Raport o stanie projektu FAIR – przedstawionyw oparciu o folie prof.W. Henninga, dyrektora GSI, oraz

H. Wenningera kierującego pracami STI i H.-F Wagnera kierującego pracami AFI

Reinhard Kulessa – UJWarszawa 11 stycznia 2006 r.

The International Committee Structure for FAIR

PAC QCD E.Chiavassa

PAC NUSTAR R.Casten

PAC APPA D.Schwalm

TAC Yanglai Cho

Observers:

FAIR Project

Cost Review GroupsCore-E D.Plane

Core-A W. Bartels

Full Cost Structure Group B. Brandt

AFI Working GroupAdministrative and Funding

IssuesH.F.Wagner

Legal Working Group U.B. Jahn

STI Working GroupScientific + Technical Issues

Horst Wenninger

ISCInternational. Steering Committee

H.Schunck

FAIR Technical & Scientific Status – November 2005• Initial scientific programme defined (based on CDR, LoI's (June 04), and Technical

Proposals submitted January 2005 and evaluated by PAC's / TAC and STI): ~70 international workshops (post CDR)

2100 international scientists as authors of the proposals 2003-2004 ~ 8,4 M€ (national) & ~ 12,6 M€ (internationa l) effort 2005 ~ 80 FTE (national) und ~ 120 FTE (international)

STI & PAC/TAC reviews performed (60 international members) STI Recommendations completed see presentation by STI Chair H. Wenninger

• Accelerator development underway (R&D and proto-typing)– Draft Technical Reports / Draft Cost Book available & under evaluation (TAC/miniTAC's und STI); project definition and T(D)R by mid-March 2006); cost reviews by CORE-E & A and mini-TAC's

3(6) consortia (& bilateral MoUs) for R&D and construction of the accelerators 2003-2004 ~ 18,9 M€ (national) and ~ 0,8 M€ (international) effort 2005 ~ 100 FTE (national) und ~ 20 FTE (international)

see presentation by STI Chair H. Wenninger• Comprehensive civil construction and building pre-planing performed (Eng.-Co. BUNG) 'Offenlegung & Bürgerversammlung' of Civil Construction Plan (Nov.3, 2005) Final version T(D)R underway, based on new layout (and staging)

• Regulatory and legal processes initiated, environmental impact study completed:20 regulatory procedures (of these 9 concluded in the meantime) 8 environmental impact studies (UVS) radiation safety study completed and preliminary approval received

• Development of organisational, cost and management structure see presentation by AFI CHAIR H-F. Wagner • T(D)R in March 2006, with cost, schedule and overall project definition

24 November 2005 FAIR STI - ISC Berlin 4

FAIR Scientific and Technical Issues working group

Mandate

Accompany preparations of FAIR Technical Design Reports

Evaluate the advancement of prototyping of critical components

Present the three phases of FAIR project realisationscientific goals and costs of each realisation step

Explore cost of construction and operation of the facilityCost-book: material / personnel /risk budget…

Resource loaded schedule with milestone/critical path/…

AFI complements for legal - financial issues, procedures, contracts,..

PAC on Nuclear Structure and Nuclear Astrophysics (NUSTAR-PAC):

667 users1.) Low Energy Branch (LEB)High-resolution In-Flight Spectroscopy (HISPEC)/ Zs.Podolyak/ SurreyDecay Spectroscopy with Implanted Ion Beams (DESPEC) + B. Rubio ValenciaPrecision Measurements of very short-lived Nuclei using an Advanced Trapping System for highly-charged Ions (MATS) K.Blaum MainzLASER Spectroscopy for the Study of Nuclear Properties (LASPEC) P. Campbell ManchesterNeutron Capture Measurements (NCAP) M.Heil FZKAntiprotonic Radioactive Nuclides (Exo+pbar) M. Wada Riken

2.) High Energy Branch (R3B)A Universal Setup for Kinematical Complete Measurements of Reactions with Relativistic Radioactive Beams (R3B) T. Aumann GSI

3.) Ring Branch (STORIB)Study of Isomeric Beams, Lifetimes and Masses (ILIMA) Y .Novikov SPNPIExotic Nuclei Studied in Light-Ion Induced Reactions at the NESR Storage Ring (EXL) M. Chartier Liverpool Electron-Ion Scattering in a Storage Ring (e-A Collider) (ELISe) H. Simon GSIAntiproton-Ion Collider: A Tool for the Measurement of Neutron and Proton rms radii of Stable and Radioactive Nuclei (AIC) R. Krücken TUM

Technical Proposals

PAC on Quantum Chromo Dynamics (QCD-PAC): 909 users

ASSIA Study of Spin-dependent Interactions with Antiprotons R.Bertini Torino (90)

CBM Compressed Baryonic Matter Experiment P.Senger GSI (294)

PANDA Strong Interaction Studies with Antiprotons U.Wiedner TSL Uppsala (348)

PAX Antiproton-Proton Scattering Experiments with Polarization F.Rathmann FZJ (177)

PAC on Atomic Physics, Plasma Physics and Applications (APPA-PAC)578 users

Laser Cooling of Highly Charged Ions at SIS 100/300 U. Schramm LMUFLAIR - A Facility for Low-energy Antiproton andIon Research E. Wiedman TokyoSPARC Stored Particles in Atomic physics Research R. Schuch StockholmHEDGEHOB: High Energy Density matter Generated by Heavy-iOn Beams( LAPLAS, HIHEX) D. Varentsov DarmstadtBIOMAT Applications of Relativistic Ions in Radiobiology M. Durante Napoliand Space Research/ Materials Research with Relativistic Heavy Ion Beams S. Klaumünzer HMIWDM Radiative Properties of Warm Dense Matter F. B. Rosmej Marseille

Technical Proposals

FAIR layout summer 2005

FAIR – Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research: New Layout

100 m

UNILAC SIS 18

SIS 100/300

HESR SuperFRS

NESR

CRRESR

GSI today Future Facility

ESR

SIS100/300 Underground Tunnel

5 m

-24 m

Tunnel in Open-Pit Construction

Tunnel Drilling Machine

2004 2005 2006

Contract(s) Development

Contract(s) Negotiations

Closing

PAC's Technical Committees:PAC's & TAC

Signing of MoU

Phase I – Governed by MoUPhase II

Governedby

Contracts

The ISC-FAIR International Working Groups

MoU

Proposals / TR's

LoI's

(2100 authors)

T(D)R (March 06)

Evaluation by Advisory Committees (March 05)

Cost Review by CORE group (Fall 05)

Project Definition in 2005

Path of Evaluation (both Investment and Operation cost)

Experiments:LoI PACi TP PACi TDRs

CORE E

Accelerator + Infrastructure Projects:

Core Groupe “E” for Experiments

CORE ‘E’ Members:

• Wulfrin Bartel, chair (ex DESY) large experiments • H.G. Ritter LBLdetector systems, electronics• J.Simpson CCLRC gamma ray Detection• A.Vacchi INFN Trieste silicon detectors• I.Lazarus CCLRC detectors, exp.systems• H.J.Hilke ex-CERN experiments, detectors• P.Lazeyras ex-CERN general detector systems

First Meeting scheduled May 30/31, job to be finished by September 15, 2005

E-CORE Evaluation

EXAMPLE E-CORE evaluation of PANDA

PANDA Cost according to E-COREItem Cost [kŰ] Risk money [kŰ] Pellet target 700 Cluster target 565 MVD 2820 1250 STT 3120 DIRC 3043 300 Barrel TOF 350 Forward DC 1315 Forward RICH 1268 1800 Forward TOF 237 Barrel EMC 16012 4350 Forward EMC 677 Forward HCAL 368 Muon detector 486 400 Ge detector 1650 Solenoid 4104 531 Dipole 1633 187 Interaction region 220 Infrastructure 4000 DAQ 4200 Computing 1170 Prototyping and tests 856 Sum 48839 8818

E- CORE cost table for all reviewed major FAIR experiments

Experiment

Cost [k€] Uncertainty Remarks

MATS 2537 10 % Low risk

LASPEC 591 10 % Low risk

SPARC Low risk

Laser 1092 15 % Manpower

NESR 5505 15 % Manpower

R3B Manpower!!

Phase I 14600 20 % R & D

Phase II 9355 20 % R & D

PANDA 48839 25 % Add 8818 k€ (risk) low prices, R&DManpower?

CBM 60520 20 % 55950k€ down gradeManpower!!, R&D

ILIMA 1902 15 % Manpower

HISPEC/DESPEC

16277 20 % Manpower

Three stagesThree stages according to fields of science:according to fields of science:

Stage 1: Radioactive beam physics

• Nuclear structure and nuclear astrophysics• Atomic physics studies with highly charged/radioactive ions & plasma physics

Stage 2: Proton-antiproton physics

• QCD studies with protons and antiprotons• Precision studies with antiproton beams addressing fundamental symmetries

and interactions

Stage 3 Full facility capability & all research programs

• Full parallel operation of up to four research programs • Full energy and luminosity for nuclear collisions program at CBM• Precision QCD Studies at PANDA up to 15 GeV/c • Plasma research (full gain factor in power density: ~400)• Atomic reaction studies with fast beams

Next Steps: from today until March 2006- Follow up on the ideas on lowering the cost for the machine facilities

-Get Draft of Technical Report by end of the year-Get FAIR Cost Book validated by AFI

- Open new FAIR Project Division at GSI ( FAIR Technical Director )

- Form further FAIR-Consortia with countries and laboratories now: - On the way: HESR Sweden+FZJ+GSI,

- NESR Spain+GSI, - CR China+GSI, - LEB KVI+GSI

- In preparation: France+GSI, Italy+GSI, UK+GSI, Russia+GSI, CERN+GSI, India+GSI, .....

- Publish final FAIR Technical+Administrative Report for Spring 2006

Organization of the FAIR-Vorlaufphase Personnel: New Appointments ( ? 43 ) in 2005 (Jan. –Oct.) at GSI

Project group

Vorlaufphase Project Office (1)* NN FAIR Project Division Leader*

H. Eickhoff B. Becker-de Mos H. H. Gutbrod G. Fehrenbacher

Civil Construction (4) Responsibles of working

packages working

packages

Experiments (10) Responsibles of

working packages

ISC*

STI

FAIR Internat. Project Office (2) NN (H. H. Gutbrod)

Accelerator (23) Responsibles of working

packages

AFI

GSI Aufsichtsrat

Controlling

GSI Geschäftsführung (2)

Safety and Radiation Protection (1)

Responsibles of working packages

.......Strengthening the FAIR work force

Personnel:Total GSI working for FAIR FTE 72 New recruits 2005 for FAIR FTE 43

Administrative Issues

Legal StructureLegal Structure• Basic legal structure of a future FAIR

Limited Liability Company:– Convention– Articles of Association– By Laws

• Organs: Shareholder’s Assembly, Supervisory Board, Managing Directors

Administrative Issues: Convention

• Convention was discussed in detail three times• Open at this moment:

– Germany has to clarify how VAT for external contributions will be handled. F definitely will not pay VAT.

– Handling of decommissioning.– Details of In-kind contributions: Paper by GSI very narrow to

XFEL-paper.– Transfer of shares: seeking for joint position of D, F, I.

Reaction of F, I is missing so far. – Transition from present GSI to FAIR: Paper with details of GSI

for next meeting.• Things will be cleared at next meeting January 16• Convention will then be ready on the level of AFI to be

submitted to ISC in spring

Administrative Issues: AoA

• Articles of Association discussed once in full length.

• Not ready for submission to ISC• Points of interest for ISC:

– Voting rights• Shares for construction and operation different. Calculation

of mix? Voting separated according to special topics?• Amount of majorities for voting on specific subjects

– Final catalogue of responsibilities for shareholders assembly and supervisory board

Administrative Issues: By-laws

–By-laws were not discussed yet– They will regulate the day by day

business of the company– Will be tackled not before spring

Bonn, 22.11.2005

The International Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research (FAIR)

- Key points of the German position -Germany strongly affirms its commitment to FAIR as an international research facility inDarmstadt with a great long-term scientific impact, in particular for Europe. FAIR will providethe European and international science community with a worldwide unique and innovativeaccelerator system to perform forefront research in different areas especially concerned withthe basic structure of matter. The establishment of the international Facility for Antiproton andIon Research represents an important element of the European Research Area.Germany greatly appreciates the high interest and engagement of the international partners inthe preparation of FAIR. Due to this, significant progress in the scientific, technical andadministrative preparation of the project following the signing of the Memorandum ofUnderstanding on the preparatory phase in 2004/05 has been reached.For Germany some key points are essential in the further negotiations with its partners.1) We should maintain the already reached momentum to start the construction of FAIRswiftly to ensure the completion of the facility in 2014.2) This requires the creation of an efficient scientific, technical and organisational unit, whichwill be supported by Germany and its international partners in fair partnership.3) Departing from the position Germany has put forward in the past, we are now seeking toestablish an independent FAIR Company for constructing and operating the facilityalongside the GSI for legal and general science policy reasons. This will not affect therights and obligations of the international partners as discussed in AFI and ISC. We arejust in discussion with our Finance Ministry on that matter.