Download - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Transcript
Page 1: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Hong Kong University, July 9, 2013

The Right to Be Forgotten

Page 2: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 2The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Notion of the right

to be forgotten

Right to forget: No revitalization of historical event

Special case of convicted persons

Virtue of forgetting

July 9, 2013

Delete Erase

Page 3: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 3The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

New European approaches

Spanish courts

French initiative

Development

of

legal

approaches

United States:

Continental Europe: The power of civil/personal

law

The tension of freedom of expression v. tort

Canadian policy and corporate practice

Page 4: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber page 4July 9, 2013

Page 5: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 5

Right to erasure of data loaded as child

EU Data Protection Ordinance

Obligations of controller

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Scope of erasure

Restriction of processing personal data

Implementation of erasure mechanisms

July 9, 2013

Page 6: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 6

Multi-dimensional approach

Privacy as cluster concept

Different forms of privacy

Structural relations in informational privacy

More user-centered approach

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

Page 7: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 7

Digital abstinence

Privacy risk mitigation

Information privacy rights

Digital privacy rights infrastructure

Cognitive adjustment

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

Information ecology

Perfect contextualization

Page 8: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 8

Information power and cognition

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

Laws

Technology

Cognition, decision-making

and time

Information power (incl. information privacy)

Individuals Digital abstinence Cognitive adjustment

Privacy rights Information ecology

Privacy DRM Full contextualization

Page 9: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber page 9July 9, 2013

Page 10: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 10

Expiration dates on digital data

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

Technical implementation

Negotiation of expiration dates

Active deletion and erasure of data

Page 11: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 11

Technological responses

Cloud Computing: A cluster of complex liability issues - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

PET: Privacy Enhancing Technologies

Anonymity: Concept of k-anonymity

CARPE: Continuous Archival and Retrieval of Personal Experiences

Page 12: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 12

Infrastructure security

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

Network ad information security

Safety precautions and cooperation

Technical and organizational measures

Page 13: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber page 13July 9, 2013

Page 14: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 14

Limits of the right to be forgotten

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

Balancing differenthuman rights

Balancing data protection and information access

Cultural and social elements

- Censorship

- Free flow of information

Page 15: Prof. Dr.  Rolf H. Weber

Law Institute

page 15

Paternalistic reasons

Exceptions to the right to delete

Communitarian reasons

Administrative or economic reasons

Archival reasons

The Right to be Forgotten - Prof. Dr. Rolf H. WeberJuly 9, 2013

Security reasons