Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

31
!" $%&'() *+,!"- Reclaiming Public Space !""#$ &"'()*)+,'-. /.,0"($,'1 2-.3-(1 4564 7 $'3#1 )8 '"9*)(-(1: $9-++;$<-+": <)993.,'1;+"# ,.'"(0".',).$ ,. '=" 3(>-. +-.#$<-*" -$ - <-'-+1$' 8)( ?("@0,'-+,$-',).

description

critical study on the changing nature of public space.

Transcript of Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

Page 1: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!"#$%&'()#*+,!"-

Reclaiming Public Space

!""#$%&"'()*)+,'-.%/.,0"($,'1%2-.3-(1%4564

7%$'3#1%)8%'"9*)(-(1:%$9-++;$<-+":%

<)993.,'1;+"#%%,.'"(0".',).$%,.%'="%3(>-.%

+-.#$<-*"%-$%-%<-'-+1$'%8)(%?("@0,'-+,$-',).

Page 2: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes
Page 3: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!"#$%#$&

!"#$%&'(#)%"!"#$%&'()*+,'%"-%*#(.*/00"#-"1"(%222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222223450,"--&'(*#(.*450",&1"(%#%&'(22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222236#(#7&(7*#*8#9:#;9"*!"-':,$"222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222<

*+,-#.$/01/2'.3#)%"/%4/5'67)(/8-,(./,"&/9:".$3+)-=>"*?>#(7&(7*@#%:,"*'A*+:;9&$*B0#$"2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222CD,"#E&(7*%>"*!:9"-222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222FG

*+,-#.$/;<$%=/>,$?.@8(,7./A,3#.$@57,"")"?/#%/A)($%@#,$?.#)"?/*H&AA","(%*=I0"*'A*+,#$%&$"2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222FF6'.",(*="$>('9'7I*#(.*B%,#%"7&$*6#00&(72222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222FJ

*+,-#.$/BC'.$$)77,/C,$&.")"?/@/!77)()#/*'7#)D,#)%"/,"&/1--$%-$),#)%"/%4/>,"&450,"--&'(2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222FK!#99I&(7*%>"*=,''0-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!F3

*+,-#.$/EF<$%=/!77)()#/#%/G.=-%$,$H/C,$&."3/IJ)#+/5.$=)33)%"K6#E&(7*B0#$"*&(*H#9-%'(222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222F<L(&'(*B%,""%*:,;#(*+>I-&$*M#,."(222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222FN

*+,-#.$/LG.=-%$,$H/'3./,"&/G+./J)&.$/5)(#'$.410'O",&(7*?'11:(&%&"-222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222JJ="-%&(7*%>"*P#%",*Q*=>"*R10',%#($"*'A*450",&1"(%#%&'(2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222JS=>"*,'9"*'A*T#(.-$#0"*/,$>&%"$%-*#(.*%>"*U#9:"*'A*M#,."(-222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222JK

M.4.$."(.3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#

N)67)%?$,-+H!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!JC

Page 4: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!../+,0123#1##$## 41%+ 5 26# ##&+'7( 8)*"#$29#+#:,;# ' #12 5"-)$ "#!"&+5"-# + #" ". $ "#$29# + #1'/0 #$26.#/1 ( #%*) <%&*)+## ##2. %-= " ) 2 -#&$##! # #$2 ( #3 )#>) 11## " %%*14 # &' 5"-;#' #)-# 0# # "9# 0#% 1 # 0#'2& #+ # $## 1)-.#?14) # /% #&$ # ##! #%*) ;#!26#'2 6#! # ( # 0#% &+' % #

&+#+#)&6;#5 )&*)+# ;# ( % ;#- # 2 #$29#' *17 ) )*"....

?: ! , ) #$29#@2 %$4 #ABC6DE

“)

Page 5: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

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

F&0"01-&#,001#'-1%*#*)/#'+%#2):"&+#0.#2)$3%7*&)2%# $%3%"%$)'-0"# *&+%1%*# 2->%# O-22# P2*069*#?-*-0"# .0$# Q$)8.0$84# ,:'# *-"&%# '+%# *')$'# 0.# '+%#$%&%**-0"4#1)"(#0.#'+%*%#62)"*#+)?%#,%%"#*')22%8#0$# -"'%$$:6'%84# 2%)?-"3# 3)6-"3# +02%*# -"# '+%# &-'(#)"8# )# 8-*-22:*-0"%8# 606:2)'-0"<# D0162-&)'%8# )"8#&0".:*-"3#0/"%$*+-6#-**:%*#)$-*%#)"8#0.'%"#$%*:2'#-"#1)"(#)$%)*#0.#2)"8#0$#%16'(#,:-28-"3*#$%1)-"-"3#:":*%8# 0?%$# 20"3# 6%$-08*# 0.# '-1%4# ,2-3+'-"3# '+%#

'#$(")*+$,"#

!"#$%&'()*+,'%"-%*#(.*/00"#-"1"(%

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

L

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

!"#$%&"$'(")#*'+#"$,*'-./0.12'3&*45"635,$'&*'57,'45#88,$'9,45!',8$'$,:,8&;<,*5'4=5,'=*'!"#$%&"$'=*'#*'#55,<;5'5&'",:=5#8=4,'#*$'=<;"&:,'57,'#,457,5=3'#;;,#"#*3,'&%'57,'4=5,>

Page 6: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

2&"3%45"*6'(.'(*789::;/<'(=-&."*'("*'>*%?"*<#,="-%*,"="(",#%&'(*0,'@"$%-*&(*%?"*AB*C*D?"*E<F10&$*0#,G*C*2&"3%45"*&-*#*$'114(&%F*#,%-*#(.*".4$#%&'(*H"(4"*."-&=(".*%'*&(%"=,#%"*<'$#<*,"-&."(%-I**/*$'(H",%".*-?&00&(=*$'(%#&(",*0,'H&."-*#*H&"3&(=*0<#%>',1*'>*%?"*0#,G)*#*$<#--,''1*#(.*#*$#>"I**/,%3',G-*5F*6&-#*J?"4(=*#,"*&(%"=,#%".*&(%'*H"="%#5<"*=,'3&(=*5".-)*3?&$?*-400<F*>''.*%'*%?"*$#>"I

?#*#@=*@'#':#86#)8,'",4&6"3,

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

Z$,)"# D)')2(*'4# )# Q%$2-"7,)*%8# 1:2'-78-*&-62-")$(# 3$0:64# -"&2:8-"3# 2)"8*&)6%# )$&+-'%&'#[2):*# T?%$1%(%$# )"8# )$&+-'%&'*# R+-2-66# T*/)2'#)"8#R+-22-66#=-**%2/-'\4#&)$$-%8#0:'#$%*%)$&+#0"#'+%#-16)&'#0.#*60"')"%0:*4#'%160$)$(#'$)"*.0$1)'-0"*#0.#%?%$(8)(#*6)&%*<#P*#)#&-'(#2)&>-"3#-"#$%3:2)'-0"*#)"8# 10"%(# 8:$-"3# '+%# LWWK*4# Q%$2-"# ,%&)1%# )#

O

AB;",44=&*'#*$',B;,"=<,*5#5=&*

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

Page 7: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!

!"##$%&'('")*&$(+)"(,-&.(/*01*"#23(#&4%")&,#&12(-&$( %&%1%-1%4#23( 5%16( 6%'6( 0#4#02( )+( /"#-1%4%1.( -&$(#78#"%,#&1-1%)&9( ( :6#( "#2*01%&'( !));3( <"!-&(=%)&##"23( %2( -( ,-88%&'( )+( !)11),>*8( 8")?#/12(16-1( 1));(80-/#9(:6#.(/)&/0*$#( 16-1( 16#"#(26)*0$(!#( ,)"#( +0#7%!%0%1.( %&( 16#( 80-&&%&'( 2.21#,( 1)(-//),,)$-1#(1#,8)"-".(*2#2()+(4-/-&1(0-&$(-&$(!*%0$%&'29(

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

F016)*'6(1#,8)"-".(*2#(1-;#2(,-&.(+)",23(16%2(21*$.( +)/*2#2( )&( /),,*&%1.( '-"$#&2( -2( %$#-00.(2*%1#$(1)(1#,8)"-".(*2#Y(56.(16#.(-"#(2)(%,8)"1-&1(-&$()+1#&(2*//#22+*0(%&("#4%1-0%2%&'(*"!-&(-"#-23(-2(-( /6-&&#0( +)"( 8")1#213( #78"#22%)&3( -&$( /"#-1%4%1.3(-&$(,)"#("#/#&10.(1)(,##1(-&(%&/"#-2%&'($#,-&$(+)"(28-/#(+)"(+))$('")5%&'9

Page 8: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!-./$%(017%A3"$',).%)8%B3>+,<%C*-<"%-.#%DE."($$%&

D?"*J?#(=&(=*K#%4,"*'>*+45<&$*L0#$"-*FB'%"*-?%# %&0"01-&# $%3%"%$)'-0"# -"# '+%#1);0$#

&-'-%*#0.#'+%#Z[#+)*#&$%)'%8#)#":1,%$#0.#56$-?)'%2(#0/"%8# 6:,2-&# *6)&%*9# 0$# RTRTI4# )# 108%2# 0.#8%?%2061%"'# '+)'# -*# &0110"# -"# P1%$-&)"# &-'-%*<##@+-*# )$&+-'%&':$)22(72%8# $%8%?%2061%"'# -"*6-$%8#,(#%&0"01-&#6$0*6%$-'(#+)*# $%*:2'%8# -"#*+-"(#,:'#,2)"84#+0103%"-*%8#&%"'$%*#10"-'0$%8#,(#DD@]#)"8# *%&:$-'(# *')..# E# 56%$*0")2-'(7.$%%9# \0"%*# '+)'#$)-*%#A:%*'-0"*#),0:'# '+%#")':$%#0.#6:,2-&#*6)&%#)"8# '+%#60**-,2%#%$0*-0"#0.#6:,2-&# .$%%801*#)"8#*60"')"%-'(<# # @+-*# +)*# 2%8# 1)"(# &011:"-'-%*#'0# $%)&'# ,(# .-3+'-"3# .0$# 10$%# -"?02?%1%"'# -"# '+%#8%&-*-0"#1)>-"3# 6$0&%**%*# )"8# .:':$%# 8%*-3"# 0.#'+%-$#%"?-$0"1%"'4#'0#%"*:$%#'+)'#'+%-$#*'$%%'*#)"8#,:-28-"3*#$%*6%&'#'+%#&+)$)&'%$4#&:2':$%#)"8#+-*'0$(#0.#'+%#62)&%4#)"8#'0#6$0'%&'#?)2:),2%#3$%%"#*6)&%*<#C@+%# 8)"3%$# 0.# 6$-?)'-*)'-0"# -*# '+)'# -'# $%*'$-&'*#)&&%**# '0#62)&%*# '+)'#*+0:28#,%# .0$# '+%#&0110"#3008<# #@+%# .$%%801# '0#10?%#,%'/%%"#*6)&%*#)'#)"(#'-1%#)"8#-"#)"(#0$8%$#-*#,%"%.-&-)2#.0$#%?%$(0"%<##

J#(#,F*M?#,>*789::;*C*+45<&$*('%&$"-*#,"*,"1&(.",-*%?#%*#*$",%#&(*$'."*'>*$'(.4$%*&-*"N0"$%".*&(*%?"-"*0,&H#%"<F*'3(".*-0#$"-

P

@+)'9*#/+(#2)"8*&)6%#62)""%$*#*+0:28#'+-">#),0:'#06%"# *6)&%*# )*# &0"*')"'2(# %?02?-"3# )"8# .:22# 0.#60**-,-2-'-%*GH^%83%*4#JKLL4#6<JXN<##

P"")# =-"'0"# HJKKWN# )2*0# 0,*%$?%*# '+)'# &-'(#8/%22%$*# "%%8# 62)&%*# /+%$%# -'# -*# 60**-,2%# '0# 80#"0'+-"34# %16+)*-\-"3# '+%# "0'-0"# '+)'# &-'-%*# "%%8#$001#.0$#*60"')"%-'(#)"8#.$%%#$%&$%)'-0")2#)&'-?-'(<##I+%# )$3:%*# '+)'# '+%# >%(# '0# &$%)'-"3# +)66-%$4#+%)2'+-%$#62)&%*# -*#"0'# '+$0:3+#)#8%6%"8%"&%#0"#'+%#1)$>%'#)"8#)8?0&)'%*#)806'-"3#)#F:$06%)"4#$)'+%$# '+)"#P1%$-&)"#108%2# '0/)$8*# '+%#&$%)'-0"#0.#6:,2-&#*6)&%<

#CI1)22%$#-"'%$?%"'-0"*4#0"#)#10$%#+:1)"#*&)2%4#/+-&+#)$%#,)*%8#0"#)#/-8%$#*%'#0.#?)2:%*#'+)"#'+%#*-"32%71-"8%8# -8%0203(# 0.# -"&$%)*-"3# 6$06%$'(#6$-&%*4#)$%#10$%# 2->%2(# '0#,$-"3#/-'+# '+%1#)#10$%#8-?%$*%# )"8# 6:,2-&7*6-$-'%8# &:2':$%4# /+-&+# -*# ':"%#/-'+# 20&)2# 6%062%# )"8# &$%)'%*# 10$%# *:&&%**.:2#62)&%*#)*#)#$%*:2'G<#H=-"'0"4#JKKW4#6<LW_N

!F6 G-## ##H2 6# # " %$71) #$ " #!26# #7 % #7' # "+7( #0# +5" 1123#H2 6#!"#/% 123# 1%+2 #+ # ( $8123#+ #

"%*123.##I ) # /% "-#$ #$## 8/$2 )+## ##8+: # -"#8+: #+5 .##J' "#$ #$# #' # 1%&( K.#"#$%&'()*+,--.

““

Page 9: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

Q

L'4%?5#(G*6'(.'(*789::;*C*,"=#,.".*#-*#*%,4<F*045<&$*-0#$"*%?#%*"($'4,#="-*&(%",#$%&'()*.&H",-&%F*#(.*"(=#="1"(%*&(*,"$,"#%&'(#<*#$%&H&%&"-I

J#(#,F*M?#,>*789::;*C*E("*'>*%?"*>&,-%*1#@',*0,&H#%"<F*'3(".*045<&$*-0#$"-)*&%*&-*-1#,%)*',.",".*#(.*-#(&%&O".I

/((&H",-#,F*'>*%?"*P"-%&H#<*'>*Q,&%#&(*789::;*C*%?"*-0#$"-*#,'4(.*%?"*L'4%?5#(G*J"(%,"*#,"*%,#(->',1".*%'*#$$'11'.#%"*#*,#(="*'>*#$%&H&%&"-/5'H"R*#*-0#$"*%'*-&%)*1""%*#(.*5"*"(%",%#&(".Q"<'3R*#*%"10',#,F*,''>*=#,."(*0,'H&."-*-'1"3?","*,"<#N&(=*%'*-&%

Page 10: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

C@+%#*1)22%$#8%')-2*#0.#6:,2-&#62)&%*#'+)'#3-?%#)#62)&%#6%$*0")2-'(#)$%#,%-"3#%$)*%8#,(#320,)2-\%8#&011%$&%#)"8#320,)2-\%8#2)"8*&)6%#)$&+-'%&':$%4#62)""-"3# $:2%*# )"8# &08%*# 0.# &0"8:&'<# # R:,2-&#*6)&%#-*#-"&$%)*-"32(#)"08("%#E#'+%#$02%#0.#6%062%4#0:$#$02%4#-*#%B6%&'%8#'0#1-1-&#'+)'#0.#'+%#*'-&>#1%"#32:%8#'0#)"#)$&+-'%&'9*#108%2<<<G#H`%("028*4#JKKW4#6<MMN<

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

@+-*# &+)"3-"3# ")':$%# 0.# 6:,2-&S6$-?)'%# *6)&%#+)*#2%8#*01%#6$)&'-'-0"%$*#-"#:$,)"#62)""-"3#)"8#2)"8*&)6%# )$&+-'%&':$%# '0# %B620$%# "%/# /)(*# 0.#$%&2)-1-"3#6:,2-&#*6)&%#E#'+%*%#6$)&'-&%*#-"&2:8%#)$&+-'%&'*4# 2)"8*&)6%# )$&+-'%&'*4# )$'-*'*# )"8#62)""%$*# /+0# &+)22%"3%# '+%# '$)8-'-0")2# '06780/"#)66$0)&+# '0# &-'(# 62)""-"34# )"8# /+0# )$%# 200>-"3#.0$#/)(*#'0#-"'$08:&%#*60"')"%-'(#)"8#-"8-?-8:)2-'(#,)&>#-"'0#0:$#6:,2-&#*6)&%*<##

T"%# *:&+# 6$)&'-&%# -*# `%,)$# -"# '+%# Z"-'%8#I')'%*4# )# 1:2'-8-*&-62-")$(# 6$)&'-&%# 0.# 8%*-3"%$*#)"8# 2)"8*&)6%# )$&+-'%&'*4# /+0# &01,-"%# )$'# )"8#)&'-?-*1# '0# 5$%1-B9# *'$:&':$%*# )"8# %2%1%"'*# 0.#'+%#:$,)"#2)"8*&)6%4# -"#0$8%$#'0#A:%*'-0"#*+)$%8#)**:16'-0"*#),0:'# '+%-$#:*%<# #FB620$-"3# '+%# -8%)#0.#80B)#)"8#+),-':*#,(#a$%"&+#*0&-0203-*'#R-%$$%#Q0:$8-%:# H=%$>%$4# JKLK4# 6<bWN# '+)'# -"8-?-8:)2*#80# "0'# '%"8# '0# )*6-$%# '0#/+)'# -*# "0'# )?)-2),2%# '0#'+%14#`%,)$#8%*-3"*# -"'%$?%"'-0"*# '+)'#)&'#)*#)"#-"'%$$:6'-0"#0.#+),-':*4#&+)22%"3-"3#0:$#%B6%&')'-0"#0.# +0/# *6)&%*# -"# '+%# 2)"8*&)6%# )$%# :*%84# )"8#6$0;%&'-"3# )# "%/# *%'# 0.# ?)2:%*# 0"'0# '+%1# E# .0$#

Q,"#G&(=*%?"*!4<"-*

0R

Q"<'3R*D?"*',&=&(#<*+/!B7&(=;*S#F*7899T;*C*&(-%#<<#%&'(*5F*!"5#,*&(*L#(*P,#($&-$'*899TI*L&($"*%?"(*%?"*&."#*?#-*5""(*#.'0%".*#(.*."H"<'0".*&(*$&%&"-*#$,'--*%?"*3',<.*&($<4.&(=*6'(.'(*#(.*6"".-*#-*0"'0<"*>&(.*$,"#%&H"*3#F-*%'*,"$<#&1*%?"*-%,""%-I

%B)162%# ':$"-"3# )# 6)$>-"3# *6)&%# -"'0# )# 1-"-#6)$># H6)$>H-"3N# *6)&%N<# @+%# -8%)# 0.# R)$>H-"3N#c)(#+)*#,%%"#)806'%8# -"#&-'-%*#)$0:"8#'+%#/0$28#)"8# -"?02?%*# 6%062%# '$)"*.0$1-"3# '+%# .:"&'-0"#0.# )# 6)$>-"3# ,)(# .0$# '+%# 2%"3'+# 0.# '-1%# '+)'# '+%(#+)?%# 6)-8# .0$# '+%# *6)&%<# # O-'+# '+%# -"&$%)*%# -"#R$-?)'%2(#T/"%8#R:,2-&#I6)&%*4#`%,)$#A:%*'-0"*#+0/# 6:,2-&# '+%*%# *6)&%*# $%)22(# )$%# )"8# -"-'-)'%8#'+%# %B6%$-1%"')2# 6$0;%&'# D0110"*6)&%# -"# I)"#a$)"&-*&0# '0# %B620$%# '+%*%# -8%)*<# @+%# 6$0;%&'#-"?02?%8#1)66-"3# )"8# 80&:1%"'-"3# '+%# *6)&%*4#3)'+%$-"3# 8)')# 0"# Lb# *-'%*<# # @+%(# '+%"# :*%8# )#6%$.0$1)"&%# )$'*# 3$0:6# '0# C)&'-?)'%G# '+%# *-'%*#/-'+#)#*%$-%*#0.#C6)$).0$1)"&%*G<# #T"%# -160$')"'#)*6%&'# 0.# '+-*# /)*# "0'# 0"2(# '0# 8%'%$1-"%# 6:,2-&#$%)&'-0"4# ,:'# )2*0# '0# %B620$%# '+%# %B'%"'# '0# /+-&+#6$-?)'%#0/"%$*#:"8%$*'008#/+)'#/)*#%B6%&'%8#0.#'+%1#-"#'%$1*#0.#6:,2-&#6$0?-*-0"<#

Page 11: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!-./$%(02F()9%+-(G";$<-+"%9-$'"(%*+-..,.G%')%9,<();'-(G"',.G

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`%,)$N4#/+-2%#0'+%$*#*%%>#'0#,$-"3#),0:'#)#10$%#6)$'-&-6)'-?%# $%3%"%$)'-0"#6$0&%**# '0# :$,)"#)$%)*<##@+%#-8%)*#,%+-"8#:$,)"#)&:6:"&':$%#%B'%"8#'0#1)66-"3#/+02%#)$%)*#'0#8%&-8%#/+-&+#)$%)*#'0#5-16$0?%9#0$#5+%)29<

=)"(# 0.# '+%*%# ,0''017:6# 6$0;%&'*# )$%# 2%8# ,(#&022),0$)'-?%# 6$)&'-&%*# '+)'# &01,-"%# )$&+-'%&'*4#2)"8*&)6%# )$&+-'%&'*# )"8# 0'+%$# 8%*-3"%$*<# # !"#)88-'-0"# '0# `%,)$# 6$)&'-&%*# 2->%# =:.4# FB(\'4# PPP#HP'%2-%$# 89)$&+-'%&':$%# ):'03d$d%N# )"8# O)(/)$8#R2)"'*#/0$>#:"8%$#'+%#:1,$%22)#0.#')&'-&)2#:$,)"-*1#0$# :$,)"# )&:6:"&':$%# -"-'-)'-"3# -"'%$?%"'-0"*# '+)'#1)(# )&'# )*# )# &)')2(*'# .0$# $%?-')2-*)'-0"4# *'-1:2)'%#&011:"-'(#&0+%*-0"#)"8#)'#'+%#*)1%#'-1%#,%"%.-'#

'+%#%"?-$0"1%"'#,0'+#)%*'+%'-&)22(#)"8#%&0203-&)22(<#@+%*%#6$)&'-&%*#+)?%#0"%#'+-"3#-"#&0110"#E#'+%(#*%%># '0# %160/%$# &-'-\%"*# '0# A:%*'-0"# '+%-$# $-3+'#'0#6:,2-&#*6)&%#)"8#+0/# -'#*+0:28#,%#:*%8<# #@+%#")':$%# 0.# '+%*%# '(6%*# 0.# )$&+-'%&':$)2# 6$)&'-&%# -*#'+)'# '+%(#.0&:*#0"#&$%)'-"3#&0"8-'-0"*#$)'+%$# '+)"#-160*-"3# )# ?-*-0"<# # e)$8%"-"3# -*# 0.'%"# &+0*%"#)*# -'# -*# )# *-162%# :"-?%$*)2# )&'-?-'(# E# 6%062%# ;0-"#-"# $%3)$82%**# 0.# )3%# 0$# ,)&>3$0:"8# E# )"8# -'# +)*#'+%#)88%8#)8?)"')3%#0.#,$-"3-"3#6%062%#&20*%$#'0#")':$%<#=)>-"3#6$0;%&'*#*%2.7*:*')-"-"3#'+$0:3+#'+%#:*%#0.#&0160*'-"34#*02)$#6)"%2*#%'&<#&0"'$-,:'%*#'0#)#6$0&%**#0.#%"?-$0"1%"')2#%8:&)'-0"<

@+%#&022),0$)'-?%#/0$>#0.#P'%2-%$#89)$&+-'%&':$%#):'03%$d%# HI':8-0# .0$# *%2.71)")3%8# )$&+-'%&':$%N#')>%*# )# ')&'-&)2# )66$0)&+# '0# :$,)"-*14#&022),0$)'-"3# /-'+# 20&)2# $%*-8%"'*# '0# *%2.71)")3%#6$0;%&'*4# '+$0:3+# '+%# '%160$)$(# '$)"*.0$1)'-0"#0.# 8-*:*%8# :$,)"# *6)&%*<# # FDT,0B# -*# )# 10,-2%#5$+-\01)'-&9# 3)$8%"# )"8# .008# 3$0/-"3# 6$0;%&'#&0"*'$:&'%8# .$01# 6)22%'*4# /+-&+# /)*# 0$-3-")22(#20&)'%8# -"#)"#)$%)#0.# -"800$#)"8#0:'800$#*6)&%*#-"#)#8%$%2-&'#$)-2#()$8#-"#"0$'+%$"#R)$-*<##P20"3*-8%#'+%# 3)$8%"*4# 10,-2%# 108:2%*# 6$0?-8%# )# >-'&+%"4#'002,0B4#1%8-)#%A:-61%"'#)"8#2-,$)$(#'0#%"&0:$)3%#0'+%$# &022%&'-?%# *0&-)2# )&'-?-'-%*<# @+%# 6$0;%&'# /)*#%?%"':)22(# .0$&%8# '0# 10?%# )"8# '+0*%# -"?02?%8#"%30'-)'%8# )# "%/# 20&)'-0"<# # !'*# *'$:&':$%# 1%)"'#'+)'# -'# &0:28# ,%# 8-*1)"'2%8# )"8# $%7-"*')22%8# '+:*#%"*:$-"3#'+%#&0"'-":-'(#0.#*0&-)2#"%'/0$>*#&$%)'%8<##

///*U$'5'N*+#,&-*789::;

/*.&>>","(%*%F0"*'>*0,#$%&$"

00

Page 12: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

U-%'('"-'<#,*+,'@"$%*&(*L#,#='--#)*L0#&(*7L'-%"(&5<"*89::;

0;

@+%#/0$>#8%10"*'$)'%*#)#6$0&%**#0.#%160/%$-"3#&-'(# 8/%22%$*# '0# )66$06$-)'%# *6)&%# .0$# &022%&'-?%#:*%4#)"8#)#*'(2%#0.#)$&+-'%&':$%#'+)'#&+)22%"3%*#'+%#'$)8-'-0")2# $02%*#0.#&2-%"'#)"8#,:83%'<#@+-*# .2%B-,2%#)"8# $%?%$*-,2%# :*%#0.# *6)&%#)-1*# '0#6$%*%$?%#)"#C:$,)"#,-08-?%$*-'(G#,(#6$010'-"3#'+%#&07%B-*'%"&%#0.#8-..%$%"'#2-.%*'(2%*#)"8#2-?-"3#6$)&'-&%*<#

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

!"# '+%# .0$1%$# -"8:*'$-)2# '0/"# 0.# =)38%,:$3#F)*'%$"# e%$1)"(4# -'# -*# +06%8# '+)'# '+%# 06%"7)-$#2-,$)$(#/-22#)&'#)*#)#&)')2(*'# .0$# $%?-')2-*)'-0"<# #@+%#6$0;%&'# 2%8# ,(# [)$0# )"8# P$&+-'%>':$# f# "%'\/%$>#)$&+-'%&':$)2#6$)&'-&%*#*')$'%8#0:'#)*#)"#%B6%$-1%"'#'0# $%-"*')'%# '+%# 2-,$)$(# )"8# -"?02?%8# )#6$0&%**# 0.#/0$>*+06*#)"8#%?%"'*#'0#$%-".0$&%#*0&-)2#"%'/0$>*<##P# '$-)2# 2-.%7*-\%#108%2#/)*#&0"*'$:&'%8#:*-"3#,%%$#&$)'%*# )"8# -'*# *:&&%**# $%*:2'%8# -"# 30?%$"1%"'#.:"8-"3# '0# ,:-28# )# 10$%# 6%$1)"%"'# .)&-2-'(<# # @+%#6$0;%&'# -*# "0/#1)")3%8# ,(# '+%# &011:"-'(4# /+0#)2*0# ')&>2%# 6$0,2%1*# 2->%# ?)"8)2-*1<# # Q:-2'# .$01#$%&(&2%8# 1)'%$-)2*# '+%# &0"*'$:&'-0"# 6$0?%*# '+)'#-'# -*# 60**-,2%# '0# &$%)'%# %B&-'-"3# )$&+-'%&':$%# /-'+#2-1-'%8#$%*0:$&%*#)"8#'+)'# 56)$'-&-6)'-?%9#80%*#"0'#"%&%**)$-2(#+-"8%$#0$-3-")2#)"8#8(")1-&#8%*-3"<#

Y0&)2# &08%# ,(# U-&+02)*# 8%# =0"&+):B# /)*#)# &016%'-'-0"# %"'$(# 6$060*-"3# '+%# :*%# 0.# e!I#*0.'/)$%#'0#6-"60-"'#6:,2-&2(#0/"%8#"%32%&'%8#*-'%*#-"#ZI#&-'-%*#)*#6)$'#0.#)#*'$)'%3-&#/)(# '0# -16$0?%#3$%%"# -".$)*'$:&':$%# )88$%**-"3# %"?-$0"1%"')2#-**:%*# )20"3*-8%# '+%# &$%)'-0"# 0.# ?)2:),2%# 3$%%"#*6)&%*<# # @+%# 6$0;%&'# 20&)'%*# gKK# *-'%*# -"# I)"#a$)"&-*&0# %A:-?)2%"'# '0# ),0:'# '/07'+-$8*# '+%#*-\%# 0.# e028%"# e)'%# R)$>4# I)"# a$)"&-*&09*#2)$3%*'#6)$>4#)"8#A:%*'-0"*# '+%#"0'-0"# '+)'#:$,)"#

V'.",(*D"$?('<'=F*#(.*L%,#%"=&$*V#00&(=

$%3%"%$)'-0"# -*# ),0:'# $%,:-28-"3# %"'-$%# 8-*'$-&'*<#@+%# 6$0;%&'# *:33%*'*# '+)'# ')$3%'-"3# 6)$'*# 0.#*'$%%'*4#%16'(#,:-28-"3*#)"8#?)&)"'#20'*#)220/*#.0$#)# 10$%# *:*')-"),2%4# 8%10&$)'-&4# )"8# %&0203-&)2#8%?%2061%"'<#!"#)88-'-0"#'0#6)$>*#)"8#*A:)$%*#)*#8%*'-")'-0"#*6)&%*4#$%*-8%"'*#,%"%.-'#.$01#)#*%$-%*#0.#C1-&$076)$>*G#&20*%$#'0#/+%$%#'+%(#2-?%#)"8#/0$>#H[)(%4#JKLLN<

P#*':8(#,(#P$&+-'%&'*#^%$")"8%\#)"8#D)*)"0?)#HJKLLN#%B620$%*#'+%#-8%)#0.#*'$)'%3-&#56:,2-&#*6)&%#)&:6:"&':$%94#'+%#-162%1%"')'-0"#0.#20/7&0*'#/0$>*#'+)'#+)?%#)#60*-'-?%#-16)&'#0"#&-'(#2-.%<##FB)162%*#-"&2:8%# I)$)30**)9*# 5F*'0"0%*:"*02)$9# 6$0;%&'4#/+%$%# )$%)*#0.# "%32%&'#/%$%#1)66%8#)&$0**# '+%#&-'(#)"8#)#*%$-%*#0.# 2)"8*&)6%# -"'%$?%"'-0"*#/%$%#&)$$-%8#0:'#,(# -"'$08:&-"3#,%"&+%*4#62)"'-"3#)"8#62)(# %A:-61%"'# '0# '+%# %16'(# *6)&%*<# R20'*#/%$%#*%2%&'%8#)&&0$8-"3#'0#20&)'-0"#.0$#3$%)'%*'#-16)&'<##@+%*%#62)&%*#,%&01%#)#"%/#.0&:*#0.#)&'-?-'(4#'+:*#&0"'$-,:'-"3# '0# '+%# $%?-')2-*)'-0"# 6$0&%**<# T"# '+%#.0$1%$#D)$2*,%$3# *-'%# -"#D06%"+)3%"# )# *%$-%*# 0.#)&'-?-'-%*# )"8# -"*')22)'-0"*# %"&0:$)3%# :*%# 0.# '+%#*-'%# -"# )# $%&$%)'-0")2# /)(# :"'-2# %&0"01-&*# )220/#8%?%2061%"'# '0#6$0&%%84# '+:*#,$-"3-"3# 2-.%# '0# '+%#)$%)# )+%)8# 0.# '+%# &0"*'$:&'-0"# /0$><# @+%# .:':$%#8-2%11)#.0$#1)"(#&-'-%*# -*#/+%'+%$#)"8#+0/#'+%(#&)"# %"&0:$)3%# 6$-?)'%# 8%?%206%$*# '0# '%160$)$-2(#$%2%)*%# 620'*# /+-2%# '+%(# *')"8# %16'(# )"8# )220/#'+%1#'0#,%#:*%8<

Page 13: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

0B

V#=."54,=*E0"(C#&,*<&5,#,F*7L$?<#1#(()*899W;IQ">',"*#(.*/>%",R*/*%"10',#,F*&(-%#<<#%&'(*54&<%*3&%?*5"",*$,#%"-*3#-*."H"<'0".*&(%'*#*1',"*0",1#("(%*-'<4%&'(

6">%R*J#,<-5",=*Q,"3",F*!"."H<'01"(%*LX%"*789:9;D"10',#,F*&(-%#<<#%&'(-*'(*%?"*>',1",*J#,<-5",=*-&%"*&(*J'0"(?#="(*"($'4,#="*#$%&H&%F*#(.*?"<0*H&%#<&-"*%?"*#,"#*3?&<"*."H"<'01"(%*&-*-%#<<".I

Q"<'3R*L$"(%".*=#,."()*?#,5'4,*>,'(%)*J'0"(?#="(*789:9;*D?"*=#,."(*3#-*"-%#5<&-?".*5F*0"'0<"*&(*%?"*<'$#<*("&=?5'4,?''.*#-*0#,%*'(*"N0",&1"(%#<*0,'@"$%*%'*&(H&=',#%"*%?"*?#,5'4,*>,'(%I**D?"*=#,."(*$#(*5"*,"<'$#%".*%'*?"<0*&(-0&,"*=,'3%?*&(*'%?",*("&=?5'4,?''.-I

Page 14: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!-./$%(03H3"((,++-%G-(#".,.G%;%,++,<,'%<3+',0-',).%-.#%

-**()*(,-',).%)8%+-.#

P2'+0:3+# 3:%$$-22)# 3)$8%"-"3# -*# "0'# )# "%/#6+%"01%"0"#-'#+)*#)''$)&'%8#)#20'#0.#1%8-)#)''%"'-0"#-"# '+%# 2)*'# 8%&)8%<# T.'%"# $%3)$8%8# )*# 602-'-&)22(#10'-?)'%84#-'#+)*#%?02?%8#-"'0#)#$%*6%&'),2%#+0,,(4#)"8#/-'+#'+%#$-*%#0.#'+%#-"'%$"%'#)"8#*0&-)2#"%'/0$>-"3#*-'%*#-'#+)*#,%&01%#%)*-%$#.0$#6%062%#'0#*+)$%#'+%-$#5/0$>9#)"8#%B6%$-%"&%*<#@+%#6:,2-&)'-0"#0.#`-&+)$8#`%("028*9#,00>#5T"#e:%$$-22)#e)$8%"-"394#)20"3*-8%#'+%# *:&&%**# 0.# +-*# /%,*-'%4# +)*# +-3+2-3+'%8# '+%#":1,%$# 0.# 6%062%# 6$%6)$%8# '0# 3-?%# '+%-$# 0/"#'-1%#)"8#10"%(# '0# '$)"*.0$1#)$%)*#0.#"%32%&'# -"#'+%-$#&-'-%*<##!"#)88-'-0"#'0#60*-"3#A:%*'-0"*#),0:'#0/"%$*+-6#)"8#)66$06$-)'-0"#0.#6:,2-&#*6)&%4#'+%#6$)&'-&%# 0.# 3:%$$-22)# 3)$8%"-"3# +-3+2-3+'*# -**:%*#$)"3-"3#.$01#8-**)'-*.)&'-0"#0.#600$2(#62)"'%8#)"8#

#Ce)$8%"-"3#-*#)#?-?-8#.0$1#0.#%B6$%**-0"<##c0-"3#-'#-"#6:,2-&4#0"#2)"8#'+)'#-*#"0'#(0:$*4#*%"8*#)"#%?%"#*'$0"3%$# 1%**)3%<# # I0&-%'(# "%%8*# '+-*# >-"8# 0.#&$%)'-?-'(GH`%("028*4# JKKW4# 6<MMN<# @+%# 10'-?)'-0"#'0# ')>%# 0"# 3:%$$-22)# 3)$8%"-"3# 0.'%"# *'%1*# .$01#.$:*'$)'-0"#E#'$(-"3#'0#3%'#*01%'+-"3#80"%#'+$0:3+#'+%# ):'+0$-'-%*# -"?02?%*# *0#1:&+# $%8# ')6%4# .0$17.-22-"34# 3$)"'# )662-&)'-0"*4# )"8# +%)2'+# )"8# *).%'(#-**:%*#E# -'# -*#1:&+#%)*-%$#'0#*-162(#3%'#0:'#'+%$%#)"8# 80# '+%# /0$><# e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`%("028*4#JKKWN<#I1)22#)&'*#0.#3:%$$-22)#3)$8%"-"3#

UN0,"--&'(

0E

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h# '+%(#)$%# 0.'%"# *60"')"%0:*# )"8# .2%%'-"34# ,:'# $%.2%&'#)# 3$0/-"3# 10?%1%"'# 0.# &-'(# 8/%22%$*# /+0# .%%2#%160/%$%8# '0# 62)(# )# $02%# -"# *+)6-"3# '+%-$# 20&)2#2)"8*&)6%<

Page 15: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

0L

P*#'+%#")1%#*:33%*'*#3:%$$-22)#3)$8%"-"3#-*#)#'(6%#0.# 5/)$.)$%9#)"8#/-'+# '+)'#&01%*#*'$)'%3(4# ')&'-&*#)"8#0$3)"-*)'-0"<##O-'+#&)16)-3"*#2->%#5R-16#V0:$#R)?%1%"'9#`-&+)$8#`%("028*#$)22-%*#6%062%#'0#3%'#0:'#)"8#3)$8%"#-"#'+%#*'$%%'#-"#)#10$%#0$3)"-*%8#/)(<#Y)"8*&)6%#)$&+-'%&'#̂ %)'+%$#̀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`-"34#JKKW4##6<iWN<@+-*#3:%$$-22)#3$%%",%2'# $%*60"8*# '0# '+%# -8%)# 0.# 1)66-"3# '+%#&-'(#.0$#0660$':"-'-%*#.0$#60'%"'-)2#-"'%$?%"'-0"4#)"8#%"&0:$)3%*#)#&0"'-":0:*#)"8#3$0/-"3#"%'/0$>#0.#"%/#-8%)*#)"8#&$%)'-?-'(<

!#<<F&(=*%?"*D,''0-

6">%R*Y4",,&<<#*Y#,."(&(=)*Q,4(-3&$G*+<#$")*

6'(.'(*789::;

!&=?%R*Q'((&(=%'(*LZ4#,")*6'(.'(*C*D?"*+<"#-4,"*Y#,."(*#(.*+#,#.&-"*+,'@"$%*789::;E,&=&(#<<F*#(*#$%*'>*=4",,&<<#*=#,."(&(=*'(*#*0&"$"*'>*3#-%"<#(.)*#*$'114(&%F*=#,."(*3#-*"-%#5<&-?".*3&%?*%?"*-400',%*'>*%?"*<'$#<*#4%?',&%FI*D?"*+#,#.&-"*+,'@"$%*"N%"(.-*%?"*0<#(%&(=*'(%'*%?"*0#H"1"(%-*%'*=,""(*%?"*-4,,'4(.&(=*("&=?5'4,?''.I

&)"#)2*0#6$016'#0'+%$#*&+%1%*4#.0$#%B)162%#'+%#F8-,2%#Q:*#I'06#6$0;%&'# -"#Y)1,%'+#/)*#-"*6-$%8#,(#3:%$$-22)#3)$8%"-"3#6$0;%&'*#-"#'+%#)$%)<##!"#)"#:$,)"#%"?-$0"1%"'#'+)'#*%%1*#'0#,%# -"&$%)*-"32(#$%*'$-&'%84# /-'+# *-3"*# %?%$(/+%$%# '%22-"3# 6%062%#/+)'#"0'# '0#804#3:%$$-22)#3)$8%"-"3# -*#)# $%1-"8%$#0.# /+)'# '+%(# &)"# 80# '0# 60*-'-?%2(# -16$0?%# '+%-$#%"?-$0"1%"'4# )"8# 10*'# -160$')"'2(# -'# $)-*%*#'+%# 8%,)'%# ),0:'# 6:,2-&# *6)&%# )"8# .$%%801# 0.#%B6$%**-0"#/-'+-"#'+)'#*6)&%<

Page 16: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!-./$%(04F()9%,++,<,'%')%'"9*)(-(1%G-(#".$%IE,'=%

*"(9,$$,).J

@+%# F)*'%$"# D:$?%# e)$8%"# -"# c)2*'0"4# F)*'#Y0"80"# /)*# ,:-2'# -"# $%*60"*%# '0# '+%# .-3+'# ,(#'+%# 20&)2# &011:"-'(# .0$# 10$%# 3$%%"# *6)&%# )"8#0660*-'-0"#'0#/+)'#'+%(#$%3)$8%8#)*#5-")66$06$-)'%9#8%?%2061%"'#)*#6)$'#0.# '+%# $%3%"%$)'-0"#6$0&%**#)"8# 6$%6)$)'-0"# .0$# Y0"80"# T2(16-&*<# # =);0$#$%8%?%2061%"'#/0$>#)'#c)2*'0"#j:"&'-0"4#-"&2:8-"3#)#"%/#*')'-0"#)"8#"%/#+0:*-"3#,(#Q)$$)''#^01%*4#'$-33%$%8# )# *&)2%# 0.# &+)"3%# *0# +:3%# '+)'# -'# /)*#1%'#/-'+#+0*'-2-'(#,(#20&)2#&011:"-'-%*<##P#&:2':$)2#c%?%2061%"'#'%)1#$%*60"8%8#/-'+#)#6$03$)11%#0.# 6)$'-&-6)'0$(# )$'# 6$0;%&'*# -"# %B-*'-"3# 6:,2-&#*6)&%*#-"#)"#)''%16'#'0#)22%?-)'%#'+%#8-*$:6'-0"#)"8#,:-28#60*-'-?%#$%2)'-0"*+-6*<

P*# )# '%160$)$(# -"*')22)'-0"# .0$# '+%# Q)$,-&)"9*#`)8-&)2#U)':$%#FB+-,-'-0"4#'+%#a$%"&+#)$&+-'%&':$)2#&022%&'-?%# FkVl@# /)*# &011-**-0"%8# '0# &$%)'%#c)2*'0"#=-22#E#)#.:"&'-0"-"3#/-"81-224#/+-&+#&0:28#3$-"8#/+%)'#3$0/"#0"#*-'%#-"'0#.20:$#)"8#3%"%$)'%#%"%$3(# .0$#)# $%*-8%"'#,)>%$# '0# $:"#)#,$%)8#0?%"<#@+%#1-22#)''$)&'%8#Lb4iKK#?-*-'0$*4#10*'2(#.$01#'+%#-11%8-)'%#)"8#*:$$0:"8-"3#)$%)*<

@+%# 0:'&01%*# 0.# '+%# 6$0;%&'# /%$%# )**%**%8#,(#P$'# -"#@+%#T6%"#)"8#'+%(#&0"&2:8%8#'+)'#C'+%#*:&&%**#0.#'+-*#-"-'-)'-?%#3)?%#20&)2#6%062%#)#60*-'-?%#%B6%$-%"&%#0.#&+)"3%<##!'#8%10"*'$)'%8#?-?-82(#+0/#'%160$)$(#-"'%$?%"'-0"*#&)"#)2'%$#'+%#6%$&%6'-0"#0.#62)&%#)"8#-"*'-2#"%/#)1,-'-0"<##@+%#-"*')22)'-0"#/0$>#+)*#*-"&%# 2%8#0"# '0#)#&011-**-0"-"3#0660$':"-'(#.0$#FkVl@#'0#8%*-3"#)"8#-"*')22#)#'%160$)$(#6)?-2-0"#.0$#'+%#F)*'%$"#D:$?%4#/+-&+#/-22#)220/#20&)2#6%062%#'0#:*%#'+-*#$%&2)-1%8#*6)&%#)*#)#?%":%#.0$#)&'-?-'-%*#)22#(%)$#$0:"84GHP$'-"'+%06%"4#JKLLN<

=)>-"3#I6)&%#-"#c)2*'0"4#)#mL#1-22-0"#-"-'-)'-?%#.:"8%8# ,(# c%*-3"# .0$# Y0"80"4# /)*# *%'# :6# )*# )#*%$-%*#0.#1-&$0#6$0;%&'*#.0220/-"3#)#1)66-"3#*':8(#,(#1:.#)$&+-'%&':$%#)"8#2)"8*&)6%#)$&+-'%&'*#jnY#e-,,0"*<# !'# -"?02?%8# %B620$-"3# 60**-,2%# 0:'800$#*6)&%*# '0# *-'%# &:2':$)2# )&'-?-'-%*<# # P# 6$03$)11%#0.#&011:"-'(#%"3)3%1%"'# .0220/%8#)"8#6$0;%&'*#

@+%#.0220/-"3#&+)6'%$#')>%*#)#&20*%$#200>#)'#'/0#'%160$)$(#&011:"-'(#3)$8%"*#-"#Y0"80"4#,0'+#*1)227*&)2%#6$0;%&'*#:*-"3#?)&)"'#8%?%2061%"'#2)"8#-"#8%"*%2(#606:2)'%8#)$%)*4#)"8#-22:*'$)'-"3#)#>-"8#0.#:$,)"#)&:6:"&':$%#$%*:2'-"3#.$01#&022),0$)'-?%#6$)&'-&%<#

V#G&(=*L0#$"*&(*S#<-%'(+,'%"-%*#(.*,"-0'(-"*%'*,"="(",#%&'(

$)"3%8# .$01# '%160$)$(# -"*')22)'-0"*# '0# 1)>-"3#*:,'2%#2)"8*&)6%#-16$0?%1%"'*#E#6)?-"34#*-3")3%#)"8#2-3+'-"3<#@+%#F)*'%$"#D:$?%#3)$8%"#8%?%206%8#)$0:"8# '+%# "%/# 6)?-2-0"# 0$# 5Q)$"94# .0220/-"3# '+%#*:&&%**# 0.# '+%# 1-22<# # @+%# Q)$"# /)*# &0"*'$:&'%8#,(# 20&)2# )66$%"'-&%*# -"#6)$'"%$*+-6#/-'+#^)&>"%(#D011:"-'(#D022%3%<

@+%# c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c)2*'0"#)"8#TZ@#-"# !*02)4# '0# %"&0:$)3%# )# ,0''017:64# 6)$'-&-6)'-?%#6$0&%**#-"#.:':$%#8%?%2061%"'<##!"#,0'+#&)*%*#20&)2#$%*-8%"'*#&+)22%"3%#'+%#'06780/"#-"'%$6$%')'-0"#0.#53$%%"9# # 7# !*02)# -*# '+%# *-'%# .0$# Q0%$-# I':8-09*# '$%%#&0?%$%8# '0/%$*# C]%$'-&)2# a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c)2*'0"#6$0;%&'#)''%16'*#'0# $%8$%**# '+-*<# Q0'+# &011:"-'-%*# )2*0# .0:3+'# '0#$%')-"# ,:-28-"3*# Hc)2*'0"# '+%)'$%Sa0:$# )&$%*#D2:,#)"8#!*02)#P$'#D%"'%$N4#'+)'#'+%(#.%2'#$%6$%*%"'%8#'+%#?-*-0"#)"8#-8%"'-'(#0.#'+%#6%062%#)"8#62)&%<

O+-2%# &011:"-'-%*# )$%# $)$%2(# ),2%# '0# +)2'#$%8%?%2061%"'#62)"*4#'+%*%#6$0;%&'*#8%10"*'$)'%#)"# %160/%$-"3# 0.# &011:"-'-%*# '0# &+)22%"3%# '+%#

0O

Page 17: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

0S

Q"<'3*<">%R*Q'-$'*2",%&$#<"[2",%&$#<*P',"-%*V&<#(*7Q'",&)*899\;Q"<'3*,&=?%R*S,"--".*&(*Y,""(*789:8;*K"3*."H"<'01"(%*0,'0'-#<-*>',*S#<-%'(*

6$0&%**<##@+%#-8%)*4#$%2)'-0"*+-6*#)"8#%B6%$-%"&%*#,0$"#0:'#0.#'+%*%#&011:"-'(#6$0;%&'*#&0"'-":%#'0#62)(#)"#-160$')"'#$02%4#%?%"#-.# -"#)#10$%#'$)"*-%"'#.0$1<# # @+%#F)*'%$"#D:$?%#e)$8%"#,$-83%*# )#3)6#,%'/%%"# 6)*'# )"8# .:':$%4# ,%'/%%"# 8%$%2-&'-0"#)"8# $%3%"%$)'-0"<#c%*6-'%# -'*# '%160$)$(# ")':$%# -'#&0"'-":%*#'0#3$0/#)"8#.20:$-*+4#)"8#'+%#2)'%*'#62)"#-*# '0#,:-28#)#3$%%"+0:*%#0$# 5R-"%)662%#^0:*%9# '0#6$0?-8%#10$%#*6)&%#.0$#&011:"-'(#)&'-?-'-%*#8:$-"3#'+%#/-"'%$#)"8#.0$#3$0/-"3<

@+%# c)2*'0"# 6$0;%&'# -*# "0/# ,%-"3# $%&03"-\%8#")'-0")22(4# )"8# +)*# $%&%"'2(# 6-&>%8# :6# )# ":1,%$#0.# )/)$8*# -"&2:8-"3# 0"%# .$01# '+%# Y)"8*&)6%#!"*'-':'%<# CjnY#e-,,0"*4# -"# &022),0$)'-0"#/-'+#1:.#)$&+-'%&':$%S)$'4#/%$%# $%&03"-*%8# .0$# *:&&%**.:22(#&$%)'-"3# ,%''%$# A:)2-'(# 6:,2-&# *6)&%# /+-2*'#C)?0-8-"3#"%-3+,0:$+008#*)"-'-*)'-0"G<#@+%#;:83%*#*)-8h# C@+-*# -*# )# *'$->-"32(# 3$)&%.:2# )66$0)&+# '0#:"8%$*')"8-"3#)"#)$%)4#)"8#*%'*#)#108%2#.0$#+0/#-'#*+0:28#,%#80"%<G#Q(#$%*-*'-"3#'+%#'$)8-'-0")2#5'06780/"9# )66$0)&+# '+%# 6$)&'-&%# &+0*%# -"*'%)8# '0#/0$>#?%$(#&20*%2(#/-'+#20&)2#$%*-8%"'*4#,:*-"%**%*#)"8#0$3)"-*)'-0"*# '0#8%?%206#)# *+)$%8# ?-*-0"# .0$#$%3%"%$)'-0"<#@+%# ;:83%*#)88%8h#C@+%# 2)"8*&)6%#)$&+-'%&'*# %"&0:$)3%8# 20&)2# 6)$'"%$*# '0# ')>%#0/"%$*+-6# 0.# '+%# 6$0;%&'*G4# HY)"8*&)6%# !"*'-':'%#JKLLN<

/5'H"R*S#<-%'(*U#-%",(*J4,H"*Y#,."(*]Q#,(^*789::;I*!#&(3#%",*&-*$'<<"$%".*'>>*%?"*,''>*&(*%?"*3''."(*5#,,"<-I

Page 18: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

C)&:,'8,%52'DE5=FG'#"5H&"F'&*'#*',B=45=*@'H#88'-./001'A#45,"*'I6":,'+#"$,*C)&:,'"=@752'J7,'!#"*'-./001'4,":,4'#4'#'<,,5=*@';8#3,'#*$':,*6,'%&"'H&"F47&;4'#*$'3&<<6*=5K',:,*54!,8&H2'C47H=*'E5",,5'L8#*5=*@'-./001M'N*,'&%'57,'=*5,":,*5=&*4'<#$,')K'57,'?#F=*@'E;#3,'=*'O#845&*'L"&P,35!,8&H'8,%52'(")#*'L7K4=3'+#"$,*'-./001'A*5"#*3,

0P

Page 19: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

0Q

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

@+%# Z"-0"# I'$%%'# Z$,)"# R+(*-&# e)$8%"# /)*#)# '%160$)$(# C6067:6G# &011:"-'(# 3)$8%"# -"#I0:'+/)$>4# Y0"80"4# 06%"# '0# '+%# 6:,2-&# .$01#j:"%# '0# P:3:*'# JKLL4# .0220/-"3# '+%# *:&&%**# 0.#'+%# Z"-0"# I'$%%'# Z$,)"# T$&+)$8# -"# JKLK# 0"# '+%#*)1%# *-'%<# # O)(/)$8# R2)"'*# /%$%# )66$0)&+%8#'0# &$%)'%# )"0'+%$# 0$&+)$84# ,:'# ).'%$# 8-*&:**-0"#/-'+#[-"3*#D022%3%# )"8#e:(*#^0*6-')2#/+0#/%$%#200>-"3# '0#&$%)'%#)#6+(*-&#3)$8%"#0"# '+%#&022%3%#&)16:*4# -'#/)*#8%&-8%8# '+)'#)# '%160$)$(# .%*'-?)2#&0:28# 6$0?-8%# )"# %B6%$-1%"')2#108%2# )"8# )'# '+%#*)1%# '-1%# %B620$%# '+%# $02%# 0.# 62)"'*# .0$# +%)2'+#)"8# /%227,%-"3<# @+%# 6$0;%&'# /)*# '+%# $%*:2'# 0.#&022%&'-?%#/0$>#,(#8%*-3"%$*#)"8#?02:"'%%$*4#)"8#/)*#&0"*'$:&'%8#.$01#$%&2)-1%8#'-1,%$4#*)2?)3%8#

A(&'(*L%,""%*A,5#(*+?F-&$*Y#,."(*M#F3#,.*+<#(%-*C*_4("C/4=4-%*89::UN0",&1"(%#<*S"-&=(

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`!QP# a0$30''%"#I6)&%*# D016%'-'-0"4# )"8# O)(/)$8# R2)"'*# +)*#$%&%"'2(# /0"# )# =%)"/+-2%# Y0"80"# D016%'-'-0"#H6)$'#0.#)#&022),0$)'-?%#%"'$(N#'0#&$%)'%#1%)"/+-2%#*6)&%#-"#D)""-"3#@0/"4#'$)"*.0$1-"3#gKKK#*A:)$%#1%'$%*#0.#,$0/".-%28# 2)"8<#@+%#6$0;%&'# -*# -"*6-$%8#,(#'+%#D)$)?)"*%$)-4#)"8#/-22#&0"*-*'#0.#%"&20*%8#6:,2-&# *A:)$%*# +0:*-"3# /0$>*+06*4# .008# *')22*4#&).%*4#62)(#*6)&%*#)"8#3)$8%"*4#)#*0$'70.#1-&$07*&)2%# H+:1)"7*&)2%N# T2(16-&*# -"?02?-"3# 20&)2#&011:"-'-%*#)"8#,:*-"%**%*<

Page 20: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

;R

/5'H"R*Y,""(*M#<<*#%*%?"*A,5#(*+?F-&$*=#,."(*789::;Q"<'3*<">%*R*S&>>","(%*]3#,.-^*."1'(-%,#%"*%?"*?"#<&(=*0'3",*'>*0<#(%-*789::;Q"<'3*,&=?%R*D?,""C3#F*L""C-#3-I*D?"*]E0",#%&(=*D?"#%,"^*5"?&(.*&-*#*H"(4"*>',*%#<G-*#(.*0",>',1#($"-I

Page 21: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

;0

Q0'+# '+%# c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

Page 22: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!-./$%(05K"9*)(-(1%/$"%-.#%'="%L,#"(%B,<'3("

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a%$$%$-4#JKKW4#63<#b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e)$8%"-"3# 6$03$)1*# '+)'# 80"9'# &0".$0"'# 6$-?)'%#2)"8#0/"%$*+-64#)'#2%)*'#.0$#'+%-$#0/"#6%$1)"%"&%4#)$%# *0/-"3# '+%# *%%8*# 0.# '+%-$# 0/"# 8%*'$:&'-0"G4#HD)$2**0"4#JKK_4#6<#LKiN<

@+%# $%*%)$&+# 0.# Z$,)"# D)')2(*'# &0"&2:8%*#'+)'# '%160$)$(# *6)&%# 6$0?-8%*# 0660$':"-'-%*#.0$# .-")"&-)22(# /%)># 62)(%$*# )"8# &+)22%"3%*# '+%#

U10'3",&(=*$'114(&%&"-

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c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

;;

Page 23: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

;B

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

D"-%&(=*%?"*M#%",*C*D?"*X10',%#($"*'>*UN0",&1"(%#%&'(

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

A,5#(*+?F-&$*Y#,."(*789::;*C*U($'4,#=&(=*"N0",&1"(%#%&'(*#(.*."-&=(&(=*3&%?*<&1&%".*,"-'4,$"-I*2&-&%',-*#,"*"($'4,#=".*%'*#.'0%*0<#(%-*#(.*=&H"*%?"1*#*?'1"I

Page 24: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

;E

!"#+-*#2)'%*'#,00>#a:':$%*&)6%*4#@-1#`-&+)$8*0"#*:33%*'*# '+)'# C`)'+%$# '+)"# )''%16'-"3# '0# 8%?-*%#*01%# >-"8# 0.# 0?%$# )$&+-"34# :'06-)"# 5*(*'%19# '+)'#/-22# :"-'%# %"'-$%# &-'-%*4# 2)"8*&)6%#)$&+-'%&'*#1-3+'#6$0.-'),2(# &0"&%"'$)'%# -"*'%)8# 0"# *+0$'4# *+)$64#-"'%"*%#-"'%$?%"'-0"*#)'#>%(#-"'%$*'-&%*#0.#'+%#:$,)"#%"?-$0"1%"'<# # R:,2-&# 6)$>*4# 62)\)*# )"8# *A:)$%*#$%1)-"#'+%#10*'#-160$')"'#2)"8*&)6%#-"'%$?%"'-0"*#'+)'#8%*-3"%$*#&)"#1)>%4#)"8# '+0*%# '%)&+-"3# '+%#"%B'#3%"%$)'-0"#0.# 2)"8*&)6%#)$&+-'%&'*#/0:28#80#/%22# '0# )&>"0/2%83%# '+-*4G# # H`-&+)$8*0"4# JKLL4#6<g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e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`-&+)$8*0"# 2-1-'*# '0# 6)$>*# )"8# *A:)$%*4#%B'%"8#'0#*'$%%'*&)6%*4#$0:"8),0:'*4#/)22*4#$00.*4#,)2&0"-%*#E#)*#8%10"*'$)'%8#,(#6$)&'-&%*#2->%#PPP#)"8# `%,)$<# # !"# 8%"*%2(# 606:2)'%8# )$%)*# /+%$%#3$%%"# *6)&%# -*# *&)$&%4# -'# -*# 10$%# $%)2-*'-&# '+)'#2)"8*&)6%#)$&+-'%&'*#/-22# 200># .0$# -""0?)'-?%#/)(*#

0.#&01,-"-"3#*'$%%'#)"8#6)$>#*6)&%<#@+%#F)*'%$"#D:$?%#3)$8%"#1)(#%?%"':)22(#,%#),*0$,%8#-"'0#'+%#3$%%"/)(#2%)8-"3#'0#'+%#*+066-"3#&%"'$%4#)"8#-.#*0#/-22#&0"'$-,:'%#2-.%#)"8#)&'-?-'(#'0#'+-*#6:,2-&#*6)&%<

CD011:"-'(# 3)$8%"*# )$%# )*#1:&+# &011:"-'(#)*# 3)$8%"4# )"8# /+-2%# 1)"(# *%%# '+%# 3)$8%"*# )*#2-''2%# 6)'&+%*# 0.# 5")':$%49# '+%(# )$%# -"'%"*%2(# ,:-2'#:6# )"8# /0$>%8# )*# )"(# 0'+%$# +:1)"# &$%)'-0"#-"# '+%# &-'(<# e)$8%"*# 6$0?-8%# )# $)$%# 6:,2-&# 62)&%#.0$# 6%062%# '0# 1%%'# )"8# *0&-)2-\%4# )"8# '+%-$# $-&+#+:1)"# %&0203(# *')"8*# -"# *')$># &0"'$)*'# '0#1)"(#&-'(#6)$>*#)"8# 56$0;%&'#6$)-$-%*9#o#8%)8#\0"%*#0.#?)&:0:*4# 30?%$"1%"'7,:-2'# 2)"8*&)6-"3#8%?0-8#0.#+:1)"#2-.%<#=)"(#0.#'+%#3)$8%"*#.%)':$%#*&:26':$%4#1:$)2*4#1:*-&4#'+%)'%$4#8)"&%#)"8#60%'$(4#6$%&-0:*#&01108-'-%*# )*# "0"76$0.-'# )$'# *6)&%*# )$%# 6$-&%8#0:'#0.#'+%#&-'(<#!"#)#$)6-82(#*%3$%3)'-"3#&-'(4#3)$8%"*#)$%#*01%#0.#'+%#.%/#*6)&%*#2%.'#/+%$%#6%062%#&)"#'$)"*&%"8#'+%-$#")$$0/#8%103$)6+-&#,0:"8)$-%*#-"#)#&0110"#&):*%G4#HO$-3+'#LWWWN<

O+-2%# '%160$)$(# :*%# %1,$)&%*# )# /-8%# $)"3%#0.#)&'-?-'-%*# .$01#)$'# -"*')22)'-0"*# '0#"-3+'# &2:,*# -"#%16'(#,:-28-"3*4#:$,)"#3)$8%"*#$%':$"#)#+-3+#(-%28<##Q0'+#'+%#Z$,)"#R+(*-&#)"8#c)2*'0"#3)$8%"*#*+0/#'+)'# -'# -*#60**-,2%# '0#&$%)'%#)#A:)2-'(#3$%%"#*6)&%#-"# )# *1)22# )$%)# /-'+# 2-1-'%8# $%*0:$&%*<# # e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

D?"*,'<"*'>*<#(.-$#0"*#,$?&%"$%-*#(.*%?"*H#<4"*'>*=#,."(-

Page 25: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

;L

/ #> )#. # ' #* 29#<+ #:, $##% ) *: #$29# 0 #) *: #12 2 )5".##L# # %%*)+##M# 6#% "9#NO#$29#:2 #M#. #3$% 2-#%-#+ /0 #: )* "-#<+ #&+ ': )*"#%&*)+# .##L# #! "9# ##" ) #)-# +,0123#1## 1)-# 1 )6;#+##%+9"& -# 2& #%-# ' #P, $##I18 ) #3$% # ;#

:L;@#$29# ' #"- ( #Q2-# + .#"/012(34'5&)*+,-+.

“8

“ %

Page 26: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

!"#$%&'(#)%"*M-,."$:%NO%%?455P@%!-.#%,.%!,9>)Q%!"#$%&'#(')*+$&,$'-*(.)'&-/$0-1*($.%*2#.$)($*$-#2#..)&(*-/$%#-)&34%R).+,."S%T/UV%70-,+->+"%-'W=''*QXXEEEO(3#,O."'X.)#"X465YPZOR7<<"$$"#%65%D<')>"(%4566SO

N7M[:%?455\@%501+)2$.%*2#$+#..&(.$6*(3$)($+)71&8$7*9)(:$'"#$1#.'$0.#$&,$;*2*('$0-1*($.%*2#.O%R).+,."S%K="%]-',).-+%7(<=,0"$%N7M[O%70-,+->+"%-'W=''*QXXE">-(<=,0"O.-',).-+-(<=,0"$OG)0O

3^X4566566\5PY_Y`X=''*QXEEEO<->"O)(GO3^X*3>+,<-',).$X+-.#;,.;+,9>)ZR7<<"$$"#%65%D<')>"(%

4566SO

N39>"(+,#G":%NO%-.#%&3$G(-0":%!O%?455a@%U"$,G.%-.#%!-.#$<-*"%8)(%B")*+"O%K=-9"$%-.#%b3#$).:%

*O%6aO

DJT)3(^":%2O%?455P@%<%*2#.$*(3$5+*2#.$)($=*)')(:O%70-,+->+"%-'W=''*QXXEEEO(3#,O."'X.)#"X46\P470-,+->+"%-'ZR7<<"$$"#%65%D<')>"(%4566SO

C-93"+$:%!O%?4566@%<')'2"#.$*(3$>(.#-')&(.$>(8$?*.'@?&-A*-3$B-1*().74%N388:%U%-.#%C="(9-.:%T:%"#$O%B(,.<"').%7(<=,'"<'3(-+%B("$$:%**O%6_4;6c4O

L-$=>)3(.":%NO%?4565@%5&%@B%$5*-9.4$<'-*'#:)#.$,&-$'"#$)('#-)7$0.#$&,$;*2*('$0-1*($.%*2#%R).+,."S%.<+O-<O3^O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXX("$"-(<=O.<+O-<O3^X".G$<<X-$$"'$X*#8X'))+^,'O*#8ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%

])0"9>"(SO

+,-,$,"(,.

/012#,$34B+".$-:%2O%?4566@%5-&C#2'$<%*2#$DE")1)')&(O%d)(^$=,("%C<3+*'3("%B-(^O

T"1.)+#$:%TO%?455P@%F($G0#--)++*$G*-3#()(:O%!).#).:%M+))9$>3(1%B3>+,$=,.G%*+<:%*O__O

&,.').:%7O%?455P@%G-&0(3$H&('-&+$?#*-$*(3$I*%%)(#..$)($'"#$!A#('/;%F,($'%N".'3(1%N,'1O%!).#).:%B".G3,.%M))^$:%*O6P\O

&"(^"(:%MO%?4565@%K-^,.G%B+-<"Q%T">-(J$%->$3(#%'-<',<$%,.%G"."()3$%3(>-.,$9O%%V.%b)3:%2O%"#O%?4565@%

>(.0-:#('$501+)2$<%*2#O%7>,.G#).:%De).:%T)3'+"#G"O%

!516,.!"#$&-):)(*+$5JKLM)(:N$)(.'*++*')&($1/$K#1*-4$<*($?-*(2).2&:%?455Y@%RD.+,."%,9-G"S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXX*-(^,.G#-1O)(GXE*;<).'".'X3*+)-#$X4565X5\XT[M7Tf556f$9-++Og*GZR7<<"$$"#%64%

2-.3-(1%4564SO

;O

/012#,$37N-$-.)0-:%b%-.#%b"(.-.#"h:%2O%?4566@%J20%0(2'0-#4$!"#$K#:#(#-*')&($&,$501+)2$6),#4%IC<-*"%4566X6%**O6P;4YO

DE/O'$P*(),#.'&Q%?455_@%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'%W=''*QXXEEEO"e1h'O)(GX>";3')*,-.XZ%R7<<"$$"#%6_%)<')>"(%4566SO

?)(*+).'$)($'"#$=5J$R4S$2&7%#')')&($.%&(.&-#3$1/$BH6J$H)'/+*1Q%?455P@O%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXX.,<=)+-$O#"9).<=-3eO<)9XL)(^X+)<-+;<)#"ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%D<')>"(%4566SO

i-1":%!O%?4566@%H&0+3$H)')#.T$%-&1+#7.$1#$.&+;#3$1/$0-1*($*20%0(2'0-#U%R).+,."S%K="%H3-(#,-.O%70-,+->+"%-'%W=''*QXXEEEOG3-(#,-.O<)O3^X$3$'-,.->+";>3$,."$$X3(>-.;-<3*3.<'3(";<)993.,'1;

+)<-+,$"#;("."E-+;*()g"<'$ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%D<')>"(%4566SO

Page 27: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

;S

/012#,$38T"1.)+#$:%TO%?455P@%F($G0#--)++*$G*-3#()(:O%!).#).:%M+))9$>3(1%B3>+,$=,.G%*+<O

T"1.)+#$:%TO%?455P@%<*%-&%"/'#$G0#--)++*$G*-3#()(:$J#.'"#')2.O%R).+,."S%H))#%7'%&-G,<O%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXXEEEOG))#-'9-G,<O<)9XGG9"#,-XGGU)93$F">65O*#8Z%R7<<"$$"#%6_X65X4566S

]-,^:%UO%-.#%D+#8,"+#:%KO%"#$O:%455PO%N(,',<-+%<,',"$%0)+%6O%&1(#+"%N)3('%*("$$O

T,.G:%bO%?455P@%7%H3"(,++-%H("".>"+'%8)(%!).#).O%V.%]-,^:%UO%-.#%D+#8,"+#:%KO%"#$O%?455P@O%H-)')2*+$2)')#.$;&+$VO%!).#).:%&1(#+"%N)3('%*("$$:%*YPO

/012#,$397(',.'=")*".%?4566@O!#7%&-*-/$2&77)..)&($'&$*()7*'#$#E).')(:$%01+)2$.%*2#.$)($'"#$D*.'#-($H0-;#$*3C*2#('$'&$*$7*C&-$(#A$3#;#+&%7#('$)($W*+.'&($X0(2')&(O%R).+,."S%D*".%N,'1O%70-,+->+"%-'W=''*QXXEEEO-(',.'=")*".O)(GO3^XG3,#-.<"X<-$"$'3#,"$X<)99,$$,).$f#-+$').O='9+Z

R7<<"$$"#%65%D<')>"(%4566S

6*(3.2*%#$>(.')'0'#$5-#.)3#('T.$JA*-3$,&-$W*+.'&(Q%?4566@O%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXX#-+$').G-(#".O$,'"66O<)9Xj*k6P_cZ%R7<<"$$"#%65%U"<"9>"(%4566SO

!516,.M)"(,:%CO%?455a@%Y&.2&$Z#-')2*+#%R).+,."%,9-G"S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO$'"8-.)>)"(,-(<=,'"'',O."'Xj*k45a%ZR7<<"$$"#%65%U"<"9>"(%4566SO

W-#..#3$>($G-##(:%?4566@%R).+,."%,9-G"S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXX)*".#-+$').O>+)G$*)'O<)9XZR7<<"$$"#%64%2-.3-(1%4564SO

/012#,$3:F"(("(,:%&O:?455P@%C"+8;D(G-.,$"#%C*-',-+%B(-<',<"$O%V.%]-,^:%UO%-.#%D+#8,"+#:%KO%"#$O?455P@O%H-)')2*+$2)')#.$;&+$V4%!).#).:%&1(#+"%N)3('%*("$$:

D$E-+':%BO:%&,$$"+E,'h:%BO:%-.#%D0"(9"1"(:%iO%?455a@%B-''"(.$%)8%'="%/.*+-.."#%/(>-.%N-'-+1$'O%V.%

F(-.<^:%iO7O%-.#%C'"0".$:%AO%"#$O%?455a@%6&&.#$<%*2#O%7>,.G#).:%De).:%T)3'+"#G"O%

B"".:%&O%?4566@%J2');*')&($*(3$!-*(.2)#(2#O%IC<-*"%4566?6@:%**O4`;_aO

T,<=-(#$).:%KO%?4566@%?0'0-#.2*%#.$W#.):(#-.$,&-$!&7&--&AT.$F0'3&&-$<%*2#.O%!).#).:%K=-9"$%l%b3#$).O

L(,G=':%2O%?6PPP@%N+"-(<3'',.G%'="%[-$'%m,++-G"O%V.%L,+$).:%B%-.#%L",.>"(G:%M%"#$O%J;*('$G*-3#()(:$D2&+&:)2*+$<'-0::+#$)($'"#$H)'/$*(3$'"#$=&-+3O%73').)9"#,-O

!516,.J'#+)#-$3T*-2")'#2'0-#$J0'&:#-##$MJJJN8$D2&@0-1*($[#'A&-9\D2&1&E$)($5*-).$?-*(2#%?4566@O%R).+,."%,9-G"S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO>3$'+"(O."'X,.#"eO*=*X-(',<+"f,9-G"X4566f<3((1f$')."f#"$,G.f

G(-.#f*(,h"fE,.."(f-..)3.<"#f$3$'-,.->+"f-(<=,'"<'3X,9-G"XY6_`Z%R7<<"$$"#%64%2-.3-(1%4564SO

DBKFH>!>D<$%-#7)*$#+$%-&:-*7*$0-1*(].')2$^#.'&(&#.0(.&+*-T$3#%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO$)$'".,>+"O<-'X$)$'".,>+"XE">X.)',<,"$X$)$f.)',<,"$fE">O*=*j<)#f,#,)9-k6l$"<<,)k`l.39f

.)',<,-kccY`aPZR7<<"$$"#%64%2-.3-(1%4564;56;6`SO

C<=+-9-..:%7O%?455P@%F%#(@J)-@6)1-*-/Q$P*:3#10-:$MG#-7*(/N%RD.+,."%V9-G"@%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO*3>+,<$*-<"O)(GX".XE)(^$X85\c;)*".;-,(;+,>(-(1Z%R7<<"$$"#%64%2-.3-(1%4566SO

Page 28: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

;)<=)%6$120>

;P

M->$:%bO%?4566@%P/$G*-3#(Q$'"#$H)'/$*(3$P"O%!).#).:%K,9>"(%B("$$:%V.<O

N-(+$$).:%NO%?455\@$[&A'&%)-O%[#,.>3(G=O%7i%B("$$O

N-(+$$).:%NO%?455\@%m-<-.';!)'%H-(#"."($O%V.%])E')*,-O%[#,.>3(G=O%7i%B("$$O%N=OYO%**O\6;65YO

N)(."(:%2O%?455`@%K"((-%F+3e3$O%V.%L-+#=",9:%N%"#O:%?455`@O%!"#$6*(3.2*%#$B-1*().7$K#*3#-O%]"E%d)(^:%B(,.<"').%7(<=,'"<'3(-+%B("$$:%**O46;__O

N39>"(+,#G":%NO%-.#%&3$G(-0":%!O%?455a@%W#.):($*(3$6*(3.2*%#$,&-$5#&%+#O%K=-9"$%-.#%b3#$).O

F"(("(,:%&O%?455P@%C"+8;D(G-.,$"#%C*-',-+%B(-<',<"$O%V.%]-,^:%UO%-.#%D+#8,"+#:%KO%"#$O?455P@O%H-)')2*+$2)')#.%0)+%6O%!).#).:%&1(#+"%N)3('%*("$$O%**O%c5;Y_O

&"+,$:%!%"#O%?455_@%5*-*.)'#$5*-*3).#$J$7*(),#.'&$,&-$!#7%&-*-/$J-2")'#2'0-#$*(3$?+#E)1+#$B-1*().74$T)''"(#-9:%]7,%B3>+,$="($O

F(-.<^:%iO7O%-.#%C'"0".$:%AO%"#$O%?455a@$6&&.#$<%*2#O%7>,.G#).:%De).:%T)3'+"#G"O

b-1#".:%UO%?6PPa@%!"#$5&A#-$&,$%+*2#8B-1*($+*(3.2*%#.$*.$%01+)2$").'&-/O%&-$$-<=3$"''$:%K="%&VK%*("$$O

b)3:%2O%"#O%?4565@%>(.0-:#('$501+)2$<%*2#O%7>,.G#).:%De).:%T)3'+"#G"O

2)(G".$".:%7%-.#%i"".-.:%TO%"#$O%?4564@$B-1*($A)+3.2*%#.O%7>,.G#).:%De).:%T)3'+"#G"O

i+-.'".:%T:%[=9-..:%[:%-.#%M)+=)8"(:%i%:%"#$O%?4566@%P/$G-##($H)'1O%M"(+,.:%U,"%H"$'-+'".%m"(+-GO

&<i-1:%HO%?4566@$K*3)2*+$G*-3#()(:$5&+)')2.Q$>3#*+).7$*(3$K#1#++)&($)($'"#$G*-3#(O%!).#).:%F(-.<"$%!,.<)+.%!,9,'"#

&,.').:%7O%?455P@%G-&0(3$H&('-&+$?#*-$*(3$I*%%)(#..$)($'"#$!A#('/@?)-.'$H#('0-/$H)'1O%!).#).:%B".G3,.%M))^$O

&)$'-8-0,:%&O%-.#%U)="('1:%HO%"#$O%?4565@%D2&+&:)2*+$B-1*().7O%!-($%&n++"(%B3>+,$="($O

]-,^:%UO%-.#%D+#8,"+#:%KO%"#$O%?455P@%H-)')2*+$2)')#.$;&+$6O%&1(#+"%N)3('%*("$$O

T"1.)+#$:%TO%?455P@%F($G0#--)++*$G*-3#()(:O%M+))9$>3(1%B3>+,$=,.G%*+<O

T,<=-(#$).:%KO%?4566O%?0'0-#.2*%#.$W#.):(#-.$,&-$!&7&--&AT.$F0'3&&-$<%*2#.O%K=-9"$%l%b3#$).O

T,.G:%bO%?455P@%7%H3"((,++-%G("".>"+'%8)(%!).#).O%V.%]-,^:%UO%-.#%D+#8,"+#:%KO%"#$O?455P@O%H-)')2*+$2)')#.$;&+$V4$6&(3&(:%&1(#+"%N)3('%*("$$O%**O%Yc;`6O

C-93"+:%!O%?4566@%?*.'@?&-A*-3$B-1*().7$2"*%'#-$<')'2"#.$*(3$>(.#-')&($O%B(,.<"').%7(<=,'"<'3(-+%B("$$%4566O%%

;%%?.

Page 29: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

K=)9*$).:%[O%?455c@%!"#$6&(3&($G*-3#(#-O%!).#).:%F(-.<"$%!,.<)+.%!'#O

/(>-.%B,).""($%M"(+,.:%?455a@%<'*3'#('A)29+0(:$30-2"$_A).2"#((0'O0(:$!#7%&-*-/$B.#$*(3$B-1*($W#;#+&%7#('$)($Y#-+)(:%M"(+,.:%2)0,$%0"(+-G%H9>bO

L-+#=",9:%NO%"#O%?455`@%!"#$6*(3.2*%#$0-1*().7$K#*3#-O%]"E%d)(^:%B(,.<"').%7(<=,'"<'3(-+%B("$$O

N)".:%!O%?455\@%X*)7#$6#-(#-$*(3$").$6#..&($,-&7$H0-)')1*O%IC<-*"%455\%?4@:%**O%Y\;a6O

N)(>,.:%NO%?455_@%Z*2*(2/$*(3$'"#$6*(3.2*%#8$H0+'0-*+$H&('#E'$*(3$W#.):($K#.%&(.#O%!-.#$<-*"%2)3(.-+O%44?6@:%**O64;4cO

b"#G"$:%FO%?4566@%<%*2#$'&$Y-#*'"#O%!-.#$<-*"O%4566?4c@%C*(,.G:%%**%4Y%;4aO

B".":%&O%?4566@%J2');*')&($*(3$!-*(.2)#(2#O%IC<-*"%4566?6@:%**O4`;_aO

T,<=-(#$).:%KO%?4564@%!-#(3.$,&-$RSVRO%H-(#".$%V++3$'(-'"#:%2-.3-(1%4564%*OP_O

d)3.G:%[O%?4566@%K*%)3$K#2&;#-/O%TVM7%2)3(.-+O%66\?aX\@:%**Oac;aYO

@%'$"1=.31"&3A161B)",.

7'"+,"(%#J-(<=,'"<'3("%-3')G"("":%?455\@%D2&@0-1*($(#'A&-9$D2&1&EO%R).+,."S%7'"+,"(%#J-(<=,'"<'3("%-3')G"(""O%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXXEEEO3(>-.'-<',<$O)(GX*()g"<'$X"<)>)eX"<)>)eO='9+ZR7<<"$$"#%Y%

])0"9>"(%4566SO

7'"+,"(%#J-(<=,'"<'3("%-3')G"("":%?455\@%6#`a\D2&@)('#-.')2#O%R).+,."S%7'"+,"(%#J-(<=,'"<'3("%-3')G"(""O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO3(>-.'-<',<$O)(GX*()g"<'$X*-$$-G"o45Y`X*-$$-G"Y`='9+O='9+ZR7<<"$$"#%

Y%])0"9>"(%4566SO

7'"+,"(%#J-(<=,'"<'3("%73')G"("":%B-(,$%?4566@%H0--/$<'&(#$W#.):($5-)O#$=)((#-%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'%W=''*QXX<3((1$')."#"$,G.*(,h"O<)9XE,.."($X4566X-'"+,"(f#o[4o\5oPP-(<=,'"<'3("f

-3')GoN_o7P(oN_o7P"f*-(,$ZR%7<<"$$"#%65%])0"9>"(%4566SO

M""^9-.$:%2O%?455P@%L+*0.$F;#-7#/#-$&($'"#$>7%&-'*(2#$&,$B-1*($5)&(##-.O%R).+,."S%K="%B)*;/*%N,'1O%%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXX*)*3*<,'1O."'X455PX5`X^+-3$;)0"(9"1"(;).;'=";,9*)('-.<";)8;3(>-.;

*,).""($%ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%U"<"9>"(%4566SO

M(-0)%M)(#-$:%UO%?4565@O%F%#(@J)-@6)1-*-/8$P*:3#10-:$MG#-7*(/NQ$RSSbO%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'Q%W=''*QXX%EEEO*3>+,<$*-<"O)(GX".XE)(^$X85\c;)*".;-,(;+,>(-(1%Z%R7<<"$$"#%6_2-.3-(14564%SO

U"9).<=-3e:%]O%?4566@%6&2*+$H&3#8$K#*+$D.'*'#.4%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXX.,<=)+-$O#"9).<=-3eO<)9XL)(^X+)<%-+;<)#"ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%D<')>"(%4566SO%%

C=,(#$%")(3D%'$(,.

;Q

Page 30: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

[-$'"(.%N3(0"H-(#".O%?4566@%?0(3)(:$*%%#*+$,&-$'"#$W*+.'&($5)(#*%%+#$I&0.#4%R).+,."S%U-+$').%[-$'"(.%N3(0"%H-(#".O%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXX%#-+$').G-(#".O$,'"66O<)9Xj*-G"f,#k456c%ZR7<<"$$"#%

6_%U"<"9>"(%4566SO

H,>>).$:%2O%l%!O%?4565@%[-$'"(.%N3(0"%R).+,."S%2l!%H,>>).$O%70-,+->+"%-'Q%W=''*QXXEEEOg+G;+).#).O

<)9X*()g"<'O<89j,#k64ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%D<')>"(%4566SO

H("1:%!O?455P@%!"#$.#2-#'$+),#$&,$'"#$^G0#--)++*$G*-3#(#-TQ%R).+,."S%K"+"G(-*=O%%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO'"+"G(-*=O<)O3^X+,8"$'1+"XY6Yc_\\XK=";$"<("';+,8";)8;'=";G3"((,++-;G-(#"."(O='9+ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%

23."%4566SO

H()3.#E)(^%?4565@%H-#*')(:$'"#$^Y):$<&2)#'/T%R).+,."S%H()3.#E)(^O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO"-$')8".G+-.#OG()3.#E)(^O)(GO3^X."E$;;"0".'$X."E$X4565X<("-',.G;'=";>,G;$)<,"'1O

-$*eZR7<<"$$"#%Y%])0"9>"(%4566SO

b-<^."1%N)3.<,+%?4566@%!"#$H&0(2)+T.$5+*($?&-$W*+.'&(4%R).+,."S%D*".%U-+$').O%70-,+->+"%-'%W=''*QXX)*".#-+$').O>+)G$*)'O<)9Z%R7<<"$$"#%46X65X4566SO

b)++-.#:%NO%?4565@O%!"#$0-1*($%)2'0-#.c0"O%R).+,."SF-.'-$',<%2)3(.-+O%70-,+->+"%-'QW%%=''*QXX8-.'-$',<g)3(.-+O>+)G$*)'O<)9X4565X5PX3(>-.;*,<'3("$p3"f46O='9+Z%R7<<"$$"#%6X65X4566S

i-()O%?455P@%F%#(@*)-$6)1-*-/$P*:3#10-:$G#-7*(/$H&7%+#'#3$RSSd@RSSb4%R).+,."S%7(<=,').,<O%70-,+->+"%-'%W=''*QXXEEEO-(<=,').,<O<)9X-,$='X)*".;-,(;+,>(-(1;9-G#">3(G;^-()XY655c`6Z%

R7<<"$$"#%64%])0"9>"(%4566SO

i",.,<^"%l%D0"(G--(#%7(<=,'"<'$O%?4566@%!").$'#7%&-*-/$0-1*($C0(:+#$)(;)'#.$#;#($*30+'.$'&$%+*/4%R).+,."S%765O"3O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO-65O"3X."E$X9"-.E=,+"X,.$'-++-',).f<)*".=-G".O

='9+ZR7<<"$$"#%65%])0"9>"(%4566SO

!-.#$<-*"%V.$','3'"O%?4566@%%eV$7)++)&($-#:#(#-*')&($)($W*+.'&($A)(.$'"#$BLT.$%-#7)#-$+*(3.2*%#$*A*-3O%R).+,."S%!-.#$<-*"%V.$','3'"O%70-,+->+"%-'Q=''*QXXEEEO+-.#$<-*",.$','3'"O)(GXBUFXN).'(,>3'"XB("$,#".'$7E-(#!V7E-(#$4566f555O*#8ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%U"<"9>"(%4566SO

!).G:%iO%?4565@$!"#$Y):$<&2)#'/$1#:)(.$)($W*+.'&(O%R).+,."S%!).#).%[0".,.G%C'-.#-(#O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO'=,$,$+).#).O<)O3^X+,8"$'1+"X-(',<+";4_\Y655_;'=";>,G;$)<,"'1;>"G,.$;,.;#-+$').O

='9+ZZR7<<"$$"#%C"*'"9>"(%4566SO

!)0,.G%U-+$').%?4566@%W*+.'&($:*-3#($,*2#.$'"-#*'$&($'&%$&,$,0(3)(:$20'O%R).+,."S!)0,.G%U-+$').O%70-,+->+"%-'%W=''*QXX+)0,.G#-+$').O<)O3^X4566X5aX#"0"+)*9".';8"-($;)0"(;"\;G-(#".X%Z%R7<<"$$"#%

46%D<')>"(%4566SO

P*9)(:$<%*2#$)($W*+.'&(%?4566@OR).+,."S%!-.#$<-*"%V.$','3'"O%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXX%=''*QXXEEEO+-.#$<-*",.$','3'"O)(GX<-$"$'3#,"$X<-$"$'3#1O*=*j,#k466ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%U"<"9>"(%4566SO

&))-++"9:%2O?455\@%G0#--)++*$G*-3#()(:O%R).+,."S%K="%7(<=,'"<'3("%V$$3"%]dK,9"$O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO.1',9"$O<)9X455\X5`X5\G3"((,++-;'O='9+ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%23."%4566SO

&)(()E:%TO%?455a@%P&1)+#$3#;)2#.$*(3$0-1*($'*2')2.O%R).+,."S%U)93$O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO%=''*QXXEEEO#)93$E">O,'X".X-(<=,'"<'3("X"<)>)e;9)>,+";#"0,<"$;-.#;3(>-.;'-<',<$%ZR7<<"$$"#%65%

D<')>"(%4566SO

DJT)3(^":%2O%?4565@%<%*2#.$*(3$5+*2#$)($=*)')(:j%R).+,."S%T/UVO%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXXEEEO(3#,O."'X.)#"X465YPZ%R7<<"$$"#%D<')>"(%6_%4566S

BR

Page 31: Critical Study - Rachel Forbes

F,,)2#$,&-$0-1*($!-*(.,&-7*')&($F0'$<'&-/%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO)88,<"8)(3(>-.'(-.$8)(9-',).O)(GX*-G"$XC')(1O='9Z%R7<<"$$"#%65%D<')>"(%4566S

T"1.)+#$:%TO%?455P@%<*%-&%"/'#$G0#--)++*$G*-3#()(:$J#.'"#')2.4%R).+,."S%H))#%7'%&-G,<O%70-,+->+"%-'QW%=''*QXXEEEOG))#-'9-G,<O<)9XGG9"#,-XGGU)93$F">65O*#8Z%R7<<"$$"#%6_X65X4566S

K3":%7O%?4565@%6&2*+$H&3#8$P*%%)(:$[&$P*(T.$6*(3O%R).+,."S%7(^,."'O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO-(^,."'O<)9X-(',<+"$X+)<-+;<)#";9-**,.G;.);9-.$;+-.#O='9+ZR7<<"$$"#%65%])0"9>"(%4566SO

B-1*($5"/.)2$G*-3#(%?4566@%R).+,."S%70-,+->+"%-'%W=''*QXXEEEO*=1$,<G-(#".O)(GO3^ZR7<<"$$"#%6`%23+1%4566S

L-$=>)3(.":%NO%?4565@%5&%@B%$5*-9.4$<'-*'#:)#.$,&-$'"#$)('#-)7$0.#$&,$;*2*('$0-1*($.%*2#%R).+,."S%.<+O-<O3^O%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXX("$"-(<=O.<+O-<O3^X".G$<<X-$$"'$X*#8X'))+^,'O*#8ZZR7<<"$$"#%

])0"9>"(%4566S

L))#E-(#:%NO?4566@%!"#$*:#$&,$?+&A#-.O%R).+,."S%F,.-.<,-+%K,9"$O%%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO8'O<)9X<9$X$X4X5_>58\a`;"-\_;66"5;>58Y;556cc8"->cP-O='9+ZR7<<"$$"#%6_%D<')>"(%4566SO

!516,.B=)')G(-*=$%;%73'=)(J$%)E.%3.+"$$%)'="(E,$"%<("#,'"#%,.%("8"(".<"$O

5-#.#('*2)&($%-&/#2'&$#.'&(&#.0(.&+*-$?4566@%R).+,."%0,#")S%70-,+->+"%-'QW=''*QXXEEEO1)3'3>"O<)9XE-'<=j0kUcKq8m[NaUGl8"-'3("k*+-1"(f"9>"##"#ZR7<<"$$"#%64%

2-.3-(1%4564S

B("$".',.G%C399"(%B-+-<"Q%!,$-%N="3.G%-.#%m,"E%K3>"%G()E%?4566@%R).+,."%0,#")S%70-,+->+"%-'QW

=''*QXXEEEO1)3'3>"O<)9XE-'<=j0k+bpg9)E0P;/Z%R7<<"$$"#%6%D<')>"(S

E)&,%.

B0