih tL4i Lu |�i 4L_i*<t t�Lh|UL4�?}t� 6�ht|c �| L�iht|@|it |�i �L*@|�*�|) LuUL?t�4T|�L? @?_ �?_iht|@|it �|t _)?@4�U ULhhi*@|�L? ��|� L�|T�|� ,��_i?|*)c |�i ti@tL?@*@_��t|4i?| ThLUi_�hi t�Mt|@?|�@**) hi_�Uit |�i hi*@|��i �L*@|�*�|) Lu UL?t�4T|�L? �? |�i _@|@EUL4T@hi A@M*it S @?_ .�c M�| ?L| �? |�i 4L_i*� 5iUL?_c |�i 4L_i* �4T*�it |�@| �?�it|4i?|*@}t L�|T�| L�ih |�i U)U*ic ���*i L�h i4T�h�U@* 4i@t�hi Lu �?�it|4i?| �t UL?|i4TLh@?iL�t��|� L�|T�|� �t i T*@�?i_ �? ��h�t|�@?L @?_ AL__ E�bbS�c |��t �4T*�U@|�L? Lu |�i 4L_i*hi�iU|t |�i |�4i�|L�T*@? ui@|�hi Lu |�i �?�it|4i?| �i�}�|t� A��t �@t |�i igiU| Lu �?|hL_�U�?}@ _i*@) �? |�i hitTL?ti Lu �?�it|4i?| |L @ t�LU!� A�i u@U| |�@| L�h i4T�h�U@* 4i@t�hiLu �?�it|4i?| �t UL�?U�_i?| ��|� L�|T�| L�ih |�i U)U*i hi�iU|t |�@| �| �?U*�_it hit�_i?|�@*�?�it|4i?|c ���U� *i@_t |�i U)U*i tL4i��@| Etii ��h�t|�@?L @?_ AL__ E�bbS� uLh @ _�tU�tt�L?Lu |�i i4T�h�U@* i��_i?Ui�� ��t�?itt �?�it|4i?| �? t|h�U|�hit @?_ _�h@M*it _L *@} |�i U)U*i�ThLM@M*) uLh |�i |)Ti Lu |�4i�|L�T*@? UL?t�_ih@|�L?t �?ULhTLh@|i_ �? L�h 4L_i*��H 5Lc �i|��?! |�ihi �t tL4i ��t_L4 �? |�i 4L_i*<t �4T*�U@|�L?t uLh �?�it|4i?|� �t @ hit�*|c �i|��?! |�i 4�t4@|U� Mi|�ii? 4L_i* @?_ _@|@ hi}@h_�?} |�i L�|T�| � �?�it|4i?| _)?@4�Ut �tL�iht|@|i_ �? A@M*i .� 6�?@**)c @t �? |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i t|@|�t|�Utc |�i 4L_i* �t?<| U*Lti L? |�i_)?@4�U ULhhi*@|�L?t Lu }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L?� ��|c @t MiuLhic �i _�tUL�?| |��t MiU@�ti|�i hit�*|t Mi*L� @hi ?L| �ih) ti?t�|��i |L L�h U�L�Ui Lu 4L_i* uLh |��t tih�it�

�*|�L�}� |�i 4L_i* �@t |�i i4T�h�U@* 4�?�tit ��t| t|@|i_ E�? L?i U@tic ^�@*��i_�c L�ih@**�| @TTi@ht |L _L hi@tL?@M*) �i**� ��h hi@_�?} Lu A@M*i . �t |�@|c _itT�|i U*i@h t�Lh|UL4�?}tcL�h 4L_i*<t @M�*�|) |L hiT*�U@|i M�t�?itt U)U*i t|@|�t|�Ut �t }LL_ i?L�}� |L t�TTLh| L�h }L@*Lu @?@*)3�?} |�i igiU|t Lu ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| ��|� @? i4T�h�U@**) hi*i�@?| _@|@ }i?ih@|�?}4iU�@?�t4�

4;Wlph0wr0sodq frqvlghudwlrqv suhvxpdeo| kdyh uhodwlyho| ohvv gluhfw lpsdfw rq exvlqhvv lq0yhvwphqw lq gxudeoh jrrgv1 Krzhyhu/ lw pd| kdyh dq lpsruwdqw lqgluhfw lpsdfw yld frpsohphq0wdulwlhv ehwzhhq lqyhvwphqw lq exvlqhvv vwuxfwxuhv +zkhuh wkhuh lv dq lpsruwdqw wlph0wr0sodqfrpsrqhqw, dqg gxudeohv1

�S

Page 18: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

S� �L?t|h�U|�?} �ti@tL?@* �?@*L} �L_i*t

i ?L� �@�i @ M@ti*�?i @?_ @? @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* |L �ti @t *@MLh@|Lh�it uLh ^�@?�|�u)�?} |�i _�t|Lh|�L?t �? |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui ��|� hitTiU| |L ti@tL?@*�|)� A�i 4L_i*t��** Mi �ti_ |L }i?ih@|i @h|��U�@* _@|@c ���U� ��** Mi ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ @?_ ThL��_i_ |L@ �)TL|�i|�U@* M�t�?itt U)U*i @?@*)t|� A�i @?@*)t| �tit |�i _@|@ |L it|�4@|i @? @ti@tL?@*M�t�?itt U)U*i 4L_i* @?_ i�@*�@|i �|t @M�*�|) |L @UUL�?| uLh |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i u@U|t� A��ttiU|�L? _�tU�ttit |�i @?@*)t|<t it|�4@|�L? 4i|�L_ @?_ hit�*|t�

A�i @?@*)t|<t 4L_i* �@t |�L |)Tit Lu T@h@4i|ihtG |�Lti |�@| Tih|@�? |L |�i i L}i?L�tt�LU!tc @?_ |�Lti |�@| _L ?L|� A�i *@||ih T@h@4i|iht �?U*�_i |�i _�tUL�?| h@|ic |�i |�4i�|L�M��*_ �?�it|4i?| ULt| �i�}�|tc U@T�|@*<t t�@hi �? |�i ThL_�U|�L? u�?U|�L?c @?_ |�i _iThiU�@|�L?h@|i� A�i UL?�i?|�L?@* �@) |L it|�4@|i |�iti �tit |�i �ht|�4L4i?|t Lu |�i _@|@� 5�?Ui |�itiThLTih|�it @hi ?L| t�}?��U@?|*) _�t|Lh|i_ M) ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?|c ��|� L?i i UiT|�L? �i@tt�4i |�i @?@*)t| !?L�t |�i�h |h�i �@*�it� A�i i UiT|�L? Tih|@�?t |L |�i |�4i�|L�M��*_�i�}�|t� W? |��t U@tic �i tTiU�u) |�@| |�i @?@*)t|<t it|�4@|it @hi |�i �i�}�|t |�@| @TT*)|L ThL�iU|t �?�|�@|i_ �? ^�@h|iht 2c �c @?_ e Etii A@M*i ��� i |�ihiM) �?|hL_�Ui @ t4@**_�t|Lh|�L? �?|L |�i @?@*)t�tc t�?Ui Thit�4@M*) @? @U|�@* @?@*)t|<t it|�4@|it Lu |�i �i�}�|t��** @*tL Mi �?��i?Ui_ tL4i��@| M) |�i t*�}�|*) _�gihi?| �i�}�|t |�@| @TT*) |L ThL�iU|t�?�|�@|i_ �? |�i �ht| ^�@h|ih�

AL LM|@�? _@|@ ?ii_i_ uLh T�hTLtit Lu it|�4@|�?} |�i T@h@4i|iht Lu |�4i tih�it 4L_i*tuLh |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!tc |�i @?@*)t| �t @tt�4i_ |L uL**L� UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui� A�i t�LU!t@hi _i_�Ui_ �t�?} |�i 4L_i* T@h@4i|iht @*hi@_) it|�4@|i_c |�i �?|h@|i4TLh@* ,�*ih i^�@�|�L?c |�i ThL_�U|�L? u�?U|�L?c @?_ |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ L? UL?t�4T|�L?c L�|T�|ci4T*L)4i?|c U@T�|@*c @?_ }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L?� ,@U� t�LU! tih�it �@t 4L_i*i_ @t |�it�4 Lu @ UL?t|@?| |ih4 @?_ @? @�|Lhi}hitt�L?� 6Lh |�i UL?t|@?| |ih4c |�i @?@*)t| �tit |�it�4 Lu |�i ti@tL?@* _�44�it� A��t �t hL�}�*) |�i t@4T*i @�ih@}i |�@| |�i @?@*)t| �L�*_it|�4@|i �t�?} @ *@h}i t@4T*i�

W? U�LLt�?} |�i *@} *i?}|� uLh |�i @�|Lhi}itt�L?t Lu |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!tc �i �@�i |L UL?�uhL?| @ |iU�?�U@* ThLM*i4� A�i |h�i @�|Lhi}hitt��i hiThiti?|@|�L? Lu |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_t�LU!t �t �? u@U| Lu �ih) ��}��Lh_ih @?_ �@t @ ti@tL?@* T@||ih? �? �|t ULi�U�i?|t� 6�}�hit 2@� 2U �ti _@|@ uhL4 |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* |L �**�t|h@|i |��t TL�?|� A�i �}�hit hiTLh|*L} tTiU|h@ uLh *? �|c b|c @?_ *? }|� A�i *�?it �?_�U@|i_ M) 8<t @hi |�i tTiU|h@ Lu |�i ti@tL?@**)@_��t|i_ _@|@ �ti_ M) |�i @?@*)t|� 6Lh UL4T@h�tL?c |�i tL*�_ *�?i �t |�i tTiU|h�4 Lu |�iti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ _@|@� �L|� tTiU|h@ @hi UL4T�|i_ M@ti_ L? @? @h|��U�@* _@|@ ti| Lu2cfff LMtih�@|�L?t }i?ih@|i_ �t�?} |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*��b �L|i |�i ti@tL?@* Ti@!t�? |�i tTiU|h@ Lu |�i ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_ _@|@� �Lhi t�}?��U@?|c uhL4 |�i Thiti?| t|@?_�

4<Wkh vshfwuxp zdv hvwlpdwhg e| wkh iroorzlqj surfhgxuh1 Ohw |w ghqrwh wkh orjjhg gdwd1 Zh

�.

Page 19: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

TL�?|c @hi |�i ti@tL?@* _�Tt �? |�i tTiU|h@ Lu |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@� A�@| t|@?_@h_ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| 4i|�L_tc *�!i |�i �i?t�t j��� 4i|�L_ |�@| �i �tic ThL_�Ui |�iti _�Tt�t �i** !?L�?c @?_ �?_ii_ �| �@t Mii? t�L�? |�@| t�U� _�Tt @hi U�@h@U|ih�t|�U Lu ti@tL?@*@_��t|4i?| ThLUi_�hit |�@| @hi LT|�4@* �?_ih UL44L? @tt�4T|�L?t EBhi|�ih @?_ �ih*L�i�b.f�� AL hiThiti?| _@|@ ��|� _�Tt *�!i |�iti hi^��hit ��}��Lh_ih *@}t ��|� ti@tL?@* T@||ih?t�? |�i ULi�U�i?|t�2f

W? ��i� Lu |�i Thi��L�t UL?t�_ih@|�L?tc @ U@hiu�* |�4i tih�it @?@*)t| ��|� @ *@h}i t@4T*iLu ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ �L�*_ �| ��}��Lh_ih @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t�2� W? |�i t�Lh|ih t@4T*it@�@�*@M*i �? Th@U|�Uic ��}��Lh_ih ti@tL?@* ULi�U�i?|t �? @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t U@??L| Mi @UU�h@|i*)it|�4@|i_ @?_ |�i TLtt�M�*�|) Lu ti@tL?@* _�Tt �? ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ �t �}?Lhi_� �iU@�ti�i �@?| |L t|�_) |�i UL?ti^�i?Uit Lu UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Uic �i �@�i L�h �)TL|�i|�U@* @?@*)t|�}?Lhi ti@tL?@* _�Tt @?_ �?t|i@_ �| *L� Lh_ih @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t |L |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU! _@|@�i ti| |�i *@} *i?}|� |L |�hii L? |�i M@t�t Lu i��_i?Ui |�@| @? iUL?L4i|h�U�@? �t�?} ti@tL?@**)

@_��t|i_ _@|@ }i?ih@|i_ uhL4 |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* �L�*_ ThLM@M*) ?L| �@�i }L?i |L��}�ih Lh_ih *@}t �? _@|@ ti|t Lu t|@?_@h_ t�3i�22

hvwlpdwhg wkh iroorzlqj uhjuhvvlrq e| ohdvw vtxduhv=

|w @ �.Q[

l@4

!l|w�l . %w=

Ohw � ghqrwh wkh hvwlpdwhg vwdqgdug huuru ri wkh �wwhg uhvlgxdo lq wklv uhjuhvvlrq/ dqg ohw

V+}, @�5

!+},!+}�4,> } @ h�l$� >

$�m @5�m

W> m @ 3> ===>

W

5>

!+}, @Q[

l@4

!l}l=

Wkh �jxuh glvsod|v wkh judsk ri oq V+}, djdlqvw $> zkhuh $ @ $�@�= Lq wkh fdofxodwlrqv/ zh xvhW @ 733 dqg Q @ ;1 Zh dovr wulhg Q @ 45/ exw wkdw pdgh olwwoh vxevwdqwlyh gl�huhqfh1

53Vlpv +4<<6, kdv fdoohg wklv sdwwhuq lq wkh frh�flhqwv ri kljk rughu dxwruhjuhvvlrqv �w wrvhdvrqdoo| dgmxvwhg gdwd _xqudyholqj ri wkh vhdvrqdo dgmxvwphqw1% Pdudydoo +4<<8, surylghv djhqhudo glvfxvvlrq ri wklv sureohp dqg dq h{dpsoh edvhg rq XV JQS gdwd1

54Reylrxvo|/ wkh skhqrphqrq mxvw ghvfulehg iru wkh edvholqh prgho dssolhv wr wkh dowhuqdwlyhprgho wrr1

55Iru hdfk vkrfn vhulhv/ zh glylghg rxu vdpsoh ri 5333 txduwhuo| revhuydwlrqv lqwr 43 vhjphqwvri ohqjwk 5331 Rq hdfk ri wkhvh/ zh xvhg wkh Vfkzdu} fulwhulrq wr ghwhuplqh wkh dssursuldwh odjohqjwk ri dq dxwruhjuhvvlyh prgho1 Rswlpdo odj ohqjwkv zhuh doprvw dozd|v ohvv wkdq ru htxdowr wkuhh1

�H

Page 20: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

A�i *L} tTiU|h@ Lu |�i |��h_�Lh_ih @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t it|�4@|i_ M) |�i iUL?L4i|h�U�@? �t�?}M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* _@|@ @hi hiTLh|i_ @t _@t�i_ *�?i �? |�i �}�hit� �L|i �L� |�Lti *�?ititti?|�@**) �?|ihTL*@|i |�i tTiU|h�4 Lu |�i ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ @?_ 4�tt |�i ti@tL?@*_�T�

.� +it�*|t

W? tiU|�L? e �i �ti_ N5 _@|@ |L UL?t|h�U| �@h�L�t _@|@ }i?ih@|�?} 4iU�@?�t4tG |�i M@ti*�?iti@tL?@* 4L_i* @?_ @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t� W? tiU|�L? Sc �i _itUh�Mi_ |�i @ti@tL?@*4L_i*t |�@| @? @?@*)t| �t�?} UL?�i?|�L?@* M�t�?itt U)U*i 4i|�L_t �L�*_ it|�4@|i �t�?}ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_c @h|��U�@* _@|@ uhL4 |�iti _@|@ }i?ih@|�?} 4iU�@?�t4t� A��t tiU|�L?i�@*�@|it |�i _�t|Lh|�L?t �4T*�i_ M) |�iti 4i|�L_tG �i UL4T@hi |�i _�gihi?Uit Mi|�ii? |�iM�t�?itt U)U*i ThLTih|�it Lu |�i @h|��U�@* _@|@ @?_ Lu _@|@ }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i iUL?L4i|h�U�@?<tit|�4@|i_ 4L_i*� i �?_ @*4Lt| ?L _�t|Lh|�L? ��i? |�i _@|@ @hi }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i M@ti*�?iti@tL?@* 4L_i*�

i TihuLh4 �@h�L�t i Tih�4i?|t |L i�@*�@|i |�i hLM�t|?itt Lu |��t hit�*|� i UL?t�_ih��@| �@TTi?t ��i? tiUL?_ 4L4i?| ThLTih|�it @hi UL4T�|i_ M@ti_ L? �ht| _�gihi?U�?} |�i_@|@ h@|�ih |�@? @TT*)�?} |�i O� �*|ih� i @*tL UL?t�_ih ��@| �@TTi?t ��i? |�i _@|@ @hi}i?ih@|i_ M) |�i @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t�

`�i? |�i �ht| _�gihi?Ui �*|ih �t �ti_ @?_ |�i _@|@ @hi }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i M@ti*�?i 4L_i*c|�i? _�t|Lh|�L?t @hi @}@�? �ih) t4@**� OL�i�ihc _�t|Lh|�L?t _L i4ih}i ��i? |�i @*|ih?@|��iti@tL?@* 4L_i*t @hi �ti_ |L }i?ih@|i |�i @h|��U�@* _@|@� A�iti _�t|Lh|�L?t @hi 4@}?��i_ ��i?|�i �ht| _�gihi?Ui �*|ih �t �ti_� A��tc t�}?��U@?| _�t|Lh|�L?t U@? Mi uL�?_ �Lh!�?} ��|� |�i@*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* @?_ �t�?} |�i �ht| _�gihi?Ui �*|ih� OL�i�ihc |�iti hit�*|t t�L�*_Mi !iT| �?|L TihtTiU|��i� 6�ht|c |�i @*|ih?@|��i 4L_i* �t t|@|�t|�U@**) hi�iU|i_� 5iUL?_c �?Th@U|�Ui |�i �ht| _�gihi?Ui �*|ih �t L?*) h@hi*) �ti_ �? |�i @?@*)t�t Lu M�t�?itt U)U*i 4L_i*t�2�

i �ht| _itUh�Mi |�i hit�*|t M@ti_ L? |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*� i |�i? UL?t�_ih |�i@*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t�

.��� +it�*|t �@ti_ L? �@ti*�?i 5i@tL?@* �L_i*

��t�?itt U)U*i t|@|�t|�Ut UL4T�|i_ uhL4 ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@ }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i M@ti*�?iti@tL?@* 4L_i* @hi ULT�i_ uhL4 �@?i* � Lu A@M*i . |L �@?i* � Lu A@M*i H� �@?i* � Lu A@M*i

56Wklv lv ehfdxvh wkh �uvw gl�huhqfh �owhu pdjql�hv wkh yhu| kljk iuhtxhqf| frpsrqhqwv riwkh gdwd/ zkloh uhgxflqj wkh uhodwlyh lpsruwdqfh ri exvlqhvv f|foh iuhtxhqflhv1 E| frpsdulvrq/wkh KS �owhu uhvhpeohv d kljk sdvv �owhu wkdw lvrodwhv wkh exvlqhvv f|foh iuhtxhqflhv dqg kljkhu+vhh/ h1j1/ Fkulvwldqr dqg ghq Kddq +4<<9/ vhfwlrq 6, dqg Vlqjohwrq +4<;;,,1

�b

Page 21: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

H _�tT*@)t |�i ULhhitTL?_�?} t|@|�t|�Ut UL4T�|i_ uhL4 |�i _@|@ }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i @ti@tL?@*@?@*L} Lu |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*� A�i |�L ti|t Lu t|@|�t|�Ut @hi L?*) |h���@**) _�gihi?|�W? hit�*|t ?L| hiTLh|i_ �ihic �i uL�?_ |�@| |��t �t @*tL |h�i ��i? ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| �t_L?i M) �t�?} _i|ih4�?�t|�U _�44�itc h@|�ih |�@? j��� A��t u@�*�hi |L �?_ igiU|t *�?!i_ |Lti@tL?@*�|) t�TTLh|t |�i |)T�U@* Th@U|�Ui Lu tTiU�u)�?} @ti@tL?@* +�� 4L_i*t @?_ i�@*�@|�?}|�i4 ��|� ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ _@|@�

.�2� +LM�t|?itt ��iU!t

W? |��t t�MtiU|�L? �i UL?t�_ih hLM�t|?itt Lu L�h hit�*|t |L �ht| _�gihi?U�?} @?_ |L |�i @*|ih�?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t� A�i igiU|t Lu �ht| _�gihi?U�?} �? |�i M@ti*�?i 4L_i* 4@) Mi tii?M) UL4T@h�?} �@?i*t � @?_ � �? A@M*i b� �L|i |�@| |�i _�gihi?Uit @hi ^��|i t4@**� 5Lc L�h!i) �?_�?} |�@| |�ihi �t ?L _�t|Lh|�L? ��i? |�i @h|��U�@* _@|@ @hi }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i M@ti*�?i4L_i* �t hLM�t| |L |�i �ti Lu |�i �ht| _�gihi?Ui �*|ih�

�i |c �i @?@*)3i hit�*|t uLh @? @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i* �? ���U� |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!ThLUittit uLh |@t|ic |iU�?L*L}) @?_ }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? @hi t��|U�i_ uhL4 |�i�h M@ti*�?ihiThiti?|@|�L?t |L ?L�_�44) hiThiti?|@|�L?t ��|� @ UL?t|@?| |ih4 @?_c hitTiU|��i*)c Hc Hc@?_ b @�|Lhi}hitt��i *@}t� ��t�?itt U)U*i t|@|�t|�Ut UL4T�|i_ uhL4 ti@tL?@**) @_��t|i_ @?_O���*|ihi_ _@|@ }i?ih@|i_ M) |��t 4L_i* @hi hiTLh|i_ �? �@?i* � Lu A@M*i H� �@?i* #_�tT*@)t |�i ULhhitTL?_�?} t|@|�t|�Ut UL4T�|i_ uhL4 |�i ti@tL?@**) �?@_��t|i_c O���*|ihi__@|@ }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i @ti@tL?@* @?@*L} Lu |��t @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*� A�i _�gihi?UitMi|�ii? |�i |�L ti|t Lu t|@|�t|�Ut @hi ?L| @*�@)t @t |h���@* @t MiuLhi� A�i @?@*)t| UL4T�|it@ UL?|i4TLh@?iL�t �L�ht�ThL_�U|���|) ULhhi*@|�L? �? �@?i* # |�@| �t f��. ��}�ih |�@? |�iULhhitTL?_�?} ?�4Mih �? �@?i* �� 5i�ih@* L|�ih _)?@4�U ULhhi*@|�L?t @hi Lg M) f��f Lh 4LhicitTiU�@**) uLh �?�it|4i?| @?_ L�|T�|� 6�h|�ih4Lhic |�i @?@*)t| t�Mt|@?|�@**) �?_iht|@|it |�i�L*@|�*�|) Lu �?�it|4i?|� �*tLc |�i @?@*)t|<t TL�?|t it|�4@|it �4T*) |�@| �?�it|4i?| *@}t |�iU)U*ic @*|�L�}� �| �t UL�?U�_i?| ��|� |�i U)U*i �? |�i @?@*)t|<t R@U|�@*� _@|@ Etii �@?i* �����ih@**c �L�i�ihc |�i _�t|Lh|�L?t �? �@?i*t � @?_ # Lu A@M*i H _L ?L| tii4 _h@4@|�U�2e

�Lhi _h@4@|�U _�t|Lh|�L?t hit�*| ��i? |�i _@|@ @hi }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@*4L_i* @?_ |�i O� �*|ih �t hiT*@Ui_ �? |�i @?@*)t�t M) |�i �ht| _�gihi?Ui �*|ih� A�iti

57Wklv frqfoxvlrq lv vhqvlwlyh wr wkh ohqjwk ri wkh dxwruhjuhvvlyh surfhvv iru surgxfwlylw|1Uhfdoo wkdw wkh 70odj uhsuhvhqwdwlrq zdv udqnhg dv d forvh vhfrqg wr wkh ;0odj uhsuhvhqwdwlrqe| wkh Vfkzdu} fulwhulrq1 Zkhq zh dgmxvw wkh dowhuqdwlyh vhdvrqdo prgho vroho| e| vkruwhqlqjwkh ohqjwk ri wkh surgxfwlylw| dxwruhjuhvvlrq wr 7/ fhuwdlq glvwruwlrqv ehfrph pxfk odujhu1 Iruh{dpsoh/ wkh _wuxh% fruuhodwlrq ehwzhhq krxuv wrgd| dqg surgxfwlylw| |hvwhugd| gursv iurp 174wr 148/ zkloh wkh dqdo|vw*v fruuhodwlrq ulvhv iurp 18: wr 1941 Wkh jds ehwzhhq wkh dqdo|vw dqgwkh wuxwk wkxv ulvhv iurp d prghudwh 149 lq Sdqho G/ Wdeoh ;/ wr d vxevwdqwldo 179/ vroho| gxh wrwkh vkruwhu dxwruhjuhvvlyh uhsuhvhqwdwlrq iru surgxfwlylw|1

2f

Page 22: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

hit�*|t @hi hiTLh|i_ �? �@?i*t � @?_ # Lu A@M*i b� �L|i |�ihi |�@| |�i @?@*)t| �?_iht|@|it|�i �L*@|�*�|) Lu �?�it|4i?| M) �@*u� Bi?ih@**) tTi@!�?} |�i _�t|Lh|�L?t �? |�i _)?@4�UULhhi*@|�L?t @hi ?L� *@h}ih |�@? |�i) �ihi �? �@?i*t � @?_ # Lu A@M*i H�

W? hit�*|t ?L| hiTLh|i_ �ihic �i uL�?_ |�@| |�i |iU�?L*L}) ThLUitt �t Uh�|�U@* |L |�i�?Uhi@ti_ _�t|Lh|�L?t �4T*�i_ M) |�i @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*� A�i hit�*|t hiTLh|i_ �?A@M*i H U�@?}i �ih) *�||*i �u �i hi|�h? |�i |@t|i @?_ }L�ih?4i?| t�LU! tih�it |L |�i�h M@ti*�?ihiThiti?|@|�L? M�| *i@�i |�i |iU�?L*L}) tih�it �? �|t @*|ih?@|��i hiThiti?|@|�L?� Wu �?t|i@_ �i��t| hi|�h? |�i |iU�?L*L}) t�LU! |L �|t M@ti*�?i hiThiti?|@|�L?c |�i? |�i _�t|Lh|�L?t MiUL4it4@** @}@�?c *�!i |�Lti �? |�i |LT |�L T@?i*t Lu A@M*i H� 5Lc |�i i��_i?Ui Lu _�t|Lh|�L? |�@| �i�?_ �t _h��i? M) |�i @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* hiThiti?|@|�L? Lu |�i |iU�?L*L}) t�LU!� W? @ttitt�?}|�iti _�t|Lh|�L?tc �| �t �4TLh|@?| |L hiU@** L�h �?_�?} |�@| |��t hiThiti?|@|�L? �t hi�iU|i_ M)|�i _@|@�

H� �L?U*�_�?} +i4@h!t

i �ihi uh@?!*) t�hTh�ti_ |�@| @ _iui?t�M*i 4L_i* UL�*_ Mi UL?t|h�U|i_ ���U� t�TTLh|t|�i UL?�i?|�L?@* Th@U|�Ui ��|� hitTiU| |L ti@tL?@*�|) �? |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i *�|ih@|�hi� 5|�**c|�ihi @hi @| *i@t| |�L hi@tL?t ��) L�h @?@*)t�t _Lit ?L| ti||*i |�i �tt�i� 6�ht|c L�h ti@tL?@*4L_i* �@t t�Lh|UL4�?}t� i U@??L| h�*i L�| |�@| @ t�Tih�Lh 4L_i* |�@| ULhhiU|t |�itit�Lh|UL4�?}t ��** �4T*) M�}}ih _�t|Lh|�L?t� W? i T*Lh�?} 4L_��U@|�L?tc �| �L�*_ Mi �?|ihit|�?}|L uLU�t L? @*|ih?@|��i tTiU��U@|�L?t Lu |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU!tc t�U� @t @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t ��|�Tih�L_�U Lh t|LU�@t|�U@**) i�L*��?} ULi�U�i?|t�2D �?L|�ih T*@�t�M*i hL�|i �t |L i T*Lhi 4L_i*4L_��U@|�L?t ���U� i?�@?Ui i?_L}i?L�t tL�hUit Lu ti@tL?@*�|)� A��t �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|�hiUi?| �?_�?}t |�@| ti@tL?@* T@||ih?t �@h) ��|� |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i Etii �@?L�@ @?_ B�)ti*t�bbec �iUU�i||�c k@t�)@Tc @?_ `�*UL E�bb.�c @?_ B�)ti*t E�bbe@��� 5iUL?_c L�h @?@*)t�t�@t uLU�tti_ L? @ u@�h*) t�4T*ic M@t�U i^��*�Mh��4 4L_i* Lu M�t�?itt U)U*it� i |��?! |��t�t �@*�@M*i uLh |�i T�hTLti Lu ti||�?} @ Mi?U�4@h!� 5|�**c |�i *�|ih@|�hi L? i^��*�Mh��4M�t�?itt U)U*i 4L_i*t �?U*�_it �@}i UL?|h@U|�?}c �i|ihL}i?i�|) Lu @}i?|tc 4�*|�T*i tiU|Lhtc|@ t�LU!tc 4L?i|@h) u@U|Lhtc @?_ 4L_��U@|�L?t _it�}?i_ |L hiThL_�Ui ui@|�hit Lu @tti|4@h!i|t� `�i|�ih L�h �?_�?}t @hi hi*i�@?| uLh |�iti U@tit �t @? LTi?c ^�@?|�|@|��ic �tt�i|�@| U@? Mi @__hitti_ �t�?} |�i ThLUi_�hit �4T*i4i?|i_ �? |��t T@Tih�

58Vhh/ iru h{dpsoh/ Ervzlmn dqg Iudqvhv +4<<8/4<<8d,/ Iudqvhv dqg Sdss +4<<7/ 4<<<,/ Jk|0vhov/ Kdoo/ dqg Ohh +4<<9,/ Jk|vhov/ PfFxoorfk/ dqg Wvd| +4<<;, dqg K|oohehuj dqg Sdjdq+4<<:,1

2�

Page 23: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

�� A�i �TThLTh�@|i �i@t�hi Lu OL�ht Lh!i_ 6Lh 5i@tL?@* �?@*�

)t�t

�hi��L�t t|�_�it Lu @}}hi}@|i ti@tL?@* ��U|�@|�L?t �@�i uLU�ti_ L? @ 4i@t�hit Lu �L�ht�Lh!i_ @?_ ThL_�U|���|) _ih��i_ uhL4 |�i it|@M*�t�4i?| t�h�i) Lu i4T*L)4i?|� `�|� |��t4i@t�hi Lu i4T*L)4i?|c *@MLh ThL_�U|���|) �t *L� �? |�i |��h_ ^�@h|ih @?_ |�i? �ih) ��}� �?|�i uL�h|� ^�@h|ih Etii hL� 2 �? A@M*i ���� A��t �t T�33*�?}c MiU@�ti �| �t �@h_ |L |��?! LuT*@�t�M*i |iU�?L*L}�U@* u@U|Lht |�@| U@? @UUL�?| uLh |��t� A�i LMtih�@|�L? t|�4�*@|i_ �@h�L�t4L_i*�?} igLh|tc �?U*�_�?} @||i4T|t |L i T*@�? |�i T@||ih? @t hi�iU|�?} �?Uhi@t�?} hi|�h?t�? |iU�?L*L}) @?_%Lh *@MLh �L@h_�?} Etii �h@�? @?_ ,�@?t E�bbH���

A@M*i �� t�L�t |�@| |�i T�33*�?} ThL_�U|���|) hit�*|t @hi @? @h|�u@U| Lu �t�?} |�i it�|@M*�t�4i?| i4T*L)4i?| _@|@� A��t tih�it |hi@|t TiLT*i L? T@�_ �@U@|�L? @t |�L�}� |�i)�ihi �Lh!�?} @?_ i Tih�i?Ui_ �Lh!iht @t |�L�}� |�i) �ihi ?L 4Lhi ThL_�U|��i |�@? ?i�i4T*L)iit� ��h i4T*L)4i?| 4i@t�hic M@ti_ L? @ t�h�i) Lu �L�ti�L*_t @?_ @_��t|i_ M)B@h) O@?ti? E�bb�� uLh *@MLh uLhUi UL4TLt�|�L?c hiThiti?|t @ Mi||ih �?_�U@|Lh Lu �Lh! iu�uLh| MiU@�ti �| 4i@t�hit �L�ht @U|�@**) �Lh!i_ @?_ @_��t|t uLh �Lh!ih i�U�i?U)� �UULh_�?}|L O@?ti?<t 4i@t�hic �Lh! igLh| �? |�i |��h_ ^�@h|ih _hLTt t�Mt|@?|�@**)c @t i Tih�i?Ui_�Lh!iht }L L? �@U@|�L? @?_ t�44ih|�4i |i4Tt @hi i4T*L)i_ Etii hL� ��� A�i _hLT �? iu�uiU|��i �L�ht �Lh!i_ �t t��U�i?|*) *@h}i |�@| L�h it|�4@|i Lu *@MLh ThL_�U|���|) _Lit ?L|_�tT*@) |�i T�33*�?} ti@tL?@* T@||ih? �? |�i |��h_ @?_ uL�h|� ^�@h|iht |�@| hit�*|t ��i? |�iit|@M*�t�4i?|�M@ti_ �L�ht _@|@ @hi �ti_ EhL� e��

�� BLL_?itt�Lu�6�| Lu |�i �*|ih?@|��i 5�LU! +iThiti?|@|�L?

W? |��t @TTi?_� c �i �?^��hi ��i|�ih |�i @*|ih?@|��i t�LU! 4L_i*t Lu 5iU|�L? e�� U@? @UUL�?|uLh |�i i��_i?Ui Lu _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|) |�@| �i �?_ �? |�i t�LU! ThLUittit� 6Lh |��tc�i �ti @ t|)*i Lu |it| @TT*�i_ �? ��h�t|�@?L @?_ w��?}^��t| E�bHH�� W? T@h|�U�*@hc �i _i�i*LTti�ih@* t|@|�t|�Ut |�@| ^�@?|�u) |�i @4L�?| Lu _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|) �? |�i i L}i?L�tt�LU! _@|@c @?_ �i @t! �L� �@h_ �| �t uLh |�i @*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t |L @UUL�?| uLh|�i4� i �?_ |�@| �? |�i U@ti Lu |�i |@t|i @?_ E|L @ *ittih i |i?|� |iU�?L*L}) t�LU!tc |�i@*|ih?@|��i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t U@? _L tL L?*) ��|� �ih) *L� ThLM@M�*�|)� �? |��t M@t�t �i hi�iU||�i T�hi*) �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U @�|Lhi}hitt��i hiThiti?|@|�L? uLh |�iti |�L tih�it� i �?_ |�@|�i U@??L| hi�iU| |�i T�hi*) �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U hiThiti?|@|�L? uLh |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L?t�LU!c �L�i�ih�

AL U@hh) L�| L�h |it|c �i �ti |�L |)Tit Lu t|@|�t|�Ut |�@| U�@h@U|ih�3i |�i i��_i?Ui L?_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|) �? |�i i L}i?L�t t�LU! ThLUittit� i �ti E�� |�i |�t|@|�t|�U L? |�i�?_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@* ULi�U�i?|c wc �? |�i M@ti*�?i ti@tL?@* 4L_i*tc hiTLh|i_ �? A@M*i ��

22

Page 24: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

A��t �t t4@** �? |�i U@ti Lu @** t�LU!t i UiT| |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? t�LU!� i @*tL�ti E��� t|@|�t|�Ut |�@| U�@h@U|ih�3i |�i i��_i?Ui |�@| |�i ti@tL?@* T@||ih? Lu �Tt @?_ _L�?t�? |�i _@|@ �t t|@M*i L�ih |�4i�

A�i uL**L��?} _itUh�Mit |�i �ht| Lu L�h |�L t|@|�t|�Ut Lu |)Ti E���� 6Lh i@U� U@*i?_@h)i@h �i UL4T�|i |�i TihUi?|@}i _i��@|�L?t E*L} _�gihi?Ui� Lu i@U� ^�@h|ih<t LMtih�@|�L?uhL4 |�i t@4T*i 4i@? uLh |�@| )i@h� i @*tL UL4T�|i |�i TihUi?|@}i _i��@|�L? Lu i@U�^�@h|ih<t ti@tL?@* _�44) uhL4 |�i @�ih@}i Lu |�i ti@tL?@* _�44�it� A�i?c uLh i@U� )i@hc�i UL4T�|i |�i ULhhi*@|�L? Mi|�ii? |�i |�L tih�it� A�i @�ih@}i Lu |�iti @??�@* ULhhi*@|�L?t�t L�h 4@}?�|�_i 4i@t�hi Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|)� 6Lh |�i Thiuihi?Ui t�LU!c |�i ThL_�U|���|)t�LU!c @?_ |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? t�LU! tih�it UL4T�|i_ uhL4 N5 _@|@c �i LM|@�?i_4@}?�|�_i 4i@t�hit Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|) Lu f�b�c f�bHc @?_ f�S�c hitTiU|��i*)� A��tc uLh |�i�ht| |�L t�LU!tc |�i T@||ih? Lu ti@tL?@* �Tt @?_ _L�?t �t �ih) t|@M*i L�ih |�4ic @t �L�*_Mi i TiU|i_ uLh @ ThLUitt ��Lti ti@tL?@* �t Th�4@h�*) _i|ih4�?�t|�U� `�|� @ ti@tL?@* |�@| �tTh�4@h�*) �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U �i 4�}�| i TiU| |L tii tL4i _h�u|�?} �? |�i ti@tL?@*tc ���U� �L�*_ThL_�Ui @ *L� �@*�i uLh |�i 4@}?�|�_i 4i@t�hi Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|)�

W? L�h tiUL?_ t|@|�t|�U Lu |)Ti E���c �i h@?! i@U� ^�@h|ih �? @ U@*i?_ih )i@h @UULh_�?} |L|�i t�3i Lu |�i TihUi?| _i��@|�L?t _�tU�tti_ �? |�i Thi��L�t T@h@}h@T�� A�i ��}�it| ^�@h|ih�? @ }��i? )i@h �t h@?!i_ �c |�i tiUL?_ ��}�it| 2c @?_ tL L?� E i @*tL i Tih�4i?|i_ ��|�h@?!�?} ML|� 4�__*i ^�@h|iht 2�Dc |L @**L� uLh ti@tL?@* T@||ih?t �? ���U� 4�__*i ^�@h|iht@hi ?L| t�@hT*) _�gihi?|c M�| |�i hit�*|t U�@?}i_ *�||*i @?_ @hi ?L| hiTLh|i_�� i @*tL h@?!i@U� ^�@h|ih<t LMtih�@|�L? @UULh_�?} |L |�i 4@}?�|�_i Lu |�@| ^�@h|ih<t _�44)� 6Lh i@U�U@*i?_@h )i@hc �i |�i? UL4T�|i |�i 5Ti@h4@? h@?! ULhhi*@|�L? Mi|�ii? |�i h@?!�?} Lu |�@|)i@h<t ^�@h|iht @?_ |�i L�ih@** h@?!�?} M@ti_ L? |�i _�44�it� ��h h@?! 4i@t�hi Lu ti@tL?@*

t|@M�*�|) �t |�i @�ih@}i Lu |�iti ULhhi*@|�L?t L�ih |�i ��L*i t@4T*i� 6Lh |�i Thiuihi?Ui t�LU!c|�i ThL_�U|���|) t�LU!c @?_ |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? t�LU! tih�it UL4T�|i_ uhL4 N5_@|@c �i LM|@�?i_ h@?! 4i@t�hit Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|) Lu f�b�c f�b2c @?_ f�D�c hitTiU|��i*)�

AL U�iU! ��i|�ih |�i �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U 4L_i*t Lu ti@tL?@*�|) @hi UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i t|@|�t�|�Ut _�tU�tti_ @ML�ic �i t�4�*@|i_ Dcfff @h|��U�@* _@|@ ti|tc i@U� Lu |�i t@4i *i?}|� @t L�hN5 _@|@ |�4i Tih�L_ E2D @?_ @ �@*u )i@htc ULhhitTL?_�?} |L DHG� |L H�Ge�c uLh i@U� Lu |�iit|�4@|i_ T�hi*) @�|Lhi}hitt��i ti@tL?@* hiThiti?|@|�L?t� W? i@U� U@ti |�i Tih�L_ DHG� |LS�G2 �@t ti| i^�@* |L |�i @U|�@* �@*�it �? L�h N5 _@|@ tih�itc @?_ |�i hi4@�?�?} LMtih�@|�L?t�ihi t�4�*@|i_ �t�?} |�i �||i_ T�hi*) �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@* 4L_i*t @?_ MLL|t|h@TT�?}E��ihiM) _�t|�hM@?Ui |ih4t @hi LM|@�?i_ M) t@4T*�?}c ��|� hiT*@Ui4i?|c uhL4 |�i �||i_hit�_�@*t�� Nt�?} |�i t@4i UL4T�|@|�L?t _itUh�Mi_ @ML�ic �i UL4T�|i_ @ |�t|@|�t|�U @?_|�i |�L 4i@t�hit Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|) uLh i@U� t�4�*@|�L?� A�@| �tc uLh i@U� @�|Lhi}hitt��ihiThiti?|@|�L?c �i LM|@�?i_ Dcfff @h|��U�@* |�t|@|�t|�Ut @?_ Dcfff T@�ht Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|)t|@|�t|�Ut�

2�

Page 25: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

6Lh |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? t�LU!c |�i @h|��U�@* |�t|@|�t|�Ut �ihi t4@**ih |�@? |�ii4T�h�U@* L?i �.�2 TihUi?| Lu |�i |�4i� A��tc i�i? @| @ �f TihUi?| Uh�|�U@* *i�i*c |�i @��|Lhi}hitt��i ti@tL?@* hiThiti?|@|�L? �t ?L| hi�iU|i_� 6Lh |�i |@t|i t�LU! @?_ ThL_�U|���|)t�LU!c �L�i�ihc *itt |�@? � TihUi?| Lu |�i t�4�*@|�L?t )�i*_ @ |�t|@|�t|�U t4@**ih |�@? |�ii4T�h�U@* L?ic �?_�U@|�?} |�@| |�i�h it|�4@|i_ @�|Lhi}hitt��i hiThiti?|@|�L?t U@??L| i T*@�?@�@) |�i i4T�h�U@* i��_i?Ui �? u@�Lh Lu _i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@*�|)� W? L|�ih �Lh_tc |��t |it|hi�iU|t |�i @�|Lhi}hitt��i ti@tL?@* hiThiti?|@|�L? uLh |@t|i @?_ ThL_�U|���|) t�LU!t @| |�i �TihUi?| *i�i*�

A�i hit�*|t uLh |�i 4@}?�|�_i 4i@t�hi Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|) @hi t�4�*@h� 6Lh }L�ih?4i?|UL?t�4T|�L?c �2�2 TihUi?| Lu |�i t�4�*@|�L?t ThL_�Ui_ TihUi?|@}i _i��@|�L? t|@|�t|�Ut @t��}� @t |�i i4T�h�U@* L?i� 6Lh |�i |@t|i @?_ ThL_�U|���|) t�LU!tc M) UL?|h@t|c *itt |�@? �TihUi?| Lu |�i t�4�*@|�L?t _�_ tL�

A�i h@?! 4i@t�hi Lu ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|) �@t t*�}�|*) _�gihi?|� A�i @�|Lhi}hitt��i ti@tL?@*4L_i* uLh }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? @}@�? �@t ?L| hi�iU|i_( 22�e TihUi?| Lu |�i t�4�*@|�L?tThL_�Ui_ 5Ti@h4@? 4i@t�hit @t ��}� @t |�i i4T�h�U@* L?i� A�i LTTLt�|i �@t @}@�? |h�iuLh |�i |@t|i t�LU!c @}@�? @| |�i � TihUi?| Uh�|�U@* *i�i*� 6Lh |�i |iU�?L*L}) t�LU!c �L�i�ihcD�H TihUi?| Lu |�i t�4�*@|�L?t ThL_�Ui_ 5Ti@h4@? ti@tL?@* t|@M�*�|) t|@|�t|�Ut i^�@* |L Lh}hi@|ih |�@? |�i i4T�h�U@* 4i@t�hi� �| @ D TihUi?| Uh�|�U@* *i�i* uLh |��t t|@|�t|�Uc L?i �L�*_EM@hi*)� ?L| hi�iU| |�i @�|Lhi}hitt��i ti@tL?@* hiThiti?|@|�L? uLh |�i ThL_�U|���|) t�LU!�

AL t�44@h�3i L�h hit�*|tG E�� |�i |it|t t|hL?}*) hi�iU| |�i �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U 4L_i* �t�?}|@t|i t�LU!t( E��� |�L |it|t hi�iU| |�i �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U 4L_i* �t�?} ThL_�U|���|) t�LU!t @?_L?i _Lit ?L|( E���� |�i |it|t _L ?L| hi�iU| |�i T�hi*) �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U ti@tL?@* 4L_i* �t�?}}L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L?�

W| �t �4TLh|@?| |L i4T�@t�3i L?i �?@* TL�?|� Wu �i �@_ @**L�i_ i�i? *L?}ih *@}tc �i UL�*_�@�i ThL_�Ui_ T�hi*) �?_i|ih4�?�t|�U 4L_i*t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i i��_i?Ui L? _i|ih4�?�t|�Uti@tL?@*�|)� A��t �t MiU@�ti *L?} @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t U@? @hM�|h@h�*) �i** @TThL �4@|i hiThiti?�|@|�L?t *�!i L�h M@ti*�?i 4L_i*t ��|� ti@tL?@* _�44�it�2S 5�U� *L?} @�|Lhi}hitt�L?t @hi?L| Lu �?|ihit| �? @TT*�i_ �Lh!c t�?Ui |�i) @hi _��U�*| |L it|�4@|i ��|� ThiU�t�L? �? |)T�U@*TLt|�@h _@|@ ti|t�

59Wklv uhtxluhv vrph h{sodqdwlrq1 Irupdoo|/ zh fdq wklqn ri wkh vshfwudo ghqvlw| ri rxuedvholqh wlph vhulhv uhsuhvhqwdwlrq dv wkh vxp ri wkh vshfwuxp ri {gw dqg {qgw lq +61;,1 Wkh odwwhulv zhoo gh�qhg1 Zh gh�qh wkh iruphu dv wkh Irxulhu wudqvirup ri wkh fryduldqfh ixqfwlrq riwkh gxpplhv wkdw zrxog eh frpsxwhg iurp d orqj vdpsoh ri gxpplhv1 Wklv Irxulhu wudqviruplv frpsrvhg ri Ghowd ixqfwlrq vslnhv1 Vr/ wkh vshfwuxp lpsolhg e| rxu edvholqh prgho fdq ehwkrxjkw ri dv wkh vxp ri d vprrwk sduw dqg d Ghowd ixqfwlrq sduw1 D vhtxhqfh ri vshfwud lpsolhge| orqjhu dqg orqjhu odj dxwruhjuhvvlrqv fdq dssur{lpdwh wklv sdwwhuq duelwudulo| zhoo1

2e

Page 26: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

+iuihi?Uit

d�o �@hhLc +LMih|� �bbf� �@UhLiUL?L4�Ut� aL�? `�*i) : 5L?tc W?U�

d2o �@ht!)c +LMih| ��c @?_ ��hL?c aighi) �� �bHb� A�i ti@tL?@* U)U*i @?_ |�iM�t�?itt U)U*i� aL�h?@* Lu �L*�|�U@* ,UL?L4) b.c Df���e�

d�o �i@�*�i�c a� aLtiT�c @?_ ��hL?c aighi) �� �bb�� � UhLtt UL�?|h) UL4T@h�tL?Lu ti@tL?@* U)U*it @?_ M�t�?itt U)U*it� �@?�tUh�T|� �Lt|L? N?��iht�|) E�@)��

deo �i?�@M�Mc aitt( +L}ihtL?c +�U�@h_( @?_ h�}�|c h�}�|� �bb�� OL4i�Lh! �?4@UhLiUL?L4�UtG OL�ti�L*_ ThL_�U|�L? @?_ @}}hi}@|i ��U|�@|�L?t� aL�h?@*Lu �L*�|�U@* ,UL?L4) bbc ��SS��H.�

dDo �Lt���!c O� �i|ih @?_ ���*�T 6h@?tit� �bbD� �ih�L_�U UL�?|i}h@|�L?G hiThi�ti?|@|�L? @?_ �?uihi?Ui� +i��i� Lu ,UL?L4�Ut @?_ 5|@|�t|�Ut� ..E��c ��}�t|cT@}it e�S�De�

dSo �Lt���!c O� �i|ih @?_ ���*�T 6h@?tit� �bbD@� Ait|�?} uLh Tih�L_�U �?|i}h@|�L?�,UL?L4�Ut wi||iht� eHE��e�c a�?ic T@}it 2e��eH�

d.o �h@�?c +� �?|L?c @?_ ,�@?tc ��@h*it w� �bbD� 5i@tL?@*�|) @?_ i^��*�Mh��4M�t�?itt U)U*i |�iLh�it� aL�h?@* Lu ,UL?L4�U #)?@4�Ut @?_ �L?|hL* �bc Df��D���

dHo �h@�?c +� �?|L?c @?_ ,�@?tc ��@h*it w� �bbH� 5i@tL?@* 5L*L� hit�_�@*t @?_��h�t|4@tG � U@ti uLh *@MLh �L@h_�?} @?_ �?Uhi@t�?} hi|�h?t� aL�h?@* Lu�L?i)c �hi_�| @?_ �@?!�?}c �L*� �fc ?L� �c ��}�t|c T@h| ��

dbo �@?L�@c 6@M�Lc @?_ ,h�U B�)ti*t� �bbe� ��@?}it �? ti@tL?@* T@||ih?tc @hi|�i) U)U*�U@*qc aL�h?@* Lu ,UL?L4�U #)?@4�Ut @?_ �L?|hL* �HG ��e����.��

d�fo �iUU�i||�c 5|iT�i? B�c �?�* k� k@t�)@Tc @?_ #@��_`�`�*UL � �bb.� W?|ih@U�|�L?t Mi|�ii? |�i ti@tL?@* @?_ M�t�?itt U)U*it �? ThL_�U|�L? @?_ �?�i?|Lh�it��4ih�U@? ,UL?L4�U +i��i�� H.ED�c #iUi4Mihc T@}it HHe�b2�

d��o ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a� �bHH� `�) _Lit �?�i?|Lh) �?�it|4i?| ��U|�@|i tL4�U�q aL�h?@* Lu �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Ut 2�c 2e.�Hf�

d�2o ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�� �bbf� w�?i@h�^�@_h@|�U @TThL �4@|�L? @?_ �@*�i�u�?U|�L? �|ih@|�L?G @ UL4T@h�tL?c aL�h?@* Lu ��t�?itt @?_ ,UL?L4�U 5|@|�t�|�Ut�

2D

Page 27: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

d��o ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c @?_ �@h|�? ,�U�i?M@�4� �bb2� ��hhi?| hi@* M�t�?ittU)U*i |�iLh�it @?_ @}}hi}@|i *@MLh 4@h!i| ��U|�@|�L?t� �4ih�U@? ,UL?L4�U+i��i� .H Ea�?i�G e�f�Df�

d�eo ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c @?_ L�|ih _i? O@@?� �bbS� 54@**�5@4T*i �hLTih�|�it Lu B�� uLh ��t�?itt��)U*i �?@*)t�t� aL�h?@* Lu ��t�?itt @?_ ,UL?L4�U5|@|�t|�Ut �L*� �ec ?L� �c a�*)c TT� �fb��2.�

d�Do ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c @?_ w@ht w��?}^��t|� �bHH� �L?i) _Lit }h@?}ih�U@�ti L�|T�| �? |�i M��@h�@|i L�|T�|�4L?i) hi*@|�L?� aL�h?@* Lu �L?i|@h),UL?L4�Utc 5iT|i4Mih�

d�So ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c @?_ +�U�@h_ �� AL__� �bbS� A�4i |L T*@? @?_ @}�}hi}@|i ��U|�@|�L?t� 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ��??i@TL*�t "�@h|ih*) +i��i�c`�?|ihc �L*� 2fc ?L� ��

d�.o �*i�i*@?_c `��� @?_ B��� A�@L� �b.S� #iUL4TLt�|�L? Lu ti@tL?@* |�4i tih�itG@ 4L_i* uLh |�i �i?t�t j��� �hL}h@4� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@*�ttLU�@|�L?� �L*� .�c �tt�i �DDc 5iT|i4Mihc TT� DH��DH.�

d�Ho �LL*i)c A�L4@t 6�c @?_ �hitUL||c ,_�@h_c �bbD� ,UL?L4�U }hL�|� @?_ M�t��?itt U)U*it� W? A�L4@t 6� �LL*i)c i_�c 6hL?|�iht Lu M�t�?itt U)U*i hiti@hU���h�?Ui|L? N?��iht�|) �hitt�

d�bo 6h@?titc ���*�T @?_ +�U�@h_ �@@T� �bbe� �L_i* ti*iU|�L? �? Tih�L_�U @�|Lhi�}hitt�L?tc � uLh_ ��**i|�? Lu ,UL?L4�Ut @?_ 5|@|�t|�Ut� DSEe�c �L�i4MihcT@}it e2���b�

d2fo 6h@?titc ���*�T @?_ +�U�@h_ �@@T� �bbb� �? |hi?_t @?_ UL?t|@?|t �? Tih�L_�U@�|Lhi}hitt�L?t� ,UL?L4i|h�U +i��i�t� �HE��c ��}�t|c T@}it 2.��HS�

d2�o 6h@?titc ���*�Tc Oi?! OLi!c @?_ +�U�@h_ �@@T� �bb.� �@)it�@? @?@*)t�t Luti@tL?@* �?�| hLL|t @?_ ti@tL?@* 4i@? t��u|t� aL�h?@* Lu ,UL?L4i|h�Ut� .HE2�ca�?ic T@}it �Db�Hf�

d22o 6h@?titc ���*�Tc 5�i?_ O)**iMih} @?_ O@�? 5� wii� �bbD� 5T�h�L�t _i|ih4�?��t|�U ti@tL?@*�|)� ,UL?L4�Ut wi||iht eHc TT� 2eb�2DS�

d2�o B�)ti*tc ,h�U� �bHH� � t|�_) |L�@h_t @ _)?@4�U |�iLh) Lu ti@tL?@*�|) uLhiUL?L4�U |�4i tih�it� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c �L*�H�c TT� �SH��.2�

2S

Page 28: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

d2eo B�)ti*tc ,h�U� �bbe@� �? |�i Tih�L_�U t|h�U|�hi Lu |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i� aL�h?@*Lu ��t�?itt @?_ ,UL?L4�U 5|@|�t|�Utc �2c TT� 2Hb�2bH�

d2Do B�)ti*tc ,h�U� �bbeM� �? |�i iUL?L4�Ut @?_ iUL?L4i|h�Ut Lu ti@tL?@*�|)� W?���� 5�4tc i_�|Lhc �_�@?Uit �? ,UL?L4i|h�Utc �L*� �c �@4Mh�_}i N?��iht�|)�hitt�

d2So B�)ti*tc ,h�Uc �*��i Bh@?}ihc @?_ ��ihhi 5�!*Lt� �bbS� Wt ti@tL?@* @_��t|4i?|@ *�?i@h Lh ?L?*�?i@h _@|@ |h@?tuLh4@|�L?q� aL�h?@* Lu ��t�?itt @?_ ,UL?L4�U5|@|�t|�Ut� �eE��c a�*)c T@}it �.e�HS�

d2.o B�)ti*tc ,h�Uc �*@t|@�h O@**c @?_ 5��! O@�? wii� �bbS� �? Tih�L_�U t|h�U�|�hit @?_ |it|�?} uLh ti@tL?@* �?�| hLL|t� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@*�ttLU�@|�L?� b�Ee�S�c #iUi4Mihc T@}it �DD��Db�

d2Ho B�)ti*tc ,h�Uc +LMih| ,� �U��**LU�c @?_ +�i) 5� At@)� �bbH� �@)it�@? �?uih�i?Ui uLh Tih�L_�U hi}�4i�t��|U��?} 4L_i*t� aL�h?@* Lu �TT*�i_ ,UL?L4i|h�Ut���E2�c �@hU���Th�*c T@}it �2b�e��

d2bo Bhi|�ihc #���c @?_ �� �ih*L�i� �b.f� 5L4i ThLTih|�it Lu RLT|�4@*� ti@tL?@*@_��t|4i?|� ,UL?L4i|h�U@c �� �H E?L� Dc 5iT|i4Mih�c TT� SH2�.f��

d�fo O@?ti?c B@h) #� �bHD� W?_���t�M*i *@MLh @?_ |�i M�t�?itt U)U*i� aL�h?@* Lu�L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Ut �S E�L�i4Mih�G �fb�2.�

d��o O@?ti?c B@h) #� �bb�� A�i U)U*�U@* @?_ tiU�*@h Mi�@��Lh Lu |�i *@MLh �?T�|G�L4T@h�?} i�U�i?U) @?_ �L�ht �Lh!i_c aL�h?@* Lu �TT*�i_ ,UL?L4i|h�Utc�L*� Hc a@?�@h)��@hU�c TT� .��Hf�

d�2o O@?ti?c B@h) #�c @?_ h�}�|c +@?_@**� �bb2� A�i *@MLh 4@h!i| �? hi@* M�t��?itt U)U*i |�iLh)� 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ��??i@TL*�t "�@h|ih*) +i��i� �SE5Th�?}�G 2��2�

d��o O@?ti?c w@ht �i|ihc @?_ 5@h}i?|c A�L4@t a� �bb�� 5i@tL?@*�|) @?_ @TThL ��4@|�L? ihhLht �? h@|�L?@* i TiU|@|�L?t 4L_i*t� aL�h?@* Lu ,UL?L4i|h�Utc DDc2��DS�

d�eo OL_h�U!c +LMih|c @?_ ,_�@h_ �hitUL||� �bb.� �Lt|��@h M�t�?itt U)U*itG �?i4T�h�U@* �?�it|�}@|�L?� aL�h?@* Lu �L?i)c �hi_�| @?_ �@?!�?}c �L*� 2bc ?L��c 6iMh�@h)c TT� ���S�

2.

Page 29: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

d�Do O)**iMih}c 5�i?_ @?_ �_h�@? +� �@}@?� �bb.� 5i@tL?@* �?|i}h@|�L? @?_|�i i�L*��?} ti@tL?@*t 4L_i*� W?|ih?@|�L?@* aL�h?@* Lu 6LhiU@t|�?}� ��E��c5iT|i4Mihc T@}it �2b�ef�

d�So O)**iMih}c 5�i?_c �*@h@ aLh}i?ti?c @?_ ��*t k@h* 5Lhi?ti?� �bb�� 5i@tL?@*�|)�? 4@UhLiUL?L4�U |�4i tih�it� ,4T�h�U@* ,UL?L4�Ut� �HE2�c T@}it �2���D�

d�.o k�?}c +LMih|c @?_ 5ih}�L +iMi*Lc �bb�� wL� uhi^�i?U) �*|ih�?} @?_ hi@*M�t�?itt U)U*it� aL�h?@* Lu ,UL?L4�U #)?@4�Ut @?_ �L?|hL*c �L*� �.c TT�2D��2���

d�Ho k)_*@?_c 6�?? ,�c @?_ �hitUL||c ,_�@h_ �� �bH2� A�4i |L M��*_ @?_ @}}hi�}@|i ��U|�@|�L?t� ,UL?L4i|h�U@ Dfc ��eD�.f�

d�bo wL�i**c ��U�@i* �� �bS�� 5i@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| Lu iUL?L4�U |�4i tih�itc aL�h?@*Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c �L*� DHc TT� bb���f�f�

defo �@h@�@**c �}�t|��?� �bbD� N?LMtih�i_ UL4TL?i?|t �? iUL?L4�U |�4i tih�it�W? �it@h@?c �� O@t�i4c @?_ ��+� `�U!i?tc i_t� E�bbD�c O@?_MLL! Lu �T�

T*�i_ ,UL?L4i|h�Utc VL*�4i WG �@UhLiUL?L4�Ut� � uLh_G �*@U!�i** ��M*�t��ihtc w|_�

de�o �UBh@||@?c ,**i? +� �bbe� � ThL}hitt hiTLh| L? M�t�?itt U)U*i 4L_i*t� 6i_�ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ��??i@TL*�t "�@h|ih*) +i��i�c 6@**�

de2o �*Lttihc ��@h*it W� �b.b� A�i @?@*)t�t Lu ti@tL?@* iUL?L4�U 4L_i*t� aL�h?@*Lu ,UL?L4i|h�Utc �� �f Ea�?i�c TT� �e.��S��

de�o 5@h}i?|c A�L4@tc �b.H� �L44i?|t L? �5i@tL?@* �_��t|4i?| @?_ ��*|�T*iA�4i 5ih�it �?@*)t�t< M) ki??i|� 6� @**�tc �? �h?L*_ ~i**?ih Ei_�� 5i@tL?@*�?@*)t�t Lu ,UL?L4�U A�4i 5ih�itc �hLUii_�?}t Lu |�i �L?uihi?Ui L? |�i 5i@�tL?@* �?@*)t�t Lu ,UL?L4�U A�4i 5ih�itc @t��?}|L?c #���c 5iT|� b��fc �b.Sc,UL?L4�U +iti@hU� +iTLh|c ,+��c N5 #iT@h|4i?| Lu �L44ihUic ��hi@� Lu|�i �i?t�t�

deeo 5@h}i?|c A�L4@t� �bH.� �@UhLiUL?L4�U A�iLh)c 2?_ i_�|�L?c �U@_i4�U�hitt�

deDo 5U��@h3c B� �b.H� ,t|�4@|�?} |�i _�4i?t�L? Lu @ 4L_i*� �??@*t Lu t|@|�t|�Ut�SGeS��e�

2H

Page 30: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

deSo 5�4tc ��h�t|LT�ih �� �b.S� +itTL?ti |L 5@h}i?|<t �L44i?| L? |�i �@Tih M)@**�t� �?T�M*�t�i_ 4@?�tUh�T|c �L�i4Mih 2��

de.o 5�?}*i|L?c ki??i|� a�� �bHH� ,UL?L4i|h�U Wtt�it �? |�i �?@*)t�t Lu ,^��*�M�h��4 ��t�?itt �)U*i �L_i*tc aL�h?@* Lu �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Utc �L*� 2�c TT��S���HS�

deHo vL�?}c ��O� �bSHc w�?i@h @TThL �4@|�L?t |L |�i Ui?t�t @?_ �w5 ti@tL?@*@_��t|4i?| 4i|�L_t� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?�

debo @**�tc ki??i|� 6� �b.e� 5i@tL?@* @_��t|4i?| @?_ hi*@|�L?t Mi|�ii? �@h��@M*it� aL�h?@* Lu |�i �4ih�U@? 5|@|�t|�U@* �ttLU�@|�L?c �� Sb E?L� �eDc �@hU��cTT�c �H����

dDfo @|tL?c �@h!c �bb�� �i@t�hit Lu �| uLh U@*�Mh@|i_ 4L_i*t� aL�h?@* Lu �L*�|�U@*,UL?L4)c �f�G�f���e��

2b

Page 31: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH �� ([RJHQRXV 6KRFN 0RGHOV�

3DQHO $� 3UHIHUHQFHV� W

VH I� I� T HG� H

G� H

G� H

G� 4 ':

(TXDWLRQ ��� ���� ���

������

���

������

���

������

���� ���� ���� ���� ���

����

����

3DQHO %� 7HFKQRORJ\� O

VH I� I� T G� G� G� G� 4 ':

(TXDWLRQ ��� ���� ����

�������

���

�����

���

�����

����� ���� ���� ���� ���

����

����

3DQHO &� *RYHUQPHQW� J

VH I� I� T HG� H

G� H

G� H

G� 4 ':

(TXDWLRQ ��� ���� ���

������

���

������

���

������

����� ����� ����� ����� ���

����

����

�(TXDWLRQ ��� UHVXOWV DUH IRU ILWWLQJ WKH PRGHO� [W G�G�W � G�G�W � G�G�W � G�G�W � >���I�/�I�/

�����T/

��@

��HW WR [W� ZKHUH [W ORJWW� OW� ORJ�JW� DV LQGLFDWHG� GLW LV

� LQ TXDUWHU L DQG ]HUR RWKHUZLVH� L �� �� �� � DQG VH LV WKH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ RI HW� &DOFXODWLRQV GRQH LQ WZR VWHSV� GXPP\ FRHIILFLHQWV DUH REWDLQHG LQ

VWHS RQH E\ 2/6 RYHU ������ WR ������� DQG LQ VWHS WZR WKH UHPDLQLQJ FRHIILFLHQWV DUH REWDLQHG E\ DSSO\LQJ 5$76 SURFHGXUH %2;-(1. WR WKH UHVLGXDOV�

7KH VWHS WZR UHJUHVVLRQV DUH RYHU ������ WR ������� :LWK RQH H[FHSWLRQ� QXPEHUV LQ SDUHQWKHVHV DUH W�VWDWLVWLFV� 7KH H[FHSWLRQ LV WKHFROXPQSHUWDLQLQJ WR

4� ZKLFK FRQVLVWV RI WKH QXPEHU RI ODJV LQ WKH %R[�3LHUFH VWDWLVWLF FRPSXWHG RQ WKH ILWWHG GLVWXUEDQFHV� 4 LV WKH S�YDOXH RI WKH %R[�3LHUFH VWDWLVWLF� ZLWK D

QXPEHU EHORZ ���� LQGLFDWLQJ UHMHFWLRQ DW WKH � SHUFHQW OHYHO� ': LV WKH 'XUELQ�:DWVRQ VWDWLVWLF�

Page 32: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH �� 6HDVRQDO 'HYLDWLRQV IURP 7UHQG � 8�6� 'DWD�

$YHUDJH 3HUFHQWDJH 'HYLDWLRQ E\ 4XDUWHU 'XPPLHV &RUUHODWLRQV

4� 4� 4� 4� 'XPPLHV

6WG� 'HY�

:LWK <

'XPPLHV

:LWK <�Q

'XPPLHV

< ����� ���� ���� ���� ���� ����

& ����� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���

, ����� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���

* ����� ���� ��� ���� ���� ���

Q ���� ��� ����� ���� ���� ��� ����

<�Q ����� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���

�< UHDO *13� & UHDO FRQVXPSWLRQ RI QRQGXUDEOHV SOXV VHUYLFHV� , UHDO IL[HG LQYHVWPHQW� * UHDO JRYHUQPHQW FRQVXPSWLRQ� )URP +DQVHQ ������� Q HIIHFWLYH

KRXVHKROG KRXUV� 2WKHU GDWD IURP %DUVN\�0LURQ ������� 5HDO YDULDEOHV DUH %DUVN\�0LURQ QRPLQDO YDULDEOHV GLYLGHG E\ WKHLU &3, VHULHV� $OO GDWD ZHUH RULJLQDOO\ LQ

QRW VHDVRQDOO\ DGMXVWHG IRUP� 7KH\ ZHUH VHDVRQDOO\ DGMXVWHG ZLWK WKH GHIDXOW VHWWLQJV LQ 5$7V (=;��� DQG WKHQ ORJJHG DQG +3 ILOWHUHG� 7KH HIILFLHQF\ KRXUV GDWD

ZHUH SURYLGHG WR XV E\ *DU\ +DQVHQ� 'DWD SHULRG LV ����±��� H[FHSW ����±�� IRU KRXUV DQG SURGXFWLYLW\� :KHUH SRVVLEOH� UHVXOWV DUH UHSURGXFHG IURP %DUVN\ DQG

0LURQ� 7DEOH �� 5HVXOWV IRU FRQVXPSWLRQ RI QRQGXUDEOHV DQG VHUYLFHV� &� DQG IRU KRXUV ZRUNHG DQG SURGXFWLYLW\ ZHUH FRPSXWHG E\ XV� 5HVXOWV REWDLQHG E\ ILUVW

ORJJLQJ DQG WKHQ +3�ILOWHULQJ WKH GDWD� 7KH WUDQVIRUPHG GDWD ZHUH UHJUHVVHG RQ VHDVRQDO GXPPLHV� 7KH WDEOH EDVHG RQ WKH UHVXOWLQJ FRHIILFLHQWV� DIWHUPXOWLSOLFDWLRQ

E\ ����

7DEOH �� 7LPH�WR�%XLOG :HLJKWV E\ 6HDVRQ DQG 6WDJH RI 3URMHFW�

6HDVRQ �FDOHQGDU TXDUWHU�

6WDJH RI 3URMHFW 4� 4� 4� 4�

6WDJH =HUR ����� ����� ����� �����

6WDJH 2QH ����� ����� ����� �����

6WDJH 7ZR ����� ����� ����� �����

6WDJH 7KUHH ����� ����� ����� �����

�(QWULHV LQ FROXPQ KHDGHG 4L UHSUHVHQW WKH UHODWLYH VKDUH RI UHVRXUFHV SXW LQ SODFH IRU LQYHVWPHQW SURMHFWV LQLWLDWHG LQ TXDUWHU L� 7KH

ZHLJKWV DGG WR ��� LQ TXDUWHUV �� �� DQG ��

Page 33: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH �� 6WHDG\ 6WDWHV YV� 6DPSOH $YHUDJHV

%DUVN\�0LURQ 'DWD�

%DVHOLQH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHO�

4� 4� 4� 4� 4� 4� 4� 4�

KRXUV

ZRUNHG

����� ����� ����� ����� ����� ����� ����� �����

,�< ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

&�< ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

.�< Q�D� Q�D� Q�D� Q�D� ���� ���� ���� ����

*�< ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

�'XPP\ FRHIILFLHQWV LQ UHJUHVVLRQ RI LQGLFDWHG YDULDEOHV RQ TXDUWHUO\ GXPPLHV� )RU ,�<� &�<� *�< WKH VDPSOH SHULRG LV ����4������4��

)RU KRXUV ZRUNHG� WKH HIILFLHQF\�EDVHG PHDVXUH ZDV XVHG� DQG WKH VDPSOH SHULRG ZDV ����4������4���1RQVWRFKDVWLF VWHDG\ VWDWH YDOXHV RI LQGLFDWHG YDULDEOHV�

7DEOH �� 6HDVRQDO &\FOH� 0RGHO DQG 'DWD

'DWD� %DVHOLQH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHOV

4� 4� 4� 4� 4� 4� 4� 4�

< ����� ���� ���� ���� ����� ��� ��� ����

& ����� ���� ���� ���� ����� ���� ����� ����

, ����� ���� ���� ���� ����� ���� ���� ����

Q ���� ��� ����� ���� ����� ��� ����� ����

* ����� ���� ��� ���� ����� ���� ��� ����

. Q�D� Q�D� Q�D� Q�D� ��� ��� ���� ����

�'HYLDWLRQ IURP +3�WUHQG RI ORJJHG GDWD �PXOWLSOLHG E\ ���� DORQJ VWHDG\ VWDWH JURZWK SDWK�

�7DNHQ IURP 7DEOH � IRU FRQYHQLHQFH�

Page 34: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH �� 6HOHFWHG 6WDWLVWLFV� 6HDVRQDOO\ 8QDGMXVWHG 'DWD

3DQHO $� 8�6� 'DWD IRU ����±��

'\QDPLF &RUUHODWLRQV

9DULDEOHV5HODWLYH

9RODWOLW\� ;��W� ZLWK ;��W�M� IRU M

;� ;� � � � � �� �� ��

< < ���� ���� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ����

< & ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����

< , ���� ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ���

< Q ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ��� ��� ����

< * ���� ���� ���� ���� ��� ���� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ���� ��� ��� ���� ���� ��� ���

3DQHO %� %DVHOLQH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHO

< < ���� ���� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����

< & ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����

< , ���� ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ���

< Q ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����

< * ���� ���� ��� ���� ��� ��� ��� ����

Q <�Q ���� ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ����

��(QWU\ FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR < LV WKH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ RI �ORJJHG� GHWUHQGHG� RXWSXW� (QWULHV LQ WKH IROORZLQJ ILYH URZV DUH WKH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ RI WKH;�YDULDEOH

UHODWLYH WR WKH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ RI WKH ;� YDULDEOH�

Page 35: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH �� 6HOHFWHG %XVLQHVV &\FOH 6WDWLVWLFV� 6HDVRQDOO\ $GMXVWHG 'DWD

3DQHO $� 86 'DWD IRU �������

'\QDPLF &RUUHODWLRQV

9DULDEOHV5HODWLYH

9RODWOLW\� ;��W� ZLWK ;��W�M� IRU M

;� ;� � � � � �� �� ��

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ���� ���� ���� ��� ��� ��� ���

Q <�Q ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ����

3DQHO %� %DVHOLQH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHO

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

��(QWU\ FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR < LV WKH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ RI �ORJJHG� GHWUHQGHG� RXWSXW� (QWULHV LQ WKH IROORZLQJ ILYH URZV DUH WKH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQRI WKH;�YDULDEOH

UHODWLYH WR WKH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ RI WKH ;� YDULDEOH�

'DWD IRU 3DQHO % ZHUH VLPXODWHG ZLWK WKH EDVHOLQH PRGHO� )RU ERWK SDQHOV� GDWD ZHUH VHDVRQDOO\ DGMXVWHG ZLWK WKH ;�� SURFHGXUH LQ (VWLPDV 5$76���[

SDFNDJH�

Page 36: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH �� (IIHFW RI 6HDVRQDO $GMXVWPHQW RQ 6HOHFWHG %XVLQHVV &\FOH 6WDWLVWLFV

3DQHO $� %DVHOLQH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHO

'\QDPLF &RUUHODWLRQV

9DULDEOHV5HODWLYH

9RODWLOLW\� ;��W� ZLWK ;��W�M� IRU M

;� ;� � � � � �� �� ��

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

3DQHO %� 'DWD )URP $VHDVRQDO $QDORJ RI 0RGHO LQ 3DQHO $

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

3DQHO &� $OWHUQDWLYH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHO

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

3DQHO '� 'DWD IURP $VHDVRQDO $QDORJ RI 0RGHO LQ 3DQHO &

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

3DQHOV $ DQG & DUH EDVHG RQ DUWLILFLDO GDWD VLPXODWHG IURP WKH LQGLFDWHG PRGHOV DQG WKHQ VHDVRQDOO\ DGMXVWHG XVLQJ WKH &HQVXV ;��� SURFHGXUH LPSOHPHQWHG LQ

5$76 (=;��� 3DQHOV % DQG ' DUH EDVHG RQ GDWD VLPXODWHG IURP DVHDVRQDO DQDORJV WR WKH PRGHOV XQGHUO\LQJ 3DQHOV $ DQG &� $OO GDWD ZHUH ORJJHG DQG KS�ILOWHUHG

SULRU WR FRPSXWLQJ WKH VWDWLVWLFV� 6HH WKH QRWHV WR 7DEOH � IRU IXUWKHU GLVFXVVLRQ RI WKH IRUPDW RI WKLV WDEOH�

Page 37: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH �� (IIHFW RI 6HDVRQDO $GMXVWPHQW RQ 6HOHFWHG %XVLQHVV &\FOH 6WDWLVWLFV 8VLQJ )LUVW�'LIIHUHQFH 'HWUHQGLQJ

,QVWHDG RI +3 )LOWHULQJ

3DQHO $� %DVHOLQH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHO

'\QDPLF &RUUHODWLRQV

9DULDEOHV5HODWLYH

9RODWLOLW\� ;��W� ZLWK ;��W�M� IRU M

;� ;� � � � � �� �� ��

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ���� ��� ������� ���

���� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ��� ��� ������� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ������� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ������� ���

���� ����

3DQHO %� 'DWD )URP $VHDVRQDO $QDORJ RI 0RGHO LQ 3DQHO $

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ���� ��� ������� ���

���� �������

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ������� ���

���� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ������� ���

���� �������

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ������� ��� ��� ���

3DQHO &� $OWHUQDWLYH 6HDVRQDO 0RGHO

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ���� ��� ��� ��� ������� ��� ���

< , �������� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q �������� ���

���� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

Q <�Q ��� ��� ��� ������� ��� ��� ���

3DQHO '� 'DWD IURP $VHDVRQDO $QDORJ RI 0RGHO LQ 3DQHO &

< < ���� ��� ��� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���

< & ���� ��� ������� ���

���� ��� ���

< , ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

< Q ������� ���

���� ��� ��� ��� ���

< * ���� ��� ��� ��� ������� ��� ���

Q <�Q ���� ��� ��� ������� ��� ��� ���

3DQHOV $ DQG & DUH EDVHG RQ DUWLILFLDO GDWD VLPXODWHG IURP WKH LQGLFDWHG PRGHOV DQG WKHQ VHDVRQDOO\ DGMXVWHG XVLQJ WKH &HQVXV ;��� SURFHGXUH LPSOHPHQWHG LQ

5$76 (=;��� 3DQHOV % DQG ' DUH EDVHG RQ GDWD VLPXODWHG IURP DVHDVRQDO DQDORJV WR WKH PRGHOV XQGHUO\LQJ 3DQHOV $ DQG &� $OO GDWD ZHUH ORJJHG DQG ILUVW

GLIIHUHQFHG SULRU WR FRPSXWLQJ WKH VWDWLVWLFV� 6HH WKH QRWHV WR 7DEOH � IRU IXUWKHU GLVFXVVLRQ RI WKH IRUPDW RI WKLV WDEOH�

Page 38: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

7DEOH $�� 6HDVRQDO 'HYLDWLRQV IURP 7UHQG � (VWDEOLVKPHQW YHUVXV (IILFLHQF\ +RXUV 'DWD�

$YHUDJH 3HUFHQWDJH 'HYLDWLRQ E\ 4XDUWHU 'XPPLHV &RUUHODWLRQV

4� 4� 4� 4� 'XPPLHV

6WG� 'HY�

:LWK <

'XPPLHV

:LWK <�Q

'XPPLHV

Q� HVW ����� ��� ���� ���� ���� ��� ���

<�Q� HVW ����� ��� ����� ���� ���� ���

Q� HII ���� ��� ����� ���� ���� ��� ����

<�Q� HII ����� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���

�+RXUV GDWD DUH GLVWLQJXLVKHG E\ VRXUFH� ³HVW´ PHDQV HVWDEOLVKPHQW VXUYH\ DQG ³HII´ PHDQV +DQVHQV ������ HIIHFWLYH

KRXVHKROG KRXUV� 6HH QRWHV WR 7DEOH � IRU IXUWKHU GHWDLOV�

Page 39: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

60 70 80 900.22

0.24

0.26

0.28

Figure 1a: Preference Shock, τ

τ

time50 60 70 80 90

-0.2

-0.1

0

0.1

0.2Figure 1b: Technology Growth, λ

λ

time

50 60 70 80 905.4

5.45

5.5

5.55

5.6

5.65

5.7

5.75Figure 1c: Detrended gov't consumption (G/z)

G /

z

time

Page 40: Ai L? i?| L?@* hi@A|4i?| Lu 5i@tL?@* |) ? t ?itt )U*i …lchrist/research/...#iUi4Mih Dc 2fff Devwudfw cQr*1 Vr |vdv rqh prgho wkdw lv eurdgo| frqlvwhqvw zlwk srvwzdu XV vhdvrqdo dqg

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

frequency, divided by π

log,

Spe

ctru

m

Figure 2a: Tastes, τ

Raw Data

SeasonallyAdjusted Data

Analyst's Model

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

frequency, divided by π

log,

Spe

ctru

m

Figure 2b: Technology growth, λ

Raw Data

SeasonallyAdjusted Data

Analyst's Model

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1-9

-8

-7

-6

-5

-4

-3

frequency, divided by π

log,

Spe

ctru

m

Figure 2c: G/z

Raw Data

SeasonallyAdjusted Data

Analyst'sModel