!"#$%&'

()'*+,'

-./010'2-3$45'65'78$$%93'

:;<'+='>'?#@#%?'A;#&'B9CAD39E'FGH  >'+='A;#&'?D<'

:;+A'+39'!"#$%&E'

!"#$%&I5'

!=$%?&A'$A;93'A;#%?&J'+%$A;93')+3K'=+L93'C+%)#)+A9'M'

:>N-&'+39'+O$DA'A;9'=+&&'$4'+'%DCB9D&5'P;9<'#%A93+CA'O<'A;9',9+K'%DCB9+3'4$3C9J'$3'+'&#=#B+3'4$3C9'#%@$B@#%?'&D893&<==9A3#C';9+@<'8+3QCB9'9"C;+%?95'P;9#3'499OB9'#%A93+CQ$%&'=9+%'A;9<'+39';+3)'A$')9A9CA')#39CAB<5'P;9<'=D&A';+@9'O99%'83$)DC9)'#%'A;9'9+3B<'R%#@93&9J'$3'A;9<',$DB)%SA'9"8B+#%'A;9'4$3=+Q$%'$4'?+B+"#9&5'P;9<'=D&A'O9'&A+OB9J'$3'A;9<',$DB)%SA'&QBB'9"#&A';+@#%?'O99%'83$)DC9)'#%'A;9'9+3B<'R%#@93&95'

T$=8+39)',#A;':>N-7II'

!39'O9A,99%'GUVG1'+%)'GUVW'$4'A;9'=+&&'$4'+%'9B9CA3$%'MMM'P;9<'#%A93+CA'O<')#39CA'C$D8B#%?'A$'XD+3K&J'ODA'A;9'#%A93+CQ$%&'+39'499OB9M'P;9#3'499OB9'#%A93+CQ$%&'=9+%&'A;9<'+39';+3)'A$')9A9CA')#39CAB<5'P;9<'=D&A';+@9'O99%'83$)DC9)'#%'A;9'9+3B<'R%#@93&9J'$3'A;9<',$DB)%SA'9"8B+#%'A;9'4$3=+Q$%'$4'?+B+"#9&5'P;9<'=D&A'O9'&A+OB9J'$3'A;9<',$DB)%SA'&QBB'9"#&A';+@#%?'O99%'83$)DC9)'#%''A;9'9+3B<'R%#@93&95'

&$'&$=9'&#=#B+3#Q9&',#A;':>N-7J'ODA'&$=9'O#?')#Y939%C9&M'

:;<',939'+"#$%&'#%@9%A9)E':>N-&'2',9+KB<'#%A93+CQ%?'=+&&#@9'8+3QCB9&'2'C+%'+889+3'+&'

9"A9%&#$%&'A$'&A+%)+3)'=$)9B'8+3QCB9'8;<&#C&'43$='+'@+3#9A<'$4'8B+C9&5'P;9'=$&A'8$8DB+3'#)9+'#&'A;+A':>N-&'+39'A;9'B#?;A9&A'&D893&<==9A3#C'8+3QCB95'7D893&<==9A3<J'#%'AD3%J',+&'#%@9%A9)'A$'=+K9'A;9'&A+%)+3)'=$)9B'<#9B)'Z%#A9'839)#CQ$%&'4$3'+BB'=+&&9&'+%)'C$D8B#%?&'9@9%',#A;'+'=+&&#@9';#??&'O$&$%5'

![>\67'2'+889+3'+&'+%'9"A9%&#$%'A$'&A+%)+3)'=$)9B'8+3QCB9'8;<&#C&'A$$5'P;9<'+39'+'C$%&9XD9%C9'$4'+'A;9$3<'C+BB9)'A;9'-(TT(>']R>66'N(T.!6>7NJ'A;+A'9"8B+#%&',;<'&A3$%?'%DCB9+3'#%A93+CQ$%&'839&93@9'A;9'T-'&<==9A3<5'

!"#$%"&'()*$+$',*$-'./0.)0$120*3$"-$.312-'$&21%3*'*$./0$.312-'$&2/-"-'*/'4$56'*/-"2/-$')7$'2$86$',*$)*1."/"/#$"--(*-$9"',$"'4$5.&,$*6'*/-"2/$,.-$.00":2/.3$&2/-*;(*/&*-4$<21*$2=$',*-*$&2/-*;(*/&*-$.)*$1.--">*$%.):&3*-$',.'$&2(30$?*$0.)@$1.A*)4$

-3$A$A<8#C+B'&A3$%?B<'#%A93+CQ%?'8+3QCB9'2'A;9'69DA3$%5'

*$%SA'K%$,',;+A'+'39+B'%9DA3$%'B$$K&'B#K9J'&$'B9AS&'=+K9'+'A$<'$%9I'

!$BC5DE$

-\7>P>^('T.!_`('\6'P\-'

6(`!P>^('T.!_`('*\:6'a(b\:'

(b(TP_>T'*>-\b('

The Strong CP problem"

!$BC5DE$ !$BC5DE$

T-'

!""#$%&$'(&)*+,&(-*./&0$,1(2'$&-#.&$'$34,2'&,),5(2*5&%*6'),&7'7,$(8&

(b(TP_>T'*>-\b('

(b(TP_>T'*>-\b('

!$BC5DE$

9-:&*.&(-,&$,1(2'$&)*+,&(-*.!""&0$,1(2'$&-#.&4,2'&,),5(2*5&%*6'),&7'7,$(8&

!$BC5DE$

c%9DA3$%S' c%$A'%9DA3$%S'

The Peccei-Quinn Mechanism"

_$O93A'-9CC9#'+%)'.9B9%']D#%%'+39'+'C$D8B9'$4'A;9$3#&A&',;$',939'+A'7A+%4$3)'#%'A;9'B+A9'GWdU&5'P;9<')39+=A'D8'+'8+3QCB9'8;<&#C&'&$BDQ$%'A$'A;9'&A3$%?'T-'83$OB9=5'

P;9'-9CC9#']D#%%'=9C;+%#&='#&'4+3'A$$'C$=8B#C+A9)'A$'9"8B+#%'#%'A;#&'CB+&&J'ODA'4$3AD%+A9B<'A;939'#&'+'%#C9'+%+B$?<')D9'A$'-#9339'7#K#@#9',;#C;'#&'=DC;'B9&&'A9C;%#C+BJ'+%)'+B&$'3+A;93'4D%5'

T$%&#)93'+'&%$$K93'O+BB'$%'+'e+A'A+OB95'

>4'<$D'$%B<'C$%&#)93'8;<&#C&'$%'A;9'A+OB9J'A;939'#&'A3+%&B+Q$%+B'&<==9A3<'V'9@93<';$3#f$%A+B'8$&#Q$%'#&'A;9'&+=9'+&'9@93<'$A;935'

The Snooker Ball Sees the Wider World".$,9@93J'+'&%$$K93'A+OB9'#&'+%'+3QZC#+BB<'e+A'B+%)&C+89J',#A;'+'&<==9A3<'#=8$&9)'O<'#=8$&#%?'&89C#+B'C$%)#Q$%&5'P;#&'#&''C+BB9)'Z%9'AD%#%?5':;9%'<$D'+39'%$A'$%'A;9'A+OB9J'A;939'#&'%$'&<==9A3<',#A;'39&89CA'A$'A3+%&B+Q$%5'

-93;+8&'%+AD39'O9;+@9&'B#K9'A;#&5'-93;+8&'T-'@#$B+Q$%'#&'+CAD+BB<'A;9'%+AD3+B'&A+A9'$4'A;#%?&J'ODA'4$3'&$=9'39+&$%'#%'A;9'8;9%$=9%+',9'C+%'$O&93@9J'T-'#&'C$%&93@9)5'P,$'8$&&#O#B#Q9&J'Z%9'AD%#%?'#%'A;9'&A+%)+3)'=$)9B'A$'=+K9'#A'&$'FB#K9'A;9'&%$$K93'A+OB9HJ'$3'+'&A+%)+3)'=$)9B'=9C;+%#&='A$'4$3C9'T-'C$%&93@+Q$%5'

Why is the Table Flat ?"

T\R6P(_':(>`.P'

.>6`('

P;9'cB9@9BB#%?'=9C;+%#&=S'9%&D39&'A;9'A+OB9'#&'e+A5'P;9'-9CC9#']D#%%'F-]H'=9C;+%#&='#&'A;9'+%+B$?<'4$3'T-'C$%&93@+Q$%'#%'A;9'&A3$%?'#%A93+CQ$%&5'

*#&C+3)#%?'A;9'Z%9'AD%#%?'+3?D=9%A'F,9')$%SA'39+BB<',+%A'A$';+@9'Z%9'AD%9)'@+3#+OB9&';+3)V,#39)'#%A$'A;9'&A+%)+3)'=$)9BHJ',9'C$DB)')9&#?%'+'=9C;+%#&='A$'4$3C9'T-'A$'O9'C$%&93@9)5'

!%'+%+B$?<'#&'+'=9C;+%#&D='A$'4$3C9'A;9'&%$$K93'A+OB9'A$''O9'e+A'

Symmetry restoration at low energies"7D88$&9'A;9'&%$$K93'A+OB9'&A+3A9)'$DA'+A'+'+3O#A3+3<'+%?B9'+%)'A;9'=9C;+%#&=',+&'+CQ@+A9)'A$'39&A$39'#A&'e+A%9&&5'P;939'=#?;A'O9'39&#)D+B'$&C#BB+Q$%&'$4'A;9'C$D%A93,9#?;A5'!&'+'39&DBA'A;9'A+OB9S&'$3#9%A+Q$%';+&'&=+BB'$&C#BB+Q$%&5'P;9&9'&=+BB'$&C#BB+Q$%&';+@9'C$%&9XD9%C9&'4$3')<%+=#C&'$%'A;9'A+OB95'

!6!b\`>(7g'

\3#?#%+B'+3O#A3+3<'+%?B9'$4'&%$$K93'A+OB9'

T-'#&'%$A'+'&<==9A3<'$4'%+AD39'+A';#?;'9%93?#9&h9+3B<'Q=9&5'

b9@9BB#%?'=9C;+%#&='

-9CC9#']D#%%'F-]H'=9C;+%#&='4$3C9&'T-'C$%&93@+Q$%'+A'B$,'9%93?#9&'h'B+A9'Q=9&5'

_9&#)D+B'P+OB9'\&C#BB+Q$%&'

!"#$%&'M'

Axion Couplings"!"#$%&'+39'D%C;+3?9)'8+3QCB9&J',;$&9'=+&&'#&'D%)9A93=#%9)'O<'A;9'-9CC9#']D#%%'=9C;+%#&=5'.939'+39'&$=9'+"#$%''#%A93+CQ$%&5'P;9#3'&A39%?A;&'+39'+BB'83$8$3Q$%+B'A$'A;9'+"#$%''=+&&J'&$';9+@#93'+"#$%&'C$D8B9'=$39'&A3$%?B<5'

![>\6'T\R-b>6`'P\'(b(TP_\6J'NR\6J'P!R'6(RP_>6\7'Fi(_N>\67H'

![>\6'T\R-b>6`'P\']R!_j7'

![>\6'T\R-b>6`'P\'-.\P\67'FMH'

+'

+'

+'

-_\a!a>b>P/'\i''-_\T(77'-_\-\_P>\6!b'P\'7]R!_('\ig'

γ

γ

q

Axion properties depend on its mass"T\R-b>6`7g'

!aR6*!6T('

(6(_`/'-(_'-!_P>Tb('!P'![>\6'-_\*RTP>\6'

b>`.P(_'![>\67'!_('-_\*RT(*'!P'.>`.(_''(6(_`>(7'!6*'!_('N\_('!aR6*!6P'P\*!/J'aRP'P.(/'!_('.!_*(_'P\'*(P(TP5'

What is the Axion Mass ?"b#LB9'#%4$3=+Q$%'43$='A;9$3<J'ODA'B$A&'$4';#%A&'43$='+&A3$8;<&#C&5'

!TT(b(_!P\_'7(!_T.(7'

![>\6'*!_j'N!PP(_'\^(_Tb\7(7'R6>^(_7('

j7^k

'

*i7k' _(*'`>!6P'7P!_'a\R6*7'

.!b\'*(T!/'([-(_>N(6P7'

7R-(_6\^!'GWld!'

7(!_T.':>6*\:J'GUVm'9^'n'=+'n'GUV0'9^'

b\:(_ 'N!77(7'N(!6'![>\67'N\_('!aR6*!6P'

Detecting Axions in Our Galactic Halo"P<8#C+B'+"#$%'@9B$C#A<'#&'A;9'@#3#+B'@9B$C#A<J'ODA',#A;'=+&&9&'A<8#C+BB<'+3$D%)''''''''''''''''A;9<';+@9'*9Va3$?B#9',+@9B9%A;&'$4'GU&'$4'=9A39&5'N$=9%AD='A3+%&493'43$='+'&#%?B9'+"#$%'A$'+'&#%?B9'%DCB9D&'#&''9&&9%Q+BB<'f93$5'.$,9@93J'A;9<')$'C$D8B9'A$'8;$A$%&J'+%)'A;#&'+BB$,&'A;9'4$BB$,#%?')9A9CQ$%'&C;9=9g'

FP;9'+&A93#&K'#%)#C+A9&'A;+A'A;#&'#&'+'c@#3AD+BS'8;$A$%'39839&9%Q%?'+'*T'=+?%9QC'Z9B)J'+%)';9%C9'#A';+&'f93$'439XD9%C<J'+%)'f93$'9%93?<5'/$D'%99)'A;9'@#3AD+B'8;$A$%'A$'C$%&93@9'=$=9%AD='#%'A;9''+"#$%'A$'8;$A$%'C$%@93&#$%5'

O<'C$%&93@+Q$%'$4'9%93?<'

439XD9%C<'

+'

=+&&'

10 µeV

γν

Basics of Resonant Cavity Detectors'Cartoon diagram illustrating the resonant cavity, containing a tuning rod, the electric field probe used to measure the power in a cavity mode, and the electronics used to read out this power.

A resonant cavity for axion searches."

43$='+O$@9',#A;'B#)'39=$@9)5'*98A;'#&'G=5'

oUC='

+BD=#%+'AD%#%?'3$)'

C$8893'C$+A9)'&A+#%B9&&'&A99B'

F+')#9B9CA3#CH'

F+'=9A+BH'

!'39&$%+%A'C+@#A<'#&'+'O$"',#A;'C$%)DCQ%?',+BB&5'P;9')#=9%&#$%&'$4'A;9'O$"')#CA+A9'+'&9A'$4'_(7\6!6P'N\*(7'$4'A;9'C+@#A<J'+A',;#C;'&A+%)#%?'9B9CA3$=+?%9QC',+@9&'$&C#BB+A9'+A'%+AD3+B'439XD9%C#9&J',#A;'A;9',+BB&'#=8$&#%?''O$D%)+3<'C$%)#Q$%&'F#%'A;9'&+=9',+<'+&'+'?D#A+3'&A3#%?';+&'%+AD3+B'439XD9%C#9&'#=8$&9)'O<'#A&'B9%?A;H5'

Schematics of cavity and receiver electronics"

&;$,&'C+@#A<J'C$$B#%?'A$'1jJ'C3<$&A+A&'A$';+%)B9'C$$B#%?'B#XD#)&J'=+?%9QC'Z9B)'C$#B&5'

Noise Background"P;9')$=#%+%A'O+CK?3$D%)'#%'A;9&9'9"893#=9%A&'#&'p$;%&$%'%$#&9'#%'A;9'C+@#A<'+%)'A;9'+=8B#Z935'p$;%&$%''%$#&9'#&'C+D&9)'O<'3+%)$='=$Q$%&'$4'9B9CA3$%&'#%'A;9'39&#&A$3&'$4'+'C#3CD#A'C+D&#%?'eDCAD+Q%?'CD339%A&'A;3$D?;'A;9'39&#&A$35'P;9&9'CD339%A&'+39'A;9$39QC+BB<'$4'A;9'&+=9'=+?%#AD)9'+A'+BB'439XD9%C#9&5'P;9'%$#&9'8$,93')D=89)'O<'+'oU'$;='39&#&A$3'#%A$'+'oU'$;='C+OB9'#%'+'O+%),#)A;'a'$4'439XD9%C<'&8+C9'F4$3'9"+=8B9J'439XD9%C#9&'GUU'A$'oUUN.f',$DB)'C$339&8$%)'A$'+'O+%),#)A;'$4'qUUN.fHJ'#&'

.939'Ka'#&'a$Bf=+%%S&'C$%&A+%A5'6$QC9'A;9'%$#&9'8$,93'#&'#%)989%)9%A'$4'A;9'C9%A3+B'439XD9%C<'$4'A;9'O+%),#)A;'D%)93'C$%&#)93+Q$%5''

P;#&')$9&%SA'&99='B#K9'+'O#?')9+BJ'D%QB'<$D'39+B#f9',;+A'&#?%+B'8$,93'<$D'9"89CA5'

7#?%+B'8$,93']R!6P>P/'>6'a_!Tj(P7'>7'*>N(67>\6b(77'

IO#?'%+&A<'4$3=DB+',;#C;'<$D')$%SA'%99)'A$'39=9=O93J'ODA',9SBB'B$$K'+A'A;9'$3#?#%'$4'&$=9'$4'A;9'A93=&5'7#?%+B'8$,93'83$8$3Q$%+B'A$'A;9'=+?%9QC'Z9B)'&XD+39)J'A;9']'FXD+B#A<'4+CA$3H'$4'A;9'C+@#A<'39&$%+%C9J'+'4$3='4+CA$3',;#C;'')989%)&'$%'A;9')$A'83$)DCA'$4'A;9'9B9CA3#C'Z9B)'$4'A;9'C+@#A<'=$)9',#A;'A;9'=+?%9QC'Z9B)'43$='A;9'9"A93%+B'=+?%9AJ'A;9')9%&#A<'$4'A;9'+"#$%&'#%'A;9';+B$J'A;9'&XD+39'$4'A;9'C$D8B#%?'C$%&A+%A'C$D8B#%?'A;9'+"#$%&'#%A$'8;$A$%&J'+%)'A;9'@$BD=9'$4'A;9''C+@#A<5':;9%'<$D'8DA'A;9'%D=O93&'#%'4$3'A;9'!*N['9"893#=9%A'FR575H'<$D'?9Ag'

7$'A;9'&#?%+B'8$,93')#@#)9)'O<'A;9'%$#&9'8$,93'#&'+O$DA'GhqU'MMM'b$$K&'O+)5'

Fortunately, the radiometer equation rescues us"P;9'+O#B#A<'A$')#&Q%?D#&;'+'%+33$,'89+K'$%'A$8'$4'+'e+A'%$#&9'O+CK?3$D%)'#&'A;9'3+Q$'$4'A;9'8$,93'#%'A;9'89+K'A$'A;9'ibRTPR!P>\67'#%'A;9'8$,93'#%'A;9'%$#&9'O+CK?3$D%)5'

>4'<$D'+39'=9+&D3#%?'+'%$#&9'&$D3C9'$4'#%A3#%&#C'8$,93'-6'',#A;'&$=9')9A9CA$3J'A;9'39&DBA'$4'<$D3'=9+&D39=9%A'#&''D%C93A+#%'O<'+%'+=$D%A's-6'J',;939''

a'#&'A;9'O+%),#)A;J'A'#&'A;9'Q=9')D3+Q$%5''

i_(]R(6T/'

-\:(_

'

7.\_P(_'>6P(`_!P>\6h'b\:(_'a!6*:>*P.'

i_(]R(6T/'

-\:(_

'

b\6`(_'>6P(`_!P>\6h'.>`.(_''a!6*:>*P.'

_9&DBAJ'<$D',+#A'+A'9+C;'C+@#A<'AD%#%?J'&$'A;9'&9+3C;'A+K9&'Q=9'A$'C$@93'=+&&'3+%?95'

P;9'!*N['+"#$%'&9+3C;'9"893#=9%A'#&'&QBB'?$#%?J'+%)';+&'%$,'9"CBD)9)'&$=9A;#%?'B#K9'A;399'Q=9&'A;9'=+&&'3+%?9'A;+A',+&'9"CBD)9)'O<'A;#&'Z3&A'3D%5'

GUV1q'

GUV01'

0' GU' 1U'

:;+A'+O$DA'%$%V)+3KV=+L93'+"#$%&E'a9C+D&9'A;9'+"#$%'+OD%)+%C9'4+BB&'$Y'+&'+883$"#=+A9B<'Gh=+'#A'#&'D%B#K9B<'A;+A'D%B9&&'A;9'83$)DCQ$%'=$)9B'#%'A;9'9+3B<'D%#@93&9'#&'39+BB<'9"$QCJ'+"#$%&';+@#%?'=+&&9&'+O$@9'+O$DA'GUVo9^hC1',$DB)'C$%A3#ODA9'&#?%#ZC+%AB<'A$'A;9')+3K'=+L935'

.\:(^(_J';9+@#93'+"#$%&';+@9'&A3$%?93'C$D8B#%?&'A$'%$%')+3K'=+L93J'+%)'C$DB)'A;9394$39'893;+8&'C$%A3#ODA9'A$'8;<&#C&'#%'$A;93',+<&5'i$3'9"+=8B9J',9';+@9''&99%';$,';9+@#93'+"#$%&'C+%'&;$3A9%'A;9')D3+Q$%&'$4'&D893%$@+9'+%)'A;9'B#49Q=9&'$4'39)'?#+%A'&A+3&'O<'A3+%&8$3Q%?'9%93?<'$DA'$4'A;9')9%&9'C$39&'$4'A;9&9'$Or9CA&5'

i$BB$,#%?'A;#&';<8$A;9&#&'4D3A;93J',9'=#?;A'9"89CA'+"#$%&'A$'O9'83$)DC9)'#%'A;9''C$39&'$4'&A+3&'B#K9'A;9'&D%5'>%'A;#&'C+&9J'=+<O9',9'C+%'OD#B)'+%'+"#$%'A9B9&C$89I'>%'4+CAJ'A;939'#&'+%'9"893#=9%A'C+BB9)'T!7P'O+&9)'+A'T(_6'A;+A'#&'9"+CAB<'A;+A5'

T!7P'T(_6'+"#$%'&$B+3'A9B9&C$89'

;L8ghhC+&A5,9O5C93%5C;hT!7PhT!7P5;A=B'

P.('7R6'

7D893C$%)DCQ%?'=+?%9A' [V3+<')9A9CA$3'

T!7P'39&DBA&'p$D3%+B'$4'T$&=$B$?<'+%)'!&A3$8+3QCB9'-;<&#C&'FGH$FIF$JKFFLM4'

:;+A'<$D'&;$DB)'A+K9'+,+<5'!"#$%&'+39'+'C+%)#)+A9'A$'9"8B+#%'A;9')+3K'=+L93'83$OB9='

P;9<'+3$&9'$DA'$4'+%'+L9=8A'A$'Z"'+'83$OB9=',#A;'A;9'&A+%)+3)'=$)9B'$4'8+3QCB9'8;<&#C&J'rD&A'B#K9':>N-&'

!"#$%&'+39'=DC;'B#?;A93'A;+%':>N-&J'A;$D?;',9'$%B<'K%$,'+'3+%?9'$4'8$&&#OB9'+"#$%'=+&&9&'2'&$=9A;#%?'B#K9'GUVm'A$'GUV0'9^hC15''

R%)93'&A+%)+3)'83$)DCQ$%'&C9%+3#$&J'+"#$%&',$DB)';+@9'A$'O9'+A'A;9'B$,93'9%)'$4'A;#&'3+%?9'A$'O9'+'&#?%#ZC+%A'C$=8$%9%A'$4')+3K'=+L935'!883$"'GUVm'A$'GUVo'9^hC15'

T+@#A<')9A9CA$3&'B#K9'!*N['+39'&9+3C;#%?'4$3')+3K'=+L93'+"#$%&'43$='A;9';+B$'$4'$D3'?+B+"<'#%'A;#&'3+%?9J'ODA'#A'A+K9&'+'B$%?'Q=9'O9C+D&9''A;9')9A9CA$3'#&'39&$%+%A'+%)'A;9'9"89CA9)'&#?%+B'#&'@93<',9+K5'

N9+%,;#B9J'+"#$%&'43$='A;9'&D%J',#A;';#?;93'=+&&9&'F,;#C;'+39'A;9394$39'D%B#K9B<'A$'O9')+3K'=+L93H'+39'O9#%?'&9+3C;9)'4$3',#A;'&$B+3'A9B9&C$89&'B#K9'T!7P5'7$'+"#$%&'=+<'AD3%'$DA'A$'9"#&AJ'ODA'%$A'O9'&#?%#ZC+%A')+3K'=+L935'