15:40 17:40 P1 P8 - JAFYE · 2017-11-06 · B0 Gú0 m0 y0 Õ= C /H0}¬ = ;Æ ¤YXo]XnbW0 Ær fnNf [...
Transcript of 15:40 17:40 P1 P8 - JAFYE · 2017-11-06 · B0 Gú0 m0 y0 Õ= C /H0}¬ = ;Æ ¤YXo]XnbW0 Ær fnNf [...
���� �
9� 7���� 10:00�12:00 �A1�A7� � � � � � � 15:40�17:40 �P1�P8�
�
A1� ńĶɨȚƣɅ,
― ― 76
@uXlgc�sy�UT�I`�:=b�I��qVZ�p��
�
5ȉɔɀ6� ǥǜ� ÅʱȖƈńʙĻńʲ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
{z�����
ĻńƣɅ[ǹĴ\0Ļ>@ķĆHRR7n1
~®´�®ĆV©��´�®Ć[ǩ¾[ĻńU0
ńǼ=ƴòYƘJnêʃƣɅșȋY0ÇbW0
ńǼɪĠ[ĻńʷťʕU[ń^[���´�ª
²[űø=ĥqoT8nƱÌ=7QNOp9<1
ĺNJXçɢU0FdGdXńǼ=çńH0ńǼ
ʕ[ńú³ńȾƃǕ[ǂŜ\ƑĻ[µʂrNW
QT8n13ƣĤ=×rƣ:N<4<l3ńǼ=0
×=U>nk9YXQN<4[�¬�w¤��
�`[Ŏż=ǝflonÇ0ńǼ=çńHTƴ
òYęɬJnêʃƣɅșȋ[{|¨¬¤\0
ŏʓƣɅYRX=ng[YXmRR7n[Op
9<1W9HNl0IJȓȐɭ³ńúrɸYRB0
ȋƓJŏʓƣɅUĻń[ń^rƴĻʘYäņU
>n[<1D[ɩƦU\0èçƱÌ[ĻńY;
BnêʃƣɅșȋ[ɨʨræƷH0ńǼr¿Ö
ȊXń^Yɥ90ńǼ=XIehJ8¥�vu
VęɬǼ[�£¨��vrǢǽHNɏɦVȕÐ
șń[êʃƣɅșȋ[Ɩdž[ɢeYR8TȿŌ
HN81�
|z/)*7!1%7"05�@uXlgc�
ĻńèçƱÌ[ĻńƣɅ0VmqBêʃƣɅ
șȋ[ƎŮɀ[ĺ@=ȌʡJnɨʨ\0ȋ[÷
[ęɬǼ[ɇú0Ȑɭ0ʖŹ0ƃǕ[ţ=Ļ>
J?0W[k9YƖdžrʇfT8B]0kmĺ
@[ęɬǼY0ƖdžrĘQNDVU0//Jn
DV=U>nk9YXQNV89ņƄrƒQT
gl:nDV=U>n<V89DVU\X8O
p9<1ŏʓƣɅșȋV\ȅXm0êʃƣɅș
ȋ\0çńHTJAęɬJnDV=ĺ8șȋU
7n1çɢůƅ=ĺNJĆJn¾0ęɬǼ[ƤO
B0ɇú0Ȑɭ0ʖŹ0ƃǕ=ŃįH0}¬�
=ĻÆƤYXo]XnbW0ƖdžrʇfnNf
[��¬w}�´²=ɖðHY@8ǹǴ=Ńį
Jn1WDYɺɵrȹ8TƖdžrʇfo]0ę
ɬǼYǪɵHTgl:nƖdž=ŔʔU>n[O
p9<1�
�� mr�@uXlgc�
3Njǫɏɦ �³��4\0� ťǓƴò[ɏɦ[ș
ȋU0çńƱYņƪJn�¯w�¥²�³��
�U0¯�®ñB=ɓqo0� <l � [k9X
ůU0� <lƆȷʥY}¬�=ñ<on13Njǫ
ɏɦ ��³���4\0��²~V��´|²~
YʐǮrȹ>03Njǫɏɦ ��³���4\0´�
v²~V¬w�v²~YʐǮrȹ@DVYXQ
T8n1�
� Ī[�¯w�¥²�³���UWDdUǖ
ȒY¯�®=óŅU>n[<ȇĥ=Ǚn¾0ŗ
ÞǼ\0�� Ğ0�� Ğ0�� ĞVĺ@0FlYƎ
Ů}¬�=0�0�0� [k9X¯�®[}¬�
U7nV0ŗÞǼ[ɏɦú0ńȾƃǕ[Ŝ= �0
[k9X}¬�Í·YĻ>Xţ=7m0ǚĪ
�� ñ[ƖdžU0W9HNlµǗKRUgɏɦY
əHsU0¿ÖȊXń^Yɥ:n[<=ɨʨU
7n1�
òťũ\0ǹÌȕÐńʎ[ȕÐʗǭńș[ń
Ǽ=Ŏɯ[}¬�rƎŮU0ƽƫƺĻʟǭYʖ
Jn �����$%"��� *& [�¨´�rʝfN�|�
�rƗǽHN=0�¨´�ɏɦ\0ŲlY\ʞ
HJ?N1Ǔ[ťũ\0ǹÌȕÐńʎ[¼ńș
ʱǹÌȕÐńșVȕÐʗǭńșʲ[}¬�U0
÷ťũ[Ėȍrɷd:0ƫƺ[Ç[ƦĆhȕÐ
[ǴǠrɏɦUɧƮH0ȉÝHk9V89ɢe
[�|��rƗǽHNg[[07dmʖŹrƒ
QTgl:X<QN1�
MDU0���� ťũ<l0��� [3;VX[IJ
ȓɏɦ4[�t´���´�²[ ��� Ë[�|
A1� ńĶɨȚƣɅ,
― ― 77
��rƗǽH0��� rǢǽH0Ĵʡrɷd:T0
�¯´�rĀŭH0�u±´}rʃIT0�|
��[|´�¯´�rȶȾH0ÞŶJnƩǡr
ĘmçoT8n1�
���� ťũ\0ǓĪ[ƖdžY0åʆ[|´�¯
´�[�y�}ǽ[±´}�´�rƚðglQ
T8N=0Ɩdž÷Y0�|��rɖT0Ƴ>ï
HTƚðńǼ=ĺ@0��� ťũ<l\0Ǔ[Ɩ
dž[ƴŴY0�¯´�=ɸYR8T8n<0ɢ
ʯůūU0±´}�´��y�}rőçHT8
n1FlY0��� ťũ\0�t´���´�²
[�|��Yû:T0ǹįơƯFoT8n�´
�² � \0ńǼɪĠ=ŐƼɠon�§²�=7
n<gHoX8�¨´«´}V°²�²=0ʛ
ʆEVYɌěVXQT;m0�®´¯wUʒȀ
H0ĝƱYƖdžUǢǽHT8n1�
ʠŢąɬŠ=ĻĊrĎf0ɏɦń�°�´[
ŏÎƣĤ=0șȋɰÎɀVHT�°~¬¤èÖ
r�y�}Jn���¤=ǐɇHT8nĻń\
E@qK<YJ?X8[=ǹǴU7n1��� ť
ũYʔńHNɼȆĻń[Įʜńʎ[ɏɦƣɅ[
�®��V[ʅƝ\0ĻɗnjȘȞĻń=ðH
N � R[ȯɩVȿ:Tk8[U\X8Op9<1�
�� f<gIBw�@uXlgc�
êʃƣɅșȋ[3ǹÌ[Ƣǟ403ǹÌ[Įʜ
ʖÜ4[k9XșȋY\0ŏʓƣɅșȋ`[Ǐ
ǨHVHT[ȕÐșńñʑ[IJȓȊȐɭ[ljȤ
=ǝflon=0ĺNJXçɢʍƌƩūUçńH
T@nńǼr÷Y0èĤrǪɵFLnDV[U
>nƖdž��w²[ņǹ\0ĻķīʞrLJfn
g[U7n1Ƣǟ³ȮǦ0éǛ0ǹÌȕÐ[ș
ȋ[Ȑɭ[X8ńǼ[NfYWD<l��´�
Jo]k8<0µƩ0Ƣǟ³ȮǦ0éǛ0ǹÌ
ȕÐYʖŹ=7m0Ȑɭg7nńǼr0ʀœF
LKY0W9HNlFlXnń^Yɥ:n<=
ɨʨVXn1RdmƖdžrʃIT08<YIJȓ
ȐɭhʖŹrĵhH0ɉñ[ȿ:ƩrŔʔ0¿
ŬU>nk9YJnNfY0���� ťũ<l0ǚ
ʆ0�§�®{´�[ÊY0ǚĪ[�´¢YR
8Tȿ:0ɉñ[ȿ:rŔʔJn±´}�´�
rőçH0ȽʆɽđJn���¤rőçHN1
±´}�´�rőçHNg[[0ƖdžV�|�
�[îňrNO��´H07N<gɉl[ƃɖ
[k9YɩɾJnńǼ=Ƥĺ@ŃįHN1 D[ǴǠYȌʡH0ńú0Ȑɭ0ʖŹ0ƃǕ
[ʌ9ńǼ=ǤįHT8n[O<lHj9=X
807n8\u}�v�¬´�²~rǢǽJo
]0XsV<XnVɉñrȨŶFonDV=U
>NXl0WobWɄ[ɐ=¸mnDVOp91 êʃƣɅșȋ[ȕÐșńñʑU\0¯�®ñ
B[���=7nɏɦVȅXm0FdGdXń
Ǽr÷Y0Ųlr¿ÖȊXń^Yɥ80õʋȋ
NjrʋƆHTgl9Nf[��¬w}�´²r0
Ɩdž[¾UɖRBnDV=¹ĚǒU7n1����
�w}®rǢǽH0WoOB��¬w}�´²
YɼSBn<=0ǚĪ[ƖdžU[ƔƇU7n1 �|��OBYʧQT8T\0ǹǴrɖRf0
ȿ:0ɉñ[ƃɖrƒRDVY\RX=lX8
VȈƄH0��� ťũ<l0Ç[�¨´�`[ʖ
ŹhȐɭrĵhHTgl9DVU0ńǼɪĠ=
Ǽ>nǓ»ÌrɖRfTbH8V89ʩ8<l0
ƶʬĨǿ|§��´³DŽłȎŞ|§��´Yk
n ���3�¨´�xz�� �4r�®´¯wUʒ
ȀH0ǚʆµʎrƖdžUǢǽHŀfN1�
DŽł|§��´Vƶʬ|§��´[ȄȭîU
[ȱĿX|§�� ´®\0ưťũ[3�¨´
��y�} ��4<lķqlK0DŽł|§��´
\0ƽÄĹĮɦĻń°�u³ƽǔɨȚʱ�y�
ɦŏƠʲðɸU0ƺť � Ƶ �� ƫU0�� ƋVɎ
@ńǼYgɼ@0|§��´[3ñ<lX8D
V\Ɂ>dJ14V89��²�=0ńǼ[Ɇ¾
rƍH0w²�}�rº:T8n1�
�� �������
©��´�®ĆV~°´��®Ć[ǩ¾Y7
nĻńƣɅY;8T0ȘȞĻńYVQT0çń
HNńǼY08<YúrËB0ċdžFL0ȕÐ
YʁmðJ<=Ħȳ[ɨʨU7n1���� �w}
®râ<LX=l0ń^[¿ǍɀU7nńǼ[
Nf0!#�(�'!) Xu�°´�rȜeʐZT0
w¢�|[ńǼ[ńǼrń^Yő@���XƖ
džrşǝJnþú=0ÇbWǝfloT8nƱ
\X8[UX8Op9<1
A1� ńĶɨȚƣɅ,
― ― 78
;aiMZHIGOXl$5&7�� �CN[Xl�
�^]�Fy\��
�
5ȉɔɀ6� śǣǷʊʱÀȂȥŚĻIJŦƣɅ�²�´ʲ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
{zGOXl$5&7�oh�
ǹįĺ@[ĻńU\ƨçǼ[IJȓńú[ʫ
Ɔ[NfĺŰXɢe=XFoT8n1¾Ug
Ɖɫʺ¬²}ʱ7n8\ʘȁʲĻńU\ńú
[Õ8ńǼ=çńHT@nNfM[ŎȢY\
WDgʦrȈfT8n1MDU\bVsW[
ĻńUƣɅƞƜ�²�´=Ølo0IJȓńú
[ʫƆYĘmȭsU8n1ÀȂȥŚĻʱ͸
ƺńVȃʲU\IJȓƣɅƞƜrƎŮJnʎȺ
VHTIJŦƣɅ�²�´ʱ͸ƺ�²�´V
ȃ =ŤƆ � ť � ƵkmȉɵH0ǹį � ť=
ȮʉHN1ƺń\ŚșȦčșĻńU7mDzǺ
ńVƤń[ńȾ\ĻķʐɕXDVU7n1D
[NfŮò<lD[ � R[șȋYdzĆHTIJ
ȓƣɅrɓ9ȋȊUƺ�²�´\ɡȞFoN1
M[ɆƲȡYR8T\ưť[ƺńÐY;8T
ijġHN�ʴ�1ƺijġ\M[Ŵ0Ċť[Ȯʉ
VÖöȡYR8TķĆ=7QN[UM[DV
r¾ŹYɾa0òťǓƣɅ[ņɶÚVHN81 |z$5&7�jk�?K�
ʵʳʴʲ� ťũ[�²�´[Ljɕ�
�²�´ȉɵƱ\ÂĂɂĤgŏÎ����
gX@ƣɅùʄŚńșYŕJnƤń0DzǺń
[ƣĤr¾ŹVHNɜQTeo] ¬²�w
u~®´�[k9XůUȉɵHN1ƤńY\
ʠŢąɬŠʱʆ � ƫʲ=µÆʏȹFoN1�
ƵYȉɵHNg[[0Ůò\ɱĥYƼnńǼ
g8X@ʔŨÏdž[ǴƅU7QN=0ɬȼ=
7nȚũʇŔHNʅÏŴ<l0Ɖɫ3ʭBɻ
eōƩū4�ʴ�rVQNǯ0ŵ2YƼɠɀ\
ĵ:0ưťȬqmEp\ŪaÆƤUȧ ��� Æ
rƤ:N1Ĕ�´�´gĺ@ôǽ= �� Īɳ
[ńǼgĺ@ƴʰ\ �� ĪdUÓ^N1Ɔȷg
dzYƴ¸Ô[ńǼNPr¾ŹYÓ^T8nD
V=óƮHN1D[DV\ģ^ðHr<BN
ńǼ\ǘW=Ɔȷƴ¸ÔŖ[ńǼʋU7QN
DVrȿ:nVĉñ9XKBnDVU7n1
NOĻńèÖVHTIJȓƣɅh¥�wu®
ƣɅ`[ƃɭ=7dmʰ8V\ɜ:K0ĺ@
[ƣĤ\ƬƅǰVHT;m0Ļ>XĥʨVX
QN18KoYLkìıȊXʺ¬²}ĻńU
7nƺńU\�²�´ȭȸ[äņ=Ƹdon
DVVXQN1 ʵʳʵʲ�²�´[ȭȸ[Ɵȭ � 28 ťũ[ȬqmEp0Žʩ[ÂĂɂĤ=ȏ
ÎH0ModUÙÎ����=íZT8N�
¨´�¯�´[ȵʝdžĂhòǗȊXƣńʻʽ
rɓ9k9YXm0ʈħ\Ļķ�¤´�Yɓ
@k9YXQN1NOƓő����=ʠŢą
U7QNmńșƣĤ=ɬȼhċȑUĺŻrLJ
fNNf0Ɠő=ƊɑYXQN1D[Nfĸ
ÏeŴ\Ƽɠɀ=ǧŒHN1FlY�²�´
= 1 ʎʓU7QNNf0DorƑäH0km
ŧ8ɚǮ<lIJȓƣɅYŮNnNf�²�´
rĭ 1 YȔJk9X 3 ʎʓöVHŏÎ[��
��rŢʮFLnk9XƩğUƟȭ³Džɞr
ɓQN1D[Ēǃ\bcM[ddɤflo0
ʖÜɀ\ 4 Ƶ<l[ƨÖöljȤ[NfÆÂé
ăXWYĽɲJnDVVXQN1 µƩǹį[ÖöUņȷr·CnNfʰǀƣ
ĤYƼTgl8ʰĻʅƝ[µǻVHTȑȝÐ
[ʔá0~°´�®ĆJnIJȓƣɅ[Nfǣ
Ĺ<l[ɬŠrƏ8NɬǬÐXWrʔáH0
Ļń[ƣɂĤ[ƃɭƟʢ[ɢerɓQN1F
lYD[ 1 ťU[ǢārŧijJnNf�¨´
�¯�´r 3 Ī[ȉɓHFlYťij[ȵʝX
A1� ńĶɨȚƣɅ,
― ― 79
WrɝȀHN1
ĭʴʳIJŦƣɅ�²�´[ƨH8Öö ʎʓ\ 3 R7m03ǺƤIJȓƣɅʎʓ4U\Dod
Uʃm[DzǺ³ƤńYdzĆHNIJȓƣɅƞƜ03ńĶ
ɨȚIJȓƣɅʎʓ4U\·[ 2 șȋYʘlK0ŧ@
ƦȟɔǹƓőXWgɓ913ƣńʻʽʎʓ4U\IJȓ
ńúɢʯXW[�´�[ɣȪXñƾ<lƺń[ƣɅ
ƞƜ[7na>ŁrɿǝJn1
ʶʳŤƆ 29 ťũ[�²�´[Ǣā ʱ¾ʕijġʲ ʶʳʴʲçń÷ƣɅYR8T � D[Ǣā\ĺ@[ʺ¬²}ĻńUɓqoT
8n=ƺńU\DodUXFoT8X<QN1
D[ǺǾ\¹ƮU7n=ɈĻXØdžVƣɂĤ
[ƃɭʱďǐƄʲ[ǒľU7nVžqon1
Çť\ɢeYƙɒĕ^ʹʼçńɀYŎHTƤ
ńrɨʨVHTº:02 ƵʣYɨʨrȉʁ0
çńƱYĪėH0ƗǮHNŴńǼrģ^ðH
q<ndUƓőrɓQN1Do\ɈĻXØdž
U7QN=ęɬɀ[ĺ@\çńȌŴ[IJȓń
úɢʯU\Ɔȷ=·=QT8Nk9U7n1 ʶʳʵʲƤń³DzǺ[ƓőÖö � ƨťũ<l[ƓőÖörŭĆJnNfƤń
U\ʠŢąɬŠ[ąĂƱʕrĻţYĵhH0
dN�²�´ŏÎ[dzÎýƣVHT 1 ÆʱDz
ſDzǺńŏƠʲrƨNYƗǽHN1dzYýƣ
Y\�²�´[ʈħhDzǺńĕ^Ƥń[ƣɅ
ƞƜYȜLJȊY<<qQTglQT8n1Ƥ
ń0DzǺ[IJȓńúɢʯɦ çńū[ƫYņƪʲ
[ȯƿYIJS>0}¬�ñBrɓ80dzYƴ
Õ[¯�®[}¬�ʱDzǺń 2 }¬�ĕ^Ƥ
ń 2 }¬�ʲ[ɬȼYēûHTgl8ƞƜr
ɓQT8n1D[}¬�[ƞƜ\Ɔȷ¹ƕ[
NfʀńJnńǼ[ƤrǧlJDVYŊºJ
ng[Vžqon1dND[ 4 }¬�[ɬȼ
[ůÖȡYR8TgŚļrHN1 ʷʳĥʨǮVÇŴ[ɨʨ � ÷ȣUưť<lÇťũY<BT[Ǣā[Lj
ɕrȫÈHN1Dol[Ǣā\¿Y�²�´
ŏŕ[ɂĤ0ĕ^ƣɅùʄŚńșVêʃƣɅ
ș[ƣĤ[ ¬²�wuȊǢāYkng[U
7n1H<HM[DV\Êńș[ƣĤ=ʖº
HT8X8DVrDzɦng[U7m0IJȓƣ
ɅƞƜ=èńȊɗnjUɓqong[U7nV
ɜ9ɘǮ<lĻķ8^RXůƅU7nVɜ:
n1Rdmƺ�²�´\dOƺńY;8Tĉ
ñXȐĞũrŶT8X8HdzYŏʓńșYŕ
JnƣĤ[ƃɭ\Ƭƅǰ[ddU7nVɜ9
ÂYXn1ÊƩ�²�´YƼnńǼ\ǞHT
1 ťǼ]<mU\X812ʾ4 ťǼdUŧ@ñ
ŝHT;m0ɱĥîňgŏʓĆHT8n]<
mUX@0ńǼǼǢ[ƁeXWņYĺřYq
NQT8n1M[k9XɘǮ<lƺ�²�´
\ĭʴ[¸[±}YĬdoNńî[7lin
ʎȺVČúʖÜYXBo]XlX8Vȿ:n1
DDYƉɫ3ƣɂČâ4V89ȿ:=ðT@
n1ĐPƺ�²�´[Ǔ[ɨʨ\ńî[ȐĞ
ũrW9·Cn<Vɜ9ÂVĥʨƃɭrêƶ
HTèńȊXɘǮ[IJUʈħFonDV=Ƀ
ɕU7n1ʖÜɀ[İĢXþú=ƸdonƉ
ÍU7n1 ēȿƦǶ [ʴ]śǣǷʊʸòťǓƣɅńÐȠ 9 ĪĻÐȉ
ɔɕƭʝʱĩĮĻń0ŤƆ 28 ť 9 Ƶʲ.p.66.
A1� ńĶɨȚƣɅ,
― ― 80
CN[�� �LxGegc�_nPE8�#&'�#�2Jd�9h�
� 27,63+.7�47�"7(�%-�Q>gc�vW�u����
�
5ȉɔɀ6� ȗŘƀÈʱćʚĻń� Įʜ�£¨��´�ª²ńʎʲ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
{z�����
� ƺĘmȭe\òťǓY;BnŏʓIJȓșȋ
[Ǻɛũğ·V0���v�|®Ņȏ[¼Ȟ
rȋȊYņƪHNg[U7n1�
ëÖȊY\0òťǓ�£Y;8T0ŏʓIJ
ȓșȋ[îňrʨƻVHN���v�|®ƣ
ɅrņƪHN1ĝƱYMo=ŏʓIJȓșȋ[
ŷȾYgXn0V89ĘmȭeU7n1�
� D[Ęmȭe\ 2016 ťũ<lʔŀHN1
2016 ťũ÷ƹ\ʴťǓ÷ƹYɡȹHNʶR
[ŏʓIJȓșȋʱźÞʲVòťǓ�£rʅƝ
FL02017 ťũ÷ƹ\ńʎƟķYÒ8ʴťǓ
÷ƹYɡȹHNʴR[ŏʓIJȓșȋʱźÞ³
z¤���ʲVòťǓ�£rʅƝFLN1
� �
|zFyRt�cb�
ƺĘmȭerʔŀHNĥʨƃɭ\0Ļ>@
¶R7n1�
Ƞµ\0ŏʓIJȓșȋ[Ǻɛũğ·U7n1
ĺ@[ĻńY;8T0òťǓY\ńʎ[ƣɅ
ÖȦ[ȠµǗVXnŏʓIJȓșȋ=źÞșȋ
VHTɡȹFoT8nDVOp91{|¨
¬¤¢��=ƥàFo0�²�²~=Ņȏ
HRR7nǹį[ĻńƣɅY;8T\0ŏʓ
IJȓșȋ[ʐɕſ\8QM9ʰdQT8n1�
H<H0M[ŏʓIJȓșȋ[Ǻɛũrğ·
FLnĘmȭe\0șȋƎŮɀYÛŃHT8
n1M[ƎŮɀ=Ǻɛũğ·rʐɘHT8o
]ɍ8=0źKHgM9V\ɜ:X8�´�
gŒX@X8[U\X8<1ŏʓIJȓșȋ[
Ǻɛũğ·\0ńʎńșèÖVHTòťǓƣ
Ʌ[µǻVHTĘmȭdXBo]XlX8�
´¢7nYgʖqlKU7n1�
ȠÃ\0���v�|®[ȩƻU7n1ò
ťǓƣɅY;Bn3ń^[ɹƛ40���v�
|®Ņȏ[ʐɕſ\ɜ9dUgX81JUY
ĺ@[�|��=ðDZFoT8nDV<lg
Ʈl<U7n1�
D9HN�|��rɖTenV0W[ńʎ
ńșY;8TgêʃHTźɕVžqonîň
=ȲȻFoT8n1H<H0ŮNm÷U\7
n=0M9HN�|��Uǽ8lonÂÚ\0
źKHgW[ńʎńșY;8TgêʃJng
[U\X81ÂÚrM[ddôǽJo]0ń
ʎńș[ń^VXIdX8�´�gðT@n
Op91ńǼ<lHTgɸɼU\X8�´�
Uń_DVYXn1ńʎńș[ń^YĐHN
�´�U7o]0kmńǼYVQT\ǺɛH
hJ8[U\X8Op9<1�
Ƞ¶\0òťǓ�£[ƎŮƣĤU7n1Ļ
ńƣĤ[ĺ@\���v�|®rƣƖJnD
V\ŏʓU\X81dNɼť\ńĥǎƧȊX0
ȴĜȦ[ńʎ=ĵ:T;m0ƣĤ[��}~
¬x²�=ȰµFoT8X81M[·0ņĂ
ŇðɸƣĤgĵ:T8n1D9HNƣĤNP
=���v�|®rƣƖHk9VJnV0ƣ
Ɩîň=µɊHX8V89ĥʨ=ðT@n1�
Í·[ĥʨƃɭYIJS>0ŏʓIJȓșȋ[
Ǻɛũğ·V���v�|®[Ņȏ[¼Ȟr0
ƣĤ[ĺNJſrÁmɴ:TņƪJnƩǡrȿ
:nDV=0ƺĘmȭe[ȋȊU7n1�
}zA=b�D�j��
D[Ęmȭe\0Ļ>@¶R[ÉȭeYk
QTƆmȞQT8n1Ƞµ\~®´�³¯�
¨´ʱ͸0GR 0ȠÃ\Morƞ:n±´
A1� ńĶɨȚƣɅ,
― ― 81
}�´�ʱ͸0WS 0Ƞ¶\ņɶ[ĴU7
n�£+ŏʓIJȓșȋ[ʅƝU7n1�
ŏʓIJȓșȋ[Ǻɛũrğ·FLnNfY
\0ńǼYƖdžĹU[ŷȾrFLnźɕ=7
n1H<H���v�|®YǒBnńǼ\0
�´�[ĘmƩ=ĉñU\X@0Morǽ8
NŷȾgÿǸȊU\X81�´�[ĘmƩr
òťǓ�£Uƣ:k9Yg0ĝƱʇɓȊYƖ
dž=ŔʔHTHd91�
� MDUòťǓ�£Y;Bn���v�|®
[ȾŶr0ŏʓIJȓșȋ[Ɩdžîňr�´�
Yɓ91źÞșȋU\ WS Y�´�rVlL0
ʼnʨrɨJ1òťǓ�£U\ WS rǽ8T~
®´�UŷȾrɓ80ƖdžîňrdVfn±
´}rɓ9ʱGR 1�£ƎŮɀ\0Ůǰ[D
VX=l0ŏʓIJȓșȋrƎŮgęɬgHT
8X8Op91DorôǽH03ƖdžręBT
8X8ɀʱ�£ƎŮƣĤhǒšɀʲUgǺɛ
U>nk9XdVfrØƆJnDV4r0GR[�´®VHTŅfn1
ƹųFonÿƿ\0͸[¶ǮU7n1 � èĤ=źKŷȾ
GR UƖdž[ɕǮ\×OQN<rɮɩH0
ƖdžręBT8X8ɀYɧƮJnDV=0
ŷȾYXn1D[ĘmȭeU7o]0ź
KèĤ=ŷȾrɓ9DVYXn1ĝƱY0
Ǻɛũ[ãoNńǼ=Ǻɛũ[ünńǼ
hǒšHNńǼYɧƮJn�u³�¡´
�VXn1 � WS [ʤȋU���v�|®rÑƖ
WS Y\���v�|®VHTɸYRB
na>¡w²�rʤȋVHTɡŅJn1
D[ WS YIJS8T�´�rĘm0ʼnʨ
rņƪJnDV=0���v�|®ȾŶ
YRX=n1dN GR [ʜYńǼĝĶU
WS rɖLĜ9DVU0kmɍ8�´�
[ĘmƩXWrȿ:n>Q<BVXn1 � WS \ƣĤ[ɵ½erMp:nNfYg
ÿƿȊU7n1���v�|®VHTƣ
:na>ʤȋrȰµU>n1dNńǼ¿
Ö[ŷȾ;k^���v�|®ȾŶYX
nNf0ƣĤ\�t��´�ª²YŸ
JnOBUɍ81
ƺĘmȭeU\Ãțʪ[ WS rǽ8N1 � �´�ǽ WS
(�) Ɩdž[ǵ8³ȋȊ (�) ¥¦ǑʱƖdž[ǵ8³ȋȊ[ɧƮh
ǁƐ0ëÖÚXWr¥¦Jnʲ (�) Ɩdž[ǵ8³ȋȊVŋƘYʖʅJn
|´±´�ɟçǑ (�) k@ñ<lX<QNǽɦ³ȿ:Ʃ (�) Ɩdž[ǵ8³ȋȊV\ʖʅHX8=0
ßÆȊYɋĢrƒQNDV � ʼnʨ WS
(�) Ɩdž[ɕȧ (�) Ɩdž[ƄƂ (�) Ɩdžîň`[ƃɖ (�) ƖdžUñ<lX<QNDV
� Í·[ WS Ykm0���v�|®VHT
�´�[ĘmƩ0ɕȧØƆ0ƄƂVƃɖ[Ĉ
ñBrĖŷȶȾJnDV=U>n1 ~zSY�
Çťũ<l[ƺǂȊXĘmȭe[Nf0ǹ
ƱǮUƆƿrɾanDV\ðƼX8=0ȉɔ
[ʜY\÷ƹ[ƆƿrɾaN81Ɔƿ[ƓNj
\0-ŏʓIJȓșȋ[Ǻɛũ[ğ·[Țũ�
.���v�|®[Ņȏ[Țũ[ÃǮYXn
Op91 dN0ńǼ[ GR [ĘmȭeŁĄhƣĤ[
ĘmȭeŁĄV8QNʎñgijġU>o]V
ž91
A2� íƭēś�¿Ř�
― ― 82
yIeYX��q,FD��):�4� G}�
�*��BC����kOdVp��
�
�ſƻƯ�� �ù� ƷŊȌŤĭêíêíǼ�ijƏíƊƓƏȍ�ƹŸ� Ø�ȌŤĭêíijídzȍ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
��6~�ed�
íƭƯ#ĥŒ=ô+8ĝ%ƃŖ?Ȏ�î<
;=ćȂVÈG-:��(:#Ā%ƉPS8
�RȌ������� ��������ȍ�+"+ȎȊŎ"
Pêí:��Ķ2<íŎŞǽ=©QȎĥŒĆ
ĕ<;>ǜĨVǢ 2êí � ÿŶ#Ȏljȉ>
I<P.�w�mMſƻ:�52ŕ�<Lj
Ćă=ô+8ĝ%�î=Ƈƃ+Ȏ0>ćȂV
ƤľƁ=őDŽ+2ƊƓ?�Ǘ+8�R� � �ù�ƹŸȌ2016ȍ?ȎµÿŚįƱƏƃ>ÌǐŶ# 3Ƒȇ>Lj ĆăȌïŃljȉ��w�m�ſƻȍ=ô+8ĝ%�î#�ÿVǧ,
8;�çÀ-R>"VƨĵƁ=őDŽ+2�ń
ƊƓ9?*P=ȎíƭƯ#ĥŒ=ô+8ġ5
8�RƃŖ>¨Ô#Ȏ(SP>Lj Ćă=ĝ
%�î=ô+8ÈG-ćȂ=6�8ȎÿĂ
>ƨĵƁ<ǎō=O58ļP"=-R�H2Ȏ
2015ÿĂ: 2016ÿĂ:��ÿĂǸ9¨ÔVŠǞ-R(:=OQȎ0>ŕƅ#Ž<R"=
6�8LőDŽ-R�(>(:"PȎíƭƯ>
ðĕVěĩ-R=ŻHP.ȎĥŒƯ#íƭƯ
>ƃŖM�îVĤ Ȏô±-R�9>ǀŭ:
+8Lłŷ<ƉƾVċPSR:Ʈ PSR� ��P]�
� 31m� HêíČŵíƏ 1ÿŶVôǒ:+
2µÿŚįƱƏƃ�áƌgy�>ÌǐŶVǎ
ōôǒ:+ȎľŃV³'2 4Û>Ūï=!�
8ª8>öĂ=ÛƘ+2íŶV³ʼnôǒ:+
2�dž?Ȏ2015ÿĂ# 59Ó>ÌǐŶ� 39
ÓȌźĐ 31 ÓȎëĐ 8 ÓȍȎ2016 ÿĂ# 77
Ó� 47ÓȌźĐ 19ÓȎëĐ 28Óȍ9�52�
_;QR� ÐöĂ?Ȏ¹Ń:ĉŃ= 2Û.
6Ȏǃ 4Û>ŪïV!(<52���9?Ȏ
¹ŃȌāƂ�ƟƂȍȎĉŃȌāƂ�ƟƂȍ:Dž
ǥ-R�ǎōðĸĹ? 2015ÿĂ: 2016ÿĂ
9Ž<RL>>Ȏ�.SLĥŒÛ?FGÒ,
9�52Ȍ¹ŃāƂ?ƕ 4 ÛȎƟƂ?ƕ 10
ÛȕĉŃāƂ?ƕ 4ÛȎƟƂ?ƕ 13-14Ûȍ�
� u6i� ǮėƃŖöĂȌŸ��ƹŸȎ2003ȍ
:Ȏkem�î=ǹ-R Cassady & Johnson
Ȍ2001ȍ>öĂVÐLj ĆăȌ�w�m�ſ
ƻȍ=ÑU/2L>Vŷ�2�ǮėƃŖöĂ
?áƌgy=ô-Rxeh��ȌƭċȍƃŖ
Ȍe.g., (>ĥŒ"P9$R3'é%>(:
VíA2�ȍ:qs\�x�eȌǫƺȍƃŖ
Ȍe.g., (>ĥŒ>�>�OQ�>ėƩV:
T�:ď�:MRš#²Rȍ=ǹ-Rȃƃ9
ŔėȌ6 �ŤȎǃ 17 ȃƃȍ�ėƩLj =ô-
R�îȌe.g., čƽ��=kem>²Ň=6�
8ČǴ-Rȍ?Ȏ�ĉơȉ-R9�T�ljȉȎ
�w�mȎſƻ:�� 36>Lj Ćă=6�
8ȎDzĜă>ǕÙȃƃȌ6 �ŤȎÐLj Ćă
10ȃƃȍ:ƳŹDžǥȌÐLj Ćă=6�8��
Dž>ǕÙȃƃ�è9Ȏ�<2#�î=Ĕ,8
�2(:=6�8Ȏ��>Ō= 16ŀ�8
%3*��:��įƍ>L:9ÛƘVŢK2ȍ�
��jU�l>�
� /L/T� ǮėƃŖ>��öĂȌxeh�
�ƃŖȎqs\�x�eƃŖȍ>ċŭV0S
1SĊøçı:+2ȎÿĂ 2Ȍ2015Ȏ2016ȍ�ľŃ 4Ȍ¹ŃāƂ�ƟƂȎĉŃāƂ�ƟƂȍ> 2ƽÜŨѳʼnV!(<52:(TȎÿĂ>�¾ŋȌ2015 < 2016ȍ?xeh��9łēȎqs\�x�e9łē¨Ô:<52ȎLj
=ô-R�î=6�8LLj Ćă):=Ò
ŕ>³İ³ʼnVƺ52:(TȎ-E89ÿĂ
A2� íƭēś�¿Ř�
― ― 83
>ƽÜVÕJ���ŷ#łē:<52�0>
2K�Ǻ>³ʼn?ÿĂV³'8ƺ�(::+
2�Ðçı>DžǥƣǃǷV Table 1=ƍ-� � z7A/T� ǮėƃŖȌxeh���qs
\�x�eȍVnjļçıȎÐLj ĆăȌljȉ�
�w�m�ſƻȍ=ô-R�îVƃƁçı:
+2ǶÛý³ʼn>ƢŋV Table 2=ƍ-� � xeh��ƃŖ:łē<ǹǨ#IPS2>
?Ȏ2015�2016 ÿĂ«=ȎïŃljȉD>�îȎ0SL¹ŃāƂ>I9�52�(S?Ȏ
ńƊƓ>ǮėƃŖ#áƌgy:��ůï>ĥ
Œ=ô-RL>:+8Ūï*S8�22K"
L+S<��ĥŒ):=ƭċ-E$ƉǑMĚ
Ʋ?Ž<QȎáƌgy:�>ĥŒ:9?Ž<
Rxeh��ƃŖVġ6ÎƲĐ#�R��ķ
9ȎLj �î?êí>ĥŒªƵVôǒ:+8
Ūï*S8�22KȎǹ¡Đ#ļƈ=<P<
"52>3T��23Ȏ¹ŃāƂ>ľŭ9?
H3êí>ĥŒƳ�=ĖS8�<�Űĕ=�
R(:"PȎáƌgyVÕJ¤�>ĥŒD>
ƃŖ?ȎůïƁ9<%ȎȊŎH9>íƭ=ô
-RƃŖ=á7�8ÛƘ+8!QȎÒľ=Ȏ
ȊŎH9>Lj ķŤ"PĦŪÎƲ<ïŃljȉ
>I:łē<ǹ¡Đ#IPS2:Ʈ PSR� � 0S=ô+8Ȏáƌgy=ǹ-Rqs\�
x�eƃŖ?ȎƼı>ŪïľŃ!OALj ķ
Ť:>Ǹ9łē<ǹ¡Đ#IPS2�ńŇȎ
µÿŚįƱƏƃ9�Ráƌgy9?Ȏ(>ĥ
Œ9O�ėƩVËR(:OQȎĥŒ9ę�
ehlYe_�VƋð=ƭċ-R(:#OQ
Ƕƽ<>9�R#Ȏ0>áƌgy=ô+8L
ėƩMȄ�VǶƿ-Rqs\�x�eƃŖ#
Ą�ãÑ=?ȎÐLj ķŤ=ô-R�îLȊ
%<QM-�>3T�� 23+Ȏ((9ťē#čƽ<>?Ȏ2015
ÿĂ=ŠEȎ2016ÿĂ=!�8?0>qs\�x�eƃŖ:�î>ǹ¡Đ#"<QǻïƁ
9�Rŭ9�R�ÿĂ=ORíŶ>ǯ�Ȏ0
SLµÿŚ=!'Rǯ�VļƋ=njļ9$R
ŌƠI?<�#Ȏ2016ÿĂ>ķ#ǮėƃŖM�î#Ȋ�:��Ŵǒ?IPS8�R�Ä=
ª�Ɓ<ċŭ³ü#ƅôƁ=Ȋ%Ž¿+8�
R3'<P@ȎçıǸ>ǹ¡Đ?Ž<P<�
?.9�R�(>(:"PȎńƊƓ9ŷ�2
çı>I9?ÿĂ=ORǯ�Vnjļ+$S<
�(:#ƍ*S2��ĉ?Ķ2<ĢŖVǦ½
-R:«=ȎǮėƃŖ:Lj =ô-R�î:
>ǹ¡Đ=6�8LéȁƁ=Ĥ R(:9Ȏ
Lj �î>ǝũMDZ´<ô±Ť=6�8>Ɖ
ƾVċR(:#9$R3T��
���� M SD M SD M SD M SD M SD M SD M SD M SD M SD M SD���� 4.78 0.59 3.64 1.03 3.45 0.49 3.29 0.51 3.41 0.48 5.28 0.58 3.50 0.88 3.80 0.88 3.96 0.84 4.11 0.81���� 4.58 0.78 3.21 1.14 3.51 0.54 3.35 0.47 3.48 0.40 5.07 0.65 3.17 0.96 3.76 0.78 3.83 0.77 4.10 0.73����� 4.61 0.63 3.28 1.01 3.53 0.41 3.34 0.42 3.38 0.43 5.01 0.72 3.29 1.02 3.50 0.70 3.53 0.72 3.87 0.83����� 4.64 0.72 3.36 1.07 3.59 0.43 3.35 0.46 3.52 0.48 4.91 0.79 3.43 1.10 3.51 0.69 3.51 0.81 3.77 0.84
�� ��
��� # ���#�"� ��������!�#� ����
Table 1
2015��$N = 39% 2016��$N = 47%����� ������������������1-6�
�� ��
��� # ���#�"� ��������!�#� ����
���
����
�"��#& .33 * .24 *
�� �&"%� .34 * .42 ** .47 ** .48 ** .48 ** .45 ** .60 ** .35 ** .28 ** .22 *
Adj R2 .11 * .11 ** .18 ** .23 ** .23 ** .23 ** .20 ** .36 ** .06 * .12 ** .08 ** .05 *
� � �� � � �
��
Table 2 ����� �����������������������
������'N = 39( ������'N = 47(
** p < .01, * p < .05β = �������!��������������������������������
��
�� $!&� �� $!&�
� � �
�� ��
� �
��
�� $!&� �� �� $!&� �� �� ��
A2� íƭēś�¿Ř�
― ― 84
89JW����co�%("$ ��? ��
9a�5�[�P�| �fh���
��9a���%("$ �q,]�? �q,�gr7M��|x���
�
�ſƻƯ�½ƹI.$ȌŤĭêíêíǼȍ�ƹŸØ�ȌŤĭêíȍ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
��6~�ed
ńƊƓ?ȎµÿŚįƱƏƃ�>ſƻǍȆ>
Lj áū:+8>��t�i`Vŷ�ȎíŶ
#(>��t�i`Lj Ť=ô-Rł¾Đ>
NjƉMȎƾR>#ȁ¥3:�52bemĔV
;>O�=ĝ%>"VǕÙƝǎō=O58Ū
ï+ȎíŶ#��t�i`VŦŷ-R>V¢
-2K=;>O�=��t�i`VǬŷ-R
(:#¾ŋƁ<>"=6�8őDŽ-RL>9
�RȌ½ƹ�ƹŸȎ2016ȍ�
� ĥŒƯ9>��t�i`>Ǭŷ>�ķ=
O58ȎíŶ>Ì'ŜKķMƋNjÛı#çU
Q�R"=6�8Ȏ�ÿĂ=U258ǎōV
ƺ���Û>ſƻȌŔĒſƻȎńſƻȍ#Lj
ôǒ:<58�RĥŒ9Ȏ2015 ÿĂ?Ȏ
��t�i`V�2Rſƻ9�Rńſƻ>¹
=�Û3'Ǵ�-R>=ô+Ȏ2016ÿĂ9?Ȏ
ńſƻ¹>ȎŔĒſƻ>¹=L��t�i`
VǴ�+ȎŦŷ>Ř�V 2Û=äM-�ńſ
ƻĉ=Ūï+2��t�i`Lj Ť=ô-R
Lj :ƋNjÛıVŪï+Ȏ�Dž>ī�#ćȂ
VÈG-"=6�8ȎH2Lj :ƋNjÛı:
>ǹǨ=6�8őDŽVƺ��
��P]
/T?t� ŤĭêíČŵíƏ 1ÿŶôǒ>
µÿŚįƱƏƃ�áƌgy II�9ðĸ*S2�
ĉŃ=ųŦ¿Vƺ�Ȏ�Û>ſƻȌŔĒſƻ�
ńſƻȍ#Lj >ôǒ:<52�ſƻǍȆ?
�êí>]�u�_|�qe9ȎȊŎŶ=(
>êí>ČŵíƏ>ȋ¼V� R�:��L
>9�52�ńƊƓ9?Ȏ½ƹ�ƹŸȌ2016ȍ
9Ūï*S2 2015 ÿĂ>l�h!OA 2016
ÿĂ=Ūï*S2l�hVôǒ:+ȎńƊƓ
9ŷ�2-E8>ǕÙƝ=ÛƘ+2 104 Ó
Ȍ2015ÿĂ 50ÓȎ2016ÿĂ 54ÓȍV³ʼnô
ǒ:+2�
Sfh�b��%("$ �� 2015 ÿĂ
9?ȎŔĒſƻ> 1ǩ¹=ȎLj >ǀŭ=ǹ
-RœƽVnjļ+2#Ȏ��t�i`>Ǵ�
?ƺU<"52�ŔĒſƻ>Ƭǩ=ńſƻ>
��t�i`VǴ�+ȎLj >ǀŭ#ļDž*
S8�R>9ſƻ¹=ƋNj+ȎƳûLj -R
O�=:įƍ+2�2016ÿĂ?ȎŔĒſƻ>
1 ǩ¹=ŔĒſƻ>��t�i`VȎŔĒſ
ƻ>Ƭǩ=ńſƻ>��t�i`VǴ�+Ȏ
Òŕ>įƍVƺ52�ńſƻ>��t�i`
=ǹ-RLj ?Ȏ�ſƻ>�ķȌe.g., ľǸǴ
³ȎNJ+ķȍ�Ȏ�ſƻòȌe.g., ƽŢ*S2
�6>ƽƞȎų>]�dn�ƽƞȍ�Ȏ��d}
{Ȍe.g., čƽ<đâ#Džǟ*S8�R"ȍ�Ȏ
�ǕžĎƘȌe.g., ǕÙ=ô+8®Ŭ=Ƙ P
SR"ȍ�> 46>ǀŭ"Pƺ¿DžǥijȌe.g.,
įñ>�żǰ%ȀS2ư$Ę=L³=ư(
Rê$*>æ9ȎĻÍ=<R(:<%NJ/
Rȍ=O58 6Şǽ9Lj -RL>9�52�
� %("$ �q,]�| �@C� ��t
�i`=ô-Rł¾ĐȌe.g., Lj áūƻ?Ĉ
=Ɣ6ȎLj áūƻ?ſƻ>ĬÚ=ł¾ȍȎb
emĔȌe.g., Lj áūƻVƾR>?ȁ¥ȍȎ
Lj >DZ´ĐȌe.g., ſƻ>ėŋVDZ´=Lj
9$RȎƜċ9$RȎLj áūƻ?ļƋ9�
Rȍ:�� 6ȃƃ"P<QȎª×>ńſƻƄ
ĉ= 0ȏ5> 6Şǽ9LjïVŢK2�
H2ȎŔĒſƻĉ"Pńſƻ>ū§ŃǸ�
=Ȏ��t�i`V;>ƐĂƋNj+2"=ǹ
+8ȎƋNj>hZy�a 3Ȍ�d}{ū§/�
A2� íƭēś�¿Ř�
― ― 85
d}{�ė�/ſƻƧƭ�ȍ�ƋNj���ı 2
Ȍ��/ųȍ> 6ȃƃ=OQȎÒ,% 6ŞǽȌ0
Ûȏ5Û��ȍ9LjïVŢK2�
��jU�l>
� BC{�q;-�\w� ��t�i`Lj
Ť=ô-RLj =6�8ȎÿĂ):=Ðȃƃ
>þߦVƙ²+Ȍƻ 1>�ŞÇŮȍȎtőï
Vƺ�Ȏ2015ÿĂȎ2016ÿĂǸ>úVŠǞ+
2�0>ƢŋȎ�Lj áūƻ?Ĉ=Ɣ6�=!
�8 2015ÿĂOQL 2016ÿĂ>ķ#Ȋ�(
:#ƍ*S2Ȍt(102)=2.29, p<.05, d=0.45ȍ�
H2ȎƋNjÛı=6�8?ȎÿĂ 2(2015ÿ
ĂȐ2016 ÿĂȕǽƯǸ)�ƋNj>hZy�
a 3(�d}{�ėū§Ȑ�d}{�ė�Ȑſ
ƻƧƭ�ȕǽƯ)�ƋNj���ı 2(��Ȑ
ųȕǽƯ)> 3ƽÜ>³İ³ʼnVðĸ+2
:(TȎÿĂ>�¾ŋ#łē9�52ȌF(1,
102)=6.87, p<.05, ηp2=.20ȍ�+"+<#P0S
�è>�¾ŋȎ���ŷ?�.SLłē=?
<P<"52�-<U4Ȏ2016 ÿĂ>ķ#Ȏ
2015 ÿĂOQL��t�i`>ƋNjÛı#
é�(:#ƍ*S2#ȎƋNj>hZy�aM
��=ORǯ�?ƾPS<"522KȎ�Ǻ
>³ʼn9?ȎƋNj>hZy�aVǡI=+Ȏ
ÿĂ�ƋNj���ı> 4ņ�9ŠǞVƺ�(
::-R��
��>Ƣŋ"PȎ��t�i`>Ŧŷ>Ř
�V 2Û=äM+2 2016ÿĂ>ķ#Ȏ��t
�i`#OQĈƔ6L>9�R:��NjǑ#
Ȋ%ȎH2ńſƻ=Ô'2ū§�9>ƋNjÛ
ıLä 8�R(:#ƍ*S2�(>(:"
PȎŦŷ>Ř�#ä R(:=O58Ȏ��
t�i`#ĈƔ6:Ĕ,Rł¾Đ>NjƉ#Ȋ
HQȎOQƋNjÛı#é%<R:Ʈ PSR�
%("$ ��q,]��q,�gr7M
�|x� ��t�i`>Lj ŤD>Lj :Ƌ
NjÛı:>ǹǨ=6�8őDŽ-R2KȎÿĂ
):ȎƋNj���ı):=Ȏ��t�i`=
ô-RLj 6ȃƃVűƔçıȎƋNjÛıVĊ
øçı:+2ǶÛý³ʼnVðĸ+2Ȍƻ 1ȍ�
0>ƢŋȎ2015ÿĂ=!�8?Ȏ��9>�
Œľ=?�ƾR>?ȁ¥�#Ȏų9>�Œľ
=?�Ɯċ9$R�#łē<Ǔ>ćȂVġ6
(:#ƍ*S2��ķ9Ȏ2016ÿĂ=!�8
?Ȏ��>�Œľ=?�Ĉ=Ɣ6�#łē<
ŝ>ćȂȎ�ƾR>?ȁ¥�#łē<Ǔ>ćȂ
Vġ6(:#ƍ*SȎų9>�Œľ=?�ſ
ƻ>ėŋVDZ´=Lj 9$R�#łē<ŝ>
ćȂVġ6(:#ƍ*S2���VH:KR
:ȎÿĂǸ9«ǧ>ćȂVġ58�RȃƃL
�dz�R#ȎÿĂMƋNj���ı=O58ł
ē<ćȂVġ6ȃƃ#Ž<R(:#ļP":
<52�-<U4Ȏ��t�i`>Ŧŷ>Ř
�VäM+2(:#Ȏ��t�i`>ł¾Đ
>NjƉVȊK8?,K8ȎƋNjÛıDćȂ-
RO�=<52:Ħó*SR�
EbN`�
½ƹI.$�ƹŸØ�Ȍ2016ȍ�êíĥŒ=!
'Rſƻ>��t�i`=ô-RíŶ>Ì
'ŜKķ=ǹ-RƊƓ―ÃÒ�ŒNjǑöĂ
:��t�i`=ô-RLj :>ǹǨ―�
�µÿŚįƱí�ƕ 9Ûê�ſƻƽĺǿ�Ȏ
78-79.
ƻ 1� ÿĂ):ȎƋNj���ı):>��t�i`=ô-RLj VűƔçıȎ ��t�i`ƋNjÛıVĊøçı:+2ǶÛý³ʼn=!'RŖūÀ¡ı(β)(�łē<ãÑ>IDžǟ)
��7�H� ��M!�� �EL� �EL�:@# ��J9 ��>G
�R' ;,�?) Q(�N&��! ���!
831< ���� � ������� ��������� ������� �������� ������� � ���������56 GO-< ���� ��������� ��������� �������� � ������� ��������� ������������� $% �� ���� � � Z �� � � � � �����
�� � ��� D �������� � � � � � �� � ����
���� $% ������ � ��� ��� � � � � ����
�� � �� D � ���� � � � � ��� � � �����
AX*K9CI.Y�� ����P+SF�=T���" �N&0BLU�W�W�W#V��2�! ���!�
� �4/��� �
A2� íƭēś�¿Ř�
― ― 86
0BZKn�����������^b���
$!&��#'^2�<v���l>�
�
�ſƻƯ�� ňŸ�ºÏ�ÁŧǭƏíêí���
�
�
�
��� fh�ed�
� ńƊƓ?µÿŚįƱ=!'RíƭƯȌíŶȍ
#íA>ǛǘVƳPŀ$ŻKȎBQ" Q#9
$RƞŅVw�ms\�]-R(:=O58Ȏ
��Ɓ<íA>�QķVŲċ-Ru�fe>
ēƫVőDŽ+Ȏ0>¾ŋVĢõƯȌį×ȍ#ő
LJ+Ȏ��Ɓ=íCĕĂVȈ�(::>ǹǨĐ
=6�8ƊƓ+2L>9�R� � íå¼MƎ��áƌ¼>ƽƞ:LƄƢ-R
b�rk�c�v�e> 21�ƛàƲ¼=á7$ȎƳPíA=Ô$Ñ�¼Vǵė-R2K=č
ƽ<NjƉe_�ȌďƮ�¶ĵ�ƻŴ¼ƗȍVȊ
KR(:#čȅ9�R:*SR�ȎȊƗįƱ9
íƭƯƳP#íAVX`kYt=BQ" Q
#9$R"?Ŷ$R¼V?&%J�9Ƕƽ<
íA>u�fe9�R� � 0(9ȎíƭŘ�ȌĥŒȍ=!�8íAċ2
íƭò?L:OQȎíƭ=Ô$Ñ�Ƴû>�
QķM�Ư:>ǹ¡Đ"Pƾ 8$2(:<
;VşľƳûLj �Ƹƒ+ȎDZľģQǣR(:
9ȎíƭƯ#ƳP>íA>Ɣ4�ƪȌ�#9$
RO�=<58�8Ȏ�#³9?<%Ȏ�ĉ
ǚ=6'2�ǔǕMƲ¼?�<>"ƗVƳû
³ʼn+2ŰţȍVŪRǭ¬:+8�"=ŘƲ+
ċR"=6�8 3ǐƫŃǸ=U258ðǙ�őLJ+2� ��� fh�?t�P]�
� ƖƯ#ĥŒVĞą-RµÿŚįƱƏƃ�u�
d[`me_��=!'RƼı>íƏ>íŶV
ôǒ= 2016 ÿĂ¹Ń�2017 ÿĂ¹Ń=!�8ðĸ+2�BQ" Q>2K>Ù�Vª8«
�ÝȔ �s�`c~�c�m�ȌµÿŚįƱȍ�
ǧs\�xim:+2c�mVŷē+Ȍǐƫľ
=!'RǮėƃŖ?şľçĿȍȎşĥŒľ>Ɵ
UQ= 10³ƐĂ>Dž©ľǸVƋ£+2�ª 15Û>ǐƫ�Ȓ�ȓÛƃǠQ9�ǸȎŁƟǐƫ9
ƦĠ>BQ" QVƺ<�ȎƳP>íƭ>Ǜǘ
VƳû³ʼn+2�íƭƯƳP>íA>ǛǘVģ
QǣR2K>ǔĴ:+8>ŘƲ9�R2KȎDž
©+2c�m>ĢõƯD>ħ²?ńŇƁ9?
<�#Ȏ²řƋNj>ēÖÑ�LÕK8ÛÊ+Ȏ
Ƽ°VË52ĉ=ǣÆ+2�Į=0>ĐŐ�Ȏ
ńc�m>Džǥò=ORėƩLj D>ÉĽ
?�´!(<U<�(:?ǂ�H9L<��
A2� íƭēś�¿Ř�
― ― 87
��� �����.=�
� ��Ɓ<íAV¢-2K>ƳûƋNjj��
:+8>ēÖÑ�V¹ħ:+8�R2KȎÙ
�?��>ȑ6>ƿŭ:+2� 1. ĥŒ�=�#ǖ(58�2>" 2. ƳûLj >¶ĵŏğ?ļƋ" � 1 ?�ĥŒľǸ9>íAD>Ô$Ñ�ķMŲċ+2(:VÎƿÀ-R(:Ȏ0+8¹
ǥ+2�ǸÈAƦĠ>BQ" Q>Ǿ=Ƴû
³ʼn-RǶƽ<ǔĴ:<R�2 ?�š7$ȎíAȎžÙŭD>Džǥ�:�ńľ>¸ǮƃŖ
=ô-RƳû>�Qķ�>ȑ6>ƾķ"PƳ
ûLj +Ȏ¸ǮŞǽ:+2¶ĵ>ŏğVļƋ
=ƍ-L>9ȎLj >ìąĐ�IJÑĐVȊK
R(:?L:OQȎǏŵƁďƮV?&%J2
K>Ƨƭ>ã:+8LēƫVL2/8�R�
Ȍ2017ÿĂ?ƃŖǮėLj >I=çĿȍ ��� <v��l>�
� ËƠąµ?ńðǙƳ�>ēÖVŵǁ9$<
"52QȎ ¦Vƾ²3/<"52íŶ#F
:W;9�52#Ȏ�Ǹ�s�`c~�>�
2Q"P0>ēƫ=š7$Ô$Ñ�ķ=çÀ
#ŴSRƯ:Ȏ0>HHo^kYt<ÅǒV
L52HHƦĠ=ƴRƯ:=ê·9$2Ȍ�
ǸÈAƦĠ�s�`c~�c�m>DžǥO
Qȍ�BQ" Q>�ķ=ŝǁ?<�2KȎ�
8ŀ$ķĢõM�ƍ?+<�O�=+2Ƣ
ŋ9�R:ďUSR��UNR�ŗƚƁ<Û
Ƙ>�ķ�Vƶ+:-R>9?<%Ȏ�%H
9L���Ɓ=íC�2K>ēǑMĕĂVǚ
=6'R(:VƃƁ:+8�22K9�R�
+"+Ȏo^kYt<HHƟU58+H52
íŶ=ô+8?¤·�ª�VÙU.ƁƋ"6
¾ŋƁ<Ģõ>�Qķ#�52>9?<�"
:Ʈ R�� @�Ɔ-R(:��w�ms
\�]>ēƫ��ŏğ#čƽ9�R:��ŏğ�
<;ȎBQ" QŦ¿=ËQƠJ¹ħ:+8
čƽ<ƉǑ�ĚƲMĕĂ>dz³9�R�(>
O�=--Kķ=6�8L¯őDŽ+ȎƤƥ+
8ËQƠW9�%(:#ê´9�R� ��� +H�s~�
� Ì¿Ɓ=íAVǪK8$2ơȉ#é�íŶ
=:58Ȏ�>a��p�ÀMđâƎ�>Ǫ
÷ȎH2 AI >ƀã<;=O58»Ɓ=çÀ-RƎ�=!�8ȎƳû>íAVƳPxod
{�m+8�%¼Vǚ=6'R(:?é³=
Ŷ$R¼>ǵė=ǤR2K>XZkz:<R
9�T��0S=Ô'8ȎÞǭ=Ȏ0+8Ƥ
ƥƁ=ËQƠW9ƺ%(:?L:OQȎ�>
į×Ǹ:LǨĪ+8ðǙ=�258�%(:
?�ĉčƽ:<RǍȆ<>9?<�3T�"�
A3� Žƺxk^�
― ― 88
��e���RW��e"\�)��'r�<4,O����
y|W¦����� �
�
�ǵɈȴ�� ĢȾǗ�óŊœƱʮȃŌȀȓǿɦĭijǿɦijʉʯ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
¬«�¥�
�� ¡ȜȊ·C�ȺS¥¼ǷAȳ!Ʌñ=%
U�Ⱥŝġ¬ƫ�Yř'NJN<�U�4B6
N�ĭijȗBʩȗƍȸǁʔC�ijǨB�Ȃɤ
ŶɆǷȹë�ʮɡǦǷŧȳë�êɻëʯ��Ŭǃ�
ʮȺōűʐ"RE¯ȴɩǣYȤȥ�ĉ�,2
Uëʯ��Ȋ·ũ�ʮȊ·�Ł¬ʔÄë�"©�
YǦɑ.ʩN� ëʯBȸűAîN<�U�� � �
ǿɦĤȇƍȸA"�<O�ƏʉȏijǾƹɔ
·ʮ���� Œ � ƥʯPùǨïÐǾƦɤȴŰɠ·
ʮ���� Œ ƥʯBĥČYĀ(�Ş0I<B
ǿɦŐ$¥¼ǷAȳ!Ʌñ=%U*>YǼŻ
.<�U�¿2<�ÆÌ�õǴ�ȌȋBßʌ
=ąłʑȷȴ>ɼƇ.<ǿɦYĹɮ0Uȹë
YǤş0UR NJN<�U�.6$9<�ǿ
ɦijǨC�÷ÐǷ=¥¼Ƿ@ijȲůŖYȲş
0U*>$%XN<ʋɊ>@9<�U�4B
6NAC�ǿɦĤȇƍȸA"�<�÷ćijȲ
P ��� ȗB\fw]����|�gBijȲƓ
ǏYń×0U*>$ƻN<ʋɊ>@U�.#
.@$S�ǿɦĤȇƍȸ=CŽƺȏǼ$Ĭ'
c�e���Bæȝ$�U6N�ƕIJBȏǼ
"�<?BR A\fw]����|�gY
ń×0UB#$ĖȨBɞʢ>@9<�U� «���
\fw]����|�g=C��Ūĥ>\^
x]\�ʮɣȰPɝƢARUþʜʯ��Ȣʨ�ʮȂ
Ƿ@Ʌñʯ��Ǿŀ�ʮɅñAŁ0UFTɶTʯ
BǒñC©�AʔÄ0U�ƩȄȒC�*BR
@ � :BǒñYɞʢƁNJijȲB¤=ňʒ0
UʁȐBɕɸYǼǷ>0U��
®«v��
®ª¬«^���r�_�
ʱŒǨ �� ĈC���]��zĹȲ�ʮèƨ�
ŤÈ�� øºʯY ĈBq�Aß#V<Āɣ
.6�¿2<��Ūĥ�w�l��ʮèƨ�ʆ
ŷ�� øºʯY � f�nAß#V<Āɣ.6��
®ª«�¥s�e���� ɞʢƁNJijȲY���]��zĹȲ�=Ʌ9
6���]��zĹȲ�BǼǷY��ğģYȻ
ăA�¬>ÄXU*>=ƟS.P®§�Ǩǒ
Əò�ǧħBǦɑYǖN�¬$Ǩǒ0U*>
YƁNJ0U�>.6��
®ª®«�q���e�<4,O�
��]��zĹȲ�BʃűǼǀAŁ0Uij
Ȳxk^�YƾȚ.6�ʃűǼǀʮ�ʯ�´ʓ
PƍĒ>÷Ð.<ɞʢAÿTȡL�ȺōBŜ
éYɿɅ0U�AŁ.<�÷ćijȲP ��� Y
ń×.6�ʃűǼǀʮ�ʯ�ǥɧBɐŀ>ɔɡ
Yɺ.<ŪĥYĺɐǷAßƯ0U�AŁ.<�
�Ūĥ�w�l��>ɼƇ.<nsx]�n
e�oYȸű.6�ʃűǼǀʮ�ʯ�ȺōBij
EBűưY¯ȴA¸!�ȺōBijȲɞʢYƙ
S#A0U�AŁ.<�ijȲ��y�a��
bYń×.6��
®ª¯«3Q7<4,O � ¯ȴ>ijEĆ ÷ćijȲP ����ĭijǨ>
.<ijG6NBnsx]�ne�oBŽƺ�
ûEijȲ��y�a��bBƍȸǷ®ſ(Y�
�� ɣBŽƺAȡLɵZ7ʮɈʱʯ�¿2<�ʮ�ʯ
´ʓ;'T�ʮ�ʯɣȰ�ǚȲ�ʮ�ʯ��� B�
|uyAßé.�4V5VDZ@UƍȸƓǏY
Ǫ�6� �
A3� Žƺxk^�
― ― 89
�
�
� ��/,9O7 ŽƺBʃűǼǀYȆɚ.�\fw]����|�g"REijȲA"(U
¯ȴBʋɊũA:�<ɣȰ.6�ƍĒCq�
=ɔɡ0Uw��YƄȈ.�ijǨC4VYʆ
ŷ.6�ƍĒ�Ĉ>ijǨĈBq�Y¾96�� �
�³� ��U£��&÷ćijȲBŶǏYɑɜ
.�ijEĆ!U´ʓ;'TYǼǷ>.6�g
�����fYɺ.<�ƒ.�ü¬ćĨ$ij
EĆ Ƽ.,Y¼ʨ0U*>Yʋɍ.6�4
BəÃY�Žƺɕʏl�y=Ʌ96� �³� ����P��ƾɻò,V6g����
�fBĹɮYǼŻ.6��Ūĥ�w�l��=
C��ɟIU�ɝM�Ƣ'�ŬɋYɸIU�n
sx]�ne�BɣȰ�ǚȲYɅ96�ȱɽ
B��]��zĹȲ�=C�ijZ7ne�B
šȲ>ĹɮYq�=Ʌ96�ƏȔBɡǦǷ@
ƾűYǦɑ0U6N�ɡƏBȪɒŕɡ�Ʃɡ�
ȣɡAßɑ.<4BɊƗYɜƙ.6�K6�
ƒȶɕ§Y�§Ĺ>Ŭɋ�Aôä.<ɝL�
ɕ§AŁ0UŬɋYǵɈ.6� �³�� ����èB�|uy=ş6ȂɤPn
e�BǒǪYǼǷ>.6���� BÜĽY�ğ
ģB¬>ÄXT®§PƟS.BĹůYɟIU
>.6�ijǨCƍĒBƉƆYĀ(@$SŽƺ
Ü�ī=ɓǯYȓ<�¥¼ǷA�]��z�
�fYɅ96�ǒñBűưY�n�^zAR
Ug���ǵɈ>ɬB���y=ĥČ.6�
�� ��$�%�ijǨC�g���ǵɈBÜĽ
YO>A�ƤâA��nBȺōəÃ>ćÒə
ÃYɅ96�ƍĒC�ijǨB4VAŁ0Uə
ÃYɅ96���nBəÃYȠ!U>�Ɗĕ
B6NBȺōəÃYɅ96�ćÒəÃ>ƍĒ
əÃY,SAȥ(6� Y��e��!&�&§èijȲ=ɟI6ɪ
ƐPx�sY�[^�Aȧ/�ijȲ��y�
a�b>.<��q�w�l��P���y
AǒǪ.6�džĘBŽƺBFTɶTYŽƺɕ
ʏl�yYǪ�<Ʌ���½YijEȳ!6B#�
P�´ʓ#SĀ(6çǛ�A:�<ɕɸ.6� ¯«�~�
ɞʢƁNJijȲYɺ.6ȺōűʐYəÃ0U
6N��Ȋ·¬Ĥȇë���əÃĤǙɈ�Y
Ǫ�<ȺōəÃYɅ96�4Bȣư�Ȋ·¬
ĤȇëYƾű0U �� ÉBëC�ě � AȈ0R
A�ŽƺĹƔè>LJɱ.<Ƞ¦ƛ=C0I
<BɊȟBǜƎC�$U>ÚA�RTĠ�@
śYȈ.6��
°«�h�
� ȺS¥¼ǷAȳ!Ʌñ=%UëBȸűAC�
�ȂɤBǤş>ĸȁʮȂ9<�U�=%Uʯ�
Y�ȂɤBŬčǦɑ>ǑȭʮX#Uʯ�Hňʒ
.��ȂɤBƦŬč@ÀǪ>ūÑʮÀ!Uʯ�
Hǵň,2UŽƺxk^�BƾȚ$ʋɊA@
UOB>ȳ!SVU�
�#"���!��� ���!����
�#"��������������
� �*�)���$*
� /O "%+&*�
� �7�2���-]
� V=�CJ� U����' X>_
� V=�T� T���' X>_
� ?N�T� T���' X>_
� �8M�4����� A��' (!+�_
8MRG�0-1� 9Q�Z����'
F58M �@_
�� 63A�A A��' (!+�_
�� HP;[��� 9Q�Z����'
�� HP�%�����
�� HPKM��
�� :B�HP�
�� ��Y� <DS.
I�# �������
����� ���� ������� ����
Ia# ���,\���
I�# ���WL`EM�
A3� Žƺxk^�
― ― 90
,D>0e�#7,;:)X('� ²¨@Q=�©�
0QNQ>±W¦cr�� bv[�� �V�bv�de��
�
�ǵɈȴ�� ʬǫȍʛʮƖƩȩĆȄȒų�èƮ«ĿĨĭijƍŽʯ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
¬«Z%��
� ƚŒC�ijǨBn^utY×VU6NAC�
¶ƺ>4*AÐ'Ȋ·¬BëY�ʼʽʾƔș
ʮğÔ¶ƺɖĔʯBǒǪA:�<ǵɈY.6�
ŒC�ğƓêǨYǒǪ.6�^�zeijǨ
HBn^utY×VUƓǏ�ʮ��y�ʯYǵ
Ɉ0U�*BƔșC��ɅƋ��ğģ"*.÷
ëʙ����ny�[����4.<�ʊ·B
ĭij�>�ğƓBĭij�Bi����l��
=�ĹƔ,VU�x�ʮ®ȡLʯ=�U�*
B®ȡLC�ğƓêǨAŁ.<OƦð@ǒũ
òș>@UB=�ŞCØĜǷAǵň.<�
'*>YŦʣ.<�U��
«Zl�t��bv[��AM2IF)j
X�'p��
¨�����a¥p�©�
ʮʱʯʊ·ÞɯBĭijǨBJ>Z?C�ğƓ
AɏŲPɄȮȴ$�@��Á!�6>.<O
°%Ć�BȐŖ$Ƀ'�ĭʊ·BǨǒĤǻC�
ƖƩ¤BğƓBƉƆ=űTȓ9<�U*>Y
ȂS@�ijǨ$Ĭ�>ɒ!U��
Á!D�ʥISVUʌɁBʳßBʱ$Ɍƶ
P���zȦźB6NBɌæ=ż<SV<.
K ʀďA�U�*VCğƓA»MijǨ=C
Ś6TèB*>=C�U*>#O.V@��
4B*>YâN<Ȃ96ʊ·ǓBijǨAC�
ʥIǠYż<U*>HB�@3ż<UB#ʻ�
>� ɇƈ$ɬU�? A#ŗƷʌɁCǒǪ
=%@�B7W #ʻż<Uy�yʮʌɁʯ
C��nsBy�yr�nA0VDż<1A
ʥISVUBA>ȟƪ@dzĔ#SǵǨ.<�
4BdzĔ#Sƒ.�ǵū$ǨKV<�'�� � � � � � � � � �
ʮʲʯğƓêǨPğƓBǒũòYƂɾ0U6
NAC�4BğƓA�ƒ.'ĸ».<'VU
»LjBǤş$ŤɊ=�U�C�n��ƛ±�
n��¡±Bȿȴ68BǨǒƿŘY�ğģǒ
ũòAʔÄ0UǟŒBi�j�s�y=Cö
ßAǦɑ=%@�ǥǢ=�U�4Bȣư>.
<ƒ.�ĸ»ȴYĎEɵM*>$=%@���
� Á!DğƓBǡǩđBēđʒǵP"ĝǩA
Ĭ�Đɀı¾T7(=C�ğƓBǒũòCǝ
Ǧ@ǢǍ=�U�?*BʂBʧ=Oć/R
@ēđ$£Z=�UÏĉA�U�K6�ǡǩ
đYʒǵ.<O�ÃƶYȦź0U6NBɉí
ʍ$@'@VDÃƶYȦź0U*>$=%@
'@TÃƶBĪơYɷSVÊ�)0U�4B
6NAǡǩđCĩV@'@U�*BR AɌ
ɌæBɐŦ=C�ğƓêǨBƾȚCʝ.���
� 4*=�ŃƭȊ·¬>@Tĸ»ȴ>@T
UĂȹũB�UĭijǨɢĊB\^x\$ÖU
B=�U�¹.�ʊ·BijǨBL@S1ğƓ
BijǨBŬɋOćƛAÿT×VUŤɊ$�U�
ğƓCƽ.<ÆĵǷ@6N=�U�Ȏ68$
�]��z��f.6Ħų=O�ƊʡƉźǓ
$ʵʰʭ�ÆĵǓ$ʵʰʭ=�96�ǵū$
ƻȕ0&U>�Ň».<�Uĸ»ȴAC�ƻ
ȕ@ǵūCĀ(×VSV@�6N=�U��
®«zlfw���x �§\]AM6-1
=�����
� ƚŒʸƥA�Ȏ$ʤĔ>.<�U�¶ƺ�
m}nȄȒćĮ·�B��~�>�ȪA�ʫ
ÿȀBʁDzğBƤÕȕğģ=�UʫÿȀƖʌ
ʈƖʌǮʮțı#SǡŨ=ʴʰßB¤Ŋʓğ
ģʯB�ƖʌǮʪëò��m_fy�Aúì
.6�ijǨCćğ=�ʴǎʵƖBǨǒ¼ʨY
�ny�[���Bļ=ľǎ.@$S��g
A3� Žƺxk^�
― ― 91
��YȢʨ.6��
ʮ��m_fyBƽɊʯ�
ʮʱʯƖʌǮBƽɊʺ¬āʳʷʴʵ¬�ʶʵ
DŽ²�B¬āC�ʱʵʷʲ¬ʮʴʲʭʯ�
ʮʲʯ��m_fyBȄȒBʳɍǜʺ�
�ǩƺ��ɐÖ��Ǩǒ��
ʮʳʯúìijǨʺʱʲĈʮʊ·BĭijʱʰĈ�
ğƓBĭijʲĈ�4B¤=�ʱŒǨCʳĈʯ
ʴĈ1:�ny�[���ĴAľǎ��
ʮʴʯÛ¼Ƿ@ÜĽ�
âƖʺb�`�w�l��>Űɏ·�
ʲƖʿʴƖǼʺǩƺ�ɐÖ�ǨǒBʳt��
ʮąʴĈʯ=ɴƺ¼ʨYċN6ğÔÿƫYĹ
Ɣ��ğģ"*.÷ëʙ�Bj��y=ÿƫ>
¼ʨCn��oAĹƔ,V6��
ƤȠƖʺƖʌǮBǸƿBè=��q�ʮǮʐ�
Ǯɥ·ɥʐ��ny�[���YċMʯ*B
��q�CĭĮə=�96�ʹƥʲƖBğÔ
ȞʮƖƩǕƒȶʯAƃɲ,V6��
ʮʵʯijǨBŮūʮʱŒǨʯ�
,Z K=AčX!@�R @¼ʨ�ƿ�
@ǢǍHBŁťPƲɰũYijI6�ȺßA>
9<CĭĪƦŬȰ@ƛʓ=�96��
� ,ZʺƖʌǮCȺǞAĚKV6ȟƞS.�
ų7�ıÂ68CǸAŭ,Vœ2Aűʐ.<
�U�ȺßCƖʌǮ=Ǩǒ¼ʨY.<ǮBʪ
ëYǵɋ=%6�¬ǨACȽ�@¼ʨ$ŤɊ
7�ƩŚAƼ.#96�ʮǰijǨ�¤Ĝʯ�
� ,ZʺƖʌǮCȺǞBƝȽ$%V�7�4
B¤=ɴƺ¼ʨY.6�4B¼ʨB¤=�Õ
ɳ>Bʄ�YɋÞ.�ȺßAC�ɭ.<�U
ʉß$6',Z�U*>$lj;�6��ny
�[���C><OÓ.'Ǹɏà796�ʮǰ
ijǨ�¤Ĝʯ�
¯«x �§\]AM6-1=��n�k¢�
ʮʱʯğģǒũòp�s�BȄÈ·Aúì�
ʮʲʰʱʶŒʱʲƥʯ�
ƖƩØĜBąȺnj¼$ƀǪ.6�ğģ"*
.÷ëʙ�BȄÈ·$ƚŒʱʲƥAʒÎ,V
6�ĘB�ƖʌǮʪëò��m_fy�C
ØĜ¤=ÓV6ÿTȡL>.<əÃ,V�Ɩ
ʌǮB�ğģ"*.÷ëʙ�B¤Ŋ,Z>ú
ì.6ijǨ$�ØĜBȄÈǨBè=�~�m
��\u�.6ܼB��q�w�l��Y
ĹƔ.6�Ǹ,Z#SC�ʩ�əÃYĀ(�
ijǨBȺÇ$,SAǖK96��
ʮʲʯʫÿȀ¥Î�ijǨ�a����Aúì�
ʮʲʰʱʷŒʳƥʯ�
ʲʰʱʶŒ�ʫÿȀB¤=ğƓêǨBǒñ
$ɂ.'ȼ#96>əÃ,V6ijǨBʷę¼
$�ʫÿȀ> ��� Ǐ¬�¬ɨ~�f�BÚć
ʒÎ=ĹƔ,V6�ijǨ�a����AŹȵ
,V6�Ʈ«#SCƩij>ƘȑǫĭijBʲƵ��
�ijǨ�a����=C�ğģǒũòp�s
�=B~�m��\u�BܼB��q�Y
ĹƔ.6�¥Îȴ#SBəÃ>.<C�ğƓ
BĭijǨBɋƓ>Cʄ ɍǜ=BǵɈ=�T�
ʊ·Bĭij>ğƓBĭijBijǨćĨBi��
��l��BʋɊũYǖ'Ů/6>BəÃY
Ā(6�*BR A�ć/ƖƩ=C�U$�
ʊ·>ğƓ$©�Aªǔ0U*>$�¢ȴC
çǛ.��,S@UǵňAȯ$U*>A@U
>� *>$Ĺɘ,V6ȣư>@9<�U��
°«���
ğƓêǨYǒǪ.6®ȡLʮ�x�ʯA<�
�^�zeBijǨHBn^utY×VUA
Cʻ�Yɡ/<%6�ŎǮƬ�ɅƋ���ğģ
"*.÷ëʙ����ny�[�����ʊ·>
ğƓBĭijBijǨ�Bi����l��AR
9<*BƔșCűTȓ9<�U��ƓR.=
C@'�ėƓR.BƔș=�U�*BƔș=
C�ȿ�ĭijǨBŮũ$ʋɊɍ,VUB=�
T�âŒǂƍȸŁɧBijǨ=OößAúì=
%ëYǵƅ=%UB=�U�*B*>CijǨ
BŮū#Sɋ<OǦɑ=%U�*BƔșC�
ʊ·ǓBijǨ68AƖƩYÝɚɤ,2�ǰij
ǨAOƖƩBƩƭBȼ%İYǦɑ,2U*>
$=%U�ƤŞA�*B��m_fyB%9
#(Y"¾T�67�6ĶǫǐƌÕǨʮĚȅ
ʹDž���ƸĨʯAŠȉǭ.�)6��ʮķʯ�
A3� Žƺxk^�
― ― 92
}Sde�Zl�8E?QKu���i¡o�
L,=P7B5GJ8Q5HO)¤g���*QJQP.17CQ6GQ� �
�
�ǵɈȴ�� ŋǫƜƱʮƮ«ĭij� ĭijʘȩĆƏòȄȒȏʯ� � �
¤ƬʐĄʮƮ«ĭij� ĭijȩĆƍȸȄȒp�s�ʯ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
¬«t`�<+5AJOPi¡�m����
Zl�8E?QK�
Ʈ«ĭij$ǥĞÿȡZ=�U�ijʉƍȸB
ȩĆǷƊʡ�B�ƩƳB�:AƍȸB�Ĺɫ
ò�$ƃ)SV<�U1�Ʈ«ĭijƍʦijʉ=
C�*B�Ĺɫò�YƉ!UʋɊ@ŽƺB�
:>.<�âŒǂq�{��Əȏ�Y ����
ŒŖ#Sʒɣ.<�U�*VC����� Œ#S
Ʌ9<%6 � ŒǨĉ(ń׎ƺ=�U�Ĥȇ
ǚȲ�Y�ijʉƍȸBȩĆǷƊʡ�BƓʎA
B9>9<Ɗʡ.6OB=�Ʈ«ĭijA×ij
.6ƏȏǨȝ ����� ĈØĒ$ � ŒǨBƤâB
ijƨAʼnÈ0UŤÈŽƺ=�U��
ěʺƮ«ĭij�ijʉƍȸBȩĆǷƊʡ�RT�
�
�ĤȇǚȲ�>>'Aĭ%'DZ@U�âŒ
ǂq�{��Əȏ�BǡŢB 1:C�ijǨ$
?BâŒǂq�{��YĀ(U#YʆG*>
1 Ʈ«ĭij�Ʈ«ĭijA"(UijʉƍȸBȩĆǷƊʡBƂɾ(����uy)�http://www.u-tokyo.ac.jp/content/400004451.pdf ʮ2017Œ 5ƥ 29ƖʕɎʯ
$=%U>� ǜ=�U�Ʈ«ĭijèƨɞȐ
ʮ1,2 Œǂʯ=C�ʆŷ.6Ȗ¨īĜɛAO
>;'f�nȫű$ɅXV<"T�ĤȇǚȲ
BŽƺCɛijäf�n+>AéTŚ<SV<
�6�4B6N�ƍĒBłʑ>ijǨBʔţ�
ʅũBʓA�n�ut$Ǩ/�ŽƺHBijǨ
"REƍĒB�t��l��A�^{nBð
ư$Þ<.K *>$�96T��w�l�
�B�UijǨAŁ.<ijɆǷAǖ'žT�)
UR @ȄȒA�-@�A'�>� ƍĒÍ
B�ǘP�ɹAO9>ƩƶǷ@âŒǂȄȒY
.6�BAŽƺ$�Ȭ��>Ů/UijǨÍB
�ǘ$Ǩ/U>�96ʝ.,$�96�
�ɸ.6�ijʉƍȸBȩĆǷƊʡ�AC�
ijǨB¥¼Ƿ@ijE�¥¼Ƿ@ʼnÈʆŷYÅ
ɾ0U*>$ 6XV<"T�âŒǂq�{
��Əȏ=BʼnÈŽƺBʆŷæń×C*VA
49<�U�âŒǂq�{��Əȏ=C�ij
ǨYf�n+>A 6:Bg���Aß(�ą
g���$éTŚ<SV6ƠʗAÞɣ,VU
âŒǂq�{��ƏȏBŽƺʮ9ʿ12 Žƺʯ
B¤#S�ijǨ$Ā(6�ŽƺYʆŷ.<Ƕ
ʏ0U*>A@9<�U�
NjÉũǷ@âŒǂq�{��ƏȏBŽƺ$
£Z=�<C�ijǨCŽƺYʆG*>$=%
@��4*=âŒǂq�{��Əȏ=C�Ú
ɺBŽƺǼǀYƃ)::O��ąŸŚƍĒ$4
V5VBłʑũYǺT*Z7ŽƺÜĽYl�
~n=Ùʒ.�ijǨAŽƺʆŷBȺǬY !�
U*>YŽƺd^z�^�ʮʟÙʒʯAǺT
ɵZ7�l�~nAC�4BâŒǂq�{�
�ƏȏBŽƺ$O>;'ijɆßʌYŤ1ƙɕ
A3� Žƺxk^�
― ― 93
0U*>A@9<�U� �ijʉƍȸBȩĆǷƊʡ�B�Ĺɫò�B
6NBÿȡ>.<�èƨɞȐƍȸA"(U�\
����`fn��m���Oƃ)SV<�
U*>#S�ąƍĒ$ąȺBijɆǷłʑBO
>=�ijǨA\cx�uf@¼ʨYɅX2U
R @ŽƺYɅ *>C�Ʈ«ĭij$ǼŻ0
ƍȸƊʡA#@ OB=�U>ɒ!U� «L,=P7B5GJ8Q5HO�*QJ
QP.17CQ6GQ�
Ʈ«ĭijBâŒǂq�{��Əȏ=C�ij
ɆǷAŬčB�UĔ�YƁ.�ÕɅȄȒYŵ
ãǷAƹɔ.�ȺßB³ɜYȓ<�4VYɡ
ɘ.�4BűưYijɆɡƏAǙ/6�ŅɡƏ�
>.<K>NU>� �ɼBijɆ¼ʨYijǨ
AɅX2U*>A@9<�U�ņ¬ƎB\f
w]���|�gśŘBŽƺ=�U6N�ij
ǨARUŽƺəÃ\�h�y=C�ɣȰśŘ
=ijG*>$Ĭ�¯BŽƺRTO�ɯA:�
6�>� ɑȘ$Ĭ�� Žƺ=ijD@(VD@S@�*>$�ɯA
:�6�>ijǨ$ĹŮ0U*>CʟőAƦǹ
@*>=�Uýʠ������\�vƍȸY
ʋɍ.�ǡĸBłʑßʌAËS@�Ŕ�ɍʌ
>ȩĆǷ@ãƑëYʦ 6NB��^y�n
�l��q�l���YƍȸƓʎB�:Aƃ
)UƮ«ĭijBĦĆ�ĭijA×96D#TB
ijǨ$ǡĸBx]l�����U�C4B¤
BǡĸBǦɡBLYɺ/<OB+>Yɋ6T
ȳ!6T0UR A@9<.K R @âŒ
ǂƍȸCƧK.'@�� �^y�n�l��q�l��YƳ>0U
�����\�vƍȸB¤=��łʑũAO>
;'ń×ƍȸ�C? �UI%#�ƩĥČ=
C�2015ŒŖ#S 2017ŒŖK=B 3ŒʓAƮ«ĭij=âŒǂq�{��ƏȏBŽƺYŸ
Ś.6łµƍĒA��^y�n�l��q�
l��>\����`fn��m��B¨:
BƍȸƓʎYâŒǂq�{��ƏȏBŽƺ=
?BR AŬɤ.�?BR A~��nYÿ
96#Yȶ%ÿT.6ȣư>�4VSBŽƺ
YĀ(6ijǨA�âŒǂq�{��BijɆß
ʌAŁ0Uʔţ$Žƺè>ŽƺŞ=?BR
AĪò.6#Yȶ%ÿTɟƴ.6ȣư#S�
ƍʦɞȐA"(Uń×ƍȸ=�UƮ«ĭijB
âŒǂq�{��Əȏ$���^y�n�l
��q�l��YʖĻ.@�R Aɗɓ,V
<"T�ĹʚAʖĻ.<�@�#��\��
��`fn��m��>.<ƦðAǁȹ0U
R ɗɓ,V<"T�ĹʚA4 ǁȹ.<�
U#�Yƹɔ0UOB=�U� ®«Tn�k{ � âŒǂq�{��Əȏ$Ʈ«ĭij=įK9
<#SK7 3ŒǼ=�T�ŽƺYŸŚ0UƍĒB×VƣTO�U6N�âŒǂq�{��
ƏȏBŽƺ>ɾijʆŷBʔÄA:�<�K7
Ȇ#@ǽʔʔÄCǵɋ=%<�@��ɾijŏ
ƧȴYĬ'Ǥş.6�ijʉPi�nB6NB
�ʞǫáT�P�Ě�ɵL�BĦ>.<âŒ
ǂq�{��ƏȏBŽƺ$åǪ,VUBYʇ
(::��^y�n�l��q�l��BƦ
ð@ŴDž>@T UâŒǂq�{��ƏȏB
Žƺxk^�A:�<�ŞOȤȥǷAɟ
ƴ�ȄȒ.<Q%6��
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 94
`gnº (+�Ù�©Ë !vÖ�
ãàY×!n#�!ÉÍ]p¯,®����
�
7Ɋʨʑ8� ɚȈʩŕŽÆɧřʼnř�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
áßhÚ!�jc#°´!® àʕʑƯǺW\3Ȃ4]¼[0ˀ ˊ Ȃ
ˊtˀhĄtTDpPi[řa5Ȃó6�
ȂȾ˅�X0�w�ƐAȎ;��w�tƐAZ
@nȎ<�ɵ\5ŞƷ6WȄƯHqV;p1ā
ʑ]´ǖDŽȀ0Ɨʑ]ãÇfP] ���&$���
���!#�%!#'��'$%�� ɵ\��°ƒƍWʥs
qpFX@ň;1ʼnW]ãÇȯōƷʦt
ipFX@ɐɌW��°LpPi3đģř
ʏ4]ʥsZ;\W0�w�ƐAȎ;ǁūʑ
]đģřʏW\ǁūtŞǛJZ;FX@ň;1�
řɀ]ȯōk˸˔]Ŕ;W]Z;@0Ȃó
[]?Zo\ʞƳƨˉtǀSV;pʑ@ň;1
�����ƂƯ ���ƃ ǥ>m` ��� ƂƯ ��
ƃ ǥ[3Ȃ*4WŞǛJP˕įɾ˃ǹW
ȂótƘƨ¸ƘƨXJPʑ]0η\˥oW
:SP1�
ʨȂó\Ƙƨ¸Ƙƨ�
� ���� ƂƯ ��
ƃ�
��� ƂƯ ��
ƃ�
Ƙƨ� ��� ���
¸Ƙƨ� �� ���
´ǚ0ˮ ȣĉkʏ;Àʃʑ@ȂótƘƨ
¸ƘƨXJPăĢ]η\˥oW:SP1�
(Ââ)Ó¥^Fº�M·Û¼!�W!��èJ��(H 2016�I
2017)
Ó ¥ ^
·Û¼
Ó¥^�
·Û¼
º � M
·Û¼
º�M�
·Û¼
�� 47% 16% 39% 15% 20% 6% 15% 5%
J�� 53% 84% 15% 85%
80% 94% 85% 95%
ζɵ?n0ʼnřW\Ȃó\řʏ]�®?
n\ř`W]ZB0LW[5ʞƳƨˉtǀS
V;pʑb\DŽȀ6X;<0ȁiVȹȒZƢ
˕\DŽȀW:pXʱ=p1 � OFW0ǭɛɮW]0ɴʑ\ƼƑLpȂ
ó[>;V0� ÷˼WˀˊĄ@ÌBDŽȀ@Ų
˻WAp\?0fP0ŞǛJV;pǚȠ@Ǧ
ɍQXʱ=p\?ɵt0řɀ\ƯʊkřǪǬ
\ǂoˠo�³�ɵ?nʐŧLp1�
âßDŽȀ\ȃʫ�
� ʼnřƄíàʕřɧ\3Ȃ*4]˥ƃ˻
ˈɧɐW:p1�¢\»W3Ȃó43�w�
ƐAȎ;43ŅȂfP]�¬�{³�¨ Ĥ
WȎSPo«�¤\řʏt˥JP0Ȃtʨ
ȽLpPi\Ŀɟʴʉ 4\ T\�®�ª¤
t � ÷Ȑĩ �� ÷āƗMTĝˈLpƒƍ
WŲ˻JV;p1�
Ȃó\ˈʎ]0 Ç�¬³�tʈƯJV
ʨ \ȅ[ŞǛJP1DŽȀŲ˻Xôţ]ʨ
\˥oW:p1�
( 3)�W��!Ñ'�Ý30YÞ
��� =G>8G>�\�!�ºhÚ d*¶&Ý3YÞ ��� �aS±Ç ���!nºXrF[Ò®�,±
ÇÝ2YÞ �� Lº����DG13G:!hÚ,426G�
±Ç(3Y) �� =G>8G> �*��}��hÚ,ÄÈ���
)ĵÝ8YÞ ��� �aS±Ç ��*Ï* ÅT���!n
ºXr,±ÇÝ5YÞ ��� ��!DG13G:ĵ �Ã�ÄÈ,�y�
)½�Ý7YÞ � � �!<C2@> ³^Ý2YÞ
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 95
Ý �Þ��vÖ�Xr!LpÝ\� �� iYÞ�
Ēé ˈ ¼Zřʏôţ }«|°�³
�©° 1 }«|°�³�©°4
�®�ª¤Ģģ 2 Ï˼UBo0w°�³�0
Ȃó\řʏôţtɜʻ
ʼnˊʨ
3 Ãʇ\Ĥā0ˊʨ\ǣA
ǚXƨĩ 4 ˊʨ\ˀgǚ0ņČʵĠ
\ǣAǚXƨĩ Ĥ 5 ġķ\Ĥ0ņČʵĠ\
ÌAǚ ɲXÑɲ 6 ˊʨX�w�˷ɏ\Ôʌ
7 ņČʵĠ\Ì;PɲX
˷ɏ\Ôʌ 8 ɲXÑɲĤāXÝ 9 ɲXÑɲĤāXÝ 10 ɲXÑɲ²ÌȱɲX
ÌȱÑɲĤāXÝ 11 ÌȱɲXÌȱÑɲĤ
āXÝ 12 ÌȱɲXÌȱÑɲĤ
āXÝ fXi 13 āǪ\fXi ʸ 14 ʸ
15 ʸˠĖ>m`ɶ=ɑJ 2016 ƃƈX 2017 ƃƈW\DŽȀŲ˻\˫
; � 2016 ƃƈ\DŽȀŲ˻]0ʨ 5 \m<[ʥ
SP1 (Âå)2016z{!�W��!Ñ'�Ý30YÞ
(1)ÉÍ;ABÔxèq�çÀ]Ä£ÝRN�»Þ(2Y)2BG<Ä£(5Y)� (2)DG13G:Ôxç�y!ÊÚÄÈ(5Y)� (3)DG13G:q�çÀ]Ä£(RN�»)Ý5YÞ2BG<Ä£(10Y) Ý4Þ�!<C2@> ³^�+Ý2YÞ
� 2016 ƃƈŞǛJV\įȱ]0+ˀˊ�«
¬[ƬqpfW] 10 ÷ζ˒kJ0fP0
,¿ʏ@ƚƆJV;Z?SP\WʘĄʰȝW
AZ;ʑ@ňB0-28 ÷Wʁ=nqZ;FX
@ň?SP1fP0.ǂoˠo@öǴZ?S
P1Hn[0/25 ÷˼WY\ɩƈřʏWAp
\?s?nZ?SPPi0Ȗǡ˼ƳLJoȺƪ
W¯³��³�tØƯJV;P1ǡ[] 1 Ƕ
\¯³��³�W 3 �¢Ú<FXj:SP1 ¶ʵ\įȱt˘f=0Èƃƈ]0+ˀˊ
]�¬�{³�¨ƼƑ[ÐNpFXWˀˊ�
«¬]ƊȏJ0,āǡ[Ȍǡ\¯³��³�
t˯ÌJV¿ʏtƚƆJ0Hn[0-ʘŻʰ
ȝ\ǡ˼tʘŚřʏ[ɨʥJV 28 ÷˼Wʁ
=nqpm<ǐİJP1fP0.ǂoˠo\
Pi[3Ēéþ˪ʨ43DŽȀǂoˠoʨ4t˯
ÌJ0Ȗǡ˼\þ˪ɐȆtɜʻJV?nȣĉ
[îo0ʁ¾ǡ[] 2 Ƕñ[ʵîLpFXW
ǂoˠpm<[JP1 3Ēéþ˪ʨ4]0ĒéïÖ\řʏtʬ˥L
FX@ɐɌW0řʏþ˪ɐȆXđģřʏW\
ȣĉȺȟtʷÝWApɐtØSP1Hn[
Ȗǡ˼ƩKPFXt3£�£��§³�¬4
XJVǣBȊjØSP1ǭɫtǣBȔW]
fQ 4 IJJ?DŽȀtŞǛJV;Z;@03¥
°�³[5s?nZ;6Xʱ=P43�¬³�
WȂJBřcV;p43¿ʏtƞqpX¥°�
³[ˢƦ@??p43fQ¥°�³XƴRʰD
nqV;Z;43ȌIJ]jSXʹNpXm;X
ƩKP4ɵXʱSPʵˡ?n0đģřʏtƨ
ˉJPȣĉ@Ų˻WAV;pXʐ=p1 3DŽȀǂoˠoʨ4]�ª£��ļ\Ɂɾ
W0;TY\m<Zř`tJP\?tʵ˶L
p1ř`ïÖtʬ˥LFX@ɐɌW˯ÌJP
@0ȋſJPřɀ[XSVjǦĆW:p13×
tÏ˼?n��§³JVjn<\?@´ɐ
ɘȴ4X\FXW0ŐʷW:p1 � ɊʨƑǝ]0āǪ\ʸʄǷ0āǪ\ǂo
ˠo�³�ɵ?n030 ÷\đģřʏWˀˊĄ
@ÌBDŽȀ@Ų˻WAV;p?0fP0ŞǛ
JV;pǚȠ@ǦɍQXʱ=p\?0ƗǪ[
ĥDV\ǐİȱɵtʐŧJP;1
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 96
¤nTÕ!��$!`gnº!tT!Æ%�
�
�
7Ɋʨʑ8� ʼnŶ� ĪũŶřʼnřȠřˮ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
áß"�' �
Ǥ˟ěǚĥˈʎZY\ŹŊ@ðʨHqV;
pȜɂ0������¶Dz0����j\\0Ƞř
\ˆɧɐ\ňB\DŽȀ]0´ǚɌZˈʎƍ\
j\@ĹäɌ[ň;W:r<1F\m<ZDŽ
ȀƒƪW]0Ƒȴ\FXZ@n0řɀ\ȣĉ
Ƣ@Õ·LpFX[Zo0DŽȀ\ôţ\ŝɗ
ƈ@ÕBZp1Hn[0řɀ]Ƞř[T;V
ǢʵLq^ʜ;Xơ;˞g0ʐ=m<XJZ
;ƌšj:p1�
F\m<ZȱtǐİLpPi[0đģřʏ
tȠřWjūîWAZ;?0ʸgpFX[J
P1jSXj0F\m<ZëʥȀʊXJV»
ŷ���@:p1PQ0F\Ş˗W]Hf
IfZŹŊ@HqV;VȡɐLcAj\W]
:pj\\0ʾʰ@ZDq^0¼ʫZřʏô
ţ[T;V]ˈʎtHqV;pm<W:p1
ɦ]0FqfW´ǚɌ[ˈʎHqV;pÀǸ
[T;V0ğʖZo0řɀ@fMʐ=0ˈ
ʎHqp]M\ôţ[řɀ˪ʘ˚Wþ˪WA
Z;?0Xʐ=V0đģřʏtĜoîqVg
pFXXJP1 âß²®!�Ã�
đģřʏ[ĜoʂuQɧɐ]0Ƞřî˺X
;<ɧɐW:p1F\ɧɐ]0ȠřˮȠř
ɧ\g\řɧÿŪ˺ɧɐW:o0ƃȌ
\ƜâɧɐW:p1Ĥ\ǒĬ@÷ƼJVƼ
ƑJV>oF\Ë[Ĥõŵâ�ª�ĻƑ
ʑ@;p 0řɀ]ġǒĬ\�ª�[ăoƑV
nqp1ɦ\ƼƑJP�ª�\Çǔ]058 Ç
W:SP1ĻƑʑ\˼W]0Ƞřî˺\DŽȀ
\<Ră\ǡ˼[T;V]0ƜMƵ<FX
XHqPôţtƵ<j\XLpɄJĢsN@
HqV;p1 F\řˮW]0î˺ɧɐ]ǔňB:pj\
\03ř`\˛NJXɨʥ\ǏNj4W:púƃȌ
ǒʕ\ɧɐ@dXuYZ;ïřñ˥ɧɐX
JVF\m<ZɐɌ\ȯʏ@:pj\\0ř
ɀïĬ@ŵâLpsDW]Z;\W0ɦ\
DŽȀǚ˳XJV0Ƞřî˺WƼƑʑïĬ@ñ
˥JVƵ<cAôţ[ą=0úƃȌǒʕ\ʫ
ɿjƹo˞g0ʼnřW\ĈƏ\ÊǚtƵ<F
XXJP1 ãßVP���!Xr�
ȖIJ\DŽȀ\]Ki[āIJ\ƙʏtʥ<
[0 ��²����²�ª�\ƷȠtɁ
;V0řɀģńWƙʏtʥsNpm<[JP1 IJɐ\DŽȀ[>;V0}«|°�³
�©°>m`ʼnřW\ĈƏ\ÊǚtƵSP1
O\[]0ª³�°��ª£��tɠJ0
ˈʎQDW]řʏôţ@ŝɗJZ;FXtɠ
J0đģřʏ\ȣĉtLpĉȉÌDtJP1
řʏǒDZtˀuQ¶WĜoʂh¯³��³�
[>;V0ɴʑ\¼Ǝtʘ÷\ʱʡWfXi
pɐ\Ë[0ǒDZ\ôţX˽˧LpÀt
ǣBȊtʶDP1F\m<[JPȾɃ]0
LTD ʹJĢ;řʏȠ\ Step0˂\
ǕɱX\˽˧UD\ʫɿtîq0ªz°�
®�°@ȣɊ[Zpm<[WAZ;?Xʐ=
P?nW:p1DŽȀtŞǛJVgpX0ɜ?
[0LTD £³�x°�dY\ȣɊZkoXo
@:psDW]Z;J0fP0LTD \¿ʏ�
³�tØƯLpdY[]˽˧UDt¿iʐ=
V;pm<W]Z?SPǯ˼ŸʮtJV;
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 97
pX˽˧UD\XFrtɋɾ[JV;přɀ
j0ŭǔW]:pDqYj0ʬĝDnqP 1
J?JZ@n0DŽȀƗ\�¡°��³�W
]0Ë\Ç\ʹJPôţjǒDZX˽˧UDp
FX@WAəˉ@ƅ@p0ZYʔŝɌZƩƧ
@ň?SP1F\ʄǷXJV0đģřʏ[ʔ
ŝɌZƩƥ@˰ƯHqPm<W:p1 O\ƗȠřĿɟ˅\ôţtƵ<[]0W
Apo0fM ��²����²�ª�t
Ɂ;V0řɀ[ʐ=HNpm<ʸgP1O\
[]0ãÇơʐtHNpPi[0ȘUAt
ßL¯³��³�tØƯJ0řɀʘ˚Wřʏ
ôţ[ȘUDpm<[ŹŊtJP1Û=^0
ȠXOqÎŇ\¬³¬\˫;tƵ<[]0
?TV\Œ˥ʋùȠǞ 183 dzX¢�y[
mpɥǣɱ 2728 ɸ\ʵˡXtȗ˜J0
ʭƖ\Ũˍ\˫;[T;Vơ;@;Bm<ʸ
gVgP1ÐƨʭŝXƏʥʭŝ\ĎütƵ<
[]0Ðƨʭŝ@Ŏɼ\ŝi[èëLpX
ʐ=VJf<X˫ĪƩtƩKpm<ZÀǽt
¯³��³�\»[Ɏo˞uQ1¯³��³
�tØƯLp[]0ğʖZo0DŽȀ\Ɯ
nj˓ǘ[ʵˡ@ZB0fPy°�³���W
˃c[B;m<[JV0ʘ÷Wʐ=IptƘ
Z;m<ŹŊJP1Z>0¯³��³�\ʵ
î[T;V]0ÛŇ]:pj\\0ĿǭɌ[
]DŽȀŇW\Ť[JP1 DŽȀƗ\�¡°��³�?n]0Ƞř[
ŨLpʙĩ@?AɰVnqP0ʵƭ[ȓok
L;ZYʔŝɌZƩƧ@ňBťNnqP1f
P0;AZoˈʎtLpmoj0DŽȀ\ôţ
[ɽƘJkLBjZSPm<W:p1Hn[
;PFX[0ȠXOqÎŇ\¬³¬\˫;
XJV0¯³��³�?n]ʼūWAZ;X
¿ƧJV;PƏÿ\Ǧȳ[Ș@T;V;P
řɀ@0×Çj;P1 äߢ��!U�!wm�
� DŽȀƗ\�¡°��³�tˀuW;pX0
řɀ@HfIfZȘUAtJV>o0�ª�
ôWñǦJP;Xʐ=P1OFW0đģřʏ
X]ɑLj˽Þ@Z;DqYj0ȖIJ\DŽȀƗ
[0DŽȀ˥átØo0�¡°��³�[ǣ
?qV;PôţXɦ\�¥°�tTDV0���
DŽȀǏNj���¤ [ƸɫLpm<[JP1�
Z>0DŽȀ˥á[Xo:EZ?SP�¡
°��³�[T;Vj0�¥°�tÌJVlj
öʑïĬ[ˠĖLpm<[JV;p1�
�
åßO~!ÊÚ�
jSXj0ÈƗǐİLcA˂]ň;1Û
=^0đģřʏ\ĿǭXZpđģ\ɺɤ[T
;V0ď÷Ó=pȉÒtǀVZ?SP1�«
³ªy�t˿CŹŊ[T;Vj0ȣĉ[îp
ā[0ȣĉƗ[ˁ?t:VVɊʱtȚipF
Xt¿ĨJP\gW:o0Ë\ƳȔjˈKp
FXjƜʫW:r<1�¬³�XJV\ˑÐ
tǠɜ[LpFX[T;Vj0Ș@T;Pn0
ȣĉ[îpā[0ˁ@:PSVjģKm<[
ʿǠWApm<[Lpm<ǁɠJV;pj\
\0�¬³�\ˑÐ@ď÷Ǡɜ[ZSV;p
?ɉį@ȓp1Hn[]0ȽǡȱW]�¬³
�ôW\ǐİƳʆ@dXuYʥ=V;Z;ȱ
j0įW:pXʐ=V;p1 ʷÝǚȠX\˽Þ[T;Vj0ïƼƑʑ[
moñ˥įtØƯLpFXXZSV>o0
˩Ęƃ\Û?n]0ɭĽiƍ\į@ň;1
F\Pi0řɀ@ʄŰǢʵtLq^ʜ;Xʐ
=pĔ@;ȱj0˂W:p1 �
|«�¨�
ȜɂɖǨ2016 3ǙºÍȠřˮǒʕ\Ş˗ ɳ 2IJʼnǒşěǚĥDŽȀ405ǣǗ\ɯ60644020-25 »ŷŗē2014 5Ƞřˮ]ʣp� ¶6ȽÍ
ÇǕɢ ¶Dz´Ā2016 3Ƞřˮǒʕ[>Dpěǚ
ĥļDŽȀ\:oǚ[T;V405½ɈɹʼnřȠ
ř607401-37
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 98
Øz�!§�,¥���Zz��¿!Æ%�
�½��� (+�n#�� !-19.E.9.�
�
7Ɋʨʑ8� ĶʼnȇǮƁřʼnř�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
áßÊÚ��¤�
3ʼnř\ʼnʤČ4@ʱsqV½J;1ňB
\ʼnřW]0řĄ˭ƺ@ď÷[ȉʖNM0
ǺfW[˚[ÌDpcAřĄtǟǪ[Y<ʪ
êLp?@˱ʫZ˂XZoúƃȌǒʕ@Ƿ
PLƔă\˱ʫƢ]ʱtfPZ;1fP0ú
ƃȌǒʕW]3ʼnřW\ř`4 �«�x~
¬²�°�°�ZY[ƟLpFXj˱ʫ
Z£��©°[ZSV;p1�
fP0ǒĬƯ0àʕʑƯZYʼnřWŪ
˺ʓƯtƼ<˂ɩ\Ńą]0Ū˺ʓ\˓˕
k�§«w�³�[Y\m<[ť¹Lp?X
;<ȱW0��³� ¬�³Pp3Ȁɇ4b
\�¡°��«�xtˎ<1�
´ǚWɢÒÇîřtAňB\řɀ]3
ƃǪ4\ȔWîřLp1ǝǭ[>;Vʼnʤ
ČHqPʼnřǒʕtʐ=pFX]0ƃǪ0
ȹ[F\˼Ń=PřɀŴW:p3�°|«³
�4Ŵ\Şƪ[ĕJ0Ǥʼn\��³� ¬�
³Pp3�°|«³�řɀ4\ɢÒęɆ[ť
¹Lpǒʕtʐ=pX;<ɊƧ\˛NJ@Ɯʫ
W]Z;?XɊʨʑ]ʐ=p1F\Ŵ]˟ƃ0
´ːJVɢÒɌʘɰĵȹ[0řǺ?nɢ
Òb[HnHqVAPŴW:p1fP0F
\ǡǪ[T;V3ɨʥǪ4X;<ʱʿ@¼Ȥ
[ZoTT:p@0ňB\ɢÒÇřɀ@×n
?\�§«w˛NJtƨĶJVîřJV;pF
Xt˘f=pXǒʕ˂t3ƃǪ4řɀX
ñ˥JV;pXjʱ=p1�
ȽÍ\ʝʑ\ʘɰĵ[T;V]LW[0
ɨʥ˩ɩ\ãÇČ0˹ǪČ0ÁȁČ0Hn[
]ĺľǼź0ƢźZY[mpǙPZ3ŴƢ4
@Ǡn?[Hq0ɢÒɌ˽Þ˓Ȭ�!�����
��"�%�� \ʯȱjħiPċƿɌZʝʑʘɰǏ
Nj\ƜʫƢ@lj˖HqV;pŠǭ²Ŭǰ
���� 1fP3ɢÒɌDž4ìǧ\ʯȱ?n0
ɢÒɌʘɰ[ˬøZɢÒɌ˓ȬtȼƘZ;
J]àJ<pǒʕ\ƜʫƢ[T;Vjlj
ʱHqVAP Ƃł ����0ȫȥ ���� 1fP0
ʝʑ\ʘư\ňéƢ˝ ����0µȦ ����Ě
`ʰƢŶ ����@ǁǎHqV;p1
ˮ2011 3_Xo\űŁƲ4]ʨɌZŘ
ɰȺƪZY[ƦsHqZ;3ɢÒɌċǍ4t
ƝĥLcAXljĮJV;p1 Fqn\˂tʼnřǒʕ[ȣɁLpPi[0
Ȯ¶2004]ʘ÷\3×?koP;4ȍȚ
@×?\Ł[ƀųLpɐɌXZp3y°�y
�²wz�4w�®³�[mSV0űŁƲb
\˽sotȨiV;B»W0ʘ÷\koP;
FXtʬ˥Npm<[ZpXǁǎJV;p1 � Fqn?n0ʼnřǒʕW]ʘŻXɢÒX\
??sotʸʥ˵ʾLp3ƃǪ4\ř`t
Ş˗Ɍ[Y<àLp?@:nlpřɀ[ñ
˥JP˂[Zp1ãü\ǒʕŞ˗0ȹ[ˈ
ʎ²ȯʏZY0[>;V]0řɀ@ãü0ñ
ģřɀ˼0řŇW¼ÖɌ[ʸʥ˵ʾLp
ř`@ŞȽWAp1úƃȌǒʕ[>;V]0
řɀ´Ç_Xo@0ʘ÷\3×?koP;4
ȍȚtòÖČJVBqpŁ@ʼnřW:pXʻ
i0;;ƨĩW3ÜŖ4 ˽sotȨipL
pǚĥƢtʘŻȝŝWAp?@~�XZp1
Oq]0ãü\ǒʕŞ˗@03śƛƩ43ʘŻ
ǦɁƩ4tħuQ3 ɬȁƢtjSP űŁƲ4
UBo[ZpƜʫ@:pFXtɠL1 � ǭɊʨW]0ζ\m<ZʮȱtƃǪ\
ȹƢtȣ?JPúƃȌǒʕ\ʸg[T;V0
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 99
ʘ˚@ʥSV;pw��x±x�xt3ʒA
:;4X3ř`:;4X;<ʯȱ?nO\ƨ
ʎ[T;V˅Kp1 âß�Ä!��n#��!¥�_�½�
�� !k,��+�
ÝáÞe<C2@>!�Á�
²řɀɒÂʷÝ\ūî Ƒú]3Ŀɟ�£�³¬4[>;V03¼Ö
Ɍř`ǚ4X3ñģ\ř`:;4\ŞƩtj
SVÖƩWApFXtɐǁJVūî1wy�
�³�0ñģW\įʰȝȣĉ\Ɨ0ġʘ
@ʙĩ\:pʹ[T;V\��°�³�
©°[ŨJ0Ë\řɀ\ʷÝt�x³���
�Jʘ÷\ř`[T;VǂoˠSVjnSP1
3���}��«Øī43>hT\ķȗ˜4
3˲ʠŔ;tY<Z>L?4ZYġʘ\ơ;
îq\FjSP�³¢tdžo·EPɊʨ[Ë
\řɀjȶƛ[ʒAîpm<[Zo0�£ƒ
ƍWřaFX\ȂJHkǚȠ[ŨJʙĩtǀ
SVÖƘLpFX@WAP1 ²ǒžXàˌʑX\˽ÞUBo¯³��©�
�\řɀĥD�®�ª¤\˻Ɋ Ŭ˲ɂȐýʼn˾ʼnř@ȽʓĥD[˻Ɋ
JPǒžXàˌʑX\˽ÞUBo¯³��©
��t0řɀĥD\�®�ª¤[ʂgɑJV
ŞǛJP1ǒĬĚ`àʕńƯ˂ɩ\�ª�
[>;V090 ÷(�¢tĿǭ[0ȅ2Zà
ˌʑ\�³¤[Y<ŨƟLp?0®³¬�
yƒƍWǒĬç0àˌʑçtȯKpFX[
mo0àˌʑ\ơ;tȾʰJTTˬøZŨƟ
tmoòÖɌ[y¥³�WAp¯³��©�
�tŞǛJP1�ª�[mSV]ɥɣǛʶŮ
ʓżǩʑj>o0O\ŁĢ]ýɁʑ\ŢǜX
\˽ÞUBo[jȭɁWApm<ŹŊJP1 ²ʒA:;\ȉÒ\ƾê
ƨʬÅȤkˋ˅\ǡ˼W]řɀ[3Ɋʱt
Țip4@:fo0řɀ@3ʱsHqP4ơ
;QDȓo깪Ʃ@ʢBZpĔƢ@:p1
OFW0ġřɀ[ʘ÷\ǡ˼t¹=p:n
?KiʹLFXtfXip 3ɬȁɌ[ʒB4
œĊt˚[TDp3ʒAǣA¥¦4tʹJ
Ƴ[ˠĖJřʏ\fXi[ȣɁ0ZY\ŹŊ
tƲ[Ĝoîq3ʒA:;4¯³��©�
�XJVŲ˻JP1O\ʄǷ0ÅȤ²ˋ˅\
gZnM0F\¯³��©��tūîJPĒ
é\fXi@˙Ɍ[êŞJ0řɀ\ǣBĄ
\ĥ¶[jť¹JP1 ãß57G:/A0?@>���!��¾T
Õ !Æ%�
Fqn\ƯǷtʼnř[>Dp3��³�~
«�¨ª¤4XJV � ƃȌāǪ\ǒʓ˂ɩƜ
âɧɐ3ǒʓî˺4[VɻʅČtʸgP1ʺ
ʀĚ`ƯǷ[T;V]ƑǝŀĨLp1 ǕȻ ˮɖʼn2011 5űŁƲ\ɢÒř6ǝǭʃ
ȩǙʒɢ Ȯ¶ƫ´2004 3ȽÍʼnřɀ\ɀAǚX�
§°��²ªy�45ȽÍʼnřɀ˅6ǝǭǑˣ
öȷđÒ ˴ǫˇÉ2005 35ĸŇ6tˤqV45~³
�±v¬ČLpɢÒ6ˈ˄ɢ Ƃłɕȇ2005 3ɨʥ���¤÷ʰ˩ɩ[
>DpʖĄʯ\˛NJXɢÒ˽Þ˓ǭ45ǒʕř
ɛɮ6734 µȦŲ2005 3ȧ˒\ȸʽ\ıŋX0Hf
m<5ʘ÷nJH64¶˲Đŕʈ5ʗwy�
x°�x�x6ćʟǣƱ ŠǭgRŕ²Ŭǰɡŕ2011 5ÁȁČLp
ʝʑXʘɰǏNj6ǠɚǣƇ Ŷ«~2002 5ň˱ČLp«w¬6RB
fǕƉ ˝ʼnÉ1999 3ʝʑ\�£¨��³�©°
ņţXǙJ;¥�xw40ȈéʜǠ²ʛȢʧʈ
5ŕYj²ŭƃX�£¨��³�©°6č
ȇöȷ
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 100
`gÇÌ!�Ð��!¬Ò� � �
`gÇÌu{!Ö¬,K� �
�
7Ɋʨʑ8� ŃÄ�ȞŌțȵǭɔɺɤàæɥɣ�°�³ ²śș�Ƥ�½Ɉɹʼnř�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
áßhÚ�®�
đģřʏX]3đģJVř`Ģ<FXW
řaôţ\Ⱦʰ²ʏƘtɐǁLXXj[đ
ģ\ƨʎ[ȘUAđģ\ƷʖtɞAđģ
\Ýåtřa�ôČLp�FX@ƨĶHqpǒ
ʕȣĉ4W:p�˽ɂ²śș������1F\ŝʎ
?nđģřʏ[>;Vđģʻˉ\ʕƯ@¼
ZǒʕɐɌXZpXģǡ[đģřʏ\˱ʫ
ZĿɏXZpFX@ˀgĜqp1�
F\đģʻˉtǃ=pɐɌW˹ Ȱn ����
] ijŕđģĆɁ²ãÇƝĥ²ÂƣƮƠ
�� ɐ?nZpđģØȀʻˉůƈt˻ɊJ
V>oǒʕǁȆXJV´ŝ\ƋüĄtǀT
FX@ʻinqV;p ˹Ȱn ���� Ǿn
���� 1J?JZ@n đģ[ŨLpʔŝɌZ
ʻˉW:p3đģĆɁ4ijŕ\Ƙȱ@ïʚɌ
[Bđģʻˉ\ƋüĄ@ď÷W:pX]
ʱ;;1fPđģʻˉ\»ǻW:pɖĂ
[ř`Ģ<X;<ƛȄ=XòÖɌZʥȲL
ZsR3øɝȿɞ4XʨȽWApçtď÷
[ȪŝWAV;Z;Xʐ=p1�
OFWǭɛɮW]˹Ȱn\3đģØȀʻ
ˉůƈ4tƳ@?o[đģřʏ\Ŀǭʫɿ
�!� $! ��%����������+ʔŝɌɒÂÜŖ�
,ß˨ɌɒÂÅȤ�-ãÇ\ÁT\ˑÐ [Ü
ƽJP3đģʻˉůƈ4t˻ɊLpFXtɐ
ɌXJP1ɛɮ � W]đģʻˉůƈėǽ
tØƯLp1ɛɮ � W]đģØȀʻˉůƈ
XėǽX\˽ÞtǿʳJůƈ\áƢXő
ƑƢtɜʻJVđģʻˉůƈŜƯȷtØƯ
Lp1OJVɛɮ W]»ɀ\đģʻˉ
tǿʳJ»řɀ?nʼnřɀfW\đģʻˉ
\ņČ˩ɩ[T;VǿʳLp1�
âß`gÇÌu{�b��!Q�Ý°´ �Þ�
�¤�Ũˍʑ� ʼnřɀ � Ĥ �˃ǹǡ
Ǫ� ���� ƃ ǥ ˕įɾȄƯ� đģřʏ
\Ŀǭʫɿ?nū;P �� ɐXđģØȀʻ
ˉůƈ �� ɐʲ � ɐ1�
¸�� ��������� � �� ���
� �ijŕ÷ǵ\ʄǷ� ijŕ � ɐÏ˼
˱ʮ²ʘŻˏȻ ?nZpđģʻˉůƈ ėǽ
tȄƯJP1đģØȀʻˉůƈX\ɒ˽÷ǵ
\ʄǷ3đģĆɁ4X;ɒ˽@ɠHqP Ï
˼˱ʮ������ �ʘŻˏȻ������� 1F\ʄǷ
?nƻöHqP � ijŕ]đģØȀʻˉůƈ
\3đģĆɁ4XdeģKçtȪŝJV;
pFX@ɜʻHqP1�
ãß`gÇÌu{�o�¦�!Q�Ý°´ �Þ�
�¤����Ũˍʑ� +ʼnř²ɓˌřɀ ��� Ĥ
ijŕȄ˦\ɜŝ� ,ʼnřɀ²ɓˌřɀ
�� ĤÙŖɌőƑƢ\ɜʻ�-ʼnřɀ ��
ĤÉîɌőƑƢ\ɜʻ 1�
���˃ǹǡǪ� ���� ƃ �� ǥ���� ƃ ǥ�
��˕įɾȄƯ� đģʻˉůƈėǽ đģØ
Ȁʻˉůƈ��x�~��©°��¬ůƈ�ś
șn�������řǺˬƟƩůƈ�öĞn�������
ƶûɌơʐƪƈůƈƂŶn��� 1�
¸�F»s� đģØȀʻˉůƈ\ ijŕXė
ǽ\ � ijŕtħiVijŕ÷ǵtʥSPʄǷ
3Ï˼˱ʮ²ʘŻˏȻ²ãÇƝĥ²ÂƣƮƠ4
ijŕ �� ɐ@ƻöHqɜʻɌijŕ÷ǵ\
ʄǷ?n´ŝ\ˬĢƈ@ʻinqP1fP
ÙŖɌőƑƢtɜʻLpPiđģʻˉXŦ
LjZ˽Þ@ʐ=nqpƛȾɌçtȪŝLp
¶ʵ\ůƈ�Ģʲ��ijŕ�X\IJƀ÷ǵtʥ
SP1O\ʄǷǪƕHqpǚĥ\ɒ˽Þǔ
A4� đģřʏ²�¬³�¯³�*
― ― 101
>m`)å@ɠHqP1Hn[ǒʕɌÉîő
ƑƢtǿʳJPʄǷđģřʏ\Ş˗[mS
Vĝˈʑ\đģʻˉ]moʔŝɌZǚĥbX
ņČLpFX@´ˮʻinqP1Fqn\ʄ
Ƿmo ijŕ �� ɐtjSV3đģʻˉů
ƈŜƯȷ 4XJP�ʨ ��1ǭůƈW]ø
ɝȿɞXʨȽHqpđģʻˉ\ç3ʘŻˏ
Ȼ4ijŕ@ǃ=nqpğʖƢ@ɠHqP1�
äßKܪ�(#lnª!¡ÎÝ°´ �Þ�
�¤���Ũˍʑ�»ř�� Ĥ�Ǻ����Ĥ1�
���˃ǹǡǪ�����ƃǥ »ř�ǥ Ǻ 1�
��˕įɾȄƯ� đģʻˉůƈ ėǽ �đģØ
Ȁʻˉůƈ��x�~��©°��¬ůƈ�ř
ǺˬƟƩůƈ1�
¸�F»s� ɛɮ W]ňȕĴģǡ÷ǵ
[mpɜʻɌijŕ÷ǵ[moŜƯȷ\ijŕ
Ȅ˦@»ɀ\�³�[jģȅ[:V]f
p?Y<?tɜʻJP1O\ʄǷ˯ʌ¸ņ
¦�¬\ˬĢǁȆ\ʄǷ?n»YRnj
ʼnřɀXģKijŕȄ˦WƑV]fo@ʜ;F
X@ɜʻHqP1fPʼnřɀXģȅđģ
ʻˉ@ʔŝɌZʑdYřǺˬƟX�x�~�
�©°��¬@Xj[;FX@ɠHqP1�
� OFWʼnřɀ\�³�ją=V ijŕ
\Ɋ˪ɌņČtǿʳLpPi ijŕ\Ƙȱt
řƃ²ƢüGX[ɷöJP1O\ʼnřɀ
\ƃt ��9�� ȑ��9� ȑ�9�� ȑ
� ȑÎ\ T[ʍ÷DJ ijŕGX[řƃ
XƢü\ � ʫij÷Ǔ÷ǵtʥSP1O\ʄǷ
LcV\ijŕWřƃ[mp¼ĆǷ@ʻinq
P1ň˱ȗ˜\ʄǷ 3Ï˼˱ʮ4] � ȑÎ
@ »ɀX ��� ȑmoǦƨ[;FX
3ãÇƝĥ4] ��� ȑ@Ëʍ[ȗcVǦƨ
[;FX 3ÂƣƮƠ4]»ř ƃɀX
Ǻ � ƃɀ@Ëʍ[ȗcǦƨ[;FX@ɠ
HqP1ȹ[3Ï˼˱ʮ4] � ȑζtB
XY\řǺɪj � ƃɀ@ǤjB� ƃɀ@
ǤjÕ?SP1fP 3Ï˼˱ʮ²ÂƣƮƠ4
W]Ƣ\¼ĆǷ@ɜʻHq 3Ï˼˱ʮ4]ŏ
Ƣ@Ǧƨ[B 3ÂƣƮƠ4]ɅƢ@Ǧƨ[
?SP1J?J;Mq\ijŕjƢü(ƃ
\ÅÂØɁ]ɜʻHqZ?SP1�
æß¹f»s�
� ǭɛɮ[mo đģʻˉ\ʔŝɌçt3Ï
˼˱ʮ4X3ʘŻˏȻ4\ � ç?nfP
ĦŝɌçt3ãÇƝĥ4X3ÂƣƮƠ4?
nǃ=pđģʻˉůƈt˻ɊLpFX@WA
P1ǭůƈ[mođģʻˉ[T;V\Ƌü
Ą@ĥ¶JPX;=p1»Wj 3ʘŻˏȻ4
]đģřʏ@Țip3øɝȿɞ4XjʨȽH
qpđģʻˉtǃ=nqpğʖƢ@ɠĭHq
P1fP�Ɋ˪ɌZǿʳ[mo 3Ï˼˱ʮ4
]ƃkƢü[ƓtĝDkLB�´ǚW3ʘ
ŻˏȻ4]O\ƓtĝD[B;FX@ɠH
qP1ÈƗ\˂XJVǭůƈWȪŝHq
PʻˉXòÖɌZʥȲX\˽ÞtǿʳLp1�
eMI� eM�$ ul um un uo vm � ��
第1因子「仲間重視」(�=4.29,��=0.57) α=.87n ©±³����¶Y�§7}��¥¤�d�{¤�����§.�¤x .73 ijkl jls ijls jqk ojnr kjsk
ln ©±³��@�¶�d�{��¥¤�¢f)¥¤x .69 jkp ijlm jkq jpp ojlo kjto
lq ©±³@�~{�¶�d�¢7}¢¥�{¤�{|-`�#��z¤x .68 jko jks ijkt jpo ojnl kjsn
mm ���¨�����w�¨���T� ¥��>¤D��¤x .68 ijlk ijkq ijkm jon ojmo kjsp
lo ©±³�@�¤���¶���{0§�d������¶�����¤¡|���{x .65 jkm ijko ijkp jot ojml kjtl
ls ©±³�9�{�d�����¶���d�R ����^���¤���#��z¤x .62 ijkl jkt ijlm jon ojot kjrl
lk X��h��{������S�¥�Z{/?§��¤x .56 ijkt ijlq jls jms ojks kjtp
t �¨��[y�-]§���|���<L�z¤x .54 jkn jkm ijkr jnp ojpn kjsk
ll ©±³F��¢�w����-]§W������¤��Y��N`�!}¤x .49 jlk ijkq ijko jnq ojol kjsl
r ���«³®¯³¬���g��=�x .45 jkr jks jks jmk ojlr kjss
第2因子「自己貢献」(�=3.68,��=0.64) α=.70lp ©±³��d�¢�|,¦¥�{¤�D�������{¡£�¶QAK�������¡|�,|x ijkp .69 jkm ijkt jos njqr kjtq
ml ©±³��d�;���¨��¤���¶Y�§O�Z{«°²ª��¤x ijko .66 ijkt jkl jop njqs kjtt
lt �d�%��Y��C�{�,|-]�¶�£�J����b5*��)�¤���#��z¤x jko .46 ijlk ijkr jnk njqn kjtq
l ����6§E�¤;¶"&�a6�z���©±³����¢¶��¨�'����{x ijkq .45 jlr jkm jlr njor kjtl
m ©±³����Y���´2X 3Xµ§|��B�{x jlp .44 ijkt ijkm jno njtq kjto
第3因子「個人志向」(�=3.19,��=0.68) α=.60q �£�Dc{���¢ ¤¡£G£� ¤:�w £H8�z¤x ijlt ijkm .49 ijkl jnp mjtn ljkk
mk �¨���T�@�¤�wY��,|¡|����{x ijkn ijlo .47 jkp jnl mjrm ljkn
lm �¨��_����{¤�;d���¤x jlo ijkq .46 jkm jmk njos ljkk
p ©±³� ¤�+�14�§�¤��{¤x jlm ijkl .46 jlp jmn njqn kjts
第4因子「互恵懸念」(�=2.02,��=0.75) α=.64s ({���U´�µ¥����|�w*{V����+\��{x ijko jkn jlt .60 joq ljto kjtr
lr P�����¦�¦����¤+\��{x ijkr ijkq jmk .53 jop mjkm kjtn
o �������>�{�������z¤x jll ijks jkq .49 jmo mjll ljkn
ul um un uo
um jpm i i i
un ijms ijmp i i
uo ijok ijnk jno i
ʨ 1đģʻˉůƈŜƯȷ\ijŕ÷ǵʄǷXijŕ˼ɒ˽
A5� ƚȌȾǬº������µ�1
― ― 102
t¯¦À�3*73?CLTJEXKWG^�
2�#;FY^Q[^E0?AMQJM�
�ÓÑÒ[^EGVJQ]L@R^M]OPXBNMY��
�
@ǴȾȨA� ŗǠǗȶʣŌŽÿȅįĸƕʜƕȬ�¹�»Èʈȅĸȅǐĸêʀʤ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ÊÉ4&72�
ÿdzȓȞĐįĸbCzưĸfGDaÈʈȅ
ĸȅi9ìœǃhòĂfŁʆȪɲƑƕȬh¼
ǮcTa9įĸbhĸlfŨɂeŵŖºſȽ
hĦưcez9ğƪʝhíǰǐ9ɘɔƚºɡ
ƛɕɅƝǐºɡƛƘǭǐcD^[´�»�º
��µ9¨¶�¹�»�²¹hƝǐvɘǭǵ
eƚȌv¶ª»�hƪJƝcD^[���¨
��º��µ~ɨf_NRXzccuf9�
¬± �»�²¹Ȯô9ȩLô9ɐVô~ē
½RX9ÌÈchŲɃÇƍ~ȉƽǵfȼFz
wEfRX9ŁʆǵeĸÜfēNahĦȁô
~ʜEPc~Ǹǁf �� œŖHx���¬
��´�³�»ʣ;9��´�ʤ~ļƞT
aJ[:�
�� œŖ��� ��� œŖ����
/� ���¹����
0���� �� 0���� ��
0ğƪʝ��� 0ğƪʝ���
/� 0��©»����
/� 0!��������
/� 0�¹�¹������
³���¹����� ³���¹����
ȧFzſȽ���� ȧFzſȽ���
ɘǭǵūȧ��� ɘǭǵūȧ���
Ȁɒ������� /�
¦�·»��¨���� /�
ƗĶiĜƗ90iǜȦ�
� �� œŖHxiĚʛĦǷģĸȦʣ���ʤ~
ļƞVz<ĮȪȇɲƑäʆ=cțĐR{9���
œŖiå � Ĝ � ƥʈļƞVz:�
� ��´�f_Dai9NJœèĽ~ɃǹT9
ļƞèĽfĬƩ~öFaDz:ÉœŖi9å
ÑĜƗIʧĜñǘR{[PcuCzI9Đɇ
b �� ĜcåÑhȔĂƗ~ątaD[9əȥI
ÂÑh³���¹�ºȧFzſȽhèĽ~Ƀ
ǹT � ĜcT9Ɯ[f !���� c�¹�¹��
¸»�9Rxf ��� œŖqbļƞTaD[�
�©»�~ťǒRX[:�
P{qbfu9<ğƪʝǒǰȽ=həȥºǜ
Ȧ~ğƪʝIƂŝTaD[PcHx9��� œ
ŖHxhʧœʈi9įĸ~IJtcT[ƕȬǂ
ʉvƪŕedbŔq^aDz<ƪɎ~ĴÊc
T[�¬± �»�²¹hĨ`LyhŽǐ=
bCz¤§´�¢�µ~9ğƪʝǒǰȽhə
ȥƂŝTaDzğƪʝȪĘchăábļƞT
aD[I9ÉœŖiƤœŖfŚJȝJ9ìœ
ǃ�¬�»µcŢƮʇəhɻƁŨÜȅǸ<ÿ
dzcǐš=ʣ� Ēʤ9<£»��´��ŧǭĸ=
ʣ��� Ēʤ9<ÿdzcǤɓ=ʣ � Ēʤ9<ÈʈʉØ
ɘ=ʣ ĒʤhɇʩȅǸʣɇ �� Ēʤbļƞ
Vz: ËÉÓÑÒ[^EGVJQ�
ưœŖHxǼɜĸɽIö}yƜ[fʩĸɽ
Ñïfe^[ưĸbi9P{qbfułƴh
ĮȪȇɲƑ~ɃƈFåʦœǯ~ď�µ»¨ �
B� ĒfêN<ÛʚR{zÿdzci=~®�
¹�»«fNJœ�§�»«~ĬF9ʱʰǐc
ʧǃãňʇ~ǒǰT�µ»¨Qcfª��»
ǴȾ~ȼ^aJ[:ưœŖh�§�»«iǸ
ƅVoJ�»ÿdzhļǬfēNabCz:�
A5� ƚȌȾǬº������µ�1
― ― 103
ÌÉL@R^M�
ʳʭʲ¸»��²�¨h�µ»¨~ � �³
�fêN9�³�èb;hşřb��©»
�~ļƞVz:�
� 3ȫĻßȋɘʣʨêʤ�
� 4ĔĻßȋɘʣʨêʤ�
� 5ȫĻßɣDzʣʧêʤ�
� 6ĔĻßɣDzʣʧêʤ�
� 7ĔĻßƫȗŘɘʣʧêʤ�
� 8ȫĻßƫȗŘɘʣʧêʤ�
� ��¤»�bi�»«iNJœĬƩTaGy9
Éqbf>HHy_NȺņ?~ïŖüVoJ
bCz9ÿdz¬�hħĕ~ȥúüVoJbC
z9įĸƙġèiåʗȄǢfVoJbCz9
ed~ċy½OaJ[:�
�
ÍÉOPXBNMY�
ưĸbi ��� œŖwy��´�edhì
œǃƕȬbȉƽǵfċyä{aJ[I9Ƥœ
ŖHxiìœǃ�¬�»µcŢƮhɻƁŨÜ
ȅǸbļƞTaDz:�
ìœǃ�¬�»µiÿĸɽʍĻbCz[t9
ĮȪȇɲƑciexeDuhh9�� ĒòŢh
�µ»¨bȼ^aDzPcHx9Ìh�µ»
¨ĸȦcđǀhùƷICz:�
ɻƁŨÜȅǸbi9ȅǸQchÄɻįÎc
ʩȅǸĐđhǍûįÎ~ļƞTaDz:ĸǯ
iȅǸɻƁƥf¤§´�¢�µIļƞR{z
Pc~ǭɅT[½bŊÜTaDzPcHx9
H_aåĸǯ~ĿɞfļƞTaD[ƥfC^
[9<ưİJIȉƽǵfȼEoJƪɎĐź~9
ɕƪȱÑfȲĖheDĸǯfŜïǵfvxX
zŲĖICzhH=cDEŸŪižƃR{[:�
Rxf9ļƞƥƮIŢƮfe^[Pcb9
Y{qbfșʟT[���¨��IǒHR{
aDzPc9ɻƁȅǸQcfưhèĽ~ȅǸ
cʉɲCzʙǸfȢy~HN[Pcb9ţƴ
ciɹ^[àēIǬ{[Pced9Ɯ[eƕ
ȬùƷIǬ{[:�
� THT9ĸǯhɕƪʓ{~ĆŰTaIJt[
¤§´�¢�µbCzPcHx9uE¼Ŗ�
��¬��´�³�»båĘfťǒRXzP
c~ƻɈTaDz:�
�
ÎÉ)3a�
ÉœŖHx��´�fƜ[e�µ»¨¸»
�cTaŃäR{[9ʁ �ʳʮʯc�¹�¹�
�¸»�f_DauÔXaǴȾVz:�
�
ÏÉ`~3½Å�
Phʧœʈ9³���¹�cȧFzſȽ~
ɿɄT[èĽb��´�~ļƞTaJ[I9
PhȅǸhưƴhǸǵbCzǜȦʣ����
§³» ¹�ʤ~ɿɄT[şřfÜdžVzŨ
ɂICz:ÉœŖh��´�hļƞǦǏ~ɧ
qF[½b9ƝēŬ~ǴȾT[D:�
�
ĈȧƚǨ�
��Ƶưɷś>ğɅ��©»�äʆ?Áșéǣ
������
�¤§´�¢�µƦĉijĘÎ>¤§´�¢�
µäʆ?¼ȳȃĝǐÈůħȅĸſȽăÎ
�����
�ŗǠǗȶºȻǞȤȈºʊŋŮĵºȵɠǽǭ
ĵºǙɫƖĵºāȷĦśºʂƯƨʞºǺǞƚ
ŭºŒƶʞȣ<¤§´�¢�µʬ���¬�
�º´�³�»fGNzğƪʝȪĘchăá
/��� œǣ/=>ŌŽÿȅįĸƕʜƕȬǿȊ
œħ?��9������������
4)ŌŽÿȅįĸƕʜƕȬ�¹�»Èʈȅĸ
ȅºŌŽÿȅįĸʋʼnğƪʝȠ>IMU STUDY
NAVIGATION?(2017)
A5� ƚȌȾǬº������µ�1
― ― 104
���������>c�%*����������fvk½Å3o:¨6�
�
�
� @ǴȾȨA� ŋư� ȿĵʣųǾǔŦįĸʤ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ÊÉ4&72�
� äĸɏʟhĮǀü9ƠƮüfwy9äĸq
bfɖʛ~ļƞVzįĸIīFaDz:TH
T9ǸǵfĐ}X[ɖʛ~ÓŹ9ļƞ9ƅŃ
Vzhi9ƕĘfc^aįJeɟƂcez:
q[äĸȨhŇÏġIįĸhɬʒciʍxe
DPcuĮD:Yh[t9PET[ɖʛ~
e-learning bȼEǂʉuīFaDzʣʅɝ
ŎºńƵŎ 2011 Ìʤ:e-learning ~ǰDzP
cb9ɖʛ~ĜĊT[y9ƊǡT[ycDE
ŽʈIɩǘbJzPciįJe®´��bC
z:ĭɽǂʉfijɉTeDĨĐ9���~
ȱòbƿȒ9ɵǰVzPcfezI9ĮLh
ƕĘiȱêb���~ƿȒ9ɵǰVzwE
eŁʆǵǾɚiƄ]Đ}XaDeD[t9®
´��~}H^aDauļǬbJeDPcu
ĮD:PET[ǦǏ~ȭƧfÁɽįĸÈƚĸ
ɽƟưɓƟưƚüĸȅbi92015 œŖäĸǯ9
2016 œŖäĸǯ~Ŀɞf9�¹¥±»�fɑ
TLeDƕĘbu�´��µhɖʛ~ĽƢf
ƐɪbJz���9MY Server1)~ÕǰT
a9�¹³�¹bhäĸòɖʛ~ļƞT[:
ưǴȾbiPhċyȘrf_Da9ƾɂcȚ
Ʒ~ħĕVz:
ËÉfvk½Å3�µ�
����¢¡�
Áɽįĸbi9ƌƑƸHxäĸVzĸǯ~
Ŀɞfäĸòɖʛ~ļƞTaDz:Íòiɖ
ʛğƪhɂȔcŴűƚ~ƪHX9ǖñVzc
DEɖʛ~ļƞTaD[:THT9ƌéIä
ĸǹòfey9Āêe¦�»�¢��IbJ
eDPcv9äĸòɖʛhƫuįJeǸǵb
Czäĸòh¼ĻƮʈȜȝǵfĸȦRXzP
ciʔTDPcuCy9ʦĜʍyhɖʛbi
eLɀƗhɖʛ~ɖT9q[ʔƢŖ~ɗƘT
[�´��µhɖʛb9H_ƌéǦǏ~ƀƎ
bJz MY Server ~ÕǰVzPccT[:
������������� 3���
� MY Server fi91)YhĨbƊǡR{9Ț
ƷI}Hz:ʈɹF[Ȑż~vyǹVPcI
bJz:2)D_ĸǯI����T[H9d�
eɅȏ~T[HI·�fLjz:ĸǯIdhw
EfċyȘ�\HǦǏIƀƎbJz9cDE
e-learning h¼ȳǵeíǡföF9;hǡ
IǥȎVoJǡcTaƆOx{z:
� ĸǯfĐ^[ɖʛ~ļƞT[DcȧFau9
���fʉVzǾɚheDƕĘi�´��
µhɖʛ~ƐɪT[���~ÓzPciĞ
ʔbCz:THT9MY Server bi9word
v excel cD^[QL¼ȳǵe�¦�~Õǰ
Ta9¼Ļh¦�»«��fţ^aÓŹV{
jYhqqƕƲcTaƐɪVzPcIbJz
[t9ǾɚIeDƕĘbuĽƢfÕǰbJz:
��� ½Ågx�
� ¼ȳf e-learningbiƊǡIĽƢVe}]
ɅȏIkc_fǍq^aDzɖʛIɺTaD
z:_qy9ĄɓvȾǬedhɓŞ9ƚǐh
ǂƺǵ�´µIļƞTvVD:THT9ȎȨ
xi9įĸäĸŢ9įĸǯǒbŨɂcey9
q[¿ɤTaDzcū}{z��µcTa9
<ɕsºƪL=fʉVzɖʛ~ļƞT[Dc
ȧF[:YPbƚȌ~ȖƲcT[ɖʛ~ļƞ
VzPccT[:
A5� ƚȌȾǬº������µ�1
― ― 105
2015 œŖi9ȃɔ~ƌȂT9ǝĶhɕrc
ɂȔ~ɏr[I9ƚȌhɂȔ~�¹³�¹b
Ɏ×VzPcIʔTDPcc9ɂȔcDEÓ
ƼYhuhIʔTH^[cȧFx{[[t9
èĽ~ĬFzPccT[:2016 œŖiƚȯf
Đ}Xaėɓ~ǝĶɓf£³¦¶»�VzĚ
ʛʣȡȦʦʤc9ȃɔhɂȔ~ĺŹVzĚʛ
ʣȡȦʧʤ~ɖT[:;fĚʛÖ~ȂV:
sÅd�
«®Ê� �±2�,*»>Â�%1$���
dÊ� ¬�"0��"/�1;�u>c��
Ô�c�';� ]� j�';� ]� w�';Õ�
«®ËÇ¥¼>�¤%È� Ô� � Õ2Áh1
·²>f<�_3�§3gx>5071$���
y� 9Æez5/У25*!;¸ �� 3�
¹ ! � � � � � 3 Ô � � � Õ 0 % . �
Ô� � � � � Õ2 Ä$<;¶¿%!mq$<
*�{� 9���2/"*´��³0��3
bª�n3Ô� � � Õ28; �� 3���¹>�
Ô� � � � Õ>�-p¦Ã�0%.Ô� � � � Õ
%*º�!mq2-1!,*3+�Ç~�È�
�
���w¾�
�����µ�
� ưļɦhĿɞȨcļƞƮʈ~ȾʧfȂV:
ÀœŖcu95 _hɖʛ~NJɳʦ_W_92
ƬÁơHx 3 Ƭ¾ơqb 5 ɳʈf}[^aļ
ƞT[:d]xuiUtf�´�¹�»�²
¹~ȼD9ɖʛʦhȡȦʧHxi9ďĜhȟ
tëyfʈfĐEwEfďȱbɇDZǵfɴt
aux^[:
� Ⱦʦ� ĿɞȨcļƞƮʈ
ĿɞȨ ļƞƮʈ
2015 œŖ 6 Ē 2016.2.15~3.20
2916 œŖ 12 Ē 2017.2.13~3.20
��� ©��
� ʪ_hɖʛf_Da9ƌéÈƗ9Ǜǡʣ100%
h���ʤ~ċŤT[ÈƗ9ɀƗĜċyȘ�
\ÈƗ~Ƀ[cP|9ÀœŖcuƌéǪiʖ
őfʠH^[:
Ⱦʧ� ɖʛƌéǪ
ȡȦʦ ȡȦʧ
2015 œŖ 96.7% 86.7%
2916 œŖ 95% 91.2%
2015 œŖi 100%hŤǡ~Ť[ĸǯ9ʈɹ^
aD[ʑfvyǹT[ĸǯƗI 2016 œŖf
NjoaŅeH^[:2016 œŖiDW{uƓě
R{[:[\TȡȦʦiɀƗĜċyȘqeL
au 100%~ǩŤTaDzĸǯIĮDhbĚ
ʛIƢTVK[čȮŬICz:ȡȦʧiʦŖ
bi 100ʢfexW9ɀƗĜċyȘ�bDz:
��=:2�
� Ʈʍ~þë^[ɖʛhƌȂ9ĸȦƒƏ®»
µhɰÛIƭùbCzPcIŎɁpHʣ2008ʤ
bȂR{aDz:ưċyȘrbu9ɖʛQc
fȟtëy~ɋĻT[:q[9ĿɞhĸǯI
ŅÈƗH_ƌƑƸƋȹäĸǯbCzPcHx9
<vxeD=hiʔTDǮĪbCzPcuŠ
ʘT[cȧFx{z:
� q[9·�Hx9ɖʛhèĽvʔƢŖIċ
yȘrfŠʘVzPcuȂęR{[:dhw
EeɖʛIıŝbCzH9ċyȘr~ȜȝT9
ȚƷ~ȸȉVzPcbƻɍT[D:
��
�� MY Server iƵƳÚŀnjhÓŹfwz:
Õǰ¨·�³¬¹�Ɇɓi Prolog:
�
}����
ŎɁʕúƜÆʀǑ¼ºǚŎǎƔºńƵŎǓ
� (2008)<e ³» ¹�~ǒǰT[äĸòƕ
� ȬfʉVzļɍǿȊ=>´®���µƕȬǿ
� Ȋ?ȍʪŏȍʦĎ9pp.87-95.
ʅɝŎǭºńƵŎǓ(2011)<e ³» ¹�~
� ǒǰT[äĸòƕȬbhĸȦƒƏ�»¤
� �=>´®���µƕȬǿȊ?ȍʫŏȍʧĎ9
� pp.113-118.
A5� ƚȌȾǬº������µ�1
― ― 106
ULY>¶(;���
�i|��°2�#;ULY�¤3�0l���
�
@ǴȾȨA� ƣƟ� ȤȈʣįdžįĸʤ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ÊÉ4&72�
įdžįĸbi9ìœǃƕȬ¨·�³hk
c_cTa9<ĸlhĦȁſǐ �=cDEƉƼ
~ŃäTaDz:Ŀɞi � œǯåĘbCy�9
� œʈ~ɱU[ŨÜȅǸce^aDz:èĽ
i¶ª»�ĥȎfHH}zǀ;e��µ~ɨ
f_NzuhbCy9òƮºŢƮcĂƮY{
Z{IŨÜbCz[t9� œǯåĘIɱœf
}[y¶ª»�ĥȎh��µ~ǕtzcDE9
ǥȴhCz¨·�³ce^aDz:îɸǸ
ǁi9ƟưɓȾɊµ»µIĹx{9ŚǰIǵ
ȀfeR{[ ��� Ķͽh¶ª»�IĥȎ
bJzwEfezPcbCzI9şř\Nb
ieL9�µ»¨¸»�v¨¶�¹�»�²
¹ed~cGTa9ūȧ~ǕtzPcuđƥ
fɯȊTaDz:�
ưƉƼ~ȼEfC[y9RqSqeċyȘ
r~ȼ^aDzI9�� œŖƉƼfGDai9
<¯�µ~ɃXz=Pc~ɿǡǵfȼ^[:
çÑǵfi;h � ǡbCz:�
3����h¯�µ¶ª»�ʣƕĘ2ĸǯʤ�
4�� h¯�µ¶ª»�ʣƕĘ2��2ĸǯʤ�
5ĸǯh¯�µ¨¶�¹�»�²¹�
ʣƕĘ2ĸǯ2ĸǯʤ�
ͽ � ǡ~ucf9ƉƼèhɖʛY{Z{�
f9çÑǵe¯�µ~ƌȂVzPcbîɸǸ
ǁIčɄüR{9ĸǯh��µ9ĉl¯�©
»�²¹hē½f_eIzPc~ɮoz:�
1 2016 œŖwyóɋR{[ġĤóǯĸɽf
GDai9ļȦ¶ª»�ĥȎIŨɂcez[
t9<ƟưɓȾǬ=cDEƉƼĒbǧȱhňʇ
IeR{aDzI9Ħưɽêi<ĸlhĦȁ
ſǐ B=cæɱTaDz:
ËÉKDHM3ULYZS^MÇ�r�v�È�
�� œŖh<ĸlhĦȁſǐ �=bi9ƕ
ĘIêƂĥȎ~ȼ^[æɱ����~ÕǰT
[:Yh����hÂʙǸhkc_cTa9
<¯�µ¶ª»�=ICOx{z:ļʑh¶
ª»�ĥȎhɶȆ~ȂTeIx9îɸǸǁc
đU ��� Ķͽh¶ª»�~ƌȂT[uh
bCz:ĸǯiY{~ucf9qWişř~
qgzPcHxȱêhuhfT9YhEFb
ɖʛhèĽvȱêhŁʆhşŵf�¶¹�b
JzwEfezPc~ǸǵcT[uhbCz:�
¯�µ¶ª»�fwy9ĸǯI<dhwE
euh~dEv^aƪLhH}HxeD=c
DEǦŵfʏzPcIeD[t9ĸǯhĸl
IìLJǵeljʐbÞDžTaTqEPc~Ĝɼ
VzPcIbJ[:�
�
ÌÉ 3ULYZS^MÇ�r� �v�È�
� <ĸlhĦȁſǐ �=bi9įdžįĸįĸ
ʎǯ~ÁŧcVz �� IƉƼfĈöTaDz:
�� fi�³�ƂŝICy9ďĜhƉƼfĈö
T9ĸǯhÓƼv�µ»¨¸»�h÷Ɇ~ȼ
E:q[9ȎȨh�³�bi9ĸǯiNJĜª
»�¦�´�~ɊäTaGy9Y{fĿTa
�� I�®¹�~ɊäVzPcb9ĸǯiƉƼ
nhɣĚvǪǹeŴű~ɮozPcIbJz
wEfe^aDz:ĸǯchœʡuɬL9��
hķĠYhuhIĸǯh·»µ¯�µce^
2 ����i<ĸlhĦȁſǐ B=ƂŝȨ9
ĉlįdžįĸfGDaæɱƕȬ~żȑVzƕ
ȬʇǴƋɴ�¹�»żʼnhƕȪĘIĥȎT[:
¯�µ¶ª»�iđ�¹�»ɬȻȿĵnj~Á
ŧfɈɛhucÓŹR{[:
A5� ƚȌȾǬº������µ�1
― ― 107
aDzcDFz:�
�� œŖhƉƼbi9� œǯhȍ � Ĝhɖ
ʛcTa9ńĸǯh�«»�¦�¹żƄhɢ
Ĕf_Dahńɘƚ~ɖT[:�� i9���
�h¯�µ¶ª»�~ĈȧfTeIx9ĸǯ
cđU�»«b¶ª»�~ĥȎT9Y{~ĸ
ǯfɾŐT[:����h¯�µ¶ª»�i
ĸǯIƪD[�»«ciɹE�»«bƪH{
aDz[t9ĸǯfc^a �� h¯�µ¶ª»
�iwyɨɬeuhcTaČNDžtzPcI
bJz:q[9�� hƪLuhi9ȾǬ9Śǰ
hƝǐ9êʁed9ĸǯwyuâ{[ǡIĮ
D[t9ĸǯfc^awyɨɬeǸƅVoJ
Ǹǁcez:�� h¯�µ¶ª»�i9ĸǯȱ
ɨhĥȎŲDŽf_eIzİƕƲbCz:� � �
ÍÉv�3ULYQZI\K^GV\�
�r�v��v��
� ��� œŖwyȎȨh�³�bi ��� ĶÍ
½h¶ª»�~ĥȎVzʑ9�µ»¨bh¨
¶�¹�»�²¹~ŃäTaDz:��� œŖ
iȎȨI¯�µhɡƛ~ɾŐT9ĸǯiY{
~ucf¨¶�¹�»�²¹~ȼ^[:Yh
ʑ9VM{[¨¶�¹�»�²¹~ȼ^[�
µ»¨huh~ʃDZT9�� œŖhĸǯfɃ
X[:ĸǯiȱêcđU � œǯI9ȱêcđ
Uɖʛf_Daȼ^[¨¶�¹�»�²¹h
��´��~ĈȧfT9Y{cđȆŖ9Cz
DiY{ͽhuh~_Ly[DcøôVz:
Yh[t9��� œŖwyuèĽhVM{[¨
¶�¹�»�²¹IƹljfīF[:q[9��
œŖheHb9¨¶�¹�»�²¹9ɣDzũ
ȏc9�³�åÑhċyȘrIVM{aD[
uhf_Dai9œŖhƫŢfÌ�³�f¯
�µcTa¤��~ɄȩRX[:òœh � œ
ǯbieL9đUĸœheHf9VM{[¨
¶�¹�»�²¹ĉlɣDzũȏ~ȼE�³�
ICzPci9ĸǯfc^aiįJeðǟc
ey9ª»�¦�´�f œǃÍʌhĸl~
Ǖt[DǍŲ~ƪLĸǯIĮƗD[:�
¯�µ~Ĉȧf9ȱê[]bɖʛf_Da
ȧF9ċyȘr9RxfuE¼ŖđUȋĨh
¯�µ~ɃzPcbȱêȱɨ~ƇyɭzPc
IbJz:đUȋĨhĸǯfwz¯�µ~Ƀ
XzPci9ÉŢh¯�©»�²¹f_eI
zƭŲȥeċyȘrbC^[cȧFx{z:�
�
ÎÉ�=:2�
� ĸǯhƉƼɖʛf_Da9ĮLh¯�µ~
ɃXzļɦ~ȼ^[:YhPcfwy9ĸǯ
ȱɨhĸl~ÙVPcfŹõT[:q[9ɿ
ɂeùƷcTa9<Ò~VzhHq^[L}H
xeD=cDEìLJǵe_qWJ~eLVP
cIbJzǡICz: �µ~ɃXzPci9
ǥfìœǃƕȬheHbiƭùeŽljbCz:�
� ÉŢhɖʛcTai9ĸǯȱɨI¯�µ~
ĈȧfT__u9YPHxȰćT9ȱêȱɨ
bȧFx{zËȘrhƿȒbCzcDFwE:
ǬĠ9 ¶�¹�»�²¹qbhɶȆhÁb9
ĚD~Ǖtz¸»�ed~ļɦTaGy9Y
hùƷf_DaÉŢȧľVzÄĻbCz:�
�
@ĈȧƚǨA�
ÐȻǓȌʣ���ʤ>įĸƕĘh[thƉƼƝǐ
c���¹?ǫŎįĸéǣɽ�
ƜÆėŔºĢÝƱÊʣ2013ʤ>�µ»¨ĸȦ
äʆ/ĸlCEĨ`Lyhſǐ?Ŷŷȥĩį
ĸéǣΠƾāÍĵʣ2014ʤ>ūȧ~ʄFz¶ª»�º
ɘƚÓŹǐʴȍ ǣ ?ɻŶŷȥĩįĸéǣÎ�
�����»°»ʣǶɌʬįōȕÌʤʣ�� ʤ>ĸ
Ȧȅĸ¡¹�§��� ȍÅǣ� ȍ ŏ/ùƷ
ǵeĸl~ÙɴVzļɦʥæfĸm/?ýį
ɥƪŻ�
ƚɽȅĸǻ<��»�¹�º����¹�ʣ��ʤ
f_Da=�
**'���,,,�$�-*��&�"'���$�%+�) !%�!�� +#
.&�� +#.&������!"!(&#+���������������
� *$ �
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 108
=>��HS�@��9�f���j��Gx��>[�g}�
�
!ǹɆȴ"� ǜü½ʱªʊĦĮĦĮʕʲ�
ńǯÝÿʱªʊĦĮʲ� � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
��:{�_^�
ƟƭGʫȘƔȷE(%@Hʳ�~��l�
LJʘEȏɄ3ʳĮǬGĥƾé*ʀQD)ʳȊ
µ)VĦĮENJRVYXɈɞSģé3@+: (¼'I�rȊµ«ěȇà�, Ȩǭǿ, 2006; �Įġà�, ƘȎǿ, 2008)�2011ŒG¢ħƔȷĸɣµȚDZAH0Y°ÜEƍĎ2Y@+:ȹà
\ěE�ěȇǻ�NjǮǻȹà�*ƍĎ2Y: (ƘʉȎĮǿ, 2011)� 8&3:¢ʳCGU&DĮǬ*ĦĮA0Y
VGȹà\ɲE®.ʳŵʏ5XG;Z&)�
ÌɄȅȔAHʳĦĮǬ\ta�Ô.5X0B
Aŵʏ5XĮǬÉ\Ɔ'U&B3@+: (ǜ�,2009; ńǯ�Ʒ, 2010; Ņǯ, 2011; ǵʎ�ǜ�, 2013; ʎ¢, 2016DC)�0&3:ȅȔAHʳĦĮAGĮȲƣʒTĮȲűŔʳk
�w{��{3@%XǑåGȑØEUXĮǬ
Gta�BʳĦĮAGĮȲŵƲTĻưŁƪB
Gʓɾ*Ƹɐ2Y@%X�3)3ʳŵʏ5X
ĮǬGʂôGȨʪE>%@Ƹɐ3:ȅȔHĿ
D% (¼'Iʳǜ��ªʊĦĮʫȘƔȷȅȔʑǹƋʀq�t��ǍăĞ, 2015)� ƭȅȔE(%@HʳĦĮAGƇƹEĹ5X
úWȧP\SBEĮǬ\Ôʧ3ʳĦĮAGĮ
ȲŵƲBGʓɾ\Ƹɐ3:�AʳʫƴAGä
ŗEĹ5XúWȧPTĮȲȨʪʳ¢Įƴ�ʫ
ƴGûʪȨʪBGʓɾ\Ƹɐ3ʳŵʏ5XĮ
ǬÉ\ơV)E5X0B\ǾǻB5X� ��MV�
ʸʴʷʵɝƳĹɤ ��wqƔȷȭăȅȔŷEU=@ 2012 Œ
EıƝ2Y:�ȗ 2 Ē ĦĮǬGĮȲ�ǬǑıűɝƳ \ƭȅȔGĹɤB5X�18ʼ24
DŽGĦĮ 1ʼ4 ŒǬ*ĹɤA$WʳƩãĒȚƖH 4,911ąA$=:� ʸʴʸʵɝƳʢǾ (1) ĦĮAGƇƹEĹ5XúWȧP� ĦĮAGƇƹEĹ5XúWȧPE>%@ 26 ʢǾ\4²ǏAļF:� (2) ĦĮAGĮȲŵƲ� 28ʢǾGĮȲŵƲE>%@ĦĮǬǑιACGȐŔɲE>%:)
\ 4²ǏAļF:� (3) ʫƴAGäŗEĹ5XúWȧP� ʫƴGƣGĮƴTijAGäŗGƾĬE>%@ 15 ʢǾ\ 4²ǏAļF:� (4) ʫƴƣ¯GĮȲȨʪ� ĖƦʩTa�t��w{GÙǮʳĖɆDCGǹɆɪƙGºŵȨ
ʪE>%@ 7ʢǾ\ 3²ǏAļF:� (5) ¢Įƴ�ʫƴGûʪȨʪ� ¢ĮÍɔ�ʫƴÍɔAĮàÍɔ\Ȩʪ3:)Ĉ)\ļF:� ʹʵȩƲBȳķ ʹʴʷ ĦɻĮAGƇƹEĹ5XúWȧPE
ě?-ĮǬGta� �ĦĮAGƇƹEĹ5XúWȧP�G 5ē
Ĭ (�ûɠGěƭǻ�}�Gʆį���z`ofwm��ȘKGɦǦ���ȽĊEě?%:Ȼ
£ĮȲ���ɏdzǻ�ȫȬǻȻ£ĮȲ���Ƈƹ
G¦Ȳ�ţȲ�; ńǯ, 2012 \õȳ) GƿǛ
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 109
šǞ\ȜÓ3ʳ8YV\Ǯ%@ʝʘŃh�o
tÔƱ (K-meansǏ) \Ʉ=:�ƉȥǻEƸ
ɐ3:ȩƲʳɍʌþȹŪ)VƧʅBũ[YX
6>Gh�ot\ƈǮ3: (Ė 1)�
ʹʴʸ ĮɻǬta�1BGĮȲŵƲGŊǷ
� ĮǬta�1BGĮȲŵƲ\Ƹɐ5X:R
E ĮrȲŵƲG 28ʢǾE>%@ēĬÔƱ (Ƨ
ŀǏ PrromaxĒɳ) \Ʉ=:ȩƲ 4rēĬɍ
(�NjǮǻȹà�r�ƖǻÒǪȹà�r�Ĥėəʁ
Ǯȹà�ėʙŪ�r�ȓƺŪ���u�mw��r
:;3�ȓƺŪ�HÑǻ�ɧŪ*¸)=::
R (� = .58)ʳÔƱ)VʖĤ) *ĩŘA$X
B×ƚ3:�
3 >G�·ēĬE>%@ĮǬta�EUX
�ɈēÔƕÔƱ\Ʉ=:�8GȩƲʳĮȲŵ
ƲG�·ēĬ5L@E(%@ĮǬta�G£
ãƲ*ƩŮA$=: (p < .001)�2VEĥʍ
ljɴ (TukeyǏ pr < .05) \Ʉ=:B0Z�Nj
Ǯǻȹà�r�ƖǻÒǪȹà�AHʳ6 *ƧS
ʫ- 4 > 2 > 1, 3 > 5GʣEȬ%:��Ĥėə
ʁǮȹà�ėʙŪ�AH 6 > 4 > 1, 2 > 3 > 5
GʣAʫ)=: (Ɇ 1)�
� ta� 4Bta� 2GĮǬGŊH�z`o
fwm��ȘKGɦǦ�Gʫ¸A$X��Ɯ
AdžWG 4ēĬE>%@Hta� 2GƜ*ʫ
)=:�2VEʳta� 1Bta� 3GĮǬ
AHƩŮDŊHɉVYD)=:*ʳta� 3
GĮǬGƜ*ĮȲŵƲ*¸%B%&ȩƲA$
=:�0G 2>GĮǬta�GŊS�z`o
fwm��ȘKGɦǦ�Gʫ¸A$X�£¹
ǻ�ɏdzǻEĮȲ\Ʉ&;.AHD-ʳƇƹ
GD)AǑåKȓƺǻEʓ[XĪç*NjǮǻ
ȹàDCGǧšEHŦɈA$XBɎ'X�
ʹʴʹ ĮɻǬta�1BGʫƴƣ¯GȨʪ
ǁEĮǬta�1BGʫƴƣ¯GȨʪ\Ƹ
ɐ5X:RE�rʫƴAGäŗEĹ5XúWȧ
P�E>%@G 15 ʢǾEĹ3@ēĬÔƱ\
Ʉ% 2rēĬɍ (�ƇƹEĹ5XèäDűŔ�r
�ȓƺǻDĮȲűŔ�) \š:�O:�ʫƴ
ƣ¯GĮȲȨʪ�E>%@G 7ʢǾEĹ3@
H 1ēĬɍ\š:�
8Y9YE>%@ĮǬta�EUX�Ɉē
ÔƕÔƱ\Ʉ=:ȩƲʳ5L@E(%@ĮǬ
ta�G£ãƲ*ƩŮA$=: (p < .001)�
2VEĥʍljɴ (TukeyǏʳp < .05) \Ʉ=
:B0Z �rƇƹEĹ5XèäDűŔ�H 6 >
2 > 4 > 1 > 3 > 5A$X�Ɯ �rȓƺǻDĮȲ
űŔ�Hʳ6 > 4 > 2 > 1 > 3 > 5GʣEʫ-ʳ
�ʫƴƣ¯GĮȲȨʪ�AH 6 > 4 > 2 > 1, 3
> 5A$=: (Ɇ 2)�
� ta� 4GĮǬ*ta� 2GĮǬUWSĦ
ĮAGĮȲŵƲ*ʫ%0B\ȳ'XBʳʫƴ
ƣ¯)VƇƹEĹ3@èäEúWȧQ;.A
HD-ʳäŗEȓƺǻEúWȧPʳO:ĖƦ
ʩGÙǮTǹɆɪƙGºŵȘGȨʪ\ȓQ0
B*ʍɈA$XBɎ'X�
ʹʴʺʵĮǬta�BûʪȨʪBGʓɾ
� ĮǬta�B¢Į�ʫƴAGĮàÍɔGȨ
ʪE>%@�2 Ƹİ\Ʉ=:B0ZʳƩŮD
ʓɾ*ɗRVY: (p < .05)�ǢEʳta� 6
Eǁ%Aŵʏ\Ȉ3:ta� 4GĮǬta�
B�ǟƩȰ�EƩŮDɥGʓɾ �rǟǟȰ�E
ƩŮDǃGʓɾ*ɉVY:�±ɚGĚ\ÓD
%SGG�ûʪȨʪBĦĮE(.XĮȲǑå
GƸɐ\Ʉ&0B*ƫŝ2YX�
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 110
A/~c>R���4w^ZKJl�=>��abW7�8��6P�
�=>z[�@r��pQ,ab��
�
!ǹɆȴ"� ¨�ǔȱʱųŴȱĞĦĮìĮʉéĮƔIJʲ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
��pQ,absO�
ǩĘ�Ŷ*ėAHĻưGėʙǻEǑɱA+
X«ƮGȷŵ\ǾǻE�ľ¢ʫȘĮƴE(.
XȎĮƔȷGËı\ɏ=@(W�8GɓÀ(
UJƊȬ*ĦĮ�ǢE�ÖŒǁGʍɈD»ċ
BD=@%X�¼'I�ʫȘĮƴE(.X
SSHʱo���lac�o�aoh��ʲÛ
ŔHƞE 16 ŒǾ\ɶ'@(W�8GŵƲB
¬ŞGģʟǞ*ǩĘƸɐ2Y@%X�ƭɝƳ
AH�0YVľ¢ʫȘĮƴGȎĮƔȷ*�Ǫ
ȡGĦĮʕǬECGU&Dśʠ\�':)E
>%@ÎėǻEɝLX�2VE�ƭɝƳ\Ȩ
@�¬ŞGľ¢ʫȘĮƴE(.XÌʀǻǪƖ
ƔȷG$WƜE>%@ȳķ5X0B\ǾǻB
5X�
��pQ,abMV�
ƭɝƳHőŵ 28Œ 4ƨ#őŵ 29Œ 3ƨGƫ
ʒE�ÎėGĦĮGǪʼnȡĮʉEŷł5XÂ
ġɜȐ$X%HðġɜȐGĘȠȴ�öJ0Y
VGɜȐ\Â¥Ş 3Œ°ÑGȴ\ĹɤB3@
ıƝ3:�ƭɝƳHĂĮʉ�ĂȅȔIJGŢź
ɗ\š:ŞE�Øɻǘ®G_�j�{ɝƳȋ
\ĂĮʉöJĂȅȔIJKɈNJʉƖ\ɹ®3:�
_�j�{ɝƳȋH�ǟɑąA$W�ĒȚH
ȻǰŮŧA$X0B\ɑɵ3:�O:��ʉ
Eʓ3@Ha�t��w{�G_�j�{�
d��\ɒİ3�ɑÍ5XƜŖ\ƈ=:�
��;dk�BFc�
ƭɝƳAHÎėG 29 ĦĮʕGĮǬ)VĒȚ
*$W�544 ą)VƩãĒȚ\š:�_�j
�{ɝƳȋGʋŎƖEĹ5XĒùƖ)VɏȜ
2Y:ĒȚǨH 21.6ʰA$=:�
3-1ʵŒʮƽŵ
ĒȚȴGŒʮƽŵ\ĀɆöJ�ĖEȈ5�Â
ġɜȐEł5XĦĮʕǬ)VGĒȚ*ĥ-�
22ʼ24DŽGĒȚȴHιG 81.1%\ñR:�
3-2ʵŪØ
ŪØHDzŪ 390ą�ĨŪ 133ą�ƬĒȚ 9ą
A$=:�
3-3ʵÓɲʫƴëÔ
ĒȚȴEHėȕ�Ïȕ�ȍȕ�ǕĤ�Ƹİ�
8GG 6>GʇžȶAÓɲʫƴGëÔ\ļ
F:�8GȩƲ�ėȕ 29 ą�Ïȕ 203 ą�
ȍȕ 291ą�ǕĤ 8ąA$=:�ƸİöJ8
GGȨDžGȴH 2ąA$=:�ιGȢí
Ɩʱ53.3ʰʲ\ȍȕʫƴÓɲGĦĮʕǬ*ñ
R:�
��hP�
ĒȚȴG&<�59.7%E$:X 325 ą*Įƴ
ƔȷɜȐ°ĤGɜĤAÌʀǻǪƖƔȷ\ûɠ
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 111
3:0B*D%0B*Ô)=:��ƜA�205
ą*ɜĤAGÌʀǻǪƖƔȷɦ ¼'I�SSH�
ʉǑå�ȅȔǑå�ĦĮɒȯȎĮƔIJDCʲ
\ûɠ3:0B*$XBĒȚ3:�0GÌʀ
ǻǪƖƔȷ\û.:ȴ*ÖȘ¢ȘƔȷGCG
LJʘAǀµ\š:)\�ĖEȈ5ʱɇƖĒȚ
þȹ �
ľĮƴƣ¯EȨʪ3:«* 40 ą�¢Įƴƣ
¯EȨʪ3:«* 32 ą�ʫƴƣ¯EȨʪ3
:«* 148ąA$W�ʫƴƣ¯*ƧSɜĤE
(.XǪƖƔȷ\û.Xǀµ\š@%X0B
*ơV)BD=:�
� ƭɝƳAH�ĦʢǾB3@°�GÑĴE>
%@ɝƳ\Ʉ=:�
ʷʲľ¢ʫƣGɜĤGǪƖĮȲEU=@ǁG
ȹàTʓťHCGU&Eģé3O3:)�
ʸʲǩĘGȻVGʓťTȹàE>%@(Ț'
-;2%�
ʹʲȻVGȅȔŵƲGʈÊB3@�ľ�¢�
ʫƴǬ$X%H�ȾGƜKGȎĮƔȷǑå\
Ʉ&0BEʓ3@(Ț'-;2%�
ʺʲľ¢ʫƴAÌʀǻDǪƖƔȷ\Ʉ&0B
EĹ5XȻǰŮɉ
0YVGȩƲ��ʷ�ľ¢ʫƣGȎĮǻDĮȲ
EU=@ǁGȹàTʓťHCGU&Eģé3
O3:)��B%&ďEĹ3@��ȻǡKGʓ
ť���ȎĮ�ŻɅÔʎGǪɟ�óǪKGʓť
(UJ�ȎĮ�ŻɅÔʎGıʪŻɅ�G 3ʢ
ǾE>%@�ĂĒȚ\ok_é3@ljɴ3:
ĝă�ľ¢ʫƴƣEɜĤGǪƖƔȷ\Ȩʪ3
:ȴ*Ȩʪ3D)=:ȴElj3@ƩŮEĆ�
3:BĒȚ3:��ƜA��ȎĮ�ŻɅÔʎG
ÄǪʱȅȔÄǪ�ǬċÄǪDC ���ƘǦȘG
ƸȥŻɅ���ɀəGȹàʱµɕà�ɛɍàD
C �DCAH�8GŊHƩŮAHD)=:�
D(�ƭɝƳGȻǰɑɵ\õȳE5XB0Y
VGʢǾE>%@H�ɜĤAGǪƖƔȷAH
úW�/VY@%D%þȹŪ*ʫ-�8GŊ
*>)D)=:SGBȳ'VYX�
� O:�ľ¢ʫƴǬEĹ5XÌʀǻDǪƖƔ
ȷ\ıƝ5XǀµH�ȓƺǻEɒ.XG*ƪ
O3%Bȳ'XĦĮʕǬHʂíƖ\ɬ':�
3)3�ľ¢ʫƴǬƣE�ɜĤGǪƖȎƔȷ
\Ȩʪ3:ȴBȨʪ3D)=:ȴGʒEŊH
D)=:��ƜA�¬Ş�ȻVľ¢ʫƴǬ\
ĹɤB3:ÌʀǻDǪƖȎƔȷEƐ[Z&B
%&ŮǂH�ok_é3@ljɴ5XBƩŮE
ȻV*ľ¢ʫƴƣEȨʪ3:ȴGƜ*ĥ)=
:�ȻVGȨʪ*ƔȷıƝÆKGȏɄ\ĴƢ
E3@%X0B*ơV)BD=:�
� D(�ƭƔȷãƲBHʓÁD%*�ĦĮʕ
ǬGɿGȅȔƣʒH�50ʼ70ƣʒ*ƧSĥ-�
70 ƣʒ\ɭ'XĦĮʕǬS 16ʰ\ɬ'@ĭ
Ę5X0BSơV)BD=:�
��qu�
ƭɝƳE1îà\ʡ+O3:ĦĮöJĦĮʕ
ǬGǼƾEǗɡDZ3�/O5�O:�ƭɝƳ
G�ʉH�ǤȕȅȔʑǹǏ«ȎĮŻɅƅȽǀ
ƽ�i����lac�og���o§ƹ�
ųŴȱĞĦĮ� ǴGìǸ\ÕWƁ-ć�Ȼ
Ŷºý�ɦ őŵ 26Œ#29Œ öJȎĮȅȔɩ
ěǽȅȔʱCʲɦ ɜʥǶāʻ16K01032ʲɦ őŵ
28 Œ#30 ŒʲGƒƏ\šO3:�ò-Ţȉ
DZ3�/O5�
�
�
�
�
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 112
>5�.me�X|��~=vI�n��
�=>[���~R����<HS�9�f�� �GP,o{��
��
!ǹɆȴ"Ƀʎ� ðɄʱ¤ŇėʙĦĮ �ȄņæŚʱńƶĮʕĦĮʲ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
�������
� ���� Œ � ƨ�¤ŇėʙĦĮGov��z�
{_mot�{ʱ��ʲ� ą*�ȌŅȀȕê¤
ŇʫȘĮƴG�ŒǬ h�o���ąEĹ3@�
�ȭăǻDĮȲGƣʒ�Gʺƣʒ\ÙǮ3@
_hy`���~�ięƇƹ\ıƝ3:��
� ƭȒAH�Ƈƹ��i��GƼɈ(UJ�
ǬşEıƝ3:§Ş_�j�{GÔƱȩƲD
C)Vɉ':ŵƲBɜʥE>%@ɷLX��
��&*!)'?N�gi� �
� ȌŅȀȕê¤ŇʫȘĮƴAHLjŒ�ɜʥɍ
njęĮȲGŵƲǹɆB3@��r�y�m�
�Ħµ\ıƝ3@%X�3)3���r�y
�m��Gĥ-*ɝLĮȲGĚ)VÓ@%D
%DCGɜʥ*$=:��Ɯ�ƭĮǏĮʉA
S �� ŒMCÜ)V�£Er�ȎǾE(%@�
�r�y�m��ºŵ�ǹɆ\ıƝ3@%X�
°�GȸƤ)V�¡ƴGʫĦƔȷɾƐîİE
ě?+��i��\ıƝ5XEȼ=:��
��&*!)'�Tm�
ʱʷʲ��i��GŮȱ�
� O6�UWĥ-GʫƴǬEĦĮGĮJ\Ȃ
=@SV&0BA$X�_hy`���~�
iEUWĮàG � ɈȤ\ǖʨ5X��i��
\UWĥ-GʫƴǬEƍ¾5X0BH�ĦĮ
ʀĮŏƪȴGPDV6ĦĮʀĮ\ȳ'@%D
%ǬşEĹ3@S�ĻưG¦ɉĔʛDȊµ\
Ǭ+Ž-à\ɲE>.X:REŦɈD0BA
$W��ʫĦƊȬ�°�GŮȱ*$Z&� � >,E�ƭ��i��GƩãŪ\Ȇɗ3�
ÍĮÜƔȷTÖŒǁƔȷE�`�|�wh5
X0BA$X�¬ĒG��i��EUWǬş
Gà*CGȐŔ¶J:G)\ȂX0BH�Í
ĮÜƔȷGƜĆŪTÑĴ\İRX0BEɪ5
XI)WAD-�ÖŒǁƔȷES�`�|�
wh5X0B*þȹA$X��
� 2VE��� GȷŵA$X�ƭĮGÖŒǁƔ
ȷH �� EʤXB0Z*Ħ+%*��� GƃĽ
àEëŊ*$X0B*ďʥɋ2Y@%:�
80A�ƭ��i��GƃĽ\ �� EɄ[7X
0BEUW�8Gɪɫ\œ�/3�ÖŒǁƔ
ȷGɫ\Ć�5X0B\ŮĖ3:��
ʱʸʲ��i��GƜĆŪ�
� ¼'I�ÖŒǁr�E(.X��r�y�
m��ºŵEH � ƣʒȐŔ*ɩT2YX��
Ɯ�¬ĒG��i��H � ƣʒ�&< �� E³
2YXƇƹƣʒH ƣʒA$X�8GȞĕA
$XȐŔGʃș\>.D.YIDVD%�O
:�¬ĒG��i��AƃĽ\ƀ&GH ��
A$X�ƾ�DɟǪGŁʑǏEŲY@(V6�
ȹàTȨʪSIV>+*$X:R�Ɣč*ƃ
Ľ5XGBĄ4U&EH%)D%��
� 80A�ƘʉȎĮǿG�ǭƹǴG~�pE
ĹŨ3:ƔȷƓĐ�Ëı¹ÛƗǧƹ�Aʑ
ǹ3:ŸǏ\õȳE��� *ƃĽ3T5%ƔƮ
\ʑǹ3:�0GŸǏH�ɪƙùʚ�ÔƱ�
ɜʥǹɉ�ƽŭ�ɆǩB%&ʂȐʱ�y�m
�lah�ʲEě?+ɜʥɍnj\Ǿƃ5SG
A$X��y�m�lah�B%&�ę�E
Š&GAĦĮǬHƃĽ3T5-�ʫƴǬES
[)WT5%�O:�0GƔƮEUWĦĮǬ
Ć.GȅÂ\ɇƖĒıƝ3:ȨʪS$X:R�
�b�bSɂȓ2Y@%X��
ʱʸʲºŵ3:ɜʥBʀɄǏ� �
� ɜʥB3@�ê¤ŇōEʓ5XĂȑɪƙ\
ɛɍ�ÔƱ3�8Gɜʥ\żƎ3:&'A�
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 113
ɍnjț\ƽŭ27XƔƮ\ºŵ3:��
� O6�ɛɍ�ÔƱG:RGɪƙB3@�ê
¤ŇōGǩǣEʓ5X � GĖɆ�ƘȖ\ǮŮ
3:�ƣʒǻÛȢT�Ĺɤ*ʫƴǬA$X0
B)VʛƢŔHɁB3:�ȻVùʚ3:ɪƙ
\ÔƱ3:ȨʪGĿD%ʫƴǬEĹ3@�ƣ
ʒǻÛȢG$XǣǎAȻǰDŬĜùʚ\27
:ĝă��ʅÕDɪƙEUWŬĜÔƱ\5X
þȹŪ*$X:R�ɪƙùʚH27D)=:�
��hm�{E>%@S�ĦĮǬĆ.GSG
Eljɴ3@ŗRGɘĽ\Ʉ=:��
� ǁEıƝƜǏE>%@H�£¹ŪTîÈà
\ȷŵ5XŮĖ)V�nis�ĮȲǏEUW
ɛɍ�ÔƱ\3�ιÉ\żƎ27:��
� 8GŞ��� ǏT �� ǏEUWɜʥ\ǐ%Ó
3:�ƧÖE �� ǏEUWɪƙGɈǞ�ê¤Ň
ōGʬà�ɜʥ�83@ŰŭE>%@ȻǰE
Ʀ+Ó27:�8G&'A��� ǏEUW�ʬ
àTɜʥ*CGU&DȨȮAǹǬ3:G)E
>%@�o{����\ȳ'27:�8G¢
)V�ʬàE>%@H�¶I7IŗPEDX
Ǟ��ū%B0ZE>%@H�ƓĐA+8&D
B0Z�\ſÓ27�ɍnjț\ƽŭ27:��
ʱʹʲ�� EĹ5X{��~�i�
� Ƈƹ\Ʉ& �� *o��pEʀɄA+XU
&�ƾ�DǛÇ\Ʉ=:��
� O6�ʀɄŜG �� EĹ3@»Ǯ¦İGƔƮ
\Ǯ%:§Ü��hm�w�\ıƝ3:���
E��i��GɮƠTʀɄ�ƔƮÑĴ\Ǫɍ
27:M)�ƃƑ\ÊEƔƮ\ƓĐ3:��
� O:�ƭǶAʀɄEǮ%X����a�{
B8GʀɄƵ���hm�{GɍȚ¼B�ɣɟ
*Åǝ3@%XƣGĢ).¼\ºŵ3:�0
YVɪƙ\§ÜEǙ3:�A�ŘƟEƧȦŹ
<ă[7\Ʉ%ƭǶEȺ];��
��?NE��+"-$hP�
� ��i��ıƝŞ�ǬşEĹ3@_�j�
{\ıƝ3:�ƇƹʛƢŔE>%@H��C<
VASD%�*ʝŐEĥ-��ȟï;=:��
�TTȟï;=:�Bȳ'XǬşHĿƖǒA
$=:��ƜA�ɪƙT��hm�{Gďʥ
E>%@H�ʛ3%Bȳ'XǬşHMB]C
%D)=:��
� i�����hE>%@H�ƻ3-D)=
:���$OWƻ3-D)=:�BȚ':Ǭş
HĿƖA$=:�ƻ32GÑĴE>%@H�
�ɣɟ�BȚ':Ǭş*�Ƕĥ-�>%A�î
à���ɝLX���r��GʣA$=:��
������
� _�j�{ȩƲAH���i��8GSG
GʛƢŔ*ʫ%BŰ4:ĮǬHĿƖA$=:�
U=@�ʛƢŔGɒİ8GSGHʅÕA$=
:Bȳ'X�3)3�ǩĝGƔč��� G£Ɍ�
O:Óư�*=:��r�DC\ɉ@%XB�
ĥ-GƓĐǞ*ɉû.VY:��
� O6�ɪƙɛɍE>%@HŭİɼWGɍȚ
*A+@%:�z�tGȪă�ÔƱºƹE>
%@H�ÃغƹAHȿ3]A%XǬşSɉ
VY:*�ĺʐijµɣAGĮǬ)VƔ'@
SV&DC3@ǪɍA+:U&A$=:��
� �Ɯ�ɜʥǹɉ°ʔGºƹE>%@Hȿâ
3@%:�¬ĒH�йǻ5,XBÔƱGɋ
ǞT_az_GȻǰŔ*ǥOXGA�ê¤Ň
ōGɜʥ�B%&ſɤǻDɜʥ\ɒİ3:*�
ɺEȻǰŔ*ʫ5,@ʫƴǬEB=@Hɜʥ
ǹɉ*ʛ3-D=@%:U&EŰ4VYX��
� 0GǞE>%@H�ʫƴƔč)VSĄ4U
&DŮɉ*Ķ7VY:�O:��� )VS�ɜ
ʥǹɉ°ʔGqwm��AH�ĮǬGʚ¢à
*ÕY@3O%�^m�y�{*Ħģ;=
:��B%&ŮɉSĥ-ȵ)Y:�ɜʥǹɉ*
&O-%)D)=::R�8G$BG_az
_Gƽŭ*&O-%)D%B%&ūŤǫEʗ
=:GAH$XO%)��
� °��ÖŒŔHŸƉWǣűA$W�ǚɯG
%-SGA$=:BHɎ%ʛ%*�ʫƴǬĆ
.GƔƮGʛƢŔɒİT�ƃĽƜǏE>%@
�Ħ+DȨʪBȂɉ\šX0B*A+:Bȳ
'@%X��
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 114
�-&+ (+%#���>[2]�Jl6P�y��ab�
�gCUthP�`_���
�
!ǹɆȴ"� ʭǯ÷ɨ�ůīĦĮǪĮʉʶʜŅĦĮĦĮʕ��
�
�������
ĦĮÎÍƣ¯\ɶ'ʳĦĮ\úWŌ-ǫğ
*Ħ+-ģé3@%X�ʫĦƊȬƓʟEUWʳ
ÍɔřűGģƥ;.AHD-ʳʫȘĮƴGƔ
ȷʞBĦĮƔȷGƔȷʞGøƜ)VG_��
�v*NJRVY@%X�O:ʳĮġɜȐƔȷ
ιE(%@SʳÖ¢ȘƔȷAƌ/VY@%
X�Ǭ+Xà�B�Ȇ)DĮà�\ȫȬ3@
ĦĮE(%@Sȷŵ3ʳĮġàDCGNjǮǻ
ȹà\ȷQ0B*NJRVY@%X�
ůīĦĮǪĮʉAHʳǪĮʉGŧʦȴƖG
Ġá;.AHD-ʳĘĮǬEĹ5XƔȷǀµ
GƂË\ǾǻEʳe���g���oEĘĮ
ǬEUX´dz\ 2015ŒŔ)VĽÍ3@%X�
0G´dzHĘĮǬEĹ5Xg��_ȎǾGı
ɰB3@ɒɏ2Y@(Wʳ´dzEõá3@ʳ
Ǒå���{\ƍÓ5X0B*ï·ɗİGƯ
²EDXDCʳĘĮǬGĮJEǠǞ*Ř@V
Y:f�g���ɒɏ*2Y@(W 2r015Œ
ŔGĘĮǬ´dzGÑĴT8GŵƲE>%@H
ʭǯ(2016)E@Ĝĉ*2Y@%X�3)3ʳ
��i��ƣʒ*ʝŐEȃ%0BT��i�
�GÜŞAGljɴ*A+@%D%0B)Vʳ
Řɖ��i��GƔȷãƲEʓ3@õáȴE
¿ĭ3:ȩƲGþȹŪ*$X0BDCGɜʥ
*Ƅ/VY@%X�
� 80AʳƭȅȔAHʳůīĦĮǪĮʉAı
ɰ2Y:ʳe���g���oE(.XĘĮ
Ǭ´dz\úW�/ʳõáȴEĹ5XȊµ«ě
ȇàEʓ5XɫďȣɝƳGȩƲ)V 2r015Œ
ŔGȩƲBGljɴ\ɄD%ʳõáȴEƔȷã
ƲG$X��i��\ƍ¾5X0B*A+@
%X)\Ƹɐ5X0B\ǾǻB5X�
��03�Tm�
ůīĦĮǪĮʉAH 2r015ŒŔ)Ve��
�g���oEĘĮǬ´dz\ĽÍ3ʳǪĮʉ
*ıƝ5X´dzGƂË\Ʉ=:�0GĘĮǬ
´dzEõdz5XĮǬHʳ0YOAıƝ2Y@
+:ʳǪĮʉƛÍǬq�}�A ăĵȅÂE(
.XĮǬl��t�ʨŵG�b�b\SBE
Ƈƹɒɏ*2Y@%Xg��_ȎǾ�ȎĮk
��~j�m�������(2016 ŒŔ)�G
ûɠȴS3-HÜŒŔOAEŘɖȎǾ\š
3:Â¥ǬEU=@ʁđ*D2Y@%X�
2016 ŒŔGĘĮǬ´dzAH 2015 ŒŔGı
ƝÑĴ)VĦ+-ģƥ*D2Y�r��vqw
m���*BWTRBDWʳ�ƟG��i�
�GƧŞGƣʒEĘĮǬBG©Ǔ\ǾǻB3
:�q��aBəZ&ʯ�*ɒİ2Y:�O
: 2r015ŒŔOA_��a{*ĹŨ3@%:
ǪĮʉg���ox_�\ŘɖĮǬ*ıƝ5
X0BEDWʳůīĦĮǪĮʉG 5ĮȎEʓ
5XȅȔIJTƝɒ\ňX��{Gx_�\º
ŵ3 xr_�G_y�|TʁđȝǪ\Ʉ=:�
�Ɣ'@q��aʯ�E>%@Hʳ´dzk�
q�{H8GOOE ƣrʒ* 5Ôŕʏ2Y 55
Ô��i��BDWʳůīĦĮAGĮJE�
d�fo3:�ĦĮǬǑ������B%&
´dz\ƛɊAɸá5XƂË*Ʉ[Y:�
� ʁđEõdz3:ĮǬH 57ąA$W õráȴ
ƖH´dz��Ɣ'@q��aʯ�* 90ąʳ´
dz��ĦĮǬǑ������* 14ąʳǪĮʉ
g���ox_�*ŕL«Ɩ 200ą°�A$
X(ǪĮʉg���ox_�H 2 ��{Aʁ
đ2Y@(Wʳ��{1BEõá«Ɩ\ȓȜ
3@%X:RŕL«ƖBD=@%X)��
A6� ʫĦƊȬ
― ― 115
��MV�
��i��Ȧ¥ŞEõáȴEĹ5X_�j
�{ɝƳ\Ʉ%ʳ8GȩƲ\SBEÔƱ\Ʉ
&�ƭȅȔAHʳĘĮǬ´dzE(.XȨŒģ
é\Ƹɐ5X:R �rƔ'@q��aʯ� dz
GõáȴGĒȚEȁǾ3@Ƹɐ\Ʉ&�
� йǻEHʳ3 >GÚʄǾƿEĹ5Xʄŵ
ŔEʓ5XɒďB��i��\ɼ4@ɲE>
%:Ȋµ«ěȇàEʓ5Xɒď\úW�/X�
� ÚʄǾƿEʓ5XɒďE>%@H�rŗ-8
&ũ&�r�O$8&ũ&�r�$OW8&ũ[
D%�r�Î-8&ũ[D%�G 4²ǏAĒȚ
\NJR �rŗ-8&ũ&��O$8&ũ&�G
ĒȚȴƖGČ\ȭƩãĒȚƖAʖ3ʳǺÔǨ
E5X0BAÚʄǾƿʄŵŔ(%)\ȜÓ3:�
� Ȋµ«ěȇàEʓ5XɒďE>%@Hʳ�
�wqk����m��(2013)Gɒď\SB
E Ȋrµ«ěȇàEɖŘ5Xɒď\ºŵ3:�
ɒďHÎʉA 11ďA$W �r)DWɲE>%
:��$XȐŔɲE>%@��$OWɲE>%
@%D%��Î-ɲE>%@%D%�G 4²Ǐ
A$X(11 ď¢ 7 ďH��wqk����m
��(2013)BĄƾGɒďƘB3@(WʳÎė
ɝƳBGljɴ*þȹED=@%X)�
��hP (ʷ)ÚʄǾƿʄŵŔ
� 3 >GÚʄǾƿEʓ5XǾƿʄŵŔGŊH
2%ʼ4%°ÑE(2O=@(W�2fŒʒGȪ
ɏǻDƩŮŊSPVYD)=:�
(ʸ)Ȋµ«ěȇàEʓ5Xɒď
� ŒŔØGȊµ«ěȇàEʓ5XĒȚȩƲH
Ė 1 GɼWA$X�2 ŒBSMNÎ@GʢǾ
A�)DWɲE>%:�r�$XȐŔɲE>%
:�GČ* 8Þ\ɭ'@(WʳĦ+DŊǷH
PVY@%D%�
������1E�o{�
� ǾƿʄŵŔTȊµ«ěȇàEʓ5XĒȚG
ȩƲ)VõáȴE¿ĭ76�İGƔȷãƲ\
ƍ¾A+@%XþȹŪ*$+V)BD=:�
¬ŞGɜʥB3@ʳ��i��ÜEŮɢɝƳ
\Ʉ&DCʳ��i��GÜŞAGljɴTk
�y�xÑĴBƔȷÑĴEʓ5XʓÁŪEʓ
5XƸɐDC*Ƅ/VYX��
�
��D\LY
��wqk����m��(2013)�ȗ 2Ē Ħ
ĮǬGĮȲ�ǬǑıűɝƳĜĉƦ ��w
qk����m��
ʭǯ÷ɨ(2016)�ĮǬEUXe���g��
�o´dzGãƲEʓ5XȅȔ�Ȋµ«ěȇ
àGȻŋɓÀEȁǾ3@���ÖŒǁƔȷĮ
µȗ 9ĒĦµǹɆɟƘʚ r 120-121.
��qu�
ƭȅȔE$:WĂȑɪƙ(UJɝƳȩƲȘ
\ƍ¾3@-;2=:ůīĦĮǪĮʉEť)
VŰɡDZ�/O5� ƭǹɆHʳʜŅĦĮßɽȎĮŻɅĦĮʕG
ƒƏ\&.ʳǹɆ\Ʉ=@(WO5�
Ė 1� Ȋµ«ěȇàEĹ5XȻŋɓÀ(ȨŒljɴ)
A7� ƇȭèÅ
― ― 116
Ne4-�g�0DWNf�
�
"Ǭȼȫ#� ƶ�ƣ� Ã�ěʡʉĸċʐĚĢʢ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ts�����
ƣĢFņĢFǡśG��¦ʌİʃ�@$[�
0FǡśɿŤF9SD��%=T¦)Y�83
?ŗ)Y�_�uy�DƇȯ_ijʋ3��� þ
ŀ_ɲ'X&A3?%[�0\_ƷDƇȯĦ
ɫFNjä_ĊZ�įƦǻ±FǂS[¦ƤFȯ
ŤD$9]&A%&ǁɽ*Ǣ4�ƔŀńF ��
ƜD � ��m�FƂɆ*Ȼ^\9�00@G�
¦ʌİʃFǡś_XZδä3�ĢĖöFŷ
�ƎʅA3?�o�s�wbFǜœ*ƒǹ2
\9�0FɿŤDû.9ĢĖɖȁƇȯȢŤF
�@�ÖŀƺƇȯF$ZƎ*ɞɘDCZ�8
FƂĆ�ÇĦDû.9ƎȌ*Ɏ3ø^\9�
0FÏĪU8FĦƏDȳ[P@Fțȣ�83
? Ɯ)YFĦɫȊD=%?ēý5[� us0DWNfAQ�6��Y=P,�
���LU^\�P,�
ƔŀńP@FƇȯɖȁȢŤD(%?G�Ö
ŀƺƇȯDʍ5[ɞɘGC,�ĚĢƇȯLF
ıÊǿǰA3?�Ƈʞp�{�A�ʡ1ŀƺÜƟʢA�Ƈʞp�{�B�ʡ1ŀƺőƟʢ*ȚQÊ\Y\?%9�0\YG�IJ¦ƈ@Ȼ&
ǿǰA3?³Ȧ>.Y\?%9*�ĢǿD8
FÏĪAƎDž*¯2\?%99S�ĮʊƇȯ
ǿǰFıÊǿǰFŠÿø%*Ŋ)<9� 80@�ÖŀƺƇȯFŠĊU$ZƎD=%
?ƾôǭDŵZɴ[AÍD�ƣĢA3?FÖ
ŀƺƇȯFŠȨ_Ȫ'9�0F+<).D¸
<9FG�ɷĢǝU°Ģǝ�ť%GŷƯLF
ǐɨńCBFƇĢ IR Fx�s@$<9�P9�Ȉ�řƞCF)Ȉ£řƞCF)A%&÷
ĢǿǀFÊĢȫFĦŢT²'9�83?�0
FǘDŽ_ƄȦ5\H�ƍ9DŻ/9xb��
���m�FɿŤ*ë&,C[0A_ɋ'9�
8FȜƨ��´ǭCĢÀU¦ʌǭCŤʉFĒ
ǯƲȐF9SD�ŒƦ)YŻ/Y\?%[Ö
ŀƺƇȯFǙ%F&;�ƺFǙ%_ʃɂ5[
ÖŀƗƇȯ_ĦƏ3?%,0ADC<9� � �´ǭCĢÀFĒǯ_Þ[ĢÀof�
FÀœ � ȲYF»ÂɃ_ǶȆ3�ū×ǭɍȻ_
ȯR¦ʌǭŤʉ � ĚĢj��|wbLFîàïJ��|
�hj��|wbFŌŤ � f���o�c�_ÐǒD5[9SF
əŞēFǜœ � įƦFɼɪFƮɈAʁŭ 0\Y_ɬP'�ĢǢ9;Dxb����
�m�_ƒǶDɑɜ27�8FĢÀFĒǯ_
ƲȐ27[9SDG�Ƈʞp�{��:.@
Gʔ3%A%&0ADCZ���o�s�wb
Ʊɘ���ȷɾƊä����Ƈʞp�{�A�F 3ǿǰ)YÖŀƺƇȯ_ƲŤ5[0AD39� ���KEd�P,�
� ĢǢ9;*ĚĢ_ɭɳDš4�00DÊĢ
3?ȶ)<9AŜ&9SDG�ËĢŴ/?Ö
ŀƺƇȯ_ĦƏ3?%,Řȿ*$[AFŠɀ
TŊ,CZ�ŒƦFƇĂFQFŷƯůŋD¬
'?ƇĂA¢ãȭĂ*èÅ3?ůŋ5[ǿǰ
LFėƙ_Ȼ&0ADC<9� � ¢ãȭĂFƯãÔůUŸǤG�ƣĢFƿ´
@$[ ĹƊäĢČFŨȍ¢ʙAC<?%[�
80@�ŎYFÓâDʍ3?ƣʂD8FɧƑ
_ɔƒ5[AÍD¡Ʉ_ǂS�ƇȭèÅLF
Ȉ�ƽ_ɬQÓ50A*@+9� vs0DWNf^\�Hc�/B�
A7� ƇȭèÅ
― ― 117
� ÖŀƺƇȯF�D�µƅ�ȷɾƊä�*ü
P\?%[F)A%&ǫĄ*ę%0AAŜ&�
ƣĢG� ĹƊäĢČ_ƿ´D3?%[0A
GɵM9*�8FÞȆGŦő5-Fƕā 20ŀ@$Z�ʠȊĢƪFÞȆ*Ȉ�ƽ@$<9�
8Fő�łȂČUǴƟĚĢ_à'�2000ŀDÌǾèßƎŇFŌ_A<?ƣĢ*ʋɊ2\9
F@$[�ĢČÞȆŋÖ)Y¦ʌİʃFǡś
*ɛ^\9*�8FƇȯFƫDȷɾ_Ŷ'?
+9�ȷɾA%'HAT5\HĐ_Ŝ%ɥ0
50A*ę%)Tdz\C%*�8\Gŗ_ɱ
S9Đ@$Z�ª¦_Ŝ%U[Đ@C.\H
CYC%�0F�ħ*¤%Dş%ø&0A_
ƇȯFĒƣD39%AFÞğȫFş%*$Z�
8\_ĢČË´*ň+Ȟ%@+?%[�Œ<
?�ƣĢ@G�ȷɾƊä�ʫ��* 4ŀʌ_ɹ3?ʋɚ2\?(Z��ȷɾƊä��G�N
OË?FĢǢ*ñɚ3�ȕ 1ÝFĢǢG 1ŀƺ)Y 4ŀƺP@Fǿǰ_ñɚ3?+9� � 0FȰƘ_TAD�xb�����m�D
Ż/9�o�s�wbFǜœDG�ËĂ*0
FȷɾFŗ_ɭD=.[0A*ĒƣAFɑɜ
)YÖŀƺƇȯFʃȿCȿȖA39F@$[�
�ȷɾƊä��G�ȷFǏFȒǼ)Yɔ+ɥ
03�²ȝƊäFȑ_ʒS9AɅ^\[ɾÎ
UȷĨF%^\_ɔƒ39őD�Đ_ɭD=
.[Ýȃò_ȄQʃE[0ADC<?%[�
0FÝȃòG 10 úȁńFǞDÔ)\?Ȼ^\[*�00D¢ãȭĂʡ8 úȁńʢ*ɚĽA3?îà5[F@$[� � �ȷɾƊä��*ş%_´@ȼǟ5[FD
ĭ3?���o�s�wbƱɘ�G�ş%_Ğ
µDŲ=)�P9�8\_BFX&D²'[
)_ǡɄ5[0A*Ě+CǙ%AC<?%[�
0F9SDG�Ģǿ1AFg�oȢŤ@GC
,�ęƳC»ÂɃ_Ų<9ĢǢ*ÍDĢKM
+@$[AFȪ')Y�ŘÀǿǰA3?ă�
FĢǿ_ɦ'9g�oȢŤAC<?%[�9
:�ƗʌÝȢŤF¢Ş)Y 1ɻʌDȾƈFj�_ÝZŋ?5[0A*@+C%9SD�1
j�F�@ 500ƈæú*ĢK0ADC[�0FůŋD 8úFƇĂFªD 8úF¢ãȭĂ*=,�00@G�15 ɻ_Ě+, 3 =DÔ.�Ȉ���ug@Gǡ¢ʉ�ĢʉȊ*�µƅ�
�o�s�wbCF)�_�ƺF��ug@
G��ǻ±@ŘȿC�o�s�wbAG�_�
ůŋ5[ƇĂU¢ãȭĂ*ȲɭFțƾF�@
š49Řȿŝ_²'�ĢǢ*ȲÔȲɭFĄʜ
A3?�o�s�wb_Ȫ'[0ADC[�
ƇĂFțƾGéɗ@$[)Tdz\C%*ƇĂ
AFɩʓ_ȤS[0A*@+[�P9�¢ã
ȭĂDGƇĂUɝĬĤDğPZ��ʄǠ¦T
%?�ĢǢ9;DA<?Ƴ�CįƦǻ±*ɭ
ɳCTFDC[AŜ&�Ȉ���ug@G�
ŨĴ5[ĢǿǀDÔ)\�ĮƃÔʄ@FÈɰ
9;F�o�s�wbLFş%_Ȭ+�ĚĢ
@FĢJ_Ȫ'[ĔAC[� � �Ƈʞp�{�A�G�ę,FĚĢ@Ȼ^\?%[IJ¦ƈƇȯ@FıÊǿǰA3?FÏ
Ī*ǮZɱP\?%[�9:�ƔŀńP@F
ĢǿǀFɽć@GC,�ËĢ�ƋFÏĪAƎ
Dž@FĦƏDC<?%[�00@TĚĢFɽ
ć_ů&¢ãȭĂ*�ÐǒCf���o�c
�FƁžDû.9÷ʂȧFōÝ_²'�ËĢ
Ŵ/?�´ǭCĢÀFk��yD$9<?%
[0AFǡɄDîǨ3?%[�T;]`�0
Fǿǰ@G�´ǭCĢÀFĒǯAC[ĢȩƁ
žmow�FLJǤȱßU�ɕRȱß�ƚ,ȱ
ß�j��|i�m��ȱßFǵǷTüR� ws����
� ņĢFǡśFþdzŖŃA8\_ĒD39x
b�����m�LFÜû+CŢńFȯŤ_
Ċ[9SF�ƇȭèÅ´Ú@FÖŀƺƇȯF
ĦƏ@$[�ØD���y�d�eFƉÄU
����ugF·ŤTȻ%�ĢǢ�¦IAZ
FŤʉ_óɂä@+[´ÚTƉ'9=TZ@
$[�ǟčFA0]�ţ9:3%Ū;ø^7
G$[TFFĚ+CʑĩTC,źȀ3?%[�
ĢǢ9;FƟƢ@FɌ»_ư3QDŏ;9%�
A7� ƇȭèÅ
― ― 118
0DWNfLU�`b[Co����KEN8zy�
�.lNT�Z��hON8KELU%2]+(Ak<7��
�
"Ǭȼȫ#� ʆƠljĠʡƒƓĚĢʢ�
"Íùǵȅȫ#� ŔíPZĠʡƒƓĚĢʢ�ȸĎǑěʡƒƓĚĢʢ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ts�����
ƐƣD(%?ÖŀƺƇȯ*ĚĢƇȯFx�
d�yǭġčʡĶǥ ���ʢDCZ==$[ǟ
č�ËÊĢǢŘÀȊFɁƵǭŰĚ_ɂʄDÊ
\9Ĕø�ůŋƇĂFǶ¾AǡɄUŠƻCB
D(.[ɤǭď�äGĚ+Cɖʜ@$[��
ƒƓĚĢ@G�ʦŀǢÜƟŘÀǿǰ�ȲȆ
A´ʟʦ�_�ĢʂĢǿnjøF 1g�oȕ 30¦ 68g�o@ʋɚ3?%[ʡ2017ŀńFĔøʢ�ŷƯGagwb����|�hFũDž_
Ǥ%9èùĢȩ�ŵZɴZ_ʃɂ39´ʟĢ
ȩʡƇĨÏ�ĢÏʢ*�ŗAC[�ůŋƇĂ
G÷ĢʂFĮ¯ƇĂ_�´D �ʫ ¦@$
Z�ʋɚF 2010ŀń)Y 2017ŀńDȳ[ 8ŀʌFůŋƇĂFŅM¦ƈG �� ¦�ËĢF
Į¯ƇĂFȕ � Ý*ŷƯůŋ_țʟ3?+9�
3)3�agwb����|�hU´ʟĢȩ
Fơțʟȫ*ę,�ůŋƟʌT�ȵǭDG �
ŀʫ� ŀʌ@$[�8F9SŷƯɽć_ȝű
5[ƒƓƇȯp�s�*ȞȟǭCŷƯƂĆD
ðZȚQ�ůŋƇĂDĭ5[¢ÜǵÀ±ʡ �ʢ
_ĦƏ3?+9��
ƣēýFǰǭG�� ŀD^9[¢ÜǵÀ±
Ħɫ_Ș¨3�ÖŀƺƇȯŷƯFȚȥǭijʋ
D(.[8FōÝ_ȪĬ5[0AD$[��
usKEN8]+�Vi�
urts� D\ � D\�AQ/B�
� ���� ŀ ƜDʋɚ39�ȲȆA´ʟ ��F
ÖŀńFůŋƇĂ_ʒS����� ŀ � ƜDůŋ
ƇĂɔƒ±*ĦƏ2\9�8FʐFǵÀÏĪ
FĚƩG�ǟčĦƏ2\?%[¢Üɔƒ±A
ùƳ@$[�8Fő�ÖŀńFĦɫ_ț?ŷ
ƯÏĪFƂɆ�ŷƯɣƤFƂĆ*Ȼ^\�ŷ
ƯFĒƣAC[h���ĢȩʡèùĢȩʢF
ǡɄAÜû+CðZȚQFʃȿŝ*ĕ39�
P9�ƇƭĘDɔƒ5M+ÏĪ*ę,�ɔ
ƒ±_ � ĈDÔ.[Řȿ*$<9�8F9S
ƍ9D�h���Ģȩ´ʟ�AőçʂÔʡ�Ȳ
ȆA´ʟʦ�@G�Ȉ�Ȏ�AĀKʢDʍ5
[ɔƒ±_ɶà39�ɉǵÀ±* 2011 ŀńDû.?ĦƏ2\9��
"ʦʥh���Ģȩ´ʟ#�
6Quywxw ! xy ; x~ 6Ïywxx ! x ; y~ 6 } qu
Í���Ë��©� x ���Îu
NMu u³ÆÌ¿�[ ���Ja�«u2B¬.$�«®ÂÌ·¬��§u
��u
�f7d8u�³ÆÌ¿�[�£u�³ÆÌ¿�[�tu�¸±ÆX��adu�1ªhª¢�t�¦�¨u
"ʧʥůŋƇĂǵÀ# 6Qu u
ywxx ! y ; � 6Ïz ; yy 6 zË{ quÍ���Ë��©� x ���Îu
NMu2B¢¡©�Ë�lNE¬Ja�«u x| �¢2B��Ë3@¬Ja�«u2Bk�¢�¨¢µÀ̼� ¬Ja�«u
��u u u u
�ne0/u�"�¢VPË��¢3]NEu�2B¢C_uͶĽ¸Ë�lNEË3�¢'�Îu
�2B��Í3@ËÀ̼¾¯Å°Îu�¹ÊºÌ¢µÀ̼� u���v�� ¢'�u�D���K �*�«�¨ u�³ÆÌ¿�[%#�Ja¬H¨«ÍÀ¸¼®»¼É̲Ñ2B��K �[��¥����TÎu
"ʨʥȈ�Ȏɔƒ±# 6Qu
ywxx ! } ; yz 6Ïy� 6 } quÍ���Ë��©� x ���Îu
NMu S�U¢2B��Ëj¨4¬Ja�«u
��u�ne0/u�^ L`ÇÀ̼d8u
�S�U¢j¨4 ���u
� 0\YF¢ÜǵÀGËĂîà_ĒƣA3�
ǗDʧAʨD=%?GƹľȫDÁØĭŚ_5
[0A@ ����Fîàǝ_ɿŤ39��
urus� D\�M:/B�
� ���� ŀńĦƏőDůŋƇĂDa�i�y
_ĦƏ39A0]��îà3?X)<9�A%
A7� ƇȭèÅ
― ― 119
&Šɀ*$[�Ǝ@�ǗDĢƟɸ�FǵÀD
=%?G��ȿ�AFŠɀ*ę,��țʟȫD
G�ȿ���îà3U5%ƗƟDĦƏ3?N3
%�AFųƀT$<9�P9�h���Ģȩ
´ʟ�Gh���ĢȩDŮŬšF$[ƇĂD
ǡɄ_½5DGƗʌ*Ǵ,�ǵÀĦƏȫFĦ
šA3?�ŷƯDDZŹōȆ=ÏĪDėƙ5[
Řȿ*š4Y\9�8\Y_ñ.?����� ŀ
ńDû.�ǵÀÏĪ_ƺFX&Dėƙ39� �îàȿ®_�h���Ģȩ´ʟ�Ȉ�Ȏɔ
ƒ±G�ÖS?ůŋ5[ƇĂGËĂîà�ů
ŋțʟF$[ƇĂGļƞȫ��ůŋƇĂǵÀF
QËĂîàA39� �ůŋƇĂǵÀFĦƏƗʌ_ 2�3 ʎA3�Ɩʝ_º3?ůŋƇĂʌF¥LjƗʌ_Ɋ.9� �h���Ģȩ´ʟ_�ŷƯũDžDʍ5[ɔ
ƒ±�AƂS�ůŋƇĂ*ĢǢōDCZŷƯ
@ĦʐD¸Ǥ5[ũDž_´ʟ5[�@�h�
��ĢȩFŠȨAư32_Ħš@+[ÏĪD
ėƙ39�ùƗDɼȻ�Fwbu�oTȘ¨
39� �Ƈƭ_ÇĦ27�ɕSHÔ)[�ä_ǰų
3�ƇĂFǵÀîàFɠů_ɯǎ39� urvs��F�M:/B�
� 2 ŀǰFƂĆDX[ǵÀÏĪG�ƱEĝŠǭDñ.ƼSY\9�8Fő�ƇƭFƙC[
ÇĦDXZȈ�Ȏɔƒ±G�ȿDC<9� � 6 ŀǰʘ)Y�ÖƟDůŋ39ƇĂ*Ñńůŋ5[i�o*ÓğS�ƂS?�ŷƯFŠ
ȨUƣƦFǰǭ�_ǡɄ3?TY&Řȿ*Ǣ
49�P9țʟF$[ůŋƇĂAÖS?ůŋ
5[ƇĂ*ĺěUjv_ÍƝ5[Ĕ_·Z9
%A%&ş%T$<9�7 ŀǰ 8 ŀǰDû.?FǵÀ±G0FƎûŝ@ĦƏ2\9�õD
8ŀǰDû.?FǵÀ±FƱȿ_ǹ5� � 7 ŀǰFĦƏőFƇĂa�i�y_ɀ[A��ǵÀ±�ɔƒ±FĦƏƗƟ�ÏĪGʀŋ@
39)�DG 24¦��ƍ¯ƇĂ 10¦_üRĈȋȫ 23 ¦*�ʀŋ�AĈȋ3�ÏĪD=%?FǐɨńGʖĿDʠ)<9�P9ƍ¯ů
ŋƇĂFQDŷƯƟʌ�DĦƏ39a�i�
y@TËĂ*�îà3?X)<9�AȮĥǭ
DĈȋ3�δǭCŷƯc��n*@+9�
�ŷƯFɧƑUǰǭ�ŷƯFɼSƎ*ǡɄ@
+9��ůŋƇĂʌ@Ɏ3ø&0A@�ģ*Í
Ɲ@+ǫĄǓTɄNJ39�ȊFŠɀ*ī7Y
\9ʡŔíª 2016ʢ� "1ʥ¢Üɔƒ±# 6Qu
ywx~ ! z ; y 6Ïx| 6 yËz qu
Í���Ë��©� x ���Îu
NMu u (>¢.$3�O���:��u
��u uu
�=6¢NM���u
�ne0/u
��^R��tÐ�¢I)Í��� -&�2B¢I)MÀ®Ê¼�~ !o¢�g¢,?Í�Kʴ̼TÎÎu
��^R��tÐ�¢+ZÍ��¢3]NE�¢pi�
�m�©¢c���� { !o¢�[¤¢�?Îu��WM±ÃÅ3]¿È³ÄÁu
�3�¢'�˵À̼� u
Ò9sË3�o�GÓu�F �«�K¢�*u
�3@¢`4Ë2B¢C_u
�³ÆÌ¿É̲Í�r¢2B��¢��¢Ab�Yt\¢��¢<Îu
"ʧʥŷƯũDžɔƒ±# (>�������d8��6 { q��5u
vs&F�6���
� 0\YFƂĆG�ůŋƇĂa�i�yAů
ŋȫF´ʟǭĦš_ÆDĊY\?+9�8\
G�Ť¦ĢȩĢFɃǓ)YT�ĢȩȫFȲĻ
�ıŝ�ĄʜɄǃ�ŗFƎû«.ȊFƁž�
c�yDɏŋ5[TF@$[ʡʆƠ 2015ʢ��� ƣŷƯ@GĢƟș¡ƗDɐȗCĢǢa�i
�y_ĦƏ3?%[�8FȲǦɉɵƸ_ÔƧ
5[A�ĢǢFɉɵÏĪGƇȯǰƴD�ȴ3
?(Z��ůŋƇĂĵ*8F�ɡ39ǡś_Í
Ɲ3?ƇȯĦɫDŋ9<?+9Ťƨ�_80
Dɀ[0A*@+[ʡȹø 2017ʢ�ŷƯFɤAĢǢFĢȩFɤ�ůŋƇĂFŠƻȠŲFĦ
ǟDû.�§őTɍȻʇɓ_ȟ.?%+9%� îǕƊǛʢ ĶǥǺĠ�ƍƗ¬FÖŀƺƇȯ_Ȫ'[� ĚĢƇȯǵȅ�
d���!Ȉ 20öʣpp.44-48�ȆƇĚĢ�2015 ŔíPZĠ�ȸĎǑě�ʆƠljĠ�ƒƓĚĢËĢÖŀƺƇȯǿǰ�ȲȆA´ʟʦ�ĦɫēýʤƍɁDůŋ5[ƇĂ_
ĭɟA39a�i�yȜƨAƇȭĢèù@FŷƯɽćʤ�
ÖŀƺƇȯĢ±Ȉ 9Ĉ̱ȲǦǵȅǬȼ�2016ŀ ȹø�dž�ĢJFʈA3?FñɚȫšşʤƒƓĚĢFÖŀ
ƺƇȯ�ȲȆA´ʟʦ�(2010~2016)F 9,270 ¹Gµ_ɒ[)ʤ� ƒƓ--ƒƓĚĢƒƓƇȯp�s�ǵȅȔȿ!Ȉ 7ö�pp.27-38�ƒƓĚĢ�2017ŀ ʆƠɃ ǵÀɊɇ�|�a�� ¦ƤȯŤF9SFc�o
y�gm�{�xlc�!åĚɪƚŧ�2015ŀ
A7� ƇȭèÅ
― ― 120
N8�4-)1���"!�#$ ���
�3p>?aXa;?m�%*� ���
�
"Ǭȼȫ#� Ķƣą�ʡåʏĚĢʢ�
ts9qj@�
� åʏĚĢțǍțćĢʂʡ�ƣĢʂʢ@G�
ÖŀƺȊFȾƈFǿǰ@��Ȫ'[ß�A�ț
ʟ_Ʌɒä3ŤʉLA=C/[ß%^V[
�Ǣ+[ß�_ɭD=.[9SF��h��
_ıÊ3?%[�0F��h��F�CǗŕ
G��ǿǰFDz¤ʍɺŝUɺâŝ_Šɜ39
��h��DC<?%[0A��ƇĂ*Ôů
3?·Ť39ÍɹƇƤ_Ǥ%?Ëg�oFŷ
Ư*ùƗɼȻ5[0A��ŷƯș¡őDƇĂ
FŪ;ø^7_Ȼ&0A@�ƇĂʌFèÅß
U¿ʛš�Á�FƇĂFŷƯȱß_ʠS[�
%^H���� Đ ��F©ȚQ*ȚQɱP\?
%[0A�A%&ʨ=*$/Y\[��
� 0FX&CƇȯ��h��_BFX&Dı
Ê5[F)A%&ĄʜGÍĢ�}n��yF
ɖʜ@$[�ǗDƇĂFèÅʍ¼FƲȐG�
Ƈȯ��h��FȚȥäUÚńä_ɼS[&
'@�óƹ@$ZC*Y�ƛTʔ3%ɖʜ@
T$[ATɅ^\[0A*ę%�80@�ƣ
ēý@G�ƇĂFèÅʍ¼_BFX&DƲȐ
5[F)A%&Ǔ_�ŗDēý39%��
�
usN84-�niG�
� ÖŀƺƇȯ@G�IJ¦ƈȾƈg�o@Íɹ
F��h��_ĦƏ5[Ĕø*ę%�8Fʐ�
ŷƯɊɇ�ƇƤʋǬ�ĢǢƁžȊD(%?Ƈ
ĂFèÅ*ʃȿDC<?,[��
� ɤǭɮŽȋǧ����@G��ĢĖɖȁƇȯF
ɤǭɮŽF9SDG�ƇĂË´F�´ǭCî
ǨDX[ƇȯɖȁF´ȓäA�`@�ŷƯÏ
ĪU8FĦƏDʍ^[ƇĂFȚȥǭCðȚ*
Řȿ@$[�Aųƀ2\?%[��
� δǭDG����h��F�@Á�FŷƯ
ǿǰ*ȱßȯŤFBFʂÔ_ů&)Fɑɜ_
ůŋƇĂʌFɞɘ_ɹ4?ÍƝ3�ªFŷƯ
ǿǰAɺſ3ʍɺ3ø%C*YȚȥǭCƇȯ
_ijʋ5[0Aʡ�ǩʢA%&�ɺFƂʗk
cg�*Ʒȱ5[ËĢǭCƇĢ�}n��y
FǶȆ�*ǂSY\?%[F@$[��
�
vsR?m�%*�
�ʦŀq�Af��aǿǰ�
� ʦŀǢŘÀǿǰF�ĒǸq�{��ʡʩé
³ʢ�Af��aǿǰF��c����|�h
ɘʡʧé³ʢ�G�ƔŀńXZʧj�ɺȟ@Ħ
Ə3�øɇ �� ÔA3?%[��
� ĒǸq�{��F�ȿCÙɿǰƴG��w
�m�ʡŜȪß�×ƌß�ȼǟßʢ@$[�
ªƎ��c����|�hɘG�ĢǢF�ț
ʟFɅɒä�ʡ���gm��ʢ*�ŗAC[�
δǭDG�ĢǢ*ȲYFțʟ_ɒ[��� Ô
ʌo��t�Ȋ_ĦƏ3?%[��
� 0Fʧ=FŷƯĦƏő� ÔʌF¶Ƚ*@
+[�80@�ǀɻ8FƗʌDůŋƇĂDX
[Ū;ø^7_ĦƏ3?%[��
�
�Ɗȇȼǟǿǰ�
� ƔŀńXZʦŀƺǿǰF�=_Ɗȇȼǟǿ
ǰDɮŽ39�ŷƯɊɇAƇƤG�ēýȫF
ܯƪ@ʋǬ39Ɗȇȼǟǿǰ�_LjǤ5[
0A)YğP<9�0FŷƯ@T�ŷƯș¡
ő�ǀɻŪ;ø^7_ĦƏ3?%[��
1Ťǥ�ǽě�Ěķ�ʼnǢ��ƥ�êŁʡÍȺʢ� ĚĢǢFƐ
ƣɒ�w�m�_%)DʠS[)��ĚĢFŷƯ_xlc�
5[�ʡI=4ƚŧʢF&;�Ȉʧʂʪȇ(XJȈʨʂʩȇ
ʡĶƣđȉůŋʢîǕ�
A7� ƇȭèÅ
― ― 121
�ʧŀĮʊĒǸq��
� 0\YFǿǰDà'?�§ŀńG�ʧŀǢ
Fq�@$[�q�{�� ��T�ʧŀƺf
��aǿǰF�j��|i�m��ɘ�AP
AS? �� Ôq�A3?�ƇĂèÅ@ĦƏ3
?%[�ƇĂ*ÍɹF�|uyƇƤ_·Ť3�
ËĂ*8FƇƤ_¸<9ŷƯ_Ȼ<?%[��
� ƇƤDG�țǍĢ�țćĢ�DžŐĢ�o�
�v�}n��yȊF÷ÔʄFĒǸǭ)=Ƭ
ƣǭCÏĪ_üRwfoy_ʁ`@%[��
� j��|i�m��ɘG�ʦŀƺF�c�
���|�hɘAù4,��� Ôʌo��t_
�ŗA3?%[�ʧŀƺFw��G�ĚĢÊ
ĢőFŤʉUa�~cyFÏĪCB@$[��
� 0FŷƯ@T�ŷƯș¡ő� ÔʌFŪ;
ø^7_Ȼ<?%[��
�
wsLUF�J�5���
� ù�ǿǰ_ȾƈƇĂ@ŷƯ_ĦƏ5[Ĕø�
0FX&DĥƟǭCŪ;ø^7*ƞP\[�
9:3�Ū;ø^7*Ʒȱ5[9SDG%,
=)FÜż*Řȿ@$[��
� P6�ŷƯFÙɿǰƴUŷƯɊɇD=%?
G¢ÜDǃĥ2\?%C.\HCYC%3�
2YDG�x�AC[3<)ZA39ƇƤU
ŷƯƭ*Řȿ@$[�8&39�Ħǖ�*$
[)Y08�ƇƤʋǬDʍ5[ǢǣǭCɞɘ
*@+�8\V'DŷƯ*ɼ`@%,�@�
ƇȯǰƴUƇȯɃDʍ5[ƇĂʌFj�p�
ko*ƺȈDÓƦ�*<?%,F@$[��
� ƺD�ƇĂʌF��uyCʍ¼*�óƹ@
$[�÷ƇĂDX[;W<A39ĺěUǁ>
+�$[%GĜƆȊ_ȲǦDɎ7[ʕĉǁ·
Z*ʃȿ:�8\_ƇƤD�b�z~ug3
?%,0A@�ƇƤFɤTʠP[F@$[��
� P9�ƹľ3*;CĢǢUųı*&P,%
)C%ĢǢCBD=%?G��&P,%)C%
¢¹08ªFƇĂA�ȡDɄǃ5M+:�A
%&ìÛ@ɼS[0A*ĚÕ@$[�ªFƇ
ĂAĭÒ5[0A@ĝɮ39¢¹Gę%��
� ĢǢF��r{�ƁžG�ƇĂ*�¦@ɠ
ů5[F@GC,�8FĢŀ_ůŋ5[ƇĂ
*èÅ@$9[M+@$[�=PZ�t��
A3?F��r{�ƁžA%&ɂǓ*Řȿ:��
� 8F9SDG��¦FĢǢŞē_ƇĂùĖ
@ÍƝ3C,?GCYC%�8\G�Ū;ø
^7_ɹ4?ȲǔAóȱAC[��
� ¹'H�ĢǢF �� Ôʌo��tG�q�@
Gɀ7C%X&CĢǢF�a�CŜ%*ɱS
Y\?%[0AT$Z�ƇĂFĢǢɃ_ė'
[ß_Ų<?%[0ATę%�8`Co��
tFÏĪ*Ū;ø^7@ÍƝ2\[0A@�
ȜƨA3?�ƇĂ9;FĢǢɃFėäDT=
C*<?%[AŜ^\[��
� 0FX&C��po@ŷƯ_èÅ@ĦƏ3
?%[&;D��èÅ@ÍɹƇƤ_·Ť39Z�
Ū;ø^7_5[N&*Ƴ�CĄʜ_ªFƇ
ĂAɄǃ@+[9S�Ɨʌǭ�ȒǼǭDưD
C[�A%&èÅŷƯ��uy_ę,FƇĂ
*š4Y\[X&DC[�ŷƯFèÅĦƏG�
ƇĂFɠů*ʠ,C[AŜ^\*;@$[*�
ĦG�ʖĿDáǝǭCƎDžCF:��
�
xsN84-�I_���S'�
� 3<)ZA39ŷƯɊɇAǚȲFƇƤ_è
Å@ʋǬ3�Á�FƇĂFɠů_ɯǎ5[9
SFŪ;ø^7_©ȚQA3?ȚQɱR0A
DX<?�œY\[��uyGĚ+%��
� 2YD�ƇĂFèÅŷƯ*ʚɗDɼRD=
\�ƺFʨ=F¿ʛš*ƇĂAĢǢDŌŤ2
\?%,G6@$[��
ʦʥ���h��FƝáŝDĭ5[¿ʛš�
ʧʥ�ĢǢËĂFŤʉDĭ5[ƟŏA¿ʛš�
ʨʥ�ƇĂʌFèßʍ¼A¿ʛʍ¼�
� 0&39¿ʛš08*èÅFɁȏ@$[�
0FɁȏDƁ'Y\9Ƈȯ��h��G��
ńŤȆ5[A�èÅFɁȏ*èÅ_2YD½
ɼ27[A%&kcg�*ğP[�0\08
*ÖŀƺƇȯ�}n��yFǰƴ@$[��
ʡJSPSǿǵɢ ɖʜǪö 26381108ʢ�
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 122
z¦«tv'��0vr½ªÌ{¡cv�8R7WEY?PWX�
95CWA$)^2"0+���
�
=Ȫɾɨ>� Üǡżř˪ǡÑŲǫদȢƹƵ�»�½˫�
ˇǚƽř˪ǡÑŲǫদȢƹƵ�»�½˫�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ÌË)!,'�
ǜȽ[bˬȠŲɏȲȿŕŚaŚŐʘȻ � Ż
Ȣ_ŤOuùŚǍaŚî�¶�»�½�´
»¼�~�»�\MZäyOuhFDy�� Ų
ǫŕŚaŚŐʘȻ � ŻȢ_ŤOuùŚǍ�~
�»�aÎçɕÔyIJnZƱɔOu9džǜa
ĈŻǴŚȢga|¨¹½�aŞʪĦdȲȿbˬ
Ƽɬ˪Ƕʘ˫_˃FEɤDv˪ɳˬ2013˫ˬ Ƕ
ʘœ�¶�»�½�´»¼�~�»�¨¹�
µ¯_X@ZaȲȿɹȾbũ^@9 ǜȽbˬȠŲɏŕŚˬȲȿŕŚ\@A��
�¶½_ŬOuŕŚ[ˬˈŻɘ˦ȫ_ŞDžL
vZ@uŚŐ 1 ŻȢ�¶�»�½�´»¨¹
�µ¯yrtŚȢaƠē_ʤOuoa_Ou
TnaȠʛȫ¼Şʪȫ^ʠȜyȭƪO9
�Ë��ITYLVY;(ºw�
�
m � v¡(v*'Ä"0i�£&NFS�
�Terenzini & Reason(2005)yʐĄ)�
ǜȽ[bˬdžǜaȠŲɏȲȿŕŚaŚŐ 1
ŻȢaŕŚ[aɘ˦yȠʋOuǭƗ¦¸½¯
º½�\MZˬŁ 1 aŚȢaŚd_ˌOuĚ
ƨȫ^±�·yƵȣOu9 Ɔ±�·_C@ZŚȢbˬȶÝÒĪɚʌŚ
ȫˬŚǫÀˬïÒȫRvvSvłǗașƘ\
ɘ˦aŹyƩWZŕŚ_ùŚMˬJvsaʄ
ɓb8ŚȢaŕŚga�»�½�°»�˪ˌ
Ã˫yǯ:^ó˚[Ƈåu9Ls_ˬŚȢE
ˌÃOuǯ:^ɘ˦bˬ�¶�³µ¯ˬƼŠ
_CHuɘ˦ˬƼŠœaɘ˦aRvSva¡
µ��}_rWZʆŝLvu9¾ɴȫ_b8
ŚȢE|��}§_Jvsaɘ˦_ˌxvc
ˌxui]8ŚŐbrtƠˈM8|���¯
EŕFG^u\ÙŝLvu9Jvsa�~�
®��^ėFbˬŕŚa�»����ˬŕŚ
aɗɢȫ^șƒ¼Ǯʹ¼Şʪ¼DžɈˬƼĹp
ŚȢˋaǀě\ȡŎaƉ˜Á[ʧJu9
��b´¦«�.(¥·�
Jaȼa±�·yŞʑMTȲȿaəǣy@
GXDɕÔOu9|��®���»¥�»�\
@A�~¨aŚȢa|���¯aʆŝʄĿy
ƱɔMT Reason Tˬerenzini &ˬ Domingo(2006)
_rvcˬ|��®���»¥�»�aȱʇ_
ŤMZbˬŚȢaïÒŬƘˬťƻ^]aŒƾ\
ǺʮMZˬŚȢaïÒaɘ˦yɾOŒƾEˬo
W\oʗNJĒE˧@9\G_ˬĈŻǴŚȢǍa
ŕŚa�¬½�_X@ZaŚȢɯʬaȱʇE
ɵ@ŚȢˬXktˬĈŻǴ_ŕŚaƼɪĹDs
ɯąEƕʄ\OuŚǫÀ¼ŚǫØœ[ƕʄ^�
¬½�yĩHsvZ@u\ȱʇMZ@uŚȢˬ
ƼɪĹ\ɵ@ˌëyɌHZ@u\ȱʇMZ@
uŚȢbˬɯʬa|��®���»¥�»�_
X@Z˧@\ȱʇMZ@u9ǜȽaˌƔÎ[?
uȠŲɏ\@Aʊȓ[bˬȢĶȸŚˬŲŚˬɯ
ȕȸŚaťƻ˪ major field E˫ 5˩ǽȍ[|��
学生の大学入学以前の特性と経験
・社会人口統計学的な特性
・学業に関する準備状況と成績
・個人的、社会的な経験
7E�&2���%����
,-<@�"���96
������I�5?H(��
�$�!���"���96
8.��#� �
2*+:�B>
=��2*�1A
8D,��1A
8D3��1A
5?�G/ �1A
�����
�2F
�)C
�;0
�2'J4
大学における経験
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 123
®���»¥�»�aȱʇ_ǗƜ_Ɖ˜MZ
@uEˬúã\MZťƻą˄aƉ˜bõıE¾
ʢMZCsPˬťƻą˄bˬŚȢa�¬½�_
X@Zaȱʇ˪1˩ǽȍ[ǗƜ˫i]ˬ|��
®���»¥�»�aȱʇ_NJȳ^Ɖ˜bĦ
jL^@\ɧBsvu9
� Gasiewski Eˬagan Gˬarcia Hˬurtado &ˬ Chang
(2012) � b ˬ ɍ Ń 15 ŕ Ś 73 a Ĉ Ƿ
STEM(science ˬ technology ˬ engineering ˬ and
mathematics)�½�_ƢŬOu 2873 İaŚȢ
a�½�a˒ŭȫľŸąǢ_rtˬŚȢa|
��®���»�½�°»�aʆŝʄĿyƱ
ɔMZ@u9Raəǣ_ru\ˬùŚØĐa
ŚǫƠɡ˪SATˬŕŚaƾŚaġày˧Ǩ[
øĨtMZ@TD]AD˫bùŚƍa|��
®���»�½�°»�_ǗƜ^Ɖ˜yÃB
^@9¾DŽ[ˬ˧ǨǍ×_Ưǫœ[ƼĹ_ʦ
ĺMTˠžbŕŚùŚƍa|��®���»
�½�°»�_ 1˩ǽȍ[ǗƜ^Ɖ˜yÃB
u9RaÕ 1ˬ˩ǽȍ[|��®���»�½
�°»�_ǗƜ^Ɖ˜yÃBu˝ȭbØÁa
1)˰11)[?u9
1)¦¸��³»[?u
2)@XˬUv_ĕHyǾnvcr@DyȱW
Z@u
3)Śÿ[�³½�¶»�˪ïĊƪŧ˫yǾn
T˪ľƾ˫
4)Śœ[ťˉȫ^�³½�½yǾnT˪ ľƾ ˫
5)ʵĔ�µ�_ĥĔMT˪ľƾ˫
6)ƼĹbŚȢ_ŤMZǀǓ[¦}½�¡��
yMZGvZ@u˪Jaǀɂ_ĮƜOu˫
7)ǃM@ǭƗyŚfJ\_º�º�Ou
˪ľƾ˫
8)Ţˢ_ƟĶ_ĨtɗmrAėDzYHsvZ
@u˪Jaǀɂ_ĮƜOu˫
9)ƼŠ[aǍˋúãaAVʜɥ_ʣpLvu
ǍˋađĮ˪~��aƉ˜˫
10)ʦĺOuJ\yƔŅr@\ƝNsvuƼ
Ša˘ŀǼ
11)ŚdıÀOuTn_ǗƜɥ^¦}½�¡
��yƏZ@u
Reason et al.˪ 2006˫ˬ Gasiewski et al. (2012)
aəǣyɞĮOu\ˬȠŲɏȲȿŕŚ_C@
ZˬŦǠa|���¯_X^EuŚȢa�»
�½�°»�yıÀLQu_bˬùŚĐaƠ
ɡp]aťƻ_@uD\@AJ\rtoˬØ
Á 1)˰3)aùŚƍaɘ˦EŕF^Ɖ˜yÃB
Z@uJ\ExDu9
1)]z^\F_]J_ɼHcĕHEƏsvu
aDyȱWZ@u9
2)ƼŠ[ƯǫyĩHuØœ_ˬŚÿœ[ïĊ
ƪŧpʵĔ�µ�yĩHuɘ˦yOu9
3)ƼɪĹDsˬɯąEƕʄ\OuŚǫÀ
ĦdŚǫØœa�¬½�yĩHsvZ@u9
1)˰3)aÿšbˬȸȭpŚˁ\@AǤyʨ
BZüʷ[?tˬDXˬŚǫUH[^GŚǫ
ØœyoĚIJOu9ŚȢEJvsaɘ˦yƏ
pOG^urA^ÿš˪Śÿĭȼ¶�½�y
æ@DŽoIJnZĴȱOu9ƼŠ[ƯǫyĩH
uØœ_oȾǬȫ_ŚfDzÝyŏpMˬƼɪ
Ĺ\aÐȄyìʻOurAŚȢyǽʩÖH
u9˫ b ŚˬȢȢȃa[FuUHLj@ǍǙ_ö
FDHuJ\EǗȬ[?tˬDXˬïĊƯǫ
pťˉaǤyʨBZǿȣȫ[?u9MTEW
ZùŚƆĈaúŚ�¶�»�½�´»aÆ[
ŞDžOuÿš\MZeLxM@\ɧBsvu9
���� z�tvva>W?6S@O'-0
vr½ª � {¡95CWA�
T ŲǫŕŚ[bˬŕŹ^Ƽɬƺ˛aDžɼĈ
Żž_ĮxQZˬîŚƹƵyɼAŚî�»�
�·�³ɪyǃʏM8ŚȢyũÒƾ(15 ÒȻ
ž)a�·½¨[˕nuŚî�»��·�³
_ruùŚǍîŚ�~�»�˪Ƕʘœ˫yˊ
ŘMT9ĈŻžaĥĔȝ 73.8%ˬ2 Żȭb� � � � �
87.9˩UWT9Đɋk[[ǪʍMTÿšyƜ
ʝMXX8ŚȢaőp�½�_ƖNZ¨¹�
µ¯aÿš¼ʼĻDŽȂyŒǒOuTn8ŚȢ
a|»�½�ɯȥʎʴy����¼~�»
�aƣȂ[ąǢMZ@u9Ȫɾ[b82 Żą
aąǢəǣyŊijOuÍŝ[?u9
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 124
���Ãs(v*2��"0�������� q�(k®�
��pHDGVY;zv©'��0o¨�µ(����
�
=Ȫɾɨ>� ˞ɻ� í˪ÈȧɍŲǫŕŚ˫�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ÌË)!,'�
� ƚŊ ��º½�ŲŚȸbˬǕøɃaƚŊ
ěȶÝyƹBuƤɽɨaɬƠyȭƪOŚȸ[
?u9ƆȕaJ\^Es �ˬ� _ˌOuǯ:^
ȱʝpƤɽyʬ_XHuJ\oǾnsvu9
ǃùȢo˧ž^ �� _ˌOuȱʝpƤɽaî
Ə_b˧@ɲĵˌƔyȵMZ@u9MDMˬ
�¶�³µ¯ǮƠÀˬǃùȢaɲĵˌƔyLj
@ǍǙ_ȌTOJ\E[FPˬǃùȢaėDz
YHyáÁLQuJ\o?u9�
� çBc ǜˬȸaǃùȢb �*)+/.$,��, +&'"-�
����aʂå_ɲĵˌƔyƩWZùŚMZGu9
\JwE Şˬ˔_ �� čåaƯǫEŘkuab
ŻƍǙ[?u9Ja�~¯µ�EǃùȢa
ėDzYHyáÁLQu¾XaʄĿ\^WZ@
u\ɧBsvu9ÀɒȢDso;oW\LjG
DsƤɽyʬ_ÖHTDŽEɵ@<\@AƜʅ
oɩDvu9�
� JarA^ɭǏ_ʼnYF �ˬ� aťˉȫ^ȱ
ʝpƤɽyŚfDzÝyùŚȮƍDsƳèOu
J\bǃùȢaŚɦėDzaɝƩ_X^Etˬ
ŚɦĖǣo˧ku\ǙƌLvu9RJ[ˬǃ
ùȢyŤʟ\MT �ˬ� aʼnǜȫ^ȱʝ\Ƥɽ
yƹƵOu;�'"./,$ ō<y ��� Ż_ɁVÀ
IT9Ó[bˬŚȸașƒȫ^ȃėa¾X\
MZˬŚÿœ_ʕȱLvZFZ@u9�
� ǜŊij[bˬ�� Ż_ŞDžMT;�'"./,$
ō<aþãȫ^ĨɗyɕÔMˬRaƠǣ_X
@ZǪʍOu9�
�
�Ë��� {| ������� q(�¶�
���ʼnǜƚŊ� �� ŻžĐǙb;ˬ�� čå<;¨
¹�µ®»�<a XaʜſyˊʜMT9ƚ
Ŋ ��º½�ŲŚȸ � ŻȢ˪�� İ˫aƯǫ
[ȃėÿšyȱsQ ŶˬǘɨyęWT\Jwˬ
�� İ�AVŗř � İ�E˕kWT9;�� čå<
ĩʜɨ �� İ ;ˬ¨¹�µ®»�<ĩʜɨ ��
İˬÄʜſĩʜɨ � İ[?WT9�
��ƪŧɨ� Ʌɨ\ � ŻȢaǍ_ōȢ[?W
T ŻȢ � İEƪŧ\ƹƵyɼWT9Ja ��
yĘnu ŻȢbˬɅɨEƤɽpȱʝ˚Ds
ʿƆ[?u\ʕnTŚȢ_éˡMT9RvS
vaʜſ[ƕʄ^ƤɽpȱʝEȨ^uTn ˬ
İPXa � İEƕʄ[?WT9�
��ȃėȭȫ� �� čå˯�¶��·�²µ�
�yåƠMˬ�»���_ĄĸOu9�
¨¹�µ®»�˯%*, ǀk[yȠʋMˬʼnǜ
ȫ^¨¹�µ¯EåvurA_^u9�
���ȃėÿš�ɾ ���Äʜſ\o ¾ˬľ �� ąa
ȃėyǽǑdžĝƍ_ɼWT�ú � ľ�9���
�bæȣQP ƕˬʄ^ʤǂ�½�y˂ÖMT9�
�
�˾}(x�
���;�� čå<ʼnǜȫ^Ȅv� ǕĈa � ąȻ
ž[ĐľÿšaƸåƐɦ_X@ZÆˋ±��
J��FA
�� ���� ��2;(84<(� ���� ��
� ]H�Jf�TL_P eRcX
� S�D� 2;(85!NaWZ
� %.*:=2 VMBG��������
� ^I 48= KUOb�����
� /'+-7 KUOb�������
8$/#<( &=3=1BG�������
h[]H Y?EQ���V�
� +5=,2;&) Y?EQ���V�
� >@609<( Y?EQ���V�
�� >@609<( Y?EQ�������V�
�� diFA `"g�C\����V�
�� diFA `"g�C\����V�
��������
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 125
yÔMZɼA9ʜſǍˋÆbäDȭǰ\^u
�§�����Țˬǝˬʭ^]�yčåM^E
sˬ�¦�aƸåʗNJyɼA9ÂNJȓE^@
DƾƸåCF_����MˬƬƣMTĩʜȢ
E@TŋĮˬ�� oMGbɅɨEŤƖOu9�
��;¨¹�µ®»�<ʼnǜȫ^Ȅv� �� Eˬ
˓ǍĺˢyÆˋ±��_njMĄMˬĩʜȢE
Raľɇy¨¹�µ®»�MĄĒOu9çB
c ;ˬËËaɾ<\@AĺˢaŋĮˬ¨¹�µ
®»�aəǣˬËËaɾEFVz\ĄĒ[F
vcʘˢ�¶|\^u9¨¹�µ®»�_X
@ZÂNJȓE?uŋĮ �ˬ� oMGbɅɨE|
�¡~�p£»�yÃBu9úĹEľɇyĄ
ĒMTƍˬʋʗyɼ@ˬǴaĺˢyɾȵMZ
@G9�
�
�Ë3W=YG(x��
� ��� Ż_ȃėy��½�MZDsˬ
�'"./,$ ōaĩʜȢbˬǛĩʜȢ\ǺʮMZ
ŚɦƜǵp±�©½�´»EáÁMZ@^@
ĢʟyĩHT9RJ[ĩʜȢˬǛĩʜȢˋa
ƜǵáÁ_X@ZʙhuTn_ˬƜǵáÁ˟
ňŪž˪ÁŮ������ Ŀ � ÚȂ˫yȣ@Zˬ
|»�½�yŞDžMT�ɾ �9JaŪžbˬ
ĭĿř � ˝ȭ ʌˬ �� ˝ȭDs^t ˬ��}
§^i]ˬƏȓE˧@9�
�
�
Ťʟ˯�� ŻȢ �� İ�ĩʜȢ �� İˬǛĩʜȢ
�� İ�9�� İaAVˬŞDždž_¾ľ[odzŷ
MTǛĩʜȢ � İbąǢDsˑœMT9;��
čå<;¨¹�µ®»�<a]VsD¾DŽ[o
ĩʜMZ@uɨy �'"./,$ ōĩʜȢ\MT9�
ŞDžǍǙ˯�� ŻžĐǙˬ� ǖ\ � ǖaʌ
ľ9�
əǣ ;˯ƯǫƜǵáÁ<Ŀř_C@ZˬǛĩʜ
ȢbǗƜ^ƜǵáÁEʅsvT9kT ;ˬŕŚ
ƜǵáÁ<Ŀř_C@ZoˬǛĩʜȢbˬá
ÁaõıyȵMT9Rv_ǺhZ ĩˬʜȢbˬ
ǗƜ^áÁbʅsvPˬmMwˬxPD_Ɯ
ǵıÀEʅsvT9�
�
�
����
����� čå�
� �� čåaȭȫb ;ˬ�¶��·�²µ��
yåƠM �ˬ»���_ĄĸOu9<[?WT9�
ʜſɖÌƍ �ˬ� čåyɛɜMZɼWTŚȢE �ˬ
�� ǖ_ɼxvT˨Ĩª�»���~»�»
���_åĸyĄĸMTəǣˬ İEùˀy
ǣTMT�ÿ � İbâǻƥȷʥ�9�
��¨¹�µ®»��
� ¨¹�µ®»�aȭȫb ;ˬ%*, ǀk[yȠ
ʋMˬʼnǜȫ^¨¹�µ¯EåvurA_^
u9<[?WT9�� İaAV İEˬȭȫy
ʽƠ[FT9�
�
�1/'�
� ȃėəǣ\ʙǦəǣrtˬ�'"./,$ ō_b
ØÁaĖǣEǙƌ[Fu94ঠ� ŻȢaŚ
ǫƜǵˬƯǫƜǵˬŕŚƜǵyƩɜ[Fu9
5ōȢEǴŻž_ʜſyƧƆOuɛɜȫ^�
~�·EȢkvˬʼȣEšNj[?u96ȨŚ
ŻˋaX^EtE[Fu97ōȢbŚzUƤ
ɽpȱʝyȃDMˬʤǩĨƏpŚœ�»��
�gaĄĸ^]yɼAJ\[ˬ��·|�¨
E[Fu9ÓƍoˬŚȢ\\o_ˬɛɜMT
ȃėyɼWZ@FT@9�
=ƃȣǀȜ>�
ÁŮǐƈ������. ȦřŕŚȢaȔǼĒaȲȿ��
ƼɬƔȠŚȲȿ�������������
������� �������
%(���)����
'$ ���%(�/����!�
����%(�������
"#���.*�0�,+��������!�
%(�-1�&��/� ������ ��������
�($!3���� ��4�� 6��6��51����
)� ,� 1� )� ,� 1� )� ,� 1�
��� 2.21 2.16 0.50 1.66 1.73 2%$+, 2.14 2.01 1.46(0.87) (0.80) (0.83) (0.71) (0.79) (0.80)
2.24 2.37 2&$*' 1.57 1.93 2($+%** 2.12 2.28 2&$-+8
(0.60) (0.57) (0.63) (0.55) (0.71) (0.70)( )�70/ **9$%&!#!!"!.$&%
������ ������ ������
����
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 126
z�v�²'��0vÂ��no¨[Ƨ¼EAG(x�_�
���[��dv �� ��%(À�% #( �� �¢��
�
=Ȫɾɨ>� ŕŰƁʀ˪ůŇŕŚ˫�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ÌË)!,'�
ůŇŕŚ[bȠŲɏŚˁ_ŤMZźƠ �
ŻžDsƾŚaʼnȴŚĒyʙǦOuTna¨
¸½�°»����yŞDžM���8ɦȗžĊ�
µ�ɠƠyɼWZ@u��9ƾŚƼɬ_ˌOu
ŚȸaƜı\aʙƿyɼWTÀ[8ȠŲɏĈ
ŻǴ_ƕî\^uJ\EŔ@ƑąȾąŚ_X
@Zb8ČʽžȭǰyŕFGąHZ ɏɚȣ
ƜMZ8RaÆ[ɦȗžĊ�µ�yɠƠMZ
@u9�
ɦȗžĊ�µ�ɠƠčžaʼȣEśŝMZ
Dso8Ơɡaʒê_ˌMZbʼnǜȫ_ĭƧ
ƆƼĹaɿ˅_ÛQZFT9RaDxt8æ
ȣOuƼȸǓy � ȼˣ_ɚ¾OuJ\[8Ơ
ɡ_ħnjLvuʓ˦aĺˢ_X@Zb8ʼnȍ
\MZƼȸǓa˗ž[åƠOurAƧƆƼĹ
ˋ[DŽˆa¾ɱyŁWZFT9�
ÍË°�|f;QAÃ$(¯Z»`Ƥ(�
¹�
��� yȣ@T $ µ½�»�gaʉķƘy˧
nTŨ���^]80$! yȃȣMTƾŚƼɬ
yŞDž[F^@D8\@AƜʅ_X@Zș_8
ůŇŕŚ[ŘkWTƼɬƺ˛¨¹�µ¯EŞ
öǙ_^WTźƠ ŻžØˎbƾŚƼĹˋ
[ǪʍMZFT9�
MDM^Es8ŚȢaƩX �� DzļaÂɚ¾8
ŚîyƹƵOu �� ȐɦŠgașŝa�¦�
��|a~»��½·éˡ8úŚȔɟ ��� a
ƿôʻƮțȁ8ŚȢa �� ¶�µ�½ʼnȴƼɬ
aŚȸK\aųȨ8^]ƾŚƼĹUHaŶǘ
[bŚȢ_śNj_ ��� yċȣMTʓ˦pʘˢ
ƳȵyŞDž[F^@țȁE?uTn8ƾŻD
HZƎ:_ȍôyɼWZFT9�
��� ȃȣƼɬaȍôyʻnZ@TJ\8k
TĴʰȡŎaŒě8ƿô_rtØÁarA^
ȡŎEƿWT9�
�
! ȠŲɏŚˁ_C@Z PC ƕƶaDŽˆEŚ
Ȣ_ƓŽLvT9 ! PC ȐɦŠ_ƾŚƼĹa¶����_r
tĭȼ�¦���|a~»��½·E
īɮ\^WT9 ! IT ¶�µ�½ʼnȴƼɬyɼAƼĹ\a
ţ^ƚŊÐƴ_rt8ĈŻǴĐǙaŚȢ
ʽaʺK\a LMS _ˌOuɦȗžaȭ
śyȱuJ\E[FT9 ! ŕŚƼɬĂȢĔʸ¨¹�µ¯˪AP˫Î
ǫ_ůŇŕŚEưƦLvTJ\_rt8
Raȭǰ[?uŕŚːȢ¼ÀɒȢDsÁ
ɒȢgaŚîȯʚŤƖyɼAčžEŧ
ùLvT9Jv_rt8PC Dzļp LMSaƸå_X@ZaȯʚɀĪ\^tAu
ȯƣE8ŚȢaɁŋDslu\ŕŹ_ŏ
BT9 ! �½�¦�»aǎĦ_rt8��§§
µ��aʾ@_rtɾȵəǣ_ųȨE
?uJ\8��§�½¤�_rWZbƣ
÷[aˍʈȡŎaĆtǔBEƕʄ[?
uJ\_X@Z8ŚȢ_ʕȱLvZFT9 �
ÎË�dv �� � �°�(yc�
JvsĴʰȡŎațȁyʫkBZ8Ǵar
A^ƘʦyƩX ��� À[a�¶·ƇƂaƾŚ
ʼnȴν_ˌOuĺˢ_X@Z8źƠ Żž
DsåƠyˊŘMT9�
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 127
! ĺˢbµ»�¯Ąˢ8ˀ ƦɫaÅdoµ
»�¯\Ou9�
! ġ÷K\_ŚȢ_ƳȵOuĺˢƾa8
ðDs �� ðȻžaĺˢyȣƜMZ8R
aÆDsµ»�¯ĄˢOu9�
! ƾƂ_X@Zb[FuUHŚȢ_\W
Z˥ǥlȈ@ɾʎ\Ou9çBc81 a
Ê[?vc8;1�< ][b^G8;1<
\ɾȵLvurA_Ou9�
! ĭġ÷_X@ZĮǩʼnȍyƳȵMZ8ɷ
ƣ^ġ÷_X@Zbäž[oƫơ[F
urA_Ou9�
! ƼĹEåĺOu˔_8��� À[ � ĺ � ĺ
ùĒOua[b^G8¡��ăȠ[¾ƨ
ùĒE[FurA_Ou9�
! ŕŚaǰȍ ��� [?u �$!�( -- aDzɮ
yǕŕˏ_ȃDMZ8ŚȢE ��� aƸå
_ɦȗOuTna¾ĕ\^urA_O
u9�
! ��� À[aƸå_X@Zb8�� Îǫ[˖
ȣLvTŕŚːȢ_ã˦MZos@8R
aɘ˦yʫkBT�³|·yåƠL
QT9kTĈŻǴŚȢa ��� À[aƸå
_ˌMZ8Crdĺˢ_ˌMZaʦĺ_
ŤƖLQT9�
�
JaǟÚyȌTOTn8źƠ Ż_ïÒȫ
_ɟƇ×ƾŚaʜɥ_ZʓɼMZ@Toay
ƺɵMZ8åĺȣ¦{~·Crd ��� Ĩtʱ
lȣ � .&�� Œƴ¨¹�µ¯yåƠMT9�
o\o\ ��� À[aĺˢaʏʌ_?TWZ
b8ůŇŕŚaŚȢ_˥ǥlEȈ@8ɸʖƼ
ɬ[ŞDžLvZ@u;���� |��}¤�}½<
^sd_ �**#($ [aĭȼ�¶·aʼȣyĥ
ɧ\MT9JaJ\yʫkBZ8ŚȢgaȅ
ʶyŁt8ȠʋaTnaʗNJaƣˋyũM[
oȰGȭȫ[8Jaȳʕ���aİȹy;ú
Ś ���� Ȑɦ<\MZ8ŚȢ_ĨtɗkQuJ
\\MT9�
�
ÏË�dv �� � �°�(x��
źƠ ŻžyȍôǙˋ\MZ8źƠ � Ż
žDsĐǙ;ƑąȾąŚ �<aŕŰaƧƆ�
µ�ɑ �� İ_ŤMZŞDžM8ƍǙ;ƑąȾ
ąŚ ��<_b8úZaƼĹaƧƆ�µ�ɑ �
İ_C@ZŞDžMT9 C8źƠ � Żž_X
@Zb8źƠ � ŻȖǜŅ˙_ruƯǫʻɼg
aƉ˜oɧƞMZ8ƍǙaŤʟÒƾyĞƾ\
MZŞDžMT9�
Ơɡgaħnj_X@Zb8ȐɦȓoMGb
Ũ���ȓ\MZ �� ȓaǤyĭƧƆƼĹE
ÍnʏŝMZ@TTn8RJgaɉùyɼA
J\\MT9^C8�µ¡�_o8úŚ ����
ȐɦyŞDžOuJ\8CrdƠɡɉùyOu
J\_X@ZbʎʯȊl[?u9�
ƟƗMZ@T8ŚȸK\8ɦȗž�µ�K
\aĨɗgaȘƔLaųblsvP8ƧƆɨ
¾įśŌMZ@u9�
�
ÐË�1/'�
źƠ � ŻžDsb8Jvk[ǛŞDž[?W
TɺŚȸ_ŤMZoŞDžOuJ\y�µ¡�
À_ʎʯMZ8ĮxQZƯǫÿ[ŚȢ_ijȱ
yŞDžMT9�
Óa\Jw8ĺˢaɎˀE[FZCsP8
ʼnȴȫ^ĺˢ\˗ĺEȉńMZ@u9JaT
n¾ˁaŚȢaʋɇǍˋE8Įǩk[aźņ
ȫ^ʋɇǍˋa � ðʲ@ÎçolsvT9Ó
ƍbǶɇȝyąǢMZ8ŚȢaɮĒĉŝ_ʿ
MTĺˢǮƠ\MZ@FT@9�
j±���
[1] ƾŚaʼnȴŚĒĊ�µ�ɠƠ\ƾŚƼɬ, ȤÆǶɐ, ʃǜŜÉ, ůŇŕŚȲȿŊij, Ʉ28 ŴɄ 1 Ĭ, pp39-48, źƠ 15 Ż(2003) [2] ùŚĐƪŧDsĈŻǴk[y¦�¹½O
uƾŚƼɬãčaʼȣ, ŕŰƁʀ, Ʉ 64ľË
űŅĜŕŚƼɬȲȿĠʞÝ ɏćĊˁÝ , (2015) � � � � � � � � � � � � �
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 128
�Èv©'��0RMF43S�²É¸¬A:SÊ(x¿_�
�� e{��²©¤�o¨BK��(�h_%u�_� ��
�
=Ȫɾɨ>� ÆÏȞř˪ýƀŕŚ˫�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
Ì˦«³��
ɊȠǧˤŐˤƠǨaˮX[?uýƀŕŚò
ƁȸŚˁǧˤ �°»�Śȸ[b8Ŕǯ^
Ş˦¼Şɦ¼ȐɦȸȭEˊʜLv8ǯ:^�
½»[ƾ˅ȫăȠƤɽ˪ʌɉ��·Ɇ˫Eƕ
ʄ\Lvu9�
ŕŚùŚĐaĭƼɬDzˌ_C@Z8ʬ_X
HZCGhF8ƾ˅ȫăȠƤɽEǛȗ^ŚȢ
EŔGʅsvurA_^WZFTTn8Ƌs
aƄȓȳʕCrdƅěyŁuƕʄE?u9J
arA^ƜŁyoWZźƠ ŻžDsǃT
_¶°�}|·Ƽɬȸȭy;ʼnȴȐɦ<\M
ZˊʜM8Øˎ8;ʼnȴ�®3<\İȹŒǒO
u^]ŕŨaƺŒyɘZ8ȟń_ɰuk[ƺ
ɵyɜHZ@u9�
Óľb8RaĨɗǭʄ\ʻƮțȁyŊijO
u9�
�
ÍËk®�¶É��Ê�
ÉÌÊJU<QL%Ál]g�
� Żȭ˪źƠ Żž˫b;ʼnȴȐɦ<\@
Aȸȭİ[2Ǚ_ˊʜMT˪ú �� ľ 9˫ȸȭ
ƧƆɨ İ[8ŚĒ¸©·Ċ_ƪŝLvT�
µ�aŚȢyĩHƩX��~·yĨWT˪ɑ
�� İ˭�µ� 9˫ƯǫaɄ � ľȭ_ĩʜȢ_
ŤMZ¾ǁ_;�µ�ąH���<yŞDžM8
Raȓƾ_ƖNZ�µ�_ƭtąHT9Ra
ƍb �� ʺPW\ǹľƢŝaǍˋÿ_ŚȢE
ɯÇȫ_ʘˢ˪ʌɉ�¶·˫_Ĩtɗl8Ƌ
sDsĄTʦĺ_ȸȭƧƆɨEïĊŤƖOu
@xqu;ûǀƂ<\@xvu��~·[a
ƪŧyȭƪMT9kT8�������aĮ
ǩȓ_ʽOvc8Àa¸©·a�µ�gȺė
yīɮ\MZ@T�
Żȭ˪źƠ � Żž˫b;ʼnȴ�®3<\
@Aȸȭİ[3Ǚ_ˊʜMT˪ú �� ľ 9˫Ɔ
Śȸb8ũÒƾƧÛč˪�³½�½č˫yĨ
t8ťÛƼĹEĤď\MZùŚǍDsğǫǍ
k[8ƩVÀEt[ƧƆŚȢaŚȢȢȃƹƵ
_?Tu9;ʼnȴ�®3<b8�³½�½Eĭ
ɯa�³½�½�µ�ȢyĩHƩXũÒƾč
[aƪŧ��~·yĨWT9˪ɑ İ˭�³½
�½�µ�8�³½�½� İ˫Ja�µ�b
łŝč[?t8kT8ƯǫbúãʗNJaľa
Ǵ_�³½�½�µ�_ąDvZaƪŧaľ
yʏHT9�
ÉÍÊ���
� Żȭa;ʼnȴȐɦ<_C@ZŚȢƪŧ_
æȣMTƼǞb8@xquʌɉ�¶·aƇƂ
yĨWZ@T9ĭŚĒ¸©·_ĮxQZʏŝ
MTʘˢ_X@Z8ƯǫǍˋÿ˪ɑ � ą˫[
Ĩtɗnu\ÍƛMTą˅a�¶·Ƃĺˢ˕
˪ʋɇ^M˫yȍôMZ8ǹľŚȢEɯąa
¸©·_ƖNZˀz[ĨtɗmrAƪŧMT9
ʋFɖxWTŚȢbȸȭƧƆɨ_Ċāaʋɇ
˕yñtZɇBĮxQ8ʅȮMyɼAJ\E
[FurAȍôMZ@T9�
kT8ÿšaǮƠb8ŵʡLvZ@uŨŚ
ǨDs˧Ǩk[aĥɧǓ8��� ŤɈĺˢ˕a
ÿšy÷_8Ǵ_ƬIuĭ˝ȭE˝ȭĊ_Ś
ɦ[FurAʘˢ˪ ĺˢ˕ y˫åƠMZ@T9�
4¸©·;B<ȣŚɦ˝ȭ˯ĽďȐɉ�
5¸©·;@<ȣŚɦ˝ȭ˯DŽȻƂaċȣɆ�
6¸©·;k<ȣŚɦ˝ȭ˯đĮ\�µ¦Ɇ�
7¸©·;`<ȣŚɦ˝ȭ˯ěŚ˟ň_ƕʄ
^ʌɉ��·�
P1� ŚŐʘȻƼɬ3
― ― 129
Żȭa;ʼnȴ�®3<_C@ZŚȢƪŧ
_æȣMT°~»aƼǞb8@xquĥɧǓ
aƇƂyĨt8;üʷ����<\MZæȣM
T9ƯǫǙˋɖÌǍ_b8ĩʜȢúĹEįN
ÿšyŚîMTțȁ_^urA_ʏʌMT9�
����aÿšǮƠb8ǜɠ8ɯɦɠ8ʁ
ɦɠa¿ˁǮƠ\MT9ǜɠCrdɯɦɠb
RvSv � ɂɁZ\^WZCt8ĭɂbǧˤ
�°»�ŚȸaťˉƼɬȟŋ[ǿȣLv
uʌɉ��·;ġàƴɉ<;ȎȇaȒžʙʂ<
;ʙĵ˩<;ɾaȃȣ<y�¸½�»�Ouÿ
š\MT9ǒ_8Jvsa��·yæ@J^
OÀ[ĐƳǟÚ\^uĽďȐɉ8ǺaǭƗ8
ǺçƂɆ_X@Zb8ʁɦɠa¢½�[�¸
½�»�[FurA˂ɤMZ@T9�
�
ÎË���
� Żȭa;ʼnȴȐɦ<_C@Z8ʏʌǍ_
bǙˋÿ_ĩʜȢúĹE8ũ^G\o¸©·
;k<ØÀy�¶|[FurA_^uJ\E
ǙƌLvZ@T9MDM^Es8ĩʜȢaħ
Ɩb±�©½�´»aáÁ8�«¶aȪȢɆ
OJfuɶMG^G8Ş˔_bAkGDzɮM
Z@^DWTrA[?u9�
ŚȸaƼɬ�¶�³µ¯úã_X@Z8ƺ
ŝåǫEʻnsvZ@uǍǙ_˃^t8ĈŻ
ǴƼɬ¨¹�µ¯aĂɠƠ_X@ZoǪʍL
vT9Raəǣ8źƠ � ŻžØˎb8Żˋy
ʷMZũÒƾa�³½�½�µ�ġà[ǃù
Ȣƪŧ_?TuDŽˆEȀŝLvT9Jv_r
t8LJ¼ʼnȴȐɦaÿšbźƠ � Żž_;ʼn
ȴ�®2¼3<aÿa;ʼnȴ�®3˪�¹¡
»ɠ <˫\MZŚȢ_ƳèLvuJ\_^WT9�
ƪŧãčaŒǒ_Þ@8RvyħnjMTƯ
ǫʏʌyĂǪʍOuƕʄEȢNT9LJ¼ʼnȴ
ȐɦaħȰȓa¾X\MZ8ĩʜȢó_Śɦ
aƕʄƘEŞƝ\MZȠʋ[Fuoa[b^
DWTīɮƘ_X@ZƪƷLvZ@T9ʌɉ
��·Eƕʄ^ǬĒ¶|·^�½»y8ȩß
ã˦^]_rWZɘ˦LQZ8ŚɦɨaƜǵ
yĎȑ8ɝƩOuŲŖaƕʄƘEǾnsvT9
JvyĩHZŚȸúã[;ɊȠǧˤŐ_Ǿn
svuʌɉĒ8�½»<aÎç\¸©·ʏŝ
aĂȳʕ8ƚŊüǗě_X@ZĨtɗl8ü
ʷ����åƠEʻnsvT9�
Żȭ˪źƠ � Żž˫a;ʼnȴ�®3<[
bǃʆ_åƠLvTüʷ����y÷_8ǃ
M@��~·[ƯǫEūˊLvT9Raəǣ8
ĩʜȢaÎĐ���\Îƍ���aǶʋȝb8
ŚŻźņ\MZɑ ��˩Ds ��˩g\NJsD
^ÀljEʅsvT˪şʊȫʒê 9˫kT8Ưǫ
ǙˋɖÌǍ_ŞDžMT|»�½�əǣDsb8
��˩aĩʜȢDsʌɉ��·_ŤOuÂśʋ
Ȇ_ƊɁWT\OuľɇyƏsvT˪Çʊȫ
ʒê 9˫�
�
ÏË\~(½Ç�
ÓľaĨtɗl_rt8ʌɉĒ_Âśa?
uŚȢ_ŤMZ8ťˉȸȭgaĀȏ^Śîy
Jvk[ØÀ_ƣģG�¬½�OuJ\Eī
ɮ_^WT9ťˉȸȭgaDZȋMƊȫ^ˢǞ
y©½�\MZåƠLvTƼǞb8źƠ
Żža;ʼnȴȐɦ<ĩʜȢpƼɬȟŋ[ȮƲ
ƪŧ_?TWTƼĹ8Crdĭťˉą˄_C
@Zodž:ŚȢƪŧ_ƙmƼĹʽ\aŤʔy
ɣtʳMTÆ[ƏsvTƜʅ8|~�|Eħ
njLvToa[?u9ǜŚ\įǯ_ŚȢaŚ
ĒáÁgaŤƖ_ʵxvuŕŚƼĹaʔbƾ
ŔG8úŃȫ_¶°�}|·ƼɬaƕʄƘE
ƪƷLvZ@u9Rv_oˌxsP8ȟǍȓ
_C@Zǧˤɏ_șěMT¶°�}|·Ƽɬ
ȣaƼǞbŵʡ\@AƇ[¾ɴěLvZ@^
@9rWZ8øɼÎç\MZÕaƼɬDzˌa
ĥɧ_^ua[b^@D\ɧB8JJ_Ŋij
OuJ\\MT9MDM^Es8ǸƗ^Es
ĩʜȢúĹaÂśʋȆ\b^WZ@^DWT9
ÓƍbJA@WTŭ_ŬOuŚȢgaƪŧ¨
¹�µ¯yȈěLQZ@FT@\ɧBZ@u9�
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 130
Dc�(,�X�n~$`O�#¢R�
�
�DZɇȲ�� ǼľßŒ�ʥļɰħ�ÉĽÚăʲļƦĨʝĝĨʳ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
½¼�����
ÓʼnƵƂȷ&ơ60K'ŔØ>D?CT"
@RC7Y"%�ÓʼnƵƂȷCÏĭDĜƮ=
V�u��vCęáRǑ.!�ļǧ 2009ʳ
DÓʼnƵƂȷCƋșƻɸɥƢ%U�ƋƜD�]
bt�qdjc�ʲɣOƕ'ȹÙ �r�jp�
�t�u�n�h��jc�ʲǤDžȹÙ�c
��]ʗDZCȹÙ �r[ʐɎ.�șĎD�Ïʦ
dz]_t�s^s^ʲŠšdz/řǢdzʉś�Ȃ
á �r[»ʄ0W|�e��[ʐɎ.<!W
+>[ƐU%A.<!W�
� =D�++=Ïʦdz]_t�s^s^>ā
ȇ-X<!WɋȠ�îVȢODÓʼnƵƂȷA
$!<�ɋ@C7Y"%�]bt�qdjc
�[�ř>.6ȹÙCȷŧ>DǜȌ@C7Y
"%�ƜĖþ=D�]bt�qdjc�>Ǥ
Džjc�CȷŧAį.�d�j;(V>ĨǤ
CřǢdz$TGĨȰ�Cʉśţ&?CT"@
œʨ[êM0%ɥƢ.6�
¾¼w��
� AĝĨCÓʼnƵm� 5ĨȆ 899ú[įɭA
ɲĆȞ[ʍŅ.6�ÓʼnƵm�D�_s^�
eȆǵ>.<ʅǦ-X<$V�ĕǿdz@Ĵɦ
Ƅ&Ĕȏ='WT"A@W+>[ÖʇǵƯ>
.<!W�¶2<�ĨÏƊɚCÕǦƉǁ[ɏ
#W>!96ǤDžjc��4.<řǢdz@ĩ
Ī[ŗW+>[ýQ<ĝĨAŦXW+>[¶
2<ÖʇǵƯ>.<!W�
Ȏ 14ć�15ćCŷƩƒʘ�AćȒ�ćí
[ƽQ6>+Y�45d�j� 40d�j�703
ȄʲćíǞ 78.2%ʳ[ćí.6�
� ɚĆCƭŧ[Ȁ0�ĨȰŧơCŵƯ>.<
ŦX�ĕǿǐȰDĝĨǤDžAŦXW"#=Ŕ
A696�r��_s^�ejc� �ĴɦƄC
ƕ'Ɖ&Z%96�r C 2ʩǵ[ɚĪ.6�
� ĨǤCȸƔ[IJBWʩǵ>.<�ĝĨ�ʉ
śʲ2ʩǵ �rĨȰĊʣţʲ2ʩǵʳ[NjĪ.
6�
ŷƩ;(VAʙ0Wʩǵ>.<ȼ!ʤċƼ
ʲ6ʩǵ �r��dCʫŋ 4ʩǵ [rIJB6�
� Ɯȉ&Ū"t�oD 1 d�jAȝ 20 úC
ĨǤ&yju-X6��p�}�t�o=
W�NjĪÁADd�jCœʨ>À¢Cœʨ&
Ljď0WóȹŞ& W�4+= 2:Cœʨ[
ù ƒ A Ż Ī = ' W ʟ ĺ ȩ ő � t �
ʲHierarchical linear modelʽHLMʳ[Ǧ!
6�
¿¼�~��[�
d�jCœʨCǾɠ
� N1öęƃAd�jCœʨ&OUXW%?
"%Ǿɠ0W6QȟÏǷʙºƃʲIntraclass
Correlation Coefficient ICCʳ[ȔÐ.6>
+Y��_s^�ejc�ʲICC=.14ʳȼ!
ʤċƼ ICC=.17 �r��dCʫŋ ICC=.32ʳ
=Ƙš@Á&ŗUX6ʲps<.01 �r+XUC
ęƃDd�jÏ=ćȒ&ʮ°.<$Vd�j
Cœʨ[ï)<!W>!#�HLM CÕǦ&
ģŐ= W�
ʟĺȩő�t�ATW�t��e
� ŦX[ǵdzęƃ�ƹVCęƃ[ɢƐęƃ>
0W HLM [Ʌ96ʲTable.1 �rÀ¢�}�
Cęƃ=Dȼ!ʤċƼ&ʱ!L?�N6ĝĨ
�ʉśţ&²!L?�ŦXCŗǒ&ʱN9<
!6�ʡĉ�}�Cęƃʲd�jňđ[Ǧ!
6ʳ=Dȼ!ʤċƼ&ʱ!L?ŦX&ʱ%9
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 131
6�d�j�}�¡�µǦ[OW>�ĝĨ�
ʉś�ȼ!ʤċƼ&Ƙš796�ʉśǛŤ&
ȼ!ė÷D�d�jCʤċƼCȼ.ş.DĨ
ȰŧơAœʨ.@!&�ʉś&ş!ė÷AD
d�jCʤċƼ&ĨȰŧơ[ĝ'(Łõ.6�
� �_s^�ejc�[ǵdzęƃ>0W
HLMCȤơʲTable.2ʳ[O<OW>�À¢
�}�=D�ȼ!ʤċƼ&ȼ!L?�ĝĨ�
ʉśţ>ĨȰĊʣţ&²!L?�_s^�e
jc�Cŗǒ&ʱ%96�ʡĉ�}�=D�
�dCʫŋ&ʱ!L?ŗǒ& &WÄû&O
UX6�ĝĨ�ʉś�ȼ!ʤċƼCd�j�
}�¡�µǦ&Ƙš796�ĝĨJCʉś&
ş!ė÷AD�d�jCʤċƼCȼ.ş.&
ĨȰŧơ[Łõ.<!6�
À¼�P�[�
ÑƠCȤơ�ŦX>�_s^�ejc�C
�ƉAį.ȼ!ʤċƼ&ŏ!œʨÙ[R96�
ȼ!ʤċƼDĨǤCĹŞ=D@(�d�jʘ
=łC Węƃ= W�ŦXCO@U1�Ŭ
ȹɗȪdzŞƤCŏ!�_s^�ejc�Aį
.<Rœʨ&OUX6�ȼ!ʤċƼCNjĪʩ
ǵD�ÿVC¢>ɞ.S0!ʤċƼ& 96�
�ȺÑCšɌSȱ#[ıʐ.<RU#Wʤċ
Ƽ& 96��ÿVC¢CšɌ[<!B!Aȴ
+">0WʤċƼ& 96�@?= 96�
ĨȰȲ&¢ƤdzAıʐ-XW+>�4.<ï
ĭdz@d�jCʤċƼ&ĨȰ[»ʄ.<!6
>ɒʏ='W��
� ĝĨ�ʉś>ȼ!ʤċƼCd�j�}�¡
�µǦ&Ƙš796+>%U�ïĭdz@ʤċ
ƼDǶźÝơCO@U1�ĨǤCʉśǛŤ[
ȣǨ.<Ƿ�µǦdzAĨȰŧơ[Łõ0W+
>RZ%96��
� Ïʦdz]_t�s^s^CƭȖƀž�0@
Z8ŠÞdz�řǢdzʉś[ƀž0W+>D�
]bt�qdjc�>ǤDžjc�CǝŗAį
.<ǔʙº=D@(�»ʄdz@Ʊȹ[Ŵ:+
>&ƐU%A@96�4CÏī>.<�¢Ƥ
dzūɠ�ïĭdz@d�j;(V&ƘÝ= 9
6�£ŕDÍ´dz@d�j;(VCũǁCű
Ð&ɤʭ>@W��
Table.1� ŦXAį0W HLM
Table.2� �_s^�ejc�Aį0WHLM
Á¼e�u��
ļǧȁħ� 2009� ĝĨA$)WÓʼnƵƂȷCĸʗ.�
Journal of Quality Education vol.2 157-174.
� ����� b SE b SE)8 4.12 0.03 �� 4.12 0.03 ��
(&���
<�A-7 0.56 0.07 �� 0.56 0.07 ��
!"��B3 0.06 0.05 0.06 0.0501#>4 -0.08 0.03 � -0.09 0.03 ��
1:,@5� -0.03 0.04 -0.04 0.03
?+���
<�A-7� 0.51 0.09 �� 0.51 0.09 ��
!"��B3� 0.07 0.06 0.07 0.06
� ����%$'9
01#>4�<�A-7� 0.22 0.10 �
01#>4�!"��B3� -0.05 0.06
1:,@5�<�A-7� 0.15 0.11
1:,@5�!"��B3� -0.02 0.05
�����** p < .01, * p < .05, + p < .10*;������/6����2.�/6� ����=�
� ����� b SE b SE(7 4.18 0.05 ** 4.18 0.05 **
'%���
; @,6 0.42 0.06 ** 0.42 0.07 **
!��A2 0.01 0.04 0.01 0.04/0"=3 -0.08 0.03 ** -0.09 0.03 **
09+?4� -0.12 0.04 ** -0.12 0.03 **
>*���
; @,6� 0.15 0.21 0.14 0.21
!��A2� 0.20 0.12 + 0.21 0.12 +
������$#&8
/0"=3�; @,6� 0.16 0.07 *
/0"=3� !��A2� -0.10 0.07
09+?4�; @,6� 0.08 0.13
09+?4� !��A2� 0.03 0.05
�����** p < .01, * p < .05, + p < .10):���� �.5����1-�.5������<�
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 132
��U8�y��SXki�:3�#��
�XA1XV�K7±hl��� ���
�
�DZɇȲ�úîǃÎ�³Ƀų�ÓɌŌɅʲ!Z'ƐƑĝĨʳ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
½¼��
!Z'ƐƑĝĨA$!<ƈ6AĤN96Ó
ʼnƵƂȷ|�e��CʴîVȢOÏĭ>ŧơ
A:!<Ėþ.6 úɹî�ÓɌ�³Ƀ 2016ʳ
=Dʴ×ƚȡ�ƒ>ŕƚʗĤƒCʘC�ďĨ
šŝ�CɁ8ɺO&ɌÐ-X<!W�
@3ʴ̬OƐ)AďĨšŝD²�0WC
7Y"%ʾ
ƜDZɇA$!<DʴĝĨÏ>ĝĨěCë¢
Aį.<ĨǤ&R9<!W�ɐdz@ɠɫAǺ
ǵ0W�ĨÏTVRĨěCë¢Aį.<ȶĪ
dz@ɠɫ[R9<!WĨǤDʴ̬OCƱ
[ÕǦ.<ʴĨěCë¢>C¡dž[LJQW7
Y"�¸#Eʴʱƣƒ§Cë¢CʄĨÈCǛ
ǀ[ȳ'ʴȺɶCŨĹ.<WĝĨ>ƻɸ.<
ȱ#6ȤơʴŨĹ.<!WĝĨAďĨ0Wš
ƶ&²�. �ɹɹQ<.N!6!�>!"ŝ!
&ʱNW%R.X@!�67.ʴĨÏCë¢
>Cʙº&ȼĢ= XEʴ4CT"@�ďĨ
šŝCNJɿ�>�ɿĨšŝC�Ə�[Ů#U
XW%R.X@!�ÓʼnƵƂȷ|�e��C
ŷƩŲŐƂĄ&ʴƋŇʴĨǤAź0W�=ţ
/6ȠƝ@©ɢAŖ!ÑƠ[Ʌ"�
Ðñ�øǧʲ2005ʳD�ĝĨǤDžSĨȰDž
ÞAȻĀʙř[Ȁ.�ʉś.<!W>ţ/<
!W%ü%A:!<CĨǤȺɶATW�ɐdz
@ɠɫ�[ĝĨJCʉśţ>Īȯ.<!W�
ƜDZɇ=R+CĪȯAŖ!ʴĨÏ>ĨěCë
¢Aį.<Ű(ʉśţCo_|ATVĨǤ[
Ñʮ.ʴ4X5XC�ďĨšŝ�>�ɿĨš
ŝ�CęáA$)Wʈ![ƐU%A0W+>
[ǵdz>0W�
N6ʴÐñ�øǧʲ2005ʳD�ŷƩ�Cȅ
ɡ�>!"ȂdzAƙN.(@!ɅǓ[0W
> �ɹį¢ʙºAį0Wʉś&ʱNW�>!"
ƙN.!Ȥơ&ŗUXW+>[Ėþ.<!W�
ƜDZɇA$!<DʴȂdzAƙN.!ɅǓ>
.<ʴɻʼnĨǤAƙNX<!W��´dz@Ĩ
¿Ťŋ�[îV�*ʴë¢ʉśţCo_|A
TWʈ![ƨɖ0W�
¾¼w�
C}\¬�� {�qh��kl�w�1 ×
ƚʳ$TG{�qh��kl�w�2ʲŕƚʳ
CïɨȲCÏʴƖÓCŷƩʲT1 ,r×ƚƖŕC
ŷƩʲT3ʳɹ ŕƚƖÓCŷƩʲT4ʳC0K<
CŷƩAéÛ.<!6 65 úCćȒ[ÑƠC
įɭA.6��ÃC 96ćȒDÑƠ,>A
ʞě.6�
o��� ×ƚA 3 ćʴŕƚA 4 ćC÷ɕ 7
ć�ǔəúŎCɲĆȞɥƢ[Ʌ96�×ƚ�
ŕƚCʗĤƒʲT1�T4ʳ>ȡ�ƒʲT3�T7ʳ
AÛ#< �ɹȺƣƂȷ� T2ʳɹ��ib�h�
c�e� T5ʳɹ�İʖɤȈJCijÊ� T6ʳC
N>QCŷƩƒʘÏA�ƅʍŅ. ćɹí.6�
ɇȞAɥƢɳƍ[Ȁ.ʴùš��ùšCʊů
Ƴ[ɚ)ʴćȒD«š= Vŧȫɝ¹>D�
ÒCʙº&@!+>[ñʪ=®#6�
¨�AZ� ·Ǧ.6ɲĆȞADʴƜDZɇ=
·Ǧ0Wʩǵ¨ěARʴƂȷÝơNjĪC6Q
Cʩǵ&ýNX<!6�ËʩǵƃDʴÓćɥ
ƢCO 109ʴ2ćǵ¨ʜDʴ102= 96�Ɯ
DZɇ=·Ǧ0WCD¨�C 4:= W�
º�»XAK7±hl� Ðñ�øǧʲ2005ʳ
&�į¢ʙºAį0Wʉśţ�CŵƯ>.<
·Ǧ.<!W 6ʩǵA:!<�ɹË(4"ŝZ
@!�%U�ŏ(4"ŝ"�C 5ªǁ=ćȒ
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 133
� 4� ����������������
� 3� ������������ �
� 2� ������������ �
[ƽQ6�0K<�ĝĨCë78�A:!<
IJBWʩǵ= 966QʴƜDZɇ=D�ĝĨ
ěCë¢�>ãÔ0W6QA �ɹĨÏë¢ʉś
ţ�>āI�
º�»XVK7±hl� ĨÏë¢ʉśţ 6
ʩǵCÏ �ɹĝĨC¬OƒʘAD ëɹ78>ʢ
X<ʴF>V=!W+>&Ĝ!>ŝ"�¨ě
C 5ʩǵAįś-2<µŧ.6�
º�»SXki1°Xki� ö 4ʩǵ�ë¢
ʉśţ>ùƮC 5ªǁ=ćȒ[ƽQ6�
º�»4;�X>md� Ǭʑ�ǎ�ʲ2013ʳ
&µŧ.6��´dz@ŷƩŤŋ�9 ʩǵA:
!<ʴƒǒ,>=ĈħÑƠ.6Ȥơʴʀɷʩ
ǵCO&ʱ!ɮɀʒ[Ȁ0Ĉħ&űÐ-XW
@? ʩɹǵCN>NV&ƒǒ,>=ǰ@96�
4C6QʴƜDZɇ=Dʴƒǒ[ʂ.<N>N
V&OUX6 4ʩǵCO[·Ǧ.�ɹ�´dzĨ
¿Ťŋ�>āI�� <DNU@!�%U�
<DNW�C 5ƺʟɝĪ=ćȒ[ƽQ6�
¿¼�~��[
]dg���B� öʩǵJCćȒ[ 1%U
5Aŗǒá.ʴňđÁ[Ķŋŗǒ>.6�
K7±hl�)&+� k-means ǁd�jo
�ÑƠATVʴë¢ʉśţCʈ!ATW 4:
Cd�jo� o_| Jr>ĨǤ[Ñʮ.6�
T1ʴT3ʴT4CöŗǒCƮǷ%Uʴ4:Co_
|[�ʉśţNJɿ� n=18ʳɹ�ĨÏʉśţ�
Ə� n=24ʳɹ�ʉśţ�Ə� n=10ʳɹ�Ĩϲ
Ĩěʱ� n=13ʳ>Ăú.6ʲČ 1 �r
SX1°Xkig�� T1ʴT3ʴT4 CďĨ
šŝŗǒ>ɿĨšŝŗǒ[ČȀ.6 Č 2 3ɹ �r��ďĨšŝ�DĨÏʉśţ�Əo_|=Dȧ
Ŵ-XʴĨϲĨěʱo_|=D̬OCʘ
CɁ8ɺO&O
UX6��Ɖʴ
�ɿĨšŝ�D
ĨϲĨěʱo
_|=D�ɯ.
<ʱN96&ʴ
ĨÏʉśţ�Ə
o_|=Dʴ²
!Á[ȧŴ.6��
4;�X>m
d� ĨÏʉśţ
�Əo_|=D
×ƚ�AʱNW
RCCʴ̬O
CʘAɁ8ɺO
&OUX6�P
.YʴʉśţNJ
ɿo_|CƉ&ʴ
ŗǒ[ȧŴ.<
!6�
���� ĨÏCë¢Aį0Wʉśţ&ʴď
Ș0WšŝAį.<DȶĪdz@œʨ[�#W
óȹŞ&Ȁą-X6��Ɖ=ʴƙN.!Ĩ¿
Ťŋ>DȤG:!<$U1ʴë¢JCʉśţ
[ƙN.!Ĩ¿ŤŋJ>:@*Wŀğ&ƽQ
UXW�
u�
ÐñųŒ�øǧ¼ă(2005). ĝĨCŷƩA$)
WȅɡCʫŋ>ɍȕšɫ�À¢ǚŞ>Cʙ
ʃʽĝĨǤDžJCʉś>!"ɐǒ%UCƨ
ɖ ȂřǢĨǽȋ, 21, 160ʵ169.
Ǭʑ� Ŝ�ǎ�ť�(2013). ĝĨǤC�´dz@
ŷƩŤŋ>ĨȰƒʘAĕ;(ĨǤo_|
Cƨɖ ƋƜƂȷŀĨɦƄ, 37, 13ʵ21.
úîǃÎ�ÓɌŌɅ�³Ƀ� ų(2016). !Z'
ƐƑĝĨA$)WÓʼnƵƂȷCīɵ>ȱ
Į―1 ʼnǵCîVȢOÏĭA:!<― Ó
ʼnƵƂȷĨȎ 9 ćĝDZɇɋƍʡ, 136
ʵ137.
� 1� ����������������
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 134
aA�T�p"¯"�E���¦=��#X>n~�N£F�
�W¶��WXº7u�X²»�Dc�r�$<���
�
�DZɇȲ�� �ļȾƿʲĝʛǥƩĝĨʳ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
½¼W¶��WX�Dc�r��
����WX�w³�
� |X���ňŧ �� ʼnŋAɉƃCĨʌCƁȢ
A¯!�ËĨƂȷƱƭ&ƈ6Aɚȭ-X�Ë
Ĩdz@ÓʼnƵƂȷ[�´dzAĸʗ0W+>A
@96�ƜĨCÓʼnƵƂȷCƉʓD¨�Cʂ
V= W��
���Ś¿N6DËĄĻ¿ȆǵCɚȭ�
�Êʖm�w�����c��]ƂȷȆǵ��
���ȆǵÏĭCƉʓ�
@µ(,*2/� '-.%r����
ōĨCȚȃ�ĐēƂ
ȷ�ĝĨǤDž�Ȃ¢
őŧ�ƋƜɡ�s�h
��
Ȃ=Å(+>Cš
ȯ�ƎƚCȵƩɐCʎ
ŧ�� ʼnƒ¨ʜCc�
�]ƂȷCĕǿčQ�
�
����7u�X²�Dc�r��
� DZɇȲ&ŨĹ.6ƌĨʌʲ¢ʘǣĘĨʌʳ
=D+XN=�əCƉʓAʮ°.6ÓʼnƵƂ
ȷ[ĨʌǜȺAĸʗ.<$V�N6ƈĨʌ Ď
ʠĨʌʳ=D��əƉʓAè.<ƈ6AÓʼn
ƵƂȷȆǵ[ɚȭ.<!W�
+0(,*2/ºx»� @µ(,*2/ºv»�
�Ļ¿ŵij>ƊɚƥÏ
�z�us_c�e
�ƄȍµǁCĕƜ
�ČƕʰCÕǦǁ
�Ƅȍ[ɣP+>
��i��Cµŧ
�ñʪDZɇC¤Ɖ
��~�uCµŧ
�ĝĨǤDžCǍÃ
�z�us_c�e
�ČƕʰCÕǦ
�yquSŠĖCÕǦ
�Ƅȍ[ƕ(+>
��i��Cµŧ
�|�m�s�h��
��~�uCµŧ
�ŶVɼVCDžÞ
¾¼?¡���t��
���� aA�T�p"¯"���¦=�
� Ƨǧʲ����ʳDȺŃɝ¹DžÞA:!<�ě�
dzĬɐdz@Ɏǒ�[îVÊX��ȺŃCįɭá��
CƱ>@Wǒ[ŵſ.<!W�Ǽ ����ʳ�
DĎʠǢɒ>c��]Ƃȷ>CưƇ[šČ.�
6ŷƩīɵCĖþ=ƂȷÝơ[NjW6QCɝ�
¹ɍǍ[żȀ.<!W�¨�AɽKWƜīɵ�
=RȺŃÏǸĒCŶVɼVDžÞ[ʐɎ.6��
�
����X>n~�N£F�
� ƄȆǸCÈijdzĝĨƁʧŻʄĥɘ�ƩC�
:= W�Ĩ¿ŧơCŭŽA:!<CÍ´dz
ƉȓAʙ0WɥƢǽȋ� H25 ʼnŋʳ[ɌW
>�ĝĨA$)WĨ¿ŧơCɝ¹CǠǛSɤ
ʭ&Ǿɠ='W�ɉƃCĝĨ=DĨ¿ŧơC
óɎá&ʄ\=!W+>RZ%W�
¿¼|Y��¢�p"¯"�E�
� ňŧ 27�28 ʼnŋAŲŐ.6ÓʼnƵƂȷȆ
ǵCŶVɼVDžÞ>4Cɝ¹êGĨ¿ŧơC
óɎáCīʠD�¨�CʂV= 96�
����M©�´�s�^j�
� �� ʽ� úʲƋ �ʷǭ ��Ǫ ��ʷġ �ʳ�
�����ʽ�� úʲƋ ʷǭ ��Ǫ ʷġ �ʳ�
����Xz{�H9Lg1Bb����
� �� ÷ � ú� � � ú ňđÐņǞ � ���ʳ�
� ��� ÷ �� ú� � � ú ňđÐņǞ ����ʳ�
ĨƚʗĤƒAĻ¿ÞƱ>Ĩ¿ɕǫ�ǵƯ[
ƕ%2��ʘƚ>ĨƚƛAŶVɼVh�u[
·Ǧ.6ȺŃÏǸĒCŶVɼV[Ʌ96��
�ŶVɼVDžÞCr��DŐƋj�_véǖC+>��
�
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 135
����p"¯"�E�Y·�
� ƜīɵCŶVɼVDžÞDʴʸʶ=ɽK6ŵ
ʓ[HN#< ƵɹC+>[ĨǤÀ¢=ÏǸ.ʴ
%:ĨǤʘ=4CŠĖ[ÌƘ.6��
� ʲʸʳŷƩCǵƯ>4Cʇŧŋ�
� ʲʹʳ�ǯ&\EX6+>JCnjɴŋ�
� ʲʺʳɶA:)6>ŝ"jc�SȹÙ�
� ʲʻʳȺǨəɽ>Ȩ÷ɝ¹Cǒƃá�
�
À¼�~��[�
�����~�
� ʲʸʳŷƩCǵƯ>4Cʇŧŋ�
�� ��
� � � ɝ¹�
ʩǵ�ʇŧ� LMʇŧ� ʇŧ='1�
g���į¢�
Ĩ¿jc��
Ĩ¿Ťŋ�
ƋƜɡ�s�
3 0 4 1
4 4 5 2
0 0 1 0
����
� � � ɝ¹�
ʩǵ�ʇŧ� LMʇŧ� ʇŧ='1�
g���į¢�
æÅĨȰ�
Ĩ¿Ťŋ�
Ĩ¿ʆȈ�
4C¥�
6 3 3 0 2
2 2 4 3 2
1 0 0 0 0
�
� ʲʹʳ�ǯ&\EX6+>JCnjɴŋ�
�� �
� � � � � ɝ¹�
ʩǵ�njɴ� LMnjɴ� njɴ='1�
Ðņ�ƴņ�
ɞ.%)�
ɤʭîȢ�
ƂȆƕ�
~�u{`�a�
5 5 4 5 4
1 2 3 4 2
4 3 3 1 4
����
� � � � � ɝ¹�
ʩǵ�njɴ� LMnjɴ� njɴ='1�
Ðņ�ƴņ�
ɞ.%)�
ɤʭîȢ�
ƂȆƕ�
~�u{`�a�
5 5 5 3 3
6 6 6 6 8
0 0 0 2 0
� ʲʺʳɶA:)6>ŝ"jc�SȹÙ�
�� �
� � � � ɝ¹�
ʩǵ�njɴ� LMnjɴ� njɴ='1�
ȺŃʗȀ�į¢�
Äȴ�z�u�
Ļ¿�ȺƣŢǺ�
ƋƜɡ�
ʲȺǨəɽʳ�
2 2 2 2 3
7 6 5 5 4
1 1 2 2 1
����
� � � � ɝ¹�
ʩǵ�njɴ� LMnjɴ� njɴ='1�
ȺŃʗȀ�į¢�
Äȴ�z�u�
Ļ¿�ȺƣŢǺ�
ƋƜɡ�
ʲȺǨəɽʳ�
1 1 1 3 5
9 8 8 5 4
0 1 1 2 1
�
� ʲʻʳȺǨəɽ>Ȩ÷ɝ¹Cǒƃá�
�� ʽǭĨǤ>ƋƜ¢ĨǤC¡džCėʴ�
� Óįʦ=Cg��xf�h��ʴăOCė�
���ʽĨ¿ʆȈ>ȺÑCŧʕJCɠɫʴ�
� Ⱥ¾SĩřţʴŶVɼVCʐɋŞ�
�Ȩ÷ɝ¹CȺŃŸǒCňđǒ � �� ʽ��� ��� ú�� � ���ʽ ������ ú��
�����[�����
� � ÐņǞCû�>ʢĨ[ʯ!ƷQWȤơ � � ~�u{`�aATWĨ¿ȰŦá � � Ĩ¿jc�Cû�SDŽȪ I�u��
Ǽ ȯôʲ2010 �rĎʠǢɒAʙ0WĨȰ>c��]Ƃȷ>CưƇ[Č96Ȩ÷dz@Ĩ
ȰCƒʘCƂȷÝơAʙ0Wīɵdzǽ��ŷ
ƩīɵʗDZǽȋ�Ȏ 3ń, pp.37-44 Ƨǧð� 2010 �rƂȷɝ¹ ȎʹǘɈɔʹǘ�
(ƘƆʚìƕ) ƄȆǸʲ2013 �rĨ¿ŧơCŭŽA:!<CÍ´dzƉȓAʙ0WɥƢǽȋ�ÈijdzĝĨ
ƁʧŻʄĥɘ�Ʃʳ
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 136
§¹¥�Tq�� #Dc�X��E����X�¤��f¸�
�5_WX��#§¹GX������q�Y�6<!��
�
�DZɇȲ�� ʔǏ�Ɠȁʲ�ĿĝĨ� ĕŊƂȷʝʳ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
½¼Q¹k«����
� ɻʼn�ƋƜCÓʼnƵƂȷCʐɋŞDɪZX�
ËĎCĝĨC�=ÓʼnƵƂȷC´țdz@Çī
&ČUX<!W�4C�=��ĿĝĨA$!
<D 2011 ʼnAĕŊƂȷʝ&Ȍ8�V�Óʼn
ƵƂȷC�ǣ>.<�ɤʭæĨȆǵ�1>�ĕ
ŊƂȷl�w��2 &ËĨʌCƈĨǤAį.
< 2014 ʼn%Uʗɨ-X<!W�ËĎdzAɅ
@ZX<!WÓʼnƵƂȷC�=��ĿĝĨC
ɤʭæĨȆǵCT"@ 4 ć (8 g�) [�ã
ÒVCɤʭɒƾ (PBL) ĒŷƩ[åƚA 3 ć
ȬVɼ0T"@ŷƩjfi���CRCD@
(�ĝ'@ǚŘC�:= W�
� ƜǽȋCįɭŷƩ= WɤʭæĨȆǵA:
!<ȗçAɢƐ0W>��ĿĝĨ=DĕŊƂ
ȷC�=�ɖɦ@?[ýQ6æÅDžÞ[�ř
>.6ĆʭDZɌĒ�:ɤʭɒƾĒCŷƩ=
V�ËĨʌCƈÊǤAijÊ-X<!W�+C
ŷƩD�ËĨʌ (ƄĨʌ�ƂȷĨʌ�ǁĨʌ�
ȣljĨʌ�ǢĨʌ�äĨʌ�ƸĨʌ�ɂĨʌ�
ŀĨʌ�ȽɆŀĨʌ�21 �Ȝ|�e��/ȝ
2700ú) CŚ¿Ȇǵ= V�ƄǢɄ÷Cd�
j=�ȝ 3�Ɨ= 3:Cs��A:!< PBL
ĒŷƩ[ĸʗ0W�+CɤʭæĨȆǵCĨȰ
ÝơD�ĨǤ]�f�uCȤơ=�æÅDžÞ
@?Cʩǵ=ƬBŧÚ796+>&Ȁ-X<
!W 1&�ÞƱ¦)N=ʙʃ.6ǽȋĖþD
@!�N6�ÓʼnƵƂȷCǵdzDöĝĨAT
VƮ� W&�ʥʑ(2008)D��ÓʼnƵƂȷC
�ɋ@ǵdzD�ĨǤ68JCĨȰÞƱ;)�
0@Z8ĨG6!>!"šƶ[ʱQW+>A
W�ĨǤ�´>.<CĨǤ>!"ɎǒAȌ
<E�0K<CƂȷƁʧD�İʖƂȷ= X�
ĝĨʝƂȷ= X�ĨȰÞƱ;)&ƖĝCɤ
ʭ>@W��3>ɽK<!W�ÞƱ;)Cīɵ
ǽȋD�ƂȷřǢĨCÑʑA$!<ǚA@-
X<!W&�ËĨdzAijÊ-X<!WÓʼnƵ
ƂȷA$)WÞƱ;)CīɵǽȋDĵ@!
4,5�4+=�Ɯǽȋ 6D��ĿĝĨA$)W
ÓʼnƵƂȷC�:= WɤʭæĨȆǵCÏC
ƖÓC 1 s�� 4 ćÑ (8 g�) CŷƩÝơ
AǕǒ[Ő<�+CŷƩ&ÊĨ.6<CÓʼn
ƵĨǤCÞƱ;)>ĨȰɐA�#Wœʨ[Ɛ
U%A0W+>[ǵdz>0W�
¾¼w�J�\¬�
� ɥƢƉǁD��×��ŕCÞƱ;)Aʙʃ
.6ȺUĨIšƶ[NjĪ='W�ȺUĨIš
ƶɛƇ 7�ATWɥƢêGĨȰɐAį0WȺ
ǨəɽAį.<d�jo�ÑƠ[Ǧ!W�Ⱥ
UĨIšƶɛƇC�±ĶŋD��Ƙȹ-JCƶ
ƽ��ǻdzĢĠř��LJ!ŝȱ��ǜȌʇŧ��Ȋ
ƪŹȋ��ʦDz->ƫ.-��Ƙȹţ�C 7:
= V�ö 5ʩǵ W�Ɯǽȋ=D�ɤʭæ
ĨȆǵCǚŘ=R W�æÅDžÞ�8CĶŋ(6
ʩǵ)[�əCĶŋAɾÛ.6�+XUC÷ɕ
41 ʩǵ[��Ë(Ő<DNU@!ʽʸ�%U
�T(Ő<DNWʽʼ�N=C 5ªǁ=ćȒ
[ƽQ6�ïɨȲ 54ú (ǪŞʽ43ú�ġŞʽ
11ú) (ƂȷĨʌ 4ú�ȣljĨʌ 9ú�ǢĨʌ
ǙǢĨȆ 5ú�áĨȆ 5ú�ƃĨȆ 5ú�ä
Ĩʌ½ÂĨȆ 11 ú�ŀĨʌĐǡǣĘŀĨȆ
15ú) [įɭAɥƢ[Ʌ96�
¿¼�~�
� ×ɽC�ȺUĨIšƶɛƇ�C 8:CĶŋ
Aį0WɥƢȤơ(�×��ŕ)êGöĶŋC
CronbachC�ºƃ[ɇ 1AȀ0(n = 48)�?
発表取り消し
-136-
P2� ĨȰšƶ�ÞƱ�
― ― 137
CĶŋR�ºƃDʱ(�¾ʬŞDʱ!RC>
ɓ#W�ö�±ĶŋŗǒCŷƩ×ŕ=Cęá
[ƨɖ0W6QA�įśC W t ƨĪ[Ʌ96ȤơD��Ƙȹţ� (¸ʽǻdz@ȹÙADȺ¾& WS�Ƙȹ= W�@?) >�æÅDžÞ� (¸ʽ¥C¢Cȱ#SšɌAį.<�ɲĆ.6VšɌ[ɓ96V0WS�ǟĄ>æÙ
.<ĨȰAîVȢQW�@?) =Ƙš@ŗǒC�Ə&Ǿɠ-X6 (Ƙȹţ:t(47) = 3.233, p < .01, æÅDžÞ:t(47) = 2.716, p < .01)�N6��Ƙȹţ�CňđÁ (2.5 Ȉŋ) &�¥C�±ĶŋCňđÁ (3.3~4.4) >ƻK<�²!+>&Z%W� � ƵA��ŕCȺUĨIšƶC�±ĶŋʘC
Ƿʙ[ɇ 2AȀ0�++=��Ƙȹţ�>�æÅDžÞ�CŗǒC�Ə[ƨɜ0W6QA��
ə 2ĶŋAȥV�ǷʙɒƠCȤơ[ÑƠ0W>��Ƙȹţ�>�LJ!ŝȱ�AǷʙ& V�
�æÅDžÞ�D�ǻdzĢĠř���LJ!ŝȱ��
�ȊƪŹȋ��ʦDz->ƫ.-�AǷʙ& W
+>&Z%96�4.<��LJ!ŝȱ�D��ǻ
dzĢĠř���ȊƪŹȋ���ʦDz->ƫ.-�
ARǷʙ& W+>&Z%96��
� ƵA��+C ćCŷƩ= @6CĨGCĦ
àD?CT"Aęá.N.6%��>!"ɲĆ
Aį0WȺǨəɽ[R>A�ĨȰɐCęá[
d�jo�ÑƠ.6�4CȤơD�ĨȰȲD
ćCɤʭæĨȆǵAT9<�ȹÞdzŝȱĒ
ĨȰJCęĭ��ĜɑdzɎǒCǝŗ��DZɇDž
ÞCšȯ��æÅĨȰCšȯ��ɤʭAîVȢ
Pšȯ�C � :CĨȰɐCęá[ţ/<!W
>Ȁą-X6�N6�+XUCȺǨəɽCɒ
ƠȤơ[ɟ.(ɌW+>ATV��Ƙȹţ�>
�æÅDžÞ�CŗǒC�ƏêG��æÅDžÞ�
>�LJ!ŝȱ�CǷʙȐCȦɕÑƠȤơ>ʙ
ʃ.<!W+>&Ȁą-X6��
À¼�[�
� ƜǽȋȤơ[N>QW>�ƜŷƩC ć��
g��C�=�ÊĨ.6<CĨǤD��Ƙȹţ�
�æÅDžÞ�&�Ə0W��æÅDžÞ�>�LJ
!ŝȱ�>CȤG:'&ŏ(@W��ȹÞdzŝ
ȱĒĨȰJCęĭ��ĜɑdzɎǒCǝŗ�@?
CĨȰƉǮ[ƈ6Aǝŗ0W��DZɇDžÞCš
ȯ��æÅĨȰCšȯ��ɤʭAîVȢPšȯ�
@?ĨȰţCęá[R6U0��ɤʭAîVȢ
Pšȯ�[ʂ.<�Ƙȹţ�[ţ/<!W+
>&Z%96��
ª®�
]�f�uAæÙ.<�-96ĨǤCǴƮA
ţɩǩ.�*N0�ƜǽȋD JSPS ȆǽɱʲJP16K16308ʳCÜŧ[ï)6RC=0�
I�u��
1òķ ɧƿU, ĕŊƂȷȜɋ, 1, 63, 2015. 2 ĴĽ ÂĞʋU , ĕŊƂȷȜɋ , 2, 73-85, 2016. 3 ʥʑʁ, ƟâĝĨÐǘ, 113-125, 2008. 4�ɊȼƄU, �ʐĝĨƂȷĨʌǽȋȜɋ, 66, 261-264, 2015. 5�ļǭȮħU, řǢĨǽȋ, 86, 2, 170-176, 2015. 6ʔǏƓȁ, ĕŊƂȷȜɋ, 3, 33-46, 2017. 7Ʋ ȿǪU, ȑǂĝĨřǢĨǽȋ, 38, 61-71,
2009. 8 ƞ�ɬÆU, ňŧ 23 ʼnǗƜǹȌƂȷl�
o�ǽȋȜɋ ɥƢǽȋ, 40, 2011.
ɇ � ȺUĨIšƶĶŋC�ºƃ>ŗǒCęá�
� ���� � ����
�%*.-�� .884 4.249 0.797 4.426 0.654 1.891! �� .829 4.008 0.994 4.063 0.868 0.690�)�$ .881 3.517 0.892 3.623 0.862 1.511�#&� .842 3.569 1.087 3.551 1.131 0.497"��� .845 3.350 1.056 3.460 1.022 1.164
'�*,�+* .950 3.704 0.977 3.789 0.866 0.573�%� .930 2.408 0.955 2.638 0.976 3.233*���� .847 3.670 0.914 3.910 0.821 2.716*
Note. * p < .01.
(���� ��
��
ɇ ���ŕCȺUĨIšƶĶŋCǷʙºƃ �� ! " # $ % & ' (
! �*.-�� .563** .284 .254 .256 .243 �.013 .243"����� .310* .287* .441** .505** .007 .368*#�)� �.128 .458** .484** .334* .679**$���� .137 .027 .016 .153%���� .674** .016 .549**&��*,�+* .108 .673**' � .185(����
Note. * p < .05, ** p < .001.
P3� ŋȮƅǁ¹ĉǁǤŌ
― ― 138
�$(!&��\_�JNq'mq09=gHO�M4D� ���
�
GǾȿȰH� ȎŜ� ȸǚ¹Ôɻ� ʒɭʣƁŇĿŋʤ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
xw�����
ȘȰ|��l@�� ťŨ{}@Ʀƹɗfȸɗ
�ɶƙV[^ôĠŋȮkı}ƤibJdôĠ
Ȉȕ�ȽadJ~A\kȗ»ǔʐfWd@ʲ
²º¢·��ǟǷW^@Ʀƹɗfȸɗ�ƴǎ
ǿiʋɶcR^ɗŮŋȮƞƺ�ʉǾW@ƁŇ
ĿŋʌŚʠDŽeƞȴōɩ�Ƚa^AƹǾȿe
l@\kƞȴōɩ�ɪuL@ƦȸôĠʲ²º
¢·�ɗŮŋȮƞƺkƴĉŽ�ȯőY~A�
ywHO�v`�
� Ʀƹɗfȸɗ�ƴǎǿiʋɶcR@ĉǁǿ
Nbĉdz{QŋȮeP~ʲ²º¢·�ƞƺ�
ȀƐW@ʅƷʣ���ʤ��hg�Ĕȯi@įʨ
iȋY{Ki@ʬʀNJƅkƞƺ�ʉǾW^A�
� ȗʨi@ȸɗkɗٵ§´�ɌŌW^Aİ
ʑǿhɇɗŘŨeI~ ���� zƊʃ�Ȫ�ʣ��ʤ
��ĔǭW@ȸLJǦ Ȟµ§´eI~ ����¹
� µ§´fW^A� ťŨʣť � Ĭúʤkȸ
LJǦ ȞkʇƢȟƺN| ���� k � µ§´k
ȸĐɗ�ħɏýʣůŏɏ¹Ċɏ¹Ăɏ¹ġɏʤ
i ɗZbƌùW^ʣįʨ:;ʤAȸĐɗkƌ
ùl@�-&+(1'��0.%(+$�'22/����
444�$-&+(1'/0.%(+$�.0&��eóʉV�dJ~
Text inspector �þǷW^A�
� ȗʩi@ȸĐɗ�ģwȸƢ�@�´�kȸ
ɯ ɿ �'22/���$.4� +"�".�)/� ʤ z �$!+(.
ʣ'22/���$))$�4$!+(.�)/�ʤ�ĔǭWdÝƅ
W^Aĩʜfh~ȸĐɗil@Ʀƹɗkƀĥ
�ĩKɾƋȳ�ʬbɌŌW^ʣįʨ:<ʤA�
� ȗʪi@ȸĐɗkƀĥ�ɅȚY~f@ǒɘ
�üŌW@ǒɅkɾƋȳkəƧ@ɘȚkɾƋ
ȳkəƧOȿȋV�~{KiɌŌW ʣįʨ:
=ʤATTel@ȸĐɗiœŻY~Ʀƹɗ��
; �� HO�VE�
�
ȉɕWhJf@ǐk@ʔŨkʠJƦƹɗkĩ
ʜqɸxhJɌŌfW^A�
� ȗʫi@ȸĐɗkƀĥʣǒɅʤkƦƹɗk
ƀĥiɲJ@ʔŨkʠJƦƹɗkĐɗʣʝȭ
ɗʤ�ĩKɾƋȳ�ʬbɌŌW ʣįʨ:>ʤA
� Ʋųi@ʔŨkʠJƦƹɗ�ɅȚY~f@
ǒɘ�üŌW@ǒɅkɾƋȳkəƧ@ɘȚk
ɾƋȳkəƧOȿȋV�~{KiɌŌW^
ʣįʨ:?ʤA
� Ò¾@ÎĬʉǾW^ʲ²º¢·�ƞƺl@
CȸɗD9CzVWJƦƹɗD9CʔŨkʠ
JƦƹɗDfJKǠ�fh~A
�
zwHi?r�
� ʉǾW^ʲ²º¢·�ƞƺ�ǷJd@ʌŚ
ʠDŽ 2 ťǵʣ109 Ì@Ǻň 43 Ì@łň 66 Ìʤ
�œɣi@Ò¿k{Ki@ƞȴōɩ�Ƚa^A
� ʨʦƦƭʭ2016 ť 11 Ƴ 17 ƦʣƷʤ
� ʩʦƒLjȏȀʭ�«°¢�º�±·ȸɗ8
� ʪʦƒLjƍŭʭ½ŃŷƧʣʌŚʠDŽƞɞʤ
P3� ŋȮƅǁ¹ĉǁǤŌ
― ― 139
� ʫʦƒLjljɁʣ45 úʤʭ � � (1) iPad kǦê@ƹƭkəƧʣ5 úʤ � � (2) e ²º¢·�ƞƺkōƥʣɅȚʤ
ʣ20 úʤ � � (3) ƹƒLjiʋY~�·�º�kĬȚ
ʣ20 úʤ � Ò¿@ʲ²º¢·�ƞƺkɅȚȦǁf@Ľ
ʀLJŌɐʟʣȸLJ¹ƦƹɗLJŌʤkȦǁfk
ǖɬ�ȽKA {w~$(!&�HO�M4D�
{wxwmS��Zt�
� e ²º¢·�ƞƺiĘ}Ȥ�_ȝ 1 ¸Ƴų
i@ȸLJ 2 Ȟ�ęʟW^ǵŴ 55 ÌibJd@
»ǐɐʟkȦǁʣ³º��·�@³�¢·�@
²���·�@»ǐğɉʤf@e ²º¢·�
ƞƺʣȸɗ@Ʀƹɗ@ƦȸğɉʤkȦǁfk
Ȃʋʋã�ȋYf@ȿ 1 k{Kih~A
� ȿ 1 {}@ȸLJk³º��·�f e ²º¢
·�ƞƺkȸɗ¹ƦȸğɉiūʳÃȐŨkȂ
ʋʋãOɕx|�~A\�ÒĽȂʋʋãOɕ
x|�hJkl@e ²º¢·�ƞƺOɗŮi
ǯčW^ykeI}@ȸLJkúʃfœŻWh
JʀúOI~Tf@u^ e ²º¢·�ƞƺf
ȸLJfiµ§´ŠOIa^^xfȯL|�~A {wywJNqS>��Zt�
� e ²º¢·�iĘ}Ȥwȝ 5 ¸Ƴāi@Ʀ
ƹɗLJŌ 3 ȞʣʠDŽĎLjȐŨµ§´ʤ�ęʟ
W^ 105 ÌibJd@\kȦǁʣƠɗ@Ƣǜ@
ɗŮ@ɇȹkƀĥ@ȿɋ@Ǩʼn@ȩğŶǩdzʤ
f e ²º¢·�ƞƺkȦǁfkȂʋʋã�ȋ
Yf@ȿ 2 k{Kih~A
� ȿʩ{}@Ơɗ@Ƣǜ�ʏQƦƹɗLJŌf
e ²º¢·�ƞƺiūʳÃȐŨkȂʋʋãO
ɕx|�~Ae ²º¢·�ƞƺkƦƹɗfƦ
ƹɗLJŌfkȂʋʋã_RehQ@e ²º¢
·�ƞƺkȸɗfƦƹɗLJŌfiȂʋʋãO
ɕx|�dJ~ǩOǝȀV�~A |w����
Ò¾@»ʀĩʜlǓ~ykk@Ʀƹɗfȸ
ɗfkȂʋʋãOɕx|�dM}@ƦȸôĠ
e ²º¢·�ɗŮŋȮƞƺO»ŌȐŨƴĉe
Ia^TfOȉɕV�^AÎĬTk{KhȦ
ǁOŶ|�^kl@ʉǾW^ʲ²º¢·�ƞ
ƺiMJd@CzVWJƦƹɗDO@CȸɗD
fCʔŨkʠJƦƹɗDfkʊ�Ę}Əb@
I~ȑkCÃʊɇɗʣinterlanguageʤDǿhű
ă�ǁ^W^Tfi{~ykfȯL|�~A [ [1] Ťƅ 28¹29 ťŨƁŇĿŋƞȴƜʗäɸÈ � ÈLjkćƅ�ęR@ƞȴÖǻɛ¹ƞȴ��
�·ŎkďĄkyf@ǜƢŋʀ¹ʌŚʠDŽ �ßi@ȸɗƞȴ�·�º¹İʑƞȴƛ Ƙ�·�ºfôĠȈȕ�ȽadJ~A
7hI]�
1) ʅƷðƧʣ2006ʤCID kɃǩeĿŋƞȴ � ����·Y~ʡȅįʭʲ²º¢·�kɧ� � åɍµ�¯º®�´kƖdžDEƦƹƞȴʠŋ � Øȗ 22 ĬòİĿØɟǧɝƢʓFp.337-338 2) ƊʃǹȜŀʣȪʤ(2013)EȸɗÿɼŨƐnj � CEFR-J �� ¥��FĿæʞƱŧ
n �� mS��Zt�
ny� JNqS>��Zt�
P3� ŋȮƅǁ¹ĉǁǤŌ
― ― 140
Eep-�G:��$"��GY�8�d��
�2AKC.FT��),��
ʰȽIR~ʱ�
GǾȿȰH� ½¾ÍźʣÃʀĿŋʤ�
ʰȽIR~ ɦ� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
xwjL�ba�
�²£�flʥǯŌkƒLjkIJįʧ, / e
I~ʣ�..#1���3*$�����$(0����ʤAʣǯi�
³�kķǦiǦƎW^ʤ�²£�ilƒLj
kÿɼȀnjʥƒLjɉǻʥЃLjkNJƅʥƅȫ
Ɏâ���¬hgOƧɋV�~AT�|kž
ĸOʥƒLjiɮʁ�ÁLŋȮkƤĢŽ�ȋY
IJįkNJƅɁȟfh~ATköʥʣ ʤÿɼȀ
njfɎâk»ɥŽʥʣ!ʤɎâiʋY~ɋɳk
ƧȄŽlʥôiƞȴkńŭŽfóŤŽ�şĝ
Y~AƹȒlʥȺȰO �� ťŨiōƥW^ƅ
ȫɎâkńŭŽfóŤŽƜĪkĘ}Ȥv�Ȣ
ÏY~ykeI~A�
ywFT��$"��Uo�
ɜǃœɣfW^ƒLjlʥɇɗŋñʈ �¹�ʣÒ
¿��¹�ʤeI~AƒLjfyi ťǵĢRŹ
æȏȀeI}ʥŋȮöŏilɶȨŽOIa^A
� lƪƶȏȀʥ� lȎƶȏȀeI~ʣƒLjƭʊ
ʧĬơlƒLjfy �� úʧ ĬʤA��
� � k�²£�ʣ�²£� �ʤilʣ ʤƒLj
kÿɼȀnjfʣ!ʤƅȫɎâ���¬�ƧɋW
^Aļ×vi�º�úƿ�ōƥWʥƅȫɎâ
iʋY~ĩʜǩ�ǞJùW ʣųɳʤAúƿȦ
ǁ�ķiɎâ���¬�ĻưWʥĻưöŏ�
� k�²£�ʣ�²£� �ʤiĖƩW^A�²
£� � ilʣ"ʤƒLjɉǻʥʣ#ʤЃLjkNJƅʥ
ʣ$ʤƞĨfkƕɆƤǜiʋY~ɋɳ�ɴĆW
^AȎƶȣÆųi�º�úƿ�ōƥWʥƅȫ
ɎâiʋY~ĩʜǩ�ǞJùW^ʣųɳʤA�
�
zwFT�3ubW�Eep-�
� �¹� \�]�kƒLje � bkÿɼȀnj�Ɍ
ŌW^ʭʣ ʤɇɗŋiʋY~ķȊǿhȆɠ�
Ŷ~ʥʣ!ʤŋ�_Ȇɠ�ȶúkɇȹeəƧe
P~əƧĄ�ɫibR~ʥʣ"ʤɇɗŋǿhĩ
ʜ�ȶúeúƿeP~úƿĄ�ɫibR~A
T�| � bkÿɼȀnjkɼƅŨOƅȫiĖƩ
V�~{Kʥ� el � bkɎâʙȀ�ɌŌW
^AɎâʙȀf\kɌŌǴǹʥɎâķǦfɎ
âƤǜiʋY~žĸʣʯ´º¥³��ʤlʥ
òd�²£� � iƧɋW^A�
� ʨ�ƒLjöɛʜʣ�� ǩʤʭòdkƒLje 6
� ĬkƒLjöɛʜ�ùʜW^AɛʜkɹȽi
lƒLjeŋȮW^Ȇɠ�ǟǷY~ŹɁOI}ʥ
ǟĊl¨�N�´º¦ĐÙeȽ��^ʣ¨�
ʧ�´º¦úRil²·�¬ʋơ�ǷJ^ʤA
ɛʜkɹȽi{} � bkÿɼȀnjkɼƅŨO
ʠu~fJKāƖkķʥɛʜiĘ}Ȥ�_ŋ
ǵiʨƒLjibP ǩ�ÁL^ʣ ǩ5 Ĭ
ƒLjʯ�� ǩʤA�
� �����ʣ�� ǩʤʭƒLjeŋȮW^öŏ
kɁȝʣ����ʤ�ƒLjĽɛʜfW^ʣÿ
ɼȀnjʣ ʤ¹ʣ!ʤiœŻʤA����kƓǩi
l´º¥³���ǷJ^A ǀk����k
ǥǩl � ǩʥȩƖùǀơl ŋƶʊi ǀʥ
ɷʊiƖùěȵhĒȒơl ǀfW^ʣ� ǩ
5 Ĭʯ�� ǩʤA�
� ��ĚʛǾȿʣ�� ǩʤʭ�´º¦f¨�ek
ĚʛǾȿ� ĬZbōƥW^A¨�ʧ�´º
¦úRfǾȿʚkǙŌilʥ²·�¬ʋơ�
ǷJ^AǦêƶʊl ɷʊʥǾȿƭʊl ú
fW^AǾȿelɇɗiʋY~ĩʜ�ƑSʥ
ƒLjeŋȮW^Ȇɠ�ǷJdĩʜ�úƿY~
Tf�ǘx^ʣÿɼȀnjʣ"ʤiœŻʤAĚʛ
ǾȿkƓǩil´º¥³���ßǷW^AÂ
P3� ŋȮƅǁ¹ĉǁǤŌ
― ― 141
ǾȿfyƲʠŶǩl � ǩeI}ʣ� ǩ5
Ĭʯ�� ǩʤʥ�º¬iÁL^ǩơ�çÌkĚ
ʛǾȿŶǩfW^ʣàʭ�º¬kǩơO �
ǩʯ�º¬kòNJƅĨkŶǩO � ǩʤA�
� ��ǯýǩʣ� ǩʤʭƒLjÃkȶÄǿhǾɇ
fƒLjĽekȶÄǿhɧĩlʥÿɼȀnjʣ ʤ¹
ʣ!ʤkɼƅ�ćR~fȯL^A{adʥT�
|kȽǪil Ĭ ǩʥ� ǩueȠȓěȵh
ǯýǩʣʯɀćǿhŶǩʤ�ÁL^A�
� ¾ɋ � ʙȀkğɉŶǩʣƲĿ � ǩʤ�ƅ
ȫɎâiǷJ^AÃʀĿŋkƅȫl �:�� ǩ
kțĮ�Ę~^xʥ�� ǩÒ¾kŶǩl ��
ǩfWdƈa^ʭ� Ɏâ�����:�� ǩʮ� Ɏâ�
����:�� ǩʮ� Ɏâ�����:�� ǩʮ� Ɏâ�����
:�� ǩʮ � ǩÒ¿lĐÙÀɕŌA�
{w�(�1Q � ��$"��G>�
� òęɟȰkƒLjƅȫfĞɎâʙȀekŶǩ
�ʄǿ�º�ʣ� = �ʤʥ»ʀkŋǵN|Ŷ^
ɋɳũƒLjɎâʣ� = ʤf�·�¤°ºö
ŏʣ� = ʤ�ɧǿ�º�fWdúƿW^A � Ò¿ʥúƿN|Ƨ|Nfha^Ähĩʜǩ
�ɋɳY~AʣʤǯýǩkğɉŶǩiœY~
ŰʘĄOʥŭûÇŌÒ¾iʠQhadJ^ʭ
úƟəƧdzʯ�ʢʣ����� ������ʤAʣʤ�
���ƸƖùʣ����Ŷǩʯ�ʤkŋǵl
� ġJ^OʥTkö � ġOĐÙ�DzŶWd
J^ATkǰǛlʥÿɼȀnjʣ ʤ¹ʣ!ʤiʋ
Y~ɎâkńŭŽfóŤŽ�Ú¿V[~Au
^ʥ�·�¤°ºN|ʣ�ʤǾȿǦêiĔĆW
hJuuĚʛǾȿŶǩ�Ŷ^ŋǵOJ^Tf
OüƧW^ʣƐƚÕơʯʤATk{Khŋǵ
kŊılʥÿɼȀnjʣ"ʤkɎâkńŭŽfó
ŤŽ�Ú¿V[~A¾ɋkĩʜiœøY~^
xʥ� kƅȫɎâ���¬�Ò¿kɵ}Ļư
WʥĻư��²£� � iĖƩW^A�
� �ƒLjöɛʜʣ�� ǩʤʭĻưhWA�
� �����ʣ� ǩʤʭǀk����kǥǩ
� � ǩiĻưW^AÞ[dƓǩǷk´º¥³
���ƜŌW^A\kÐkƼÕlʥĻưhWA�
� ��ĚʛǾȿʣ ǩʤʭǾȿkůũ�çÌǾ
ȿʥǾȿĬơ� ĬʥǾȿƭʊ� � úqfĻ
ưW^AÞ[dƓǩǷk´º¥³���ƜŌ
W^A\kÐkƼÕlʥĻưhWA � ��ǯýǩʣ ǩʤʭǯýǩk¾ʍ� ǩf
Wʥʂǩ�ĻưW^ʭƒLjÃkȶÄǿhǾɇ
ʣ Ĭ �� ǩʤʥƒLjĽekȶÄǿhɧĩʣ
Ĭ ǩʤAu^ʥ� ǀȀk����ƖùʣƲĿ
ǩʤ�ɎâœɣiɴĆW^A�
� Ɏâ���¬kĻưi{}ǯýǩkğɉŶ
ǩqkŰʘĄOÚ¿Wʥ����ƸƖùǰƂ
ekĐÙĘŶlĭʔfha^AĚʛǾȿib
Jdl��Å}ĩʜiœŻY~»Ƥʥŋǵk
ɤƍ�ȯƃWǾȿĬơ�Ǣ|W^A |w�(�1Q � ��$"��G> � 1 ŨȀfĠNjkƤǜe�º�úƿ�ōƥW
^ʣ^_WʥɋɳũƒLjɎâl � = ʥ�·�
¤°ºl � = �ʤA����ŶǩO � kǰƂe
ĐÙ�DzŶW^ŋǵkơlʥʨġueǢŗW
^ʣƸƖùl � ġʤAƣ^hĩʜfWdʥ�
���kƓǩķǦOƯƫfkƐƚOIa^
ʣɋɳũƒLjɎâe ÕʤATkƐƚ�ęRʥ
ȎŋƶiƖùV�^����N| �� ǀ�²
·�¬ɾùWʥ÷ƓǩW^A÷ƓǩȦǁ�ȗ
ĬȀkƓǩȦǁfǖɬW^fT�ʥ�� ǀÃ
� ǀʣ��ʢʤkĒȒeòɎâʙȀkƓǩȦǁ
O»ȷW^AǓ}k � ǀkĒȒelʥ bk
ɎâʙȀeƓǩȦǁOǼhadJ^ATk�
µOƯƫŽkîeI~fÓŌWʥT�| b
kʙȀiʋY~´º¥³��kɋɳ�ƜŌW
^A�� k � elʥ¾ɋkĻư�ƥW^Ɏâ
���¬f�²£��ßǷÃeI~A�
�
}wB_I]�
���� �� ���� �"���� ���� �� ������ ��� �������
���������� ��� � � �� ��������� ���
����������� �������������� �� ��!����!������
���%��������������"��!���������������$�������
� �#�����
P3� ŋȮƅǁ¹ĉǁǤŌ
― ― 142
�k5a TA�df6�@.^'TAls'<=/+��4R
�P*<=�2AX�# (%Ic��?r,� �
GǾȿȰH� ÃƻʇĜʣƾËĿŋ�ĿŋȩğƞȴȈȕ�·�ºʤ�
ŝǸƮǂʣƾËĿŋ�ĿŋʎȩğƢčȈȕȏʤ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
xw�����
ƹĸĤkȀǿl@ŵƽk´º��·¶º�
ʣùǏ����zµ�°ʂšhgʤkvh
|Z@ȶ|kŔʈŽ�ǟNW^Ljċʣµ�°
kÝƅɀćzɡɝqkɽŨhÏñhgʤ�
yÄÛǿiȽhK��º�·�����·�
ʣCȵĊǿ TADfĦpʤ�ȤȬǿiǟǷW^
Ȧǁ@ŭɒƒLjkśæǵz TA ȶɫ@\Wd
ĿŋòÛiœWd@gk{KhŰʘOǵu�
^kN�ȢÏY~TfiI~A
ƾËĿŋel���ťŨN|Ƣȏťǵ�œ
ɣfY~ŹæƒLjfWd@ñŋȁųkȗ ŋ
ƶȀiCķȊǧȮDfJKƒLj�řʉWdP
^A� ť@TkķȊǧȮkƅǁ�ǟNW@
{}PxȡNhƐŕ�ȽKrQCûťǐ�«
¡º´ƢȏDfJKƒLjOʉŅV�^AƾË
ĿŋiñŋW^Ƣȏ»ʝ@Éʝ@½ʝkŋǵ
���� ġÜ}�œɣfWd@ƒLjƍŭƞĨk
ŔʈŽ�ǟNW^£²���ɢNh �� Ò¾
kƒLjOʉɟV�dJ~A�²�ƐŌeśæ
Y~ƒLjOǙx|�dJ^ķȊǧȮfǼh}@
ûťǐ�«¡º´Ƣȏel@ƐŌV�^ �ʳ
kƒLjkÃN|ŋǵOȶúkʋŸiğ�
[dśæY~ƒLj�ɾƋeP~{Kiha^A�
ķȊǧȮelŋǵçBkʋŸfƞĨkŔʈ
úʃkʊi«�ª��OɨT}zYJfJK
ȇƆOIa^A\k^xƞĨkŔʈŽiIu
}ǯčY~TfhQŋǵkʋŸiI~ȐŨu
N[d@ŦQÌƢȌØȏŋǿh�ºªeŋȾ
Ȉȕ�ufxV[@ǾȿV[~fJa^ƒLj
Osf�geIa^A\�iœWûťǐ�«
¡º´ƢȏelŋǵOƒLj�ɾƋeP~^x@
ĞƞĨkŔʈúʃiI~ȐŨɪvɰ�_KL
e@ŋȾɝƢiǦX~ŖɝƢkĶȘ�ɛWd
J~AÒ¿@Tk{KhȈȕźĢij�«iM
R~CȵĊǿ TADkǟǷà�ȢÏWdJQA hM@ƬťŨkȗ 9 ĬȈȕĿØel@ȗÉ
ĸĤȰOCûťǐƞȴkɧĢ¾iĢR^��
º�·�����·�kďì 7ƾËĿŋEû
ťǐ�«¡º´ƢȏFkōɩàDfʜWdĸ
Ĥ�Ƚha^A\Tel@TA ʊkɶƙ�ä
ɸY~^xkƞĨé¹TA ȶɫkŞŀ�ȢÏ
W^AÎťŨl@\KWdďì�Y~{Ki
ha^CȵĊǿ TADOy^|YĉǁiǬǩ
�ŭd~AÒ¿@śæǵ¹TA ȶɫ¹Ŀŋò
Ûkʚi@œɣUfi\kĉǁ�ɝX~A
yw@.^��4R�
ȈȕźĢij�«el@ƞĨȶɫkŔʈiŪ
PbRdŋĩkķȊ�ƞL~TfOeP~T
fOƞĨékʠJ®�§º�±·ibhO~
»Ƥ@ŋĩkñĚiȖa^mN}kśæǵi
œWdʠŨiŋȾǿh�·��WdWuJ
O`eI~ATTe@śæǵfƞĨfkʊk
ǍǣW�ƶŲV�~kO@CȵĊǿ TADeI
~AƞĨf¼Œižĸôƴ�W^KLe@ś
æǵOȿʖǿhɜrŋȮelhQCȈȕD�
ȽL~{KiɖŕW^}@ĞśæǵkCĩJD
OŋȾǿ¹ȌØǿiƔǘY~âèkI~yk
ih~{KDžǗŬQœɑ�W^}Y~ŹɁO
I~A�
el@Tk{KhCȵĊǿ TADǟǷl@
śæǵkŋnigk{KhŰʘ�ĕtWdJ
~kNACȵĊǿ TADŕñkāųʧƴǫeŋ
P3� ŋȮƅǁ¹ĉǁǤŌ
― ― 143
Ȯƅǁ�ēŐiǖɬY~Tfl@�º�kĩ
ʜz�²�ʊeɛʜOǼh~TfN|ʔWJA
^_W@śæǵqk�·�º�ɜǃiMJd
l@ŖɝƢĶȘzǾȿiʑWd TA fkƀɂ
ÊƗOʕţiűȖa^fkƀɂOľQv|�
^AƞĨiĆLd TA OƄǽǿhɚȰʧȱȼ
fWdŊıY~Tf�ƀɠWd¼ŒiȖɝz
LJɍ�ȽhK{Kiha^śæǵkņOĴʊ
ɂL~A
zwTAls��4R�
TA �ċx~ʎǵkľQlƞȴȈȕȲ�Ţ
ƵWdJ~O@ƞȴȈȕȲqkŻČkʑi@
ȈȕLjȫfI�[dƞȴLjȫ�ĩ��~Tf
OĹLdPdJ~Aûťǐ�«¡º´Ƣȏk
TA Ljċ�ɵWdƞȴiŹɁh��´�ɫi
ȃR|�@ƞȴLjȫiȤvɰx~{KhìP
OeP~h|m@\��ǑɱY~ʎǵlŗh
QhJA el@CȵĊǿ TADfWdkȥʟl@TA
ȶɫi@gk{Khĉǁ�ǵvùW^kNA
Tkǩ�ȉNx~^x@TA qkɧǿhɋɳ
ũk�·�º�ɜǃ�ōƥW^AúƿiʑW
dl@Ğɋɳ����³NJƅʣúʝʤW^A
\kȦǁ@ƞȴqkʋŸOʠu}ƞȴƜĪq
kõÛǿhɂɅ�Əb{Kih~ëĢOv|
�^sN@ȶɫkȈȕǟĊqkėȔʣCśæǵ
iœŻY~ɺȐe@DZJƀĥeŔʈfY~IJ
ĵzƭÑÒĽqkǴɅOǡua^Ȧǁ@ȶɫ
kȈȕ�ºªiƣ^hȃſOKu�^DzCŖ
ɝƢĶȘkĔȯifżJ@ȶúOƱJdJ~
ɝƢ�ĬɄW^Ao_�śæǵiƄǽǿhɚ
Ȱ�ſŌ[{fɇadJ~Ƈā@ȶúkɝƢ
OƹŭiÇſV�~ĖɝiœŻePdJ~k
N�Ɯxd����Y~Tfiha^Dhgʤ
�ƑS~ĺy»ŌơIa^ʣĸĤƭil@ŋ
ƶāfŋƶųfe@TA igk{Khƀɠk
ĻčOǵu�^kNiʋY~{}ɓȡh�º
��ĸĤeP~ÇŌeI~ʤA
{w<=/+��4R�
yafy@íȍhȈȕȰʣkđʤOíȍh
CȵĊǿ TADflʍ|hJAȶɫkŔʈ�
ǡx~ʦʦʦ
ƭƶi@śæǵkʋŸ�ŦS~ʦʦʦ
{Kh
œŻOǘx|�~ TA LjċlǙWdŏƨhy
kelhQ@TA LjċiăQƭʊOĹL~T
feȈȕƭʊOǢŗWNjhJAT�el@
UQ»ʀkƞȴǮŸNbīǷhʎǵiáŊY
~Tffh}@CȵĊǿ TADOĀŨfWdƏ
ȨWiQJA\Te@TA ɟȮØʣŋƶāʤ@
TA Ʀɔșk�º¬�¦³�ɵX^žĸôƴ
fďLjʣŋƶÃʤ@TA i{~ƀɂÊƗØʣŋ
ƶųʤfJa^ǎØ�ɌR@ƅąÈàʣ��
¦²����ʤzŁƝÈàʣƞɊʤkôƴ
iĈx^A � \kȦǁ@ǵu�^kO@TA ɼOßf
hadȶǾǿiÝƅW^ETA �©º�¥�
�FeI~A´º��·kʀúkª¢°�´
či{}Ljċĉdzč�į~ffyi@ŋǵq
k� £��iʑWdɐȽʆɘ�W^ōɩà
�ôƴY~Tfe@ưh~Şŀ�ĦnNR~
öŏfhadJ~A�©º�¥��l@Ǖť
ŨƜɈV�dM}@ť�ȥ~UfiöŏOï
ōWdJQůeǐťŨiȧƉV�dJQTf
ih~ATKWd@ȤȬčV� CȵĊǿ TAD
OƏȨěȵhůeȨJdJQTfl@Ŀŋò
ÛifadyɦǶeI~fJL~_�KA
|w����
Cûťǐ�«¡º´ƢȏDl@2017 ťŨO
ōƥ 3 ťȀiI^}@ƹĸĤeȢÏY~yk
�ģx@ŗWZbƅǁiʋY~�º�OȻȓ
V�dPdJ~AÎųl@ŪPȨP@�º�
kėʓ¹úƿf\�iķcQƜĪiĄ�ñ�
~»Ƥ@{}ʇƶǿhƅǁkǤŌʣƞĨih
a^î TA kƞȴ¹ȈȕǟĊiCȵĊǿ TAD
ȥʟOgk{KiǟNV�dJ~kNhgʤ
fJa^ƣ^hɛʜiyĘ}ȤwŹɁOI~
fȯLdJ~A �
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 144
Yo�|��´ ±��
���'��"%§!�
�
4ȇɠɋ5� ȻšȌɗ¯šˌǩˎƭÀŇʶļŇˏ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
»º�n�´ �V¡y��
ƸŬŭjl-òŬǖƩɏUùǀ-Źǀqʗ
FTdmCVU-WZj8XŇǿ<���
Hmēɑƃ<ˊ7Z;¼ǫqɞ:8VHmX
;U-ŇǿʠZǴǡqƒƣFj8VÿfN.
LZȺLJ-ſÞțȋU6mòŬǖƩɏțȋZ
ĊÏđżYəĀHmŇǿ[-ʺɒYRX<m
ēɑƃ<ˊ7CV<ȓɳU=N. ¼º� o[�Yo�|�������
ǕũZ¹Y[-ȇɠqɞpXAn\XkX
7ĦYÌrOl-6m7[-¬ °�ZƢð
ƲYÌeÖ<ɣknN.Cn[-ȇɠZNf
YſɢXǮâ<EnT7m;W8;-6m7
[-¬ °�ÔƊ<ʛrU7m;W8;qȓ
ɳF68CVUƨĤðǃmʦñ<6mj8Y
ƂpnN.�
ǂŇZIJĖ[-y°�®|¦®��-ƭą
ȘȦĕȞŃĠÍǥĂYƥpQT7mŇǿ[ʺ
ɒ<ŖX7.LCU-ÂŬ[-ǥĂYʲpQ
T7m;W8;q-ʽƠȦZʸYŇǿYɌ?
OAUX?-ŃĠÍq� °�FT7mƩɍ
ĠYgȓɳFTdN.�
� cN-� ĘùŹZ~©�ɁƊUɞQT7m
�®�§°�°ƞǏqŝÞF-ĊÏđżYɕ
mŇǿYgŇŬǁUZʺɒɋ[ŖX7.NO-
Cn[�®�§°�°ƞǏqŝÞFNi9ɤ
øȊXļŇǿǥqʕmCV<U=mj8YX
QNZU[X?-gVgVɤøǙF7ǿǥq
ʕmCVZU=mŇǿ<LZj8Xțȋqŝ
ÞFNOAVƂpnm.� �ºYo�|��-C3�Kr�D3- fP
!N²¹�
1 Ŭǖùǀ¹[-ʚ±Ħ[~©�ZŇǿʠ
V˅qĖpJmCV<ēɑU6m.F;F-
ĹÌdǀʱ¹[LZǔÍ<ľpnĹÌd¹Y
;XlĸŎHmŇǿgǼnm.cN-1 Ŭǖ
Źǀ[-œÊƩĠYjmòŬǖƩɏ[ɞQT
:kI-ĺʦYŃɬFT 1 ~©� 40-50 Áȝ
ŭZɤǓUòŬǖƩɏqɞQT7m.ŹǀY
éQTƴ7ǛʷU-ùǀZòŬǖƩɏƗŵƩ
ĠYjmʽƠqŋƱFT7m<-ȋZùUʺ
ɒFT7?ŇǿYŒFT-ȌƠƏRƎ<X7
ǴǡU6m.CZʽƠZŋƱǴǡqƒƣFN
³U-ɦ ƠȊYŇǿʠYt�°�qɞ8Å-
ƠɩǔÍZX7ǴǡU6m. Ňǿʠ[-CZʽƠZȌŹY 2 ŬǖÇʴé
ōHm�¢Z{v�®�YðũF-�¢qɣ
ŇFʽƠqĒAT-12 ƽć\Y[éō¼ŊZ
�¢qǟŊHm.NO-�¢[ſÞțȋU[
X7ZU-�¢YékX7ŇǿgŖƫX<k
ņīHm. CncU[-U=mOA�¢YƍŜHmj
8YŇǿY[Ąf-ƩĠY[ŇǿZĒAén
qŴ?ÚFT=N.NO-�¢éō<ǟcQ
TÇʴZŇǿZǴǡcU[ĆñYƖE9kn
T7X;QNŋƄ<6m.�¢YƍŜFT7
X7Ňǿq-œÊƩĠUɣT7?ÒöqǑȫ
Hmſɢ<6m. œÊƩĠ<-�¢ƍŜŇǿÇĺYƗŵHm
ŇǿqĴhFTgk9mj8Y-LZNfZ
ʻĨǝÔlZŢĽq[GfN. ċP-œÊƩĠ±Á6NlZŇǿƫ;k-
œÊƩĠ<ɣT7;XAn\XkX7Ňǿƫ
qǞf-ŋʸY[êīȭŇǿZǴǡ<ƒƣE
nT7X7ǴǡqļŇįɞʦYɵƵFT7m.
ƩĠYjQT-2-4 ŬǖZ�¢Zéōˎ īōˏ
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 145
Áƫ<CnYǬNX7ƩĠZIJĖ[-Ňîɤ
ȝ³ſɢXŇǿʽɹˎʔŇȦYý9-ʛȲ-
ĈǏYʲpmgZˏZñƗh¤®�°VFT
�¢YékX7ŇǿVŊǀȊYʽɹHmXW
ZʲplqǞfT7m.
NO-LnUg-ĊÏđżVʲÙZX7¤
®�°öŭZIJĖ[¤®�°ƩĠZåYŊǀ
ȊYʽɹYǃmŇǿ[ŖX7.cN7QNr
éQN�¢Y˅q6kpEX?XmŇǿgɡ
ƫņīHm.C87QNŇǿYR7TƴǀY
ŒƀU=mj8XÄȸdZǑȫ<ǞfknT
7m.
�º|�\UGgX®{QZI�a¶�
� ŋʸYǕũ<PYXmŇǿ_Zt�°�
qɣmV-CnkZŇǿYR7T[½ăř;
kʼɱXWU�®�~�qFT-ƞǏ_Zð
ũqÚFNl-òŬǖƩɏƗŵƩĠVZʽƠ
qĄfT7m.NO-ƸÂZŇǿ[ʼɱYð
j8VFX7�°�<Ļ?-ƹʱq;AT7
múY[ÔǏ<ʛrU7X7.cN-òŬǖ
ƩɏZIJĖ[cOŎƶU6m<-2 Ŭǖjl
³YXmVƩĠVZʽɹZNfY[ƩĠVZ
t ZɸƬ<ſɢYXm.½ăɍZɿƗʐǪ
ZNf-òŬǖƩɏYR7Tg-œÊƩĠ<
ɔkƗŵ~©�ZŇǿY�®�~�HmŶq
ČøVU=X7;-œÊƩĠʱU�®�®�
�ZŶƊYđl;;QT7m.
� Ňǿ[ǙɷĺǥĂUļ=?ƊʮHmZU-
ŇîZĕȞŃĠÍǥĂYčýFT7mŇǿZ
ƒƣg-Ʃɍĉã³Z�°¡Z±RU6m.
ß/ZŇǿZǴǡqƒƣHm³UgʩɢX�
s~�°U6m.
�º·j<92?F7�� ��g�ym�#
s£�
� ǂŇȹĥŇʦU[ 2009 ŬjlʼŅ °�
�xªyqŔéF-ǼƹǰU[-
Salesforce.com Z CRM �©���x°£
(CRM [ Customer Relationship
Management Zȅ)³YCnqśʰFT7m.
Cn[±ÁZŇǿZƊʮqɡƫZƩɍĠUɣ
T7?gZU-đŲçZˇŌqɡƫZȗĠ<
ɣT7?ÄȸdqļŇYʏȀFNgZU6m.
DP õʠYɕmƊʮqdNlƼȷȊY DP Y
õʠFT7m;W8;Ʃɏ³ZƊLJqȖHw
��®�VFTgŇÞ °��xªy[ƾā
U6l-LZŇǿZƊʮYɡƫZƩɍĠ<ʲ
pmCV<Ňî CRM ZÄȸdqƧ9T7m.
� ŴöȊY±ÁZŇǿqdzŊZƩɍĠZƗŵ
YU=X7VHn\-CZŇǿYʲpmƩɍ
Ġ<ſɢXƄıqëƾFTLZŇǿZƊʮq
ɣňmÅX7.CZIJĖ-ʢ?;kɣňmȝ
ŭUɗ7Ňǿ<Ļ7gZZ-±ưU-ǝ<R
7NƹY[;XlǨ÷XǴǡY6mŇǿgņ
īHm.1 ŬùǀZòŬǖƩɏZʸY-ß/
ZŇǿZǴǡqƒƣF-ƍɣVFTǚH`=
Ƅı[-ŇǿƚŔɸƻV[óYʽƠɭʬV7
8IJƍYɭéU=mZU-CZɭéqÚFT
7=N7.CZj8XƄıqƒƣF-ɭʬY
ǚJmCV[-ƩĠVŇǿZʋʺ<ɃcmȺ
LJUg6l-·ɋZʱY[Ŵ7ȍʲʲÙ<6
mVƂpnm.
�"H@5);H1BFp�I���°®�
� ƸŬjlǂNjȊYß/ZŇǿZ�°�qƒ
ƣFñdžq[GfN.ǂŬ[�°�ZƒƣZ
ʟȝUƩĠVŇǿZʋʺqɃfmŢĽqEk
YơFʛfmſɢ<6mVɊ9T7m.ļ=
Xɷ˄[ŨƿYɐɓkcJTéŇHmŇǿZ
¥�u�°�¨®qȾƙF-éŇŹLnqE
kY³ę;J-¸ɞFT-Ǚɷ-ǙɷĺZǥ
ĂUļ=?īŇ¹YƊʮEJmCVU6m.
CZǰ-éŇŹƴ7ǛʷUļ=?дHm¥
�u�°�¨®YR7TưȨqVmſɢ<6
mVŻǃ;kɳɼFT=N.LCUƯŬŭU
[-�°�«ª°�°���ȒÞq 1 Ŭù
ǀZòŬǖƩɏZ¹YʦñȊYđlʒe¼Ŋ
U6m.CZȒÞqĒANŇǿʠ<ļ=?Ɗ
ʮF-ǖZŇŬZŇǿʠZùYȈIJHmƲ<
ǃmCVqˆQT7m.
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 146
Yo�|����b��ª�z�_�v���� g��h���"�Yo�|�'l¬��
�
4ȇɠɋ5� DŽ� Û»ˎʫǠŢǏļŇˏ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
»º��"�¸a¶w«���¹ ūƊ 26 ŬZƭʦțŇȎZɸLj 0ˎŇǿZ¹
ʖʔŇhÌŇȦZǴǡYR7T1ˏ YjmV-
Ňǿˎȑļ-ˊœqěeˏZŬʱʔŇǹ[-
2.65ˍU6QN.cN-¹ʖʔŇZºɢXǽ
ȂVFT-0ŇǏµƜ1<6BknT:l-ˊ
ljVļŇY:AmƩɏZ}¦��YŇǿ<ʣ
ƀU=T7X7ēɑƃ<ƚƦEnT7m.L
FTLZŒȨVFT-ƯéǿqŒɾVHmɀ
ĖȊƩɏ��©£ˎòŬǖƩɏˏqơʛ<
ſɢU6mVɪĎEnT7m. F;F-0ǼīZƲǂZļŇY:7TòŬǖ
Ʃɏ[¹ʖʔŇģ˄qɨǟHm²ɑɜU[X
71ˎ ȁ¹, 2016ˏVƚƦEnT7mj8Y-
LZưǢ[ǓȴǛʷV7QTgʟɪU[X7. Åư-ËǏȸɅqŒɾVFNȹĥȸɅɺU
g-Ňlj;kËǏȸɅ_ZȜɞǀZ¡��¤
®�-dzYʺɍ_ZŒȨ<±RZɷ˄VXQ
T:l-Ļ?ZȒȡ<ɛȠEnT7m. CZj8Y-òŬǖƩɏVȹĥȸɅɺ[-
0ȜɞǀZŒƀ1V78ǰUëʗHmʽqě
rU7m.F;F-ȩɣZʵl-CncUò
ŬǖƩɏY:ATȹĥȸɅɺZƤȀ[ĆñY
XEnT7X7. LCUǂıĜU[-ȹĥȸɅɺZòŬǖƩ
ɏ_ZƤȀēɑƃqǎɫFN7.CZǎɫY
jQT-òŬǖƩɏZºȋȊU6m0ˊlj;
kZïǯXȜɞ1qɊ9mNfZƯNXɥŮ
qƢ×U=mVɊ9m˓ˏ.
¼º�b��ª���%�¡����z� � LgLgȸɅɺV[0ǼÆȗÍZİȕȊǑ
ƊɢȳVFTZȸɅqŒɾVF-LZɞĂh
ĸąZ¤z��£qɨƵHmŇģ1ˎ Ǎȁ¯ȁ
Ř, 2010. P.3ˏV7pnT7m.X;Ug-
ȹĥȸɅÒˎËǏȸɅˏqŒɾVHmZ<ȹ
ĥȸɅɺU6m. � ȹĥȸɅɺ[-ȸɅLZgZqƑ8ȒȡU
6m0¡~ȸɅɺ1V-ȸɅZ¹ZÁʱq
ŒɾVHmȒȡU6m0¢~ȸɅɺ1VY
ļóU=m<-¢~ȸɅɺZºɢ�°¡Z
±R<|¦ªtɺU6m. � |¦ªtɺU[0Ȝɞǀ1ZǎɫgXEn
T7m.Ö9\-½ùYƙQT7NĽhÍ
ȗZv¤°�VǼŋVZ¢�¡��<ʈCm
CV<6mV780ªtª�u¯�¨�~1
Zģ˄U6mˎSchein, 1978 .ˏ � C8FNªtª�u¯�¨�~qʥAmN
fY-0ªtª��u�~¯�¨�¯�¬�§
°ˎRJP 1ˏVĞ\nmgZ<6m.Cn[-
0ŇǿáYVQTËǏ<Î9mƄıYŒFT-
jlŌɧȊ¯ǼŋȊXɥǰUƠHmV78C
VU6l-ËǏá[LZj8XƄıq¶9N
ư<¢�¡��qʳBmV78Ɋ9ư1ˎDžǂ, 2012, pp.238-239ˏU6m. � CZ RJP ZǐƁqƤȀHmCVYjl-ò
ŬǖƩɏqȮɂąU=mVɊ9m.HXpP-
òŬǖǛʷUzª|§©£�°qƢȖHm
XW0ļŇǿǥZêÒä1qȖHCVU-³
ÏŇŬ_ʛȲFNŹZ0ªtª�u¯�¨�
~1qʳ>-ƴǀUZʛʌĸƺqÚHCV<
ēɑYXm. ½º�b(*6F5)5)ª�z� � cNȹĥȸɅɺU[-ƯéȗĠZǛʷY:
7T-ÍȗZ±ĠVFTZɔɦ-Rcltv
�®�u�uZǑȫZſɢƃ<ƚƦEnT7
m.CZ0ÍȗZ±ĠVFTZɔɦ1qÚH
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 147
NfZưǢq-0ȸɅtv�®�u�u1Zǐ
Ɓ;kǎɫFN7 2ˏ.�
ȸɅtv�®�u�uV[-0ȸɅZǑƊĠ
NPZ2pnpn[Óɋ;3YŒHmëʗZ
ɳȐ¯Øà1ˎ ʫ, 2010ˏVŊɇEnT7m.
cN-ȸɅtv�®�u�uqǬNH 3 RZ
İǮVFT-*¹žƃ ȸɅYVQT¹žȊ-
ǂʆȊdzŽ-+Ƕɔƃ˕ÅȸɅVǜʑFTȆ
XQT7mVƈGknmdzŽ-,ʙȽƃ˕6
mȝŭZǀʱU±ʂFNdzŽ<6BknT7
mˎAlbert & Whetten, 1985 .ˏ
LFT-ȸɅtv�®�u�uZɳȐ;k-
ȸɅ_Zė±ąˎidentificationˏ<:Cm.
CZė±ąYjQTȸɅʺɒqʳ@āLJ<6
mV7pnT7mˎˊŘ, 2013 .ˏ
� C8FNɥǰ;kòŬǖƩɏqǎɫHmV-
ǖZǰ<ƚƦU=m.HXpP-0ɔljƩɏ1
h0yªw®�°�¨®1Yjl-“ļŇZ¹
žƃ¯Ƕɔƃ¯ʙȽƃ”qòŬǖŇǿYƢ×H
mCV<U=m.CnYjl-ȸɅ_Zė±
ą<ǿcnhH?Xl-ŇǿZŊȏqÚHɢ
ħYXmVɊ9knm.
¾º�bd¢ª�z�
CncU|¦ªtɺhȸɅtv�®�u�
uɺZɥǰZƤȀēɑƃYR7TɺGT=N
<-LgLg0ßÁ[XKȸɅYčýHmZ
;1gȹĥȸɅɺZºɢXȒȡ˂ĮU6m.
C8FNɽɺ[-ȸɅĭɟɺˎMarch &
Simon, 1978ˏVĞ\nT7m.
ȸɅĭɟɺU78ĭɟV[-0ȸɅ<LZč
ýɋYŒFT-ȼȽȊXčýqĂǔSAmZ
YĆñXƧƐ7qƬ9mCVYƊüFT7m
CV-HXpPȸɅ<ǿņYſɢXȹĥʅǭ
ZǸż-ôȀYƊüFT7mCV1ˎ Ǎȁ¯ȁ
Ř, 2010, p.42ˏCVq6kpH.
ȸɅĭɟɺU[-cIùƢVFT0ȸɅY
ƍŜHm;Ě;[ßÁZƆƂYjmgZ1V
Ɋ9m.LFTȸɅ[-0ßÁqȸɅYčýE
JmNfYɴħˎinducement 1ˏqƢ×FȽ
AXAn\XkX7VFT7m.ƺY-ɴħ
<ßÁYVQTǬʊq¶9mgZU6n\-
ȸɅYčýF-ʀǷˎcontributionˏqRS
AmVɊ9T7m.
CZɴħˑʀǷʲÙ;kòŬǖƩɏqɊ9
N7.Ö9\-éŇȋȊƆɼ<Ð7ŇǿYV
QT-H@YȐɦU=mļŇ;kZ0ɴħ1
[ŖX7.F;F-òŬǖƩɏY:7T[0�
��u¯�|«1Zę³h-0œʯƩɏ_ZŔ
é1XW-jlȐɦFhH70ɴħ1ZƢ×
<ēɑYXmVɊŐU=m.
¿º�&$�¸ �"�Lr�©¶¹
dzZj8Y-*|¦ªtɺZɥǰ;k-
0ªtª�u¯�¨�~1ʐǪZNfZòŬ
ǖƩɏ-+ȸɅtv�®�u�uɺZɥǰ;
k-0ɔñNP[ÓXZ;1YʲHmv¤°�
qƢ×HmgZVFTZòŬǖƩɏ-,ȸɅ
ĭɟɺZɥǰ;k-0ɴħ1ZƢ×ɋVFTZ
òŬǖƩɏ-Z 3 ǰYR7TǎɫFN.
ǂıĜU[ŋɯȊXǎɫqɞQT7mpA
U[X7< 3ˏ-ȹĥȸɅɺZȒȡɛȠqǥȀ
HmCVYjQT-ŋʍZŇVFTZòŬǖ
ƩɏYƯNXɥǰqƢ×U=mVɊ9knm.
ÂŹ[ȹĥȸɅɺZɥǰqƤȀHmCVY
jmŋʍȊv®�ª�°�¨®ˎ ìÒȊƎǢˏ
ZƢ×qǎɫHmCV<ſɢU6m.
4Ǥ5
1ˏıĜɋ<œʯȊYȒȡFT7m0ȹĥȸɅ
ɺ1V-ƍŜljU6mʫǠŢǏļŇY:Amò
ŬǖƩɏUZ0ȹˉ1<-ǂıĜZȏƅZ�°
�VXQT7m.
2ˏȸɅtv�®�u�uYR7T[-Ñɝș
íˎ2013 0ˏȸɅtv�®�u�uɺZȇǿV
ȇś1ȸɅŇÍɁ2ȸɅɺ¬�§°)3ȉnjƻ
ƌ-qčDZEnN7.
3ˏıĜƹY[jlɲȵXǎɫqý9m¼ŊU
6m.
ˎ(čɊƭǷ[ıĜƹYʨŧFcHˏ
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 148
gT¯tx��~W��cgwu��J %qµ�
� :9E6H4'R���i¥��� �
�
4ȇɠɋ5�òɣůɞ�ˎ7p=ƵƷļŇˏ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
»º��"��
ǂıĜU[ːòŬǖƩɏYjm0ŇÞʣƀ
ƈ1<ːŇǿZ0īŇƆƂ1Y¶9mŷʾY
R7TıĜqɞ8˒ŋɯȒȡZȺLJ;kːò
ŬǖƩɏZīlưh��©£ZƨĤYŏ¶
HmCV<ːǂıĜZȋȊU6m˒�
¼ºa¶w«�
Ñɝ¯Ęđa;ˎ2016ˏː òɣˎ2016ˏU
[ òːŬǖƩɏZāLJqǫŊHmNfY 0ː�
��u¯�|«1ː0ŒÁʣƀƈ1ː0ļŇ_Z
Ƈȏ1<ːƯéǿˎĬưȚȢļŇZ 1 Ŭǿˏ
Z0īŇƆƂ1YWZj8XŷʾqĎbH;
YR7TñdžqɞQT7m˒LZȺLJːļŇ
îZďÁʲÙŶƊqȖH0ŒÁʣƀƈ1[ː
ŇǿZ0īŇƆƂ1YƾƆXŷʾqĎbEX
7CV<ıĜEnT7m˒cN 0ːīŇƆƂ1
YƾƆXŷʾqĎbHZ[0���u¯�|
«1U6lːòŬǖƩɏqʗGNďÁʲÙŶ
ƊjlgŇÞʽUZ�|«ę³hʣƀƈqˊ
fT7?ʩɢƃ<ȖĢEnT7m˒
½ºYo�|��^$�!
� ³ɭçɞȒȡZȐɣqǥ;Fː7p=ƵƷ
ļŇU[ 2ː016 ŬŭZòŬǖƩɏ��©£
YR7Tː���u¯�|«Zę³YǤûq
FN˒ìÒȊY[ːƄıZ0Đʹ¯ñdž¯ȇ
Ý1Z 3 ǰZɑûqˊfT7?CVq�®�
��YƝ9ːŇÞ�®�®�ZæŋąqĩQ
T7m˒cNː���u¯�|«Zę³qʗ
GN0ŇÞʣƀƈ1< ƯːéǿZ0īŇƆƂ1
YƾƆXŷʾqĎbH;YR7TːƨfTɸ
Lj¯ñdžqɞQN˒
¾ºO¨
� ǂȒȡZÈɵ[Ç´ZʗlU6m˒
H1 0ŇÞʣƀƈ1[ ƯːéǿZ0īŇƆƂ1
YƾƆXǙZŷʾq¶9m
� dzZÈɵqǎɯHmNfY ǂːȒȡU[ː
0ŇÞʣƀƈ1<0īŇƆƂ1Yŷʾq¶9
mħLJ¥�«qÈŊFːëñƪǑʘñdžYj
mǎɫqɞQN˒
¿º��
ñdžŒɾ� 2016 ŬŭƩˈŇʦƯéǿ 53 Ę1
ɸLjǀʱ� 2016 Ŭ 4 ƽ;k 2017 Ŭ 1 ƽcU
ɸLjưǢ� ȱńÒYjm 7 ĦZ�°�vɸLj
ÕȀŗŭ� 0īŇƆƂ1[ːŕǺˎ2011ˏː
ȣîˎ2003ˏː Şǂˎ2005ˏː Lyonsˎ1981ˏ
q ǂːȒȡYĖpJTÞǙFN ì˒ÒȊY[ː
0ÂZļŇYĈǏcUȄclN71ː0gFɔ
ȂYʤƔU=mZU6n\ːÂZļŇYŚR
SAN71ː0ǃŬgCZļŇUŇ]N71ː0g
FÓk;ZǽȂUļŇqÌŇ¯ʔŇFXAn
\XkX7VFTgːÂZļŇYƋQT=N
71ː0ÂZļŇV[ʡQNļŇYɞ=N7
ˎR 1ˏː0ǔÍ<6n\ːÅZļŇUŇrUd
N7ˎR 1ˏː01 ŬŹːȚ[CZļŇY7X7
Oo8ˎR 1ˏZ 7 ˀȋqÕȀFT7m˒
0ŇÞʣƀƈ1YR7T[ːçɞȒȡqčɊ
YÔƊFN ì˒ÒȊY[ 0ːļŇZƞǏYR7
1 ŋʸZƯéǿ[ 75 ĘU6m<ːȤ 1 Ħȋ;kȤ 7 Ħȋ
cUZ��«�°�<đżU=NɋOAqñdžŒɾVFN˒
ŋʸZñdžU[ːȤ 1 ĦˎéŇƹˏː Ȥ 3 Ħˎ7 ƽˏː Ȥ 7ĦˎɈŬ 1 ƽˏZ�°�qÕȀFT7m˒cNːʆģȱU
[ːǂȇɠUÕȀHmˀȋgěfː102 ģǫŊFT7m˒
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 149
T7?ɔÝ<6m1ː0ļŇZƞǏUj7ƊɄ
qÞfmCV<U=mVƂ81ː0ļŇZƞǏ
YR7T7?CV<U=m1ː0ļŇZƞǏ[
p;kX7CV\;lOˎR 1ˏː0ƞǏ¹ːÓ
qɵƵEnT7mZ;ñ;kX7CV<Ļ7
ˎR 1ˏː0ˁųQT7mZYːļŇZƞǏYR
7T7AX7ˎR 1ˏː Z 6 ˀȋqÕȀFT7
m˒Ħȧ[êT05˕Ŵ?L8Ƃ81;k01˕
ê?L8ƂpX71Z 5 ÉǢYjQTɞQN˒
ĕ 3 ĦZŗŭZÝ˃ƃ[ 0ːīŇƆƂ1<&
˖.82˗.93 0ːŇÞʣƀƈ1<&˖.76˗.84ː
U6lːŗŭZîȊ±ʂƃ<ȓɳEnN˒
Àº��
� 3 ǣZ¿ŤʜŰāLJ¥�«qǑʘưȝű¥
�ª®�YjQTǎɫFNȺLJ0ːŇÞʣƀƈ1
V0īŇƆƂ1ZʲÙ[ːÇ´Zĩ 1 VXQ
N˒X:ːėĸƫZĕƹǰʱZ��YȦàö
ȰqɷFN˒
ĩ 1˕Ǒʘưȝű¥�ª®�ZȺLJ
� ñdžZȺLJː¥�«ZʣĖŭ[ɮŎȪĨî
U6lːCZ¥�«qƟƔFN˒cNː³ɭ
ȺLJjl H1 [±ʦƧƙEnmȺLJVXQN ˒
Áº�k
� ǂȒȡZȺLJ;k ǖːZ 2 ǰ<ɊŐEnm˒
Ȥ 1 YːǂȒȡY:7Tg 0ːŇÞʣƀƈ1
<ƯéǿZ0īŇƆƂ1YƾƆXǙZŷʾq
¶9mCV<ȓɳEnN˒T3ˎùǀƼȷ˕7
ƽˏY:Am0ŇÞʣƀƈ1<ːT7ˎŹǀƼ
ȷ˕ɈŬ 1 ƽˏZ0īŇƆƂ1YŒFTːƾ
ƆXǙZŷʾq¶9T7mCV<ȓɳU=m˒
çɞȒȡVėǒYːƯéǿZīŇƆƂqˊf
mNfY[ːļŇZŇÞYŒHm0ʣƀƈ1
qˊfmCV<ʩɢU6mCV<ȖĢEnm˒
cNːCZŇÞʣƀƈ<ĦȧɋZ0Ȑɦ¯ɳ
Ȑ1U6mǰqʭdmVːŋʸYļŇZŇÞ
YʣƀU=T7m;Ě;V78ŌɧȊ½ŋV
ëYːƯéǿǂÁZȐɦ¯ɳȐ<ʩɢU6m
CV<ơǫEnm˒òŬǖƩɏU[ĻǒXt
z�¢�~�|«ZǸż<ȋƚEnT7m<ː
�|«ZǸżVėǒYˎgF?[Lndzˏ
Y 0ːɔñ[ļŇZŇÞYR7T7AT7m1
V78Ȑɦ¯ɳȐqˈ8CV<ːòŬǖƩɏ
Y:7TʩɢU6mCV<ȖĢEnm˒
� Ȥ 2 YːT1 Z0īŇƆƂ1< T3 Z0ŇÞ
ʣƀƈ1YƾƆXǙZŷʾq¶9T7m±ưː
T3 Z0īŇƆƂ1[ T7 Z0ŇÞʣƀƈ1Y
ƾƆXŷʾq¶9T7X7˒ǂȺLJYR7T
[ƨfTɸLj¯ñdž<ſɢU6m<ːéŇƹ
Zˊ70īŇƆƂ1[ːļŇUZŇÞƆǗ¯
ƉŭYɎŊȊXŷʾqĎbFT7mēɑƃ<
6m˒F;FːÑɝ¯Ęđa;ˎ2016ˏUg
ƚƦEnT7mj8Y ƯːéǿZ0īŇƆƂ1
<éŇŹź/YдFT7?½ŋqʭdmVː
0īŇƆƂ1<ŇÞƆǗhƉŭY¶9mɎŊ
ȊXŷʾgːƹʱZȹʟVëYдːgF?
[ǧľFTFc8ēɑƃ<Ɋ9knm˒
º³��©¶
� ǂȒȡZʵȃVɷ˄YR7TÇ´Z 2 ǰ<
6Bknm˒Ȥ 1 Yː�®�«�v�ZŕE
EU6m ǂ˒ȒȡU[Ưéǿ 75 ĘZ¹Ugː
��«�°�<ĐʹU=N 53 ĘZdqñdž
ŒɾVFT7m˒ǂȺLJZÝ˃ƃ¯łŵƃq
ƗÜHmNfYgː�®�«ƫZƘļ<ſɢ
U6m˒Ȥ 2 YːƯéǿ[ĻǒXɻɇqŝÞ
FT7mNfːòŬǖƩɏțȋÇĺZŷʾq
ĒAT7mēɑƃ<6m˒ǂɷ˄qɨǟHm
NfY[ːòŬǖƩɏțȋqŋƱFT7X7
ÅŇʦhÅļŇVZǜʑ ñdž<ſɢU6m˒
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 150
~W�,D+F5H1BF�i����
0=A8.H1BF/H>�����ie`��
4ȇɠɋ5� őşġūˎŪȔļŇˏ� �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
»º���������
DŽÀŢɘļŇ<êĪZ ŬöļŇYʗ8ļ
Ňǿ � ĘqŒɾYɞQNɸLj��Yjm
V-0ÁʱʲÙZæŋ[-ŇǏhļŇǿǥZǬ
ʊŭqŲ=³BmʩɢXɢȳZ RU6m1
CV<Ƶk;YXQN.ļŇǿǥUƯNYď
Á<ðǃNƹǀ¯=Q;AYR7TėɸLjU
[-0ƞǏ¯ɻɇ˕ Ŭƹ�������1h0yª
w®�°�¨®�������1-0�°~«¯ʦǥĂ
UðÍQT� ����1XW<ˊ7CV<p;m.
F;F-0òŒʽZÁYĶq;Am1V78Ǵ
ǡUµʼnqƈGmVĦȧFNɋ< ��� �g7
m.�
� ŇǿėĵZ¿ǦqĩmưǢVFT-ŞŠ���
[0ȬĊX�°£h~v�XWZǥĂqʗF
T-čýɋZȿųqğkB-čýɋėĵZ;
;plZ=Q;AqÔm1CVqǵ7VFN
tv��¬v~������"����qƛBT7m.F
;F0�«°�Z¿Ǧ<Ǩcm;W8;[-
ʛɞŸVXm�s�ª�°�°ZûʪYjQ
TţĔEnmCV<6m1V7QNtv��
¬v~Zģ˄ǰgƚƦFT7m.LZNfŞ
Š['ʝ]'Yˊ7ʲžqȖHŇǿZNfY-
�°��°£qƞǏ_ŔéFN.�°��°
£qƞǏYŔéFNȺLJVFT-ƞǏZIJY
ʼnžƈ<ǿcnNVɊ9T7m.�
� ǂȒȡU[-CZj8XǴǡqʎc9-Ư
éǿyªw®�°�¨®ƹYɞ8tv��¬
v~ZƹʱY�°��°£qŔéFN.�°
��°£V78'ʝ]'qŔéHmCVU-
0ŇǿZòŒʽǴǡUZµʼnhƕƓqǪkH1
V0��°��°£ÇĺZ�dzóXǾijhʞĥ
����qʨɆJI-ƩĠ ĘUŋƱU=m1
Z¾RqǂȒȡY:AmȋȊVHm.�
¼ºi��£����
� ǂȒȡU[-NJűÍȗª�«�§°�¦°
jlʁķEnT7m2�°«�w~��ªw
®�˗ˋʫÒˉ˗3�qƯéǿyªw®�°�
¨®ƹYŋƱFN.ŋƱǐɢ[´ɭZV:l
U6m.�
Ʋƹ˕�� Ŭ ƽ � Ʋ�ʫ����ˑ���
IJƍ˕ŪȔļŇ�
Œɾ˕ÁʱțŇʦ�¢§��°�¨®Ňț�
� � � Ưéǿ � Ę�
� � � īljǿ Ę�� Ŭ � Ę�� Ŭ � Ę��
îŎ˕čýɋq �˗� ĘZ � �«°�YñA-
LnMnZ�«°�DVY�°��
°£2�°«�w~���ªw®�˗
ˋʫÒˉ˗3qŋƱFN.�
� ³ɭZj8Y�°��°£qŋƱFNtv
��¬v~<čýɋYWZj8Xŷʾq¶9
N;ɸLjHmNfY-tv��¬v~ŋƱù
VŋƱŹYt®�°�qŋƱFN.�
½ùt®�°�U[-òŒʽǴǡYR7T
Z � ˀȋZʆģqɞ7- ÉǢ��VTgəƎ�
��əƎ���żƆ� �VTgżƆ�UĦȧFTg
kQN�ĩ˓�.�
� ½Źt®�°�U[-�°£ZŷʾYR7
TZ � ˀȋVŻǃZɔťȶÃVZǜʑVXm
ˀȋZʆģqɞ7- ÉǢ��cQN?ŵT
[ckX7���ŵT[ckX7���ŵT[cm�
�VTgŵT[cm�UĦȧFTgkQN�ĩ
˔�.EkYÂĦZ�°£qɔťȶÃVFTɞ
8CVYŒFTɔȂɭʓZ�¤®�qƻ7T
ʃQN.�
� ĩ˓Vĩ˔qǜʑHmV-H`TZˀȋY
ŒFTùę=XĦȧ<Ĵ9T7mCV<p;
m.�
P4� ¹ʖʔŇʳǘ¯ŇǿZŊȏ
― ― 151
½Źt®�°�UZɔȂɭʓUZĦȧg
0�°£UɱHîŎ<ǟcQT7mNf-ò
ŒʽOQNV=Y[6l<N71h0ȿųH
mCVX?òŒʽZÁVɱJN1V78ɎŊ
ȊXĦȧ<Ļ;QN.NO0ɶ;<ɱFH>
mVɔñZɱ<U=X?XmÁ<ðT?m1
V78�°£«°«³Zģ˄ǰqƚƦHmƆ
ɣh0ʉĝh-Ł=X½XW-ÂZƄı<Ŗ
X7Nf-ȐlĖ7dzY[XnX7VƂ7
cFN1V78�°£���£Zģ˄ǰqƚ
ƦHmĚŊȊXĦȧg6QN.�
�
½º¦S��k�
� ǂȒȡZȋȊZ±R[-�°£qŔéHm
CVUòŒʽǴǡUZµʼnhƕƓqǪkHC
VU6m.t®�°�ȺLJ;k±ŊZƊLJq
żNCV<ȓɳU=N.�
� g8±RZȋȊVFT-dzóXŇɉǾijZ
Ǒȫhʞĥ����ZʨɆqɞpI-ƩĠ
ĘZdUʞĥHmCV<U6QN.½ùǮâ
VFT[�°��°£ZʇéV«°«ɵƵZ
NfZʅƮÔƊZdU6m.±ɖȊXǾijU
ŋƱēɑU6mCV<ȓɳU=Nǰg-ŋȀ
ȊXāLJVɪ9mOo8.�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
� ɷ˄VFT[-ɔȂɭʓZĦȧ;k�°£
«°«h�°£���£Y:Amģ˄ǰqč
ýɋjlƚƦEnN.cNÅZtv��¬v
~VāLJqǜʑ¯ǎɯHmſɢ<6m.�
�
M¤ ǂȟZįȥZNfY-JSPS țȒʄ 16K13571ZþƊqĒAN. �
� ��ǂȒȡUȀ7N2�°«�w~��ªw®
�˗ˋʫÒˉ˗3[ƳDzqÕȀFN.�
]�}� ��DŽÀŢɘļŇ�����0êĪZļŇǿ�¢
§��°�¨®ɸLj1�2�§°�ªª°�3��
�##!���%%%�#�� $��������!��$����!"��� đ
żƲ˕�� Ŭ ƽ �� Ʋ�
���ŞŠǻĿ�����0ÜɏɋˈƊY:AmŇ
ǿZ�¢§��°�¨®ɑûɏƊZɰd��
°��°£V78ʝ^qʗFT�1�Àʧèɚ
ŀŅļŇÀʧèɚŀŅȑǀļŇȯɢ��
Ŧ������ � ʿ�
ĩ˓˒½ùt®�°�
ĩ˔˒½Źt®�°�
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 152
����µ��¦)v�¨S`Zj*;/3E�¾r��
%����RVU^:_KhY_U^<Á}�%�
�
3ǧȶȥ4� ʌȳ� Ƌ¤Ĩƺ� şʖ°ǣȍğħʗ�
�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ßÞ=5A;�
� ȆȥkYʙgSgSƋȃɐȾXħȣǀSE
QɽǧCnK ��� ɉEþ7ħȣǀʖ����������
��������ʣĨƺ¤ʌȳ�����ʗq/ɐȾ0X
dUkH/ɂɒ0h/ƋȃÉŪ0UTɀɍŰ
ȵ¦ȭXŷijVgǂǞGmASqfDEQ
/��� ėǪĖżƨ0qƀƦEʙżƨXɁǢ¤
īɝ¤ƅČqȜ?Q7m-U;RgƋȃÉŪ
YʙħȣȥXȰŭţɕ<ʼn7AS;kʙ���
Vjm/ɐȾ0qÓœCIK©Rʙ��� qǂ
ǞEK/ƋȃÉŪ0qijØGmS78ǃnq
ţɕEKŷijqɈdQ7m�ʌȳ¤Ĩƺʙ�� �-
cKʙƋȃqƚ>èVʙ��� VƾNK¼ȥS
XıɉqŖHȴ7ʙƋȃƫŪqĂćEQ;k
ƚ>S78ǃngdzȂEQ=Q7m-�
� ơĘąRYʙƋȃƫŪqȂQmʃX¼ȥS
XıɉV:7QʙýȫXȤ9q/Ⱥ9mò0
GmKfV�u£����qǂǞEʙ��� X
����SșþCIKɈdVO7QĘąGm-�
àÞ�¦'v�¨S`Zj(<§Ë�
����żƨXėơšĘ� żƨY���ł�Ɯɽɔ
R �� àżƨÙ �� ��R6NK-ûɔǝYǮ
ɗʔȇIJÓħƥ � łǝ � Ā�ĢĤ � ĀʙǡĤ
� Ā�R6lʙżƨȥYȅ¦ȆȥR6NK-�
���żƨǫǨ� ���� ĥǽŅXĴɒƋqƚ>-
�u��Y/UlK7ȫà�ǛŢXǮɗľ0-�
���}�¥�ȝŪ� ǥɛU}�¥�ȝŪʖ�
Ā}�¥� Ǚʙ� Ā}�¥� Ǚʗ-�
����żƨXėơƫŪ� ÙQXżƨV:7Q�
õÿVjmıɉ®ŕXżƨqɈdKʖĨƺ��
���ʗ-JXėơŌYʙŹŶ¤èƖX]lɤl
ʖżƨɨÒʗ¤żƨĸɽ¤ơƖX]lɤlʖż
ƨɃɺȑʗS78ǃnR6NK-�
����żƨĸɽ�ȶ ��� żƨY/ɐȾ0/ıɉ0
/ƋȃÉŪ0X ƵʂR6lʙɐȾƵʂR ���
qÓœCIʙȜ>µOXƵʂR ��� Xɮǽ�
�£qǂǞEKŷijqɈdK-�
�
���_KhY_U^r�<��
����ǍÕ� �u£����XƪȹS � X�
¥�qDZkIK-�u£����ÉŪVŦn
mKfVʙ���u£����qÉŪCIK-
�¥�Y/E6pI0R6NK-ÉŪŐʙȫ
àXǙL?RU>¼XǙSgʙÉŪEKgX
qȺIþ7ʙıɉqGmƖɾqɄ?K-AX
¸ǃVjl�u£����Xſ=ƏXǛȾ<
džcNK-�
���ÉŪ� /ǛŢXǮɗľ0SJXǛǠVO
7QʙȫàXȤ9qƚ;IK-ƮVʙǛŢX
ǮɗľVUmKfX¯ȹ�¥�qȤ9ʙǙR
¸ǃCIK-JXŐʙ¯ȹ�¥�q 456 Ô
ɲZIK-JAcRƽfQ;kʙ�u£��
��ÉŪVúlȗcIK-ȫà<Ȥ9K/Ǜ
ŢXǮɗľ0ʖLTD step 3 X¯ňʗq�£�
���������
Ql h 4�A_S:
� A �U@��$nJM�VP2cj�
� ;=A_�B^2?LbZ
fd � ���Nbne�<�S:�,1)�G�#�m�
� ����n ��kX-/1
� 89> ���a8�`�na8�R"%�
� (03-7\n�aE[5��&��
Ce .'1+.*-��n.'1+.*-]_
.'1+.*-��$��a8�TH�WiF�
� DgKoKYOI
�� DgK6I��$��a8�TH�WiF�n!�"
KY6I
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 153
��u�¥�Vʙ¯ȹ�¥�ʖLTD step 4 X
ɉʍʗq�u£��£�©Vƚ>j8ŷǶE
K-JA;k��£�qŃ@,�u£���
�qĩŪCIK-ĩŪEK�u£����q
ŭ<;lVǙX®R¸ǃCIK- ���Õ�r�<�Ú�
����ƋȃƫŪ� /ńɒ0/ơɒ0/șɒ0S7
8ĴɒƋXėơƫŪqDZkIʙ¯ň������
Y/ńɒ0Vʙɉʍ�������ʘɿɫP?������¤
�Y/ơɒ0Vƚ>ASqƆ9K-/șɒ0V
Y¯ňXɀ7ǬEhţƹɣdqƚ>SȮ7A
SʙɿɫP?YʙńɒhơɒVgƚ7QȮ7
ASg½?ë9K-ƮVʙ�u£����q
ȺQʙ¯ȹ�¥� 456 ÔX®;kɿŕ<dž
7gX���£�<K>Cr6mgX�q¨O
ɲZIʙJn</¯ň0������qɯŪGmK
fVŖȹU¨OX/ɉʍ0ʖ������ʗVUmA
SqDZkIK-JXŐʙ��£�qǯfKlʙ
ÁɾSıɉEKlEU<k/ɿɫP?0(stepʟ¤6ʗq½?ë9QƋȃƫŪqĩŪCIK-�
���ĴɒƋÉŪ� ƋƚƫŪVėP=ʙĴɒƋ
qÉŪCIK-ĴɒƋqƚ=6@KȥÿěR
ɎĥȪĥq®ŕSEKžƉǂðù\ŤŢ¸ǃ
qȴNK-R=mL?ȸƈXÁɾS¸ǃGm
j8ŷijEK-żƨƖɾÝRʙÙĊ ����� ĥ
ǽŅXĴɒƋqĩŪCImAS<R=K- ���Á£:Ã��
����ĴɒƋXɇÎ� /ƋȃƫŪ0S/ɿɫP
?0Y ǐnjǐʙ/ÙÇ0Y � ǐnjǐRɇÎE
K-/ƋȃƫŪ0VO7QYʙŷijɨlʙ¯ň
ʖ�����ʗ%ɉʍʖ������ʗ%ɿɫP?ʖ�����
ʟ¤ ʗ<R=Q7mgXq ǐʙàɸX��
£�<Š7gXhŌŇ<¦ɴƊNQ7U7g
Xq ǐʙÙ>R=Q7U7gXq � ǐSE
K-/ɿɫP?0VO7QYʙɿɫP?XƈR
ŽǐEʙ¨O¿©q ǐSEK-/ÙÇ0VO
7QYʙ¯ň<ÄpmgXq ǐSEʙɏœ
ê<6mgXVëǐEK-ŁĕǐYʙ/Ƌȃƫ
Ū0� � ǐʙ/ɿɫP?0���� ǐʙ/ÙÇ0���
ǐR6NK-ƋȃƫŪVɿEQYʙƪWǛȾ
R=KSäƍR=m-ɿɫP?VɿEQYʙ
¨OXɉʍX8MʙĵU>SgµOVYɿɫ
P?qƚ7QƯE;NKXRʙg8ĵEɿɫ
P?qÐGļĠhƖɾXdzÑ<ŖȹLNKS
Ȥ9m-cKʙɿɫP?<Ě9nZʙ¯ňV
ıGmɏœê<ĚEʙÙÇXɇÎg©<mS
Ȥ9knm-�
���ħǝXŤŢ�ƛȖɔXŤŢjl��
&ħǝƖ¾�Ĵ¤®¤ʔ�ʙĴɒƋYSQgȰ
ŭRʙÉŪV7OgƖɾqȹEQ7K<ʙ�
u£����;kȠ@QXÉŪVjlʙSQ
gƚ=hG;NKSś8-�
'ƚ=ãfVOcH7KgXXʙǃnV±N�
Q;kY����Sƚ?K-gSgSĴɒƋ
Y6clœţRYU7<ʙ�u£����R
¦ŅėǪqÉmASRʙArUVɰ8rLʙ
SśNK-�
(Ƌȃqƚ>ASVʙĵEȫÒ<O7K-º
gưcmASU>����Sƚ?Q7mȫà
<7Qʙ��� XïƤ;USś8-�
)à;lhG>ƋȃqƫŪGmhlƏqħ^
AS<R=K-�u£����qȺmASRʙ
ĴɒƋ<ƚ=hG>Qʓ7K-�
*�u£����<6NK;kĬȽǨVȫà
qȺOfǬGAS<R=K-��� żƨRȫà
XŕXġdž>XǓqDŽ=©@mAS<R=K-�
+ǙXdrU<ţȺVÛŤEQ>nKlʙɎ
ĥȪĥqƆ9Q>nKlSʙSQgNJ;7ʅ
ĐƹLNKXRʙhlhG;NK-�
� ßƢ©<NKĴɒƋhħǝXŤŢ;kʙ�
u£����qǂǞEʙȤ9q/Ⱥ9mò0
EKASYʙ��� X����qɞdhG>Eʙ
ĴɒƋÉŪVōȂNKSžįR=m-�
���ÀGD;����
� ƛȖɔqȖ9QĿNQ7mSʙħǝX¦¹
;kĈ\ưfknK-/×ǝʙƋȃqƚ>X<
ȰŭRʙĴɒƋUrQƚ?U7SśNQ7K
?Tʙƚ?cEKʕ0SȄʎRɉEQ>nK-
ºŐg/ƚ>AS<ƩE70Sś9mƋȃÉ
ŪŷijqʙļĠEU<kȜ?Q7=K7-
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 154
������#�������
%�����µ����VcjXeIf<�×�%�
�
3ǧȶȥ4� ɻǟƇ·ʖƒơƲǻğħʗ¤Ĩƺ� şʖ°ǣȍğħʗ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �
ßÞ=5A;�
� PBLʖċʍėǪĖħȣʗ��¥��s�Y,ħ
ȣȥ<ĴʄďǂðXƆȧǨïƤqƛğʀVǂ;E,
ħȣȥ<ÁɾSXɂɒqɨEQ,ȫkċʍqǧ
Ⱥ¤ųßE,JXċʍqħȣȥȫɠ<ȾƽEQ7
>ħȣƏǤR6m-JXKf,PBL ��¥��s
�YħȣȥXċʍǧȺȩê,Ⱦƽȩê:j\��
��~¥��£ȩêȇqDžʑGmKfVʇŀVƝ
ïR6mASYĆDZXS:lR6m-�
� ƒơƲǻğħƎǎǝĉƲħɴV:7Qɻł
PBL ��¥��s�qīɝEQ=K<,ħȣȥX
�z�t�Əā_Xɧɳ,DZɕXĪǰ«ɜ,ɯŪ
Ť«ɜ:j\��¥�X¹ƈ«ɜSəŴɮɶUT
XơɛUċʍǐ<ʆĄEQ=K-�
� JAR,AnkXċʍǐXıřȉSEQ LTDɉEþ7ħȣǀʖĨƺ 2006, Ĩƺʨʌȳ 2014ʗqėǪSEKPBLʖLTD based PBLʗqȤƦE,
ƒơƲǻğħƎǎǝĉƲħɴXħǝqıɘVīɝ
EK-��� YõÿħȣX¦ŰǀR6mXR LTD based PBL YÙȴǽVljNQõÿħȣXǛɒS
ŰǀVÍŵEQ7m-ŒNQLTD based PBL V
Yõÿħȣh���RȺ7LCnQ7mïƤgƟŏ
R=m-ÜÇǨVY,ħȣȥXȫĽɿ¬Ņ<ʼnc
l,ǂðŜ<ʔcm-JXșƤ,ħǝÿěX¶Ş
ɿÏXʼnò,ƑĦXDZɕhȘʒSXɫș¤țþ:
j\ħȣŪƤǧȶVjmDZɕXĪǰUT<ƟŏR
=m-ºčYLTD based PBL żƨXīɝÝĭS
JXƝïŜVO7QĘąEK7-�
àÞ�¦<§Ë�
� LTD based PBL Y,���ɒǐųßSħȣʊǫX
ƽĪ,��ħȣʊǫVɿGmȫĽħȣ,��}�¥
�ɂɒSȫĽħȣRœKƎKUDZɕSƑĦXDZɕ
SXɫș¤țþ,���ħȣŪƤXƊǛSdzɌ,Xʞ
ƵʂRƫŪCn,TXƵʂgõÿħȣXǛɒSƏ
ǀqėǪSGm LTD XħȣƏǀqèƀSEQɁ
Ǣ¤īƐCnK-�
ı� ɘʢƒơƲǻğħƎǎǝĉƲħɴȅʛħł
ʖ75 Āʗʚ īƐƖƟʢŁŪ 28 łŅŐħƟ,ɬʛ
čʖƷɬɹƙƒ 13 Ɩ517 Ɩʗ áÞ���ª�� PBL ɑʍSEQ � ɑʍqǍÕE
K-JX8M,ɑʍʛYŒƢXPBL RīƐEK-
ÜÇǨUƏǀYɻǟʖ��ʗqøǑXAS-¦Ə,
ƴlXɑʍYLTD based PBL RīƐEK-U
:,� OXɑʍq ɬɾRīɝGmASYŒƢX
PBL SÿFR6m-¿ª,LTD based PBL Xƪ
ȹSŭʋqɬBSVǶG-�
3ȅʛɬ4� ħǝʢ4 ¹}�¥�(Gr),Ù 18 Gr-ƆĊʢ152 ¹RÙGr qŴŊGm-� żƨXǫǨʢ
õÿXǛŚSŰǀXǛȾqèƀSEK LTD qī
ƐGmASR,LTD based PBL qɨEQŖȹU
ħȣťŅhśȤƏǀqÓœGm- ŭʋʢ& PBL ɑʍXƀǶʢɑʍY�{��cK
YǢÖ- ' ÔåVjm³ȣʢLTDʖ³ȣʗqţɕEU<
kɑʍqɐȾGm-ɍŋ¤Ǟɍ¤ėơǨ´ʊX
dzɌ,Ǧċǐ¤ɒǐXųßqȴ8- ( ʄďVjmɂɒʢLTDʖ�¥�t£}ʗqţ
ɕEU<k,³ȣÝĭqdzɌE,ýȫXħȣʊ
ǫqƽĪGm- ) ÔåVjmħȣɑʍXȫĽħȣʢżƨŐôXƖ
ɾqËNQ,ýȫXħȣʊǫVɿGmȫĽħȣ
qȴ8- 3ȅʜɬ4� ħǝʢ6¤7 ¹Gr,12515Gr-ƆĊʢ
12518 ¹,¦¹RʛGr qŴŊ-� żƨXǫǨʢ
ħȣŪƤVėP>}�¥�ɂɒqɨEQ,ħȣÝ
ĭXdzɌSDZɕXțþqȴ8-
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 155
35
45
55
65
����(PBL)
����(LTDPBL)
����(LTDPBL)
����(LTDPBL)
���� ���������������� ���������������
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
����� ������ ����
ŭʋʢ&ħȣŪƤXǧȶʢŴŊEKħȣʊǫVO
7QǧȶE,}�¥�RɂɒGm- 'ċʍǧȺʢ}�¥�ɂɒVjNQƎKUǦċǐ
hħȣʊǫqųßE, ýȫ<ŴŊGmħȣʊǫ
qƽĪGm- (ÔåħȣʢżƨŐôRýȫXħȣʊǫVO7Q
ȫĽħȣGm- 3ȅʝɬ4� ħǝSƆĊʢƫŪYʜɬǫSÿF- ŭʋʢ&ħȣŪƤXǧȶSɂɒʢȅ 2 ɬ&¤'S
ÿF- 'ħȣÝĭXdzɌʢǦċǐhċʍǐ<ȾƽCnK
;,ħȣʊǫ<ǛȾCnK;q}�¥�ÝRdz
ɌGm- (ƪŚđȇXÉŪʢħȣÝĭqǶGƪŚđUTq
ÉŪGm- )źlɤlʢÔ¹S}�¥�Rǂðqźlɤm- *dzɌ���ʢħȣÝĭVɿGmĴ���XīƐ- âÞÔ¤�ª�
(1)õÿɌɕXNjĪʢõÿÉƨɌɕķŅʖɻǏk, 2009ʙʝĎĤ 5 ÂǀʗqħƟƠVīƐEK- (2)DZɕXĪǰŅXNjĪʢýɑʍXƛȖɬVīƐE
KdzɌ���ʖ100 ǐnjǐʗXŪȟ- ãÞÁ£:Ã� (1)õÿXɌɕʢõÿÉƨɌɕķŅXʝĎĤXŁĕ
qđ 1 VǶG-õÿïǞĎĤXŁĕœǐY 4.23 (SD: 0.23),Ô¹ŘāĎĤRY 2.89 (SD: 0.38),¶ŞũŚĎĤRY 2.05 (SD: 0.09)R6NK- (2)DZɕXĪǰŅʢdzɌ���XŪȟžǼqđ 2 V
ǶG-LTD based PBL RY,PBL XdqīƐE
KęþVƸ`Qƕk;VDZɕXĪǰŅ<ā©Gm
AS<äƕEK- � ºčXīɝqɨEQLTD based PBL VY¿ª
XïƤ<ƟŏR=m-&�z�t�Əā_Xħȣ
ȥXɧɳċʍVıEQY,õÿħȣqèƀSEK
ĵ¹ƈʖʞ¹ʗ}�¥�X LTD VjNQ,ħǝ
ÿě<ǭ¶VħȣǕƿqűƁE,áǴǜǵhíc
Eþ7RħȣţƯ<ā©Gm-' DZɕXĪǰ«ɜ
XċʍVY,LTD XīƐVjNQ,ɍŋhǞɍȇ
Xėơ´ʊ<ħǝǭ¶XȘʒhƑĦXDZɕSɿɫ
ŜqgKIQdzīVĪǰCnm-( ɯŪŤ«ɜX
ċʍVY,LTD X¦ɫX�¡��,ƪŚđXÉŪ
:j\dzɌ���XīƐȇVjNQdzīUɯŪŤ
<ƟŏR=m-) ��¥�X¹ƈ«ɜSəŴɮɶ
XċʍVɿEQY,ȅ 1 ɬY LTD qīɝGmK
fV,ƆĊʛ¹RgıřR=mXR��¥�Xņ
`¹ƈXçLjSÔ.XîêXəŴqɡLjR=m- � ºŐXīɝqɨEQ,AnkXǐqCkVƧɂ
që9m- +�±�,�
ɻǟƇ· (2013).� PBL ��¥��s�īɝV:
?mċʍǐ.� ãłƮƆȧħÃɋ. 5: 26-32. ɻǏƋ¬k (2009).� õÿÉƨɌɕķŅXɽǧ.�
ƆȧŕǛħDzȀ. 57: 24-37. Ĩƺş¤ʌȳƋ (2006).� īɝ¤LTD ɉEþ7ħ
ȣǀ. 156pp.� �y���ßǒ. Ĩƺş¤ʌȳƋ (2014).� LTD ɉEþ7ħȣǀ.
180pp.� �y���ßǒ.
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 156
¼¶<¡Ö®Í:z~�H«AE^gQLNX��
INVJ]idj[hO<¹½�×�
%'aTÑ·(<ÆÌxHm�;%�
�
3ǧȶȥ4� ®� Čæʖȯēğħʗ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ßÞ¡´É<§Ë�
ơǧȶY,ƆȦɔȢǻǫ/ǝőŷijXDzȀ0
RXs|�t�¤�¥�£}�¿ª,ʥʦ�X
īɝDzȀqȕ»GmgXR6m-GRV,Ȇ
ȥY,ȅʠʧʡčơħÃR,ÿżƨXĘąq
ȴNQ=K-JARY,żƨY,/ǻǫXơɛ
ǨǛȾ0S/õÿŜʖõÿħȣX�{�ʗ0X
ʈXȧŪqȤŧGmŖȹ<6mAS-cK,
JXKfVY,/ıɉ0S/ǂð0qɶȻEK
�¡�v|�Ė �� <ƝïR6mAS-U;R
g,JXdžòXKfVY,żƨȖ²ƖVȴ8
/]l;9l0<ɶȹR6mASUTq,ɽ
ɔèŐXħǝs£~¥�VjmɸǨàƣȇR
ƕk;VEQ=K-E;EU<k,ǻǫXơ
ɛǛȾXKfX/��ɌDZ0Xȫȼòqdžf,
ħǝÔ.¹XÅɻqT8īɆGmX;S78
CkUmɑʍgDŽ;\©<NQ=K-JAR,
�� łŅ,JnkXɑʍgăfK,ªđXj
8UīɝÀɏqȂQ,īɆDzȀqȴNK-ơ
ǧȶRY,JXżƨĘąqȴ7,ãłƮƆȧ
V:?mƻfknm �� X6lƏ,ǔV/��
ɌDZ0XȫȼòVā?KúlȗdqƀƦE,
Johnson, D. W.k<ɀ8/õÿħȣ 5 OXėơ
ǨƫŪȹȓ!0VgǑkEQƧɂE,żƨX
Wk7<ɯŪR=K;T8;,ɖɒEK7-�
àÞ'°���<¹½(�×<§Ë�
ơīɝY,ʜöÆXƆȦǻǫR,16 łŅY,
62 Āʖ14 ǙȝŪʗRɽɔEK-ħǝXÝɅ
Y,ʜčǝ<ȐʝàXʜ,ƴmY©čǝR,
®ʔXǷÃ,Ēɍ,ǺǸǻ,ǔåƄƂƆɓh
ʑɗƆɓqǫŷGħǝR6m-
� żƨXWk7SEQ,ħǝSÛɨǛȾVì
fKǐY,AʢǝőŷijVO7QXėơǨU
Ȥ9qǙɂɖqɨFQǛȾEQ7>AS,
BʢǙRıɉqɭf,/7Ffċʍ0VɿGm
ȫàKMUlXƎKU/DZ0qƫȌGmAS,
CʢǙRcSfKASqǧÒ¤ȴðGmAS
ʖ�¥�Y,/7Ff0q�¥�VEKħȒɨ
ÒqÉŪE,ŝľVƀƦGmSSgV,īʃ
X®ħǝVɐrRgk7,ůäEQgk8ʗ,
DʢżƨqɨFQ,õÿŜqʑ7,;Oõÿ
ħȣXŷijǀqħ^ASXʞǐR6m-īɝ
ȘɮXɊȔY,ǧȶƖVǶG<,ªđXj8
U,Kolb XȘʒħȣǛɒqƂǞEKƫŢRż
ƨqȴNK- =EG�>:6
�A0�8O�(Kolb�JT7KBQ ��D�?H(�#)!&)�(%)#!$)(&)#�(� �
��"�PD��LM1�(@<SI*<��������(�L.���;4���
UXWZWXY5<V(-,�����U155<V
A0�8O
"�PD
237K���#
FC�=RBN
+/�'�)�
+9�'�)�
�� �����
� /*$, )%0�%
-1&4����#%
)%0�%
+8'�2"
�3�
������
-1&4����#%
9!:; .�-5(
� /*67�
�3�
� �
�
�
�
�
�
�
� �
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 157
áÞ'aTÑ·(<ÆÌx@�39�
AARY,ǝőŷijXơɛǛȾXKfX/�
�ɌDZ0XȫȼòVā?K,3 ǐXļĠVȚ
NQɃØEQ:>- &/]l;9lX���|�0Vjm/]
l;9l0
żƨXčƈʖdžŅʗVřFQ,/]l;9l0
XÝĭgdžckU?nZUkU7S78Ȇȥ
XȤ9XgSȤƦEK,ȶXj8Uu�¥�
X/]l;9lX���|�0XgS,Ʒż
ƨȖ²Ɩ/]l;9l0q§İVȴNK- '¢¥|�¥�ʖ/ȫà<gEƆĊLNK
k0ʗ żƨXɭȴŅþ7VřFQ,ħǝȫɠ<,
ȫkXȤ9XdžclqüȻòR=mj8V,
ÿFċ7ʖ&/7Ff0VıGmƆĊSEQ
XȤ9Yʤ'ǝő_TXj8U���¥�q
ɦlcG;ʤ(ƆĊSEQ,TrUȴðqE
cG;ʤʗq,3 Ƶʂʖżƨ 1,5,14 čƖʗ
R,ħǝVƚ;ImɈdR6m-CkV,J
XɃɥVĜò<6NKęþY,ÊIQ,/Ȥ9
<ĜpNK=N;?¤ǛǠ0gɃØCIK- (ƛȖčX/ÙÇ]l;9l0�¥�
ýǙV,ƷčXǙÉƨXɚƌSýÔ¹XƷ
ƖɾX/]l;9l�¥�0qƊǛ¤ÑȊC
I,ħ\XĺƳ<¦ǫRp;m�¥��w�
xqÉŪ,ƛȖčX 15 čƖV,/ÙÇ]l;
9l�¥�0q,�¥��w�xqǯfU<
kɃØCIK-/ÙÇ]l;9l�¥�0X¯
UʊǫY,&/żƨqû?mèXȤ90ʢ� 1čǫXżƨqû?mè,/ǝőŷij0h/ħȒ
ɨÒ0qTXj8UgXSŻ9Q7cEK
;ʤ'/¡¥�� ¥Vjmdžcl0,(/¢
¥��y�vVjmdžcl0,)/ǚĔXȤ
90ʢ¦ɫXúlȗdqɨEQ,Ƭ.U¹XȤ
9Vȿn,ǚĔY/ǝőŷij0h/ħȒɨÒ0
qTXj8UgXSŻ9Q7cG;ʤS78
j8U,żƨX¦ɫXǃnqG`Q]l;9
kImgXR6m- AXj8V,ȫà<Ȥ9KASq§İV]
l;9kImAS,CkV,¿èVƚ7Kg
XqÞ\]l;9lU<k,ǚĔXȤ9qƚ
>ASR,ȫkXħ\XdžclqɌɕGm,
Ocl,/��ɌDZ0XȫȼòqţɕR=m¢
¥|�¥�qɶĹǨVȡlɤGżƨƫŪqȤ
9K-ǧȶƖVY,JX¢¥|�¥�XīǓ
qgSV,ɊȔqĘąEK7- âÞ¡�×<�£:6<u¢�´É<A-9�
AncRg,ɽɔèŐXħǝs£~¥�ș
ƤqƸɢE,/õÿŜ0Xā©hȏțǨ¤Çȏ
ǨVȴ8/]l;9l0<,ħȣÝĭSõÿ
ŜqdžfmASVĮ¬EQ7mASqīɆE
Q=K-ºǧȶRY,/��ɌDZ0Xȫȼò_
ā?QXļĠ<,T8,ǝőŷijXơɛǨU
ǛȾ_ș\O7KX;Xàƣq®ŕVǧȶE
K7-ÊIQ,s£~¥�șƤqƸɢE,ħ
ǝÔ.XÅɻXɛǨUàƣqȴNKșƤgÚ
ɽE,õÿŜqʔfm �� X6lƏqƀƦEK
7-U:,ǧȶŐXɂɒRY,S>V,/��
ɌDZ0Xȫȼò_XŷijƏǀhJXàƣŭǀ
VO7Q,ŗŨXU7ţȺqʉ=K7-�
�
& �"�!#"!�������"�!#"!�������� �" $�������� �
¸²Êni¥{�p�ÜÏÝ����)�Â<Ø� �
?-.<z~�ÅsÙ� �Î�¬*o¯º�����
�|���
Ç���INVJ]idj[hO¹½q)»1�
GF>l³1�GEä�°::B;82EINVJ
]idj[hO*ÜZM[Pbt¬Ý�� �á
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 158
�¡Ò©ÒÐÄ;CE\IiejWJhO�×���
%¿Ów<�kH¶�47�¾ÓÍ�¦%�
�
3ǧȶȥ4� LJǟƞȷʖǹūħʁğħ� ÛɨƆȧ�£�¥ʖʇʗʗ�
ßÞ=5A;�
ơǧȶYǹūħʁğħV:7QŴŊEK,
�s¤�¥�t£}VgSP7KżƨXīɝ
ĘąR6m- �¥�¤ɒƋqÉŪGmʃ,ȶǚêL?
RYU>,ƋȃqůäǨVƧɆGmůäǨɐ
ȾêgÿƖVƻfknmASYɀ8cRgU
7-E;E,JgJgůäǨɐȾqʑ8VY,
TXj8Uȩê<èƀSEQÕpNQ7mŖ
ȹ<6mLo8;-JnY,×ȴDzȀSUm
Ƌȃ¤ɚƌXÝĭq,ȎdzVűƁGmȩêR
6m-JAVYɍŋ¤ƋǀXDZɕ¤ɒǛƫŪ
L?RU>,ȆȥXȻǐʖȂęʗh,Ƌȃ<
ƚ;nKȨƗUTqűƁ¤ǛȾGmêgăc
nm-AnqÀV/Ȏɐê0SĈ^UkZ,
Ȏɐê<6NQYFfQ,ɱáUůäǨɐȾ
<üȩVUmS79m- ¿©XAS;k,jlj7 �¥�¤ɒƋ
ÉŪqȴ8KfVY,ůäǨɐȾêV×ȴE
Q,×ȴDzȀSUmƋȃ¤ɚƌqȎdzVűƁ
GmȎɐêqóàVÕ9Q:>Ŗȹ<6m-
AnqżƨŴŊȥXȂę;kŻ9ǬEQ:>
S,ħȣȥVůäǨɐȾêqţɕCImèV,
ȎɐêqʑpIQ:>Ŗȹ<6m,S78A
SR6m- àÞ�Û<���
� èȋRůäǨɐȾXèƵʂSEQȎɐê<
ɶȹR6mASqɥ`K-ơȋRY,¿ªV
ơǧȶRȤ9K7ċʍǐqâŸGm-¿ªX
ɨlR6m- &� ħǝYȎɐêqóàVÕ9Q7mS79
mLo8;-
'� ħǝ<ȎɐêqÕ9Q7U7XR6nZ,
ůäǨɐȾêqʑpImèƵʂSEQ,
ȎɐêqɠVO?CImŭLQ<ŖȹU
XRYU7;- (� Ȏɐêqā©CImKfVY,¦ƏāǨ
UɔȢŌŇXżƨRj7XLo8;- � ¿©XċʍţɕVgSP=,ơǧȶRY,
ǧȶȥ<ǹūħʁğħV:7QŴŊEK/Ƌ
ȃɐȾ0XżƨXīɝĘąqȴ8-șɒq×
úlGnZ,ƒơɍħȣȥVıEQïƤ<ŷ
ƃCnQ7m�s¤�¥�t£}Xŭǀ<,
ƒơɍƶɍɉȥqıɘSEQgïƤǨR6N
KASqɥ`m-ÜÇǨUǂðSEQY,ħ
ȣȥVʖŌҤţćʗƵȱƷVȹȐCI}�
¥�ÝRdzɌCImɑʍh,ÜÇÌqȤ9C
ImɑʍȇqɑE,JXɵŅħȣȥV,ɑʍ
VıGmɌDZ�¡��qĝòCImƭÃq¬
9K-JXșƤ,ħȣȥY,ħȣ¿èjlÝ
ĭűƁȩê<ā©EKASqɥ`m-6pI
Q,�u£�qŲC9mȩêgā©EKAS
R,ȹȐêgā©EKASqɥ`m- áÞ�°<¿Ów=yu0�
� ã®ȇƆȧXĒɍʖƒơɍƶɍɉȥıɘʗ
RY,¯VƆǻǞđƚʖ7pimƆǻƚʗq
ɨFQƋȃɐȾXżƨ<ȴpnQ7m-JA
RY,EZEZůäCnmj8V,�{��
Vƚ;nQ6mÝĭqűƁR=Q7m;T8
;<¯VɇÎCnm-JXKf;,ğħXj
8UʔȇƆȧV:7QY,ħȣȥXÝĭűƁ
VɿGmȩêqdzɌGmƭÃY6clU7j
8Vśpnm-eEo,ȆȥX¯ňqůäǨ
VɐȾGmAS<ɐȾÉƨV:7Q®ŕǨU
P5� õÿħȣ¤}�¥�¢¥|#
― ― 159
ɑʍVUNQ7mXRYU7Lo8;-E;
E,ǧȶȥ<ŴŊEQ7mğħ 3¤4 čǝı
ɘX/ƋȃɐȾ0XżƨV:7Q,ĶȦɈʒ
RßʍCnmÚñĊɈʒh SPIXj8UƋȃ
ǛȾXċʍqħǝVȾ;IQdmS,ǛȾ<
«óàUħǝXĦĔVƹP;Cnm-Ŏkg,
¼XżƨR �¥�qÈŅgƚ7Q=Q7m
YHR6l,6mǽŅXůäǨɐȾêqʑN
Q=Q7mYHR6m<,JXèƵʂSg7
9mÝĭűƁXƵʂRɟ=<ȁ9mXR6m- âÞ�×��%\IiejWJhO%�
� èȋXj8UħǝXǕƿqɞc9mS,ů
äǨɐȾê¿èX,ȎɐêqDžʑEQ7>A
SgŖȹLSȤ9m- � JXǫǨqɯŪGmKf,ƒơɍħȣȥq
ıɘSEKƒơɍƆȧRīɝCnQ7m�
s¤�¥�t£}ʖƼǟ¤ȬĻ 2007ʗqøȤ
VE,AXŭǀqƒơɍƶɍɉȥVgƂǞR
=U7;SȤ9K-ÿ¦�{��qŮASV
EKKf,ǔV�¡��¤�¥�t£}Xŭ
ǀqøȤVEK- � SAoR,Ȏɐêqʑ8KfVY,ƈĞ>
XȞȣ<ŖȹR6mXR,R=mL?Ȕ;>
ɑʍqɄĪE,ǿdɶWmƏǀ<ģcE7- JARǧȶȥY,2016 łŅVŴŊEK/Ƌ
ȃɐȾ"¤#¤$0V:7Q,�{��qŌ
ŇƵȱ,cKţćƵȱƷVÝĭqƊǛ¤ȹȐ
CImżƨqīƐEK- � ÜÇǨUżƨĸɽSEQY,2000ʧ4000ĥǽŅXƎƚ ��;kIJɼXƪɏƚ ��
X�{��qúl©@,¢¥|�¥�VƵȱ
ƷVȹȐCI,ƋȃÝĭhȹȐq}�¥�Ý
RɉEþpIU<kdzɌCImÉƨqɑEK-
ȫàSǥUmɴàqúl©@Q7mţȺ<ß
KęþY,JXȽǐXȮEŠEV;;pkH,
¢¥|�¥�VɃØCIK-ɃɺGmASV
jl,TXj8UɉEþ7<ȴpnK;Ŕȣ
EhG>GmKfR6m-cK,ƋȃRcS
fmAS<R=U7ħȣȥVY,{¥¢¥�
VUlJ8UɀȲqƚ=ßCI,ĵERgǂ
ðVøëCIK- ¿©XÉƨY,YFfVÔ¹R¦ɨlɃØ
EȖpNQ;k}�¥�ǂðVǼmęþS,
YFf;k�{��qƵȱƷVɐdþpIC
I,ȹȐCImęþXµǾʏqǞţEK-Ʒ
čÿFƏǀLSħȣȥ<ʐ=QEc8AS,
ƋȃqɐeɩŅYɩ7<,ǛȾY«óàLS
78ħȣȥV,FN>lɀȲSā=þNQg
k8ASȇqţđEKKfR6m- ãÞÁ£ � żƨXïƤqNjĪGmKf,ȅ 1 čʖ/Ƌ
ȃɐȾ"Xdȅ 7 čXżƨƖ0ʗXżƨƖV
Ⱦ;IKÝĭűƁXċʍSÿ¦Xċʍq,ȅ
15 čXżƨƖVgȾ;IKSAo,abG`
QXħȣȥXƱȈǗ<©ƔEK-ȅ 1 čżƨ
ƖVYȾȈqǶEQ7U;NKXR,ħȣȥ
YƱȈqƘɃEQȈ9KS78ASYȤ9V
>>,ƋȃJXgXX÷ɘ<ƴNQ7müȩ
Ŝ<6mAS¿ĝY,ãȺXċʍqȾ7Kș
ƤSȤ9m-cK,ƟƠɈʒV:7QȹȐċ
ʍgɑEK<,�u£�qŲC9KɃɥ<Ğ
>dknK-AXșƤ;k,żƨqɨEQħ
ȣ¿èjlgȎɐê¤ȹȐê<ā©EKAS
<ȁ9m-CkVżƨs£~¥�XșƤ;k,
�s¤�¥�t£}Vjmǂð<,¦¹Rɐ
ȾÉƨVúlȗejlg,Ń7ȻɷqgM,
ĞƬUȤ9ƏqǛȾGmȩêh,Èqƚ>`
=�u£�UX;q,ȓƓ>ǧȺGmȩê<
ɠVO7KASqīŤEQ7mƬĤ<ȁ9K- ãÞ/GD; � ůäǨɐȾêXā©qǫŷGèVȎɐêX
ā©qǫŷGASY,ƝǩR6mSȤ9m- øȤƋǖ ƼǟǘĤ¤ȬĻǁĤʖ2007ʗ1�s¤�¥�
£}�éɪǨUħ\X��u£XKfV�2
[OFƚŬ
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 160
(;&1�g�� ¤!b��WMb�XT����
=6A0�§I�³�!P}�
�
:Ȳʉɵ;� ÎȾǍÀ±şǟȎ±ǸǟʲŚ±¾ȰĞɜœ±Űǭŕƈ˻ƞȼēɊŋŗ˼�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
¾½�����
˃Ż4x��y�ª²�°�`ƦȈ`´W
[KY4ĖðŗɳBġpôrorWW<q5�
ĖðZ ²�mDžɑuÚơMqŃħ4�
ª{��²��uāȩKY�wz¬uəȦM
qH[^np4�wz¬÷ǚmĨǓɩ˦]\
BĤɺ[]qSkāàƙBĪ¶K4Ėðŗɳ
�²¬[KY˩Ź^ǚčZ<q[ɴ?orq5�
ƞȼēɊŋŗZlÿŻǼ`ŗȨ^ŜljKY
=q�¨²�«x¬ƹǯ^@=Y4�ª{�
�²��`�WZ<q�((#&"��¨¤°�u
āȩKY4��¬²� �ĩZ �ɩ`ʵdž˻
�¤˼uÚơJOY=q5�¤Úơ`Sk
`ʩǪ@ncȔîa½[KYƹǯǓ˟ň^ʆ
trY=qB4Ǔ˟mŃƥ`ĂɝBũ]=S
kŗȨAo`ʞßl˹=5�
H` �((#&" ��¨¤°�^aɩ˦`ɻĎ
äŔǹɺB<p4�wz¬^ôĈKSɩ˦ɵ
[ɩ˦ǓăuƨƽMqH[BZCq5H`ǹ
ɺuȩ=Y˦ʖuʆ=4ýǥMqH[^np4
HrhZƨƽBĸ˨Z<VS ²�Úơ`
ĖðÚǯ^ˠMq�®��^ţKYx�®²
�BĤɺ^]p4Ėðŗɳ^ţMqǂɸčǨ
mǚčƙ4ƱŧLjȈ`ǀijd`ƔȩBǜƍZ
Cq5�
�
¿½�´g�"���WMH��¬�w��
¿¼¾½¬���£�
�ª{�`ɩ˦ůǾAoƏorSɩ˦Ǔă
u˦ʖKSɣǨ4ĨǓă^ʋDŽ`ɩ˦ɵBÚ
ǯKY=qǓ˟ŷ[4�¬²�ŗɳɡÂƎ^
ʆVSx°�²�ZƏorSĖðŗɳuʆV
SǓ˟ŷ`ýŴBfg´ɼMqH[BǎoA
^]VS5QHZ4ĨǓă^ʋDŽ`ɩ˦ɵB
ɩ˦KY=qůǾ˻˙ʋůǾ˼uĖðÚǯ`
Ʊǵ[KY4˦ʖ[ýǥuʆ>H[^KS5
¿¼¿� XTJu�b��.%5�P·�
hN4�¬²�ù`Ħɩ˦ɵ`ůǾDŽ[4
Ì`ɩ˦ɵ[˙ʋKSƁeůǾDŽu˦ʖKS5
˙ʋůǾDŽ^ȂÞKYĖð^nqÚǯǓ˟B
˜D]q[ɴ?orqB4HHZaÎȾfA�
�������ZśɱKS8ĜĉáDŽ9uȩ=Y4
²�Úơ^@FqĖðÚǯ^ţMqɎǰƙ
uDŽêđMq5�
1˼ĖðÚǯ`ĜĉȟȇuʉMƱǵ˻Ĝĉá
DŽ˼ ˦ʖKS�²�uŁ^4Ǽ`W`Ʊǵ
˻ èÈ˙ʋůǾDŽ 4 ɨ˙ʋůǾDŽ 4 Ĝĉ
áDŽ˼ uśɱMq5 ± èÈ˙ʋůǾDŽ 1 ĩ`ɩ˦ɵ˻ŗȨ˼
B4Ì`ɩ˦ɵ˻ŗȨ˼[˙ʋKSůǾ`ɨ
DŽ ± ɨ˙ʋůǾDŽ ĨL�¬²�^ŮMqɩ
˦ɵ˻ŗȨ˼`èÈ˙ʋůǾDŽ`ɨĮ ± ĜĉáDŽèÈ˙ʋůǾDŽuɨ˙ʋ
ůǾDŽZĆVSl`5˻èÈ˙ʋůǾDŽ
˿ɨ˙ʋůǾDŽ˼ H`śɱ^KSB>[4Þ?b43 ĩ`ů
ǾBĨǓ^ 10 Ķ˙ʋKSŃħa4 èÈ˙ʋ
ůǾDŽaQrRr 104 �¬²�˙ʋůǾ
DŽ30 []p4 ĜĉáDŽa 3 ĩ[l 1/3˻0.333˼[]q5QKY4�¬²�<S
p`˙ʋůǾDŽa4ĦèÈ`˙ʋůǾDŽ`ɨ
Į[]qSk4�¬²�<SpĜĉáDŽ`
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 161
ħʖa 1 []q52 ĩ�¬²�`Ńħ4ƒN
ĨLDŽTF˙ʋMqSk4ĜĉáDŽaQrR
r 0.5 []q53 ĩж`�¬²�`ŃħZ
l41 Ķ`˙ʋ<Sp4ǘÖZlʚ˛Jrq
˙ʋůǾDŽa 2 []qSk4èÈ`ĜĉáDŽ
`ǘŋêa 0.5 []q5 2˼ĜĉáDŽ^nqý˴ ĜĉáDŽBŋC=f\4ĖðÚǯ^Ɏǰȵ^
ĜĉKY=q[ʕ?qB43 ĩõįBĿɔ^
ĖðÚǯuʆVSŃħ4ɔýȂȢ` 1/3 []
q`Z4HruŁȔ[KYŗɳɵ`ý˴uʆ
>5ĜĉáDŽBɔýȂȢ`ĕý˻1/6˼ǝȓ`
ŗȨu8ȌǰĖðŗɳɵ94ĜĉáDŽBǿp`
5/6 `ĕý(5/12˼ж`ŗȨu8ɎǰĖðŗ
ɳɵ94Q`»˟Z<q 1/6 жAW 5/6 ǝȓ
u8»˟Ėðŗɳɵ9[KS5 �
À½)<A5�e�!WMb�.%5�P·�
�¬²�ùZ`ŗɳɵ�z�`ýŴAo4
�¬²�uŋCD 3 W`�z�^ý˴KS5 1 õ˼įĖð�z�� � 3 ĩ[l»˟Ėðŗɳ
ɵ`�¬²�uH`�z�[KS5H`Ńħ4
ĖðÚǯ^ţMqèÈ`ʱȡſaĿʇKY=
q5Ėðŗɳ[KYǛhK=ƇƠ[ʕ?q5 2 »˼ƑĖð�z�� � 3 ĩ`>U 1 ĩBɎǰ
ĖðŗɳɵZ42 ĩB»˟Ėðŗɳɵ`�¬
²�uH`�z�[KS51 ĩB»Ƒ[]V
Y4Ì` 2 ĩ[ÇÅ^ĖðŗɳuʆVSŃħ
^H`�z�^]q5 3 Ȟ˼śĖð�z�� � 3 ĩ`>U 1 ĩBȌǰ
ĖðŗɳɵZ4ǿp` 1 ĩhSa 2 ĩBɎǰ
Ėðŗɳɵ`�¬²�uH`�z�^ý˴K
S53 ĩ`>Uf[v\ 2 ĩTFZĖðŗɳ
uʆVSŃħ^H`�z�^]q53 ĩ`Ė
ðŗɳ[KYaǛhKD]=ƇƠ[ʕ?q5
Á½WM.%5�o���³J�
¶˅`n>^4�ª{�`ɩ˦ůǾAoĖ
ðŗɳ`ƇƠu 3 �z�^ý˴ZCS5Ėð
ŗɳ[KYǛhK=ƇƠZ<q[ɴ?orq
8õįĖð�z�9 �¬²�a48ȞśĖð
�z�9mĖðÚǯBf[v\ʍor]AV
S�¬²�^ȂeYè6`ÚǯmĖðÚǯ`
˞ŏǓǜBnjD4njǜ^ȺƦKYĖĈMqï
ĪBʍorS˻ÎȾfA˻2017˼˼5 Hro`ɣǨAo8õįĖð�z�9aÅ
=`ĖĈˠá[=>ȗZaĖðŗɳ`čǨB
<VS[ʕ?qB4Hro`ƜłTFZa4
ǂɸčǨ4ŗɳčǨuýǥ±ǮʗMqH[a
ĸ˨Z<q5 QHZ4Ƣ6a4´ɽȵ] ²�^l˓
ȩZCqn>]ơɭʞß`¬²�«��uÚ
ơMqH[^KS5¬²�«��`Úơ^<
SVY4Ǥ·fA�����`ȿɏuĜɴ^KS5
ƆNJaQ`ʞßLjȈmŎƆƙlīkYłĬM
q5 �
®°�
ǟȿɏ`´˔a4���� Ɋȿʳ �������� `Ċ
ơuĢFSl`ZM5�
�
X�v��
ÎȾǍÀ4şǟȎ4Űǭŕƈ4¾ȰĞɜœ4
ǸǟʲŚ (2016) �ª{�uāȩKSʨňȊ
Ď^@FqŗȨ`Ėðŗɳd`Ĝĉȟȇ`ý
ǥ˾ŋŗǂɸŗÓɓ 38 ĶŋÓȲʉʌNj˦˛ pp.226-227�ÎȾǍÀ4şǟȎ4Űǭŕƈ4¾ȰĞɜœ4
ǸǟʲŚ (2017) �ª{�uāȩKSĖðŗ
ɳ^@FqÚǯůǾAoʍS ²�Úơˎ
Ɍ`ýǥ NJ˾ǟǂɸűŗÓȿɏÓłĬ˦ 17(1) pp.557-562�Ǥ·�ÛÏ4Ũ˚�ĮŚ4˹Ǹ�˥Ê(2013) ²�ʞß^@Fq¬²�«��`˞Ȳ[Q
` å ˱ ƙ ` Ǯ ʗ ˾ ŋ ŗ ǂ ɸ ŗ Ó ʢ 4
35(1)pp.107-115
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 162
q�c¯a]ÃQj�s�� !�tªS��
�)<A5?A(��!\|Ho�B��¨���
�
:Ȳʉɵ;� ľǣŜœ˻ǃƞŋŗ˼�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
¾½b��tª�
�� � ŻÏ^�°��}°���xBȳŃ5
�� Ż^�w¢«²��ª°8��²�9
`NJǟ¶ˢ5�� Ż^ĒȋˏZʤȨKSū˗
Ŭ8Wgö9B4õĺŭ˞u˞ŏMq`B ����
Ż5���� ŻÏnp4�°��}°���x4
�w¢«²��ª°mū˗Ŭ�|²°BƘ
ˈ^ȲŭKS5�
ɉa ���� ŻȨhrZ4ɉBŽũǜuˆVS
ǓÏ^a4hTQroa<hpȘAVS5ʼn
D`œ\lĪF`ȝʥ]\^lǃʥB<Sp
h?`n>^ÝtrY@p4�� ZʑY=S
8hvB¹ȯǐʠ9lɰK=ǃʥZʥorY
=S5ºʐB4äɸĻmŗǫ`óȨ4˃ƥ`
Ż˖`Lj6[ǃʥZʠKY=q`uɶD`l
NJŹȵ]H[TVS5�
KAK4���� ŻÏÐˡ^ʤȨKSŗȨSU
a\>Ts>A5Ƌoa4ŽũǜAo�w¢
«²��ª°m�°��}°���xZ
8�z�ǃʥ9uɶC4877ƣˣ9m�¦ª
��²`ʠM4ƿ˫ʥƿƠʥBʼnD4ȽDžm
ėʥKAȳŃK]=n>]DTFSNJǟʥ^
ʔrYɸVS5ʐlǂŶmŻ˖ɵ^ǃʥuÝ
VYa=]AVS[ɖ?qŗȨlʼn=5�
ŋÈSUB8�z�ǃʥ9uǔˇZa]=
[tAVYɶ=Y=S`^ţK4Ƌo^[V
YaQroHQB8ǃʥ9TVS5<qɌſ
ʧǗuMqŗȨZ<rb4ǃʥ`ȼʬlǟA
oƏorqTs>5KAK4ʧǗ˧rBˌi4
Ɯłu�¡�AoƏqǓÏ^]VSƉˬlŋ
C=5ƋoBCUv[KSǃʥuÝ?]=`
aƋo`O=bApZa]=5�
�
¿½Qj�s�� !tªb��
ŋŗȨ^]VYx¬�z�uŏkqŗȨl
ʼn=5x¬�z�aǃʥ`Ŝʺ`ŃZ<p4
QHZŇ]ǃʥuʼ^WFYKh>Ńħl<
q5ŋŗÿŻǼ^4CUv[KSǃʥuŗc4
x¬�z�ZŜʺMq[=>`a4ɅÓȵ�
�¬uɁDSk^lǚčZ<q5�
ǃƞŋŗĺˤŗ˔´ŻȨ8Džɑʉȥ98ģ˰
ʉȥ9 ƹǯZa4ąǜ^lƎǜ^l8ǃʥ9
`ėòuʛFY=q5�
�
À½R{�C©����w��p���
ąǜ^a4ǂɊǗ˻˼`8ǃʥ`�«¬9
ZŗvT<[^48ƭIJ9[8ǃø9Zз`
ÆȀʂuƴj8@¹ʠ^]VSLjd`Ʀɞ9
uǗD5�
ɓ´ȀʂŖɚmìƀuȃ˒><=JWDž�
ɓÄȀʂȩÒ˻H`Ńħa8@Ʉ9˼ �
ɓµȀʂ˃ȇ˻ǎǖuWFq˼�
ɓĵȀʂȶǵmŊ˻ˑ˃uWFq˼�
ɓÆȀʂHrAo`Ŗɚmìƀuȃ˒>
<=JWDž�
8ǎǖ9uWFq[a4==H[bApZ
a]D4Q`ą^ʀČKY=qH[mƤƝV
SH[uôrqH[48ˑ˃9uWFq[a4
8ŦǢaĺˤɅÓZȊʻKS=5ÉahNʁ
ʥuɻļ^Ý?qn>^]pS=59]\`n
>^4ņŋ]Ŋ[4Ʀ˃]ċĈȶǵuǗDH
[Z4ɐØȵ^]pʦƏĈBńM4[=>Ʊ
ɃZ<q5�
ʛʖĹuŀk4ɫǗCĚɍȩɞ^ǗC4ȏ
ĄB˄VYCSl`uɫǗCàɘ^ȐǗMq5�
Q`ȐǗaǂŶB��²uäəK4ĚǟaM
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 163
E^ŗȨ^˄KY4Ŝˤ^˕ˆMqn>^Ô
?q5ȐǗ`��²a4ŗǜǞ^ÚơMq8è
ÈDž˦9^ƴi˂j5�
Ʀɞ`<Yóa4˹ ǫ`óȨ4 Ȋ`˵ı4
ʐ4Ɇțȁ]\Bʼn=5ôŗɇuloVS`
^hT@ɄȟuüKY=]=ŗȨlʼnD4=
=ǹÓ^]q5hS4Ƌo`üʼǫ`óȨ`4
ǃƞŋŗd`ĘʯlɾD]q`Z4ŗȨĐ˦
^lʱȡZCY=qn>Z<q5�
�
Á½l{�tªS��
Ǝǜa4�¬²�¯²�Z8ǃʥć9`ĥ
ǟuÚp4¶ȖMq5ĥǟaȩɞǧ^
ĠhqH[48ë=È˻ ǃʥuÝ>eCȸƦ 9˼
uĩƒNȳŃJOqH[4x���°�u
´WƒNʸHMH[4ǃʥ`Ý=LjuŌǁK
Y4ȷM�²°uôrqH[4]\`ǡÒ`
l[Z4ĥǟuÚVY=D5�
�
� Ĺƹǯ���¨²¬�
ˎě`óˀSUBÚơKSĥǟuȤZŜˤ
^ʧiħtOuKY{~²¢°�x��^K
Sp4Ǝǜ`ɓ´ˋAoũKNW�¬²�¯
²�`Ǔ˟ulVSpMqH[Z¥��²�
©°u¶G4ɓˋhZ^aĥǟařơMq5
ɓˋB¶ȖNJ5H`NJaŋŗ`óȨSUB
Ì`óȨ`ƹǯuʍŗMqˋ˟`»^<qS
k4ĩ`óȨmÃď`Lj^ʑć4ʫʞ
KYlo?q5�
˽ĥǟÞ8@ŒJvuDTJ=9˻˼�
� ÓɅZÍCħVY=qƋō`ŜŠ^4ɣŐ
ȬK˂i`ƵƯ^ʆD4[=>ć58@ŒJv
[@ÍCħ=JOY=ST=Y@phM77
ZM59[ĩ¿VSȻ˟^4Ƌō`țʐB8ʜ
ĤKSʏ?a]=˺9[Ɩq5]PƖVS`
AtAo]=Z=qÄÈ^4Ƌō`ȁʐB8ʜ
ĤKY=]=H[^4JOY=ST=Y@
phM4[=>[ȃuƛDMqÈl=q`n9
[ʦǎMq5ƎNJÄÈal>´ſƲƣK4ɣ
ŐuʜĤJrq5˻ ýƄ˼�
�
� Ĺǃʥć¶Ȗ�
� Ì^l8ǭȪìÚĔʃȹȼÃB¢����
�^mVYDq948ǃʥ^>qJ=§°�²
Bª²¤°Ŭ`�z�žį`ǃʥuȷM94
8ǃʥ^>qJ=ȣǴ9]\4˪ȴ=ĥǟB
ȨhrY=q5ˎě`ŗȨ`ŢÍmɉBƥʄ
MqAWomŨȝ4ʈʊ]\lÝtrq5�
� ŜaĨL���¨²¬ZȰŗȨ8ɨħNJǟ
ʥ9[=>ɉBƬƆMqƹǯZl8ǃʥć9
uKY@p4ĞƜüȖB<VSp4Ì`�ª
�`ʑćuKSp4DZK=z�°�[]VY
=qB4ĥǟÚơ`Sk^ǂɊǗ`ǃʥ`ė
òuMiNihZʧvTp4�«�uʏ?S
pMq>U^4Ŝȩȵ]ǃʥlʼ^WFor
Y=q5
˻˼� ľǣŜœ8ŋŗȨ`Sk`Džɑʉȥɪ
ɳŸ9˻ ĺǗþʆÓ 2016˼ ˻˼ĎȮ8ǃʥć ����9�(,�,�"�
$++)*���...�/(,+,�"� ('�.�+ $�-�!&�����
��%�
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 164
Nb�l�G¹���l�#(/$4;A2@)�Y��kµ�
���¡h�r��5>);8�ZG¹��Vb��bLo~�³J��
�
:Ȳʉɵ;� ŋĮȪ� Ɉ´˻˘ˁŗĻŋŗ� đŗȿɏޱ÷ˇǂɸ˞ȲŞ˼�
�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
¾½�����
LJôȨ�«}°�²�©°ɔ`ŋŗôŗȷ
Ǝ^˻Ǔ[KYôŗą^˼ŜljJrqÿŻǼ
ǂɸ�®�ª£˻з48ôŗǓ�®�ª£9
[ĭɋ˼a4ʼnD`ŋŗZaÑ˟XDp4ŋ
ŗȨȊd`˓Ɣuȶȵ^ŜljJrY=q[Ɨ
trq5KAK]Bo4Qro`�®�ª£
`»^aɅÓƑȦŗ4�¬²��z�¢��
ɔ`ȼʍ^ŁXCLJôȨuȍ=ɻųȦʓ[Ì
ɵȦʓ^ŧDl`l<p4Ǝ^ɦD½Øȵ±
ţʠȵZȍ=ŗcuƓĪMqƹǯuĢʫMq
ɟĽXDp[KYlǹɺMqĤɺƙB<q5�
ǟȿɏ`ȶȵa4ɻųȦʓ[ÌɵȦʓu˹
kqH[^ʵMqôŗǓ�®�ª£uØ˷K
SH[B4ĖĨŗɳ^ŁXD8đŗ9`ŗæ
^ĝgMƉˬuǎoA^MqH[Z<q5�
¿½Nbz5>3;8�q���£�
X ŋŗZa 2011 Ż2014 Ż`˟4ɢɮ˞
Ȳ`Ȧʪ^ŁXCdzơJrY=q0ɻų`ƻ
Ȇ1�®�ª£˻ ³ª²�°��«¨² u˼4
õLJôȨţʯ`ôŗǓ�®�ª£[KYŧô
KS5Hra4èȯ²�4�¬²�¯²�4
ƶp˄puɢiħtOY4Ñ˟`ɻųȦʓȍ
đuƦĊFMqH[uØ˷Mq 2 NJ˟`�®
�ª£Z<q52015 Ż^a=VSvĦŗ˴`
Ƞɻ�®�ª£^ƐKSB4B ŗ˴Za 2016
Żnp 1 NJ˟`ȽɬȜ[KYûcŜljJrq
n>^]VS5
H` B ŗ˴` 1 ŻǼƎǜ^˞ʫJrY=q
8đŗ9Za4ĖĨŗɳ`ƧȈ` 1 WZ<q
LTD ʠKħ=ŗɳȈuŁʽ^Ƹ?Y4ŋŗǂ
˶�¬`đŗ`ŗæuˌkY=q˻ ŋĮȪ4
2016 5˼ĢʫɵDŽa42015 Żſ114 ĩ42016
Żſ85 ĩZ<VS5 À½w��
8đŗ9`ĢʫɵB0ɻų`ƻȆ1�®�
ª£uØ˷KY=q ���� Żſ[4Ø˷KY=
]= ���� Żſ`ŗæȟȇuȂʾKS5�
Ȅ˚o˻����˼a4ôŗǓ�®�ª£uØ
˷KSĜĉɵ^ȨʸMqƑȦȵčǨa48ɻų
Ȧʓ`í˪98ÌɵȦʓ`í˪98ŗǫȦʓ`
í˪9 í˪AoƷ?qH[BZCq[K4
H` í˪uȒśMqɛǏȜŪſ˻ ʖ � ˭ȶ
`ʶı˼u˞ȲKY=q5H`ŪſuƺȩK
SʶıɞʩǪu4ôŗȷƎ` Ǚ˻���� Ż^
W=Ya0ɻų`ƻȆ1Ŝlją˼[ƹǯǘɡ
Ķ` � Ǚ^ʆ=4ŗȨè6^W=Y í˪I
[`Õ˜uȒśK4ƹǯùš`Ȧʓſ˻ʟ˷
ơɭ˼[`ˠáuǮʗKS5 í˪`ʶıɞ
ʩǪZMeY`˭ȶ^ĶɖK4AW48đŗ9
`ʟ˷uĢ˷KSɵuǮʗţʯ[KS5 Á½�~��d�
ʉ � ^4���� Żſ[ ���� Żſ`ʟ˷`źĿ
ȗ[Q`ȁDŽuɃM5���� Żſ`LjB˹Əȗ
uɃKY=qB4Hr^aƹǯǓ^ʆVSƱ
ŧ˻Ƕƿʟ˷uŜlj˼`čǨlʉrY=ql
`[ɴ?orq5�
ʶıɞʩǪ`��x` ǙAo � ǙdAF
Y`Õcu ǙƆÿ`êZĆVSl`uŇđ
Ȣ[śɱK4ţʯŗȨè6`Ħí˪`ŇđȢ
uȆkS5ʉ � a4ÌɵȦʓ[ɻųȦʓ`Ň
đȢ`ǽʰ^ƔLY W^ý˴KSǓ`4
���� Żſ`ʟ˷źĿȗZ<q5hS4ʉ a
QrRr`ý˴`ÈDŽZ<q5Hro`ʉA
o4ƹǯùš`ȦʓſaÌɵȦʓ±ɻųȦʓ
`ŇđȢBʰZ<qɵnpl4ǽZ<qɵ`
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 165
LjB˹=ïĪ^<qH[BtAq5�
H`ɻųȦʓ±ÌɵȦʓ`ŇđȢ^ˠMq
ý˴`ÈDŽdzơȂuɃKS`B4ʉ ˻����
Żſ˼[ʉ �˻���� Żſ˼Z<q5ºɵuȂ
ʾMq[4ÌɵȦʓ^W=Ya ���� Żſ`Lj
Bǽ`ŇđȢuɃMɵBʼn=H[BtAq5�
ж`ɣǨnp4ôŗȷƎ 0ɻų`ƻɏ1
�®�ª£uØ˷MqH[aÌɵȦʓ`í˪
uÕbK4Q`Ǝ^ŭ˞JrSĖĨŗɳ^Ł
XD8đŗ9`ŗæơǨu˹kY=qĤɺƙ
BɃİJrS5�
:ƂȩDžȡ; Hochi, Y., Yamada, Y., & Mizuno, M.
(2010). Effects of Organizational Development on the Psychological Aspects among University Students. International Conference for the 40th Anniversary of Human Ergology Society Program and Abstracts, pp39-40.
Ȅ˚ŁǷ4ŰȪȉʆ4ɿĽȉż4×ȪǕƃ4
Ēǭɱǎ (2010)8ŋŗǂɸ^@Fqɢɮ˞
Ȳ`Ø˷BŋŗȨ^lSoMčǨ^ˠMq
ȿɏ94ÿŻǼǂɸŗÓɓĶŋÓȲʉʌNj
˦4p108-109. ŋĮȪɈ´ (2016). 8LTD ʠKħ=ŗɳȈ
uȩ=Sŋŗǂ˶đŗ`ƹǯ˻ 9˼4NJǟ
ĖĨǂɸŗÓɓ 13 ĶŋÓʌNj˦. Rabow, J., Charness, M. A., Kipperman, J.,
& Radcliffe-Vasil, S. (1994). William F. Hill’s Learning Through Discussion. California. Sage.� ¼˚ã ±Řȅƚ˻ ÷ʝ ˼ʗʪZŗɳuȍkq^a3LTD ʠKħ=ŗ
ɳȈ3. ����§üȜ, 1996. Řȅƚ, ˮʅDž (2014). LTD ʠKħ=ŗɳȈ ����§üȜ.
.
2015 ˻ɻųƻ]K˼
2016 ˻ɻųƻ<p˼
źĿȗ 45.8 77.5 ÈDŽ 64 56
źĿȗ ÌɵȦʓ`ŇđȢ ʰ ǽ õØ
ɻųȦʓ `ŇđȢ
ʰ 38.4 47.5 40.6 ǽ 51.0 60.9 58.3
õØ 40.0 55 45.8
2015˻ɻųƻ]K˼ ÈDŽdzơȂ
ÌɵȦʓ`ŇđȢ ʰ ǽ õØ
ɻųȦʓ `ŇđȢ
ʰ 53.1% 17.2% 70.3% ǽ 7.8% 21.9% 29.7%
õØ 60.9% 39.1% 100%
ÈDŽ ÌɵȦʓ`ŇđȢ ʰ ǽ õØ
ɻųȦʓ `ŇđȢ
ʰ 34 11 45 ǽ 5 14 19
õØ 39 25 64
2016˻ɻųƻ]K˼ ÈDŽdzơȂ
ÌɵȦʓ`ŇđȢ ʰ ǽ õØ
ɻųȦʓ `ŇđȢ
ʰ 39.3% 28.6% 67.9% ǽ 8.9% 23.2% 32.1%
õØ 48.2% 51.8% 100%
¢ 1. ¨¹�i_���u
¢ 2. ¢ 3.
¢ 4. ^P·�Du�o�º2015
¢ 5. ^P·�Du�o�º2016j»
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 166
U�bL"K±�!`��+792*A,:@-'<�¸o�
�On��F��¦"�����fN�0=A2@)�²��¨���
�
:Ȳʉɵ;ʮȪǦŅ˻ŋǽŋŗƑȦɅÓŗ˔˼�
¾½�����
˃Ż4ÿŻǼǂɸ^@=Ya4ŗȨɻʼB
½Øȵ^ʨ˲uȲʍK4Q`ɖ?uƻKȆk
Y=DɺĎȵŗæuġpôrqH[BȆko
rY@p4Q`ơǨučǨȵ^¶GqSk^
a4ŗȨ`Ėʩƙm�¢¨��²�©°��
¬[=VSʵʶ^ȺȶK4Q`˶ơuÜOY
ŜljMqH[B˙ʌ[]q5 Hro`��¬ɔ`Ī¶B˙ʌ]ʨ˲Z<
qH[a4ɺĎȵŗæ^W=Y`ŌǁÃÞ`
ýǥ[Q`dzˉđuʟiSÁç˻2015˼^@
=YlʕĝJrY=q5ÁçaŌǁ`Ěķ[
KY4ƹǯ`dzơ`i]oN4ŗȨ`ŗĈ¸
ʹm8ţÈƧɺ¸ɾ9[KY`�¢¨��²
�©°��¬`ǻʂuƳGY=q5KAK]
Bo4ŋŗȨ´ɽuţʯ[K4Jo^Ɋŗȵ
ǬƮ^ǬŲKS�¢¨��²�©°��¬Ī
¶`�²�°�Ȉa<hpŔļK]=5Q
HZǟȿɏZa4÷Ɵȵ]ÌɵȦʓ^șȗu
ƆY4ʉƜuÊK]BoȸƦ[ƟƜu÷ǚM
q[=>Łɂȵ]�¢¨��²�©°��¬
^ˠKY4ÿŻǼɊȶ`ƹǯ`´ȧ[KYŜ
ljĤɺ]�²�°�Ȉu˞ȲMqH[uȶ
ȵ[KY=q5
¿½Onm�����F��¦�
Ìɵ[ƟƜu÷ǚMqH[a4úȕ]�¢
¨��²�©°uˍʆMq¶Zl4�¬²�
¯²�ZĖʩȵ^Ìɵ[ʗʭMq¶ZlǻA
MH[`ZC]=ʌɟZ<q5H`Ìɵ`Ɵ
Ɯu÷ǚMqȥʯa4ƜĎÔǩ[ĭbrq5
2 ɵ˟`ƟƜBĨǜMq˻ ÷ǚJrq˼ a4
hNĚŏȵ�®��[KYʉƜǶéBȨʸM
q5ʉƜǶé[a4Ìɵ`ʉƜuʣȼKSˤ4
ğťȵ^ȸƦ[ĨǴ`ʉƜuʉüMqȥʯ`
H[Z<p4ǶéKSʉƜ^ŁX=YLJS^
ƟƜBȨʸMq5H`Ȩʸ^ˠKYa4ȸƦ
[ĨLʉƜuǶéMqH[^nVY4Q`ʉ
Ɯ^ţƔKSƟƜB�y²����Jrq5
Þ?b4ɒ˳`Ƕé4M]tUģʒBƂC¶
Bp4˯`ɕɷ˻ŋ˯˸ɕ˼BȊƙđKSȟ
Ơ[=>ÃŜ^nVY4ɻų`»^żO[=
>ƟƜB�y²����Jr4ÉaőK=[
=>ƟƜBƎAoĴʸJrq[=>¤���
£Z<q5H`Ëɢi^np4ǶéKSʉƜ
AoȸƦ`ƟƜu÷ǚMqH[BĤɺ[]q5 À½[¥V"���0=A2@)�
ǟȿɏa4Ìɵ`ƟƜu÷ǚK]BoȸƦ
u÷Ɵȵ^ȦʓZCqn>^]q�²�°
�Ȉu˞ȲK4ÿŻǼǂɸ`ŧôǓǜ^H`
ʘɪu˙_qH[ZŗȨ`�¢¨��²�©
°��¬mĖʩƙuĪ¶JOqTFZ]D4
Ǝ`ʫɱZŜljMq�¬²�¯²�Z`Ȳʕ
mʗʭuâˌJOqH[u˜ǜȵ]ȶȵ[K
Y=q5 ǟȿɏZa4ţÈŃ˪Z`ɻʼ`ʉƜǶé
uŝʑȵ]ƦȈuȩ=YƨƽMq[=>Ĥʎ
đ���£uȩ=Y�²�°�uŜljMq5
øØȵ^a4ĤʎđJrSǑñmʉƜǶé`
Ȩʸ`ɌſuɻʼZɀʣKSpýǥKSpK
]Bo4npȚːKSʉƜǶéuʆ>Sk`
ǀijuɻoĹqH[4hS4Ėʩȵ]ˠáu
Ƈơ±ɧưMqSk^ȸƦ`ʉƜuǶéMq
H[B˙ʌZ<q[`ȃXCuâˌJOqH
[uȶƱKY=q5
P6� ĖĨŗɳ±�¬²�¯²�2
― ― 167
Figure1. óʆȿɏ`Ĥʎđ���£
HrhZ`Ĥʎđ`óʆȿɏZa42 ɵ`
ţÈÓʠŃ˪uʛF4ʠKƦ[ɶCƦ`ƊĆ
^ýFYʘɪuŜljKS5ʠKƦB˯`ʉƜ
ɕuȊƙđJO]BoőK=ʠuKY=qˤ
`4ɶCƦ`ʉƜɕ`ĎCuȒśMqH[Z
ʉƜǶé`ȨʸBDŽêđJrq5ÜOYÓʠ
Ń˪`ºLj`ʉƜu���Z˛ȮMq5Ĥʎ
đ[KY4Hro`�²�uɤħKSɻʼ`
�²�˻Figure1˼uɲˋ^ƦȑJrýǥB
Ȇkorq5ɶCƦaɻʼ`ʉƜǶéuƨƽ
K]Bo4Q`ǀijuĹqH[^]q5
Á½�y��[¥V0=A2@)�¨��
ɛǏȜ�²�°�Ȉa4ÿŻǼɊȶZ`
Ŝljuƕ˰^ɯC4Ť˝ȵǹǠuÝȩON^4
ʉƜǶé`Ȓś[ɻʼ`�²�ýǥuŜljM
q5Ȕîȝa4���ª�¬[=>ȷƌ 1cmɌſ`¼Ƈ`�²¬[4Ĝĉɵ`�¡²��
~°Z<q5H`�²�°�Za4Ĝĉɵ
a 2 È 1 ɢ^]p4ʠKƦ[ɶCƦ^ýAr4
ʠKƦBȸƦ^őKAVSʠuʆ>ţÈÓʠ
ʨ˲uŜljMq5H`ʨ˲»4Å=^ȸƦu
�¡²��~°ZȸƦuƾƉMq5Ǝ^Q`
ĎȮuȩ=YʉƜǶé`ȨʸuǮʗMq5ø
Øȵ^a4ŋ˯˸ɕ`Ȋƙuʎʏȵ^ȦʓK
mMDMqSk^4ʠKƦlɶCƦlº˯`
ŋ˯˸ɕ^ʷ`�²¬uʴÍMq5QKY4
Ħɻ`�¡²��~°uÇƼK4ʉƜ^˙]
o]=n>^ɹò^�¡²��~°udz?4
ʠKƦBʠKY=qˤl4ɶCƦBQruɶ
=Y=qˤlÅ=`ʉƜuĎȮZ˛ȮK<>5
ʠKƦBʠuɡ?SoƊĆuÇÏMqB4ʨ
˲BɥɦKY=qˤa4ȸƦ^�¡²��~
°uʙMSk4ɻʼ`ţÈʨ˲»`ʉƜBĎ
ȮZ˛ȮJrqH[^]q5
ʨ˲uɡ?q[4QrRr`�¡²��~
°uưU½Z<qȸƦ^˄ęMq5ɛǏȜ^
@FqʉƜǶé`Ĥʎđ���£[a4H`
�¡²��~°^˛ȮJrSɻʼ`ĎȮuʍ
]Bo4ɶCƦ`ˤ^�²¬ZƅʩJrSʉ
ƜɕBĎC4ʉƜǶéBȨʸKY=q`A\
>AuƨƽMqH[Z<q5
½�y��cx�El�«¶�
ǘƎ^4ǒŻ^ÿŻǼɊȶ`ƹǯZŜljK
SɛǏȜ�²�°�[ÃƎʶıɞ^ţMq
ĶɖułĬMq5H`ƹǯZa 2 ˋˊɦZɛ
ǏȜBŜljJr41 ˋȶ`Ĝĉɵa 37 È˻ ȭ
ƙ 21 È4ōƙ 16 È 4˼2 ˋȶa 30 È˻ȭƙ
17 È4ōƙ 13 È˼Z<VS5 ÉƎ`ʨ˲uƫüMqSk4ÃƎʶıɞ`
ɻȫʚ˅Ǻ^ʚʿJrSзuĜɴ[KS5
8˳^�²¬uʴVS`aɾAVSB4ȱƙ
`ąZ�²¬uʴqH[^ƪƩB<VS94
8ĎȮZƾƉJrY=qSk�§�§KYK
hVS9Z<q5ţɗ[KY4ĢʫȨ`�x
`ƙĀ`ŵǛuÃą^ƨƽMqH[m�²
�°�Ȉu˞ŏMqą^ɻƾp`ĎȮƾƉu
ÙſlŜljMqH[ɔ`ƒʌƙBɃJrS5 óʆȿɏZ`Ĥʎđ[ĨǴ`��¬Ī¶`
čǨu¶GqSk^4ƹǯùZɛǏȜu\`
n>^ŜljMeCA4Q`¡�¨x¬līk
ʡɠ]Ǯʗu˙_qH[BÉƎ`ʨ˲Z<q5
Figure2. ɛǏȜ�²�°�`Dzʌ
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 168
F-8,J0��\nW/F3 ��)_Sas�bM*�w��a(�%�
�/F3[!�Ozy���KF-8,J06EL4L ')zy!u��«³��
�
0țɲɚ1� ǐĕ� Őŋ�ĂÞŃō�®±Ň� ˗ʷ�ĂÞŃō��
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
1´c³!vf���!��
ǓțɲVȞȜW)ƨǟ\VˁƈeėĄŵV
Ò3§q�pzȪȞV÷ţãy§�T63
O)y§�öVȠÀƳưQōʳȑV��¤¯
��o����(ʳ)SA)eŃō˄ȑV§q�pz�¤¯�¯(ʳ)WT)TfiƳưlěhðji>QPēÑěƅȍTRVf4
Sſˎlµ5i7lǞʁDi>QP2i* ÷ţãy§�TW)ōɘƑǪ)řÃˁß)
ȑǹɘƕ)ÔʍȽȏȹTĪ˓lƟ5O3iō
ȑ8ł3*GVIc)øŭȍeƨǟ\Vˁƈ
QėĄŵ8Ò:Sh)ēÑ8ěƅP9E÷+
ţãQSLOB`4Ȏȋ82i*ʻŋ(2008)W)ŃōûűǩƉãVƸȴɲȎȪȞ(÷ţãy§�)VŒʛVʌ˓QBO)÷ţãy§�TWĸǓȜSȑǹɘƕTĪ˓lƣMōȑ8ł:)
Ǩŭ8ʸSi>QPƨǟTM3O3<S:S
h)M`gS:SiQ34÷ţãy§�Ȋnj
VˊB@lȨBI*`I)Ē(2014)WûűǩȪȞ÷ţãy§�VŒʛQBO)đġōɘT
fiĻ×heä+\Vë97<ȹlɰ3)|
�¤�{¯�¦ălʞTÈ<@Fi>Q8
P9I8)ª�¯�×ƘɟăVǼ˕Qʨ·P
¨�qoDiōȑlȀŞ@Fiěhɉalʌ
˓QBOƥ=I* °ƻ)§q�pzƳư}¯��TˁʫD
iĺĤQBO)ďɬ(2016)W)ÂʴȒǟŃōPW)Ƶĩ7gV�p¯���yVŞS@7
g)ɠʞVª�¯�×ƘɟăT´ŎlƟ5O
3iōȑ8ŞS:S3>Qlʦ])ȅijȜS
§q�pzƳưTˁDi�¯�8ŌijDi
>Qlǁg7TBI*B7B)ȎȋQBO)
ōöV,ōɘƳưvr�¯-VþȓȍWɤ
B:S3>Q7g)ûűǩǫʌȪȞQʫƱB)
þȓlàD>QP)ûűǩƵɞPVʝ9Q�
p¯���y´ʙlɳ3)ōȑVōY\VƑ
ǪQɎƣlƳưDi>Q8P9iĝɟƍ82
iQʦ]O3i*>Vf4T)÷ţãy§�
ȊnjVêģTĄ5)GdGd,lj:>Q-T
řBOɧƚƑʑVż3ōȑdł3Ic)ûű
ǩ§q�pzȪȞ÷ţãy§�VʭĭTW
ǣ+SŪŅ8Dzcgji* >j`P)ǐĕ®Ť˚(2016)1)PW)ǓōǓ
ȪȞ÷ţãy§�VŒʛQBO)z©¯�¬
¯yQ�oˬ}�¯�Věhɉalɰ3)GV
ɋǘ)2015űŵƃǏQǮʠBO)ēÑǑʆőȍ8 28.94%ȀŞBI>QlĺĤBI* I)
ǓȪȞT63OǨŭʗʮPɴƶĮēÑlɫQ
BOB`4ōȑW)ÇȪȞT63OdġǣV
êģ8agjiIc)ŃōñÔPřƊlǞɼ
DiƉɵ82i>Qlʌ˓QBOƥ=I* ïɰŒʛeĺĤ7g)÷ţãy§�ȊnjV
ˊB@TřDiƨǟʭĭ²VŪŅ8Dzcgj
i>QQ)§q�pz��¯QVđëT
fLO)ōȑVƑǪeª�¯�Vʕ8ģ²D
iĝɟƍ82i>Q8ù7i*ïɰȥȰlZ
`5)ǓțɲPW)ƉãV§q�pzȪȞ
V÷ţãy§�P)ƨǟʭĭVŪŅTĄ5O)
§q�pzƳư}¯��lþȓ@Fi>Q
VƘǘQʌ˓lǁg7TDi*ôÔȜTW)
ǐĕ®Ť˚(2016)VěhɉaTĄ5O),"ƿǏTûȮlŏƘ@Fi>Q-Q),#ǓōV§
q�pz��¯VþȓlʌB)WT VƳưlĜ<@Fi>Q-PēÑěƅȍQª�¯
�Vʕl˙ci>Q8P9i7lǞʁDi*
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 169
2 �h£|�U���(\nW)!a(�%
țɲɚ8ƢŽDi,ōɱƸȴ×ǵ!-V÷
ţãy§�(2017űŵĀǏ)TW)ǐĕy§�25 Ģ)±Ňy§� 19 ĢVĠɻP 44 ĢVţãɚ83i*ōűýPW)4 űȑ8 6 Ģ)3űȑ8 15Ģ)2űȑ8 23ĢP2h)ñōʳ8ǾALIy§�P2i*ƨǟWñ 15 ĮPǢƘ@j)ōɱȜSƸȴ×ƘTƉɵSȤʑ®
ƝɟVɘƅlȞȜQBO)ōǏǒTNJɈª�
¯� 1ǓlƭøDi>QlȞǤTʬcO3i(¤ 1)*`I)ȷ 3Į)ȷ 7Į)ȷ 10ĮVƨǟPW)ǓōV§q�pz��¯V}¯
��lĜ<i>QlʌBO3i*ƨǟöPW
Ļ×hVIcVoy�p��peȠÀƳưV
IcVz©¯�¬¯ylŜðB)SA Tfi�oˬ}�¯�e)Ǩŭɚ\VäýʫɌdɰL
O3i* ¤ 1� h£|�U��(\nW)!2F<3
e� x�[l�
1 wq��)ª�¯�×ƘV�«�� 2 �¯�ʀő)Ī3Vʀő)ƏĺĚˉVÆƻ 3 ǢƘQ°ʓƍ)or�§q×Ƙ 4 ·ˀțɲÎ)ŹȓV©¯© 5 �§z§�§q�pz)Ǔʏķȸ 6 ōɱȜSƸȴTʰBIɲȎ)Ǔʏķȸ 7 ʊaeD3ƸQW)Ǔʏķȸ 8 ǣŸ)ɋʏVlj9ƻ)ɋʏķȸ 9 ėəƸȌ¨��)ŴʏVlj9ƻ)Ŵʏķȸ
10 NJɈª�¯�ûȮV�oª�¤¯Qãǫ 11 �ª��¯�¦Vƻǵ)�§q�×Ƙ 12 �ª��¯�¦ 13 �ª��¯�¦ 14 �ª��¯�¦ 15 NJɈª�¯�ƭø)ƨǟVƦhʥh
3´��²�!a(�%!u��«³
� Ȏij)ƨǟWȷ 5Į`PʬmP6h)øŭȍW 72.7%QÛű¶aVƶåQSLO3i*`I)ȷ 3Įʌ˓V§q�pz��¯VþȓW 65.9˛P2i*ƨǟlʸUi?QT)
ɏŻƓV2LIōȑTdȶ˔8ɶgjif4
TSh)țɺʺ8Ľ5)ȠÀÁǺdɰkjO
3i*°ƻP)ʌ˓lƭøBO3S3>Ql
ǰTBO)ɍ<OǨŭBOB`4ōȑd°ʳ
ɶĜ<gji*ēÑěƅVIcTW 3 ùV 2ʲVøŭ8ƉɵJ8)ƿ3ǬˆP 4®5 ĮǨŭBOB`3)ƨǟɈȝPÔʍlŧDSR
BO)ebS:ǨŭʗʮQSLOB`4>Q
dƗƋ@ji*ÄƃW)Ź9ɍ9)ª�¯�
TřDiɧƚƑʑlĽŮ@FS3ˋįǰ×h
eƵĩ®SA QōȑQVˁßǢȿlɰ4>QQ)ª�¯�VʕlDzci>QQVʰŵS�
§�lǥɆBO3:*`I)y§�öPȠ
ÀƳưVP9iˁßƍlʶƘDiÆƩ<lɰ
3)@gT SAe WTVƳưlɰ4>QTfLO)ēÑěƅȍeª�¯�Vʕȹ)ƘǘQ
ʌ˓lǁg7TBO3:* �
� 1)� ǐĕŐŋ®Ť˚c;a(2016),§q�pzȪȞ÷ţãy§�T6<i�
o®}�¯�VnjĆƍ˞SA VǹȓQz©¯�ōɘlʩBO˞-ûűǩƵɞ
ōÎȷ 9ĮŃÎɠȔȥȰțɲ
�
`�|��
Ąɯīŋ®ŝťǻŋ(2013),âũŃōT6<iª�¯�×ƘƳư İlj˖QƨǟQ
VʫƱVʃa -.âũŃōÈšİlj˖
ȥȰ/(2),pp.125-133 ʻŋǷŋ(2008),ŃōûűǩȑVIcVƸȴ
ɲȎƤŜ ÷ţãȑVŒƔQGVʂÞ
-.ʽʹŃōɂɵ/30(2), pp.13-26 ďɬɕáŋ(2016),¸ÔȜSōYlàʬDi
IcVōɘƳưǢȿTģ<O ōȑ\
V�o¨zʍǙ7g -.˙ȹƵɞ�
t¯§�/(6), pp.97-102 Ēƒ(2014),ûűǩƵɞQBOV.ɠȳQÔ
˘ 1/÷ţãƨǟŒƼĺĤ-.ǁǂ:ǁǂŃōǁǂƵɞ��¯ȥȰɂɵ/(4), pp.97-100
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 170
?+1BL:*����}��h#!Q�%�
��h� ').DG+zy¢N!R��¯d*�����
�
0țɲɚ1� Ǎʳ� õŋ˜6ɨVDZņŋŃō˝�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
µ´"�& �
� 6ɨVDZņŋŃōōȑ®x¢¨oƳư�
�¯PW)ʬʚʱƞQşɜǹĉTˁDiƏĺ
ƭÜSgYTŒʛřȻVƤŜVĻQBO)ğ
ȭVwq��ĘY���¯lŒƼBO3i*
ƳưřʒWñōʳñōűQBO)ŰƘ 28űŵ
WĠɻ 86Į)3,700ĢÖhVōȑ8ėĄBI*
ğɰ¾W)ʐɖTſˎS:ėĄP9if4T)
DŽÍaVDžˀl·ƈTŒƼ@jO3i*ǓȮ
V�«z§�W)ŰƘ 28űŵōöƵɞ GP�
«z§�¾ǟ˜ɪɥĶ˝Tƪƞ@jI,x¢
¨oƵɞ/ƳưT6<iƺISōYVÆɉa-
T63OŒƼ@j)x¢¨oƳưTˁDi�
o}�¯�QBOǓōPWûcOVěhɉa
P2LI*
�
¶´~AI0FC!���¯d�X�
Ǔ�«z§�VȞȜW)ōȑ8�o}�¯
�SgYTȒǟȘQVʫƱlʩCO)ɠƂȜ
Tx¢¨o�~qlŒȎDiălɞƘDi
>QP2LI*ôÔȜTW)ǓōPŒƼDi
x¢¨oƳưǹĉT63O)ōȑˀVȠÀ}
�¯�lɉɓȜTɰ4>Q)`I)ōȑɠʞ
8ƳưǹĉTƉɵSÆɉalÌȗDi>Q)
đăɚl���¬¯yčBx¢¨oƳưɰ¾
Vʭĭlɰ4>QP2i*�
Ǔ�«z§�VʭĭȃèQBO)ƢŽƵĩ
g8�«z§�VȞǤQűˀɻȗlȳOI*
Ǔ�«z§�VȞǤW) 1˝�o}�¯�ɉ
ɓlʀȳB)�«z§�lÌȗʭĭDi¨¯
�¯lɞƘDi>Q) 2˝>j`Pōȑ®x
¢¨oƳư��¯¸éQBOʿéBO9I
OG ƖʎÎQöőɚƖʎÎlǓ�«z§�P
ŒƼDi>QQBI*`I)Ǔ�«z§�V
űˀɻȗ˜ɲˠ˝W)�«z§�VʬƧTƊ
COɶȟD>QlȦʆBI*�
�
·´?+1BL:��!§� Ǔ�«z§�VȞǤTƄ3)ōȑ8¸ÔȜ
Tx¢¨oƳưɰ¾VÌȗQʭĭTěhɉb
�o}�¯�ɉɓlʀȳB)¨¯�¯Vōȑ
lɞƘBO)¨¯�¯8ƃʡʯTąɺDiÔ
ČlƷ5i>QQBI*�o}�¯�ɉɓʀ
ȳT2Ih)Ǔ�«z§�ƢŽƵĩVƨǟl
ţãBO3iōȑQ)ɠțȜTėĄlȖBø
Iōȑ 3 Ģ˜ñĩ8şɜǹĉlɈ5Iōʳ 4
űȑ˝QˌʎlɰLI*3 ĢVōȑW)ōö
Vòʆ}¯y©e NPO)ōŁ}¯y©SRP
ȯǠȜTǹĉTěhɉmP6h)ƢŽƵĩg
ñĩ8 3Ģñĩl�o}�¯�ɉɓV¨¯�
¯TZ@kB3QüƹlBI*`I)¨¯�
¯ÊŁVėĄōȑTM3OW)ōȑ®x¢¨
oƳư��¯8¸éDix¢¨oƳưɰ¾
ȹPųĺlɰ3)ōʳȑ 5Ģ˜4űȑ 2Ģ)3
űȑ 1 Ģ)2 űȑ 2 Ģ)4K 4 űȑ 1 ĢWș
ōȑ˝8ėĄBI*
¸´AI0FC!ª��
Ǔ�«z§�PŒƼBI OG ƖʎÎQöő
ɚƖʎÎW)>j`Pōȑ®x¢¨oƳư�
�¯8ɰ4x¢¨oƳưɰ¾P2LI*Ǔ
�«z§�T63O)ōȑ8¸ÔȜTŒƼD
i>QTfh)Ǔō OG eşɜǹĉlɈ5I
ïʡ˜öőɚ˝SRʞʤS«¯©¡�©QV
ÁǺlʩBO)ɠʞVĐǟƃVʬʚlə5i
ǧÎlƅi>Q8P9iQǏƁ@jI*
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 171
˜1˝OGƖʎÎ
OG ƖʎÎđăÌǟW)>j`Px¢¨o
Ƴưɰ¾Tđă3IJ3IÌǟV4K)OG
˜ǓōĐǟã»ȑ˝8ijɀDiÌǟ 4ȩlō
ȑ®x¢¨oƳư��¯8ʱőBI*đă
Ý˒VIcT)Ǔ�«z§�ƢŽƵĩg8ƪ
ȓƢŽʔËɚlɿĪBO)ėĄĝɟSDžǏe
OG TˁDiƏĺSRTM3OƑɶÁƮlɰ
LI*>VƃT)¨¯�¯l·ƈQBIz©
¯�˜2˫3Ģ˝8ÎȩɿĪlɰLI*Îȩɿ
ĪV¾ĀȃèQBO)ōȑ8ğȩVƢŽɚQ
ȟƬʫɌlěhĠ3)ɿĪƾȬVʍƷlɰL
I*`I)ÎȩɿĪTģ<O�¯�pz8
ɰkj)ÌǟƢŽɚTʉǁDiöŖlǞɼD
iQQdT)������¯V÷ȦʆlɰL
I*ÎȩɿĪƃW)GVöŖlğɠ8ª�¯
�T`QcOónjBI*OG ƖʎÎŽƾVʭ
ĭW)�o}�¯�ɉɓėĄōȑ8ƵŔȃè
eĞÎʬɰ)ʭĭɳąSRƢŽldzcOŒƼ
BIIc)ğɠVƨǟe}¯y©ǹĉ\Vſ
ˎWS7LI*
˜2˝öőɚƖʎÎ
� öőɚƖʎÎVđăōȑ˜ōʳ 4űȑ)ã
Ŀ 2űȑ˝W)>j`Px¢¨oƳưɰ¾T
ėĄBIōȑTōȑ®x¢¨oƳư��¯
fhđălÝ˒BI*ŒƼƾȬW)¨¯�¯
8·ƈQShǞɼlɰ3)đăōȑVƨǟe
Đǟ®ãĿʏƸķȸTſˎ8S3f4T)11
Nj³ǀ7g 12Nj²ǀVDŽÍaT)ɻ 3ĮŒƼ
BI*öőɚƖʎÎVōöųĺT2Ih)ō
ȑ®x¢¨oƳư��¯V�¯��¯�S
RlǹȓDiQQdT)�o}�¯�ɉɓV
ōȑ8 SNS SRlǹȓBOųĺlDi>Q
QBI*öőɚƖʎÎŽƾW)ōȑ®x¢¨
oƳư��¯V����8·ƈQShȃè
lɰ3)ōȑWʭĭVɳąlƢŽBI*
�
¹´$�&�Pr!«³ �o}�¯�ɉɓVōȑW)x¢¨oƳư
ɰ¾VÌȗQʭĭlʩBO)¾ĀȃèVʸɵ
ƍe)ȩÎÃV°ĩQBOƉɵQSi��¯
SRł:VōY82LI*S7Pd)Îȩɿ
ĪTģ<O)ÌǟƢŽɚQɰLI ¯©Ve
hěhW)džǬVŃōȑǹPWɊ˘P9S3
>QP2LI*`I)�o}�¯�ǹĉlʩ
BO)ōʳōűlĪkEōȑġĿVMS8h
lƣLI>QTĄ5O)şɜǹĉlɈ5Iï
ʡe OGgQVÁǺlʩBO)ōȑ8ɠgV
śǕlƐìDi>Qe)ë:>QVƑĦlə
5i9L7<QSLI*ȊTÒōűVōȑT
QLOW)fhȯǠȜTÄƃVŃōȑǹlʮ
?BI3Q34ĉǧN<QSLI*
ÄƃVʌ˓QBO)Ǔ�«z§�PW)7
NjTėĄōȑVċˉlɰ3)ǓǛȜSǹĉʿ
ʼnW 10NjP2LI8)ėĄōȑVċˉDžǏl
ƿci>QP)ǹĉʿʼndƿ`h)ōȑġĿ
8|�¤�{¯�¦lQiǧÎlĽeB)
ƺISÌȗlǞɼDiDžˀlȦáP9iQə
5i*
ɲˠ� Ǔ�«z§�Vűˀɻȗ
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 172
]p�GL5L27A{ AI0FC!k¬�
������ ��������������^q ')GL5L27AK=-AF-J��*�w����
�
0țɲɚ1� ÓÏ� Ĉ˜ȕĒņŋŃō˝�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
µ´"�& �
ȕĒņŋŃōPW)���� űŵfh),Ǧ˃
8S:OdțƯP9i¨¯�¯���VɞƘ-
lȞȜQBIûűǩƵɞ�«z§�lʱƞȪ
ȞQBOʿʼnBI*Ǔ�«z§�W)���� ű
ŵ f h ȳ Ƶ Ń ō Ɋ ĭ ō ʳ P ʼn ` L I
����������������������������������l)ǚ
ŸÎȩq����VđăTfh)Ǔōģ<T
v���q�BŜðBIdVP2i*�
ǓĺĤPW)ƺB3¨¯�¯���Qoy
�p�§¯�zVˁßQ)Ǔ�«z§�V
ǡɵlʉǁBIƃ)Ǔ�«z§�VʂÞTM
3Oʦ]i*
¶´}��GL5L27A�+/8,@FL
;J0�
ŀčVȆB3)ïVʊcS3DžÉTW)ɉ
ɓV���ŢJ<V¨¯�¯���PWŀč
TĔƊP9E)q��¯�¦lʖ>D>Q
dˊB3Ic)ñĩ8¨¯�¯���lțƯ
D]9Q34ə5ƻ8¸ǺTShMM2i*
ƾģʹW>Vf4SƺB3¨¯�¯���V
NJŝ 3ɵɅl)"ȞǤʀő#ȍïĵȾ$Çɚ
ƳưTƷȏB)oy�p�§¯�zTW>
V 3 ɵɅ8ƉɵQSi>QlƤƲBI ��*M
`h)oy�p�§¯�zVĶlƵ5iĀ
T)ƺB3¨¯�¯���lɞƘDiƉɵ8
2iQə5gji*
·´~AI0FC!�¥�
ĀǏ,¨¯�¯��� 1-QƃǏ,¨¯�
¯��� 2-VʫɍĜʐlƉˑQB)ĜʐŬ
ǎȏȔlɾðDiȖʢƚɍlʌBI*Ĝʐɚ
WÃƸɁ 4ōȪǾƘV 26ĢP2h)4˫5Ģ
V 6�¯�P�����§V|���l
ɰ4*y§qo�Ìǟ7g¨o©Sʌ˓l
ƭȨDi>QPĜʐȑlǓǰT@F)ƨǟŁ
PVz©¯�¬¯y8ƉˑQSif4ƨǟl
ʀɻDi>QP)ñĩ8¨¯�¯���lț
ƯBS<jXSgS3Ȑļl×i*
¨¯�¯���VɞƘTW)KolbVɊ˘ō
ɘ¡�© ��lȓ3),ǹĉ−öȡ-,Ɋ˘−ơʒ-Q34¿ʟ7gSiʏȏȱˀPVƆȐĶ}q
y©lŒʛDi*ǭĮVƨǟʿʼnDžTW)ğ
ɠ8țƯDi¨¯�¯���lœɺB)Ɉ»
DžTWœɺʩhTțƯP9I7lȠÀ�p¯
���yPƦhʥh)ğɠV¨¯�¯���
ƣʏlLjƺBO3:*NJƃV 3˫4 ĮVƨǟ
l,Ʀhʥh-TîO)ğɠ8¸ÔȜTɰĉ
B)z©¯�ǹĉlǹƍč@Fif4S¨¯
�¯���8țƯP9I7lƦhʥi*
İ � � T Ȩ D f 4 T ) LA(Learning
Assistant)QħXji²Ʉȑ8ƨǟV�n�
¨�¯�¯lƢŽDi>Q8Ǔ�«z§�V
Ń9SȊƇP2i*LA V L V¸ʇWĜʐȑ
P2h),ĜʐȑVōɘVʕȜģ²-Q34)
°ɢȜS TA fhʸ3ËĊlƢ4*ƨǟVĀ
ƃTƵĩQ LA VȃèQƦhʥhVDžˀlʀ
<)Ƶĩ8 LA T|¯�zlƼB)ƨǟV
ƴīƭǜlȯǠȜT@Fi*ƨǟDžˀŁTW)
İ��� Ƶĩ)��)ĜʐȑVƀā�
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 173
ƵĩQ LA W,ȫŗV Facebook z©¯�-
PƏĺónjB)LA W LINE SRPˇDžĜʐ
ȑVřƊlDi*LA WĜʐȑV«¯©¡�
©QBOǧɟB)ɗűŵTĜʐȑ8 LA TƊ
ċDi>QP)¨¯�¯���®�q�§q
lǢȿDi*ûűŵV LA TWƵĩVɇÅ
lʩCO 4Ģ8ƊċB)ʱəVɋǘ 2Ģlƪ
ȓBI*3 NjTW 4 DžˀV LA ȥãlʿéB
I*LA TWēÑWʆő@jS38)ĺʵ8
Ƴƛkji*
ÄĮW 1y§�VaVʿʐJ8)ɴƶy§
�VʿʐQDiĻĠ)ġCLJƾDž˃TġDžʿ
ʐB)ƦhʥhlĠġPɰ4*Ƶĩˀ)LA
ˀVƏĺónjlİh)æñSȵ½ƑʑlƣI
Fi*Ƶĩ8đëBOōȑlɞƘDiÔÿ8
ǨňBO3iƸɁōʳT63O)ɠȈSžV
FDVŒȎlȞƤD*
¸´~AI0FC!¨V�$�&�
Ǔ�«z§�lʂÞDiTW)ĜʐȑQ
LA GjHjV¨¯�¯���Vŀčlȁő
DiƉɵ82i*ǓȥȰPW)ĀǏ 2ĮȞV
ƨǟɈ»ƃQĀǏɈ»DžT)"ōȑȑǹ#ś
Ǖʀɻ$ʬōĉǧ%ōɘŊČ&ª�¨s�
'ōYƻ(¨¯�¯���ɰĉTˁDiĠɻ
84ĪVo{¯�lŒƼB)ŀčȍVŃ9S
ˏȞQ^QmRŀčVS3ˏȞlơøDi*
`I)ñōȜTŒƼBI���� i-x¢¨o
VŃōȑĸȧăʍǙV�¯�Tfh)Ĝʐȑ
VȊƍlǁg7TDi*LA TWȷ 6 ĮȞV
ƨǟɈ»ƃQĀǏɈ»DžT¨¯�¯���ƣ
ʏlɾʦ@F)ŀčȍVŃ9SˏȞQ^Qm
RŀčVS3ˏȞlơøDi*
>jgVəŘɋǘW)ŃÎțɲDžTȨD¼
őJ8)ȎDžȇPWĀǏ 2ĮȞVƨǟɈ»ƃ
Vo{¯��¯�Va8ŌijDiIc)G
V·P 95%ʲVĜʐȑ8ɝőBIˏȞl
ɾʦDi*
! [śǕʀɻ] ɠùVśǕVɶʩB82i
! [ʬōĉǧ] ɷʹlų=i)ɠùl˙ci)
Ůų3Ƶ˕lʞTȣ<i)ɠùVŮlų
=i)dV?QlłǣTɶi)ɡĦV2
iùʹlō[
! [ōɘŊČ] ǣ+SɊ˘VǧÎlDzci
! [ōYƻ] Ɋ˘lȯb>Q8Ńú)ʧŠ®
ɧB3ȋǴPdɠùVƀālñ4Di)
ȠƚTĬmPdg3I3®ȠƚQâ˒ˁ
ßlȿ9I3®ȩÎVƀTȳKI3Q3
4ƌ3PɰĉDi
>Vɋǘ7g)ĜʐȑVȊƇQBO)Ȣˌ
Ȟ)Ɋ˘¸ɖ)ɷʹlų=I3Qə5O3i
>Q8ù7i*
ǓȮVƭøDžȇPW)ĀǏ 7ĮȞVƨǟ,�
����§V·ˀțɲ-8Ɉ»BIǬˆP
2i*·ˀțɲɈ»ƃTW)2i�¯�7g
LA T,�¯� �¯V 1 Ã8�¨¯§q
�¯TSLO3i-QVȠʎ82h)ŽûV
ʀɻʩhT)ȠÀ�p¯���ylBS<j
X�¯�QBOV��t¯��8țƯP9
S3ȋǴ8ȑCO3i*ņŋōȑW�w�p
�®�p¯���ylʲ<iêģ8ż38)
`JÃˀˁß8ı`LOS3 1űǩĀǏSg
XƈȏȜˈľl¹hʘ5O¨¯�¯���8
ɞƘP9iV7)Œʛlʜ`5IǞɼlʬc
I3*
`�|��
1) ƾģʹŲº(2013),ŃōƵɞo�ª�ª
�¯��� ƺDžÉV¨¯�¯���V
Ǽ˕-.�v��£øȉ/.
2) Ǘ³ØÉɐɭ(2015),�p¯�®oy�p
�§¯�z-.ćɩljƙ/241-260.
3) Kolb, D. A. (1984) Experiential
Learning : Experience as the Source of
Learning and Development, Prentice
Hall.
4) ȕĒņŋŃō,ȕĒņŋŃō¨¯�¯��
� Ƶ ɞ � « z § � -
https://www.facebook.com/ls.kwu/ (2017
ű 5Nj 8ƾ).
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 174
M��*����}Y�!gh°t*ij� ˟˟˟˟
"�)�
�¡o�¦*�&)6LC>H9,J0AI0FC*����p±!©%��
�
0țɲɚ1� ŨŦźº˜ǚŸÎȩ§¯�z�¨¤¯˝�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
µ´"�& �
˩ˡ˥VƸȪȡVʍǙˠ˝TfiQ)Õg7
VžPûűǩƵɞlŒƼBO3iŃōW)ƽ
T ��� Ńō˜Ƀ ��˛˝T²LO3i*GVô
ÔȜSöŖV·PW),ōĪeŃōƵɞñɢT
řDiĉǧÈ<VIcV�«z§�-VŒƼ
8���˛Q �ȚȞT˙3*ŃōƵɞT63O)
ûűǩTRVf4Tō[ƑǪl˙cO3:7)
Qɺ4>Q8Ń9Sʌ˓TSLO3i>Q8
Ȳ5i*>jWŃōV¥��¯}©čTÐ3
ƺðȑVðōĉǧ8łǣčB)ŽʄŃōeō
ʳ\Vðōĉǧ8ŬɮS``TðōBIh)
GdGdōY\VǏƁeƑǪ8S3``T)
ĥį8ʬōDi7gʬōldzcIQɺ4Ţ8)
ŞS7gEŌijDiIcQə5gji*�
°ƻ)ûűǩƵɞT63OŒƼçVɸȇP
ə5OaiQ) JŚʾŕdG4ł:WS:)
R>VŃōPdƵĩ8ùƢBOŒƼBO3i
>Q8ł3*GVIcTûűǩTÕlR4Ƶ
5iV7)ƺðȑlō[¾\QR4ĉǧN<
iV7)SRTM3OVóʩȏɹ8ƅgjS
3``)ƢŽƵĩTóʩVƵǔeƵǔVÚ3
ƻJ<8ƠBM<gji˜ǣTƓCi˝Qɺ
LIƎadf:ɛ:*Ƶ5içVĉǧÈ<T
dʌ˓82iQɺ4>QP2i*�
>Vf4SȐļV·PŷȩPW)ːńĹŃ
ōĢʅƵƨVĎǝɖǁǯ8ʿțBIɠūȏɹ
lǽci�¯��©�pzˡ˝�«z§�
,ɠūVƫDz-lǹȓBO)ñIJVŃōP)
ƺðȑV¸ÔȜTō[ƑǪl˙c)ęÃˁß
V9L7<l×h)ɉɓȜTƿǏVŃōʰƊ
làDƳưlɰLO9I*ƵkiçVĉǧÈ
<lɉɓȜTàB)Ƶ5içVƚƊ5TMS
=iQɺ4>QP2i*�
ǓĺĤPW)GVɠūȏɹlǽci�¯�
�©�pz�«z§�loª�BO)²
Ʉȑ�n�¨�¯�¯�¯�lɞƘB)ƺð
ȑlɉɓȜTĉǧN<i>QlʃaO9I)
ŃƚĀŃōPV 6űˀVŒƼ¾Ûeo{¯�ɋǘlíT)>VƻǵVnjĆƍeŎőƍT
M3OǞɼBO3:* ¶´ZT!�® ����
ŃƚĀŃōPWƺðȑu¨s�¯�¦
l ƾˀPŒƼBO3i˜���� ű˝8)GV
4KV � ƾˀ˜�˦��˫��˦��˝lÚLOƺð
ȑ8ɠūȏɹlǽciŃōʰƊ�«z§�
,x¢¨o�~q ��-Qijōȑ8ĨĢ˝
lŒƼBO3i*>V�«z§�VUg3W)
ġŃōVz§��~q7g),ȑĨă®Ŭ
ǎ ˧>>Pō[Qɺ4ɠūdző -6fY,ɠ
ūƵɞ˜¸ÔȜSōYVŊČlʞTM<i -
V � MQɔ7jO3i*�
,x¢¨o�~q ��-Vy§�}q�
W � ĢĀƃP2h)ġŃōV � űȑĀǏVƉ
ãȪȞ,x¢¨o�~q!-QġCy§�
PŒƼBO3i*,x¢¨o�~q ��-W
�¯��©�pz�«z§�QBOǢʪč
@jO6h)ƺðȑVōɘŊČVŀčlɉɓ
ȜTàDQQdT),x¢¨o�~q!-V
y§�N:h\Qɒ8iǣTʀɻBO3i*�
���� űŵV,x¢¨o�~q ��-W� �
Nj � ƾ˜ǐ˝T � y§�) Nj � ƾ˜ʻ˝
T � y§�P2LI*� y§�TřBOW²
Ʉȑ�n�¨�¯�¯8 � Ģ`IW ĢV�
¯�QSLO�n�¨�¯�¦lɰ4*�
P7� �o}�¯�
― ― 175
²Ʉȑ�n�¨�¯�¯Wí+˪˨QBO
o©�q�P�n�¨�¯�¯˕Ƙȥã6f
YǓȚ˜x¢¨o�~q 0.5˝V�n�¨�¯�¦TėĄBO3I8)2015űŵ7gWGjgñÔV�«��8,PBL ȊýȄɘ-QBOƨǟč@jI*,PBL ȊýȄɘ-W 1ƾ 5|�˜9˦10˫18˦00˝Vˉ·ƨǟ 6ƾˀ7gǢƘ@jO3i*3 NjT«¯©�ªql·ƈQBI�¯��©�pzȥãlˣƾ
ˀŒƼB)�n�¨�¯�¯�¯�lžƘB
O3:*GV²Pƺðȑlʣ5i,x¢¨o
�~q 0.5-V�n�¨�¯�¦l)2ƾˀP 2y§�)ȥãPǢƘBI�¯�PƢŽB)ÙFO 6ƾˀQSLO3i˜İˠ *
·´����m�
,x¢¨o�~q ��-�«z§�W)
ʮĖ�űˀTŶ]� V�n�¨�¯�¯�¯
�8�n�¨�¯�¦BO9I*Ɯ4�«
z§�WǭűɦůVãǫlɰLO3i8)�
«z§�Ɉ»ƃTW)ƺðȑTřBO)ǭű
ġCo{¯�lěLO9I*>Vo{¯
�ɋǘV·7g�«z§�\VȂʙŵTǶȞ
BOəŘlʬci*�
ƺðȑWûűŵV ���� űl˅:Q),QO
dȂʙ-8ǭű � ālʗ5),łŞȂʙ-QÙ
FiQ �˛Ê²8ȂʙQȺ5O3i İˡ *�
`I)ƺðȑVȂʙŵTM3O,QOdȂʙ
BI-lˤQB,ñ:ȂʙBS7LI-lˠ
QBO)�n�¨�¯�¯y§�?QTŰĴ
ålɻȼBOaiQ)2012 űV 3 y§�l
˅3OD]OVå8 4.0˜łŞȂʙBI˝Ê²QSLI*@gT²Ʉȑ�n�¨�¯�¯
V˕Ƙ�«��8ƨǟč@jI 2015 űÊ˂W)^_D]OVy§�8 4.5 ʲlȨBO3i˜İˢ *>jgV>Q7g)ŃƚĀŃō
T6<iƺðȑŃōʰƊ�«z§�Wű+Ŏ
őŵlĽB)²Ʉȑ�n�¨�¯�¯8ʋP
2i7TˁkgE)ƺðȑVŃōʰƊT°ő
VĆǘl²=O3iQɺ5i* ōÎțɲPW)ȂʙŵÊŁV�¯�e)R
Vf4S�«��P>jgV>QlŒȎBO
9I7)6 űˀVʃɰʼʈPƅIdVdónjBI3* 0ėəƸȌ1
ˠ˝ƸʳȪōȡ˜2016 ,ŰƘ 26 űŵVŃōT6<iƵ
ɞöŖȹVƴˍȋǴTM3O-
ˡ˝Ďǝɖǃ˜2008 ,ɉɓ8ǹ9i�¯��©�pz-
˜ǖǸɊǿƺĺȩ˝fh.�¯��©�pzQW,ƑǪ
QǹǰT2Zj)amS8ɣŇSÃˀˁßVdQT2if
4S�¯�-lĂLO3:Ƶɞ®ɽɑV°MV�«��/
˜İˠ˝
˜İˡ˝
˜İˢ˝
P8� ŢǓȃƲ�dhmWd]�e�
― ― 176
=GL�}��Vh8Qs?"E5���y��
�
�ƽȃǷ�� ęƷȅāɗNJłăɆüă·ȰŞǹf�h�ɌğËȠĞɘ�
ęŻȅdzɗNJłăɆüă·ȰŞǹf�h�ȠĞɘ� � � �
�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
�������
µăǀİ?ɟȲɄ9�ăƴ@ŢǓȃƲǺÄ
T;?ǍĢà�*/NQP? �V\m~j
^��XlW�_?óLJɏƿŏĒT 1ġƏƴà&ÂŶNjƿɜɥɟìƿ?őƆ9Ɋ�ƾ=ȁ
��¦Ţldn=M58�1?ÉƁTƢ52�
Źƽȃ9@�1?ÕOǥH:ƅȕǧƁTõã
-P� ��HWZv�
� NJłăɆüă9@ɜġɄ9Ɗ�<ŢǓȃƲ
ŇȂTȪ=6&P(:Tƿƾ:+8�ŢǓȃ
Ʋ����!ɃȠ*Q8�P��ì@�ƭ=
V\m~j^��XlW�_=Ʌ-P¸ċT
ɟȲɄ=Ɋ�+8Ņ52� � ćŧ+2?@�ɜġƏƴ?H!Ę9"P
Ʋ�lj ăȺ? 3^�d9�P�Ę�ş@Ü^�dǝ 20ß�Ȑ 58ß9�·Ȱb�sdTƶ�8 2ß?ȠĞ!ŊĨ-P�¦Ţldn@ɜȲƿ:ɟȲƿ=Þl�}�Þż�9ȁ��
1?ǧƁTƔȬ-P(:9ÉƁTƢĆ-P�
l�}@�üăƴ=:58V�sXn@ȽȈ
��ż�@�20 ½9ɣɠƬ?Dzǭƶǟ 1 ƀ=�üăƴN+�ŢǓ9�Ű$(::+2�
Ȗ©óƤ@ 2007ġ=ǘĆ�2013ġ=ŝȏ*Q2K?9�P���=1?ɏƿTŕ'P� �Ɠǿ½&!ȸ¾9�Ɠǿ?ű¿!ɜĂ½Ǒ
�8�PɗƓǿɘ ůȰ¥9ǩ�*Q8�PɗŢ¥ɘ ȚĂ��ȸ¾<ȃȓ!<�ɗŢĂȃȓɘ ��ȸ¾<ŢŸȃƲ!<�ɗŢŸȃƲɘ ��ȸ¾<șĩ�ȃƲ!<�ɗșĩ�ȃƲɘ >,QŢ<;!<�ɗŢƚƾȚOɘ �Ţƚƾ<ƳƸ�ú9?ȜH=$�Ţ!<�
ɗºɁ*�ȜH=$*ɘ �ɞȺƉŁ9Ű&8�PɗƉŁɘ �ȸ¾<ȟŌ!Ű&8�PɗȟŌɘ �¸ċ=�ȥĺ!�Pɗ¸ċ?�ȥĺɘ ��? 10 ɏƿ=6�8�ɢ�ɣ�ɤ?ɞƓɇ9Ȗ©-P� � G2�ɟȲƿ?¦ŢldnǤ�İ�ăƴ=
ɜȲƿ?¦ŢTȮÓ+�ɟȲƿ?¦Ţ:ȉƔ
E8;?M�<ùÌ!�52 ăƴ?ćĿT
đ>PV�`�nȞƃKȁ52�V�`�n
9@�´? 10ɏƿ=Ʌ+8��Ǿ$<52�ùSN<��Ļ$<52�?ɞƓɇ9Ǘ�8
KN52� ��8V*'+�kX�
� ăƴ?¦ŢMOÜ^�d 10ß.6ʼn¼+�Ȑ 30 ß½Tɝɛ?Ȗ©óƤTƶ�8Ȗ©+2�ɜȲƿ?ǧƁTȃɜ�ɟȲƿ?ǧƁTȃ
ɝ=Lj-� � ȃɜ:ȃɝTƔȬ-P:�;?ɏƿKȖ©
!�!58�P(:!S P� � ƭ=ü"<ùÌ!ȉNQ2?!�Ɠǿ��Ţ
¥��ŢŸȃƲ�9�ɢȖ©!÷��ɤȖ©!
üĠ=ơP �<$<52�G2��ŢĂȃȓ�
�ºɁ*�KɢȖ©!�ĆǍĢ÷�2� � G2�ăƴǻȪ?Ȗ©9�PV�`�n9
@��Ɠǿ��Ţ¥��ŢŸȃƲ��șĩ�ȃƲ�
�ƉŁ�=Ʌ+8�Ǿ$<52�!Ü 20 ß����ŢĂȃȓ��Ţƚ��ºɁ*��ȟŌ�
��ȥĺ�=Ʌ+8�Ǿ$<52�!Ü 10ß��:�ăƴǻȪKń)2�TĿ,8�P
(:!ŬN :<52� � �Ŧ9��șĩ�ȃƲ�@¦Ţldn9?Ȗ
©ǧƁ=@1QF;Ĝ!ȉNQ.�ɢȖ©!
P8� ŢǓȃƲ�dhmWd]�e�
― ― 177
g� N 4 ßD÷�2K??�ɣȖ©! 24ß:ùSO!< 52�+ +�V�`�n
N@�Ǿ$<52�:Ǘ�2ăƴ! 21ß��ùSN<��! 9ß:��Ćş?ăƴ!ń)2�TĿ,8�P(:!� !�P�ăƴ
!V\m~j^<șĩLȃƲTľȢ+�ćɈ
=ùÌTćĿ+8@�PK??�ƗJNQP
�{�?șĩÄTȪ=6&Ćǁ*/P=@<
�ŭɄTȈ-P:��(:!ŬN :<52�
(?�șĩ�ȃƲ�=Æ��ƉŁ��ȟŌ�=
6�8@�Ɋ�ƾ=Ņ�MOK�ÏŶ�P�
@Ȱġ?őƆ9�ƳȍTƠJ<!NĆǁ*/
8�$(:!ĶȈ9�P:Ȏ�P3R�� ��C�j��@X�
� ęŻɗ2017ɘǖ9@�Þ,Ȗ©óƤTƶ�1 ġ?őƆŁƁTƅȕ-PK?:+8�ġĢ?ű¿:űİ=Ű /2¦ŢTȖ©+2K?
!õã*Q8�P��ì?ɟȲɄ9Ɋ�ƾ=
ȁ52öÝ:¦Ţldn?Ȗ©TƔȬ-P:�
ûĔ?Ĝ@�PK??�ƈ>ÞƊ?ǧƁ9�
P:Ȏ�P�+2!58�ű¿? 4ȲɄ=Ɋ�ƾ=V\m~j^��XlW�_?óLJŏ
ĒTȁ�(:@�ăƴ?ŢǓȃƲǺÄ?à�
=ÉƁ!�52:��P� � G2�ăƴǻȪK1?ùÌTćĿ9"2(
:!V�`�nMOŬN :<52�ǻƸa
��n9@�ű¿?ŢMO@P =S OL
-$<52��ǻ½?Ȏ�2�(:!MOħ$
¡SPM�=<52ƕ!+2��K?-)$�
Ȍ!µ52Ţ352?9ǀ58Ǿ 52�<
;?ĿĽ!ȉNQ2��Ŧ9��Ɠǿ?¦OŦ
@�ń=<52!�șĩ?ǃȢ!<*-#P
?9ŝë+8�"2���K�Ĕ+¸ċTƥ$
+2���K5:ȟƳƾ=Ű&PM�=<O2
��:��a��nK�O��İ?ȝɑ!Ŭ
dž=<52ăƴKȉNQ2�ū�Ɠɇ9ȝɑ
!Ŭdž=<P(:9��İ?ŢǓ¦Ł=Ɲ
+8�$(:!ŶĮ9"P� ������
���ű¿?ɟȲɄ=Ɋ�ƾ=V\m~j
^��XlW�_?óLJŏĒTȁ�(:@Ţ
ǓȃƲǺÄ?à�=ÉƁ!�P�*N=�İ
�ŢǓȃƲ����?�9ÔIJǯǵ?ŶɄT
Ɂ$:P(:!9"�G2őƆú?üăƴƝ
¶ǽ?�9KÔIJ�ĸƶ?ǯǵTǏIƍ !
K8P�G2@�1Q=6<!PM�ľȢÌ
9"PM�=<P:Ƕ�NQP� u�� �}d�8V*'+�kX��� D��
Ȗ©ɏƿ�Ȗ©Ɠɇ
ɢ ɣ ɤ
ĪĤ�
Ɠǿ� 0 22 8
Ţ¥� 13 17 0 ŢĂȃȓ� 15 14 1
ȃƲ�
��
�
ŢŸȃƲ� 5 13 12 șĩ�ȃƲ� 0 24 6 ŢƚƾȚO� 14 13 3 ºɁ*�ȜH=$*� 17 11 2
ŢǓ�
¶¥�
ƉŁ� 1 27 2 ȟŌ� 2 19 9 ¸ċ?�ȥĺ� 30 0 0
u�� �}d�8V*'+�kX��� D��
Ȗ©ɏƿ�Ȗ©Ɠɇ
ɢ ɣ ɤ
ĪĤ�
Ɠǿ� 20 10 0 Ţ¥� 28 2 0 ŢĂȃȓ� 21 9 0
ȃƲ�
��
�
ŢŸȃƲ� 25 3 2 șĩ�ȃƲ� 4 24 2 ŢƚƾȚO� 18 12 0 ºɁ*�ȜH=$*� 24 6 0
ŢǓ�
¶¥�
ƉŁ� 8 20 2 ȟŌ� 17 12 0 ¸ċ?�ȥĺ� 29 1 0
BpV`�
ęŻȅdzɗ����ɘ�üă¿ġƏƴ=ŏĒ!ĶȈ
<șĩɚ¦Ţldn9ȉNQPșĩ?ƭĴ
Nɚ��·ȰŞǹDžǐǜȈ�ǔ � Û�NJłăɆ
üă·ȰŞǹf�h��
P8� ŢǓȃƲ�dhmWd]�e�
― ― 178
04,/)%^b���tIx9�:�Vh?�Q�
�Ga�67c�Go^A"dS ���
�
�ƽȃǷ�� ȇȤ�ĕijɗǒƑüăɘ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
��\�� �sAcG;�Qmx9 2012ġ��þŞǹčȣ �ť2<ŷŽTǙ
$2J?üăŞǹ?ȧƾȫŗ=à&8ɚƴƞ
ăBǪ&��¥ƾ=Ƕ�PÄTǹŁ-Püă
DɗǗƹɘ�=��8�ǺÊƾă-<S4V
^lWy���q�_D?ȫŗ!ŖȎ*Q2�
(Q N?üăŞǹ9@ăƴ¯�?ǺÄTĥ
"¼+��¥ƾ<ăTª-(:9�ȧ?ɖ
�ăøȝǍŞǹ�?ĖɃ!ŶĮ*QP�
üăŞǹ?ȧƾȫŗ9@�ăƴ!�¥ƾ=
ă9"PŞǹ¥ÁD?ȫŗ:�Şæ?Şǹ
ǺÄ?Ɵɒ!�ÚƎ=<P��ŦŞæ@ăƴ
?V^lWy���q�_?ÕǥHLăŁ
ƁTȸdž=ňŘ+� 6ȸ¾=Ȗ©-P(:
!ƗJNQP�üăŞǹ9@ƭ=z�_��
?ÉƁƅȕLőƆ?ŁǰȖ©=Ʌ-PVfd
��n�|�b�T;��52Ī9Ŋ«-P
!ȝɑ9�P�(:*NŁǰȖ©=��8
@���y�j^Ȗ©Lă|�nxZ�[
!ǫōƾȖ©�P�@ĪŁƾȖ©=ƶ�NQ
PM�=<O�1?ĶȈĺ!ŜŎ*Q8�P�
��Vh8]oM���Urz� üăŞǹ=�&P�|�nLȟަŁ9@�
Ñ=ăȂƾ<Ȗ©TıP2J3&9@<$�
ăƴ!ȟ,PɗȟŢTŰ$ɘ:��ȁƨ=�
�8��ŬN =-P(:���¡�P(:��
�P�@�Ǟı*/P(:�:�52ȈǡT
ȩG�P2J9K�P�6GO�Şæ@Ű
Q2�|�n�ȟŢTȖ©-P�Ŧ9ăƴ!
Ű"ŦLŰ$ȈǡTȩG�NQP :�52
Şǹƾȝɑ?ȶŁT*QP(:!ŴGQP�
� ăƴ=Ď-P�|�n�ȟŢȖ©?ȌƧ9
@��ĥƶ¦ƚ!ĄNQ8�P ��¥Ȅ!š
�NQ8�P �<;?ĪĤƾƖƤ?F �
ŢǓ?¸ċLȶŁĢ<;TȉP2J=ăƴ?
ǺÄ=ȉÝ52Ȗ©ƖƤT;?M�=ȔĆ-
P !ƗJNQP��Ŧ��|�n�ȟަ
Ł?ćȨ9@�ƿƋȔĆLƝÊȔȐ=�&P
ƪƧ?Ĩ8Ŧ=M58ũŹș?�XlW�_
ǺÄ?à�?+ 2!ƻ<P��|�nLȟ
Ţ?ĺȧ?Ƴȍ@�ďNŞæ±?ŏĒƚLĎ
»ƚ=MPŇȂȟƾ<ȝɑ9�O�;?M�
=Ȗ©-P :���Â=�;?M�=ǺÊ
ƾ<ăTª+Şǹ-P :��ȝɑ9�P�
��UrR]� ��04,/)%
� �|�nLȟަŁTŏĒ-PȴǍ9@�
Ȗ©ŏƋ?�6:+8��y�j^!ƶ�N
Q�1?ćȨõãKȆşŐ'NQ8�P�ă
ƴ?txZ�}�dTȖ©-P2J?ŏƋ:
+8Ɲƶ*QP��y�j^@�Ñ=ăƴ?
Ȗ©TÀŤ-PŏƋ:+8Ɲƶ9"P3&9
@<$�ăƴ!ǻȪTĈȌƾ=ňŘ+�Ű$
(:D?éɑľȢTȘȢ9"Pk��:+8
ƿƋľȢTɖJ8ăC(:TÚǺ:-P�
� ¨�A��ȟƳĺ�L�țıÄ�:�52ɏ
ƿ:ɅSPȟȕ�ȣȟǖ?ŇƚTŏĒ+2É
Ɓ=6�8�¿ġƏŞǹ:��ż��9Ȗ©
ƅȕTȁ52�¨!�P�7 ȌƧ?�4 5 Ȍ
Ƨ=��8Ïş��?ăƴ!�{� 2��?
ɖȖ©9ǻĝȖ©+2ǧƁ!Ő!58�O�
��I>őƆ¸ċ?Ƴȍ!ȶŁ9"2:��
õã!<*Q8�P�
P8� ŢǓȃƲ�dhmWd]�e�
― ― 179
��04,/)%Tf���tIx9�:~
� ǕǷ@�ȓ�¨DžǐTK:=�ɖȖ©!ı
NQ< 52�ȟƳĺ��țıÄ�=ǁƿ+�
(QNŢǓÄ?ƟɒTƿƾ:+2�ăǵk�
�:+8?��y�j^ŖLj�=MPƅȕT
ȁ52�ƿƾ@���y�j^ŖLj=MOă
ƴ?�Ħ?Ŭdž*LƄŌ�ȟŌ?×ȯT®ǂ
*/ŏLj-P2J9�O�ăƴ?ăǵƝÊ:
ǻĝȖ©?ªȳ9�P���y�j^ŖLj!
ŢǓÄɒŁ?2J?ǺÊƾăTª+�ăƴ
!ǻĝȖ©TćȨ9"Păǵk��:<P(
:Tƿŏ+2�
��04,/)%Tf�UrcPn�Yw
� ƅȕ@�2016ġ 9Ų 27ũɥ2017ġ 1Ų 18
ũ�ȠǴ�ŢǓĸƶȠģ�ɗȲ 1ì�Ȑ 15ìɘ
=��8ēȟŢȝɑTȝ-Ɉ���y�j^
TĘǷ 158ß=�ÂŖLj+�Şǹńƚ:+
8?ƝƶTȗH2�ēȟަŁ?Ɉ� ��y
�j^TiYj^�dn:+8Ɲƶ-P(:
9�Ȗ©?ȌƧ):=ǻĝȖ©Tª-(:T
ľï-P�ēȟŢ?¦ŁȴǍ=��8�ƭ=
Ȗ©ȌƧ�ľȉ?ɐK+*�?Ƴȍ�·ųT
ª+�ƄŌ:ȟŌ=ŜŎ*Q2Ŭdž<�ĦT
Ő'P2J?Êƍ7&:ŁƁTŶĮ+2�ƅ
ȕǧƁɗȃ 1ɘ9@��A.ȈŪ?6 HL-*�
!ƈ>ɖȖ©TıNQ2!��H.ľȉ?ɐK+
*�!¤�Ȗ©9�52�
������z� Źƅȕ9@�ăǵǷ:?Ȗ©ɏƿ?·ȰƳ
ȍTïP(:9��y�j^!ǻĝȖ©Tª
-ƿƾ:+8�ŢǓÄɒŁ?ŞǹÉƁTɖJ
P�ńƚ:+8ȸ+8�PȋģTıP(:!
9"2�ȝɑ@���y�j^Ɲƶ=MPă
ǵƿƋ?ŬdžÌ:ȶŁG9?ȉƇJLȖ©T
;?M�=ȉP 9�P�
�ǽ?üăŞǹ9@�V^lWy���q
�_?ȽȈĺ!ȡSQ8�P(: N�Şæ
@ăƴ?ǺÊƾ<ăǵTȰ+2�¥ƾ<ăB
T;?M�=ĖɃ-P !ƗJNQP�-<
S4�V^lWy���q�_Ȗ©?ȧƾ«
ȕ9�P�1?2J=@�ăǵǷD?ŞǹÉ
ƁTɖJP2J=�X�xZ��oVfd�
�n!ĪŁ*QPM�³" &PĶȈ!�P�
��y�j^ŖLj=6�8@�Ȗ©=Ʌ-
P�ɏTăǵǷ:·ų-P::K=�1?�
OŦ:ăǵƿƋ?ȶŁ=6�8ƅȑ+8�$
ĶȈ!�R��
ƽȃ9@�¿ġƏŞǹ=�&PŢǓÄɒŁ
?2J?ăǵȁÊ:ǻĝȖ©?ªȳTǶČ-
P=�2O�Şǹńƚ:+8?��y�j^
Ɲƶ?ćȨ�¨TǢ�-P�<��ŹDžǐ@
ǒƑüăDžǐŔȳ�ñòȱŚf�h�?ÇŁ
TÖ&2K?9�P�
�KbV`��ǣȾɔ�ŹȻŵɓ�DŽě£Ů�ĉę�ȹɗ2011ɘ�<0ȟ,NQ<� ―K��6?ŢǓȃƲŞĉ��ŢǓƉŁƚ���Obirin todayɡŞǹ?Ʋö N�11�79-93. ŁƦĕķɗ2014ɘ��|�nȖ©=��8ƗJNQP[�cp�lW:ȟɑ?ȔĆ=6�8��ɁĚúü
ȟØ�18�99-108. Ʒ�Ǹƙɗ2011ɘ�ŞǹȖ©?ŷŽTŋ$―ƿƋ=ƤŌ+2Ȗ©?ƲƮ�ĖŴ�ĖŴ―�ž¬ô. Ȁ�ȵƑɗ2013ɘ�¿ġƏV\m~j^��l�b�Njƿ�ũŹș?Ňƚ�ɗǔ 4Ǔɘ�ɅȇñÍ FDȱǨÐȣ ��ȼüăɖǖŞǹDžǐɃƽŔȳf�h�
Ǯ�ĹǶ+ȃƲ-PăƴTǹ8P�XlW�_ŏ
Ē?u�n�~r��UŰŃ�78-94. Ȁ�ȵƑɗ2015ɘ�¿ġƏV\m~j^��XlW�_Njƿ=�&PŏĒƚ:1?ÉƁ―t�_�x��XlW�_:ȟȕTƂ=―���ȼüăɖǖŞǹDžǐ�21�15-25.
CAWZTVSR��KPQ��#���\*!%�]B
. / 0 1
9 ��LIDMOHF .- 11- 35- 6-
: $MOHF 0- 12- 27- /0-
; ��L( Y)L'�F 0- 2/- 23- /.-
< ��F 1- 17- 23- 6-
= &�L,F 1- 15- 22- /1-
> �"�OWZWL��F 0- 07- 3.- /5-
? ��L�DF 0- 1.- 24- /6-
@ ��L+NGF 2- 33- 1/- 6-
�/
#� �XUWEJL��\[]8/10�^/..[
P8� ŢǓȃƲ�dhmWd]�e�
― ― 180
iF���-1('3.$*#2&"��|{�
�>J[.$*#2&gd���Goq�Olc_N�ed ���
�
�ƽȃǷ�� ȇÙêýɗNJłüă� Ɇƴɘ�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
������
z�fd��XlW�_@əąŁ*Q2¦
å(ŢǓ)9@<$əŢǓTDZOȮ+Ű$z�
fd:+8:N�əăǵǷ=1?ƓɇTǦɕ
*/PK?9�P�(Q@əǚð?Ű$(:
=Ʌ-PŏĒƚ:+8�ǽÌ+8�P�
ǚð9?z�fd��XlW�_@əû$
?ŏĒǷ NćȨŦƚ:+8ŜŎ*QP�Ŧ
9ə1Q@ν=Ƴȍ*Q8�N.əÉƁƾ
6ľä?�PŦƚ9ćȁ*Q8�<�:ŏ
ś*Q8�P(Pritchard & Honeycutt, 2006)�(
�+2ńƚ!ÉƁƾ=�(<SQ<�Ȉí:
+8ə�XlW�_ŏĒ=�&PăǵǷ?ļ
Ǭƾƭĺ=Ď-PƳȍ!�ν9�PƧ!�
'NQ8�P(Driscoll & Wells, 2012)�
Źƽȃ9@əǚðüă?¿ġƏ�XlW�
_Njƿ=�&Pz�fd��XlW�_TJ
%Pȣȟ=6�8šƳ+əǻĝÉÄĿLǻĝ
Ȟš:�52�i{�b��=īɎT��P
ăǵǷ?ļǬƾƭĺ?ĬÃTǶČ-P�
��-1('3.$*#2&�@X�z�
ǚð9 1980ġ�=əŰ$(:?ŏĒ=��
8ƛƿTɊJ2K?!əz�fd��XlW
�_9�P�(?�m�9@Ű"ń?ǻƸľ
Ĺ!ĐȽ*Qə�XlW�_?ȴǍ:ŢǓ?
ŔŠ=ƪƧ!Ĩ8NQ8�P(ü�ə2002)�
z�fd��XlW�_=Ʌ-P´ȁDžǐ
9@əȓɀ:+8ƒPŔŠT:O�'2K?
!û��1?ȿ=Ʌ+8@əųǺ<Ű"ń@
ŔŠ!û�²à!�Oə1?ȧKȷ�:*Q
P(ƠȤə1999)�
ăƴ?Ű"ń:ƫȶ+2Ű"ńTƔȬ+2
Sommers(1980)LəIsaacs(2012)=MP:əü
ăƴ?ŔŠ9@əșĩ?Ȏ�ŗ�:�52ȃ
ėƾ<Ƒ!û$�(<SQP(:TŬN
=+2�G2əŔŠ=MPŢǓ?ľä?ùÌ
=ǁƿ+2 Faigley & Witte(1981)@ə¿ǎ:ǔ
�ǎ?ùÌTȞE2�ȃėƾ<Ƒ:ľä?
Ƒ?Ɣ@əƫȶ+2Ű"ń9ǝ 2ɡ1ə�Ǡ
^�d?üăƴ9ǝ 3ɡ1əŰ$Ä?ŷƫ<ü
ăƴ9ǝ 7ɡ19�52�
� źŹ(1991)!ə�Ũ=ǃ58�2(:LĹ�
6�2(:TÑ=Ű"ȱ>P3&9@<$ə
(?M�=Ɗ�<Ƽé NŨųǃȢTáä+
ŬdžÌ�ǩÝ+<!NƴŁƾ=ŢǓTƵ¼+
8�$�:ȯEP�(( NKəŔŠz�f
d?�9ǻĝLnwj^=Ʌ-PƳȍTªȳ
+əŢǓTƜǯ*/8�$ȴǍ9əĹǶƊĤ
TùÌ*/8�$:��P�
�Ŧ9ə(�+2ŏĒƚ=@ȝɑK�P:
�SQP��XlW�_?ŏĒƚ=6�8�
h½ſT�(<52 Graham & Perin(2007)=
MP:əz�fd��XlW�_?ÉƁ@ə
ŏĒǷ?n��q�_?ųƩ=M58Ĝ!ƴ
GQP:�P�ν<ƳȍT¢S<�ŏĒ=
MOəÉƁƾ=z�fd��XlW�_!�
(<SQ8�<�(:!� !�P�
G2əIsaacs(2012)@ə¿ġƏ�XlW�_
Njƿ=�&Pz�fd��XlW�_=6�
8əŢǓ=Ď-P�d|�dLwV��v�
�?ćŧəĒµ?Ű"Ŧ?ǀœŏĒ:�52
ÑƯ?ŦƺTćȨ-P3&9@əűǤǎ?ŝ
ë=6<!N<�ÚǺĺ!�P:ȯE8�P�
1+8əz�fd��XlW�_?ćȨ!�
G$ƍǺ+<�ƳƸ:+8əŢǓTŖ¼-P
P8� ŢǓȃƲ�dhmWd]�e�
― ― 181
şũÂ=ÒǼƾ<wV��v��T�(<�
:�52ŔŠ?ǯǵ!əȺ½ƾ=+ �(<
SQ8�<�ƧT�'8�P�
��Ga�Olc<���ed
� �XlW�_?½Ⱦ=��8KəăǵǷ?
Șǃƾ±ɍ3&9<$ļǬƾ±ɍ=Kǁƿ-
PĶȈĺ!ŏś*Q8�P�2:�AəHidi &
Boscolo(2006)@əȘǃƾ�MBļǬƾ±ɍ!ə
ǻĝȞšLÊƍ7&?ȌƧ NŒǐ*QPĶ
Ȉ!�P:ŏś-P�ǻĝȞšd]�?Ʊı
@əîɋLɉĊ=ǀɍ+8KÈÄTǪ&PM
�=Êƍ7&PǻĝÉÄĿ=īɎT��P
(Zimmerman & Risemberg, 1997)�
G2əPajares & Valiante(2006)@əŰ$ÄL
ǻĝÉÄĿ=6�8?ăǵǷ?ǻĝȘȢ=ǁ
ƿ+2�ăǵǷ?Ű$Ä=Ď-Pǻ¬?ųƩ
L1?ǍĢ!əăǵŁƁLľƐ=īɎT��
P:ȯEP�Ű"ń@ŢǓT¦Ł-PɈəǻ
ĝ?ȈƗƖƤTƣ2-2J=ƑT$OȮ+ə
ǻĝȊį(self-discipline)=Ʌȱ-Pd]�T
ƽȶ*/P(Zimmerman & Risemberg, 1997)� ȭġ9@əüă=��8KļǬƾ±ɍTÕ
OµQ2�XlW�_ŏĒ!ə¶ǚȊƌ9ƿ
ŏ*Q8�P�Council of Writing Program
Administrators, National Council of Teachers of
English, & National Writing Project(2011)@əü
ă=�&PûƊ<ďɂ½Ⱦ?< 9ăǵǷ?
ŁÅTŜř-PȈǡ:+8əĹǶŀĢ(habits
of mind)T�'8�P�(Q@əĀÿĵLǛO
ħ*:�52ļǬƾƭĺ!âGQ8�Oəü
ă9ŢǓTȜHŰ"+2OəņÀƾ=ƅȑ+
2O-PǦɕTȰ,8ə(QN?ĹǶŀĢT
ɖJP(:!ƿŏ*Q8�P�
*N=əǚð9@əǃȢLd]�əǺÄ:
�52ǃƾƭĺ9@<$əăǵǷ!ǻȪ?ǃ
ȢT;?M�=§�əĸƶ-P TƘĆ-P
ƭĺ(disposition)?ȌƧ Nəüă=�&P�
XlW�_ŏĒ!¹ƅȑ*Q8�P�Driscoll
& Wells(2012)@əăǵǷ?Êƍ7&L©°Ȍə
ǻĝÉÄĿ:�52ƭĺ!ə�XlW�_?
ȫnj(transfer)=��8LjçT��P:ŏś-
P�1+8ə´ȁDžǐT1QN?ƭĺ?ȌƧ
N¹ƅȑ+əăƴ?ļǬƾƭĺ!ə;?M
�=ăǵǷ:1?ăǵ=īɎT��P !Ŭ
N =*QPĶȈ!�P:ŏś-P�ǚðü
ă=�&P�XlW�_ŏĒ9@əăǵǷ?
ļǬƾƭĺ?ƽȶTȋȾ=µQ2ŏĒ!əȽ
ȋ*QPM�=<58"2(:!S P�
��!��
ǚð9�ǽÌ+8�Pz�fd��XlW
�_LŔŠ?´ȁDžǐ9Lj*QPM�=əŰ
"ń!ǻĝƳȍTƠJəĹǶƊĤTùÌ*/
P(:9Ű$¸ċKùSP(:!Lj*Q8�
P�+ +əȘǃƾd]�TȒǯ-PŏĒ3
&9@əăǵǷ?Ű$Ä?ƽȶTν=Ŝř
9"8�<�:��ȝɑK�P�
(Q@əŔŠ:�52Șǃƾ±ɍ3&9@
<$əăǵǷ?ļǬƾ±ɍ NKƅȑ-PĶ
Ȉĺ!ŏś*Q8�P:��P��ăǵǷ?�
XlW�_Tù�Pűë9è�?Ŧƚ@əĭ
NǻȪ?ŀĢTƑ-PńÇ&T-P(:9
�P�(Warnock & Warnock, 1984):��M
�=əǚð9@əŰ$(:TȰ,2ăǵǷ?
ȘȢ?ùċLǻĝȊį?ƱıəŀĢùċ:�
52ƭĺ!ƽȶ-P(:9Ű$ŇȂ?à�=
6<!P:��ŞǹȌ!�P(ȇÙə2016)�
�İ?ȝɑ:+8@əDriscoll & Wells(2012)
!ŏś-PM�=ə�XlW�_Njƿ=�&
PŦƺŏĒ:ăǵǷ?ļǬƾƭĺ?ɅȱLə
ļǬƾƭĺTƽȶ*/PŏĒ=6�8ə\�
]���?ȌƧ Nƅȑ-P(:9�P�
�BpV`��?Ţư@Ĩũ?Ȧţ=Lj-� Driscoll, D. L. & Wells, J. (2012) Beyond
Knowledge and Skills: Writing Transfer and the Role of Student Dispositions. Composition Forum. 26.
Zimmerman, B. J. & Risemberg, R. (1997) Becoming a Self-Regulated Writer: A Social Cognitive Perspective. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 22, 73-101.