coullr oF APfJ£ALS

{);VISION m 0~ Tfi-E:_ STA--T€. o.,C w:4Sf/JN(rt0A/.

v.

A'7A'lTH£w 'StM0/\1 (rAROU7T£,

,4f'p£ (.L.4/V'T.

STA-T£M&VT oF AiJbJ77oNA-t.... (r120uNIJ s

FILED FEB 1 0 2015 \_·,_;·J/:\i ul--r.f t•._:.. ..

nrd~llJ!'-l ! r )'L\11: CIF W.>.:iH' 'I'; I y,

Rv ~---------.~-, ·-·

MA-TTII£.w S. (r/ll!£/u7T£ f''8'/0/fs9

C..r; ... y.o"Tk k..dXr£ C..oJI</l. CJ:Nt.f~

1").:J ..Svx 70 9

<:JJNI\/1£1...(., WA. 9C, J2fl

VIOL.4TIOI\J OF '5p££1J'-I TR.IFJL

(!_,~ 3.1

A'JR. M~OU7'7.C.'S JZ/(j-#T 70 ~oy r,e/....U u...vac~ CrR .S. 3 VV-'9S V/<JL~/CLJ

~'1 TilL 7"R//9L <::_ou,-:er A~,.} /N V/OL"'?-//0/\1 o/ W/"'S#. CO/'ltST~ ~AC7: 1 SECl70/I/

10.

71/f TR/.4L t!..DO~r IS .-<t:S~I&-C ~t!J~ ASSU'.RPV& A S,~!7Ec"/)y 'T"~//1{. u...vk-"~

C.,/? 3. 3. S.TA-TE V. f!..AteSO~, /28 vvn. <!d 8os- (1f9~). ;n;.c· /O"~_,t?<JSE vNtJc-t".{yp~

Crlf 3.] IS TcJ /7A?..O'lCCT A U~cNQA#Ts (!.DNST77U77CM/.4(. A?/~T TO ~~~·.07 7'1'("'/,q<'.

SlATE V .. "'74(&, 89 w,-, . .ze/ 78f, 7?1·7< (/P7fj AtSo, IV /7~0V1.IK ';,q /..eO.A--1,/)/- /lte/-1L

Fo~ TtlL k!=crVti4rVr oAICE ~osLc:..u?-t0/\1 1s P1/1714Te·tJ.- "37criE v £DHA~/Js, 9'>"

wn. <c/ 20!" , 21<, {I 'itO J. IN vv"'SII/.nl<rlor-1, /#.{" ";;A-?E ~ 7/f'I....Pt. '' ;<?v~.c·s u/1/dk;(

C..rl< 3.] ••. £ST/!/1LISII 57-'9N~d TiA-1~ U~I.?'S ~d hA/t9L. 57/9-'e/ LJ/I'?S ~ ~~~L

.4-vJ ,(!b)Ui~INCr iJI'fMt5SI9-( ~1/// ~LJ<AiJICE 1/ T#E .S;«'.C.d'1 7~/>9-l ;OC-"CIOd LA,/).SLS

wn-fiC/U'7' -"f T~/4l... S7.47£ y. S.cJ(J(/'1/tUIIIT, 111 ~Nn ~~- <"0?., <Y(;-/? (<oc.,).pl"ls7

£~?~Ae!.CrVC..t /1/IS .S~/\1 7/'f:.,_T Unl(.t'If /'1 S/Ric.,T -'?U.U IS .--9-~r"L/.c·,-jJ ThL ;€'/(;-/,//

/(I .A Sj?c~/.)'7 7AC/fl7.l. .4:r vvcLl. Af 7#< 1"1/.TE<J--A?/?'7 o/ 7/Y.C JV!JIU-9i ;CJ,f{}Oc.t:SS~

c~.....vor &( ,(j/£UJVLL.., .I'R.{.fE,(!vc~. SlA-7£ r sHtetK~-'f"/ 8? ¥Vn-~c/ 87o, 877 (1~7(,).

C:..cM.e.T Ruus, LtKL sT..,.JVT.Cr, -slt/u<.J I$( <:...oNsneuEo 7V /"'o.o;-:::~ r#~ r?"'R~s.c /0~

wlltc.ll Tllc7 vYc~ ltrV-<~~Tctl. If!:/ ~.t A?c(cLo:r#~~-/1/~ 99 vv.o- ec/ .J1r, rz<? (/'Ji'~) ....,,y~;,v

/lv'l~l? ;?~77rVrr Cvvoer !E'WL~I, Tfr",(. cvu-e7 A_p>~.-?o...;IC:#.<''f 7//.L: -<"wL.c·f -"'S :.-~e:v¥

?l/£'1 fl-41.1 ~EN iJif7-4/T~'tJ -dy T.Hc L.Cv!S<~n.,r,p..C. S/19....-""7 r. A?cracz-~,..-e~ '}2' ~-rn.<?c/

(p<.o, ~Z2 (19 7 9)- dVITtAt.L.., 1 '-ot...(~T'i '-~x-k T<:J 7H.C ;:JL...,_,./'11 LANr;.-UAW. t:.)/- T#~

R.uu .ANi) ~ON'Srleu£. 71/£ .<!JU ,-,.y A<:...<...Q..-e_d t-v/71-1 7H.£ /).('.4-'-1/N<r- do/J 't 's /-vT£/VT.

Ool.I~U.~. V<Ju~qu::'J ·, t-s-& vvn. ~c/ 4/~Q 1 L((Q(p ( <.00~) // T#L tf'utU. S .,t1,C4.rl/tr!/(r- IS

UNAA<J.(jJ(J-U()US <.ou;e1s. Nilb LO<)K NO /<..11(!/ft'E,-e. ~k'4NL: ~Urv7'z V'. <j,IJCC/-4<.7-:,

A4'TO f ·ue4.-lr:...k t?Am/77r\IV--, ,-,yc,, IS 1 ........ ;?. <c/ '<'36, :?.<f'T (<oo<l}

'Stf?LE/)'7 7.('141. t../NtJ.O~ TH~ ,. 7/M£ ~r;Qe r~~4t '' I?GI~,e Cf/ C"l't! 3 • .1 ~H.Cn/

TH~ (tr<-f~.T rAI(.L~ TO )/4(;£ /-115 7-l!/A-( /.J.(£~11(~ /#E ~0 /J~ CLot./<" <"'r,d/"'<".Cd

fo!R. (r~/Tk. CN UNT.tN4~t~ <1-JE'Ot..-...VOS ro ,t£ YT.C/"l/i:J H/5 5,.4.C~.t)'7 7.1{'/4/. <Lot/("

7'0 '7o ~""-'f'l .4FT£/( ;T D£rv/£(J /#~ S7i"1-7.t~ --*o77o,/ ro <:..orV NNv<: .dcc.4u.s<

;r ;::C/t.M/IJ TII-4-T IH.€. S.T/1-U .. S I(!£4So;...f W4S NoT 4 .(![AS()/VA~L~ -'5Asts .t:<;~ ~

0/Y' Jul.., ~, Z0/3 Tlfi(. ST/'1-7:£ .;Ct(~d A./1/ /-o/,c~__,.A77(Yll' ,.;y C4-US~

11-1-00</~0 -1 Cf/4~v!N(i- ON£ <:._o<.-1/VT 0/ ~S<."SS/O"V -o/ _,c7#_.,4-1/Vf~7AA?//V.C.

ON 4-uvusr l(p 1 ~on """'~· <r~~.c ~+As A.-e~ .. csr-eu.

oN Au(J-Wr ~c, ?..ol3 ~A!. (r.Aif!(x.rr-/.1[ H.-•uJ #/S /""J//T/.4(. -""'~~-"'9/(r./1/...W~/r./T

AN/J A sc.H£1JuL~N'(I- c-ea.tl<' n--AS .CNT.CAtciJ .' eo-.-..eNt~-u.(/1// i)A.T£: 8- <O-/J

OMNtdus: tQ-i-13 11(!~4-lvrv.css: tl-'1-11 T<(!Mt: 11-ll-11 T.tel.tJL tJc-4/)L;N".C:jl-18-11

eN ..44((-uSI 23, <ol3 Tfi£ CVu~'T £N7~..-e£1) A/\1 O~£k~ cS7AI!JI..ISJINll'~

(_f;]l\ll!IIIONS OF ~£L(4S£

ON .!JAN<A4-;(.'7 Its, ZO!'/ /I?~. ~ w-4S AAI!.eC:Sr£/1 ON A w4..-ell?~r

AN~ f@tl A /\1€-k..- c#-41e.V£ o/ /-)OSS~:SSIOrl v..n-r-H NV7VV/:

ON J4rl~ 'V, ZOI<I ft'TO'r/QN 7"0 ~C..S£7 ilA-r.ES' Sc/l£duUtJ Fo~ FoLLOIN?rv'{r-

ON J"'<NU41e-'1 Z.i, Zol'/ CO!.-f4_T .CNT£-e£J N~ k.- Sc.H£/julNV(i- O"f?~:

UJ"'1AI!(NU.MI£NT i)A-1'£.: /-Z/-1'/ OMNti3US; ~ -1/-1<1 /2C',46fN~S.S: 3 -/7-/'/

z

~7 ov~ ro ~~;$RuAte.., Z<l, zct</.

c111 Fti1R.U~'1 '2.'11 :zql'f o~~-rNtl1ur .,...As ~At) 4-Nl) 1.s-1 3.~:p H.t::4A!Irv(r-s

. t2, <?oli/ /3.(.C4<-!S.C Sl~T~5 W17N~SSk5 ""£;e£ /VQT Ay_.,/LAJ!!J(.c, .A-T.ti?. (j.A~t/U7T~

Fol€ rlet4L) o6.l£c.TS 7o r_r.:,,v7tA/U4NC£. s7,__7/C NV~-"'->d ~~l'f!T 7~/ eN~ c;C

rH£. Sr~·r ......,.17N£SS£f J-1..'4S t;UT Or/#.£ <.ou/V/~'1 ~J ~~y<,/LJT~LJ <:.e7...V/I/V~G<!

TO Z<.jT/1. IJLF.UVf"£ o('JJ£CfS TO C_Q,VT'NUAN'U:.. (:pUII(.T iU/1/IcS '5"/AI,C.S M0770rY'

IH,:r Mit. (}41'(t;U7/.E /St._ llt!.O.~/rStJ) ON ~~ .6<>Nb • TI~PI-1... ~l'uvu.aJ <W'.£ u,££K 70

•ZoiH £.~l'J ol(.~ btrLNlm./(r 0'-(ISI~ DA-T.£. 70 ,..4.1'~1( :Zj.(!~·

.ON ~t.H 2..<.1, <J)II./ i'E?~MIN.CS.S'. /.Joh'/ /~7%<[J c.-a££. ~c..#~ Fe~ 7K/4(.

~s£ MOv~s ro DtSA-rtSf ~ 6-ov~A/~OVr MIS/14.-r./AW~.tZ~VT. A4<>?1orv .IJ~/1/1.£J.

li' ,,

?"() FeLLow TO LA/SUII!.L ,..,_ ~/>ANr T/-14-Tr .4~---t-t'Th'l/~- Tlei-4-L ;.N J-4/L 1

#.4S

4 T/e.t4-L .,...,rNNv r,;~ ALWTTLIJ 77M£ o;C ~o ;JAys ~ rH<. <://4~v-a AAe<:

" Cq.sUAw 4LSo bJO"A-TC.'i 11-1-47 r-H£ 77tt.t-+L <-t7V1..-e..r /S ;e~spONSI~U h-A? AS.SU~"l/(r.

A ..-.;dUll-.., 1'"1et4L uNblA. ~te :s. 3 :' STA7[ v. C!4-~H;I'I', l<.ft ~~Vn,i!c/ a-or {I'J<J<,)

or c.rte. ~-l (6)(1)(;)(3)

(b) nM£ A;lt! -r-AU-9L ·

(I) il!Fb./IJ,4.;vT &.TA1rv£.!J 1111 J-9/(.. -9- iuH:N04-Nr .,.11-0 tr -O.(rA/N.C.J nv

0 J l.t;.o o~s .14FT£~! 71ft CS.'MMJEA/tiM&vT 1)19-T£ ~~t..;,J:.t£d 1/\/ 7/lts ~LIVZ .••

(£M~#,fS/f Ai)M}j)

II " /V14N!l4-T£ oF Cfl(! 3. 3 (b) 8£c <1-4S'c H.c n-4s lu.7;•tHv.oJ NV .l4t (. '~a .-v~ Y.t:~ II

,e.U.E4S~ Fi!!oM Jt4-1('' /JL~.t: 771£ qo-IJ-4., 71~~ L~~t-r .tK/N~<f'J.

~fiCIN TO <-ON7YNU£ IJCJ /0 IT /VOT /.J£1".--v't- ;4 .tec41'r::v¥'4/.S~ -6~IIr 7'0 C0-"1/J'//VW.C.

7 #.£ C£h-1At/ rHE/11 ,/\/}Jtc_.q_r,ctJ 711"'1-1 77TC: £4f~· ~LA /l-¢v.C ?o IS~- C-'1-(t.L;J -;--H4r

"v"£ljN£S~ [jfi~ 1?/lt], Tit£ C~~ 4Lso NVdiC4-77::() 1T CA/1/T Cvrl/?7/\/Gt'~ /F;

&C4Ui£ ~,e£.'5 N'o 1/,..,.Ci.., TR~A--( ~,._~ lo {Cm/7-//VU.C ,;- 7<J A-NO 7'114-:r ,7

t§IA,(/lNT Ci>tv>tbCI( .1'9 S£71/N(/ .. '1 C~;J£ ,4£/'Uot1 1'3.£CIIfU,(Y,I£ ,,r CVvt.(._Jl,..;/ IS£

DoN£ UNTIL IH£ St~ ~s f/ti7-S Jt:x,llf?/~.£d, ~/' ,+z,o7TQnl /'I.('AI(li-N(;- 1-17-11./

,&Jfr tfi'- ~1)

0~ r(/1(! 11!..£(.(4-Y£ or Mil(!. (j-~7"74• ?c/ 1"C.-~~J /#~ C~~T /t-r~l"HEA ~c,k;\/Otv<_Lij6-.££1

rHA-r ;F 15A-IL ~ue£ c.#~WtJ X> St<rfl47'U/f!':C 6"C>--ll.d, 7"#47 1-f.#u<-iJN/ _,J.IeotJuu,;­

/-II'S !e.€/...EA-3£ /.14!4-Ufe .1/E S //1/ CUJ7"C;~ or!/ A.N'OT,H;E<I(' kr.4-r/£.;('. {c/.,4tr SO ~s-1)

colt/ -4/\/ o..e'Ob{ ,......,_S .bv~.<?CtJ //\/ AU(JAA!ar TO c.o,.d/l7'Q-1/S or ~~~EAti<. A<V ~e.

6-.A-<Cf?"l.Alf£~ )AIL TIM.( ct.~rr,crc~7t<:.N 711£ ,j"'';C.. 1/\/IJICif.I£/J A/\/ £";vJ /)An( Ft:Pc

(,4.(,.,(>£ t"l-t-oo'lv:J-1 oF ,/lo"1A-AZU'f '31, eo/'/ w#tV/ /N.OtC4-f.t.d 1WS Atcu~s£ /'-eo,.,_,

JAIL • ( s.(£ ~41'- l'IA?E ~iii=IC4-Tiv.IV)

Afl~. ~VU71~ ~7£NdS TNAI ·~AIN£0 IN J.4tL" .-vvJ ':e.t'LE4S",£-:i ~A?o..t-r JA/( •

4Aec NW AMI.Y<i-Uvus-. THe a£6--v/TfcN o.t' tttcu.4sc/j '"' wt~.sn:~'r ;?o-e.Ja:.T t1tc..71<:JN..4/ey

4

t)>b7 £/Jrrtct11 p<r· .2~S STA-r£5 ~ R£L£r1S£ v. L£.45.€/)- t.<.LI-;;r./(r-(J,) TO 5-t,T ;:~££;

/...tl3iR4T£. 1'1. (IJ TH.£ .4c..T of- L£.Lc4Sml(r c~ 51~ oF tj£/N(r I(?.CLE,.¢5,£1) •

(}-4..J1!(I'U TT£ ,<M! frU .(<;;. 7/-I..._T r-1.£ W-4 s NE v£ "l. ,J 11'.1 sICA((.. '7 _.e .C U 4 SJ!IJ /' lf!!cA-r JAIL

4N6 IVAS fJ/t..,51C4-U..., l:>(_TA..Ir./.0) L/1/ .J4/(. HIS ~0 1)...:.., ,dL<tr;/J £,.r~t-eCJ C/V A4A-"t'(//

211

ZoiC{ F~M /HE CvM.M.Col"f/'CL,.WEN'T tl4-1£ 131..17 ,F¢(? -4ii'Zc;,c,.,_,6/V7j S #fh..rL J 7""#-e."

CVUAZT N<JI .4(,-.f!!LL ~Nn# <J •• ruetJVrT£r ""7d/'L/CAtrto/l/ #.C S'/ILL w-<s-/1/r .l'f?e~L~#J'CL)

/ILL /V?~ut 31 1 zct4/ wHIVI /-JWT #tA? /o ~5 /).A.FT #".r 6o LJ~ 77A?.ct,/VL

TJ/4-7 L./LTI~T£t'1 /)JI)Nr ;4Llcn-v r/"f,{._ ~ ,YTE/VT/0/\1 70 A ~ d-<T 7/~L-LI.I\/.t:: • "/#IS"

NV 7U«!N vto/-A...r£4 THe C .. /·~ "3. f l(?uL.£ ~.("<juNfU/1/~ LJIS,-w/SS-4(..

C/V To • ~TJ4TL.

f',:a)fl? "-•die~..., OA/ 7/{;(l' ~IH IJ""-'7 or.? {po?l'/ l\A~1 ..• 7r/c,p"'· -s /V(;

vti-i4 Ttc/V O/ C;~ 1. 3 so Lt-~ AS Tl"lf 7~/A( 15' """ ?'#PV ?-o ..J<~ys

o/ A.te/!41(!-N.M;(l'/1/T ~lin' d!,L_LHc)6U 7119-ot _i(D Q/ 7i'/or£ /)~Lif ..

' / cu)TOD:-,. r,;>:-;;:J,tl4r;<; . .qiJf)Ci))

.. Muf'ic:.S, ~0 ~11 4fj_,?. 9<-1 (!<t9t)

,/ A-LLouLIJ THL 5?.4-7L. rc a._t:.j..cAS£ llt~vr lc' LX tz:,·v,j 711~ "::.{::1~~-lj"' 77?1'4{ C: Lc'C..i<' -4r"T£/I

'' /)t,l..i/{ t} 7"fit:. ')jAT£ ~ ,/14( ITO .rtf /r;-?.? <: Ort//1,11</A,Y(..[ /5.NSt/1/<. //S iJ.("Ct.l/0/\/ <Nv

UI\/Lt:\S !tiL -4;?/'te..LLN/,// A14k.~S ,/J C.L£·4~ SIIOtt.t/Vfr T/-/--9-T /It/: TR/4(.. ( .. t/l--t~rj

OC.Ct\tvrl! t<; -"VJA/\11F.<:"srt"1 U!VI{?,c"rJJoi\IA.(JLLf 1 o~ £x.C,.;?\.J5<:,J o.rv uAi?.<;;tA6'L.((

(rtfvurvOS cr)2 rv?e Un//(tl/4/JU! /?c-4'JCJ.rv·r. 57"'!1£ ..,·:_ /.Z_{X_:__r;_:?_.-<"dcL.-.ic~__,i_<,i.nLu::£d', 7?

Vv-/1 LeitZ, 20 (1171); 'S_T.-...r£ t.-· ,<fcN.e;uf, 1'-l'i *n. zc/ <;J'-17. <;.rV (<7 ccJ)

fl,£r<!~:_·, 1/k' /l{'t4L Ct?4XZ T z\L',;V!c·J /,/1£ ST.4T[f .A·-?()T/()/\1 70 cc.,l/71.-V<..t.t::. 4A/d

A<:.KrvowU=_!Jv.tJ 711,( !/f-'7/'Cr<?741V'~z~ c/ A 7/-4-;t.t".t.._, 7/.Z/4L A/'viJ T/-147 /WR. (;-.4A'tn...-7TES

'5;(7c<'/)'1 //(?/4L <:LOCK VV4f ,.:;{...:.·70S/ Lf/)· J:';V(IU.i'/'1/£,. /HI<;, 7r/L' CC.·l.,·,Z;;- ,,~'?,r?-"?CJ,-::!E-"'??'7

'><Av(r£STcJ 7f/47 77iE S74-7~ A--'l'OVIt .,::~0 /JI5#/.Jf'4( ol'l? ,&';C.'i...t"..-?s;<· o/ 7/>'L' 0-<'./4v,d.4,-V/

wr!rc./1 Co?VI,:ZVL/'V£'i tT'i f"J/.21(/'P- j.('(tJYQ,-,1 TO JeN'7 T/Y'C S7A-77!'J' ."!4C7/C-/1/ 70

<:!JrV///!/1./£. /T ~41 7/IE 7t<f?;4l C.e-1...!1('!75' {jCA7'7 /(• L'/V}vtR~.; .-4 'Y,_,::?<''c'-1'7 Tk'/-;z( <-t;V/},(./,?

QrR ?l

-"'J/'. (};f,Z/7l.J"TTC .4-LS<J u':JJ£c..7[J 7L> .4./'o/'7 <C(,r\/T//l/L.../4/'l/C<::'S ~/l/0 ,.-r7..:z./.),c C~[...-?4'

TO 't'ft!:: Cr/U~T -;;·N47 ,1-// 1/VT£/VL),£;) TO .C:.Yc'K?CtfC NIF '5/Ee·/J'? T/C"/,.4( /(7/(r,H',7I.

tfl{_ At.S'-' .4-<'(rUL'S Tfi"'-'T !#.e'-<'~ ..Z."'9J. IVO (>OQd C'-'9-vf')£ TC.• C('...Vt!/l./(..4-C (r-I{,·{'.,Jl.

1$'1 Ttil!: C VU~'T CN /Yl-4.-"f:':C...Il 17, e>olt./, Vt.-ifiC If' ;r; -eCy~.;-tl'~<f'O /.Jv ~/.-1,/..-~ 6£r~~,C

t"1 Cc.N ri;'VIA-4--/VC"-, c~-v Bt: Gt'?ar.rr.t:.J,

yt.A5f/- cvv57- A/.27 I S.(C/fC..N /() 5 7.4J..(S .

,. j L~fTfC.£ o'l/ 4 L( C "i'S.(f <;f/4£ ( /].(' .4,dlf.-t//li/S l:t·~[ tJ 0/-7<!'/1/i. 'f J AVvd ~~ 7/fi/'l.t T

UNNLUr'iA-e.-'7 tkl4...,·: (t!N?;?IIAJ-;J .4tJ!JOJ}

/f'?R- (j,<1''(?t)"'...f7T£..<; ~crJf7t7uT/Q/\/Al. /(!l(r/'115 ...._.te:tf?l! Vt(JL.AJL($ vvHE,ll 7/"''L C?URF

c .. £(4-·Jt!J Ad u,vl'\lt;CcSS.4.e 7 /)El4'7 8'7 .-4Lt..ovv,?V(i.-- ,4-Nt) 14-J_,c?.l"?£,/-)k.-e'?--, Suv.(r--EJ'T//V(/

7D y-l'f,(- ST/9-'1"£, 7<... .C!T.h(C't? LJ/)4'7/J'J c»(7 Rk'L.(--45'E Tft'.[ ..j.('/,e',-v#.-<2/VT ./(.; c:,,;?cuAo-rYL'tVT

THe ':>;<?<'c'l\7

Ti<2;4C CLOCk C-'€1!.4///V?- ;'t--tA?7/7<:'t? /J~LA'7- 'TO ,4LL17Z..... 7"//..;z-T tA..VZ..fLIJ

jj.(!,-v;c·-4,..( TH:C: ;(lt.4R/)CJ'"'-. o/' 77-l.t:: C,~I-Ht/1/4-( R<..lt.Z:s A-..-v,:) AA:.I t:3L CCA/Sr.J;/;-;;/1/'/

W1?1i C'Vf/.? vv/fs/1- curv:>l/7I.-tTiv-'V.4.( A'!IV-n/ <.;/' 4.-e,-. / s-.ccii'<..Fv' /0.

/3t(4UJC. 7/t6 C&-1.4-r!T Vl(i{-<.T[LI <::_t-r! l-J ..,crvJ -4.tr?;'. I .r.c"C.l/C;-1/ /U ~-;«· 7H.e' /AI4Sh'.

c..r,:.-vJ·,-. I'Jtf-4'7t'.FJ/1 <. ,-s F?C7?-r/4cJ.

IN5UF;::I<.i£N I //Vh:J/e.M47lDA/

BAIL JUM/)Ul./(r 9A· 7t.p. 170 (J)(<J

Mlf. M£OU7Tc's ;/\lkv(l'A747ION tS /11/SU/"ri(~J.C/VT ON #IS /JA/L JuA?;CJ.NV(r

CJ-/4NJj,£ 13£C4US.C IT lJok.SAfr <:.!::J/\JT/11//ll ALL. ~ £SS,C,V7/.-'9 { E~.CA-?[/1.//$

t:Y= 7#.€ Cl(?l~ > V!OL471'N(, HIS S/X:/N ANd ~&V~Tc"E/1/T/-/ A..#.t:/VLJ~.E/1/T

J?lti#T 70 7#£ U.S. CONS71Tc./110AI ANt) 1.1'1/AS.#. eo/'1/ST. A~/ / S.c'C.T/0/\1

4N ;J\I~~TION .N!USI CON/-41/11 ALL £SS,tl'l/l/-"1-t. £LC/Hc/VTS (}~A

<Y'<IM£. S7/'17L v. C'7¢tflV; 101 vvn-.-9/-f!:J· 3S.r (zooQ). 71"'<:. A?477<VV'4LE &/H,-vd

//1/(.LU/J;rt(r 'E_s~/\/1/4( .CLC'rl4.CN7S" Je?47fiC:/'l 7##"9/1/ OtV4y S7~7U701(!'? ELE-+tL/VtS"

IS To vltr£ 7~ ACCt.-JS£/J /'~0_/1£/( A/C/1<:..,1:: ~ 7//E N-4TW~.C o,C 717'<. C~/A4.E

SO 7f/4T TH.C ACCUS.€/J ~I'll /)R~~~.C A-1/ Ad£fjU..¢7.£ M'h"I'VS.£. STA~- V.

KJO!fSVI/S //7 VV#. .zc/ ?3, /01 (/97/ j. vti#U\1 su//IC/01/Cy ()/ 1'/VN.I(7~?-4710AI

IS 1\/QT Cfi4LU/I/W.IJ UN7tt.. APT£4 CONVtr;:.."rtoN, TH.C //l//(7,-e-4-?..-¢.770/\1 IS U6'~~4(L'7

C(Y>(Sl"RULiJ lA/ /A~ C./ /TS vALtiJ;T'T. f<Jo~SVIKJ 1/7 IIVA/...C/ A7 /o"i. 4/1.1

tNFoi<'/11714-TICJI\J wtt.L 1'.5£ 1 .. -ijfJI/cJ. ~ tJN A//if'..¢(_ U/1/tU~ 1/IL .U4EA?4{. <vNS71(?U<:.:7/<JAI

ift.JL£, I~ A.N A~/'4K!Em/L'7 ,t;t/5S/N6- £LE/U.CNT A4..a._, &£ /'~/A't.., I-*1/'LI.CtJ /'~o-""'

71/C L411i(;.uA(r£ o/ 7/I.C <U-~(rl/\/(i.- nO~A4.CA/T. KJ<J/f!.SVIK, //7 4'(.//1.1", <c/ A/ /O{/.

lf/JA.A/f'\lcll< Tf/£. £SS&VTI4( t:.UM~NTS <()/ A ~l<eiA-·1/!. S/A-1.(. Y'· C""'A--?~/5£L_4, /Z r

WN-W 7"17, S'O~ (t?9s-) UNUte wAS#I'/1/(r-IOAJ (4vv, TO t$L' C..<.vvvtc..T.C;j 0~ 4."/l'l.

JuMf}IN(r, 7f/L W&v/J/1./vT ,#U5'T /.$.1: <::.1/-'f..eCr.ctJ ,V/7/1 'A /AA!Ttc..vt-4;<( uA/L~Ly/TV~

c..£/M~.' '?.!/97£ v. ~' /t.,o wr7 4~_/- t.-::21/, (f27 (zouu) Cvv.K?.7f /C'Evt£/A/ A

l!J./4/..I..t..n/0£ TO 711£ St.IFhC.i£/1/C."' tJ.f- 7/1~ c;/44(r/rVC-- IJOC..UA4c/vT d{ AI'OV'O.

SI/R"l. I(:._...J:~!.~..I}/3£LL, I:Zf" vvn.z.c/7'77, 8tTI (1775')

1

,WI/?. Cr-4KV-u77.( Al(!vU£~ 7//47 //'/~ AA-r~>vd.t:'tJ //l//c.!-<l.-47_,r.771;;/\/ ~/Lf/) ON

JA/'IL1Aie'1 28, 2olt:/ IS 1/\/Su///c,,[/l/7 6.t:<:4US.E ,- L!OL5 /VOT C<..V\/7.--9//1/ A~(_

71/.c .LSS£.N7/4l. .£.t.L>wc>v7r o,.l-· 7#~ <;(!JA.u .:·/ .6..A/t ..Jt.AA-?_,d//1/<;--, v/0~4r//l/t;:­

;ps SIX/II ANd /r/Z../~71!.6rl/TI/ A-vr.CrvdA,c/1/'7 ~/(;.#7S /<J 7//.C L/. S'. Cu/V.fT//"f/1770/1/

AN,1 w,;s/;- <..C.·/YS'T Allt?7. I Sc'<770/V ~ ~tJ .?.?.

/N £f/Lif!'7 _,d,I/!OS.t:!CUT/()/1/, 7;/£. tJL./'.£rVdArv7 ~t./s:T 4L //1//<.M?..-w<.d 0/ 7//£

NA-7UJI(f AN-0 <J41A.J'.C o.r· T#~· A(:.c_uSA-770/1/. J S. <o;vS.T· A-4-u:.,,;(). ¥'7 _; 1-V/!5.//. CC>/1/.f/-:

A.R7. I ~~7/r;yv 22. 7/1£ //V/0~-4-rAT/<YI/ 5'//--ff'~L &. ~~---;r .... /1/, C()NC/Sc· A/1//)

!Ji./'l/1/;T.C.. W-<1/71£/11 S74T,t!./ff,C/I/T ();I' 7/T-<. ~S5.C,V//A& /'/?c7r Cc/1/STJ/c.r///t/? 7#£

iJ;:/L/vSL ~~~~V,C;j. Cr~ 2./ (7)(/) /T ..A?us/ ALLL~- _,;.:-AC7<; SiJt_,?,r:?o..e.T//'1/'(f­

£1/CK'r S7-471A7VAC? <5'-Lrt-rc/l/T <:.v' 7H~ C~/-HL. S7&7 .. ( w. KJGA?Sf/t.K', //? "'-'A/. <?d 73,

/01 (;'?'?!)

6,.,;{. JUA--t/'PV6- IS ~//....-vctJ //\/ -ec~A-- 9'.4. 7~. /70. 7#~ -c'&EA-?<!',....c/75 Or

&.4/( JuM/J/rV(,. .A/&. ,#£./ p< T/"1£ o£/.6-vtl4-N/: (t) wAr #Ct.LJ r04'' c/-/4;!('(/LO

w/711, <Jilt C...oNI/I~T.t/) o/ A ,4~7/c.utAA ~/4?.<(',· (?) U----?S lf!£Lc'-4S£t) /.5''? CPU/'tr

Ot<l/)L~ 0~ AtJ.N7777.t..tj 70 15~/L ~17.1/ 7/7~· ~--,W'/A!,([A-?~/'1/'7 o~· /'? 'Su~5.Ef7<./~/VT

jlti!!S"-tV.tl(. A~/CrM"Arvc£; ArvJ (J) kN(.~..<;t/1/{rL{ /A/UIJ To A_,.:?_,<?C"'A";!(' . .-?r .lt!'~yw/r?~d.

·~_z:~r-./O.LJ{, ;oo ...v""" A~_r?· GJ2~ tp27 (<ooo)

H.t=R~, 711£ .-4-#.C,vMiJ t/\1/0.R'.rnAr/GAI /AI cc-·z.ovr Z .ST-47~4:

01\1 oR 4/'J()UT Tl'l:t. S//1 /JA-7 t:J/ o<:JC.V.5.!4, Z0/3, 1..-v TH.C S7~7'.C· o/

W4Sflt/l/(r.7QI\I, T;lc ,46;..y,t- /IU/#r,('~ Llf/2NtJA...-v7; /hV//1/(r &.UV ~LU'..-?.U()

&.., ~/'tT o.JI(!tJL/1 o/(1 /"?0.-<4/77cd 7o -:5/fl/t: v<--/7.# k/V<JK--.t..c/.J(;..f o/ 7.8-i'

RE')ut~~UErv7 o/ A St..'dS.Ef1<-lh117 ,_,dL,e.Jf:MIAl. ,4_,<?~.C--s?..e"A...-v~~- /.5£/c.J/('/

A <:pu;e_r ().!- 7fit5 57/'F-7/[ O/(' 0/. 7/7.( teLj>U/~~.M'cNT To Ai!~,:?o--eT TO

A <:.(fl'eeL.c.:rtONAl 1"~1(/7'7 F~ S>(.~YICc o/' S.C:IVT~NCC; d;.J rAt(. T<.J

AflfUt+~ o.e IJ1i) ;:A/f.. TO SL.JR-e£/\IMI'f ,:."..e s.c-evi<Y.: t:t~ S.I!./VT,C/l/1C-C /N

wHt<J-1 A <:.L4SS .(3 oA' ~ l"c Lotv'7 /14f l$~L!V //U't), /0 t;Vt/ .' t/R.4,v/

~NT'! SufJEI!?IO'< C.vt..U(.7 CAUS£ NO iS-1-0o':/20-11 · <:.oN'ne_..,~'7 70

RLV/5L=.IJ <'-.oM. C/' lA/A:S/IIN(r/OAI ?.4- 71';;,. 1 7o.

,, INSVrF/Vbi!T 15£CA.u'S<_ IT r/7/L~-J /0 /M/vT//'f vtd/...;.T ;dA,eT/C.ut.-94 U/1/4-Eiii!Ly,;/V(,.

vf?l~£ }/L rt;'AS C/14~Crl(/) vto7# /3vrr .nv'S:T~4/) oN'--'1 ALUVi:_/) A (}-£-4-/1/r CCYl.NVT'1

S4,g.t.~H/I~ ~VUI'{.T C.A<.ISL /\lvA-'f6€4 · (su ./;V;.C«?#?•7'1CYJ ~tl.£1) .JA.At. <'f, ZOI~)

Ol'e/JIN4/VCL tin! /VC T S#rlf/'r Ju£ ;#Ai!O~SL ,e'~·L )"//1/V «~O..v KJc~fVI/c 1

T#L <:<YW-'1?/

~c!T,C.<'.I'i-T£d ,, [w]£ /I4V.C -<</'E#T,CiJL 7 J"''-'4 7#,.,.7 .iJ£/L./1/tf~,-t//.f S~LGI ...VeT _,t.ky,c

10 SC'.#J('t/1 ,=(/}'!' Tlf;c RU~S o~ ~.6(/'W~IIN.f T#C'7 ~.C ACCUI'£# <J/ V/0<(~77/1/(r-.

1'31!a:Ji:./:, 1/"f WI'1·Y AT &1'3J (t~H) (.c-_,#I'Mrtf .4.J/J-ciJ)

/#L t\/LQ5f.g,e'7 r~/f .do /\/o/ .-¥/""L'4..-e' nl/ Aro/7 /o~A-? .A/~ .6''7 /.4/"'<' <o/1/She'­

i.Ac.:TIOAI ('J9.Ar T/t'<:'? 6'£ /i;-u/1/d //1/ ~:C ~~Cr//'Vv ..d~v4-r£/V"7. &<:~UJ..C: .0/ 7//t$",

7#f Cfi!?r~C cr /.fA/( J<.-u·~~-'/1/V.. /rv· 78~ ,;/1/~~.-cvt/ ...._.foe# o~/T7£'d 7#~

/J~rrc.v(.~ L/N0-(0-E""L!?/...VC- <:...<etrw.t! ''rll"''-7 4£Swc..7-ctJ r:--eo.,.., ///c -6'19.-L .Jvr..-_,.,:?//1/{,­

ell"/<~.

cY T/fL Cl/4~ vv.-<~f' V"IOL4T£t), ,A/Vd #If R/tf'I¥T 70 Jv£. _,4,;ec•c:L..ff AA/J ~~C..-C ~?.:l"Cfi'I::VV

k--A5 V1Cl.47CJ uNtJC-"C ~07/Y C(}.rVJ'T//f...-f/7(;/1/f, A:".C_.k~tJ 15 R.c5w,r~c;.J /o .J/.F-H/S.I'

('VVC-LUS /Or-J

/':J4Ti: - 2 - C - IS

'"

CLA:!. 71riC4r£ or sc -e ~- ·;c_£

I U~Ti/''7 7;-/;Q.-T CN THI"> iJ~T£, ;<Jvf/.?5</~t/ To <:J../.? s .!, TN4T I . .4'741L£A

TfiC. FcLLC!Ad/V(r OvC<A.N'l.C:NT:S, lo ~l-Ite./! IS A,r;<::;xc·LJ, 4'7 v.>- .A-'lA;L rtos7.-9v-£

1-:;,zt; (J41b /0 ·.

/2£/ik~ <;. TO~L-NSL£'1

CVU .tel o~ 4-;t:J,<?E AL 5 c. u: 4! K }) I v .iZi

~·ov N- C.c iJ.4A. Sl

04-TLb TrliS ~1!-1 /J~ ot-' fC-fiJ.<!t-tA-£'7 2c-.;)· AT C:C'-VNL'iL, vv/7.

&~~f..t:.~t7fC

1/

M ·h" c fl, et /,- z.a ~-l, n 0 ~ De.~ en~ e. Obi ect(' <.H'

o "'-- tv\. A r c..k \ 1, "00 11../

' ! -t-o - c c 1.f &0 - '

AVVle.v.__de.d I. ntor"""-~~ 1'c>"'\ o.., ~ C\1'\ ~'t" dO 1 "/

Gr~t Coun-ty

Tom· Jones, Sheriff JAIL TIME CERTIFICATION

i

The following information is provided for the purpose of crediting time spent in cbnfinement per RCW 9.92.151 priorto:the transfer of the below listed subject . ' ' . ; . . ' '

NAME DATE OF BIRTH

Listed are all dates of arrest and release concerning the above subJect up to the' Date of Transfer \·

START DATE END DATE TOTAL DAYS SERVED . - .. - -·

·. <K-.\1- \ ~ 0'",~1- \7 4· J-:-'/)n -: l Lt ·.· -~- ~-~' ~ 14 : (on

.-·~~ln-- \U .- (j- J:-(1/-1'-f ~~ \

.. -

.-.•

.,

b.

. - -.. TOTAL DAYS, SERVED l41 ..

~.· Y .. Early Release Credits LOst or Not Earned

NOTE~_fu&}£f#1ma l\n ·~ ~~tlr\~ ·@A 3])[__,

Date ·

.. : ' I

i '

I ! '

. I I

1111111111111111111111\lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll 07-740947

SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF WASHINGTON COUNTY OF GRANT

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

Plaintiff,

) Case No.: 13-1-00420-1 ) ) Memorialization of Defense Objection on ) March 17, 2014

VS.

Matthew Garoutte

Defendant.

) ) Re: Denial ofTime for Trial )

COMES NOW the defendant by and through their attorney the Grant County Public

Defense , Stephen Kozer, staff attorney , and respectfully memorializes the Defense Oral

Objection on March 17, 2014 and I or the Defendant's ProSe Oral Objection to the State and I

or the Court allowing the State to release the In Custody defendant , so as to extend or otherwise

push into the future the Defendant's time for trial deadline.

Background

The State had originally filed a Possession of Methamphetamine charged against the

Defendant. The Defendant had missed a court hearing and a warrant for the Defendant's arrest

was issued by the Court .

- 1

The Defendant was arrested on the warrant on or about January 28, 2014 and the State

moved to amend the Information to include Bail Jumping on or about that date.

That the case as amended, was set for was set for Trial Readiness Hearing of March 17,

2014, Trial on March 19,2014, and an outside or end oftime for trial period ofMarch 24,

2014.

Grant County Public Defense PO Box 37/238 W. Division St.

Ephrata, W A 98823 (509) 754-6027/Fax: (509)754-6027

On or about January 28, 2014 the State also argued for and had bail set on this case. The

Defendant is without financial means to post bail.

The Defendant was also being held on a new charge of Possession with Intent to Deliver

under another cause# in Grant County.

On March 13, 2014 the State finally provided after approximately 40 days discovery on

the Bail Jumping case . The State also provided 3 amended witness lists on the above entitled

case.

That the Defense worked all day Sunday March 16,2014 to prepare for the new charge

of Bail Jumping .

On March 17, 2014 the Defense called the case "ready for trial " ( aside from the eye

doctor appointment ) . The State made some excuse about readiness for trial . That the Judge

ruled that the case was going out to trial on March 19, 2014.

On March 17, 2014 after the Defendant was taken do"MI into the jail the State informed

the Defense that ( and this was new ) the State key witness Officer Harvey would be out of

country, the State's representative stating he just learned of this. (Ironically the Officer had

just testified in a 3.6 Hearing with the defense and the same State's representative the

Wednesday before and made no mention of himself being out of country" on another case

involving the defendant ) .

On March 17, 2014 , the State had the Defendant brought back up from the jail and had

the case recalled before the Court. The State explained to the Court that it's witness would be

out of country and just learned of this . It is unclear if the Court or the State suggested that the

Defendant be released on the charge , but it was suggested and not by the defense . It was

Objected to . the Defendant was released on the charge and the case was continued for trial .

TIME FOR TRIAL RULE

That the above procedure of releasing the defendant 1 week before the time for trial

rule expired , was done to thwart the defendant's right to a timely trial while incarcerated. It is

the "spirit" of the rule to have both sides prepared for trial in a timely manner or otherwise

extend to the court the courtesy of a "heads up" that a continuance is needed.

-2 Grant County Public Defense PO Box 37/238 W. Division St.

Ephrata, W A 98823 (509) 754-6027/Fax: (509)754-6027

•

The State was not prepared for trial. The State waited almost 40 days to give the

Defense the discovery ( most of which was located in the courthouse ) on the Bail Jumping

charge, most likely in the hopes (and we have seen from past practice of making it necessary for

the defense to request a continuance . The defense was ready for trial having worked on the case

a good part of the weekend . The defense was not asking for a continuance. The State had not

asked for a continuance. It had been suggested the defendant be released on the charge.

The State had originally asked for bond when it suited there purposes and the State's

purpose was to keep the defendant incarcerated, especially after the State had amended the

Information to add the Bail Jumping charge. Now with the State not prepared for trial (it seems

plausible that the State anticipated a defense motion for continuance after dumping all of the

discovery on the Bail Jumping charge on the Defense March 13, 2014, for a "Readines~"

calendar March 17, 2014 ) , the State requested no bond in the matter. (The State also knowing

full well that the defendant was held on another case number and thus would not be released. )

The State doing so only to not have the case dismissed for time of trial rule violation.

This was not the intent of the rule .

Conclusion

The defendant position is that the case should have been dismissed . Thwarting to the

time for trial rule when the State is not prepared within the 60 days as required of the defendant

is not the "administration of justice"

Dated:

- 3

LfJ::y Submitted,

Grant County Public Defense

PO Box 37/238 W. Division St.

Ephrata, W A 98823

(509) 754-6027/Fax: (509)754-6027

-4

~ }i~·l~ Grant County Public Defense Stephen J. Kozer #14413 Attorney for Defendant

Grant County Public Defense PO Box 37/238 W. Division St.

Ephrata, W A 98823 (509) 754-6027/Fax: (509)754-6027

..

Public Defense

JAN 2 8 2014

Received

SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR GRANT COUNTY

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.

MATTHEW SIMON GAROUTTE, EPD, 13EP1267

Defendant.

No. 13-1-00420-1

AMENDED INFORMATION

D. ANGUS LEE, Prosecuting Attorney for Grant County, State of Washington, by this Amended Information accuses:

MATTHEW SIMON GAROUTTE of the crime(s) of

Count 1: Possession ofMethamphetamine, 69.50.4013 Count 2: Bail Jumping (From Class B or C Felony), 9A.76.170(3)(c)

committed as follows:

COUNT 1: Possession of a Controlled Substance [Methamphetamine]

On or about the 3rd day of April, 2013, in the State of Washington, the above-named Defendant did possess a controlled substance, to-wit: Methamphetamine, including its salts, isomers, and salts of isomers; contrary to the Revised Code of Washington 69.50.4013 and 69 .50.206( d)(2). (MAXIMUM PENALTY-Five (5) years imprisonment and/or a fine of not less than $1,000 nor more than $10,000 fine pursuant to RCW 69.50.4013(2) and RCW 69.50.430, plus restitution and assessments.)

(Ifthe Defendant has a second or subsequent conviction under RCW 69.50.401, .4011, .4012, .4013, .4015, .402, .403, .406, .407, .410, or .415, the minimum fine shall be $2,000 pursuant to RCW 69.50.430.)

JIS Code: 69.50.4013 Cant Subs No Prescription-Felony

• / !

COUNT 2: Bail Jumping

On or about the 8th day of October, 2013, in the State of Washington, the above-named Defendant, having been released by court order or admitted to bail with knowledge of the requirement of a subsequent personal appearance before a court of this state or of the requirement to report to a correctional facility for service of sentence, did fail to appear or did fail to surrender for service of sentence in which a Class B or Class C felony has been filed, to­wit: Grant County Superior Court Cause No. 13-1-00420-1; contrary to Revised Code of Washington 9A.76.170. (MAXIMUM PENALTY (Failure to appear in Class B or Class C felony case)-Five (5) years imprisonment and/or a $10,000 fine pursuant to RCW 9A.76.170 and RCW 9A.20.021(l)(c), plus restitution and assessments.)

JIS Code: 9A.76.170.3C Bail Jump B or C Felony

contrary to the form of the Statute in such cases made and provided, and against the peace and dignity of the State of Washington.

DATED at Ephrata, Washington,

Edward A. Owens, WSBA #29387 Chief Deputy Prosecuting Attorney