· - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.-...

32
- - - _ c. ~ - - . , : :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = = .- * . ^=a'"=L [,_ g-- ~ <- a-}:1~T ..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:- ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" - -- > = = . _ .:.-;...-.=..=_= . , . .;,,;: 2 -- r .=:- 98 Myrtle Street y.=y - . = == m = ;;;n r c == -- *82 v,ij'18 , Boston, MA 02114 '- == =mr= M*- ,= . . . . . . . . . . January 13, 1982 " c,.0C, _ 3 . . _ . . .,_ . ""..~_....'f.f"_...- pi -. , u u. ;g _ .g .cm;mmm; ;._. _ _ f --- _ .._ .== n .:._ ..,....:..._-.-..- Secretary of the Commission { " - " ' - '., [- gd . f3') . _ _ " - ~ "~ Nuclear Regulatory Commission , - '" u *.m=w :-""J~ ' ~ ~ ~' :---- " " " . - Washington, DC 20555 " ~ ~ . . . . . . . . - PE: Docket No. 50-537---exemption request under 10 CFR 50.12) ;;;[ XI -= 5 . . ,,,,, :.:c |:=- . . Dear Secretary, *% W~" =s- . .e = :c"'". - . . . . . - . . . ,. I am writing to protest your proposal to exempt the _ . . . . . . . , . Clinch River Breeder reactor f rom certain licensing proce- ;..y;|" '.. .sN[.. du're s , I wrote to President Reagan and tne Dept. of Energy =;;;g;;;_... g-.-- :+- :== stating my opposition to the Clinch River Breeder reactor : == .x m. _ t:nen it was clear that funding for the project would be e==- app roved. At that time, I was assured that "we share your " - " " * = = = " " = " deep concern about the safety of alI nuclear reactors and . . . . . nave many large programs in place to assure that reactor . . operations in this country can proceed with acceptable , m . . . . . risk to the public" and that "we are not relaxing these = --- standards in the case of the CRBRP project". By attempting to bypass standard regulations now, you make me wonder further '' about your sincerity in ensuring public safety. , "-" . . _ . . Congressional approval for the project was not over- " n=, wnelming by any troans (amendments to cut CRBR funding lost ar r -m- by only 2 Senate a.d 20 House votes), in addition, it is =+ = == "== a project that has been billed as 'long-term' and I f ail '- --- to see' the need for speeding up ground clearing at this E [* 'iE- ~ - ~ ~ ~ - ~ point. _. ^^"?|.;:._ ''~~".m.. .. . I urge you NOT to exempt the CRBR from ANY NRC 1icensing rusn= .r . . _ . . . . . p roce du res . s - Sincerely, " g" p - ~" . . . . - . . . ... . ::. .. :." ' ' ' " '' ':".**? *' gC6 June Robinson ? ? "" ~ "' ""~ ~ .-- :-- g'h g,,Y =g Ok = = = = ~ . . .....--..:.... DSU |5.yc.r: = . G- $ -|,f 5 ; ' ..= g 5 -= , , , . . . . .... ...m.. Q . ==== .. c: ===.. /n ~7; ..:.;: . = = = - - q/ 3.) \' " "' ..; ;. _, . m .=.m.. m=====5_| | . . ""' . . . $ ::1:: . . . . . - . . . - - . . 7.i= ~ ""7 ' " - " ...::: . . . . .:::=---- - :.2. "-"~. 1. A;?..... ... $. .. .. ..._A. A m 2.' .'..M L..;E ~"""== = 53^[ T ~~"~" W ~ --"1?? " 5:* ... _7====:===_. ;3. . _-- _ - . . . . - ._ = . . - . . . . = =-.= = - - - -" ;;; u- 8201290178 820118 . . . . . . . . :== =: === == . r.- . . . . .,3E:7 . . . . . .. . PDR ADOCK 03000337 ~ ~~ ~""""""=== _=======.=v= ..;;t. " . = = q; " - _ . , _ . 5 55'5 _ -- + .====v .5S "- - i17... .;:. " .. :s "" """ %~'~ ~ ~ " " - - . ,

Transcript of  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.-...

Page 1:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

- -- _ c.

~

- -.

,

: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.-

*. ^=a'"=L [,_ g-- ~ <- a-}:1~T..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:- ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= ="

- --> = = . _ .:.-;...-.=..=_=

.,

. .;,,;: 2 -- r .=:-

98 Myrtle Street y.=y - . = == m = ;;;n r c == --*82 v,ij'18 , Boston, MA 02114 '-

== =mr= M*-,=

. . . . . . . . . .

January 13, 1982 "

c,.0C, _ 3 . . _ . . .,_ . ""..~_....'f.f"_...-pi -. ,u u. ;g _

_.g .cm;mmm; ;._. __

f --- _ .._ .==

n .:._ ..,....:..._-.-..-

Secretary of the Commission{ " - " ' - '., [- gd . f3') . _ _ " - ~ "~Nuclear Regulatory Commission ,

- '" u *.m=w :-""J~' ~ ~ ~' :----" " " .

-

Washington, DC 20555 " ~ ~.

. . . . . . . . -

PE: Docket No. 50-537---exemption request under 10 CFR 50.12) ;;;[ XI -= 5. . ,,,,, :.:c |:=-. .

Dear Secretary, *% W~"=s- . .e = :c"'". - . . . . . - . . .,.

I am writing to protest your proposal to exempt the_ . . . . . .

. , .Clinch River Breeder reactor f rom certain licensing proce- ;..y;|" '...sN[..

du're s , I wrote to President Reagan and tne Dept. of Energy=;;;g;;;_...

g-.-- :+- :==stating my opposition to the Clinch River Breeder reactor : == .xm. _

t:nen it was clear that funding for the project would be e==-

app roved. At that time, I was assured that "we share your " - " " * = = = " " = "

deep concern about the safety of alI nuclear reactors and. . . . .

nave many large programs in place to assure that reactor . .

operations in this country can proceed with acceptable, m . . . . .

risk to the public" and that "we are not relaxing these = ---

standards in the case of the CRBRP project". By attemptingto bypass standard regulations now, you make me wonder further ''

about your sincerity in ensuring public safety. ,

"-"

. . _ . .

Congressional approval for the project was not over- "n=,

wnelming by any troans (amendments to cut CRBR funding lost ar r -m-

by only 2 Senate a.d 20 House votes), in addition, it is =+ = == "==a project that has been billed as 'long-term' and I f ail '- ---

to see' the need for speeding up ground clearing at this.

E [* 'iE- ~ - ~ ~ ~ - ~

point. _. ^^"?|.;:._ ''~~".m....

.

I urge you NOT to exempt the CRBR from ANY NRC 1icensing rusn= .r . . _ . . . . .

p roce du res . s

-

Sincerely, " g"p -

~". . . .

-

. . . ... . ::. .. :." ' ' ' " '' ':".**?' *'

gC6 June Robinson ? ? "" ~ "' ""~ ~ .-- :--

g'h g,,Y =gOk = = = = ~ . . .....--..:....

DSU |5.yc.r: =

.

G- $-|,f 5; '

..=

g 5 -=

, , , . . . . .... ...m..

Q.

==== .. c: ===../n ~7; ..:.;: . = = = - -

q/ 3.) \'" "'

..; ;. _, .m .=.m..

m=====5_| |. .

""'

. . .

$ ::1::. . . . . - . . . - - . . 7.i= ~ ""7 ' " - "

...:::. . . . .:::=---- - :.2."-"~.

1. A;?..... ... $. .. .. ..._A. A m 2.'.'..M L..;E ~"""== = 53^[ T ~~"~" W ~ --"1?? " 5:* ...

_7====:===_. ;3. . _-- _ - . . . . -._=. . - . . . . = =-.= = - - -

-" ;;; u- 8201290178 820118 . . . . . . . . :== =: ===== . r.- . . . . .,3E:7. . . . . ...

PDR ADOCK 03000337 ~ ~~ ~""""""=== _=======.=v= ..;;t." . = =q; " - _ . , _ .

5 55'5_

-- + .====v.5S "- - i17... .;:. " .. :s "" """ %~'~ ~ ~" " - -

. ,

Page 2:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

+ s. . . _ ..

.- .

. . . . . . . . ' Of %REcEWED Q3

.=~e...2.~,.s..w.55?(2)

_ x JAN271993gi~~

b g.

. . . . - - =. . . . ._ _ .

5 s.::5?!-s,

.

3 .%.. .:] ~. _ . . _ . _c. .

n ::. . .

r. . . ..u.s. :.. ..s

* *,t ( - '. 55N".5.'...

,

. _ . . . . . . . . _ . _ _ . . . _ , . _ . , , , . . .. h. . . . k] k -t<.A' . .. Tc . .lu - fQ If0 G w,k. =.;;~=

. . . . . . . . . . . . .

w.6.r.:

; .z-_=== .

L * '' ' .; .' i i F ' ' * . . . . . . . . . .

''. . .. . . . . : . r.A* '~s.

b. D ._.. M 6 :.[M (fC.JL, . ._ b /7t/ cZ :- :8.". -*

,f y. i .. a . .;. ==:.,***": a.=' 4

// S . d T.-Nk ._ / M._ A _. ML., .

9 .. b. h = :.,xx:.--

=j d&kM 4, A c _dcw>w fuccccdyogv. _ _ T]"'

.

h5 .;...| .. . ..& NLOY Y. ] ' .5= W-. - da'& % . _ ,,.;;;.- .J

.v .. h / _- h.5

3.j,i|. {TT:I,.- -. . , -M

f..,*

e ; .. . .;; _ .

..f ..' ),W-.- ,LA__st,,/y,. gyn -. gft, d L W ,A ._ /., A % K t = W = -

. .

,:a:::...r.muma

' : - .. .- k .6 Md@,.aO_ v . . M _ bG47./4.'J. ,'

.:.-.......j ~~

_JC. g'd~;f,.? 2db& __ ..

jm:n a:w::.s

- . ~[ 44).-_ DD. . . 67.8 . 4.. . ' c'="

;;i r : ri;'

,jj ^~

" ~ - * '. . . . . . . . . . . - .''"',.[. .,h _ L h . ,,g.L , ._6 .. . I6' a '

~~"""""".",] }:. :.::a.:.(,, , ,s

1,,{ 0 0 Y..,|A0 ) ~ & <,,..% Q-. f. $U - -W(,))''\,,. . /

b .I@a - ANM - . 'I.'I. ..,

- /-- # f:-" :: .

h f & L ,ha $ ;3fhfi -,ck '<f' 42nal - . . f}| '' t==. :.. .*-. . . . : u.u,: f -,hb A Wu ,h $'fa h.,,/ -. fhb . . , ,

7. .,

~--.;-._.__... . . _L;-.-

.. . .f , ,

bf h ? N h,. t ,1 V M (/ 5 I .[,.G 7 %.-.. -- },[1~.~~"U-N:. . . : . V.ld

,,t. . ,,:.:=:== , y

- .|W/ b - - - .|"$... "

. ** .. . 4/[- .Yw '$ & Y Y- - _ .-a

% :=2:

.. . I .W....... ,/-*

&&.. .. & A.*$. . -

.,, bD vd,,O L & '

C - I.O . h ' _. dd .

'

.bhjM(''Q . 8 . - , ,"-

fq: . y

D '

- | . ./,s A ---..h $ --- .**

*-;;; ;q

f ; . . . .. . ==NAf*-'

. & /, .. bI i, (,,,a .< C ... U *s''

|a ==

7.~E._,. ijf"""

M'.. ... :..".M. .d - a. . . . . . - . _ . . . - . .

. '2

,.) - , wi=i= 2-

' % Wa(,$.,/?.A/ -. - - .- --.

, . ; :- z"== . . - . - , . - - - . - . . -

' ::"=.[f:-E5|$5

_.5 5h _ .. _... . . .. . _ _ . l.2 . I . . .k/ f., f.,< h dt2 M< -{ b5e4/ q. . . =

c., ""*t, , j5=

~. .- . 0 k) A 0 . . ~. $. . - . - -

-

_

, " _ _ _~ ~ - . Eb W' ~ ' ' ' * - ~

- ~ - -- | ::?E-? ~,

. . . . - . . . . . . . . . . " . .-

,

^

. . . _ . . . . . . s...m.a.u - . ..a . .Is._:".i.a

Page 3:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

* 4, ,

.

n== unr""r".7.3:~^U *'9". : *.17~; - uv s ~~"

*=h=/N'3.'i.' :";;;"**" . :. _; w .:

=4 .==..==: :. .: ;...= ::.-=' " -

:..w3;;:. . . . .

.=a"':. . 2^~' .k": ' .: . l".u~C." "= ~ ~ ~-" :~""~ . . . : m=:""'

.

.

5.2.55.:" C u- "*M".F --- nm : ...-.9 .z.u. " .':., ,=== : . ... ;;_.:-._. , . _ . . . .. 3..;

.. ,q. ..

y.f.g.2,W.

.

v . . . . . . . .

. - ~ ~ .::....... . . . . . . . . .. . .g .ngy . . ..g.,g._.

-ic--" 7~""" "

,,, .. _ ,.; n nmq,g; -.:_.. . _ .

- ..nvr....

..

__ . .. , , - . .,

. . .

.m,..... . . . . . . . . . m.,m . ... . . . . . . . . .. .m... . . . . . . . . . . . . ,

- - - .

. _ , , , ,

. . . - -=.=:: .

- - - - - - . - . . . . . . _ . . ,7?.- v.n.x-r.. .:: -- '_~~,p.,2. . . . , _ . , , , , , , , , _' "w- " .e

- -. . . , , .

' w... >,,;~~~ -2 . - ~ +! % 3Xi-T:::.-

,, -. . . . . :.*: . .. ... m:== ,.

- =,6 l,,! } n% D ,. ,, ]. ,| - .

- y; _,_ .. .. -,.cy.;; ;.a.: .s ...a.5.. 4.u.a.s -

L . ,,. fm. = = . = . . . . . . . . . . .

.

+ ,

..r. a na a . c m.a -4y , ,,

. . . . . . . . . . . , , = . . . . . . , -.' * .. . . (-' * .r. . ..o.... ,.

r % .,D''e===:=a.:r AMY PR ES ENT. M.A. ,L,,,, - N"

-r ,. , t%, s.n. , ,, .e s 346 wlN CH ESTER STR EET F.a-3, -~ ~ . -

'--"*r.--

>

.....p . ..

~

N EWTO N, M A3 3 A C H U S ETT5 0 216 9 L*'r ."- '

. . . . . . . . . " . - -. ~, . '

"

x- . ~c,".

a. :.m.. - - :ua _..n a .n . .

. n. i? 527 4945 g . , , , ,

a a....a .

m 6%.

,7,.g,s . r -- .? n=-g ~-) % ~w

v = ~;g -- ..

= ~ . .. . . " . . . . - Vi. .. . .-._., ;, , .-

.

&. - .-' ~..*y2,,.

. . -

=' === < . .Q- *+.

.. . . T 24.sid.). . .

1 . . C m .' g .. < . , -

RECEIVED1. = .=ma i n ^' sA=d /% d RA /d gfe @| (fm.D 6 v ._ & & YQW g, 3-,.

u |gsr., . .~~ -- - ;

' " " . . . . . . -~".:.:. * ::|n=

% k (, C5 { 6,.f'(QQpy,, /m g,y ggg y, g y. , j, 'qfmj

_uu===wu.: =w =a$Q8 i 38.*M(if M r =.d. *-% .W2* %J

. . _ . .-

/ &.."...g.~7.. ' .) g . f-g*mk - jh. .- .- , ' w , y . cg

M ~8

1%~.,

' * * * ' ' " * * . . . . . ' * ' f Q'.

* %&..

_W,, '', 'AC a. .u;.m""" :.;;;u16.i2'' f' ''

f * :..' .* I:::~. 3 # %/ -...t..... -

- M te 'y - cp y"* ,. _ _ "s

p.a_.w. - ::==== ~

., #4 .,,4 J M p r.

. . .. ... ..D W m ..; g:.s tv.w g ,

..-

. _ . . .. m

| %*

e a.f" . *:: *. ;~ ~? f,f g . *w.j%

,L- , a

e .- .

. . - . = . . . = ".~:.".. f

-

g. ..

.] q/ g..

d , ( ,'- e

,

...

,, _

- - = , , -. . , - . . ~ . . , . - - * . . . ., 7 ,

,

--e. .

.}*

4,

,

* '

, * * * " * * - '

. . . . . . . . .

.................::1 j p ,,- . ,i

,- y[ ,v.

w. . _ , , , . . . .,.

. . . . . . . . . .

q,)D -P*

:

\. . . , .,

. . - . . . . . . . . . .. p

&. ~ L* '? - ~ *gs~,NZ.,b > "V ! . .;-

' a <,.,f M e. | .| * *-

f; . -. .s :==- . ~ &:==... -sQQ" e ,bQ: ey,, :=-_ ....a:. : t-- --,- c : --- --

..-.... .: . . L h.., %.e%..= =. ; .2 ; n= =

. m-- 2(L"p, J . ,!to: q . :[.% .r =_ _ " c...--

E=~=~'~ -

=h ~-~ m a.s ( ig%, Iu -s. ,

..

+M.,; %v w- m

..- - -

.- ': -;3 I . . . .a,

-

. , ,,,_x j /k K g-,n,,

~'~~~=-s~ w..- -:: ... . _.r ;a ,m .

f)A,a* ~':. .

y d(,M < q,.,.,,Q UQ m 'M .,

T'?~?j'. &-~ ~~ - ~ :--~/ e*

. ..- . . ' ,. . . , . .. . . . . ; ~ . . .~' - . , .. g

. . .

m , | ,,

),., W j 'G l je * ~ ~-.

- - - - . . . . . . ,

L

&.- .~:7:.;$f.. .$5|i':|$ .} j 3. . . . .. . _ . . ,- gy

' * ~ ' '.. :'; .'_** . J .; _r, [_ j.a .g'

%.. " '-

.. ' m....... .:::::: ::.:::.I....: s 4 s .--

-, . - - . 7::::: . . . . . . . . . . . . ,

. - . . . g. y

.

$ v b-s-'j ' <- w ri |

e b e~' ~ $ '',y f Y -' *|

3 ,. . . . . . . :: ;:. u. ;.

: =" ::. :=:_ .;-. . - . _ . _.n_

""" **'":."."".""$

..j r- , . . . . .

. . . , . . .-

.==:=:: m =su ..

'*;*"...;.4 . , . *:.'... ....... ' ' ' ' ' ~ '' ' ' ' ': 4 *.:::. . . ' ' ' . . . . . . ..* * " * . ,. . . . . - . -. . . . .- a : ,- -. . . .2: .. :..w. : e.. . . ..:.------ ,

- as +- -

. - . . . ~ . . . ..!..... ..-.. ' ''.

****

:.. a :2.a ''.'24.

-- =nn -

.... .

: r:t = n: . -- . . . - - . . ~ . . ..y;3.,;.. p ,,_ ,.

''4_:

. " ' ' " " ' ' '' :.*."d* 1~ . . . .- . . . ...........u*"*.U

. ~ . ..a.*." *-

~u-.a....-- - .. .L,. .' . . .": 4;;

2 .*:.=.. :.'.* U.::

- -- - . . -

?**:.I; a * *? *- '..a.u:: :.a - *..

,..__'::...-.."."."'*.|"'":. .. :fU:U,.,., . . . ~ . . . . . . .

. _ .,. . , . . . . . " " * " . . . . " . " . . " .' P*:*! {*n* - _;... ...,y. .--,

. . . . . . , . , .

= . . .

. - . . ??..:*.=*=. ..' r -~~~~-- .i r . "- r v -. * - '-. . = .

.....~...2. . . _. . ,.

,, . ." ;;.,... ..7.. u; ~ ==.: :.:.r.:

... . . . . _ . ...

~~n::=.

- - . . . . . . .,.

~-

m:z:~~r-+=.. ::.... = = ~n ". ;;. . . " _ . . .

' . =:== .:..o.. . . . . . . . .==.

...--:-.:

c. --.:. . . . : . u.a.. . . _ ....w... :-....... .a.. "-w. aza.:. . . - . - . . . . . - . .. . _ _. .- . . - _;;. ;

. . . . . . . - :;. . .' ' " ' '

-. :u.. .:. :. .. :;. .. .;;

==:.:.~r.;; =: wan=:nz.u=n"ruuz_

;.;;,..;. . . . .:=.:..... .,j , ,,_,

. . . . . . .y;. ' ..;a au-:. ... . - . ''_ ;, ~ .;;; _ [-~'. . . . '~ - . . . ^ .a ;. ;; _ -- --- _

"

. ; - ,, : .- .. " ._ --N N b-._.

.

'^~ ~ ~ ~ " " *

$N" ...^.$:M;: =n:==r nrn =.:.=.-~.-

"-" :ns:r =-== S:A-re ==::.N.. ::..u. " -" .. ': -

..

.e - "..-';.- -

f'..a.... rm:.

:r v.":: >re:: . . . . . . . . . - . . .. .=:::=::.-":..

;_

l - _-(~ . - -

"" n .:En.:.;.=u., ".- - --" "---" r... g. 7 _,r.

"i . . .w. , ,

-.t1 ..

:r.=: :. =:n :~. :::==:=:-:.v.=:" '" .. =;=Q .m;.- u_ .=:: . . :. -- ,--7_

.

Page 4:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

. -o..

.

.:::- . .. ::- :... . :. uah. =:- :.: a :.T. :. .. . <:: .: :.. :- ::==.. - . . . ..u. :

. . " . " . . ' . .;..:.[~. |?.}. - . . ?.:.'... . ..._.::.--....=...._ ..........._...3.. .:.=.=.:

. . . . . . . . . . .a, . .. ... '-*::::::.:L- - . . . - - . .....:........

. :- : . . . .

. . . ~ . .. . . . . . .

* *:*-*: .u.*^ ? ::::::. :;;::- -

.:: T:: ':.T *:. n= 7.

. . .

- - -

u:9 " V -'" : n: .;".2: .:T7

": :.r:: c 'a***-*. . ' . . " . . ' . ' * * " '.'.-..'-'.: .. ..'..'r . . . . . . . ..

. . . . A.'C. . _.

- - - - -- . . . " " . . . '.. R L''.4".1 - -

'CL. '-:" * * 'a : . P -'" :- ~~ - ::. J: ? S'r ..~r.':

- . - ....-.::";:' :: "M:":::rJ.T! ::"J .; ::4:.:P.""-t ""*-"*: ...4. .. .

u.-

-

2,**. . - - - - . . . - . . . - . ""..".~:.2*'- . '.. .- .a. . . . ....-r- - . . . . . . . . 'M: '" *::-uM.: ::*.L ..*:."*:2.7.*:6. : *:."::.'""**C'4..,........: . . . - . . - :"*.: 3 r.~.*: '.

:: .. -.......=r::-m--.

.

.:.--- r ,:::r:a.:. =. = :.: :.:=.=:---- =.-- -

-: n.- -: =- == .=:... .

. . . ..:.-.. ::

W ,:- :n=-.:.. .. . . . - - ... ::.. .. . . . . . ne- :=- ==- . = = = - -="=....a.==..:r- -- -- r=:=r::.2- .r er . =.: ,::a_ . . . - - . . . . . . ..a..,...u.c.=- - . .n...u. w -- -

.-.

- -

. _ _ . _ - - - - - --:. _ . _ . . . . _ ..

. . . .. . . . .y. 7. ;

,.

. $ . '' /* d .,,|*^ '*''.:::: *:::::: u --.n . 3 !~ n ,q . si, [a s~ - (, y. ,, e ) g, a/- .v e M a *. {)

,

f (w-w .-. . ,.

. e :.:.. :: r.. .: - - .

.-:- g jo..

.; .m. ::-:::.s. .z.us= ..:.=:.am . . a.u.w.m.;a

.! .j. .nz:=: n: ~.:r. .*

.-.: w... s. a.v . =?::::a.=:::: % ,I j . ( |. , ~-- # .- - -..::...:::::?:nez a:.

- -

- [_,2 3,,, r.g.g r. -- e p. . _ _ _ . - - . , .t _

g ;. 1,.M *% / **

v . \ ,.,.A - /,,a- M / ; ,v-.,ru : :nr.n

, ,

..

.n .:: .; .. y; e s.,jj, , ............s. . , . . , . . ..-sa', j . ::12=| ::.; .v.=v. . ._ .,;:. ::::::.;. :...._ .. .. . . . .J , - y , ,. _ g! '.: ; "

* "' ' "'' " : 7.:.",,~.q.; . .- . - . e- .

.&| 1 g s t ? : :: - =:*-

Y YW. S '.,J bW '' ~ ' h * i. ._ . _ :.;: .: . . "' ~ ~d.O::#r - . . I '

. .:.= : = ;: u.=:wt

T. :.a . [._u5 - L- - . _ . _. ,

*. , ' ' ~' .[ y ~~~--- - ...n:-~~~----

, . . . _ _

---- -h..$:$::=ur - -- .- /* ,,. O y, p ,,< we '. % % 3' M %^ ) -' g , ., , * - " ~ ~n-be ], , | . r . IM. . g g s . . . - - . . . .- - - -

g .! \ ( ...:~::. . . . . . . . . ... ..........c...

.. .. . . . . . - - - . . . . _ . . :. :.::.c. . . . . . , .. . . ... . . . . . . . . .

, ;- _ . . _ - . - . . . . . ....- '

.

j ,V. :: ~-~-

' ';. . . . ::~": ., , ,

(~- g, \,. . *p. .. .. ::.:-

*/ s,

. . . . - ,,,,, . , *) p| /, -\"::~ : :: , , , , ,

b y * oy A. * %1 x ..a ...a..a.w.m

s..-...~--9 .. ...: -:-~r.

*> j ...

. .. w.aasute4, y.. :::::::.... :: . :a..u.::2:r::::: :--~ . . .

*,

!- * ,~/**,,) n........~.=-~. . =:.---

[f. ,',,,j,. h-~ 6.' V, -. . . , . . . . . . :.a , **n

': :n nnn=:r cr .. ..

. @. y m,,w-r:2:-- ..- s;; : . w -. . ..: ,a,-::.. :. .. ..w -

,9 =,. I- )e, 5 . . - . .

y.. :./:- ::.nnum: ... . n... -

. :::::::::.s--n . . ::: en,. .;; .

y;., -

. .

.--.m...'

, .y+f.,,,,, . * a, ,. . . , , ,

, s 4.: . .; .;..

. j' ,,,- _ ,V.;; .._.;,_,.u_;, _;,,

, w... .. . . . . ,H ..n-.' 9 u... ._.:----* . . r _y % :. 4. 75 /

-. . . ~ . . - ....r.......:...t-nu:-.- .

|. , , f ~a'''ig+

#

p* .s - T.- ~ ~ :::.~.:--*

' '4z;-:-.. .. . . ; ~. :: :::- ,".:.:= .s

,

T.'....... . . . o . ; -i. . . . . . . . . . . , ~

. . _ . , .' . .u ..: 2 u.; ::a ; w! * * I

" [f Qh b . _

, . ' -

. ::.J. s.; -

$' . W* 2".--.... .. :.--.......-..

.f,,g ,E

q4 |G y e K.e.;.s : 's.... :..: .~;w. ::: :.4 ,,1 | ,-

-;$ vZ 6- * ...

. . . . . , . .d

=~....c...:.-.----.-..- - - - **

[\t '\/

', y'\.,,,,.o ,

.<;-i

. .

Q] | / :

.

c - =:- :: :-- =: .*~ - . z. . . . . . . ..

-.. . - . . z :::.'.4., . . . . * l'1" . .. ...i.".-.. ..* -

. . - . . ..

-. .." . :.2 ? *. .I L ... . . . . . . . ~ . .. . . . ,

%y% a.5Y ''' ' W~.~d.* ~ 2*~. ~ ~A''"; ~ M

u~ . .m. .:.. . :4 -su--. -. . .. .*:.Ti".*A**,""_ :. 4':. %. . . . .

- :

n....'*."..';;..'**C."..'-^*.".:.",4 | jr -.w._ .. . . -** *: C I * J.

*

.. .:.. ge._ .. ~ . . _ . . . . _ . -

.. .... ...t =m., ,

. . .'.'.n. .;;.. } , y j j e-

.c....-_. .._. - .

, if / = . L....---....- _ . . .*...:....-

:--~:-~~.- . . . '"" N. . I'. ,// *- 4.: .ua

\.

Nh! P.7.:_.-.-c...-..-. . . . . . . . . . . , .

L . - - . _ , . . ,. . . . ... . : . :. s

I"^^'~~".-.--..-.--.;~~.~. -

;:--:=: .::. . . - .,J. . .. .u .: . u. 6 -

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. _ . . . . .. ."~~..;.~.~ _ - . ~ ~ -. . . .. . . , . . .. . .. .;

. . . . . . . . . . - . . . . . .:: ~: ~;:~ r . -- ~ .~. - *~. . ;:.-. . w. ; .. . . . . . . . . - . . . . .. .

.-a

f,7 . - ~ ~L : --,

.'*'"i^.,~ .,

34.4 - ~ . --- -

. . .

s.. .

, _,,

t*'~,.,.a_. .~ * ;;;., ,_ .,,.i''... , . _ . " " * * * ~ * * E-.'

1 ~ - - . . . . ~ . . .&

. - . . '-- . --.-........-.__.-J.'2 -

-- - ...

- - - : 7 -:= .: : .. -- --$- .

~"*~7*~.JM......-...-~ t'" .i . _ , .

|

* ::. .L .- ''-- y: , . , . _ . , , _

":^L v=3. ' _ . _ _ . __. - ~ . . . , , ,

*.'n.-,t- . . . .

:'

. :3 . *: ~%~ ~ :~.*d W'%- ~ * * ~ ,, .

. _ ' . ' . ' . . . . . " . . . . . ' . . . . . ' _ ~ ~ ~ . . . . . . . . ' ~ . , , .. . . . . . . _ _ _ _ .

|

. ..

~. " -- -

~': :"':: ~:L *; m ~ *. . . . . ..,

: ... . . . . . . . , . .

G.[ ~ . .: . . " + = = -| .:T.:" ^::'*:: *::** - '

:: , ..... . th. . -s- . - .

1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ._

{= = *~-o ~=--1- -. -

' - ~ ~ "'***r"'.".*.*.~".._T';'-""-

. ... -m- - -- . -.

(.. . . ': : ~ :.~. . - . .

. . .. " . . ,- - . _.

l,~

yea. :3

. . ...*

. . . . .-

_.C..7".'*'..*.*, _ .

.-_

_7,,_ _ _. . ...-.;,-,._ ... . . _ _ -- .| |'.C ' ':'.' ZL. . , . , . . . -.. , ._ _-.. ..^ ~ * ~ ~

. . _ .. . . _ . . , . .-

. . . . . . . . ' . . ^':.._

.. . . . . . . *:: -": . .,.-__;.'-'...L. ~~~~ - ~~^~T~, ~~"** *2''**:*~~'~;;; . . . ~ ' ' ' ' * :..:....._..:.~:-. *:.'* :. ' . . ' , . . . _.

:',~~~~.~ '

. - . - ..

. . . . ' . -* ,.

:~ '*:,,; J" -"

** *****'**~~L*";.' .. *~!7:**::

" * * * ' * ~ ~ *. . . . . . . . . ' ^ . ' . ' . . . . . _ . - _ . . . . . ..**''**' ~~ ~~*' ** * % **. ::::."*::' ': *::. .''"". ':*::L*"""':2. :. . . . .--:. '.;-." .s - ''....=::;.........,... . . .. . . .

.-- - - : - - . ;. - .. .L -. . : -.

u. ===-==:. .

...-.n,u**:~"'''~~:.', . , . . _..

"...:,.-..=r.,=.= ''

= - . .1 ::.-- =:::::= ~:: - - = = :=

. . . . . . .. .-.. - . . - - . . .,73 ,.; _ . :. .: . ;;. . .;;,.;,.y. - ;,, . .;;;g3,. -.; ,. . ".. -.;,. g.,'.-.~.. . . . . . .. _..;.... ... . . ; . _ , . _. . . . . . . ;._.-....

'

L a ;. .. . ' ' ^

,

'......L.-.. . . 4.. 4.....

. - - . ..**.

' -........;4

"t.J..:'"^.* ^ * " * * *. . ..- . _...._ ...L**.*..-.... - !1 a. I***"*";''...

" ' a. . ;; _

. .L;42'

.: *** - ~ ' * - * * * * ^ " " " ***"""~*,"*"*:J'"!...;;"^'~.%...:.";""*- .* * "*

**""' " M l!T ; "".;S* "*"* ' :--.. --': - ..*' ' ~ ~

.- - :~; ,;..,.,,..- :: - ~ '.. '

.;L '

.

. . . :: S . . ' ' * " ' "'OL*''***. ' :7'*.. * * ~ ~ *. . . 1*

-n.........;'J~.*2."e.^'~***"" ~".*::*'.."",2|'"*.*".T.':|.*.";:.'L'*::*L?~~~~*''~'"*''.'.~~.**:''-'.~'*~*"*''~^~~**.*.:d..;L,**..

, . . . , , - . ' . ' * " '-||.'i,e......L"*.**~L.LL'.'"*:^ ~' -- *;,,.;.. . . . _ . - . - . . . _ , . - . , -" *E'';.': ;.L

'E..??"L ::*. .*'* *:. L . :",. - . . ~ - - ;;;* ' ~ ~ ' " * -... ... ;;;;; :; - ;.* . . . , . ~ ' * . . . . . . . .

' ' ' * * " ' ' *" 6, "' ' :- ^ '

.

. - . . - - . , , . . '.:.-.,.t.. . .':,."."'.*

''?*C=~.,**. . . - . -- * : , . . . . . . . -

**C,~.**''''*"'"*'****~';**;;.L*^."... .*****"*"'""|. :..... . ***'..*:.*|***~~~.- -.

* * * * *

..,,

.

'' f*;|*: .,,

. . ~ ~ ' . . * * * ' " *

. _"***?:~*.:;;'.T,''***L'*~~T';;****.".""*::.~~'.'.****.**'.'.'.~..:.".-. 4:* * ' ' . . . . + - . ~ . .

-:.".'.-..~~"~*T*''""**' *

| *L "**""'.:,. -.. .. ._. . ;: ' ' ::::' ; :*:...... '.

d'

.- L.... ' ' * " .- ~ .* * * * ' ~ ~ '.' . - -. . . .

G':**.:'-.''~~*".*J: ' ~ ~ ~ '..',

. . ~ ~ ' 'X ~ . .:e* * *. :' ..n *.W. ..'',..;*"''''~~* ''** ^ * * * *

-..n ....,,;-.".:-.:L..;.:.,.. . . . ,

':. * * * ''~~~'iG".L"'' ' ~ ~. ~ ~ . ~ * * * * *,._d;L*:*'.".'^..'.".."7.J.****".''.*.**.**'?" '' ' . ~ " . . * . . ..- .

*' .* '

:.' . ' . ,,.;;,,, J :

. . ' . - . - - . . " ' ' . . . - J -. .

' ' ' . - . . ~ :'

2* .' . . ;;."*;. | ": ;'," * ;,, ,; * ': * ^

.I

:. L ;. . . . - * ."~~ " " . ' " * ~ " ' ' " ^ " ' * * " ~ ** ''~ '~| . - . . . . . -

.~--LL..4,.L......'..''.'.'"L.....'..-.'s"- .. 't..

1- J- - . ~-' .':-.. . *L : .,; .~ .

'

:- ~ ::.~ ~- - ~~ :~~ --. . - - . . . . . ' . ..a - = ::=- . : --c ~;;~ ''-" ..L : --": : ~: - ~ ~- .. .

. . . . -. .. . . . .

>

~

= = . = -| :- *:-~'*"*"|"'. :**'.". **

** ** * * " ' ' * " ' ' " " ~ " *.?'- : . . .: - - - - . - - . . - - . ..;.~..a .. . .. .e .-.Y.|***L2,|"::i*'.',,;',_;;.'".'*:*|.""%'*.*.''**.-..-. '5|**|*2.":**"***''" , , . . . - . - , . .

' ~ ~ ~ ~ "

'.'"*.*.*.".*.'*..~.****'"**:.:*''"~'.."~~.-" ' ' *-----a"*"--~ ' '

.

I -,,.;,.. ~ *

__*'"'''.E''_ -* " ' ~ ' "*A.- [ E * ""*''L*'.

' " ' ^

-. ..:-. . J:.a.4 ..|'"* 1,7 ..' :2 L., " ' " " ' * *

***^*:~ *^ . . , 'I;; . ^ ^1"2";L ' ****['.'**.-~ ~ * " " " " ~ ~ ' * ..'.',J''.. . . . . . . - .. .:'*

'' '' . - .J n"""j..

..

'L- - - - - - --.

* *^^^*'": T " L."*.n.

. .. -. -.,_

*::,,,,,:','.:?.**""",*~:"*"*.~..'"' '.':.:~^**".~'_*.*"_.. - .

"~~~'""''""..".~.2^:L'|:.^:".*"**.J*'*=:*;:::.;.**.... ~ * ~ ^ .E ** L::,, '.*6L', " . ;. ., ||~ ' ""* ~** *;,*'_^ * * '* ?| * L a"*.Y . . ' iL ''., , _,. ,

u.,_,, ,

.

Page 5:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

*I

#

/g'

-,...

.;.. - c . ..s. .s o rg)_

. s.a..

-- -. . ,qqq

d'T .

tuasky% % d,ao555-

hptkd 1[r 60- S 3 7 : N*f$ ;, _FK 50./ ,g: ,

Jgl4N b,gggggi ;

._

6

& f ,) cf'

-

~

gaf & un c. k wn"hcvh sv4p 4 & Ds f .hhcm

2 fa %cA W &.Y |,ee,et+ ph

. . A ' n %.h&~wnd_wJan:w,,.

-> CI C ? ? i ;'.' ..' '

*

_vgj Y;M5|Ci! :$--

,

[(,f@# LONJ < xce.wr. :sdM 2h

M d"'<, A M_& '''h% .pAuiA c g[c K ~ n . w p ?

..4= eS ce. Lk fs,JPE p# h a f & & m c / reb;~| K _; ^D fMt .

. . . _ _ _ . . . _ . . _ . _ _ . . . -- 'DSo3

5

//o

-

_.

Page 6:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

e

'' _g -.., .-

h b Y $ , / D f f k & & y ; C'% g~

WS .

6.bn /d- Qr>v0CsY a

/ A ,

~>% m %p ;g.-

A cl4~< A pu2 & c % d u<c4 Aw m v w + u u l s h A f v o ct w M

ge &en I w c k p<r n ,unc L R ;7

ca~ tLadr a s. WpnO af > R k ?

ffa. G ao~~&& ''k; wpm asoA & pu c8nt Mw

Anu,,e-e p' j . y

f G> y s h a k us & %&&%% ad p% fnA m n &ae &

ce eg40 r .+m_~J Wm&cl wr+1

s.aw dscism L/m&he e D1 WfM f' cas&

CL 96p a % &+ * a-

ArsuckW<a'u o 45sAbM ra

AA}Pa AL'

;

'

esdr u m a~raDwkwrm &

3=230/,

,

-. ~--

Page 7:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

n % . ._ . --- ,

L. ..

* ~, -th. _ . . 4 * dN *e D - ~~E'*' W H** -

**

gg.53g(g}~'

==...s.aea,

[. :-' .. ^

M M. ANO M R a. ''" A *5 M YW'O RIM EN ::"I"

....b....... J AM AICA 0 343 C9 J c5769 e- e#-

..VE MCNT 0.( '., um | L) , iq Q , <"<<|.;;;.'.-2.g{

c,d '- % ' =:::: :. =.- ::! :::~:::-i s

.-. . : t ?--

b // h ... 2.sa.e

.

. . . _ _ bMh *

3 1 y~w- .s . .i ,, ,

WM w b.c. 9.055- , ; ="-WnECEggo

<

...n mi j % .i. 3. . . .

* ? f." ..N-. y' y. , w wpg |

w\ 9 ,,p 4 p .

1-

..

cc... c,.- q)Ye s s a (=.

-

s. r.. :=:..

:u. . ns

^[ ][~

""'''[-,,,,_.[',, ' JCW M d* d *

.,-.3.,~,.33 3., y . h k . . -

k.yf Y( S4 &~b:^ Y:

m:;,m aau.:, % . -n..- . . . . . . . . . . .

' '. C-==' is W k\' 4.WlA W, 144 , w ,

.h. . . .1 ,,

t g * Mtg 'h w M,4 L i ,",

- ~&a..:..:a:.: nuwa q .: :*

. - ,. "i.:mL=.?RD;5Et 4 ?,'

u d, h,.u h k' atL(, c & n . ku tw Y ~'

'

u ct-

..:._

Q h ea 4 uh act u %%J ucaevt. .f;i.;..1 w:.w.,i

-s ; ; . .= w.:. ..u=

(0L.d b[,1

'

. . . .

*% dagf 6,,tl ,%sgy y C.k WTis(w (C7 Awt, , , , ,,;,7..; .

< " n:" V- Os w

.. .$ ( ~ = ~ -e.-y..-.;

W N%W.:.,

. J A W % ' " ~ ' ' ' """

. : .u.: u.a..a .. .... . . :a. :.;:.

-- t.~ ,tc y an,, s - _

=-

-

.- , _

.

U$5 NNE.".'. !' V % :. M ( (, W,. NM . ( (i , m ,/v

O.e * N *N 4.s r- --*

. .-

h.

.,.....a, y g ... . . . . . . . . , , .: ::.

..,.7.,....{-- O. i MI4 LC'd % d . ds .i [.1 Mg.,, [ I.! :;.,. ... . . . .L w v. ,. p.

% 4 dW 0%,' (b % t" g %'N OC L m.. . . . . -... 7 .

. . .- r d 6 | ----. - . .

iEh.n .. .a' :=..... = . . . - ..

,7 ,

!! =. . h d4 Q , . .g g 'q g

'a ~. j i. g e - - ==. m==n:mg p 7 %.wpwus;e .. .;=

>

~=z=.x +;- yk - ===-== .

>==aoM=.%}s.t

=== , .

*N u wf. E N RC C- mt c c.pd ts.: D{ ___

=.

. , .=1 . . . . . . = = _ ,

4t,, ,

W, *, m c4,, _ ,

'= =

m._ . . _ =* '::"M . %.

#g h *i'''*I'f...., ..;...m,

. . . . . . (4d (' \ ( 4.(*s\\%1 Y'N D. "..; .=:: a ,

: . r.. . .

a.r.su..',_ _ , , , _ _ . + -

. ::j v-

.m. . . . .-

, , , , .d.r.e'

. _, _ ,g..=

_,::= .:= :=. .=. . . . . ...:.-..:..-.=.==.:.. == = - = = == ..=- ..

. , , , . .- - - - - - - - . _-- -

Page 8:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

>; A, . .

. . ,

...

:= a.- = wd,.=-. - - . -=.......=;:-..=. m. ..;;. . ..

. "',

. . . . ., . . - .

-. . . . .Q-~ '~:;i!"# "~ - :p".;' :f.d. ""1;. . * ..

::-- -, _ . .

. . . . .. _ _ . -

#' n*...?......,.. . . . ~ . ~ .,

* . . . . . .y r; . - . ,

. . . ..

----

. . . . _ ~ . .. . ..e-=***f, . - -, , , . ,

2- - - - - ~ . - =... ane .. .- .n. r. r .. =...;

. , . _ ,, ,.

.. .u. ra. .nr. . - - . . _~- ja....... .m

.

.,,,,m, u..".".n.*: "r**"a?".J :. 4. ... . . .. ,. .

. _ . . .* |V, =.c .n .; : xws: v ==.= - -

. . _

S *'s r= % .:"~~:== *

* O , ,[,, .7 / GV=''*

...;; '' :*:"==. .:: ---, =: .. . . .- ' ' ' .,. . . .-

, . . . ,,.n

c. . . . u . . c.~, . . . . e: e tw. *>). . . * . . - E..___......_.EE2+;"=?= =E32.;:2. . . _ . . . . . .

er O *

J '.~'' "' . ~y-*'*

. . y. :: :=:g ,_,..

{L .,. ,,; ; f" GG1m::.:v

~*

W . . . . . . ." " " . . . . " . " . . . . . . . .- -~~. . ." ,n, . o -s9.,i 310 17th 3t. N- U2qd .- .%. _.m d, |g g g

. '

. . . " . . . . . . .. ~ . . .' . ' . _ . . ' . . ...

January 14' p 77590.

Ims. :; ==- ~~ $"

*exas ",ioy_.....1Idi +

,3.". . .. m"a-. - :.. . -. . . . . . = .

, .g....-. . . . , , .,

p. .... , . . .- {, o

, ;'t~. ., , . n. (", , .~ r y;.-- 2 9' ECEWED C ?= === = ".=a=:===4

- = x+e ..

aecretary of the Commission - J A N ET W.7. ..... . .. . . =w:=...=.....---"'=

c, .. ;...,

- - - = -

. . : -

._

.

us.MC'G N""% d =D.d- _ Nuclear Regulatory Commission

MP ~~ i ~~~~dashington, DC 20555 <.,,( . --

' .- .==w=. tr... .-.x==%- . = . =w -

.r., . .a

?.I _ 4.. Dear Secretary: /, T =' ;ss.;-

- - . . .. y- - - . -O) . .v.=v -

.g ~.. 7 6.

"-~M"5 Mt As a concerned citizen, 1 "$ ""

.._2. .rm:J. writing to oppose the exemptiou Of . . . . . . . . _ . .-~

' " - "

the Clinch River Breeder Reactor from-

a . . _ . . . . . , .

. ;m;g certain NRC licensing proceduren.. . . . . ' " . ~m~~~ ~~..

#'. ...m

* m.a. If the CR3R project was denigned_

.

WP9 to demonstrate the licensibility of =.,v

- ~. .- breeder reactors, it seems absur 1 to =n- aexempt it and defeat the purpoor- v i=== ="- =~= =.s- - - -

O? . Q There is no emergency situationC' '_S,

="

.% ._ -here which warrants this specia1

.:c ' . ,, exemption. . Since Congress is almost',._..

.'fC M. evenly split on this issue, it veeCS r- . . . . . . 2:

_ *~~ ~ ~ 7A M unwise for the NRC to a decision for . . . .==.

. .

1:. . ., a exemption. ..e --

Gir. ~~ W Please' vote "no" on the CR W fl ='= = ' =

1, T_.1d.

fast track exemption (Docket No. 50-537 -- ?m-

5 ~ .. ' exemption request under 10 CFR W.12. ) :v=.-.."-" .

1-:-. .. ) __

..-:.es

. .

g-

E. . ., Sincerely,. - . . :.- . .~ ~ ~a_. . .

..

; = ._ ...

.,-

.g .. _ .; .

_ . . . . . _. ,,. ,

.. . . . . . ..-. .

. , . . , . .. .. ..

*

+ . . . . - . , ..

-

,.

Trancine KelleyrE.m. .....;#.s.6: e'

a-

. ~ ^...e.+ ' w, + . , . .

- q.=.- . . - . -

'n: .*a, .. . ... ::':: ... $ " *;::. ~~=:~=

. ;;;:- = .,",_ ~ ~Q ,A - - *.- 4.

.

;

%.*S.

. . . 4 . ..

't.*,

r.. . . . . . . . . . ..

- .J . . . . . . . . . . -

t. :. .,. . . . - . .

' .?. s . + t . . . . . ~ .....; . . . . . . . .

- . . . =

s.. -

. . . . . . . . . . ...

-|

+ * .

...- . :.u::::a "

,-*.4... +?..+* . . . . . . . . . . . .. - . . .

;g,,,,,,_ . .

. . . _ . . . .

.H y - " " " -f..- . . . ..

r .v.g

=::q : nu.-~'~r. . . . . . ,. y'*s- *n :~: u

f. :. . .. ;. : ::::::.;;. ,.:....*t==

. e .* m p- -. ..._ ...:.::- .~ .,. ,. .: n ..

g 3. . . . . .- _;-

.I'J*P*''.--""*"~'"'c"-- ....:.. ...**; , -- ,_ _

. . . . ._ . __ .; . . su ::y~ v : r=_

u~~:, m.,,..

. ~ ..:q , . - 1 a .y

.

. . . . . , . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . _ . -

..- .

;,. . .

._. . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . _ . . - . _ . _ . . . . . . . . . .

. _ _ . . _ . . _ . - - . . , - = ,- =, - -

..=,

..

* , ,' . . . _ . . - .e, z. ., a. e _ - . - . . , _.. .=_.,.,..;, _ . . . : .y : - - - ~ ~

. . . . . - . . . . . . .m. .1._.; ..

me.aw .3. - - - . a .., a a,._

_,4 , ::~ v. .* * -': ; *:~ r *'' ~ - .': ** *~y -

. a.; ::: 7-~~ . : ~~; ::.? *;=*:~:',

-.c .. .{ ,

,.y .

::. :.=.,:=c "- - ~~ ~ ::=.;:.*

M -+ ..2-...._.f._ L W ..y - _Z. - - Mi .~4 . J-~ ~~.*~:$.s._'"."sua:-/".".~"'t.._~:. ' ..._ .. . . . . . . . . , . . _..

., _ . . . . ., _ . . _ . , . ,

:"~ --y -.

.

_

!3. - . .*g*. . .* * ' * ._

. [ ~ * ,** f. -.. .- ...,.: ; _.t . ..m.

* wyy.. .m. ,m _ . . . , _ , , . _ ..

.

'7eg an... s w. . a. e- . + . . = > ... . . . , , , . ..,.;.,.; .;,.,;...,.y

.. -. -

~, t j; W' * '* ^

. |- ., .a . . ,

At e. . ... . . . .. .., -. .- , -

Page 9:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

*.

.

r 3 ;;;- ;-~- r . ::: 7::;u-"- _.q:;; .,,.y.;_. . ., ;;;,, . :_ _ . . ,

~~-" :.vfN. :::: ~ [.| " |;0. .y.. = . . .

-" -- gi: -''

"- ""

=u7'"~'

~" Y .. . .. .:n

== . .:i: = = ' ~ * : .= =~ -:=.=::$? ~.

= - =

r- - .--- .: r: =: .

'2_.d~. . sd "Y }~

1 :- v== = = .

^: I - '""n :. . .. 51.B.. ." ' " '

.._.'"=_=:=r====_=--=""i = """ ?.._w.is.';n~=:-'="* " n"""'!=i%. , . w ; X " """

. =. :- :: .3. . - . . 3:. :=z.:.=7 . . . . .-- -?=.

3.= ur r. ::-:= = ;= =. . . . _.: .;

; _. ::T"~:: "!?j :2''|:L, := - ::;;; .:~.""""*" [*~~ """ Q R q. ;,. .. :.=,"+_., = . ' " '_

;;r;;;, ---::-a-?: ==:==:" @ - ;;;;$;;:. =='''--=::. ==:; ;;: .,. .,. .. :n- u - : . . .;::===""= - : " " " = ~ * = ~ " * " ~ = " ' " ~ " . .* -

. ,_

2. ,~~ . ._. ; ._ ._._g -- _ _, _ _;- ;_-- -- u == _ , ,: , .:====. .

. . . _ . . . -. .=x==: ==.yg w. :.,. sq;.=-=v. e;:::a;;: : =:=:=- - = ..,.=..

'k. _ ;===

_

a*- : = c;;.;;;;;;;;;;;2;;;;;;,;;- --- - -- -. ~"'~~ =- -=|''... :--- .u . Z..v :-~=--

x? )! .. '"??.: ..: ::, . :.u .:

. ::: .i.a GECEIVED ..

"":" ~

, ,

.. ... E.? N5 * .::.: . . n.GEG: =- - - -

U JM 271982d === = m= =... 2: . - .

, " *A Crn thtmfy Ju = . .T. "T +"* " ~ " . . ~ , ~ . " JCDY HEND5EY \ y,,;g qq g 7 r = . , . .

TEST HILL ROAD, R. F. D. 2 & $ ~- M '~

. _ , , , __,_ . , , , , ,

NEW HARTFORD, CONNECICUT 06057''' "' =" ~ RF"'"-"55H :

. . . . . . ..d.'"L .:.,

......... ....(203) 379-1949 .I :;..'mp: = ===_:3 - =

i . . . . . . . . . . .

Cm' (3 l JAN 18 P4 30' T

=Z;..J li:'~~... =w..

, ' " ~ ~ '

"" . : :..u.uma 6.:.*: *~== :. :af- .|[ ,~, b. _ .. ..s3.f!F$:S m

; . ,0. [~"i _ m-..,._.4 . " ' *-gj j ,.,

#'335.833 6CQ h L U* O $~~#

..u... x_a

: . Q fS 7[, ,

4 AcAcI h ="...vn=.

.e

~El-E

_G,Q=:=:= . ..

@h'V 1.Ub55...' " ~ "

T-Q'C r::::: ~.L*i::.'.-.3..' *V\ Q

f s :.: ". -.. . . . . . . . .~~;2

l U.".iG-~ . fW $ M$ ~ ~

*. . . . . . -. . . . . . . " .-

J

ay T "*N .:5..._..Q./w- " ' ' ""

- :> + ======

L* .:. :-. . -". b e A

^ ?.~ .~. . . %. .. :|bf: uk ==

,/) L 6\ , j',r g.. .

g ... . . . . . ..'..n,

.a.J m:...

S.: a 1:: r. N JfkQ Q _

~.-- . . - . - . .,

|L.. . .=

.:.=.. m' * (,/ )O ?r.. .. .:::.Y.

" = "*

.-. 4 [ ,-.;_..-..

i k bY%,M,1,- |l'i'G":' . ; .id=:=:,

-...:......= { f L"::"*'""''

=:si."Ji:1 N-2:.;.::: .:2-- "'

-

; _f 8 p, j, lMc) * W"| = ""**

3 ga mwwm =

=, .,: . ::( _

f+ cc m::: .25. 5

A, 0 $ "::-.~.

""" ^ f | j /fNc 7....;

|0 I.?} 7 -..

- |i-?$5:.Eh::Si $ r. -

^=. +:--r~ :r : Y . . ~ ~ . 5:~ :- ..:w: .. .-.=.u....a.u :.. ... -- :.. .::: u.. . .

. . . . . . .-.:. - - . . - . . . ..

. . u . u .. a ..

-2.i~.22"._,,,..._..,.... 2."_','._ """" _,,*" ' = -"C"=i.; "r 5!'"- "f."" . _". " . , _, ,,c , . n=

., . . ., ,2 ;;;,.,.

"'5s..?: 12.. . .' ' . . 5 ' :: -~ M~ 1 5' . . ...:L'.? ? .:.;, .. . h ..:. . . .|.?..- -..,;.5"

. _?=f,,,=.;= -. , _ . . _ . . . . |"":====g. = "*F=

.-r. - v . .:== =: =- r ====--~=: w -

. . . .- u_.

. . . .

~ * " ~ ^ ' ' '*' ~":'' " " *

. T . ' = * * * * * ' "

- .. _ . . , . ;. .. .:. ~ :.., ''::a.... , . - ..Z.",".;'.":. - * =" ;;. =.. * = .

. . . a::"~": .".. ._ '""~~.. . _ _ , . ,.;.

"~ "~^ '

*.- . . . . ,

"''.....l'i. " ..~.-.....'.1..i~.. ....

- ' " " '

. . . . . :. .J . ..

m== :=~::. -= .: =?-: .: r- v: = - - --

. . . . . . . . . . . . w--..w._ - - - ~ - " * - "_

- * - - - - - - " "-"a

i h:..f"''"::":23=L'&= === .==: a.uk """""|:h=_===a:= . "~ ^"'~M= .; - -- = 9;}" |=:yLQ~ '~""}~,_"""=.:u

.- __ - _ _ __ - - _ _ _, , _ _ _ _ . _ _. . - _ _ _ - ,.

Page 10:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ______ __ __

. i

**O . . -!

-

=. x;,, .

Ef: ';j[y'f ^r " Q M T,:~

c'cc):.P ~:.E ':17.

f$rWJV77/ JNr N h &N fh$hk * .

,

% N 4 W b 9 7 - M 4 a /> ~ h$14I h h Nff|&& .

9 y #%-& J:arx& %y h

/w/w/se/rr.1./fa6~

W7"fWM& N/f

pe a utun } ' ]"%AG f /*id*fm,w'

b k$td k /hph/shf Mrs-

h /.

4

2 JAN 271982, 1 - u|Dff REC 3iVEO 3

'

Q'"9i'Ef,Migy'd'

n -

\*~'

- - -_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Page 11:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

. -_

e i

w

= .r g . ....

~ pg@ MtENCAN A55CC!AT:CH CF ENGINEENNG iCCm. dC.TELEPHONE 212 644 784oNEW YORK. NEW YORK 10017. 345 EAST 47th STREET ee

.. . = =. h y a.

*'"' U# 3 3- .

. F. " " - January 13, 1982~~

~

Ai [2121 011/12

""||| |-"' " 000:tE: -

. ..

. "."b"""'||"'~~~ O

.. .-=='== -

-. .

, , , , , , , ' " , " Mr. Samuel J. Chilk*

p,s A um. FAc.N ".g.. g- - - }- -- .'

O ,a=== Secretary' - .

..

Nuclear Regulatory Comission_

"O"||' Washington, DC 20555 _

-

~

" " " ' ' " " '

-

Dear Mr. Chilk:,

-- -.

-

I am writing to inform you that the Department of Energy's request _'"='

'

"- iO for authorization to conduct site preparation activities for the Clinch

-

j:"|",' River Breeder Reactor Plant beginning in March.of 1982, is iii keepingwith the recomendations developed by the AAES. Coordinating Comitta on- s- .

_ _ T.9, Energy ard approved by the Board of Governors of AAES~. - _.- ~~ces.s a yers

'

w'"." 'O As you may know, AAES is a national organization-of 43 engin.eering -

''"4" "'"" societies with a membership of close to a million ~ engineers. TheCoordinating Comittee on Energy of AAES is comprisTed of knowledge-===

~ able engineers appointed by societies to develop profession-wide-%i,

positions on energy-related matters as they affect the national--a

" " " " * " . interest. One of these positions is that "the development of thes

"O breeder reactor should be given high priority." The proposed site- - preparation would appear to be in keeping with this policy. _.

" " ~ ~ '

--s-=' Sinc ly, N '

#

y[ + RECE|yED" " " ' " . " . " . * / q.:

== ,

s - s== s- . A' y '3,,,%,, Robert A. Frosch -.- g

S2sI u ,' j P Q px a ,.s'T'."|||".l||||||

-

.6 F MRAF:bpis = x t 3: m is

. . - r~ ~,

cc: John A. Ahearne (> g'2' '* '""""

,,, .s --= a m Peter A. Bradford js' Mg/"""" % Victor Gilinsky-

'

;~ ~~

,,,,,,,,,,;, Nunzio J. PalladinoThomas J. Robertsins;: m :: m is

""" *' 503D== . S.i||||:

7= -- / D'"""2

"*:::'="e-

=1==15v. ma .e.= v.s .w..c w :amez=5

- .

Page 12:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

a 4

* O

00 0.HT tlUi.'3F.R ~~I

- - - -- -- F10DaUT1Lnch,*fE9

87t4 fm~ mt~w v Re,Sva /cc cgs 4 12 J." 19 P4:09 g_ ,, ,

- M* r' da SC ' T37 q , ,- j ~ g , ( ,W -

.,

<~ FK S*6 . ( 2 Q %2 Ryg4 5L ecc Seeeemay sp- 7;is d m~iw (M),

.

g~/AN y gg, 'f?g k*NM/ ,

WE*'!4 '?E' PM;6SS SW \014R. * G e, ) wis4 % x

& caa~ e.v vne 4 u ~ ce 2 < az Beesoek % a ~

5 A_$9<- 739 [(K B R) Ps a 7-1 v c - 7 77 E,<ese p7,~<

ir fao- n'ec z.<ceu.c iac nsceo wes . zy..

A/0 s*1 EMS $/-{c UC O Aqf ,Qucc-gpAir fgc_ rf^ ~

Bn- Armsu'Ep %M w y' Fra.r- a f- - i~5e ' /-ixasci- s_

~

^^

fppcggg,-: : :-- ~ ; . . . .: -

3_ ~~

5 FEAC4 -7*,*,e m Q,d&tS $ PEVDs ~7 5 %

' Tic ? eo /E9" 7s Ai/sa-r ,no.ssisie ec'o4*s-r <=urs - =-

es: -T*1*tf' 06~% $, ;;;C" v *2d K '/d U 'Y3 UA' wow ^.

o- .* Tae2 t.s:5 u E . &As= c;'",o-. r.s e p C2 % a::'' A/O ' Ver-d,

l'~~d4 t.d & W & ,*

l.) 'I~ F 7"E E CR5R (S A D E.M o p si W e w o m A 7 ,_

%=. - A %g <~ < w o m. w%-,.

,,*

db d ] EM '$ h b bh+446 Ej

y s'm ea.e STRAT"5:- L-.td E J S LN AB.L L i-r y/ ,

C ~ <* @ 2 iS L- M 4 ''TER At 'S.TtJ F P % s!; g gs,-

i is e c.~ am ~. - - 4.s-

R 7.- As- T K' -e o w ~Fr co.s. s yorc'G* ~Co LAld,l ), 'iE| , EN EG:'C / *I'>EM AD$ (

- pse3-??ms so o ME A- Mr' af r7/ e ,

Onvistm c:r F -7 9 ^) R C- eJ %s j% r .' jfo

-r;T m~ Av /%t %ve Ms * " - ; ,.-;-

- - - -. . . . . _ _ _ _

e

QC 0f ~

,

we c 17 5 --

Page 13:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

. .

s .

11 ?/e dowbrosk Rd.- oruninriUkT.ldrO401r

Jan. 12, 1982

h;0J. a UTli. FAC.[. d * Nk'

Jacretary of the Connaission - --,.

'

--

- --

Nuo)h" M.,y Commissionator

i sa 20555~

f y

G4 '82 JM 13 P a :C9 -

"

RECEIVED adants of :/tra. Willard H. Bonner on Docket No. 50-537 --"

s

Exemption request under 10 CFR 50-12. . . -g g jggyd " - - - '

g graal 1:1 TM |t' ' *: . ?e mmrn:t ton ~

lEC

lemen: As(b t/ eyou for this opportunity to :nake my thou6 hts known to you on this

issue.

You are, I hope, sn re that the NRC has only recently, since it has beenseen to enforce its own safety and licensing regulations, begun to cli:nb out fromunder the oloud of lies, misinformation, and cover-tp secrecy which had underminedany faith knowledgable citizens had in the AEC and ERDA. It would be unfortunate if, atthis point, you wiped out your gafns as an agency truly concerned with the sm26and welfare of all the people of this country. The majority of American tax 3payers has no faith in the nuoloar industry's interest in their well- beingexcept as it can be a refloation of their faith that the NRC:isJ no lenger usrely~ .!-

that part of the government-industrial-military complex that has easy access toits packets.

~ -

- - - .

.

Why, therefore, should you grant the CRBR organizatien an exemption fromrule 10 CFR 50,107 From the point of view of the industry the reason ta self-evident. Once,they have cleared ground, excavated foundations, and spent$88 million :noe dollars me=derr of our :noney, they would have an extra argumentfor getting their constructioh permit - with perhaps some waivers there, too?

And this would not be the first time that construction of the CRBR hasattempted, with the help of the ABC, to circumvent the law. In 1975 the AECbrushed aside NEPA and determined that contracts could be signed and i=plementedwithout an Environmental Impact Statement coveri36 the entire breeder reactorprogram which CRBR was to usher in. In fact, ERDA had requested-$181 millionfor the CRBR without even filing any EIS.

In the light of the 1973 confidential internal :nomorandom of Burns andRoe, Inc., the architect-Engineers of the Clinch River Breeder Reactor, onewould hope that the NRC would want to pay particular attention to site clearingandexcavationratherthanexemptingtheconsortiumfrcaruls10C7R50,10/The Burns and Roe memorandum, aside from charging unreliable ma q emest, neglectof important safety problems, diversien of funds, etc., specifically said of the

- -site of the CRBR that " varying rock conditions", " voids and cavities", and -

Tope stability" ... made it one of the worst sites ever selected for a nuolear'3 paar power plant," Based on topography and rock conditions; they stated more than

[S once that they expected poor results.

h True, Burns and Roe testified very shortly after this :nomo was finallyI leaked to the Congress in 1977 that the problems of 1973 had all been resolved

and the resolutions accepted by other participants in the project - like T7X,which chose the site in 1972; and |Utc and ERDA witnesses, who based their -testimony on their initial reviews of TYA data! ,

-

Nor can one forget the statements in the 1973 memo that both Westinghouse- - . . - . ..

Page 14:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

, .

/ .

_ Z.,-. Research

and Burns and Roe had been told orally by the Reactor /Divisien of EC and Fl:C,the h agement grouj, not to comply with the safety requirements "already in

_ mistence"; and the6 Burns and Roe make it clear in the 1973 document that eneof their major concerns is "that the corporate reputation not be damaged bythe results of the project, since it is in large nessure a key to our futuregrowth." And it is a fact that in spite of Burns and Roe's list of seriouscomplaints against the project the firm remained committed to its development, 1an understandable position when ERDA announced That Burns and Roe had been. ~

paid $37,4 million in fees as of September d 30, 1976. This, however, will -

not chan6e basic topography, rock formations, voids and cavities, and landslidepropensities in the cite - which merit your attention, not an exemption.

There was a time when there may have been genuine concern about thesufficiency of the supply of Uranium for the existing and to come IJFR's, whichwould necessitate reprocessing and breeder reactors. Doubt is cast on this,however, an view of the fact that the shortage figures came frem the AEC, andthe AEC's known interest in the breeder from the very beginning of the peacefuluse of the aton for energy. It OK'd the Fermi commercial denonstration breeder-to proceed to the design phase as early as December,1951, the same year thatits own Experimental Breeder number 1 (EBR-1) produced its first electricity- off"g ,,

enough to light 4 light bulbs. ( By1955ithadarunawayexcursionandmeltdown$The near catastrophe at Fermi in 1966 and the catalogue of mishaps both before segLL*-the accident and after did nothing to halt the AEC's obsessive interest in thebreeder. It was not ooincidence that CRBR was born i= mediately after tiis AEC

- gave up on Fermi and refused to extend its license to operate in 1972. It had-already chosen Oak Ridge as the site of a second demonstration breeder. And mwhat better way to get funding than a Uranium shortage scare.

However, the question of a Uranium shortage no longer applies as a reasonfor putting the CRBR on " fast track" that requires an emergency exemption fremrule 10 CFR 50,12. The projected level ofg nuclear power for the year 2000dropped 68 % between 1972 and 1977,2 and has no doubt continued to drop in theface of conservation,which has already created excess capacity; and theexcessive. capital costs of new plants, which is putting some utility companiesin financial straits - which will, of course be passed on to the consumers.

l| For these reasons, I urge you not to exempt the CRBR from rule 10 CFR 50.12.) The exemption would have no validity in itself and would, almost certainly,

be an inducement for further requests for exemptiens from other regulations by!

any company proposing to build a nuclear reactor.

|

1. Scienca, 7/22/77.

2. Bulletin of the Atenic Scientists, 9/80.

J[A : *

6,m

|

|

||

Page 15:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

.

. .

-_ _ . _ . _ . . _ _ . . . _ ~ ._._

%

)enn sq s.n,,, saw -

Mode op F x 67 82 y 18 Pa:09 .

Dawed. 70m 54736 N~

CM. . a : ;-^

" working for .o ufe energy fu nere **

January 13, 1982

yyg}E0 0 - * ' ""' Z23" * ' " ~*

Secretary of the Ceumission 'Nuclear Regulatory Commission fWashington, D.C. 20555 J g

Docket No. 50-537, exemption request under 10C550.1% f(! ,jE/VEoRE:

% 7199g 2'

ktsDEAR SECRETARY OF THE COMMISSION:

The Badger Safe Energy Alliance is a citizens' organization'vith .nearly 1000 members in Wisconsin. We have earned a reputationsfor'Wresponsible citizen advocacy on a variety of energy issues over

'

the past sever il years before both state and federal agencies.

We urge the NRC to deny the request fra the U.S. Department ofEnergy to exempt the Clinch River Breeder Reactor (CRER) fromcertain NRC licensing requirements.

At a time when public confidence in the NRC is rapidly eroding,it would be a mistake for the Consnission not to require fulllicesing for the CRBR. There is clearly no mandate from the USCongress concerning the CRER. Indeed, Congress is likely toterminate the project next session. The claim that there is anemergency situation which would warrent a special exemption forthe CRER is preposterous, considering declining electrical demund, and ?,

~'nationwide overcapacity.

'

Once again, we urge you to deny any request to exempt the Clinchi

River Breeder Reactor from full NRC licensing requirements.

'

Thank you for the opportunity to submit these comments.

QCbVERY TRULY YOURS: vf'r

'% Y |DPa Prevenas /

,

NUCLEAR POWER TASK ICRCE.

J-

Page 16:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

- - - - -

. .

,- -

m :. w' -. .. ...i!!?,"E.9.o....m (s..,.)-

' .:;-

-. . . . . . . . . ..

82 J|JI18,

.W l '/2- ci [/. ..

- iC' EAm C427 EsnQ . . . . . .w_

- y a p o. .-. 4 ; ,.. -- .

3 ...

- .

.-

_

pA #4 m <. d s q e 4 * a rN'#i(7 + f g M *- P*%._.

,

. m_%, .._. ._

'g- .

-- - .

.. . .

.. .. c - .. .

- - k -1% Ot"@5to to +%c_

lb,GL % IW< /Ma4. . Loe ~t da. A c&A

j nd c2A Jf M c]2 4 % < L ,

fcd~~~.M h._-|-OU O !~Ax

h. "%2]

v w,

d) g '? e

bMI ~~ bl / F2 'v-'

'

. . . .

psd..__..._.(3jd{R.psses)ScA 7/ (g- { mm W4az9m , dg .

ci4WD vpf8'-

Page 17:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

|. .

. .

' '

"Northem Illinois University 33--.DeKalb, Illinois 60115

COW""

Departrnent of Biological Sciences... January 13, 1982 815 753 1753815 753 043372 anu it :10 ..

Re: Docket No. 50-537 - Exemption Request Clinch River Breeder Reactor under 10^

CFR 50.12 _

"" ~ * " " ' " *" ' '*;*""~( ) _f.1[0-[37Secretary of the CommissionNuclear Regulatory Commission *

Washington, DC 20555

On behalf of San the Breeder Committee, I write for the following reasons to oppose therequest of the Department of Energy to exempt the Clinch River Breeder Reactor (CRBR)from certain Nuclear Regulatory Commission licensing procedures:

1) To truncate the licensing procedure of the first commercial demonstration of'a breeder would be to undermine the alleged licensibility of CRBR and futurebreeder reactors.

2) Because of the uniquely dangerous and highly controversial aspects of CRBR,more, rather than less, care nust be taken to protect the public healthand safety. _ _ _._

,,

3) Richard .L. Garwin, IBM Fellow & Professor, Harvard University, states "Recentprototype large breeder reactor (PLBR) studies in the United States estimatedthe capital cost of a breeder reactor to be at least $600 million more thanthat of an LWR. Present uranium costs of some $30/lb would have to rise some$130/lb before such a breeder could compete with the LWR, even if no economieswere achieved in LWR operation. One economy in the present fuel cycle that islikely within the next ten years is a reduction in the cost of isotopa enrich-ment from the present $80-100/kg SWU to around $20/kg SWU." Clearly, the de-cline in electrical demand coupled with the rise in uranium supplies demon-strates the " emergency" proposed by the DOE to short-cut the CRBR licensing .

procedure is a myth. -

4) The CRBR site at Clinch River is among the worst sites that could have beenselected (ERDA, October,1976). According to Burns and Roe, the architect-engineer for CRBR: "The Clinch River site selected for the LMFBR DemonstrationPlant is one of the worst sites ever selected for a nuclear power plant basedon its topography and rock conditions. The suitability of the site will not beconfirmed until af ter an extensive soil boring program. There is a possibilitythat the site may not be acceptable." This evidence is illustrati y.danger inherent in exempting . R from established NRC licensingQt' .J .N

cerely, j g ,

,

[ 77)_

8 .

Y M(%kBruce W. von Zellen 3\ ,

Professor and Co-chairperson (\ ,

Ban the Breeder Committee ^

Enclosures Qn- BWZ:bb / D!.

- - . - - - -

Page 18:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

&M* fl D $ /6 het MM$DHOf $h W$'

i gjggg gm jg y g most nonnuclear technologies and elimi-I. . . .'7; low Priority for Cim.ch River ? some reg *rts of DOE concerned

nated pa with -

. .-

ions. nus. Energy Secre.tary Edwards said, in a press bnennaThe Department of Energy's top research advisory committee has )when the ptan was announced. that mostresommended that funding for the Clinch River Breeder Reactor be of the financial savings will be made

terminated and that the savings be channeled into higher prionty areas such before DOE is scrapped.as conservation and environmental R & D. The recommendations, made

fast month by the Energy Research Advisory Board (ERABl.have had little () Congress will react to the proposal. TheA major unknown in all this is how

intluence on the Reagan Administration *s budget proposals for fiscal > cartFY) 1983. but they are sure to figure prommently in the annual con- plan was announced the day after Con-

,

.

gressional skirmishing over the breeder reactor program. gress adjourned for a 6. week break. Re-

action was thus somewhat muted. Sutfi.The committee was asked last August by Deputy Secretary of Energy W. cient opposition had developed ev'en be.l

Kenneth Davis to take a look at DOE's research priorities in the light of MReagan Administration's professed desire to get the government out of fore the formal announcement, however.

, to suggest that a tively debate is in store,projects that it believes pnvate industry should fund and to concentrate The plan wdl come under attack oninstead on long-term, high-nsk R & D. The ERAB report is perhaps the three grounds. First, severai niembers ofmost detaded entique so far of DOE *s new research directions. / Congress have expressed doubts about

ERAB essenually concurred with DOE's overall goals but concluded that \ the wisdom of downgrading energy pro--too |arge a fraction of R & D funds is going to electric power programs in I grams from a Cabinet-level department,general and into nuc! car energy in particular. Conservation R & D. in ( Senator Henry M. Jackson (D-Wash.),ccmpanson, is being underfunded, the committee argued suggesting that for example, has called the proposal ai"ti e budget needs a reordenng of pnonties to reflect better the " tragedy" that wdl weaken the Unitedoppetunities that exist for efficiency improvements and the unique Federal

States' dnve for energy independence.role in conservation R & D." In respor.se to the argument that private

Second, fears have been raised that sup--mdustry wd! do all the research that is needed in conservation. ERAB port for nonnuclear energy R & D wdlpented out that many sectors-such as the building industry-are toofragmented to mount an adequate research program. be even further croded if energy pro-

grams are subsumed in a sub-CabinetDese arguments seem to have fallen on deaf ears in the Administration. agency. Republicans and Democrats on ' ~

however. Reagan's budget proposels for FY 1982 would have raised the j the House and Senate energy commit-share of DOE's energy R & D funds claimed by electric power programsfrom 63 percent to 77 percent. chiefly by boosting spending on nuclear (tees have already expressed dispicasure

i at the fact that DOE virtually dismantledprograms, and they would have reduced the share going to conservation [ many conservation and alternative ener-from 16 percent to 8 percent. The FY 1983 proposals. which will be sent to % gy programs even before Congress com-Congress early in February, are aimed at shifting the balance even further

pleted work on DOE's budget. And (mal.toward elecincity supply technologies. According to widely leaked figures, ly,13 senators have sent a letter tothe Otfice of Management and Budget is proposing virtually to eliminate President Reagan protesting the transferspending on conservation R & D, while the nuclear budget is slated for,

of DOE's weapons programs to the De-f another large increase.partment of Commerce.They would pre-!

De ERAB report suggests. however, that by shifting pnorities awayfrom some expensive supply technologies and putting more emphasis on fer the establishment of a new agency in

the Department of Defense to handleconservation. DOE could actually reduce its research spending while

i nuclear programs-a move that would} buying a more effective program. Among its recommendations are the end nearly 40 years of civilian controlfollowing:

[ over nuclear matenals-or the reincar-* Delay construction of a demonstration breeder reactor. Sutficient coal ,) nation of an autonomous body like theand uranium supplies ettst to satisfy projected electncity demand for at old Atomic Energy Commission.[ least 40 years, and thus a demonstration plant is not urgently required, the Whatever Congress fmally decides topanel argues. Continuation of research on breeder technologies is iustified. ,

do with Reagan's proposal, there is nohowever.doubt that the uncertainty over DOE's

* Reduce or eliminate funding for the development of wind technolo-fate has already taken a heavy toll on

gres, geothermal energy. magnetohydrodynamics, and hydropower. These morale in the department. By next Octo-technologies are either oflimited potential or are at the stage where pnvate

) ber. DOE will be slimmed down to someindustry should take over. ERAB says. 16.000 employees. almost 4.000 fewer* Terminate DOE support for electnc vehicle R & D.than when the Reagan Administration

* Increase funding for R & D aimed at improving the use of energy in took control. More than half the reduc-buddings. De building industry is too fragmented and is in too shaky a tion has already taken place, and the restfmancial state to support adequate R & D, the report argues, yet the payos (

) wdl happen whether or not DOE is dis-from such research would be very high. For simdar reasons. ERABmantled. In addition, many jobs havei

recommends an increase in support for R & D on industnal energy been downgraded and thousands of em-conservation.

ployees have been reassigned to new* Increase funding for research on the impact of rising levels of carbon posts. "If you don't have a lot of tenure

dioxide in the atmosphere and on the efects of scid rain.* Finally. DOE's basic research and technology base programs should

here, it's probably wise to be looking fora job." says an employee in the solar and

receive higher pnonty because industry is unlikely to provide sut?icientsupport to otiset federal reductions.-CouN NONMAN (> renewable energy division, which has

been among the hardest hit by cuts sofar.-CouN NORMAN

in uowssiurun4 aso: oso Covnsne c #9st AAAS SCIENCE VOt. 215.8 JANt|ARY ivs:^

-

.

Page 19:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

-.

_

e

e

.

m, =

. oait, c,-ca. o.a. . i a.,. u,2i. i,.i j ,,

Clinch River reactor mu ti~million-dollar fias'

WASillNGTON - Gover.: ment boondoggles are Dat's bad enough. actually made. Among the *always good for evanescent hea "!nes. But if they are But it's actually worse than that. lowestigators for Fraud has also plagues the project. One internal overruns, insusreally to stick in the public craw, two considerations Rep. John Dingell, D-Mich., told my associates Tony Department of Energy memorandum told how an em. steel. While theare usually necessary: De fiasco must occur under Capaccio and Howard Rosenberg that at least kee ployee of Atomics International, a subcontractor, to have been cohigh auspices, and the story must have a certain fourths of C11nch River's prime contracts are open en- received a $1,000 interest free loan in return for ad. contractor, Gencomph capable of kindling public laterest. ded, that is with no firmly set costs or completion vance information on contracts, and another $5,000 in sion,are nervouBy all the comoh Indicators, the Chnch River dates.breeder reactor at Oak Ridge,Tenn., may not register

, cold cash for bid p Icelaformation. The Trident i'li,e FBI found that Iwo purchasing officials inven- ne first sub wahigh, il is an unheralded project, with an awkward ted bogus companies, from which they claimed to and while the iname, well off thp beaten path. But it is a g% have solicated bids for items needed at Clinch River. may be deliveramultimillion-dollar fiasco born of fraud and 4 rd a his resulted in overcharges running as high as 800 December is a smismanagement. &D, percent. that more delecg,

De plant, darling of the nuclear power industry, is iTypical of the cavalier way contractors behave As for the I-supposed to produce more nuclear fuel than it uses, h when Uncle Sugar is paying the bills is an incident fatigue testingwhich sounds like a bargala. But it has been no repolted in another internal DOE document dated serious defectsbargata for the taxpayers who are unwittingly paying JOCK Anderson Feb.13. It discloses that the chief of Westinghouse's thght. He planforit. data processing facility at Clinch Rover had been us. disaster,ils cosOriginally, it was to be in operation by Des .mber Ing a $200,000 computer for his own personal business. dreds of miliion:

a

1979, at a cost of $660 million. But it has alreadj cost lie not only stored leases and business directories in ne F It wasi e

$1 billion, and b latest estimate la that it won't bethe computer, but used it for a football pool. for the negt detoperational until February 1990. By that time, the bill he investigators warned that even the staggering De Congressional Budget Office has estimated that into a nig$tmaswill be at least $3 2 billion. $3 2 billion estimate may be optimlatic. It Ialls to take terminating Clinch Hiver "could save the government decision makerHow could this happen 7 It's easy, when the govern. Into account the possibility that the entire Cilach $1.4 billion over the five-year period of 19821986." But We don'bdant itment officials who are supposed to keep track of the River facihty might have to be relocated for safety the fleagan administration. reportedly over the objec. Navy brasshaprojects' contractors shirk their responsibilities. reasons. tions of Budget Director David Stockman, has decided Den 2ckati Scn, e According to a spokeswoman for the Clinch River A 1978 Nuclear Regulatory Commission repprt to go ahead. Tip O'Neiuc forproject, about to percent of the cost increase was due listed nearly 100 safety problems. A Clinch River /of- 7HOUBt.E AT SEA - Two of the Navy's most their state's in,to circumstances beyond official control. In other ficial said many of the problems had been ad.fressed glamorous weapons programs are awash in troubles. Office probe ofcords, the bureaucrats were responalble for "only" even before the NHC report, but the commission had One is the Trident missile submarine; the other is the findings njay be$500 million of the estimated $2 5 billion overrun. not yet checked to see if the needed corrections were carrier based F Is fighter-attack plane. will ''*" ~~ '

s,.

!4

1 '

!

..,

'.

Page 20:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

- . .- _ _

,

s* - - -

.

%.

~[ Nation I~)' '

c -

. . Indeed. Bntain. West Germany, the

Ch*nch R= er: a Breeder for Baker Soviet Union and France are already op.w mtmg e,eedm me,c adenced than useone not yet built attlinch River. To ent.

In a leanfederal budget, pork-barrelpolitics as usual ics this atgues against a.us commitmentto the expensive Tennessee project. "It's

Ronald Reagan was elected as a fierce these contracts." A steam generator like the Concorde." lays Vanderbilt Uni-penny pincher, and the budget thun- pnced at 55 million in 1975 actually cost versity Physicist John Barach. "Let the -

denng toward final passage by both hous- the Government 571 m lhon. The report French do it. If we need it, we can get ~

es is full of pared-down appropnations found evidence of both bnbery and fraud them to license a breeder to this country."But tucked amid all the austenty is $228 by some contractors. A consortium of Breeders can be fueled by" titanium ormillion to begin construcuan of an ex. 753 private utilities agreed in 1973 to plutonium. but they produce only the lat- - -

, penmental nuclear power plant on the put up more than a third of the capital ter. P!utonium is a far handier substance| Clinch River in eastern Tennessee. Sincefor Clinch River. Thanks to the cost over- for making bombs, and some skitush ent- '

i ,1970 the Government has invested more runs, the private sector investment will ics are afraid that Clinch River might be-,l | than $1 btllion in the project and the come a target for terronsts seeking to' , , , ,i plant is seen by its backers as central to n, .i' cadge a few pounds of plutonium to make

' ' Amencan nuc! car development. The F N an atomic weapon. The reactor is de-| President is a strong supporter of nuclear ; .' signed to be cooled by liquid sodium, a -

| power and the Administrauon has lob- 4 highly volatile substance, ansk there are -

! bied hard tocontinue Clinch River's fund- some doubts about the ability of the re-j -

| mg. Last week the House voted down.206H,- J,. , actor to control a catastrophic leakage in

i to I86.a last ditch attempt to cancel 1982 J. the sodium ducts. "It is a much more dan.'"

I appropnations for the plant. The Senate gerous and complex device than other re-Energy Comnuttee had earlier authorned

; funds withcut debate. actors." says Vanderbilt's Barach.

., g*Clinch River's proponents insist that,

'Congress gave Clinch River the go- . ' ;. , breeders are the only means that the US,

. e; has to guarantee itself an unlimite i do-Li% z -- % - - Q - d mestic supply of atomic fuel But even this-

9 advantage may not justtfy the costs.g.q.. *There won't be a sh:atage of:conven-

. f tional uranium for at ! cast 50 years." saysJan Beyes, a physicist on the statiof the*

; Audubon Society. "Certainly there is no-

-- . _ _ - urgent rush to get into breeder technol-?.E_'""' C.~ - - ' . - ~ ogy." President Jimmy Carter, worned

Q.Q p about the proliferation of plutonium. tned,

'

~ + - to stop Clinch River. Even Budget Di-, .

- M rector David Stockman, while he was a.g Michigan Congressman. opposed Clinch

I- River, contending that the Government'

should not underwnte nuclear develop-'

DM ment for the private sector by buildingpthe reactor. He called the project " totallyincompatab!c with our free-market ap--

, p. ..

.c. . . preach to energy policy."+

fleector site se a Tesessesse river bensk least: the Senator. left, with constiteents g tockman argued within the WhiteCongress says yes. bur enttes say no to an exposaw technologscalfiasco. G House for denying Clinch River fur-

ther funds, but was overruled. Whatahead despite mounting evidence that the be no more than 8%, and probably less. scaled the Admmistration's commitmentreactor is an unneamy and colossally At the heart of the Clinch River de- to the reactor wss geography---and poli-mamanaged boondoggle--and potential- bate are r.ot its finances but its technol- tics. The plant is to be burit in the homely dangerous as well. Feur days before the ogy; the 375-megawatt plant to be built state of Senate Majority Leader HowardHoiise vote, an Oversight and Investiga. is a breeder reactor, which creates more Baker. Already 458 Baker const'tuentsuons Subcommittee staffissued an exco- atomic fbel than it burns. The physics be- work on the project.and there is the prom-nating report on the project subutled "A hind this alchemy is not new. A few light ise of 4.000 more jobs for the seven-yearCast and Technical Fiasco" The report bulbs were powered by the first tiny breed. duration of construction. "In large mea-cited well-known problems, like Clinch er 30 years ago, and a 200-MW breeder sure." says one congresssonal aide. "theRiver's increase in cost from 5669 million plant was fired up-and failed-near De- Reagan support is due to the fact thatin 1973 to at least $3 2 billion and raised troit in 1966. Conventional nuclear reac- Baker is for it." Yet Baker barely had toagain questions about the adequacy of the tors also create fuel, but about 35% less enter the fray. Admits one of lus aides:reactor's safety mechanisms, than they consume rather than like "This year we didn't have to save it our-

The most damning revelations were breeders about 20% more. Says A. Da- selves. We didn't have to do that much."' in the report's catalogue of financial vid Rossin of the Amencan Nuclear So. Republican Judd Gre,Ig of New Hamp-

abuse. Many contracts for the manufac. ciety " Breeder reactors will be needed. shire, who werked to kill C! inch River tnj ture of reactor components were slackly To abandon Clinch River now would be the House. imisted that his toughest oppo-; wntten, lacking even techical spectra- a enppling blow to the U1 breeder pro- nent was Howard Baker. And who else?i cations. Said Invesugator A. Ernest Fitz- gram." Agrees Pietro Pasqua. a physicist "Howard Baker." Gregg repeated.> gerald of one contractor's agreements: "I at the Uruversity of Tennessee at Knox- "After that, you don't need any other

think it was sery decent of Westinghouse vtIIe "We ought to be proceeding as fast lobbytsts." -8v r6er Analersertto 40 any work, because it is not c! car as we can. We are now ten years behind Espare Ny Gaylee/Waewgrarr arutperor

, they hase to do anything at all under the rest of the world." Soder, v rort16 TIME. AUGL;ST 3.198 8

_ . _ _ . - . _

w "Y - - -_ _

Page 21:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

_- -

_ _ __-

. .

._.- ..- . _ - - - - - -

...mo . -. .-. ... .. . . - . .

W

54

e -

.

.

se

~

A Xuc_ ear D-Jayin Congress ^'['*'$wIf the Clinch River nuclear breeder reactor is ever nuclearfuelfarmoreetDefenti thancurrent reactors;tobestopped,it willhave to be now.The House Science and Technology Committee is it could, some day, provide virtually unlimited energy.

about to vote on $254 million to start construction. Head But demand for electricity is slowing and supplies ofcounts yesterday suggest that the vote will be extraor. uranium are plentiful; the breeder won't be able to

compete economically for decades. Even the French,| dinarily clase. It will also be decisive. A favorable votepioneers in breeder development, now face economicwill probably assure that the Tennessee tiernanstration problems.

i

.

plant progresses to compladon. A contrary vote may fl. The design of the Clinch River project is also ques.!nally turn Congress against this costly, ill-enneaived tionable. Some experts consider it outmoded; others( t=*ansagical turhey,

question its safety. Worse yet, the reactor will produceClinch Riveris a political gift from the Reagan Ad-plutonium, which can be made into bombs. It is odd, _

ministradon to $enator Baker of Tennessee, the ma. , evenreckless,forthe Reagan AC.: -aationto plungel

jority leader, and the nuclear industry. It clearly vio. ahead with such a project even before sett!!ng on itslates the President's acenomic principles: C11nchRiver requires huge Government subsidy for an uneco. overall policy on nuclear proliferation.

The annual vote on Clinch River has wrongly as-nomic energy plant that would never be built by pri. sumed a symbolic importance far beyond the merits. Itvate industry - and continuing subsidy at that, withmore than 31.2 billionin five years, is not a vote for or against nuclear power. One can

The economic case was laid out forcefully in 19yf favor the une of conventional nuclear reactors as partby Mr. Reagan's budget director, David Sr~+=an, of a hatancari energy system, as we do, without want.

Ing to build C11ach River. It is not even a vote for orwhen still a Congreamman He rightly branded C11nch against breeder reactors; there is plenty of money forRiver " totally incompatible with our free market breederresearch.approach to energy policy."

The only real issue is waste. Rarely is there betterMeanwhile, the arguments for building such a reason for both conservatives and liberals to vote

commertfal demonstration plant have grown standfly against a costly project; rarely will there be more3

weaker.The chief value of a breederis that it can burn reason to remember thces who vote for it...

.

|

___ ._

Page 22:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

- _ - - _ _ - _ _ - _ - _ _ _ - _ - _ - - - - _ _ _ _ _

..

. , _ . .

r. .

.

.

.

*

Dispensaie Pork - r= "n= 1m .-After cutting funds for food stamps, youth em. The Tennessee.Tombigbee Waterway. in Missis-

ployment, Medicaid and a host of other social pro. . sippi and Alabama, would link the Tennessee Rivergrams, tse Reagan Adelaistration endorsed two with an existing waterway that leads south to thehighly questiocable multibdllonalollar construction Gulf of Mexico. It has powerful supporters au the Ap.projucts of particular interest to powerful legislators propriations Committee hr two .Wmmienippians, --- the Cinch River breeder reactor and the Tennee- Jamie Whitten and TourBev111. About $1.1 billion has- !*- see.TombigbeeWaterway. already been spent on construction over the last dec.

This week the House has a chance to derail both ade, more than half the total estimated cost. -

of them it should. An Adminiarration and Congress Even so, there may be good reason to halt theasking everyone to make do with lees have no right to project. Tenn Tom will create a. bottleneck on the ' ~

clingto suchblatantperkbarrels, waterway to the' south, and eastng that problem -

The Cinch River breeder reactor, which is to be would cost another $1 billion. Moreover, both thebuilt in Tennessee, is champlaced by that state's General Accounting Office and the Coup 406al Re-Senator Baker, the majority Linder. It is suppcsed to search Service question predicieu. that enough -

%te the breeder's potential for using nu- barge traffle will materialize to justity the bat:p.clear fuel more efficiently than conventional reac- The economic case against both projects was -

tors. But this 33.2 billion project is apt to wind up a forcefully stated by President Reagan's own Dudgettechnological turkey. Some consider the relatively director, David Stocyman; while he was still a Con-3- c-

- small reactor nhanlaae='*; it might also fall short of pressman. FManeMr Clinch - River, he warned. - N m-

Federal safety and environmental requirements. A would encourage "2 never.ending stream of ~out-~. House sidmnmittee staff recent!y concluded that stretched palms'* for Federal; subsidies. He~sug.~ ~"

projected costs are soaring becatte of lax manage- gested that if Congress paid for marginal esterprisesment. And the need for even a well. conceived like Tenn Tom, it ought to "go wtole hog and build abreederis diminiahine as demand for electricity falls pyramid in every state /* The House should give bothand estimates of uranium supplies rise. prejects a pharaoh's burial.

.

..

O

_ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Page 23:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

. _ . . , _. - - - ._ _

.. ...

.

.

e

% e ,

m3d yn} ||_~

. . New %R %- ~[_

~

. Way 3 0 Buc get Cuts for 4 ucLear?E..T.il .;I

.

Most Federal energy programs are being cut, but say, for example, as a storige'fa'etl'tyior~juelear ~ ~ *i~

nuclear energy is headed for a costly, and indefensible, wastes. ~ ~ - - - - - - - "

boost. Full details won't be imown till Tuesday, but Breeders and reprocessin'g plints are objection.Senate Majority Leader Howard Baker has told report. able for another reason. They use plutesium, which - ;

- ers.that the heavily subsidized Clinch River breeder can, more readily than most reactor fuel,-be made inta- - - '

reactor, which the Carter Administration wisely tried bombs. That's why PresidenrCarter tded to persuade - -

to kill, will continue to be built in Senator Baker's state the world not to turn prematunty to breeder technolo,of Tennessee. And Energy Secretary Edwards has gies. President Reagan may.want'to change Mr. Car.urged the Government to buy a huge plant for reproc. ter's nonproliferation policy. But that ought to be done ~essing nuclear fuel in his state of South Carolina. Both orJy after the most careful consideration. The potentialprojects are a waste of money, consequences are toolmportant to world peace for the

Breeder reactors and reprocessing plants that pre. polley to be fnttered away piecemeal. ._

pers fuel for breeders are well worth experimentatien. The economic case against CI!nch River was stated. -.c A successful breeder would burn nuclear fuel far more forcefully !n lirF7 by Representativ9 David SMman.

.

efficiently than current reactors and thus might, sorno. Es warned that this plant was." totally incompatible . -

day, provide vast amounts of energy. But that day is with our free marker approach to energy.p3:!cy'* and ~

far off. Uranium for reactors is plentiful and cheap; would entangle the Government in further subeldles.-- the breeder will not be able to compete economically "Tutay it is the nuc!aar t*eeder lobby looking for a- ~

until well into the 21st century. There is co point now in large, unarmamic subsidy,"; he said. " Tomorrowsubsidizing the plant at Clinch River, which is intended it will be the solar power gang, then the windmill

.

to demonstrate the possibility of rapidly commercialis- freaks, and so on in a never ending stream of out-ing breeders. stretched palms."

Nor is there any need for a reprocessing plant Now the same Mr. Stockman is concerned bothto service it. If there is any reasonable case for the with market approaches and energy policy as directorGovernment's acquisition of the now. idle plant at of the Reagan budget office. His counsel was rightBarnwell, S.C., it will have to rest on other grounds - then;it is right inw.

_ . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . . _ _ . . _ __ -

.

w - -

Page 24:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

_

. .

0- .

' :* ,3ll n o w T r\t Sr.e

. . .

SffM FMs)ctSco, CA'S2 f: 1 ? Pd :10

-./ 9 / F A . ~ :.J

-

-

-

_.

-

.. .,.,

Se essrnM 0 F TN E cuMtens5 tor)n

NUCL&ftn. KE6 0%Af CoMMISS(CA)%gg, _miceroa , oe nsss : _

. . . . . . . . . . . ,, . . ..

* | ,# 5,

.NNM/ ; ..

u 8 s,, , -

y-

a - % + -v ~ w it @ p31.._ .+ e * e @u 8 * u .~ ..

1 .

M.s w u. 30- 537 . ,% e a ,o em so . , c .

'

d p ** A byM 4 0177 A @ A e% ~

n .u nx 4 p. a ~ .-b h -pat p thy 05 9 d~Cche& Q, M -

,,

* Q " %%% M & .a y k -lo

u m.m,ua~ w .. _.

k y M A n p<&d. %m kw%, s s. q , q % 4 5 u ~ p

RAhNW W ^ M 1%+ 9 a b te<- A & " 4 % w + 6

p , ~ % & e A M " W:4a m pn su. W> g a 8 . f W A Awdyt k .L~ W

2 A aaa a% m #27a AM m yF%w.w % 4 & -P% .da na m a "mu s

g/oe& trnal n % a M 4 $& w &1. A>o

,y

|

'

.- . | - - _ . . _ . _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _

Page 25:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

..

4- .

/

u an, y . a .i. e & %f % n -h .-

p y M u & of etlL ,.4 2 4 R 42- 2r,

g %| m A sA y .~- shat g qq

g. -

. . .

- . . . ._ _

75 g % Doe.io yAJA@m44~ e wt

o-(ktkttr & M typnas' y & kcoeA e<ela- %- % 4 as. % ka n dstal<-

y .hadeu.. Tsk 4 4 Lt. a k ~

-.% vp 4 ", J is w p M J .p M . w --

Q 4.Dz. W y %not Q_w"'=%.My- I

-

y44 -fa24,' yy ~

_

=

M*

*.%

+

"Y

_ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Page 26:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

_ - _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

P .

]0%t-r 6 -1"5)(ht.ufrio a) /E.squd3r vNP&& ./0,( V]2

!&FA n, t 2. ) .: ~ r 3, m g, fypy

[h- /t; /7432 J;n 18 Pa:10

W_

& La:n & n n... ...: :.-= .p. Sg- ~

-

5aq)A.scou<-

--

% m.is1m : . .:.-.2 ~.~-'

yuagz,,fgjt/a:., pc >arff ,

d UECElVED 3

% 6Jy, =san ar 1882 =a4"Fanggy

$rgeh aZ sAr- 9 z.~

G S-44 A dl4 /ja-GP&nL*- jw k. sq ud p-~

%pJ, a un n.g .

kLLL. /$ rf &CM% 5'I TT/so-n o sj wy > .t. u

kw.)L.9 M ke'9 Ass 510- H ed SM"F77 su p1,g_ @ u,,, z,4

b s'*I2 , a ij rn.o J u 3 , n psm,,A~v 1'+vt-LPstLt- J'e< s c

G- a wp e ~ ~ ~ < e nu , , , , ,

W,0 u & 4 7"I+b C4f--WULL| D Gh gs,29 g e 9,w

S'r- I w~e yea.se. a 7. ,nk"**y up .

D ,63S

,2.g , [,atamp,

fi(u., m c 4,;; !!J

_ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___

_;

Page 27:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

. *

%

.

. . . . . . " . _ :.:. . . . w.= & \3Ggg G

.. . . . c --

. 4 h4 5 G '82 JDI 18 P4 :10 .

NA / C:l''i-h"~~ h < W t )E. .- i

~

. Wtag b.c. Aos ss. g,ji

b Sts,

3. n h u p p #_ _. T y o 3 ~ s ~_

g FA e c.i= s s o. e . A a p6_n le --U- c_a R.s L.uk P A .g

~-

A M b

i>45:r.,ig.m we% A+3* ' n. .

sw 4 W w- mee i

~ T W a a -.c u f & | + 2 & . % '="; p"' ["-m ,

w~- p a .% * % wwc~ e o .\%a % a & wa:t &

a > & A % e n <c..:

.%.Jn A & M .Dko LWA gmpaAhg - q oia wy,,

'

a h k h t s<u.A a.

| *i

503h.U k DpIIU

-- - - - - -

Page 28:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

.. ..

''

. .. . , . .)=5...So - S37[E) .;--

.... ... ... .s.-

January 13, 1982 82 g:la PM12.

p:.' Secretary of the Commission O.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission . ...?~ ASS 'f

Washington, DC 20555

k.f'/*!ECElygnq.

s -

RE: Docket No. 50-537Clinch River Breeder Reactor Exemption Request

(E>,Jgfg 7 I90b ''~__

~

Pursuant to 10 CFR 50.12 3'a$gt #

Dear' Secretary; .gq','2h. P

I 'strongly oppose the proposal presently pending before the . '#I'to exempt the Clinch River Breeder Reactor (CRBR) from certainNRC licensing procedures. In the wake of the continuing problemsof Three Mile Island and the more recent " embarrassment" of DiabloCanyon there is no reasonable justification for these exemptions.The technology and economics of the breeder reactor are in flux,and it would be greatly detrimental to the public to put the CRBRon a " fast track" at this time.

There is no Congressional mandate for the proposed exemptions. Recentattempts to cut funding for CRBR lost by only slim margins in both theSenate and House.to the current mood of Congress, but also the general public. Adopting exemptions for CRBR is contrary not onlyfailures in breeder development have seriously undermined public confi-Priordence. This is clearly not the time for exemptions which would serveto foist a technology upon an unwilling and dubious public andeconomy.

I urge you to reject the proposed exemption.s.

Since ely \

Ws

D. Scott StuartAttorney-at-Law747 GrandAllegan, Mi 49010

Of0s. /d

.. - - - .---

Page 29:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

- _ _ _ .

. .

_n

, __ -_-- -

/.n_., . . . L ., . c . - . , , ~ .

r;cuntain View, .ht ','2560J anua ry 13, 1982

T.;;_ d':' 1 ) Pd,.,.,.- .

,

"

"sc-h we/s,

, t. -:

Jecretary of the Commission-

.~.

~a...9-

.!uclear negulatory Commission'

i.asnington, D.C. 20555

~- e : kee.et ho. >G-53'l - exemption request uncer 10 CFR 50.12.

Lear mir:--

I unaerstand the LC_is considering an exemption for the Clinch liverreeder Meactor Pro 1ect which would allow grounc breaking ano site

preparation on the project.

1 oppose the granting of such an exemption. My reasons for opposingthe exemption are as follows:

1. There is no energy emergency that would call for an exemption ~

at this time. The energy usage of our country is declining. Yetthe Breeders were planned when the projecticca were for increasin.Tenergy usage.

2. Congress is not strongly in favor of such a program. There isno clear voting mandate on this issue. In 1981 the amendment tocut the CHER Project lost & by Alq votes in the Senate and twentyvotes in the house.

3 Any type of exemption which will allow ground breaking andsite preparation (to the sum of $88 nillion dellars) on a projectwhich has neither a construction permit or a limited work author 1-zation would surely not set well with the public. . Shat littlepublic confidence the public has in any nuclear program wculd W scompletely eroded. . @ '/

14 This exemption would serve to defeat the purpose of th j

indtr .3,l'UDgRiver Breeder Reactor, unich is ostensibly designed to demtr - N27 -

-e,

| the licensibility of breeder reactors. 2U 939'qu .,7[o 2A. 'i

| Please make my opposition known to the other Ccamission nember '' Wgdjy.-Sincerely, .p

', . . . ,*

- so-

Joe SanfDrd *

J5:kl 5/bec: NIM //D

{

i

Page 30:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

. .

~ .

l ',., "

, g, i,c cM ;- /M. '< |-

/,.--

,,u . i. c q .q- q m ./ .1% /, -..

-

.

.- <~ . . -

7. ,, ,

t J e c :.A.1. ,i.t; W A T +eC, v c / w , u.w g w ,',

~ ' Un ' 6 L,vf. ,t, h() 'A2 JM 13 Pa:10c

heat pop . 3T.E2'&.aW12)x /' ~'

w r .-.

c.. ..

f,(.c A 3 A c ftc1~ a uf ,% n'.f.c >;ecqt. , .''l-||q '.i 5.

,-- _

'' M A. u u d -v 5 . b c t a c k -f u k m. ,el $ .r.] '.T A ='O-

'

CM, cA l''u4 t d' ult Nh*,.7 -Q. ;c# -7.

~.f.

,' '. ') ^ ^'LC'*! A '.A. 2.-yy.L v,~.iQ.o T._g.-t[,.v.G G n . 6 J .-

k d LeL< ' i .t vk'a. EU A.ui Nu..G.'.

A 2^-f6 F?cO %) w ^'i n -4c w ,,> -j ,y;G' c.4-me a 6. _ -

.y- - . . .

A~

$pu a m x ,a~us.+1..u s n c- c a g..,,. .,

Wh/A t-%-c-u. d e msrids idh m |iO. Y |E.(.0:: - ..u

.fh.p.) U (; to dL u /t LA< +Ma t.,eMi'.<-44c.N :f HCDHL u~ .Li gr.m_' * '

r/v ccdf .

- - --:

W ,L flegy. g -rly.Cl<:~A k. '-.me,ecb Ncc"M4:c/ hyu m- M s.t...

,

+'

- # ~

7,g<.7,9 <z/'& C p<c6-0 m t u d p .zg f4-y y ._et at4 #r 3%,.

g g-tc.n y'I)%2 $4Ay,2-A1g c:1 ouki.QM wf ' G.i -

. ..

1s

~

} < o c.rc u l3vf.

)))$.&thcic-irw~

T?en 75~d('t, 4'euc ._ h n L 'Wa . -~/, &'j %'__ -q.

it i

nECEIVED '}g.- JAN 2719825 C'

ae muww nc,6 CLa.! Wa::Y.T.? F2

m p

' 'Q qh

D$o3e

- .. .

Page 31:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

- _.

-. . , - .~~~ ,- - .,.. . !/ - -

.. .....' ~L . . ~ - .--

- - .

,-

/ .u_\. .~ - = =e--m-. n..

- - - f, - , ..-- - - . . - -

~d2 J2118 P ~- --

-,- , o ,.. ~-- aj.2- -

+ u. -<, w , - . . _ ,

. . -- - ~ . . .. sg -s 3 9 _, , -.

/na . ... ...

;, . ,..- -,,., - - . . . . .

.ad.m% *., %a *w4 .,.

**

,-L-Af~ .'e= w ; _ y,, ,i *.

. ,4 3=

6, .1.t %- - -. ... s.

,,/,_-,% ..

,

- - - .- - --- .,%c a n

Y- ,~ '(, ,..s

..

.s - . .f .. - e .

]s Mc;gjb,e,* ^ -

-

-

-e d W

k-g''., !! % ,,$~ ' ~ ~ .

da? '

d.-

c- . . .,~ t .4 6 L_ h -o. t ._ ,,s.,. . _j- .m.

.

S'(,y &0*W %=t- , ~. m _

~,L LnM'~-- fYW *L m~. ~ *' - - ~ . . _

- . _ _. _ ._

*

f., . - . - . .

q'

b y *t-d w' g-,._ . . _ .^'- *

.

# p

..t..,.u :,. - , . . :., . ,w* * , ,

y-.s-y _ , I,k.A n~ .

4- ~~, .

s. J.~ - *,, - . . % Chn $ wsyn ;

M <-vvuj' % " ~' .

~*w-/ A w= ' shI '-W /,w , '.

.

w.'4s , %v ..

su*' " * ~ ~ ' ** ~"'~.

e

* ~' ''~d.'. G . 5 ',- ,''b,.,

.

(,h , < , [-- % t. py W-

,

.w- "bs.6 - .*** * ( * -%

8lth

.# .

p ,s ~j r w ,.%. >*

+ ' . .y ~ s/a s .,, q ,m.se

4- .=**

~~

*; A 4,, L, VW a* * * r

''

( gg. ,

e

h 9ei.., , ,,,,,9

pw$ .P4p

, ~. #-- ,A.,. . a .-~.*- ,

_,,___ w a.,

G.,.*7 -

J.-. *L._n,

*sms~.

h *= [%',d 4.,*e

_- *

i . .' s . . -< --

* --.. .., .. - - ~ .

99, , ,

, ..R m. , . . , -- p -

.

,

s

2..,,_--- g

/

w e% , A*Wg g <E"b.

[

, - eae*

.a

~%e *- e e a

d

Page 32:  · - - - _ c. ~- -.,: :: .:a " : . ..a.. .::.. . .:. =rmuu .:== a. +- =^=2.=::=====- = = = = = =.- *..=.... .g _ ::::.=.;":. .:-. ":a =,G"" .;=.a...BT =~= =" ^=a'"=L ...

. -

---,

.. .,

7. .

&-S39 $). . . ~ . .-....... ..

'82 &|! 18 P4 :11.

.

..b. .Ib4rfCOCME

..

. . ,, ,e ,., . . . -.- ..

8$3 ==.

+ t, .* . u. . n.w..n. s ..e..,,.,....._..,..,,,._.:.. y RECElVEo

.

w. .. .. . . . .. , , . . . . "- .: ,,.... _. . ....,e.w.. . . ..

4. , u...

eee .-...,y., e JAtIg7 g9gga, ,. .s ~ - -w -. -.

b 3DQ . ij

---.a ...s =. : /, ., P;c<h5 tg % 1v. -aa

A%. . . ., . , . . , . n., 2. e.,, .t s. w. ./ . s. G n e.,t...e . .%..,.* s ,s.. , ,,,.. . . . . . w.. w . .. .. sp/. ., . , ,.

''v i C'

.1.L.e 16 a. .* .0 go.l9, mu.s a. 8 .- .' .a 8 a. a _l ..n s. w .e.,a :o. .e 0 -. _ . ..,n. s . .. .. ..w

.d' c . . e .b. e.s. a. J.Q , . s. .,,9 . ,A v. .a .*.*.y"'*. .I .a '". . "." b. e .w.3 .Ie ,e,' e .s.* a .4 ' ,.. a

. . w . . . . . .,

.

..th.8 h.. . . . . 1 ,4 . . a,. 3 ... 3 c. 3. c .! ,,1g 2 c a. s a. . . a .I a.. . , e. 4 O= , . . . , , 3,.

6 .s . . . . . . . .. . . . . .._ . -. . ..

3.* I e v. ,e .e A. .h. .! , ' . ' . .C . g e. e .,. . 4e ,e a. .f . ,. g 9 . . 3 3 1 2..,.1.e ,

, .

. y.. .. . .. .. . - . .......s . .

q ** .3 * b. i k. .** e. a. '.I. e '* "V a ". " .'. .*.C n . *f a.,.8 a'.'.'.'.'.'..''.e'.*..*.**.'j*****,'$.a'. ' ' - * - " * ,... .. . . . . . .w . , . . ,

a. .=.* e .v= * S. **.a. g .'.'*****('****5.8''.. *1.J. w .I '. .I .* ". ) * '* 3. *.* n .I.*.* J * * ' ..c.e 4 as c. 3 .e.

ar ** * * * .g,w - . . . g. ... . .... . ..w .w.

* * * I ." 3.e.r.I *2. '. g .v= "* I.*.g* .#d.t e *.g . a. c e .IC '.".*t f". w m ~ ** s e. .= e.n l". * *. a '' ** *: O. . )*

..g.... . . . . . . . . ... * g. .

*f...C .d ' w . .., 3 Me w. 3 r. = b. 4.a I .3 , n. e.....'..S.a.._e. . ...e.e ai ..3.,*g.. #.. .. .g .. ...g . . d u....e.. e . ...g g .

*w ..t .e . . . .e_ia., ....,,-.. > ,,... .i :. .:.. .w :.n ,-.,. . . .. . . . . .. . . . . e .. .. . ... . .: 4.

n .e. s.%. . 3 ~ ,, . e .m .t .e. .....y.6 ,,....

.

i

-e. ,r ._-.. - ,,

* *.c f

'.:. '!' J.'fy " . . [,. _ -. . . . .n. ...

-,

,..

r,. 4 .,.,a. . , I.ui 's....s. . .

1.224 ?.'illcwbrech- 47Munts*tille , A; 35C2

Q56'l5

/ D.

b . .- 4


@A B 01 A B 01 +=Îg CD g E F ag`a ¹Ê01 , ¸ g = g #G - E F ag H Í e I JK 2± `a ¹ÊÔ¸ C? r LM )* #

@A B 01 A B 01 +=Îg CD g E F ag`a ¹Ê01 , ¸ g = g #G - E F ag H Í e I JK 2± `a ¹ÊÔ¸ C? r LM )* #

F o P A g F o A g

F o P A g F o A g

Bramo otwórz się - Elektronika Praktyczna · ISM (Industrial, Scientifi c, Medical) w technice FHSS (Frequency Hopping Spread Spectrum). ... SET BT LAP 9e8b33 SET BT PAGEMODE 4

Bramo otwórz się - Elektronika Praktyczna · ISM (Industrial, Scientifi c, Medical) w technice FHSS (Frequency Hopping Spread Spectrum). ... SET BT LAP 9e8b33 SET BT PAGEMODE 4

NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DURGAPUR Name of … · b.tech-bt 16u10160 16bt8006 rahul kumar 3 b.tech-bt 16u10187 16bt8007 ritesh yadav 3 b.tech-bt 16u10700 16bt8035 debkanta

NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DURGAPUR Name of … · b.tech-bt 16u10160 16bt8006 rahul kumar 3 b.tech-bt 16u10187 16bt8007 ritesh yadav 3 b.tech-bt 16u10700 16bt8035 debkanta

Instrukcja montażu modułu BT do MMI 3G

Instrukcja montażu modułu BT do MMI 3G

H j ] Z g b a Z p b y [ t ^ b g g g u o G Z p b c A ...€¦ · H j ] Z g b a Z p b y [ t _ ^ b g _ g g u o G Z p b c A /CONF.234/RPM.1/1 Генеральная Ассамблея

H j ] Z g b a Z p b y [ t ^ b g g g u o G Z p b c A ...€¦ · H j ] Z g b a Z p b y [ t _ ^ b g _ g g u o G Z p b c A /CONF.234/RPM.1/1 Генеральная Ассамблея

Petra Stanat Katrin Böhme Stefan Schipolowski Nicole Haag … › bt › bt › BT2015 › Bericht › IQB_BT... · 2017-04-03 · In 2003 and 2004, the Standing Conference of the

Petra Stanat Katrin Böhme Stefan Schipolowski Nicole Haag … › bt › bt › BT2015 › Bericht › IQB_BT... · 2017-04-03 · In 2003 and 2004, the Standing Conference of the

t t&% t tt tttt ttt t · 2019-02-07 · íh ÑÑ íh íh!a!g!a!g!a!a!a!a!a!a # m e"Û $8 $8 $8 #!g!g!g!g!g!a!a!a!a!!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!!a!a!a!a!!a!!a!a!a!a!a!a

t t&% t tt tttt ttt t · 2019-02-07 · íh ÑÑ íh íh!a!g!a!g!a!a!a!a!a!a # m e"Û $8 $8 $8 #!g!g!g!g!g!a!a!a!a!!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!a!!a!a!a!a!!a!!a!a!a!a!a!a

2017/2018 - agapit.plagapit.pl/upload/cen/Maszyny czyszczące.pdf · torem marek Comac, Cramer, Multihog, Truvox, Porto- ... 20 B Classic - 50 E Classic Simpla 45 BT/50 BT/65 BT Classic

2017/2018 - agapit.plagapit.pl/upload/cen/Maszyny czyszczące.pdf · torem marek Comac, Cramer, Multihog, Truvox, Porto- ... 20 B Classic - 50 E Classic Simpla 45 BT/50 BT/65 BT Classic

Twine&Pinch BT - grzejniki dekoracyjne Jaga

Twine&Pinch BT - grzejniki dekoracyjne Jaga

(U F4F FI a Ig a I t...Fi! E.53 "o5 E;eoerrX oFEJ9L g o, E EE€ bt E 3h-{trE cd tf Ct 8 F g A€ F z gsg g Fg' P,rr3)}lb Ert 3v)o'6E g E 5 .6 € €: sE E x6c)tr€H 19 EqP=:r.=t-;.Y

(U F4F FI a Ig a I t...Fi! E.53 "o5 E;eoerrX oFEJ9L g o, E EE€ bt E 3h-{trE cd tf Ct 8 F g A€ F z gsg g Fg' P,rr3)}lb Ert 3v)o'6E g E 5 .6 € €: sE E x6c)tr€H 19 EqP=:r.=t-;.Y

A L I G JSJ G G J N J by Martina · GG G G G G G G I by Martina S by Martina by Martina sss f N A L J J J J J G J G GG G G G G G G I by Martina S s s s f N A L J J J J J G J G GG

A L I G JSJ G G J N J by Martina · GG G G G G G G I by Martina S by Martina by Martina sss f N A L J J J J J G J G GG G G G G G G I by Martina S s s s f N A L J J J J J G J G GG

ppdjb.edu.my Taklimat.pdf · fitriyanie binti aminudin zainon bt muhammad zaini bte muda haslinda bt amid hawa bte osman hazanah binti sari hjh me-riah bt. hussin irdawati @ nor zakiah

ppdjb.edu.my Taklimat.pdf · fitriyanie binti aminudin zainon bt muhammad zaini bte muda haslinda bt amid hawa bte osman hazanah binti sari hjh me-riah bt. hussin irdawati @ nor zakiah

Helsinki 220 BT / London 120 / Sydney 220 BT / Melbourne 120 - … · 2015-02-17 · niki i ogólnie uznanymi zasadami bezpieczeństwa. Mimo to nieprzestrzeganie zawartych w niniejszej

Helsinki 220 BT / London 120 / Sydney 220 BT / Melbourne 120 - … · 2015-02-17 · niki i ogólnie uznanymi zasadami bezpieczeństwa. Mimo to nieprzestrzeganie zawartych w niniejszej

Tester akumulatora / baterii 12V AUTOOL BT-360 - test ...

Tester akumulatora / baterii 12V AUTOOL BT-360 - test ...

BT - Maj2013

BT - Maj2013

G N S M I C H G I G A N 170 S T LR2 SF 5 0 E S G A I R P R RC (M) G A V 0 4 1 6 9 … · 2020. 3. 11. · g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!.

G N S M I C H G I G A N 170 S T LR2 SF 5 0 E S G A I R P R RC (M) G A V 0 4 1 6 9 … · 2020. 3. 11. · g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!.

B - A - G - “sh-sh” B - A - G - “sh-sh” G ... - Weebly

B - A - G - “sh-sh” B - A - G - “sh-sh” G ... - Weebly

I a* 4il¤²े.अ_काज.pdf · 6 sl.J,l d 4, 1).11),A L 1l)d A!! ql' 31 ol q. 3 q A, e g.,]4 {1! a. {] d I *-j4-31f j? fl 31 fl fl fl n o n n G G o G o G G o o o n o n G o G

I a* 4il¤²े.अ_काज.pdf · 6 sl.J,l d 4, 1).11),A L 1l)d A!! ql' 31 ol q. 3 q A, e g.,]4 {1! a. {] d I *-j4-31f j? fl 31 fl fl fl n o n n G G o G o G G o o o n o n G o G

G 1 7 A V S A V E S V E S W H A H T G T SW KE NYO T G SW ... · g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!.

G 1 7 A V S A V E S V E S W H A H T G T SW KE NYO T G SW ... · g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!. g!.