¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1....

62
I d c.- d 2 1 il\\\lt3J €)'1'1-b'Yl ... . ........ . ................... ...... ::: . 0 tl. -la'bo 0 1wYi 6'10 i'IA.11fl:lJ klcfcfd , . 0 tl. €) . I '11\l V1 CU a.; .:::1 d Yl (9) , 0 ..., <=t Yl kJ fl L £..11 n V!U 1 £..1>'11'1,1, Yl1>'1 u n fl'JtJ>'I'VI1 tJ L "lJ .... . 0 tl. I '11\l CJ.J I Q,..l Q,..o .c:f d Yl (9) , 0 ..., <=t Yl kl <=t 0 ...

Transcript of ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1....

Page 1: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

I d c.- d 2 1 l31.~1 2558~ il\\\lt3J €)'1'1-b'Yl ... . ........ .................... ...... ::: •

. ~ 0 ~

~~Vi3J1~1,6fl.1~1'Yl tl. ~mGt'-Gt'<i'G>, ~Gt'~c'rc'ro

~~Vi3J1m~t~u~\l~®. ~iJ -la'bo J\gtri~

0

1wYi 6'10 L~tJ'IA. i'IA.11fl:lJ ~Y1Tifi'n11"11 klcfcfd , .

~ 0 ~

~~Vi3J1m~ti~1'Yl tl. ~m~/lsJtrc'ro

~~Vi3J1llt~iltt~\l~ €). ~/l9trct~

I

'1~ '11\l

V1 CU a.; .:::1 d ~1111"11n11~>'~V!1~"15~u1 Yl (9) ~ ,

0 ..., <=t

n1~Yl11>'~n11f1~>'~ Yl kJ

L~t) fl ~ ~ ~1Yl L ~ £..11 n un11~ V!U 1 £..1>'11'1,1, Yl1>'1 u n fl'JtJ>'I'VI1 tJ L ~1V! U1~ "lJ tJ>'Ii'~n1~Yl1n11 ....

hw1~hmu<li'1un!JV!:U1u (~Ylll1rnf11~~1nM1) .

~ 0 ~

~WIVi3J1llt~ti~1'Yl tl. ~cto/lsJc'rc'ro

~~Vi3J1llt~iltt~\l~ ~.lfc1dJlsJtrij

I

'1~ '11\l

• CJ.J I Q,..l Q,..o .c:f d ~1111"11n11~>'~V!1~"15~1J1 Yl (9) ~ ,

0 ..., <=t

n1~Yl11>'~n11f1~>'~ Yl kl

<=t 0

/fl~V!:lJ1UL ~"lJ~1 ...

Page 2: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

I .o=t 0 .o=t

~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo

~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct<lJ

I

'l~'Vi11\J

\I I Q...<l Q...l ,::::1 .d ~1111~n11~~~1~~~u1 ~ G) 'IJ ~

' ""' <=!

n1~~11~n11~~~ ~ ~

~~wvn~ L ~ r.nnun11~w1-b r.J~1U~1~un~,D~~1u L ,r,~,x,~"ll u~1'~n1~rhn11 .tS

t~ui.~~eJu~1r..ln!J~111r.J (~~1J1rnf11wvnm~n) .

I .o=t 0 .o=t

~~'Vi3J1m~ti~1'Yl €1. ~~Cf/l!JCfCfo

~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jrf ®.GI1o /l!Jctcl"J

I

'l~'Vi11\J

L~eJ~ ~~w vn~ L ~ r..11nun11~~~1 u~,u~1~un~1e1~~1m ,r,~,x,~"ll u~1'~n1~'Yhn11 .tS

t~ui.~~eJu~1r..ln!J~111r.J (~~1J1rnf11wvnm~n)

~~el~~~~ ~ ~~el~~~~ rn ~~el~~~~ ~ LL~~~r1nv:JeJ~~~~~~1J~'UeJ~1J1rn 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ~

f11wvnm!f11u~~~111m~"ll~l~ G~d~/~cf.~d ~111m~·1m~~~ G~cf.d/~cf.cf.o ~~~111m~"ll~l ' ' ' .d e:::l .c::t o A

~ G~drn!kJcf.~~ ~1llr.JL~"lJLL~~~ GJcf.~/kJcf.cf.o ~~~1Jlr.JL~"ll~1~ GJ~kJ/kJcf.~~ ~111r.JL~"lJLL~~ ' ' ' .c:t .::::1 0 .d. e:::l

~ G~cf.eii.!kJcf.cf.o ~~~1Jlr.JL~"ll~1~ kJG~ol~cf.~~ ~1llr.JL~"lJLL~~~ G)'Q)o/kJcf.cf.o "llel~

f'fl ~tJn ~1u~.ffu~u ( f'fl ~tJn~1e1~1~ r..1 eJ~)

\ )

Page 3: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

,

1,;1 I t,; t.l I I

fl~vl..1*~1U 1U U f11~Unfl'Hl..1i'W~lU~..1~1~fl~ L "1l1~1 r.JflUL .W Elf111~~:;~nn

LL ri 1 ~~ ~ 1 ~ill 1 1 ~HJ hK ~1 u 1 u f1 ~ ~ ~ 1 tH ~ "lJ ci11 ~ COJ d c:£ f]§j ct. c:£ d dj u ~1 u 1 u f1 ~ ~ ~ n

LL~ L1r.Jn~~El..1f1~1Uf1~~~1tJL~"lJci11~ COJdc:£/]!jcf.r3'_fd ~~1tJL~"lJU~..1~ COJcf.d/lncf.cf.o 11 '1.1

._'lfl~~ COJ L1r.m~~El..1f1~1uf1~~~1m~"llci11~ COJfiim/]!jcf.c:£~ ~~1m~"lJLL~..1~ COJcf.~/]!jcf.cf.o 11 '1.1

..1f1~~ ]§j L1r.m~~El..1f1~1uf1~~~1m~"llci11~ COJ~ln/]!jcf.c:£~ ~~1m~"lJLL~..1~ COJcf.ci./]!jcf.cf.o 11 '1.1

~~~._'lfl~~ m L'1r.m~~El..1f1~1uf1~~3J1tH~"lJci11~ ]§jCOJof]!jcf.c:£~ ~~1tH~"lJU~..1~ COJbo/]!jcf.cf.o 11 '1.1 I '1.1

~~ · ..1f1~~ c:£ LL~:;1lKL1un~11~1"1l'n1~~"w1~"1l'~u'111~rm~EJ..1f1~~ CO) L1unn~:;'Yl~1..1n1~f1~..1 '1.1 '1.1 ~ '1.1 '1.1

11 t1n~EJ..1f1~~ ]§j LL~:;L1un1~~u~'111n1~n~:;'Yl~1..1~11i1~rn~"ll 11~t1n~EJ..1f1~~ m '1.1 ~ ~ '1.1'1.1

~~El..1fl~rr..1~~EJ..111 "1Jru:;di~L~~1Ufl~'if ~~El..1fl~~ COJ ci11~..1ci11LLWli..1 '1.1 ~ '1.1

U1~l Lfl~1:;~u 1 tJ1J1 ULL~:; LL~U '>;) u~:;~1..11UU~U..11U n ~ ~ ~-uu ~UU..11U1J'1~1~ ~ ~

..11U~1i1~rn~"ll~"~1~"1l'~u1 ~~tt'1~1'u~~"ll'EJ1J..11uu~:;nu~"lJ1l1'V'l ..11uu~~u~:;nu~"lJ1l1'V'l ~ ~ ~ ~

..11U ..., ~~~l ~~n1~u~:;"ll'1"1l'U~1U 1m~1'V'l tJ11J1 ~ LL~:;..11UU~~u~:;nu~"lJ1l1'V'lU~..1..11U~1..1"1l'1~ ~

~~ ..1 f1 ~~ ]!j ci11~ ..1 ci11 LL ~U..1U 1 ULL 'V'l'Yl £f ~ ~1UL 1"1l'n~~~iJ El..1 nu ~1Un..11U~11i1~ill~"ll '1.1 ~

~"~l~"ll'~u1 ~~El"fl~~ m ci11~"ci11LL~U"L-;)1~U1~1J'1~1~"1U-A'1LU d ~1uu'1~1~ ~ '1.1

~1 n"1U~11i1~ill~"lJ~..1~l ~"ll'~1J'1 ~ ~ El" fl~ ~ c:£ u 11 U~ ~1"1l'n1~LU U~ "li'1 tJU 1 ULL 'V'l'Yl £f ~ ~ '1.1 ~ '1.1

~11i ~rn~"ll~"~1~ ~1Un..11U~11i1~rn~"ll~"~1~"1l'~u1 ~tln~EJ"fl~~ CO) ~1~~~n1~~~1~ru1 ~ ~ ~ '1.1 '1.1

fln~El"fl~~ ]§j l~~f11&" 1\K~~El"fl~rr"~"ll'~ 1i'L~ULLrl~U1tJ..11W'lJEl"1'~ n~rnL~U 1uuru; cu cu at9 Q.l

U~ ~:;nU~"lJ1l1'V'lLL~""1U~1""1l'1~ LL~:;u ru;L~UnEJ"'YlU~~ULi tJUU ~~u~:;nu~"lJ1l1'V'l •'1}' ru;~ ]!j" q Q.l q q q Q.l

"ll1~ 1 tJLU L -d,El"~1n ~~ El"fl ~rr" ~u~u~"1U~1 tJf111~u~:;~TY1 L~UL~ El El ci1"1'1 tJU~..1 LUU ~~1lKu1"~11tJ1l1'V'l~ 'YlEl"L~ru ~n-;i1"i'1f1~11 ci11LL~U"'V'lun"1uuru;t1EJUL~U~1n

q q cvcu QJ

Uru U~~u~:;nU~"lJ1l1'V'lLL~""1U~1""1l'1~ L~"lJ~Uru; ocf.m - ]§j - ]§joCOJOCOJ - ~ -;51U1UL~U ... ~ ...

cf.,G'!. o,~hcf.c;:a' 1J1'Yl LL~:;uru;L~UnEl"'YlU~~ULitJUU~~u~:;nu~"lJ1l1Vl •'1Jru;~ ]!j" L~"lJ~uru; QJ q q q Q.l Q,l

ocf.m- CO)- O<i)OCO)b-@!. ~1U1UL1u ci.c:£cf.,ooo 1J1i'l i.u1iu~:; 1tJ"ll'U~1U~1 ~1~LUUL~urr"ju,

cf.,c:£b ]§j .ct.~ 1J1i'l ~" 1\K ~~ El"fl~rr..1~"1l'~ 1 i'f111 m*tJ~1 tJ~1~~~~1U ~ El ~~ El"fl~~ COJ '1.1 '1.1

"ll'~ 1 iLUUL~U~1u1u l§j,moCO),CO)~d.~d 1J1i'l ~~EJ"fl~~ ]§j 1u~~"ll'~ 1"11 LUUL~u~1u1u '1.1

~.G'!.bcf..o]§j 1J1i'l ~~El"fl~~ m 1'u~~"ll'~1i LUUL~U~1U1U COJ,~c:£o,bri.c:£ . b]!j 1J1i'l '1.1

YlEJ"f)~~ c:£ 1u~~"ll'~ 1"11 LUUL~U~1U1U mc;:a'<9),C3'.mb.mm 1J1'Yl ~~El..1fl~rr"~El'Yl1i~rnT11&" '1.1 ~

Page 4: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

1 1 I \.1 I

"lle:J~~rmvh:J~fl~Yi <il LL~:;~rmv:Je:J~fl~Yi m ~-;JTHU.1LL~1iif11i~tJne:J'Yl1i1rn ~v:Je:J~f1~Yl~~Ly;U11 • '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 q '1.1 "'

f11i~ 11K-¥u~~"15~ 1i'L~u~~n~11 L6J"15e:JlJ~1 tJn!]~~ltJ ~~Ulf1~~1v:l e:J~~ e:Jf11~Unf11e:J~iu~u

"lle:J1if11~iif11~vnm~n~1e:Jf11i~ ~~d <il. L~ntle:JUf11i~"lle:J~~nnv:le:J~f1~~ <il ~l~~,X~~e:J ~ "lflJ ookJdl<iloriori

'1.1'1.1

d d d C),..l d 'Yl "15lJ o o kJ d I <il o ri <il <il 'Yl "lflJ o o kJ d I <il o ri <il o LL ~:; 'Yl "15U o o kJ d I <il o ri <il kJ t'l ~ 1 U 'Yl kJ <i

iinU1tJU kJcfu:'d ~i~ 1i~v:Je:J~f1~~~~"15~ 1"J!L~ULLnm.btJ~1U"lle:J~-¥;) ~1~~1~U q '1.1 ...

h L~ntle:JUf11lU-;JUtJ"lle:J~~nnv:le:J~fl~~ kJ ~l~wui~e:J ~ nf1 o<io"o:J.<il<i)mdd<i '1.1'1.1

I I I "" I

t'l~1uri kJ<i) Y'HlM1l1f1~ kJcf<id 1u,huYiditJ1"lie:J~nu~v:le:J~f1~'Yl~~

m. L~nr1e:JU~~n11~';l11nl,le:J'Yl1i1rn"lle:J~~nnv:Je:J~f1~~ m ~l~~U~~e:J q '1.1 '1.1

~11-t~~~ ~ ~1i okJo<i).ocfmlmodcf ~~lU~ mo iinUltJU kJcf<i~ 1uthu~i~tJne:J'Yl1i1rn q q q

"lJ e:J~~v:l f)~ f)~~~~ '1.1

~v:le:J~f1~~ kJ LLt'l:;~v:le:J~f1~~ m ~Uf11"lle:J1if11t'liif11i~'YlLt'l1n11U~f1u '1.1 '1.1 q

~1 :u f11 i~'Yll~ u n f11e:J ~"ll e:J~ ~ n n v:l e:J~ f1 ~~ <i) L 1Ltl u n11-E'1 f1111-;J u n11 fl ~-;u :;~~~ ~~ '1.1 '1.1 q

\J I I I

LL~:;f11~unf1"le:J~iu~uiif11i~ 1 i'Yl Lt'l1n11U~T1u~1 ~f11i~'Yl1~Unf11e:J~"ll e:J~ ~nnv:l e:J~f1~Yi <i) q ' '1.1 '1.1

1 1Ltlu n11-E'1 f1111-;uun11f11~-;u:;ii f11~vnnM1 ~nnv:Je:J~f1~~ <il LL~:;~nnv:Je:J~f1~~ m 1in11LLt'l:;1in11L~~L~~11 Lde:JlU~ '1.1'1.1 '1.1'1.1

kJ 't1 n1n!J1f1 ~ kJ <fci<f a-1lXn~1u~11i11rn~"ll,r~~1 ~"lf~u11~-¥u11 tJ~lU-;J1nu1~1~l111 q q q

YnU"lf~l"ll urhJ'~~,Z1~i1~,Z1~1ULL~U~lU n~:U~UU~UU~1UU1V111 11L~u1uuru~U~1 ct :w q q Ql

u 1:;nu ~"ll 111 'W LL 1 ~ ~1U~1~ "151 ~ ~ a-1u n ~1 u ~11i1 1rn~"ll -;)~ Vll ~"15t'IU1L ~L tJ ~ u ru ~ q q q QJ

U ~1U1:;nu~"lJ1l1'W LL 1 ~~1U~l~"151 ~L lrllJ1iU 1 f111L ~ e:J n11L n M~1LL~:; ~VI n1rnn11L n M~1 q

. "' ~1"1Jl"15~lJ1 uru~Lt'l"llri ocfm - kJ - kJO<i)O<i) - ~ ~~LL~tl 'W . f1 . kJcf<ikJ L~"lJ1~~1tJLU

q QJ

a-lu n~1U~11i11nl,~"ll -;)~~r ~"15t'IU1~~ L~ e:J e:Jn f11i~~ <i)<i) ~lkJ cf<i cf ~~ru ~ l!:J rlUtJ1 tJU q q

kJ <f <i <f LL ~ ~ i~ f1 rn:;n 11~ n11 ~e:J u"li m r1 -;u -;u1 ~ 1 u n 1m d f1 rn:;n11~ n1 1~e1 u"li m r1 -;u -;u1 ~ 1~11 tJ~1u~ ~n11~e1u~1u~ e1u1 tJ LL -w'Yl £J ~11i11rn~"ll,r~~r~"15~u1 ~1u1~ fl11 :u11 L~u~1 ~

q q q

uru~U~1U1:;nu~"lJ1l1'W LL1~~1U~1~"151 &i L~"lll ~~1 tJLU~lU 11-t "oJ' rim cf ,<i"o:J kJ 0 cf~ Ul'Yl QJ q

l~tJ'U1~~11tJ1l1'W1 'Yle:J~L~ru ~n~1~-t1f1111 ~1LL~U~owun~1UUru~ d]u~Le:J1L~U~1U1U q Cllqj Cll cu

~~n t=h1LU LLt'l:;ii L ~1~ '1X1 ~~ e:J~-¥u ~ ~~ ~1 tJ f1 U 11~ ~~ ~y:j el~ f1 ~~~ ~~1 tJ LL~:; L ~Uel 1 i '1.1

~nnv:l eJ~ f1~~ <i) LL~~i.Jflrn:;n11~n11~eJuoff m ;1-;u-;u1.J f111 ~-ru ~~'Yll~ ~:; Lii~"ll e:J.J L ~1~'1X1~ '1.1'1.1

l~e:J~l ...

Page 5: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~8 1 i~VI1~"1l't:n~·rt~nf11i~~ <9)klo~/kl<f~\) ~~1-u~ <9)~ n1n!J1~3J kl<f~\) LL~~i~ 0

t.J~ A Q...l.c:::.. A t.J V.c:::l. e:l OQ...I

~ rn n113J n11~81J"IJ 8 L 'Yl \1\11 ~ ~113J11J ~ ~ 'Yl1 ~ ~:; L 3J ~"IJ 8 ~ L \11 VI U 1 'Yl <ll13J1:: L1J tJ 1J ~1 U n

u1 n1~3Ju!ll'111~1 t.JVI~n L nrn"t1n11tl~u~ L ~ t.J1nu ~113J1u ~~'Yl1~ ~::dJ~"IJ 8~ L ~1V1u1~ 0

t.J ~A Q...l,c::::.. A IV liJ.c::t

'Y'l. . kl <f rn ~ ~ rn:: n 113J n 11 ~ 81J "IJ 8 L 'Yl \1 \11 ~ ~ 11 3J 11J ~ ~ 'Yl1 ~ ~:: L 3J ~ "IJ 8 ~ L \11 VI u 1 'Yl

l~1 r.J~1U~~n11~81J~1U~8~rlnYl8~~~~ <9) ~1UL~11 L~U<ll13JUlli~LL1~~1U~1~"1l'1~ 'IJ 'IJ ~ QJ

Uqj r L~"IJ~ o<frn- kJ- kJ0<9)0<9)- ~ Vl1r.JlU\11nUqJ~~1'U1Uo <f.~~o.~\)kJ.<f~ 1J1'Yl

LL~~ ~u1uuru~L~'U,'Yl'U,V13JULlr.JUU<ll1U1~nu~"IJ111'WUlli~L~"IJYl o<frn - <9) - 0<9)0<9)\o:l - ~ Ql q q q Q.l

Vl1t.J U~1U1U ~~<f,ooo 1J1'Yl 113JLUUL~'U, 'o:l,~rn<f,~'o:lkl.<f~ 1J1'Yl 1~r.JU1~~11r.J111'W1 ~

Lllu ""iJnr.J8nL~U~1U1U~~n~11 LL~::~rn~n113Jn11~~n~T~LoV;u11 ~Yl8~~~~ <9) ~8~1u~~ 'IJ

"ll'~1 ""L~u1'lXLLrl'Yl1~11"1l'n11 ~1U1U <9),<9)~~.o~kl.<fkl 1J1'Yl ~1UL~1VIU1~~U~U') Tl~8 113J11J~~"ll'~1"1fL~U1U~1U1ULL<lln~1~nou, l~r.J~YJ8~~~~ kJ ~8~11J~~1WiJ1U1UL~U

'IJ

~<f ,~<9)~.rn~ 1J1'Yl ~Yl8~~~~ rn ~8~1u~~ ~1U1UL~'U, ~klo,kldrn.~~ 1J1'Yl ~W8~~~~ ~ 'IJ 'IJ

~ 8~ .... u ~ ~~1U1UL~ u kl o ~, rn 'o:l rn. ~kl 1J1 'Yl n13J u ru~n ~1~~~1~1u 3J 81J ~1U1\l\11 n QJ

~ rm Yl8 ~ ~ ~ ~ kl 'W \111 rn 1 LL ~ 1 L v; u 11 \11 n 11 tJ ~ 1 u ~ ~ n 11 ~ 81J -iJ m Y1" \11 ~ ~ 113J 1u ~ ~ 'IJ'IJ

0 ... 0

'Yl1~ ~ LiJ~"IJ 8~ L ~1VIU1Yl LL~~\11n'W r.J1UVI ~n~1U ~1UL~11 n1rnun ~L n r.J1-iJ 8~ LL~::~ 8~ ~ ~ 'IJ

1u~~"ll'<ll1i113J <9)0 flu ~~n~Yl8~~~~~~113J8~~1t.J 1<llr.J~Yl8~~~~ <9) ~8~1u~~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

L ~ 8 \11 n L U U ~ <ll11 \1 ~ 81J 1 U n 11i ~ Yl1 L 8 n ~11 L ~ tJ 1 n 1J n 11 rl 8 U L ~ U 1 U off U ~ U rl 8 U ~ 'IJ

U1~ 11 ~111'W1\1~1-b 11Jfl8UL~'U, LtJ1 'lX~rn~n113Jn11fl 8U~U~~U13J 1 U 11Jfl8UL~'U, l~U~U~

~ 13J l n-n 11 ~ 1 r.J L ~ 'U, "IJ 8 ~ 'Yl1 ~ 11 "1l' n 11 ~ rl 1 VI 'U, ~ LL ~:; l ~ ~ 11J ~ 3J ~ LL ~ n 11 U 1i U~ ~ 1 'U, ~ 'IJ ::w

"IJ 8~ 1~ ~11 r.J111'W1 LUUL VI <ll1 'lXu 1~ ~11 tJ n1w1,;h L~U"IJ 8~'Yl1~11"1l'n11Ltl1 iL ~ 8U1~ 1 r.J"n'-J ~ ~ ~

~1'U, ""1u 8 tJ ~-r~ 'Wbj ~n11rufl8L~11 LU'U, n11n1::'Yl11~ r.JU1::3J1'Yl L~UL~ 8 8 ~1~1'1 r.J LL1~ ~ YJ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ <9) ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ 1u ~ ~ "1l' ~ 1 "If fi 1 ~ U l VI 3J 'Yl ~ LL 'Yl U ~ U LL rl 'Yl1 ~ 11 "1l' n 11 <ll1 3J i ~ ~ 1 U 'IJ

LLv;~ · 113J1u~~"ll'8u1un11tll)u~VIU1~LUUL~U~1u1u kl , rno<9) , <9)~d . ~d 1J1'Yl ~W8~~~~ kl

~YJ8~~~~ rn LL~~~YJ8~~~~ ~ 1u~1U::n113Jn11~~~U13J1u11Jfl8UL~U\11nliU1~11 'IJ 'IJ "" 'IJ

iJ1~ i~113J 1~ ~ ~1::1~ <ll13J ~3J ~111 u n11<ll11" ~ 81J L 8 n ~11tl1~ n 811 n11fl8 uL~ U<ll13J ~

11 r.J 111 'Y'l1L ~'U, 8 rl 8 U~ ~ U 13J 1 U 1u rl8 U L~ U 'Y'l bJ ~ n11rnfl8l ~11 L U 'U, n11n1::'Yl11 ~ r.J ~

1 'Yl L~ UL ~ 8 8 ~1~f1 r.JLL 1 ~ ~~ ~ 8 ~11J ~ ~"ll'~ 1 "lffi1 ~'U, l VI 3J'Yl ~ LL 'YlU~ ULL rl'Yl1~11"1l'n11

~ ~1uu v;~ ~113J1u ~ ~"ll'8u 1 un11tll)u~V1u1~ 1~ r.J ~Yl8~~ ~~ kl ~ 8~1u ~ ~"ll'~ 1 i . · · - 'IJ

r~ ·-.wf'

Page 6: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

dJttL3tt G>,dG)c;:i,&<!\>cf.okl lJl'Yl ~~f)>1fl~~ r;n ~eJ>1i'lJ~<11"11<111i LUttL3tt G),c;:icio,\>&<!ci.\>kl lJl'Yl 'IJ

~~f)>1fl~~ ci ~eJ>1i'lJ~<11"11<111"1f LUttL'3tt mc;:iG),cim\>.r;nr;n lJl'Yl ~13J't!£J3J1WJ1 G>O 'IJ '

1 V Q..<le:., V A A 'iJ 'iJ .c:::::l

u1:::n eJ u 3J1 ~11 c;:i Lm>1~1:::11"11u ru ru ~ wn 3J11J C-J<11 'Yl1>1 ~::: L3J <11"ll eJ >1 L "ill~ u 1 'Yl ~. f'l. kl cf m &<! ......

u~:::i.~m1>1 C-J~n11~"il11lli1 f1113Ji'u ~ <11'1'11>1 ~:::L~ <11"ll eJ>1 L ,Y1~1X1~~>1n~111 \K ~rm~ eJ>1f1 ~~ G) 'IJ'IJ

~f) 3J1 i>1 ~ 1 <11 "Jj~ u~i. ~~ ~ '\!>1 ~f) ~>11 \K ~ ~ f)>1 fl ~ ~>1 *'\.tl L'3 'U, i.ui11::: 1 \KLL n ~ 1-i 1 £..1 >11 'U, "lJ f) >11'~ q 'IJ ~

rn ~1't!n>11tt~1TI"11rn~"lli>1~1 <11"11~1J~ n1 £J 1 u m o 1u '\!u LL~1u ~i.~1u~ '\!>1 ~m tlu~u i.tJ q q

LL ~::: l ~ LL,) >1 ~ 1 Wll ~ 1 n ~ ~ fJ >1 fl ~ ~ >1 *"il::: l ~ LL U >1 1 \K f) 'Ylll1 ru fll i >1 ~ fJ ~ rl n ~ fJ >1 fl ~ ~ G> 'IJ q 'IJ 'IJ

111 £J 1 u G) cf 1 u '\!u LL~1 u i.~i'u f11 i>1 <1113J ~1:::11"11u tlJ b!T~iTitJ l)u~·n "11n11'Yl1 >1 tJ n f11eJ >1

~.f'l. klcfm&<! 3J1~11 cici ~~fJ>1f1~~>1*i.~1u~'t!>1~fJ~>1n~T-.ndeJ1tt~ l!Jc;:i ~rltt1£Jtt klcfctd 'IJ .. . .. q

LL~:::l~~'U.fJ'YlTI"1lli1~LLrJ>1 f11i>1 ~ fJ ~rln~ fJ>1 fl~~ G> ~f) 3J1 ~~ fJ>1 fl ~~ m l~~~'\!>1 ~f) ~>11tt ~ q 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

klct 3Jn11f13J klcfctc;:i "lleJ~eJtti11:::L'3tt~1tt1tt G),c;:icto,'<>&<!ct.'<>kl U1'Yl L<11£Ji11:::i.tJLL~1

LUttL'3tt~1'U.1'U.113J~>1~'U. G>,kldo,mcid 1J1'Yl ir>1f1>1L~~m'3u~~~fJ>1fl~~ m "iJ:::~eJ>1i11::: 'IJ

1\KLLn~'\.i1£..1>11'U."lleJ>11~LU'U.~1'U.1ttL'3tt cfdo,mcid.~kl lJl'Yl LL~:::LdeJl'U.~ G>G<! 3Jn11fl3J klcfcic;:i ""

~~fJ>1f1~~ ct i.~'1-t1L'3tt~1tt1tt mc;:iG),cim\>.mm 1J1'Yl i.ui11:::1\KLLrl~1'\!n>11'U.~1TI"11lli~"ll 'IJ q

i>1 ~1<11"11~ lJ~ ~ fJ3J1 tJ ~ <11 n1:::'Yl11>1 ~1TI"11lli~'lJ l~~"il11lli1 fJ'YlTI"1rn"ll fJ>1 ~~ fJ >1 fl ~~>1 *LL~1 q q • q 'IJ

i.~Yi1f1113JL~ttL~tteJ~rln~eJ>1fl~~ m 11 ~~eJ>1f1~~ G) ~~U1~1un11rhnu<11LL~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

n11ul) u~>11tt"ll eJ>1tt 1>1 ~11 ~n1~1 ~L ~ £JU 1ur~ eJttL'3 u LL~::: irn £JeJnLeJ1 L'3 tt'll eJ>1'Yl1>111"11n11lu

LUUL ~~ 1 \Kd1<11 fl~d ~~ eJ>1fl ~~ kl 1 u~1u:::~ eJttaJ~~1 mL~:::n113Jn11~ ~>1u 13J 1 u 1ur~ eJttL'3tt q 'IJ "" 'IJ q 'IJ

"il1nTI"tt1f111 ~~eJ>1f1~~ m LL~:::~~eJ>1fl~~ ct 1u~1tt:::n113Jn11~~>1tt13J1u1ur~eJttL'3tt 'IJ 'IJ "' 'IJ

"ill nTI"tt 1 fl11 ~ eJ>1i'lJ ~ <11"11 f) lJ L tteJ>1 "ill n L <ill~ ,X 1 ~ LL~ ~:::flU i.aJ tJ lJ u~ ~ Ul ~ LL ~::: i.aJ <1111 "iJ ~f)lJ

L f) n ~11~ ~ n ~1 'U.<1113J ~1'1-t l"il ~,X l~"ll f) >1 ~ ""~ ~ f)>1 tJ lJ u~ L U'U. n11U lJ u~ ~,X 1 ~ ~1 £..1 fl113J

U1:::3J1'Yl L~ttL~ eJ eJ ci1>1f1 mL 1>1 Yi11 \K 'Yl1>111"11n11l~i'ufl113J L ~£..1~1 £J ~ eJ>11'u ~ <11"11eJU"11<111 iL'3tt

~13J-;)1u 1u ~ n1:::'Yl11>1n11fl~>1~"il11rn1i it "ilu £J 1<11 £J~1 \K 'Yl L~1n11u>1~ uf1~ L ~ ttfl11£JneJ'YlTI"1rn q q

"ll eJ >1 ~~ fJ>1 f1 ~~>1 * ~ >1 ~rl n~ eJ >1 f1 ~ ~ m ~ "il11llil LL~ 1 L ~ WlffJ u ~1 £J <1113Ji m ~ttfJ ~>1 n ~11 'IJ 'IJ'IJ

LL~:::i:if11 i>11 \K £Jn fJ'YlTI"1ru"lJ fJ>1 ~~ fJ>1 fl~~>1 * i>1'VI1 <11"11~1J~l~ij~ '\!>1 ~f) ~>1l'U. ~ G> ct n1n n1 fl3J q 'IJ q dJ

kl cf~c;:i LL,r>1 C-J~n11~"il11lli1 eJ'YlTI"1rn1 \K~~ eJ>1f1~~>1*'Yl111J q 'IJ

~rln~eJ>1fl~~ G> LL~:::~rln~eJ>1fl~~ m 1\Kn11l~LLU>1fl1~fJ>1"llfJ>1~~fJ>1fl~~ G> 11 'IJ'IJ 'IJ'IJ 'IJ

~~f) >1 fl ~~ G) l<11l \K n f) £..1 fllrllJ fl rn:::n113Jn11~f) u"JJ f) L rl"il"il1>111 ~~ f)>1 fl ~~ G) LU 'U,~ <11 LL~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

Page 7: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

rh lJnTaJ nu~\l1u.ff\.t.~U"ll 8\lU 1\l~11 £..11l1~1 ~\li1-J1~ m~WYlUV! 3JUL l UUU ~11.h~nu ~ ~ ~ ~

~"ll 1~ ~U1\lni111~1 3J1ii.~ £J i1V!U1 ~1 mL~U\l1ULUU~U\l f1uuru"ll'1 ~1wn 8 el1\l~-;h

~ ~

LL~~U ru~ cf. L U U~ ~ LL ~U 1 \l ~11 £..1 1l1 ~1 1\K T111J1n M1 ~11"il ~81J11 £..1 \l1 U 1 UL~8 \l n11L~ U ... 'U'U ~

LL~::u ru ~ ~ \l u 1 \l ~11 £..1 1l1 ~1~ L~ ,r\l '¥11 \l1 u ~ \l1 u n11L~ u LL ~ ,r\l '¥11 \l1 u ~ ~1 £..1 LL ~ U\l1 u ... ~

L3J~L 8n ~11'\Ji tn:nu ~LL~~\l··:h d:Ju 11J~13JoJJ8 el1\l"ll 8\l ~Yl8\lfl~~ ~ ~ 'U

~1w~'un1rn"IJ8\l~Yl8-Jfi~~ k! ~rmYl8-Jfl~~ ~ LL~~~rmYl8-Jfl~~ rn 1lKn11l1 'U 'U'U 'U'U

T11R "ll8-J~nnYl8\lfl~~ ~ LUUT11i-J~ 88n~13JT111ii."UU£J"ll8-Jn13JUru~n~1\l~\lL~1u3J8lJ~1U1"il 'U'U ...

"il 1 n tr n n Yl8 \l f1 ~ ~ k! 1 ~ tJ 1 rJl ~ "il 11 rn 11 U "il u u LL ~ ~ ~ f111 3J L ~ u 1 ~ u "1l' 81J rJl 1 u n !] Vi 3J 1 u 'U'U

~YJ \lfl~~ k! 1 U~1U~n113Jn11~~-JU13J 1 u 1un8UL~U"il1nTIU1f111~L~L"lff1116J1~6J~1~l-J 'U ~ 'U

~13J ~3J fl111 U n11~11"il ~81J L 8 n ~111J1~n 81J n111:1 8UL~ U~13J ~ U 1-J ~11 £..1 Jl1~1L ~U8 ~

n 8 ~ -J u 1 3J 1 u 1u n 8 u L ~ u L tJ '-H Vi ~ 1\K u 1-J ~11 £..1 1l1 ~ 1 tt 1 L ~ u "lJ 8 -J Yl1-J 11 "1J n 11 L 1J 1 i' ~ ~

1~ 1u"1ru~1u~1u 8 u fi{-J ~q~n11rnii 8 1rll11 Ltlun11n1~'¥111~ ul.J1~3J1Yl L~uL~ 8

i' 1 £..1 LL 1 \l ~ -J ~ 8 -J 1u ~ ~ "1J ~ 1 i fi 1 ~ u L Vi 3J Yl ~ LL Yl u ~ u LL n "(11 \l 11 "1J n 11 ~ 1 3J ~ ~ ~ 1 u

uV:-J 113J1u~~ 1un111Jfiu~V~ll'1~ LL~~ 1un11~"il11nn1U"Uu£J8YlTI1rn"ll8-J~nnv:l 8-Jfl~~ rn ~ ~ 'U'U

1m 1 "UutJht.~1U"lJ8\l~v:l8\lfl~~ ~ ~v:l8\lfl~~ kJ ~v:I8-Jfl~~ rn LL~~trv:l8\lfl~~ oc 11 'U 'U 'U 'U

fl11 L ~ £..1 Vi1 tJ LL rl11 "ll'n11fl{\l ttL n ~ -;)1 n L i1 Vi ,X 1 ~ LL ~~~f) u~ ~ L ~ £..1 1aJ1J ~ U~Vi lX i ~ ~13J ~ Yl1-J 1"ll'n11n1V~u~ LL~~13Jl.J~u~V~ll'1~~13Jlb!J~"ll'u VJ'1-8 Li1V~U1~1 u!1u~ L iu J u ~-Jin~ 8-J

l.J~u ~-J LUUn11~~L~ £..1~ 8n111J ~U~V!U1~"1J 8\l ~Urll1 tJ fl113J181Jfl81J LUU-rl8\li11\l1lKL n~ n11 "il1~L~3J1nrl-J ~c!. fl{\l ~Yl8-Jfl~~ ~ 1u~1u~~V!U1~n1nu~LL~n111J~u~-J1U"ll8\l

r 'U .... 'U

u1-J 1£J1l1~1 ~Yl8-Jfl~~ k! 1u~1u~~8u6J~hun~1m~uLL~~n113Jn11~~\lU13J1u1un8uL~u ~ 'U .... 'U~ 'U

U1f111 ~Yl8\lfl~~ rn LL~~~Yl8-Jfl~~ oc 1u~1u~n113Jn11~~\lU13J1u1un8UL~U"il1n 'U . •. 'U "" 'U

11 c/( 8 -J11J ~ ~"ll'8. U L ~8 -J-;)1 n L i1VJ U1~ LL~ ~~~f) f)~ 1aJ1J ~ u~ Vi U1 ~ LL~~LaJ ~11-;) ~81J L8n 1Vi tn !1U~13J eJ1U1"ilV!U1~"ll 8-J~u ~ cll 8-Jl.J~u~ ~ 8 1aJ ~11"il~8u L8n ~111.h~n 8un11

u~ LL~~\ll1~V!d~n~u~"il~~ 8\l ~1 L Uun11~1 u L~ul.J1~n 81JV! tn~1u ~1rll1u 8U6J~ 'U "" ~

L~ULL~1 ~\l~13J1Jn ~Yi'1 Ll.J"IJ 8-J ~ ~-Ju 13J 1 u 1un 8UL~u~ 8\l ~11"il ~81J L 8 n ~11~\ln ~11 'U

Ln m Ul1~V!tt~ 8-J~1 £J"il1-JLL~~~-;)1U 1UL~U~13J 1un8UL~Ub1n~ 8-J~13J3J~V!tt~"U~rJl 8-J~1£JLL~1 'U 'U 'U

~-J"il~ -JU13J1u1un8uL~u V~1nLrll~11"iltif8lJ 1~un111J~u~<1l-Jn~11 LLir"il~L3J~n11~11"il~8u

Page 8: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

.ffu~u "il1n ~u\l f1u uru"ll'1l ~ueJ.ffu~u Lu ~1eJ 1~ ~ n11n kun1eJ \l :JJ1 ri eJUl ~u eJ f1 \lU1 :JJ 'U "'

1 u 1un eJUl~U n"il~YllJl1n11~1 m~u~~\l1~~~d~ eJ\!~1 r.m1eJ L~ Vi'1eJ~~d~ eJ\!~1 tJL Yh 1~ 'Yl11 ~u 1 \l ~11 tl111 Yl 1L~ ~1 :JJ11rl rY n t1 eJ n l f.l1l~ U"ll a \l Yl1 \l11"1l'n11L~ll f1 ~YI1 \l11"1l'n1 1

q

n"il~L~L~1u~11 :JJ l~t1~1 t1 "il1n"ll eJl Yl"il"il1\l~ l~w1n~uru~n1rnddJun11r1 aul~u 1~ t1L~ ~ "'

~ d~ n~U~"il~~ f.l\!~1 t1 ~'1eJlUUn1rn~1 til~ Ul nun11~d ~~ f.l\!~1 tl"il1 \l Yl{l ~n11rn"ll f.l \l 'U

~a Ylll 1 nt ll ~ f1 ~ 11 t~lll u n 1 1 u l) u~ ~ ,X 1 ~ ~ 1 t1 ~ 11 :JJ u 1 ~ :JJ 1 Yll ~ u l ~ a eJ rJ 1 \l f 1 t~ll 1 \l 'U q

Yl11 ~YI1\l11"1l'n11l ~tl ~1 tl ~ eJ\l1lJ ~ ~"ll'~ 1 "lf\lJ Ul~ U~1 :JJ~1U 1Ul~ U ~ n1~YI11\ln11~ ~\l ~"il11rn1i it ';)Q tl 1 U~1U ~ l ~ tl1nlJ n11f.lYill1rn"lJ eJ\l ~w f.l\l ~ ~~ ~ U11n n"ll f.ll Yl"U"U1\ll1

q 'U

~nnwa\l~~~ Ci) 1~u<il\l~YITI"n11Wf.l\l~~~af'!1f1Un~1f.l\l 1~t~ui\ll1~WeJ\l~~~ ~ 'U 'U 'U

~.~~UeJYill1rn111 t11 urh~u~ U~1 ~1n ~w f.l\l~~~ ~ rJ\l L~L~1u u<il\l ~ f1n11Yh11rn1 f.lYili1rn q 'U q

111 tl1 Ul rl1 ~lJlUUlJ u~1u~ ~UeJYill1rn ~w eJ\l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~YITI-~ UfllW f.l\llU UV! U\l ~f) q 'U

~a f'!1 f1 u n ~1f.l\l ~ ~ l "lJ ~ ~1 u 1"il 111 t~1 Ul n1 ~u1 u uu ll~1 u ~u n1V~ u~ l1 f11l n1 ~u1u ~ 1 ~ 1 ~ 1u ll i \l ~ f1 n 1 1 ~ ';) 1 1 rn 1 a Ylli 1 nt ';) 1 n i \l ~ 1 ~ "1l' f11J 1 l ~ a1 'lK f'! 1 f1 ~ Yl1 n 1!1-1 ~ 1 a

q q

lu~ uuuuf1\ll ~n n aufi1 i\l i\l n ~11 ~w f.l\l ~ ~ ~ ~ 1~1u u oil\! ~Y1TI-n11w a\l ~ ~ lrl a1u ~ 'U

rno n1n!J1~:JJ ~<f<tb'lf ~\l~eJ\ll~:JJUtJ1~t1~l1f11~Ufi1Wf.l\l~1:JJ:JJ1~11 <fo 111~~f.l\l ll ~\!Vl1~11"1l'ururu~i~ #\lf11f1un ~1eJ\l LLf1 ::ili~';J11rn1 ~ ~un~1a\l Yl. f1. ~ <f<t~ ~\l"il~~Ju

"' "' n1~U~ln1~u1u1u1u~ kl~ ~f11~:JJ kl<f<ib'lf ~Wf.l\l~~~ ~ ~~YITI"~UWf.l\l~~~a

q 'U

f'!1 f1u n ~1a \!1~ t1 f.l\l 1~ 111 t~1 Ul n1 ~u1 u uu ll~ 1u ~u n1V1 u~ l1 f11 i\l n ~11 ~ a111 t~1 u

1u~ ~'-> :JJn11~:JJ ~<fei:'~ ~Wf.l\l~~~ ~ L~~UW€l\l~~dlrla1u~ Ci)~ nut11t1'U ~<fei:'t<i 'U

n11Wf.l\l~~"llf.l\l~W eJ\l~~~ kl i\ln~11 ~\llUUn1JW f.l-:J~~ lrl a~un1~U~1~tl~b1f11~1:JJ~n!)Vi:JJ1t1 0 d 1 Q,..l Q...l.:. Q,..l ~ n1Vi'U~~1:JJ:JJ1~11 Ci:'G'I llf1~:JJ1~11 <fo 111~~U\l 111~~f.l-:J ll~\lVl1~11"1l'lJllilli~"il~<il\l

"' "'

f11f1un~1a\lllf1~ili~"il1rn1~~un~1a\l Yl. f1. ~ <f~ ~w a\l~~~ ~ 1~ ~~YITI-u 1~~d:JJ1w a-:J 'U

n1rn"lla-:J~Wa\l~~~ rn ~nnwa-:J~~~ Ci) uf1::~nnwa-:J~~~ rn 1\Kn11'11fi1i\l 'U 'li'U 'U'U

"lJ eJ-:J ~ rl n W f.l-:J ~ ~ ~ <il lU ufi1 i\l ~"If fJ lJ ~ 1 t1 n n ~ :JJ1 t1 LLf1 ~1~ L U tllJ LLlJ lJ LL~ U"lJ fJ \l Yl1 \l11"1fn11 'U 'U ~

Yl m.h~n11 1<il tllUUn11eJ a nfi1 i\l<il1 :JJ fi1iit"UQtl"lJ u-:J n1:wuru~nf11\l~\l 1~1u:JJ eJlJ ihu 1"il"il1n q "'

~ rl n w eJ \l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ \l fi 1 i it';) Q tl "lJ f) \l n J :lJ u ru ~ n f11 \l nl ~ n J ~ 'Yl11 ~ tl "1l' f.llJ ~ 1 tl n 1l ~ :lJ 1 tl '1.1 '1.1 "' ~

~\ll~ ~ l ~<il~"il~L ~nrl f.lUfi1 i\l i\ln~11 l~ ~1Un11~"il11n1,1 f.lYlll1rn"lJ f.l\l ~ rlnW eJ\l ~ ~~ r;n q q 'U'U

n lUU Lu1 ~ tl"ll'ulJ ~1m~ <il ~ f1 n n ~ :JJ1 t1 llf1 ~lll u ll11:JJ ll ri ~w f.l\l ~ ~~ rn u ~1 ~1u n1rn ~ q ~ '1.1

3 0 S.f-l.

Page 9: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~ ~ ,H) ~ ~ rn "lJ EJ1lK f11 ~ ttl ~ 1 'U LL ~ ~ fl11 3J 1J n Vd El ~ "lJ El ~ ~ t.h tJ ~ 1 'U "lJ El ~ -r ~ LL ~ ~ ':i ~ 1J 1J ~ ~

t,l t.l I I

n1':i 0

1 L U'U~1'U~1'U ':i13J3J1~n ~1'ULL ~~fl113J-ru ~~ eJ e:Jn~1 mr 'U n':irn itdJ'Un':irnth ,)1WU1Yi

LU'U "'n1~rh~~L~~~ EJ~u 1tJ~1'U"llEJ~-r~~13JaJ1~':il <9)0 LL~~'V'I':i~"lnrruru~ f111aJ.ru~~wn~~~L~ ~ cu al3 QIQI

"llEl~ ~1WU1~ 'V'I.f1. l!l~rn~ ~~LU'Un':irn ~~1-i, 1 tJ~1'U"llEJ~.r~ij~'YlTIL1un 1lKL-;)1~U1~ ~'Y11~~L~~ ~ ~

"lJEJ~ ,)1~U1~1~'1'11n1':i~e:J1J-ffm.Yhr;u1~LL~1 ijf1113JL~'Ul1 ~~e:J~fl~~ rn ~El~-ru~~ LL~~ ~

n':iaJ ""'ru~n~1~~~1~-ruaJEJ1J~1'U1';J';J1n~rm~EJ~f1~~ 1!1 ~';J1':flli1LL~1L~'U11tY~EJ~f1~~ rn v ~~ ~

~ e:J~ 1J ~W15~ 1 -irL~'U~13J f1113JL ~tJ~1 tJ ~ ~'U~ e:J~.ru ~~ 'Yl1~~~L~~ LL~~16J1h1n!J.ff m ;1-;u-;u1 ~11

f111 -ru~~'Yl1~~~L~~"lle:J~L-;)1~U1~ 'V'I.f1. l!l~rn~ ~~16-Jij m~~-;u~~ EJ~~ n~1'ULL~~f1113J.ru~~Ele:Jn ~

~rln~El~fl~~ <9) 1~LL,)~~'YlTin1':i~El~fl~~e:Jf11~Unf1':iEJ~1i~~El~fl~~ rn 'Yl':i11J L~mL-;)~11 ~~ ~

~~ ~ fl ~ ~ rn 1~~ 'U El'Ylli':irnrn tJ 1 'U fll ~ 'U~ LL ~1 ~1n rl~ 16J1~-ru LL-;) ~ ~ ~ n11~ ';J1':flli 1 ~ ~

min tJ 1 'U, ';i~ tJ~ L 1 ~1 L rl1 ~1J1'U U1J LL~l'U, ~ ~ 'UEJ'Ylli':irn ~~ e:J~ f)~~ rn ij~'Yl TI~'Ufl1~ E)~ ~ ~

U ~ ~ El ~ eJ f11 ~ U n fl ':i El ~ ~ ij L "lJ ~ ~ 1 'U 1 ';) 111 tJ 1 'U L n 1 ~ 1J 1 'U U 1J LL ~ Yl 'U rl 1 ~ 'U ~ L 1 ~ 1

ul'1 u1"U~16J1~-ruu-;l~~~n1':i~';J1':frn1EJ'Ylli':irn ~~El~fl~~ rn 1~-ru~tt~*mdEJ1'U~ ~ ~

l!Jb')( n1n!J1f13J l!l~<ib')( ~~~e:J~L~3JU1J':i~tJ~L1~1~'Ufl1~El~~13J3J1~11 ~o 1':i':ifl~El~ LL~~ 1~11"1fururu~-;l~i~f11~unf1':ie:J~LL~~ili~-;u11rn1f1~unf11e:J~ 'V'I.f1. 1!1~<1'1!1 ~~-;u~

v v

f111J 0 1~'U~Ln1~1J1"U1"U1'U~ 1!1~ ~~1f13J l!l~<ib')( ~~e:J~fl~~ rn· ij~'YlTI~'U~El~fl~~e:J

~ ~

f11~ n fl';je:J~.ff'U,~'U, 1~111 tJ 1 'UL rl1 ~1J1'U U1J LL~1'UYl'U fll~'U~ L1 ~1~~n ~11 ~~E)~ f)~~ rn ~

ij~'Yli"~'U~e:J~f1~1~111tJ1'U1'U~ l!lrn 3Jn':i1f13J 1!1~<1'~ ~~El~fl~~ rn 1~~El~fl~d~e:J ~

nfl':ie:J~ Ld EJ1'U ~ ~ ~~1fl3J 1!1 ~<i ~ ~~ LU'Un1':i~ E)~ f)~ Ld E) ~1~ L~ tJ L1~1~13J~ururu~11 ~ v v ...

~':i1"1fururu~-;l ~~~ f11 ~un fl';j"EJ~ LL~~ili~-;u11rn1 f1 ~un fl';j"EJ~ 'V'I. f1. 1!1 ~<tl!l 3-11 ~11 <t~ ......

1 ~o 1':i':ifl~~~ LL~~1':i':ifl~El~ ~~e:J~fl~~ rn 16Jij~'Yli"U1fl~d3J1~El~ ~

n':i~'Yl':i1~ ~1li1':irn~"ll 1~ k~ 1 i ~1 u n ~1 'U~1li1':irn~"ll -;)~~1 ~ ;t 1 u1~ L 'Yl f1 ~ ~

<ii1 L 'U n11 1 fl':i ~ n11u ~1u1~n 'U~"ll 111 'V'I LL 1 ~~1 'U~1 ~ "lf1 ~ ~1 tt n ~1 'U ~1li11rn ~"ll -;)~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~

~1'U ~ ru1~aJ EJU~ 3J1 tJ 1 i~1 mL~'U~1'U<ii1 L U'Un1':i ~ ~n11<ii1 L u"Un1116J'V'Iuuru~1 mJ1~ 1~ ... ...

Page 10: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

(9)0

~1Un.:J1U~11511rn~"lli.:J~l~"lf~U1dJU WU 1 t.l.:J1U ~rt.:~~ 3JaU~3J1 t.l 1lX ~1 t.ILL~U.:J1U~1 L ii un11 ~ ~

~Yla.:Jfl~~ rn L~3J1unu~11"1fn11~~1Un.:J1U~11511fil,~"lJi.:J~l~"lf~U1i.:~LL~U YLf'f. kl<frn~ 'IJ ':cJ ~ ~

naui11fi1-:Jn1w~m1:;nu~"ll111V'm1.:!.:!1U~1-:J"lf1~ 1~tJ~11.:!~1Lm'l-i-:~~1VItt'1~1tJU'1V111.:!1U,t1LU ~

i:J~tt'1~1 un11n1nu~ U~.:J1U 1 U~1 tJU'1~11 113J~.:J.:J1Un11L~ULL~:;uru~ Ld eJi:J1fi1-:Jn11 'IJ ... •

u <;lJU1:;nu~"lJ1l1yj U1-:J.:J1U~1-:J"lf1~1~ tJ ~1 tJ LL~U.:J1UdJ u~ ~1 L Uun11 ~Yl a.:~ fl ~ ~ rn ~ 'IJ 'IJ

~1~-r1 n'Yl1.:~~1af1~f11uu~ a ~1.:~ 1~ ~Yl a.:Jfl ~~ - rn 1~1u 3J au~ 3J1 t.~1lXLiJun11:JJn11~-:J~a 'IJ

iJ,:::{ 0 ~ ~ I Q.,.ol ,d Q..l ~ ~:IJa1U1"ilflaUL.:JU"il1n15U1fi11~-:JLL~1U'Yl rno 15U11fi:IJ kl<fcik! U1.:1~11t.l1l1yj1 'Yla.:JLyjlli 'IJ ~ ...

L~'!.-h L~ u~ n au"il1nu ru~u ~1u1:;nu~"ll1l1yj LL1.:~.:~1u~1-:~"lf1~ 15U1fi11L vl an11L nM~1 ... ~

LL~:;~~n1mn11Ln~~1 ~1"ll1"1f~u1 1u Llluu1dt.~"lfu~hui1~1u1u ~<f fi~.:J LL~ ~:;fi~.:J ~

i:J~1U1UL~UL~h'Yhnu u~:;~U"il1nuru~L~U'YlU~ ~ ~1U1U C9l fl~-:1 1~tJLdJi:JLan~11~tmnu ... ~ ~

n11aU~~1lX~1m~u1lXLLrlh.:JyjtJ1U1~1~ i.:~LL~L~aU:JJn11fi3J kl<fcirn ii.:JlU~ rn Vjr]M1l1f13J ~

kl <fct<f 113J LUUL~U~-:1 iu d, ~rn \> ,ct\> kl. <f~ U1'Yl u~:;L~'tt1L~U:IJ1~ULoll1Ulli~LL1-:J.:J1U ...

~1-:J"lf1~ ~1U1U \> fl~-:1 113JL~u~'tt13J1~U ~o(9),ooo U1'Yl rJ.:JL~~e:JL~U~La1LU~1U1U "' '

\>, ~rn <f, ct\> kl. <fr;s' U1'Yl LL~:;u11n n"JJ ElL rl"il "il'1-:Jl1 1 ULL~ ~:;flf.:~Yi U1.:1~11 ~I11yj1'\t 1L~U"il1n

uru~LL1.:1.:11U~1-:J"lf1~~flaU"il1n15U1fi11LU1i'Lvlau1dtJ"lfU~1Ui1Ju ~Yla.:Jfl~~ rn L~~.:JU13J ... 'IJ

LUUtrrmUL~u1u1UfleJUL~ULL~:;:JJaU~1U1';1 1lXU1-:Jffl1t.l1l1yj1L UU~1u L~ULL 'YlU~1 U 1U dC9l fl~-:1 'IJ ~ 'IJ

tJa~L~U~~11rlU~~.:JU13JfiU~ULL~1 ~1U1U kl,\><iC9l,o<fd.cid U1'Yl LL~:;~YJa.:Jfl~~ rn 'IJ 'IJ

rJ.:JL~~.:JU13JflaUL~U';l1nUru~L~U'YlU~ kl ~13JrlUn113Jn11fiU~U~n C9l fl~-:1 Ly;UL~l1 ... ~

n11~1tJL~u1uuru~LL1-:J.:J1U~1-:J"lf1~ ~~.:~Lan~1VItmnun11Lun~1£.Jfln~a.:~fi1U~1u~:JJu1m ~ ~ ~ ~

LL~:;LdJ i:J L an ~11~ t n~1Un11L un~1 t.l 1 U~1U~LdJ ~ L an ~11~ tn~1U fl rn:;n113J n11 ~ ~

~~ ~1U1"il~.:JU13J 1 U 1un aUL~U"il1n15U1fl11 L~~.:JU13J 1u 1un aUL~U 1~ tJLdJ ~ Lan~11~ t n~1U 'IJ ~

Ltlun11~-:~u 13J 1 u 1un auL~u 1~ tJLdJ i:Jn11~11"iJ~au~ tn~1un au~.:JU13J LUUfi113JUnyj~a.:~ ~

n1rn ~~~a .:1 fl ~~ rn eJ1-:Jl1 n11rl1~ u~ fi113Jfu tl ~J1sna u LdJ L iJ U15113J 'IJ

L~t.l1nUn11flaUL~U"il1nUru~~ kl L~"ll~Uru~ o<frn - C9l - o(9)o(9)\> - ~ 1~tJU1.:1~11t.l1l1yj1 ... ... ~

L~Yl11ULUn113J1utJa~L~U113J rn,klrnrn,d~~ U1'Yl1aULoll1Ulli~ o<frn- kJ- (9)1;1/oci~- ~ ...

Page 11: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

b ... 1.MLL1f1lL~I.'-L't1./

~ ~

~\ t!L't1.L~I1Grt~~11't1.~1't1.8 Uf1\'t1.\ '11t1'1t8U_t!'t1.fJ1reL't1.1.'-~~k ~ ~~~1.'-8 ~_t: 't1._!bl~'t1.l~_!bSl.f1p1-, ~

~ b

Z0 \f1k1.L~ L 't1.!LU Lt! 't1. 8 U ~~ LSl.I.'-L~'t1. U' 1.'-1. 11 8:fU _ct U Lt! 't1. ~1 L !1. 1-MLLl f1lL~ 1.'-L 't1. ~ !.'-!~ ~ ~ ~ 11'11. t ' ' ~

"'~ "'"' ~ L~1.LU~\ UJ ~~~I.'-8~UU_t:~~11 (!) ~~~I.'-8~UU_t: ~ ~~~l.'-8~_t!l.'-8figU11.U't1.l~

~k~t:l1!ftll~!L~1gf1t!L8ftkl.'-~ UJ ~~~1.'-8~~ 't1.~1f1L~UQ11.LU't1.LiU~V1.~ftk L'-!~~~~111L~L'!1llLULt! ' ~

't1. ~1't1.8U1.LU't1.\ L~11M 1.LUrt1.1.U~'I11~1.'-8figl.'- ~(!(!~ 18 ~118~1.LU't1.LI.'-f1 L1.'t1. \ [jUL1.f1~1.'-~(!(!~ 18 ~

't1._!b8 ~1.LU't1. '!J. 1L~f1kL'tl.~t! ~'ti.LI.'-'11.~11 f1 L~~~11 (!) ~ ~~1.'-8 ~_t!l.'-8figl.'-1.~f1 ~1118Sl.~ t:l1! ~ ' '

~

~L,!bV1.'t1.fJ1f1k 8 ~~8~'t1.g. l~~'t1.~1't1.8Uf1\'t1.t rtL't1.1.'-~ UJ ~~~1.'-8 ~_t!8 ~1~~11 't1.~1't1.8Uf1\ '11.\ rtL,I.'-~1.'-~

l ~11'11. ~11 ~~1-LSl.fU £111 ~1.'-_ct_t! ULt!l.'-81-11.!-ftL '11.1.'-~ ~~11 118~ t!l1.~1.LUI11-~k 't1. ~1'11.8 Ul1t 118 ~ ~1-fb .,.

LrtL !1. ~ 't1.L!l:U ~ V1.1.~U81~~11't1. ~1U Q1 11\ft 8,tMLrt 11'11. 11 U Q1G fig~ 't1. ~1 l.'-8figLft ~I.'- ~I.'-~~111.~U81 11~~11 ' ' '

~ b

l ~11 t!L 't1.L ~ ~_t! ULt! ~~ '11.8 11.!-~k 't1. _!bU Q1G fig~ 't1. ~1't1.l 't1.L~L ~1.L~U81 118~t!l1.~ 8 ~ ~_ct ~ '

't1.Sl.mfu~'t1.¥o1 ~_ctgfb~k (s 't1.~8:fu £1'11.\ rtL't1.1.'-~1.LUI1~lf1 ~1't1.jl.1 ~Ufb't1.(J1 ~L,!bV1.~_ctgf1~k f1 Lrt ' '

~ ~

LSl. ru £111 ~ 1.'-_ct_t! ~rt L~'t1. ~'11. ~1.LUrt1.1.UI1~ rt l~ 't1. ~1'11. 8 U 11\ 't1. \ rt L '11.1.'- ~1.LUrt1.1.U 't1.(J 1 ~ 1.'-L~

~ [j ~ "' UJ ~~~l.'-8~_t!~~~11 ftlJ>kLV1.~t:l1.!-ftLl~!l~1~f11.'-~ UJ ~~~l.'-8~_t! 't1.~1't1.8Uf1\'t1.\ftL't1.1.'-~'t1.8~ V1.~rt

I I I 1'\

~ ~

118~t!l1.~['tkf1~1lL~UI.'-~'t1.~1't1.8Uf1\'t1.\ftL't1.1.'-~~k~rtL~~t:l1!1.'-8~ w ~~~l.'-8~_t!~~11 Gil~~~ G~_t: b b b

8 ~ 1.11 ~Sf.~ l V1.1.'- t! fig~'l1.11. L!l L~ 't1. Ll.'- U 't1.L~ 1.'-8 fig[). L 't1. V1.Lt! 1 Ll 't1. V1. 11.11 ~Sf.~ lV1.1.'- t! 't1.l~ 11 8~1- LlU ~ ~ ..,. F=' l"'b 1'1) l"'b o F ,... 111 ' ~ F=' ro l""b

~ ~ ~

lA.LI1 ooo';p~'(>!J 't1.l't1.L~f1kr1LV1.fU~~k '(>!J- (\(!)O(!lo- (!)- w;po ~fig~1 Gil ~8:fU£t't1.\'t1.~111~ rf1~1 b

~ L,!b V1.L~, 1.'-8 fig~ G 1 ~~ 1.'-LlA.~ t: 111-ft Ll~ 1.'-~(!(!~ 18 ~118~1-LU ft1.1.U~'I11 ~ !.'-~ l.'-~,,~k~f1~Sl.~ ' ~

b

1.'-81'11.~ 1.'-8 ri.'t1.fJ1 Lrt 8~~k1.MLL1 f1lL~ I.'-L't1.~~'t1.f1 U1.f1 LfiglA..fl~l1~ \f1 L~fbk lL~ Ul.'-~'11. ~ '

b

'11.~1 L'tl.~kf1 ~ll~'t1.l~_!bSl.f11 ~1.f18 ~ 1Z0\f1k')jo't1.l't1.L~'t1.~1 L'tl.~k1.MLL1f1lL~ I.'-L't1. ~t I.'-L~ I 8 ~11 ' "

~ b b b

~'11. f1 U1.f1 L!T.lA..fl~l111 ~'11. ~ U ~'!jo V1.~~k[S~I1 ~Sf.~ ~V1.1.'-~ fig~'I1.11.L!L L~'t1.LI.'- U_!bL¥ f1 ~ l ~11~Sl.~ lf V1.1.'-~ ~

b

fig~'I1.11.L!lL~'t1.LI.'-U_!bL¥ ~:[o 1}f18: 1Sl.~11 U8 8 ~ 't1.l 't1.L~'t1.~1't1.(J1'!jo 't1.l 't1.L~'t1.~1 L~rt Ll~~k !.'-~(!(!~ 18 ~ ' ~

lA.LI1 ooo';p~'(>!J 't1.l't1.L~~'t1.f1U1.f1LfiglA..fl~l1 ~11~\ f1L~~:[o 1}f18: 1Sl.~11U88 ~k 8 ~V1. 1 ~'t1.~11.'-8fig't1.f~'t1.\ b b ~ I'D

1-L~ L '11.!111~ ~ k !.'-~ U~ ~k~l1 ~Sf.~ ~V1.1.'-~fig~'I1.11.L!lL~'t1.LI.'-U _!b L¥ ~fig k '11.8 ~1 rt L~ 1.'-8 ~ U U 8:fU..,. 1.'-8~ ~ ~ ~ n.

8:rL1£1L~1't1.811-LU~lL~UI.'-~'t1.l't1.L~'t1.~1 't1.~1't1.8Uf1\'t1.trtL't1.1.'-~_t!'t1.fJ1 Gil ~~~l.'-8~_t!~~11 w ~~~1.'- 1 ~_t!

lA.LI1 'f>!JPft.' ' WWCil'w 't1.l't1.L~8:fll£1Ult!U88't1.~1't1.8U1.LU~~ Gil ~8:fll£t't1.t't1.~1 't1._!b1-L~L't1.!UtlA.11 ' ' ~

~t:l1!1.'-8 ~ (s 't1.~~L,!bV1.L~1~~11 w ~~~1.'-8 ~~ ~f1 LV1.f1~1reLl~~8f1't1.fJ1rel1.LrtL !1.1-l~(lk l.'-1. 1 f1~1 ~t:I1!1.'-8~~(!1.~~L't1.!LI.'-8figi.'-8~MU~rtLl~'t1.fJ1 ,lA.LI1 ooo';p~'(>!J 't1.l't1.L~ ~:[o1}f18:1Sl.~111.'-8fig't1. ~'t1.t

~ b

L~'t1.~1 w ~~~l.'-8~_t! lA.LI1 ooo';p~'f>!J 't1.l't1.L~ ~~L~ ~}L~L~'t1.8!;~11~Sl. lA..fl~l1~11~1f1L~

(!)(!)

Page 12: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

U1-:l ~11 t.lll1'V'l'HUU~ru L~ULL YlU-;l1U1U ~ fl~-:1 tJ a~ L~U~'VIl'HlU ~~-:IU1 :lJf"lU~ULL~1 ~ ~ ~

-;l1U1U ~oG),~Hnb'lf.cfo U1Yl "il:::Lv;u1~11 n11~1t.IL~U1UUqJ~LL1-:I-:11U~1-:I"lf1~ ~vY.:JLan~11 'VI~n~1Un11LUn~1 mln~ a.:Jf11Un1U~:lJU1rnLL~:::16J~ Lan ~11'VI ~n~1Un11LUn~1 tJ 1 U~1U ~

aU qJ ClJ at3

16-1~ ban~11'VI ~n~1u f"lrn:::n11:1Jn 11~m ~1u 1"il~.:Ju 1 :JJ 1 u 1un au~u"il1nllU1f111 ~-:~11 :JJvY-:~ .... ~

~~a.:Jf"l~~ ~ ~1tJ 1~~-:JU1:JJ1u1unaub~u1~t.~16J~ban~11'VI~n~1U bUUf111:JJUn'V'l'ia-:~"lla.:J ~ ....

~ ~-:~u1:1J n aub~u ~1-rif111 :JJun'V'l'ia-:~"ll a-:~'VI1-i1 t.1 -:11uu~ a ~1-:~1~ ~1 :JJ'V'l q~n11rn~-:~n ~11 ~

n1:1Juru~n ~1-:~~-:~1~-ru:JJ au ~1U1"il"il1nn1:::Yl11-:Jn11f"l~.:J ~tln~ a.:Jf"l~~ ~ 1U"ilut.~11 ~ ~~

'V'l q~ n11rnri a 1~11 b u un11n1:::Y11L111 tJU1::::JJ1Yl b~ Ub ~a a ~1-:11'1 t.1 u 1-:1 ~~ a-:1 f"l~ ~ ~ ~-:~~a-:~ru~~"lf~ 1 if11~u 1 'VI:JJYl~Lb Ylu~ubbnYl1-:J11"1fn11 ~1:JJ~~~1Ubb ~.:Jf1:11:JJ-ru ~~ 1un11

i.Jfiu~mX1~ ~nn~a.:Jf"l~~ G) 1~bb~.:J~Yllin11~a.:Jf"l~~arn~i.Jnf11a.:J1~~~a-:~f"l~~ ~ Yl11U ~ ~~ ~

1~mb~-:~11~~a-:~f"l~~ ~ 1~~uaYlll1rn.rn t.~1 uih'VIu111u~1 'V11n rT-:~16J1~ru~~n11~"il11rn1 ~ ~

aYlll1rn1l1tJ1U1:::tJ:::b1~1bn1~UlUUUbb~lU~~UaYl1J1rn ~~a.:Jf"l~~ ~ ~~Ylli~u ~ ~ ~

~1~ a.:J bUU'VIU.:J~a~ arn~i.Jnf11a.:J~~ b "ll~ ~1U1"il1l1 t.~1 Ub nl ~u1uuu bb~vrun1'VIU~ b 1 ~1 bn1 ~u1u~16J1~ru bb~-:1 ~~n11~"i111ru.1 aYlll1rn"il1 ni.:J'VIll11"1f~u1 ~1:lJ'V'l1:::11"1fUruru~

q q QIQI

i~~.:Jf11~Unf11a.:Jbb~:::1li~"il11rn1f"l~Unf11a.:J 'V'l.f'l. ~cf~~ :JJ1~11 ~~ ~~a.:Jf"l~~ ~ ~

1~ru'VIu-:~~abda1u~ ~~ n1n!J1f"l:JJ ~cf~b'lf ~-:~~a.:Jb~:JJuu1:::tJ:::b1~1~U~1~a-:~ ~1:JJ:JJ1~11 <fo 111f"l~a-:~ u ~.:J'V'l1:::11"1fururu~i~~.:Jf'l1~i.Jnf11a.:J bb~:::1li~"il11lli1f"l~Unf11a.:J

~ ~

'V'l.f'l. ~cf~kl ~.:J"il:::f11Url1'VIUI1lbn1~u1u1u1u~ ~~ ~~1f"l:JJ ~cfcib'lf ~~a.:Jf"l~~ ~ ~ ~

~~Ylli~u~a-:~f"l~d1~.n1t.~1u1u~ ~ci :JJn11f"l:JJ ~<f~~ bdau11n!J11~~a.:Jf"l~~ ~ 1~~a.:Jf"l~dLda1u~ ~~ ~~1f"l:IJ ~cfci~ ~.:JLUUn11~a.:Jf"l~bda~1-:JL~m1~1~1:JJ~ururu~11

~ ~ ~

1u'V'l1:::11"1fururu~il11~-:!f11~i.Jnf11a.:Jbb~:::1li~"il11rn1f"l~i.Jnf11a.:J 'V'l.f'l. ~<f~~ :JJ1~11 ~~ ~ ~

:IJ1~11 cfo 111f"l'VIrt.:J bb~:::111f"l~a.:J ~~a.:Jf"l~~ ~ 16J~~YlliU1f"l~d:lJ1~a.:J ~1un11~ ~

U1-:1~11tJ.n1'V'l1 Yla.:Jb~ru bb~:::u1-:~~u11m Yla.:Jb~ru 1~r11'VIu-:~~a11"il:::u1b~u-;l1u1u q Ql q Ql

~.oo~.~~b'lf.b'lfG) U1Yl bb~:::-;l1U1U ~~~~~.b'lf~~ U1Yl ~1:lJ~1~U :IJ1"1f~1,rl~,fu, 'VIU.:J~avf-:~~a-:~uuu~-:~n~11L6Ji.J11n 11-li af111:1Jl1 u 1-:1~11 t.~.n1'V'l1 u~:::u1-:~~i.J11m "il:::'it1 b~u

~ ~ ~

-;l1u 1U~.:Jn~11 :1J1i11::: 1 ~bb n~l~ bb~:::~\11 ~ ~1U1"il ~ auru bUUoli a~n~-:1~1:1Jf111:lJ'VI:lJ1 t.1 ~ ~

"ll a-:1 ~ru ru1 i.J1:::ui.J1:::ua :lJ t.1 a :lJ f111 :lJ 'VI u-:1 ~a ~-:In ~11 bUUb an ~11~ b uu~1 b ~ua ~h t.1 b~ tJ1 ~ ~

Page 13: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

... bb~:;~1 "'"ll'rJ aJ1~dl ~<fo u1:;ne:1un U'Y11\Idl"lrn11~\liJL~-rui11:;b1 u~1nu flfl~i'l\l~e:J\Iu@i e:J~1\11~

q

aJ ~VI.n ubn ~~1nf111aJ-ru~~'Y11\I~:;biJ ~"lle:J\I~v:l e:J\Ifl~ ~ ct ~\I~\IL~1:;ru1u~1aJ~ ~v:l e:J\Ifl~~ ct ~ ~ ~

~r~nv:le:J\Ifl~~ kl 1lXn1Yh ~r~nv:le:J\Ifl~~ kl L~lt1b~e:J\Ib~Ue:Jf1rn:;n11aJn11 ~~ ~~

0 o,._... A I Q,..l Q....l Q...IA Q..l A A V V .c=:f.

1 f111 aJ11J ~ ~ 'Y11 \1 bb ~\I ~1 aJ UEJ ~1:;11 "ll'lJ qjqj ~ f111 aJ11J ~ ~ 'Y11 \1 ~:; b aJ ~"11 e:J\1 b ~1VI U 1 'Y1

~. ~. <f rn @'! bL ~:; 1:; b u tJ 1J ~1 ir n '-!, 1 tJ n -r] aJ '-!, ~ '111 ~ 1 tJ VI ~ n b n rn ~ n 1 1 u ll u~ b ~ tJ 1 n lJ

f111 aJ u ~~'Y11\I ~:;biJ~"IJ e:J\1 b -;l1V1 tt'1~ ~. ~ . kl <frn <9'! 1 ~ tJ f1 rn:;n11aJn11~~11rn1 f111 aJ-ru ~~

'Y1i\lbb '\IL~~aJ~1uf1111U1:;"1raJ fl~\1~ kl~/kl<fcid 1u~ klkl baJ~1EJU kl<fcid ~~11nt1bb~1 q

bv;w;h ~v:le:J\Ifl~~ G> ~VIU1~1un11f111Jf1aJ~bb~n1nun11Ufiu~\11U.ffu~u"lle:J\IU1\1~11tlll1~1 ~ q ~ dJ q

1~ mi.lu~ ~11~~e:1u 1 un11i ~'Yl1 be:Jn ~11b~ t11n un11r1 e:Jub1u 1 u.ffu~uri e:Ju ~ u 1\1~11 t1n1~1 ~ q

~:;\t1 Ubl e:JUb1U Lu1\X f1 rn:;n11aJn11bl e:JUb1U~ \IU 1:1J 1 U 1ur~ e:JUb1U l~U DU~ ~1 :1JlTin11

~1 tJ b1U"ll e:J\I'Y11\111"1rn11~ n1VI u~ n ~11 ~ e:J L~ :IJ EJUVI :IJ1 tJ 1\Xu 1\1 ~11 tJ n1~1b iJ u~ti EJ b1 u q ~

Lf1u-r ~1~~~fi ~1n b1U~1n1iU1f1Tm~:;~ e:Ju1 VILU bDn~1 m1u~1n1iU1f11'Hb@i b ~ EJ\H~\~r_n q ~ ~

n11~f tJ b1 u 1lXbb rib -;l1 VI d Vl1 e:J 1lXbb ri VI u 1 tJ \11 u 11 "ll'n11L~ ~1 tJ b iJ u b oli~~ ~ f11 e:J ~ bb@i n ~ u

~1m ub1u~~ 1~EJL~~VI~n~1Un11-ru~1E.Jb1u1\X~11~~e:Ju ~ni'l\1 L~f111Jf1~~bb~ .. q ~

n11u · u~\11Wlle:J\IU1\1~11 EJnTvn 1\Xbi.lu LU~1~1:;bu EJU"lle:J\I'Y11\111"1l'n11 ~\lbUUn11bU~ 1e:Jn1~ q

1\Xu 1 ~11 t1n1 ~1~1 ~11rli-b b1 u-11 e:1 \1 'Y11\111 "ll'n111u1 ib ~ e:1u1:; 1 t~"ll'u ~hu~1 u e:1 t1 fl~\1 q

~bl ~ 11nHi e:J 1~11 b i.lu n11n1:;'Yl11~ tJ u1:; aJ1 'Y1 b ~Ub ~ e:J e:J ~1 \11'1 mb 1\1 ~\I~ e:J\1-ru ~ ~"ll'~ 1 i fi1~u VlaJ'Y1~bmu~Ubbrl'Y11\111"1l'n11~1aJUEJaJ1~11 G)o u1:;ne:JuaJ1~11 ~ bb~\1~1:;11"1l'uqjt1J~

f111aJ u~~'Y11\I~:;dJ~"lle:J\Ib-;)1VIU1~ ~-~- kl<frn<9'! ~1Un1rn"lle:J\I~v:Je:J\If1~~ kl ~v:Je:J\Ifl~~ rn ~ ~

bb ~ :; v:J e:J ·\1 f1 ~ ~ ci 1 u ~ 1 u:; n 11 aJ n 1 1 ~ ~ \1 u 1 aJ 1 u 1u r1 e:J u b 1 u ~ 1 n 1i u 1 f11 1 ~ VI t! 1 ~ ... ~

1 Un1 ~\1'-1,13-J e:J'UdJ~1 U 1ur~ e:JUb1U~1 3-J~'-1,1\1~11 tlfl1~1l~\t1aJ1b~Ue:J ~\11 U~1U:;n11aJn11 q q ""

~~\1 aJ1 u 1ur~ e:Jub1u ~ e:J\11if111aJ1:;dT~1~1\11 un11~11~~e:Ju11n11r1 e:JUb1u hub@i~:;fl~\1 ~

aJ VI~ ~1 Ubb~:; b e:J n ~11~ f111J n1 Ubb ~:; L~ ~1 b u u n11 b ~u e:J aJ1 e:J ~1 \1 r1 n ~ e:J \1 ~1 aJ.ffu~ e:J u "" ~

u~:;1 bU EJU bb~1 ~\IVI1n l~L if111 aJ1:;6J ~1:;l\1~11~~e:JUVI~n~1U 'Y1nf1~\l n~:;~u-li e:J~ ~~~1~ "" q

1 un1 bDn~1 tJ b1uu~:;L~hi.lun11bll~ 1e:Jn1~1lXu1\l ~11 E.Jfl1~1lt1b1U"ll e:J\I'Y11\111"1l'n11Lu1 i q

b iJ '-!, 1:; 1 tJ "1r ,r ~ 1 u i 11 ~ tJ ~ 1 tJ bb ~ :; iJ e:J tJ f1 ~ \1 ~ \1 ti e:J b iJ u n 1 1 ~ :; b ~ tJ 1 '-!, n 1 1 u ll u~ VI t! 1 ~ ~1 aJ D VI aJ1 mb~ :;1:; b u EJU"ll e:J\I'Y11\111"1l'n11 u~ :;iJL~L if111 aJ1:;dT ~1:;1\1 ~1 aJ ~aJ f111 1 un11

/~11~~e:J1J ...

Page 14: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

YHl~nTnl!l~~ u 1~11LU'\-l.n11n1~v111~ u1..h~:JJTYH ~tu~ e1 e1 rJ1.J1'1 ml 1-J ~.JGi u.Jfu ~wn~ 1 i ~1 ~ulvi:JJ'Yl~ ll 'Yl'\-l.~'\-l.ll nrn.J11"1fn11 ;-f._,if ~1 :JJ i~~1'\-l.ll vi.JT111 :JJfu~~ 1 '\-l. n11ul)u~rnt1~ ~1:JJ'L!r.J:JJ1~11 CO)o u1~nu1.J:JJ1~11 c;i Llvi.J~1~11"1fUllHU~T111:JJfu~~'Y11.J~~Lii~ ., .,

"ll u.Jl ~1vn!1~ ~. f1. l!:J cfm ~ ~1~fun11"1f~ 1"1f~1l~r.J~1 r.J"ll u.J l ~1~t!1~~Gi u.Jfu ~~J'\-l. 0 0 0 ~ Q...l A ,Q, C)) C)) ,::::1 1 .::IV Q...l A ,::::1 I Cl,..J

L '\-l.u ._, 111n T111 :JJ11.J t:--J ~ 'Y11.J ~::: L:JJ ~"ll u .J l111 ~ '\-l. 1 'Ylll~ ~ ~T1 '\-l.:JJ ~ m~ru~ T111 :JJ11.J t:--J ~ 'Ylll ~ n ~1-J n '\-l.

l yj uu1~~Y1~.rn~ 1 '\-l.n11u.J ~u 1 in n~:JJ1 u Ll~~T111:JJ u ~Ii11:JJ un l ~1~'1.!1~ ~ Gi u.Jfu ~~ 1~ dJ ~ ~

"lf~ 1 "1f~1L ~ u ~1 u u rl1.J Lu '\-l. Ii11:JJ ~ ~ u ~ 11 '\-l.u 1~ 1 u"lfu"ll u.J 'Y11.J 11 "1fn11~ 11 ~ 1 Gifu"1111~ ~if 1~ u :JJ1 ~1n11U.J ~1.J'Y11.JUnT11u.J T1 ru~n11:JJn11~1111ru 1 T111 :JJfu ~ ~'Y11.J ll ~ .J LGi~1111ru 1

i~ ~1 '\-l.T111 :JJfu ~ ~ 1 ~ u ~h U.J ii .J i~ ~1 '\-l."ll e1 .J n11~ ~1 '\-l.l ~ u1off e1 .J 1 '\-l.ll~ ~ ~Ii1n11:JJ ll ~ 1 ~

~ ._, 1 '\-l.ll~ ~~Ii1n11:JJ 11~ utl.J i~ ~1'\-l.T111 :JJfu ~ ~ e1 e1 n ~1 :JJ ~ ~ n;n '\-l. ~ l ~1 ~ '1.!1~ u~ ~:::T1'\-l. ~ ~

1~il ~1'\-l.l ~ u1off u.J ~1~fuli1n11:JJ 1~~1~ l ~ u1off u.J n11 ~1~1-t 1 :JJ1 n1 ~ '\-l.~ Lu '\-l.T111 :JJfu ~ ~ ~

~1~fu L~1~t!1~T1'\-l. ,f '\-l. ll~~~n~1'\-l. 1'\-l.l~'\-l. ~'\-l.1.J~11 r.J1l1~1L~"lf~ 1 "lfll~1 e1 un~1'\-l.Vtrt.J~1 u ~

~~ u.JT1~~ C9) ~~~1'\-l.f111 in11'Yl1'\-l.u.Jl~ u1nuf11~ u.J ~

~~u.JT1~~ l!:J ~~~1'\-l.f111'\Xn1111 ~~u.JT1~~ l!:J 1~LT1mL~.JGi1u11111nu ~ ~

'j,j, 1£.1 ll ~'Yl rJ ~1Ii11lli~"lli.J~1 ~ ll~~~1~ U1 ~h £.1 llt:--JU.J1Ull~~U1~ liiUt:--J ~ ll~111 T111Gl u.JU l)u~

~1:JJ1~ l u £.1 1.J 1 ~ £.11 i u 1l~UU ~1U1:::n U~"ll1l1 ~ ll 1-J .J1U~1.J"lf1 ~ l "1Y11:::1.J1.J"ll f) .J.J1U n11l~ u ~

ll ~ ~u ru ~ ~ .J lU u 1~1.J 1.J :JJ1 ~1~1 UT111.J T1 dJ l~'\..b~.J n ~11 ii1 i~1 L ~ ~ ll ~ ~ l n ~ n11'Y1111~ Ql GtS q q

n1rnn11ln~ l ~~ l~U~lli~1 £.1 U1li £.1~ ~n l rtu.J:JJ1111n WUU~1U1~nU~"ll1l1~ ll1.J.J1U~1.J"lf1~ ~ ~ ., ~

lU U.J1U ~1l~:JJ 1 ~ ~v111 i1~1.J 1J n11~h l U U.J1UrJ.J L~f~ n :JJ ll~~1~1.J un11<ll1l u U.J1 U"ll u .J ~

~1U11"1fn11L~ul)u~ ~1:JJ1:::lu £.11.J ll1.J1.Jllt:--JU"llu.J'Y11.J11"1fn11~ rl1~U~ L 1 ~~,f u n1rn~.Jn~11

~u.J~uuru"lf1 1~1~i.Jn11 rJ u:JJ~ e1 1~11~1~U1~1u11"1fn11 Ll~~~1 mLt:--JU.J1ULL~:::u1~Liit-H-J~ ~ .,

Gi u.Jfu ~ ~"lfu u l ~ ~ n11m~ l n ~.:ff u 111n n11~ T1 ru~n11:JJ n11~uuoff u l -Yl11111.J 1Gi ~u u ~1 u ~

u1.J.rl'Y111~1 :JJ1u~ rf u~~u1.J'i.Jri11 ~1u"lf~ 1 "ll ~._,;-f._,~u.J u u:JJfu11Luu ~1~'1.!1~1 mlt:--JU.J1u ~ ~

ll~~U1~ l iiut:--J ~ ~~ U1 ~ T111J T1 dJ rl1 n 1J ~ ll~ .J1 u 1 U~1 £.1 ll~ :::.J1 u ~i.~1u dJ f) 1.J ~ :JJ1 £.1111n ~ ~

u 1 u ll ~'Yl rf ~1Ii11lli~"lli.J~1 ~~ lUU.J1U1l~:JJ 1 ~~ ~ u.J1uu ~1U1~nu~"ll1l1~ ll 1.J.J1U~1.J"lf1 ~ ~ ~

u T1 T1 ~;-f._, ~f)._, 1~ dJ e1 u ~ :JJ1 u .J1 uu ~1u1::: n u ~"ll .n1 ~ ll 1 ._, .J1 u~1._, "1f1 ~1 i ~~ e1 ._, T1 ~ ~ C9) ~ ~ ~

~ .J LU u off 111 "1f n 11 ~ ~ L1 e1 u ~1 ~ ru <ll1Ll ~ ,;,._, L ~ 1 Vi u 1 ~ i l T1 11 ~ ~ u 1 u u 1 u Ll ~ ~ ll t:--J u \) .,

.. ,

Page 15: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

LL~ l~ lJ f) lJ VI :IJ1 tJ 1lK 'U, 1 >'] ~11 tJ fl1 'V'l1 ~1 LL VI U>'l ~ n-;l1 >'li1 f1111 dj 'U~\J 1i u~ >'11 'U, n11L~ 'U, ~ 'IJ 'IJ ~

LL ~ U ru ~"ll f)>'J >'11 'UU ~1ll1:: n 'U ~"ll fl1 'V'l LL 1 >'1 >'11 'U~1 >'1 "151 ~ ~ >'1>'11 'U n11L~ 'ULL~:: U ru ~"ll fJ >'1 ... ~ ...

>'11 u-~1lh::n'U~"lln1'V'lLL1>'1>'11'U~1>'1"151~ d'J'U>"J1'U~~1f1'ru LL~::~r.Jf)~L~'UL-ih~uru~ q Q,l cu QJ

"' LlJ -;)1 'U 1 'U VI ~1 tJ ~ 1 'U 1J1 i1 f111 LL ~ >'1 ~ \1"1l111 "15n 11 ~1 LL VI U\1 U ni "151 n 11n11 L~ 'ULL ~ ::u ru ~ ... d i.J d Q,..l ~ Q..J.d. Q.;~ A O Q...l I

'1l' \1 f111 :IJ 1 f111 :IJ ~1 :IJ 11 r1 L n tJ 1 n u n 11 L \1 ""LL ~:: u ru "15 :IJ 11u c...~ ~ "15 eJ u L \1 ""~ 1 ""1 ""~ \1 n ~ 11 'IJ ...

LL~ 1 tJ LL 'V'l i1 U ~11l11rn~"ll ~\IV\ 1 ~"15~u11 'U"ll rn::J 'U LL~::i1 wJ 1 e:J1 tJ LLt-.I'U\11'ULL~::lh:: dJ'Ut-.1 ~ ~ ~

n ~ :IJ f) lJ VI lJ1 tJ ilK 'U, 1\1 ~11 tJ fl1'V'l1~ \1 L iJ 'U,~ n-;l1 \l-t1 f111111J ~ ~ "lJf) lJ LL~ ::ll5 U~\11 'U,L ~ r.J1 n lJ ~ 'IJ

n11 ~'ULL~ ::u lli~"ll fJ\1 \11'UU ~1ll1::n 'U~"ll fl1 'V'l LL 1 >'1 \11'U~1\1"151 ~ ~\I ,_f 'U i1 VI U 1 e:J1 r.JLLt-.1 'U\11 'U . ... ~

LL~:: 1:: L ii'Ut-.~ ~~:;~f) >'1 f111J f1 :IJ n1 n lJ ~ LL~ ~11~ ~f) lJ n111.lfiu~ \11 'U"ll f) \I~ n ,)1 \l-t1 f1111 ~ 'IJ ~ 'IJ

~\I ~11 f) ~1 \1 ~ f)L ~f)>'] LL ~:; 1 n ~~~ L 'V'l11:; ~llfi u~ VI U1 ~~\In ~11 L iJ 'U,~ n-;l1 \l-t1 f1111 'IJ ~ 'IJ

0 0 "'

eJ'UL~ 'UU~i r.JL ~r.J\11lKL11 ~LVI~ n11rn i1 ~1~ L n r.J1nlJ n11L~'U 11lJYl>'l i1 VI U 1 ~1'U 11"15n11 ~ ~

.c:!:l fi' Q,..l Q,..l i.J OQJ I~ ~ f1 eJ 1 tJ u 'V'l'Yl tJ ~1li11rn~"ll ~\IV\ 1 ~ ~:: ~ eJ \1 ~11 ~ ~eJ un1 n u ~ LL ~ eJ r.J1 \1 ~:IJ1 L ~:IJ eJ L 'UeJ\1 ~1 n

~ 'IJ

1 'U ~1 L ~ :IJ 1 VI 3J LL ~:; L ~ tJ 1 "1] f) \1 n lJ L~ 'U-;) 1 'U 1 'U :IJ 1 n U:; ,_f 'U n 1 rn L~ 'U-;) 1 'U 1 'U ~ \1 n ~ 11

~ru 1 r.JLll ~\1Ln~"il1nn11irn tJ eJn"ll eJ>'l'U1\I ~11 r.Jfl1'V'l1 L ~eJ\1:1J1~1nn11~::L~ r.Jn11llfiu~ 'IJ ... ~ ~

VI u1~"ll eJ\1 i1 VI u1 ~1'U 11 "1Jn11 ~ eJ ""1 tJ LL 'V'l i1 u ~1li11rn~"ll i-.:J 'VI1 ~ "15~ u1 LL ~ ::i1 VI u 1 e:J1 tJ ~ ~

LL t-.1 >'11 'U, LL ~ :; D1:; L ij 'U, t-.1 ~ 1 'U, "lJ rn:; ,f 'U, n 11ll5 u~ \11 'U, "lJ f) >'] ~oW f) \1 f1 ~ ~ 1!:1 i. 3J i. ~ ~ :; L ~ tJ

1"" n 1ll5 u~V\ u1~ ~1 :IJ n!! VI :IJ1 r.JLL ~ ::1::L ii tJ U"ll eJ \1 i11 \111"15n11 LL~i.~1 "11'f111lJ1:: ~ ~1::1\1 ~11 ~eJu L eJn ~111h::n eJun11r1 eJ'UL~'U i'lnfl~\1~1 :IJ~'U 1\1 ~11 r.Jfl1'V'l1L~'UeJ

~ ~

~oW f) \If)~~ rn fl~~1'Uf111lKn1Y:h LbiJn1::'Yl11\1~1li11rn~"ll~::nTVI'U~'U 1r.JlJ1 tJ 'IJ ~

1lK ~~ ,r n >'11 'U,~11l11rn~"ll i\1 VI 1 ~ tt 1 u 1:: b i1 f'l ~1 bit 'U, n111 f11 \1 n11U ~1U1:: n 'U, ~"ll fl1 'V'l I q q

bb1\l 1\.1,~1\1"151~ V\1n bb~ iil~n1VI'U~'U 1 r.JlJ1 r.Jl1~::~eJ\11lKe:J1 tJ bbt-.I'U\11'Ubb~::l.]1::bii'Ut-.~~

b lJ"" "'1u ~ ~ "15 eJ u ~ 1 bit"" n 111 f11 \1 n 11 ~ \1 n ~ 11 vf \1 VI :IJ ~ 11 :IJ vf \11"" ~1 """lJ eJ \1 n 11u1 VI 11

i ~n 1~1'Un11b~'U~1 tJ LL~ Lll'Un111 i~~~it~"ll eJ >"J ~~VI u 1~1'u ~~"IJeJu~~::~ eJ>"Jl.lfiu~\11'U ~ 'IJ ~

~1lJ 1r.Ju1 tJ ~ eJ ~1Un\11'U~1li11rn~"lli-.:Jw1~tt1ll1::b i'lf'l ~\I Lbir ~1un\11'U~1li11rn~"lli-.:JVI1 ~ ~ ~

~1 'U, VI ru :IJ f) lJ VI :IJ 1 tJ 1lK e:J 1 tJ LL t-.1 'U, \11 'U, LL ~:; D1:; L ij 'U, t-.1 ~ b iJ 'U, ~ 1u ~ ~ "15 f) lJ lJ 1 VI 11 i ~ n 11 ... 'IJ

LL ~:; 3J 'V'llJ U ill V\1 L ori'UL ~ r.J1 n lJ ~1 U n \11 'U ~1li11nt~"ll i\1 VI l ~ "15~ u1 n iii.~ VI :IJ1 tJ f111 :1Jl1 ... q ~

~:; Yl 1lK n11:1J f) lJ VI :IJ1 tJ 1lK e:J1 tJ bL t-.I'U\11 'UbL ~:; U 1:: L ij 'Ut-.1 ~ b lJ 'U~1u ~ ~ "15 f) lJ U1'VI 11i ~ n11 'IJ

L ~ r.J1 ..... u L~ ""1 ""1 f11 \ln11~\l n ~11 n ~1 tJ L U'U 1::u 1J\11'U ~ r1 n ~ eJ\1 ~1 :IJ1:: LU r.JlJ11"15n11;J'U:IJ1 i.~ 'IJ

Page 16: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

nTl"U'1V111~1U, 1 U,~';mdn1~Yl1~1 r.Jfl11 :JJVI ~~VI ~1:JJ 13-J n1~1J1Jn11~11-;u ~eJ1JVI1e:rU eJ~nu, n11Yl"il'1~ 1~ ') LYl11~~tJ1iu~~1t.J,13J nfi11:JJff111:JJ~1:JJ11tt1t-1,~1r.J~lt.l,~U~U~ ~~f)~ f)~~ rn

, 'UdJ 'U 'U

1~Lfl un ~1Tnnri1~ LL~~f) ~f11u, 1~uun11tJ ~u~~1u,~~n ~11~ eJ ~u~f1uu~"lf1 LLtf1~1 r.J11"il1

fll r.JVI t~~1~11Jn11LL~~ ~~ 1 ~L U t-1, n11:JJ n11~ ~ ~u, 1 :JJi1 :JJ 1 u,ni1tt flt.J,L~ U, LL~ L rteJ~"il1 n 'U

~~ eJ~fl~~ rn ii1~Luu,n11:JJn11 1 t.J,fl rn~n11:JJn11~1'u~~"lfeJ1J 1fl1~n11U~1U1~nu,~"JJ111Yl 'U 'U ,

LL 1 .J .J 1 t-1, ~ 1 .J "1f 1 ~ LL ~ ~ iJ 1 ~ n VI U 1 ~ VI 1 eJ ~ 1 t-1, i 1 :JJ 1 t-1, n 1 1 tJ 1 ~ "1f :JJ 1 t-1, 1 fl 1 .J n 1 1 ~ .J n ~ 11 , ~ .J 1 3J eJ 1 "il fl ~ f1'1 U, VI 1 eJ rl n rl 1-J 1 t-1, ~ tJ 1 ~ "1f :JJ 1 ~ tJ 11 n n VI t n ~1 U, 1 ~ tJ 1 ~ n eJ 1J n 1J 1 t-1, n 1 rn d

, dJ ~

LUt.J,fhi.J"J.JeJ.J~U.Jf11Juru"lf1:JJeJ1JVI:JJ1r.J1~~~fl~fl~~ rn i1:JJ~.Jt.J,1:JJ1t.J,11JtteJt.l,L~t.l,rl1J 'U ~ 'U

n11:JJn11~u, 5u,iJ1·Mh &~~i ~ ~ eJ n{JVI :JJ1 r.JV11eJ ~~1l11:JJ e)u,~"JJ eJ.JU1~"1f1"1ft.~, ~~ eJ.J fl~~ rn

1 u,!lu,~~1~u.Jf1uu~"lf1 tJ eJ:JJ~ eJ.JtJ~u~~1:JJ~1i.J 1~ uii m"i!VI ~n L~ r.J.J 1~ 1 U, tJ 1 ~ L ~ U, ~ n ~ 11 eJ 1 .J 'Jl ~ ~ eJ ~ fl ~ ~ rn 1 ~ ~ ~ U, 1 :JJ 1 U, 1u tl eJ U, L ~ U, LL ~ ~

'U

:JJeJ1J ~1t-~,1"il1 ~t-~,1-J ~11 r.Jfl1Yl1LUt-~,~1uL~t.~,LLYlt-~,~1t.~, 1t.~, drs) fl~~ 1~ r.J 1 t-~,~1t.~,"JJ eJ~n11LUn~1 r.J , 'U

~13-J n VI 1 eJ 13-J tJ 11 n!) L eJ n ~1 1 VI t n !1 t-1, ~ eJ 11 fl rn~ n 11 :JJ n 1 1~ ~ .J t-1, 1 :JJ 1 t-1, 1u tl eJ t-1, L ~ t-1,

~.Jt.J,l:JJ 1~ u13Jnn11~11"il ~eJUVI tn~1u,n eJt-1, LUU,f111:JJUnYlieJ.J"JJ eJ.J~~.Jt-1,1:JJ 1 u, 1un eJt.J,L~u, tf u, ~ 'U

L U t-1, n 1 1 n ~ 11 eJ 1-J ~ iJ 1 ri( ~"ill 1 rn 1 n .J fill :JJ L ~ r.J 1i eJ .J 1 t-1, n 11 tJ ~ U~ .J 1 U, ~ 1 :JJ VI U 1 ~ "1J eJ .J

~~f) .J fl ~ ~ rn ~ n n lJ .J1 t-1, 1 fl1 .J n11U ~1U1~n t.J,~"JJ 111 Yl ~.J 13-J L u t.l,1l11:JJ LL ri ~~f) .J fl ~ ~ rn 'U , 'U

L Yl11 ~VI1 n ~ "il11rn 1 ii ._, n11 1 ~ t1 eJ u ~1"JJ eJ .Jt.~, 1-J ~11 u 111 Yl1 ~ n1~'Yl1 fl11 :JJ ~ ~ 1 u, ~1 u, 1 u, , 'U

n11~eJ1J ~1u,i eJ L Yl"il"il'1.J~1~u111 W'lJ rn~~ll11un eJt.J,L~t.J,:JJ1 L ~u,f) 1 ~ n11:JJn11~n ~1u, 1"il , 'U

~.Jt.~, 1 :JJ 1~ll1 L eJ n ~11~ L ~ r.J1 nu n11 L U n tt flt.J,L~t.~, 1 u, 1fl1 ~n11U ~1U1~nu,~"J.Jfl1Yl LL t-~,1Jrl1 r.J , :JJ1 L yj eJ 1 ~ n 11 :JJ n1 1 L i 11 "il11 L U t-1, L ~ eJ .J L ~ r.J 1 n U, tJ eJ :JJ LL ~~ .J 1 ~LV: t-1, 11 t-1, l.J ~11 r.J fl1 Yl 1 , 1~U1VI t n ~1t.!,~t.l,:JJ1U1~n f)lJ L yj f) ~1-J 1 ~ n11:JJn11L i11"il11 n fl11 :JJ L ~ r.Jli eJ.JrllJ 1u tl f)t.l,L~t-1, ....

' ... ' Yi L~fl:JJ1 n1rnL"1Ju,i(, "il~LV:u, 1~11 t.l,1.J~1r.Jfl1Yl1n L"il~t.l,1Yi"il~Yl11~ n11:JJn11~ ~.Jt.J,1:JJLi1 h~~

, 'U

~ .J tf t-1, ~ ~ eJ .J fl ~ ~ rn ~ .J 13-J n ~ 1 t-1, 1 "il VI U 1 ~VI 1 eJ n ~1 U, L ~ r.J 1i eJ .J 1 t-1, n 11 u1 VI 11 ~ 1 U, 'U

Vl1eJ tJ ~ u~ .J1 t-1, 1~ ') 1 t-1, 1 fl 1 ._, n11U ~1U1~n t.J,~"JJ fl1 Yl Vl1 f) L ~ r.Jli f) .J L u t.J,fl rn~ n 11 :JJ n1 1 , ~n ~1t-1,1"iJVIu1~fi11Jfi:JJ~ LL~n11tJ 1iu~1 u, 1fi1.Jn11 tJ f) :JJ13J eJ1"i!Yl11u1~11 LeJn~11~ LL u,u :JJ1

, 'U dJ "' I I I

LUt.l,LYl"il Vl1eJttnll1:JJ1LLfllJeJ1.J ~.JUt.!, n11Yi~~fl.Jfi~Yi rn ~.Jt-1,1:JJ1u,1utteJ1..bL~t-1,~1:JJYi 'U 'U

~1 r.J LLt:-Jt.J,.J1t.J,LL~~U1~LiJt.~,t:-J ~ L~t.J,fl:JJ1 ~1 :JJ.fft-1,~ flt.J, 1~ r.J~"il11fil,1"il1nVI tn~lt-1,~ LL t.J,lJ :JJ1 ....

Page 17: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

.. "lA. 'tt11Ll/ F'""

't1.Q 1 ~~ 1L~ L 't1.!l't1.L~Ll _tl ML~ 1 ~8 IT.~ 111 r1 L}~ L~ 8 8 ~ 1'11. ~ 1 lA. Ll1 ::!1f111 Lt~'t1.Q 1::! ~11 ~~

~ t: ~qA.::!1Ll1Lll 't1.Q 1118 ~ ~L~ 8 t~ 8~8 (; r1 L~ 11_y '11.8 (; ls1. 1 ffl8~8 (; r1 L~::!~11 !! L 't1. L~

1 L u1111 u u L (! 11_y L ~ n ~ 11 L u u re l r1 ~ 1 11 ~ 1 11 ~ 1 11 L t ~ 8 ~ n r1 ~r: 11 L u u n t 1 u G 1 11 t ~~ u ~

~~'t1.t1 r1 L~1Lll~~ls1. '11.8 (;~1 ~~ f1l Ll8 8 ~!& 1}r1~ 1~~11::!'111-Ft Ll~'t1. t~fu11't1. t 't1.t1 r1 L~1L~L't1.!l~1Lll "~ ~ 't1. t 1 't1. Q 1 't1. 8 L111 L ~ 't1. !l L !A 1 't1. 81 ~ ~.¥- t;: (! 't1. t 1 r1 L ~ 1 L Ll, L ~ ~ l 't1. t 1 't1. 8 L1 Ll G 1 1 L Lll1l! t r1 ~ 1

COl ~~fu 11 ~ f1 1 ::!'111 IT.'t1. ~ l h;:t~ ~.ru~.U.~ !--ls-1. ~ ~ IT.~'tt11L!lL~ 't1. L~Ll _tl L~ ~8 IT.~~ L~ 11 L~ rr.1J 8·~1 "' b

~ t: qA::!1Ll1~H Ll 11Llljt11Llls1.~::!~111~H Ll 11Lll8 ~ 11L~L 't1.!l~1Lll 8 ~ COl ~~ffi11't1. t ~~!! ll1Lll ' ' '

"' b ~ h! 1~ t L~~~~ ~L~ 8 ru ~ L~ ~ 1s1. 1 L~;:~11 n~1 ::!1f1¥o tffl ~~ 1 VL~ 8 ffl8~1s1.Jl't1.r1 L11r1 Lrr.lA.jft~l1

n. b b

11_y 't1. ~ Llt-;1 1}\s-1. U::!!! ~ !--ls-1. ~~IT.~ 'tt11L!l L~ 't1. L~ Ll _tl L~ ~8 IT.M. Lll IT.~ 't1.l!::!1f11~ 111Lll ~ 1~ 1 't1. L~ ... b

't1._tl::!'t}::!L1M 1 ~81'11.~8 (; r1 L~r1 t~~~ ls1.r1 Lll't1. t 11Lt~8 ~11~1't1.r1 (!: 1 LI11MLL1r1 tL~ ~L 't1. ~~!!!!~ 18 ~ ...

11 L~ ~~ Jl'tt r1 L11lA._tt~l111l! ~ t ~!& 1}r1 ~ 1 .U.~11 Ll8 8 8~\s-1. 't1. t1't1. 8 ~ls-1. trt::!11LllU L~[j Ll L~ fb ffl

't1. _tl 't1. t 1 't1. 8 L111 t 't1. t 11 L 't1. ~ ~::! '111 IT. 't1. t ~ 11 ~11 g f1 ~ ~ 't1. .Q. m fu ~ 't1. ¥o 1 ~ ~ ~ Ll f111 L ~ r1 L 11\s-1. h 8 11 ... b .,

11! ~ l ~ ~ L ,!\ ls1. (! L 't1. L ~ 11 L ~ r1 L ~ Ll G 1 ~_ce 't1. 81 L Ll 't1. L.!l: Ll ~ ls1.;: ~ 11 1 L~ Ll8 1 118 ~ (! t 1 ~ ~ 8 )p 1118 ~

n. tn ~~~~8 ~~U11Ll n_ytr1 ~1 11t1 't1.t1 ~8 r1't1. tr1 L~Ll[}11Lll't1.Q1L~l!t L~ 11Llli111Ll~ t 1L

1M. Lll ~ tL~ ~L 't1. ~ ~ 't1.~1L~ Ll8 1 ~ 1A.I1 t1 't1. 8'11. rt. 11 ~ L~ 8 't1.t1't1.8 L111t 11_y 118}M. LI11Lll.Q.L ' ' ...

b "' ~ 8 rr.11r1!} 1 ::!111 L~ ~l r1 L~ u G 11LllU~ t~_cen 81L~ Ll8 1 ~1A.I1 tt ~8~ ~ lA~ru 11 L~ 1't1.t1n 8

... ... ., n.

11_y~8 ~tr1 ~1~'t1.L~Ll~ls1.1L~Ll8111't1. 11 ~8~118~ ~'t1.¥o 1~~'t1.t't1.L~'t1.t1't1.8 L111t 11L't1.~~8't1.~11tll't1.t n. n.

~~l!l!~18~r3~l COl ~~~~8~~11l!'t1.t1't1.8L111t't1.ti1L't1.~~11t$- tn ~~~~8~~~~ lA.LI1 _ooo' ;D~ b

't1.t't1.L~ ~_yL~ ~}L~L)p't1.8.(g~I1~.Q. lA._tt~l1~.m~tr1L~~!r-1}r1~1.Q.~11L~::!~11 lA.LI1 C\~;p'p c\ ~'Ul

"' "' b 11t1 ~L.Q.~L~'t1.L~~111~ffi11 P- ~O~OCO\- COl- tn;po ~ffi_.Cb::!~11 ~~1::!11~1111~11t~J ::!~11

n_y~81Jg't1.~~8rr.~fu11 ~- P;DOJU'~- COl- tn;po ~fu11L~1't1.811LllUr1~llA.LI1 ~pfU''tn ~Ul ' tn b "' "'

11t1~8r1't1.t1Ll[}111t L~~l1M.Lllr1tL~~L't1.~~ ~ - C\ ~o~o - ~ - tn;po ~ffi,.[b~IT.~1 COl ~~fllj.[1'ttt n.n. n.n. l-

't1.t1~t:I1!11Lt~l1l!tr1~1~'t1.q~nt~L~tL~Ll tn ~~~~8~Lll1~::!~11 ~ ~~~~8~Lll1~~1Lllrt~

~ tL$-~r1 ~l't1.t1't1.t't1.L~I18~l!t1~~~11t1LI111't1. 11~'t1.LKLl~ls1.~l!t1~~11~r1 ~ 1~11~V~ 1Lll~1~l (j

b n. ~8 IT.'t1.L~~11"" f11Lll't1. t ~8 ~tr1 ~1't1.t~U~l~~~ls1. 1::!L1M 1 ~lA.Ll~ t~11'11.~~8 !}1'11. ti18.U.~t: 11!,.. ~8 rr.

I I .... l"l

8~8 (; r1 L~ [j u L1f18't1.~1 L 11.~1L~ Ll8 1 ffl8~1s1. 't1.~Ll~~ls1.U ~t lA.l11::!1f1r1 L~Ll[}11LllU ~t ::!l 'tl. t n. n.

L~'t1.L~'t1.U1L~1Lll~8IT.~r1~1::!~r1L1~~}~t~l!L8(1ltn ~~~~8~~::!L1M1 't1.8~'t1.lf-11L~I1 .Q.~ ' " ' b n. b n.

't1.t1't1.8 L1Ll[}11Lll't1.Q1 L~l!t ~~l!~r1 ~18~ 1 tn ~~~~8 ~~~ t ~ls-1. 1't1.Q1 118 ~ t~11 ~8~Lll1~ ~ 8

JU'~

Page 18: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

n1ru ~VI~ 1 th'll\-ti n ~ a-:I'W ~h'l1a" 1 ~'D\-t 1f111"1f~ 1 if\1 ~~r.JVI1 r.J ii1 "Jif11VI\-t~ 1 ~ ~.;.q a" f1 ~~ m 'U

~~~:; ~ ~1 VI ,X 1 ~ f1 \-t~ \-t~ a" ~11u ~~"If~ 1 if\1 ~ ~r.J Vl1 r.J L~ i'l\-t'D\-t 1 f111 ~1V11Un11 1 i~ ~~it "il ~

L~~:;f11iit"ilur.J"1J a"~ rml4 a" f1~~ kl ,f \-t iiL~'ll1off m Yl"il"il1" ~ ~ r.J1nu ~1\-t1"il VI u1~ ~~~:;f111 ~ 'U'U

1u ~~"If a U"lJ a"~ ~1VI ,X 1~ ~~~ ~ :;f)\-t ~ L ~ r.J1off a" 1 \-t n11U ~ u~ "1\-t~1 U1:; n au n11~ "il11nl. 1 t.l I I t,.l

n1VI\-t~ f111 ~1u ~ ~ ~n-0'" iiL~LlJ\-t LU ~1 ~ ~ "il ~\-t 11~ru"lJ a"n lJ VI ~1 r.Jfi di r.J1off a" 1 \-tn1rn it ~a vn:;11"1fururu~ f111 ~1u ~ ~ i11" ~:; ~ii ~"lJ a"~ ~1VI 1X1 ~ YU'I. kl cfm ~ ~"';):;~ a"'ll1 ~1 ~ U\-t

"' "' VI Gln 1 \-tn11~"il11rn1n1VI \-t~f111 ~1u~ ~"lJ a"~ ~1VIU1~ ~U\-t~1T1ru Vl1 n u~ ~tl nl4 a" f1 ~~ kl

"' 'U'U

iit"Uur.Jn1VI\-t~f111 ~1u ~~ 1 ~L~ n ~.;.q a"f1~~ m u~:; ~ ~1VIU1~ f1\-t~\-t ') 1~ r.J~"il11nl.1"il1n 'U

~1\-t1\-tf1~" u~:;~1\-t 1\-t~~\-t ~ L~~ ~:;u f1f1~ L~ ~"\-t 1 ~ 1 \-t 1un a\-t~~\-t 1 \-t~~~ ~:;f1~" 1~ mXu ~U\-t ~

n11rl1 'D1n11~ 1 \-t~l ~ ~:; f1~" m~ ~" \-t 1 ~ ~1 n f1~" L~~:; ~ ~1 'U, 1 \-t L~ \-t 1 \-t 1 U tl a \-t~~ \-t ~1 \-t 1 \-t ~" ~ 'U 'U

n ~a" 1 u ~ ~"If~ 1-tl \-t ~ 1 \-t 1 \-t ~ ~ \-t ~ ~" L3J ~ n 11 L u ~ r.J f111 ~ 1 u ~ ~ 1 ~ r.J n 11 'll1 off a ~ fl "il "U1" 'U

1 \-t f111 ~ ~ ~ r.J 1 off a ""lJ a " VI U 1 ~ 1 \-t n 11 U ~ U~ "1 \-t "lJ a " ~ ~ 1 VI U 1 ~ ~~ ~ ~ :; f1 \-t ~ -:1 VI ~ 1 r.J n " ~U-:1 T1uu ru "lf1"1J a-:1\-t 1" ~11 r.J 1l1'V'l1~" 1 \-t 1:; ~ u ~ \-tLL ~:;1:; ~ u ~ ",r \-t~1 ~-:I~ VI U1 ~1 ~ r.J ~1" 'U "' ~ 'U

1 \-tn11n1nu~ ~L~ ~~~:;1u ~ ~"lfa11 1 \-t~ ~n11u 1lu~"1\-t"lJ a"\-t1"~1 r.J n1'V'l1~1u1:;n aun11~ "il11rn 1 'U ~ ~

~1V1111n11d\-t l4 a"~ elf'f1~Unf11a" ~tlnl4 a"f1~~ m l~~f11&" l ~ r.J1n11n11~"il11nl.1 ai'l'D1ru 'U 'U ~

"1Ja"~~a"f1~~ m ~da1\-t~ r9J~ n1nn1f1~ klcf~" 1~r.J~"il11ni.TJ1 L~1VIU1~~~~r.J1offa"i'lnf1\-t 'U d) ~

u~u~"1\-t~1 r.J f111 ~u1:;~1r1 ~~\-t~~ a a r.h"1'1 r.J ~~1" rh 1 ~i11"11"1fn11L~111 f111 ~ ~ ~r.JVI1 r.J

~ a-:~111 ~~"If~ 1 i~~ \-t~1 ~ ~ n1:;r111 "n11f1 Gl"~ "il11rn 1i it "il u r.J ~~ ~ :;1:;11 11 Vl1 n ~a i1 'D1ru ~ 'U ~

L3J L v; \-t~1 r.Jn11 fl1lit"UUr.J ai'l'D1ru"lJ a "1~~\-t~111 n11n1:;i111" ~1'D11nl.~"lJ ~~~:;~off a 1~~~rr" ~ ~ ~

1 ~d \-t f1 1l4 a"~ U \-t VI U" ~a~ a ~1 ~ U n f11 a"~~~ "lJ ~ ~ 1 \-t 1 "il1l1 r.J 1 \-t ~ n 1 ~U 1 \-t U 11 ~~ ~ 1 \-t ~ L~1UVIU"~a ~l4a"f1~~ m L~d\-tl4a"f1~d<i1a~1~Unf11a".ff\-t~\-t1\-t1\-t~ cf ~mf1~ klcf~Q'

'U ~

l4a""lJa-:~~l4a"f1~~ m ~"L3J"1J1~a1r.Jf111~ \-tan"il1nd n11~~.;.qa"f1~~ m L~"lf~1i~~\-t 'U ~ 'U

1 ~L~nVI~ 1 r.J"1\-t"lJ a-:11~111"~1\-t 'V'l1a~~" "lJ a~ a\-ti11:;VId1~ r.J"lJ a"~~~~ amrl' r.J,f \-t iiL~LU\-t ~

n11r.J a ~1u11 f11i it "ilU r.J ~~ ~ :;f11 &-:~"lJ a-:1 ~ tl nl4 a" f1 ~ ~" ~1 ~"If au~ 1 r.J n n VI ~1 r.J ~l~ a ci1" 1~ 'U'U d)

Vl1 n u ~ ~ u \-t L 'V'l11:; ~VI~ ~ n 1" 11 in rJl a" 1u 1111:; ~ an~ if r.J 1 \-t a \-t 1 f1 ~ ~ ""lJ a "If~ 1 i u 1" ~1 \-t ~

~~~:;"lJ a"~~ an ~if r.J 1 \-t 1:;VIl1"n11~ a\-t"lf11:;

~.;.q a"f1~~ ~ T1 ~fl1\-tfl1L ~ n1111 11 r.J"1\-t~ ~n11~a11~1\-t"1J a"f1rn:;n11~n11 'U

tl ~ A CV d IV CV .d QJ A 0 CV

~a11"lJaLi'l"il"il1" ~1~11\-ti'ln"1Jaf111~~"1\-ti1 kl'-' 'D\-t11f1~ klcf~cf ~n\-tn1VI\-t~L1~1 ~cf 1\-t

Page 19: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

0 ~ ~ 0 Q...i' I Q.,.l V ~ .A Q...l Q....l

t;~1 :JJ f11 ~ ._') LL t;J._'j t;J._'j f1 rn~n')'):JJ n1')~81J"ll 8 L 'Yl ';J ';)') ._') t;J._'l"U u n1')~81J ~1 U"ll 8._'1 f1 rn~ n')'):JJ n1')

~8 ~1u"lle:J L Yl';J-;u1._'1~._') La.l"ll'81J L ~')1~Vi :JJ t;~ 811-t 1-;uVJ t!1~ LL~1 LL~~n1')LL~._'l i._'jfl rn~n')'):JJn1') ~e:Ju v m Y]-;u-;)1._'1 L ~ 8Vi1~1u ~t;J'Yl1._'1 ~~ Lilt;~"ll e:J._'j L ~1Vi t!1~lt;~ t.1 mf1t.1 ~ ~n1')~81J ~1u"ll8 L ;1-;u-;u1._'1

'\J

i._'jn ~11 ~._') 1a.J"ll' 8u ~1 t.~n n Vi :JJ1 m -riu nu ')1 :JJvf._'j ,h1 u-;uut.~"lJ e:J.J ~tln~ 8._'1 fl ~,.f._') ~1 :JJ~1 '\X dJ '\J'\J

~~ .Jfl~~ ~ "lft;J1iL~'U~1'1-t1'1-t rn~(9).~rn~.rnrn 1J1'Yllt;Jt.le:J1f1tJ~~n1')~81J~1U"llmfl-;u';J1.J '\J

Vi1 1u ~ t;~'Yl1._'1 ~~Lilt;~ i._'j n ci11 ~ ._') La.l "ll' e:JU ~1 f.Jn lJ VJ:JJ1 t.1 ~1 t.1 t;~1 :JJ')1 tJ-nu n1')~81J ~1 1-t

';J-;u1.J ~ t.l1'1-t1Jflfl~~L ~ tJ1off8.Jn1Jn1')LUn~1 tJ L11-tlh~n'U~"ll111~ LL ')._'1._'11'U~1.J"ll'1~'Yln flU , , , ~1._'1 urTu~8 t;~ f1 ~ 8 .Jn 1-t 11 1~ t;l')1 ';) ~e:Ju L e:J n ~1')U')~n e:JUn1')~._'l"U 1 :JJ L u n ~1 tJ L1ui._'jn ci11

l1 ij r1 n ~ 8 ._'1 fl')1J tl1 'U 'Yl n U ')~n1') fl.J ij LL~ 'U 1._'1 ~11 tJ 111 ~')~ .J 1 '\X n1')l ll u.ff"U ~81J ~1 'U '\J , q

"118 L · ';) -;u1._'111La.l ii L e:J n ~1')U')~n 81J 1u r18 1-t L1 u ~ ._') 1-t 1._'1 ~11 tJ 111 ~ ')L iJ u~n')~Yl1 f111 :JJ ~ t;~ q '\J

f111"' n1')"1J 8._'1'\.t1._'1 ~11 tJ111~')~._'1L~iiJ1V!Un1u.W._'lL~ i._')Ju off m Y]-;u-;u1._'li._'jn ci11~._'1 La.l 81';1 q

1u .J L~11 ~~ 8-J fl~~ cs:: l~ ~ ._'l'U 1 :JJ tl8UL1 1-t 1 t;~ tJ ilLt;~l if111 :JJ')~3J t;~')~l._'l t;~1 :JJ ~:JJf11') 1 1-tn1') '\J

t;~')1 L8n~1')U')~ne:Jun1')tle:J"UL1u tY~8.Jfl~~ ~ La.lL~U1~:JJ1'YlL~ULci88~1._'lf1tJLL').J '\J

~1u 1')~~r1n~8.Jfl~,.f.J~:JJiif11lU';JUt.~1'iX~~e:J.Jf1~~ ~ "ll't;~1iL1u~1U1U rn~(9).~rn~.rnrn U1'Yl '\J'\J '\J

0 0 a...- ,d:l Q V d A A Q

t;11:JJV!'U.J~8 'Yl nfl o~o~/rn(9)l!:l<frn fH1'U'Yl (9)(9) ~tlf'f';Jn1tJ'U l!:l<f~~ "llfl.J')e:J.J81J1Jt;J

n'):JJ ""'ru~n~1.J 1m~1')1"lfn11LL'YlU8liu~n'):JJUru~nm.J 1u-ri8.Jfl~.J~ l!:l<f 1u~ l!:lkl ~.JV!1fl:JJ ~ ~

l!:l<f rn 1'\Xtr~e:J._'jfl~~ ~ 1u~t;J~1'U1'U l!:l~.~~o.(j)~ 1J1'YlJ'I-t 1u1u~ 1!:11!:1 ~._'1Vi1f1:JJ l!:l<f~rn '\J

~~ .Jfl ~~ ~ rJ.J La.lL~1u :lJ 81J 1 'iXLiJUn')'):JJn1')~.J'U 1dJ 1 '\,\, 1ur1e:J"UL1ULL~~La.ll~ ~.J ~1 tJ n 8~8 '\J

L U n r1 8 'U L 1 'U 1 'U l 'U i .J n ~ 11 LL ~ 8 ~ 1 ._'1 1 t;J Ll ~ ~ n 1 ') ~ '1-t 1 .J ~ 11 tJ 11 1 ~ ') Yl1 Vi U ._'1 ~ fll1 q

L1U~1'U1'U ~.oo~.~~d.dC9l 1J1'Yl dJ1"ll't;~hfl'\XLL~~'U1._'l~U')1rn 'Yle:J.JL~ru l~Yl1V!U._'l~8 q ~

v 0

f11u ~nUU1.J~11tJ111~') lt;~tJ';J~tbL1u kl.~~~.d~~ 1J1'Yl :JJ1"1f1')~111tJ1u1wY1 rno q

1 f1 dJ 1!:1 <f cs:: <f J 1-t il1 -rif11 L ~'I-t 8 ~1m~ tn L ~')1 ~~1u n.J1 u~11l1')lli~"ll ~.J V~1 t;J"lf~ u1 , q

nn ci11 ~'U8.J11JLU LL~1 ~.J'I-t 1 tJ LL ~'Yl u ~11J1')lli~"ll~._'lV!l t;~"ll'~ u1LL~~ ~r1 nv:l8.J fl ~~ 1!:1 q q '\J '\J

n l t;J ij fl11 :lJ L V: '1-t 1 '\X~ 8 ._'1 f 8 .J ~ 1 L U 'U fl ~ n 1J '1-t 1 .J ~ 11 tJ 11 1 ~ ') LL ~ ~ '1-t 1 .J ~ U ') 1 rn i .J J 'U q q

Lrl 8 1.J~11 tJ 111~')LL~~'U1.J ~U')1 rnL~rh iruru1t;~n ~.J L ~ e:J')~.Juoffe:J~~1'Yl~~ 1-J ~11 tJ111~') q q QIQI q

rJntJe:JnL1ULUlt;JtJ';J~,;h:JJ1"1f1')~1VJL'Ul'U~ rno n')nl)1fl:JJ l!:l<f~<f eJULiJUnl')~e:JUtru

1 'iXLL 0

nu ti 8l~l1 LiJ"U;llilli1U1~UU')~t\,f)dJ tJ 8:lJfl11 :lJ :IJ~wtr~t\,1._'1 ~11 tJ111~')rJn tJ 8nL1u LU Q.l Ql 1\J q

Page 20: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

.. ·n 1.'-lA./ I=' ..... ... ...

n. n.

I I ,· )~~ v :>A~ t, -@>

lr ' -_.,_,f.< >,=-"-- -~ ~ ~· ~ t' '" ~ ·- \.h --.~~· '~~~~~~~

L 'IU 1 L t! ~ )f> ~ Ul ~ ~ ~ !.'- l! ~ U L1 ,t1 ~ N: L ~ 't1. ~:: ~ ~ 11 !.'- l! IT. tl.l ~ ~ ~ N: L ~ tl.lA. 11 ~ lA. N: ¥1. ~ 't1. ~ L ~ Z0 t ~ .Q". n. b n.n.

~L'-~~~L'-l!~,t1Jtt ft"~~Ul 't1.rJL't1.L1~ ~Ul ~'t1.~L'-~l!~L'-_!t¥1.'t1.fJ1L'-~L~~L'-~ ® ~~~L'-l!~UL1,t1 I ,... ' I I I

n.n. n.n. 11L1lA. ® ~ ~~1.'-l! ~UL1 ,t1 J1. t L 'IU1Lt! ~1 LU ~ 1'-:1 !.'-~ 11:: ~11 L 'IU1Lt!~ ~~ Ul ~ ~ ~ !.'- l! ~ U L1 ,t1 l! ~ 1:: ~ 11

' ' ' n. n. l L .~ U !.'-..... ~ 11 rJ ,G 1::1 !.'- l! IT. fC" ® l! ,.rr. N: L ~ fl ~ G ~ L 'IU ~ L t! ~ Ul .~ ~ ~ !.'-@ ~ U L1 ,.1'-:1 ,.¥1- t !.'- l! ~ 1 l! tl.~ 1,.~ ~

n.n. l~11 ~ ~1 ::~ 1.'-LlA. ~ t: 11kN: Ll~ 1.'-~t! t!!J 1@ ~11G~~LU~ l':lti.LL'-rJ L~11k~~ ® ~ ~ ~ 1.'-l! ~U L1,t1 G ~ 1 ::~11

;:."> w~ Ul . ~. tv1. ~L,l1 ¥1. L~ 1 !.'-@fT.~~ 1 ::~ !.'- LlA. ~ t: 11kN: Ll~ 11l!lr3 ~ 1 ~lb gfl~LU }b'tll U 1 U ~ ¥1. rJ l~ L~ ~ n.

~~ti.N:~kU rJ L 't1. U _ttL~ 11rJ ~ 1 ::~1.'-l! fT. ~ @ ~re L~~ t ~.[.!.'- G )f>tl. _tt ,t1 ~ '!1. lA. 11 ~ lA.N: ¥1. ~ '!1.~ L~tl.l ti.L~::~ 11 ... '

n. ~ 1'-:111 ~ !.'- l! ~ 1'-:111 U l rJ U 1 '!1. ¥1.1 N: L l ~ l! tl.~ 1 L 'IU ~ L t! tv1. l! tv1. 1 ~ N: 1:: ~ !.'- L lA. ~ 1'-:111~ N: L l ~ !.'- ~ t! t! lA. 1 G fT. ~ J""'' f1olfl l"'tt ,r=r ~ '10' f' '10' '10' """D "=' ::;:3 f1o

. n.n. n

11G~~LUN:11U::'IU~L'-~L'-~11~~ ® ~~~L'-G~UL1,t1lA.LI1 ~~-Ul<\~·~w;:.o>'<\ tl.lti.L~fl~~nllb~Lrr.~ ... ' '

b

't1.t1G ~¥1. 1 !.'-~ lA.LI1 ooo' ®o;:.o> 't1.l't1.L~ti.IJ1 !.'-~ ¥1-rJ Llttl. ttl.~fo t ~.Q".LN:'ltt1L ');t~~~tv1.Lltl1lL~L'-L't1.::~11

lA.LI1 ~~. Ul <\~' <\ w~ 'JC" ti.~L'-~fl~ ti.G L1~'t1.~1't1.l't1.L~ l~'t1.l~)t.Q".r31 ::~fbG ~ 1~tfl~ L'-k~ ® ..... l"l I I ft.

b b b n

tl.l 't1. L~ tv1. Llt fT.~tl.l!::~fl~~ ....,11't1.rJ ~ 1'!1. N: ¥1. tl.lA. '!1.~1 &m lbU Lt!:: ~11 !.'-k~ ~ ~ tl.l ti.L~~ L.Q".L'-L~ ...

b n b

't1. LL'- !.'-~ 11 tv1. Llt fT.~ 't1.l!::1f1~~ ..... 11& m lb U Lt! 't1. t1 't1. G L1 ~~ ~ L.Q".L'- L~tl. LL'- !.'-~ 11 tv1. Llt fT.~ tl.l!::~ fl~~ lb n b

~LU !.'-~~ 1 '!1. t 't1. t1 rJ L~11k~LU::~11~m lb 11l!l rJ ~ 1'!1.LL'-L~J1. t rJ LN: ¥1.11 G N: 11k~~ !.'-~ ~11 ~.[.~ ~ ¥1. !.'-~ b (j b b b

fT.~'IU~L!L L~ 't1. U U _!l L~ 'ltLL'-tl.t-:1 11 rJ L~ ~ '!1. LL'- ~lb., f1 tv1. Llt fT.~tl.l!::~fl~ ~ lbtl. rJ ~ 1't1. N: ¥1. '!1. lA. 't1. t1 lb lbro b

rJl~L'-Lt! .Q".nll1't1.LL'-U't1.tv1.L'-'t1.\s1.11L~ lL~~l.Q".L'-Lt!U~ nltv1.1L'-GlA. ~tv1.Lltl1lL~L'-L't1.lA.~LUULt!~U1 ft. ft. J=' 1"11 f"'b I 0 7 f"ff ~ f' '10'

n. ~ ~ ~ N:U~ ~ L~ '!1. ~ 1 l~11J1-::L~~ 1 ~ N:~~!L'ltfJ 1:: ~11N:~::Lre ¥1.1 ::t!L'-~ ~t Lyt 1't1.l ti.L~ 'ltfJ1 [t~ G~¥1.

... ~ t: 11kL'-G ~~ !.'-~~ ~ 1.'-G ~F rJ LN: ¥1. (J UrJ l~ 11 G.Q".[t~ U L¥1. [t~ l!~¥1. rJ LN: ¥1. (J U rJ l ~ 11 l!.Q".~L'-~ L~ti.IJ 1

1 ..... I I

n.n. b n.n. w ~~ ~ !.'- G ~UL1 ~ 1.'-G fT.jll~!LlA.G f"J,!' l!Uh1LU ~1'-:1 ::~11 l~11 L 'IU~Lt!~ Ul ~~ ~!.'-@ ~UL1~ ~~ t: 11k

' ' ' ~ n. n.n.

N: Ll~'lt l~ ~~ N: L~ ~kL'-G fT.ti.LL'-rJ l )b \s1.~11J1. t 't1. t1Z0 t ~.[.~ !.'-~ ~ ~ !.'-@ ~,t1 J\ t !.'-~ ~ - ® ~~ ~ 1.'-l! ~UL1,t1 I !"& I I I

1.'-GfT.L'-~L~ L~rJ ,!!l!UhL'-l! )f>::l!~'t1.~1::~f1~ ~~ L~'lt ~ 1l~11L'IU~Lt!~'lt~'l1.Eo!.'-l!1~Uf1~L~ ' ' ...

b

HlA.l ~L'-1l~'t1.~ ~¥1. 1 ~::~11 n. b b

n 1W L}ftVL~ G 11_!th~t:L~::1U ~ ~~ ~1.'-G ~,t1 L~ tl.~ m.o-.::~f1~::~11 _p. '!1.~~~1 ~~ ¥1. 1'!111U't1. t n. b b

~ ~~~L'-G~,t1r3_!thL'-LlA.HlA.F~L'-~L~Jtl~!LlA.l!L'IU~Lt!~~ ~11~.[.~~¥1.1.'-~ ·tvt·u·G ~N:N:L~ ' ' ' n.

't1.l!~1U~lL~UL~Jtt::~11 1> ~~~L'-G~,t1r3_!thL'-LlA.HlA.l~L'- ;:."J'l>~Ul N:~Ll'ltlL ~® ~ti.~L'-~ b n.

;:.'l'l>~Ul/~;:.'lft"Ul ~L'-~L~~~~~I1~.Q".~~¥1.L'-~ L~rJl~N:~1N:~1L'-t!11~ ~ ~~~L'-G~,t1 I I I l"l I

UG1LU.Q".L~rJ l 't1. ¥1.U11't1.L'-1 ::1L.Q". J:::1 I I '10' 0

n. n n

~ t: 11kL'-l! ~ re~ !.'-~ ~ ~~ ~L'-G ~,t1 re Lt..~ reG rare l!n::~f1u::~f1Lmm~ re L~ft 1s1, tU¥1-~ ~, f1~11l::~L'-~ ' ...

OU[

Page 21: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

tf._'l <ill~"lJeJ CiJ~ "llfJ._'I1~Llh.Ju"1Jl._'I~U l~Ul~ll ~rlnWfJ._'I~~~ CiJ l~~llitUnl1<ill~.ffU<ileJU 'IJ'IJ

"ll eJ n !J VI ~l ml~~1~ ~ u r.JU 1 u~~eJ._'jdu~1 I I I \.1 I

nuruVIl~ eJ._'J'W-;n1rnl~ eJ 1tl1l nl1Yi~rmw eJ._'j~~Yi (i) n f1l~._'I1.X~w eJ._'j~~vr._'l~ v 'IJ'IJ 'IJ

"15<il ~ ifil~ULVI~i'l<illLi'lU<ill~i<il~1UYl,~t1n~eJ._'j~~~ l£J L~oW-;Jl1rnltfu dJULU<ill~ _I 'IJ 'IJ

~l<ilrl (9)0 ~~~~~l<il1l ~ uv;._'I'W1~1l~UqJ~~~1l~1u~<il'Yll._'l~~~il<i!"lJeJ._'j~~l~iXl~ -w.ft. kl~rn~ ~~~1VI1r/bJ ~~Ull ~tlnWeJ._'I~~Yl CiJ <ill~~1l~~~U"lJeJ,H.ft1n~eJ.J~~Yl l£J l~nf1l~._'l1i I 'IJ'IJ 'IJ'IJ

~ ~ .J ~ ~ rf .J ~ "15 <i!1 "If fl l ~ U l VI ~ i'l <il ~~ i'l U ~it eJ .J -;J l n l ~ n 1 ~ Yll ~ ~ ~ ij ~ 1 <il £J tJ 1 ~ ~ l i'l ~ ~ U ~ ~ eJ 'IJ

eJ Ul._'l{l tJL~1._'11 Unl1tll)u~VIiXl~"lJ f) ._'I ~l~ ~~~u n~l1~ eJ ~w eJ.J~~~ (i) ~l ~~ VIU._'I ~ ~lVIiXl~ ll ~ l ~lfu 1 £J 1Jl £J lL ~~ ~~~ u \) i1VI Ul ~1 u nl1~11J ~ ~ ~ ~~~ rh n 1J nl1U nu~.J lu.ffuiu

q 'IJ ;;w

"lJ eJ u l._'l ~l1 £J 1ll 'W 1 1 ~ m tJ u ~ <il 1 1-;) ~ eJ 1J 1 u n l 1-;) <il Yll ~ eJ n ~l 1 ~ ~ £J 1 n 1J n l 1 t1 eJ u ~ ~ u q 'IJ

1 u"15uiuri eJu ~u l.J ~l1 £J1ll'W1-;J~ul1ut1 eJu~~u 1tl1 i ~ rn~n11~nl1t1 eJU~~u~.Ju l ~1 u q

1u t1 eJ U~~ U l~ tJ n U~ <ill ~llinl 1"iil £J ~~ U"lJ eJ .J i'll.J1l"15nl1~ rll VI U~ lL ~ ~ l~ ~11J ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ;;w q 'IJ

nu~.JlU"ll eJ.JUl.J ~l1 £J 1ll'W1 ~ iJu~ VI <i!1.Xu l.J ~l1 £J1ll'W1U l ~~U"ll eJ.Ji'll.J1l"15nl1Ltl1 i ;;w q q q

1d£J"15t-h~·1ui1ueJ£J~f._'l ff1u~WeJ.J~~~ k1 ~WeJ.J~~~ rn ~~~~~WeJ._'I~~~ ci 1u~lu~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ""

n11 nl1~~.JUl~1 u 1ut1 eJu~~U-;Jln1iUl~l1 i11~1i~1l~1~ir~1~l.J <ill~~~~11 1 unl1 'IJ

<il11 ~eJU~eJn~l1U1~neJunl1t1eJu~~u<ill~~ul._'l~1 £J1ll'W1~~ueJri eJUnl1~.Jul~ 1u 1ut1eJu~~ u q

lUu Vl<i!1.Xu l.J~l1 £J1ll"W1Ul ~~U"ll fJ._'Ii'll._'l1l"15nl1Ltl1 il ~ eJtl1~ 1£J"15'i!ff1Ui1ll eJ r.J~f.J q q

~ ~ eJ .J ~ ~ rf .J ~1 i ~~ tf ._'Ill n 1 ~ n 1 ~ tll 1 <il £J tl 1 ~ ~ l i'l ~ ~ u ~ ~· eJ eJ ti l.J f l £J ~~ 1 .J 'IJ

~ .J <il EJ.J iii-;) u £J 1 u~ if eJ .J ~uri eJ u 1l ~~ eJ ._'! ~ ~rf.J ~L~n1~'Yll ~ ~ ~ D ~ 1 <il £J tl1~ ~l i'l ~ ~u~ ~ eJ 'IJ

eJ Ul fl m~ 1 .J 1 u nl1tll) u~ VI Ul ~ Vl1eJ 11l -w ~ ~1l~ ~~~~ 1 ~ ~ u ll ~~ eJ.J ~ ~ ~ (i) 1-x rl' eJ £J f1l

j.J ~ A Ve::., A 1 'i,l ~ A e::.,Q...I

~eJ "ll m i'l-;J-;J1.J ~1l ~1u ~ ~i'll.J ~~ ~~ ~ u~~<il eJ ~ rn~n11~nl1~eJ1J"ll m 'Yl-;J-;)1 .Ji'll.J1U£J

il1 "11nl1<ill ~ f1l i.J,r._'j Vll wn~ u11l ~~ eJ._'j ~ ~~ (i) tl 1iu~1l"11nl1tl1~-;Jl.JlU~l~u.Jl u q 'IJ ;;w

~l u .JlU~l1il1rn~"ll -;l.J Vll ~ "15~u11 u~l ~l VI U.J ~ ~l VI Ul ~1 ~ ~ 1l ~'\{ u 1 £J1Jl m~ ~ ~ ~l~ u '".:> q q

i1VI l ~fu ~ ~"15eJ 1J.Jl UU1~ nu ~"ll 1ll 'W .Jl uu <i11U1~ nu ~"ll 1ll'W ._'ll u U<i11~l ~~nl1 q q

l"15U~lu 1n Ml'W £Jl1Jl ~ ~~~~.JlUU <i11U1~nu~"ll1ll'W ~~ 1 .J .Jl U~l.J "15l ~ n ~-ri1 £J 1 U.JlU q 'IJ

u <i11U1~rlU~"ll 1ll ow~~ ~~.JlUU <i11U1~nu~"ll 1ll ow ~l 1 .J .JlU~l.J "15l ~ ~ eJ u l.J ~l1 £J 1ll'W1 q q q

i'leJ.J~~ru ~.Jltlu~n-;ll.Jai1~1l1 ~llLVIU._'I'WUn.JlUUru.n il.J~1£J~~Ui'lUVI~u~i£Ju Cll ClJ Ql " "

/U<i11U1~nu~"lJ1llYL. q

Page 22: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

u <?J';i"U';i~nu ~"11 rn'Y'I u 1.:1 ~11ll n1 'Y'I';il <?lfu aJ e:Ju ~ aJ1ll L i'Yl1.:11 ttb ~ ll 1 nu u ru -i1n1';ifu q \ .,

~1 t1 b~ u .:~1 u u r-J u-:~1 u~ ~ 1!1 ~ n1 n u <?J bb ~ 1 f1';j .:~ n 1';i"U <?J';i"U';i~ n u ~"lJ n1 'Y'I bb ';i .:~ .:~1 u~1.:~61J1 ~ ~ q

n 1 ';i T111J T1 3J <?] bb ~ n 1 ';i tl 11 u~ .:1 1 'U "lJ El-:1 'U 1.:1 ~11ll [11 'Y'I ';i ~ Yl El-:1 T1 ~ ~ Ci) dj 'U ~ <?] bb ~ n 1 n lJ q ~ ~ q ~ ~~

n1';itll)u~-:~1u.ffu~u bb~~ nu 1.:1 n'Yl';i1'Y'I';i aJTU<?J rf ~1'V11!1 e:l1 mbr-Jtt.:J1ttbtlu~u.:~ ~uu t1)61J1

~ElaJ1tt1.:~1-:~.Yh .1 'Y'I1U61J~1"ll btlwi1'VIU1~1llbbf..ltt.:J1ttbb'Yltttt1-:Jn'Yl';i1'Y'I';i n1';i~l~ q q

3J e:JU 'vi 3J1£J L iu 1.:1 ~11£J n1 'Y'I';ib tJ u~b u n ~1£J b~ u "il1n litt 1 T11';ibb~ ~ 3J EJU L ~1tl bl EJ ttb~'U "il1 n q ~

litt 1 T11';ibb ~ ~ i1 m~u ~<?! "il1 n litt 1 T11';i 3J1 ~1£J L iLL ri v;)1 ~if ';i13J ~.:~ Lib tJ u~ul"ufn H1 ~

~3J <?] f1 ~1 nli'U 1 T11';i b 'Y'I';i1~~~ El.:JT1 ~~ Ci) l~ n T1113Jf'Yl1-:J ~1'Un1';ib~'Ubb~~u-ru~ bb~~ b ~ u 11 q ~ ~ ~ .,

' ~

u 1.:1 ~11 t1 n1'Y'I';in T111aJf'Yl1-:J ~1uu ru~ btl u n1';i-;)1.:~ aJ1 b ~ElL itll)u~-:~1tt~1u it1<?Jll bu '¥'11~ q ~ .,

~ -J 1 <?Jl i <ii 1 b u u n 1 ';i i .:1 n ~ 11 L u n 1 ';i ~ 1£J b ~ u b tJ u ~ 1u 1 ~ 1 ';i -;ij <?J n 1 ';i ~1 'VI f u 1 ';i .:1 'Y'Ill 1u 1 ~

bb~~~1L i~1£J-:~1uiJ EJ.:~nttbb~~';i~ru 1 ';if1"il1mb';j.:J.:J1 wih.:J61J1 ~ 1 ';i.:J'Y'I£J1U1 ~"il~i <?J'Yl11f1';j.:J n1';j

b~'Utl ti\ e:JU 1 llbb 'Y'I'Yl rJ ~1li1';illi~"lli.:J~l <?1 b ~ tl~"il1';illi1 e:Jtt3T~ bri e:Jl~1un1';ie:J'U3J'~L i ~1ll bb~1 q q q

~ ' u 1.:1 ~11£J n1 'Y'I ';i 1 ~b ii £J u Lu bl e:J u b ~ u 1 <?J m-h u n 1 ';i<?J ';i1 "il ~ EJU T11 .:1 bb ';in "il1 n ~ Yl e:J.:J T1 ~ Yi Ci)

q ~

ri e:JttL~tte:Ju 1mb 'Y'I'Yl u ~1li1';irn~"ll~.:J~1 <?J e:Jtt3T~L i~1 m~u 1~ ~Yl e:J.:JT1 ~~ Ci) 1~ ~';i1"il ~e:Ju q q ~

£J EJ ~ L~ u LuLu bl EJ Ub~ uu1.:1 b tJ UT1~-J T1';i11 Lri e:J n';i';i3Jn1';i~.:Ju 13J L u LUbl Elttb~ ttT1';ilJ ~El.:J T1ttbb~ 1

u 1.:1 ~11£J fl1'Y'I';il~t-b LUbl e:Jttb~ U3J1L i ~~ EJ.:J T1 ~~ Ci) ~';i1"il <?J b uuu1.:1 T1~-:J 1 <?J£J';j~ £J ~ bb ';in~ q ~ ~

tt1.:~~11£Jn1'Y'I';i3J1'Yl1.:~1u L ~ 3J "J 1~tb 3J1L i~';i1"il <?J'YlnT1~.:~ bbti\';i:; £J:;'V\ ~.:~13J1iu13J1L ~ q ~ q

<?J';i1'il<?J Lri e:Jtt1-:J~11£Jfl1'Y'I';i~b LUbl e:Jttb~tt ltlbl e:Jttb~tt"il1nlitt1T11';i "il::u e:Jn ~~e:J.:JT1~~ Ci) ~ q ~

~

di e:Ju'Yln T11.:~11"ll e:J e:Jttru1 <?Jltllitt1 T11';i "il~l~ nn1';ibb -;).:~ 1 ';i.:J'Y'Ill1U1 ~bUtt~ tt.:~ ~e:JL iaJ11'u b~tt q q .,

~ b1 e:Jtt"il1nru1T11';i3J1 bb~ 1 bbtilL iilibb ,r -J'Yl1-:J 1 'Yl';if1'Y'I'YlL ~b ~1'V\ ,X 1~ ~1u ~ <?J61Je:Ju-:~1tttl';i~n tt~"lln1'Y'I ~ q

"lJ EJ.:J 1 ';i .:1 'Y'Ill 1u 1 ~ 3J 1 f u b ~ u ~ <?J L u ';i ~ t1 ~ bb ';in b ~ u ~ bl EJ u 3J 1 'il1 n li u 1 T11 ';i b d EJ ~ 1£J 1 ~ 'VI 3J ~ tt1.:!~11ll1l1'Y'I';i<il~'l.t 1 b~ttaJ1 ~1n 11 nu ~~ El.:JT1~~ Ci) bLL'l~~~ El.:JT1~~ Ci) 1~ ~1ntt1-:Jn'Yl';i1'Y'I';i

q ~ ~

b nufn H1llL 'U ';i~ ll~~ ~.:J'U 1.:1 ~11ll fl1'Y'I';i"il~l3JU1 b~'U ~ b 'V\ ~ tl ~1ll 3J1 ~1 n ~~ e:J-:1 T1 ~~ Ci) q ~

';i13Jvf.:~ Lubl Elttb~ufH11~lt13J1L i~';i1'il~e:Ju bb~~~~ EJ.:~T1~~ Ci) n1~1~~<?J~13J ~

tt1-:~n'Yl';i1'Y'I';i 3J1it~ rr ~1'V1tt'1e:l1 mbr-Ju-:~1u ~1un-:~1tt~1li1';irn~"lli.:~'VI1~61J~u1 q q

L ~~f) llf11~ f) f) rn~n';i';i3J ni';j~e:JlJiEl b "r1 "il<il1-:J"ll El-:1 ~1 un .:11 'U ~1li1';illi~"lli.:J~ 1~61J~ u1 q q

u~~~ EJT1rn~n';j';jaJn1';i~e:Ju"Ji' m Yl"il"il1-:~T111aJ1u~ ~'Yl1-:J~~ d1~11 tt1-:Jn'Yl';i1'Y'I';il~ aJ e:JU'VIaJ1£J-J1U L ~

'U1-:J ~11ll 1l1'Y'I';ivl1 u ru~ l~ uu ~';i"U';i~n 'U~"llfl1'Y'I cfo o 1J1'Yl vl1.:11'Uli';in1';i vl1-:J1'UU';i~n u q ., q q

Page 23: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

LL~:: 1U~U") ~1:1J~:IJEl1JlUJ1tJ 1~ullfEJULUf111:1Jf111Jf1:1J"1JEJ.J~v:JEJ.Jf1~~ (9) LL~:;:.JLL~lU~ 'IJ ~ 'IJ

(i) ~~1f1 ;u kl cf<i (i) Li:Ju~u;u1 1i~1"~" nTnT ~~1.h::nu~"IJ111'V'l R1VIfu LL ~ .J.J1U~1.J"ll'1 ~ ~ ~

~ 1 LL C..J U .J 1 U l ~ f 1J :lJ El1J VI :lJ 1 tJ l i L U U ~ ~ 1 L it U n 1 ~ ll ~ :: f 1J t:j ~ "1l' El1J 1 ~ tJ ~ ~ El .J f1 ~ ~ (9) 'IJ 'IJ

... Q,..l Q..l ,Q, 0 Q..l ~

"~" n1~'Yl.J~:;u u Ll ~::u 1-J ~11 u 111 'V'l~~u C..J <il"ll'EJ1J'Yl11J ru"ll' ~ ~

U 1-J ~11 tJ 111'V'l~ 'Yl El.J L ~ ru l lf n El tJ 4h Gl El f1 rn::n~~:IJ n1~~EJ1J"JJ ~ l'Yl-;J-;J1.J"1J El.J ~ ~

~1 n .J1 u ~1 'D11ill~"1J -;u .... ., Vl1 .... ~ "1l' ~ u111 1ifu n1 ~\11-J L u u ~ n \11-J i'1 f1 ~11 :., LL <ii'll ~ ~ 'IJ

kl cfrn ~ 1<il mJ 1iu~.J1U~~1 u LLC..JU.J1u ~1T.J~uuru"ll'1L~;u EJ1JVIU1~1lfl'11L~ u1nu ~ 'll ~

~::nu~"1J111'V'lU~~ cfoo lJ1'Yl ~El:IJ1LUU 'V'l.f1. klcfci(i) .J1ULL~.J.J1U~1.J"ll'1~l~:IJ ~ '

L"JJ1 1LU~1Ulle..JU.J1U ~-wEl.Jf1~~ (i) LL~::U1.Jlli'l~1'V'l~ :IJ1it~rf ~1VIU1~1rJLLC..JU.J1U 'IJ

1 ~ ;u EJU VI ;u 1 u 1 i l'11 " 1 u u..., ~ ~ Ll ~" .J 1 u @) 1 " "1l' 1 ~ <i!"" 1 u 1 <il u Y11 u u fin l ~ u Elll ~ :: Y11 u ru ; ~

n1~ u~1m~u 1f1~.Jn1~~1~.J'V'ltJ1lJ1~rl1L"ll1:1J1 ~-wEl.Jf1~~ (i) -;u::LUU~lnHtJUVIU.J~El 'IJ 'IJ

~1 u ~1 VI 1!1 ~1 u LLC..J U.J1 Ul ~Ell iu 1 u LL 'V'l i'l rf ~1'D1~rn~"1J i.J VI 1 <il EJ u3T~1 f1~ .J n1~ ~ ~

~ .J 'V'l tJ 11J 1 ~ ~ 1 L it U n 1 ~ ll i 1 -;J :; l'11 L ~ El .J L U n L ~ U :lJ 1 .yj' ~ 1 tJ ll C..J U .J 1 U <i1 U -;J :: ~ :lJ vf n l ~ U El U 1 tJ lL 'V'l i'l £1 ~1 'D1 ~ rn ~ "1J ~ .J VI l ~ El U iJ~ ~ 1 tJ L ~ U 1 ~ tJ LL U 1J 1 f1 ~ .J n 1 ~ lL ~:; L El n ~11

~ ~

1"JJEJ.JlUi1u 1<ilmhu~v:JEJ.Jf1~~ (i) LL~::~1VItt'1~1Ulle..JU.J1U lTilUnL~U-;J1n'DU1f11~ 'IJ

1 tJlL 'V'l'Yl rJ ~1'D1~lli~"1J~.JVIl<ilEJUiJ~Llf~1 m~UlL~1 ~y:j El.Jf1~~ (i) -;u:; Llf~UlUnblEJUL~U ~ ~ 'IJ

u1"1~ ~u-;u::d:Ju~L:n uu11u~::L~ tJ<i1~1u1uL~u~" 1u1ub1EJUL~u LL~TI-b 1ur1 EJuL~u 1u1 i 'IJ

n1~~i:JehU1-;J~.JU1:lJ~1U1U kl f1U 1<ilmlUlJ11rJ~::l~tJ<il1f1~.Jn1~U~::nEJ1JLin~~:!Jn1~ 'll

<il~1 <il~1u i.Ju@)~uu 'V'l.f1. klcf<ici Ltlu<i1""u;u1 <ilUL~;uu~::~uuruVI1'Yl1.Jn1~L~u 'll ~

El El n 1l ~l El.J ;; El n 1 ~ l El111J bl El u L ~ u l u1 i ~31 ~1 u 1-;) ~.,] u 1 :lJ l D n <i!"" 1 tJ f111 :lJ ll11.J 1-;u 'IJ

1<iltJ 11lJrlE!Ul~U 1~uv:J;u L~UEJ~.JU1:1J Llf ~ij el1U1~~.JU1:1J LLGlL6Ji:J lEln~1~1h::nmJ llJbl EJUL~U 'll

LL v:J :IJV1tt'1n <illU LlJUl~El.Jn1~LUn~1 m~uu~::n U~"1J111'V'l ~.J ldJ l ~ tJ1"JJ El.Jrl1J llJbl E!Ul~U ~

U1f11~ ~ULoll1 h-;hn~~:!Jn1~f1.Jl"JJ1 h-;)1 dJt~,L~El.J L~ tJ1rlU ~ .J ~ .J U 1 :lJ 1 \I, 1u bl El UL~U

u-ri El.J 'Yl1.J L -riu if~.J l<iJ U ~ U~ ~ ~ El <i1 :IJ1

-;u1ml' EJ mh;-f.JVI:IJ<iloll1.J~u L ~u 1i 11 ~v:l EJ.Jf1~~ (i) ilV1tt'1~fu~<il"ll'EllJ 1<il tJ<il~.J 'IJ

1un1 ~1LU'U,.J1u 1f1~.Jn1~u~~lh::nu~"lJ111'V'lLL~.J.J1U~1.J"ll'1~;-f.J~::uu ~.J-;u::~ EJ.Jf11lJ ";u <ilLL~ ~ ~ 'IJ

Page 24: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

nl'~U nu~.J1U"'J e:J.Ji-n.J ~11ll .nl'Vf~-~ dJu~ml1-Ji1fl111 LL~:::il'VI'IX 1~ 'YhU ru~LL~:::1u~1 m~ '\,1, ~ ~ ~ ~

1u1fi1-Jn11 n11~~Y!e:J.Jfl~~ G) eJ1-J';hL3Jilfl11aJf~1UUru~LL~:::n11L~U 113-J~.J iJL~fu ~ ~ ~

aJ e:JlJ'V\ 3J1 tJ 1 Vi'fi11Jfl 3J<~m~n11U nu~ .J1U"'J e:J-J'\,1, 1-J ~11 tJ111'W1 L3J e:JT;Ji'lJYf.J L vi f) 1 Vi' 'VI~~ vru ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~1nfl11aJ1u~~ L~ L'W11:::"1T~LLU.JrllJ'Wbl~nl'H~~U11nlJ 1un11 1Vi' n f) m11"'le:J.J~Y! e:J.Jfl~~ G) Le:J.J

LL~:::-n ~ LLU.J nun f) lJ f11"'l e:J.J u 1-Jll'Yl11'W1 ~.J dJu ~1'V\ U1 ~1 tJ LL ~ U.J1 '\,1, 11 aJ ~.J n f) tJ f11"'l e:J.J

U1-J~11ll.n1-w1 ue:Jn'inmfu n11~ ~YI e:J.Jfl~~ G) eJ1-J11~1un.J1U~1li11nt.~"'li.Jwr ~-n~u~ ~ . ~ ~ ~

iJf11i.J 1 Vi' U1-J ~11ll111'W1e:J ci1 Un11f11lJflaJ~ LL~"'J e:J.JU 1-J~1'W1Yl'W1 11L 1"15 L ..ij1'WU n.J1Un11L~U ~ ~ ~ ~

LL~:::u~~ c!. Ju nL~e:J1~1uYf.JL~ L~e:J.J~1nU1\1~11~111'W1 unu~.J1U~~1r.HL~U.J1U ~.J~ e:J.J f) ci1 Ufi113Jf111Jfl 3-J~ LL~n11U nu~.J1U 1~ lJ L ..ij1'V\U1~1 U~1 mL~'U.J1'U iJhh..ij1'V\U1~

~ ~ ~ ~

1 U~1 tJ~'U~1 aJ 'VI~ n n11lJ~'V\11 \11 'U LL ~:::U 1\1 Jl'Yl11 'W1fi.J L3J1 Vi' tl e:J tJ f111 U~ n ~rn:::~ ~UL e:J.J

~ e:J.Jfu ~ ~ "15€1 u 1 u~n u::: ~ U.J f1u u ru "151"'l e:J.J u 1\1 ~11 rJ .n1-w1 'V\1 n u 1\1 ~11 rJ .n1 -w1e1 ci1 'Uf\11 aJ .... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I I ..... I

fl1lJflaJ~LL~"'leJ.JU1-J~11'W1Yl'W1~1aJYi~YJeJ\lfi~Yi G) n~11eJ1\l ~1r.H'V\~U ~'Wel.Jfi~Yi G) . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

oV V

~.J LiluL ..ij1'VIu 1Yiiu~ u 1 un111'u ~ ~oneJutlfj u~.J1u~1 aJ 1 f11-Jn11U ~1tl1:::n u~"'J.n1-w'Yl.J1:::uu

113J~\ln11fi11Jfl 3-J~ LL~n11U nu~.J1U"'J e:J.JU1-J~11ll111'W1 ~.J LUU~ n..ij'1-Ji1fi111~Unu~'V\U 1~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

1 u 1fl1\ln11~1 tJ Ld el'U1-J~11tJ111'W1L~LUnrle:JUL~U~1nuru~"'lel.J'Yl1\111"15n11 kl uru~1u1"11' ~ ~ ~

Lvie:Ju1:::1rJ"15U~1'U~1 1:::'V\l1-JlU~ kld aJn11flaJ klc!.cirn ~.Jl'U~ rn 'Wbl~111flaJ klc!.cicf v ' '

11 aJ ~\) fli'.J ~.JLU'Ufl11aJU1:::aJ1'YlL~UL~ e1 eJU1\lf1mL1-J 1un11tlfju~'V\U1Yi"'l eJ.J~Y! eJ.Jfi~Yi G)

~~eJ.Jfl~~ kl 1itl'e:JrJf11~eJflrn:::n11aJn11~e:JuieJLr1~~1-Jfl11aJfu~~ ~

'Yl1\l~:::Li1~l1 LdeJ1u~ rno TIU11flaJ klc!.cikl ~YleJ\lfl~~ kl 1~1lJaJellJ'V\aJ1milu~ila1U1~ ~ ~

' ' .::.., Q..l I ~ ~ ,;' &;:i

rl e:JUL.J 'U ~ .J ~ 1ll L.J 'U ~1 n li'U 1 fi11L 'W eJ n11L n ~~1LL~::: ~'VI n 1nt. n11L n ~~1 ~1"'J1 "15~lJ 1 ~

11aJrllJn11aJn11~UBn rn flU U1:::ne:JlJ~1lJ U1tJnt.'1\lfl ~'V\L3Jli1~<UJU U1-Jll'Yl11'W1 aJ1U~rJ LL~:::~YJ el.Jfl~~ rn n11~-JU13J 1u1lJrleJUL~U~1nliU1fl11 'U1-J~11 tJ111'W1~:::t.b 1un eJUL~'U -wfe1 aJ

~ ~

'VI ~mnun11e1u~~k\1~1 m~uaJ11 Vi' ~.:JU1aJ 1~ llU 1-J~11 rJ.n1-w1~:::;LL~.Jtl1:::n eJlJ'VI~n~1u .... ~ ~ ....

~Y!eJ.Jfl~~ kl L~ ~11~~ ll e:J~~1u 1'UL~u 1 u 'VI ~n ~1un11e1u~~ k\1~1 u LL~:::ll e1 ~~1U1UL~u ~ ~ .... ~

1 u 1un e:Ju Lda L ~u11lleJ~~1u1uL~u~1\lnu ~.JL~~.JU1aJ 1 u 1un eJU 1~ tJ~11~~eJU'Ylnfi~.:J ~

~~ e:J \1 fl ~Yi· rn 1 VI" tl' eJ rJ f11 ~ e:J fl ru.:::n 113-J n11~ e:J u"JJ e1 L Y1 ~ ~ 1-J f\11 aJfu ~ ~ ~

'Yl1 \1 ~::: Lil ~11 ~'W eJ\1 fl ~~ rn 1~1u aJ e1 lJ'VI aJ1 rJ 1 VI"L ilu~il il1u 1 ~ ~ .J u 1 aJ 1 u 1u n e:J 'UL~'U~1 n ~ ~

liU1fi11L vi e1n11L n~~1LL~:::~'VIn1rnn11L n~~1 ~1"'J1"15~lJ~ Ulli~L~UU ~1U1:::nu~"'J111'W ~ ~ ~

/LL1-:l.J1U ...

Page 25: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

u~h>1"151&l~>"JlL~l'U,~ rna TIU11~UJ klcfcikl ha.J~£l>'l~>'!U1~'haJf11JnTl~n11~U5n ~£1 ~Wfl>'lfl~~ kl U1r.Jn1,1>'!fl ~VIL~ll1vr~6J1! LL~~U1>'lrl'Yl11V'J1 ~1U~rJ ~£1~1

'lJ

u~ cf n~n1~ui klcfctcf L~~n11LU~uun11~n11"15<n1VIaJ U1~n£J1J~1r.J ~ ~

fl~~ rn U1r.J~ruiu l~U1 ~Wfl>'lfl~~ <i LL~~U1>11>'lll11 V'J1U"15~1"ll n11~>1U1~1u ~ 'lJ ~ ~

uL~u ~1 nllu 1 fl11 u 1>'1 ~11 u 1l1V'J1~~ L uu~'!-b 1ufl £J u V'Jf£J ~VI t n~1uu~~~~ <n fi ~-h n ~ 'lJ "-' ~ 'lJ

lK~~fl>'lfl~~ rn ~>'JU1~ ~~fl>'lfl~~ rn l~~11~~£l1JVttn~1U'Ylnfl~>'l ~1>'!tl1J11Jfl£JUL~U 'lJ 'lJ "-' ~

11 i ~>'! u 1 ~ LL~11 u ~ ~ L 5 u <n 1 fl'l >1 n11LaJ L ~ u L flu ~flu r11 ~u 1>'1 ~11 u 111 V'J1'h i'l1L~ ~

wd.>11 ~>'!~ £J>'lfl £JUL~u1u~~~£J>'lfl~>'l L~1'uf11~ £J1J';h~n11~~11rn1~<n ~11L ~~ L&l~ >1~1r.Jl11V'J1l~U 1L1U~1mJ lli'~L1U'YlUVI~ULi uuu ~1U1~nu~"lll11V'JLU ~>'!~~ fl>'lfl~~ rn

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'lJ

£J>'lfl~~ kl 1~11~nu~>"JU1~1u1urJ£JuL~uL~£J1u~ ct ~>"JV11fl~ klcfctrn 1<nur..~£J<nrJ£JuL1u

rn,d~<O'! 1J1'Yl LLr.JnLuu1£JuL"JJ1Ulli~LL1>'!>11U~1>1"151&J ~1U1U kl,<Olb~,cf<O'!b 1J1'Yl ~

LL~d £l UL~ UL "JJ'1 U nJ~f'!UrJiJ £l >'! n Ufi11J fl ~ 1 1fl ~ ~ L 1 >'! i>'l Vll <n "15~ 1J~ ~1 U 1 U <il kl o, <il &'! rn 1J1 'Yl ~ 'lJ ~ ~

U1>'! 11r.J1l1V'J1U1Lu1iu1~1u"15t!~1U~1 ~1u1u <O'!cicf,ooo 1J1'Yl ~

~W£J>'lfl~~ ct 1~ti£Jr.Jfl1~£Jflrn~n11~n11~£Ju"1l£JLYi~~1>'lfl11~fueJ<n 'lJ

~L3J<nl1 n1ru1f11>1n11 1 "lfL1u~1 'l>'!V'J r.J11J1~~1>'1G) Yl11fl1>'ln11 1 "lfL1ULL1>'!>'!1U~1>'!"151&J

L ~ r.J tl1Jn11fi11Jfl ~iJ £1>'1 nu 1 1fl &J <n ~ £l~1nLL 1>'!>'!1U~1>'!"151 &J e:J1 r.JLLr-.J U>'l1U~~ L ~U£1 1 fl1>'! n11 ~

~11 ~w £J >1 fl ~~ ct £J uaT&l1 fl1 >1 n11 1 u u 1 ~ u 1 mL V'J 'Yl rf ~1ll11rn~"ll ~>'! Vl1 <n L~ £J 1 fl1 >1 n11 'lJ ~ ~

1~1 £Jua1&lu~1 1 1>'1V'J u1u1~~~~1L itun11~1~ 1fl1>'ln11 ~1mXu h>1V'J r..111J1~~~i'l1wX>1~£J ~

"lJ £) £) ar~ L Dn~1 r.J L~U~1 ~VI ~n ~1 'U, ~ L ~'U,£) ~1 ~1 u n1~1J1U n11"1J £) >'! n11~1 r.J L~U 1 i ~ "-'

1 1>1 u1u1 ~ ~~Ltluwu1~"1J £)>') e:l1 u ur-.Ju>11u ~w £J>'lfl~~ ct 1~1u~ £l1JVI~1 r..~V11l'1~1 iLuu 'lJ

0 V~ 0 A A ~ fi'

n11~ >'!U 1 ~ r-.J ~ £l1U 1~ L1J n L>'l U ~1nllU 1 fi11L V'J £l n11L n M~1lL~~ ~V1n1rnn11L n M~'l 'lJ

"15~1J~ ~>'llL~lU~ cf n~111vrui klcfcicf 1<nr.J~>'!U1~113Jtl1Jn11~n11~U5n rn flU ~ ~

1>'1~11 r.Jl11V'J1~~Luu~u111Jfl £JUL~uV'Jf£J ~ L£Jn ~11VI tn~1uu1~n £J1J 1 un11Lun~1 u ~ 'lJ "-'

V'Jf£1 ~ ~~ <n fi ~-h nllU 1 fl11 l~ ~11~VI t n ~1 U 'Yl n fl~>'l ~1 M)u 1ufl £JUL~U ~U1 ~11 i ~>'!U 1 ~ ~ 'lJ "-' ~

>'!U1~ 1u 1urJ£JUL1Un11~n11fiU~U~~~>'!U1~~1ri£Ju ~~fl>'lfl~~ <i ~>'!l~~>'!U1~~1~LU 'lJ

~1nn £l r.Jf11"1J1>1 ~U ~~ £l>'lfl~~ kJ ~~ £1>'1 fl ~~ rn LL~~~~ £1>'1 fl ~~ <i eJ1>'ll1 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ

fl11 ~1~ aJ <n1~l>'l1 un11~>1 ~1 r.J ~ £1~£1 1 U 1ufl £JUL~ U~1 ~~U 1>1 ~11 r.J 1l1V'J1U 1 ~11 iL ~ £l ~

~>'!~ r.J~ £l~£lfl £JUL1U~1 nllU 1 fl11 1<n r.J 1 i <n11 ~ ~£l1J r.J £l <n L~ U ~~~fl £JUU'l~n £l1J n 1J L £l n ~11

Page 26: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

"" 't1.L'-1't1.t.'t1.L!!./ "' 0

_,.....~ It 1

~ ~

'11._!1. ~L~L't1.!HlL!!.'t1.~1't1.GL1f1t't1.tG~G!JfJL~L'-~'t1.~N:t.~ ~ ~~~L'-G~,t-1::~11 cot ~~~L'-G~_.t-j~ "" I I I I

Itt (b b b

L'-!~ ~ 't1.t.'t1.L~ ~- ~~o~o- ~- ~;po ~~~1~ru,et .. cot ~~ru,et't1.tA.'t1.~1 , MLL1~~'t1.~::~f1~l€l£t " ' '

b b "' ~

't1. ra ~ 1 't1. rt 1s1. 't1. u. 't1. ~ 1 & ru ,f1 u L!!. 't1. ~ 1 't1. G L1 u G 1 ~ L u L ,t. L'-,P 11_.l€>1 ~ .~ ~ ~ L'- G ~ ~ b

l€l~!!.tA.L~::~U~LU't1.Q1l€lt L'-!~::~11 " b

L'-~!!.'t1.Q1 N:Lt.~N:Ll€l't1.Gl1U[}1~LU't1.Q1l€lt L'-!~Lr.-~kf1MN:G ~ L'-~!!.L'-!~U U 't1.~1't1.G L1f1t't1. t G~G ~n L~L'-~ " " ' ~ ~ ~

't1.G~f1G~!!.l~l€l~k J> ~~~L'-G~,t-1::~11 ~ ~~~L'-G~,t-1 cot ~~~L'-G~_t1UL\s1. 't1._!t::'t!::L~M1 1'1:~11'1:~1 I I I "" I

~~~ l€l ~L'tt1~L~~~LU ~ Lr.-f1G l€l L~ f1!~k L'-J'-' L'-G~ :: ~'11.~ 't1.~1't1.G L1 L'-G ~ L'-~ ~ L'-~ 'A 't1.~ 't1. t N:k L~ b ~ b

Lr.-~MLLlrJ t.L~L'-L't1.N:LL1f1G~rJ ~1 L~~ ~ ~~'-'L'-G~_t1L'-G~L~rJ G ~f1~L'-G ~~l€lG~~MLL1rJ t.L~L'-L't1. b ~

L'- G ~ l€l ~ ~ u. L ~:: ~ u ~ L u 't1. Q 1 ~:: ~ 11 L'- ~ ~ 't1. Q 1 rt L r_ '-' 11: L l€l L'- G JP u L1 ~ n L ~ u G 1 ~ L u 't1. Q 1 ~ L'-~ ~ I I I f"\

b b

~MLL1rJl~L'-L't1.L'-G~'t1.~1't1.GL1f1tG't1.~KLU L~'t1.~1J't\L'-l€>~11L'-~ ~MLL1rJt.~L'-L't1.UL!!.l€l~'t1.~1't1.Q1f1!fJl€>1

~ b b

LN: rJ L~U[} 1 G ~G't1.~1 ~N: Ll€l't1.t.~f1~'-' L'-G JPUL1't1.~1 f1!~1.t ')j-~LUn'-'1'11. t~f1~Jl.l€l~ls1.L'-~~~'tt1~L!lL~ ' "

't1. LL'-U_!l.L~ ~ LN:'t1.~1 n L~U [}1~LUL'-G~1 G't1.~ 1 ~ ~ L'-L~ ~ Lf1LrJ ML'-~ 1 L~(/ U L~f1 ~f-L ~Jl.l§l ~'AL'-~ ' ' '

b

~~'tt1~ULL~'t1.LL'-U 't1.L~L'-G ~L'-~!!.!!.U. 1 G ~f1G~~LU't1.LL'-rJ L~N:Ll§l 't1.'t1.U L~UG't1. L'-LG lL~ UtA.N:Ll€> rtl 0 ~ J!:::' Ill rtl 1"11 I 'f='

" ' ~

't1.~1't1.G L1f1t 't1. t G~G !JfJ L~L'-~'t1.G ~rJL~U[}1~LUf1G u::~f1~L~UG1 f1G~!!.l~l€l~k~ J> ~ ~'-'L'-G ~,t-1::~11 ' '

~ ~

~ ~~~L'-G~,t1 cot ~~'-'L'-G~~L~'t1.£l't1.g~LU't1.Q1::~11 ~kL'-0f1!~L~rJG~'t1.Q1L'-~ 't1._!1.L'-~ 't1.l€>L'-G~ I I I f'tl;

l§l ~ N: Ll'-''11. t MLLl~L~ f1!~LU't1.Q1 ~11 lL~ UL'-~ L~ n G llJ't t ~LUUL!!. L'G 1't1.l€>L'-G ~L~::~U~LU't1. t b b

l§l ~ N: Ll'-' UL~ 't1.~l1~LN: L~~MLLl rJ lL~ L'-L't1.J't t L~~k~:: ~11 l§lt ~ ~ '-' f1~ 11 n L,}J't t~LU 't1.Q1

::'tUHU~~JP~~ J!'~MLVh t.L~L'-L't1.L'-G ~L~n G ~L'-~ LN: l§lG ~l€l~£tgf1~~L'~J!''t1.~ 1 L'LtA.L'G~'t1.~ 1't1.l€l

't1.~1't1.GL1f1t't1.tN:L't1.L'-~L'-~ 't1.~lrJ~1L'-G~1't1.Q1L~!!.tLAl-1L'-~~LUN:~~UL~!!.tLA1-1't1.l€l ~L'-'L't1.!l

b

UL!!. 't1.~1't1. G L1 rtt f1~ L'- G AT-lrJ ~ 1 fflt L' ~ MLV~~'t1.~::~f1't1.~1 n L~ UG 1~Lu L'G~1't1.Q 1 f11.t l§ll! L ,tt ~A ~

N: ~ 11'11. t~11't1.~1't1.G L1 rtt f1G U::~f1~L~ UG 1 ~ ('f~~11 N: L 't1.L'-~ ~L 't1. L~ ~,t-lJ't t N: L 't1. L'-~ G't1.~1 N:~ 11~\ ~

't1. ~1't1.G L1 f1 t L '!'l.fJ !§)1 ~ t L'-Lt.~ ~ N: Ll'-' rJ l~ UG, N: L 't1. L'-~!!. L 't1.L~ ~,t-1 J't tf11.t 't1.~1't1. (! L1f1t LG 1~LU (! ~

L'G1~~ LN: UG G l§l~'t1.~1't1.G L1~LUrJ l§l1 ~1} t LN: ~L.U.L'-L~'tl.LL'-n 11~fu,etUL!!.l§l~'t1.~1 L'!'I.::~~L'-LtA.~G~ b b

't1.'A 1~MLL1rJ t.L~ L'L '11. Lt.tA.~MLLlrJ t.L~L'-L't1.L'G ~L~rJ G L1f1UL'-rJ11 l§l~lL~ UL'-l§l L'LG t.L~ UG ~::~11 J!:::j I F' 0 1ft l'"'tl f'& l"'b I 1'1) f1, I 1ft

L'-~1!.1!. ~ 1 (! AI-N: Ll€> au L~f1~L'-L~ (! L'-!'-' ra (! f1~~ l~'t1.l~J1.u.ra 1 ::~f1G ~ 1z. tf11.t 't1.~1't1.G L1u G m~LN: L~ ' " ' b b

('f ~ N: G ~ ~ M L L1 n t. L~ L' L '11. L'- ~!!. L'- L ~ t. L ~ U ~ N: L l§l L'! '-' UtA. '11. ~ 1 '11. G L1 f1 t '11. t G ~ G !J n L ~ L' ~ ~ L U '11. G ~ ' " ' .,. ~ ~

't1.L~U~'A~L~UG1f1G~!!.t.~l€l~LU't1.tL'~::~l§llt;:~N:Ll'-'Z.~~ J> ~~'-'L'-G~,t-1::~11 ~ ~~'-'L'-G~,t-1

cot ~~'-'L'-G ~~ UL\s1. L~ '11.~ 1 L'-~ (!~(! ~ rJ L~L'~'tl.G ~L'J~ ULAL-~11 rJ L~UG1~LU't1. t ~ L'-L~'t1.LKU~'A

~cot

Page 27: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~1 1UL~U~U1~~11£Jf11'V'l1tt11u1"1f\_hdr.J"15U~1U~1 ~tl C>'!.cicf.,ooo 1J1'Yl ~~1iU1f111 ~

£J£J dJuLLfl"lfL~r.JfL~m~,~~1£Ju1~'Yl "lf~u1e:r£Ju~1f11f~ ~1n~ Lilun1&.~~Yl£J~fl~~ kl ~ 'IJ

LL~:: "'VI tl~ f1 ~~ rn 13-J ~ tJ ~1u ~ ~ L ct£J~-;J1 m U'Uf1113J ~ ~"ll tJ ~ L i1lnt'1~1iU 1 f111~ n1::Y11 ~ ~ 'lJ

L~ tl ~1."1Jn11r1 tl'UL~U L 'V'l11::L3U 1 uuru~if'1::1JL~ tlU 1"lln11rl tlUL~U 1lllXr~ tlUL~U hwn111e1u "' ~

'Yl1~ ""'ru~LrhtXu 113-.1~~ 1u"llrn::~u1~~11£Jf11'V'l1lb1ur~eJuL~U3J11lX~~~1£JneJ;eJ 13-Jii "' ~

11 £J 11Yll Llfl"lf L ~ r.JfL ~fl U11 n 1l tl ~ LL~ U 1 ~ ~11 £J f11 'V'l11~ L ;j £J UL ~ 3J L ~ 3-.l:ff U 1 'Uf11 £J VI~~ ~ 'IJ ~

n1 ifL ~ u 11 LLJJ-;J::v:r~ 1~ 11 LUUf111~ ~ ~'V'l~1~"ll eJ~L i1V1tt' 1~ 1iU1f1111 un11e1 eJmLWlH ~ r.JfL ~fl UU ~~ n ~11 eJ ULlJ U n11~ ~ L~ el U 1 "lJ 1 U n11r1 elUL~U ';11 n lil-t 1fl11rl ~13-.1 LL~ rl rJ~ fl~ L UU

1u ~~"15£JU1 Ulnel~~U"ll el~ ~~~~ ~1 on el;tll ~ elrl eJUL~U~~n~11 1~ tJ~';J11lli11~-;J1n 'IJ

11UrlelUL~UUU1J~~lU~ ci ~~VI1fl3J klcf.ciC>'!. ~~iir.JeJ~~1U1UL~U~rlelU113J~~~U rn ,d~C>'!. 1J1'Yl 1 U~1U1Uif'LUUn11 1 tlUL "lJ1Uill~U~1U1::nU~"llf11'V'l LL1~~1U~1~"111~

"' ~

L~"ll~ ocf.rn- kJ- kloCilOCil- ~ ~1U1U kl,Cil\o:J~,cf.C0'!.\o:J 1J1'Yl1eJuL"lJ1Uill~~U£Ji:JeJ~llU "' 'IJ

fl11J ~hfl~::L1~~~VIl~"lf~U1 Uill~L~"ll~ ocf.rn- kJ- Cildoci~- CO'!. ~1U1U CilklO,CilC>'!.rn 1J1'Yl ~ ~ "'

LL~:; o1Llfl"lfl~tJfL~fl C>'!.cicf.,ooo 1J1'Yl V11n1uv:1~~13J"lJeJn~11eJ1~"llel~~YleJ~fl~~ rn l1 'IJ

1 U"ll :;~ ~~ ~1 £J 3j el~tl 1aJ :W11 r.Jn11Yl1 Llfl"lfl ~r.JfL if1-;J1 ~ LL~U1~ ~11 t.lf11 'V'l11(~)\ ;j r.JU ~

L ~ ~ L~3J~Uf11 r.JVI ~~';11 n :Wn11~~ ~1 £J 3j el ~eJ1 U 1url eJUL~ULLtf1 n ~13J11rl ff~ L n ~ L ~U f111 ~ ~~un~1 un1&.d1~ L cteJ~-;J1n £J eJ~ L~u 1 u11 r.Jn11~1eJuL"l11U'!J~ kl U'!J~ -;J:;~eJ~ii ~11-t U~1~nU£Jel~113J"lleJ~1ur~eJUL~U ~el rn,klrnrn,d~C>'!. 1J1'Yl ~~V13J1£Jf111~l1n111eJu

L"l11 ru~U~1U1::nu~"llf11'V'lLL1~~1U~1~"111~-;J:;iiL~U kl r.Jel~ ~tl kl,Cil\o:J~,cfC0'!.\o:J U1'Yl "' ~

LL~:: C>'!.ctcf.,ooo U1'Yl 5uLUUf1113J ~ ~un~VI1mtlu"l1 £J ~~ ~r.J1~11 LVI~ 1~~~~ tJ~ 1eJuL "111uru~ ~ "'

~~n '11LUU kl £J tl~ LL'Yl'U ~-;J::LUU~1U1UL~UL ~ r.J~ r.Jel~L~ r.J1 ~~~ eJ~ii ih:fu-;J~~ ~~LVI~ ~3-.1~~ ~

-;J1n 1~~11£Jf11'V'l1 LL~LdeJ~YleJ~fl~~ kJ LL~::~Yltl~fl~~ rn iJ1~ii"lJeJ~~~r.JVI1eJ"lJm1nl'11~ ~ 'IJ 'IJ

1~ G) LL~:;~~ ~1 r.Jn tl;el1 U 1u rl elUL~ULL~1 U 1~ ~11 r.Jf11'V'l1~~ ~13J11mii r.JU"lJ elf111 ~ L~3J ~~ 1u ~

1u~ LL'VIU~~~1~n1J~1U1UL~U C>'!.cicf.,ooo l1 "Yl1LLfl"lfL~r.JfL~f1" 1~L~r.J~::~1n ~1un11~ -;J:;e) ~11 Lilun11L ~3-.IL~~~~"lJ £Jf1113JLL~::~1U1UL~u~1£JtXu ~ e1mtlu 1u13J1~ L'V'l11::-;J::Y111lX

~11-b UL~U ~~VI~~ Ld tl113JllU 13J~1~n1J r.Jtl~11~~U11n!J 1 U 1ur~ elUL~U3J1i~LL~ LL1n

~Ylel~fl~~ kJ ~Ylel~fl~~ rn LL~::~Y!eJ~fl~~ ci 1~LLU~~1£Jl1 n1rndii~1LVI~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ~

3-.11-;J nf1113J~ ~'V'l ~1~"ll e1~1::uu~1u 1~ £J ~1u 113-.1 ~1lX ~1 £J u~u~1uL tlu~uiu1n ~1 L~ULL~:: 'IJ

Page 28: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

LUn~1 r.J b~Ubb 'YlU ~';)~ bUU~1 r.Jn11b~U ~~El ~1 r.J1J1~11._'111-\. J1 i.iJ 11 ~rt._, i.aJ nn11~1 r.J b~U b tJ Ub iffl o/11 ~1~ b u r.J1JiJ D U~"ll EJ._'I'Yl1._'111 "lrn11 ~._'! b n o/1 fl11 ~ b *r.J~1 r.J';J1n n11n1:::rl1'Y~';l1o/l

"ll EJ>'~u 1._, ~11 r.~n1 ·vn ~._, L v; u··.h n1m di.aJ11';)~n f111 ~ t:l o/I'W ~1o/11J n-w-iEJ._'j"lJ EJ.,'j1~uu._,1 u q '

1<ilr.J~1U11~L"li1~1L~r.J1"1iEJ._,~~EJLaJno/11~ ~YlEJ._'jfl~~ l!:J ~YlEJ._'jfl~~ m LL~:::~'WEJ._'jfl~~ ci ~ ~ ~

ci EJ~i.aJ~~11twm ~o/l~._, -n~11:B'uL ~ EJ1'!X~U';J1nf111~1ut:lo/l l<ilr.~iuL~._, i.~ L 'W11~~v:l EJ._'jfl~~ l!:l q ~

~YJEJ._'Ifl~~ m bb~~~YJEJ._'Ifl~~ ci 1u~1U~n11~n11~n~1U1-;J~._'I~1r.J~EJ~miJnflEJUL~U';J1nUru~ cu c:u ct.S ClJ Ql

ci EJ~~EJ._,1"1ff111~1~~o/11~1._,1EJ1Jf1 EJU 1 un11o/111-;J~e:Ju LEJn~11~~n~1u~1._, GJ ri EJU~>'~~1 r.J~ EJ~EJ 1 u 1utl El Ub~U b ~ mJ f) ._'I nu n11n1~rl1f1';l'1o/l"ll EJ._'j b -:il1~U1~~iJ D U~._'l1 u n11n1~rl1"ll f) ._'I

~YJEJ._'Ifl~~ l!:J ~YJEJ._'Ifl~~ m bb~~~YJEJ._'Ifl~~ ci LUUL~<i11'\Xu1._'1~11r.J1l1'W1~1~11flflEJUL~U ~ ~ ~ q q

"ll El._'I'Yl1._'111"1rn11EJ EJn i.iJ1 iL ~ EJiJ1~ t r.J"Iru~1w~11 i.~ll EJ r.J flf._,1 wrl1._, L 1 ~1~ ~1 r.~tJ~ m ctEJ._,nu

~._, LUUn11iJ1~~1'Yl L~UL ~ El El ci1._,f1 r.J LL 1._'11 un11iJDU~~u1~11"1rn11bb~~~ EJ._'j11J t:lo/11 u~ ~

uV:._,n11n1~'Yl1~~Liio/l~u LL~:;,hwru"liEJ t~LLrJ.,'j"lJEJ._'j~YlEJ._,fl~~ ct L~r.~1nuc-~~n11~EJu ~

'1.1 ~A 0 V V V ~d ~ V o tL, "ll m 'Yl ';! ';! 1._, "ll EJ._'j ~1 u n ._'11 u ~1li11 rn ~"ll -;u ._, ~ 1 o/1 "1J ~ u 1 6JJ ._, L n u 1:; r.J ~ L 1 ~ 1 ci cf. 1 u o/11 ~ f11 ~ ._,

q q .., ... ... I Cl.l 'I.J r:;: A Q...l 1 Q..ol V r:: A

bbo/1._'1 o/1._'1 f1 rn~n11~ n11~EJ1J"ll EJ L 'Yl';J -;u1._, 11 ~ 'Yl._'l n11LLo/l._'l o/1._'1 f1 rn~n11:1J n11~EJ1J"ll EJ L 'Yl ';! ';11._'1

f111~1u t:l o/1 'Yl1._'1 ~~ Lii o/1 t o/1 r.J EJ1 i r.111 r.J ._'111-\.c-J ~ n11~EJu"li m ;1-;u-;u1._,,r1._, iu L uu n11LaJ"Ir EJU

i1 r.Jn~ ~~1 r.J Ju i.aJ EJ1';)11JVf._'j Lib 'W11~1~ r.J~b 1 ~1~1 "111 Un11~1 b uun11~EJ1J"JJ m Yl';J-;)1._'1

ci EJ ~aJ1-rl~11~tt1 T1ty~-;u~'Yl11 'IX c-~ ~n11~t1u"li m r1 ';J-;u1._,J U"lrEJU~~EJ i.aJ"JrEJU ~1 r.~n~~~1 r.J LLil ~Yl EJ._'jfl ~vr._, ~i.i n1~'Yl1 ~~ La:io/1 ~ EJ ~ u 1 r.J.,'j1U"ll EJ._'jf~-;)1 nn11iJ fiu~~ u1 ~

~ ~ ~

to/1 r.JiJ1~~1'Yl b~Ub ~ El El ci1._'1f1 r.J bb 1._'1 i._'l~lmU';J U r.Jbb~1 no/11 ~ rJ._'jfl._'l iiu ru~1i EJ>'I'W';J11lli1 .,

~ EJ i.iJ 11 i<il ~1 Uf111 :IJ fu ~ o/1 ~ ~Vl EJ._'j f1 ~ vr._, ~i EJ._'j "Iro/11 "IrLlKmi 'Yl1._'111 "Irn11o/11 ~ f11 ~._,"ll EJ._'j ~

~fln'WEJ._'jfl~~ C9) ~._,~._,o/11~c-~~n11'W';J11m1"llEJ>'~~fln'WEJ._,f1~~ l!:J Luui.i.Jo/11:1J:IJ1o/111 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

bb v: ._'I'W1~11"1rUru ru~ fl11 :IJ11J ~ o/1 'Yll._'l ~ ~ Lii o/l"ll f)._'l _b -:il1~U1~ 'W. f'f. l!:J cf.m ~ ~~El i.aJ n ~11 ~ El ., ., . ' A ,::::f~ A A A ~ 1 1 Q...l ..:!(

:1Jn1rn 'Yln11~~L:IJ o/1 L no/1';11n f111 :IJ ~o/1~1EJ f111 :IJ1Jn'V'j1EJ.,'j"lJ EJ._'j~ u 1 r.J.,'j1U"ll EJ.,'j1~~1EJ1~uun11 ~

~1 L UU._'I1U~1U11 ~ ~._,-;u~i EJ._'j~ n~1ULL v;._,f111 ~fu t:lo/l~._,n~11 EJ EJn~~EJ i.aJ 'W Lf111~~LL~1 LV: u 11 ~l L ~ o/1 tt1 f1 ru ~ 'Yll1 '!Xu 1._, ~11 r.J 111 -w1~1 :IJ11fl L iJ n r1 EJ UL~U~o/1 -;u1 n liU 1 f111l~ q ., q

n L cte:J._'I';J1nUl._'l ~11 r.J1l1'W1iJ fiu~~Ul~ El ci1 1-1.~1 r.J LL~U>'I1U"ll e:J._'j tllUn._'llU~1li11ill~"ll,)._,~1 o/1 q ~ ~ q

~ ._, dju ~1 u._,1 u ~i.~1u :IJ EJu ~ :IJl r.~ 1 'IX1u t:l o/l"lr EJu ~1 Lit u 1f11._'1 n11u o/11iJ1~nu ~"ll 111 -w q ... ' '

't1._'11~1J1J bb~~iJ1ln!)o/ll~f111'1Xnl1"lJEJ.,'j~tlnYlEJ._'jfl~tl C9) bb~~~flnv:lEJ._'jfl~tl m 11 n1~'Yl11._'1 ~~ ~~

-/ '=---~·-r.,

Page 29: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~1 11rn~"ll l.~i~ 1 i~1 ,rn ~ 1 u ~11l11rn ~"ll ,)~ ~1111 ~1 u 1~ L 'Yl ~ ~1 L uu n1 11 fl1 ~ n11 q q

u ~ th~n u~"lln1'Y'l LL 1~~1u~1 ~"Ir1 ~ ~1.Xn~1 u~11l11rn~"ll<il~ 'VI1111 ~1u 1 'VI nJI.~JJ f)lJ'V\ 6J1 tJ q q QJ

1 i 1 tJ LL ~ u ~ 1 u ~ 1 L it u n 1 1 ~ ~ n 1 1 ~ 1 L u u n 1 1 LJJ' 'Y'llJ u ru 'VI 1 eJ tJ, 1 ~ 1111 L ~ u I. ~ 1' 1 QJ

~1 LL~ U~1 U"ll f)~ ~1 un ~1 U ~11l11lli~"ll ,)~'VI 1111"Ir~ u1L~flJ 6J f)lJ 'VI 6J1 tJ 1 i ~1 L UU n1 1 q q

1fl1 n11~~n ~11 L "liu.L~ W.lnlJ ~1un~1U~11l11lli~"ll<il~'VIll11 ~u ") 6fr~ n11~1 Lit un11116Jn ~ q

n11 nu1nM1L~U Yl1U~iLL~~Lun~1tJL~u1iLLri11~'Y'ltJ11J1~~1~ ") <11'1tJ ~~,fu, 1111tJ1~1JlJ ~n <11 u~ ~1 tJ LL~u~1u~16J11n1u ~l11"1re:Ju~1 Lit u 1fl1~n11L111L111 tJL~~1Lllu~ f)~ Lnu1nM1 L~it

~

LL~~ un~1 tJ L~U.Le:J~ L 'Y'l11~~1 tJLL~U~1U l~ n L i1'VIU1~n11L~Un11Drui n L Vi tl~ L i1'VIU1~ QJ

1 Lfl 1~~'1-t. 1 tJlJ1 tiLL~~ LL~UL 'Yh,fu, ~1 tJLL~U~1 U~~ LlflUnJ'V\11111 tJ n11i1~ ~ ni1~i1fl111 QJ ~

JJ11J5u~'VIU1~d 6fr~r111 iL nl11fl116J'VI ~~'VI ~16J 1 un11u5u~~1u L rte:J~111n iil.~~n fl11J~6J 1 i e:J '1 U 1~1J lJ n11 L~ ULL ~ ~n11U ru~~ rl n ~f) ~"ll fJ ~ '1'11~11 "lrn11 el UL U Ufl116J L ~ tJ1 "1!1 ru

1\J Ql qJ Q.J

LL~~ 116J11J~I11"lre:JlJ"lle:J~~1Un11L~U ~1tJlJ1'VI11~1U~1lU L'Y'l11~u~Ju ~1u1u1fl1~n11~~n~11 ~~~J 6J11rlLLU~e:Je:JnL~dju, kl ~1'1-t. n~11~e:J ~1UlLfl11~'VI1fl1~n11<il'I11Yl1LL~U 1J1'V111LL~U

e:JU6J ~1 fl1 ~ n11 LL~ ~ n11fl11J fl6J '1'11 ~ D ru i 'VI 1 f) tJ f) 111 L~ U~16J1 1rl f) ci1 Ufl116J11J~ 111"lre:J1J"ll f)~ q q QJ ~

~1 tJ L~U~1U ~.~ u~nTH nu-rm~1L~ULL~~LUn~1 tJL~Uffl3JTH1 LLtJn f) e:Jn LU f) ci1 unT~fl11Jfl3JI11 LL~ ~ q ~

LL~~ nu~~1Wlle:J~~1Un11L~U ~1 tJlJ1'V111~1lUl~ L ~f) 1 i n11fl11Jfl3J ~1 L~Uf) ci1 U 1~1JlJ :w q ~

uu u ~ wll f)~ '1'11 ~11 "1Jn11 f) ci1 ~ L fl'i ~ fl1111 113-1 ~~ n1rn n 1 1~ 1 tJ L~ u L ll u L ~ fli1113J 1~ dj tJ u

n11L .,;u1m~1L~ULL~~n11U1L~U~~fl~~"lle:J~~1U11"1rn11 YL~ . kl<fklo 6fr~LUU.n11-il11111~1~1J1Jll

L~e:J f)~nun11n1~Yl1'Yl111111"llf)~L,r1'V\U1~f)ULL~1 n11~~rmWe:J~fl~~ C9) Ll~~~nnWe:J~fl~~ rn q ~ ~~ ~~

eJ1~ '1 ~1U n ~1U~11l11lli~"ll ~1U 1 'VI nJ 3J eJ 1J 'VI 6J1 tJ 1 i ~1 tiLL~ U~1 U 1u ~ 111"1r fJ 1J ~1 Lit U n11 q QJ

1111 tJ ~ nuru'V\1 ,f u L v; u l1 L llu n1ru ~ <11 f)~~U,f) cinu fl116J~m~-111 tJL u n11U nu~ 'VI U1~"ll f)~ QJ ~ :w

L,r1 u1~ Lllu~1 fl'~ 6fr~iihh-~uu~1u ~~ L 'Y'l11~1~uu~1u ~~11~<11' f)~ ~16J11niJ e:J~nun11 n1~ 0

1'Yl111111"ll f)~ L i1'VIU1~l111L~l1 L i1'VIU1~ ~,fu,1)~~m~-111 rf ~111111'VI1f) l~ni1116J ~~,fu, q ~ q

1 '1-t.fl f d'~~ L V:_u l~l1 ~1 L 'VI ~"ll e:J~n11n1~YlTr~111111~ L fli11~UdJUL 'Y'l11~fl116J ~111'Y'l~11111Jn'Y'l'ie:J~ "lJ f)~ r 1-h tJ~1 U"ll f) ~-r~ LL ~ ~1~1J lJ ~1 u ~1 u 116J L_UU~1fl ~ 1111 tJ1 i ~1 tJLL~U~1U ~1U n~1U ~11l 1lli~"ll<il~w-r 111"1r~lJ1 -ru ~ 111"1ff)lJ L nu-rm~1 L~ ULL ~ ~ L u n ~1 tJ L~ u 1111 tJ l~ L i1 Gh~lJ lJ n11

q q ~

L rllJ '""'n M1 L~U LL~~ L U n '<iJ1 tJ L~UI1116J1~ L U tJ lJ LL lJ lJ LL~ UU n ~"ll e:J~'Yl1~11"1rn11L ~ e:JU e:J~n U

n11 1~Yl1~111111"ll f)~ L ,)1'V\U 1~ ~unu~~1U 6fr~ 1 Un1rn d l~U11n!Jl1~16J'V\U~ ~f)~~n11"ll f)~

Page 30: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

rna

' ' ' Q...l d Q.,.l I ~ ,:::1 Q...l • .d

~lt..J~Eln1:::'Yl11..Jn11fl~..J ~1U'Yl~~ 'Yl nfl ocf.~b . cf./rnoocf.d ~..:111-t'Yl d ~~1fl1.1 ~cf.ciC9l q q

u~:::1:::LU r.JlJn1:::'Yl11..:1~11l11rn~"ll 11~1 m~ttU11..J"ll a-:~~1-b r.1u1n111 tt~Ml~ YL f'l. ~ cf.rn b q q

1~rh~u,~~~n L nrn~n11L nu1nH1 L~ULL~::;djn~1 r.J L~lt 1idJWW Lf'IH"il1n1:::LU r.JlJn11L fllJ ....

1nH1 L~ ULL~ :::n111-b L~lt~-:1 fl ~..J"ll El-:1 ~1 U 11"11n11 'V'L f'l. ~ cf.~ o uti\ El ~1..:1 1~ L W11 ::;Q::;U U

n11~ ~ rmv:l a-:~ fl ~~ C9) 1~ r.1 fl111.1 L v; tt"l!au"IJ a-:~~ rmv:l a-:~ fl ~~ ~ LL~:::n11~"il11ru, 1 EJ'Ylll1rn 'U'U 'U'U q

"lJ EJ..J ~ bl n v:l a-:~ fl ~ ~ rn ii 1 ~ u 1 ~1 u, "lJ EJ..J fl11 :IJ ~ ~ w ~ 1 ~ lJ n w 1 a-:~ "ll El-:1 ~ 1-b 1 r.J ..:1 1 u "ll El-:1 1 <U 'U'U ~

~1a"ll a-:~1:::uu-:~1U~1u 111.1 1.11lKn a an"il1n i~ ~1"Ufl11 :u1u ~~"ll a-:~ ~v:l EJ..Jfl~r-f..:~ ~~..:~ 16.1 Llltt 1u 'U .

~..J"il::: L ~ 1.11 :::~1.1 LUttll111.1 LL~::; L ilu 1u ~1 :IJ ~ ~ m n rn~"ll a..:~n !I ~:IJ1 r.1 ~ L fl11 ::;~LL~1 L v;u, 11

~1 nn11L nu1nH1 L~ULL~::; LUn ~1 r.J L~lt~1 :IJ 1 fl1..Jn11L Ult 1u ~1 :IJ1:::lJlJ..J1 ULL~:::1::; L u r.JlJ

LLlJ lJ LL~ U U n ~"ll El-:1 'Yl1..:111"11n11 U 1..:1 ~11 r.J 1l1 W1 ~ El :IJ 16-J n -ria~ 'Yl1~ "il :::n1:::rl1 n11'Yl"il1~ 1~ q q

L W11:::tt 1..:1 ~11 r.J1l1W1"il:::16J ~1 :IJ11bl L nu ~:IJ ~u ru~1in lJ ~1 La~ LL~:::16J ~1 :IJ11blbl EJUL~ u,~~ q q v

a Eln'il1 nlltt 1 fl111~ n11~~ ~1 r.J ii EJ~a1 u, 1un EJUL~ U,"i]::; LU~ r.JULUU n11~..:1 ~1 r.J ii EJ~a1 ttL anfl '

~~'il::;n1:::LU r.JlJlTIU~u~1~ r.J LQ w1::: L yj t~i11\K~l~U1 L anfl1u,rttLUUL~lt~~ 1~ ~'1El~1mJ~fl..J LUttn11~..:1~1r.Jii EJ~a1u1unauL~UEJ ~1-:IL~ 1.1 n~ El..J~1ttn11~11'il~EllJ"il1nL~1~U1~n11L~U, ri Ellt

ii1-rilfJ U U 1 ~ ~11lJ 1l1 W1 L ~ lJ ..:1 erL ~ r.J1 ~ LlJ ltfl lt~1 Lit U n11 L W11::;Q::; ,_f U ~ ~ fi t~1i l1 L U U q 'U

fl111.1 ~ ~ w ~1 ~unw1a~"ll a-:~~ 1-b 1lJ~1 U"ll a-:~1<U~'1a1:::uu~1tt~1u 111.1 ~ ~ Lllttu'il-;1 lJ~ ~n~ ~

Yl11 'l-f L fi ~ "Ji El-:1 'Yl1..:1 1 U n 11 'Yl "il1 ~ L 'Yl, 1 6) n""' lJ fl11 :IJ U 1::; :IJ 1 'Yl L ~ U L ~ El El tf 1 ..:1 f 1lJ LL 1..:1 "lJ El ~ q

~w EJ..Jfl~r-f..:~~ ~._,~ a~lK n~1tt"ll a~fl111.l~~W~1~unw1a~d~1tt1w;:·a r.J~::; cf.o "ll EJ..Jfl11:1J1u~ ~ 'U

~1:ui~~1u~~nnv:la~fl~~ C9) ~1:1Jfl11:1JLv;tt"llEJ~~nnv:lt~~fl~~ ~ 1iaan~hi~1\K 'U 'U 'U 'U

.... ' .... ~ v:J El ~ fl ~ Yl ~ ~ 1 lJ ~ ~ 1 U n 11 n 1 ::; rll ~ ::; L ij ~ ~ ~ 91 ::; L ~ 1.1 1 ::; ~ :IJ LL ~ ::; L U U ll11 :IJ 'U El n 91 1 n U U 'U

LQ W1:::n1rn"ll El~ ~v:l El~ fl ~ ~ C9) ~~ ~ El ~1u ~ ~ 1 lt<U1 u,::;~ fl11J fl :IJ ~ LL~n11U n u~~U1~"ll El-:1 'U .... 'U q'IJ dJ

u1..:~ ~11lJ n1w1 ,! u 16Ju11n n11 ii ~u..:~ f1uu ru "1111::: iu L ~ ·-u, a,ru, 1u ~ a-:~1u ~ ~111.1 ~1lJ q dJ 'U v

n~1'J~El n1rn"llEJ~lt1~n'Yl11W1 :IJTU~~ lK1~U1~1mL~lt~1lt ~..J~El1.11lt1..J1..Jti11 W1it"11~1"ll q q

:u11u<111uwu..:~lK1~tt'1~1mL~tt~1uLmu u1-:~n'Yl11w1 ~..:~u flfl~r-f..:~~a..:~d~ a~1u~ ~ 1 un1& d~1 r.1 . • q

/u~dJttnTL.

Page 31: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

LL~ L u n111'u ~ ~ Lu ~1~ ~1 u ~ u fl fl m 'r>'l fffl>'l L tJ un116Jn1Tb dJ ~>'l ~1 £.J 3j El~ fl 1 u 1u r1 flUL~ u q

u~ ~fl~>'lLrhJu iii.~1u~~1u~1u~dJu~u>'J~uuru"Ir11u1~~un~:B'ui.l.J~"il~iEl>'l '\J "'

fl1 fl dJ ~ LL ~ n 11U .fi,jG) >'ll u "ll fl >'l u 1 >'l ff11 £..1 fll ~ 1 <ii El "ill n ~ YJ fl >'l fl ~ fi' G> U ~1 fl d 1 >'l1 ~ q '\J ';cJ q '\J

~>'l u ~>'lL~LUUli11dJ~fl~f:Jfl>'lfl~fi' G) fi'ifl>'lfu~~1u~1U~~fl11JfldJ~LL~1~~uiu '\J "" '\J q '\J

' I .d ~ .cl d ~ Q..J I ,d .c::::l t.J Q....l Q..<l Q.J

"ll fl ..:1\ u 1 >'l ff11 ~ n1 ~ 1 LL ~ L ~ u >'l ~ L ~ u 1 f'll ~ "il >'l LVI 'U, fl11 VI n ff 1 'U, 'Yl fl1 1 :JJ ~ u >'l flU u ~ "111

1 u 1""~1J ff >'l~ u i.u "ill n ~YJ fl >'l fl ~Yi' G) fu ~ ~11 :JJ ~-HJ ~>'l L~ fl iJi.~ii n111 i'U, 1..:1 .rl 'Yl11 ~1 '\J '\J

LL~:; 1>'l1>'lYi11 11 dJ,t>'l ~u>'l ~uuru"Ir11 'U, 1~~u~ff>'J:ff'l,.t i.un-hdfu ~~ 1 u~1'\,.t d ~>'l i fl>'li n q '\J "' '\J

~1'\,.tfl11:JJ1'u~~"llfl>'J~v:lfl>'Jfl~~ G> flfln~nfflu~:; klo 11dJLUU1fltJ~~ do "llEl>'l"il1U1UL~U~ '\J

~y:j >'lfl~~ G> ifl>'lfU~~ ~>'l"il~LVI:IJ1~~:1JLL~~LU'Uii11:1J ~1VIfUn1rn"llfl>'J~YJfl>'lfl~~ cr '\J '\J

"il"il1>'JU11nrd1 L~U~~v:lfl>'Jfl~~ cr rln&>'l1~"15~1i"il1U1'U rn~G>,crrnb . rnrn Ul'Yl Ju ';cJ '\J '\J

n11rlflUL~'\,.tfl~>'l~ k!oc Lrifl1u~ k!kl ~>'lVIlfl:JJ k!oc<irn ~>'l~v:leJ..:~fl~~ cr ifl>'lfu~~ '\J

"11~ t"L U 'U "ill 'U 1 'UL~ 'U kJ b, crb o. G> ~ 1J1 'Yl 11 :lJ eJ ci i 1 tJ LL~ "ill n 11 £..1 >'ll 'U n11~ fl 1JoV fl L Yl "il "il1 >'l '\J

fl11 1u~~'Yll>'l~~Lii~"llfl>'lL~1VItt'1~ U11nn-ffmr1"il"il1>'l'"h ~v:lfl>'lfl~~ cr i.<l!1udJEJu1~~~1'\,.tl"il ~>'l ~ ] u 3j EJ~fl 1 u~l'\,.t~n11:JJn1Th :JJ 1 un11r1 El'UL~ 'U,Lrl Ell 'U, ~ cf n dJ n1~ uf kl <fer <f Ltlui 'U, i.u

"" q

~>'Juu 1'\,.t1uri' klkl ~>'lVIlfl:JJ k!occrrn ~Wfl>'lfl~Yi· <i ~>'JL~~l:JJ11rl~>'l~1£.J~El~fl1u '\J

1ubl UL~u i.i ~>'lifl>'lin"il1U1'U,L~U~>'l n~11 eJ fl n L ~11~u:;Ju ~~ ~1Ufl11:JJfu~ ~"ll fl>'l

~YJ >'lfl~fi' cr rlfl'\,.tinfflt.~~~ cfo ~>'JdJUfl11dJ~~un~1fl>'l"llfl>'l1:;uu~1U11:JJ ~>'JLUU '\J

"il1u UL~U rncfcr,W'!db.G)oc Ul'Yl (rn~G>,<irnb.rnrn- klb,<ibo.G>~) ~1Un11~trWfl..:Jfl~~ cr '\J

hiLL >'l';h i.i~n11'Ylliruru1U1~UU1~UeJdJ u fl:JJfl11:JJ nuul>'l~11 u n1~1LL~:;ru1~ L vl flu fl:JJfu Q.JQJ , QJ

"1111 L~u~1L~tJVI1t.~1un1rnii'LL~1 Vld~>'l1:;!ui.u trv:leJ>'lfl~~ cr i.aJieJ>'lfu~~VId~>'ln~11~nJ'U, '\J

L v;u '1 13-J eJl"ilfuYl>'lL~ L ~11:;LLd1Yl>'l11~n11Yl1VIU>'l~fl1u~nl~VId1 1 ~ m1u LL ~ ~11u 1~ i.<l!~ n11"1111:;V1d~1 :JJ,f u V1'1e:Ji11d~ uL3Jfl11J tl1'\,.t fl11 dJ L ~£.JV11 £.J~VI 1-i 1 £.J..:J1U"ll fl>'lf~

"" "ill nn1rnd~ eJ :lJ rJ>'J fl>'l ij f)~ LL~~ ~w f)>'Jfl ~~ cr i fl>'lfu ~ ~ ~1 :lJ ~~ R1 'U,"l] f) >'l ~'U,~ f) LU

'\J '\J

fl ~ r-t>'l ;fl11i fl>'lfu ~ ~"11~ 1 i'fl11 :JJ L ~tJVIl u 1 u n11n1~Y11 ~ ~ L iJ ~ ~>'l d ~w fl>'l fl ~~ G) '\J

I1.J 0 .:::::lt. I Q..l

1 fl u ~ ~ rn o "ll fl >'l "ill 'U, 1 u L >'l u kl , rn o G) , G)~ fill.~ fill u 1 'Yl L 'Yll n u b &'! o, rn cfb . rn cr u 1 'Yl

trv:leJ fl~~ kl 1u~~1flu~~ cfo "llfl>'l"ill'\,.t1'U,L~u G>,filfG>~,W'!bcf . ok! Ul'Yl Lthnu ~cf&'!,<i~hcfo Ul'Yl '\J

trv:IEJ fl~~ rn 1u~~1fl£.J~~ cfo "llfl>'l"il1U1UL~u G>,~cro ,b&'!cr.bkl Ul'Yl Lrhnu ~o,rncrd.rno Ul'Yl '\J

trv:l fl fl~~ cr fu~~ffl£..1~:; cfo "lleJ>'J"iJ1U1'UL~'U rnoccr,&'!db.G>oc 1Jl'Yl L'YlllllJ G>filfd,cr~~.od Ul'Yl '\J

) ... /f'!l ~ 1.J n fl1 Eh'liu~ u ...

Page 32: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

' I

f'fl ti 1J n f1 1 eJ \l.ff u rll u ~ 'V'll n ~11 i L ~ n r1 eJ u f11 i \l "ll eJ \l ~ r1 n ~ eJ \l f1 ~ ~ l9) 'U 'U

~n 11f111 11 b ~ 'U"ll a\l ~ bl n~ €1\l f1~ ~ kJ bbti:; ~ ti nl1~';ijl1n!.l a'Yl1i1rn"lJ a\l ~ rln ~a \l f1 ~~ rn 'U'U . ~ 'U'U

LU'V'll:;~1U~1i~~€l\lf1~~ l9l ~\l~~€l\lf1~~ ct 1u~~Hnun1l~l'it1U ~<t'!o,rncf~.rnci lJl'Yl 'U 'U

' 0 a.; 0 ,::!t

c;:icf<t'!,cic;:ik!.cfo lJTYl <t'!klo,rnciG'll.rno lJl'Yl bbti:; l9lG'liG'll,cic;:ic;:i.oG'll lJl'Yl <fil11til<filJ f11"1J€l€l'U

uan-;u1ndli~m ~~€l\lf1~~ kJ bbti:;~~a\lf1~~ ci a'Yl1i1rnll nl1~'Ul\l~l1tJ.fll'V'l1 'Yl€1\lb~nJ 'U 'U ~ ~ .,

Lunr1auL~u 1wi~1ui11riltl eJtJf1~.,,f u Ln <n-;u1nn1~ ~1 tJn11wu 1JJ1rll f111Jf111LLti:;<n11';j)~eJuL~u ~ ~

' .., 'Ul\l ~11 tJ.fll'V'l11rilLUn11.1 bb~11riltt 111J1 i'<nlaJ1<n b11J1~~\lflri LUn111~1a 1JJ 11 11rl\l b n ~-;uln

~ ~

f111 11 ~ ~ 'V'l til~ u n 'V'l~ eJ \l"ll eJ \l wU.1 tJ \ll U"ll eJ\l1;J LL ti:;1:;u u \ll u~1 u 1111 1 ~ tJ 1 i ~1 tJ u~ U\ll u .. ~1un\l1u ~11il1rn.~"lJ~\l~1 ~-ntiu11u ~ ~-neJu L nu1n ~1 L~uLLti:; L un~1 t1 L~ u 1<n t1 1JJ L "IY1 ~

~ ~ 'U

1:; lJ lJ n 11 b n lJ 1n ~1 b ~'it bb ti:; bun~ 1 tJ b ~'it <n 1 111:; b li tJ lJ bb lJ lJ bb ~'it 1J n ~ "lJ a \l 'Yll \l 11 "15 n 11

L ~ eJiJ eJ\lnunl1n1:;l'lTYl-;u'1<n"ll €1\l L ~1~t.t'1~ ~lJ nu~\llU ~1rilL n~-;u1nn11~ ~~ a\lf1 ~~ kl ~ 'U ':IJ 'U

~ ~ eJ., f1 ~ ~ rn uti:;~~ eJ \l f1 ~ ~ ct ~ 1 rll <n 1 1-;u ~ eJu b €) n ~1 1 n eJ uti \l ti 1 t1 ~ €l ~ €11 u 1u r1 €l u L ~ u 'U 'U .

LL ti:; ~w eJ \l f1 ~ ~ l9) ~\l ~w eJ \l f1 ~~ u: uti:; ~L ~ t11"1Y a \!1~1 i t1 eJ tJ f11 L~a., n11 L u n~1 m~ u 1 u 'U 'U 'U

"' ' ' Q..<l ~~.:::., V.::rt, .::::., .ciQ...I Q.JII d. ~,c!l

-nu ~au ~1 u "lJ eJ L 'Yl-;u -;u1 \l f111 111u ~ ~ 'Yll\l ti:; L 11 ~ 'Yl n f1 utJ u tJ u<n1 \l n u 11 n au 'Yl-;u:; ti\l til tJ 11 eJ -n El q

1 'it 1u bun bl €) 'Ub~'U 1rll <fi11';ij ~ellJ n el'Uti \l til tJ ~ El~El 'Yl n f1~\l f1\l ~ b ~ tJ\l 'it 1\l ~11 tJ.fll 'V'l1f1 'Ub ~ tJ1 q q

1 i t1 a tJ f11111 JJ ~ L eJ n ~1 1 1J 1:; n eJlJ n 11 L u n r1 au L ~ u LL ~ eJ ci 1 \lL ~ ~ \l u 1 \l ~11 tJ .n 1 'V'l 1 ~

L tlu~ n1:;l'11 f111 11 ~ ~ f11l i nl1"1J €1\l u 1 \l ~11 tJ.nl 'V'l1 ~1 i t1 a tJ f11 i\l n ~11 ~ ~n ~rn.:; L tJ u 'U q

n11tHn1J11~~€l\lf1~~ kl ~W€l\lf1~~ rn LLti:;~~El\lf1~~ ct ~1Unl1~Ul\l~l1tJ11l'V'l1 'U 'U 'U ~

1 a 'it L ~'it b "IJ 1 U nJ ~ U <n 1 1J 1:; n 'it ~"lJ 11 1 'V'l bb 1 \l \ll 'it~ 1 \l "151 ~ bb ti:; U nJ ~ f1 'it rJ iJ €l \l n 'it f111J f1 11 QJ q Qlcu q

hf111:;L 1 \l~\l~1 ~"15tiu1 Ltlu kl tJ eJ~ L ~€1\l-;uln ~ 1111:;-;u:;r/( €J\l"1111:;L~ u 1 i nuwU.1 tJ\llUi\ln ~11 ~

J\l~a\l~~1tJ\llu ~\lrileJ\l1eJuL~uLtlu kl tJeJ~ L"IY11uu~ti:;uru~ ~.,1JJ1rilLtluL~eJ\l~~1Jn~ .,

~ n 11 1J n u~ b "1f 'it db~ €) tJ 111 tl 1:; n EllJ n lJ b d €) 'it 1 \l ~11 ~ 11 1 'V'l 1 ~ b €) n ~1 1 1J 1:; n EllJ 11 1 r/( 1 tJ

~ \l1dJ ~ L ~ <n ~ \l ~tJ LL~ n11~ u 1 \l ~11 tJ 111 'V'l11.t 1 L~ u 1 tl1 i'tl1:; 1 tJ -nt! ~1 ui11 ~ tJ tt 11t1 ~1 tJ ~ ~

fi11r1 tJU~LL nu1M'Yl "lrti u1TieJUrill f1lf~ ~ln ~ L n<n-;uln nl1~1rilL iJ tJu"IJ €l f111 11 L ~ 11 L~ 11ll q

1 i ~ 1 tJ b tJ 'it bb f1 "15 b ~ tJ { b -lr f1 bb ti:; li'U 1 f11 11 ~ l'll ~ ~ ,y €) <n n ti \l n lJ b ~ 1 "lJ €) \l u nJ ~ 1 ~ tJ ~ 1 tJ b ~'it .,

Lb f1 -n L ~ t1 f L -lr f1L in u u 1 \l ~11 t1 11 1 'V'l 1 1 <n t1 ~ ~ a., f1 ~ ~ k1 LL ti:; ~ ~ a., f1 ~ ~ rn 1 JJ 1 d~ u ~ 'U 'U 'U

LLti:; ~~ eJ\lf1~~ ct L ~u11 <nl 11 f11~\l LL~\l ~._, f1 rn.:;n11aJn11~au"JJ a b'n-;u-;u1\l 1rllih~u~ 'U

1:;tJ:;ntil1i~au~1u1iL~1-;u~u11ltJLu1:;tJ:;ntil ctcf 1-u i.,tfu Ld€J~un1~u~nti1 ct<f 1-u

Page 33: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

' ~.J n ~l1 f1 rn~ n1'HJ nl1&Hlui m Y1 -;r'il1.J ~ .J V13J ~ 8l u l ~ ~ .J nl1Yl f1 rn~ n113J n l1iHl1J

i m = ~ ~ 1.J ~l L ii, u n l1 ~EJut1l EJLu~ .J LU u nl1n1~rh 1~ r/laJ aj 8ltt l~ nl1~ f1 rn~n113J nl1

~EJ i m Y1 ~~'1.J1~u -;h ~ v:l EJ\l f1 ~ ~ 1£l LL ~ ~ ~ v:l EJ.J f1 ~ ~ ~ u1~ 3Jl i'l L ~ttL~ eJ eJ ~1.Ji'l mL 1 \l , 'IJ 'IJ

~\ll "15EJ1J~1 t.lnl)V13Jl u L 'V'l1l~ LdJ aj 8l u l ~ ~EJui eJ L Y1~ ~1.J LL~ ~ ~1u f11l3J L v; ttLL~1 aj r..J ~'Yll1 i f1 rn n113J nl1~EJui eJ L Y1 ~~1.J f11l3J 1u ~ ~ i'll \l ~ ~ L iJ ~ ~.J LL<1i.J i.J~tt 1 ~£JEll i u r..J ~ nl1

~El1J "ElLYl~~1.J~\lldJ"15EJ1J~1£JnnVI3Jl£J~1£J ~\ltftt f1l~.J"lleJ.J~rJnv:leJ.Jfl~~ GJ f11l3JLv;'U ::.v 'IJ 'IJ

~rl YJEJ\lfl~~ kl LL~~f..J~nl1~~l1llileli'l:IT1rn"lleJ\l~rJnv:leJ.Jfl~~ rn ~1i~v:leJ.Jfl~~ 1£J LL~~ 'IJ 'IJ , 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

~y:j .Jfl~~ ~ 1u~~"15~1iL~'U ~.JLU'Unl1ldJ"15EJ1J~1£Jnl)VI3Jl£J ~1'UU1~L~'Ufl1l3J1u~~"llel.J I I t.J I tJ' I

~v:l .Jfl~Vi 1£l LL~~~v:leJ.Jf1~Vi ~ iru Lv;tt1l L'iteJ.J~ln~n~unf11EJ.Ji'u~uLv;tt1l~v:leJ.Jf1~Vi 1£l 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ .

LL~~ "v:leJ.Jf1~~ ~ U1::3Jli'lL~'UL~EJEJ~l.Ji'lmL1\J L"littL~£J1nu~v:leJ.Jfl~~ G) u<1i~v:leJ.Jf1~~ G) 'IJ 'IJ

1u ~ ~ L Y) fJ \leJ ~ 1lf El fJ ~ ~ rn o "lJ El\l f11l3J L ri£JVIl fJ~ ~ un ~1'UL ~ £J1"JJ El.J 1~ fJ~ n f11l3J1'1J ~ ~ "lJ El \l ~ U \l f1u U ill "15 l1 ~ ~ 1J L VI ii, El ~ 'U l U El El n f El fJ ~ ~ 1£J o LL <1\1 'U ~ 1 'U "lJ El .J ~ y:j El \l fl ~ ~ 1£J

'IJ ... 'IJ

LL~~ "v:l El.J fl ~ ~ ~ n n ~U\l f1u U ru "15l1 'U 1~ ~ 1J ~ .J~ 'U l tJ an ~ El 'U l £J LL 'V'l i'l tJ ~l:ITl1 rn~"ll 'IJ ... 'IJ ,

~\l VI <U ~ "15 ~ u1 LL<1i f'll ~ u n f11 El.J .ffu~ 'U, n ~ 1J LdJL~ u l f11l3J11J ~ ~"ll El \l ~ U.J f1u uru "15l1~ ~ 1J , 'IJ ...

L VI ii, El ~ 'U l U ~ .J n ~ l1 3J l ~ n El El n 1 iLL n ~ y:j El.J f1 ~ ~ 1£J LL ~ ~ ~ y:j El \l f1 ~ ~ ~ LL <1\ El ~ l.J 1 ~ 'IJ 'IJ

~\JL"' ttnl1LdJ"15EJ1J~1£JnnV13Jl£J ~.Jttu Vllnf'll~Lv;'Ull ~v:leJ.Jfl~~ kl LL~~~v:leJ.Jfl~~ ~ ::.v 'IJ 'IJ

n ~1 U U 1 ~ 3J l i'l L ~ 'U L ~ El El ~ l \l fl fJ LL 1 \l n "15 El1J ~ ~ ~ r/( El \l U l ~1 'U ~ ~ U \l f1u U ill "lfl ~ ~ ~ El \l n 'IJ ...

~1u '13J1u~~~1£J~neJEJn~ln~1tt~~v:leJ.Jf1~~ 1£l u~~~v:leJ.Jfl~~ ~ ~~~EJ\l1u~~~1£J 'IJ 'IJ

El~l UEJ£J1tteJ~1li'El£J~~ l!:Jo L"ri'UL~£J1rl1J~v:leJ\lf1~~ GJ ~v:leJ\lfl~~ 1£J LL~~~v:leJ\lfl~~ ~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

~\l f1 ' 11'u ~~"15El1J 1 'Ufl1l3J L ri£JVIl £J LdJ diu5 ~1li'El £J ~~ rn o "lJ EJ\l f11l3J L ri£JV1l £J

"lJ EJ1 if'll ~un fl1El\l ~\l ~~ n f1l~'V'lln ~ln ~1J f1l~'V'lln~lf'll ~un fl1EJ\l.ff'U,~'U, 'IJ ,

~v:leJ.Jf1~~ rn Eli'l:IT1rn1l nl1~~v:leJ.Jfl~~ rn ~El\l'h3JLUttn113Jnl1 'IJ , 'IJ

~ \l ~ fJ 3j El; EJ1 'U 1u LiJ n L ~ 'U 1 'U 1 fl1 \l n l1 U ~ 1 U 1 ~ n 'U ~"ll lll 'V'l ~ \l El ~ 1 'U flll 3J 1 1J ~ ~ "15 El1J , 'IJ

"lJ El\l l fJLLf..J'U\ll'U i11-ri~l £J1J'1VIl1~ ~'UL El\l ~\l n ~ El ~ LL~ ~nVI Ul ~fu ~ ~"15El1J 1 ~ fJ ~1-:1 L rteJ\l~ln 'IJ

L~1 3J El1JVI3Jl u~ln ~u-:~ f1uu~"Ir1 LL~~-,]1~ EJ\lu l)u~~13J LL6J~~"ll~nu1~uun11ul)u~\l1tt

~13-J 1 £J\l1'U LL~~n11~ ~v:l E)\) f)~~ rn LU'U~ ~\l'Ul3J 1 u 1u LU m~U3J1nflf.Jn11n113Jn11rl1U~U 'IJ 'IJ

Luu 'V'l11~u 1\l ~11 ~1l1'V'l1 EJ1f1u-ri el\ll1\l"ll EJ-:~n11tll)u&i.Jlu 1~VI11-:JVI'ib u-:~1u ~<111\l i.Jn ~

L 'V'l1 ~~y:j El\lfl ~~ rn iJ1-ri1Jf1f1~1n11 U~1 £JLLf..JU\l1U ~~~i'l1l1Ji El3J~ 1 Un11U nu~-:11'1-tL :n\l~ n 'IJ , 'IJ ~

R '),.-r-·

3 0 s. ' / . \ - \ ll~Lrhnu .. .

Page 34: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

lb "'W IA,l§>~I,'[email protected]':jj

F'f=' t.;."'tt. '.J L.: s

'-

lb

t1.JbLyt1 IA.LI1 P~'Wf.'Gt'OGil~ 't1.L..'t1.L~l§>t;11krfLL..~'t1.l..~l§>~~l,'-~ W ~~~l,'-@~,t3N~IT.'t1.L..~'t1.tl.'~ lb

~ t l§>.ll.l.'@ ~'t1.t1 LlG111t't1. t rfL't1.1.'-~,t3 ~ ti.L..~ l§>~l§>'t1.1s1.q1Lrf@ ~ ls1. 1 ~ ti.L..~L!ll.'~ L..~11'11.@ !JI1G.U.l§>t;l1l-I.'G ~

'11. _!\ ti.LI.'-11 L..')'\.ls1. '11. t L.U.fu _ct 11 ~ 1.'-_ct ~I.'~ rf U. ti.LI.' ~_ct g J1 ~ ~ L ;ttls1. L~ 1 ~ l§> t; 11l-rf LL.. ~'11. L..~ l§>~ 11 l)p ..... I'& I I

lb lb

nG l.A.Ll ~uu::~ l§> t; 11l-I.'G ~ u~nt1 LlG, 11t't1. treLnl.'~,t3~ nr..~l§>~ n J'bl.'~ l.'~ls1. nr..~u~ntWG111t n t lb .,.

rf L't1.1.'-~,t3:!'11.L~'t1. t l§>t; 11l-l.'@~~l§>t;l1l-rfLL..~I1~rfU.LrfL!li.'~L..~1, l.'lbls1. ,1 L~I.'~L~~Llll.'@ IT.L~L.. 11.'-L..fl-

::~ ~,'11. t 11 @.(l.l§> t; 11l-rf LL..~:!~1, ~ L;ttls1.~ L ti.L~ I.'@ IT.tl. L..~ l§>~ rf Ll§> l§> t; 11l-l.'@ ~ Ll ~ L, '11. ~~L;ttls1. L~ 1 ::~,,

ti.LI.'-'11.1':1,1 11 Lt;:ll.'@ IT.ti.LI.'~_ctg J1~Lll~11 ~11~L!f rf ~ 11L..~~Lll '11. t~L;ttls1.~ ~ L.U.fu _ctl1~ 1.'-_ct~:!ti.L.~tl. t b

l§> ~ls1.1.' ~IT.~'IU~L!L L~ ~ lA. tv1. ,111 L '11. L~l1 ~~ !j. ~@~~I.'~~~~ 1@ ~11@~~LUrf~~Ll:!'tU ~ L~ JP~ '11. ~, ::~ b lb

~,:!>~Gil 't1.11LI1'11.Ll GilGil lA.'t1.L..I.'-~1111't:)l ~11~.U.l§>l..ls1.1.'-~~Lll.U.L~Ll..l':l@l§>@'t1.~11.'[email protected]@~ 1"'1) F' l"b 1"'1) p 1"'1) l"b I((, I ~ J!:J ft.

lb

~Lure~~u::m~I.'GIT.I.'~~~~ w~nr..~I1@~'11.LI.'-11L~reLl§>L'tt1~L~~uLis1. Ul.'~ n~nff., ~ ~~~I.'G~,t3 " " ' lb .,.

I.'@IT.'Ul~Lli1~L..I1~,'11.f!"., l§>t;l1l-I.'@~U~ w ~~~l.'@~,t3~'11.L~Ll~Lrf I.'@ ~L..I1 ~, ~~L;ttls1.L~,:!'t1.L~'t1. t b ~ lb lb ~ lb

tv1.Ll!IT.~'t1.~:!~J1~l§> _ct~Lll n~1 '11. t ti.LI.'~_ct~ ft~Lll ~,, l§> [email protected]§> t; 11l-,t31.' ~ rf L..~ ti.LI.'~_ct ~ J1,t3 (,7J I'D lb 1\

:!'t1.L~'t1. t '11. Ll.'-'11.1':1,, 11 L~ ~L;ttls1.L~ 1 I.'@ IT.l§> t; 11!rf LL..~:: ~11 w ~~~I.'@ ~,t31.'@ IT.L.U.rli _ctl1~ l.'_ct,t3 ' '

I.'@ IT.l§>t; 11!f'f LL..~L!l~l~~w~Llti.[J1 I.'~ JPbti..U.I1 1 :!~J1Lis1.1.'-L..~,, fb~ L!l~g. 1}11~ ,,a.~,@~l.'~rfLL~@ ~ ' " ' b

rf ~m ~ 1 J1~ tl.tWG, 11t L!l:!~,, 1.'-~L~ 11l§>1 ~Llltl. !j., L~~tv1.Ll!l1 L..L~ 1.'-Lti.Ji t 11 ~,::~::~1111@ ~ ftfl. t~ b ~ lb b

~tv1.Ll!l1 L..L~I.'L '11.1.'-@ IT.ti.LI.'~_ct~ f1~Lll~1, l§>rf ~11L..~I.'@ ~~ ti.LI.'-'11.1':1,, 11 L~ I.'@ IT.~L;ttls1. ti.[J, ~ ~L~L ti.!L

LlL~'t1.tWG1 f1~~Lll't1.@ l§>ti.E- 1.'-~Ll~ nl§>l1l§>1 't1.LI.'~£bgf1~ ~L;ttls1.L~ 1 11~Lyt 1 L..L~Lli.'~~Llln~1 " " ' . lb b

'11. tl1 L~LlG1~Llll.'@ IT.l§>l1 ~ 1 ::~ 11 L~I.'-~11L~IA.(l~ w ~~~I.'@ ~,t3 ~l§>ls1., :!L~M 1 t1.@p~~~Llll1 L~l1~

1.'-11 ~,~Llt L~ L, L..L~~I1l§>11T.~1 L..~I1@~~L..~~I.'-11 tt-1 ~11)p~l.'~ 1.'-L,(bl§>t~fu_ct~t '11.@1 G%,1s1. 't1.UI1 llbls1.Ji t

't1.G 1J1~ L!ll.'@ ~::~ L..L~Lll.'~tl.tWG, 11trf L~'t1.t1 11 L~LlG1~Lll L~l1 ~1JP~ l§>l1 ~1 ::~ 11 L~I1L~IA.~L@ ff~ lb

w ~~~!,'-@~~ '11._!\ -Pl!J11A.LI1'11.~11 ~ Ll~~g.1}11~1.U.~1,L~~'t1.L..~~::~11 -Pl!J,IA.LI1'11.~, ~ 't1.L..'t1.L~Ll~ ' " '

~- PlJOJUl~- Gt- w~o ~IT.~1~fu_ctL~1t1.@p~11 -Pl!J,IA.LI1'11.L~ Gil 't1.t1'11.fJ1 P- ~o~oGt- Gil- w~o lb lb lb b

~IT.~1~rli_ctL~1'11.@11.'-@~::~wt1t1l§>@l1~11l§>1 ~- ~~o~o- ~- w~o ~rr.m~ru_ct "Gil ~~rli_ct't1.U.'t1.t1, I I I I

~fu_ctllL~'I1.t1'11.@l1~Lll't1.fJ,I.'~ ~lJ~Gil rf~Lis1.1.'~ lJ ~'t1.~1.'~11_ct't:)l't1.t1'11.@l111trfL~ tl.fl-1 lb b

1.'-~~'11.~, I.'~~ ti.L.. 't1.L~'t1. t 't1.t111 L~LlG, G%,1s1. 1.'-~~tl.t, 11 L~LlG1Ji t~~ti.@~Lll~L~@~ 11.'-~ls1. l§>t;~t L~1 ' . '

lb

w ~~~I.'@ ~,t3 J1. t 1.'-L..~ Ll@ ~ ls1.@ ~ 1 11 G Ll:!~J1Lrf I.'@ ~L..I1 !J, ffk::~ ,'t1.t1 LlG ,~Llll1~1.'@ ~L..I1 !J 1 ~ 1 I I I I

b lb

I.'~~~Ll@1 L !ll1l§>111 L~l1l§>~~!L~~@ ~11@~~L..~~~Llll.'-11 ~1U~ ls1.@ ~ 1 I.' !~11@ [1rfL't1.1.'~ w ~~~I.'@ ~,t3 ..... I I ..... I

b

J1. t L rf '11. t, Ll G 1 11 t ~ L ~ Ll @ 1 L !ll.' ~ ~ tv1. L l! 11 L.. L ~ I.' L '11. '11. L I.' '11.1':1 11 11 L ~ '11. t ~ L ;tt ls1. L ~ 1 11 ~ L [A. 1 )p k

;JJW

Page 35: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~~ ~fl~~ m Lv;U1l nl')fllVI'U~~~~1'Ufl1l6JflJ~~Wri'Ud rln~tl~ LL~::LtJUTITI6JLLrlL~lVIUl~ ~ ~

6Jln 1lnl')tllVI'U~~~~1'Ufl1l6JflJ~~i~~ ~rln~ f)~fl~~ l£J Yhll')llil L'\Al')l::~rln~ f)~fl~~ l£J ~~ ~~

ii L~ 0

l"ll m rh:r;u1 ~LL~::fl1l6JL~ r.J1"1l f)~ 1 'U~l'U::t~\Jn u~ ~l'U6JloW ';Jl')llil116J~ 1 mm.J Ltl 'Ut-J~ 1lX ... ~ :w

~~ ~fl~~ m ~~iJL~L~ r.J1"1i' tl~ 1u~lU1fl')~nl')1h::nu~"lJ11l'Y'ln ~lJ ~ e:J~fu ~ ~"15~ 1 "lfL~'U 1lXLL ri ~ ~

Vl'!-i r.J~l'U"lJ e:J~f~ LtlWillU 1U~~~ ~~ 6Jlnn1l L~lVIUl~ ~iJ nu~~l'Ufl'U~U ~~ tl~fl~~ m ... ~ ~ ~ :w ~

" "lJ f) 1 .., f'll ~iJ n fl')f)~ ~ ~ ~~iJ f1loW '\All n ~l Ll n f1loW '\All n ~l"lJ f)~ f'fl ~ iJ n fl')f) ~ i'u~U 1 'U~1'U"lJ f)~ ~ ~

nl') 0 lVIU~fl1laJ1u~ ~"lJ e:J~ ~~ e:J~fl~ ~ m 1~ r.J'I-b"ll m r1 ';1';11 ~L ~ r.J1n u ~l'Ul';JV1Ul~1 u nl')

~

u~ Gl~l'U"lJf)~~~f)~fl~~ m ~1aJil~1'UL ~ r.J1"1l f)~rllJnl')~lL Uu~l'U~l6J 1fl')~nl')U~Ji.JJ::nu ~"lJn '\Al LL~::;~~1'Ufl1laJ1u~~-ne:Ju1u~lul-;uV\ul~"lJf)~~u~f1uuru-nl ~~f)~-;uu~unu~~lu~~f)~ ~ ~ ... ~ :w

1u~ "ne:JU~ e:J~lu1u1fl')~nl')U ~JUJ::nu~"lJ11l'Y'l1~ r.J~J~ aJl~ ne:Je:Jn-;uln~1Ufl1laJ1u~ ~"lJtJ~ ~

~~ ~fl~~ m Vl~~-;uln~1~t.b~1u"1Je:J~fl1l6J~~'\Al~l~un'Y'l1e:J~"1Jf)~Vl'l-i1r.J~lu"1Je:J~1~ V~1e:J ~ ... "lJf)~ ::uu~l'U~1'U')16J6Jl~ ne:Je:Jn-;uln~~~1'Ufl1l6J11J~ ~"l]f)~~~ f)~fl~ ~ m <lll6J6Jl<l!Jl ~ 1Tifl~6J

~

~ bl n ~f)~ fl ~ ~ COl LL ~:; ~ bl n ~f)~ fl ~ ~ m LL n f)l'lll') rn 1l ~ ~ ~ tJ ~ fl ~ ~ l£J ~~ ~~ ~ ~

LL~:; "'v:J f)~ fl ~ ~ ~ f)'Ylll')rn 1l '):;1J1J 1 fl') ~ nl')U <ll ')U'):; nu ~"ll 11l '\Al"ll f)~ n'):;'Y]')1~ ~llll')lli~"ll ~ ~ ~

~1lX 0 lt:t'n~lU~llll')lli~"ll~~Vl1 ~~l L U unlJ J u ~lt:t' n~l'U~llll')lli~"ll~~Vl1 ~ ~1u 1 VI nh:: ~ ~ ...

6J tl V16Jl r.J 1lX ~l r.J LLt-J'U~l 'U~l Lit U nl')LL ~ ::fu ~ ~ "1! tJ 1J ilL~ 6J tJ 1J V16Jl r.J 1 i ~l r.J nl')L~ U

fl11J fl 6J ~ LL ~ ~ n ~ ~ L aJ u J l n 1l1l iJ n l J 'Yl ';) 1 <ll L ~ r.J 1 n lJ 1 fl J ~ n l J i ~ n ~ l11 'U ~l -u n ~ l 'U ~ ~ :w ~

~lll ')ffi~"lJ~~Vll~~'U') fl1l6JL~r.JVllr.J~Lll~~U1Ufl~dLn~-;uln~~f)~fl~~ l£J ~~f)~fl~~ m ~ ~ ~

LL~:: ~ e:J~fl ~~ ~ iiL~<ll')1';J ~tllJ Ltln ~l')nl')L un~l r.Jn tl'U~~ ~l r.J ~ tl~tl 1 U 1url tl'UL~'U 'Ylnfl~~ ~

Vlln "~tl~fl~~ l£J ~~tl~fl~~ m LL~:;~~tl~fl~~ ~ <lJ')1';J~tllJLtln~l')nl')LUn~lr.Jrie:Ju ~ ~ ~

~~ ~ r.J ~ tl ~f) 1 'U 1u bl f) 'UL~ 'U 'Yl n fl~~ -;u1 ~ n -;u:; '\AllJ 1l nl')L U n bl f) 'Ufl~~ 1~ L tJu-;u1 ~ LL~:; fl~~ 1~ ~

Ltlu l')n')::Yll'Yl';J1<ll i~J u fl1laJL~r.JVIl r.J~ Ln ~nl')'Yl';J1<l!~u 1u 1fl')~nl')U<lJ')U')::nu~"ll11l'Y'l"lltJ~ ~ ~ ~

~lur~l'U~llll')ru~"lJ~~Vl1 ~-n~u1~ ~ii 1~L n ~-;ulnfl1l6J~ ~'\Al~l~un'Y'l-Ie:J~"ll f)~Vl'l-i 1 r.J~lu ~ ~

"lJtl~ ~<lllaJ~~v:ltJ~fl~~ l£J ~~tl~fl~~ m u~:;~~tl~fl~~ ~ eJl~ ~1Uf1l~~LL~~i~ .... ~ ~ ~

flrn::n')')aJnl')~e:Ju"ll m 11-;u-;)1 ~nlVIU~ 1 i fl ru::n')')aJ nl')~e:Ju ~1u 1lXL~1-;u ~unl r.J 1 u ~ rf. 1u

uuu 'uJ::munJJaJnl')~e:Ju"ll m r1-;u-;u1~1u'Yl')l1Jf1l~~ ndnt du')::lllUn')')aJnl')~e:Ju"ll tJ L r1-;u-;u1~

Page 36: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

' '

n11~';111lli1LUU~1"vl.1U:IJ1n f1rn::n11~n11~8u-iJmrl';J';J'1.:!~-:!l~"ll8"llr.J1tJ1:;tJ:;L1~1n11~81J~1U

~ 8~ 8 8fifl1i.:l ~ 8U1 tJLL "v''H'l ~ ~11i11lli~"ll~.:!VIl Wll'~U1LtJ U~1U1U rn fl~-:1 f1rn:;n116Jfi11 ~ ~ ~

~81J-iJ m Yl';J-;)'1-:!l~ ~1L U Ufi11LL~1 L~';JJ11 tJ 1 U'l:;tJ:;L 1~1~"11 8"11 r.J1 tJ

~1Uf111~fu~~"ll8-:!~v:l8-:!f1~~ rn ~.:~u~u~wJ1~i1VIU1~1tJU1VI11.:!1U~1LU ~ ~ ~ 8 n U~1 L UUL 1 ~1VI ~1 tJU LL~:;1u ~ ~"ll'81J-:11U n11L~ULL~:;uru; ti( 8.:1 ~ .:IU 16J b18UL~U

"' 1uuru;~1.:1 ') ~1naJ1tJ .:!1U~~v:J8-:!f1~~ rn 1u~~"ll'81J';J:;ti(8.:1<il11"il~81JL8n~11U1:;n8un11

"' - ~

LiJn~1 tJ 1 un11~.:1U1~~1~un~ LL~Lu vn:;n11~.:1u1~1 u 1ur18UL~u 1 U-:11ULL1.:1.:11U~1.:1"11'1~

n~ul.6.1~11"il~ LL~~.:~ii.:~aJ1~1~1Un11Uiiu~-:~1uLtl tJ-:1 Luu l.u 8 ci1.:1~1n LL~:;fl~d'LtJun11 ~ "' dJ

£Jn tJ8nLU tl~U.:IL~U 1~ tJL6J ~~~VIii' ci 8~ LL~~-:~1 iL v;u l1~v:l8-:!fl~~ rn 1.6.1~~1"il~81J L8n~1J ~ ~

n11LiJn~1 tJ"il1.:~ Ltlun11~.:1u1~ 1 i~n11LiJm~uu~:;'ib l.u1 i'Ltluu1:; 1tJ"ll'U~1ui1 ~8~f1~ 8.:1

rl1Jfl11i fi11"lJ8-:IU1.:1~1tJJ11"r'l1 'Yl8-:IL ~ru ~1VIll ~ 8f1rn:;n11~n11~81J-iJ m Yl"il"il'1-:!f1116J11J ~~ ~ "'

'1'11.:1 ~:; dJ ~"ll 8.:1 L ~1 VI U1~ fi11U ~ u~ VI U1 ~"ll 8.:1 ~.y:j 8.:1 f)~~ rn iil.~1 if111 ~d:; 61' ~1:;1.:~ ~16J ~~f111 1 Un11~11"il ~81J L8fi~11U1:;n 81Jn11b18UL~ U~1~~U1.:1~11 tJ J11"r'l1L~umi 8U

~

~.:IU16J1 U 1ub18UL~U ~v:J8-:Ifl~~ rn 1 U~1U::n11~fi11~~-:IU1~1 u1ur18UL~U"il1nliU1f111 ~ "' ~

~1U1U dGJ fl~-:1 LL~:;£J"'.:~l~~.:IU1~b18UL~U';J1fiUnJ;L~U'YlU~ kJ 116Jrl1Jn11~n11fl"H.~U~n "' ~

G) fl~-:1 ~.:I L UU'VHl ~ n11rn~ ~ 8l~l1 L tJ u n11n1::rh 1~ tJU1:;6J1'Yl L ~UL ~ 8 8 ci1-:lf1 tJ LL d .:1

r111i'Yl1.:111"ll'n11L~1uf111aJL*tJVI1 tJ ~.:~~ 8.:~1u~~"ll'~ 1 ifi1~u I. VI~'Yl~LL 'YlU~umi'Yl1.:111"ll'n11

~16J i~ ~1ULL ~.:lf111 ~1u ~ ~"ll'8u1 un11U~U~VIU1~ ~1Ufi11~U1 tJ LL "r'l'Yl ~~11i11lli~"ll ~.:!VIl~"ll'~u1L6JL~·;h~fu ~~~1 mfu L "r'l11::LUU~U.:If1uuru"ll'1~ L vi-:~~111J11"ll'n11LL~:;Ltlu

~ ~ "'

tr"r'lu n11n1::Y11'Yl';l'1~ iii.~ ~.:1u1 ~ 8u61'~1 iL iJn~1 tJ 1.6.11.~ ~.:1u1 ~b18UL~u u~:;Lri 8 Ltlu ~ ~ ~

n11'ih m~u~I.6J ~~~VId'8 ~';11.:~ ~u.:~f1uuqJ"ll'1~.:~1.6JI.~u~u~VI'IX1~11"ll'n11~1 tJf111 ~ U1:;6J1'Yl L~UL~ 8 8 ci1-:lf1 tJ U'l-:1 LL~:;L6JL~Ltlutrri 81 iL n~f1116JL*tJVI1 tJLLrl11"ll'n11

~

"ll81if11~unf118-:~~.:~~~~"r'l1m~1LLnLtlu1 itJnv:l8-:~"ll8-:~trv:l8-:~f1~~.:~~ . ~ ~ ~

~r1nv:l8-:!fl~~ kJ LLrl8'Ylli1rn 1u~1U~trv:J8-:Ifl~~ rn 8'Ylli1rnl1 iiL~n1:;t'11 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

1~ tJU1:;~1'YlL~UL~ 8 8 ci1.:1f1 tJLL'l.:lttU ~r1nv:J 8-:lfl ~~ kJ "lJ 8~ 8L81Tl11 in11LL~:;f118'Ylli1rn ~ ~ ~

~I o v ft !LuUf11 LLn 8'Ylli1rn ...

~

Page 37: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

-· ~ \. flo

"" W U,~~!;@M.i';lf F' F=' ~.:& .. ,... __ .~( 'l:l'S 0 [ )*'1 _,/

' ~~- .. ~~;-. '~.·~ / ./~ , r:1 ?' t;. ~ '~·i ~--.V ~--~~ ~-:---~~;~;--

flo floflo b

C9l ~~~t'-8~~ L~'lt~1 'lt_!t w ~~~b'8~Ul1~b'81T._!11!.!LU.8L'I11!.L~~!.LU~I':lb'~11f1f~~~'lt~ ~11f1_!1. I f"' I I

flo flo flo

'It~ o~ L~l1::11::!.'1tti1Lll~~b'8~'1tU ~ ~~~b'8~~ w ~~~b'8~~ C9l ~~~b'8~~ L~l1 I I I I

b floflo floflo

'lt~'lt,2-t'8!.~Uf1~L~~!.LU L~JU!.!LU.8 w ~~~b'8~UL1~::~11 <!> ~~~t'8~UL1~ f\ I I I

b b

~t t'L~ 8 ~11~f1~lt.~~lr1.b'~IT.~'l11!.L!LL~ ~ U.M. 1111 L'ltb'8 IT.t'!. 1111 L~t'L~ 8 8 ~1'11,~1 U.Lrt:::!.f1rt: Ll

~L ,itlr1. ~,Cb Qf1!.LUUL~~ ~1L~b' ~~~ ~ 1G ,lf.(!UL!.f1 !1~ lL~Ut'~I1Lir1.11~1rt:Ll~UL~t'8 ~ 1~~ U88 I ~Lrt: b b

~f1~lt.~~lr1.b'~IT.~'l11!.L!L~~U.M.11r3L'Itb'81T.~ ~r1frtLl~L!bl1!.Lrt:~!1~ L~'lt~1 'It _!1. 'lt~'ltJl. 1b'8~M.U 11 ~1 ~

~ "' flo b b

'It Lt'~,Cb!;! f1::~11 L.U.fU £bf1~b'£b~'lt~1 ~n; ~.U.~ ~lr1.t'~IT.~'l11!.L!LL~ ~ U.M. 1111 L 'It~ ~ ~~~ t'-8 ~ ::~11 flo flo flo

C9l ~~~t'8~~UL~t'8!}1 11l~ ow ::~118_tttl'ltL~U~ <!> ~~~b'8~~f1~'1t~ll1~1'1tJl.1 ~ ~~~ @~~ I I I I

flo

::~11 C9l ~~~t'8~~~t~~r1fl't:Ll~'ltl~U~!.l~b'~ 'lt_!tb'~ ow ;:~118~'1tl'ltL~ <!> ~~~1,'8~. !,'8fT. ' "' '

flo "' flo

~ ~ r1fl't: Ll~ttl '11, L~8 ~ 1r1. 1 I,'~ o C9l ;:~ 11 8_tU ~~ t <!> ~~ ~ 1,'8 ~~ t'-8 fT.L.U.fU £bf1~ b',Cb~ t' 8 IT.'It f~'l1, t

~ ~ r1fl't: Ll~ U ~;: ~ 11 o;> ;: ~ 11 8 _t '11, l 'It L~ U 8 8 rt: l!. ~ L-~'11, Lb' f1 n;;:!,~; 8 IT.8~1r1.Kft'8 fT.'ItLb' ~ l't1, lr1.

flo flo

b'81T.t'8~M.Uf1~L~M.~~rt:Ll~UL~t'G~1 1J ~~~b'8~~t'~ <!> ~~~b'8~~t'81T.~~r1f flo flo

'11,L,~U~~~tt~'lt,2-t'8!.~Uf1~L~~ ~ ~~~t'-8~~ C9l ~~~b'8~~~rt:L~~~r1fl't:Ll~'lt , I I I I

~'11,\r1.L~!.LU'I1,L,~ JU!.!LU.G~11L~'It~1 o;>;>Cil t1.11LU~~l1M. C.Cil ~'11,~1;~ P<;Cil®Wf~·c;o~o b b

~~U.tl.L-~::~11 P~;>Cil rt:~Ll'lt!L flo' U.ttlt'~ ~~~ww1~·c;o~o ~u u. ~~U.ttl~ p ~ I f"l) f=' f"'"" F=' J=' I 1 I I I

tti1LU~~l1M. <!><!> U.'ltlt'~ w;>Cil®Wf~·c;o~o ~u u. ~~U.'Itl~ t'L~u.u.furtrt:!.U8~t'tt ~ f't""" F' F' F='ro IY"I"'ll

b

_!11!.!LU.8L~::~m.LU ~ t L~L81G ~8fT. 'lt_!t t'!.11rl L~b'L~88 ~1'1t~1U.U'f::!.f111~1 L~;t::!.U~~!l~ L~t'L31 ~1~ ~ '

flo flo b

~ ~~~1,'8~~;:~11 Ul ~~~t'8~~b'81T._!11!.!LU.8!.LU'Itl~'ltt U~~~~~r1fl't:Ll~'ltl~U~Lrt:'ltt1'1t L1f1t flo ~ flo .

'Itt rt: L 'Itt'~~!. LU rt:!.!.U::'It L~'lt t w ~ ~ ~ t'-8 ~~ 1,'8 IT.~ L ,it lr1. L!,A.!.LU G ~ t'-8 ,lf.L-11 ~ 1'1t t.,~ ~~ [! t' ~

(, '11,~ ~ ~~~t'-8 IT.t'8~M.Uf1rt: Ll~L!b~L8!1~;:~11 l~11rt:~::Lrt:lr1. 1 b'~ w ~~~t'-8 ~~1,'8 IT.~~ r1f b flo

'It l~ t' f1 11 L '!11!.L ~ ~ L rt: rt: !.!. U!.!L L !b!.LU 'It _!1. I,'~ !.L U rt: !.!. U ::'111 ~ b' 8 IT.f1!. 'Itt~ L ,it lr1. L~;t::!.U!. L ~ '

UL~b'8~ 1 ~~ 'lt~b'L~U~11~ t ~~r1fl't:Ll~'ltl~~~~'ltlr1.L~!.LU'Itt L'l11!.L~~8 ,lf.'lt~1Lrt:'ltt111Ll Ut}1 flo flo

!.LU'It Ur1fb'8 ,lf.L-11 ~ 1 rt: Ll~ 8~\(\. ~ L,tt \(\, l''tllr1. 11 L~ L!bl1!.Lrt: L~ !1~ ttt1'1t 8 L1 rtt '11, trt: Lttt'~ ~

!.LU rt:!.!.U b'8 IT. ttl~ '11, t ~ ~ r1fl't: Ll~'ltl~b'f111!.LU::~ 11 'It~ L-11 ~ 1 ~ lr1. 1 ::L!.M. 1'11,~~ ~ 1 ~ (,'It? 11 L!. flo

ttt1tt8 L1f1t'lt trt: L 't1t'~ ~!.LUrt:!.!.Ub'8 IT.~~ r1fl't:Ll~f1~ll1 ~1'1tJl. 1'1tt1tt8 L1f1ttt t 8~8 ~11 L~b'~~8 ~

[, t'L~'ItLK U ~ lr'\.!.L~ U 81 f1 8~ l!.l!.~!.LU 't1 t f1 8 ~ f1 8!.1,'~;:!,~ lf ::!.rt: Ll~~ ~~(! 11 ~1 'ltt1'1t8 L1 rtt

flo "" ~ b flo

'11, t rt: L 'It I,'~~!. LU rt:!.!.U::'It L~'lt t~ L,it lr1. ~,Cb!;! f1~~~ ~ 1r1. 1;: L!.M. 1'11, ~~ ~ 1 w ~ ~ ~ t' 8 ~~I,' 8 IT. flo b

~~r1fl't:Ll~ 'lt_!t w ~~~b'8~~b'81T.~~r1fl't:Ll~ttl~~~~'t1\r1.L~!.LU'I1,L,~ _!11!.!LU.8~11L~t1.~1 ~ '

pw

Page 38: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~v:JPJ.Jfl~~ rn fJ'Yl1i'HUfl1~.JL1£Jn1~~~1"1fL~U~fJ~rmv:JPJ.Jfl~~ G) LdfJlU~ 19'! n·m!J1fi3J 'IJ ~ 'IJ 'IJ

kl<lcib'll LL~~~v:lfJ.Jfl~~ ct PJ'Yl1i1rnf11~.J~.Jn~11~fJ~tinv:lPJ.Jfl~~ G) LdPJ1u~ b'll n1n!J1f13J 'IJ ~ 'IJ 'IJ

kl<lcib'll ~fJ3J1~t~nv:lfJ.Jfl~~ G) l~ih'Jt!.J~fJ~.JlU~ kl\:> n1n111flaJ kl<lcib'lf LL~.Jl1~WfJ.Jfl~~ kl 'IJ'IJ ~ 'IJ

~v:JfJ.Jfl~~ rn LL~~~v:JfJ.Jfl~~ ci l~~UfJ'Ylli1rUil1£J1Un1V'lU~LL~1 V'l1n~.Jl1Jl<;)1'u~~n1~';111lli1 'IJ 'IJ ~

PJ'Yl1i1rnn1 £J 1 UL n1 ~u1u t!uu~1u ~ ~ UfJ'Yl1i1rn ~~UfJ'Yl1i1rn~ ~'Yln~u v:l fJ.Jfl~ ~ PJf11~1Jnfl1fJ.J ~ ~ 'IJ ~

~~ L "ll~ B1U1';11l1 £J1 UL rl1 ~1JlU t!u LL~lU ~Ufll'VlU~ Lrl1~1JlU ,Xu LL~lU ~l1Jl~1'1J LL ~.J~ ~ n11~';111lli1fJ'Yl1i1rU';J1n~tinv:lfJ.Jfl~~ G) ~.J~v:lfJ.Jfl~~ kJ l~1'u'Vlt!.J~PJLdPJ1u~ rno

~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

n1n!J1f13J kl<lcib'lf ~v:lfJ.Jfl~~ rn l~1'u'Vlt!.J~mdPJ1u~ klb'lf n1n!J1f13J kl<lcib'lf ~v:lfJ.Jfl~~ ct

l~1'u'Vlt!.J~mdPJ1u~ kl~ n1n!J1fi3J kl<tctb'lf ~.J~fJ.JL~aJt!u1~£J~L1~1~Uf11v:lPJ.J1V'l11 ~13-1 3-11 ~11 <to 111fl ~PJ.J LL ~.J'V'l1~11"1furunT~..ij ~i.Jf11 ~l.Jn f11PJ.J LL~~1li~-;u11ru1 fl~l.Jn fl1fJ.J

"' "' I t,.l I I I

Y.L f1. kl <tctkl ~ m1aJt!u~.J u~1wYil~1'uVlt!.J ~fJ~\In ~11-;u1 n ~nnv:l fJ.Jfi~Yi G) ~v:l PJ\1 fi~Yi kl 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

~y:j fJ.Jfl~~ rn LL~~~y:j fJ.Jfl~~ ci l<;)1'1JLL~\I~'YlTin11W fJ.Jfl~ ~ Elf11~1Jnfl1€l\lfi11Jrl1V'lU~Ln1~1JlU 'IJ 'IJ

I I I I I I ~QJ,ci .=IQJe::l ~QJ&::I;

L3J€l1WYl kl~ ~~1fl3J kl<lcib'lf L3JfJ1U'Yl kl<l ~~1fl3J kl<l<i:'b'lf L3J€l1U'Yl kl\:> ~~1f13J kl<lcib'lf ~ ~ ~

~13-Jih~u ~WfJ.Jfl~~ kl ~WEJ.Jfl~~ rn LL~~~WEJ.Jfl~~ ci ~~'Ylnt.bf1~3J1WEJ.J~Elf11~1l1£J1u 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

I I I • QJ .c:i QJ e::l QJ Q

1U'Yl kl\:> 3Jn11fi3J kl<lci~ 1U'Yl klrn 3Jn11fi3J kl<l<i:'~ LL~~1U'Yl klci 3Jn11f13J kl<lci~

~13J~1~1J LL~~WEJ.Jfl~~ kl ~WfJ\Ifl~~ rn LL~~~WEJ.Jfl~~ ci l~tl1fi~3J1WEJ.J~Elf11mdEJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

v.d o,...o AQ...I.d dv.d 1'1-t'Yl G)kJ nU£J1£JU kl<lci~ L3JfJ1U'Yl <t ~~1fl3J kl<lci~ LL~~L3J€l1U'Yl kl~ ~~1fl3J kl<lci~

~ ~

~13J~1~1J n11WEJ\Ifl~"ll€l\I~WEJ\Ifl~~ k1 ~\I~WfJ.Jfl~~ ci ~\ILllun11~UWEJ.Jfi~LdfJ~U 'IJ 'IJ

.d 0 d I

1~£J~L1~1~13J'Yln!)Vl3J1£Jn1V'lU~~13J3J1~11 etC>'! LL~~3J1~11 <to 111fi'VlU\I LL~~111fl~El.J LLV'l.J

"' 'V'l1~11"1furunT~..ij~ ~._, f11 ~l.J nfi1EJ\I LL~~1li~-;u11ru1fl ~l.J n f11EJ.J vL f1. kl <tctkl "'"'

~1 Ufi113J L ~£JV'l1 £J~ L n ~~u-;u1nn111J~U~V'l u 1~"11 fJ\1 ~W fJ .J fl ~J._, ~~ ~~ L ~ £J

l111J l) u~ V'l iZ 1 ~ ~ 13-1 ~ 'Yl1 \111 "1f n 1 J n 1 V'l u ~ ~ l <;) L n ~ ';] 1 n fl113J 1J n 'V'l '± €)._') "lJ €)._') V'l U1 [J ._') 1 u

V'l1EJ1~1J1J.J1U~1U113J L rtEJ.J';J1nn113J €l1JV'l3J1 £J.J1U 1 ~ ~1 £J LL~U.J1ULUU~11J~ ~~€l1J~1L U Un11 'IJ

~ I I t,.l

113-1 'tl.J L n u1n 1!1-1 L~ULL 'YlU .yj-;u~ 1 ~ ~1 £J n11L~U V'l1 €l ~1 £J1J1V'l11 \11 U 'tl1ll.J ~1 L U un111X U

Lllun113J fJ1JV'l3J1 £J.J1U 1 un111Jl) U~11"1fn11"ll EJ\IU1 mL 'V'l'Yl u ~1i11lli~"ll..ij.JV'll ~LL~ ~~ LL ~._, ~ ~13J11tl ~

u1V'l11.J1ud:Jun111l1 £J1 u~13-1~ L ~u11 Lllun11~3Jfi11LL~~L V'l3J1~~3J ~1w~'un11LLU.J~1u

.J1U1l1 £J 1 U ,f U V'l U1 £J\11 ULL~ ~1J fl ~1 n11 U ~1,X n.J1 U~11i11lli~"ll..ij.J V'll ~ V'l ~1 £J LL ~ .J nl~ ~ ~

l.J~U~\11'1-t 1~ £J 3J €l1JV'l3J1 £J 1 ~~1 £J LL~U\11'1-t n ~3J~t!1J~UU\11U1J1V'l11 1u ~~"lf€l1J L ~ £J1rl1J ~ ~

Page 39: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

1:;n 'U~"ll .fll~ 1 'U~ n Mrn:; L "lfu d n iJ 1~di Ci1 uru 'V\1 n11'Y1';!1<11 n11~ ~ n n vh:J.;] f1 ~ ~ <9) ~ OJ ~ '1.J '1.J

rh'VI C?11 iLU<llUllJ~El a 6J'Yl1~ £J n L ~ mhdr.J"lf11"lla.J'Yl1.J11"1fn11 ~.Jn11LUn~1£J~6J11rtn1:;'Yl1 OJ

1<111 r.Jn11 1auL~ u 'Yl1.JU ru~ n11L iJ <11U ru~a a 6J'Ylf~ £J~.J iJ1~d:Ju"lfa.J'Yl1.J 1 i ~16J11rt'Yl";J1<11 OJ OJ ~

n11 ";J1<1l"ll a.J u 1.J ~11 £J n1~1 'Yl a.J L ~ ru iJ1~di 'i1';!1 nn111~ ~ f1116Jff1116J"lf1u 1 ru 1 un11 'I q Q.l cu Ql

U ~ q~VI t! 1~'11 u~ ~ W u~ ~ ~~ ., . LLwi Li'hu vm ~ L i\ wrlu Jm~•1n m1U ~ li~ ml' 1 ~ m'l ~VI <n ~ d:J u ~ 1.J 6J 1 n "ll a .J ~ v:J a .J f1 ~ Yi <9) n 1 1 ~ .J u 1 6J n a u L~ u 1 'i1 £J 1 ~ <11 11 ";J <11 L a n ~1 1 'VI ~ n ~ 1 u

'1.J '1.J ~

1h:; a1Jn11~1m~u"IJa.J~WEJ.Jf1~~ l!:l a1f1'£Jf1116J11l";J 116JJ.J 6JEJ1J'V16J1£J1iu1.J~11 '1.J

1 L n1J1n '1!1-1 ~6J CilUru~fi ~hn li''U 1 f1116J El1J'VI6J1 £J 1 i ~.;]11 £J n11UllJ~ n111~ <1111 ';) Ci1 q O.lqj Ql \1

11f1116J Lfl ~au 1 'V11'Yl1.J u qJ~ ~ .J ~v:J a.J f1 ~J.J ~~16J11rt <1111 ";J ~a 1J 'VI~ n ~1 u~1.J ') 1C?1L r.J~1 £J 1C?1 r.J1~~ El.J El1f1'£Jf1116Jff1116Ji1U 1llJ LL~:;~w El.Jfl~~ rn ~1u:;i1'VIU1~1 r.J1J1'V111 cu Q.l '\1 ctS

~ f11 6Jff1116J "lf1 u 1 ru 1 U.J1 u1J1'V111<1111 ";J ~a 1J 'VI ~n ~1 u n11~1 £J LL~:; ~ .J u 16J ~ 1 £J L~ U6J1 cu . Q.l ct3

L u u 1 ~ 1 u 1 u n 1 1 ~ .J u 1 6J 1 'i1 £J 1 ~ ~ 6J ~ 'VI d ~ a 6J L u u n 1 1 LL ~ 'i1 \11 i L ~ u tl 1:; ~ n Hi <1111 '1.J

L ~ £J 'V\1 £J ~ L n <11 ;ff 'U d L n <11 ';! 1 n f1116J 1J n ~ 1 El \1 ~ Ci1 ~ ~ 1 Ci1 "lJ El .J 1J f1 f1 ~ L U 'U 'VI~ n ~1 ~ llJ ~ ...

L ~r.J a ~1.JL~ r.J1 iJ1~L ~11:;f1116J ~'i1~~1'i11Jn~1a.J"IJ EJ\I'V\1-b r.J.J1U"ll a\11~'VI1a1:;1J1J\11U ~

~1'U 16J ~ r]~ n11ru"IJ El.J ~v:J El.J f1 ~J.J ~L uun11tll) U~'VI U1~tl1:; 6J1'Yl L ~'UL~ a a ~1.Jf1 £J u 1\1

1~ i 1 ';) tll)u~ 'VI U1 ~1 iL n Ci1 ~ ~ ~ LL n11 "1fn11 1~tll) u~ 'VIU1~ LL~:; 1~ <1111 ';)~a 1J La n ~11 'VI~ n ~1 u<1116J ~1 u 1';! 'VI u1 ~"ll a.J <11-u ~~a \1 tll)u~ L "lfu 1 u~1 u:; ~u\1 ~ 1J u qJ"lf11:;~ 1J ~u 13-J f1 1J f16J Ci1 LL ~ 13-J fh n 1J tJ n U~ .J1 u.ffu~ 'U 'VI1a 1 'U~1 u,:; n116J n11~ \1 'U 16J 1 'U 11J rl El 'UL~ 'U

~ '1.J ~ ~

1 ~ tl .. u~ 1 u i TI-n 1 1 ~ \1 u 1 6J 11J n a u L ~ u 1 in n il a .J 1 3J <11 1 1 ';) ~ a 1J L a n ~ 1 1 tl 1:; n a 1J n 1 1 '1.J

I t.l I I

Lun 1 m~u Yi LL~'i1.Jl1~wn~n~u Yi";J:;~ a.J~1 L Uun11~1 £J L~utl1:;n EJ1J'VI ~n~1u Yi1~11J au~~ '1.J ~ ~

1 i~ m~ULL~1 ~.J <1116Jtl n ~ri'1 1tl"IJ a \I~ ~\IU 16J 1 u 11J n auL~ u 'VI1n 1il <1111';! ~a1J LLaJ";J:;1~ ~ '1.J

11 ";J ~a 1J .ffu~ u ';!1 n ~ U.J ~ 1J u ru "1f1 L 'VI-fi. a:ff u 1tl 'VI1a 1~ ~ n11n k u n1EJ\16J1 Ti au L ~ua '1.J OJ

~ \1 'U 6J 1 'U 11J rt El 'UL~ 'U n ';!:; ~ 1J l1 n11~1 £.H~ 'Uf1{\11C?1 ~'VI diJ El .J ~1 £J 'VI1 El 13-J 'VI1 El ~'VI d~ El .J

~1 £J L Yh 1'i1 'Yl11 iu 1\1 ~11 £J n1~11~ ~16J11rt n1:;'Yl1 n11'Yl';J1<11 1ilLL~:;'Yl1.J11"1fn11n";J:;1~1il ~ ~

16J L ~r.J 'V\1 £J ~v:J a .J f1 ~ J.J ~~ .J ~a \111J ~ ti1"1fti11 i'L~ U<1116J ~1 u 1 u ~ ~ n nv:J a \1 f1 ~~ l!:l '1.J '1.J '1.J

Vl ';!1 rn 1i it ";J tr £J LL ~:; 1 u 11 £J n11n a UL~ 'Ufl{.J ~ l!:l cf L d a1 u ~ 1!:1 l!:l ~.J 'V\1 f16J l!:l cf <i rn ' ., '

~1u UL~urinau l!:l'o:l,<:t~o:>o.<O)~ 1J1'Yl uu ~Yi~.JU16Jrte:JUL~Utl1:;na1J~1£JU1\Itl'Yl11~1 6J1U<11£J '1.J

LL~:; ~El.Jfl~~ rn iJ1"1f~WEJ\If1~~ <i Liia.J";J1n1un~1Ju ~WEJ.Jfl~~ <i U.JiJ1il11J6JEJ1J~1'U1';! '1.J '1.J

t11X~.J'U16J ...

Page 40: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

. . cio

1 ~ Gi._'!U 1 ~1:1 t~uL'~hmGi::~rm-w e:J~ f1~~ G) 31i.~'!-b L'~u~1u 1 u kl '-', ci'<l o. G)~ Ul'Y1 ~1 ~ ~ f11u 1 rn 'U'U

1 ~ ~-w e:J~ f1~ ~ ct G) t~~1u ~ ~ ~ 1 u f'!l Gi tln f11e:J~~~ i.3J e:1111 u 1l'3u ~Tunu<?l~ n ~11 ~1~ n eJ t1 n 'U

111nL~U~1U1'U rn Q'GJ ,cirn 'ol .rn cf 1Jl'Y1 i.~ f11 i~"ll e:J~ ~1:1n-w tl~f1~~ GJ ~1~f111~l v;'U"ll e:J~ 'U'U

~ 1:1 n -w tl ~f)~~ kJ ll Gi:; ~ Gi nld'~ 1111lli 1 e:J'Y11i1m"ll eJ ~ ~rln -w tl ~f)~~ rn 1:1 n G) tl ~ ll ~ 1 "lJ eJ 1 ~ 'U'U ~ 'U'U 'U

f'!l ~tlnf11e:J~~~~~~vnn'l!l-1 mid:Ju 1 ~ un-w e:J~f1~"ll e:J~~-w e:J~f1~~~~ 'U ~ 'U

~1:1n-we:J~f1~~ kl t~'Ylmm11 n1~il1ml~'U,._'ll'U, ~1un._,1u~m1rn~"ll~._'!Vtl~"11~u'1 'U'U ~ ~ ~

1u~ ~"lfe:JlJ ln u1n'l!l-1l'3 'Ull~:: lU n~l tl ~ 'U, 1~ ui.3J li 1~h::uun11l n u1n'l!l-1l'3 Ull Gi:; l u n ~1 tll'3 'U, 'U

<ill ~1:: dj uu"ll eJ ~ 'Yll ~11 "11n11 dj u n11~h lit u n11<il1 ~ ~ n1::'Y1 11 ~ ~11i1 1rn ~"ll i.~ i~ 1 ~ ~

~1u n~1u~m1rn~"ll~~Vt1 <i!ri'1tl1::l 'Y1f'l<llll it un11 1 f11~ n11u <i!1tl1::nu~"ll1ll'V'lll1~~1u~1~"111~ ~ ~

llGi:: ~1un~1u ~11i11rn~"ll~~ Vt 1 <il ~1 u 1 Vt nJ i.~ ~ e:JlJVt ~1 u1 ~ il1 r.J ll~U~1u<ll1l it un11 1 ~ u ~ ~

L3J 'V'lU U ru Vtl ll~~ ~ LoXl v; 'U ll f111 ~ l ~ tl V\1 tl ~ l n ~.;ff u31 i.~n ~ll Vt <il ~1111 n f111 ~ ~ ~ Vt1 tl ~ ~

n11n1::tl1Gi::l31~"1Je:J~~-wt~~f1~~~~ ~1Un11~n~1Uf111~1u~~"lle:J~~-wt~~f1~~ G) 'U 'U

~f'll~tlnf11e:J~.ffuGl'u~n1~anfe:Ju~:: klo 11~luufe:JuGi:: ~o Ju ~1:1n-wt~~f1~~ kl lv;u11 'U'U

~-w t~~f1~~ G) nVI1X1~1~ t1<il1~L un11<ll1l itu 1f11~n11 ~~ ~ t~~n1nu~ ll~ n11tl nu~~1u 'U 'U ~

1~ r.J lU 'V'l1::~1U~lun11l'3ut~ ~1~1n~~~ ll~n ~uGi::l~ U11UlUUl Vt <ilL ~ln ~n11'Y111'1<il.;ffu ~ ~

tl1::n t~unun11n1Vtu~ f111 ~ l ~r.J Vtl r.J lU'U~ ~~it11"1J e:J~ il1 r.J u1Vt11 ~11 ::u1Vt11~ <il n11 ~

'Y11'V'l rr~u ~i.~1u f111 ~ l ~tiVtl r.J 1 ~ r.J n11l'1 u n"lf~ 1 i111n ~ n1::l'l1 Gi:: l31 ~ ~ ~ n11n1 VI U<il 'U

~ f'll Gi tl n f11tl ~ .ffu~ u 11:: u 1 ~ll u u l Vt <ill u n11~ n ~1 Ull V: ~ f111 ~1u ~ ~"ll e:J~ ~ -w eJ ~ f1 ~ ~~ ~ ~ 'U

e:Jt~nft~u~:: cfo ll~::~n~1'Uf111~1u~~"lle:J~~-wt~~f1~~ G) 1~anfe:Jr.JGi:: klo "llt!L~ 'U

" f'll Gitln f11tl~~~ ~<il n f11~'V'lln '1!1-ln ~lJ f11~'V'lln ~1 f'll ~tl nf11e:J~i'u~u

'U ~

~-wt~~f1~~ G) llne:J'Y11i1m11 ~-we:J~f)~~ G) tlnu~Vt1X1~1u1::<?lutlnu~n11 'U ~ 'U ~ ~

31i.~luu ~1Vt1X1il1r.J 31i.~luu~1Vt1!1~1u i.3J lf1t1L~1un11LL~~i~ 1oXluu~ <i!llGiU1~~11r.J111'V'l1 'U 'U ~

!"I "" !LuU~~lLGi ... 'U'U

Page 41: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

···jt~U.~1~

~L,l\ktL~ 1 N3 ~ 1 !J't1.L!;'t1.t111rl Lt:JUL~!;8~ 1 rt lt 't1.l~'t1.LN\11~t8~kt 't1.LN3l !tk1.!;8 fT.!;8~Mlll1ftLl~ ~ ~

llL~~h!1't1.}~h!1~rlLktrl~1rtLl~ q .. 't\.~1 ~ ~~~1;8~~~~11 1:91. ~~~1;8~~ l~11 1:9J.~;p1:9J. I·~ · M

!;8t~ll[1~ ~L'tl1tL~~~~~~11 !;8t~ll[1~ L~ !;~ ~~~lli fu ~.Q.Lt~tM!;~ 11 ~ ~ Lt~Lrt rt L~jU1.!lU~ "'

L 'IUtL~ ~tLll~ t1 !;~ 1111£~1~ 't1.l~1111_!b 't1.~11~Ll!1 L~l1~rl ~t 't1. ~ rl Lll ~ ~1;8 ~tLll'ti.IJ1!; ~ p~;p 1:91. b ~ ~

rt~L~~ PI:9J. ~'t\.~~~11 'tl.rlLrl'tl.~ 1:91.~ ~'t\.~8~1~~1;8~ ~ ~~~1;8~~~~11 1:91. ~~~!;8~~ !U-tLll I I I I I •

11~L~rtL~ p~;p1:91. rt~Lkt!;~ ~ ~'t\.~~~11 p~;p1:91. rt~dllltll P~ ~'tl.~'ti.~'IUt.!lU~L'IUtL~tYltLll ~ ~

~t1!;~118~!;_!bk1.11_!.~k ~ ~~~1;8~~~~11 1:91. ~~~1;8~~8~1 !;8t~llf1~L~8~~~!;8~~U~!;t11~k b b

jUt.!l U 8 fa~ ~'J:1. ~tLll ~ t1 !;~ 11 8~ !;_!b k1. rt L~ !;~jUt.!l U 8 rl~~ 'J:1. ~tLll ~ t1!; ~ 1111_!.~1~ 't\.~~11 11_!b ~~

't1.~11g Ll! 1't1. t rl Lll~k ~ ~~~ 1;8 ~lll.l~ 1;8 rr.~;~ L~'t\.8 L1ll~ 1 ~~1;8 ~~U~ !J!;~ ~ ~~ ~1;8 ~ ~~11

1:91. ~~~!;8~B ~w;p1:91. "WM !;8t~ll[1!;LUtLll.Q.Lt~~Q[1~~~,LUfu~.U.Lt~tM!;~11 ;p Lt~Lr rtL~ ~ ~ b

!;8t~ ll [11; LUI;¥ L~'ti.IJ18 ~~;~ ~ ~~ ~ 1;8 ~~~~11 1:91. ~~ ~1;8 ~~ 1;8 fT.jUt.!lU8 rl~~~ ~~k ~~ ~~ ~~ b

w ~~~!;8~lll1~Lrt8~~~11 w ~~~!;8~lll.1~8~ ~ ~~~!;8~lll1~!;8fT.!;¥L~jUt.!lU8 ~~k ~ ~ b ~ ~

~ ~~~1;8~~~~11 1:91. ~~~1;8~~ L~jUt.!llA8l!11 ~ ~~~1;8~~~~11 1:91. ~~~1;8~~ I I I I

ULI1 Jt.3P"Jt.3P~'~ p w ' 1:9J.

~ b ~

'tl.l'ti.L~'tl. ~1Z0 ~ ~.[. ~ ~ ~ ~ 1;8 ~~~ ~~ !;~ L~'tl. 8l.1ll ~ 1 LH ll LM~L~ !J ~k! !;k! !;8t~ ll ITT. ~ L~ b b

~ t 8 rr. n L ~; 1111 ~ t ~; 8 rr. ~; 8 ~ M u11 rt L l ~ u L ~ ~ h! , n ~ ra ~ ~ ~ k! ~ k1, , n1:5 , ~ 11u L k1, ~; t ,, ra L k 1 ~; L r 8 ~

8~1't1.~1ULrt~tf1~1[£ ~ ~~~1;8~~ !;_!.~ ;pp 'tl.l'ti.L~ 't1.~1't1.8l.1tLlll1~lrl\J1tLk!ll81L~ ' " 0

~ ~ ,. 118k!~lt~~'ti.IJ1~1[£~ ~ ~~~1;8~~ 'tt_!b~fll~~Lrr. P - ~o~o1:91. - 1:91. - w;po ~rr.~1 ~

0 "' 0

,. b

't1. L!;!; t 11 ~ fll ~'tl. ~ 't1. ~1 ~tLll 1;8 1~ktL~ L 'tl..!lll L~ 8 fT.L1tLrt Lk!tM Lll rllLk! !;L 't1. 't1. _!b 't1. ~1't1. 8 L111t 0 "

,. ~ b ~

'tl.l~ p- ~o~o1:91.- 1:91.- w;po ~rr.~1~ru~ llLjj~~rtk!l1~1~trlLrtk1.118rtl1_!.~1[£ ~ ~~~1;8~~

I":: ~ b

~~ ~ [1,t-l't1.[J1tM Lll rllLk! !;L 't1. '!Jo 'tl.l~'tl. ~ 'ti.L!; ~k 't1.~1ll [} 1 ~~~; ~ 'tl.~~'tl. t !;8k!tLllrtttll~'IUI~ 1;8 rr. "' 0

8~8 ~fa L~ !J 1;8 ~fa ~1 't1.~1ll[}1Z0t ~~11 't1.}~h!1 ~rl jJ1ll8 ~'tl.l 't1.L~I18k!~lt~ rl LrT.~t~~1l't1.L~

11~'t1.~1't1.l 't1.L~I18k! ~lt~z. t~ 'ti.L!;~~g [1tLll't1. ~ 8 ~ !;8~~1'ti.IJ1 L~~ ~ ~~~ 1;8 ~B llLjj~~~k! b

11~lrl \J1't1.l~ 't1.~1't1.8L1tLllrtttu~m~~;8rr.~u~~ ~'ti.IJ1't1.~1't1.8L1tLlll1~~;8 ~lrl \J1 ~ 't1. ~tlk!ll~m~kt I I I I

~ ~

't1. ~1't1.8L111~'t1.l~ 't1. _!bL~ 1't1.LU!;L~~'ti.IJ1 ~ ~ ~~1;8 ~~1;8 rr.~; ~~,0-11 ~8~8 ~rl L~ !J ~tLk!ll81 .... I I I I

~k 'tl.~'ti.Eo'tl. ~ 't1.~1't1.8 L1tLlll1~lrl \J 1tLk! ll8 1 L~~~tLlll18k! ~lt~L1tLrtLk! ~fu ~tLll~ " 0

!ll ~ 't1. l ~ 't1. ~ fu ~, !; 8 u t M L L1 ~ l Lk! !; L 't1. !; 8 rr. 't1. L!; ~~ g [1 t L ll ~ ,, ~ rt ~ 11 u~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r 8 ~ B

fu~ 11;8 u tMLLl~ lLk!!;L't1.~11~fu~::~11't1.~1tLll!;8~1't1. tnL~;ra Ltl18k!~lt~Lftll~L~; ~ ~11 ~B'ti.IJ1

~~

'0 .

Page 42: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

LLt'l ~ ~ rl n v:J Eh'lfl ~ ~ rn ~ eJ 1J Vi ~lll~l U 1 U fil1U11 u~hl"ll'fil1"ll eJ ~U lll LL 'Y'l 'Yl rJ ~l1ll1lli~"ll 'lJ 'lJ ~ ~

LL~t'l~ LL V:~ ~l~l1rlU'1Vil1~lU l~ LLt'l~Ul l!LL 'Y'l'Yl rJ~l1ll1lli~"ll~~W)~"ll't'l1J~l~~ el1JV!~lll1 ~ ~ ~

~lllLLc-IU~lULflUi'n~l~U'tllUqJ; LLt'l::LUfi~lm~u1~mih~'Y'llll1Jlt'l~l" G) ~1ll LdeJ~lllLLc-IU~lU L3Jnfl1lU~\ ~ll1"1fllli 1 UL~eJ"i~n~l1~l~i'u ~ eJUV! ~lll Ulll LL 'Y'l'Yl rJ~l1ll1lli~"lli~w1~"1l't'l1J~

'lJ ... ~ ~

~~ l~ --ill"U l~ ~l1ll 1ll'Y'l1 'Yl el" L ~ ru ~~ L3J n fl1l ~ffl1l ~"HlU l ru L ~ ll1 nuL~ el" i~ n ~11 ~ .., cu Ill

~l Lll ut'ln-.ill"i'1fl1l1 LLt'l ~ 1 ~ ~v:l eJ~fl ~~ <9) ~~ LDUL --il1 Vi u1~1 L fl1l~r{ u 1uul mLt'l~ LLt:-JU '-' 'lJ 'lJ

~~nl3Jnfl1l~fl UL~eJ~ i~n ~11 fi11Jfl ~~ LLt'l Einvf~ l~LU ~uru;eJ eJ~'Yli''Y'l £fl ~Ul~ ~l1ll1ll'Y'l1 'lJ ~ 'lJ ... ~

LUnLDUL~U~~ L3JL~~l mlJuL ~f) ~l ~d~ LU lJU nl1L nui'n~l L~U LL~::nl1U l L~Uff~fl ~~"ll el"

~1u11"1rn11 'Y'l. ~. 1!:1 <fl!:l o Ul~ ~l1ll1l1'Y'l1~~ eJlflll"lieJ~'Yll~i~n~l1 rTn u eJnL~u 111 i~~u ~

L 'Y'l1l::~h Lit Ufil1~1~fllk~"ll el~U 1ll LL 'Y'l'Yl rJ ~11l11lli~"ll~~Vi l ~"ll'~ u1~L~i'u ~ eJU Vi ~1ll~l n ~ ~

~nn~eJ~fl~~ <9) u~~~nnv:leJ~fl~~ rn ~1u~~nnv:le1~fl~~ <9) LL~~~nnv:leJ~fl~~ rn eJ'Yl1l1rn1l 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ ~

~ n n v:l eJ" fl ~ ~ <9) ii 1 ~ u 1 L ~will u 1 u 1!:1 '-' , u:.''-' o . <9) Q' u 1 'Yl ~ 1 ~ ~ f11 u 1 rn 1 ~ ~ v:l eJ ~ fl ~ ~ u:.' 'll'll 'lJ

~ eJ"i'u tJ ~ LL~ eJ cil~ 1~ ~lt'lUfifl1eJ~.ffu~u~ ~L3J ell~U 1L~U~lU 1ui~n~11~1lK n eJ eJn~1nL~U ~lU1U rnQ'<9l,u:.'rn'-'.rn<f Ul'Yl l~~u L3JeJl~i'uY1~1~ LiieJ~~1n~l~~ldl~LLU~~~ff1Ufl1l~i'utl~

' ' I ~ ljJ V .c:::l Q...l Q...l .c:::l .c::=t. A A

"lleJ~LL~~~fiU ~l~fi11~LV!U"lleJ~L~1V!Ul'Yl U1J1Jt'l~1U'Yl <9l<9l 'Y'lr]~~nlllU l!:lcfu:.'Q' 1eJ~eJ1l1J~

n1~uru;nt'l1~L~1::uL1eJcil~i'~L~U111~~v:leJ~fl~~ u:.' 1uti~"ll'~1-E'L~u 1!:1'-',u:.''-'o.<9)Q' Ul'Yl ... ~ 'lJ

1unl1L~mun~1m~u1u1u~ 1!:11!:1 ~~Vt1fl~ l!:l<fu:.'rn 11:JJeJci~1ll "lleJ1~~l~Unfl1eJ"~~~~ ' 'lJ 'lJ ~

Yl'Y'l1 n ~1un eJ'Ylll1ru"IJ eJ~ ~ nnv:l eJ~fl ~~ <9) LLt'l::~ nnv:l eJ~ fl ~~ rn ~ 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ

~v:JeJ~fl~~ rn LLrleJ'Yl1l1rnll fil1~~nnv:JeJ~fl~~ <9l l~nVIU~~eJLL-.il~1~ 'lJ ~ 'lJ 'lJ

~ v:J eJ ~ fl ~ ~ rn 'Yl111J ~ ~ n11i'u eJ 'Yl1l1llil ~LL rJ ~ fll k" Ylf eJ ~ vf" LL -.ij ~ 1 ~ ~1 Lit U n11v:J eJ ~ fl ~ 'lJ ~

111u 1uLnl ~u1u uu LL~lUfi1UrllVIU~ Lnl~u1u uu u~1u ~~U~'Ylll1rnL3J"ll'eJU~1lln !JVI~lll ~1~~1~11 u:.'<f LLV:~'Y'l1~1l"ll'UqJ~~1lii.J~u~h1"1fn11'Yll~unfl1eJ" 'Y'l.~. l!:lcfrnctt! LiieJ~~1n fi!J Vi~l llfllVIU~ L 1t'lll~ ll11~ 1 ~L--il1V!Ul~Yl~l1lli1 el'Yl1l1rn1 ~L ~1~ ~U1llll1 UL rll~UlU

~

uu LL~1u i'u eJ'Ylll1ru LL~~ 1 ~LL--il~ L Vt~ 5u 13J m~Yl~l1rnleJ'Yl1l1rn1 ~u~1 L~1~~l~nlVIU~ 1 ~mi ~ ~ ~

~ eJ'Yl1l1rn 'Yl1l1J LL~ iil~L ~ eJl U l ~ L --ill Vi U l~ ~ ~::n1 Vi U~ L 1 t'll1 Ufil1~U"ll eJ L Yln rl eJ Ufl1 k~ 'lJ ~

'Yl1 ~ U n fl1 eJ ~ l ~ lJ ~ rJ~ L3J 'Yl1l1J t:-J ~ fil1~ U eJ 'Yl1l1rn L 'Y'l1l ~ L d eJ ~v:J eJ ~ fl ~ ~ rn rJ~ L3J 'Yl11 ~ ~ ~ ~ 'lJ

/n11Yl ~11m 1 ...

Page 43: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

"il11lli 1 fJ 'Ylll'Hll'n ~ ~ LlJoUl "lfu 11 n rJ~ 13-J fJl"il rl fJ 1~11 c.Yv:J fJ ~ fl ~ ~ m 1~f~1l Vi~ q 'U 'U q

iv~n r1 eJu~h k~'Yll~ un fl1eJ ~J u ~1 :JJ :JJ1 ~11 u:: CO'! 111fl ~eJ ~ lb v:~~1~11"1l'unnu~ "' "'

U~11"1l'n11'Yl1~Unfl1eJ~ ~. ~. kl cfm CO'! ll~n11ll~~n1V!U~1~ tJ~l1 ~11 ic.Yv:l eJ~fl~~ m 'U

~ u f) ~ fl ~ ~ f) ~ 1 ~ u n fl1 f) ~ 111 tJ 1 u b n 1 ~ lJ 1 u u lJ ll ~ 1 u fl11J n 1 Vi u ~ l n 1 ~ lJ 1 u u lJ ll ~ 1 utJ eJ 'Ylli1rn J u l ~n eJu Vi rt~ dj un11n1V~ u~1~ tJ~ l1 ~11 un111 i~'Ylli"ll eJ~ c.Y v:l eJ~ fl ~ ~ m

q 'U

:ffu:JJ 1V~3JueJnmueJ-:u1n-ir eJUqJI!T~~l:JJn!) Vi :JJ1 tJ b ~11~.ffu~ eJUbb~~n1~lJ1U n11~1l it un11

~l:JJ 0

n!J Vi :JJ1 tJuqJI!T~lrrT~ 13-l~u~~ V~lmL~V~u~~eJ~~n~11n ~11~~1~qj l ~ eJu ~~ 1111~ fl11 fu ~~"l)'f)lJ"lJ f)~ cr~ n Blt.b 1"ilWtt'1~1 u n11~"il11lli 1 fJ'Ylll1rn1 u5u ~-:u~<11 f)~ ll~~ fll k~

'U q

1un1 ~"il11lli1~'Ylli1rn111tJ1uln1~lJ1u ~1:JJ:JJ1~11 U::cf uV:~~1~11"1l'Uqji!T~1Tiufju~11"1l'n11

nfl1e:J~ ~.~. klcfmCO'! lrh.Ju c.Yv:leJ~fl~~ m 1~fu'Yl11Uf111it-:uutJeJ'Ylli1rn"lleJ~ 'U q

0 0 0 ,::::1 ..-.::1. Q...O ,Cj V A 6' ,::::1 Q..J .c::l

fJ~fl~'Yl m ~1:lJVit.b~~fJbb"il~~~n11~"il11lli1fJ'Ylll1lli 'Yl "ll'lJ ookld/G)klbU::b ~~1U'Yl q

G) u:: 1n !]1 fl :lJ kl cf ci ~ . ~ ~ flll it "iJ u tJ ~'Ylll1rnrJ f)b iJ t.bfll k~ 'Yll~ un fl1 f)~ ~1 :lJ n!] Vi :lJl tJ

u~~ eJ 1~11 t:Yv:leJ~fl~~ m 1~1ii~ l V~~~-:u~ 1 iL ~nr1 eJuf11k~'Yl1~1lnfl1eJ~Ju eJ ci1~b 11~ ~~ 'U 'U q q

uul ~1u~ G)ci n1n!J1fl:JJ klcfU::~ u1~neJunuV~u~~eJlb~~~~n11~-:u11rn1~'Ylll1rn 1~u ~ 1 i'Yl111J11 c.Yv:l eJ~ fl ~ ~ m n~'Ylli~uf11v:l e:J~ ~ eJ ~1 ~u n fl1eJ~~ n b "ll ~ il1 u 1 -:u 111 tJ 1 u

'U ~ I I I

1u ~~u u ~'Ylli1 un11~u v:l eJ~fl~~ eJ~1~Unfl1eJ~ l Vi eJ"ll eJ 1 il ~nb1 eJUfl1i~'Yl1~Unfl1eJ~

cieJ:JJ 11Jfl1ViU~b11~~~111tJ1u1u~ <9)<9) ~~lfl:JJ klcfU::~ ~~c.Yv:leJ~fl~~ m 1~~uv:leJ~fl~ q q 'U

~eJ~ ~unfl1eJ~.ffu<1luLrieJ1u~ cf ~~lfl:JJ klcfU::~ fl~~~rr~1aJ~un1V~U~1~tJ~nm~1:JJn!)V~:JJ1tJ ~1'\X 'Ylli1un11~uv:leJ~fl~~1:JJ:JJ1~11 U::CO'! 111fl~eJ~ uV:~~1~11"1l'UqJI!T~1Tiufju~11"1l'n11

n fl1f)~ ~. ~. kl cfm CO'! c.Yv:l f)~ f)~~ m b v;u11 fl11:lJ b~tJVil m n~"illn fl11:lJlJn~~f)~ 'U

l~u 1n~1V~ful~u1uuru~Lb1~~1u~1~"1l'1~ll~~l~u1uuru~L~u'YluV~:JJuLiuuu~m~nu~"ll111~ QJ QJ ~ q . q

c.Yr1n eJ~fl~~ kl 1<1leJuru1~ 1'\X ~1un~1U~1ll11rn~"ll-;ij~V~1~-;ij~Lnul~U11tJ1~-:u1nn11,)1V~t.btJ 'U'U q<V q

u ~1u1~nu~"1J111~1 1\."11~1 tJ lUUl~uu11~ bl~~ 1 '\X~.hn 11nullu1 fl11~ Luuf~1~1V~n-:u q q ""'

~~ ~ un~1U~1li11rn~"ll~~V~1 ~"ll'~u11~Ltl ~ Luuu ru~u1~ b11'Yl eJ eJ :JJ'Ylf~ ml'nullu 1fl11 q q "'

l~f) 11bn1~~1bb~~~Vin1rnn11bnM~1bUU~e:J~Uru~ 1~mi Ulli~l~t.b'Ylt.bVi:lJt.blltJU uru~~ kl QJ QJ q q QJ

~~n V!U~b~ eJU1"lln11bU n~1tJ1111 n11~1m~u-:u~ 1"111li1eJuboYhJu '\X1 :lJ b1 eJUbUUb~U~~ qJ~ll1~~1u~1~"1l'1~ ~~1aJ1~n1V~U~l~eJu1"lln11Lun~1tJ ~~Ju 1u'Yl1~ufiu~ n11LiJn~1tJ

Page 44: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~ 1 a r1 a u L ~ u a a n -;u 1 n u ru ~ a a :u Yl1' 'Y'I rft ~ t.1 L u '¥'11 :; 1 u ~ 1 u "lJ a ~ u ru ~ LL ')" ~ ~ 1 u ~ 1 ~ "151 ~ v v

-;u:;~ a~ dJU n1')LUnb1 auL~U~~ ~1a1~ t.ln1') 1 aUL~UL "ll1uru~~UL rhtf U 13-J a1-;u~1 tiL~ U v

LUUL ~T11~ ~~Ju i~n1')LUn~1 m~u 1 uuru~~~n ~11~~13-irJn~ a~~1:1J'):;dj t.llJU 1iu~"lJ a~ v '\J :w

Yl1~')1"15n1') ~~~ a~ul)u~~1:1J'):;LU t.l1Jn1')L nu1nH1 L~ULL~:;'U, 1L~U~~T1 t~"lJ a~ ~1U ')1"15n1')

'Y'I.~. l!:Jcfl!:Jo n1')~~b1n'Wa~T1~~ (0) LL~:;~r1n'Wa~T1~~ rn n~11eJ1Yhn1')LU~LUUUru~ '\J '\J '\J '\J ' v

U'):;L.nYl a a:uYJ1'Y'I rh ~au'):; 1t~-nu "lJ a~Yl1~')1"15n1') Lll un1')n~11 a1~ ~a t.1 6J ~~ 1 ~ t~"ll m Yi -;u -;u1 ~ n1')L tJ ~u-ru~U'):; L.flYl a mm1'Y'I rrJ u 1~rln~ a~ ~1 :IJ'):; LU t.IUU 1iu~"lJ a ~Yl1~')1"15n11a ci LL~1

v '\J :w '\J

0 0 "

L ua~-;u1nn1')Yi nnTHl1~U~'):; L u t.IUU l)u~Yl1~')1 "nn1') 1 ~nn1')LUn~1 tJ L~ULUUL ~m!u 0 "

n L'~ ail a~ nuii1 ~L n~n1')n'):;rl1Yl-;J'1~ eJULUUU'):; 1 tJ"l5ULLTiYl1~')1"15n1') 1~ mL 'Yi-;u1~ ~~u u , n1')Ltl~uru~a a :uYJ1'Y'I rr1~ t~13J n1~ u~ L~ au 1"1J 1 un1')LUn~1 t.1 L~u 1111 1 ~'lau Yl1~uru~ v v

L oyhtfu ~1 :IJrl aUL~U~~ ci amiJu~~ 1 ~L ~1~U1~ ~U 1iu~~1U 1 i'LlJwrla~Yl1~n1:;rl1Yl-;J'1~ '\J :w ,

LL ~1 ~~1 U'):; 1 t.l"l5U~1U~ u 1~~1 tJ:ff u LLaJl1 ';):; n'):;U 1J n1')f111J T1 :IJ 111 tJ 1 u Witl tJ ~1 U~1 :IJ , .ffu~ aULL~1n ~1 :IJ n')ru~~ii a11 LUUT111 :IJUn'Y'I1a~"lJ a~'):;1J1J~1 u 1~ tJ ~1U ')1 :IJ eJULUU

~1 L ~ ~~1~ ru~n a1 ~L n~-rla~Yl1~ 1 Un1')Yl';)'1~ ~~ L UUT111:1J1u ~~-nau"lJ a~ ~u~~1JUlli"l51 ct Cll q cu Ql

'):;~u ~~"lJ a~~tb t.l~1U ~ LUU~ fl1 ~ U~'):;1JU~1U~~ n ~11 ~-w a~ f)~~ rn L ilu~1~1u ~ ~ '\J '\J '\J '\J

-;u1 n f111 :uu n Y~1a ~"lJ a ~1:;u u ~1 u ~1 u ')1 :u ~~ n ~11 :u1 n n 11 ~ L ~ t.11"ll a~ f1 u ~ u b) 1 UT1 ~it '\J

~'W a~T1~~ rn ii1~nlil1 LL ~U~~1a~u1~1~ b1 L ~ t.11-iJa~ 1 U~1U 1f1')~n11U~')U'):;nu~"lJ1l1'Y'I '\J J ,

13-J n ~1U1-;J 1 Un1')1J'1~11~1ULL~:;u'1~11L~U ~1a f111Jf1 :1Jfl1rl1J~ u~.ffu~ aun1')U 1iu~~1U ~ '\J :w

1 u 1f1')~ n1') 1~ 6J ~~ iu u'):;n1')~1 ~ qJ 13-1 n ~1 u 1 -;u ~ 1l'1~1 un11,nu~ :u~1eJ ~')1';) ~au n1')tl1iu~~1u"lJ a~u1~~11 tJ1l1'Y'I') YJa~ L ~~ ~~Ju Lrla~u~~uuru-n11~ tJ~')~~~ 1 u.ffu~u

dJ q Q..l cu Q,l

LL~:; 1 U'):;~u~~"lJ a~U1~~11 t.l.fl1'Y'I')~~13J nf111:1J1'T111:1J"J11U1lli 1 U~1Un1')L~U 1.J1iu~~1U '\J ~ '\J v :w

~ ~:;V!~1:u 1 un1')f11UT1 :un1nu~ LL~ 5n~~'):;uun1')Lun~1 mlluL~ u~~n Li a~ an1')n'):;'Yl1YJ-;J1~ ~ '\J ~

~~ LUUL ~~ ~1~ru~'Yl11 ~u1~~11 t.l1l1'Y'I') 1 i\ilu-rla~Yl1~ 1 un11~ ~an ~1~ 1 ~~'W a~T1~~ rn ~ v , '\J

~~U1:1J1 u1uLUnL~U~LUUL fi-;u LL~:;~~U1:1J1 u1ULUn L~U~ Lnu-;u1~ 1~ tJ LL UU Lan~1')L ~ a1 ~ L -ir11 ';) ~ ~ L ~ tJ1nUn1')~ ~ ~')')L~U L UUL ~ ~ 1 ~ ~-w a~ f)~~ rn ~ a~1u ~ ~"15~ 1 i'L~U:IJ1nn11

, '\J

L~1~1l'1~ T1u~u 6J ~ L~ t.11-ir a~ LL~:;Lllu~u1iu~~1u 1~ tJ~')~ 1 u~1u 1T1')~n1')U~')u'):;nu~"lJ.n1'Y'I '\J :w ~

n11~ ~ r1n'W a~ T1 ~~ (0) 1~ t.1 T111 :u LV: u"lJ a~~ r1n'W a~ T1 ~~ l!:J LL~ :;n1Tvh11rn 1 eJ YJTI')rn"lJ a~ '\J '\J '\J '\J ,

~bl n 'W a~ T1 ~~ rn ii1~u 1 ~1U"lJ a~ T111 :u ~ ~ 'Y'I ~1 ~u n'Y'I1a~"lJ eJ~~ 1-i. 1 tJ~1U"lJ a~1~m1a'):;uu '\J'\J ~

r

Page 45: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

f11 ~tin f11fl>:l ~ >:l ~~ fl fl n J>:l ~ -;u11ru1 f1 ~ 1~ tJ Lili'u w >:l ~1tl-if fl L f!-;u-;u1 >:l"ll fl>:l ~ ~ ~

11L il"ll fl>:l ~1'\.-b 1'U LL~ :;f11~LL ';u>:liJ1 tJ11';u1tl1:;n flUf11 LLfl ~>:ln11rn"ll fl>:l ~ ~1 n11~LL 1:1 ~>:l fl ~ ~ ~

f11 ~tin f11fl >:l ~>:l ~~ Lil (7111-;u~ -;u11rn 1 L fl n ~11tf>:lV1 :~J (711 u~1u 1uf1 ~ n n VI :~Jl u ~ ~ d)

1:;Lth.Ju -iJmJ>:lflU ~~~ ~L~tJ1-iJfl>:ltl1:;n€JULL~1

iLfl 1:;~u1uu1mL~:;LL~u \) tl1:;~1>:l1ULL~U>:l1U n~:~J~uu~uU>:l1UU1VI11 ~1Un>:l1U q ~

1 rn~"ll ~>:l Vll wn ~ u1 ~VI t! 1 ~i'u ~ (71"15 flu >:ll utl1:; n 'U, ~"ll 111 'Y'l >:ll 'U,U (711tl1:;n 'U, ~"ll 111 'Y'l ~ ~ ~ ~

(711~l ~~ n11ti1:;"151"15UiJ1U i'm~l'Y'l tJ1U1 ~ LL~:;>:ll'UU (711tl1:;nu~"lJ 111'Y'l LL1>:l>:l1'U~1>:l"151~ ~

~ v:l >:l fl ~ ~ kJ ~11 >:l Gll LL VI U>:l 'U, 1 tJLL 'Y'l 'Yl ~ r;:i ill 'UL1"15n11:1J iJ fl >:l n '\.-1, ~1 u n>:ll 'U, ~1TI"11lli~"lJ ~ ~

~ >:l VI .,_, (71 "15 ~ U 1 ~ v:J fl >:l fl ~ ~ rn ~ 1 1 >:l Gll LL VI U >:l L -;ij 1 VI U 1 ~ U 1 Vll 1 >:ll 'U, ;t 1l tl d ~ 1 tJ U 1 Vll 1 ~ ~

~1 u >:ll u ~1 !i11ru ~"lJ ~>:l Vll (71 "15~ u1 ~v:l fl >:l f1 ~ ~ ~ tl fi u~11 "15n11L tJ u ~ ·zh uu 1 mL 'Y'l 'Yl ~ ~ ~ ~ ::cJ ~

' ' Q..,.l Q.; 0 Q...l Q..,l Q...l .d. I ~ Q..l .d.

~1TI" 1lli~"lJ';u>:lVI1(71 ~1Un>:l1U~1!i11rn~"lJ-;u>:lVI1(71"15~U1 (7lfl:IJ1L:I.Jfl1U'Yl kJ\) n1n1l1fl:IJ kl<f~<£ ~ ~ q d)

~1u >:l1U~ii11lli~"lJ~>:lwr (7l"J5~u1Lili'u11 tJ>:l1U-;u1nU1>:l1 >:lYl11 'Y'l1U"15~ 1 "ll ~1VIU1>:l1ULL~U>:l1U ~ ~ ~ q

n ~ :IJ ~,Xu ~'U, 'U>:l1UU1V111'h L~ 'U, 1 'U,U ruiu (711tl1:;n 'U,~"lJ 111'Y'l LL 1 >:l>:ll'\.-1,~1 >:l"151 ~ ~ ~1U n>:ll '\.-1, ~ ~ Ql ~

~l!i 1rn~"lJ~>:lVIl (7l"J5~u1Li1Lu (71UruiL1nu!iU 1 f111L ~ fl n11L n ij-(711LL~:;~VI n1rnn11L n ij-(711 ~ ~ Ql

~"lJ "15~u1 uruiL~"lJ~ o<:frn - kJ - kJ0(9)0(9) - r;:i Lil"lJ1(71VI1tJLtl ~1Un>:l1'U~!i11lli~"lJ~>:lVIl(71"1mu1 ~ Ql ~ q

~>:lL"'~f11~>:l~ (9)(9)r;:i/kl<£CS:.cf. ~>:ll'U~ kl nutJltJU klcf.~<£ LL~>:li>:lf1ru:;n11:~Jn11~flu -ifm .; -;u-;u1>:l LL~:;L~11tJ>:l1U~~n11~flU~1U-ifmfi-;u-;u1>:lL~fll'U~ kJ\) li'U11fl:IJ kl<fCS:.cf.

~ fl 1 mL 'Y'l'Yl ~ ~1!i11ru~"lJ~>:lVIl~"15~u111 L~'\.-1,(711 :~Juruiu(711tl1:;nu~"ll111'Y'l LL1>:l>:l1U~1>:l"151~ ~ q Ql ~

Ubl.l L~"lJ~ o<frn- kJ- kloco:Jo(O)- r;:i LL~:;uruiL~'U'Yl'UVI:IJ'ULltJ'UU(711tl1:;nu~"lJ111'Y'l lU Q,l q q q

"L~'\.-1, uurui kl" uruiL~"ll~ ocf.rn- CO) - 0(9)0(9)\)- ~ "lJ1(71VI1tJlti~1'U,1'U, \),~rn<f,~h<:fr;:i Ul'Yl q Ql Ql

1~tJU1>:l~11tJ111'Y'l1 'Ylfl>:lL~ru ~ni1>:li'1f1111 GJ1LLVIU>:l'Y'lUn>:l1Uurui LUU~Lfl1L~u q cv ClJ QJ ClJ

~1 1 u~>:ln ~11Ltl LL~:;~ L i1V1 t!1~ il fl>:li'u ~ (71VI ~1 tJ f1 u 11 :~Jtf>:l ~v:l fl>:l f1 ~tf>:l ~i11 tJ ~ fl :I.Jl ~

~1:1 v:lfl>:lfl~~ <9) L~~f11~>:l~>:lVIl(71"15~u1 ~ (O)kJor;:i/klcf.~\) ~>:ll'U~ CO)r;:i n1nn1f1:1J kl<f~\) ~ ~ ~ d)

LL~>:l ~>:lfl rn:;n11:1Jn11~flu-if fl L f!-;u-;u1>:l f111 :~Ji'u ~ (7l'Yl1._'1 ~:; LiJ (7l"ll fl>:l L i1V1 t!1~ LL~:; Lil11 tJ>:llU~ ~

/n11~flu .. .

Page 46: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

nTHH:l u"ll e:JL rhr;u1~ ~~l'U ~ 1!:1 kJ n 'UtJ1 tJ'U kJ cfci'o> G) El cr ri nYJ El~ T1 ~~ co:l l1 U 1 ~ ~11 tJ 111'W1 ~ ~ ~

LUWYriEl'UL~w;nmJru~U~1lh~nU~"lJ111'WLL1~~1UGi1~"1r1~ uru~L~"lJ~ o<fm - kJ - kloco:loco:l- ~ \1 QJ q Q.l

'V I I tJ Q...l I Q..l ,::1, ~ Q..,l ~ Q...l 0

~~LL~1'Ui'l kJ(;'J( 3Jn11T13J kl<fcr'm ri~1WYl m 'Wtl~111T13J kl<fci<f 113-1 ~<f T11~ ~1U1'U

<f I <i'! <i'!o I ct'-> kl. <f~ u1 i'l LL~~n EJUL~ u~1nuru~L~u nu. ~ aJUL i tJuu ~11h~n u ~"ll 111-wu ru~ Ql q q q ..,

"L~'U,Yl'U,Uill~ kJ" uru~L~"lJ~ o<fm- CO)- OCO)OCO)'o>- <i'! 1~tJ1'!X1lU1T111Yl1LU'ULLT1"1rL~tJfL-nf1 ~ ... ...

k~~1tJlJ1~i'l "lr~lJ1f1EJ'U~1T11f~ ~1ll<il ~1'U,1'U, CO) fl~~ LU'UL~'U,~1'U,1'U, <i<!ci<f 1 ooo 1J1Yl ~

113-1 L u 'U,L~ 'U, ~1 'U, 1 'U, '"'I <i'! m <f I C(''o> kJ. <f ~ 1J1 i'l LL~ ~ T1 rn~n113J n11~~ n ~11 L v; w;h n1rnn

L oD1 ~ U1~ ~ El ~11aJ1u ~ <il~ ~1 tJ T1 'U, 113-1 vt~ cr-w El~ fl ~ vt~ *~ El ~11aJ11J ~ <ll1 Und"rn~~ n ~11 ~

1<ll tJ crv:J El~fl~~ co:l ~EJ~11J~<il"lr<ll1"lf'L~'U, 1 iLLrl'Yl1~11"1rn11 ~1U1'U co:l 1 co:l<i'!~~o <i'!kl .<fkl 1J1i'l ~

crv:JEJ~fl~~ kJ ~EJ~11J~<il~1'U1'UL~'U, ~cfo 1 ~co:l<i'!.mci 1J1i'l crv:JEJ~fl~~ m ~EJ~11J~<il~1'U1'UL~'U, ~ ~

!i'!klo 1 kl(;'){m . <i<!~ 1J1i'l crv:JEJ~fl~~ ci ~EJ~11J~<il~1'U1'UL~'U klo~~m'->m.<i'!kl 1J1i'l LL~~1'\X~~L~EJ\lli.J ~

1'\Xcrnnv:JEJ~fl~~ kl ~~11rn1 Gie:JaJ1 n1aJuru~n~1\l~~1~1uaJEJlJ~1U1~~1ncrnnYJEJ~T1~~ kl ~ ~ ... ~ ~

l~n~u\l~El ~ nfl ocio'o>.ci/co:lm(;'){(;'){ci ~\ll'U~ klco:l 'Wtl~111T13J kl<fcr'(;'){ LLoD~~~n11~~11rn1 ~\l crnnv:J El~fl~~ CO) l1~1n11tJ\l1U~~n11~EllJ"ll m ;1~~1~T111aJ1u~ <ili'l1~~~LiJ~"lJ El\lLoD1~U1~

~~

LL~::~1n'W tJ1'U, ~~n~1'U, ~1i.JL~l1 n1rndcr-w El\lfl~vr\l*~ EJ~11aJ11J ~<il ~1 tJ 1~ tJ cr-w E)~ f)~~ CO) .. ~ ~ ~

~ El \l11J ~ <il L ~ El \l ~ 1 n L U 'U, cr n ~ U 1 ~ T111J T1 3J <il LL ~ rl 1 n lJ n 1 1 iJ 1i U~ ~ U 1 ~ 1 'U, .ff 'U, ~ 'U, "lJ El \l ~ ~ ~ ~

U 1 ~ ~11 tJ 111 'W1 i'l El~ L ~ ru 1 <il tJL U ucr ~11 ~ ~EllJ 1 U n11~ <il Yl1 L El n ~11 L ~ r.J'"J n lJ n11r1 El 'UL~ U ~ ... ~

1 U .ffu~ U rl El U ~ U 1\1 ~11 tJ 111 'W 1~:; tb1u riEl U L~ U l i.J1 '\X T1 rn~ n113J n11r1 El U L~ U ~ \1 U 13J ~

1 'U, 1u n El 'U, L~ 'U, l~ iJ ~ u~ ~ 1aJiTI'n1 1~1 tJ L~ 'U,"lJ El \1 i'l1 \111 "lrn11~ rl1 ~ 'U,<i) LL ~ ~ LdJ T111J T13J ~ LL ~ ~ ~

n11u ~ u~ \11 U"lJ El~U 1~ ~11 tJ 111 'W1~UL u UL 'VI ~'Yl11 iu 1\1 ~11 tJ 111'W1U 1 L~U"ll EJ~ i'l1 \111"1rn11 ~ ~ ~

l u1 "lf L ~ El U 1 ~ 1 tJ "1J U ~1 U ~ 1 U El tJ T1 ~ \1 'W tl ~ n 11 rn ~ \1 n ~ 11 ii Ell~ l1 L U U n 1 1n 1:: Yl1

1~ tJU1~3J1i'l L~UL~ El El ci1\lf1 tJ LL1~ crv:J El~fl~~ co:l ~~~ EJ~1u ~<il"lr<ll1"lf~1~'U l 'V\3Ji'l<il LL i'l'U ~

~ 'U, LL n i'l1 \1 11 "1J n 1 1 L tJ 'U, L ~ 'U, ~ 1 'U, 1 'U, kJ I m 0 CO) I CO) ~ (;'){ . ~ (;'){ lJ 1 i'l ~ 1 'U, cr YJ El ~ T1 ~ ~ kJ ~

crv:J El\1 fl~~ m LL~:;~YJ El\1 T1 ~~ ci 1 'U~1U~n113Jn11cr~~'U13J1 'U, 1un EJ'UL~'U~1n1l'U1f111 ~ ~ .. ~

iJ l <ill "lff1113J1:: ~ <ild"::l~ ~ 13-1 ~aJ T111 1 u n1 1~ 11 ~ ~EllJ L EJ n ~11i.J 1:: n EllJ n1 1ri EJ u L~ u

~1aJ~u 1\1 ~11 ~111-w1 i'l EJ~ L ~qJ L ~ue:Jn e:Ju~~u1aJ 1 u 1u n EJUL~u -w q~ n11rn~~n ~11ii EJL~11 L U U n 1 1 n 1 ~ Yl11 <il tJ iJ 1 ~ 3J 1 i'l L ~ 'U, L ~ El El ci 1 ~ f1 tJ LL 1\1 ~ ~ ~ EJ \111J ~ <i1 "1J <ll1 "Jf ~ 1 ~U l ~ 3J i'l <i1 LL i'l U

~ULLrli'l1\111"1rn11 1<lltJcrYJEJ\IT1~~ k1 ~EJ~11J~<il"lr<ll1"lf'LUUL~U C0) 1 (;'){C0)~ 1 <i<!'o><f.okl 1J1i'l .. ~

Page 47: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

···I(I.:::U.~1M./ -" ""

.::....;) _' : c ,;)4 • f_ \!.~ .

,, "·' ~~ .............

-

ff18~1(1. le>'ti.I(I.Lklr;1Lf'fl(l.lJLl~f'fLl~L~U:::r;1:::1.'11.M r;1Lll ~ ~ ~

~~~~8~'11.~ ~ ~~~~8~~:::~,, w ~~~~8~~ ut ~~~~8~~ ~pl(\.~'11.~1:::1-f1

u~~ '11.~1:::1-f1~8 ,. ~~ ~ ~ ~ b

f'fL~~,0-~~~8~Lll.l~:::~11 ~ ~~~~8~~ w ~~~~8~~ ut ~~~~8~~~8floj111-!Ll.A. .... I I I

b ~

r;1 ~ (! '!1- ~ ~ 8 JP::: (! ~ '11. ~ 1:::1- f1 ~ '!j> ~ ~ L ~ '11. ~ 1l ~ 11 L 'tli 1. L (! ~ te> ~ ~ ~ ~ 81. ~ Ll f1 ~ LJJ ' ,.

'11.JP'ti.,E"o~81.~ Llf1~ L ,. b ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~

LHLlLM.~L~j111-!Ll.A.8f'fL~~,0-~~~8~Lll.l~:::~11 ~ ~~~~8~~ w ~~~~8~~ ut ~~~bl8~~ "' I I I

Llr;1Jt~ 1j.LlL(!Ll8'11.'11.~8floL~ 11~L~f'fL!e> l.A.LI1 po·~~~'pp® :::~11 LA.LI1 ow ·p~w' [Outf>!> ,. '

l.A.LI1 o;p·ut~~'f>!>;p~ l.A.LI1 l'w·<;;pw'Of>!>(\ '11.l'ti.L(!Llll'ti.Ll1le>t':ll11. ~ l.A.le>~~8 0 I tJ '=!' f"'t) F' f='

~ ~ ~ b

® ~~~~8~~Jt~~'tl.l~:::LM.'I31 w ~~~~8~Lll.l~~8flojU~LA.8L'tli.hL(!~1.Lll~t':l:::~11 ut ~~~~8 I I I I

~ ~

~8 flo'tl.~ 1 re Ll~f'f Lie> ® ~~~~8 ~Lll.l~ ~8fT.~~ L~'l1.8 l.lll~ 1Jt ~ LHLlLM.~'ti.JP'ti.,E"o~81-~Ll ' ' ,.

~ b b

~~~~~~8~~~8flojU~l.A.8Llr;1~~~'11.l~'l1.~ ~~;put '11.r;1L'tl.l.l(! OW ~'11.~~~ ;ppOWJW;po·®outO!~ ~ b ~ ~ b

te>~~'tl.l~ 8~~_!tl(l.f'fL!e> w ~~~~8~Lll.l~~8floj111-!Ll.A.8L'tli1.L(!~1.Lll~l':l'l1.8l.lll~1~,. f'fl.h ' ' ,.

~~,0-~~~8~~11l!~8~lr;1~1~'11.l~'l1.~ P~;J>ut re~LVHUM. ®ut ~'ti.,F~ l>PPW®J~·<;o~o Ll ~ I .... I I I I

~~ ~

8~ ~_!tl(l. re Lie> ut ~ ~ ~ ~8 ~ Lll.l~ ~ 8 flo[;1 ~ (! '!1- ~L~'tl. 8 l.l Ll ~ 1 :::~11 ~~~8 flo'ti.L~ r;1l111(1.lJ11'11. ~1 ~ b

~~,0-~~~8~~JtV~~ p~;put '11.r;1L'ti.Ll[! ~ut ~'11.~~~le>f'fl(l.~,0- ut®f>!>O®jputoo f1.(Tg I f'& I I I f't> I

~~

O®f>!>O®JPutOO f1.(Tg LA. ®®f>!>O®JPutOO f1.(Tg LA. f>!>Of>!>O®jPutOO [1.(Tg LA. 8~~'11.1(\.f'fLtel ® l.A.tel~~8 Lll.lt':l F=' F=' F=' "'""~) I=' I=' l't. I I I I

~8 flo~~ L~'l1.8 l.lll~ 1 LHLlLM.~~LJJJt ~ 8 flo~ LJJ8 ~~8 ~Lf'f ~~ L!b~~ r;1 Lf'fl(l. lJU[;1l)p f18.(Tgff1lL, Ll~~ ~ ~

'tl.l.A. 11 te>l.A.f'fl(l.1 '11.gL~_2.~ le>.(TgJt ~ Ll [;1~1 ~~L~ L~'tl.~ 1~~,0-~~~8 ~~ 11L.hl.A.~~,0-~ ~~8 ~~Jt ~ lL~ Ll~~ I I f"(( I ,..

b ~ ~

j111-!Ll.A.8L'tli1.L(!~1.Lll~t':l~~11 ~~;put f'f~LLCLl.hll ~® ~'11.~~~8~~_!bi(I.~JP1 ® ~~~~8~Lll.l ' '

~ b b

~~,0-~~~8~~~8floj111-!Ll.A.8Llr;1~t':l~~11 ~~;put '11.[;1L'tl.l.l(! OW ~'11.~~~ ;J>f!.'OWJW;po·®outo ' ,. '

b ~ ~ ~ ~

te> ~ ~ 'tl.l ~ 8 ~ ~ _!tl(l. ~ JP 1 w ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ Lll.l ~ L re 8 ~::: ~ 11 ® ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ Lll.l ~ 8 ~ l L ~ Ll ~ ~ b ~ b I ~

j111-!Ll.A.8 JP1~~,0- ~~~8 ~~ P~;put '11.r;1L'ti.Ll[! ~ut ~'11.~8 ~1lL~Ll~~8~~_!tl(l.f1~JP1~~,0- ~~~8 ~~ I ,... I I I I"&

b

te>'ti.I(I.Lkl ~L~L-1:::[;1:::1. '11. ~ r;1 LVlL~Ll~ ~'tl.l.A. 11 tel LA. f'f 1(1.1 'tl.g L~_2. ~ le>.(Tg Jt ~ Ll r;1 ~1 fl.' ~;put '11.[;1 L 'tl.l.l J. l'ut ~ ~

~'tl.~~~telf'fl(\.~,0- ~ ~~~~8~~~~ ut®f>!>O®JPutOO f1.(Tg ~ G~~_!tl(l.~ w ~~~~8~t':l~~ I f"ff I I I

~ ~

O®f>!>O®jputoo f1.(Tg ~ 8~~_!1.1(1.~ ut ~~~~(! ~~~~ ®®f>!>O®jPutOO f1jl. ~ 8~~_!tl(l.~ ® ~~~~8 ~~~ ~ ~

f>!>Of>!>O®JPutOO [1jl. ~ 8~~_!bi(I.~JP1 ® ~~~~8~Lll.l~ Lf'f8~ l.A.Lf1 WW " (\W~'®~W '11.~ '11.Q1

~ I ~ _2-~te>JTgte>~f1~~8JP ?> ~~~~8~~ LA.LI1 utC\.~f>!><; ' o~~'® '11.~1'11.Q1_2-~le>.(Tgle>~I1~~GJP w ~~~~~8~~

p~

Page 48: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~ lf111~~llth l v; u11 n11~ ~ r1 nv:l H-.'lfl~~ <9) ~ r1 nv:l H-.'lfl~ ~ rn a 'Ylli1rn11 'U'U 'U'U q

~WH-.'Ifl~~ ~ ~WH-.'Ifl~~ rn ll~~~WH-.'Ifl~~ ci WH-.'If1~ldavrurhvm~1~ll~b1~1n11WH-.'If1~ 'U 'U 'U

1~ tJ l v; u 11'il~rJI a \IW a \I f1 ~ .n1tJ1 Ul n1 ~u1u iru u~1 u ~vru n1V1 u~ l n1 ~u1u iru ll~1u ~ lrJi~VIit'-.'l~aH'Ylli1rnf11&-.'I~H~rlnWH\If1~~ <9l 1~ll~rlnWH-.'If1~~ <9l lrJi~VIli'\l~a~-.'11u~ ~b

q . 'U'U 'U'U

n1n !]1 fi:JJ ~ <f<i b1f u -;l..1~'Yl~n11W H\lf1~1lK ~y:j a -.'If!~ J\1 ~'Yl111J ~1 :JJ:JJ1 ~11 ci ~ ll~~:u1~11 cfo ~ '

llvi-.'!'V'l1~11·JnJ'ruru~~~~-.'lf'f1~unfl1a\lu~~ili~'il11rn1fl~i.Jnrt1a-.'l 'V'l.f'f. ~<f~ ll~ ~Y:J a-.'lfl~Y1 ~ ~ ~ 'U

~ Y:J a ..1 fl ~ ~ rn ll ~ ~ ~ Y:J a ..1 fl ~ ~ <i ~ 1 rJI 'll1 fl ~ :u 1 Y:J a ..1.n 1ll 1 u 1 ~ ll ~ l1 ~ 1 ~ ..1 n ~ 11'~t u l y; u 11 'U 'U

imYl'il'il'1..1u11nn11 ~WH\Ifl~~ ~ 1rJI~uVIli'\I~H ~ "ll'1J oo~b11/<9Jo~<9JC9) ~WH-.'Ifl~~ rn ~ 'U 'U

I I I CV

lrJi~uVIit'-.'I~H Y\ "ll'1J oo~b11/<9Jo~C9)o ~WH\Ifl~Yl ci l~~1JV1it'-.'l~a Yl "ll'1J oo~b11/<9)o~C9)~ l'1..1VI:IJ~ 'U

~..11u~ ~<i ~rl'U1tJU ~cfcib11 l1tJn1lK"ll'~1i'fi1~UlVI:JJ'Yl~ll'YlUlda1u~ ~<;:9' ~rl'U1ll'U ~cfcib11 q q

ll~~~ H:JJ1~W H-.'lfl~~ ~ ~y:j H-.'lfl~~ rn 1rJi~VIit'-.'l~a~-.'11u~ ~ n1nn1fl:JJ ~cfcib11 ~1'U~W a\lfl~~ <i 'U 'U ~ 'U

1rJi~VIit'-.'l~a~-.'11u~ b1f n1nn1fl:JJ ~<fctb11 H'Yl1i1rnf11&-.'l~-.'ln~11~a~rlnWa-.'lfl~~ <9) ~ q 'U'U

1~tJ~rlnWH-.'Ifl~~ C9) 1rJI~uVIit'-.'l~aa'Yl1i1rn"IJa-.'I~Wa-.'lrt~~ ~ lda1u~ C9)rn n1nn1fi:JJ ~cfcib11 'U'U q 'U ~

lrJi~uVIit'-.'I~HH'Yl1i1rn"llH-.'I~WH-.'Ifl~~ rn lda1u~ <9l~ n1n111fi:JJ ~cfcib11 ll~~lrJi~UVIU-.'I~H q 'U ~

H'Yl1i1rn"IJH\I~WH\Ifl~~ <i lda1u~ <;:9' n1nn1fi:IJ ~cfcib11 ~rlnWH-.'Ifl~~ rn ~-.'I~VIU1~rJia-.'l q 'U ~ 'U'U

~"il11rn1a'Ylmrnll~~u-;l-.'l~~n1m"il11lli1H'Ylli1rnLlK~v:la-.'lfl~~ ~ ~Wa\lfl~~ rn ll~~~WH-.'Ifl~~ <i q q 'U 'U 'U

'Yl111J .n1tJ 1 u l n1 ~u 1 u u u ll ~ 1 u ~1 rJI~u a 'Ylli1rn~1 :u :u1 <n11 <i <f ll vi \1 'V'l1~11 "ll'u ru ru~ q ~ ~

iliu~u~11"1l'n11'Yl1-.'!Unrt1H\I 'V'l .f'f. ~cfrn~ u~~VI1n~rlnWa-.'lrt~~ rn ~L~it"ilUllH'Yl1i1rn 'U 'U q

1lKu~1l~"il.n1tJ1u1~tJ~n~1i1-:JrJiu ~a.n1tJ1u1u~ C9)C9) ~mrt:u ~<f<ib11 1u~ C9)o <nmrt:u ~<f<ib11 q q

ll ~ ~ 1 u ~ b <n ~ 1 fl :JJ ~ <f <i b1f <n 1 :JJ ~ 1 ~ u ~ v:l a ..1 fl ~ ~ ~ ~ v:l a ..1 fl ~ ~ rn u ~ ~ ~ v:l a \1 fl ~ ~ <i q 'U 'U 'U

cia :u ~ ~'Yl~W a..1 fl ~~a f'f1 ~"ll a 1lKl ~nr1 auf11 ~-.'ll1tJ n 1lK"ll'~ 1 i'fi1 ~u 1 VI :JJ'Yl ~ ll 'Yl'U~\1 n ~11lrJi .n1tJ1u~tJ~nmln1~u1uuull~1u~vrun1VIu~~ll~n~1~"il11rn1a'Ylmrn ~a:u1 ~r1nv:la\lrt~~ <9)

q 'U 'U

lrJi~VIU-.'I~H~ "ll'1J oo~b111<9J~bci~ ii-.'I~Wa-.'lfl~~ ~ VIU-.'I~a ~ "ll'1J oo~b11/C9)~\lcib 'U

ii.:J~WH-.'Ifl~~ rn Ll~~VIU-.'I~a~ "ll'U oo~b11/<9)~bci<i ii.:J~WH-.'Ifl~~ <i vr-.'IVI:JJ~~-.'11u~ <9l<i 'U 'U

n1n!J1fi:JJ ~cfci<;:S' u-;l-.'l~~n11~"il11lli1H'Ylli1rn"llH\I~rlnWH-.'Ifl~~ rn <n1:JJVIU-.'I~a ~1'U~~~ q 'U'U q

~ ~li o~o<9).ocfrn/rnob1fcf ~..11u~ rno ~rl'U1ll'U ~cfci<;:S' 1lK~WH-.'Ifl~~ ~ ~WH-.'Ifl~~ rn q 'U 'U

~y:j H\1 fl~~ <i 'Yl111J 1~ ll~ f11iit"ilUll ~'Ylli1rndJun111 i'~1'U1'il<n1 :un !]VI:JJ1ll"ll H-.'ll -;)1VIU1~ ~~ ~~dJun11~1'1-:JU~~:u~ui:B'u1~VI11\11Jflfl~ 1u5u~"il~n a lU~ tJUllU~-.'1 1au ~..11u 1~ru

q

Page 49: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

Vt1 ii ~ ~ n1~'Yl u ~a tHn "H,111 ~"lJ Eh'l ~'YlliVt1 e:m ,X 1~"11 a -:1 u f1 f1 ~ ~ -:1 lU"H,f11 k-:~ 'Yl1-:JU n f118 -:1 ~

~nu 1~11 ct. ll~.:J~1~11"1l'UqJ~~iliu~u~11"1l'n11'Yl1-:Jumi1a-:~ ~.f'f. ~ct.rn~ lda~~a-:~f1~~ ~ ~~ ..:Jfl~~ rn ir~a.:Jfl~~ ct 1~i'uVtu-:~~mv<il'-:~~~n11~"il11rn1a'Yl:o1rn~-:~n~11lda1"H,~ Ci)~ ~ ~ ~

' ' Q.,l ,:::::1 Q..l ,:::l ~ 0 Q..o'

n1nlJ1f1:1J ~ct.ci~ 1"H,'Yl Ci)ci n1nlJ1f1:1J ~ct.ci~ u~~1"H,'Yl Ci) ~.:JVt1fl:IJ ~ct.ci~ ~1:1J~1~u

u~~~a:1J1t1'Yla-:~f1~~ ~ irYla.:Jfl~~ rn ll~~trv:la.:Jfl~~ ci L~U1f1~:1J1Yla-:~~af'f1~"1Ja1~\~nrw"H, I ~ ~ ~

f11 . , ..:J"lJ8-:Jt1'b1nYla.:Jf1~~ Ci) ~1:1JV!U.J~8 ~ "ll'U oo~d/Ci)o~Ci)Ci) ~ "ll'U ool!:Jd/C9)o~C9)o ~~

U~~d "ll'U oo~d/Ci)o~Ci)~ ,r.JV!:IJ~~-:Il"H,~ ~ci nb1"H,1r.J"H, ~cf.cid ~k-:~1'1XirYJa.Jfl~~ ~ ~ ~

ir oW .J fl ~ ~ r;n lL ~ ~ ir YJa -:1 fl ~ ~ ci "15 ~ 1 "If L ~ "H, LL fi Vi 1-h r.J .J 1 "H, "lJ 8 .J i' ~ LL ~ ~ L ~ n b1 8 "H, ~ ~ n 11 ~ ~ ....

~"il11rn1a'Yl:o1rn"IJa.:Jirb1nYla.Jf1~~ rn ~1:1JVtU.:J~a ~1"H,~~~ ~ ~lf o~oCi).o<f.rn/rnod<f. ~ ~ ~ ~

~-:11 ~ r;no nb1"H,1r.J"H, ~cf.ci'"' 1"H,tll"H,~k-:~r.Jna'Yl:01rn"lJ8-:Jt1'Yla.:Jf1~~ ~ irYla.Jfl~~ r;n ~ ~ ~ ~

LL~~ ""YJa._'lfl~~ ci Ld8l"H,~ (9)~ rl"vv,r.J1r.J"H, ~cf.ci'"' Ld8l"H,~ <f. ~~1fl:IJ ~cf.ci~ LL~~Ld8l"H,~ ~

~1f1:1J ~ ct.ct~ ~1:1J ~1~u f11Yla-:~ 1 "H,R1"H,~"lJ a1'1XL ~nb1a"H,~~n11~"il11rn1a'Yl:o1rn"ll a-:~ ~ ~

~b1 Yla-:1 fl~~ rn ~-:I LU"H,n11~"H,fl1Yla-:~n1 r.J 1 "H,rl1Vt"H,~ l n1~Ul"H, uu LL~l"H, ~fVt1af111'~·~._, ~ ~ ~ ~

m~ l ~-:1n11~ a-:~f1~~1:1J:IJ1~11 ct~ u ~.:J~1~11"1l'ururu~i~i-:~f'f1~unf118._'1 LL~~ili~"il11rn1 ~ "' .,

f1~unf11a.:J ~.f'f. ~ct.ct~ ~.:J,f"H, n1rn~-:~~a-ht1'Yla-:~f1~~ ~ irv:Ja._,fl~~ rn u~~trv:la.Jfl~~ ct ~ ~ ~

l~~ Yl8._'1f1~111 r.J 1 "H,1~r.J~L1~1~1:1J~nlJVt:IJ1 r.Jrl1Vt"H,~LL~1 U1~L~"H,~~8.J n11rfirt1nv:la.Jf1~~ Ci) iif11i-:1~1:1JVtU.J~8 ~ "ll'U oo~d/Ci)o~o~

~~

~._'IV! ""'-:1~8 ~ "ll'U oo~d/Ci)o~Ci)~ ~.:Jl"H,~ ~ci nb1"H,1r.J"H, ~cf.cid ~l1r.Jn1'1XirYJa._'lfl~,r-:l~"ll'~l"lf ~ ~

Yh~ l Vi :IJ'Yl~ LL 'Yl"H, ,_f "H,"ll'8U~1 r.Jnl;)Vt:IJ1 r.JVt1aLdJ 1~ r.Jiiu1~L~"H, ~"il~~ 8-:l~"il11ill1~1 :IJ ~'Ylll1rn "lJEl-:1 ""Yla.:Jfl~~ ci naw;h n1~U1"H,n111"H,n11~au"JJ'mil"il"il~.:Jf111:1Ji'U~~'Yl1._'1~~Ln~LU"H,lU ~1:1J ~ "H,~ 8"H,lL~~ilin11~1:1J~nlJVt:IJ1 r.Jn1Vt"H,~Vt1a16J

A fi' V ~ I tJ ,:::l 0 Q,..l Q,..l .c::l I 1).1

~lf111~VtLL~1lVt"H,11 "lJ8 d "lJ8-:11~LUr.JU~1"H,n"H,1r.Jn1~:1J"H,~111~1r.J ....

Vt~n nrnsrfn11U~U~L~r.J1rlUf111:1Ji'u~~'Yl1.J~::dj~"lJ8-:JL'<il1VtU1~ ~.f'f. ~cf.rn~ n1Vt"H,Wh

Ld 8 n~f111 :1J L~r.JVt1 r.J unVt1-b r.J-:11"H,"lJ 8._'11'~ 1'1XL '<il1VtU1~~ L ~ r.J1"JJ' 8-:1 Ll'<il-:1~ a tru._, flUUUJ"ll'1 .... ~ .,

1~ r.J 6Janni1 ll~ ~ 1'1Xii n1111 r.J._'J1"H,~1 :IJ ~1 ~U.ff"H,~.:Ji1 Vi Ul'V\ 1-tl £.J-:11U"lJ 8 -:~i'~LL ~-:I ,X "vv, ....

th~ aunu"JJ'a ~ 111f1Wd,.:J "lJ8-:11~LU£.JU~.:Jn~11 rl1Vt"H,W:h Ldmn~f111:1JL~r.JVt1r.J UnVt '1 r.J.:J1"H,"lJ8-:Ji'~u ~-:I 1~ lL~~i1VtU1WU 1 r.J-:11"H,"lJ a-:~i'~LL ~-:~tf u~ L Vt~ eJ"H,f111l ~811 L n~"illn

d.3 d.3 , q

n11 1::'Yl1"1J a-:1 L '<il1VtU1~"lJ a-:~Vtu 1 r.J.J1"H,"lJ a-:~i'~LL ~-:I ,X "vv, 1'1Xi1VtU1VtU1 r.J.:J1"H,"lJ a-:~i'~~._,n~11 .... ....

Page 50: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

... n!!.!!.U. m rr.rT.I:!.~/ '=' ~ ,..

,.,.ct

"' ro ~LUI'f~~U~m~c-~c-~m .. UMt~L~L'tU~L!!.~jt~ L!l~!!.L!l.fll,.[lrT.~c-,.Cl~~c-~'t\ 'ltl¥(;~1!.1!.~ 18 ~NJ ~ 1'ltfJ1

c-~1!.1!.~ 18 ~'ltl~f18~~LUc-8 fT.~t-;1 L2oL~f'fLl~fa l~'ltl~f18~ ~t~ l~ 1f"3~1f"t~ !!.~~1l~11~t'ltl~lm~ ~t

L~U~fa~~~'lt't\L~~LU(;fa ~ 1'ltfJ1 'ltllJ"!J '\1, tfa LL1!!.~~1l~11~ t'ltl~f18~~ t ~'lt't\L~~~c-~L~~~LU b b

c-L,et (;8 ~lfa ~ 1 ~~t ~ ~ ~ 11~ ~t L~ 1'\1, l 'ltL~'\1, fJ 1 [t~ 8~'t\ jt~ fa Lit\~ LrT.~ L!l.c- L~'\1, Le-e-~ 11M Lll rr.~

'lt~~~jt~~,.[l~fu,.[l'lt t'lt~1L~c-~!!.!!.~ m ~~k.'ttt G~ 1'ltl~f1G~~LU'lt[J1UL!!.c-Gp. 1 jt~fJ~1c-G ~c-~1!.1!.~ m ~ b

'ltl~f18~~LU~I';l~tL!,A~~~~ 'ltllJ"!J 'lttfaLL1!!.~~1l~11[t~'ltl~f18~ lJ"!JlJUJ./P~~ ~~rT.~!l.~l'ttc-~ b

rT.k1'tt1~L.!lL~'ltL(;U'ltL~c-~ L~ f'fL~n!!.!!.lA.1 8rT.f1G~~LUI'f~~U~'tt1~c-8 rT.'ltl~f18~~LUI'f11 c-u Lt'lt't\ 1 l""bo?o ~~n. n. &=''~

'\1, _!bfa t~ f"t1rJ Lrf't\(JUfa l~f18!l.[t~c-~~ ~1~~c-LU.~ t:rT.~f'fLl~c-~1!.1!. ~ 18 ~f18~~LUI'f~~U~'tt1~c-8rr. ... ro roro

'ltt~f18~~LU~t1rJ~L8 fJ ~1 'lt~1Z.t ~!To lJ ~~~c-8~~~t~f'fL~c-~~~c-8~UU~c-Grr.fa~l!.'!J.~L~~~11 ' ' ...

~ roro 'lt~'lt¥o1fa Lf'f't\LIUfat~f18!l.[t~c-~lL~Uc-~c- ~!!.!!.~ m ~'ltt~f18~~LU~t1fa ~L8fJ ~1 ~ ~~~c-8 ~UU~

c-~L~f'fL~~L,!b't\L~ 1 c-8 rr.~~1~~c-LU.~t:rT.~f'fLt~c-~!!.!!.~ 18 ~f18~~LUI'f~~U~~c-~c-~1KLU ~ t L!,A~t-1 ~ ' ' ...

t~11 ~L,!b'tt!!.L'ltL~~f'f't\~L~M 1f18!l.[t~c-~ c-~1!.1!.~ 18 ~f18~~LUI'f~~U~'tt1~c-8rT.'ltt~f18~~LU 'lt_!bc-~ ' ...

b b 'ltt lJ"!J L~U~'lt't\LU'ltU1lJ"!JlJUJ. rt~Lt'lt.!l ~UJ. lA.'lttc-~f'fLt~8 rT.UlA.'ltrT.f'fL~ ~rT.~!l.~t't\{;l!.fT.~'tU~L.!l~

l""b o "0:;;::1' ,.., F ,.., "' ~==' l""b F=' ,.., ,..,

b

~lA.M11fJL'ltfa~1c-~c-~11 ~c- ~!!.!!.~ m ~f18~~LUI'f~~U~~ c-8 fT.'\1, l~ f18~~LU ~ t1'lt Lc-rJ L~ L~ JU~.!llA.8 ... '

ro ~ ~~ ~ (;8 ~~ c-~ tL~ U c-~w~Ll'\1, t~ L,!b 'ttL~ 1 c-8 fT.~ ~1 ~~e-LlA.~ t: rT.~f'f Lt~ c-~1!.1!. ~ 18 ~118~

~LUI'f~~U~'tU~c-~c-~11 ~"!JlJUJ. f'f~L(JU~U P~ U.'lttc-~ ~"!JlJUJ.fPO~GJ.~ U.~rt~!l.~t't\c-!!.c-~L~ l""b I f='" l""b f=' f=' l""b l""b f"b 0 ..... I I I

ro ro ro ~~~c-~ ~ ~~~c-8~UU~ rJt~~c-~~~c-8~~c-~f'ft~'lt~rJL~'tt~t:rT.~c-8~~L,!b't\L~1~rJ~1

I I 1"'1 1"'1 I

b "' lA.LrT. PlJ. UJ. ~'lJl)j~ ·~ 'ltt 'ltL~jt~fJ L't\~LrT.~~~L!l.c-L~'ltLc-c-~11 MLLlrT.~'lt~~~jt~~ ,.[l~fll ,.[lrf L~'\1, ~1

"' b b b

L~~~fll~ L~~~L~ jt~~ ~rT.~!l.~ l'ttc-~rr.~m~L.!lL~ ~ U.M 11 fa L'\1,8 ~'ltLN~ L~ lJ "!JlJ UJ. f'f~ Ll 'lt£l ~ UJ.

~'ltl(;~f'fLt~8~U~'lt,.[l~~~c-~!!.!!.~1G~'ltl~f18~~LUI'f~~U~'tU~Lrt8~ lJ~lJUJ. 'ltrJLfa'\1,~ UJ. ~'ltlc-~ ' '

lJ~lJUJ./P~~ ~c-~L~f'fL~c-~!!.1!.~ 18~~1-'tt t 8~ 1(;~1!.1!.~ 1 8~f18~~Lllf'f~~U~'tt1~c-~c-~11(;~L~U88 I I I 1'\ I

b b "' ~~c-~~rT.~!l.~l'tt(;~fT.~'tU~L.!lL~'ltL(;U_!bL~ jt~faL't\~LrT. P- ~o~OUJ.- C9J.- l)jlJO ~rT.~1~fll,.[l

b "' b ~rT.~!l.LrT.L~ ~~HU 1~LUJU~Ll 't\~:!~11~~HU 1~LU8 ~ 1~L~ L'lt.!lrT.~~ ~~fll,.[l~f11~~~f1~!l.~l'ttc-~

b b "' b

rT.~'tU~L.!l~'ltLc-U _!bL~ ~ ~L!l.c-L~'ltL(;c-111MLL1rT.~'lt ~~~~ ,.[l~fll ,.[l'ltt'lt~1L~jt~ lJ"!JlJUJ. f'f~~Uf'f ~UJ. b b b

~ '\1, l--8 ~ 1 ~L't\~rT.'\1, Lc-'lt '\1,~ 11_!1.~ f'f ~ U 'ltLc-'lt t111'ltLc- L ,!bIt\ t~UL!!. 'ltL(;fa L~l1~~~~11 ~!To~ l'tt c-~ b

rT.~'tU~L.!lL~'\1, L(;U_!bL~ L~~~c-0-11~c-~!!.!!.~ 18 ~8 ~1 fat~~ ~~LUI'f~~U~'IU~c-8 rT.L'tU~L!!.~~LU

c-8 rT.!!.~~1 t~11 L~ t1 ~'lt't\L~ ~ t ~LUI'f~~U~'IU ~c-~c-~n~LU '\1, t L~~'lt't\L~ ~ ~~~t Z0 t ~!l.c-8 ~ ... '

ro ro 'lt_!b~ ~'ltlA.11 ~ U.f'f It\~ '\1,~ L~'ltt'ltL~~~11 ~t: 11~(;8 ~ ~ 11~tfJ !J1'lt~ 1 f'f Lt~8'lt~1L'IU!:L!!.~8 ~ 1

" I I I

LZ. UEo [t~ fa~ 1 c-~ 't\~'111 ~'\1, ~~ ~ 1 ~ ~ c- LU. ~ t: 11~ f'f Lt ~ c- ~!!.!!. ~ 18 Jf-11 8~~LU f'f~~ U ~'111 ~ c-~ c- ~11

OlJ

'

Page 51: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~81JW mYJ-;J-;J1-:!fl113J11J~~rvn.:~~::;Liien~u~nflrn::;wct.:~ L Yl 8VJ111~ ~~ 8.:!11J~ en"ll'en 1 "lffi1 ~u L Vi 3J

'Ylen LJ'Ylu VJ'18 fi1 L ~tJ VJ1 tJVJ'18 LaJ d:Jwil1 u 1 UL~ UL rh len ~ n~.:~ 1: ~ n!)V!3J1 tJVJ1m-::;dj tJ1J len

fill\~ >I h\ n110'~1J0'1U"Ji' ilLY\ ilil'i" Lil "".;' U \\lfi0'1llJ0'1UL f\ufi.lliU~ L101 LLil1 il~l'i111i e-~~nf1~81J~1u tt uL~tJLu LL~ 8 ci1.:~1en e-~~n11~81J~1u"l1' 8 L YJ-;J-;]1-:~Lu 8-:!~u~.:~n~11 ~.:~~13-11:!1

t.t1 L~l "lfu1::;n 81J l un11~';111rn1V!1 ~1 ~ ~ 8.:!11J ~en'Yl1.:1 ~::; Liien~ 8V!U 1 tl-:!1Wll 8.:!1~L~ ~.:1-J u .1. ~ ~

n1::;t1un11l un11~81J"l1' 8 L YJ-;J-;J1-:!fll13J11J ~en'Yl1.:1 ~::;Lii en ~.:~ dJu Luen1:1J.ffuen 8Uu~::;ilin11 en13J 'n!)V!3J1tlrl1V!UenLL~1 ~'Yl1i1rn"ll8-:!~Yl8-:!fl~~ ci ~.:~VJ'.:~LaJ~u . -

fl ~ ~u1::; L~u ~-;)::;~ 8.:1~';111rn 1 ~ 8 1u11 ~Yl 8-:lfl ~~.:~ ~L~ n1::;rh ~::; Lii en~ 8 ~

~!1 nv:J 8.:1 fl ~ ~ <0) VJ'18 LaJ LL~::;VJ1n dJ u n11n1::;'Yl1 ~::; Lii en u~1 ~Yl 8 .:~ fl ~~.:~ ~L~ n1::;'Yl1 ~1 tJ ~~ ~

-;)._'I hVJ'18U1::;3J1'Yl L~'UL~ 8 8 cil-:!1'1 tJLL1-:!V!'18 LaJ

~ L fl11::;vi'LL~1 L y; U l1 3J1 en11 cikl o LL V: .:!U1::;3J1 ~n!) Vi 3-11 tJLL yj .:1 LL~::;vn rn"ll' rJ

""~11 e-~Len-;J.:~l-;JVJ'18 U1::;3J1'Yl L ~UL~ 8 'Y11~ 81J fl fl ~ ~u Len tJ ~ enn n Vi 3-11 tJ 1 ~L "ll1 L ~tJV!1 tJ ~ , ~

~.:ILL '~ienn~ mi11.:1n1ml~ 8U13JtJn~ L~1ll1yjll~ 'Yl1yjrJ~UV!'18~'Yl~8ci1-:!Wct-:18ci1-:!lenn~ "" ' ""

rh 11 ~ oJ u 'Y11 ~ ::; L ii en -;(} 1 ~ 8 .:~1 i fi 1 ~ u L ~ 3J 'Yl en LL 'Yl u L ~ 8 n 11 oJ u LL ~ ::; 3J 1 en 11 <0) o LL V: .:~ ~

'V'j1::; 1"1l'U ruru~ fl113J11J ~ en'Yl1.:1 ~::;Lii en"IJ 8.:1 L ,)1V!U1~ 'V'j. ~. kJ <fm ~ u ruru~11 1 'U n1m ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

L ,)1 'IX 1~ L uu~n1::;'Yl1 ~::; Lii en~ 8V!,;, l tJ .:11'U"ll 8 .:~1~ tl1 L U'U n11n1::;'Yl1l un11U nu~ Vi 'IX 1 ~ ~ ~ ~

n11L tJn1'8-:!fi1~'U LV!3J'YlenLL'Yl'U-;J1m-;l1V!U1~ 1 ~t.t11J'YlU ruru~3J1en11 ~ 3J1li'u-:~~1J lentJ8'U l~3J ... ... , ~.:13-1 en11 ~ LLV:.:!'V'j1::;11"1l'Ururu~~.:ln~1l ururu~11 V!ttJtJ-:!1'U"ll8.:!1~~~'Yl~L1tJnl~

QIQI QIQI at.9

L ,)1 U1~ ~rl1 ~::; Lii en"ll'en 1 "lffi1 ~'U L ~ 3J'Yl en LL 'Yl'U~.:In ~11 LL nVJtb tl-:11'U"ll 8.:11~1.~ TI1 L ,)1V!U1~ ~ ~

L~n ::;'Yl1n11tf u LU~1 tJf1113J-;J.:I hVJ'18U1::;3J1'Yl L~UL~ 8 8 ci1.:~1'1 mL1.:1

en13-1"11' mYJ-;J-;J1.:~1ufl~d' ~v:J 8-:lfl~~ <0) 1enl.~n 8tJf11~ 8flrn::;nTI3Jn11~81J"l1' mYJ-;J-;]1.:~ ~

0 Q..<l Q...l Q..<l ,:::1, I i.l ~ ~ Q...l J:lr.

"ll 8.:1 1Un-:11U~11i11rn~"ll-;J.:IVJl en"ll'~1J1 en 8 fl ru,::;n113Jn11~81J"ll 8 L 'Yl';l-;)1.:1 fl113J11J e-~en , , 'Yl1.:1 · ::;Liien11 ~Yl8-:~fl~~ <0) ~~1Lmu.:~LuuL-;l1~U1~iLfl11::;vi'u1tJ1J1mL~::;ue-~u 'il U1::;-;(}1.:~1u

~ .

' I Q..l .:::::., 0 Q...l Q..l Q.; ~ ,:::1, Ill .d. Q..l &:Ito

LLe-J .:11 u n ~ 3J ~u1J ~u U-:11U1J1V!11 ~1 u n-:~1 u~11J11rn ~"ll -;J.:IVJ 1 en"ll'~1J1 3J Vi u 1 'Yl11J e-~ en"ll' 8 1J . , , , , .:~1u 1::;nu~"lllll'V'j .:~1uuen1u1::;nu~"llll1'V'j .:~1uuen1~1 ~~n11U1::;"1l'1"1l'U~1u1nH1'V'j tJ11J1~ , , .:11'U cv en1U1::;n 'U~"ll 111 'V'j LL ';i .:1.:11 'U~1-:I"ll'1 ~ LL ~::; L uu~11J ~en "ll'8 1J .:11'U 1 fl1.:1 n11U en'lU1::;n 'U , ~

~"ll 1yjLL1.:1.:11'U~1-:!"ll'1~ lentJ~'U1.:1~1ltlll1'V'l1 'Yl8-:!L~ru ~.:ILUU~n-;l1-:~i1fl111 ~1LLV!U.:! , , ... ~

'V'lu .:~1uuru:n 1~11J3J 81JVJ3J1 tJ 1 ~'Y11.:~1uL ~ tJ1n1Juru:nn1111J~1 m~u 1 u Lfl1-:ln1'l~.:~n~1l ... ...

Page 52: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~1 u n11fl1 u fl ~ ~ ll ~ n 11U fi u~ .J 1 U"lHh'l u 1.J ~11 tJ 111 yj1,f u ~~ eJ .J fl ~ ~ G> d] U~ ~Hl ~ ~ 'IJ ~ ~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

n11U 5u~.J1wffu~u ll~ :;~u 1.Jil'Yl11yj1 ~1 it~ rJ l-:D'T}Hl'1 ~llfl11:;~ U 1 tJ U1 tlll~:; ll~U ~ i1VIU1~hml~U.J1U i.Jll<lill 'V'j.fl. klcfrnrn "ilU~.J1u~ G>cf ~n11fl~ klcfctcf d]u~u.J~uuru"151

'IJ QJ

ll~:;G) eJ ~1U1.J1.JYi11 'V'j1it"15~ 1"ll l-:5'1VIU1~llfl11:;~u 1 £JU1 tJ u~:; ll~U ~ lUUi1VIU1 ~ ~

~1£JU~U.J1Ull'YlUU1.Jil'Yl11yj1 ~1ii,~rj' i.JUGilU~ G>~ ~n11fl~ klcfctcf "ilU~.JlU~ rno "'

nuu1 uu kl cf ct cf hw 1 u n11u 5u~.J1U 1 u 1 f11.Jn11U~1U1:; nu~"ll1l1'V'j ll1.J.J1U<li1.J"151 ~ i! u

~~ eJ.J f1 ~~ G> i.~ ~ eJUVI ~1 u 1 i u 1.J ~11 tJJl1'V'j1l u u~d:Jn~1 m~U"il1nllu 1 f111 ll ~:;~ mJ 1 i 'IJ ~ 'IJ

"' "' i.u bl eJUl~'U, "il1nllU 1fl11ll~:;~ eJ l~ 'U,~~ "il1 n l)'U, 1 fl11~1~1 tJ 1 ill n l-:5'1VI it 11 ~ 'fl.J 1 il UU~l n u

'IJ

ll1.J.J1 UGi1.J"151 ~ U~ ~:; h .J yj £J1U1 ~"il:;..ij' ~Yl11 fl1.J n11l ~Ue:l G) eJU 1 r.Jll yj'Yl rJ ~11l11n!,~"ll ..ij'.JVIl ~ ~

l ~ eJl~';J11n.1,1eJUdJ~ ld eJ L~1Un11eJUdJ~1 '\K~1 £Jll~11Un11bleJUl~U"il1nllU1fl11 ~~ e:l.Jfl~~ G> ~ ~ 'IJ

i.~ ~11"il ~eJ u u eJ ~ l~ u 1 u 1 Ubl eJ u l~ uu1.J d'J Ufl ~.J f1111 l d eJ n11~ n11~ .J u 1 ~ 1 u 1u rl eJ Ul~ u

fl1U ~e:l .J fl Ull~1 U 1.J ~11 tJ 111 yj1 L~ t.b 1 U bl eJ U l~ U3-J1 1 '\K ~ ~ eJ .J fl ~ ~ G> ~11 "il ~ lU UU1.J fl~.J ~ 'IJ 'IJ

1 ~ u1:; u:; ll1n ~u 1.J ~11 tJ 111 'V'j1~1 Y11.J1u 1 VI 3-l 'J i.~tb ~11 i ~11 "il ~ 'Yl n fl~.J ll<li1:; u:;VI ~.J ~ 'IJ ~

i.a.Ji.~tb~11 i ~11"il ~ ld eJU1.J ~11 tJJl1'V'j1tb 1url eJUl~U i.ubl eJUl~U';l1nllu 1 f111 "iJ:;u eJ n 'IJ ~

~~ eJ., f1 ~ ~ G) di eJ u 'Yl n fl~Yh"ll eJ eJ u ru1 ~ i.u llu 1 fl11 1 u 1:; u:; ll1n ld eJ i.u rl eJ ul~U~1"il1 n 'IJ ~ ~ QJ

llU1f111ll~1 ';l:;tb l~U~~~ lUn~11 i ~11-;}t!'u l Yi uunu tJ eJ~~"il:;G) eJ.J~1 tJ 1 ~ nu 11-Jyj £J11J1 ~

~1 ~VI ,_r., ~eJ~11.J'V'j £J1 u1 ~"ll eJ eJ udT~ ~1 ~1 u 1url eJUl~ u "il1n llU 1 f111 i.a.Ji.~ Y11 ~1l u 1 i.il ~ eJ ~

~11 "il ~eJ u i.a.J ~ n11ll-:5' .J 11-J 'V'j £J1 u1 ~ l u u VI ,r., ~eJ 1 i ~11'u l~ u ~ bl eJ u "il1 n llU 1 f111~1ll ~1

U <li1 "lfi ~ll-:5' .J 'Yl1.J 1 'Yl1f1'yj 'Yl1 ~ l-:5'1 VI U 1 ~ ~1u ~ ~ "15 eJ U .J1 UU 1:; n U ~"lJ 111 yj "lJ eJ .J 11-J yj £J1 U1 ~ 'IJ ~

~11'Ul~U~~ 1u1:;u:;u1n l~U~bleJU~1"il1nllU1fl11 ldeJ~1£JLJJV1~~ U1.J~11£J111yj1 ~

"i]:;u1l~u~1~1ni.inu~~eJ.Jfl~~ G) ll~:;~~eJ.Jfl~~ G) i.~c.hnu1.Jn'Yl11'V'j1 ~1u~rr 'IJ 'IJ

l n U 1 n M1 Li1 U 1:; tJ:; VI ~ .J U 1.J ~11 tJ 111 yj 1 "il:; l aJ U 1l ~ U ~ l VI~ eJ ~ 1 tJ ~ 1 ~ 1 n ~ W eJ .J fl ~ ~ G> ~ 'IJ

v ' "'

11 ~'fl.J 1ubl eJ Ul~ Url iJL~U1 ~11 ~ ~11"il ~eJU ll~:; ~~ eJ .J fl ~.yj G> nla.JL~~ ~~1 ~ ~ n'fl.J 'IJ

u 1.J ~11 tJ 111 'V'j1 1.~1 i r1 eJ tJ 'h G1 eJ f1 rn:; n11~ n11~eJ u"li eJ l Y1 "il "il1.J"ll eJ .J ~1 t!' n .J1 u~11l11rn~"ll ~ ~

..ij., Vll ~ "15 ~ u 111 ~ ~ e:1 ., fl ~ ~ G) ll ~ :; u 1 .J .n 'Yl11 'V'j 1 ~ 1 u ~ rr v: 1 VI ,x 1 ~ 1 u ll ~ u., 1 u ~ 'IJ

' i.~ ~ eJ u VI ~1 tJ 1 i Yl1.J1 'U, 1 fl1.J n11U ~ 1U1:; n 'U,~"lJ 111'V'j ll1.J.J1 u<li1.J "151 ~ 1 ~ tJ Yl1 u 'U, .y; n l ~'U, eJ ~

ll~:;Y11uru:nn111'u~1 m~ul ~ u1nu 1f11.Jn11~h.Jyj u1u1~ l~um "li1~1 1~ u ~~ eJ.Jfl~~ G) QJ 'IJ

Page 53: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~~L "" 'l-l.il'LnH£.J'ii.V\U._'I~ElL~'il.m-hui1VIU1~1 £.J LLe-l'U._'I1'UL ~ e:J 1 \Ku1 £.J LLYfYl rJ~11lTH\.b~"ll~._'IV\l~ ~ ~

e:J'Uif~1f1";i._'l n1";i Ld e:J 1 ";i ._'! Y'W1lJ1 ~ ~1 Lit 'U n1";iLL~1 ~~l'11 L~e:J._'I L U n L~'U6J1~ ~1 £.JLLe-l'U._'I1'U ~

~'U ~::;~ 6J 'Vfuu Vln L ~'Ue:J'U 1 £.J LL 'V'l'Yl rJ ~11l1";illi~"ll ~._'IV\ l ~ e:J'UdJ~~1 £.J L~ 'U 1~ £.J LL 'UlJ 1 Tl";i ._'ln1";i ~ ~

LL~~ ~ e:Jn~1";i~L~£.J1"Jie:J._'I:U~1£.J 1~£.J~1'U~Yle:J._'If1~~ Cil LL~~i1VIU1~1£.JLLe-l'U._'I1'U ~1uili~1";i Lun hu~1nllu 1 T11";i L~ au1 mL 'V'l'Yl rf ~11l1";illi~"ll~._,VI1 ~ audT~1 \K ~1 m~uLL~1 il'Yl e:J._'jf1~Yi Ci)

~ ~ ~

~~ 1 ~uLunn auL~'U~1nllu 1 f11";i ~u~~ Luuil'L ~ £.J'U";i1 £.J ~~ L ~ £.J ~~1u 1'UL~u~._, 1 'l-1.1un auL~u ~

LL~1 °11unauL~u 1u1 \Kn";i";i6Jn1";iil'~ ~1u1~~._,u16J~1u1u kl flu 1~mmud1£.J~~L~£.J~ 1f1";i._'ln1";i ~

au1\Kn";i";i6Jn1";i~";i1~~~1£.J LL~~._'ILL~~ull 'V'l.~. kl<f<t<t LUW~l'U6J1 ~uL~6JU";i:::~uuruV\1 ~ ~

1";iL~ 'U LL~~L v; Wlfe:J._'I'Yl1._'1~ ~~U1L~'U~~~1nU ru;LL";i._'I._'I1'U~1._'1"lf1~ 6J11"lfL~ 1~ £.Jn1";ifle:J'UL~'U~~ ~

1L~La._, ~a n1";iL a11un auL~u 1u1 \Kil'~ ~1u1~~._,u16J Lun~1 £.JT1116JLl11._, 1~ 1~ £.J'tl1 ~

'UL~ u 1 ~LL Yl6J L ~'Ue:J ~._, u 16J 1 \K ir~ ~1 u 1 ~ ~ ._, 'U 16J LL~LaJ ~ L e:J n ~1";iU";i~ n e:J lJ 1u fl e:J'UL~ 'U ~

LL~1 LLYl6JVIU15~1uLuuL~a._,n1";iLun~1 m~uu";i~nu~"llfl1'V'l ~._, 13-l L ~ £.J1"1i a._,nu1un auL~u ~

'U 1 T11";i ~ 'UL "li11 ~11 n";i";i6J n1";if1._'1 L "li11 ~11 L U'UL~e:J._'j L~ £.]1 n 'U ~._'I~ ._'I'l-l, 16J 1 u 1u fl EJUL~'U

~uL wrla._'I'Yl1._'1L-riwd ~~1~u5u~~~EJ~6J1 ~1n"limY1~~1._,~._,n~11 Lv;u1~11 ~v:Ja._,T1~~ Ci)

LU'Url1V\U1~~._'1~V\U1~1u ~~"lfEllJ 1~ [J~";i._'l 1 un1";i~1 L Uu~1U 1f1";i._'ln1";iU~";iU";i~nu~"llfl1'V'l

LL ~ J Jc \1 ~Wlll ~ LL ~"ij 1-1 ,X l ~ Li'J \1~ ~~1 il 1HllJ m~~ ~llh W mHll ~ m fi lJ nl~{l <J tiL~ u1 ~ .ffu ,;' \1

nau ,'l-1.1._'1~11 £.Jfl1'V'l";i~._'l LU'U'V'lUn._'I1UUru; ~~'tl11un EJUL~U 1u1 \KT1m~n";i";i6Jn1";i~~~1'U1~ ~ ~ ~

~._,u 6J 1 u 1un EJUL~U LL~~~V\U1~T11lJT16J~ LL~n1";iUniJ~._,1U 1 u.ffu~'U"ll EJ._'I'l-1.1._'1~11 £.Jfl1'V'l";i ~ ~ ~ ~

LL~~ El._'lf1~~ Cil n~uu~EJ£.JU~~~~L~£.J1\Ku1._,~11£.Jfl1'V'l";i~._,LUUL~£.J._,~n~1._,i1T1";i11 ~ ~ ~

Lun~1 m~u~1 nllu 1 f11";iLL~~6J EJlJ 1 V\Lun auL~u ~1 nllu 1 f11";iLL~d\ EJ L~u~~~1nllu 1 T11";i

6J1~ £.J1\KunL~1wd ";i16J~._, 1\KLuuil'Lnu1nM1~6J~~~-hnllu1T11";i LL~~ij1~~n11~11~~au ~ ~ ~

n11L nn e:J'UL~'U~1nll'U1T11";i"ll El._'I'U1._'1~11 £.Jfl1'V'l";iLL~ mh._, 1~ ~'ULU'UL Vl~l'111 \Ku1~~11 £.Jfl1'V'l";i ~ ~ ~

~£.J 1 an1 ~~._,n ~11'Yl~1~ L unn EJUL~'l-1.~1 nuru;U~";iU~~nU~"llfl1'Y'l LL 1._'1._'11U~1._'1"lf1 ~ ~ ~ ~

uru L~"ll~ ocfrn- kl - k!OCi)OCi) - ~ ~1U1U ~<£f)~._'! LU'UL~U <f.~~o,<i\)kJ.cfw' lJ1'Yl LL~~L~'U ~

1uu ;L~U'YlUV\6J'ULl£.J'UU~1U1~nU~"llfl1'V'l "L~U'YlUUru; kJ" uru;L~"ll~ ocfrn- Ci)- OCi)QCi)\)- ~ 'I q q q QJ Ql

~1u u Cil T1~._, LUUL~'U ~<icf,ooo lJ1'Yl 1u1iL~EJu1d£.J"Jft!~1U<?i'1 1~VI11._'1lU~ kid 6Jn";i1T16J

rn TI._'Il'l-1.~ rn 'V'l~Mfl1T16J klcf<icf 116-l w'\) fl~._'l LUUL~U \),~rncf , <i\)kJ.cf~ lJ1'Yl

11n";i~l'11~._,n~11"llEl._'lil'YJEJ._,T1~~ Ci) iiEJL~11il'YlEJ._,T1~~ Ci) ~~L~£.J~EJV1u1~ijl~ ~ ~

Page 54: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~8 ~~fl._,~ LL~nTnJ 1111~vnX1 ~"11 8._,u 1._, ~11 un1-w~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~u331~ if111~~~31'~~~1._, 1 un1~ ~ dJ ~

uij11~V!u1~"1J fl.,~u auLuun1~tl ij11~V~u1~1~ u1~1 if111 ~~~31'~~~1., ~1 ~n1~~V!u1~ ~uLuu"li8.,'Yl1._, 1 iu1._, ~11 Ll1l1'W~fl1i u18n1 ~LL~~V~u1~n~~'Yl1n1~'Yl~~~ Ern Llfln L~u 1u1-K

~ ~

L~8tl1dmnX~1ui1 LUULV!~'Yl11i'Yl1.,~1"1fn1~L~1uf111~L~LIV!1LI n~&,~.,ti8-:h~~fl._,f1~~ CO) ~ ~

l~n~:;'¥11 ~~ L3J~~1 Llf111 ~U~~~1'Yl L~'UL~ 8 8 ~1._,f1 LILL ~._, ~._,~ 8._,1'lJ ~~ 1 'Ue.J ~ LL ~._,n1~n~~Yl1

~~L3J~tfu ~1~~1~~1 COJa U~~nfllJrllJ~1~~1 ~ LL~.,'W~~~1"1f11ruru~f111~1'u~~'Yl1._,~~L3J~ ... ...

"" "' .d "1Jfl.,L":il1Vi'U1'Yl 'W .fl. l!:l<:frn<;<!

~1Vi1'lJ~~fl._,f1~~ l!:l ~~fl._,f1~~ rn LL~~~~fl._,f1~~ ~ 1u~1U~n~~~n1~ ~ ~ ~ ....

~ ~ ~ 1 'U 1 ~ ~ ._, ~ 1 L1 ij 8 ~ 8 L U n bl 8 'U L ~ 'U ~ 1 n 11 nJ ~ 11 ~ ~ U ~ ~ n U ~ "lJ 111 'W LL ~ ._, ._, 1 'U ~ 1._, "1f 1 ~ ~ ... ~

11ru~L~"lJ~ a<frn -l!:J -l!:JaCOJaCOJ- ~ eJ1._,'-hl~Lif111~~~~~~:;1._,1Un1~~._,~1Lii:J8~81u1Ublfl'UL~'U ...

~1~~'U1.,~11 Ll1l1'W~ 'Ylfl._, L ~ru L~'Ufl 1~ Lll~~~1~~8lJ Llfl~L~'U ~~~blfl'UU~~n fllJrllJ Lfln ~1~ ~ ...

Vi~n~U~1._, G) 1un1~LiJn-;J1LILL~1'Ylnf1{._,n fl'U~._,mLii:J fl~fltf 'U, L~'Ul1 ~~ fl._,f1~~ l!:l ~~fl._, f)~~ rn .... ~ ~ ~

LL~~~~ fl._, f)~~ CS:: l~l i TI 8 Ll ~1 ~ 8 f1 rn~n~~~n1~~81J"JJ m fl~ ~~ ._, f111~1'lJ ~ ~'Yl1._, ~~L3J ~ ~

1~LI~~e:J.,f1~~ l!:l 1ine:JLI~1l1 Lde:Jl'U,~ rna liu11f1~ l!:l<:f~l!:l 1~1lJ~e:JlJV!~1LI1iLU'U, ~

t./.:::::1 o A d fi' ~ e.J ~ 81 u 1 ~ flfl u L ._, u ~ 1 n liU 1 f11 ~ L -w 8 n 1 ~ L n ~~ ~ LL ~~~Vi n ~ rn n 1 ~ L n ~~ ~ ~1 "lJ 1 ozr ~ u ~ ~ ~

~1~nun~~~n1~~u~n rn flU U~~nfllJ~1LI'U1LILL'W'YlrJnl,~._,~ ~V!L~li1oW~lll1 'U1.,Il'Yl~1'W~ ~1it~rJ LL~~~~fl._,f1~~ rn 1~Lin1~~._,'U,1~1u1Uflfl'UL~'U~1nli'U1f11~ 'U1.,~11LI1l1'W~ 'Ylfl._,L~nJ

~ ~ ...

~:;'it 11lJ flfl'UL~'U 'Wffl ~Vi~ n ~1Un1~8'U~~ ;._,-;11 L1 L~'U~11 i ~ ._,u, 1 ~ 1~ LI'U 1._, ~11 L11l1'W~~~ .... ~ ~

;LL~._'IU1:;n fllJV!~ n~1u ~~ fl._,f1~~ l!:l 1~ ~~1~~ L18~~1u 1UL~ u 1 u Vi~ n~1un1~e:Ju~~ ;._,-;~1 u ol3 cu cu ol3 'I

LL~~LI8~~1'U, 1'UL~'U, 1u 1Uflfl'UL~'U Ld 8L ~ 'U, l1 LI8~~1'U 1'UL~'U,~~._,nu, ~._, l~ ~._,'U,1~ 1 'U, 1un e:J'UL~'U,

1~LI~~1~~8lJ'Ylnf1{._, ~1U~~fl._,f1~~ rn 1in8LI~T:h ~~e:J._,f1~~ rn L~1u~8lJV!~1LI1iLUU ~ ~ ~

~~ ~ 1 u 1 ~ ~ ._, u 1 ~ 1 u 1u n 8 u L ~ u ~ 1 n 1i u 1 f11 ~ L ~ u n 1 ~ L n ~ ~ ~ LL ~~~Vi n ~ill n 1 ~ L n ~ ~ ~ ~

~1"1J1"1f~lJ~ 11ru~L~u11~~tl~~nU~"lJ1l1'WLL~.,.,1'U,~1.,"1f1~ ~.,LL~l'U,~ rna TI'U11f1~ l!:l<:f~l!:l ~ ... ~

1~LI~e:J._,~._,'U1~~1~nun~~~n1~~U~n rn flU ~e:J ~~e:J._,f1~~ l!:l 'U1LILL'W'YlrJni,~._,~ ~

~V!L~li1oW~U LL~~'U,1.,Il'Yl~'W~ ~1u~rr ~e:J~1Ldu1u~ <f n~1l1oW'UTI l!:l<:fCS::<f 1~nn1~LU~LI'U, ~

n~~6Jn1~"1f~1Vi~ tl~~nulJ~1LI ~~u._,f1~~ rn ~~u._,f1~~ ~ U1LILL'W'YlrJ~ruiu 1~u1 ~ ~ ~ ...

LL~~u1._,~ ._,Yi11 -w1it"lf~ 1 "11 1 ~ Ll n1~~._,u 1 ~ 1 u 1un e:JUL~u~1 n liU 1 f11~ u 1._, ~11 Ll1l1'W~~~ LUU ~ ~ ~

~'it11unuUL~u-wfu~Vi~n~1ULL~~~~~Ti~1n'it1~11i~~u._,f1~~ rn ~._,u1~ ~~e:J._,f1~~ rn ~ ... ~ ~ ~ ~

Page 55: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

1~~ ~ 1"il~eJ1J~~n~lU'Y1nf1~~ ~1~nu 1ufleJUL~u~'lll:JJl1i~~ulaJ LL~1l£J~~L~ u~ 1T11~nl1L~LV:u "" q

lJl~r~~"il~Luu~~~Ul3J 1 u 1ur1 eJUL~unl u~ ~~"illn~n113Jnl1T1U~u 1~ ~~u l3J u~1 lJl~Tl~~n ~~] :uri eJUn11~nl1T1U~U 1~£JUl~~1£Jfll'W15l~1ln11:1Jnl1T1U~UL~ eJ ci "llfl 1\K ~~t.l.l3JLUri flU

q 'U

~1 ~v:leJ~Tl~~ ~ 1 \Krl' eJ uf1l1l n1rn1T11~nl1 1 i'L~u~h~'W tJllJl~~l~ 6J 'Yll1T11~nl1 1-iL~u

LL1~ l lt.l.~l~"lfl~ L ~ £J1rl1Jnl1T11~~ 3JU eJ~nu 1 1Tl~~~fl"illnLL1~~lU~l~"lfl~ ~l tJLLt:-Jt.l.~lU <J~L ueJ 1T11~nl13Jl1 \K~v:l eJ~Tl~Yl ~ eJu:JJ~1T11~nl1 1 uu l:IJUl mL'W'Y1 rr~llll1ru~"1J~~wr~

'U q q

Ld eJ T11~nl1L~1u eJu:lT~ LL~1 11 ~'W tJllJl ~"il~4il L il, unl1~n :u 1T11~nl1 "illntt u 1 1~'W tJllJl~ q

' 0 Q.,.l~ Q,..l~ &). I A Q.; ~ I 1 A

"il~'Y1 ~u~ ~eJ"ll eJ eJUaJ~ LlJn"ill m~u~l :u~ ~n ~lu 'Y1l ~UeJ:IJl ~1un1~1J1unl1"1J eJ~nl1"ill m~u q ""

1~1 ~'WtJllJl~"il~LUU~Ul~"lleJ~~lmLt:-JU~lU ~oWeJ~Tl~~ ~ L~1u:ueJ1J~:IJltJ1\K~~ulaJ 'U

113-l ...,1Jn11:1Jnl1~U~n rn flU :~LL~lU~ ct. n:unTv~\.rfi l!:Jcf.~ct.1~£Jt.l.l~~l1£Jfll'W1"il~LUU q q

~1-b lJfl eJUL~t.l. 'WfflaJ lfln~l1~ ~n~lt.I.U1~n fllJ 1 t.~.nl1LUn~l tJ LL~~~:IJ~~ ~lnllUlfll1:1Jl ~1 tJ 'U "" q 'U

~u 1 ""~11"\l~ ~n~lu 'Y1nf1~~~1~nu 1ufl eJUL~u~'lllaJl1 \K~~Ul:IJ nl1~~Ul:IJ 1 u 1ufl eJUL~u "" q

n11 nl1T1U~U"il~~~Ul3J3JlrieJu ~v:leJ~Tl~~ ~ ~~L~~~Ul3J~l3JLU "illn"lim Yl<J<J~~~~n~l1 'U

~ll ~v:leJ~Tl~~ kl ~v:leJ~Tl~~ rn LL~~~v:leJ~Tl~~ ~ SJ1~"1ff11l3J1~:J1~1~1~1unl1 'U 'U 'U

~eJ u L eJ n ~l1~ ~ n ~l uri eJ u nl1~ ~ ~l u ~ eJ 1 u 1ufl eJUL~ u 'Y1 n Tl~~ <illaJ ~ n ~l15l ~ <J~ ~ "" q

~~~ n 1~1 if11l3J1~ :J1~1~1~ t.~.l~~l1 £Jfll'W1cieJ:uL~~l:IJl1munrl eJUL~u 1u1 i'L ~ eJu1du"Iru q

~1u "'1 L~tl eJ tJT1~~~l:IJ~U1lnlJ ~nvr~ Ul~~l1 ~.nl'W1rJ~L~1 \Krl' eJ tJfll ~ eJT1ru::n113Jnl 1

-;nn "'ru:nLL1~~lu~h~"lfl~hn1-rl~ 1~ £JnTHHlUL~u~~ eJ eJmn L~LEh'l ~eJ nl1LeJl11Jfl eJUL~u ...

1u1 ""~il alu l"il ~~ulaJ Lun~1 u T11l3JL 11l~ 1 <J 1~ u'lll1ufl eJuL~u 1~LL ~ aJ L ~ueJ ~~u laJ 1 i 'U

~il a Ul"il~~UlaJ LL~L~il LeJn ~l1u1~n eJu1ufl eJUL~u u~1 uu ~ aJvnt'ln~ 1u d:JuL~eJ~nl1 'U

Lun 'lm~uu1~nu~"llrn'W ~~1~ L~ u1"1i eJ~nu 1ufleJUL~U<Jlnllulf1l1 ~uL"lil h-"hn113Jnl1 q

Tl~L l1<J-:hdJUL~eJ~L~tJ1rlU ~~~~UlaJ1u1ufleJUL~U ~uLV:wll'eJ~'Y1l~Liuif ~~L~unu~ ~ ~ eJ 3-ll rl' eJ u fll ~~ n ~l1"1J eJ ~u l~ ~l1 u nl 'W1SJL~il t:-J ~ 'Yll1 i u l ~ ~l1 unl 'W1.WUT11l3J ~ ~

q q

1 un 1n1~'Yll"ll eJ~~ULeJ~ LL~ d:Junl11'1J~l1fll'W 1 UT11l3J~ ~"ll eJ~~u ~~ Luurl' eJ £Jfll~1uv:I~ 1~

LL~~ UUnl1UUrJUll~~fl~Tl~~ l!:J ~~fl~Tl~~ rn LL~~~v:JeJ~Tl~~ ~ SJL~~11"il~fllJLeJn~l1 'U 'U 'U

u1~ eJ1Jnl1Lun-;h uri eJU~~~l u~ eJ;eJ 1 u 1ufl eJUL~U~laJ~n~l15l~

' ' ~ /~1U'Y1 ...

Page 56: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~1U~~~t:l.Jfl~~ kJ LL~~~~t:l.Jfl~~ rn 1iLLrJ.Jll nT~LUntteJUL~W~ln1Jlli;gL~U'YJU 'IJ 'IJ ., ~

0 ~

ViJJULiE.JUU~11.h~nU~"l.Jfll'V'4 "L~urmuru:n kJ" uru:nL~"l.JYi o<frn- G)- OG)OG)'.i>- ~ ~1U1U G) fl1-J q 'I 'I QJ Ql

~~~ e).Jfl~~ kJ LL~~~~ e).Jfl~~ rn 11JJrlU~.J~1E.J~ e)~ e) 1u1utteJUL~w;nnllU1fll1 LL~~U1-J~l1 'IJ 'IJ

E.J1l1Yn1~\.b1tJ1ilh~ 1u"1fU~1Ui1 ~1U1U ~ci<f,ooo 1Jl'Yl ~.JllUlfl11EleJnLUULLfl"1fL;gE.JfL;fl ~

i.J~lE.J u1~'Yl "1f~1J1TieJU~lfllf~ ~ln~ LUUn1rn~R~El.Jfl~~ kJ LL~~~~El.Jfl~~ c;n 1~~El.J ~ 'IJ 'IJ

1u ~~ L tteJ.J'illn LUUfl11JJ1u~~"l.l EJ.Jl. -.il'1VJ11'1~1lU1fl11~ n1~'Yl1~~ L1 EJU 1"lln11tt EJUL~UL Y411~ n11n EJUL~w;nnuru:ni.Jn~l1 'il~i EJ.Jtt t:JUL~u 1~ un111t:~u 'Yl1-Juru:nL Yi1,f u 11JJvf.J 1 u"l.lrn~~ ., .,

Ul.J ~11 E.J1l1Y411~,;t11un EJUL~UJJ11 i ~.J~l E.J ~ El~t:l 1~ ~11 un11'Yl1 LLfl"lfL ;g ufL ;flU1ln n t:1 ~ ~ ~ 'IJ

LL~U 1-J~l1 E.J1l1Y411~L~ E.JUL ~ JJ L~JJ~U 1 U1l1 E.JV! ~__,,_fu, L y;Ull ~.J LL:J'il~LUUfl11JJ ~~Y4 ~1~ ~

"1J t:l.J L -.il'1VJ1l'l~llU lfll11 Unl1t:l t:Jn LLfl"lfL :nufL ;flUUlJ ~.Jn~11 L Y411~ L UUn11t:l t:Jn ~~ L1 t:JU 1 "1J

1un11tlt:lUL~U'il1nllUlfll1fl~lJJ LL~Ldt:~'W'ili1rnl~lL U111Jttt:JUWUUU1J~.JlU~ ci ~.JVilflJJ

kl<fci~ ~.J~E.Jt:l~~lU1UL~U~tlt:lU 11JJtf.Jiu rn,klrnrn,d~~ 1Jl'Yl1U~1U1UifLtJUn111t:Ju L"JJ1uru:nu~1U1~rlU~"l.J1ll'V'4LL1-J.JlU~l.J"1fl~ uru:nL~"l.J~ o<frn - kJ - kloG>oG> - ~ ~1U1U ., ~ .,

kl, G> '.i> ~, <f ~'.i> 1Jl 'Yl 1 eJ UL "111 uru:n~urJiJ t:l.J rlUfl11J fl JJ 11fl JJ ~ L ~.J ~\I 'VIl ~"lf~ u1 U ru:nL ~"l.l ~ Ql cu 'I q QJ

0 0 &::t f(~

o <f rn - kJ - G> do ci ~ - ~ 'iJ 1 U 1 U G> kJ o, G> ~ rn 1J 1 'Yl LL ~ ~ 'Yll LL fl "1f L "1f E.J 1 L "1f fl ~ ci <f, o o o 1J 1 'Yl

Vil n1u~.J ~1 JJ"JJ t:1 n ~1151-J"l.l eJ.J ~v:l EJ.J fl ~~ rn ~ 51-Jl1 1 U"l.lrn~~ ~" ~1 u ~ t:J~t:J1~~11 un11 'IJ

'I'll LLfl"lfL :nufL ;fl'il1-J LL~U l.J~l1 E.J1ll'V'411~L~ E.JUL ~ JJ L~ JJ~U1l1 E.JV! ~.J'il1n~n11~-J ~1 E.J~ t:l~El ~

1u1unt:JUL~ULL~1 ,fu, Lv;Ull rl1'V11n~~t:l.Jfl~~ kJ LL~~~~e).Jfl~~ rn 1i~11'il~El1JLt:Jn~11 'IJ 'IJ

tl1~nt:~u 1unt:~uL~u~.Jn~11 e1 ~1-J~~La u~1EJ1Jflt:JULL~1 ~ t:JJJ~1JJ11tt~.J Ln~ L v;ufl11JJ~~tln~

1 Un1rn if1~ L ttt:J.J'illn E.J t:l~ L~U 1 U11 un11~1 t:JUL"JJluru:n~El.JUlli;g'il~i t:l.J~~1U 1U~1-Jrl1J "' "'

E.J El~11JJ"l.l t:l.J 1un t:JUL~U ~ eJ rn ,kl rn rn ,d ~~ 1J1'Yl LL~~~ eJJJ'Yll1 i'Yl111J1~111 W51U1UL~U

~"l.lt:lflt:JU rn,klrnrn,d~~ 1Jl'Yl ,fu, ~~1W"JUL~U~Lund1u11.l ~ci<f,ooo 1J1'Yl i.J,XU ~.JLL:J U1-J~11 E.J1l1Y41'il:;LtJu~n1~'Yl1n11'Yl'il1~ LL~~LUUfl11 JJ ~ ~Vi~t:J1Jn'V'41El.J 1 un11~1 E.J L~U"l.J t:l.J

~ 'IJ ~

llU1fl11 LL~ ~~t:l.Jfl~~ .kl LL~~~~ t:l.Jfl~~ rn n U.Jfl.J~ t:l.J~~1U1u~~ 1 U~i1U~~~.J~l E.J~t:l~t:l 'IJ 'IJ "" 'IJ

1 Un11tleJUL~U'il1nllU1fll11~ uii1i ~11'il ~t:JUi1~1U1UL~U ~"l.J t:l LUntl eJU ,_f unni t:l.JV!~t:l 1~ 'IJ

~ ~ ~ d d ~ d d ..s "~ VJ ,.r "l.Jt:lt:ll.J"l.JEJ.Jc-Jv:JeJ.Jfl~'Yl l!:J LL~~c-Jv:Jt:J.Jfl~'Yl rn 'il.JY'I.J LJJ"l.JU

'IJ 'IJ

'il1n"JJ mYl'il'il1-J~.Jn~l1 ~.JLv;u1i11 ~~ t:l.Jfl~~ kJ ~~ t:l.Jfl~~ rn LL~~~~ eJ.Jfl~~ ci 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

~.J~Vi11'1~LUUn11JJn11~~~1Ul'il~.J~1E.J~eJ~munneJUL~U'il1nuru:nu~1U1~rlU~"l.l1l1Y4LL1-J.J1U 'IJ ., ~

/~h.J"lfl~ ...

Page 57: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~1~r1~ lJill~U~"lJ~ ocfm - 1!:1 - l!:Jo<O)O@) - ~ bU;~:;Uru~b~'U'Yl'UV!~'I-Ui £J'UlJ~1lh:;nU~"llflT'v'j Ql Ql q q q

"b~ui uuru~ 1!:1" uru~b~"ll~ oclm-@)- 0@)0@)~- ~ ~:;L~£J~e:Jw1X1~1un11~11"il~e:JuLEJn~11 1h:; ~ e:JU;11fle:J'UL;Ufi e:J'U~~'\,1,1~1 '1-b 1ufl El'\-bb~'\,1,~1 ~~'\,1,1~ ~11 ~1l1Yl1 'Yl El~ b ~q) b~'UEl~l :B~ L un11i..l filr~ V!Ul~l~ £J iiL~L ifl11 ~1:; 6T ~1~1~ 1 un11i..l fjlr~Vi u1~"1J e:J~ ~u "il'UL ilu

"lfEl~ L l~ 1 ~u 1~~11 £Jfl1Yl1e:J1i £J 1 EJnl ~LL~:;V!ul~ n1~rhn11'Yl"il1~ rTn £J Eln L~u Li..l1 iL Yl El f1 ~ ~ i..l1~ £J"ll'U~1 ui1 L iJ uL '~-'~ ~ .Yh 1 ~ 'Yll ~11 "1l'n11L~1u fl11 ~ L ~r.J '1-'11 £J n1rni~ n ~11 ~ ~ ri EJ11

~

~Yle:J~fl~~ 1!:1 ~YlEl~fl~~ m LL~~~YlEl~fl~~ ~ L~n1~'Yl1~~Lii~~1£Jfi113JU1:;3J1'YlL~UL~e:J 'U 'U 'U

mJ1 1'1mL1~ ~~~El~i'u~~1u~~LL~~n11n1~'Yl1~:;Lii~Ju ~13-13-11~11 @)o i..l1~ne:Junu ' 1 Q...l Q....l.c:::. V .e.. .a. IV V .::::1

3-11~ 1 ~ LLV!~Yl1~11"1l'lJillill~fi113J1lJ~~'Yl1~~~L3J~"lJEl~L"il1V!'U1'Yl Yl.f'l. l!:Jclm~ .., ..,

El~1~L1n~13-l 3-11~11 ~ 111fl~13-l LL~~Yl1~11"1l'Ururu~fl113-1i'u~~'Yl1~~:;Lii~ .., ..,

YlEl~fl~~ 1!:1 ~YJe:J~fl~~ m LL~~~YJEJ~fl~~ ~ L~LLEJ~ll n1rn~Lll~;ff'U~~1LV!~3J1"il1n 'U 'U ~

fl11 UnYl'ie:J~"lJ €1~1~lJlJn11~1 Lit 'U.~1'U.~1'U. 113-1 ~1 ~ ~1 £J LL~'U.~l'U.LiJU~L nui'n ~1 L~'U.LL~:; 'U

1£J L~ULL 'YlU ~"il~LiJu~1 r.Jn11~u V!'1El~1 £JU1'1-'111~1LU 11~~~ LdJ ~n11,]1 m~uLiluL ifl

... '

n1rn~~~U1~ L~'\-1,~ f)~~"il11ill1 ~ ElLU11 ~~~1'U.fl11~1u~~"ll El~~Yl f)~fl~l-1~~ 'U

"ll'~ 1 ifi1 ~'U. l Vi 3-l'Yl ~ LL 'Yl'U.~13J ~1 ~~"ll €1~ ~ fl n YJ e:J~fl ~ ~ @) ~ n1rn ~ n11~~ LiJ ~ L n ~"ill D 'U 'U

Ad I I Q...ld OA I d t.l

fl11 ~ ~V!1Elfi113JUnYl1 El~"ll El~V!u 1 £J~1U"ll El~1~V!1e:J1~uu n11~1 L u u~1u~1u 113-1 6!l'~"il~~ El~ ....

~n~ ULL~~fi113J~~i~n~11ElElnV!1EJL6J

~ bfl11~~ LL~1 L v; 'U. ll ~13-loiJ Ell Yl "il "il1 ~ 1 'U.fl ~if n1:;'Yl11~ ~1'fi11ill~"lll~ ~~ 1 ~ ~

~1u ~1U~1'fi11ill~"ll..ij~V!l~'Ylni~w1~~1Litun11Lfl1~n11U~1U1~nu~"ll1l1YlLL1~~1U~1~"1l'1~ ~ ~ ~

~1u ~1U~lil1ill~"lli~w1~~1u 1 Vi ruL~ 3-1 e:JUV!3-11 £J 1 ~~1mL~U~1uLilucr~1L itun11 ~~W~L~11 ~ .., 'U

~1m ~u~1U"llEl~~1un~1U~1'fi11rn~"lli~l'l1 ~"1l'~u1L~1u 3J EJUV! 3-11 £J 1 ~ ~1 Lit un11 Lfl1 ~n11 ~ ~

i~n 11 L"lfuL~ £J1nu~1u n~1U~1'fi11ill~"ll..ij~'~-'~1~ ~u "J LL~ ~1 mL~u~1u LdJ ~ L-;)1V!U1~ n11L~U ~

LL ~ ~ ru ~ LdJ ~ L-;) 1 Vi 'IX 1 ~ ~ ~ fi113J 1 Vi 1 El fi113J -E 1 u 1 ru 1 u ~ 1 u ~ 1 u n 1 1 L ~ u LL ~ :; 1J ru ~ Ql cu Ql Cll

~ b ~ ~ L -;)1 WU l~l b fl11 ~~ 'U. L £J Ul r.JLL~ ~ LL~'U.L r\1 ,_f 'U. ~1 r.JLL~ 'U.~l'U. ~1U n~1U~1'fi11ill~"ll ~

.... .... d

/"il~V!1~"1HUJ1 ... ~

Page 58: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~.JVIl ~·1HnJ1 ~._, L~LLilUillVI11~ rm11-;l1.J~ n-;l1.Ji1~1116J1U fiu~m! 1~ ~1un11l~'ULL~:::uru;_n q OJ ClJ dJ IU

~.Jrh 1 ~\ n ~~116-lVI~:::VI ~16J lun11u~u~.Jl'U~1un11l~u:ffu ~nrt._, 1 un11lun~1 m~u ~16J 1~1.Jn11u~11.h:::nuGi"lJ1l1Ylll1.J.J1u~1.J"ll"1~ n1:::Yl11.JGi1ll11ruGi"lJ L~~VIu.J~f) ~ Gill

~ ~

' ' ' CU .::::1 (L.;I d, I Q. &::1

ol£ll£l'T1/o~/1 m<O)<i:' ~.J1'UY1 l!:J~ ~m~aJ l!:Jcf<i:'<O) LL~:::'V\'U.JGifl ~1'UY1Gi~ Yl Gill ol!:J<O)<O)/l!:Jl!:J/1 l!:J~<i:' ~ ~ -

~ .Jl 'U ~ l£J b1f n 'U£J1 £J 'U l£J cf <i:' ~ LL,) .J 1'\X ~1U n.J1UGi1ll11n.l,'!"ll ~.J VI 1 ~ u ~ u~ ~16JVI U.J ~f) (L.ol I d ClJ d .d Q..l

n1:::Yl11.Jn11fl~.J ~1'U,Y1Gi~ n~ ocfl!:J'>oJ.cf/moocfd ~.J1'U,Yl d ~~1~6J l!:Jcf<i:'<i) 6Jl".Jn1:::Yl11.Jn11~~.J ~ ~

fl 'U nll ~ 1'\X ~1 u n .J1 u Gi1ll11n.t,Gi"ll ~.J VI 1 ~ l n 1J l~ uu1::: n UGi"ll 111 Yl LL 1-J .Jl U~1.J "1!"1 ~ l i1 "11~1 £J ~ ... ~ ~

d] u l~ ull11.J ~1aJail €1 u: (l!:J) l£l. (j) l£l "1l fl .J1::: l u £J u n 1:::Yl11.J Gi1ll11mGi"ll 11 ~1m~ ull11.J ~ ~ - ~

"1J fl.J'V\ tb £J u1n111 'U, ~.J n ~n1:::Yl11.J Gi1ll11n.I,Gi"ll Yl. fl . l£J cfm '>oJ 1 ~ £J ,;h ~h n ll'U 1 ~11~ l iJ 'U, ~

-r~i GilVIn~ LL~:::1:::1J1JU ru;_nl~'UU11.J"ll fl.JVI u 1 £Ju1n111lX u n u~ ~16J1:::1J1JU nJ;_n"ll €1-J ~1'U, 11"1l"n11 d3 Ql q ~ QJ

1~ £J €JU 1 ~ 6J ~ .J ~16J1::: L U £J1J n11L n u1n Ml L~U LL ~:::n11U 1 L~ 'U~.J ~ ~.J"ll fl.J ~1 U 11"1l"n11 ~

Yl.fl. l£lcfl£lo "lie1 m~ n1V1u~11 1un11~1m~u1'\X~1miluv~~ t~nd'u1un1rn~1£J~1n

l~'U, Yl ~1€l.J11"1l"n11 ~.J L nu1nM1lllU'U,l~'UGi~ n11~1£JL~'U 1'\Xmi"li111"1l"n11VI'1fl~n-;11.J"ll f) ._'I ~

'"' ' ' I ..:::!:1 l).IQ.; 0 ~ .::1 CU .:::9 1 jQ, .cl .cl A 0 1

Gi1U 11 "ll"n11VI1 fl ~1u u1 u 1 ruV11 m u £J VI 1 ~ VI 1e1n11~1 m.J u Yl6J1.J L.J u~1 n 11 l£l, o o o u1 Yl ~ ...

~:::~1 mlluL~uGi~nL~ Ll~"li m -n~~1.Ju1ln!J11 ~1 ml~_'U.Jl'U ~1Un.J1UGilll11ru'!"ll~.JVI1~"1l"m~1

lU'U~1u ~ ~"1!" flU L n u1n M1l~ULL ~::: l U n ~1 £J L~ 'U~1 uilin11~1 r.JL~UGi~ 1 ~ £J l~ l aiJ1 ~1:::1J1J ~ ~

n11lnu1nM1l~ULL~:::Lun~1 m~U~16J1:::LU £J1JLL~:::LL1J1JLL~Uun~"ll fl.JY11.J11"1l"n11L yj m'J fl .JrlU

n 11 n 1::: 'Yl1 Yl ~ 1 ~ "1J fl .J L,) 1 VI ,X 1 ~ cJ U n U~ .J 1 'U, ~ .J ,_f 'U, Gil LVI ~ "1J fl .J n 11 n 1::: 'Yl1 ~::: L ~ ~ "1J fl .J ~ ~ ~ ~

~ YJ fl .J ~ ~ rt._, ~~ L n ~ ;ff 'U, ~.J ~ ~1U"ll fl.J ~116J ~ ~ Vl'1fl ~116J1J n Yl1fl .J"ll €1-JVI U 1 £J .J1 'U,"lJ fl .J1~LL ~::: ~ ~

1:::uu n11~h L'U U.J1U~1u 116J ~1 £J n11~ ~ rm Yl €1-J ~ ~~ (j) ~ 4h &._, L1£J n 1'\X ~ Yl fl.J ~ ~vr._, ~ ~~ ~

"ll"~ 1 i~h ~u LVI aJYl ~ u Yl u~1aJ f111aJ L ~ u"IJ e1 ._, ~n n Yl e1 ._, ~ ~~ l£l u ~:::n11~ ~11m 1 e1 Ylll1rn"ll e1 ._, ~ ~ ~

~n nYl fl.J ~ ~~ m 1~ £J ~L~tt 1 ~1U"ll fl .Jf1116J ~~VI1fl ~116J1Jn'V'l1fl.J"ll €1-J VI u 1 tJ.Jl'U"ll fl.J1~VI1 fl ~~ ~

1:::uu n11~h Lit U.J1'U~1 u 116J aJ1Vi' n fl fl n~1 n ~~ ~1 u~11aJ1u ~ ~"ll fl.J ~ Yl fl._,~~ vr._, ~ ~._, L~ ~

Lilu Lu ~16J 6J1 ~11 ~ 111~ Gi16J u ~._, Yl1:::11"1l"ururu~~11aJ1u ~ ~Yl1.J ~::: L~ ~"ll f).J L -;l1V1 tt'1~ ......

= ... /YH~11:::VI ...

Page 59: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~ Lf111~~LL~1 L v;Ul1 Vi1n n11L nu1n ~1 L~ULL~~ LUn-;il1 £J L~U~1:U lf11-:ln11

Lilu tJ ~1 :u1~u lJ-:11ULL~~1~ L u r.JlJ LLlJ u u~utJn @i"lJ fl-:J'Yl1-:111"1fn11 u 1-:1 ~11 £J 1l1'V'l1 'Yl a-:~ L ~ ru ~ ...

~ fl l~ ~-rifl-:J'Yl1-:I';J~n1~Yl1n11'Yl';J1~ l~ L 'V'l11~U1-:1 ~11 £J 1l1'V'l1~~l~ ~1 :U11blL nu ~:U~Ulli~ ~ ~ ~ ...

lltl ~1 L fl-:1 LL~~ l~~1 :U11blbl fl UL~U~~ fl an~1niTU 1fl11l~ n11~-:1 ~1 £J ~ fl~fl1 U 1ubl flUL~U ';J~L ~£JULUUn11~-:1~1£J~fl~fl1UL ifl ~-:1~~~1~LU r.JuiitJl)u@iL~mu 'V'l1~L ~aiJ1 \K~L~U1Lif1 LU"ll LUUL~U~~ i.~ V~1a-vnn rJ-:1 fl-:1 LUUn11~-:l ~1 r.J~ a~a1 u 1ur~ fltl.L~Ufl ~1-:1 L@i:u n~ fl-:1 ~1\l.

11';J~fllJ';J1n L -;i1V!U1~n11L~un au iJ1-ri1 \Ku1-:1 ~11 £J 1l1'V'l1L ~ r.J-:1 ~L~ tl1~ L iluf'lu q 'IJ

un11 L 'V'l11~u~tf u ~-:~n a i.~11 L iluf111 :u ~~ V~1a f111 :uun'V'l1a-:~"ll a-:~V~ti 1 tJ-:J1Wll a-:~1~ "-'

~lJ lJ n11~1 L U, U-:11U ~1U 11 :U ~-:I L iJ UU ';) -.ij r.JV! ~ n ~'Yl11 \KL n ~ -ria-:1 'Yl1-:J1 U n11'Yl ';11~ ~

L rl1 n lJ fl 11 :U U 1 ~ :U 1 'Yl L ~ U L ~ fl fl ~ 1 -:1 f 1 £J LL 1 -:1 "lJ fl-:1 ~ y:j fl -:1 fl ~ ~ -:1 ~ n 11 ~ ~ ~ L 1 £J n f fl-:11 \K 'IJ

L-;)1 1l'1~"1f~ 1ifi1~u LV~:U'Yl~LL'Ylu~ L V~:U1~~:uLiluiT11:u ~-:Jf111~n1V~u~ 1 \K~ n11in~1u ~ wu 1 ti-:11U"ll a-:~1~';1~~ a-:~1u ~ ~~1n f111 :uu n 'V'l1fl-:J"ll a-:~wu 1 £J-:11U"ll a-:~1~a an~1 n fi1 ~u i."' :u

"-' "-' ....

'Yl~ LL U '¥1-:!Vi:U ~ L ~r.Jrl flU l~ tJ1 \Kin ~1U 1 Ufl11:U11J ~ ~Vi1fl fl11:UlJn'V'l1fl-:J~-:Jn ~11 fl ann flU

~ <fo "llfl-:Jf111:UL~t1Vi1£J~-:JV!:U~ uan~1nd n11n1~'Y11~~Lii~ 1~m-;l1V!U1~~~1~~u U-:1 V!U1~ LL~~fl11 :u1u ~~"ll'fllJ 1 u n11U nu@iV!U1~1 un11n1~'Y11 ~~Lii ~~ ~ ;u ~ L Vi~

~ 'IJ q

' ' ~ o.Jd .c::::l 0 Cl..<'t t Q...le::. V o 1 VQ

L~r.J nu ';J-:Jfl11'Yl~~n1V!U~~~~1ULLVi-:lfl11:U1lJ~~:U1nUfl£J~1:U~1U~ ~1LLV!U-:1 V!U1'Yl . "-'

~1u ~"lfau Ldmrmri~~1-:~u11n!J11 f111:UL~£JV~1tJ~-:~"':u~LiJuL~u~1u1u \o),~~JJ<f,~<f.kl~ U1'Yl

L~ aln ~1Uf111:u1u~ ~"ll fl-:!Vitb ti-:11U~fl-:J1~aan i.tJ~a r.J~~ cfo ~-:lfl-:JLV!~ flf111:u1u~~~-:JV!:U~ n';J~ fl-:J11J~ ~LUUL~U ~JJ,~b11,b11~JJ kJ.\o)u:' lJ1'Yl LL~~L~ fl~~11ill1 LLtln ff~ ~1ULL V:-:!f111:U11J ~ ~

l)..l I ..... I 'V I I

"llfl-:1 v:la-:Jf'l~'Yl-:1~ UU Lv;Ul11U~1U"llfl-:J~v:la-:Jf1~fi <9) UU ~Ylfl-:!fl~fi <9) LlJUL';)1V!U1'n 'IJ 'IJ

1~~ ~u ~ r1 n :u au"' :u1 £J 1 \K~"',x 1~1u~ ~"ll'au Lf11-:1n11u ~1th~nu~"llflT}·'HL1-:J-:J1U~1-:J"ll'1@i 'IJ ~

LL~~ V!U1~L~Ufllf11-:ln11~1:U~LL~~~ l1-:!'V'l £J11J1~ L~Ufl"ll mun-;il1m~Ufll 1"1f-;ti1 £J-:11UUfl-:lnU

LL~~1 ru l1fl"il1nLL1-:I-:11U~1-:1"151@i~ flU1£JLLWY1£f ~1il1nl,~"ll-.ij'-:JV!l ~L~ aau3J@i n11LUn-;il1£J~-:Jn~11 ~ ~

LL~~1 n11LUnblflUL~U~-:Jn~11 ~v:lfl-:Jfl~~ <9) LlJU~~V!U1~~11~~fllJn11-.il~'Y11Lfln~11 'IJ 'IJ

L~£J1 .... un11blflUL~u1wffu~un au~U1-:J~1£Jfl1'V'l1 'Ylfl-:JL ~ ru ~~tl11ur~auL~ui.tJ1\Kmu::n11:Un11 ~ ...

~~~ U1';J~-:Ju1:u1u1ur~auL~u~-:~u1:u LL~~1un11ufiu@iV~u1~"lla-:~~v:la-:~f1~~ <9) tfu 'IJ ~ 'IJ

~u1 rl'Yl11'V'l1 :uTil~£J Lilu~u-:~f1uuru"ll'1 i-:~LL~tl 'V'l.ff. kl<f~JJ~JJ ~u~-:~1u~ <9)cf :un11f1:u 'IJ ...

klcfu:' LL~~u1-:~1-:~Yi11 v.l1U"ll'~l"ll Lilu~u-:~f1uuru"ll'1 i-:~LL~1u~ <9)\o) :un11f1:u l!:lcfu:'cf ~u~-:1 ~ q 'IJ ...

' .... "" /1U'Yl IJJO ...

Page 60: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

\lo

1u~ mo nutlltiU l!:l<fci<t ~~1u~nu:;~u~f1uuru"151 ~11rl1'vnt'1~rhnu~m~n11tlfiu~~1u lll3 CIJ QJ cu d.J

~n:w 1~1~n11U<111U1::nu~"ll.f11'V'ILL1~~1U<1ll~"151~"lle:J~~Yh:J~~~~ CO) LL~::U1~~1tlfll'V'I1 Yle:J~Lwru q ~ q v

1 ~\ iJ U LU <111 :IJ1:: dj tllJ~Yl1~11"15n11Tll~ U<111<11 tl L ~1 ~ ~f<11 LL~U 1~ tli'111 'V'I1 :IJ1'it<11 ~ LL~:;

Ul~-i~Yi11 'V'Ilii"15~1"ll iii.~tlfiu~ml'1~<11~n~11LL~e:J~1~1<11 ~~LV:U~11Th~u<111V:~v:le:J~~~~ CO) q q ~ ~

fu~~ 1 UeJ<1111fe:J tl~:; \lo "lle:J~"i)1U1UL~U~11:1J L~tl~l ti~L ~ ~ mnnn11Vi'n~1U~11:1Jf1J~~ "lJ e:J~~ ti 1 tl~lU"ll e:J~f~e:J e:Jn Ltli'e:J t1 ~:; <to Ld e:J"lY e:JL rhr;u1~U11 n 1ll1 U 1~ ~11 tlfll'V'11l~L~Ue:J

"" ~ q

1urJe:JUL~u1V:~rn::n11:1Jn11~~~1U1-;J~~ul:w"i)lulu ~'-' ~~~ 1~u~v:le:J~~~~ CO) ~~1l'1~ ~ ~

<1111';1 ~e:J lJ ~11 :IJbln rJl e:J~"ll e:J~ 1u bl e:J UL~ULL~:; L e:J n ~11U1::n e:J1Jn11bl e:J UL~U Yln ~~~ L iJ UL~U ~ q

-;)lUlU l!:l,moCO),CO)~d.~d lJlYl Lde:JVi'n~1U~11:1J11J~~"lle:J~~tilti~1U"lle:J~1~e:Je:JnLtli'e:Jtl~:; <to ""

~~L~~e:J~ll:IJflJ~~LUUL~U"i)lUlU CO),CO)<fo,<f~m.~ci lJl'Yl LL~:;~f1e:J~~~~ CO) ~e:J~flJ~<11 ~

1ueJ<n11i'e:Jtl~:; \lo "lle:J~"i)lUlUL~U CO),CO)<fo,<f~m.~ci lJl'Yl ~~~~L~~e:J~ll:IJflJ~~LUUL~U

-;)lUlU \l~o,m<f\l.m\l lJl'Yl ~1U~f1e:J~~~~ l!:J ~f1e:J~~~~ m LL~:;~v:le:J~~~~ ci 1u~1U:: ~ ~ ~ ""

n11:1Jn11~~ ~1U1-;J~~Ul:IJ 1 u11Jble:JUL~U LV: U~11rll~U~~11:1JflJ~~"lle:J~LL~ ~:;~U<111:1J~~~1U ~

"ll e:J~"i]1u lUL~ u~i.~~~ u l:IJ 1 u 1u LU nr1 e:JUL~U-;Jl nliu 1~11 1 ULL~~ :;~~~ ~~ ~l.ll e:J~~ ~~ l!:l ~

i.~~~Ul:w1u1urJe:JUL~U LUUL~U CO),b'JICO)~,~\l<f.ol!:l lJl'Yl ~v:le:J~~~~ m i.~~~Ul:w1u1urJe:JUL~U ~

LUUL~u CO),~cio,\l~ct.\l l!:l lJl'Yl Ld m~-n~1U~11:W1u~~"lle:J~~u 1 ti~1U"lle:J~1~e:J e:Jn i.tli'e:Ju~:; <to ""

~v:le:J~~~~ l!:J ~~~~L~~e:J~ll:IJflJ~~LUUL~U -;)lUlU ~<t~,ci~l!:l.<tCO) lJl'Yl ~v:Je:J~~~~ m ~ ~

~~mm~e:J~11:1JflJ~<11LUUL~U -;)lUlU ~l!:Jo,mcid.mCO) lJl'Yl ~1U~11:1JflJ~~"lle:J~~f1e:J~~~~ ci tfu ~

~l.lle:J~~~~ ci rJm1un 1V:"15~ 1-irL~u"i)lUlU m~CO),cim\l.mm 1Jl'Yl1~tl~11tln11ble:JUL~U~~~~ l!:l<f ~ ~

Lde:JlU~ l!:Jl!:J ~~~l~:IJ l!:l<fcim ~~~f1e:J~~~~ ci ~e:J~flJ~<11"15<111"1fLUUL~U l!:J\l ,ci\lo.CO)~ lJl'Yl ~

11:1Je:J~~ltl LL~-;Jln"l1m.Yh-;)1~tl11n1111 ~v:le:J~~~~ ct i.~1u:we:Ju1V:~~1U1';1~~~1tlne:J;e:J ~ ~ ~

1u~1u::n11:1Jn1111:w1un11rJe:JUL~u c#~u~1u~ <t n:wn1.Wui l!:l<tct<t LiJurJlui.tl <11~tfu "" q

1u1u~ l!:ll!:l ~~~1~:w l!:l<tctm ~v:le:J~~~~ ct ~~i.3-l~l:IJ11b1~~~1tlne:J;e:J1u1urJe:JUL~ui.~ ~

~~rJlt~~Vi'n"i)1U1U~U<11~n~11e:Je:Jn e:J'Yl1i1rn"lle:J~~rlnf1e:J~~~~ CO) LL~::~r1nf1e:J~~~~ m ~11 q ~ ~ ~ ~

~r1nf1e:J~~~~ CO) iiL~UlL~U"i)lUlU l!:J\l,ci\lo.CO)~ lJl'Yl :IJ1~~~1Ulrn1V;'~l.\le:J~~~~ ci ~ ~ ~

rJle:J~fu~~ ~~w~i.aJ~u u::tfu ~~~1u~11:w1u~<11"lle:J~~v:le:J~~~~ ct ~~Luu"i]1u1uL~u ~

' ~ (L..I I Q.,l .C::.. I Q.,l

m<fci,~m.CO)<f lJl'Yl (m~CO),cim\l.mm-l!:J\l,ci\lo.CO)~ ) L:IJ e:J~ n~1U~11:1J11J~ ~"lle:J~~U 1ti~1U"lle:J~1~ "'

e:Je:JnLufe:Jtl~:; <to ~~mm~e:J~11:1JflJ~~LUUL~U"i)1U1U CO)dd,ci~~-od lJlYl ~1U~~f1e:J~~~~ l!:J ' ~

Page 61: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

~J~:::u; ~~~~:~!;il~~::l1~n~::~: ~~:~::~!~~;:~:~;~L:~~ff~li~::J: L v;~ J,;h LL6J~l r.J LL 'Y'l'Yl ~ ~llil1rn~~"ll..ij>'~Vtl cn"ll'~u1"il~L tlu~u>'~ fi'uu~"ll'1"1JEJ>'~~W e:J>'~fl~~ l£1

q q 'U ~ 'U

~Vl >'lfl~~ m LL~~~Vl e:J>'Ifl~~ ci 1 '1-tfil';i"U nu~VtUl~~ LtlUfi>'llU~llil';illi~"lJ..ij>'ll'il (11"1)'~1J1 'U 'U dJ q q

LL~1 fil1~>1Ul:JJ1u1une:JUL~U1ULL~~~fl~>'~tfu ~We:J>'Ifl~~ l£J ~We:J>'Ifl~~ m LL~~~We:J>'Ifl~~ ci 'U 'U 'U

i1Vt l~1 U~lU~n11:JJfil1~ij eh U l"il ~>'I U 1 :JJ 1 U 1u fl e:JUL~U~>'I L tJ U V!U1~ LU 'Y'll~~1~ "il~~ El >'! "' 'U

(1111 ~EllJ fl11 :JJfln ~ El>'l"ll e:J>'I L Eln ~l1Vt ~n~l'\.t ~'U, l 111 L ~'\.tEl~ EJU ~ "il~ ~>'1'1-t l :JJ 1 U 1un El UL~UL ~:JJ El 'U "'

LL~t:-!We:J>'Ifl~~ l£J ~WEJ>'Ifl~~ m LL~~~WEJ>'Ifl~~ ci iJL(1llif11l:JJ1~6J~n~1>'11Un11(1111"il~EllJ 'U 'U 'U

LEln l1Vi ~n~l'l-t~>'ln ~l1 "ilULUUL Vt(1lrll1 ~U1>1~11 r.J1ll'Y'l1Ellf1'r.J 1e:Jnl ~Lunn e:JUL~U 1cn r.JL3Ji1 "' q q

'"il~ Lunn e:JUL~u L<A' ~_,,Xu u l mL 'Y'l'Yl u ~11il1rn~"ll..ij>'~Vtl cn"ll'~u1~>'1L3J i1 ~1UL ~ r.J1"1i El>'~ q q

';j~>'JUl:JJ1u1uLUnfle:JUL~U"lle:J>'I~WEl>'lfl~~ kJ ~WEJ>'Ifl~~ m LL~~~We:J>'Ifl~~ ci ~>'ln~l1 'U 'U 'U

LL~ El cil>'l1tn e:J'Ylli1rn"ll El>'l ~Vl e:J>'I fl ~~ kJ ~Vl El>'l fl ~ ~ m LL~ ~ ~w e:J>'I fl ~ ~ ci ~>'IW>'!L3J;}u, q 'U 'U 'U

~Yl >'~fl~~>'~~f111~e:J>'~1u~cn"ll'cn1if11l:JJL~r.Jl'ilr.J1unl1n1~'Yll~~LiJ(11 ~_,-d,' ~WEJ>'~fl~~ (i) 'U 'U

fe:Jr.J~~ "o:>o "1JEJ>'!-:filU1UL~U (i),(i)cfo , cf~m.~ci lJl'Yl LYhnu "o:>~o,m~.m"o:> lJl'Yl ~We:J>'Ifl~~ l£J 'U

fEJr.J~~ cfo "1Je:J>'J-:filU1UL~U (i) , d(i)~,~"o:>cf.ol£1 1Jl'Yl LYhnu ~cf~,ci~kl.cf(i) 1J1'Yl ~YJEJ>'Ifl~~ m 'U

fEw~~ cfo "lJEJ>'I-:filU1UL~U (i) , ~cio,"o:>~ci."o:>l£1 lJl'Yl Lrhnu ~1£Jo,mcid.m(i) 1Jl'Yl ~WeJ>'Ifl~~ ci 'U

iJ 0 .::::., I Q..l

1eJr.J~~ cfo "lJEl>'l"illU1UL>'IU mcfci,~d"o:>.(i)cf 1Jl'Yl L'YllfilJ (9)dd,cie<ie<i.od 1J1'Yl

nl~ f'!l~Unf11EJ>'!.ffu~u~ 'Y'l1fi'l!I-1L~ nnauf1l&>'~"llEl>'~~ n nv:J eJ>'Ifl~~ (i) (111:JJf111:JJLy; u 'U'U

"llEl>'~ "nnWeJ>'Ifl~~ l£J LL~~t:-~~nl1~"ill1lli1eJ'Ylli1rn"lleJ>'~~rlnWa>'!f1~~ m LU'Y'l1~~1u~1~ 'U q 'U'U

~Wa fl~~ (i) n>'I~WEl>'~fl~~ ci 1u~cndiun--h-:51U1U "o:>~o , mcf"o:> . mci 1J1'Yl ~cf~,ci~hcfo lJl'Yl 'U 'U

~l£Jo mcid.mo 1Jl'Yl LL~~ (i)dd,ci~~-od lJl'Yl (1ll:JJ~l~lJ ~1Uf11"1leJ~UUeJn"il1nd1~r.Jntfu

~ 'Y'll n '1!1-l LL n f1l~ 'Y'll n '1!!-1"1J El >1 f'!l ~u n f11EJ>'!.ffu~ '\..HU U 1 ~ L ~ n n auf1l &>1"1J El >1

El>'~ f1 ~~ (i) (1ll 11 f11l 11 L v;u"JJ a>'~ ~nnw EJ _, f1 ~ ~ l£1 LL~~ t:-~ ~n11~"il11rn l eJ'Ylli1rn"ll EJ>'~ 'U 'U q

El>'lfl~~ m LU'Y'll~~1u~1~~WeJ>'Ifl~~ (i) ~WEJ>'Ifl~~ l£J ~WeJ>'Ifl~~ m 1u~cndiun1l 'U 'U 'U

' 0 0 Q..l Q..l I Q...l ~

"ill'\.t U "o:>~o,mtf'•:un"o:> lJl'Yl ~cf~,ci~kl.cf(i) 1Jl'Yl ~l£Jo,mcid.m(9) 1J1'Yl (1ll:JJ~ltn1J UlJLL(111'\.t'Yl

m:m o l&>'~~>'ln~T1 LL~Vtln~nnWEJ>'Ifl~~ (i) LcA'1u•Jh1~Wd'Vt1e:J~1:JJ11fiU>'IfllJiT~~wd"illn 'U'U

1 r.J1ll'Y~1 'YlEl>'IL ~ru L<A'dJUL~U-:filU1UL 'Yh 1(11 1 ~\bL~U~>'Ifi~11:JJl~ nVt1El~'\.t(111:JJ~1ULL~>'I q ~

Page 62: ¸„ำพิพากษาศาล... · 2016-02-21 · I .o=t 0 .o=t ~~'Vi3J1m6UJ~1'Yl €1. ~ctGJ/l!J~Cfo ~&l'Vi3J1m~t~bb~\Jri e.~l'~l!Jct

f111:1Ji'u ~ ~ LL~ 1 LL~ n1"rn1 i ~ v:J El \l f)~ vr\l ~ 'U.Eln ~1 n~ LL n1 i dj 'U L u ~1 :IJ ~1oW vn n ~1"ll El \l 'IJ

\.1 ' I t,; I I I

fn ~u n f11EJ .Jiw~i u '*1u~1 i" f'f1 ~u n f11" EJ .Jiu~ u Vi i.J1 i 'Y1 L ~1 n11u\l f1 u ~1 :JJ ~1 ~\l"ll EJ" q

~rmv:lEJ\lf1~~ l9) 1iuii~v:lEJ\lf1~~ kl LL~:::~v:lEJ\lf1~~ rn LlllJ'Un11"i'1f11"111idJ'UeJ'U~'U~~ 'IJ'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

.... .... 'U1t.l~:IJ·1HJ 1~'UnTHl.b

q

.... ... ... 'U1r.J~:IJ1"1"~~r.J 1f'f1~1n1"rn

~~1n11"f'f1~Unf11"EJ\l~\l~~ q 'IJ q