,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011...

18
20t2tHC-4n50 o o, 6Ayb ,6. T ar- tlt o? t 34co a eva. tc-.r.t, a2a aao 3 e-tr,tJ aa ,), o ,r.reFa ,a ,, ao . ,2, ,JtP t 2}t2lHC_tuI 50 .-,..?i I3*I a ,ro, o ,ytrarpP., --- , .OrO. ,.O. Oa & e €42104 .f 2/,., ir, - ? A052614 -r3ii ltf,r.3 * a. a a C.a r?z , c a cC ,22'vt 2/r.r'-t i-, t.t a ct2 t/z - O 3OC ;22'vt 24.r'3 i-, l.t a o 2a, o. aro * * cO. 's4 a ,o. 2/-tl oO. 'tl, o o o G o3 a - srz2o-e le, l.t 2-., - . . a a. o o o 303 3ro o srpro-e Z-rt.t .trz2 " aara , c ooao o o o? o. & 4-v2/ 212.?4 lt 2r2 ir' - aa a ? ,2C. rO . , 'tliii, taZ * o. 2010s12012 ,r3, OO - 4 ,tryrepl, + 12t05t2013 ,, * ,2' ?- er-?/, ?. oo :2ro o oa :2r, o 197 4l Cv -Cl 201 l'Jr.ii 7.3 * I a z? et o z?tt . .?l/P,J a , r3 rro, o ,t, yrrr.oPr, ,a o -c? 3o 22- ,evr2r, a, a a cao a u. o2 'Jt- tarPrtz o a c., i2lo t/2, o. :Zti .i-3n * O5ll)l2}ll o, a a a o 331647 I :99j,3325029 :.?!,[3.i-i2 www'highcourt.gov.mv :E-;':; ., ,rr, oa, .4c, . .t2 .rtz Cr-, .ev-/ r ear/t/t [email protected] j- 3-

Transcript of ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011...

Page 1: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20t2tHC-4n50

o o,

6Ayb

,6.T

ar-tlt

o? t 34co aeva. tc-.r.t,a2a

aao 3e-tr,tJaa

,), o,r.reFa,a

,, ao .,2, ,JtP t

2}t2lHC_tuI 50 .-,..?i I3*Ia

,ro, o,ytrarpP.,---, .OrO. ,.O. Oa &e €42104 .f 2/,., ir, -

?

A052614 -r3ii ltf,r.3 *a.

a

a

C.a r?z , c a cC,22'vt 2/r.r'-t i-, t.t

act2 t/z - O 3OC

;22'vt 24.r'3 i-, l.ta

o2a,o.aro

*

*

cO.'s4

a,o.

2/-tloO.'tl,

o o o G o3 a -srz2o-e le, l.t 2-., -. . a a.o o o 303 3ro osrpro-e Z-rt.t .trz2 "aara

, c ooao o o o? o. &4-v2/ 212.?4 lt 2r2 ir' -aa a ?

,2C. rO . ,'tliii, taZ *o.

2010s12012,r3, OO - 4,tryrepl, +12t05t2013 ,, *,2'

?-er-?/,?.

oo:2roooa:2r,o

197 4l Cv -Cl 201 l'Jr.ii 7.3 * Ia

z?et

o z?tt ..?l/P,Ja

, r3 rro, o,t, yrrr.oPr,,a

o -c? 3o22- ,evr2r,a, a acao a u. o2'Jt- tarPrtz

o a c.,i2lo t/2,o.:Zti .i-3n * O5ll)l2}llo,

a

a

a

o

331647 I :99j,3325029 :.?!,[3.i-i2www'highcourt.gov.mv :E-;':;

., ,rr, oa, .4c, ..t2 .rtz Cr-, .ev-/ r ear/t/[email protected] j- 3-

Page 2: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012HC-A 50

a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a

ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9a.

o? c2t? , . ro..o.4zv zt'/'/) 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22'a

4 2?- orrc., orr, ,?, o ?o .a or?.2.tJ2-

'2t/.r,/ .22t y ) rrrP,J.,'

'rrr,lr,

aa C2x > a ooao o o o? /a. ?ro/ /2 o..trt eJ.rr, .rrrl zr2r., Pt Zr2 Yt rJ trr.-r ,P.r2a, a

4/ / . D a.rv.?2/ :r3 ,.,

: (A0s26t4

..t tr.rr- I 2 .t y.r,trr., J

c.ort t rc r.. a:-.rrv, ,trvr4 a

,eY., ,rr,'I

t . o, o/a€42r-4 J 2,..,

o , , c/ ,,2t/rr'/ 22rY

1974lCv-C12011 jr- .rr2 -01a/. o. ,?,-r, ev

'2212.t.r'-ta , o.. o. ?tt-o.:2 ytJ 27

40 . 14,2r.rP 3., ,r.rl

ar, a a . a.,t 2ryrt rat t/.r.o .oro. ,.a.c 54r/ --, ,, 2..-

,2.rJ 2r'

oa , o., o. o2aD-JttrrrrPrr2 ,t!l!lY,

a . .. r rtt.o. .2.,tr,. t ar.2, Yt t,aPz

A. , , D 4rry!.2, ,.rl ,t, TrrL

: (A0s2614 .j.ii

..ii.i.i.3,- t 3ij3z

i.3.3,-1 t974tCv-Ct20tt .;.i, e9 )17 5i;; j.7:r9i -02

4 . o/ r ro2o/ . ar. a, . .4o, > z oz? .tx t,2ra,t.J J-2.a v, v.rrJ2 t2y)at lr, .rten-, ...2 .Jt.rr- zell J.?3 ,22 ,4J.tD/ a. . ao. , 4 ,rr2 , ? . r..4itr./,-, ,t-r...r t-"2J3.7i 3iji|i;:l (A052614 :i3.,,.2) E5ii):i )5::

? o.oro. r.o. ? o.A o a ooc .-o/ oa o / ox,, 4e4rrr-4 jr 2r../, ,r.t -=rJ,

,r2 a.Z-, J.-frt,rjr, , €/r"J Ja /e--2, a . a a'ooa o o.x? / a. . ?oa o 4ao.o- or. crro.oc ? .c ,cae-, -z ..t -tt..rJ t.,z.,v .aer,

-2 z c.-vrL/t --r, t 2t--rt.t 2.tit I 2i2a.a.-

,:ii ii22::) .'1,694,239t66 ,;it:i -Iil i.737? 3//i i3i:;t? . oz >? azzoc r 4z o ,xo .t4 ,., o .a. , o Ar/.2./t,r.r 22rr/ .,r/)..rn \rt2/ PtlP) lrr rt, '-:t t.rprl ,J./.,.r./ z.rt-o Ax , . oo co o o o? oz-o. . I ^/\..r..r ^

o4 \ o / oro.n?:nn 2rz2r. L-2r7 -t:2, z{r2 r (l\U)ZOlz+ iz..t/) CE42/-4 .r2.,-,

4'o'?o a '. .?. o,,c.t ox?t.(J,2v.,r.r2rrr, J ,1J2- ,2t/z/ 2yt4/

a.O air 4 .,ro. ?O..rr,,/, .,rt2v,t t.rJ'-trtl -7t2.t- ,rtP 3,

.4ao,r. r err, ....r- -{.2

(lroszirq:tr...)

331647 | :Lt) ,3325029 tt,iti-.il ;t ,ti,- ?:t ,i?.t :t:i-t/www.highcourt.gov.mv :i-L 3j [email protected] J-.i-

, ra r..a .a,tryt., t/.t

Page 3: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20t2iHc-A/ts0

1rr, Jrltrrv, t J, .crPt

o 4acao, ar. arro.oa-,

./ervr.J -zJ ,tztPo....

4.Cua. ,t, .)2 - o . .,/ CrrJ..t, .,..rtP., tr2re tT.rrrY

o.o a .. crxerorca.rrtrat:rrr rrPt2t 2v../

cc oa , o ic., o .r.oa.ae-:, .,-,tt.tr, .r-)r'rtt r,rt 2Y..2,

,ac a c .orC.. ,.c. a o. Ajr2.,/r-J, laarr-4 ,21r. ar, F-,P-r.

ooa o c.-O . .- . Ooae-J, -,, -, t r.tt tr, 2, v - er-,a.

ac) . 3 ..,r,Pr.J 'rJr.,.,.

c,ccz? a.Or.;r2 .cru, 4vrP

a . o.rA a2rtr-.t 22r. -1)

. a aa

t1r,

o o c? o.-o. aF't a.r2 z{.r2 t (A052614:ii*y) 45'ari'o4 j"1'

o.-a. ar.c.. a Ax , aa acao-u..2 t, v.tP2 t err.. rrrt, zr2rr,o.

, ,r.a c . 2t... ata a oaot. .t tc aa , a ooao.J.rryrC, ,r.2 t ya2./ tr.rrr*, z-.r4/2 t, ,era-. -trt, Lrrr... a . a.

.oa- ^^

o a.. oaa 2 teac.c2 .O . O.ar..-,t zvL|-zt, zY ./t2, ,.-rt -ertJ.2 ,.tP.,,J t-.tt-rJa .'

4ao.a. ca , o ic., , aro.a o.ro , .)o o, . aat ./crv.rJ, ,trt ru rrrt -.rJ .r.., vrr-r, 222r, t-t 2r, ,rte2 trrct. aa a

-rCa ^^r^ oa.4 ---, ao. ae , ,.- roa \ ^^ ,

i-.-l ZU 12 erz.t 2rr, 2rrt t-t lj/- -r,,/rrt 2 rrt), ,..J, \rr, ) UJ F,7t

caa . 4aara. a. ru a . o a... a, . ac, u c.* 4ac.au ,.aae/./ /Crv.ta .-ottl .rr..taF,.t C 2.. r..rl2 .r.-r.9r rrt ./ Crv,,.r, .r2

, o. c.r, o .a, oro..r..r- t 2r- t-t.-o .utprt a O r. a- . C at r-rJr 2 22vt ,

chc,errrrr, ,-

4 Or. .rO.-rt-r, 7t-rc

,o arraa.a aa.c, aa-a, ata 4ao.c. o .a .., . aaa. ca.o,,- t zt.a.?v.a ttvrrt ./u.t 2 -r?t a eryrtJ,, P.4r 1 ,r, ./a.--1c2, .ayrrr

.rrca cao . lca.c. cra o .aca.a^ . n, ntt o. . ac, ..t2v-/ .tttH/t ,Erv..i ,t t: .7r.rrrr.rn-r1- :nJ /i, -.rr, trr!,

ac, atr, It r, t a . 4ao.ar..erYrri, a rO. 4 ar.-trt -lral

a, . ao t a c ar. .O...a caacu o,"-il, trrc, (Hr zrr.tt trt.zyr, utyrrt n-rrt

a .t.. a,at2t2r,

.utt66 \rr.F'r7aa , ac, \er7, azP)

t O. a.ac.t, ,aa o O .a. ,\r2. Hr./,-t lrrr..r, H',F"..4P-, a a. a a a.v.rr-., ,rr22rra )

ao. - arrrrotrzrc -2rv-P.

331647 | ::-rj .3325029 tj,;:i:i1www.highcoun.gov.mv :i-i- !l

22 .2rr2

[email protected]

.a , o D., '

O..O. a* '

a aaao a o oa 4a..a ....a,ttt.r. 2rr,r.J t rrtz2vz-.e!/r- .tr# t-rrr. Fr a.r> .t-7.a.tyi iyett.a a. a

20tt .,,.iii a r-araraaZY ,ottt2v-t,

aao taar- ,rI v22J----aa

,rar, , ara.aa aa 3 0.rrrrrla- ,rH-r.a ,t-t ,1t

a.caro c a aroa..t2yr.22r, ,r- trrt -,

2009 ?,i 25 .2ii-3 iij..,,:i,Li) .t574,9981- iiil :rti 9a tir: : 2}tr i? 25

craoa, .r.o a eaa.to. o . a /a ,c. . ., .4. ., a ar.. . c.,2 v,.,..rr2 1-, vr.?a, / CrvJtr/, p1., .7rt \tqtztt z,tzr wi;-1.* etti, zZi2

l\ Cn/ a t 4ao.o. c..., aoz a.) o... O.,v-J7O Jrv /err.J, zvrr, 2rv ,7) t-: rra 2/ -.2t,

Page 4: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20t2iHC-A/L50 4

'ltatao, a arra,ro., ,2r-

, aa ooao o c cO oro.-.r# Lrrz Pt2r2 ,rrteca.c. o. A-.erYJrJ, 2..err..

02 i:-; t)r) ,i 09 t7.i.i 2ot2 ;t2 ii; :.i3:; L-i,o o oA ccrc c-a. a rc2r. 4atD...a ar.. ac* .4c cr.ro . ,Pt arz arrr2 ,r,,,'2 , tzJr,,/r., .Czv-z. 2vu2 2r, -atr, srtJrPz \ac. aroaPt r, .FY.a.a

O . .eaP-t 2 J.t.r4ar.o, c *ar.a. a.tr,-az2 .r--rr2vri, J.r,

"..iili;ii: ,.iii ii (A052614 ii*t) 35ii):i ;i:i i-i., i:+i*i'a..o ,. or.. /ox o../

,4r,tu Jrrt,! -1., ,Yt.rJ J'Y -rr-a2

t914tCv-Ct2011 j3.1i z9 .3r- .1,3 jii .L;;;ii. ;,L. -03a./ ,.o. o4 ,o. ,.o/ a?t4 . o. t 4r, .40 .(AU)IOf 4 :/ --- tt, ,..'..,, ) cc42/-4 .,,t 2..r, .2ziz,ttt't

-ttt .r2vz r2,,r,! Ja.

.;:;-ii:irt3 .i)223 i;i/3- :i?.ia. a /

l974lCv-C12011'j,3.?7 :i9 ;'- :.7ii.L 3iij :to

r4et .*.t l-t) ln lrlaa 2t, c/, c ro...2.t ,v, t/r-/ ,-22y

1.zXI 7.37 t: 3.11 ett) ttzotoo.2 or. .,.o4 .. 1. .trrA .rr.. ,,,o,rtaJ.r-2 zr.r 2 --/ t,,/tn2 .?t lal irrJ t 2rr.-t /r,-., ,t L--a . a./ a .

, ox o?,4 o.2.o Do. .rr? o rrr ro. ..r? o aa .. . 4 , .oz2r/ ,r, ,tzr, -rvrpr-t2Jr-2 3 2Jr./ ,2P-r-r., 2./tz .rv e .*,,u t -2.F / e?n2

,\..1 t,,/tr 2 ,t l5Z tonnnJ rr,r:/2C7ta .,ri2y.,

or, .o*o.? or.r.o ,ro. ../r, .. . o/,t-r.t) 2v!.r4r. J'v!.t 2rrr2.rP2 .,v.?/- t.rJ-/ -2 .r-/2C2/ 4., 1ta

o .. . r? o2.r.r.2 .rJ eY 2t-.4.

t/O/ , 12.. .aD u-a &i.r.or2 -rJ iv.arv.r. ,t/ -a

,../v t4/ v.1P.t) t2rJltJ, ,Jr -/ ,rr.'r 2 ..rt t4., t.rJ 2-y4.,a.3'.t.,

/ rD? A 4alrrt -,.2., -,-

?r, a., a ro..t y, t-r..-, ,.22y

3]t :-t;) 3t2010

3316471 :Lij '3325029 :.2/ .|.ii-)2wrtrrv.highcourt.gov.mv f.i 3;

Ot, /rl oa.. / Ox , cOa Orz>,,t, .rt 2Y .r./r-J,tl ,,,r.D2, /Cr-, 2."r4,,

, / o, ,r:t.. .ar, -rai/-2, ,rJ iyr.r.y, ,rr? na.

\., ) t./t,,2 ?2

4 a , o/,2./ 2H)r.

22 t2.t-? 1r-. ter,2 tcar-t,

[email protected] i-i.

{ n-l un nz.- ar2. o, ..o., ao.o.o oa ot?/) r, Yr.,'r-, .lCrt.rlrJYe .iP,

o. 40 0a ox o2 a,.L, ePye J., 2rre /r'L2y

9ri9ilirit) ,a: i..p// -/rr. -2t.- i2i1 itr:::).r1,694239166o.aao., ac.c. o ro.,rty.ra/t, ..cry.t,/r rrr), \t2'

4 )r. .ac224/ v.tPrJ 2 .rr...aa

. . r.a..atrr2rY.4t2tP-U

-.t )

errrt , a ooao.rrt, 2rrrJ,

34:tlu4

Page 5: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012/HC-A/150

.4 . 20xoa. a4, oxv.r-.,) ., ,t.rJ .vrr- ,r'zv ,jrJ .tt2v ,v./r/ .?Jta.a.

.rx . . o.a ,. o c.. aa..? .r, oc? .ntrl JY-, ,'eY -/ *t2, ,2.,2r, rrt2Y .r.rP.u

o.. r. ? .40r, x col 40 0a ox o. a a2U2a.,/t v 2r2 ,-aJ t.t.,. v-7* trrs e,Jy e J ., 2)..re

o, 22..o , rr..a or4 0t 2 0 a rrrz. .. 4a,trJ2rr/ rrJ.r rr- r>J *!or,-, Jrr! r,,/r., /'a,

o- ?o., co20. o..12fJ, Y.r.,/t, ,e.-Y-,, ?rr4/

,rtQ2y ta t t/.-/ ,ar2/a

?rc o oa / 2. .. o r?2t, Frve v2t t.r2- ,eva/4., c 20r,

t/2/ ,-r'2 Y

.,-2rvro? ,r4 /Crv'r,

/oa.4 /. a , ?, o.., trct x oc , ?2? . ox ..o., ao.o'., t.rr?2, JJ ' ttr./ t2 zv2-72

"rvrrP ,Jtt v.rtJ.r) t r, vJtr, / crt/.r,,/,

o /rz coaoa a o, 2 .?o2, x o/ 40 0a o* o.c2tP .r'rt trrv-r/ -r./, ,.r2 t.rr 2.u. v ,P ,.pePve J., ,.rre ).rrL 2t'.a

.. r.. *4a /.oa oox./- ey.,.e,ven/r, ).- trrl

, ooa oox a oa, o . ,rZ o a oc/rJ eY, e-FY 'Jt .rrr' rrrrr+ rZ Jr-Jr't

-t.r./,a

,-.,.2y 2,r12.? J 2 ortt .r? o o.rt,2 t,2 3 2 v

'2r- .,.2.' v

,r.rrrr> J 2

2,.tJ-/2C2 tr4J..L/ a, a

.r'J2/ t'3 2-1) -.Yrro

aa?r, c.,.t.rt Y, t.r-,'/

(4)

o./,.. .. o 4,,'YrrJ ,t -.? t-rt.r-.tteYre.l-Y

,? oev 2tr-

c >t2 zJ e Yrr.?

.-iti t J.r. yat-r/t ..rzyrct y, trr) t/.r/ ,.?.r, t Cd42r-4.a

,ot, .... o. 2,,,'. "

...o,.//:t3 ,rrr2/J,2 .r,.r-rrv/t 2-r) v.a.rt

i.3.3,- 1 197 4lCv-ClA\ll .1 lii

.r?. orz...3 e y.r.. ,?.'2J

o. / /-r4/tP .tJ..t!e.,Y

.. . a, * /tro.oat.tl t.a ,.rrJ /, t 22rJ-rr./, ,

, a.ro o r.../.12--,-2

'v/ €,

,r32.yt rrt 12

a aaa r.....2.tt/ v 3 /)

.t2rtJ ry D. '

.. / r40 0 a r/ r. a aa ara , , \,,u)..r3 trtrrrv22 tr2rl ,tl irzv 2rrt \.)oo2 .,o. oa o . oz oo or?. ar/a. a ,.o/, olo,L.r., J.{2vrr-, .C/P) )a ,errr2 ,.?rJ Jrr2-r.,,t -.rJt .tve.r.2rj 2-r., vaa.a

.r2r. aoczo /o. ,ac 2 .o2o. ,.o, / .?tA . \ .4rx, ?o / Att/J., .r/.t2t*-.rr, ./r 2/ ,r 1142/-4 22-..t 1.22i 2.t2r.t ) trrt2J.t ,JrP-Pr.a'..... . a, x .rca

'.r2Yt.rJ r.a Y.ru ., trr 2),

2oo8 i.1i oe ita,3,12')

o.r, tzcrD o.o,zrt) ,2/vl zrrv

. .... o*.,/t .t ' .t 2 Yrr.,

. / a rrt.-2-r) 2J. t J

o ,,o2 ., ^^-u.tr.r2 Zl UJ

l,-r./, y lt.*1 .,t t )

arro /oa o../ . 2J 2rrr-.t., ,YtJrJ 2-J

.rro.oaJ, J 2rrr-rr.t

331647 | tLt; ,3325029 '",itia;awww.highcourt.gov.mv :r-i ti

.r2 ..-t-/ cr-. tEy., tf,r,r),

i,rogni{ncot$t gov.;y }- :.

Page 6: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012tHC-A/150 6

o a a o /.oa, J ,., .F-r.,/t ., 2

arra /oa o.o..o,t 2r*-r., ,Ya'rrrr.r2 ,J2'Jr,,/rr/02 .1r, 2l

. .oxo.2. ox o. rt/.-r'.rJ.-v.r.2r- -?tt.r,v224 rtt 2t rrla/

t./J r2.,,. vrr- 2*).Pa

o rx 4. .4a2 ,. ^^l.r,r. t 2 ..r2v.ttJ.r2 ,t vy

, or. arat a a or, 3 ,,v ,4 t "r2r, .. 'rrr-. .trva.a

.. clPv.rJ ,1,-,

arx o/ r12-trt trJ. Y224 .rt 2Yr/t rYa/

ar.a o , .c*ca.t vr>r., trrJ rvrr- r,t /.a.

.1 9.2 .3 9.1

t.ra arra.aa,tJC t't--Jraz i.tt Y')

,av.t/r, (2rl1v.,/tJ-

ac. t u ta aoaa. , c...,t'-..r, -l.rt l J.trr2rC zYrr/

a c.o, .4a,/ ,rr. Y rtt4

a a* o*aa. ,2ry ,.4yr)r,

arro .oa .. aoa.t 2tPO.a..2 .zre,.,

c ro. o o. a, o . oc. t\.^,,rrt t , .r'r.. Y .)r.t ,2- V')"/O

,rt.r)a,-t 2r- r7rJ: .tar..crvrr, .2vr4

ora.oa a .at-,-rr-,--r2 -u2Jrpt

Oa. c aa ,., a. aatr.t ,, e/r2 ,r, 2-, ePr2a .. a ....?4 c r.. ?...r2vtrvt-.J

^^ arra.aa n .4OA .. ', arrO /OaY,5 t 2tF,-...a2-' trJrr-r2 zi 14 t z2-,oaa

, rO .aa . tO. t a... , ,,, +) t2tP--r., .2r47yJt/r, .,-zrrJ, P7,

a ta, a a. a, a.raa . a-ao.-rrt r.-rJrv zrtr.4tzvrr-

aa. - aaa,r2, e .rav a , O.. c., ia.ra r\ .^ oa ao, a 4ao.o. ,- ,,71z- PtJ, \PrrtPt ) ov 2t.rtr2r, lervatJrl

a zaaa ..tat J.2 rt

..r2y2-u -r-tlrr -Caaoa O. 2o. arrro a

,-1.,/rJ 2 .tJttr-t-2 2,. ,eH222 tr.J. t 2, vttl-a ...

,i 44 ,' C5 ! zrF,-.- 2" 'rrrr./r2 -t 4)

a r., ^^ C.rrraa CCrra a .. aOarar.t/ 5V -2rvtr, -.2ur:, .2rertrr,z

oarro a .4a crrat aaaoo4 0.o.4 arc, o oa art aa.o,rrzttr' .. ..tr, trJrJrz2 . tr.rr-l, -rrJtr.. ,r..v ,.rr, ePrz ,2r, .rrJr..2.a

oo. o a. a, .., aa, ,. .ar, t /.rr.t P ,r, (2rtrv, tt4

: trrrt 2

-r.r7oatD ? c ccc , a.sa, o2. , c aoa o..2o. aaa otr a tD. tD tD.tr.Pe- F.rrr. ,.a ..rtt, ./.2 r,r4 Pr.a.e .Pvrt.al< --r. 2zto2 ..rv eH-2. .. a

o*o o oro.oa ,ro., c O zzacacre a ac .., ., O.,-.rr- ,tp-rtr.2 ./r -zra He- 2.-Crrtrr- ,aeP:: ,r- .-r- v2-./,

'trrtrt-, --.r e-r2 It a

aPyt.tJ 2yr2r-

z, ,r,-Y

, . ox o c c.). -r.-r/r --tr.,

- 7-3.3'- i 197 4lCv -Cl20l I z? o, -rr-t- ey ,trJ

, , a , o r.. a o,2r.vrr-z 2Pr,arx/.ozoc ?ro.oa,f2 l.?ttr"./r./, ./r2t*-rrr,

33 1647 | :!-ij .3325029 :i!,i:.2-L .; t,ti-- ij:r,igit it:ir tawww.highcourt.gov.my ii.i :; [email protected] f-.!-

Page 7: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20t 2,/HC-A/t 50

i.i;j ;e3 ilL.:: i:-; i. 2oo9

j 20tt i?4 .4 ,.-..t, lrJ rJ..t

itr:::) .,.1,119,241166 i757i;;;5., I Oy+ lSYlOO 22C v,, tt,t lt2 err-lP ,Jr>'tva ,,rPr,, FJz/t.r., v,r,.r,

a.

.t22 UY ,3rt r er/z, .,, . .

Zl t.rJ2v 2r,t.a

ljt, v./Lr./ ,ar2n,, I(:j

. ., .4. / './,,/r % YrPt,

4 . 2 ro2.tlJrrvrr-

o..ot c 4 / o.. . o2 ,,v.?rrvr, taJ-, .r?4/.> ,ttJaz

:-i;;t t ,3t r:i9;)r574,998t- t;tt:i

.*.t Ya/r 22Ytttr-..J /e?Y.,r/

o2 2 0.* a22v ar!.Jr,

e.''-' e2

.rtJPi 322/e

o ?x u a oo ao,er.?., .rr2/ 2rrr.,,,

o.. r. o r...-rt 2.rj, ,r.rJ

tr. t /erv.r,,/, P.rJ., Pt2, 'rr2v2, .u ,vr' v.PJ,

,/Crt,.t, ,-.rJ /, .r.t.rjr.tP.1e 2-/ rrYr24rr.,a . a . a.

3 er42/'4

o o oA a 2ol.4ao.o, ol. r. o r42 a2 .oro.P2 222 rr.-22 v,/ erv-r./t ..?r.t,/t ,?2.) 3 C €4r/-4.a,.. ox a. . o,ocAr, ? .o,./r2vr-F, ,t.Fr, .r-t .r.rt4., t.rJ zt,

J 2',, Y.t,J.rJ ., ,-r,,/u 2.tJ r- 4 t 24., .,a2

2 vi,,/r, /e-,v.t,/t .U2rr/r .rr-?/r, vrr-./rJ.t ,2t r.?., 'rr2'2v .t'v2-J

2 0.? .., ora. ., /oro/ ,.ol o..rrr rrr. o,.a.2.2.rtr.v3lJ ,yt.rJ.-o -.?/) 3 E 842,,/t -4 /t 2...' 22v,t v.r-2.1 lr2 y./t.rrJ./ua.-

. o t , 20, ,v2 s/2e2 3rr 4t. a/ a

arar. a n.trv./P..t2

a . a*, a.a,tJrr.rYr rr..Y o.rrcaaa.-rrvrvraPz

ar. a, .nt2vrttry , ?. o.ro'r.r2- -22rr.,

.ro ara a ? . ?... o r?. a.y22r, J er-y t,r)rrt/ ,-r.r) Ja.rra

: 20ll t33!-z 12 :.9r-3 - 183 ;ii

Jrrrrtr'J 2 ir2Y ,t, (-)

€€422'4 J2,,,, (/.,2ea.

- 40.3:2i - "ie:?.o.ro ? .ox, a., 2 v rt 2 2rr t r) zt,4.r tr-

z,er, ,ODr. 1a a.42142 .o2' P,

aa aar, ,.rtrrYarrr rYo aa araca

'rr..rr, t Yr.r,

oo a .-o, oa o / ox oo .?.L-., ,.rr2Yr'.t , eltQJ )r, r,.e-r2 ,.!.Jr). a . , .. aa.rra.or. ar. ., . 2rzoz/. c o. ?z2rvtrt,.aP2 tzyrtLrJ './rJ 22.r.s ./, t e-r.-y .r2yz-?r) t p-,J,

a., ./ ora ?.oc/ /t/r'/ ,P.r 2., .r2Y.r 2e.r.,

o r.a a

-r-r2 ,at... O.o. 4a, .vrz, trvvt

a r.-4. aa aa a,rfrtrra 1-L

o aa ar.a.,rr? 'vr4) , a*- a. a,,at./v/r ,r-voa 2c., t,t.aYJrJr rP

).o*D a.C, c.rt tr.a.. ar. a, , ,.o.roc, ,.c.t/r-v/ ..r..v ,zJ.v '.v..P2

t2Prttr., .rrzztr.rv ,rrP2

..1 crPt J.t ,ePrza ..a.. a. a, aa. ,.2ryarr, yJrr

3316411 ::-t; .3325029 tt,;:ir;4www.highcoun.gov.mv :i-i- !.1

,2 t-tr, ar-- .e,-, ta".rr,[email protected] j..i-

Page 8: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012tHC-4fi50

ol/ ao o., oa.. o.2aac. ,. .roa ar.. .. ^l\t^-2t? t2r, ,2PJ,C2. zr.t v-, ./2

'-.r -t -tr/- .?t zvlz

o ,24, 4,,.?ttJ 2r/

2r., ,ta, v, 3 .'

4a . o rx ,r4trr- ,r3rr3a. r. oc a .

.trt 2v Jr.rrt.,t -

o. / ao, . oclo . arrc/ac oclox .rrr/, , o.. o 4ao.>2..2/re2 tz.r. E2 ,rrrrr-/,/ 32tr,r.rt., ,vrl" rt'2r'v2//) 2C?2, / C.?J' v/r.,a, a 2

.r- a , o..O orr., . .or.O D .. ,a Do.a,.rr-, -t2.. zrrpl 2 ,/rrr...t ,r, .rt.. a.22-- tr.ttv., 2..r4 Lr--, ,tPr,.t-za4 0., oa.. o.-oa. c c .4.t, .r22Prte2, .att .t r.tr rt-rr..- ,4o., o e .

,./ yraJr, ,rP".t

...c,./4.r.,t,J. Y t /)

I -t Yrtc Y.r ,2, Y 3 -rJ

? /o2o. 2.o..re C42J-4 Jr 2/i,,

,r* .4.,-t ,r.o r... c, /oro.,?/J t e542/-4

o...o o .JFJ.-.art .P7t

o o.4 ...,erzl 2r4

,v2.tJ zvr2ro

,222-- J e.Pot

22t2r, t:) t2r:

2 '

C '

O ?/ C O,trvrr-2 tP./, .-r-t \r),.a. ,a2 0, -r, ev )>tP

o1/ ox o ax./, vrf a ,,5

'.v 2P

o.o, n.,.vr., Y /rrJ ..r J

.1.X3* 1 197 4lCv-Cl2\ll

l.tt*Yr ,*t

:t1) t ,,2tP'.r'.'

. / ao, .Y..2C2 trr. €2a a. a

,4 '2?

. .O '

,/- ,rl v22.v.-, J..2e2 jrr62a a . ,2 a

2,rJ t .,/r 22 .t C C42J -4.a

/ rrO /oa., t 2t P-rr 2

J., ,ePr2

./r22-2t/ '2/

' PPPl

-t5r?22422 t.r.r'2Ytc, rr.,/r2/

c ?x , a ao.ot e-/r.r, ,rr2.r. 2rrr.,a-ac4 . c 2. .. 4aoz? o.e>.

./r.rPrr) t:.'r, ,./r 2 / errrl 2r. vlP

o2-o' crx 4a o, o/ ...r'U/r 2 t?t /CrY.u PaJ,, ,t, J,rP.rC2/

,.?t2 ..r.-2 Yr.r-rrr.ri.t,, rrJ r-2 l,'r2C2, 2. al

ooao,rr./ L-,r.,

,.o/ r ro4, o//4, o a.4-2./vrr- z2v2rr3r,

,tzyt4/ - e.2.-?.t/, .r, zur2 Jrly.tl2a2

oa? . 4ao.ozttzt*"/J ./c.Pv.r.,/t

or.o.. a..o, ?x,2Yr/J, '.r 2'2 Y.r, eJ..?.,. a.

o o oA .?r,*'t Lr2 i.ttJ.r'.- ,t 6

o o o? G.,.. o.2ox,-t \22 "-r2-t

., ,rvt rt ,J2t .r/2a

oa/ox o2? c 2. orx&r?roa.,yt t t .r.r2r.r. trl.r r?tt52y.r,

aO, . t? C Oa.O*3.-/at j.- t 2trr.PY., .,t Y!?, t

o a.. ..../.c oa/o* o, .'-2 2rt.rJ t-1r.Y.., -.,Yr,3 .-/2e2

a. al

? . 4ao.o. o rU.,-.tJ -.erv.rl ,.?r.,

o. o, ,t. ,2.rr.a Y /r.r) .r j

.. ,r/ ,,ttt ,rr, .rruJ ..t J

ao, ,trr.et .rJ 20tt t.3.i7 29 i;|rl 3j:;

, 4C r./?..r..ttryt-.J

,c?ro c ara arr222-.-.t 3er-Y

o.4 z o:ao... o..o2ro o .. ..roa,vt.t) .v.r.at - .r2yrr22?.- 2.r? o ,rrt -,

aa or?. a, ,oro. ,ro/'?YJ ?rc4 te e42J-4 -t2.t,aa

oa a.., ,, v./2 c 2 t 2/ ct\ a o/ aor.oaro.oa

,2 Y.12tP-rrr,

.-O. Oa O / ax OO ,rO roa ? .a O.,,frvJrt-,'e/tP) )4 /eP-2 v2tp'-./t., 2JrJt .r2.-r,,. a , a ., a

*r.ePr2.r.rJ/2c2, . / . ,/

?2o.?2 c? c/.-r 2y.rra.,r) ,,rr t., L2 y

54'71 :L!.i ,3325029 if,i:t.-iawww.highcourt.gov.my :i., 3i

22 .-t-, 1r-, .?v,r tl-r/t)

inro@.)h{icourl. gov. ;v J. i.

Page 9: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20 t2i Hc-Ai 150

o. o t ov 2 2.-.' /rta.*2.P-a.

OD z. ...O.,2t /,2 t.t) t.., t

,?/e-?2 ..ao a, o 022.re.t2, Y I-t r..a

20 t 4ao.o orx4,2r/2 / Cr2r' "ttJo r?o 2 2 ..,e "r2H .r2.rJ t.t z, v

4..

?.4?, ar..t. ? ?. o.yt Ja 4t 3, yrrJ J,.rtatrrt ./, 2tr2/

o.. oa/o ,ro. a,22v Jtrpr-r2./r-2 t r, c 2 tr, 4t, a, a

20 0, . ao, . .rro2.r., .r,/2 e 2 rr, 4t Jtt 2t.-/. a, o 2

,4o2, ,- a-../r'jrr2 ,, LO

02a or.D4 o.oc 2. ,?, oc.o?.22vJ,J .r-rtJ.2 rvrrl Pt./rr, v,,/tr../2r rttrr-a.

./t/, ..r2v.rrtr- ,2v/c- ,2.roto

2'L? J.-' t.u tr a.r t, 2'2tr./

o a a oa, o . , o r..,tt./, ,, vr-Jr... ,--Fr 32v2

..2.. 2 oX. /./'.r2Yt.rJ.,-YtrJ

3t2oto .231 i;3J. y!. t r.u r, ,rSarrl -r./.,

,, a.rrrzat ,JrJ/r--, t

, 4.rrrarr 3 *--./Lr-rJ

22YrJlt.,Jr/a , 2 0 2 0.r c €42/ o4

a. -,rrr4 ., 4a..,c O Oa\t lrrJ ,jr.1 ./-2t, ,JYe )a,

i5i.,)si )3:1'

rc., y.rJ, /erv.tt ,Jr v224 -1J 2/t-/ P.rJ r' '.rJ.2

zrt' ./r) v.r.,rt .rtrp,/r.t2-a.a

./ erY.,rJt .r.rrrrrj ,-2r/., oa44 ,, oao,.r. t, .t.tr2.,t/ C ,t, .rr.rY t 2,a

o. ?ro .,,.t.r) 1.2€2

2rA o. o.2,/r? .rPY e

2012 i.13i ,i;ri:

/e--, 2rr.r, ,./r.'r 2 rrtr.,r,' 3 tev2t,- 'J.-rr4 rt'v1t'2*.r/r.,.a2

?er-2 ,42.r,,/, -r3rrr.. v 24rfi v.rPrrJ 2rJzv24/ ,-22v./r.t,r.t) ,-2,a2...4a t or... at /o20/ ,.o. o...aa.. / ox ,..tr2yy/t? ,,?.r.J t cc4r/t-4 .,/t 22., -.t/2y/r/rP/r) ro.r -2,.a

oax o rx4, ., /.,rrP3

"3t3 .1*.r)

o/ roa ? .. o., otar-2 v.r.rt ,J.u 2 -3rr,/- ,.r.2.t 2 t/t, -r/,

,. o. o rxa,,/t 2/,.r rt' 1.,

olox.e/,p) J.t

o..r? o. o ./ .,.rx.-t2J,r,v2 -e,J 2.rJ 2.-J/ a.

2011 ta3j7 29 -::o > / co, / .2

'?2C 2 tr/ E2 .' t. a. a .

) ,t 2) r.,

,ca 4 .oto.,2, ., C C42J.4

4 .,..., o r?. at .otoutrJ t./2., ,.rr) t C C42J -4.a4. ? ,?rx o/ /oro/ ,.o, o o z ? o a oo. .-o/ oa

3 err.t .rrv-reP ,,rJrrJ 2-18422-4 ,r2/,., .r-, P-'>', -r2 2.--, /.frv./ 3na2 . a. - a

.rr2vtrrj t.*/ ,rt.) vt9tPr24 2

a[9,.2 -19ti : 20ll laZii 09a .. . a

oo otx. ?-? .., or?./e-r2,Utr,'.r2Y'Jr).P.,rrr)a ..

t. o. .. ooJt 2.,., .rrt / er'r2.a

.i 20tt,aiii 13 -133i

t e c42/-4 ,,r 2,.r, 22 vr.,,/,

2-- ni,2ti : 2oll ,a?ii 09 : :-*/ i,,i ii: *jtu?.ia/ . a?/o. o.tor.., o.. Ao ot. ../.rror4 ozzo? o.a, or.t tr., r-2t.rr./.r.,, ..2PJr.] .r2., 2rttl.ur- .P2.,/r.r/ 2r., v ,r.,

3316471 :Lij ,3325029 :.2, ';:ir;4 ;i ,ti-- 2;:t,i?t it:iailwww.highcourt.gov.my :i-3- 3j [email protected]

Page 10: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012lHC-A/150

,c..2C*o oao, cv.r2 4t-u ,.r2.t {P

,-rl 2 ,r,

o./.. /?rxjF2yt.u 2rl

.1.i.3,- 1 l974lCv-Cl20ll

. ,2.../, 4 2.tJr2242 tJ

a rxc ./o. .2 2 ea o. o,5t? 3rYr./t HrJ .? C.r.Y.Lrt 2.-rr.rJ .rr t 25i.3)si

a , . o, o2r I e42r -4

rrr ZVI L-ev., l) ,rrJt) rr 2-/ ..,r2vtlr) tt.P.t ,rrJ rrePrP2 , ...2t/.,--/-a. 4 .4rx o. o rr..rrq- t.u2-) .C,PJ Ja ,e.-?2 -.fr) t C Carj J-t ,z2a, a2 . a . a - a

oa oo a o , ox,-,rJr-f2 v, J., 2.*., e.'.,LJ J., r. e>..p2,arao./ C*o .rxzz.

.r2-l4 tJP 3 t-r.,./ rYrrJ

aaaar..?, o2., .a2 or.r2.t.r,/ v t /) JPvt.r)r- ,rr)

./r.rP.tJ 2.rJ 2vr4, -J./J

,?

,/2C2 t-r-'.12a, a

O ,. ..t O a,''?' 2"J',

t 22r-tt J./re2 t.rr lta / a? o

o o oA ,. ?ror.-P, t;r 2 ,r2 ,r2t.1t.,r zrY

or rzll,2.rJ 'r, t

.,'o ,,,,5 2tr/ ,,r. Yr..J 'rt 2.a

\.,) r,,/t,r 2rt l3Z

o r?. c ?x > c,r/) t er.t ./, .trt.'r"

t err..ltjt

o-r. 4 ,o,. arro./rrr-rP 2r4 '2tr/4 4 . rb* ?,.r./t -.PlrrrJ

ttt 2rJ2.t !a/-1.r...aorrl ? a o a .oa.z ..

.ttr.r/rP/, Pta t r, Ytcrt +

.ro o.oro o.x4v22-- arr2-- 2rt -2a,

, .. .a oc,,tt.1)12 ?/2

3rJ tr9t rr., -Pr-1

,O? -.., O..r. 4 , o.. crro2-4 .rr22v ,Fvrt

-rP 2-7., t 2tr? r.r.t/,

, o2 /oa, ./r, o.,o,CJ, ,, ,3.r!P 3 2/ 2/ .rita 2

4ro o.o. . .24r. rr.rr2t.-/ ry.rP2 Jr y.r.>," -r.t

or?r, .oxo4.-,

yr r- , Frt 2.rt -.J ,ut,r.rr -a'

(-)

aoa.o/.. 2. ,t., vt ?.i) ...,../

.r.r.,/t.rJ ,Y Yr!.J.) Yt

.r/r-/22

.., o//2.. ,-?t, ,Y.P/) Yt / crr. v

o./22 ?..4C' 2120X Crr..r-r2r, .ra?2vv./t.- ,t 2vJP3 ,t2Jrr4

3316471 :!-ij .3325029 :.21 ,ii7/1www,highcourt.gov my :i.) 3j

2' "r.tr2

ct-..et,2 te,r-t/,

info@highcourt gov.mv J-i.

,..o, ., - 1r,?r, ,t.r/.? 24o .. ,c?,o / ,r.. .o. .,2 6 .t-,..r, ,t I r vJatev, ,tJ.vJ/) trrrr|., rr 2.r.2r.rrr.r., SSJ .s g-*ova.

.2 ,rr. t .rr, ? ...o., ..o. r.. o.-o. a4 , 2?o/ 2....,r2, ,,/rr)..t3 .lrJ2v,a t.r)2.u.v 2.,J. t r- .r..r.-r 2 ta J.t .2.rryt./)

.Oax Orxe, Aroa 4 . 4aorO. Or?. 4 ?r.,tt zvl I J.-22, z> ,rttt 2y.t/ P.t) -. cry-t/, ,?.r) o2la/

a r. r.? ox4atr2.rr v 2/ r.it,,

c ., r rD? ..,o t:rDt+rt.rt trnr.u2c

?., ,.o . ol?o ,roro, ttora,..r 2.-rtJ.2 tL 2 2..rr-r./ / 2 C2P-1J. ,J 22./rtrt z, v,.

t?zt er.JP ., .tr2J.,.

O a/. .?..ra Oa/Oz.-t2rt.,rJ trra-yt ,t te,r, J

4 .?or.. . o..oarot.t) t,,rt.t 2, Y -2Yrr22r,

, .4, O., O. 12 ? a .AO.2Cat.tJr- ..2Y .,rt J.-arPr. rtt2.r2.,a.4r?.. oa. ? ?.o a ,2 2tt 2vr, /rrPrJrP t 2r.r., ytrrJrP

a.

t32

4.. o a_o 2 4ao/,..,,r.,.2 yrr{-r -, / r-_2. y

a a,tnt4t ;--Prr-*r j tr,

o'z

?rr?.?, o.o.o....r22. v4er2 .r!r!ryrr-2,

Page 11: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20121HC-A/150 11

tr., )

,-r,

.r'rJ 2.u.ua,

1r, o / a't d-tn tur)

.r2'2v2r-/r2 r

.i 2012 ,a3;i 29

4, ?/2 o..rt tt .r2Prr22

,,/r 2.rP.t) 2 o22

4.... o/..rr'2 Y2Prr 2

. DO2., ,,/rr/t.t a.r -..P

orD , ar..2.2,2+,r 3 2Y2/2/

o, 2 ao, /,./rc2 trl c2

a, / 10t ,t/2c2 t.r.2. ct

,rt r, t, ,/r,,.

,,.ov 2t 2r., .,

o.o/o42occ*tr.?.?/Jr/.,

,2t7) 2r:

aoato.oa 4 . c,3 -.2tPO.a' t.r) tJ. t?

o. / a .. a o a

-2vrJ2jrr

ltrr 122

oaox, o., o.2./a.c .c./,J.,y*.,/r2 zrrJ PJ., ,v./r2/

ta...,, 2./.a4a.,v.rrrrr./t ..r.r-2v.rtr3, ar- lrt 2v rrtrPr*2r4 ./r.,2a

.rJ t.rJ

o.c oxo .. oro 20c or/. 2rtoa, ..ro.oa ,. .4ao.o, ot.,v., .r-vrra o 2tP-/r., ,--rJ 3 2v.r.r- 2tt-7, ,r2tP-Jtr, ,-.t) ., crv.r.,,/, .r.,,/t

o. .orol ora . ,c?roa ? .a ox / .ao.2.€142/-4 '2...' 'er-v ,,/r22v.r, -.r1.,

.,'.vrt.r) tr.t./or/. / oa/oxtr,t., Z, Y .rYt t J

-rrtz 0/o. 4.o., o ? o.rd '

. 4.o. o..r. o a...rt-rr! ,r.vrv .. cr-, v ,.r-/ 2 z2.r/ PrJ / c.F.2 .r'.r2rr.,/t -2 2rta/.4

o. , o ? 02 0. 22r, v ,rra 2 .? vrr*2

..4j Z// P.rJ, Y.r 2tr) 2Y.-2ro ,rYt Jr.H

?

'1n e Sozt'o

2008 -i; 09

2:1

.rtrYrt Jrto ,x4 r a/

,r-ttJ 2v2 1.,

o, / ao, /,/2C2 tr/ C2a, a

ooca o o oAL?r-r, ,-t zr2

>r2 . r ra:-J t 2r.,

o o oA o t/ l,-t \22 -zj, J

o2.r. 4 .a2rr.rr, -1) n

331647 | :Ltj ,3325029 ;t,;:i-,i1www.highcoun.gov.mv :i.i 3i

2' t.tt 2 1t-. ree,l tz.r,r,

[email protected] J.,i-

?,,4. rrrr4 ol /.. \ ?x > .c oo.o o o o?..t22v2Jrvr-J .r-.t l-'r 2 t errr, .rrt., zrrn Pt a22z a al

ox oo.t-r r{rt.,.t.t . C./.PJ ).t re*-2.a

-2J t.,/r r 2 .rt ++crro roc

3 22P-.r., .rt

.rto.oaa . oro 2oa 2. .ox z.r i 2t--rrr,.,, ,t ,tr--.r,,, 2.t) -rY.rP ., t2a

4., /4o/...r.,2 vrrJ Jrn zee42/-4 .r 2..,,,a

4.. /12o.r, 02/, ora.oa . /?.a oa.ox. r.p2 v .r,t /J 22Jrr, 2v 2 2-- -t P.rr, 2 r2 lrJ t 2r-? J, yrpta t

..4,

crro.oaa 02., oro roc or.ocat 2tP-.rrr./, Jr l.2 22rrJ, /v22- ,tu.rr,.a ,2vr/.,

y.r4?.t e.-r2

ii 03 : (rr1 ,3- i:3]i,Lra 3Doto

, a oo ao.trtr. Lr2ra

20ll ti 2t

, .44t 2ta a, Yrta t rr 2rrr-rJ

2. /4a o/ rrr...t2'2 Y.. Cr.'.r- J o.. ?x , a

-2Y e/r., .rrt,a.

,t A , - . tr4,,rl ,2") t,vr2,.a./

(-) -r,9 1O ! --r l J, 2-/

arx .. .o*or.t-? t t-,J.r.vr)r-

4,, zoxo 4.rr.P2v .r) 2t 2!2 -

?..o., ao/o.t Y.L/t, / Cryr./t

/'c .7 iZi: \'o'-;-=---.:

@(-)

Page 12: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20t2tHC-4n50 12

o ? o.-o, ao .,.tr2 .rr.t2 JaC4.aa

oo . . rao,e-er'.rieY2tla/

4 . 44. o r4,t.r).,/t2t,. ,.?/)

o , o. ,. o,t/-4.r2/'"

/? o c, to2U2a t t/rr*a,rJ ., Ptl.rt 2r,

..... 2' ?.O' art.,1rrr2a e ..tr.rv r./t,J ..rr

n.rzv ,r ZUI I /-2eJP ZY .r-cal zv za2

..,rJF2vrrt ZVI I /-2t, Zy ,t.rJ t 2.-., ,t 2.r- t..2C2 Jr.,. eta . a, a

:Zei;;3i ;3:t '-3',i n7 2}ll ,t€ti 04a.

.. , coator, /er-2

. o aa,r2.r!.r.r., ,...,, . oz.u

',,2.1).rvt4/z z? o

-rtZY ,tP ,,/r., .t22t.r./rPrr)

ot.-.r2e2 tr., €2a/ a

.r l 2Jt./

2'2rt./

/... o,ir2 , 2.,r....n22vr2*, ,/r v224

ii 20tt

J,J,-J''

a o oo a o 04 00 0 r,Zi -lrre 2.u./, PrrJ J/, .,' e-r2 ,r,'r-,| / , ./

7t20tt j.ii /i:./i .2 /4o. rroa,.r) t.tJ. Y 2r.,

aoaoC Oa t . C Or.?. o.,J ' e.r2J. t.. t.rJra ,v.tr-rr/r/r 2

tvr2 v/t ,rt2-.r22

4, .r..tJ ttP.t) .r.rtr2o

.uo. , oc.. . 4a o. o.Y .r/1, ., .t PrJ / C, , .r/t

.P2 t r./ erJl t .'.22.t

. ., . a.r t-rr., Y.r-,

iv2v ,tP, (-)

3.,/r r-i- JP 1., .r!.r.t2 2

.r.rJ.JP t vt rrJrP

t-?2.t,/, t, rr t Je.,.J /e2Y.rt

o. , o a , , o, a.r'2t,r, Y, , Y.,/,

> aa ooao,rt., 2r2r.,

ot.o?2a o , arrr a oa22 o aoa,Y.?f4 ., ,, Y t 2JrrJ .rJ, 3 -

-t.r.,

o... or..2. o.2a.r-/rJl2 rv.rrrP/rr2.,

4aO4 o r.4. O., ar.r. o., C . 4-., .oxo4.2 er.,/, ,v.r-P.r.r2 tt 2.rrt .s/fa t Z J-t '.t.r2t't.rJ zrrr-

Y.rJ, trttP/rJor.o?.c o ,cD,rrUry., ,rtYt2r,

,a .2.ortoc, ,22. ?.., oD o.4 or.4. o.ra2r2 ..rJ/JJ-2trr.Fv .trt-zv t/../ r2r, 2.rr2 rv/rPPr.r2.,,a/.4

,-2 a.r2 -2?Jr.t't/,tP e- rv,

420rOu O..r// CrY.r./, zr.rr.t,

a rol... .oxor..,-r,.2y2.t) zyrr-

?,..r 2 .t.rP.rJ

...r2o .. ,...o ota a 4orl2 / o.r.2.'rY2t2r, trl22-, ,eroY t.rt., A, Y .ttJt rPPrH

?2,,4

,rl t 2J. v Clr,

a .?. o.2/lrl2Prt2

?x , . oo.oer.r., .rr'.a Lrrrr,a. 2.tJ 2 Yr.,/tr,,a...rr. c2t2Ylctta t

33t647 t :!-ij ,3325029 :ij,|:.i1)1www.highcoufi gov.mv i.i :i [email protected] j-.i.

Page 13: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2ot2tHc-Anso @ l3

, a ?z o,Y., .t.rJtrr./ , J.rrrlrr 2

, tra o.ot? / ?/ o.. ,t2r-. ,r) .r'rrrr..r) 2o 2,-.122 .r2v.2./ o.2 0 , ,2. , /.,, v,?r2r/.t 2r2 , tr 2

o . cr./.,f2 t vr2/4)-?

,o* ..2?4 J.t- .rr-..2H 2 lta2.r./t F t.rt vt 2*.r 2

4, o ? ,?r.tr2 2*- r.Yr.r- ,Jr/,

/ e-rr. vJ ,J

., 3 2 t/ orr.r-, LJ- o

..t2t,2.yu/)

ozzo.rr4 ?z 4.trr..J'2 YJ'?- 3 rrr.,, PPrr-P-- J/a

Or. . O2x4C2./OrO,t 4/r4- r!.t./oy?r2r.,

a.

2420a o.yt r,.J .r, -t.-2a /.

,. ,,GH-,rJ

' 2y'

o//4 4 oa, a /2-2y52/

't r.2r+ 2

o,t ? .2.r/o ,ro..rr - e t ., y.?,?r.t2.rrJz

.. O/ 4 2AxO...2'--122 .r.2rr) J-y.r.tro

za,

tev

. ?,rt Z aAo ,ro, a o//a2 oa ..4 o. //.o/ a, 4 o/? 2... o,.t-?rrrt Jr.,tJ..r 2 c.rt/t .2vr/tv.t/t v/, 2-.rrr 2r- 2/ e/ ..ev -, J2rrrr 2./,a.

4 4 ,oro4,..r.r?2.rJ zYrr- .rt \/) ii 133

,4rrr/ o// /,2242 .rt4/'P

a

ao5 erov -.r,

o 2x a , , , r..?rJ 32J'Y)/ t'YJPY

, tao .Oa O. O rA . ?.// o.,'t--rrJt 2.-?t,L-) 2-2Pa22

., 4 , .2Uo. o, 2 .r. . a?otr. e ., -rr?r.2:- J,-/2e2 tr4r.tL JrrrrrJ2a. a .

,o o.oro o. a,.r. ao, -2-' ,trP' 2.-.- 4J 'U 3 f2.t/ v '2 e 2 J

'/ C 2aa a a. a

..r..2v.r/2e2 t.rt., L.,., t, .rrr.PrP 2r4 t3tr.l, v./2C2/ a. . a al

o..r.4 ,o? ?or...r'Yt r-rP 2r4 trrt.r 2, Y

J e vrr.,

?.orra ,.2.21 2Yr2t., tt.rr)

.2r 2Y2.rJ 2.r., .F-.r.?J. Lr-

, ../ o.z/? ?.,.ol..rrr2- .,r-rry/2 2.r) y.rlt

c ?.. o, o cJ, .r/rrr 2 yrr.rJ.2 e 2-a

o, . ao, .,/rc2 trl cta, a4. o 22,t2r, .?-r,

yr€t ..e2.'.y<lr? D2 o.o,,or.o,rt Ptzvrprt2r,a2

/ o /-o/J a r. erJr2 ?2, ..,.t 2 t .,. J.t

aO 2 / ,c ?r/ / 4aO/O. Or. t.t# Ct rr 2.t.r,-.u -/ C, Y.r.,r, 2U2.t,/,

ox ?o.. /z2-, ClPJ J., ,ePr2 ,tzvldta . 22 a a

,rt .t 2rv ql:f

y./t ,r32P.r22 .-.? 3 2

402, , o. orao ? .?ro o,2r.,. v dJ.r-? ,t2r, 21J22-: ',.a;2,t r. oa4

.rSJ .tat-.t) 4COa O..t./ cr., /?2.rJt

.rr'J. J!92.r,

..r.-2Y Prry

.Oxr.v., er.J.., ,rrt,a a/

,-?t ,rJ ,2-3-2rr-41,

3316411 :Lij .3325029

', ,;ri.;1

www.highcourt.gov.mv :i., 3j';i ,t.i,. Lt:i ,i?it i?:[email protected] J-i.

Page 14: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20r2iHC-Alr50 t4

? . .o.o. .e .ct..) .rerYrr.,/t ..n-7/ "

arx ,r2 o,ta ? . 4.oa,rt-.-J 22rr/ P.rJ /Cr-2

e/.?.tttr)

o o oA o ... 4. o?,Pt 2r2 P22, ',r2Y ,r)

y., 2, e

1)ru

o.oc?,r, ,Y.r.rP.rJ .?.r?2.r./t Yrtr 2aa4. 22 2o..., ..Jr2v 2rt.-t/rrHrJ

o.. r."/ er-2 .'.-r.2.r,,t

4/ . c 4 o a'-r.u2 Yrtrt -2

z 2? ,.Y 22 / P.rJ ., .r'.t J .t 2/a/

2-2y/ c:-2 2J.2."J' 'v-?r4,

J 4.rrr2 orx. ../oD o2/.2,tv.?-rl ,.?3.t ..r2yr, ,rr)

arrA oa.. . a/.t 2.,/, / .rrPrrJ t.t z-? t/

o.44t 4.?22'.r/ at /-2Y

t t r.rr? ,rorrrprr-.

Dd,?l t 2rrrt

.r2v..r.,r214 t .r2a

,. o. o t t ?C a42/ '4 , 2r,./, ,t t r rt'a.

o aorl? ,r, oz..oPtr4 tri 2Y ..42.rd

oo.o o o od2-2-.t ,-t t22

arr, , o. o 2?, 4cr.. orao a a, . ao, .t 2r.y 4rr? ,r/ct J"-2y ,t2rrJ, 3.r2e2 5r.r€ta . 2 a2 ,

ttr)

o , ar/r, ,r? / ,,,JP 2 JY?2./. ,rJ J., 4rP/a.a

7"-1) t.r) /erY.rJ,

,? ?a . r. o., o oax)22 ,rrru, ..r -r -/) r-22r, .rr9 t .r.r, C 2a.

,D. ' O rxc)t.?) ..t t ,t 3,

ao, .tr, €t .r 3 2011 ta'2.i7 29

o.rd ? /c.r-2J, z P.r) .,D4 Ax , ccrs I .ztt e.r.-?., .rrtr.a a.

4ao,orl orx/ Crt.rt., ,rt

o/, 2 ,arrr..rwz/J i/ ." 2142

...r,)-, v/t t7) v.rJ ,?rl tr2,-r 2 /, -r.2./ 15rPr 2:

-rrr 2.-. 22v2?t, .rJ tt.,

(-)

'-r2'Y.?rr2 ,.rJ t.rz./ ,.?4rS,or, 422 0/,/rtt rr./r2P.r2

or/ r2 0 rxo, azrr.r,,/t .-!9 3!9 t Y.,

o.2O ? .c2'2rr/ Pru .,

trt22yr./- 22J-2

, . a, ,.. 2a/ A/(r2rr).r,, Jr2 .rr2Pr22,,.

-3.3,- 1 1974lCv-Cl20l1

...22? A .4o. , ..?o...rzrrv/t trr) v.1, -r# Z?-

, ?/ oxo...t..t2.2L.rr4,

/.?o2, o.xAao.ola or?.4co.o2 , .a' 2,Y.r,,/r, .r'rt/e,Y-rJt.r rrJ.J /e,Y.rJ Pr).t

o tx D2 o. ?x,rt-ri zrrerrJt ,r-2,a a/22/4, /ozr?o arl?.(.t 2 t,2, ,J .y.r. yr., ,y.#J

2.wgo2.t Z .r.rJa

.. . 4caat,'JrJ /e.-t-2

oo ao o o o? / r r.2r/tr2s., ,-2.r2 ,2.r. Yt4/a

.2. o.P2.r.r rJ,P.r22

ev 2t,- )..f.r 2 3 c c42.,,t -4 J 2..r' '2ZiZ,t.t..t

4 2oxo.,2 /?12 ? .ox,r)lvrr.,Jt4,,/t 2.u.r.v

, a ooao/t.t, 1r2r,

3316411 :l-ij ,3325029 tl.;:i-;2www.highcoun.gov.mv,i-i t;

22 .-t-, cr-. .2"2 tz,r,r,

[email protected] j.i.

t,_

dr,:

!..P.r)

Page 15: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012tHC-{fi50 l5

.a a O-at.rJ..t JPaa

ouox(C/)PJ J.,

, . o, oaE 1422 e4

a

o/-oc ..ro /oc.r?3.r., .r2tPeAJ,

a

Oll aa . aO-?e ZLt/rJzr.?/

oo o rx4c?,,e*?2 ,ra3.ro2rr,? /a a

O. O, nrr. , n?r.rY lr).rt-f

o 2... c, . o, ol-frJ 5 C e42le4a

?zz araaarra.rt2v/r3J22J.vJ Paaa

o r*.c2?s.,

oo c2r.,

, / ol

irtS: ,n3i .32011?a

aa

oa a o c aa ..r2Y.r.rP/r)/

a-aa oa ,2 y.rl., c o a oa/ e.rY/r/,

Or, , u4rJrl

Ot?PPP' ,

OCt ? o. ,-O/ O C

/f2u4 3a

,cc.r 2l/,.r2eC

o2... c, .oro.--"rJ r €c42lo4

?coaa

2l?o

al ,a, o,Jr2' P/?

a aa

Oaara Or.aa c, aOrOa/f,.rl ,.?4 r €€421 04

?

ooo?Pt 222o r... c ?-?.?4 3 eJ'.?/,a?

/ ca2ta- / \ aaar-a\'2 zl z.t.t' -t 1 3 ., t2 3 ' s

,n3in1 2009a / CaarrC OCTO aOC,2lrJ 22t2v.' rr2t-o.r.,

au

9

o aaraaP/J..Jc/

O.. ??.o. , c o. o.rl2vtv./rl, /e.Pv.rl/

araaocaa /(./r.r2 tr.r.rP.rJ/,

t:i9i)./57 4,998t-

aa / C rOar/ aa?Oaa a /t.r) tJ. v.vro /rtrFrr2 rt

laa

. ,X a ,' .t'tcf J2t'

a?

2rro -oc9'5.t2tHo.rr,

a r. C/ Oa/Jrt /

o20.oc,tPOrr.,

4cOaOa Oaa r/-/erv.rl ?."2rrl

./oa, o2.rr...?r?J.v -21 v224a

o .cr-,rc23Jo j

aa t lz , Oa a a t

l.ttSl.z.t .//r2, .4? a,t f9p2,

c... ,r,tr2.r.e.u ,O ..C /O. , O., /- .O.OC O. OC\ tttlr\t^A1tlr /rX.rJ./Htv/, .JolrPrrl P-/rrrJ, t.tr.r., ,.r2.r/,)'r- I I Iy Z+llOO 1t*t

i:r.; 93.1it trii t:it itr:::).rl'694'239166 i3; J: i3 Vig:t,,/ oa , ?z oaa

.F 2ztt \;Zen--

, aa ac,'J.JrtJrJ ro

, ac ooco/r.rt/ 2.s2.?.,,,o).., c, .o)o.

.?_?r) t e 4421o4C

,aOa z?z aC.r2/,., ;.r-/J.,

o, /,/2C2?/

,.aO., O ., .,./r..r./t.f ?.rP.rJaau

,i 2012 Exsi

n3 20ll ,.3;7 29

43O.O/ .r-/eryrrJ /rttcs/

. r rl Oaa ra(.rs2.?t02 4r.rla aa

aa a a o Ca /P.rJ., Pt2.?

aaa,Pau

Cr./

o, .,t cl?

C'32t'?

Otz.za OZr., ,2rcO .. u...O.rr.rc/., ?I.PJ..r3 ..rt 2t2r2 t.rJ 22r,aaa/

or, ..2o(.222.r) 2r?,a

aa. 2 ocaa ol-aaoa(.r.?2P.., e 2/ .rJ..t yrrl

Oa, Oc..J.2P.te2/

OC z/zz Oa/rO,.t.r2./o 2r.,//r.rfaa

,a ., Oa-r2 .-/t/e),

/aa, c42tc./J 3t

tAet

o22P

o? -.. o/.rf.5 YAI

, 2..r. o ?- , c.J..r, v24l ?eJ.?r, rr.r2/a a ,a a a

o o o? ....4c rr rzr.F't 2rr2 .Jr.72vt, vr2o-raa

4c r..r. o.-o..rt.rv24, .r{tt.z3

ii;i. ,Lt,;9 .i.3.i*i l974lCv-Cl201l jtiiaaa,

Oa a oCaa / auaaoa, Coaoa..r..rP.r) t r../r./r.f /erYJrlaa

,a O. O raaal2/./, ,-P./J

O..rz z? .CZ.?2rrJ, ,t.t-/rJ.,

a.

, c oo co.rr2/ 2r2.u.,aaa

cO-J erro.,?.

C , . O 2 O/t e e42ue4c

c{r-

info@hi ghcourt. gov.mv >r2a

331647 I ;9ij,3325029 :.7!,|-17.i2www.highcourt.gov.mv :81:- :1

22 'rtrl t ear/tr,,,,, oa 21r-, (eYa/

Page 16: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

20t2tHc-A/150 16

a, .oro. ,.o. aoa, ar.o/ .. / , zoro, ,.o. o/xoc ,ro at c142/-4 2 24./' -'2y 2rrrt' '2y.,r/ -rr) c14r/-4 ,r2,.., .r-, t..rrt 22rp,F.4a.

t e c42/ -4

..o ora c arx6, ?.o. .aoca2r., .-er.Y rJ"Jrt -r2YrY rrl 2rrr., tr-rr.rJ12,

, rO * /?O O raY22-, t.u 2r, -er-Y -at ZU I I

3 v.?r- 2.t)/ .,-e.--y ,-r-./r-.-i.4.,

4.o. o...o ,roro, . .rra. . orrr 2/tr, 2 2..r2r.tr../ 2 C,pa, .r.r 2t.t L, y lrrgJppr*..a

orro a. ox..z.r,,rYPr22 ,,'Y4 Cr 2

? . A4. o r?./-22- Zy 2.rJJt2t.. -rr.J.a

o. . c orro a. ?tr?.?t o.o20..a 2ro o.o.. cr.ur/ ..-rt-1)r2/ ,rt -/22

,2.r.v4e/2 rrrrvrrP2r. ..r2tr/ !.v,rtJ2 t.,.vJ.r- .,/t-t

o. . a.>Jr2.ur2/

o to t . ro,2rr., Y22?,2a

... ,4 a , ,.rr/-2 v2, vl- 22vr22r, t7J 2r:,,,?

oaro .. .?.o o.x4,r22r, t,r) 2r, zrto,

o a.. 2..o...r... ,o, 4t?.o.a 4ao4oloroJ2/,.r rJ2 2, (/r.t-2v.t'vy?rPr- 2r4 tt2vrr.r rlCrt.rror2r.,a.

ao.o o o o? ot 44,-r2r, '-2 a22 ,r2 .-trJ, ,Y-r.

2 ...O., a'l.t2o-2nrn

4 > /. / Crro-2.' /ttJ 5 2 2.r.-.' PS/'

, o r2r, ,oc ol/?. 4 t / oa.?oc.r2 ,Y2H rr.r., 2t.r/) .rr -/ -t .rtr!.2?arrr,

./r -t !p22, t, -r.r 2.P, -e-r.-v u2rr,, ., v e-r2r.,/t-rv!P -- ,vr, .r-22v?,

aoc a , ra ro./4t e.F-Y r2.'. Yra'.tQ.., .exr.t errP., .rrtl,/

. r/4a 24., tr2.,,, J..,

cr2..o. 2. . . r./ oa.o* t orrot-fJ.J Pl t.rl,.rPe2/ rrY!.!.312 1222,. al

/. ,2ox oa a o.. rr..r,rr, -J.P., .F,y-,2a

3 er-v

..o o r42r, ,r-

./ ert.,

,o4 ..rOa.r. ..2r4 '.r 2 Y., Yrr. F-rr- uo.. orx aoart ,

2:4 ,!. J J.r2* ,,

:3;r4ri,.?-'rJ t -,r, 2r-

ox oo a r4J' r.ePr2 r.r. r,

a ..

z4?rj -2rt )12 trr22.p-F., .,rr'.,-t,22.r,

,22-.?t ,rt .-t J 2. . 4' 2-

' O a aO aYl 4, tt v 2 2.rr.., .-rr.-t -2a . a ..

ttr)t6ir,/_

1c'

tJ.2.r/, .t 2 y-r3.r.) r-P., tra

,/o.rao oto oa./J2222r., ,2.r, eroy

3316471 :i-ij ,332s029 tt,;:i.;/www.highcoun.gov.mv :i.i- 3)

.r2 trtz, c.,. .ayrl tc,r,r?

[email protected] j..i.

Page 17: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012/HC-A/150 @17

.., z o , ol,.1€ e42Jrt o4

. , a..rJev.,

,vt rrvry

.r 2r.., ?r t t 2/:.,

,veP

o, rr40 ,a4.ar! .tt C-, ,rj-a

44o.,/ e.-J. Y

-t t 4tt t3t::

c 2 a o oo 2 0 04 0x a oo3-/, , e L-*.t -rr) ) , t-/ e,Jr2 srr, ?2,

a / a .z

2t .oro- 4 .a oa a o... .ox.r., e €42,,/r.4 J2,a., ..tr?r, ,5r4 .PY2.r) J'Y,aa,

O2...?> O aOa.rr2242 -r.r,oa../4, /.a ,ca.rr2242 /J., /2/

4 o?A,,J' F_-.PPJ'

oa.rr 2 a.?a ,{2t r3-,

o rx a, t oz, 4,rt J 2r/r2'v, -rJ

oo,c/.pJ Ja ,e/r2

o./ . ora ,?zr4rrL, ,ytJr, t.-/

a.

aoa3er-Y.YlreP/ , a-

c, ,or02 ,.o.t C ia2/'a , z'<'t

: 2011

o o o? ao. t r..r. orzo.>'2 a22 ,,rt.,r-,2.rr Yt4J ..f rr2

,.3r3.j1ii) 3! .l 2oll /.Zffi 29

ZOtl /.9i5

. ,rtoc 4 2Y2 .rJ 2Y.r, P.r)

.. o r rx o a c oxr..'.1rr2?.r rtrl, J'Y) rJ

/ o... oa.o? o./t.tP.re 2./ ., Yr2 Err.,a.2e :t/3r:

,ePeJ.

oro .. ...o,2rr r.r) 2r.,

n7 20ll

. 4 . .rr.. -o. ? c , .ro/ ? o azo ., tJrJ2t v2r- ,rt.r2.r.? t.,r v ." 2.r2./, 2r, 22rrJ,ara-/

4CO.O. , .Oro. ,.O. O a t ?/erY.rt e.142/-4,,/r2..rt .-3tr Jua/

? . 4.o/o. or4. c ? . ..o.t,U4 PaJ ., C, v.r.,,t ,rr) r e/.? .t ,Yez2.r.Y.a

a , . o, olt . r42/ '4t. o. o. >? ? .

.r 2.,, 22r/ ,".rJ 2... /, ,/.rr2v/r32r!.

. ?x , oo.oJ ?r.rp.' "tr.

Lrru,a.

05orroa,2y.r/ ,Jev

cra a ? / ??. or... a, .oro. ,.o. ..o... o* oa cJ er.v t.r)/, ,22 ,a/J J 1142/t -4 /r 2r., 1" ve.r2vrr., ,tr.,

/.a4.

4ao.ou o?4r. U .OrO, , ,D., / .?o?ervr, -lvrP €c42/-4 Jr2Jt., ,JtJ ,r-, J-rJ.-rJ ".r)

2.7,4..4./

? . ..t o., ..t.rJ t.rz./ ,Y'.r) t

zyt .rt ry ,r/ y?r-

o.r.ox oc2/ 4co. oa2v2yrr, .,ro-P -/crr.:t

33* 1 1974lCv-Cl20ll

.t2t r-*r, ,3r, 2v)P zvr/) ,v24/ .F., e-'.rP., .rr2., ooao o o o?2rrr., Pt 2r2

tPa '2t.a

t974lCv-Ct2Ott ;.ii i9 .i",- f.|i,

.r...r, .aoa.1 J yt r. y, .tt ./ 2r,

,rr/t o Pt r-,

,4, o , 4.J rJrr*-, '.r.rr-

oxor? or2 ..vr.rr4r. ,.r.4/tp.a

o rAa /4o-PZ t'., -rJrrtr' 3

1*; o/ 2 O , ?2vrr./r\rJ

3316471 ::-ij ,332s029 tr,;:i-;/www.highcout.gov.mv :i-t- 3i

,;t ,t.r-. u:i .i?-t :i:i-j/[email protected] f-.!-

7ti

Page 18: ,6. Funadhoo judgement.pdf · 2012HC-A 50 a a, aar.:Hr2 tt4J, a ni.j3.,n ii?: 3:,-1 l974lCv-C/2011 ,,.ii z9 a. o? c2t? , . ro..o.4 zv zt'/'/) 'a 1142r-4 ,22,., '22/2-t-r't '.---2v)'J22

2012tHC-4t150 18

oDi2va a

C. O c'/Jrl

2 2C 2aa.2,2Jr. t J /)

O.?.?2

,ca2r,at ar2J./tOer.

,

ar-C Oarla ,rCrO.a/ ara?a223JP5., .rJo.DoP ?tlYrro JrS YJcf.Y,

aco

/a&coa ocr/alJ /e-*2rs2/'' o-r, a.ao a

?2YZ Sr.rre 3a

197 4lCv-Cl20ll o2tP

,2cr.. oU2 2 3J r..r.,

aa

a

t 2 2z /\\ttt;.r2 )

Oa O raa z /zzzz O./?rrt, trJ 2e2Pa22

aa

Ol.OC OCaa?2YeZ .reoP

,, ..a

o-2 .. oa D/r.l.r.f /2t 4

?

cc o ?o /.t.r2r, ltatP 3 Z?aaa

t,

?

c./O / Ctr.rtP 3.,

C. ,it-t *rva

-a Oc aaro ,.aP J 2422

o,,

/l-r./€ 12.r.2e.,

(.1i:-j) t 2 ?z z\\1.n.*..*S )

/ o, o..r)22o4o

33t6471 :93j ,3325029 .jt,;:.i-;r ;i ,i_i-- ,.,,t. ca . .4oo .. 2 /' C"a teYt/ tear,tl,

www.highcourt.gov.mv :AiU 3i [email protected] J.i-

,. o/ ,), 2rrra 2