3’˙$’ !4 ! 0 012 ’ -2 44 ˇ 27 :;< )2˚ 1 ˛ 1 )8 4 -ˆ ) 1395 [email protected] a...
Transcript of 3’˙$’ !4 ! 0 012 ’ -2 44 ˇ 27 :;< )2˚ 1 ˛ 1 )8 4 -ˆ ) 1395 [email protected] a...
1 /���� ��- � �� ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� �� ! � "#1391 ��& '� (� �� ')1 �2
________________________________________________________________________________________________
��������� ���� ���� �� ����� ��� ����� ��� ���� ������ � !� "!�
#�� ����$�%� &'�%��' ��(
+� �� ,�-� � � .� 1*' �01& 2�� �����3 ���2 )�45 � ,��6�� � 7����3
+5 ��8�0 4: 06/04/93 �0 4 =��> : 07/07/95
���+
�A0B �� �C��� �� �� , � D��E! +��� F �� ���� �BG� =�� �8 H�� (8B! ,��> 26�� �8 &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� '�-��E! L��E"�� , �
M� � C� +�� ��� .� �A0B ��� O�P7 8��K�� �� ��B�Q � � �#� �R� ���B! �� � �"��8 D��E! ���K�5 �� .S � �8 �T"�B� � ��J� , � �� �
=�� �� (8 A"�� � &�� �I��B�8�J ��U� 2 � ��B�� ��-� � C� ���& , � V�F8 ,� � �"5 � ,�! ��� .�T"�B� � 8 P�� � =�"#I ��B�� �� �
)"#�� �8 ����� , ��"�� �� �C� ��-� , � �&B! 8�B 8��3 � ,� ���� ���F �!�BU �8 8��I �W ��R ! ,8 �� �� ��X� D��E! ,��> � #� W
=�� �8 �� '�-��E! L��E"�� , � (8B! D��E! =�� (��� 8��8 ,�. =�� ���JK �8 S� , � �T"�B� � �C-� Y � �� ����� ,� � �"##I , �
)DFN (�T"�B� � �� � � �"5�I �G� �8 � � \�BU (��8 �0 T] M��X5� �� �� ��� �W 8B� ,�"��� V� Q! +�PF�� � � (8�W ,��IB�& ,��8
8��8 .+��� F �� �&B! � V�43! ��� �8 �� �� � �! -� 3 ^BJ , � Y�� �� ,�_� , � ��X5�Mathematica �T"�B� � �C-� �W �"�B� ,���
�8 �"##I ,�P�)DFN2D (�� (8 A"�� .+��� F �� � (�� �"�B� �W , � �� �� '�BF� �&��J ��0B! �� ��B! 2#�#! �"5�I �G� �8 ',�_� , �
(��8 (��8 S� +J � ',��8 `B�� ���P! ' � � � � , � (��8 8�BJ�� �� 2U 6 2 W , � �K +6 # �-� 3 � � ' � 8 ���&��J D� �
A"�� ,���Y�� �8 (8 ,8�� 2��3! , ���X5�UDEC � PFC2D�_E� �� a��� ,� K �&��J � 8�W (� �� S� ����� , � . �� (8 A"�� �
+��8�������! �� (�� Y �� , ��I��� �!b �"6� c��B! c��B! ���"�� 8��K�� � d ��P a� �8 8B&B , ��"�8 ����� , �(��8 8B&B , �
S� '�4Q� ��� �8 (��8 �C-� ������� ���! � .�&��J(��8 \�� � �0 T] ���& �� S� �� 2U 6 , � � �#� V� Q! 8B&B +�PF�� � ,��8
8�8 � �� �� ��BJ .(��8 �� 2U 6 , &�� �I��B�8�J ��X��� �-� 3 S� 2W eQ� �� (�� �WB�� eQ� +-#� ���f�� � � � , �.
�,'� �-. �(: S� '����� ,� �(��8 =�� ' &�� �I��B�8�J '�"##I �T"�B� � �C-� ' � � , ��-��E! L��E"�� , �
1. a�X�5Bgh � +A� '��P (�C���8 '8��� � �"P�U ( T���8 '��P L��E"�� ,�"W8 ,B���[email protected]
2. 8��� � �"P�U ( T���8 'a�X�5Bgh � +A� '��P ����� (�C���8 � ����8
3 .8X� ( T���8 ',h�B0 " � ��P ����� (�C���8 � �8 "��.
*\ -! C SBi#
0�� 012 ' �-2�3'�$' ���!4� ���!�
��4� ����3��� 1395 �-� )4 ���1� )81 �2 ) �:;<27 ��44
28 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
1 .���@�
S � �8 �� (� ! �����K � ,� C��P +P�U ��J� , �
M0 ] +������ ���& � ����F , � .V��� '�� Jk ��� �!
)W ��� ���& �� ���P c� � ,��� 7 4! M��X5� � � �� ���
M0 ]+� � .=�� �� (8 A"���� �-��E! , � (��� =��
(8B! D��E!+�� l�Q 2� # ��� �� m� a� ��B�� �� ,� .
(8B! D��E! =�� �8 ��� � �� � )�G� �� Jk L��E"�� ,�
� C� �� V�� � ��> 8� � .��� =�� ��� ���f�� ���!
=�� �� � �� +-#� ��0B! n�� ���!b � � ��0B! ���X� , �
8��8 �� ������� L��E"�� .! S 6�� �� �J�� �8 ��J� ^�
��� '��"#� � W �� SBo� =�� ��� � �W ��8 �8 P ��
p�B� ��PdW� Northparkes ��B�b � �0��"�� �8
Palabora �� �5 W +J �� Y�� '��B�& , 4��5K �8
� � � �� �� D��E! q3� �8 �C��C!Bgh , ����K�5 8� � .
)� �B�W� �8 , ��B�W �"5��� , �"P�U 2� �! ,��� (8 A"��
�� =�� �-��E! �8 , �� #� W +E� �! �� �f�K �8 �"�>I �
��� =�� 8�B L��E"�� ���F � '�"5�I 8B&� 8��8 .(��B��
�8 ��� =�� (��� �� ,��� , �� #� W +E� �! M0 ]
D��E! ,��> l�Q (8B� +�� � �C� �� ���"�� 2�B�
��R !��>I �� ��X� D��E! ,��> �8 , �� #� W '+E�
)"#�� �T"�B� � , � +� ��K)Tollenaar, 2008(.
�I��� 8��B �rW� �8 �T"�B� � , � (8B! ��W � "5� � �� H��
� S�"�W ���W .(8B! ����� � "J � V�F8 O��P! �Q4� H��
S� ,��� �� ,�"�� s��� (8B! +� 4 ���P! � ,� � H��
� )���5 ��W )Pine et al., 2006.( (��8 S���" � sB� ���!
�T"�B� � �T"�B� � � � �8 � (8B! , � ��"#� H�� . �>0
�I��� �� ���� (��8 , � (8B! ����� �� ��� ME� � H��
� 2�C�! �� ��8 )Wanga et al., 2003 .( �� ,� �#� �8
(B�� S� , � (8B! ,� � (��8 'H�� �tP� �� (8 A"�� � �
u�5 �v , �(8 � �PF��� � ,� � ��B� . u�5 S r ,���
(��8 �� , � S� �8 wbB�P �W +� �� ,� � � � W �� � '8��
�I��� a� (8B! �P�-x � �PF�� y���� � �W +�� H��
8���� V� Q! )Rogers et al., 2007.( SB�P �Bx �� ���f��
M� u�5 �I��� �8B� �PQF 8�B �8 �� � 8��P! '(��8 , �
(��8 )W � �#� (��8 S14"�� ' � � � #C� 8��J� S �"6� ' �
(8B! �8 +J�B�C� � �"5�I �G� �8 (��v � H�� ��B�.
(8 � ��� ,� � +�8��3 � S� �� ��B! �� ,�& �� � ,� �
(8B! �PF�� � "5� � 2��3! 'H�� ���W .S� ,��� V�F8 ,� �
(8B! (��8 �� �� & �� � H�� S� 2J�8 �8 � ��BI �� �� � ,�
(��8 c��B! �W �T"�B� � �� � � C� �6 ! � 8B&B , �
(8B! �8 �� � H�� . �I��� �� �58 _! +�� '�T�8 z�x ��
(8B! +� 4 �� ��� �R� (��8 ����� 8��8 H��)Hoek,
1998 .(=�� ���"�� �� ��-� �� ��B! ,���8 , � +�� ,� �
�I��� �58 _! � ����� , ��T"�B� S� ' � �58 _! ,� �
�T"�B� � �C-� , ��"##I Discrete Fracture Network
+�� .S� �P�B! )�] +5��� '�58 _! ,� � �8 ,��I
S� ���� (8B! ,� � ^B#3 �K � "5� ����� � H��
� 8B�)Rogers et al., 2006.( S� �8 � '�58 _! ,� �
�I��� O��P! �T"�B� � , � '�58 _! � ,� K \�BU �� �
S� S� �� (8 A"�� � � S� ��� (��8 )"#�� ��0B! , �� �
�� � ,�P��8 �"5��� �-!�� ��#�� S� 'B� �X�� S� ',�P�
S� �� � � �f�� ,�� 8��� W � �� � , � �0�B" , �
_! , ����K�5 �58 )�3AU '��B��B �QJ � ��B��B ,�
(��v (� 8 �� ��B� .
(��8 �58 _! , ��"�� (����� �� �,��I � ����� , �
2��3!� +��� ,� K , ����K .+5��� , � )�] �8 ��I
c�& =�� � ,��KS � �8 \ �1x� =��8� , � ��J� , �
�� )6 ��B"� �W (8B�� )���5 �� � C� ��� \ �1x� �� ,8
�B��J� �� �� b � +�A�W � (8B! , � 8��K +��� H�� . �>0
� )���5 � C� ��� ,� K \ �1x� { �� �� �W 8B�
c�& �I��� '(�� ,��K (8B! , � ���P! ,�"�� +�A�W � H��
��B�.
S� �f�� y�B! (�� (8�8 �P�B! (��8 �C-� �58 _! , �
Baecher S � �8 ��� C�� �1977 B� �X�� � Veneziano �8
S �1978 S� |X& ��"#� ���� ��� �8 (�� ����� �� , � .
S� ��� �8 �I��� � '8��J� S �"6� 2 � (��8 �� �� �
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 29
________________________________________________________________________________________________
+�& ��U 5 � ,��8 �� ��BJ �� ,��8 S� ,� K �Bx
(�� =�"#I � 8 P�� �I��� �� � '���)�� � ( 2�08 �� (��8
(����� \1C� �xB�� y���� 8B&� Y�� � �K ���4 ,��I
+�� (��� �"J�8� . �� � ���� ��R ! �� �&B! � �0 4 ��� �8
�C-� �58 _! S� 'H�� (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J �� (��8
� �"5�I �G� �8 � (��8 { ���� (��8 SBx (����� ,� K �I��
S� � B� �X�� S� +�� (�� �"J � �-!�� ��#�� , � .
(8�8 �� (8 A"�� � ���f�� a� �� (�� +��8�� ����� , �
�C-� ,�P��8 ����� S� ����� �8 ,��5� d ��P
(��8 (8B! , � �"5 � �P�B! �58 _! S� �� (8 A"�� � H��
+�� (�� ���! . �� � �� �� (8 A"�� � ,�P��8 ,�W �BG� ���
� ��� Y�� �#�B� ��X5�Mathematica Y � ��DFN2D (�� ���!
(8�8 { ���� +�� �8 F �W �&��J '(�� +��8�� , �
�� �� '�BF� 2#�#! � X�h �"5�I �G� �8 ',�_� , �
(��8 (��8 S� +J � ',��8 `B�� ���P! ' � � � � , � , �
6 2 W(��8 8�BJ�� �� 2U �K +6 # �-� 3 � � ' �
8 ���&��J Y�� �8 (8 A"�� ,��� D� � 2��3! , ���X5�
,8�� UDEC � PFC2D �� a��� ,� K �&��J �
�_E� ��8 ����� �� S� +J � ����� , �.
2 .A�BC�D� �!E�
S�(8B! �T�� � +P�-x '(��8 �C-� �58 _! , � H�� , �
(��8 �� (��8 �C-� ����� �� (8 A"�� � �� ��8 ,�U �� \�BU
�I��� � ����� \ �UB_J � t5 �8 �"##I �� �W �� �
(�� O��P! �58 _! �Bx � M� �� ��� ��8)Pine et al.,
2006 .(�B�8 � \ P0 Q �"�B b � S � �81980 �� � �B#���
S � �81983 � �� S �� � ��& � ������! ���� �8 ��B!
S� 8��� W � vK �Q4� +#��8 �58 _! , �)Hudson and La
Pointe, 1980, Robinson, 1983 .(X"�B���8 �8 ��"���� �
S �1988 �58 _! S� a� �"5�I �G� �8 � �W ��8B�� �����
��U 5 '+�& �8 \����o! � � ,��8 �C-� '�T"�B� � ��
�PF�� (��8 � 8 �� �� ,�! 8�W)Dershowitz and Einstein,
1988( . S � �8 BT�� � � +#�� 1988 ��� �P�B! �� Y��F�
��8B�� `B�� ,���� 2��3! ���� �8 YB�A)Priest and
Samaniego, 1988.( ����� �8 �-!�� ��#�� ����� S� ,
, ����K�5 � } -!���� ��"���� � d�� y�B! (��8 8 �� ,�
S � �81991 )Reyes and Einstein,1991( ~ ����� S� �
S � �8 ��� C�� � 2!� y�B! (�� ����� �C�� C1991
)Martel et al., 1991( � �� ��B�� �T�8 �� ��B! S� , � , �
+#��8 (�� (8�8 �P�B! �58 _! .+�8��3 S� ��� , � ' �
��S� �� ��B! (��� �8 2C� � (��8 �"�8 �8 y45 ,� �
(��8 �"�8 c��B! (8�"#I \����o! ����� �P�B! �� �� ' �
S � �8 B� y�B! �"5��� �-!�� ��#�� ,�P��8 S�1992
��)Yu, 1992( . S � �8 +#�� 1993 �� �58 _! S�
(��8 �K �8 �W 8B�� ����� �� ,�P�a#�8 \�B_� � , �
�8(�� (�� u�5 ,� ��� . �QF ,��� �58 _! ��8 4 S� ��� �8
)"��BT0� ����� �� X�� (��8 �� '+#�� y�B! (�� ����� , �
��B� � ��0B! D� � , � c��B!)Priest, 1993.( � ��B��B��
S � �8 M��� C��1995 �-!�� ��#�� ,�P��8 S�
��8�8 �P�B! �P� �� �� �� �"5��� )Ivanova et al., 1995 .(
S � �8 ��� C�� � `1�!bBW2004 ���! �� Y��F� S� ,
(8B! ,��� ,�P� �� �58 _! (��8 �C-� d�& �� �T��
� +� 4 ���E! ,��� ,���& ���K�5 ����� � +��B�8
2C����o! ��8B�� �P� �� �8 �T�� `B�� ,��> )Kulatilake
et al., 2004.( S � �8 �P�B! X�� ��J� , � �� �58 _! S�
�R� SBx � �I��� � c��B! ��� �T"#��� \��R� ����� �BG�
(8B! �C�� C � �C�� C����� � "5� �� (��8 (��8 H�� '��8
S� { �� �� +�� (�� Y �� '���� , � . ,�P��8 S�
S � �8 H��& � � � -v � y�B! (�� �����2008
)Baghbanan and Jing, 2008( �� S� � ,�P� (�� �����
S � �8 8�8 � �� y�B!2010 )Xu And Dowd, 2010( �
S � �8 M��� C�� � H�� ���f��2012 )Bang et al.,
2012( � ���� ��B! ��B�� ��B�� 8����� sB� ��� �� �� � . �8
S � , �1386 !1393 ,��6�� � � ,��8BI '���� '�45 �
S� H�� (8B! ,�P� �� ,� � (��8 , � �8 =�� �8 �� �
�T"�B� � )"#�� a#�8 )"#�� � 8��3 � , � �58 _! , �
30 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
________________________________________________________________________________________________
Y�� y�3 �8 � ��� �8 C�"�" ,��X5� ��B�� � ,�3DGM ��
��8�8 �P�B! . � �� 8�B �&��J >J� +��� F X�� � ��� ��� �8
Y�� , ���X5�UDEC '3DEC �DDA 8��8 8B&�) � ����
',��6�� �1386�� � � ���� ' ,��61388 � ,��8BI '
',��6�� �1392 ',��6�� � � ,��8BI '1393 ( ���!���&
S� �� (8 A"�� 8�B �8 (�� Y �� , �� W �C-� ,� �
�T"�B� � (��8 \�� � �"##I , � ,��� ��6 ,��8
(8B! �"��� +J �� �� }B�� �WB�� D��E! =�� �8 H��
S � �8 ��� C�� � ��&��2014 +��)Rogers et al., 2014(.
3 .F� �4� ����� ������ ���� �C� �'GH'
S� �8 ,� � L "�"�� � ����� 2 � ��W (B�� '�58 _! , �
�� � '+�PFB)(�����(+�& ' �I��� �T�8 � ,��8 , �
(��8 ����� c��B! � �58 _! , ���o" ��B�� �� � , �
S� �8B� �58 _! , �- �W +�� ,� K ,� � 8B� ���BJ � .
=�� ��� ���& �� ##I �T"�B� � �C-� �58 _! , � �"
S� =�� ��� '+�� �T"�B� � )"#�� 8��8 �P� ,� � , �
(B�� �� �� H�� (8B! �� �� 8 �� ,� K , .����B� � W ��� ,
�T"�B� � ,�� +J � (�� � , �-�� �X , � � �
+��8�� �T"�B� � ����� ��BJ , � a� �8 8B&B , �
� Y �� �4Q� 8��I .��"� '(����� 2 � ��BJ ��� \�� � 8
(��8 +�� ,��8.
=�� S� ��U� , ��X ,���8 �"##I �T"�B� � �C-� ,� �
=�� �T�8 �� +-#� S� SB�P , � +�� ,� � . =�� ���
D� � ��3 { �4 � ��� # ,��� �K �� ��B! ���� +�� �!
�T"�B� � ����� ��BJ O�UB! ,��� (��8 � �X , � �
V�F8 � �#� (B�� �� �! , � +�� { �4 ��X� �"�B� .
(��8 )"#�� ��T�� � =�� ��� ���f�� �� �� � \�BU
� ����� �_E� � e7�� ��BJ O�UB! � 2�� ��� '��W
� C� �T"�B� � )"#�� ,���W +�� ��> .)� �I��� ���!
,��� �� ,��> ���! � � C�K ��# �W +�� ��� =�� ���
S� (8�8 ,� � � (�� +��8�� , �� )���5 �4Q� � ���� ��W
(��8 �PF�� ����� ��BJ S� Y T�� �8 � ,� �
+�8 �� ����BJ �F � (8�BE�)Rogers et al., 2014(.
I��1 .S� , �� ���� (��8 �"�8 a� ,��� ,� �
S� eQ� 8 �� ,� �
) , ���X 'Y (
(��8 �"�8 (��8 }BQJ ��0B!
(��8 XW� +�PFB ��0B! ��B��B ���K�5 { �� �� �
+�5 �� ,�P��8 S� �BF� � ,��B_! �&��J 8 ��O�"E , �
�0 T] � \�� (��8 �R� SBx ,� K c��B! � (��8 D�� ,� K c��B! �
(8�8 �5�P,8��� , �
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 31
________________________________________________________________________________________________
(��8 �"�8 �� �� �"##I �T"�B� � �C-� S� +J � ,���
�A0B � �] �� +�� � �� ��� ,:
+�& S �"6� �0 T] c� ! ~ O0� (��8 ,��8 �
\�� � �0 T] ~ ^(��8 ,��8
(����� \����o! S �"6� �0 T] c� ! ~ �)�� � ((��8 �
(��8 XW�� +�PFB ~ \ �
S� , �� ���� 2C� �8 (��8 �"�8 a� ,��� ,� �1 � ��
+�� (�� (8�8.
���K�5 �� �0�B" 8��� W � ,�P��8 , t5 �8 (��8 �"�8 a�
� ��0B! �58 _!8B� .
S�� ���K�5 ~ :�B��B �C-� (��8 XW� ��0B! ,��� �T�� �
(��8 �0 T] { ���� ,��8
Y�8 ���K�5 ~ : c� ! �� (��8 D�� ���4 �58 _! ^ E"��
D�� S �"6� �0 T]
YB� ���K�5 ~ : c� ! �� (��8 �R� SBx ���4 �58 _! ^ E"��
�K S �"6� �0 T]
��B�� � (�� ���! � ��� �8DFN2DY�� y�3 �8 �W ' ,��X5�
Mathemtica �G� 8�B (8 A"�� �� �� '+�� (�� �"�B�
+��� F �K �� �J�� �W (�� ��-P! �� � '+�� 8�5 �� �_3� �
+�� (�� (� �� ��K ���"�� �� ��E� �� 2�k �8:
- ��B�� � C� (��8 �� �58 _! ,��I �� (�� ��0B! , �
��B�� �� '��W \�B_� � � (��8 �"�8 �� a�CA!
��B��60 %(��8 �� �58 _! \�B_� (�� �"J � , �
��B� ^ E"��.
- S� 8 �� � C� X�h �"5�I �G��8 � �-!�� ��#�� , �
�"�8 8��P! { ���� (�BE08 8��P! �� (��8 �"�8 ��
(��8 �.
- ��B�� , ���X�� �8B� ���8 ��X� ���P! ,��� ,��8��
'(�� �"J � S� �8 O�"E , � "��� �8 �QJ �0 T]
08 �� \�B_� � � (��8 �"�8 �� a�CA! �� ��� W (�BE
S� ���� -"�� �BG� �� ��W.
- �� a�CA! �� �C�5��I � �BF� �&��J 8 �� � C�
��W \�B_� � (��8 �"�8.
- ��B�� ��X�� �8B� ���8(��8 �� ,��I �A0B { ���� � , �
��B�� ��B�� �� '�R� SBx � D�� ���& �� ,8���
K �P & a�CA!(��8 ,� �R� SBx � , �)�� � ( ���
1/0 !8/0 �".
- `B�� 2�C�! � C� (��8 cx 4! �� 2 W , � � �
�-� 3 c��B! c��B! )���! (���� �� ��K +6 # ,
`B�� +6 # ,� K �.
- �A0B � �! �&��J � C� ��6� �8 (�� 8 �� , �
S� (� K � c��B! c��B! ',� � �K , � � �� � ��B�� ��B�
`B�� +6 # '�R� SBx 'D�� (�� 2�C�! , �.
- +�5 �� (�� �"J � S� �� �&��J �"5�I � C�
Y�� ,8��� ,8�� , ���X5�UDEC �PFC2D �
(��8 sB� a�CA! � �R� SBx '(��8 �"�8 { ���� �...
- S� ���C! � C� '(�BE08 ���4 �� �58 _! ,� �
�#� 4 �A0B , � �0 T] , �(��8 \�� � �QJ ,��8
S� �3Q� ,� K c��B! c��B! )���! � �T��C� � �
�A0B ��� �� a��� �.
4 .���� �@D!� ����
(��8 ME� �� �C� ,� T� \ �UB_J \ P0 Q �8 )� , �
(8B! ����� (8�8 ���! 26�� ���"�� �� � +�� H�� �
S� ,��� � ^B#3 ����� ,� � 8B� . ��� �� \ ����
� 8�W a�CA! ME���� �� �� ��B!:
- +��8��
- �"�8 a�CA! � )���! (��8 �
- ,� K 2��3!
4-1 .(��8 +��8�� �
(����� �B��J� ,�� �� ,��I �� �W +�X ��� �� �T�� , �
c��� �4Q� � (8 A"�� +��8�� ,��� ,�! ��8�BJ�� '8B�
+�� .�I��� �T"�B� � ����� , � ��� � +�& � D��
�K { �4 ��X� \ �UB_J �T�8 � (����� 'D�� � � ���B!
8B� +��8�� .��� } -!�� �T"�B� � (��I ��� �� �� X�� �
32 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
________________________________________________________________________________________________
�B��J� �8 +�� (�� � 2� F �T�� , � .��X� �4� ���!
�B��J� �8B-� {�"�8 �8 =�� ��� ���F ��R ! +3! ' �
�K �"5�I �� � �I8��B� � � A�� �� � ��� �8 ��� �
+�� �� �I M�B .c�& \ �1x� �0 4 ��� �8 (�� ,��K
���W 8�B �8�T"�B� � , �8 �� (8 A"�� � (��8 { �4 � , �
(�� � +��8�� yJ =�� +�� (�K +�8 �� +��8�� .
8���� "�� �W +�� ��� +��8�� yJ =�� �8 �&B! 2� F �"C�
� =�� ��� ,��� �� �& SB-F 2� F �� � cF�� �8 � 8���� 8B&
(8�8 ��B"� �W 8�8 ���o! ,B3� �� �� =�� \ �gX& Y�b , �
c�& �� �G� 8�B z�� ,��� ��3 y���� � � 8B�� ,��K
(8B! 8�8 V� Q! H�� .
�� �T�� X��! �Q# lBQ� +��8�� yJ =�� �8��BI ,�
� ^ E"�� ��U 5 � (����� �� +-#� �W ��B� ,��8
�T"�B� � ��� � ��X� � . 2 � �B��J� �� � =�� ��� �8
150 !300 �� �"�� a� 2F��6 � (8B� �T"�B� �50 �U�8
�K �� � (�� � 2� F �)Priest, 1993.(
(��8 +��8�� \ ���� yJ �� (8 A"�� � ��P (8��3 �8 �
+��8�� �����! \���B �� �� � (8 K , � , �BC� ,� �
�� Y �� ,� A6 .(��8 � �! =�� ��� �8 yJ �W �� �
� cQF �� +��8�� (����� ���W ���� ,��I . �� ,8 �� 8��P! �8
�����! �T"#C� � �I��8�J 2�08 �� �4Q� �8 8B&B , �
(8B! ,b � +��8�� � C� '�W J (� ��� 8B&� � � H��
+�� �"���� 8B&� .(8�8 �����! �� � �� 8�B , � �8 �
� , ����! , ��"�� � ��8�I +��8�� O�"E �� A!�
(��8 ����� ��U 5 'D�� 'D�� +�& 2 � � ',��8
�" � { ��W �� (8 A"�� � =�"#I � �I��� '�I��� �
(����� �� ,��I .+�8 ,��� (��8 �� +��8 ,��8 �� �� � , �
(��8 +�� Y�b (�� +��8�� ��B� )�#4! (��I �� �� � .
(��8 8��P! �� ��K , �"�� �8 �� �W � (��8 � 8B�)n ( 8��P!
(��8 �K , �"�� a� y45 �W �� � � (��8 � 8B�)m ( 8��P! �
(��8 ��� (��8 �K , �"�� �8 �� a� ��� �W �� � 8B�)p (
�A0B ��� �� }B�� 8��B �� }B�� �B"� �8Termination
Y�5 �8 �� +-R �T"�B� � +��8�� �B_E , � . d��
D���7R0 'R1 �R2 �� � y���� �8�8 � �� �BG� ��
(��8 �Q��� V� Q � � �-� 3 ��� , ��B�)Kulatilake et
al., 1996 :(
) 01(
�� = � �� + � + ⁄ �� = � �� + � + ⁄ � = �� + � + ⁄
(8 � ,��� �����! �� 8��P! sB� �8 +��8�� yJ ,� �
D� � �� (8�8 ��E�! �! . 2C� �82 �����! a� �� �� ��
+�� (�� ����� +��8�� yJ (���� ��. S��& �81 �U1J ,�
� � +�P7� �� (��8 �� � +�� (�� ����� (�� +��8�� , �.
I��2. �����! �� �C�+��8�� yJ � �P0 Q 8�B , �
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 33
________________________________________________________________________________________________
����1. �U1J� � +�P7� �� ,� (��8 �� � (�� +��8�� , �
���� �'�B� �( � � sB�(��8 �� � �(%)
R0 R1 R2
300 5 35 60
(��8 +-R �� ��B! Y�� �K SBx �W �� � (����� �6 �� � ,��I
a]BW (�������5 , QJ ��B�� �� +�� �!truncation bias
� (���BJ 8B� .(��8 ���f�� �K SBx �W �� � 2�08 �� �
��� (��8 �T�� �B��J� �8B� 8��3 , QJ ��B�� �� '8B�
(�������5censoring bias (�� �"J �� +��)Priest and
Hudson, 1976, Hudson and Priest, 1983 .( (����� ��R !
+��8�� cFB �8 (����� eQ� M� W � �� (�������5 , QJ
� '(��8 8�8 M� W ��B! .V�43! ��� �8 SBx1/0 ,��� �"
+�� (�� ^ E"�� (����� �6 .�B��J� ^ E"�� �T�� , �
(��8 (����� ����� �8 �I�X� w "-#� (����� ,���8 X�� (�� , �
��"#� 8B&B . 2� F (�������5 , QJ ����� ��+#�� �&B! .
(��8 �U�8 �W �K �� ���f�� �K , �"�� �8 �� �W �� � 2� F
� � '+�� (�� � � �� R2 � �W +�� �"��� � �#� ' �� ��B!
)�] X�� (�������5 , QJ 8�W ��B .
4-2 .�"�8 a�CA! � )���!(��8 �
�"�8 �� �&B! � (��8 �� �� a� �� �8 a�CA! 2� F , �
( T"#�� �A0B , �-�� '+��8�� 'D�� +�& � D�� , �
�"�8 � �! -��4! �W �� �E� (��8 ( T"#�� �8 � , �
�K ������5 ��X� �W '8��8 8B&� O�"E � #C� w -��4! X�� �
+�� .�"�8 ���W �"�� a�CA! � ��E�! ,��� �>0 (��8 ' �
��� (��8 , +�� (�� 2��3! C� \�B_� 8B&B , � . �
B!�4Q� �8 (��8 �"��� +��8�� � C� �C��� �� �& 8�B ,
�� (��#� 8��P! ���� �� �>0 +��8 8B&� �P0 Q.
(8�8 �� (8 A"�� �W ,�P� ��6� �� �&B! � �5�x �� , �
�T"�B� � �C-� S� +J � ,��� (�� +��8�� �"##I , �
�� D��E! � &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� (8B! ,��> H��
������5 ��X� �>0 '+�� �4Q� (��8 �"�8 a� `��� ��]��
� �K SBx � D�� +�& 'D�� ��8 4 �� �&B! � 'X�� ���B!
�� � ��>I��R ! � �#�. 2��3! { ���� �8 (�� Y �� , �
Y�� ��X5�Dips 8��P!4 +�� ��E�! 2� F (��8 XW��!
) 2C�3.(
I��3. (��8 XW��! �B"�W+��8�� �4Q� �8 ��K a�CA! � �
34 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
4-3 .2��3! �I��� ,� K , � �C-� ����� , �(��8 �
����� , ��"�� \ �UB_J ������T"�B� � � { �� '
S� ,� � ����� , � ,� K � �58 _! +��. =��8�
(8�8 �K c��B! c� ! , �-�� (��8 �� , ��"�� ���P! 2 � �
+�� (��8 �"�8 �K �8 �"�� . 8B&B \� A! ,�Bi! �G� ��
�C�� C , ����K�5 �8 \� A! �� �� � (��8 c��B! c��B! �8
� 8 �� �� (��8 �W +�� �A�"E ��W . c��B! S r ,���
��B! 8 �� q� � M�! +J�B�C�c , ����K�5 � �� �� , �
c��B! 8 �� q� � (��f� �A0B �8 S �� �b , � �R� SBx ,
�� ���BJ (��8 )Dershowitz and Einstein,1988.(
�I��� ,� ���& � (��8 �"�8 �� a�CA! � (��8 , � , �
'�R� SBx � �0 T] 'D�� +�& 'D�� ���& �� �K �� }B��
K \ P0 Q ,��� Y�b \ �1x�S� � ,� �58 _! ,� �
� )���588�I .Y�� �� (8 A"�� � ��X5� ,� KEasyfit c� ! '
S �"6� �0 T] �A0B ����� , � (�� +��8�� �� 8��K�� .
(8�8 c��B! �W ��7�5 ��� �8B�K ,��� �� (�� +��8�� , �
S �"6� �0 T] c� ! � J ,BT0� a�Probability Density
Function � ,��� �B�K �� '��J � ��W =���� ���"�� , �
Goodness of Fit �� (8 A"�� .�B�K ��� �P��B! ���"�� �
(8�8 �� �W (����� , � � =���� (�� ,��I � �� �� 8B�
� ���8 .�B�K �� V�43! ��� �8 =���� ���"�� , �
~ �] � H��0��8 ~ �B����K 'z��B����� ~ z��IB�0BW
BC�� D�� +�& 'D�� S �"6� �0 T] c� ! �� ���� ,��� ��
(��8 �R� SBx � +�� (�� (8 A"�� �.
z��B����� ~ z��IB�0BW �B�K : ��7�5 ��E�! ,���
� (8�� � C� �"�B� c��B! 8B� . c� ! { �� �� �B�K ���
���! �P�! c��B!)ECDF(Empirical Cumulative
Distribution Function �� ��+�� (�� (8 .��B�� , �
�58 _!nxxx ...,,, 21 �P�! c��B! c� ! � �P��B! ��
)(xF ����T� �G� �8 . (8 A"�� � ���! �P�! c��B! c� !
+�� (�� (8�8 � �� ��� �Q��� ��
) 02( [ ]xnobservatioofNumbern
xFn ≤= .1
)(
(� Kz��IB�0BW ~���z��B��)D( ���"I�X� { �� ��
� ,�Bi! �P�! c��B! c� ! ��� z1"J� +��� ���!
� ��K.
) 03(
−−−=≤≤
)(,1
)(max1
iini
xFn
i
n
ixFD
�B�K �B����K ~0��8 (�� � �P�! c��B! c� ! =���� H��
� �#� 4 �G� 8�B �P�! c��B! c� ! � �� (�� ��W . ���
�B�K �� +-#� �B�Kz��IB�0BW ~���(8�8 �� z��B�� , �
� ,�"��� ��� ��� 6 ��8 . (� K�B����K-0��8 H��)2A (
+�� (�� O��P! ��� ���
) 04( [ ]∑=
+−−+−−−=n
niini xFxFi
nnA ))(1ln()(ln).12(
11
2
� ~ �] �B�KBC��� c��B! Y��W �� �W �P & �8B�K ,���
� ,��� +�� �"5�I ���F (8 A"�� 8�B ��W . �� �B�K ���
(8�8 ,�� �"�8 , � (�� ,���binned data � S ��� '8B�
�T�BT] �� �B�K (� K ���4 d �"�8 8��8 �T"#� ,��� .
(� K �]- �BC� ��The Chi-Squared statistic )2x ( V� Q
+�� (�� O��P! ���
) 05( ,)(
1
22 ∑
=
−=k
i i
ii
E
EOx
�K �8 �WiO �"�8 (�� (�� � ������5i � 'iE ������5
� �-� 3 ��� �Q��� �� � (8B� � G"�� 8�B 8B�.
) 06( ),()( 12 xFxFEi −= �K �8 �W)(xF '�B�K +3! S �"6� c��B! �P�! c��B! c� !
1x �2x���W ' � �"�8 , � ��� �.
�E� 8 �"�� eQ� �8)α( (� K ���4 �I� �B�K , �
z��IB�0BW ~���z��B�� )D(�B����K ' ~0��8H�� )2A(
�� ~ �]BC���)2x (�K ����3� ���4 �� �"��� �'�� �
�� ���BJ 8� c��B! 2C� ��7�5 .�� & �8 ��] ��7�5 �W
(� K �]�� �� � �"��8 8B&� ��o" a� ,��� O�"E c��B!
c��B! �� a��� �8 (�� Y �� �B�K �"�W ,8 ���� , �
�� ���BJ �"J �� c��B! ���"�� ��B�� �� c��B! �K '�� � . ��
��8 4α �����01/0 �05/0 u�5 �� ���� ,��� wbB�P '
��! null hypothesis (H0) O�"E , �8 �"�� eQ� �8
� (8 A"�� 8B� . ���4 8��B D�v� �8α �����05/0 (8 A"��
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 35
________________________________________________________________________________________________
� +�� (�� (8 A"�� ���4 ���� �� X�� �0 4 ��� �8 8B� .
�U1J(��8 �"�8 ,� K 2��3! �� ,� �� , � �8 (�� +��8
S��&2 +�� (�� �����.
����2. �"�8 ����� , ��"�� ,� K 2��3! �U1J (��8 (�� +��8�� , �
����+�&,��8
�0 T]
3Q��) (
�R� SBx)�"(
���� D��)�&�8( D�� +�&)�&�8( (X��)P20(
c� !
c��B!
��T� � z��3��
8���� "��
c� !
c��B!
��T� � z��3��
8���� "��
c� !
c��B!
�"��
+�PFB
�"��
{ �4)s(
��T� � z��3��
8���� "�� 1 S �� 3/79 91/6 S �� 7/173 25/18 1/5 �b
S ��
62/0- 77/0 72/0 57/0
2 S �� 5/75 66/5 S �� 4/356 92/13 44/4 �b
S ��
79/0- 83/0 54/0 63/0
3 S �� 8/50 37/8 S �� 218 08/17 2/4 �b
S ��
92/0- 96/0 67/0 78/0
4 S �� 3/55 6/11 S �� 5/312 8/10 6/2 �b
S ��
95/0- 68/0 49/0 37/0
O0�- +�& c��B! ,��8
�T"5 � +�& (��8 +�& � D�� ����� �A0B �8 2 � �
+�� D�� .S� +0 6 �8 �A0B �8 ��� �� ,�P� �� ,� �
��0B! 8BJ ,� K c��B! c� ! �� �&B! � � 24"# \�BU
� c��B! �� ��K ��� �T"#-�� 8B&� \�BU �8 � ��B�
� (8 A"�� Y �T��� � ���5 (��o" ��] c��B! 88�I . +0 6 �8
D�� ,�P��8 ���BJ (8 � �G� 8�B �3AU �8 (��8 ,�� �
�� .S� ,��� ,�� � D�� \����o! ��! �� ��� �� ,� �
+�� �G�� .(��8 �"�8 �8 (�� Y �� V�43! �8 (� �� ,1 �
2 (��8 �"�8 ��"#� �4Q� ��U� , � . (��8 �"�8 �8 ���
�-�� +�& � � #C� w -��4! ,8��"� '������5 ���"��� ,���8
� z1"J�180 �&�8 �G� 8�B �3AU ����� �� ��"#� ,�
�3AU ',�P� �8 ����� S� +J � ,��� 8��"� � ,�
(��8 �"�8 �8 ��� � � #C� +�� (�� �"5�I �G� �8 . �8
S��&2 c��B! c��B! (���� �� D�� +�& � D�� ��8 4
�K +�� (�� ����� � . �� �T"5 � +�& c��B! ���P! �BG� ��
B�K H��0��8 ~ �B����� =���� �)A-D( +�� (�� (8 A"��.
^- �R� SBx c��B!)�� � (
+�� �B��J� eQ� � (��8 8�BJ�� �� �� � '(��8 �R� SBx .
(����� � (��8 �3AU =�"#I �T� �� SBx ��� `B�� , , �
+�� �T�� )Sari, 2009 .(�T"�B� � �R� SBx �"#��8 �� �
(����� �� �K ��R ! +�& `B�� 2�C�! +�� �C� �W �� �
M� ,��� '��B� (8B! � "5� ���� �I��B�8�J ��X� � H��
+�� )� �K , &�� . �R� SBx c��B! � d� ���� 'y�B"
^B#3 (��8 �"�8 �� ,��� ��� \ �1x� '�T"�B� �
� (8B! �58 _! ����� S� ���! ,��� �W ��B� H�� , �
(��8 ��"#� � �� 8�B ��8.
(��8 )�4"# +��8�� �C��� 2�0�� (8B! 2J�8 �8 � �8 H��
� u�5 ����� �� +�� �C���v 2�� (����� �W 8B� , �
�� (��8 ,�P� �I��� ,���8 � �� "� � �� � ,� K , �
M� �� �� (�K +��� ��"#� ,�P��8 , �)Xu and Dowd,
2010 .(=���� ���"�� �B�W ! ,��� (�� 8 ���� , � c��B!
(��8 �R� SBx �� �� c��B! ',�P��8 +��8�� �� 2U 6 , �
�A�)Kulatilake et al., 2003, Baecher, 1983, Zadhesh
et al., 2013 ( S �� �b ')Priest, 1993, Zhang and
Einstein, 2000, Wu and Wang, 2002 ( I � )Priest,
1993, Zhang and Einstein, 2000 (+�� (8B� .
�#� 4 �� "� �B�K , �B�K 2 � =���� ���"�� , �
z��IB�0BW-z��B����� )K-S( H��0��8 ~ �B����� ')A-D(
�] �B�K �- �BC� ��)Ch-S( (��8 SBx ,��� +��8�� , �
�B��J� �8 (�� 2C� �8 �P0 Q 8�B , �5 (�� (8�8 � ��
+�� .�b c��B! c� ! �"��� ,� I� � '�� "� ,��� �� S ��
36 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
________________________________________________________________________________________________
� ��� ! (��8 SBx c��B! �� c� ! ��� ��W 2C� �W '��W
+�� ��� \�BU:
)7( 0
−−=2
ln21
exp2
1)(
σµ
πσx
xxf
(��8 �"�8 SBx �� (�� =���� c��B! c� ! ��B�� ��B�� ��,1
2C� �84 c��B! \ _E� '+�� (�� (8�8 � �� �� c��B!
S��& �8 (��8 �"�82 +�� (�� �����.
I��4. (��8 �"�8 �R� SBx �� (�� =���� S �� �b c��B! c� !1 (� K (���� �� �K , �
O0�
^
�
\
I��5. �#� 4 �� "�O0� �R� SBx �� =���� ���"�� �B�K , ( (��8 �"�81 ^ ( (��8 �"�82 � ( (��8 �"�83 \ ( (��8 �"�84
0.1207
0.61891
1.2688
0.14752
0.76873 2.9824
0.19305
1.4798
4.139
K-S A-D Ch-S
Goodness of Fit Test
0.1207
0.61891
1.2688
0.14752
0.76873
2.9824
0.19305
1.4798
4.139
K-S A-D Ch-S
Goodness of Fit Test
0.14927
0.45944
0.5847
0.23004
1.4795
2.2928
0.23837
1.4776
1.503
K-S A-D Ch-S
Goodness of Fit Test
0.14414
0.39201
5.73E-02
0.27194
1.1891
0.23771
0.17197
0.76805
0.41611
K-S A-D Ch-S
Goodness of Fit Test
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 37
________________________________________________________________________________________________
&- ���� �C��+ ��'�
�T"�B� � �0 T] �T"�B� � 8��P! 2U� �8 H�� , � �� �
(8B! �6�� � '�6�� �K �W +�� H�� � +6 # ')6 ���B!
�� � SBx � .
�� ���BJ q� � H�� (8B! a� �� ,�P� �� ���"�8 Y��
(����� (��8 \�� � �0 T] ��6 ,��I \�B_� ,��8
�� � �C���v � 2C� ')�4"# . �W +�� �0 6 �8 ���
(����� ����� ,��I))�4"# (�"�� ��� \�B_� �� ,�P� a
)�� �I � � +��8�� yJ SBx �8 ( ,�P� �8 �) eQ� �8
(��B�8 ' �2�B! (��v � �( +�� Y �� 2� F �I8 � ��.
(��8 �0 T] ,�P��8 ,��8)P20((��8 2W 8��P! \�BU �� ' �
� O��P! (�� (8�8 +6 # �� 8B� . '�P� �8 �8 (��8 \��
P21 (�� (8�8 +6 # 2J�8 �8 (��8 ��W SBx ��B�� �� '
� O��P! +�� { �4 �� 24"# �W 8B� .P21 �"�8 8��P! '
(��8 �(��8 8��P! � (��8 �� � ' �G� �8 �� 8B&B , �
� 8��I .
�P�� (�f� +��8�� =�� �� (8 A"�� � �0 4 ��� �8
(��8 �" a� ^B]� ] a� �� (8 A"�� � ���8 2� F , �
M �C-� ,���8 �P�� ,���10 �"� � +��8�� �P�� �"
����) 2C�6 .((��8 (����� M yJ �� � cx 4" , � ,��I
(��8 ��W 8��P! � �" a� ^B]� ] �8 (�� =� �� , �
������ O��P! (��8 �3Q� �0 T] ��B�� �� �P . ��8 4
P20 +�� (�� �-� 3 �� I��& \�B_� (��8 �"�8 �� ,���
) S��&2.(
I��6. (����� (��8 �0 T] ,��I )P20(
5 . ���� ��� ���� I-:�
�� ��W�Bx=�� �8 �I��B�8�J eQ� �� �-��E! , �
�� ��!� -� �W +�� (�� O��P! : ' &�� �I��B�8�J
��B� R �I��B�8�J � ��0�� �I��B�8�J)Brown, 2003,
Laubscher, 2003 .(
38 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
________________________________________________________________________________________________
O0� ( &�� �I��8�J Insitue Fragmentation : 2 �
`B�� �� �W �� � ,� C��P \ ���� s��� �� 2-F �P�-x �Bx
(8B! �8 ����8 8B&� H�� .(��8 ����B� �I��B�8�J ��� �� �
� 2C� ����8 8B&� (8B! �8 2-F �� �W 8��I .
^ (��0�� �I��B�8�J Primary Fragmentation : �3 ��
`B�� 'D��E! \ ���� s��� � =����� 8 �� �� #�� , �
� 2C� ��0�� M��8�J � (�� ��& D��E! , t5 8��I.
L (��B� R �I��B�8�JSecondary Fragmentation : ���
eQ� �� H�� �����& � � �� ��# SBx �8 M��8�J
�B"� �� �B-� � D��E! n� ���E! �� �8 �� L��J ! ���E!
� ��8.
�I��B�8�J ��X� ���P! '+�� �G� 8�B �0 4 ��� �8 �f�K
`B�� 8 P�� � (��8 �C-� �� (�� 2�C�! , &�� , � , �
+�� 8B&B .BT� ��� ME� ��� �� (� �� �W �� �� ���B!
�A0B �� �C� ��B�� � C� ��U� � ��0�� , � ���
D��E! (8B! ,��> �� � � #� W � H�� . �BG� ��� ,���
Y�� S� ,��� (�� ���! ��X5� �"##I �T"�B� � �C-� ,� �
+��� F ,���8 �� � S� s�B�� +J � (��8 , � ,��8) ��#��
� '�-!�� � � � (c��B! s�B�� � �� O�"E ,� K , �
S� ,��� Y�b ���� -"�� \ � C� (���� (�� �"J � , �
`B�� 2�C�! +��� F � �� � 8�BJ�� �� 2U 6 2 W , �
(��8 �K 8 P�� ���P! � � �� ,� K c��B! c��B! )�� � C� � �
�� � �"��8 . +�5 �� �&��J �"5�I � C� ���f��
Y�� �I��B�8�J 2��3! ,��� ,8�� , ���X5� � ��0�� , �
�K �8 �W '��B� R M�! 'M�! \����o! �� � & � �� 40� , � �
�� � �"��8 8B&� '8��8 M4� .
5-1 . �"##I �T"�B� � �C-� S� +J � �C-� S� +J � ,��� (��8 �� � '�I��B�8�J ���E! �BG�
+�� S� D� � 8 P�� ���P! ��6� ��0�� . 8 P�� ������ �6
�4Q� 2W 8 P�� ,�Bi! \�B_� S� y���� ,���8 �W +�� ,�
(��8 � �� � '+�� (�� +��8�� �W �f�K � �� � w1 W ,��8
��BI �� �� � 8 P�� ��� ����W (��� �� �W 8B� O��P! ,�
(8B! 8�B H���� � �P0 Q . )6 YB�A �� � cF�� �8
�� (��� ��)REV (Representative Elementary Volume
��W ��U (�� ^ E"�� 8 P�� 8�B �8 . �"J � S� ���f��
� -"�� (�� +��8�� � 8B&B +�PF�� � �#� 4 �8 �� � (��
�� � �"��8 �� �5 W .(��8 SBx �� �&B! � �BG� ��� �� , �
+��8�� S� (�� 8 P�� � �� �5×5 '10×10 '15×15 �
20×20 Y��W��60 �"J � S� �� ��B�� a� '�� �"J � �-!�
8 P�� �� (��20×20 2C� �8 , �7 �8 �"�8 a�CA! ��
(��8 +�� (�� (8�8 � �� ��W \�BU �� � � .
��6� �8 +��8�� }BQJ O��P! � �P� ,)��B�� ,��I ( �45�
U�B5 �� )g F �S� 2J�8 ,�" a� 2 �0 T] ��8 4 ' �
(��8 �QJ ,��8)P10 ( '�� ���P! +��8�� yJ �� ,���
�� ,��� "��� �8 ��� �� a� �� �8 �K ��T� � ��8 4 d��
��8�I �-� 3 S� . (���� �� c��B! c� ! ��8 4 +� �� �8 �
(� K �K Y�8 � S�� �-!� , �)8���� "�� z��3�� � ��T� � (
����� �-� 3 8 P�� �� a� �� , . 2C�9 ��B�� }BQJ �� ,�
� � �� �� S� a� ,��� (�� O��P! �45� +��8����8 .
(��8 �0 T] 8�B �8 �3Q� ,��8)P20 ( ,��� ���K�5 ��� X��
�"�8 2W (��8 ���C! (��8 �"�8 �� a�CA! �� � S� �� , �
(� K ! ���#� 4 +�& � �� 8�B , � S� , 8 P�� � �
�� \� A"��K +�8. �A0B �� �T�8 �C� (�� ����� , �
(��8 \�� ���4 �3Q� ,��8)P21 (+�� . X�� �A0B ���
�� ���P! (�� �Wk 8 P�� �� a��� �8 S� �� ,��� . d��
8 P�� �� a��� ,��� �K 8���� "�� z��3�� � ��T� � ��8 4
� 3�� �- . '(��� �� )6 ���P! ���K�5 Y �� � � X��
8 P�� �� a��� ,��� (��8 �"�8 �� ,��� SBx � D�� ��8 4
S� �8 �P� �� z�P , �)�A0B � �� a�8X� ,� K , �
�P� �K ��T� �( (���� �� S �"6� �0 T] c��B! � ���P! '
(� K �K , � (� K � S �"6� �0 T] c��B! � � � ��8 4 ,
'+�� (�� (8 A"�� S� ,8��� ��B�� �� �W (�� +��8��
� �0B-F 2� F � ^BJ =���� �� �� �� S� ! �� �#� 4
�� � ��8�BJ�� �PF�� y���� . , ����K�5 � �! Y �� �� d
�#� 4 � (�� �Wk +� �� �8 '(�K +�8 �� ,� K �� "� ,
S�10×10 �� (8�8 ��E�! D� � .
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 39
________________________________________________________________________________________________
MC' ( ���� ����1
O ( ���� ����2
P ( ���� ����3
A ( ���� ����4
I��7. S� �� �C� �&��J (��8 �C-� +J � , � (��8 �"�8 �� a�CA! �� �
I��8. S� �� �C� ��W �&��J(��8 �C-� +J � , � �
I��9. ,�" a� , ����! �8 �45� +��8�� }BQJ (���� �� S� a� �� �� ��
�A0B �� �J�� S� ����� , �10×10 ,��� (�� ^ E"��
2��3!�� '�I��B�8�J�#� 4 \�BU �� �" ��8 4 � ,�
S��& �8 '(�� +��8�� , �3 !5 +�� (�� ����� . �8
S��&3 (��8 �0 T] ��8 4 �0 T] � �3Q� ,��8
MC' (���� �' ����G� �R �� ��(8/0 ���
O (���� �' ���+. �R �� ��(8/0 ���
0 5 10 15 20
0
5
10
15
20
0 5 10 15 20
0
5
10
15
20
40 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
________________________________________________________________________________________________
(��8 �� 2U 6 � V5� , "��� �8 (�� +��8�� �QJ ,��8
S� �"�8 �� a�CA! �� � -Q�� ��X� � (�� �#� 4 ',� �
��W \�B_� � (��8 +�� (�� 8��K�� .
(��8 SBx � D�� S �"6� �0 T] c��B! +J � �� d �
����B� S� ,DFN2D (8�8 � (�� �#� 4 (�� +��8�� , �
)� �W � � �� �� ��BJ � �#� ���BJ ��8 .�A0B 8�B �8 ,
�3AU ,�� �C��� 2�0�� D��S� cQ4 �W ,� 8 �� ,� �
(��8 �"�8 (�� , �1 �2 � D�� �� S� �PF� ,��� ��B�
+�� (�� (8 A"�� (��8 �"�8 �8 ��� �� �#� 4 . �8 �� "�
(� �� S��&4 +�� (�� ����� . S �"6� �0 T] c��B! ��8 4
(��8 �"�8 SBx � �� ��BJ � �#� V� Q! X�� (�� S� , �
(8�8 � � �� (�� +��8�� �� �" , � ��8 . ��B�� ��B�� ��
(� K � c��B! c��B! (��8 �"�8 �� }B�� , � (� �� ,3 �8
2C�10 S��& �5 �#� 4 ,��� +�� (�� (8�8 � �� �"�� ,.
�� �� ��E� '�K ���� -"�� � S� ����� 8 P�� ���P! �� d
(��8 l1QU� �� � (�� z>6 8���� ��4� `B�� 8 �� �8 �W
)G� S� � ,� �8B� .
5-2 .�-� 3 &�� �I��B�8�J ,
d `B�� �K �� (��8 cx 4! �� 2U 6 2 W , � �E� �
� �K +6 # � 8B� � �-� 3 � \�B_� ���K�5 ��� '88�I
2C� �8 ,��B_!11 +�� (�� (8�8 � ��.
����3. (��8 �0 T] � -Q�� ��X� ���P! S� � (�� +��8�� �3Q� ,��8 ����B� ,� � ,DFN2D
(��8 �0 T] �3Q� ,��8)P20( (��8 �0 T] �45� �QJ ,��8)P10(
����(�� +��8�� S�DFN2D � -Q�� �U�8 (�� +��8�� S�DFN2D � -Q�� �U�8
1 1/5 07/5 5/99
2 44/4 44/4 100
3 2/4 19/4 7/99
4 6/2 61/2 6/99
I. 34/16 31/16 8/99 9/8 83/8 2/99
MC'(��'���( ��� T�'���
^ (��'���� ����� ��( DFN2D
I��10. (��8 �"�8 SBx �� (�� =���� c��B! c� !3 (� K (���� �� �K , �
����4. �A0B �"�8 D�� ,� K , � (��8 (� �� , �1 �2S� �� d � (�� +��8�� ' ����B� ,� � ,DFN2D
D��)�&�8(
����
����
(�� +��8�� S�DFN2D
��T� � z��3����T� � z��3��
1 3/79 91/6 69/79 97/6
2 5/75 66/5 54/75 48/5
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 41
________________________________________________________________________________________________
����5. �A0B �"�8 SBx ,� K , � (��8 (� �� ,3 S� �� d � (�� +��8�� ' ����B� ,� � ,DFN2D
c� !c��B! +�PFB �"�� )m( { �4 �"�� )s( ��T� � 8���� "�� z��3��
+��8�� S �� �b 92/0- 96/0 67/0 78/0
S�DFN2D S �� �b 908/0- 00/1 65/0 72/0
MC' (8 !� �' U� ���� ���� �(
O (V-� I�E� ����:� � I��. ��( 3� TW��� � �(
I��11. S� �&��JDFN2D
2C� �811 `B���K 2J�8 �8 �W �� � cx 4! �R� �8 �
(��8 `B�� �"C]BW , � � 2�C�! X�� , � H�� �� X�� 8B�
����)��A� (+�� (�� �E� . ���� 2�C�! �BG� ��
`B�� � �� (� �� �W ��BT� �� �!X�� , � �� (8 A"�� � ��B!
a�CA! +��� F(��8 �K SBx { ���� � z>6 �� Y��F� �
(��8 8B�� )W SBx � , �.
`B�� +6 # ���P! �� d +� �� �8 S �"6� �0 T] c� ! �
y�B! +6 # �P�! �0 T] c� ! (���� �� +6 #
Y�� +5�I ���BJ ���F � �"J� �8 � �-� 3 ��X5�) 2C�12 .(
`B�� 2W +6 # +-#� ���f�� 2W +6 # �� � X�� S�
� ����� �U�8 \�B_� 8B� . �"J � S� ,��� +-#� ���
(��5/67 +�� (�� �-� 3 �U�8 .��3� ����� � , �
`B�� +6 # �P�! �0 T] � S �"6� �0 T] c��B! �
� �E� �� M�� �W 88�I97 `B�� �� �U�8 2 W , �
,� # � �"C]BW �"6 # ,���8 (�� 2�C�!5/0 c���"
��"#� . (�� 2�C�! `B�� ���"I�X� +6 #68/3 � c���"
`B�� ���"C]BW +6 #064/0 �� ���P! c���".
S� �T"�B� � �C-� ,� � ��X� ��P �� (�� +��8�� , �
`B�� 2�C�! � �� ^BJ �"�P7� �8 �� 2 W �T�� , �
� ��8)5/67 �U�8 ( �"��� 8 P�� �W +�� �0 6 �8 ���
`B�� 2�C�! , � (��)97 �U�8 ( ,� # � �"�W5/0
+�� (�� �-� 3 c���" . �Q���� �8B� ���F�� u�5 �
� 'V�� �8 �� � �� �-�W�! �W ���� ��"� ��� �� ��B!
`B�� +��8 �T�� , �) 8��630 �U�8 (���� �8 ,
`B�� 8 P�� �6��x �� �"#� �W +�� �"5�I ���F X�� , �
2� � =����� �&��E"�� , � � �!1C� ���� q� � ���B!
8B� ��B� R � ��0�� �I��B�8�J ���K�5 �8 .��"� +��8 ,��I
����� �� }B� '(�� l�Q sB7B �� c&�� 2 W � , �
S� '2 W �3Q���� �"5�I �G� �8 � e�3U �C�� C ,� �
2��3! � L "�"�� � +�PF�� �� a�8X� � C� �6 ! �Q����
�K +��� �� "� 2 W+�� '(.
42 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
MC' (V-� TW��� ��1�W' �C��+ X��� �(
^ (V-� TW��� �B12� �C��+ X��� �(
I��12. S� �&��JDFN2D
6 .�2� ���
�8 �rW� 8��B �� �BG� �G5 3 ���� W 2�� �8�W �8 2��3! , �
,���� )�� �� , � t5 ������� � '� ��� =�"#I
�T"�B� � � \�B_� 8��3 � �8 � � �G� �"5�I � '8B�
� �8 'cF�� �8 (��8 =�"#I 8�B �"��� �T"�B� � � �
�� (��� (��8 (8B! �8 8B&B , � +#�� 8��3 � 'H�� .���
��R ! �� ,8 �� �� ��X� D��E! ,��> �8 � #� W=�� , �
�� '�-��E! L��E"�� (8B! D��E! =�� (��� 8��8 ,�.
�I��� �"5�I �G� �8 � (��8 ����� , ��"�� �58 _! , �
(8B! �� �PF�� � C� �6 ! �0� ����� ,� K � 30 �� �W H��
�I��� , �BI � �� � �-"P (8B! ����� , � &�� H��
2��3! �8 8��� W �BG� �� '�� � ��E! , �D Y�b ,��>
+�� . �� (��8 �� � ���� ��R ! �� �&B! � �0 4 ��� �8
(8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J � (��8 �C-� �58 _! S� 'H��
(�� �"J � (��8 SBx (����� ,� K �I��� �"5�I �G��8
+�� . �� ���"�8 �P0 Q 8�B ��P �8 �W ��� �� �&B! �
� C� V�� � �5�x �� '+�� (8B-� ��> M� �K '��U� z�
Y�� ��K� W +��� F � (�� ���! ��X5� '+�� (8B� (�� �Wk , �
+��8�� { ���� ����� S� �>0 (�� Y �� �3Q� , �
+�� (�� �"J � .S� �� "� y�B! (�� Y �� ����� ,� �
Y�� � �#� 8B&B +�PF�� � �#� 4 �8 (�� ���! ��X5�
+� 7� +�� (8B� ME� .
+��� F �� �&B! � S� �8 (�� �6��x , � ����� � ,� � ,
�&��J Y�� ��� �8 ,8�� , ��W D� � , � �K �� '��X5�
� � ,���� 2��3! 'S �� � ��& \ P0 Q �8 ��B!
D��E! 8B�� (8 A"�� ��BE� ,�P��8 +0 6 �8 ,��> .
�X��!
� '����. � 's '�45 � ,��6�� �. '1386 .(8B! �C��C!Bgh '����� ,�P� �� ,� � S� H�� (��8 , � ,� K =�� �� ��8) ,8�B �P0 Q : `B��
�C��B"C!II \� o] ��P .(( T���8 '����� H�� a�� C d���A�W ��B� \b 4 ��B� ����! '��-W��� �"P�U.
� '����.s '�45 � ,��6�� � � '. '1388. ��-� �T"�B� � �C-� ,� � S� �8 � C��C!Bgh ,� �Y�� y�3 y�B! ������� , � t5 � ,��X5�
Mathematica\b 4 ��B� ' ����� 2�B! d���A�W ���"������! '.
( ',��8BI.s '�45 � ,��6�� � � '. '1392 .S� �� ,� � (8B! �C��C!Bgh ~ ����� ,�P� H�� (��8 , � a#�8 =�� �� ��8 �58 _! , �) �g���
� ���RD3DGM(����! '2�B! �� d���A�W ����8 \b 4 ��B� ' .
( ',��8BI.s '�45 � ,��6�� � � '. '1393 .S� ,� �2 �T"�B� � ����� ,�P� Y�� �8 � ,8�� 2��3! ��X5� UDEC � �K D�� c5� �
� ��� �� (8 A"��3DGM����� H�� a�� C d���A�W ���� \b 4 ��B� '.
Baecher, G., 1972. Site exploration: a probabilistic approach. PhD dissertation. Cambridge, MA: MIT.
S��T"�B� � �C-� ,� � �� �"##I (8B! , &�� �I��B�8�J 8��K�� �BG� =�� �8 H���-��E! L��E"�� , � / 43
________________________________________________________________________________________________
Baecher, G.B., 1983. Statistical Analysis of Rock Mass Fracturing. Journal of Mathematical Geology, 15(2), 329-347. DOI 10.1007/BF01036074.
Baghbanan, A., Jing, L., 2008. Hydraulic Properties of Fractured Rock Masses with Correlated Fracture Length and Aperture. International Journal of Rock Mechanics & Mining Sciences, 44(5), 704– 719. DOI:10.1016/j.ijrmms.2006.11.001.
Bang, S.H., Jeon, S., Kwon, S., 2012. Modeling the Hydraulic Characteristics of a Fractured Rock Mass with Correlated Fracture Length and Aperture: Application in the Underground Research Tunnel at Kaeri. Nuclear Engineering and Technology, 44 (6), 639-652. DOI:10.5516/ 02.2011.026.
Brown, E.T., 2003. Block Caving Geomechanics, The International Caving Study Stage I 1997-2000, Julius Kruttschnitt Mineral Research Centre, Brisbane, Australia.
Dershowitz, W.S., Einstein, H.H., 1988. Characterizing Rock Joint Geometry with Joint System Models. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering 21(1), 21–51. DOI:10.1007/BF01019674.
Hoek, E.T., 1998. Reliability of the Hoek–Brown estimates of rock mass properties and their impact on design. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci; 35: 63–8.
Hudson, J.A., La Pointe, P.R., 1980. Printed Circuits for Studying Rock Mass Permeability, International journal of rock mechanics and mining sciences and geomechanics abstracts, Technical Note, 17(5), 297-301. DOI:10.1016/0148-9062(80)90812-8.
Hudson, J.A., Priest, S.D., 1983. Discontinuity Frequency in Rock Masses. International Journal of Rock Mechanics, Mining Sciences & Geomechanics, Abstract, 20(2), 73-89. DOI:10.1016/0148-9062(83)90329-7.
Ivanova, V., Xiaomeng, Y., Veneziano, D., Einstein, H.H., 1995. Development of Stochastic Models for Fracture Systems. Rock Mechanics, Balkema, Rotterdam, ISBN 90 5410 552 6.
Kulatilake, P.H.S.W., Chen, J., Teng, J., 1996. Discontinuity Geometry Characterization in a Tunnel Close to the Proposed Permanent Shiplock Area of the Three Gorges Dam site in China. International Journal of Rock Mechanics, Mining Science & Geomechanics Abstract, 33(3), 255-277. DOI:10.1016/0148-9062(95)00060-7.
Kulatilake, P.H.S.W., Park, J., Um, J., 2004. Estimation of Rock Mass Strength and Deformability in 3-D for a 30 m Cube at a Depth of 485 m at Aspo Hard Rock Laboratory. Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, 22(3), 313–330. DOI:10.1023/B:GEGE.0000025033.21994.c0.
Kulatilake, P.H.S.W., Um, J., Wang, M., 2003. Stochastic Fracture Geometry Modeling in 3-D Including Validations for a Part of Arrowhead East Tunnel, California, USA. Engineering Geology, 70(1), 131-155. DOI:10.1016/S0013-7952(03)00087-5.
Laubscher, D.H., 2003. Cave Mining Handbook, De Beers, p. 138. Martel, S., Hestir, K., Long, J.C.S., 1991. Generation of Fracture Patterns Using Self-Similar Function
Concepts. Earth Sciences Division Annual Report, Lawrence Berkeley Lab, Berkeley, California, 52-56. Pine R.J., Coggan, J.S., Flynn, Z., Elmo, D., 2006. The development of a comprehensive numerical
modelling approach for pre-fractured rock masses. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering. 39. 5: 395- 419.
Pine, R.J., Coggan, J.S., Flynn, Z., Elmo, D., 2006. The Development of a New Numerical Modeling Approach for Naturally Fractured Rock Masses. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering, 39(5), 395- 419. DOI:10.1007/s00603-006-0083-x.
Priest, S.D., 1993. Discontinuity Analysis for Rock Engineering. Published by Chapman & Hall, London, p. 473. ISBN: 978-94-010-4656-5.
Priest, S.D., Hudson, J.A., 1976. Discontinuity Spacing in Rock. International Journal of RockMechanics, Mining Sciences & Geomechanics, Abstract 13(5), 135-148. DOI:10.1016/0148-9062(76)90818-4.
Priest, S.D., Samaniego, J.A., 1988. The Statistical Analysis of Rigid Block Stability in Jointed Rock Masses. 5thAustralia-New Zealand Conference on Geomachanics, (pp. 398-403), Barton, A.C.T.: Institution of Engineers, Australia, Sydney. ISBN: 0858254271 & 0858254085.
Reyes, O., Einstein, H. H., 1991. Failure Mechanics of Fractured Rock - A Fracture Coalescence Model. 7th International Society for Rock Mechanics, A.A. Balkema. Permission to Distribute -
Robinson, P C., 1983. Connectivity of Fracture Systems - A Percolation Theory Approach. Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General 16(3), 605–614. DOI:10.1088/0305-4470/16/3/020.
44 /���� ��- ����� ����� �� �� ��� ���� ����� � "#� ! � � ��1395 (� �� ')�� ��& '1 �2
________________________________________________________________________________________________
Rogers, S.F., Kennard, D.K., Dershowitz, W.S., Vanas, A., 2007. Characterising the in situ fragmentation of a fractured rock mass using a discrete fracture network approach, Rock Mechanics: Meeting Society's Challenges and Demands - Eberhardt, Stead & Morrison (eds) Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-44401-9.
Rogers, S.F., Moffitt, K.M., Kennard, D.T., 2006. Probabilistic slope and tunnel block stability analysis using realistic fracture network models. In Proc. 41st U.S. Symposium on Rock Mechanics, Golden, CO. ARM, VUSRMS, 06-1052.
Rogers, S.F., Elmo, D., Catalan, A., 2014. Volumetric Fracture Intensity Measurement for Improved Rock Mass Characterisation and Fragmentation Assessment in Block Caving Operations. International Journal of Rock Mechanics Rock Engineering, 44(5), 704– 719.
Sari, M., 2009. The Stochastic Assessment of Strength and Deformability Characteristics for Apyroclastic Rock Mass. International Journal of Rock Mechanics & Mining Sciences, 46(3), 613-628. DOI:10.1016/j.ijrmms.2008.07.007.
Tollenaar R.N., 2008. Characterization of discrete fracture networks and their influence on caveability and fragmentation. (Master of Applied Science) The University of British Colombia.
Wanga, C., Tannant, D.D., Lilly, P.A., 2003. Numerical analysis of the stability of heavily jointed Rock slopes using PFC2D. International Journal of Rock Mechanics & Mining Sciences 40, 415–424.
Wu, F., Wang, S., 2002. Statistical Model for Structure of Jointed Rock Mass. Geotechnique, 52(2), 137–140. DOI: 10.1680/geot.2002.52.2.137.
Yu, X., 1992. Stochastic Modeling of Rock Fracture Geometry. M.S. Thesis, MIT, Cambridge, MA. URI: http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/12176.
Xu, C., Dowd, P., 2010. A New Computer Code for Discrete Fracture Network Modeling. Computers & Geosciences, 36(3), 292–301. DOI:10.1016/j.cageo.2009.05.012.
Zadhesh, J., Jalali, S.E., Ramezanzadeh, A., 2013. Estimation of Joint Trace Length Probability Distribution Function in Igneous, Sedimentary, and Metamorphic Rocks. Arabian Journal of Geosciences, DOI 10.1007/s12517-013-0861-1.
Zhang, L., Einstein, H.H., 2000. Estimating the Intensity of Rock Discontinuities. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Science, 37(5), 819-837. DOI:10.1016/S1365-1609(00)00022-8.