0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U...

31

Transcript of 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U...

Page 1: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

������������ ������������������������������ �!�"�$#&%'�)(���������*�+��,+-/.�������0�21 �3�4�����

5�687:9<;>=@?8;A=B6DC�EGFBHI;>J!9<;>=LK$MBHI;ANO:J�CQPAFBRI7:N!S>TU7WV3X�M�YZ;A7:[\9<J�]B;>N!^`_GFB;A=Q6Lab9`;A=DcdN!=DS�Ye]B;>9<_f\gbh�ikj!lnmpoqh�rsm�t!u�v twoqiUxUmph:leyAz�{|h�rkz:hw}k~e{�lp�w{|rk{�jq�0tw���Amph�z��krU{�z���rk��mp{�mpxUmphbjr���yAm�j�mph��Zrk{|�GhWlp�n{|m��s}>�w�����z���ln�U�Uh��Zj�|��}

� ��jz��>�n�UxUlp�>}�~��*�!�G��>��B�s w�!¡G¢w£A¤A¥G Q¦�§G¨©¦«ª¢w£�¬G­A®!¡Aª�¯±°²G³s´Gµw¶k·�´GµU·�¸G¶0¦±¹s�º©¯\°²G³s´Gµw¶k·�´w»G³G¼s°�¦½ gZh�i�j�lnmpoqh�rsm�tu��\j�mp�kh�o�j�mp{�z:�ej!r���yAm�j!mp{|��mp{|z���}��0tlnmp��jrk�±yAm�j�mph��Zrk{|�GhWlp�n{|m��s�A¢A�wªA w¥�£A¤¾s¢wº©¦«ªw¢w£

¿�v h�rsmph:lÀu<tlbÁZ��t��j!�0jrk��ÂÃh��w{|tr�j��Ä�rA�A{�lptwrUoqh�rsm�j�8ÂÃh��nh�j!lpz��Q}���!�q����Å�Æ�} Å��kh��erk{|�Gh:lp�n{�m���tu©�«t�Ç�j>}���t�Ç�jqv {�m«�s}>�«�È �w���s��Ép���ÊGËs�DÌ>¥w�Í�Î8ÏG¥�­A¤s¥!ÌGÍsªwÍ�¦Ð£UÏw®!ÑA�0¦«ªw¢w£¬w­>®!¡Aª�¯\¶U·�¸s´w¶G¶G°G´w¶G¶G¶w¶�¦\¹A�º©¯�¶U·�¸s´w¶G¶G°G´w¶G¶G¶w¼�¦

Ò�Ó�Ô�Õ�Ö�×�ØÕwÙ Å��Uh�m�j�n�It!uDiUlpt��A{��U{|rk�)j!rqtwiUmp{|o�j!�kj!r�j���>�n{|� t!u8mp�khÀ��m�j!mphÀtu8mp�UhÀj!mpoqt�nik�khWlph�lph�Úsxk{�lph��©mp�khÃ�Uh��wh���Étikoqh�rsm�tuBh:Ûqz�{|h�rsm z�twoqiUxUm�j!mp{|tr�j�Umptstw�|� mp��j�m�u`jz�{|�|{�m�j!mph�j!r�h:Ûqz�{|h�rsm�{|rsmph��!l�j!mp{|twr�tuQtw�U�nh:lp�j!mp{|twrkj�D�kj�m�j�{�rsmptoqtA�>h��|���D�«r3j��wj�lp{Üj�mp{|twr�j!�©jiUiUlptGj!zW�±mp�UhI�Uj!m�j�j�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr�iUlptw�U�|h�oÝ{|�bi8t�nh���j�bj�oq{|rk{|oq{|Þ�j!mp{|tr±iUlptw�U�|h�o\}ÇÀ�U{�z��Ilph�ÚsxU{|lph:�0mp�kh��nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«��ßd�UhWlp{��j!mp{|�Gh:��à�tuDjZz:tw��m©u`xUrkz:mp{|twrkj�AÇÀ{�mp�Ilph��ni8h�z:m©mpteiUlptw�U�|h�oái�j�l�joqh:mph:lp���wÅ��kh�>{|lph:z:m��Uh�z:twxkiU�|h���oqhWmp�ktA�±��j!�b�8h�h�r�h:âAmph�rk�n{|�Gh:�|��j!ikiU��{|h��3u`t!l)�nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{|m��3��mpx��>{�h:��tu�j!{�l)i8tw�|�|xUmp{|twrB���e�!ã«tw{|rsm�nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«��{�� j�z�twoqiU��h:oqh�rsm�j!ln�Ijiki>lptGj!zW��ÇÀ�U{�z���h:Ûqz�{|h�rsmp���qz�j!�|z�xk��j!mph:� mp�khÃ�UhWlp{��j!mp{|�Gh:� tuQjbu`xUrkz:mp{|tr�j�UÇÀ{|mp�lph��ni8h:z:m�mpt�j±�Üj�lp�wh�r>xUoI�8h:l�t!uZikj!l�joqhWmph:lp�����«r�mp�U{|�Ii�j!i8h:lIÇ h��>{|�nz�xk�n��mp�kh$o�j!mp�kh:o�j!mp{|z�j��u`txkr��Uj!mp{|twrU��tump�Uhbjw��ã�t{�rsmÀ�nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«��oqhWmp�ktA��jiUik�|{|h���mptIj{�l�i8t���|x>mp{�tr�oqtA�>h��|��}kj!r���iUlph��nh:rAm�jäz�toqik�|h:mphe�nh:m�tu�z�twoqiUxUm�j�Émp{|twrkj�kmptst�|��u`t!l�i8h:lnu<tlpoq{|rk�bmp�>lph�h:É��U{|oqh�rU�n{|twr�j!��j�!ã�t{|rAm��nh�rU�n{|mp{|�A{�m«�I��mpx��U{|h����GåZxkoqhWlp{�z�j�>h:âUjoqik�|h��©�n�Ut�Çæmp��j�mmp�>lph�h:É��U{|oqh�rU�n{�tr�j!�Djw�!ã«tw{|rsm��nh�rU�n{|mp{|�A{�m«�$j!r�j���>�n{|��iUlpt��A{��Uh���{�r>u`t!lpo�j!mp{|twr$twr${|rUç�xUh�rkz:hZj�lph�j��}AÇÀ�k{|z���z�jrkrUtm��8ht�Um�j{|rUh��$�nt�|h������s��j!r�{|rA�Gh:lp�nhejrkj���>�n{|��tu�mp�UheoqhWmph�tlpt��t�w{|z�j!�Bèkh����U���Uy>h:�Gh:l�j�8{|�|�|xk��mnl�j�mp{��wh��kj�m�jäj!�n�n{�oq{|��j!mp{|trlph��nxU��mp��{|r�jÃm«ÇÀ{|r�h:â>i8h:lp{|oqh�rsmp��uÜl�joqh:Ç tlp�8}sj!�©Ç h��|��j!�©mp�Uh�j�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr�t!uDjelph�j!���kj�m�jZ�nh:m�j!lphÀj!�|�nt�iUlph��nh�rsmph��D�é�êAëBìäí Öî�Ôwï v �kh�oq{|z�j!�Bmnl�j!rk�ni8tlnmÃoqtA�>h��|��}��e�!ã�t{|rAmÀoqtA�>h��|��}8yAh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{�m«��jrkj���>�n{���}kg�j!m�jIj�n�n{|oq{|�Üj�mp{|twrQ�

ð ñkòÃó8ôDõ�öä÷�ø�óDùpõÃòú CD7�;AûD9<^Ü9ÜüpV±ü:T�;>=Uü:9<J!9ÜýQ;süWN�;A=Q6�[±;A=Q;AS>N�J�]B;>=DS>NwOÃ9<=L;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`JäýQTU^Ü^<C8ü:;>=kübJ!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BOÃ7:N!^<9<NOZT>=�;A=L;>J!J!CD7�;süWN7WNýD7WNwO�N=kü:;sü:9ÜTU=4TAcÀü:]DN±J�]DN![\9`J!;>^ O�ü:;AüWN�TAcÀü:]DN�;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7WNUM�5äOIT>CD7IcdCD=B6B;A[\N!=kü:;>^�CD=B68N7:O�ü:;>=B689<=DS�T>ce;sü:[�TkO�ýB]DN!7:9<JJ�]DN![\9`Opü:7WVI;>68þs;A=QJ�NOF�=DTsþUN!^AJ!T>[\ýDC8ü�;süW9<T>=Q;A^sü:TkTU^<O�;A7:N�=DN!Nw68N6Iü:T�9Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:N�T>ûBOWN!7:þs;süW9<T>=Q;A^A6D;Aü:;�;A=Q6ä[\T868N^<O©üWT>SUN�ü:]DN!7üWT�ýD7:Tsþk9`68N�üW]BN�û�NO�üF�ýD]�V�OW9`J!;A^<^<VÿJ�TU=BO�9`O�üWN!=küqNO�üW9<[±;sü:N�T>ceü:]DN\N!þUT>^<þk9<=DS�J�]DN![\9`J!;>^ÀOpü�;süWN\T>ceü:]DN3;sü:[�TkO�ýB]DN!7:N>M©?�CBJ�];A= ;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<O$Opü�;süWN±û�N�üWüWN7�68N � =DNOqüW]DN�OWýB;AüW9`;A^Ã;>=B6 üWN[�ý�T>7�;A^ � N!^`6DOqT>c��UN!V J�]DN![\9`J!;A^eJ�T>[\ý�T>=DN=kü:Oq9<= 7WN^<;AüW9<T>=æüWTüW]DN9Ü7)OWT>CD7�J�NwOe;>=B6LO�9<=��8O!M8ab]D9`Ob9<=8cdT>7:[±;süW9<T>=�9<O�J!7W9ÜüW9`J!;>^09Ü=�68NOW9<S>=D9<=DS\J�TUO�ü���N��0NJ�üW9<þ>NIN![\9`OWOW9ÜTU=�J!T>=küW7:T>^0Opü:7:;AüWNS>9<NOecdT>79Ü[\ýD7:Tsþ>Nw6 ;A9<7kCB;A^<9ÜüpV>F©cdTU7$ü:]DN�9<=küWN7WýD7:N�ü�;sü:9ÜTU= TAc)T>ûQO�N7Wþs;sü:9ÜTU=B;A^e6D;sü�;@O�CQJ�] ;>O�üW]DTkO�N�T>û8ü�;A9<=DN6 68CB7W9<=DSÿ9<=küWN=BO�9<þ>N� N!^`6�J!;A[\ýB;>9ÜSU=BOF�;>=B6�üWT�üW]BNqN��8NJ!C8üW9<T>=�TAc�;A9<7���kCB;A^<9ÜüpV\cdT>7:NJ!;UOpü:9Ü=BSBM ;A^<[\;>= � ^ÜüWN!7 ü:NJ�]D=D9�kCDNO�� �����kýD7:Tsþ�9<6DNÃ;äO�üWT8J�]B;UOpü:9<Je;AýDýB7WTk;>J�]IüWTäüW]DNb6D;Aü:;I;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=qýD7WTUûD^<N![�Msab]DN � ^ÜüWN7W9<=DS

üW]DNT>7:V±9<Ob68NwOWJ!7W9<ûQNw639<=��k;�����9Ü=QO���9�� �����©;A=B63üW]DNq;>ýDýD^<9<J;AûD9<^Ü9ÜüpV\üWT\;sü:[\TUOWýD]DN!7:9`J�[\T868N!^<9<=DS�9`OZýD7:NOWN!=küWNw639<=�ü:]DN��eTU7��TAcÀHä;>^ÜNV � ��!"�«M�5 ;A^<[±;A= � ^ÜüWN!7ä;AýDýD7:TU;UJ�]#�b;>O)CBO�Nw6�û�V#$4N=B;A7�6�N�üä;>^�M%� ��&��©ü:T�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:Nq[\N�üW]Q;A=DN�TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=BO9Ü=küWT�;�Opü:7:;AüWTkO�ýD]BN!7:9<JÀüW7�;>J�N7�[\T868N^�MAab]DN�J!T>[\ýDC8ü�;süW9<T>=Q;A^�ûDCD7�68N!=�;>O:O�T8J!9<;AüWN6qüWTIüW]DN � ^ÜüWN7W9<=DSIýD7:T�J!NO:O ]B;>O ýD7:N!þUN!=küWNw6üW]DN�9Ü[\ýD^<N![\N=Uü�;sü:9ÜTU=@TAc�ü:]DN$cdCB^Ü^ ;A^<[±;A= � ^ÜüWN7IcdT>7�^`;A7:S>N���O:J!;>^ÜN�ü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�ü���J�]DN[\9<O�üW7:V�[\T868N!^`OM('Ã=BO�N[$ûD^<N ;>^Ü[±;>=� ^�ü:N!7�ü:NJ�]D=D9�kCDNO�)*'Àþ>N=BOWN!=+� ,"����F.-�T>C8ü:N��s;A[\N7 N!üÀ;A^«M�� ,0/1�32©[±;GVqû�N�CBO�Nw6qü:TäcÐ;UJ�9<^Ü9Üü:;AüWNZüW]BNZýB7:;UJ�üW9`J!;>^�9Ü[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü�;süW9<T>=;>O�OW]DT���=�û�V3þs;>=+4�T�T>=LN�ü�;A^«M5� !�&���M6 ;A7:9<;AüW9<T>=B;>^Z[\N!üW]DT86DO )7�>H8� 6 ;A7wF9!UH8� 6 ;>7:2�ýB7WTsþ�9`68N4;A= T>ý8ü:9Ü[±;>^�J�TU=Uü:7WTU^);AýDýB7WTk;>J�] ü:T üW]BN@6D;sü�; ;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=

ýD7WTUûD^<N![�M<;DT>CB7��n689<[�N=BOW9ÜTU=B;A^ þs;A7:9<;AüW9<T>=B;>^=)7!UH8� 6 ;>7:2ä6D;sü�;�;UOWOW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>= ;A^<^ÜT��)O�üW]DN�T>ýDüW9<[\;>^ÀJ�TU[$ûD9<=B;sü:9ÜTU=@TAcÃüW]D7:N!NO�TUCD7:J!NO�T>c�9Ü=8cdTU7W[±;AüW9<T>=5>k;A=3;qýD7:9<T>7:9?)7@>ûB;>J:��S>7:T>CB=B6�@�2�NwOpü:9Ü[±;sü:N)TAc0ü:]DNäO�ü:;AüWN)T>c�ü:]DNä;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7WN�A���=DT���^<N68SUN);Aû�T>C8üüW]DN�ýD]�V�OW9`J!;A^ ;A=B64J�]BN![\9<J;A^ ýD7:T�J!NO:O�NwObüW]Q;süäSUTsþ>N7W=�üW]DN�N!þUT>^<C8üW9<T>=4T>cÀýQTU^Ü^<C8ü:;>=kü � N^<6DOF0;>O�J;Aý8ü:CD7:N6�9<=4üW]DN�[\T�6DN!^)«YZaB$C2�A�;A=B6æT>ûQO�N7Wþs;sü:9ÜTU=BOäTAcZOWT>[\N\TAceüW]DN±O�ü:;AüWN\þs;A7:9<;>ûD^ÜNwO!M�ab]DN\TUý8üW9<[±;A^À;A=Q;A^<V�OW9`OIO�ü:;AüWN�9<O�TUû8ü:;>9Ü=BN6ÿüW]D7:T>CDSU] ;[�9<=D9<[\9D�w;süW9<T>=�ýD7WT8J!NO:O�üWT�ýD7:Tsþk9`68N�ü:]DN�û�NO�ü � üeü:T�ü:]DN�ûB;UJ:��S>7:T>CD=B6�NwOpü:9Ü[±;sü:Nä;>=B6\üWT�;A^<^QTUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=B;>^B6D;Aü:;E)�O�ýQ;>J�N;A=B6 üW9<[\N�6D9<O�üW7:9ÜûBC8üWNw6F2\;Gþs;A9<^<;>ûD^ÜN�9Ü= üW]BN@;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=G��9Ü=Q68T��qMÀab]DN�CBOWN�T>cI;>6�HpT>9<=Uü±[\T868N!^<9<=DS üWT N!þs;A^<CB;sü:NLüW]DNS>7�;>689<N!=kü�T>cÀüW]DN�T>û�HpNJ�ü:9ÜþUN�cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=Q;A^�[±;��>NwO�cdNw;>OW9ÜûD^<N�üW]DN�9Ü[\ýD^<N![\N=Uü�;sü:9ÜTU=ÿTAc�ü:]DNI!UH8� 6 ;>7I6D;Aü:;�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=4cdT>7^<;>7WSUN��nOWJ;A^<N�;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`J�[\T868N!^`OMab]DNeýD7:;UJ�ü:9<J;A^U;>ýDýD^<9<J;AûD9<^<9�üpVITAc�üW]BNJ!UH8� 6 ;A7©üpV�ýD9`J!;>^Ü^<VI7WN1UCB9Ü7:NO©;>=$;>JJ�CD7�;sü:N�[\T�6DN!^7WNýD7WNwO�N=kü:;sü:9ÜTU=±TAc©ü:]DNq;sü:[�TkO�ýB]DN!7:9<Jä68V�=B;A[\9`J!OMLK)=B68N7ZüW]DNIýQN7�cdNwJ�ü�[\T868N!^�;>O:OWCD[\ý8üW9<T>=L;A=B6M��9ÜüW]Lþs;A^<9<6�J�Tsþs;A7:9`;A=BJ!N[\;AüW7:9<J!NOFDü:]DN-�NO:O�9`;A=�TAc�ü:]DN$[\9<=D9<[�9N�!Nw6@J�TkOpü�cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=@N�kCB;>^<O�üW]DN�9Ü=�þ>N7:OWNqTAc�ü:]DN�ü:]DN�J!TsþG;>7W9`;A=QJ�N�[±;süW7:9D�LT>c�üW]DN

Page 2: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<OZN!7:7:T>7wMkab]DN�TUý8üW9<[±;A^<9�üpV3T>c�ü:]DN�!UH8� 6 ;>7b;>=B6�9�ü�Ob7WN^<;AüW9<T>=BOW]D9<ý#��9ÜüW]�üW]DN ;>^Ü[±;>= � ^ÜüWN7�9<OZcdCD7WüW]BN!7)689`OWJ!CBO:O�Nw69Ü= � � � ��M

ab]DNI6D9Ü7:NJ�ü�6DNJ�TUCDýD^<N6�[�N!üW]DT86�]B;>OZû�N!N=�N��kü:N!=BOW9<þ>N!^<V±CBOWN63cdT>7�O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV�Opü:CB689<NOZ9<=�ü:]D7WNNI6D9Ü[\N!=QO�9<T>=B;>^9)7�UH 2;süW[\TkO�ýD]BN!7:9<JbJ�]DN[�9`O�üW7:V�üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7WüÀO�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=BOB� , � F � �>F � ,.��M>Hä9Ü7:NJ�üÃO�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV�;A=Q;A^<V�OW9`O�þk9`;M)�cdTU7��b;A7�6�[\T868N.2�;AC8ü:T��[\;AüW9`J�689D�0N!7:N!=küW9`;sü:9ÜTU=M�Z;UOÃ;A^`OWT�N![\ýD^<TsV>Nw6\9Ü=±ü:]DNäJ!T>=küWN���üÃTAc©ýD]BTAüWT8J�]DN[\9<J;A^Dü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�üÃ[\T868N^<O � � F ,��BF�,����«Mk5�6.HpTU9Ü=küO�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV*9`O�; J!T>[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü:;>7WV*;AýDýB7WTk;>J�] ��]D9<J�] N��3J�9<N!=küW^<V J!;A^`J�CB^<;AüWNO±üW]DN 68N!7:9Üþs;AüW9<þ>NO3TAc�; cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^ ��9ÜüW]7WNwO�ý�NJ�üZü:T3;�^<;>7WSUNä=�CD[�ûQN7)TAc ýB;A7�;A[\N�ü:N!7�O!M

� =�ü:]D9`O�ýB;Aý�N!7B�ZNqýD7:NOWN!=kübüW]DNq[±;AüW]DN[\;AüW9`J!;>^0üW]DNT>7:V3TAc�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�OWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüpV�;>=B;A^<V8O�9`O�;AýDýB^Ü9<N6�üWT�ü:]D7WNN�689<[�N=L�O�9<T>=B;>^�;sü:[\TUOWýD]DN!7:9`J�ü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�ü);A=Q64J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV3[\T868N^<OM� N$689`OWJ!CBO:ObüW]DN�J!T>[\ýDC8ü�;sü:9ÜTU=B;A^�ü:T�T>^`O)68N!þUN!^<T>ý�N6�;A=Q6�CQO�NüW]DN[ üWT ûDCD9<^<6 üW]BN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü�T>cä; J�T>[\ýD7:N!]BN!=BOW9ÜþUN#�UH';A9<7IkCB;>^Ü9ÜüpV [\T�6DN!^«MÀab]D9<O\689`O:J�CBO:O�9<T>= 9Ü=QJ�^<CB68NO�ýB;>7:;>^Ü^<N!^<9N�;��üW9<T>= ;A=B6ÿýQN7�cdTU7W[±;A=QJ�N�TAc �UH ;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü:OM�ab]DN�CBO�N\T>ce;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�O�cdTU7qO�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV@;>=B;A^<V8O�9`O�;A=B6@cdT>7q6D;Aü:;L;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=ýD7WTUûD^<N![±Ob9<Ob9<^<^ÜCBO�üW7�;sü:N6LCBOW9Ü=BS�=�CD[\N7W9`J!;>^©O�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=BOZTAc�;A9<7�ýQTU^Ü^<C8ü:9ÜTU=L9<= 'Ã;UOpü�5�OW9<;BM

ab]DN�ýB;Aý�N!7�9`ObT>7:SU;>=D9D�N63;UOZcdT>^<^ÜT��)OMD?�NJ�üW9<T>= ,�S>9<þ>NOb;>=�TsþUN!7:þk9<N��áT>c�ýD7:N!þ�9<T>CBO=�ZT>7 �±9Ü=4J�]DN[\9<J;A^�6D;sü�;\;>O:O�9<[\9 �^<;AüW9<T>=©M � =ÿ?8NJ�ü:9ÜTU= � �eN$7WNþk9<N�� üW]BN�[±;süW]BN![±;sü:9<J;A^�ü:]DN!TU7WV�TAcÀ;>6.HpTU9Ü=küäOWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpVL;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<O�;>ýDýD^<9ÜNw6LüWT�;>9Ü78kCB;>^Ü9ÜüpV[�T868N^Ü9<=DSQM0?�ý�NJ!9 � J�;>^ÜSUT>7:9�ü:]D[\9<Jq68N!ü:;>9Ü^`O�T>c�üW]DN\;>6�HpT>9<=UüITAce?kü:N![I� ��� J�]DN![\9`J!;A^�üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7Wü�[\T�6DN!^�;A7:N�ýD7:NOWN!=küWNw649Ü=?�NJ�üW9<T>= !BF%��]D9<^ÜN�?�NJ�üW9<T>= � 689`O:J�CBO:O�NwOq9<[�ýB^ÜN[�N=kü:;sü:9ÜTU= ;>OWýQNwJ�ü�O!M K)CD[\N!7:9`J!;A^e7WNwO�CB^�ü�OqcdT>7�üW]DNLO�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU= TAc 'Ã;UOpü5�OW9<;\;A7:NqO�]BT���=�9<=@?�NJ�üW9<T>=��DMQYeT>=QJ�^<CBO�9<T>=QO�;A=B6�cdC8üWCB7WNq7:NOWN;>7:J�]L689Ü7:NJ�üW9<T>=BO�;>7WNIS>9<þ>N=�9<=@?�NJ�üW9<T>=C/�M

� ÿô�����ù�õÃ÷�������������ô�� õÀô

ab]DN49Ü[\ýD^<N![\N=Uü�;sü:9ÜTU=*T>cäü:]DN�cdT>CB7��n689<[�N=BOW9ÜTU=B;A^�þs;A7:9`;süW9<T>=Q;A^ )3!kH � 6 ;A7 2\6D;sü�; ;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU= cdTU73^<;>7WSUN��nOWJ;A^<N�;AüW[\T��O�ýD]BN!7:9<J�[\T868N^<Oe7WN^Ü9<NOÃT>=\ü:]DNä;U6.HpT>9<=küe[\T868N!^<9Ü=BSqüWT�ýD7WTsþ�9`68NbüW]BN�S>7�;>6D9ÜN=UüeTAc�üW]BN�T>û�HpNJ�ü:9ÜþUN�cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^�M0$@;sü:]DN![±;Aü��9<J;A^QcdT>CD=B6B;süW9<T>=QOÀTAc�ü:]DNä;U6.HpT>9<=küZOWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüpV�cdT>7Z=DT>=D^<9<=DN;>7e68V�=B;>[�9`J!;>^QOWV8Opü:N![±OÃ;>7WN)ýB7WNwO�N=Uü:N6\û�V�YZ;>J!CBJ�9 � �BF�!��0;A=B6$@;A7�J�]�C��@N�ü�;A^«MJ� �!�DF�� /1��M?'Ã;>7W^<Vÿ;>ýDýD^<9<J;süW9<T>=QOqTAcZüW]DNE!UH8� 6 ;>7qüWT@J�]DN[\9<J;A^Ã6D;Aü:;4;UOWOW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>= �ZN!7:N�ýB7WNwO�N=Uü:N6 û�V;�9`OW]DN!7�;A=Q64�;A7:V � ,L����cdT>7�;�Opü:7:;AüWTUOWýD]DN7W9`JÀýB]DTAü:T�J�]BN![\9<J;A^�û�T.��[�T868N^L��9�ü:]$ü:7:;�HpNJ�üWT>7:9<NOMw5 OW9Ü[\9<^<;>7 [\T868N^0�b;>O CBOWN6^<;AüWN!7�û�V ]B;Aü�ü�;süWTsþ4N!ü�;A^«M�� ��,���üWTL9Ü[\ýD^<N![\N=Uü�û�TAü:]ÿü:]DNM!UH8� 6 ;A7q;A=B6æ; ;A^<[\;>= � ^ÜüWN7q[\N�üW]BT�6©M©5 ü:7WTUýQTkO�ýB]DN!7:9<JSU;>O���ýD]B;>OWN�û�T.�4[�T868N^�ûB;>OWN6ÿT>=4ü:]DN±J�]DN![\9`J!;A^ [\NJ�]B;>=D9`O�['X)5äH $C,#�b;>OäCBOWN64û�V 'À^<û�N!7:=ÿN�üq;A^«M�� �"��� üWT�;A=B;>^ÜV �!NüW]DN\;AýDýB^Ü9`J!;>ûD9Ü^<9ÜüpVLT>c�üW]DNI!UH8� 6 ;A7�;AýDýD7:TU;UJ�]LüWT3ü:7WTUýQTkO�ýB]DN!7:9<J�J�]DN![\9`J!;>^ 6D;Aü:;3;UOWOW9<[�9<^`;süW9<T>=�M($4N=�C8üIN!üI;>^�M � �"����;A=B66 ;AC8ü�;A7�6�N!ü�;A^«M5� !L/1�©CBOWN�üW]DN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü);AýDýD7:TU;UJ�]3cdTU7)O�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV�Opü:CB689<NO�9<=L;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`J�J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV�[�T868N^Ü9<=DSQM

� =$ü:]DN�ýB;>O�ü�cdN��*V>Nw;A7�O þG;>7W9`;sü:9ÜTU=B;A^�[\N�ü:]DT86DO�]B;GþUNeû�N!N=±O�CBJJ�NwOWO�cdCD^<^ÜV�CBO�Nw6$9<=±6D;sü�;�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=$cdTU7ÀJ�T>[\ýD7:N!]BN!=L�O�9<þ>N�üW]D7:N!N���6D9Ü[\N!=QO�9<T>=B;>^ ;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`J�J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV4[\T868N!^`O )7'Ã^Üû�N!7:= ;>=B6æ?DJ�]D[\9<6�üE�D��!"�«F<'Ã7W7:N!7�;3;A=Q6C;DTU=küWN!V�= � �"���32�Mab]DNB�eTU7��qT>c#� ;A=DSqN!üÀ;A^«MF� � ���DýD7:Tsþ�9<6DNO�;I7WNþk9<N�� TAcQüW]DN);U6.HpT>9<=kü�[\N!üW]DT868TU^ÜTUS>V$;>=B6�6B;sü:;�;UOWOW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=\;AýDýB^Ü9`J!;AüW9<T>=BOüWT3;sü:[\TUOWýD]DN!7:9`JäJ�]DN[\9<O�üW7:V>M

ab]DN 9<=kþUN!7�O�N ýD7:T>ûB^ÜN[ T>c±6B;sü:; ;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU= T>c\üW7:T>ý�TUOWýD]DN!7:9`JæSk;>O4TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=BO@9Ü=küWT ;áJ�T>[\ýD7:N!]BN!=BOW9ÜþUNG���689Ü[\N=BO�9<T>=Q;A^8'ÃCD^ÜN7W9`;A=&YZaB$ 9<O37WNwO�Nw;A7�J�]DN6 ûkV 'À^<ûQN7W= N!üMÃ;>^�MÀ9<= � ��!���MÃab]DN@;>C8üW]DTU7:O\CQO�N�ü:]DNÿ689`OWJ!7WN!üWN�ýB;>7:;>^Ü^<N!^;>6.HpTU9Ü=küäT>c�üW]DNI'ÀCD7:T>ý�N;>=@5)9<7%$�TU^Ü^<C8ü:9ÜTU=@H�9`O�ý�N!7�OW9ÜTU=C$4T868N!^�'JKäX)5�H8��YZaB$C,M��9ÜüW] X)5�H $C,±Sk;>O�ýD]B;>OWN�J�]BN![\9<J;A^[�NwJ�]B;A=B9<OW[�M©5)= T>ý�N!7�;sü:T>7�O�ýD^<9Üü$;AýDýD7:TU;UJ�]©F ��9�ü:]'&ZT>ü�ü�( O�;U68þ>NwJ�üW9<T>= OWJ�]BN![\N±;A=B6*)�?D?85 J�]DN[�9`J!;>^ÀO�TU^ÜþUN!7�9`O�CBO�Nw6�Mab]DN�9<[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü:;AüW9<T>=BO�;UO�ý�NJ�ü:O�;A7:N�689`O:J�CBO:O�Nw649<= �D�./1��M�ab]DNI!UH8� 6 ;>7ä[\N�ü:]DT86@9`O�;A^N�Z;GV8O�;>ûD^<N$ü:T�7:N�ü:7W9<N!þUNqüW]DN±J!T>=L�J�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>=BObT>c TUûBO�N7WþUN6LO�ý�NJ!9ÜNwO!M � ü�9<O�J�T>=QJ�^<CB68N6�ü:]B;sü)ü:]DN�7:N!^`;sü:9ÜþUN�O:J!;>^Ü9<=DS\TAcÀ689D�0N!7:N!=kü�O�ý�NJ!9ÜNwO )3��]B9<J�]@;>[�TUCD=kü:OüWT3;�ýD7:NJ�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=D9<=DS�TAc üW]DNq[\9<=D9<[�9N�;AüW9<T>=�ýD7:T>ûD^<N![ 2e9`Ob9Ü[\ý�T>7Wü:;A=kü�;>=B6�9<[\ýB;>J�ü:Obü:]DN�;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=�O���9Ü^<^`O!M

� = � �1&���'À^<ûQN7W= N!üM�;A^«M O�üWCQ68V üW]DN�O���9<^Ü^b;A=Q6 ^Ü9<[\9�ü�O$T>c !UH8� 6 ;>7�ü:NJ�]D=D9�kCDNO$üWT ;A=B;>^ÜV �N±üW]DNLN![\9`OWOW9<T>= 7�;süWNwO�T>cýD7WNwJ�CD7�OWT>7\J�T>=QOpü:9�ü:CDN!=kü:O\T>cIT��!TU=DN>F���9ÜüW] T>=D^<V T��!T>=BN�TUûBO�N7Wþs;AüW9<T>=BO\;Gþs;A9<^<;>ûD^<N>M�ab]DN!V J�T>=QJ�^<CB68NLüW]B;Aü,+�-/."N![\9<O��O�9<T>=BO$J�T>CB^<6 û�N3O�CBJJ�NwOWO�cdCD^<^ÜV ;A=B;>^ÜV �!Nw6@cdTU7qüW]BN!9<7$Opü:7WN=DSAü:]©F5��]D9<^<N±cdT>7q9<=B689<þ�9<68CQ;A^102-43 N![\9<O:OW9ÜTU=BO�7WNS>CD^`;A7:9N�;sü:9ÜTU=üWNJ�]B=D9NkCDNwO�;A7:N�=DN!Nw68N6�üWT±;UJ!J�TUCD=kübcdT>7B��=DT���=L7:;AüW9<TUOZTAc�9Ü=Q689Üþ�9`68CB;>^©O�ý�NJ!9ÜNwO!M

� [�ýB7WTsþUN![\N!=kü:O\9<= T"�T>=DN4ýD7:N6D9<J�üW9<T>=*üW]D7:T>CBS>]*üW]DNæ;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU= T>c�TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=BO\;>7WN@J!T>=BOW9<6DN!7:N6 ûkV 'À^<û�N!7:=N�üMe;A^«M�9Ü= �D� � ��M ú ûBOWN!7:þs;süW9<T>=QO�T>c�J�]BN![\9<J;A^)J!T>=BO�üW9ÜüWCDN=kü:O �ZN!7:NLCQO�Nw6 cd7:T>[ üW]DN ' $ '5$ 6D;sü�;AûB;UO�NUF�;A=B6*=B;AüW9<T>=B;>^�F7WNS>9<T>=B;>^�FZ;A=B6áCB7WûB;>= OWCD7�cÐ;UJ�N@TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=BO�;>J!7WTkOWO 'ÃCD7:T>ý�N>M $ÿ;A7 �>N6 9<[\ýD7:Tsþ>N![\N=Uü�O�;Ac�üWN!7�üW]BN ;UOWOW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=áT>cT"�!TU=DN�[\N;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü�OZ;>7WN�=DT>üW9`J�Nw6�M

ú üW]DN7ÀüWNwJ�]D=D9�kCDNOZ;Gþs;A9<^<;>ûD^ÜN)cdT>7b6D;sü�;$;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=±]B;GþUN)ûQNN!=LO�CBJJ�NwOWO�cdCD^<^ÜV±;AýBýD^Ü9<N6±üWT\;süW[\TkO�ýD]BN!7:9<J)J�]BN![\9<O�üW7:V[�T868N^<OM ;BT>7äN��D;A[\ýD^<N>FDþs;>=C4©T�T>=�N!üM0;A^«M?� !0&�� CBO�Nw64;A= 'Ã=BO�N[$ûD^<N ;A^<[±;A= ; 9Ü^ÜüWN7I;>ýDýD7:TU;UJ�]�ü:T�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:NqS>7:T>CD=Q6^ÜNþ>N!^�T��!TU=DN�[�Nw;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü:Ob;>=B6L9Ü[\ýD7:Tsþ>NICD=BJ!N!7Wü:;A9<=küW9<NOb9<=LüW]DNqN[�9`O:O�9<T>=L7:;AüWNwObTAc6+7- . F89- . F:0;-43 ;A=B6�34-Ý9Ü='ÀCD7:T>ý�N>M

Page 3: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� �� � � ó�� ��� � óDù�ø ��� õÃò���ù�ö��©ô�� óDùpõÃò/�� =�ü:]D9`O�OWNJ�ü:9ÜTU=4;\7WNþk9<N�� TAc�üW]BNq[\;AüW]DN[±;süW9`J!;>^�;>OWý�NJ�ü�O�TAc�J�]DN[�9`J!;>^�üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7Wü�[�T868N^Ü9<=DS3;>=B6�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<O�9`O)ýB7WNwO�N=Uü:N6�M:&ZTAüW]�ü:]DN�J!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CQO);A=B646D9<O:J�7:N�ü:N$;>6.HpTU9Ü=küä;>ýDýD7:TU;UJ�]DNO�;>7WN�68NwOWJ!7W9<û�N6 )ÐOWN!N�;A^`O�T � ;A=BS3N�ü;A^«M5� � ���32�M

���� ������������� �"!$#&%(')� �*��#��+��!�,�-/. 0213!$-�. ���4��!5�768��09�":�#&.9;� =C��]B;AüäcdTU^Ü^<T��)O8�ZN\68N!=DT>üWN�û�V(<ÿü:]DN ��9Ü=B6 � N!^`6æþ>NJ�üWTU7F>= ü:]DN�üWCD7:ûDCD^<N!=küq689 �0CBOW9Üþ�9ÜüpV�üWN=BO�TU7F@?LüW]BN�;>9Ü7�68N!=QO�9ÜüpV9Ü=(ACB$D&E$F$G$HIA _ F�;A=B6(HKJÀüW]DN$[�TU^ÜN���cd7�;>J�üW9<T>=4J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=LTAcÀJ�]DN[\9<J;A^�OWý�NJ�9<NOML )��ON2LPNQF.2�M�ab]DN$68N=BO�9ÜüpVLTAc�üW]D9`OO�ý�NJ!9ÜNwOb9<OR?OH J ASB$D�E$F5GTHIA�_GMF4©N!ü 0VU+WYXJ ûQN�ü:]DNq68N!ý�TUOW9ÜüW9<T>=�þ>N^ÜT8J�9ÜüpV±TAc�O�ý�NJ!9ÜNwOPL�F/Z J üW]DNq7�;sü:N�TAc OWCD7WcÐ;>J!NIN[\9<O:O�9<T>=QO!F;A=B6\[ J üW]DN\7�;süWN�TAcZN!^<N!þs;sü:N6@N[\9<O:O�9<T>=QO)cdTU7äü:]D9`OIOWý�NJ�9<NOM�ab]DN\7:;AüWN�TAceJ�]DN[\9<J;A^ üW7�;A=BO�cdT>7:[±;sü:9ÜTU=BO^] J 68NýQN=B6DOIT>=;AûBOWT>^<C8üWNqJ!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=�þs;A^<CDNO�A�üW]BNq7:;AüWNq;sü ��]D9`J�]L[�TU^ÜN���cd7�;>J�üW9<T>=�J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOZJ�]B;>=DS>N�9`OZüW]DN=(] J )&?"H�2_G5?�M

YeT>=BOW9<6DN!7\;ÿ68TU[\;>9Ü=a` ��]D9<J�]*J�TsþUN!7�O$;æ7WNS>9<T>= TAc�üW]DN4;sü:[\TUOWýD]DN!7:N>M�4©N!ü�b û�NLüW]DNLT>CDü �Z;>7:6 =DTU7W[±;>^eþUNJ�ü:T>7T>= N;>J�]æýQTU9Ü=kü�T>cÃüW]BN�û�T>CB=B6D;A7:Vdc9`�M©5Zü�N;>J�]ÿüW9<[\N±[�TU[\N!=kü�üW]DN±û�T>CD=Q6D;A7:V4TAceüW]DN368TU[±;A9<=æ9`O�ýB;A7WüW9ÜüW9<T>=BN6@9<=küWTc `fehg^ikjmlSg^npo@q7lSg^r�s ��]DN!7:Ntg^rps 9`Obü:]DNqS>7:T>CD=Q63^<N!þ>N^�ýQTU7�ü:9ÜTU=�T>c�ü:]DNqû�T>CD=B6B;A7:V(A�g^ikj 9<O�üW]DN�OWN�ü�TAcB)d^`;sü:N!7�;A^T>7büWTUý 2Zû�T>CD=B6B;A7:V±ýQTU9Ü=kü:O ��]DN!7:Nu<7v+baN �±;A=Q6mgwnpo@q üW]DN�OWN�üB��]DN7WNt<�v�bQx �DM

ab]DN�N!þ>TU^ÜCDüW9<T>=LTAc�J�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOe9Ü=Lü:9Ü[\Nq9`O)68NO:J�7:9<ûQNw6�û�V3ü:]DNq[±;sü:N!7:9<;>^�ûQ;A^`;A=BJ!NIN1kCB;sü:9ÜTU=BOc@HKJc�y e8zP<�v�{�HKJ>| �? {}v0)~?*=\{�HKJ*2 | �? ]$J�)&?"H�2�|�[MJP��yY�tN�y�N�� ) �w;�2

HKJ�)&yY�����(24eQHI�J )~�(2w� )��!û 2H J )~yI���(24eQH ikjJ )~yI��� 2 cdT>7��d�Sg ikj � ) �wJ�2= c@HKJc�� e � cdT>7��(�Cg npo@q � )��6F2

= c@HKJc�� e 0uU�WYXJ HKJ�z�ZtJ cdT>7��d�Sg rps � cdT>7);>^Ü^ �tN�L3N�F�� ) �N12

�æN)7:N�cdN7�üWT�ü:]DN)O�V8O�üWN[ ) �w;�2�� ) �N12�;UO üW]DN4�K�T�I�4�$���m���$���_�_�+���V ¡���¢�+£|MUa�T�OW9Ü[\ýD^<9�cdV$üW]DN�ýD7WNwO�N=kü:;sü:9ÜTU=©Fs9<=�ü:]D9`OÀýB;>ýQN7 �eNJ�T>=QO�9`68N!7Z;>OeýB;A7�;A[\N!üWN!7�O�ü:]DNI9Ü=D9ÜüW9`;A^0O�ü:;sü:NwH � TAc�üW]DNI[\T�6DN!^ AU9ÜüZ9`O �k=BT���=±üW]B;Aüeü:]D9`OZ6DTkNwOÃ=BTAüe7:NO�üW7:9`J�üÃü:]DNIS>N!=BN!7�;A^<9�üpVTAcZüW]DN\cdTU7W[�CD^<;AüW9<T>=©M©ab]BN3O�TU^ÜC8ü:9ÜTU= TAcZüW]DN\cdTU7��b;A7�6@[\T868N!^3H¡e¤H�)~yI�_H � 2I9`OqCD=D9�kCDN!^<Væ6DN�üWN7W[\9<=DN6 TU=BJ�N\ü:]DN±[\T�6DN!^ýB;A7�;A[\N�ü:N!7�ORH � ;A7:NIOWý�NJ�9 � Nw6�M

ab]DN±689Ü7:NJ�üq[�T868N^ ) �w;�2¥�<) �N12ä9<OqOWT>^<þ>Nw6@û�Vÿ;�OWN�kCDN!=QJ�N�TAc1+ ü:9Ü[\NO�üWNýBO�TAcZ^ÜN=DSAü:]�¦Oy�ü:;"�>N!= û�N�ü �ZN!N!=§y � ;A=B6y�¨ae2�$M>5ZüÃN;UJ�]�üW9<[�NIOpü:N!ý±TU=DN�J!;>^<J!CD^`;süWNwO�üW]BN)=�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^B;>ýDýD7:T.��9<[±;sü:9ÜTU=�H+©�)~�(23ªhH�)&y�©*��� 2À;Aü4y�©wehy � |(«�¦)y�O�CBJ�]üW]B;Aü

H ©I¬�E e�­¯® °&±$² °&±�³*´¥µ*¶�H © ��H ¨ e ¨^·�E¸©K¹ �

­¯® °&±�² °&±�³"´�µ*¶�HI��� ) ,"2

ab]DN)=�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^BOWT>^<C8ü:9ÜTU=�TUýQN7:;AüWTU7�­ 9<OÃûB;>OWN6\TU=3;A=\T>ý�N!7�;sü:T>7ÃOWýD^<9�üWüW9<=DS$;AýBýD7WTk;>J�]©F���]BN!7:N�üW]DN)üW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�üÃO�üWNýBO;A^<T>=DS±Nw;>J�]4689<7WNwJ�üW9<T>=@;>=B6�üW]DN�J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WVLOpü:N!ýBOä;A7:N�ü:;"�>N!=@OWCBJJ�NO:OW9ÜþUN!^<V>M ú ý�N!7�;süWTU7�OWýD^Ü9Üü�ü:9Ü=BS39<OäOpü�;A=B6B;A7�6�ýB7:;UJ�üW9`J�N9Ü=@J!T>[\ýDC8ü�;süW9<T>=Q;A^�;>9Ü7�ýQTU^Ü^<C8üW9<T>=4[\T868N^Ü9<=DSC� ,�!"�«M � ü�;A^<^ÜT��)O�üW]DN$6DN!þ>N^ÜTUýD[\N!=kü)TAc�ü:]DN�cdTU7��b;A7�6�F�ü:;>=DS>N=kü�^Ü9<=DNw;A7wFB;A=B6;>6.HpTU9Ü=küÀ[\T868N!^`O ��9ÜüW]±7:N!^`;süW9<þ>NbNw;>OWN>M";BT>7:[\;>^Ü^<V>F>9�c �eN)6DN!=DT>üWN)û�V)º ü:]DN)=�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^BOWT>^<C8ü:9ÜTU=�TUýQN7:;AüWTU7�cdTU7Ã689<7WNwJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^üW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�üwFD;A=B6�û�V�»ÿü:]DN�OWT>^<C8üW9<T>=LT>ý�N!7�;sü:T>7ZcdT>7)J�]DN[\9<O�üW7:V �ZNI]Q;Gþ>N

­ ® °�² ° ¬ ¼ °kµ e2º ¼ °&½ P. ¶�º ¼ °&½ P¾ ¶3º ¼ °&½ P¿ ¶4» ¼ ° ¶�º ¼ °&½ P¿ ¶�º ¼ °&½ P¾ ¶�º ¼ °&½ P. � )*��2

ab]DNä=�CD[\N7W9`J!;>^QN7W7:T>7�OÀ9<=küW7:T�6DCBJ�Nw63û�V3O�ýB^Ü9Üü�ü:9Ü=DS\;A7:Nä;>=�9<[\ýQTU7�ü�;A=kübJ!T>[\ý�T>=DN=UübTAc�[�T868N^0N!7:7WTU7:O )ÐOWN!NIN>M SBM<F(� !!��� 2�M � =üW]D9`O�ýB;>ýQN7FkcdT>7bü:]DNqýDCD7:ý�TUOWNIT>c%!kH � 6 ;A7�6D;Aü:;\;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=©F �eNq;UOWOWCD[\N�ü:]DNq[\T868N!^©N7W7:T>7�OÃüWT\ûQNqOW[±;A^<^�M � =B6DN!N6©FD9Ü=J�T>[\ýDCDü:;sü:9ÜTU=B;A^À;>9Ü7�ý�T>^<^ÜCDüW9<T>= [�T868N^Ü9<=DSLüW]BN3O�ýD^<9Üü�üW9<=DS�N!7:7:T>7�O�TkOWJ!9Ü^<^<;AüWN ��9ÜüW]æüW]DN3689<CD7:=B;A^ÀJ!V8J�^<N\;>=B6 68T�=DTAüqS>7:T��CD=�ûQTUCD=B68Nw68^ÜV�cdT>7�Nþ>T>^<þ�9Ü=BS$ü:9Ü[\N � ,�!���M

5)=$9<= � =B9�ü:NOW9Ü[±;A^8ý�N!7WüWCB7WûB;AüW9<T>=�À$H � 9<=�üW]DNZýB;A7�;A[\N!üWN!7�O%��9Ü^<^�7WNwO�CD^Üü�9Ü=�ýQN7�ü:CD7:ûB;sü:9ÜTU=BO À$H J )&y�2�T>cDüW]BNbJ!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=� N!^`6DOMAab]DNOWNbýQN7�ü:CD7WûQ;süW9<T>=QO ;>7WNbOWT>^<C8üW9<T>=BO T>cBüW]BNt���TÁ"Â"�KÁ���£Ã��Á@�_�T�P ¡���¢�+£s;>O�689`OWJ!CBO:O�Nw6$9<=�5�ýDý�N!=B689D��5$M � =�üW]DN�689<7WNwJ�üO�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV3;>=B;A^<V8O�9`OZ;AýDýD7:TU;UJ�]±T>=DN�OWT>^<þ>NOÃüW]BNä[\T868N!^ )��;�2�� )��!N12ÀüWTUS>N!üW]DN7 ��9ÜüW]�üW]DNäü:;>=DS>N=küZ^<9Ü=BN;A7Z[\T868N!^0cdTU7��b;A7�69Ü=LüW9<[\N � � ����M

Page 4: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

���� ')�>.@��#�.�� ��� ���m0����>#&.@�����".9��#~��#�#~� ,��m. -�:&,���#��YeT>=BOW9<6DN!7);\OWJ;A^`;A7b7:NOWýQTU=BO�NäcdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^�68N � =DN6L9<=LüWN!7:[±ObTAc üW]DNq[\T868N^©O�TU^ÜC8ü:9ÜTU=(H�)~y�2

� )�H � 24e ���°�� ��������H�)~yI���(2����¢���¢yw� )7!02

ab]DN�7:NOWý�T>=BOWN�68NýQN=B6DO\9<[\ýD^Ü9`J�9ÜüW^<V TU= üW]BNLýQ;A7�;A[\N�ü:N!7�OOH � þ�9<;ÿüW]DN468NýQN=B68N=BJ�NLTAcuH�)~y�2$T>= H � M�ab]DN�J�TU=küW9<=kCBT>CBO;>6.HpTU9Ü=küÃ[\T868N!^Q9<OZ68N � =DN6±;UO�ü:]DN�;>6�HpT>9<=UüeTAc0üW]DN�ü:;>=DS>N=Uüe^Ü9<=DN;>7À[\T868N!^0;>O�N��8ýD^<;>9Ü=BN6\9<=�5)ýDý�N!=Q689 �35$M!&ZV�9<[\ýQTkO�9<=DSüW]DN 4�;AS>7�;A=BS>NI9<68N=küW9ÜüpV�;A=Q6L;Ac�üWN7);±J!;A7:N�cdCB^�9Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:9ÜTU=�û�V3ýB;>7�ü�O �D���DF�� ���©TU=DNq;A7:7W9<þ>NwOb;sü�üW]BN�cdT>^<^ÜT���9<=DS\N�kCB;AüW9<T>=BOüW]B;Aü)S>Tsþ>N7W=3üW]DNqNþ>T>^<C8ü:9ÜTU=�T>c�ü:]DN�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�þs;A7:9<;>ûD^<NO�>

c���Jc>y e}zM{8v")&<���J 2�z {8v�� ?*=\{ ��J?! z �#" � )~?*H�2�� � J z%$�J ��� & y'& yY� ) � ;�2��J )~� ���(24e(�*)J )&�(2u� ) � û 2��J )~yI��� 23e � cdT>7��¯�Cg ikj � ) � J�2� J <�|�?"= c�)#� J G$? 2

c>� e � cdT>7��¯�Cg n�o>q � ) � 6F2

?"= c�)#��J�G$? 2c>� e 0tU+WYXJ � J cdTU7��(�(g rps � cdTU7);A^<^ �uN L4N�F�� ) � N12

��]DN!7:N $ J )&yI��� 24e c+�<)&H E �+�+���+�_H-,�2c>H+J )&yI���(2t�.� )J )&�(24e �S� ) ��2

;A=B6���J�)&yI��� 2$;>7WN\ü:]DN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü$þs;A7:9<;>ûD^ÜNwO�;>O:OWT�J!9<;AüWNw6 ��9ÜüW] üW]DNLJ�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOVH+J�)~yI���(2�F=�dN L�N¤FUM � = ü:]DN�;Aû�Tsþ>N" e cp]�GTc>H�9<OäüW]BN �k;>J!T>ûD9`;A=ÿTAcÀü:]DN±J�]DN![\9`J!;A^�7�;sü:N$cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=�] M�5ÝüpVkýB9<J;A^�O�ýQ;A7�O�9ÜüpV4Opü:7WCBJ�üWCD7:N�cdT>7IüW]DNM�k;>J!T>ûD9`;A=BOTAce;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`J�J�]BN![\9<O�üW7:V49`OIOW]DT���=æ9Ü= ; 9ÜSUCD7WN#�>M�5 68N�ü�;A9<^ÜNw6æ6D9<O:J�CBO:OW9ÜTU=ÿTAcÃüW]DN±J�]DN[�9`J!;>^ üWN!7:[±OI9Ü=æüW]DN±J!T>=küWN��küTAcÃ;>6�HpT>9<=UüI[\T�6DN!^<9Ü=DSLJ!;>=@ûQN$cdT>CD=Q6@9<= � �BF�! ,.��MQa�T�T>ûDü:;A9<=�üW]BN�SU7WTUCD=B6�û�T>CD=B6B;A7:VLJ!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>=C�eN�CBO�N$üW]DN�cÐ;>J�ü�ü:]B;sü<¯vT�ae �ÿ;Aü$S>7:T>CD=Q6 ^ÜNþ>N!^«M � N�7:N�cdN7�ü:T ) � ;�2�� ) � N12q;UOqü:]DN���� �$Á�����Á+//�0/21��d�¢�43+�T��Á/�517681I�Y�K /TAc�ü:]DN3ü�;A=DSUN!=kü$^<9Ü=DNw;A7[�T868N^�M0ab]DN�;>6.HpTU9Ü=küäþs;>7W9`;AûD^<NO9�?)&yI��� 2�;>7WN$;>^<OWT�J;A^<^ÜNw6���Á;:<//�+Á>� ���=/ Á>�+���&�TÁ>1 � ����;>=B647:N!ýD7:NOWN!=kü)ü:]DN�OWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�ü:9ÜNwO�T>cüW]DNq7:NOWýQTU=BOWNäcdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^0ü:T±ýQN7�ü:CD7WûQ;süW9<T>=QOb9Ü=�üW]DN�O�ü:;AüWNqþs;A7:9`;AûD^<NORH�)&yI���(2

�/J )~yI���(24e c �c@H J )&yI��� 2 � ) /�2

� =&üW]BNæJ�TU=küWN���üLTAc$TUý8üW9<[±;A^�J�T>=kü:7WTU^8��]DN7WNÿüW]DNæ[�9<=D9<[\9D�w;süW9<T>= TAcqü:]DNÿcdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^ )3! 239`O�7:N�kCD9<7:N6�FeüW]DN ;>6.HpTU9Ü=küþG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwO3[±;GV ûQN ;A^`OWT 9Ü=kü:N!7:ýD7WN!üWNw6&;>O�4�;>S>7�;A=DSUN@[$CD^ÜüW9<ýD^<9ÜN7:O�û�Vá9Ü[\ý�TUOW9Ü=BS üW]BNÿcdTU7��b;A7�6 [\T�6DN!^�N�kCB;AüW9<T>=BOL;>OOpü:7WTU=DS�J!T>=BO�üW7�;A9<=kü:O )�O�NN�5�ýDý�N!=B689D�45 2�M

ab]DNI;U6.HpT>9<=kü)O�V8O�üWN![ ) � ;02¥�<) � N.2Ã6DN!ý�N!=B6DObTU=�ü:]DNqOpü�;sü:NäT>c�üW]BNäcdTU7��b;A7�63[\T868N^9)d9«M NUM8T>=3ü:]DN�J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>= � N!^`6DOH�)~yI���(2�2�üW]D7:T>CDSU]ÿü:]DN±=DTU=D^Ü9<=DNw;A7�J�]DN[�9`J!;>^�üWN7W[ " )~?*H�2�;A=B6 ý�TUO:O�9<ûD^<V4üW]B7WTUCDS>] üW]BN\cdT>7�J�9<=DSLüWN!7:[?$ cdT>7q=DTU=D^<9Ü=DNw;A7cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^`OMDK)TAü:NIüW]B;AüZü:]DN�;>6�HpT>9<=Uüb9<=D9�ü:9<;>^�J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=�9<Obý�TUOWN6L;sübüW]BN � =B;A^0ü:9Ü[\Nu� OWCBJ�]�üW]B;AüZü:]DN�cdT>7 �b;A7�6±[\T�6DN!^[$CBO�ü�û�N � 7:O�ü�OWT>^<þ>N6IcdTU7��b;A7�6�9<=qüW9<[\N>FwüW]DNZOpü�;sü:N3H�)&����y�2�O:;Gþ>N6äcdTU7 ;>^Ü^"y�F!ü:]DN!=�üW]DNb;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü [�T868N^kJ!T>CD^`6qû�NÃ9<=küWN!SU7:;AüWNw6ûB;>J:� �b;A7�6DOÃ9<=LüW9<[\N�cd7WTU[ � 6DT���=�ü:T�y � M

� =@ýD7�;>J�ü:9<J!N�;�]kV�ûD7:9`6@;AýDýB7WTk;>J�]�9<OäCBOWN6�M�ab]DN$cdT>7 �Z;>7:6�[\T868N^�9`O�O�TU^ÜþUN6�CBOW9Ü=BS�;3=�CD[\N7W9`J!;>^�[\N�ü:]DT86�F�;A=B64üW]DN=kCB[�N7W9`J!;>^�;AýDýD7:T.�89Ü[±;AüW9<T>=@T>cÀüW]DN±O�ü:;AüWN\9<O�O:;Gþ>Nw6@ý�N!7:9ÜT8689`J!;>^Ü^<V>M�ab]DNwO�N\J�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=kü:O�;A7:N$CBOWN6æ9<=ÿü:]DN±68N � =B9�ü:9ÜTU=æT>cüW]DNq;>6�HpT>9<=UübN�kCB;AüW9<T>=BOM8ab]DNqJ�TU=Uü:9Ü=�CDTUCBOZ;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�N�kCB;AüW9<T>= ) � ;02¥� ) � N.2À9`Ob;�J!T>=�þ>NwJ�üW9<T>=���689D�0CBO�9<T>=��«7:N;UJ�üW9<T>=±N1kCB;sü:9ÜTU=)3��9ÜüW]�^Ü9<=DNw;A7:9D�N6�J�]BN![\9<O�üW7:V�2Ã;>=B6LJ!;A=�ûQN�OWT>^<þ>Nw63û�V3;A=�V±=�CD[\N!7:9`J!;A^0[\N�ü:]DT86LTAc J�]BT>9`J�N>M � =LýB;A7WüW9`J�CB^<;>7Z;>=�TUýQN7:;AüWT>7O�ýD^<9Üü�üW9<=DS3;>ýDýD7:TU;>J�]LJ�TUCD^<6�û�NqN![\ýD^<TsV>N6�CBOW9Ü=BS�ü:]DN�O:;A[\N�=kCB[�N7W9`J!;>^�[\N�üW]BT�6BO);>OZcdTU7)O�TU^Üþ�9<=DS$ü:]DN�689<7WNwJ�ü)[\T868N!^

� © e�­¯® ° ±�³*´ ² ° ± µ*¶@� ©K¬�E �.�/�we ¨^·�E¸©I¹ �

­¯® °A�B ± ² °A�B ± B ´ µ*¶@� ¨ � )*&�2

;DT>7�6D9 �0N!7:N!=kü$J�TkOpüqcdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^`OIüW]DN3cdT>7�J�9<=DSC$ J ;A=B6æüW]BN±9Ü=D9ÜüW9`;A^eþs;A^<CDNOD� )J ;A7:N\J�]BTUOWN!= O�CBJ�] ü:]B;süqü:]DN3;>6.HpTU9Ü=küþG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwO�;A7:N�üW]DN$OWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�ü:9ÜNwO�TAc�üW]BN$J�TkOpü�cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=Q;A^ ) /�2�M��æN$=DT�� 6D9<O:J�CBO:O)OWT>[\NqN��D;>[�ýB^ÜNwO�7WN^ÜNþs;A=kü)9Ü=@;>ýDýD^<9<J;��üW9<T>=BOM

Page 5: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� È

��� �$ ��>£������ � =L[±;A=�V\ýD7�;>J�ü:9<J;A^�OW9�ü:CB;sü:9ÜTU=BOeüW]DN�J�TkOpüZcdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^�9<OZ=DT>üb9<=küWNS>7�;A^�9Ü=�üW9<[�NUF8ûDC8ü�9`ObN!þs;A^<CB;sü:N6�;sü�;�OWN�üTAc�689<O:J�7:N�ü:NIüW9<[�Nq[\TU[�N=kü:O�y�©�� �� © ¨ F���]D9`J�]�CBOWCB;A^<^ÜV�J�T>=kü�;A9<=�ü:]DNqN!=B6DýQTU9Ü=kü:ORy � ;>=B6Sy�¨ae��$M

� )&HK�124e ¨�©I¹ �

� � � © � H�)&y © ��� 2 � ��� ) ��2

ab]DNqcdT>7�J�9<=DS�cÐ;>J�üWTU7 $>J�9Ü=�ü:]DN$;U6.HpT>9<=kü ��9Ü^<^�J!T>=kü:;>9Ü=468N^�ü�;�cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=BO�;Aü)[\N;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü�ü:9Ü[\NOMÀK° · ° ± MB5)=4N1UCB9Üþs;A^<N!=kücdT>7:[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=�9`OZüWT3689<þ�9<6DNäü:]DNq9<=Uü:N!SU7:;AüW9<T>=L9Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^�9Ü=küWT±OWCDûD9<=küWN!7:þs;A^`O� © e��Ãy © ��y ©I¬�E � � ) �1��2

ú =�Nw;>J�]�O�CDûB9Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^ � ©$üW]DNqûB;UJ:� �Z;>7:6�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�9Ü=kü:N!S>7�;sü:9ÜTU=�9`O)J!;>7W7:9<N63TUC8ü�CBOW9Ü=DS$>J e �S�.�/J )~y ©K¬�E z������(2 e ��J�)&y ©I¬�E |������(2 | c+� ©I¬�E )&H E �+���+�K�_H , 2c>H J )~y ©I¬�E ��� 2w����� �S� ) ���12

� =ÿTAü:]DN!7��ZT>7�6DO�üW]DN\9<=D9�ü:9<;>^�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�þG;>^ÜCBN�9<=æTU=DN�9Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^ 9`OIT>û8ü�;A9<=DN6@cd7WTU["üW]DN � =B;>^À;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�þs;A^<CDN�9<=@ü:]DN\=DN���üüW9<[�N�9<=küWN7Wþs;A^«FsýD^<CBOÀ; HpCD[\ý\S>9<þ>N=�û�Vqü:]DN)68N!7:9<þG;AüW9<þ>NbTAcQüW]DN�TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=�cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=©M";BT>7�ü:]DN � =B;>^89Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^/«¡e + z#��eN�CBOWN�üW]DN�J!T>=�þ>N=küW9<T>=3ü:]B;sü ��J )~y ) |������(2 e �DM��� �$ ��>£������ � c�üW]DN�cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^Q9`Oe6DN � =DNw6±CBOW9Ü=BS�T>=D^<V±O�TU^ÜCDüW9<T>=±þs;A^<CDNOe;sübO�N^ÜNwJ�üWNw6±ý�T>9<=Uü�O����� � 9<=±üW]DNI68T>[±;>9Ü= )dcdT>7N��D;A[\ýD^<Nq;sü)[\N;UO�CD7:N![\N=Uü�OW9�ü:NO:2 � )&HK�124e � �°�� � � � H�)~yI��� � 2 � ��y ) �.,"2

üW]DN= $>J:)~yI���(24e � c+� )&H E ���+�+�+��H , 2c@H J )~yI��� � 2�À�! · !#"$ �.�+)J )~� 24e �C� ) �1��2

��k %S#&��%T!$�"���d� 02���>#&.@�����*. ��#~��#��#~� ,��m. -/:~,���#&�� =�ü:]D9`OÃ;AýBýD7WTk;>J�]$üW]DN)=�CD[\N7W9`J!;>^D689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;sü:9ÜTU=�) ,"2�T>cQü:]DN ) �w;�2¥�<) �N12 9`OÀJ�TU=BO�9`68N7WNw6�ü:TqûQN�ü:]DNbcdT>7 �b;A7�6$[\T868N!^«M>ab]D9`O9<OZ;�ýD7�;ASU[±;süW9`Jbþ�9ÜN��qFk;UOÃTU=D^<V$ü:]DNä=�CD[\N7W9`J!;>^B[\T868N!^�9<Oe9<=±cÐ;>J�üb;Gþs;A9<^`;AûD^<NbcdT>7b;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<OM�;BT>7eûD7WNþ�9�üpV�üW]DN�O�ü:;sü:N�T>c�üW]DN689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�N6L[\T868N!^%��9Ü^<^©û�N$68N!=BTAüWNw6(H+©J � &"�«F���]BN!7:NtLÃ9`O�üW]BN$O�ý�NJ!9ÜNwO�9<=B68N���F�&±9`O�üW]BN�O�ýB;UJ�N�689`O:J�7:N�üW9N�;AüW9<T>=�9<=B68N���;A=B6«�üW]BN�ü:9Ü[\N±689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;AüW9<T>=ÿ9<=B68N���M@H�©L� &"�9��9<^Ü^�7:N�cdN7äü:TLüW]DN�þ>NwJ�üWTU7�TAce;>^Ü^�OWýQNwJ�9<NO�;sü�üW9<[\N\^ÜNþ>N!^ «ÿ;A=B6ÿS>7:9<6ÿ^ÜNþ>N!^'&QMab]DN�J�TkOpübcdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^©9`O�68N � =BN6L9Ü=Lü:N!7:[\ObT>c�ü:]DN�689`OWJ!7WN!üWN�[\T868N!^�O�ü:;AüWN

� )&H � 2 e ¨�©I¹ �

� � � H © � &"� � ) ��!02

;A=B6 TU=DN �Z;>=kü:O\ü:]DNÿ68N7W9<þs;süW9<þ>NwO\TAc�üW]B9<O3cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^ ��9�ü:]á7WNwO�ý�NJ�ü±üWT ü:]DNÿ689`O:J�7:N�üWN4[\T868N^�ýB;>7:;>[�N!üWN7:O�H �J � &"��Me5ýQN7�ü:CD7WûQ;süW9<T>=CÀ$H � 9<=LüW]DNqýB;>7:;>[\N�üWN7:ORH � ýB7WTUýB;ASk;süWNwOÃ9<=LüW9<[\N�;>J!J!T>7�689<=DS$ü:T�üW]DN�ü�;A=DSUN!=kü�^Ü9<=DN;>7)689`OWJ!7WN!üWN�N�kCB;AüW9<T>=

À$H ©I¬�E e�­)(~® °&±$² °&±�³*´¥µ*¶�À$H © ��À$H ¨ e ¨^·�E¸J ¹ �

­)(~® °&±5² °&±�³"´�µ*¶�À$HI��� ) � � 2

��]DN!7:NM­ ( 9<O)üW]DN$ü:;A=BS>N!=kü�^<9<=DN;>7)T>ý�N!7�;sü:T>7�;UOWOWT8J�9`;süWNw6���9�ü:]4üW]DN�O�TU^ÜC8ü:9ÜTU=4T>ý�N!7�;sü:T>74­ M(;DT>7I;A=4TUýQN7:;AüWT>7äO�ýD^<9Üü�üW9<=DS;AýDýD7:TU;UJ�] )*��29­ ( 9`ObûDCD9<^�ü�cd7WTU[ üW]DN�ü�;A=DSUN!=kü�^Ü9<=DNw;A7büW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7Wüb;>=B6�J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV�T>ý�N!7�;süWTU7:O

­)( ® °�² ° ¬�¼ °kµ eQº*( ¼ °&½ P. ¶3º+( ¼ °&½ P¾ ¶�º+( ¼ °&½ P¿ ¶4»,( ¼ ° ¶�º*( ¼ °&½ P¿ ¶�º*( ¼ °&½ P¾ ¶�º*( ¼ °&½ P. � ) �"��2

a�T�N;>J�]\ü�;A=DSUN!=küÃ^<9Ü=BN;A7eT>ý�N!7�;sü:T>7ÃJ!T>7:7WNwO�ý�T>=B6BOÀ;A=�;U6.HpT>9<=küÃT>ý�N!7�;sü:T>78)�68N!=BTAüWNw6±]DN7WN ��9�ü:]�;�O�ü:;A7ZO�CBýQN7:O:J�7:9ÜýDü:2�M�ab]DN;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�N�kCB;AüW9<T>=LTAcB) ���02e9<O

­)( � ® ° ¬ ¼ °�² °kµ ehº+( � ¼ °&½ P. ¶�º+( � ¼ °&½ P¾ ¶�º+( � ¼ °&½ P¿ ¶4»,( � ¼ ° ¶�º+( � ¼ °&½ P¿ ¶�º*( � ¼ °&½ P¾ ¶�º*( � ¼ °&½ P. � ) ��/�2

Page 6: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

O�CBJ�]�üW]Q;sü�üW]BNq7WNwO�CD^ÜüW9<=DS ���$� 1+�+���K�Y���m�¢�43+�T��Á/�R ������K£�9`O� © e�­)( � ® °&±�³*´_² °&±_µ ¶@� ©I¬ E | $ © � «�e + z �¢� + z , ���+������A.� ¨ � &"�@e �*)B)&� 2w� ) �1&�2

ab]DNqcdT>7�J�9<=DS\cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>= $ÿ;>=B6LüW]DN�9Ü=B9�ü:9<;>^�þs;A^<CDNO9�/¨Ý;A7:N�J�]DTUOWN!=4OWCBJ�]�üW]Q;sü)ü:]DN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü)þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwO);A7:N�O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüW9<NOTAc üW]DN�cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=Q;A^<��9ÜüW]�7WNwO�ý�NJ�ü�üWT�üW]BN�Opü�;süWNqþs;>7W9`;AûD^<NO

� ©J � &���e c � )�H � 2c@H ©J � &�� � ) �"��2

��� �$ ��>£������8;DTU7büW]DN�cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=Q;A^J)���!02

$ ©J � &��pe c+�c@HKJ � H © � &"� � �.� ¨J � &��pe c+�

c@HKJ � H ¨ � &�� � � )*,"��2

��� �$ ��>£���� � ;DT>7�6D;sü�;4;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU= ;>ýDýD^<9<J;sü:9ÜTU=BO!F�^ÜN!ü$CBO$;UOWOWCD[\N\üW]BN�;Gþs;A9<^<;>ûD9Ü^<9ÜüpVÿTAcbT>ûQO�N7Wþs;sü:9ÜTU=BOVH+© ² ����� T>cbüW]DNOpü�;süWN�þs;>7W9`;AûD^<NO�H+©8M>ab]DN)J�TkOpü�cdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^D[\Nw;>OWCD7WNwO üW]DN)6D9<O�ü:;>=BJ�N�û�N�ü �ZN!N=�[\T868N!^QT>C8ü:ýDC8üÃ;>=B6�T>ûBOWN!7:þs;süW9<T>=QO!Fs;>O��ZN!^<^;>OZüW]BN�68N!þ�9`;süW9<T>=LTAc üW]BN�O�TU^ÜC8ü:9ÜTU=�cd7:T>[ üW]DNqûB;UJ:��S>7:T>CD=B6�Opü�;sü:N>M

� )�HI�123e �, � HI�Pz H � � �� ·©E � HI�Pz§H � �| �,

¨�©I¹�E

� H © z§H © ² ����� � �� ·©E© � H © z§H © ² ����� � � )*,��12

� = üW]DNL;Aû�Tsþ>N±ü:]DN�J!Tsþs;A7:9<;>=BJ�N±[±;sü:7W9D� ·©E±;UJ!J�TUCD=kü:O�cdT>7$TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>= ;A=Q6 7WNýD7:NOWN!=kü:;AüW9<þ>N!=BNO:OqN!7:7WTU7:OM�H � 9`O$üW]DNûB;>J:��S>7:T>CB=B64J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>= )düW]DN�9<=D9�ü:9<;>^�S>CDNwOWOI9<=@üW]BN�;UOWOW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=@ýB7WT8J�Nw68CD7:N12�;A=B6 � ü:]DN±J�Tsþs;A7:9<;>=BJ�N$[\;AüW7:9 �4T>cüW]DNLNO�üW9<[±;süWNw6 ûB;UJ:�kSU7WTUCD=B6 N7W7:T>7wM�ab]DNLJ�Tsþs;A7:9<;>=BJ�N�[\;AüW7:9<J!NO�;>J!J!T>CD=kü�cdT>7$N7W7:T>7�J�TU7W7:N!^`;sü:9ÜTU=BOqû�N�ü �ZN!N!= 689 �0N!7:N!=küO�ý�NJ!9ÜNwO�;>O��ZN!^<^�;>O�689D�0N!7:N!=kü�^ÜT8J!;AüW9<T>=BOMDab]DN�689`O:J�7:N�üWNq;U6.HpT>9<=küb[\T868N^J) �1&�2e9<O�üW]DN=�J!T>[\ýD^<N�ü:N!^<V�O�ý�NJ!9 � N6���9�ü:]

$ © e ·�E© � H © z§H © ² ����� � cdTU7f«�& ���.� ¨ e ·�E¨ � H ¨ z H ¨ ² ��� � � � c � )&H � 2c@H � e(�/��| � ·�E � HI�Mz§H � � � )*,�,"2

ab]DNq^<;UOpü�7:N!^`;sü:9ÜTU=�7:N��BNwJ�ü�OZüW]DNq9<=��BCDN=BJ�NqT>c�ü:]DNqûB;>J:��SU7WTUCD=B6±ü:N!7:[ T>=Lü:]DNqS>7�;>689<N!=küwM

���� ')�>�����*.@���ab]DNL6D9Ü7:NJ�ü�68NwJ�T>CBýD^ÜNw6 [\N�ü:]DT86 ]B;UO$û�N!N= N���ü:N!=BOW9ÜþUN!^<V CBO�Nw6 cdT>7\OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV Opü:CB689<NO�9Ü= üW]D7:N!N�689<[�N=BOW9ÜTU=B;A^�)7�UH 2;süW[\TkO�ýD]BN!7:9<JÀJ�]BN![\9<O�üW7:VIüW7�;A=BOWý�T>7Wü OW9Ü[�CD^<;AüW9<T>=BO � �.,8F��1�DF�, � F � �>F � ,.��MwHä9<7WNwJ�ü OWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV�;>=B;A^<V8O�9`O©þ�9`; )�cdTU7��b;A7�6�[\T868N12;AC8ü:T>[±;sü:9<J\689D��N7WN=küW9`;süW9<T>= ]B;UOq;A^`O�TLûQNN!= N![\ýD^<TsV>Nw6@9<= üW]DN3J!T>=küWN��küqT>ceýD]DT>üWT8J�]DN[�9`J!;>^�üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7WüI[\T868N!^`OM� � F , �DF,�����MÀab]DNÿ6D9Ü7:NJ�ü�68NJ!T>CDýD^<N6*[\N�ü:]DT86 �eTU7��8OI�ZN!^<^�cdT>7�; OW[±;A^<^)=�CD[$û�N!7�TAc�ýB;A7�;A[\N�ü:N!7�O!M�ab]DNæ;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü±[\N�üW]BT�6 9`O; J!T>[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü�;A7:V ;AýDýB7WTk;>J�]©F���]D9`J�] �ZT>7 �8O�N��3J�9<N!=küW^<V cdTU73; O�[±;A^<^)=�CD[�ûQN7±TAcIü:;A7:S>N!ü\cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=BO )ÐN>M SBMÀ; OW9Ü=DSU^ÜNcdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^ 2q;>=B6 ;�^<;>7WSUN±=�CD[$û�N!7�T>c�ýB;A7�;A[\N�ü:N!7�OM)dNUM SQM©üW]BN�689`OWJ!7WN!üWN±9<=D9�ü:9<;>^eO�ü:;AüWN12�F�;UO�=DNN68Nw6æ9<= ü:]DN�J�TU=küWN���ü�T>c6D;sü�;�;UOWOW9<[�9<^`;süW9<T>=�M

� = üW]DN ;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�OWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüpVá;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<O3T>=DNÿ6D9<O�üW9<=DS>CB9<OW]DNO�ûQN!ü �eNN!=áü:]DNæJ!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CQO3;A=B6*ü:]DNæ6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:Nÿ;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü[�T868N^Ü9<=DSQF�OWN!N�?�9<7 �>NO$;A=B6 a��9Üý�N!7:[±;A= � ! � ��M�YeTU=küW9<=kCBT>CBO�;U6.HpT>9<=kü�OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpVæ9<= ýD7�;>J�üW9`J�N39`O$OWT>^<þ>Nw6æ=�CD[\N7W9`J!;>^Ü^<V>F7WNwO�CD^ÜüW9<=DS@9<= ;ÿ689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;sü:9ÜTU= TAc�üW]BN�J�TU=küW9<=kCBT>CBO�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�N1kCB;sü:9ÜTU=BO!M ú = üW]DNLTAü:]DN!7�]B;A=Q6 üW]DNL689`OWJ!7WN!üWN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü:O;A7:N�J!T>[\ýDC8ü:N6�cd7:T>[ ü:]DN$;U6.HpT>9<=kübT>c�ü:]DN�=�CD[\N!7:9`J!;A^©6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;süW9<T>=�MDab]DN�T>ý�N!7�;sü:9ÜTU=BOZTAc�689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;sü:9ÜTU=L;>=B6�;>6.HpTU9Ü=küCBO�CQ;A^<^ÜV�6DT�=BTAü�J�TU[\[$C8ü:N>FD9«M NUM�üW]DN�6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:N�;>=B6�üW]DN�J!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CQOZ;U6.HpT>9<=kü�;AýDýB7WTk;>J�]DNwOÃ^<N;U63ü:T3689 �0N!7:N!=kü)7:NOWCD^Üü:OM

ab]DN�J�TU=BO�9`O�üWN!=QJ�V3T>c�689`O:J�7:N�üWNq;U6.HpT>9<=kü:OB��9ÜüW]LüW]BN�J�T>=kü:9Ü=�CDTUCBO�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü)N1UCQ;süW9<T>=�9`O�;�üWTUýD9<J�T>c TU=DS>TU9Ü=BS�7:NOWN;>7:J�]©M?�N!9�;A=B6�?�V�[\NO=� !�!��k;>=B;A^<V �!Nw6qO�Nþ>N!7�;A^kO�9<[\ýD^<Ne689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;AüW9<T>=�O:J�]DN![\NO�cdT>7�üW]BNÃT>=BNe689<[\N!=BOW9ÜTU=B;A^k=DTU=D^Ü9<=DNw;A7�;U68þ>NwJ�ü:9ÜTU=N�kCB;sü:9ÜTU= ;A=B6 J�TU=BJ�^<CB68Nw6 üW]B;Aü$J�TU=BO�9`O�üWN!=QJ�VÿT>cb6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:N3;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü:O�9<O$=DTAü$;>C8üWTU[\;AüW9`JAM�?89Ü7 �>NwOq;A=B6 a��9Üý�N!7:[±;A= � ! � �Opü:CB689<N6ÿ;�T>=DN���6D9Ü[\N!=QO�9<T>=B;>^ J!T>=�þ>NwJ�ü:9ÜTU=L��6D9 �0CBOW9ÜTU=4N�kCB;sü:9ÜTU=ÿOWT>^<þ>N6@CBO�9<=DSLJ�N!=kü:7:;>^ 689D�0N!7:N!=BJ!NO�cdT>7IûQT>üW]æ;U68þ>NwJ�ü:9ÜTU=;A=B6�689D��CQO�9<T>=4;A=Q6�^<N;>ýL�«cd7WTUS�ü:9Ü[\N�O�üWNýDýD9<=DSBMBab]BN!V�OW]DT��ZN6�üW]B;Aü)üW]BN�689<O:J�7:N�ü:N�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü)^<N;U6DOZüWT3O�üW7:T>=DS\TkOWJ!9Ü^<^<;AüWTU7WV=kCB[�N7W9`J!;>^8;A7WüW9ÜcÐ;>J�ü�O!M.;DTU7 üW9<[�Nb9<=küWN!SU7:;AüW9<T>=$;>^ÜSUT>7:9�ü:]D[±O!F.-�;>S>N7�� ,",��kSk;Gþ>NeT>7�68N!7�J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BO�cdT>7 ü:]DN�689<O:J�7:N�ü:NZ;U6.HpT>9<=kü:OTAcäX�CB=DS>N C8ü�ü�;ÿ[\N!üW]DT86DO�üWT û�NLJ!T>=BOW9<O�üWN=kü\689`O:J�7:N�üW9N�;AüW9<T>=BO�TAc�ü:]DN4J�TU=Uü:9Ü=�CDTUCBO�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü\N�kCB;sü:9ÜTU=BOM ab]DNL^<9Ü=DNw;A7

Page 7: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� Ë

Opü�;AûD9<^Ü9ÜüpV�7:N!SU9ÜTU=�TAcQüW]DN)689`O:J�7:N�üWNb;>6�HpT>9<=UüÀJ!T>9<=BJ�9`68NO���9ÜüW]�üW]BNbO�ü:;>ûD9<^Ü9ÜüpV�7:N!S>9<T>=�TAcQüW]DNZcdT>7 �b;A7�6�[\N�ü:]DT86�M�;DTU7 N��D;A[\ýD^<N>FüW]DN±Ye7:;>=��0��K�9<J�]DTU^<OWT>=�üW9<[\N�689`O:J�7:N�üW9N�;AüW9<T>=4CBOWN6�9<=æ?8aB' $ )�?�NwJ�ü:9ÜTU= !02b9`OI;3O�NwJ�TU=B6�T>7�68N!7äX�CD=DSUN�� C8ü�ü�;3OWJ�]BN![\N"A9�ü�O);>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�9`O);\O�NwJ�T>=Q6�TU7:68N7�689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;sü:9ÜTU=�T>c�üW]BN�J�T>=kü:9Ü=�CDTUCBO�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�N�kCB;AüW9<T>=BOM

ab]DNZ6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:Ne;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�O�;A7:NÃ9<=�ýD7:9<=BJ�9<ýD^<NeýD7:N�cdN7W7:N6qcdT>7�)ÐOW[�T�T>üW] 2 6D;Aü:;I;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=�ýD7:T>ûD^<N![±O O�9<=BJ�NeüW]BN!VqýD7:Tsþ�9<68NüW]DNIN��D;>J�üe68N7W9<þs;süW9<þ>NäTAc�ü:]DNI6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:N)cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=3û�N!9<=DS�[\9Ü=D9<[\9D�N6�M8ab]DNV±;A7:N�;A^`O�T$=DNJ!NO:OW;>7WV�9Ü=�üW]DNIJ�TU[�ýBC8ü:;AüW9<T>=3T>cüWTAü�;A^QN!=DN7WSUV�T>7J-�NO:O�9`;A=3OW9<=DS>CD^`;A7�þUNJ�üWT>7�OM>5á]�V�ûD7W9`6\;>6.HpTU9Ü=küÃ[\T868N^Q;AýBýD7WTk;>J�]+)Ð689`O:J�7:N�üWNä;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�cdT>7ÃüW]DN)üW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�ü9Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:9ÜTU=©F�J�T>=kü:9Ü=�CDTUCBOq;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�cdT>7�ü:]DN±J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WVÿ9Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:9ÜTU= 2 �b;>OqOWCBJJ�NO:O�cdCD^Ü^<Vÿ;>ýDýD^<9ÜNw6@ü:T�!kH � 6 ;A7�J�]BN![\9<J;A^6D;sü�;�;UOWOW9<[�9<^`;süW9<T>=�ûkV#'À7:7WN7:;�;A=B6#;DT>=kü:N!V�= �D�����«ML;BT>7)OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV3Opü:CB689<NObCBOW9<=DS�üW]DNq;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�[\N�ü:]DT86LT>=DN �Z;>=kü:OeüWT;AýDýD7:T.�89Ü[±;AüWN�ü:]DN±O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüW9<NO�TAceüW]DN±J!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CBOI[\T868N!^«F�9«M NUM�9Ü=æüW]D9`OqJ!;UO�N\;�J�TU=Uü:9Ü=�CDTUCBOI;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�;AýDýB7WTk;>J�]@[±;GVûQNqýD7:N�cdN7:;>ûD^<N>M

� � ÷^� �©ôBù�ø ��� ���4��ø�ó � õ����áö�Uõeù�òeó� ���(� �wñ8ñ8ñ�æNq=DT�� 68NO:J�7:9Üû�NIüW]DN�J!T>=BO�üW7:CBJ�üW9<T>=LTAc�ü:]DN�;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�T>c�üW]BN�J�T>[\ýD7:N!]BN!=BOW9ÜþUNIJ�]BN![\9<J;A^�üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7Wü�[�T868N^�?8aB'J$ � � �� Mab]DN�cdT>7 �Z;>7:6�[\T�6DN!^©9`O�O�TU^ÜþUN6�CBOW9Ü=DS±;>=LTUýQN7:;AüWTU7bOWýD^<9�üWüW9<=DS3;AýBýD7WTk;>J�]©M8ab]DNq7:NOWCD^ÜüW9<=DS±689`OWJ!7WN!üWNq;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü)OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV[�T868N^�9<O�;A^`OWT OWýD^Ü9ÜüM � N 689<O:J�CQOWO�9Ü= 68N!ü:;A9<^IüW]DN =�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^äüWNwJ�]D=D9�UCBNOLCBOWN6ácdTU7LüW]DN O�TU^ÜCDüW9<T>=&T>c�üW]DN cdTU7��b;A7�6[�T868N^�;A=Q63ü:]DNq7WNwO�CB^�ü:9Ü=DS36D9<O:J�7:N�ü:N�;U6.HpT>9<=kü:OM�;DTU7)O�9<[\ýD^Ü9`J�9ÜüpVE�ZN�CBOWNq^Ü9<=DN;>7 � =D9ÜüWN�689D�0N!7:N!=BJ!N�689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;sü:9ÜTU=BOZTAc üW]DNüW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�ü�üWN!7:[±O!M�aÃV�ýD9`J!;>^ � =D9�ü:N$þUT>^<CD[\N$689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;sü:9ÜTU=BO ��9ÜüW] �BCL�4^Ü9<[\9�ü:9Ü=BS�J!;>=@û�N�;AýBýD^Ü9<N64üWT3ü:]DN�J!T>=BOWN!7:þs;sü:9ÜþUNcdT>7:[ TAc�üW]BN�[±;>O:O�ûB;A^`;A=QJ�N�N1kCB;sü:9ÜTU=BO�;>=B6 7:NOWCD^Üü�9<= =DTU=D^<9Ü=DNw;A7\O�N[\9<689`O:J�7:N�üWN�üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7Wü�N�kCB;AüW9<T>=BOM�ab]DNL;UJ�ü:9ÜTU=TAcÃü:]DN±^<9Ü[\9ÜüWN!7$9<Oq689`O:J�T>=kü:9Ü=�CDTUCBO ��9�ü:] 7:NOWý�NJ�ü�ü:T�üW]DN±OWT>^<C8üW9<T>=©M©ab]B9<Oq[±;GV4^<N;U6ÿü:T4J�T>=QO�9`68N!7�;AûB^ÜN�üW]DNT>7:N�ü:9<J;A^�;A=B6ýD7:;UJ�ü:9<J;A^�689 �±J!CD^ÜüW9<NO\9<= üW]BN�J!T>=BO�üW7:CBJ�üW9<T>= T>c�ü:]DN4689<O:J�7:N�ü:NL;U6.HpT>9<=kü:OF�;>OI�eN^Ü^�;UO�9<= üW]DN�CD=B6DN!7�Opü�;A=B689<=DS TAc)ü:]DN!9<7ýD7WTUýQN7�ü:9ÜNwO )ÐOWN!N�NUM SQMÜF�-)T>[\NwOWJ!C\;>=B6\K�;GþUT>= � ,"���32�M��á]B9Ü^<N �ZN�7WNwJ�T>SU=D9N�!NZüW]B;Aü�üW]DNäOpü:CB68V�TAc�689<O:J�7:N�ü:N);>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�O�cdT>7 �QCL�^Ü9<[\9�ü:N6@[\N!üW]DT86DOä9<OI;A=49<[\ýQTU7�ü�;A=küI;>7WNw;\TAcÀTU=DS>TU9Ü=DS�7WNwO�Nw;A7�J�]©F�üW]DN\J�CB7W7:N!=kü)cdT8J�CQO�TU=@O�9<[\ýD^ÜN�^Ü9<=DNw;A7 )3��9ÜüW]@7:NOWýQNwJ�üüWT�üW]DN�OWT>^<C8ü:9ÜTU= 2Z689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;sü:9ÜTU=BOZTAc�ü:]DN�üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7Wüeü:N!7:[±O�O�]DTUCD^`6�û�N�7WNSU;A7�68Nw6�;>Ob; � 7�Opü)O�üWNý�ü:T��Z;>7:6�7WTUûDCBO�ü�6B;sü:;;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=LOWV8Opü:N![±OZcdT>7);>9Ü7 kCB;>^Ü9ÜüpV>M

����� �(��!$#�����.@��-�:R14!$-�.9�+�3�/!5�-)T>7:9N�!T>=kü�;A^�üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7Wüq9<O�O�TU^ÜþUN6æCBO�9<=DS@;4689<7:NJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^9� ;A=Q6 VæOWýD^Ü9Üü�;>ýDýD7:TU;>J�]�M0ab]BN3ûB;>OW9`J\=kCB[�N7W9`J!;>^�üWNwJ�]D=D9�UCBNOO�TU^ÜþUN�ü:]DNqT>=DN���6D9Ü[\N!=QO�9<T>=B;>^0üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7WüZN1UCQ;süW9<T>=

c@Hc>y e}zP< c@Hc>� |

�?cc>� � ?*= c@H

c>� ��H�)~yI����J , 2 ehH+J , )&y�2u� = c@Hc>�

���� !������ e �m� )*,"��2

ab]DNq]DT>7:9N�!T>=kü�;A^�;>68þUNJ�üW9<T>=3ü:N!7:[ 9`O�689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�!N6Lû�V±ü:]DN�üW]D9<7�6�TU7:6DN!7bCDý ��9Ü=Q6 � =D9�ü:N�689D��N7WN=BJ�NIcdT>7:[$CB^<;+� ,�&��

z � < c@Hc>� ���� ! ¹ !�� e�� <@J�)�z H+J ·0P | ��HKJ ·©E z �¢HKJ@z ,THKJ ¬�E 2/GL) ��¦)�(2w�U9�c@<>J & �<@J�) ,¢HKJ ·�E | �¢HKJpz��¢H+J ¬�E |�HKJ ¬©P 2/GL) ��¦)�(2w� 9�c@<>J�� �S� )*,�!02

ab]DNq689 �0CBOW9ÜTU=LüWN!7:[±O�;A7:Nq689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�N6�û�V±üW]DN�OWNJ!T>=B6�T>7�68N7)J�N!=kü:7:;>^06D9 �0N!7:N!=BJ!NO�?cc>� � ?"= c>H

c>�' ���� ! ¹ ! � e )~?*J ¬ E =7J ¬�E |�?*J�=7J 2�)�HKJ ¬ E z§H+J 2�z )~?*J¥=7J/|�?*J ·�E =7J ·©E 2�)&HKJpz�HKJ ·�E 2,T?"J¥¦)� P � )*, � 2

;DT>7 ü:]DN�9Ü= �BT�� û�T>CD=B6B;A7:VqüW]DN);U68þ>NwJ�ü:9ÜTU=�689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;AüW9<T>=�6D7WTUýBO�üWTIüW]DN � 7:O�ü�T>7�68N!7�CDý ��9<=B6�O:J�]DN[�NUF���]D9`J�]�[±;��UNOüW]DNqTU7:68N7bTAc�J�T>=QO�9`Opü:N!=BJ!V3TAc üW]BN ��]DT>^<NqOWJ�]DN[\N�kCB;U687�;süW9`JäcdT>7bü:]DNq9Ü=kü:N!7:9ÜTU7�ýQTU9Ü=kü:ObT>c�ü:]DN�68TU[\;>9Ü=�M � c�< E & ��ü:]DN!=� E 9<Oä;A=@9<=��BT�� û�T>CD=B6B;A7:V�ý�T>9<=kü�A�^ÜN!üuHKJ , û�N�üW]BN�J�TU7W7:NOWý�T>=B689<=DS±û�T>CD=Q6D;A7:VLJ!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=G)ÐHä9Ü7:9`J�]D^ÜN!üIJ!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>=(2�Mab]DN�689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;sü:9ÜTU=�7:N;U6DO��H E�¢y e8zP< E

H E z H J ,¦)� | )~? P = P |�? E = E 2�)�H P z�H E 29z )7�¢? E = E z§? P = P 2�)&H E z§H J ,�2

,$? E ¦)� P� )*, ��2

;DT>7$üW]DN�T>C8ü��BT�� ûQTUCD=B6D;>7WVÿüW]DN�;>6Dþ>NJ�üW9<T>= 689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;AüW9<T>= ;A^`OWT@687WTUýBOqü:T@ü:]DN � 7�O�ü$T>7�68N!7�CDý ��9Ü=Q6 OWJ�]DN[\N>M � c< ¨ & �±üW]BN!=¯� ¨ 9`OI;A=@TUC8ü �BT�� û�T>CB=B6D;A7:VLýQTU9Ü=kü�A(�ZN$CBOWN�ü:]DN�û�T>CB=B6D;A7:V�J�T>=Q689�ü:9ÜTU=@TAc9�N!7:T�689D�0CBO�9<þ>N��BCL�@;>J!7WTkOWOüW]DNqTUC8ü �BT�� ûQTUCD=B6D;>7WVUMDab]DN�689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;AüW9<T>=�7:N;U6DO�"H ¨��y e8zP< ¨

H ¨ z H ¨^·�E¦O� | z )~? ¨ = ¨ |�? ¨^·�E = ¨^·�E 2�)&H ¨ z§H ¨M·©E 2,$? ¨ ¦)� P

� )*,0/�2

Page 8: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

ab]DNqO�ýB;UJ�NqOWN![\9 �n689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;AüW9<T>=�^<N;U6DOZüWT\ü:]DNq^<9Ü=DNw;A7�TU7:689<=B;>7WV±689D��N7WN=küW9`;A^©N1UCQ;süW9<T>=�"H�¢y e�� )&y�2 H�)&y�2 | � )~y�2w� )*,"&�2

��]DN!7:N$ü:]DN�[\;AüW7:9 ���)~y�2I68NýQN=B6DO�T>=ÿüW]DNI��9<=B6 � N!^`6�F�üW]DN±689D��CQO�9<T>=ÿüWN!=QO�TU7F�;A=Q64üW]BN�;>9Ü7q68N=BO�9ÜüpV4ûDC8üq9Üü�6DTkNwOI=DTAü68N!ý�N!=B6\TU=$ü:]DN)CD=F�k=BT���=�J!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BOB)�cdTU7�üW]DN�6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;süW9<T>=\O:J�]DN![\NO�CB=B68N!7eJ�T>=QO�9`68N!7�;sü:9ÜTU= 2�MAab]BN�þ>NJ�üWTU7 &�)dü:27WNýD7WNwO�N=kü:OeüW]DN�Hä9<7W9`J�]D^<N�ü)û�T>CD=B6B;A7:V�J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BOM

ab]DNIcdT>7 �Z;>7:6�O�V8O�üWN![ 9<O);U68þs;A=BJ!N6�9Ü=Lü:9Ü[\N�cd7:T>[¤y , üWT�y , ¬ EPe�y , |�¦)yZCBOW9Ü=DS�Ye7�;A=��0�nK)9`J�]DT>^`OWT>=

H , ¬�E e ���tz ¦)y, � )~y , ¬�E 2 ·�E�� ���w| ¦Oy

, �)~y , 2 H , |�¦)y � )&y, 2�| � )&y , ¬�E 2, � )*, ��2

ab]DN�J�]DTUOWN!=L689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;sü:9ÜTU=�^<N;U6DOZüWT±ý�N!=kü�;>689`;ASUT>=B;>^�[±;AüW7:9<J!NOb;A=B6�OWV8Opü:N![±O���]D9`J�]LJ;A=�ûQN�OWT>^<þ>Nw63þUN!7:V3N��3J�9<N!=kü:^ÜVUM'JkCB;sü:9ÜTU=C)*, ��2Ã7WNýD7:NOWN!=kü:OÃüW]DNIcdTU7��b;A7�6±689`OWJ!7WN!üWNI[�T868N^0cdT>7Z]DT>7:9N�!T>=kü�;A^QüW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�üwM8ab]DNIJ!T>7:7WNwO�ý�T>=Q689Ü=BS$;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü

O�V8O�üWN![ 9<Obü:]DN!=4;U68þs;A=BJ!N6�ûB;>J:� �b;A7�6DOÃ9<=LüW9<[\NqCBO�9<=DS\ü:]DN�689`OWJ!7WN!üWNq;>6.HpTU9Ü=kübcdT>7:[$CB^<;AüW9<T>=

� , e � �^| ¦)y, � � )~y , 2 � �Vz ¦)y

, � � )~y , ¬�E 2 ·�E � , ¬ E � )7����2

'JkCB;sü:9ÜTU= )*�"�02�9<O3; J!T>=BOW9`Opü:N!=kü±üW9<[\Nÿ689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;sü:9ÜTU= T>cäü:]DNÿJ!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CBO±;U6.HpT>9<=kü3N�kCB;AüW9<T>=©MÃK�TAü:N�üW]B;Aü3cdT>7±ü:9Ü[\N68N!ý�N!=B6DN!=kü�J�T�N��3J!9ÜN=Uü)[±;AüW7:9 �3ü:]DN�J�TU=küW9<=kCBT>CBOb;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�N6#��9�ü:]@Ye7�;A=F���nK)9`J�]DTU^<OWT>=

� , e � �Vz ¦)y, � � )~y , 2 ·�E � �w| ¦)y

, � � )~y , ¬�E 2 � , ¬ E )7�F�12

9�ü)9`O)689D��N7WN=küZü:]B;A=Lü:]DN�689`OWJ!7WN!üWNIcdT>7:[$CD^`;+)7����2�M

����� t�"!5��#�%¢-�:R13!5-/. ���4��!��ab]DNqþ>N7�ü:9<J;A^�;>68þUNJ�üW9<T>=�üWN!7:[ 9`O)689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�!Nw6�û�V±ü:]DN � 7�Opü)TU7:68N7bCDý ��9Ü=B6 � =B9�ü:N�689 �0N!7:N!=QJ�NIcdT>7:[$CD^`;

z �� c@Hc � ���� � ¹ � � e � z JF)&H+Jpz§H+J ·©E 2/G�)��5J@z���J ·�E 2w�A9Üc J & �z JF)&H+J ¬�E z§HKJ 2/G�)��5J ¬ E z��5J 2w�U9Üc J�� �C� )7�0,"2

ab]DN�þ>N!7WüW9`J!;>^�6D9 �0CBOW9ÜTU=�9`O�689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�!N6�û�V\üW]DN�OWNJ!T>=B6�T>7�68N!7bJ�N=küW7�;A^�689D��N7WN=BJ�NwO!MDK�TAüWNIü:]B;sübüW]BNIþUN!7WüW9`J!;>^�SU7W9`639`O=DTAübCD=D9ÜcdT>7:[�Mkab]DNäüWTUý�û�T>CD=Q6D;A7:V±J�T>=Q689�ü:9ÜTU=39`OZHä9<7W9`J�]D^<N�üÃcdTU7b9Ü=��QT��&;A=B63K�N!CD[±;>=D=3cdTU7eTUC8ü �BT�� )Ð9�M N>ML�N!7:T$689D��CQO�9<þ>N�BCL��ü:]D7:T>CDSU]�ü:]DN�üWTUý�TUC8ü �BT�� ûQTUCD=B6D;>7WV�2�MDab]D9<O)9<O�OW9Ü[\9<^<;>7büWT\ü:]DNq]DT>7:9N�!T>=kü�;A^�;>68þUNJ�üW9<T>=�J;>OWN>M

ab]DN±S>7:T>CD=Q6ÿ^<N!þUN!^Àû�T>CD=Q6D;A7:VæJ!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>= J!T>=BOW9<6DN!7�OIüW]DN �QT��ÝT>cZ[±;sü:N!7:9<;>^ÀS>9<þ>N=æû�V O�CB7�cÐ;UJ�N\N![\9`OWOW9ÜTU= 7:;AüWNOVZ;A=B6�û�V�68N!ý�TUOW9�ü:9ÜTU=�ýD7WT8J!NO:O�NwOB��9�ü:]@68N!ý�TUOW9ÜüW9<T>=4þ>N^ÜT8J!9�üpV�0±MQab]BN�þ>N7�ü:9<J;A^5��9<=B64OWýQNN64;süäS>7:T>CD=B6L^<N!þUN!^�9`O E e �DMab]DNqS>7:T>CD=Q63û�T>CD=B6B;A7:V�J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=L7WNw;>6DO

z = c>Hc � ���� � ¹���� ����� U ehZaz*0VH�� )7����2

��]DN!7:Nt=+9`Obü:]DNqþ>N7�ü:9<J;A^0N6D6DV�689D��CQO�9<þ�9�üpVUMBab]DN�S>7:T>CD=Q6�^<N!þUN!^©J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=�9<O�689<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�N6�9Ü=4OWýB;>J!Nq;>O

H ( E e)~? P = P |�? E = E 2�)&H P z§H E 2,$? E )�� P z�� E 2�¦�� E z 0VH E z Z

¦�� E )7�"!02

��]DN!7:NV¦�� E 9`OZüW]DNq]BN!9<S>]kü)TAc�üW]DN � 7�O�ü)^<;GVUN!7wMab]D9<O�OWýB;UJ�NqO�N[\9 �n689`OWJ!7WN!üW9N�;sü:9ÜTU=�^<N;U6DOZüWT\ü:]DNq^Ü9<=DNw;A7 ú H '

H ( )~y�23e�� )&y�2�H�)&y�2 | � )&y�2�E ¨ | ZM)~y�2¦�� E E E )7� � 2

��]DN!7:N�ü:]DNqN!=kü:7WV�� E ² E ;UJ!J�TUCD=kü:Oe=DT�� ;>^<OWT�cdT>7ZüW]DN�6DN!ý�TUOW9�ü:9ÜTU=�þ>N^ÜT8J!9�üpV A � ;>JJ�T>CB=Uü�OecdT>7ZüW]DNIü:T>ýLûQTUCD=B6D;>7WV�;>=B6mZ;>J!J!T>CD=kü�OZcdT>7�S>7:T>CB=B63N[�9`O:O�9<T>=BOM�-)N7WNtE 9<OZü:]DN�&�����J!T>^<CD[\=�TAc üW]DNq9`68N!=kü:9�üpV3[±;AüW7:9 ��M

Page 9: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� Ê

K�OW9Ü=DS Ye7:;>=��0��K�9<J�]DTU^<OWT>= üW9<[\NæO�üWNýDýD9<=DS cdT>7�üW]DN J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BO�;A=B6*cdTU7��b;A7�6 'ÀCD^<N!7�üW9<[�NwOpü:N!ýDýB9Ü=DS cdT>7�üW]DNûQTUCD=B6D;>7W9<NO�;>=B63ü:]DNqS>7:T>CB=B6�N[\9<O:O�9<T>=QOZüW]DNIcdT>7 �b;A7�6�689`OWJ!7WN!üWN�[\T868N!^�cdTU7�þ>N7�ü:9<J;A^0üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7WüZ7:N;U6DO

H , ¬�E e ���Vz ¦Oy, �)~y , ¬ E 2 ·�E�� � �w| ¦)y

, � )&y , 2 H , |�¦)y � � )~y , 2�E ¨ | Z )~y , 2¦�� E E E � � � )7�!��2

K)TAü:Nÿü:]B;süL9Ü= ýD7�;>J�ü:9<J!N@ü:]DNæN[\9<O:O�9<T>= 9Ü=küWN=BOW9�ü:9ÜNwOL;>=B6 ü:T>ý&û�T>CD=Q6D;A7:V þG;>^ÜCBNOL;A7:NæJ�TU=BO�ü:;A=küLTsþ>N!7L689`OWJ!7WN!üWN@ü:9Ü[\N9Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^<O )ÐN>M SBMA]BT>CD7:^ÜV�2�;>=B6�üW]DNä;Aû�Tsþ>NZcdT>7 �Z;>7:6I'ÀCB^ÜN7À9Ü=kü:N!S>7�;sü:9ÜTU=��9ÜüW]B9Ü=3OWCBJ�]±;A=±9<=küWN!7:þs;A^D9`O�N1UCB9Üþs;A^<N!=küÀü:T�Ye7:;>=��K)9`J�]DT>^`O�TU=©MDab]DNqJ�TU7W7:NOWý�T>=B689<=DS\689`OWJ!7WN!üWNq;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü)[\T868N!^�9`O);>^<OWT�T>c�ü:]DN�cdT>7:[ )*�"��2�M;D7:T>[ )*�"��2 ;>=B6#)*� �02 T>=DN�J!;>=�Nw;>OW9Ü^<V�TUû8ü:;>9Ü=�üW]DN)J!TUO�ü�cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^Q68N!7:9Üþs;AüW9<þ>NO ��9ÜüW]\7:NOWýQNwJ�ü�üWTqT>üW]DN7�ýB;A7�;A[\N�ü:N!7�O!M

;DT>7�N��D;A[\ýD^<Neü:]DN);>6�HpT>9<=UüÀOWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüW9<NO���9ÜüW]\7:NOWýQNwJ�ü�ü:TIN[\9<O:O�9<T>=�7�;süWNwO�J!;A=�û�N)J!;A^`J�CB^<;AüWN6�û�VqüW]BNbüW7�;A=BOWýQTkO�Nw6�J�]Q;A9<=7WCD^<N�7WN^<;AüW9<T>=

� , e c �cpZM)&y , 2 e � c>H , ¬�Ec@Z )~y , 20 � v c �

c@H , ¬�E e � c@H , ¬ EcpZM)&y , 20 � v � , ¬ E e �¦�� E E � E � �tz ¦)y

, � � )&y , ¬�E 2 ·©E � , ¬�E � )7� /�2

ab]DN$N[�9`O:O�9<T>=4OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV � , 9`OäT>û8ü�;A9<=DN64;Aü�þ�9Ü7WüWCB;>^Ü^<VL=DT�;>6B689�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^ J�TkOpüwFQOW9Ü=BJ!NqüW]BN$þ>NwJ�ü:T>7 � �Oz )¥¦Oy�G","2 � � �¥·�E;�9<O);>^Ü7:N;U68V3J�TU[\ýDC8üWNw6�6DCD7W9<=DS\ü:]DNqCDý06D;sü:NqTAc��49Ü= )7����2�M���k ')�9�*��#&���+!5,5ZüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`J�J�]DN![\9`J!;>^F��9Ü=BN�üW9`J!OÃ7WNwO�CB^�üÀ9<=3Opü:9 � ú H ' N�kCB;sü:9ÜTU=BO�ü:]B;süe7WN1UCB9Ü7:N)O�ý�NJ!9<;>^D=�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^D9<=küWNS>7�;süW9<T>=\[\N�ü:]L�T�6BO%��]B9<J�]$;>7WNZOpü�;AûD^<N>FwýD7:NOWN!7:þ>NÀ^<9<=DN;>7�9<=�þG;>7W9`;A=kü�O )�;DM ��M ;DMw[±;>O:O 2�;A=B6�;A7:NÃJ�TU[\ýDC8ü:;AüW9<T>=B;>^Ü^<V�N��3J�9<N!=küwM � =�� ! ��� �eNe]B;Gþ>NO�]DT���=ÿüW]B;Aü$X�TUOWN!=�ûD7:T8J:��[�N!üW]DT86DOq;>7WNI�ZN!^<^ÀO�CD9ÜüWNw6@cdTU7�O�TU^Üþ�9<=DS�;süW[\TkO�ýD]BN!7:9<J�J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV4ýB7WTUûD^ÜN[±O!M©ab]DN�cdTU7��b;A7�6689<O:J�7:N�ü:NqJ�]DN![\9`J!;A^�[\T868N^©9Ü=@?8aB' $�9`O�SU9ÜþUN!=�û�VL;�X)TUOWN!=�ûD7:T�J:�36D9<O:J�7:N�ü:9D�w;süW9<T>=�TAc üW]DN�J�]BN![\9<J;A^�N1UCQ;süW9<T>=QO

� J�e�� , | J ·©E� ¹�E

� J ² « � )7��&�2

� ���� z9)�� , 2 «¢J�eh]I) � J 2 | J ·�E� ¹�E

HKJ ² � « ��L�e �¢��v+v+v+�_F¡�

� , ¬�E e�� , | �� ¹�E

A « �

� = � &DF�!0,.�5�ZNqO�]BT��&üW]Q;sübüW]DN�J!T>7:7WNwO�ý�T>=Q689Ü=BS�689`O:J�7:N�üWNq;U6.HpT>9<=küb7:N;U6DO

� �� � z� � )�� ,�2 < J ehA J �+, ¬�E | �� ¹ J ¬�E

� � ² J�� | H ² J� < �� � )7�!��2

�TJ e� � ) � J 2Y< J ��L9eaF¢� FPz �¢��v+v+v+���¡��+,¡e �*, ¬�E | �� J ¹�E)��G)�� ,�2��C« J 2 � v�< J | �� J ¹�E

�TJ-)N!7:N�ÿ68N!=DT>üWNwOÃü:]DN��U;UJ�T>ûB9<;>=�;A=B6�� )�;����ü:N!=BOWT>7 2�9`OeüW]DN�-)NwOWOW9<;>=�T>c©üW]DN�68N7W9<þs;süW9<þ>NäcdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=(] M � J�;A7:N�ü:]DN�Opü�;AS>NO�TU^ÜC8ü:9ÜTU=$þUNJ�ü:T>7�O�J!T>[\ýDC8ü:N6�û�VqüW]DNZcdTU7��b;A7�6q[\N�ü:]DT86#) 6 N!7 �eN7 N!üMA;>^�M��"&02�Msab]DNZcdT>7:[$CB^<;AüW9<T>=�J;A=�ûQNbN;UO�9<^<VqN���üWN=B68N6üWT±=DTU=L��;>C8üWTU=DT>[\TUCBOeOWV8Opü:N![±OM;DT>7�J�TU[\ýD^ÜN!üWN=DNO:O �eNZS>9<þ>NeüW]DN�J!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CBO J�]DN[�9`J!;>^8;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�[�T868N^�FsTUû8ü:;>9Ü=BN6�û�V�OWT>^<þ�9Ü=DSäüW]BNZ;U6.HpT>9<=kü�J�]BN![\9<J;A^

N�kCB;sü:9ÜTU=#��9ÜüW]Lü:]DN�X�TUOWN!=�ûD7:T8J:�±[\N�üW]BT�6 )*�"&�2

�3J e(� , ¬�E | J ·©E� ¹�E

� J ² « � � J e��<)&y , ¬�E z�� J � 2 )3!0��2

� �� � z� � )�� , ¬�E 2 « J e� � ) � J 2�v�� J | J ·©E� ¹�E

H+J ² � « ��L�e ���+v+v�vK�_F��

� , e(� , ¬�E | �� ¹�E

A « �

Page 10: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

��� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

ab]DN�=�CD[\N!7:9`J!;A^�N��8ý�N!7:9Ü[\N=Uü�OÃ7:N!ý�T>7WüWNw6±]DN7WNäCBO�NäüW]BN�ü �ZT�O�ü:;>S>N>FkO�NwJ�TU=B63TU7:68N7eX�TkO�N=�ûD7WT8J:��[�N!üW]DT86LX�TUO�� ,M� ! �����]D9<J�]�9`O�68N � =DN6Lû�V±üW]BN�J�T�N��3J�9<N!=kü�O � e �3|�� ,¢G�,DF A E e �"G",8F*A P e �$G�,8F � P ² E e �UFD;A=B6CH P ² E efz8,DM

ú üW]DN7Zý�T>ýBCD^<;>7b=kCB[�N7W9`J!;>^09Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:9ÜTU=3[\N�üW]BT�6BOZcdT>7�Opü:9 �ÿOWV8Opü:N![±Ob;A7:NIX)CD=DS>N C8üWü:;�;A=B6 &b;>J:� �b;A7�6±H�9D��N7WN=L�üW9`;süW9<T>= ;BT>7:[$CD^`;>O ) &ZH ; 2�M � ü�J!;A=�û�N�O�]BT���= � !�����üW]B;Aü)üW]DN�6D9<O:J�7:N�ü:N�;U6.HpT>9<=kü:O�T>c &bH ; O:J�]DN![\NwO);A7:N�9Ü=�S>N=DN!7�;A^ )dcdT>7þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNbOpü:N!ý\O�9N�!NwO 2�9<=BJ�TU=BOW9<O�üWN=Uü���9ÜüW]�üW]DN�J!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CBO�;U6.HpT>9<=kü�N1kCB;sü:9ÜTU=©MsX�CD=DSUN CDü�ü:;�;>=B6�X)TUOWN!=�ûD7:T�J:��[\N�ü:]DT86DOT>=�üW]DNqT>üW]DN7�]B;A=B6�;>7WN �eN^Ü^�O�CD9ÜüWNw6�cdT>7);>6�HpT>9<=Uü)J!T>[\ýDC8ü�;süW9<T>=QO � ,�,8F !0����M

ab]DN�9Ü[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü�;süW9<T>=�T>c =�CD[\N!7:9`J!;A^�9<=küWNS>7�;süWTU7:OÃcdT>7äJ�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV�J;A=LûQN�6DT>=DN�;>C8üWTU[\;AüW9`J!;>^Ü^<V3CBOW9Ü=BS�ü:]DN 9<=DN�ü:9<J$À7:N�$À7:T8J�NwOWOWT>7 $�$ OWTAc�ü �b;A7:N±üWT�T>^`O�� ������M�5 7:N!^`;süWNw6 ;AýBýD7WTk;>J�] �b;>O$ü:;"�>N!= 9Ü= üW]DNLN;>7W^<V ;AýDýB^Ü9`J!;AüW9<T>= T>c)üW]DN�!UH8�6 ;A7qü:T@J�]DN![\9`J!;A^e6D;sü�;4;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=æû�V ; 9`O�]BN!7$;>=B6 4�;A7:V � ,L���«M $�$ �Z;UO�7WNwJ�N!=kü:^ÜVæN���üWN=B68N6 � �DF�!0,.��ü:T@ýD7:T868CBJ�N;�7�;AýB9<6 ;A=Q6ÿN �±J!9ÜN=kü�9Ü[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü�;süW9<T>= T>ceü:]DN3J�T868N�cdT>7�OWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV ;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<OITAc�J�]DN[�9`J!;>^ ��9Ü=DN!üW9`J±O�V8O�üWN[\OM $5$ûDCD9<^<6DO ;BT>7WüW7�;A=(/�/�F1;DT>7WüW7�;A=#�"�DFsYäFGT>7 $@;sü:^<;>û�OW9Ü[�CD^`;süW9<T>=�J�T868NecdT>7�J�]DN![\9`J!;>^�OWV8Opü:N![±O%��9�ü:]�J�]DN[\9<J;A^8J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOJ�]B;A=DSU9Ü=BS�9<=�ü:9Ü[\Nq;>JJ�TU7:689<=DS�üWT�üW]BNI^`;.�&T>c�[±;>O:O�;>J�üW9<T>=E��9<=DN�ü:9<JO!M $�$ SUN!=DN7:;AüWNwOÀü:]DN�cdT>^<^ÜT���9<=DS�ûDCD9<^<6D9Ü=DS\ûD^<T8J:�8O�>�>M���/ Á >�üW]DN�ü:9Ü[\N�68N7W9<þs;sü:9ÜþUNIT>c J!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BO�A,8M�� �¢����� �¢� �=>F�k;>J!T>ûD9`;A=�TAc ;DCD=�9<=LcdCD^Ü^�T>7�9<=�OWýB;>7:OWN�cdTU7W[±;Aü�A�DM � ������� � �$ ��(>QOWýB;>7:OWN 4%K 68NJ!T>[\ý�TUOW9�ü:9ÜTU=�cdTU7büW]DN �k;>J!T>ûD9`;A=5A!BM � ����p�$£��$����� ����@�$£��5������>QOWT>^<þ>N�O�ýQ;A7�O�N�O�V8O�üWN[ ��9ÜüW]LüW]DN �k;>J!T>ûD9`;A=�[±;süW7:9D��;A=B6�9Üü:Obü:7:;>=BO�ý�TUOWN"A� M�� �¢� � �>�_����� �¢����� � ��� ��>BOWýB;>7:OWN �k;>J!T>ûD9`;A= )�ü:7:;>=BO�ý�TUOWN6�T>7b=DT>ü:2eü:9Ü[\NO)þ>NJ�üWTU7�A�DM�ab]DN�O�üWT>9`J�]D9<T>[\N�ü:7W9`Jä[\;AüW7:9 ��?8a ú � Y=$ A/�M �M� �¢�+�Y�$Á/���������>Bþ>NJ�üWTU7ZT>c 7:N;UJ�ü:9ÜTU=�7�;süWNwO�A&DM�� �¢���M� �¢�+���TÁ/���������>8ü:]DN �k;>J�TUûD9`;A=�T>c�ü:]DN�;Aû�Tsþ>N�A�DMV��� / Á ���M� �����B>B6DN!7:9Üþs;sü:9ÜþUNOZTAc ;DCB=���9ÜüW]�7:NOWýQNwJ�ü�ü:T�7:N;UJ�ü:9ÜTU=LJ!TkN �3J�9<N!=kü:O )Ð9Ü=4OWýB;A7�O�NäcdT>7:[±;sü 2 A�1�DMt��� �¢� ���M� �����B>B6DN!7:9Üþs;sü:9ÜþUNObT>c �k;>J ��9�ü:]�7WNwO�ý�NJ�üZü:T±7WNw;>J�üW9<T>=�J!T�N��3J�9<N!=kü:OZü:9Ü[\NwO�CBOWN!7�þ>NwJ�ü:T>71A���>M! O�-1=1:>DüW]DN -�NO:O�9`;A=LTAc�;DCD=5ABüW]D9`OB���«üWN=BOWT>7b9<O)7WNýD7WNwO�N=küWN6�9Ü=4OWýB;A7�OWN�cdTU7W[±;sü1A�.,8M! O�-1=1 ��� �"�# O�-1 1$��� �>�_��> -)NO:OW9<;>=C)dTU7e9Üü:OeüW7�;A=QO�ý�TUOWN12�üW9<[�NwOZCBO�N7eþUNJ�üWT>7�O�AUO:;A[\Nä;UOÀü:]DNI6DN!7:9Üþs;sü:9ÜþUN�T>c%�U;UJ�TUûD9<;>=)�ü:7:;>=BO�ý�TUOWN6 2ÃþUNJ�üWT>7�ýB7WT868CBJ�übüW9<[�NwO�þ>NwJ�ü:T>7wM

� =G� �BF !0,��?�eN�O�]DT�� ]DT�� üW]DNwO�N $5$*ûDCD9<^<6D9Ü=DS�ûD^ÜT8J:�8O)J;A=�ûQN$CBO�Nw6LüWT39<[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü�þUN!7:V�N��3J!9ÜN=Uü:^ÜVLJ�T868NqcdTU7�689<7WNwJ�ü;A=B6L;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�OWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüpV�;>=B;A^<V8O�9`OZTAc�J�]DN![\9`J!;A^©OWV8Opü:N![±OM

% ñ����^��� ��òeó ��óDù�õÃò � � �4��ø�ó�� õ����áö �kõÃù�òeó � �(� �Gñ8ñ8ñ

ab]DN±cdT>7 �b;A7�6 ;>=B6 ;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�[�T868N^<O�;A7:N3ýB;>7:;>^Ü^<N!^<9D�N6 ;A=Q6 �eN7WN±7:CD= T>= ;ÿJ�^<CBOpü:N!7�TAc 4©9<=�CL� �ZT>7 �8Opü�;sü:9ÜTU=BO!M $�;A7�;A^D�^ÜN^Ü9N�;AüW9<T>=�9`OZûB;>OWN6�T>=L689Ü[\N=BO�9<T>=Q;A^�O�ýB^Ü9Üü�ü:9Ü=DS±;UOeOWCDýDý�T>7WüWNw6�û�V±T>CB7e^<9ÜûB7:;>7WV $�5�) $ÿ?DR � �!����M�ab]BNä^<9ÜûB7:;>7WV3OWCDýDý�T>7Wü:O6D;sü�;@üpV�ý�NO�cdT>7±O�üW7:CBJ�ü:CD7WNw6 SU7W9`6DOF�;>=B6 9<[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü:O\7:T>CDüW9<=DNO$cdT>7±6D;Aü:; 68NJ!T>[\ýQTkO�9ÜüW9<T>=�F�;>^Ü^<T8J!;AüW9<T>= T>c�^ÜT8J;A^�;A=B6S>^<T>ûB;>^©N!=küW9ÜüW9<NOFQ6B;sü:;�OWJ;sü�ü:N!7:9Ü=BSBFDSk;süW]BN!7:9Ü=DSQFB;A=Q64O�]�C�&±9<=DSBM�� N$CQO�Nqü:]DN�]DTU7W9N�!TU=kü:;A^D��þ>N!7WüW9`J!;>^�6D;sü�;368NJ!T>[\ý�TUOW9�ü:9ÜTU=ýD7WNwO�N=küWN6@9Ü= ;�9<S>CB7WN ,8M:�á9�ü:] 6D;Aü:;�9Ü=ÿüW]DN�]DT>7:9N�!T>=kü�;A^�OW^<9<J!N�cdT>7:[±;süIN;>J�]ÿýD7WT8J!NO:O�TU7äJ!;>=ÿJ�TU[\ýDC8üWN�üW]BN�]DTU7W9N�!TU=kü:;A^üW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�ü1A8üW]BN!=@6D;Aü:;±9`O�OW]�C�&±N6L9Ü=4þUN!7WüW9`J!;>^�J�TU^ÜCD[\=�cdTU7W[±;sü�;>=B6�N;UJ�]�ýD7WT8J!NO:O�TU7)J!;A=4J!T>[\ýDC8ü:N�7:;U689`;süW9<T>=�FDþ>N7�ü:9 �J!;A^�ü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�üwF©J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV ;A=B6 ;AN7WTkO�TU^ ýB7WT8J�NwOWOWNOI9<= T>=DN3J!T>^<CD[\=©M?;DTU7�üW]DN±]BT>7:9D�T>=kü:;>^�ü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�ü�üW]BN3=�CD[$û�N!7qT>cýD7WT8J!NO:O�TU7�N![\ýD^<TsV>Nw6 9<O�;sü�[\TUO�ü$üW]BN�=�CD[�ûQN7�T>c)^<;GVUN!7�O!M�aeV�ýD9`J!;A^<^<V>F�;Aû�T>C8ü �"�('�T>c�üW]DN�J�TU[�ýBC8ü:;AüW9<T>=B;>^ÃN��0T>7Wü�9`OO�ý�N!=küb9Ü=�7:;U689<;AüW9<T>=3;>=B6�J�]DN[\9<O�üW7:V±J�T>[\ýDCDü:;sü:9ÜTU=BOF���]D9`J�]�CQO�NI6D;sü�;$9<=3ü:]DNIJ!T>^<CD[\=3ýB;>7�ü:9�ü:9ÜTU=DN63cdT>7:[\;AüM�ab]DN!7:Nä;>7WN[\;>=�V�J!T>^<CD[\=BO ��]D9<J�] ;A7:N�[±;AýDý�N6ÿT>=küWT�üW]DN\;Gþs;A9<^<;>ûD^<N�ýD7:T�J!NO:O�TU7:O�O�CBJ�]@üW]B;AüINw;>J�]@ýD7:T8J�NwOWOWT>7)7:NJ!N!9<þ>NwO�;Aû�T>CDüI;A=N�kCB;A^0;A[\TUCD=küÃTAc?�ZT>7 �0M $�5�) $ÿ?DR 9<[\ýD^<N![\N!=kü:Ob;�O�ü:;AüW9`J)[±;AýBýD9Ü=BS�O:J�]DN![\N�T>c�J�TU^ÜCD[\=BO )�ü�;>O��8O 2�üWT$ýB7WT8J�NwOWOWT>7�O�ü:]B;süN!=BOWCD7:NO$;@þ>N!7:VÿSUT�T�6 ^<TU;U6 ûB;A^`;A=BJ!9Ü=BSBM ú = ;ÿJ�^<CBOpü:N!7�TAc �ZT>7 ��O�ü:;AüW9<T>=BOq;>^Ü^e9Ü=BýDC8ü�;>=B6 TUC8üWýDCDü�9`O�]B;>=B68^<N6 û�VæüW]DN[\;UOpü:N!7�ýD7:T8J�NwOWO�)ÐOWN!N ; 9<S>CD7:N ��2�AD;A=B6�;A^<^©J�TU[\ýDC8ü:;AüW9<T>=BO�;>7WNq68TU=DN�û�V±üW]DN �ZT>7 �>N7b=DT868NOM;DT>7eüW]BNI;U6.HpT>9<=kü=�ZNäCQO�N�;qü �ZT���^ÜNþ>N^�J�]DNwJ:��ýQTU9Ü=küW9<=DS�OWJ�]DN[\N>M�ab]DNä^<N!þUN!^D��,$J�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=kü:OZOpü:T>7:N)üW]BN�J!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=

� N!^`6DOÀTU=\üW]DNI689`O��\;süÃNþ>N7WV�TUýQN7:;AüWTU7ÃO�ýB^Ü9ÜüeO�üWN!ý )Ð9�M N>M�;süeN!þ>N7WV#� � [\9<=kCDüWNOÀcdT>7ÃüW]DNIJ�CD7:7WN=küÃ;AýDýD^<9`J!;sü:9ÜTU= 2�MkK)T>üWN�ü:]B;süüW]DN3^<9<=DN;>7�üW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�ü$O:J�]DN[�N±68T�NwOq=DTAü�7WN1UCB9Ü7:N±;A=�Væ;U6D689ÜüW9<T>=B;>^ÀJ�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=Uü:9Ü=BS@Opü:T>7�;AS>NUM�ab]DN3;A[\T>CB=Uü�T>cZ^<N!þUN!^D��,J�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=Uü�6D;sü�;�9<=BJ!7WNw;>OWNO � þ>N!cdT>^`6�9ÜcQ;�=BT>=D^<9Ü=BN;A7�üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7Wü O:J�]DN![\N�)dNUM SQMwCQO�9<=DS �BCL��^<9Ü[\9ÜüW9<=DS02�9`O�CQO�Nw6�Msab]DNe^<N!þUN!^D� �J�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=Uü�OeO�üWTU7WN�üW]DN�J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=QO�cdT>7bNw;>J�]3ýD7:T8J�NwOWOÃ9Ü=BOW9`68N�ü:]DN � � [�9<=�C8üWNwOZ9Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^<O�AU^<N!þUN!^D� �äJ�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=Uü�OÃCQO�N[�N[\T>7:V3ûDCL�0N!7�O!M(;DTU7�N��D;A[\ýD^<NqT>=DN�cdTU7��b;A7�639<=küWNS>7�;süW9<T>=LTAc�N;UJ�]4J�]DN![\9`J!;A^�û�T.��[\T868N^©cdT>7 � � [\9Ü=�C8ü:NO)OWýD^<9�ü)ü:9Ü[\N9Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^D7WN1kCD9Ü7:NO�;I=�CD[�ûQN7ÀTAc©OW[\;>^Ü^<N!7�ü:9Ü[\N�O�üWNýBO�AsüW]DNwO�N�9<=küWN7W[\N6D9<;AüWN)J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=QO ;>7WN)O�üWTU7WNw6$9<=3;äüWN[�ý�T>7�;A7:V[\;AüW7:9 �4;A=Q64CBOWN6@68CB7W9<=DS±ü:]DN$ûB;UJ:� �Z;>7:6L9<=Uü:N!SU7:;AüW9<T>=�TAc�ü:]DN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü�[\T�6DN!^«M ú ý�N!7�;sü:T>7�OWýD^<9�üWüW9<=DSL;>=B6LüW]BN$7:N!^`;süW9<þ>NO�]DTU7�ü)OWýD^<9�ü�ü:9Ü[\Nq9<=Uü:N!7:þs;A^`Ob[\;"�>N�9Üü�cdN;>OW9<ûD^ÜNIü:T\O�üWTU7WNIü:]DNq^ÜNþ>N^ �:�IJ�]BNJ:��ýQTU9Ü=kü�Ob9Ü=�[\N![\T>7:V>M

Page 11: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� �w�

ab]DN�SU;UO�ýD]B;>OWN�J�]DN![\9`J!;>^D[\NJ�]B;>=D9<OW[ 9`OÃ?85/$ÃX)YJ� � �I� /.�F��]D9`J�]\J!T>=BOW9`68N!7�O üW]DN�Sk;>O��«ýB]B;>OWNZ;AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`JZ7WNw;>J�üW9<T>=BOTAc©þ>TU^<;AüW9<^ÜN�T>7:SU;A=B9<J ) 6 ú YZO 2Ã;A=B63=D9�ü:7WTUS>N=±T.��9`68NwO8)ÐK ú �F2�9<=�CD7:ûB;A=3;>=B6±7:N!SU9ÜTU=B;A^�O�N!ü�üW9<=DSkO!M�ab]DNäOWýB;>7:OW9�üpV\O�üW7:CBJ�ü:CD7WNTAc�üW]DNI�U;UJ�TUûD9<;>=�9<OäO�]DT���=49<=C; 9<S>CD7:NM�>M�ab]DN�cdTU7��b;A7�6�üW9<[�N$9Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:9ÜTU=L9`OI68T>=DN ��9�ü:]4üW]DN�X�TUOWN!=�ûD7:T8J:�3=�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^9Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:T>7eX)TUO���,E� ! ��� A>ü:]DNIJ!T>=küW9<=�CDT>CQOe;U6.HpT>9<=küZ[\T868N!^0CBOWNOZX�TkO � ,qTU=±üW]DNqO:;A[\NäOWN�kCDN=BJ�NITAc�O�üWNýBOb;>OeüW]BN�cdTU7��b;A7�6J�]DN![\9`J!;A^�9<=küWNS>7�;süW9<T>=�M &ZT>üW]LüW]DN�cdTU7��b;A7�6�;>=B6�üW]DN�;U6.HpT>9<=küb[\T868N^<O);>7WN�9<[\ýD^ÜN[\N!=küWNw6�CQO�9<=DS $5$�M

1 19 37 55 74

1

19

37

55

74

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18

19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27

28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36

37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45

46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54

55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63

64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72

73 74

����� Ù���Ù ÆBh:u<mZi�j!rkh������nikj!lp�n{�m«�\��mnlpxkz:mpx>lph�t!u©mp�khäyU�e��ÂÃv�É�ÊwÊwjz�t�k{�jrÿß`ÇÀ{�mp�3èk�|�|ÉÐ{|r8àW��Å��kh:lphäj!lphäÊG�!�qrktwrUÞ�h:lpt�h�rsmnlp{|h��ZtxUmetuÈ �sË!�>}0{�� hw�Qmp�kh��nikj!lp�n{�m«��{|��j�8twx>mq��Ë��$�0ÂÃ{|�w�sm)i�j!rkh����B�ni�j�lp�n{|m��L��mnlpxUz:mpxUlphItu�mp�Uh�yU�e��ÂÃv�É�ÊwÊ$�Zh��n�n{�j!r ß`lph�iUlph:�nh�rsmph��Lj!��trkh�eh��n�n{�jr\o�j�mnlp{�â�i8hWlez:twoqi8twrUh�rsmWàW�>Å��kh:lph�j�lph����wÊ��rktrkÞ�h:lptIh�rsmnlp{�h:��}k{�� hw�kmp�Uhb�ni�j�lp�n{�m«��{��Ãj!�8twxUme�A� � �$�

;DT>7�TUCD78'e;>O�ü�5äO�9`;±;AýBýD^Ü9`J!;AüW9<T>=�689`OWJ!CBOWOWN6L9<=LüW]DNqcdTU^Ü^<T���9<=DS±O�NwJ�üW9<T>=Lü:]DNqüWT>ü:;>^�^ÜNþ>N!^D� ,�J�]BNJ:��ýQTU9Ü=kü)9<=8cdT>7:[±;sü:9ÜTU=Opü:T>7:N639`O�� �"��,$ &ZVküWNObT>c�6B;sü:;$cdT>7�Nw;>J�]�]DT>CD7�T>c OW9Ü[�CD^`;süW9<T>=?A8T>7�� !3R &ZVküWNObý�N!78,�!\]DT>CD7�OZTAc�O�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=©MDab]DN^ÜNþ>N!^D� ,�J�]BNJ:��ýQTU9Ü=kü�O�TAc üW]DN$ýB;A7�;A^<^ÜN^�[\T�6DN!^�;>7WN�6D9<O�üW7:9ÜûBC8üWNw64;>O�OW]DT���=�9Ü= ; 9<S>CD7:N �DF���]BN!7:NqN;>J�]�=DT868N�O�üWTU7WNwO�^<T�J;A^9Ü=8cdTU7W[±;AüW9<T>=±T>=�ü:]DN�^<T8J!;A^�689`O��0MUab]B9<OÀü:;��UNO�cdCB^Ü^0;>68þs;>=Uü�;ASUN�TAc0üW]DN)üWTAü�;A^�Opü:T>7�;AS>N�J;AýB;>ûD9Ü^<9ÜüW9<NOÀT>c0üW]DNIO�V8O�üWN![�M � üe;A^`O�T68NJ!7WNw;>OWNO�üW]DNäJ�T>[\[�CD=D9`J!;sü:9ÜTU=�TsþUN!7:]DN;U6 ��]DN=�üW]DN�ýB;>7:;>^Ü^<N!^DJ!T>[\ýDC8ü�;sü:9ÜTU=�7:CD=BOÀT>=\;qJ�^<CBOpü:N!7�T>c(�ZT>7 �8Opü�;süW9<T>=QO OW9<=BJ�NüW]DNbS>9<SU;>û�VUü:NO�TAcQ6D;Aü:;I;A7:NÃ=DT>ü�ü:7:;>=BOW[�9Üü�ü:N6$Tsþ>N!7�üW]BN )Ð7WN^<;AüW9<þ>N!^<VqO�^<T��82�J�T>=B=DNJ�üW9<T>=©MGab]DN�689`Opü:7W9<ûDC8ü:N6$J�]BNJ:��ýQTU9Ü=kü:9Ü=DSOpü:7:;AüWN!SUV�9`O�üW]DN7WN!cdT>7:N�NO:O�N=küW9`;A^8cdTU7�ûQT>üW]±N��3J!9ÜN=BJ�V\;A=B6�TsþUN!7�;A^<^�O�üWTU7:;>S>N�J!;>ýB;>J!9�üpVUMAK)T>üWN�ü:]B;sü�cdTU7�üW]DNäOpü�;süW9`J)68TU[±;A9<=68NJ!T>[\ýQTkO�9ÜüW9<T>= 9<[\ýD^ÜN[\N!=küWNw6 9Ü= $�5�) $ÿ?BR ü:]DN±^ÜT8J;A^ÀN=Uü:9�ü:9ÜNwOE)Ð9�M N>M�]DT>7:9D�T>=kü:;>^�O�^<9<J!NOqTU7$OWN�ü:O�TAc�J�T>^<CD[\=BOqT>cbüW]DNJ�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>= � N!^`6F2$]B;Gþ>N3üW]DNLOW;>[�N�O�9N�!N�üW]D7:T>CDSU]DT>CDü�üW]DNLJ�TU[�ýBC8ü:;AüW9<T>=©F ��]D9`J�] [±;��>NwOqü:]DN�9<[\ýD^ÜN[\N!=kü:;AüW9<T>= T>cüW]DN±689`Opü:7W9<ûDC8ü:N6 J�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=küW9<=DS�O:J�]DN![\N�þ>N7WV�N��3J!9ÜN=UüwM5;DTU7I;L68V�=B;A[\9`J\68T>[±;A9<=æ6DNJ�TU[\ýQTkO�9ÜüW9<T>=ÿO�üW7�;sü:N!SUV>F0T>=ÿüW]DNTAüW]BN!7)]B;>=B6�FBüW]DN$OW9N�!N�T>c�^<T8J!;>^©N!=küW9ÜüW9<NOäJ�]B;A=BS>N�68CD7:9<=DS\üW]DN�J�T>[\ýDCDü:;sü:9ÜTU=@;A=B6Lü:]DN�9<[\ýD^ÜN[\N!=kü:;AüW9<T>=4TAcÀ689`O�üW7:9ÜûDCDüWN6J�]DNJ:��ý�T>9<=Uü:9Ü=BS�û�NJ!T>[\NO�J!T>[\ýD^<9<J;sü:N6�M

ab]DN�ýQ;A7�;A^<^ÜN^ ý�N!7WcdT>7:[±;A=BJ!N$T>cZ;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�?8aB' $+� � �� 9<OIýD7:NOWN!=küWNw6@9<= ; 9<S>CD7:NI!BM�ab]DNM'Ã;UOpüq5�OW9<;�üWNwOpü�J;>OWN�9`OI7WCD=T>= ;�&eNT���CD^ÜcbJ!^ÜCBO�üWN7 ��9ÜüW]G,��L=DT868NwO ) $�N=Uü:9ÜCB[ !BF ,>R�- �UF9�wR & X)58$C2�;A=B6 RI9<SU;AûB9�ü�N!üW]DN7W=DN!ü$J�TU=D=DNJ�üW9<T>=5A©üW]DNT>=DN3]BT>CD7�cdT>7 �Z;>7:6 ;>=B6 ûB;>J:� �b;A7�6 O�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU= J�TU7W7:NOWýQTU=B6DO�ü:T ��� ��R�$@a T>=G$@;>7:J�] �wOpüwF ,������UM ú = ��� �eTU7��UN!7�OüW]DN�;AûBOWT>^<C8üWN�J�ýDCÿüW9<[�N$cdT>7I;±cdT>7 �b;A7�6�7:CD=@9`O�;>ûQTUC8ü�,3[\9Ü=�C8ü:NOäýQN7�]DTUCD7äT>cÀO�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=5A0;A=B6Lü:]DN�J!ýDC4ü:9Ü[\N�cdTU7I;cdT>7 �Z;>7:6 ��ûB;UJ:�0�b;A7�637:CD=@9`OI;Aû�T>C8ü � [\9Ü=�C8ü:NOäýQN7ä]BT>CD7ITAcÃOW9Ü[�CD^`;süW9<T>=�MQab]DN�O�ý�N!Nw68CDýæJ!CD7:þ>NE)*;�9<S>CB7WN!02�9`OIJ�^<TUOWNqüWTT>ý8ü:9Ü[±;A^ A8cdTU7 ����eTU7��UN!7�OÀü:]DN�O�ý�N!Nw68CDý�9`O ���BFL��]D9<J�]�üW7�;A=QO�^`;sü:NOZ9Ü=kü:T3;A=LN��3J�9<N!=BJ!V�T>c & � '�M

� � ÷^� �©ôBù�ø ����� �k÷^nó��ab]DN$;>6�HpT>9<=UüäTAc�üW]DN\?8aB'J$ J�]BN![\9<J;A^�ü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�ü)[\T868N!^�J!;>=4ûQN$CBO�Nw6�9Ü=æO�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV�;A=Q;A^<V�OW9`O�Opü:CB689<NOI;A=B64;>^<OWT\cdT>7J�]DN![\9`J!;A^b6D;Aü:;ÿ;UOWOW9<[�9<^`;süW9<T>=�M � N�=DT�� ýB7WNwO�N=Uü�üW]DNwO�N�ü �ZTÿ9<[�ý�T>7Wü:;>=kü�;AýBýD^Ü9`J!;AüW9<T>=BO$TAc)ü:]DN�J�T>[\ýDCDü:;sü:9ÜTU=B;A^eüWT�TU^<O68N!þUN!^<T>ý�N6�M�ab]BN3;A=B;>^ÜV �!Nw6 ýD7WTUûD^<N![±Oq;A7:N±9Ü= OWCDýDý�T>7Wü$TAcZüW]BN�K�5I?85 a�X)5�=BO�ý�T>7Wü$;A=Q6 Ye]DN![\9`J!;A^ 'Àþ>TU^ÜCDüW9<T>= Tsþ>N!7üW]DN�$�;UJ�9 � J )Ða�7�;>J�N"$ 2 � N^<6&N��8ýQN7W9<[\N!=kü�J�TU=B68CBJ�üWNw6á9Ü= 'e;>O�ü�5�OW9<;BMeab]DNæO�9<[$CD^`;sü:N6 7:N!SU9ÜTU=*J!Tsþ>N!7�OE/�F ,���� � !QF &��"�

Page 12: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

��� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

P1

V−ColumnsH−Slices

P5P3P2 P4

����� Ù��DÙ Å��kh��kt!lp{|Þ�twrsm�j��ÉÐ�Gh:lnmp{|z�j!�0�Uj!m�j��>h�z�twoqi8t�n{�mp{�tr\�nz��kh�oqhb�nxUiki8t!lnmph����s���D�3���±yUÁä�

I/O Data

Local Chkpt Local Chkpt Local Chkpt Local Chkpt

Node NodeNode Node

Master

����� Ù��BÙ Å��Uh�i�j!l�j!�|��h:�0jw��ã�t{�rsmbyUÅ�Ä�� {�oqiU�|h�oqh�rsmp��j��>{���mnlp{|�UxUmph��$zW�Uh�zW�Ai8t{�rsmp{|rk�ä�nzW�Uh�oqhw�

0 5 10 15 200

5

10

15

20

No. Workers

Rel

ativ

e S

peed

up

Ideal SpeedupRelative Speedup

����� Ù���Ù yAi8h�h��UxUik�$ß`lph���j!mp{|�Gh$mptLj±�n{|rk���h�Ç�tlp�wh:lqiUlptsz:h��n��à�u`t!lqtwrUh��UtwxUlItuÃu`t!lnÇ�j!l��AÉÐ��jz��sÇ�j�l��ÿ{|rsmph��l�j�mp{|twræÇÀ{�mp�@i�j�l�j�|�|h��j�!ã«tw{|rsmby>Å�Ä ���

Page 13: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� �I� [ 9Ü= 'Ã;UOpü\5�OW9<;BF�;>=B6 ü:]DN�O�9<[$CD^`;sü:N6 9Ü=küWN7Wþs;>^Z9`O�T>=DNL[\T>=küW]*Opü�;A7WüW9<=DSæ;Aü � R�$@a T>= $ÿ;A7�J�] �O�üF9,������UM�ab]DN[�N!üWNT>7:T>^<T>S>9`J!;>^ � N^<6BOq;A7:N$S>9<þ>N=ÿû�V@;�68V�=B;A[\9`J$[\N!üWN!TU7WTU^ÜTUS>9`J!;>^�[\T868N!^ )�X)58$ÿ?F2 � !0����F�;>=B6@ü:]DN\9Ü=B9�ü:9<;>^ � N!^`6DO�;A=B6ûQTUCD=B6D;>7WV�J!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>=QO J!T>7:7WNwO�ý�T>=Q6�üWT�a�7�;>J!N�� $ÿ6D;Aü:;IJ!;>[�ýQ;A9<S>=©MGab]DNbS>7:9<6$]B;>O ��� ����� � ��&�ý�T>9<=kü:O���9ÜüW]\;�]DTU7W9N�!TU=kü:;A^7WNwO�TU^ÜC8ü:9ÜTU=�T>c &�� [ �+&"� [�M

H�N!ü:;A9<^`O�TAcÃü:]DN\cdT>7 �b;A7�6@[\T868N!^ÀOW9Ü[�CD^`;süW9<T>= J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BOq;>=B6 J�T>[\ýB;>7W9`OWT>= ��9ÜüW] T>ûQO�N7Wþs;sü:9ÜTU=BO�;A7:N�ýB7WNwO�N=Uü:N6æ9Ü=YZ;A7:[�9`J�]B;>N!^�N�üÃ;>^�M�� ����MAab]DNbüW9<[\N)O�N7W9<NO�T>c�J;A^`J�CD^`;sü:N6 - _ F�+�- P F ��3 �7-�F>;A=B6 34- J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=�;A7:NZýB7WNwO�N=Uü:N6�9Ü=;�9<S>CB7WN � MQYe]BN HpC�9<OW^`;A=B6 )d^<T>=DSU9�ü:CB68N�� �1,�/�� ')F8^`;süW9ÜüWCQ68N � �"!���K 2Z9`O�;�7WN[\TAüWN�^<T8J!;sü:9ÜTU=©F8ûDC8ü)CB=B68N!7bü:]DNq9<=��BCDN=BJ�NTAc�N[�9`O:O�9<T>=BOÃcd7:T>[ Ye]D9<=B;DF TU7WNw;�;A=B6#�U;>ýB;A=�Fk68NýQN=B689<=DS\T>=�üW]DNIT>C8ü��BT��&J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BOM85�ObOW]DT���=�9<=#; 9<S>CD7:N � F 34-;A=B6 - _ J;A=\7WNw;>J�]\þs;A^<CDNOÀTAc � ! � ��ýDýBû3;A=B6 � / � ýDýBû©F>7:NOWýQNwJ�ü:9ÜþUN!^<V>M>ab]DN)üW9<[�NIO�N7W9<NOÃO�]DT�� 689<CD7:=B;A^�;A=B6\OWVk=BT>ý8ü:9<JOWJ;A^<NIþs;>7W9`;AûD9<^<9�üpV\ü:]B;sü)7:N��BNwJ�ü�OZüW]DN�J!T>[\ýD^<N���=B;AüWCD7:NqTAc�üW]DN�5äO�9`;A=�TUC8ü �BT��qM

Hours starting from 00:00:00 (UTC) on March 1st

CO

conc

entr

atio

n(p

pb)

NO

2,H

CH

Oco

ncen

trat

ion

(ppb

)

O3

conc

entr

atio

n(p

pb)

72 144 216 288 360 432 504 576 648 7200

30

60

90

120

150

180

210

240

270

300

330

360

390

420

450

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

1.3

1.4

1.5

44

46

48

50

52

54

56

58

60

62

64

66

68

70

72

74

O3

NO2

HCHOCO

����� Ù��BÙ Å�{|oqh��nh:lp{|h��Àt!u©z�twrUz�h�rsmnl�j!mp{|twrU�Ãj!mZv �kh«ã«xQ�

����� �m0����>#&.@�����".9��#~��#�#~� ,��m. -/:~,���#&�;DT>7$üW]DN�O�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV ;A=Q;A^<V�OW9`OM���4OW9Ü[�CD^`;süW9<T>= J;>OWNO �ZN!7:N�J!;>7W7:9<N6æT>C8ü�ü:TÿJ�TsþUN!7qü:]DN ��]DTU^ÜN�[�TU=küW] TAcbü:]DN�a�7:;UJ�N"$J!;A[\ýB;>9ÜSU=@ý�N!7:9ÜT86�M�ab]DNVÿ;A7:N$^<9<O�üWNw6@9<= a ;AûB^ÜN��>M�ab]DN\O�9<[$CB^<;AüW9<T>=ÿ9<=küWN7Wþs;A^�cdT>7�Nw;>J�]ÿJ;>OWN�9`OäüW]D7:N!N\6D;GV8O!M0ab]DN � 7�OpüJ!;>OWN\Opü�;A7Wü:O�;sü � > �"��R�$@a TU= $@;>7:J�] �O�üF5,������>FQüW]BN\OWNJ!T>=B6æOpü�;A7Wü:O�;sü � > �"� > �"�LR�$@a TU= $ÿ;A7�J�] !Aü:]©F?,������>F;A=B6LO�T�cdTU7�ü:]©MDab]DN�7WNwO�ý�T>=QO�NäcdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^��¡e � � H")~y ) 2 � 9<OZü:]DNqS>7:T>CD=Q63^<N!þ>N^�T"�T>=DN�J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=L;süäYe]DN HpC � OW^<;>=B6�F;sü�üW]BN � =B;A^�ü:9Ü[\N�O�üWNýLT>c�Nw;>J�]�J!;>OWN>M

5�O�O�]DT���= 9<= ?�NwJ�ü:9ÜTU= �DF O�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�ü:9ÜNwO$T>c�üW]DN�7WNwO�ý�T>=QO�N±cdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^'��e � � H")~y ) 2 � ��9ÜüW] 7:NOWý�NJ�ü$üWT@ü:]DN�O�ü:;AüWNþG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwO9)Ð;Aü�N;UJ�]äü:9Ü[\Ne9Ü=BO�ü:;>=kü:2�;>7WN�ü:]DNe;U6.HpT>9<=kü©þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwO �?)&y�2�F1��]D9`J�]�J!;A=qû�NÃTUû8ü:;>9Ü=BN6Iû�Vä9<=küWN!SU7:;AüW9<=DSbüW]BNÃ;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü

Page 14: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�:� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

[�T868N^�ûB;>J:� �b;A7�6DO)9<= üW9<[\N>M©ab]DN±689`Opü:7W9<ûDC8ü:9ÜTU=BOITAceüW]DN±;>6�HpT>9<=Uüqþs;A7:9`;AûD^<NOä9Ü= ü:]DN�üW]D7:N!N���689<[\N!=BOW9<T>=B;>^ J!T>[\ýDC8ü�;süW9<T>=68T>[±;A9<=©F0��]D9`J�]�;A7:N�;Gþs;A9<^<;>ûD^<N�;süb;A=�V�9<=BO�ü:;>=UüwFUýB7WTsþ�9`68N�üW]BN�NO:OWN!=küW9`;A^�9Ü=DcdT>7:[\;AüW9<T>=\cdTU7Ãü:]DNäOWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüpV±;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<OM�;BT>79Ü=BO�ü:;>=BJ�NUF>9`O�TkO�CB7�cÐ;UJ�NO�T>c©;>6.HpTU9Ü=küÃþs;A7:9`;AûD^<NOÀ6DN!^<9Ü=DNw;sü:N���9<=��BCDN=BJ�N�7WNS>9<T>=BO @DFA9«M N>MU;>7WNw;>O���]DN7WN�ýQN7�ü:CD7WûQ;süW9<T>=QO�9Ü=�O�TU[�NJ�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>=BO ��9Ü^<^�ýD7:T868CBJ�N�OW9ÜSU=D9 � J!;A=kü�J�]B;A=BS>NOe9<=�ü:]DN�7WNwO�ý�T>=BOWN)cdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^9)ÐN>M SBM8T"�T>=DNI;süäYe]DN�HpC � OW^<;>=B6�;AübüW]DN� =B;A^©üW9<[�N.2�M;�9<S>CB7WN �4689`O�ýB^<;GV8OIüW]BN39Ü= �BCDN!=QJ�N�;>7WNw;>OITAc�T"�T>=DN±;Aü,�!4]DTUCD7:O�û�N�cdTU7WN\ü:]DN � =Q;A^�ü:9Ü[\N39<= J!;>OWNE, )7$ÿ;A7�J�] !T� ��2

;A=B6LJ!;UO�N �#)*$@;A7�J�]�, � ��,�/�2�FU7:NOWý�NJ�ü:9ÜþUN!^<V>M8ab]DN�9<=��BCDN=BJ�N�7:N!S>9<T>=�cdT>7�J!;UO�N ��9<OZü:T��Z;>7:6\ü:]DN�?�T>CDüW]�;A=B6LJ�^<TUOWN�ü:T�üW]DNYe]DN HpC � OW^<;>=B6�F���]D9<^<Näü:]B;sü�cdTU7)J!;UO�N ,�9<O�üWT��b;A7�6±üW]BN�K)T>7WüW] �ZNO�üMDab]D9`O�689D��N7WN=BJ�Nq7:N��QNJ�ü�O�689D��N7WN=Uü)[\N!üWN!TU7WTU^ÜTUS>9`J!;>^J�T>=Q689�ü:9ÜTU=BOFD;>Ob9<=B689`J!;sü:N6Lû�V±üW]BN ��9Ü=B6 � N^<6BO)O�]BT���=�9<=�; 9<S>CD7:N4�DM

ab]D7WNN��n689<[�N=BOW9ÜTU=B;A^8ûB;UJ:��ü:7:;�HpNJ�ü:T>7:9ÜNwO�J!;>^<J!CD^<;AüWNw6�Nþ>N7WV ��]BT>CD7�OÀ68CD7:9<=DSqüW]BN)ýQN7W9<T86DO�T>c<$ÿ;A7�J�]!T� �q;A=Q6I$ÿ;A7�J�], � ��,�/�cdTU73Ye]BN HpC ;>7WNLO�]BT���= 9Ü= ;�9<S>CB7WN /�M�ab]DNLûB;>J:� üW7�;�HpNwJ�ü:T>7:9ÜNwOqýD7:Tsþk9`68N�9Ü[\ý�T>7Wü:;A=kü�9Ü=BOW9<S>]kü�9<=küWTÿüW]DN�;>6.HpTU9Ü=küþG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜN�689<O�üW7:9<ûDC8üW9<T>=QO!M05�O�OW]DT���=@9<=C; 9ÜSUCD7WN �DF�cdT>7äüW]BNI$@;>7:J�] !T� ��J!;>OWNqü:]DN��QT��)Oä;>7WN$cd7WTU[ ü:]DN�=DT>7WüW] �ZNO�üä;A=B6Opü:7WTU=DSBFsOWCBJ�]$ü:]B;süÃ;>9Ü7�[±;>O:OWNO ,�!�]DTUCD7:O û�N�cdTU7WN�;A7:7:9Üþ�9<=DSä;AüZYe]DN HpCI�eN7WNbTsþUN!7�üW]DN &ZN!9 Hp9<=DSq;A7:N;I;süÀ;A^ÜüW9ÜüWCB6DN�S>N!=BN!7�;A^<^ÜVûQN^ÜT�� ,)«*A M � =4J�TU=Uü:7:;UOpüwFk6DCD7W9<=DSM$@;>7:J�]+,",���,�!±Ye]DN HpC��Z;UOZCD=B68N7büW]DNq9<=��BCDN=BJ�N�T>c ;�]D9<S>]LýD7WNwOWOWCD7:NäOWV8Opü:N![�FD;A=B6,�!ÿ]BT>CD7�O�ûQN!cdT>7:N�;A7:7:9Üþ�9<=DSæ;Aü3Ye]DN�HpC ü:]DN �BT��)O �ZN!7:N��eNw;�� ;A=B6 cd7WTU[ üW]DN�OWT>C8ü:]��sOWT>C8ü:]L� �eNwOpü\;sü±;A^ÜüW9ÜüWCB68NLû�N!^<T��� �¡«*A M�ab]DNOWN�cdN;sü:CD7:NO�;A7:N�OWN!N=ÿ9<=@ü:]DN\9Ü=��QCDN!=BJ!N±;A7:N;>O)cdT>7�T"�T>=DN�ûQT>üW] 9Ü=æüWN7W[±OITAce^ÜT8J!;AüW9<T>=æTAcÀü:]DN\CDý ��9Ü=B6;A7:N;>OF�;A=B6�üW]DN�ýD7:T.�89Ü[\9ÜüpV\üWT�Ye]DN�HpC )ÐN>M SBM<F�üW]DN�9<=��BCDN=BJ�Nq;A7:N;�;A7:NI[$CBJ�]LJ�^<TUOWN!7ZüWT3Ye]DN HpCLcdTU7bJ;>OWN%��ü:]B;A=�cdT>7�J!;UO�N,"2�M

Longitude

Latit

ude

100E 120E 140E

20N

30N

40N

1E-06 1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

20 (m/s)

Longitude

Latit

ude

100E 120E 140E

20N

30N

40N

1E-06 1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

20 (m/s)

����� Ù��BÙ �«rUçkxkh�rUz�hZu<xkrkzWmp{�tr����G}kj!m�� � ËA� ����� j!�8t!�wh��nh�jq��h:�Gh���}D���q�ktwx>lp�e�8hWu`tlph�mp�Uhbè�r�j!�Qmp{|oqhZuÜlptwo ßdjGàÀ�\j!lpz��±���s�>}Dj!r��ß���à��\j!lpz��3� È �>�ËA�DÅ��Uhbm�j!lp�whWmÃu<xkrUz:mp{|twr\{|��� ¿ j!mZv �Uh«ã�xB�

� ×kÓ�� ê �kÙ gbh��nz:lp{|iUmp{|trk�Ãtu��n{|oIxU��j!mp{|twr�mph:��mp�Ã{|r$mp�kh��nh�rU�n{|mp{|�A{�m«��jrkj���>�n{|�v�j�nh y>{|oIxU�Üj�mp{|twr�mp{|oqhbi8hWlp{�tA� Å0j!lp�h:meu<xkrUz:mp{|twr� �\j�lpzW�L�WÉ��>}���w�A� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�±�!�U}8��w�A�� �\j�lpzW�\�!É��>}���w�A� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�±�wËA}8��w�A�� �\j�lpzW�3Ë�É�Ê>}���w�A� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�L���>}8��w�A�� �\j!lpz��L���!Ép���s}D���>� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�L� �>}8��w�A�È �\j!lpz��L� �!Ép� È }D���>� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�L���>}8��w�A�� �\j!lpz��L���!Ép� � }D���>� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�L��Ê>}8��w�A�Ë �\j!lpz��L��Ê!É«�A�}D���>� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�3��A}8��w�A�� �\j!lpz��3���É«�!�>}D���>� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�3� È }8��w�A�Ê �\j!lpz��3� È É«�wËs}D���>� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW�3� � }8��w�A���� �\j!lpz��3� � É��w�A}D���>� v �kh�ã�x�� ¿ j�me�qÁ��\Å twr3�\j�lpzW����>}8��w�A�

Page 15: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� � È

}����� Ù��DÙ ��j!zW�\mnl�j�ã�h:z:mptlp{|h��)��m�j!lnmp{|rU�\j!m)v �kh«ã«x�z�j!�|z�xk��j!mph���h��GhWln�\mp�Ulph�hä�ktxUlp���>xUlp{|rk�qmp�kh�i8h:lp{|tA�U��t!uÀ�\j�lpzW���É��3ß���hWu<mWàZj!r���\j�lpzW�±�w��É«�!�\ß`lp{���smWàW�

ab]DNä9<=��BCBN!=BJ!Nä7:N!SU9ÜTU=BOe;>7WNI689 �±J!CD^ÜüZü:T�ýB7WNw689<J�üZûQ;>OWN6�OWT>^<N!^<V\T>=�[�N!üWNT>7:T>^<T>S>9`J!;>^ � N^<6BO!F868CDNäüWT�üW]BNI9<=��BCBN!=BJ!NäT>cüWCD7:ûDCD^<N!=kü�689D��CQO�9<T>=4;A=Q6�J!T>[\ýD^<9<J;süWNw6�J�]DN![\9`J!;A^�7:N;UJ�ü:9ÜTU=BO!M &ZNJ;ACBOWN�TAc�üW]DN�ü:CD7WûBCD^ÜN=kü)=B;sü:CD7WNqT>c�ü:]DN�;sü:[�TkO�ýB]DN!7:9<JûQTUCD=B6D;>7WV\^`;GV>N!7wFsü:]DNä9<=��BCBN!=BJ!Nä7:N!SU9ÜTU=±[\;GV kCD9`J:�k^<V\N���üWN=B6\ü:T�;$þ>N!7:V�^<;>7WSUN�;A7:N;BF>J�TsþUN!7:9Ü=DS$[�TkOpüZTAc�ü:]DNIJ!T>[\ýDC8ü�;��üW9<T>=B;>^D68T>[±;A9<=©FA;>=B6�N!þ>N=�û�N!VUT>=B6$üW]Q;süMAab]BNbcÐ;>J�ü�ü:]B;sü�9<=��BCDN=BJ�N�7:N!SU9ÜTU=BO�J!;>=D=DTAü�û�N)O�9<[\ýD^<V$ýD7:N689`J�ü:N6$üW]D7:T>CBS>]�üW]DN[�N!üWNT>7:T>^<T>S>9`J!;>^ � N!^`6DOb9<Ob9<=B689`J!;AüWNw6�û�V±ü:]DN�689D��N7WN=BJ�NwOb9Ü=�üW]DNq9<=��BCBN!=BJ!NI7:N!SU9ÜTU=BOZTAc þG;>7W9<T>CQOZJ�]BN![\9<J;A^©J!T>[\ýQTU=DN!=kü�O!FN!þ>N=�9Üc üW]DNV�;A7:Nq;A^<^©687:9ÜþUN!=LûkV3üW]DN�O:;A[\N���9Ü=Q6 � N!^`6�M

� =�T>7�68N7ÀüWT�9<^Ü^<CBO�üW7�;süWNäüW]B9<OecÐ;>J�üF8;A=Q6±üWT�9`68N!=küW9ÜcdV\üW]BNI7:N!SU9ÜTU=M��]DN!7:N�J�]B;A=DSUNOÃTAc�;�J�N7�ü�;A9<=�J�]DN![\9`J!;>^�J!T>[\ýQTU=DN!=kü��9Ü^<^Q;���NwJ�üÀü:]DN�ü:;>7WSUN�üÀT��!T>=BN�T>ûBOWN!7:þs;süW9<T>=�[\TUO�üFk;>6.HpTU9Ü=küÃþs;A7:9`;AûD^<N�[±;AS>=B9�ü:CB68N);A7:N);Gþ>N7:;>S>Nw6qcdT>7ÃüW]DN�ýQN7W9<T86\TAc�üW]D7:N!N6D;GV8OZcdT>7�N;UJ�]�J;>OWN

»�J�)&�(24e �+¨^·�E�J ¹ �

� ��J�)&����y�2 � � )3! �12

-)9<S>]DN7�þs;A^<CDNO�TAct» cdT>7:[ �WJ�TU=DNO3TAc�9<=��BCDN=BJ�N1@DFZ9�M N>Me7WNS>9<T>=BOE��]DN!7:NÿJ�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=áJ�]B;>=DS>NwO3;��0NJ�ü�ü:]DN@ü�;A7:S>N�ücdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=�[�TkOpüwMF; 9ÜSUCD7:NO�&±;A=B6 �\689`O�ýD^`;GV±ü:]DNOWN �WJ!T>=DNwOeT>c 9<=��BCBN!=BJ!N�@�cdT>7)J;>OWNO ,�;A=B6 ��7WNwO�ý�NJ�üW9<þ>N^ÜVUM

ab]DN��WJ!T>=DNwOÀT>c©9Ü=��QCDN!=BJ!N�@�cdTU7ZJ;>OWN8,�OW]DT��*üW]B;AüÃü:]DN�9<=��BCDN=BJ�NäTAc©T��!T>=BN�T>=39Üü:OWN!^Üc©9<OZJ�TU= � =DNw6\üWT$7WNS>9<T>=BO ��9ÜüW]B9Ü=;�üW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�ü�ü:9Ü[\N�T>c ^<NO:Obü:]B;A= ��� � 6D;GV8OZcd7:T>['Ye]DN HpC©F(��]D9<^ÜN�ü:]DN�[±;�HpTU7)9<=��BCDN=BJ�N$;>7WNw;>OecdT>7 ��3 ��- ;A7:NqTsþ>N7büW]DNýD7W9<[±;A7:V�OWT>CB7:J!N�7:N!S>9<T>=QOÃ;A7:T>CB=B6 &ZN!9 Hp9Ü=BS�;A=Q6 � ,�6D;GV8OÀ7:N![\TsþUN6�cd7:T>[ Ye]DN�HpC©M8ab]DNä9<=��BCBN!=BJ!NäT>c +�- P T>=�T"�T>=DN)9`OcÐ;A7�7WN[\Tsþ>N6qcd7WTU[ÝYe]DN HpC©F"��9�ü:]$ü:]DNb7WNS>9<T>=�T>cQ[±;��89<[$CD[ 9<=��BCDN=BJ�Nb^<T8J!;sü:9ÜTU=$=DNw;A7 üW]BNb6DT>[±;A9<=$û�T>CD=Q6D;A7:V�;A=B6 x�� �6D;GV8OqCDý ��9Ü=Q6 TAcäYe]DN HpC�F�;sü�;A^ÜüW9ÜüWCB68NwO�û�N�ü �ZN!N= ,��0! ��[�M�ab]BN±üW7�;�HpNwJ�üWTU7W9<NOqOW]DT���= 9<=G;�9<S>CB7WN#/L]BN!^<ý N��8ýD^`;A9<= üW]DNþ>N!7WüW9`J!;>^�6D9<O�üW7:9ÜûBC8üW9<T>=3T>c©üW]BNIJ!T>=DNwOÃT>c�9Ü= �BCDN!=QJ�N>ML-�T��eNþ>N!7ÃüW]DNäcÐ;>J�üeü:]B;süZüW]BNä9<=��BCDN=BJ�NITAc6+�- P 9`Oe^<T8J!;AüWN6±cÐ;A7WüW]DNwOpü;.�Z;GV�7WN �BNJ�ü:OÃüW]DNäcÐ;>J�üeü:]B;sübT"�T>=DNä9<OZýD7:T868CBJ!N6±9<=�ü:]DN�;süW[\TkO�ýD]BN!7:N)þ�9<;�ýD]DT>üWT8J�]DN![\9`J!;>^Q7:N;UJ�üW9<T>=QOÀ9<=kþUT>^<þ�9Ü=DS +�- P M� =ÿü:]DN\7WNS>9<T>=ÿT>cÃ[±;��89<[$CD[ - _ O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV4üWT�+�- P F�T��!T>=BN$ýD7:T868CBJ�ü:9ÜTU=æ9`O +�- P ��^Ü9<[\9�ü:N6 ;A=B6ÿ9Ü=QJ�7:N;>OWNOI9<='+7- P^ÜNw;>6\ü:T$9<=BJ�7:N;UO�NwOÀ9<= - _ ^<N!þ>N^<OMUab]B9<OeýD7:T�J!NO:OÀ9`OecÐ;>O�üF�;A=B6\ü:]DN/+7- P ^Ü9ÜcdN�ü:9Ü[\N�;A=B6±üW7�;A=BOWýQTU7�üZ689<O�ü:;>=BJ�NI;A7:N�OW]DT>7WüF�O�T

Page 16: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

��� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

üW]B;Aü)üW]DN�T"�T>=DNq9`O)N=D]B;A=QJ�N6�^<T8J!;>^Ü^<V�;>=B6LüW]DN=4üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7WüWNw6�ü:TLYe]DN�HpC©M � =@;U6D689ÜüW9<T>=©FQT"�T>=DNqýD7:T868CBJ�üW9<T>=@;A^<T>=BS\üW]DNýB;sü:]�cd7:T>[ &eN9 Hp9<=DS\ü:T3Ye]BN HpC�9<O�K8$ -�YJ�«^<9Ü[\9ÜüWNw6 � ��� ;A=B6�üW]DNq9<=BJ!7WNw;>OWNOZ9Ü= +�- P 7:NOWCD^�ü�9<=4;�6DNJ�7:N;UO�NI9<=LT��!TU=DN>Mab]DN�OW9�ü:CB;sü:9ÜTU= cdT>7�J!;UO�N �@9`O$þUN!7:V 689D�0N!7:N!=küF ��9�ü:] ü:]DN �:J�T>=BNO�T>c)9Ü= �BCDN!=QJ�N�@ÿ^ÜT8J;süWNw6 ;A7:T>CB=B6 Ye]DN HpC�F�;>=B6 T>c^Ü9<[\9�ü:N6Lþ>N7�ü:9<J;A^�N���ü:N!=küMBab]BNOWNäcdNw;sü:CD7WNwOb7WN �BNJ�übüW]DNq9<=��BCDN=BJ�NqT>c�ü:]DNq]D9<S>]LýD7:NO:O�CD7:N�O�V8O�üWN![�M;DCD7WüW]DN7e9<=BOW9ÜSU]kü:Oe9Ü=küWT$üW]DNI9<=8cdT>7:[±;süW9<T>=�J�T>=kü�;A9<=DN6±9<=±ü:]DNI;U6.HpT>9<=kübOWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�ü:9ÜNwOe;>7WN)TUû8ü:;>9Ü=BN6±cd7:T>[ ; 9<S>CD7:NO ���$�

���DM�ab]DN!V 9Ü^<^<CBOpü:7:;AüWNUF©cdT>7$N;>J�] T>cZü:]DNC�1�4J!;UO�NwO�;A=B;>^ÜV �N6�F�ü:]DN3T��!T>=BN3O�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�ü:9ÜNwO$;Aü\Ye]DN HpC ;Aü�üW]BN�N!=Q6 TAc�N;UJ�]O�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=qýQN7W9<T86���9�ü:]q7WNwO�ý�NJ�ü©üWT�ýQN7�ü:CD7WûQ;süW9<T>=QO�9Ü=�O�CD7WcÐ;>J!N�^<;GVUN!7 - _ F"+�- P F ��3 ��-�F;>=B6 34- ;sü ;A=�V�ü:9Ü[\N9��9ÜüW]B9Ü=üW]DNqOW9Ü[�CD^<;AüW9<T>=���9Ü=Q68T��qM � =�ü:]DN � S>CB7WNwO!FküW]BN�OWT>^<9`6�^<9Ü=BNOb7:N!ýD7:NOWN!=küZüW]DNIüW9<[\N�O�N7W9<NOZT>c�üW]BN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü)O�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�ü:9ÜNwOZcdT>7ýQN7�ü:CD7WûQ;süW9<T>=�üWT±OWýQNwJ�9<NObJ�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=L;süäYe]DN�HpC©F���]D9<^ÜNIü:]DN�68TAü�OZ7WNýD7WNwO�N=kübOWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüW9<NO�6DCDN�üWT\ý�N!7WüWCD7:ûB;sü:9ÜTU=�T>cO�CD7WcÐ;>J!NqJ�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>=�;sü)N!þUN!7:V±S>7:9<6���9ÜüW]D9<=LüW]DN�68T>[±;A9<=©MBab]BNq^ÜT8J!;AüW9<T>=BObT>c�ü:]DNq[±;��89<[$CD[ þG;>^ÜCBN�cdT>7)Nw;>J�]LTAc üW]DN���\J!;UO�NwOÃcdTU7�N;UJ�]LOWýQNwJ�9<NO�;>7WNqOW]DT���=�9<= ; 9ÜSUCD7WN ��!BM

ab]DNIüW9<[�N�OWN!7:9<NObTAc�;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü)þs;A7:9`;AûD^<NOZýD7:Tsþ�9<68NwOZ9Ü=BOW9<S>]kü)9Ü=kü:T�ü:]DNq7:N!^`;süW9<þ>NI9<[�ýQ;>J�ü)T>c�ü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�ü�;A=B6�J�]DN[\9<O�üW7:V>M;DT>7qN��D;A[\ýD^<N>F0cdT>7�;LýDCB7WN�üW7�;>J!N!7�CD=B6DN!7�üW]BN±9Ü=��QCDN!=BJ!N±TAcb;>68þUNJ�ü:9ÜTU=æTU=D^<V )d=DT4689D�0CBO�9<T>=�F©7WNw;A^�T>7q=�CD[\N7W9`J!;>^�2�F0üW]DN;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü)ü:9Ü[\N�OWN!7:9<NOB��9ÜüW]@7:NOWý�NJ�ü�üWT39Üü:OWN!^Üc9�eTUCD^`6�û�N�;�68N!^Üü:;\cdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU= ��9�ü:]@þs;A^<CDN�T>c�CB=D9�üpV4;Aü)üW]DN$N!=B64T>c�N;>J�] �6D;GV3ý�N!7:9ÜT86�;A=B6��N!7:T�cdTU7�;A^<^�ü:9Ü[\NO)ýD7W9<T>7wM�K)=Q68N!7�ü:]DNOWN�J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BOF8ü:]DN$OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV3TAc üW]BNqüW7�;>J!N!7B��9ÜüW]�7WNwO�ý�NJ�ü�üWT;A^<^�TAüW]BN!7)OWýQNwJ�9<NOB�ZT>CD^`6�ûQN �N!7:T�;Aü�;A^<^0üW9<[�NwO!M

ab]DN±J!;A^`J�CB^<;AüWN6ÿT"�T>=DN\O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV ��9�ü:] 7:NOWý�NJ�üIüWT�9Üü:OWN!^ÜcZOW]DT��)OäüW]DN±O�üW7:T>=DSL9<=��BCDN=BJ�N\TAceüW7�;A=BOWý�T>7WüäcdTU7I[\TkOpüTAc�ü:]DNqý�N!7:9ÜT86DO�O�üWCB6D9ÜNw6 )ÐN>M SBM<FBJ!;UO�NwO �I��/8F8;A=B6 ���02�M�-�N!7:Näü:]DNqT"�T>=DNIþs;A^<CDNO�;>7WN�^`;A7:S>NwOpüZcdT>7bü:]DNIüW9<[�NwO)J�^<TUOWN!7Zü:T\üW]DN^<;UOpüäüW9<[�N\O�üWN!ý�M )�K)TAü:N$ü:]B;sü�9<=@T>7�68N!7�üWT�ýD7WT868CQJ�N�ü:]DN�üW9<[�N\OWN!7:9ÜNwO�OW]DT���=©FQüW]DN�þG;>^ÜCBN$TAceCD=D9ÜüpV�;Aü�ü:]DN�N=B6@T>cÀN;UJ�]ýQN7W9<T86�9`Ob=DT>ü)ýD^ÜT>ü�ü:N6�FDûBC8ü)9Ü=QOpü:N;>6�üW]BNqþG;>^ÜCBN�cdT>7büW]BN � 7:O�übüW9<[\N�Opü:N!ý�TAc üW]DNq=BN���ü)J!;>OWN�9<O�O�]DT���=(2�M;DT>7�üW]DNwO�N3J;>OWNO�ü:]DN3T"�T>=DN�ü:9Ü[\N�OWN!7:9ÜNwO�;A7:NMkCB;A^<9�ü�;sü:9ÜþUN!^<VæOW9Ü[\9<^<;>7F5��9ÜüW] ;U6.HpT>9<=kü$O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpVÿ9<=BJ�7:N;UO�9<=DS4;sc�ü:N!7

� !�&L]D7�OFQü:]DN!= û�NJ!T>[\9Ü=BSL=BN!SU;AüW9<þ>N\;sü � � ��]B7:OF©;A=B6ÿüW]BN!= 9Ü=QJ�7:N;>OW9<=DSBF�7WNw;>J�]D9<=DS�;L[\;��89Ü[�CD[ ý�TUOW9�ü:9ÜþUN�þs;A^<CDN68CD7:9Ü=DS ü:]DN@ý�N!7:9ÜT86 �"�$��/��ÿ]D7�OMÃ5"ýQTkO�9ÜüW9<þ>N ��� 9<[\ýD^Ü9<NO�; 9Ü=BJ!7WNw;>OWN4TAcqO�CB7�cÐ;UJ�N�T"�T>=DN@;AüLYe]DN HpC&;Aü�O�TU[�N�ü:9Ü[\N)dN>M SBM<F�]DT>CD7%�"�02���9Ü^<^ 9Ü=BJ!CD7ä;>=49Ü=QJ�7:N;>OWN�9<=@T"�T>=DN�;Aüä]DTUCD7�/",8M�ab]D9<OäJ!;>=@]B;AýBýQN=@T>=D^<V�üW]D7:T>CDSU]@689D��CBOW9<T>=@TU7�9Üc�üW]DNüW7�;�HpNJ�üWTU7W9<NOZ7:NJ�V8J!^ÜNq;A7:T>CB=B6�Ye]BN HpC©M�5 =DN!Sk;süW9<þ>NqOWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüpV3cdTU7/- _ ��9�ü:]47WNwO�ý�NJ�ü�üWT - _ 9Ü[\ýD^<9ÜNwObüW]Q;süä;>=�9<=BJ�7:N;UO�N9Ü= T"�T>=DN±;AüqOWT>[\N\ýD7:N!þ�9<T>CBOIü:9Ü[\N±^<N;>6BOIüWT@;�68NJ!7WNw;>OWN�9<= T"�T>=DN±;sü�Ye]DN�HpC ;süqüW]BN±N!=B6 TAceüW]DN#���n6D;GV@O�9<[$CB^<;AüW9<T>=©Mab]D9<O�J!;A=LT>=B^ÜV3T8JJ�CD7bü:]D7WTUCDS>]�J�]DN[�9`J!;>^�9Ü=kü:N!7�;>J�ü:9ÜTU=BOZCD=B68N7�J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BO���]BN!=�9Ü=QJ�7:N;>OW9<=DS�T��!TU=DNq68NJ!7WNw;>OWNOecdC8üWCB7WNT"�!TU=DN3ýD7:T868CBJ�üW9<T>= þ�9`;47WNw68CBJ�üW9<T>= 9<= +�- P ;>=B68T>7�ýQN7WT.�8V�^Ã7�;>6D9<J;A^`O!M ab]D9<O�ýD]DN=DT>[\N=B;4T8J!J!CD7:O�cdT>7�[\TUO�ü$ýQN7W9<T86DO;A7:T>CD=B6�O�CD=QO�N!üZT>c©üW]DN��A7�636D;GV\T>c©üW]DN�OW9Ü[�CD^<;AüW9<T>=©M8ab]DNIû�N!]B;Gþ�9<T>7e6DCD7W9<=DS�üW]DN�O�ü:;ASU=B;A=küZ]D9ÜSU]�ýD7:NO:OWCD7WNäJ!;>OWNO )ÐJ;>OWNO&3;A=B6��DF�]DT>CD7�O � ��!T� ��!0&�2Ã9<OI689D��N7WN=küF0;A=B6@OW]DT�� ;±ûD7:TU;U6�9Ü= �BCDN!=QJ�N$TsþUN!7�ü:]DN$N=küW9<7WNI�36D;GVLýQN7W9<T86�M�ab]B9<Oä7WN �BNJ�ü:OüW]DNq7:NJ!V�J!^Ü9<=DS�TAc üW7�;�HpNwJ�üWTU7W9<NO�)�;>O�OW]DT���=�9<= ; 9ÜSUCD7WN /"2e;>^ÜTU=DS ��9�ü:]4689 �0CBOW9ÜTU=©M

ab]DNIOWCD7WcÐ;>J!N�û�N!]B;Gþ�9<T>7ZTAc©ü:]DNqO�CD7:7:T>CD=B6D9Ü=DS�S>7:9<6�J�N!^<^`OZ;>7WN�kCB;A^<9Üü:;sü:9ÜþUN!^<V±O�9<[\9Ü^`;A7eüWT�üW]B;AübcdT>7ZcdT>7)Ye]DN HpC )Ð6DTAü:OZþ8O^Ü9<=DN12�9<=4üWN7W[±OäTAc�üW9<[\N$ý�N!7:9ÜT864T>cÀ9Ü= �BCDN!=QJ�N>F�;>=B6@OW]DT�� ýQTkO�9ÜüW9<þ>N$;>=B64=DNSU;AüW9<þ>N�9<=küWN!7�;>J�üW9<T>=BOFBûBC8ü ��9ÜüW]ÿ[\;��89Ü[�CD[þG;>^ÜCBNObT8J!J!CD7W7:9<=DS�;Aü)^ÜT8J;süW9<T>=QObTAüW]BN!7büW]Q;A=@Ye]DN HpC )Ðab]B9<O�9`O)689`O:J�CBO:O�Nw6�9<=�[\T>7:N�6DN�ü:;>9Ü^�^`;sü:N!7 2�M

ab]DN);>6.HpTU9Ü=küÀOWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüW9<NO�T>c0OWCD7WcÐ;>J!NZT��!TU=DN�;süZYe]DN�HpCI��9ÜüW]±7:NOWý�NJ�ü�ü:TqýQN7�ü:CD7WûQ;süW9<T>=\T>c0OWCD7WcÐ;>J�N +�- P ;A7:N�O�]BT���=9Ü= ; 9ÜSUCD7WN �"�UM � =BJ�7:N;UO�9<=DS/+7- P J;A=$9<=BJ!7WNw;>OWNÃT"�T>=DNZýD7:T868CBJ�ü:9ÜTU=�CB=B68N!7 +�- ! ��^<9Ü[\9ÜüWN6�J�]DN[�9`J!;>^DJ�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BOFs;A=B6�J!;>=68NJ!7WNw;>OWN)T"�T>=DN)CB=B68N!7 6 ú YJ��^Ü9<[\9�ü:N63J!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>= )dû�V±68NJ!7WNw;>OW9Ü=DSqý�N!7:T.�8V�^B7�;>689`J!;>^QJ�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=QO 2�M!&ZTAü:]3ûQN]B;Gþ�9ÜTU7:O;A7:N�O�]BT���=©M?K)=Q68N!7\Opü:7WTU=DS�üW7�;A=QO�ý�T>7Wü�J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BO�üW]DNLO�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüW9<NO ��9ÜüW] 7WNwO�ý�NJ�ü�üWT'+�- P ;A7:N±S>N=DN!7�;A^<^ÜV O�[±;>^Ü^<N!7üW]B;>=�üW]DTkO�N�cdTU7�T"�T>=DNUMF-)T��ZN!þUN!7wF8CD=B68N7�üW]BN$]D9<S>]�ýD7:NO:O�CB7WN�J!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>=Lü:]DN�OWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüW9<NO ��9�ü:]@7WNwO�ý�NJ�ü�üWT,+7- P ;>7WN^<;>7WSUN!7ZüW]B;>=�ü:]DTUOWN�cdT>7�T��!TU=DN>ML;DTU7)J!;UO�N &DF�ü:]DNq^`;A7:S>NO�ü�ýQTkO�9ÜüW9<þ>NqOWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüW9<NObT8JJ�CD7:7WNw6�,DM � 6D;GV8Ob9<=�;U68þs;A=BJ!N>M

ab]DN±O�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�ü:9ÜNwO�TAcbT"�T>=DNI��9�ü:] 7WNwO�ý�NJ�üqüWT ��3 ��- ýQN7�ü:CD7:ûB;sü:9ÜTU= ;>7WN\[$CQJ�] OW[±;A^<^ÜN7äü:]B;A= ü:]DTUOWN�cdT>7qT"�T>=DN;A=B6�+�- P F©ûBC8ü�OW]DT��ÝOW9Ü[\9<^<;>7�ýB;Aü�üWN7W=æüWT�ü:]DTUOWN\cdT>7$T"�!TU=DN>M �73 ��- 9`Oqû�TAü:] ;�ýB7W9<[±;A7:Vÿ;A=B6 OWNJ!T>=B6D;>7WV@OWý�NJ�9<NOMab]DN)O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüW9<NO�T>c�T��!T>=BN=��9ÜüW]±7:NOWý�NJ�ü�ü:T;34- ;A7:NZN���üW7:N![\N!^<V$OW[\;>^Ü^«FA7:N!ýD7:NOWN!=kü:9Ü=DSIü:]DNB�eNw;���9<=küWN7:;UJ�üW9<T>=�û�N�ü �ZN!N!=34- ;>=B6LT"�!TU=DNIT>=�üW]DNwO�N�ü:9Ü[\NqOWJ;A^<NOM34- 9<=��BCBN!=BJ!NO�T��!T>=BNäþ�9`;�;>^�ü:N!7:9Ü=BS$ü:]DN;- � J�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>= )�� 34- ^<N;U6DOZüWT� - � 2�M

ab]DN)^<T�J;sü:9ÜTU=BO�TAc0ü:]DN�[±;��89<[$CD[ OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüW9<NOJ��9�ü:]37WNwO�ý�NJ�üÀüWT - _ F!+�- P F ��3 ��-�Fk;A=B6 34- cdT>7�ü:]DN�9<=B689<þ�9<68CQ;A^���@J;>OWNO�;>7WN�OW]DT���= 9<= ; 9ÜSUCD7:N ��!QM%-)N7WN3üW]DN�^ÜT8J!;AüW9<T>=BO$TAcbüW]BN�[±;��89<[$CD[ )dý�TUOW9ÜüW9<þ>N12$O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpVæþs;A^<CDN�;>=�VUü:9Ü[\N68CD7:9Ü=DSLü:]DN ���n6D;GV4ý�N!7:9ÜT86æcdT>7qNw;>J�] J!;>OWN±;A7:N�ýB^ÜT>ü�üWNw6�M�ab]DN±^<T8J!;AüW9<T>=BO�T>cÃüW]BN±[\;��89Ü[�CD[�þs;A^<CDNwOIcdT>7�J!;UO�NwO �>F?,DF<!BF� F�;>=B6 ���LcÐ;>^Ü^e9Ü= ü:]DN�K�� O�NwJ�üWTU7M%K)=B68N7�ü:]DN�O�üW7:T>=DS4TUC8ü �QT�� J!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>=QOq7WNýD7:NOWN!=küWNw6æû�VæüW]DNwO�N�J!;>OWNOE)ÐJ�cpM<F�üW]DNüW7�;�HpNJ�üWTU7W9<NOF�cdTU7 J;>OWN=,)OW]DT���=�9<= ; 9<S>CD7:N�/"2�FwüW]DNZ^<T�J;sü:9ÜTU=qcdT>7�;A^<^>ü:]DNZ[\;��89Ü[�CD[ þG;>^ÜCBNO�T�JJ�CD7�;sü üW]BNZO:;A[\NÃ^<T8J!;AüW9<T>=©F9Ü=B6D9<J;süW9<=DSLüW]Q;süq^ÜT8J;süW9<T>=QOI;>7WN\68N!üWN!7:[\9Ü=BN6æûkV�ü:]DN�üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7WüM�ab]DN\^ÜT8J;süW9<T>=QOäT>cÃü:]DN\[\;��89Ü[�CD[ þs;A^<CDNOäcdTU7�J;>OWNO/L;A=B6 &LcÐ;A^<^À9<= ?0F ?L' T>c)Ye]BN HpC )ÐOWN!N ; 9<S>CD7:NE/�cdT>7qü:7:;�HpNJ�üWT>7:9<NO:2�M �á]DN=æü:]DN±ü:7:;�HpNJ�ü:T>7:9ÜNwO�68CD7:9Ü=DS@;�ý�N!7:9<T�6 þs;A7:VS>7:N;sü:^ÜV\ü:]DNq^<T�J;sü:9ÜTU=BObTAc üW]DNq[±;���9<[$CB[ þs;A^<CDNO�689D�0N!7)û�V�OWýQNwJ�9<NO )ÐN>M SBM<FDJ!;UO�N4��2�M

Page 17: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� ��Ë

+

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Alti

tude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E0

2 km

4 km

6 km

8 km

10 km

12 km1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Alti

tude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E0

2 km

4 km

6 km

8 km

10 km

12 km1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Alti

tude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E0

2 km

4 km

6 km

8 km

10 km

12 km1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

����� Ù��BÙ v twrUh��©tu8{|r>ç�xkh:rkz�h�u`tl �\j�lpzW��� �A�A�sv �Uh«ã�xä�«�n��jrk�äo�j!lp�wh��)ÇÀ{�mp�������>��Ulpto*mptwi�mptZ�8t!mnmptwo ��� ¿ }� � ½ }wj!r�� �������I�v trsmptwxUlp��tu8j��GhWl�j�wh����It!�wh:l0�|h��Gh:�����8h��|t�Ç È ��� j�lph �n�Ut�ÇÀr�twr)mp�kh��|h:u<m����Zr�mp�kh©lp{|�w�sm�}�o�j!â>{|oIxUo���{|r�rktlnmp�>ÉÐ�ntwxUmp�)�>{�lph�z:mp{|twrj�lph�xk�nh��$mptI{|�|��xU��mnl�j!mph�mp�kh�z:twrkh:�Ãt!u�{|rUçkxkh�rUz�hw�

Page 18: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

� � y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

+

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Alti

tude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E0

2 km

4 km

6 km

8 km

10 km

12 km1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Alti

tude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E0

2 km

4 km

6 km

8 km

10 km

12 km1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Latit

ude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E

20N

30N

40N

1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

+

Longitude

Alti

tude

90E 100E 110E 120E 130E 140E 150E0

2 km

4 km

6 km

8 km

10 km

12 km1E-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01

����� Ù��BÙ v trkh��ätuÃ{|rUçkxkh�rUz�hqu`tlq�\j!lpz��æ� È �A�wËs��v �Uh«ã�x@���n�Üj!r���o�j�lp�Gh���ÇÀ{�mp� �����>� �Ulpto mpti�mpt±�8tmnmptwo � � ¿ } � ½ }�j!r���������I� �Zr�mp�UhZlp{|�w�sm�}Uo�j!â>{|oIxko ��{|r�rkt!lnmp�UÉÐ�ntwx>mp�\�>{|lph:z:mp{|twr±j�lph�xk�nh���mptI{��|�|xk��mnl�j�mphbmp�kh�z�trkh��Àt!u�{|rUç�xUh�rkz:hw�

Page 19: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� ��Ê

����� Ù����QÙ Å�{�oqhÀ�nh:lp{|h�� tu � �� }Gmp�UhÃjw�!ã«tw{|rsm��nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�mp{|h���t!u��nx>lnu�jz:hetÞ�twrUhZj�mÀv �kh�ã�xqÇÀ{�mp��lph:�ni8h�z:m mpt�i8hWlnmpxUlp��j�mp{|twr�tuB�nxUlnu`jz�h� ¿ �BÅ��kh��ntw�|{����|{|rkh:�Zlph�iUlph:�nh�rsmp�emp�kh��nh�rU�n{|mp{|�A{�m«�\mpt�� ¿ z�twrUz�h�rsmnl�j!mp{|trLj�m)v �kh�ã�xQ}8ÇÀ�U{|��h�mp�khä�Ut!mp�elph�i>lph��nh�rsmb�nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�mp{|h��bmpt� ¿ i8h:lnmpxUlp�kj!mp{|twrU�Àj!mÃh��Gh:ln�$�!lp{Ü�$ÇÀ{|mp�U{|r�mp�kh��>two�j!{�rB�

Page 20: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�!� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

����� Ù�� ��Ù Å�{|oqh��nh:lp{|h���t!u���� ��}�mp�kh�j�!ã«tw{|rsm©�nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{|mp{|h��©t!u��nxUlnu`jz�h�tÞ�twrUh�j!m�v �Uh«ã�x�ÇÀ{�mp�älph��ni8h�zWm0mptZi8h:lnmpx>lp��j�mp{�trIt!u��nxUlnu`jz�h

� ½ �UÅ��kh��ntw�|{��\�|{|rkh���lph�i>lph��nh�rsmp��mp�khb�nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«��mpt � ½ z�twrUz�h�rsmnl�j!mp{|tr±j!mZv �kh�ã�xQ}>ÇÀ�k{|�|hbmp�kh)�>tmp��lph�i>lph��nh�rsmÃ�nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{�mp{�h:�mpt � ½ i8h:lnmpx>lp��j!mp{|trk�Ãj!mÃh��GhWln���lp{���ÇÀ{�mp�k{|r�mp�Uh)�Utwo�j!{|rQ�

Page 21: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� �A�

����� Ù�� �BÙ Å�{|oqh��nh:lp{|h��)tu ������� � }Bmp�khqj�!ã«tw{|rsm)�nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{|mp{|h���tu��nxUlnu�j!z�hqtwÞ:twrkh�j�mIv �kh«ã«x�ÇÀ{�mp�Llph��ni8h�zWm�mpt�i8h:lnmpxUlp�kj!mp{|twr�tu�nx>lnu�j!z�h��������I�AÅ��Uhe�nt�|{Ü���|{|rkh�� lph:iUlph��nh�rsmp��mp�khÃ�nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{|m���mpt ������� z�trkz�h:rAmnl�j�mp{|twr$j!mÃv �Uh«ã�xB}GÇÀ�k{|�|hemp�UhZ�>tmp��lph�iUlph��nh:rAm�nh:rk�n{�mp{|�>{�mp{|h��Àmpt ������� i8h:lnmpx>lp��j!mp{|trk�Ãj!mÃh��GhWln���!lp{���ÇÀ{�mp�k{|r�mp�khb�Utwo�j!{|rQ�

Page 22: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

����� Ù�� �BÙ Å�{|oqhÃ�nhWlp{�h:��t!u ��� � }wmp�khÀj�!ã«tw{|rsm��nh�rU�n{|mp{|�A{�mp{|h�� t!uD�nxUlnu�j!z�hÃtwÞ�trkhÃj!m�v �kh«ã«x�ÇÀ{�mp�Ilph��ni8h�z:m�mpt�i8h:lnmpx>lp��j!mp{|trqtuD�nxUlnu`jz�h� �I�kÅ��khZ�ntw�|{����|{�rUh���lph�iUlph:�nh�rsmp��mp�khZ�nh:rk�n{�mp{|�>{�m��$mpt � �áz�twrUz�h�rsmnl�j!mp{|twr�j!mZv �kh�ã�xQ}AÇÀ�U{��|hbmp�Uh��Ut!mp��lph�iUlph��nh:rAm��nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{|mp{|h��Àmpt� �ái8h:lnmpx>lp��j�mp{�trk�Ãj!mÃh��wh:ln�$�lp{���ÇÀ{�mp�k{|r�mp�Uh��Uto�j{|rQ�

Page 23: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� ���

����� Ù�� ��Ù ÆBtsz�j!mp{|twrU�©tu�mp�Uh o�j!â>{|oIxUo �nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{|m��)ÇÀ{|mp��lph��ni8h�z:m�mptZ�U{��Dh:lph�rsm��ni8h:z�{|h��Àß�z�tw�|tl©�wh:�sh��kàBu`t!l�j�|�B���ez�j!�nh��Àß�{|r��U{|z�j�mph���s��mp�khZz�j�nh)rAxkoä�8h:l�}sÇÀ{�mp� ��� �Ilph�i>lph��nh�rsmp{|rk��z�j!�nhq���GàW�

Page 24: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

��� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

ab]DNe68NýQN=B68N=BJ�NZTAcDü:]DN ��7:N!S>9<T>=QO �AJ�T>=BNO0TAcD9<=��BCBN!=BJ!N�@äT>=�[\N�ü:N!TU7WTU^ÜTUS>9`J!;A^UJ�T>=Q689�ü:9ÜTU=BO�9Ü[\ýD^<V�üW]B;Aü�ü:]DNbJ�T>[\ýDCDüWN6J�T>=BNO�;>7WN�;Aü�[\TUO�üI;UO);>JJ�CD7�;sü:N�;>O�;>7WN�ü:]DN$[\N!üWN!TU7WTU^ÜTUS>9`J!;>^ � N!^`6DOIO�CDýBýD^Ü9<N6Lü:T3ü:]DN$OW9Ü[�CD^<;AüW9<T>=©M � =ÿ;>6B689�ü:9ÜTU=©FDü:]DN!9<7;>J!J!CD7�;>J�V±9`Ob9<[�ýQ;>J�ü:N6Lû�V±üW]BNq=kCB[�N7W9`J!;>^�N!7:7WTU7:OZ9<=�ü:]DN�OWT>^<C8üW9<T>=BObT>c û�TAü:]LüW]DN�cdTU7��b;A7�6�;>=B63ü:]DN�;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�[\T868N!^`OM

����� %S- ��-§�m����#&��#&:&-���#&�>.ab]DNbýD7WN^Ü9<[\9Ü=Q;A7:V$6D;sü�;ä;UOWOW9<[�9<^`;süW9<T>=�üWNwOpü�O��eN7WNbJ�TU=B68CBJ�üWNw6�9<=�üW]DNbü ��9<=�N��8ýQN7W9<[\N!=kü:O cd7�;A[\N��ZT>7 �0Msab]DN�68NO:J�7:9ÜýDüW9<T>=BO;A7:N�;UOZcdT>^<^ÜT��)O�>� �M���K�K�_�KÁ@�_�m�7/ Á >�ab]DN�7:N�cdN7WN=BJ�N±[\T868N^Ã7:CD= Opü�;A7Wü:O�;Aü)y � e � > �"�ÿR�$@a TU=G$@;A7�J�] �O�üF?��9ÜüW] ü:]DN�7:N�cdN7WN=BJ�N9Ü=B9�ü:9<;>^�J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOZT>c ;A^<^�J�]DN[\9<J;A^©OWýQNwJ�9<NOM� ��� 1+�+�"�5�T���&�TÁ>1w�TÁ>�¡�81=1I�� )��£ �$�¥�&�$Á(���Á>���$� > �æNäJ�T>=QO�9`68N!7À;;��]DT>CD7�OÀ;UOWOW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=I��9Ü=Q68T��qM>ab]DN)TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=BO�;>7WNJ�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOZT>c�OWN!^<NJ�üWN6�OWýQNwJ�9<NO � ������ )Ð]DN!7:N;- _ ;A=B6 +�- P 2b;UO�J�TU[�ýBC8üWNw6�ûkV3üW]DN�7:N�cdN7WN=BJ�N�7:CD=©M ú ûQO�N7Wþs;��üW9<T>=BO�;A7:NäýD7:Tsþ�9<6DN6�T>=�;A^<^�S>7:9<6�ýQTU9Ü=kü�O);sübüW]BNqN!=B6LTAc üW]BN�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=E��9<=B68T��Qy � | � � M� P�$�_�$ ��K�Y�K�=1 >�ab]DN�J�TU=Uü:7WTU^�ýB;A7�;A[\N!üWN!7�Ob;A7:N�üW]DNq9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^�J!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BObTAc�OWN!^<NJ�ü:N6�OWýQNwJ�9<NO ��� )&y � 2�)Ð]DN!7:N;- _ T>7+�- P 2�M��� Á������&�T£� //�71=1 >�ab]BN39Ü=B9�ü:9<;>^eþs;A^<CDNwO�TAcbü:]DN�J�TU=küW7:T>^ÃOWýQNwJ�9<NO�;A7:N39Ü=QJ�7:N;>OWN6 û�V ,��('�M�ab]B9<O$ýD7WTsþ�9`68NOqüW]DN ��ûB;UJ:���S>7:T>CD=Q6�@$þs;>^ÜCDNwO � � FL��]D9`J�]�;>7WNICBOWN6�;>Ob9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^�J!T>=B6D9�ü:9ÜTU=BOZcdT>7bü:]DNq9Ü=B9�ü:9<;>^©S>CDNwOWOZ7:CD=©M�� �81I�4�=/ Á>�+�¥�&�$Á>�T£ > $4N;UO�CB7WNwOqüW]BNL689`O�ü:;A=QJ�NLûQN!ü �eNN!= ü:]DNL[�T868N^eýB7WNw689<J�üW9<T>=BO � � ;>=B6 ü:]DN�þs;>^ÜCDNwO � ������ TAc�üW]DNO�N^ÜNwJ�ü:N6LT>ûBOWN!7:þ>Nw6�OWýQNwJ�9<NOFD;>O��ZN!^<^©;>OZü:]DN�68N!þ�9`;sü:9ÜTU=�T>c�J!T>=küW7:T>^0þs;A7:9<;>ûD^<NOecd7WTU[ ü:]DNqûB;>J:��SU7WTUCD=B63O�ü:;AüWN>M

� � � � )&yY�.2 � e �,� ���� � U+X � � � � � �D) � � )~yY��2�z � � � P |

�,�� ���� � U�X � � � � � � � � )~y )92�z � ��� �� )&y )92 � P � )3! ,"2

ab]DNqûB;UJ:�kSU7WTUCD=B63;>=B6L[\N;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü)J�Tsþs;>7W9`;A=BJ!N�[±;sü:7W9`J�NwO�;A7:Nq689<;>S>TU=B;A^«F

� e&6D9<;>S � �¡� e 689<;>S �� ��� )3!0��2

��9�ü:]�Pe �1�"�"��;>=B6��Ve �>F���]D9`J�]�[\N;A=QO<�eNÀüW7:CBOpü�üW]DNÃ[�Nw;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü:O�J�TU=BO�9`68N7:;>ûD^ÜV�[�TU7WNÀüW]B;>=�üW]DNeûB;>J:��S>7:T>CB=B6Opü�;sü:N>M� � �>�¥�� )�����$�¥�&�$Á �$£ Â"�$�I��� �* I> )äCB;UO�9D�nK)N��bü:T>= ^<9<[�9ÜüWNw6 [\N[�TU7WVG45� &�; Rq? � ,.��M�ab]DN�T>ý8ü:9Ü[\9N�;sü:9ÜTU= ýD7:T8J�NN6DO�CD=küW9<^üW]DN�J�TkOpü$cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^Z9`O$7:N68CQJ�N6 üWT �BM �����±T>c)9�ü�O$9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^bþs;A^<CDN>F T>7$üW]DN�=kCB[$û�N!7�TAc�cdT>7 �b;A7�6 �«ûQ;>J:� �Z;>7:6ÿ[\T�6DN!^9Ü=kü:N!S>7�;sü:9ÜTU=BOZN��DJ�NN6DO�� � Ma�T4OW9Ü[\ýD^<9�cdV@üW]DN36D;Aü:;�;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=@ü:NO�ü:OF5�ZN�TU=D^<VÿJ�]DT�TUOWN$ü:]DN±9<=D9�ü:9<;>^�- _ )dT>74+�- P 2äJ!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BO�;>OqJ!T>=L�üW7:T>^ þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwO8��]D9<^<N$ü:]DN�9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^ÀJ!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BO)T>cÃTAü:]DN!7�O�ý�NJ!9ÜNwO�;A7:N �>Ný8ü�;Aüäü:]DN!9<7�7WN!cdN!7:N!=BJ!N$þs;A^<CDNwO!M0ab]D9`OäSU9ÜþUNO

O�TU[�N���]B;süb9`68N;>^Ü9N�!Nw63ü:NO�ü�J!T>=B6D9�ü:9ÜTU=BO!M8ab]DNqJ!T>=küW7:T>^�þs;A7:9<;>ûD^ÜNwO�)d9<=D9�ü:9<;>^©J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOeTAc - _ F�+�- P 2Z;A7:NIýQN7�ü:CD7Wû�N6ûkVE,"�(' cd7:T>[ üW]BN!9<7Z7:N�cdN7WN=BJ�NIþs;A^<CDNOM8ab]DNIT>ûBOWN!7:þ>Nw6\þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwOe;>7WN4- _ ;A=Q6 �GTU71+�- P M � NäcdT>CD=B6�üW]Q;sü�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9Ü=DS- _ TUûBO�N7Wþs;AüW9<T>=BOb;A^<T>=BNIûB7W9<=DSUOb^<9Üü�üW^<N�J�]B;>=DS>NIüWT\9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^�J!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BOZTAc�TAüW]BN!7)OWýQNwJ�9<NOFL��]D9Ü^<N�;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<=DS±O�TU[�NTAüW]BN!7)OWýQNwJ�9<NO�68T�NO)ûD7W9<=DS\CDý4;>6�HpCBOpü:[\N!=kü:ObT>c�OWN!þUN!7�;A^09Ü=B9�ü:9<;>^�J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOM

ab]DN�ý�N!7WcdT>7:[±;A=BJ!N�T>c�ü:]DN46D;sü�; ;UOWOW9<[�9<^`;süW9<T>= ýD7:T�J!N68CB7WN�9<O\[\N;UO�CB7WNw6 û�V üW]BN�X8$ÿ? 6D9 �0N!7:N!=BJ!N�ûQN!ü �eNN!= üW]DN7WN!cdN!7:N!=BJ!N±þG;>^ÜCBNOqT>cZü:]DN�J!T>=küW7:T>^Àþs;>7W9`;AûD^<NOq;>=B6 üW]BN!9<7$þs;A^<CDNO�7WNwJ�Tsþ>N7WNw6ÿû�V 6D;sü�;4;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=©M�ab]DN�X8$ÿ? N!7:7WTU7:OO�]DT���=L9<=+; 9<S>CD7:N � � ;A7:Nq68N � =BN6�;>O

X $æ?�N7W7:T>74e � [±;����� � U+X � � � � � � � W�� W � W � � W� ·�E����� ���� � U+X � � � � � ) � � )~y � 29z � � W�� W � W � � W� 2 P��� ���� � U+X � � � � � �� !

·�E� )3!�!02

ab]DNæ68NwJ�7:N;UO�N@9<=áü:]DN X8$ÿ?áN7W7:T>73T>c$J�TU=Uü:7WTU^�þs;A7:9`;AûD^<N@þs;A^<CDNO�þ>N7:OWCBO\ü:]DN =kCB[$û�N!7LTAc�[\T868N!^I7WCB=BO�6DCD7W9<=DS üW]DNT>ý8ü:9Ü[\9N�;sü:9ÜTU=�ýB7WT8J�Nw68CD7:N�9<O�OW]DT���=L9Ü= ; 9ÜSUCD7:NI� � M;DT>71- _ J�T>=kü:7WTU^Dþs;A7:9<;>ûD^ÜNwO üW]DNäT>ý8ü:9Ü[\9N�;AüW9<T>=±ýD7:T8J�N6DCD7WN�ýB7WT868CBJ!NOÀ;�7:;>ýD9<6\68NwJ�7:N;UO�N�9<=\üW]DNIX $ÿ?�N7W7:T>7wM�$4TUO�üÃT>cüW]DN�9Ü=8cdTU7W[±;AüW9<T>=4J�TU[�NwObcd7:T>[ - _ T>ûBOWN!7:þs;süW9<T>=QO�AB;U6D689ÜüW9<T>=B;>^ +�- P TUûBO�N7Wþs;AüW9<T>=BO�68T�=DTAüäOWN!N[ ü:T3ûD7:9Ü=BS3=DTAü:9<J!N;>ûD^ÜN

ûQN=DN � ü�O!MÀab]B9<O�[±;GV ûQN468CBN�ü:Tæü:]DNL^<;UJ:� TAcäO:J!;>^Ü9<=DSÿ9<=*T>CD7�cdT>7:[$CB^<;AüW9<T>= T>c)üW]DN4J!TUO�ü�cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=Q;A^«MÀab]DNOWN�7:NOWCD^Üü:O9Ü[\ýD^<V�ü:]B;sü)T��!TU=DN�9Ü=D9ÜüW9`;A^ J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BO�9`O�7:NJ!Tsþ>N!7�;AûB^ÜN�üW]D7:T>CDSU]46D;sü�;±;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=©M�;DTU7�J�TU[�ýQ;A7:9<OWT>=#�eNq9<=BJ�^<CB68N�üW]DNT>ý8ü:9Ü[\9N�;sü:9ÜTU=@TAc�ü:]DN\J�TUO�ü�cdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^ ��9�ü:]DT>CDüäü:]DN�ûQ;>J:��S>7:T>CD=Q6�ü:N!7:[ )ÐJ�TU7W7:NOWý�T>=B689<=DS±ü:T�;>=@9Ü= � =D9ÜüWN�ûB;>J:��S>7:T>CB=B6J�Tsþs;A7:9<;>=BJ�N.2�M85�O)N��8ýQNwJ�ü:N6�üW]DNqJ!TUO�ü�cdCD=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=468NJ!7WNw;>OWNOecdCD7WüW]DN7M

Page 25: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� � È

;DT>7 +�- P J!T>=küW7:T>^kþs;A7:9<;>ûD^<NO�üW]DNb68NJ!7WNw;>OWNÃ9<=�ü:]DNZJ!TUO�ü�cdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=©FA;A=B6�9Ü=�üW]DNbX $ÿ?�N!7:7WTU7Fw9`O�=DT>ü�;UO ýD7WTU=DT>CB=BJ�Nw6�;>OüW]B;Aü�cdT>7 - _ MG5)SU;>9Ü=q[\TkOpü�T>c8üW]DNe9Ü=DcdT>7:[\;AüW9<T>=�J!T>[\NO©cdT>7:[ - _ [\Nw;>OWCD7WN[\N!=kü:OF���9ÜüW]$;U6D689ÜüW9<T>=B;>^!+�- P [\Nw;>OWCD7WN[\N!=kü:OJ�T>=kü:7W9<ûDC8ü:9Ü=DS þUN!7:V ^Ü9Üü�ü:^ÜN�ü:Tæü:]DN4T>ýDüW9<[�9N�;AüW9<T>= ýD7WT8J!NO:O!MÀ5)c�üWN!73;>ûQTUC8ü ���æ[\T868N!^�7:CD=BO�ü:]DN@X $ÿ? N!7:7WTU7:O$üWN=B6 üWTOpü�;AS>=Q;süWNUF�N!þUN!=*9�c�üW]BN@J�TUO�ü±cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^�J�TU=küW9<=kCBNO�üWT 6DNJ�7:N;UO�NUM9$�N!7WüWCD7:ûD9<=DSæüW]DN49<=D9ÜüW9`;A^/+7- P J!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU= û�V,��(' 7WNwO�CD^Üü:O\9<= T>=D^<V ; OW[±;A^<^�J�]B;A=BS>NL9Ü=*üW]BN � =B;>^ )dT>ûQO�N7WþUN6F2 - _ J�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>=©MÀab]D9`O±[±;GV û�N4N��8ýD^`;A9<=DN6 û�VüW]DN�cÐ;>J�ü�üW]B;Aü +�- P ^<N!þUN!^`O$;>7WN�6D7W9<þ>N= [�TkOpü:^ÜV û�V N![\9<O:OW9ÜTU=BO!F ;A=B6 ^<NO:O�ûkVæüW]BN�9<=D9�ü:9<;>^ZJ!T>=B6D9�ü:9ÜTU=BO!F ��]D9`J�] ;��0NJ�ü:OüW]DN�T>ûQO�N7Wþs;AûB9Ü^<9�üpV T>c)üW]DN�9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^ +�- P � N!^`6 ü:]D7WTUCDS>] T"�!TU=DNL[�Nw;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü:OM�ab]DN�7:NOWCD^Üü:O�9<=B689`J!;sü:NLüW]B;Aü�cdCD7WüW]BN!7;A^<S>T>7:9ÜüW]D[\9`Je68Nþ>N^ÜTUýD[\N!=kü:O�;A7:NZ=DN!Nw68N6$cdT>7�;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<=DS%+7- P M � =�ýQ;A7WüW9`J�CD^`;A7�;IûQN!ü�üWN7ÀOWJ;A^<9Ü=BSäT>cBüW]BNbJ!TUO�ü�cdCB=BJ�ü:9ÜTU=©FüW]D7:T>CDSU]L;�7:9ÜSUT>7:T>CBOZ68N � =D9ÜüW9<T>=�TAc üW]DN�J!Tsþs;A7:9<;>=BJ�Nä[\;AüW7:9<J!NOF89<O)=DNJ!NO:OW;>7WVUM

� ü�9`O�9<=Uü:N!7:NO�üW9<=DS4ü:Tÿ=DT>üWN±ü:]B;sü�üW]DNL;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:N6 7:NOWCD^�ü�O�9<= üW]BN�J�N=küW7�;A^Ã7:N!SU9ÜTU= ;A7:N�O�9<S>=B9 � J;A=küW^<V ûQN!ü�üWN7$ü:]B;A=üW]DN�T>üW]DN7)7:N!S>9<T>=QO!MBab]BN$68NJ!7WNw;>OWN�TAc�üW]DN�X $ÿ?LN!7:7:T>7)J!;>^<J!CD^`;süWNw6L9Ü=�ü:]DN$J�N=küW7�;A^ � � �+,"�\S>7:9<6Lý�T>9<=kü:O)9`O)ýB^ÜT>ü�üWNw6�9Ü=;�9<S>CB7WN#����;>^ÜTU=DS ��9ÜüW]æüW]B;AüäT>cÀüW]DN\X $ÿ?@N!7:7WTU7äJ;A^`J�CD^`;sü:N649<=@ü:]DN��]BT>^<N�68TU[\;>9Ü=�M0ab]B9<Oä9<OIýD7:T>ûQ;AûD^<V�û�NJ;ACBOWN�üW]DNJ�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>=BOe9Ü=Lü:]DNqJ�N!=kü:7:;>^0OW[±;A^<^�7WNS>9<T>=�ýD7WNw689`J�üWNw6�;AübüW]DN � =B;>^0üW9<[\N�Opü:N!ý�;A7:Nä[\T>7:N�68N!ý�N!=B6DN!=kü)T>=�üW]DNq9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^J�T>=Q689�ü:9ÜTU=@ü:]B;A=ÿüW]DN�ûQTUCD=B6D;>7WV4J!T>=B689ÜüW9<T>=QO!F�OWCBJ�]ÿ;>Oäü:]DN�N���NwJ�ü�TAcÀü:]DN\S>7:T>CD=Q6�N![\9<O:OW9ÜTU=BOITAcÃOWT>[\N�OWý�NJ�9<NOM �á]DN!=ýD9Ü=BýQTU9Ü=küW9<=DS�üW]DN�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=47WNwO�CD^Üü)ü:T�O�ý�NJ!9 � J�^<T�J;sü:9ÜTU=BO!F �eN�;A^`O�T±cdTUCD=B64þUN!7:V�689D�0N!7:N!=kü�cdNw;süWCB7WNwO!M(;DT>7ä9Ü=QOpü�;A=BJ!N>F;�9<S>CB7WN#�./\OW]DT��)O�ü:]DN�ýD7WTUS>7:NO:ObTAcÀü:]DN$7:NJ!Tsþ>N7W9<NO�T>c�üW]DN - _ J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=QO�;sü�Ye]DN HpC ;A=B6æ?�]B;A=BS>]B;>9�M#�á]DN!=ÿüW]DN;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=�üWNO�üIO�üWTUýBO�;Ac�üWN7)üW]BN�J!TUO�ü)cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^�]B;UO)û�N!N=@7WNw68CBJ!N64û�VL[�TU7WN�üW]B;>=4üW]D7:N!N$T>7�68N!7�O�TAcÀ[±;>S>=D9ÜüWCB6DN>FüW]DN - _ ýB7WNw689<J�üW9<T>= ;sü$?�]B;>=DS>]B;>9�[\;Aü:J�]DNwOäüW]DN\N��D;UJ�ü�þG;>^ÜCBN�þUN!7:V��ZN!^<^«F<��]D9<J�]æ9<Oq;>=küW9`J�9<ýB;sü:N6�M<K)=DcdT>7WüWCD=B;AüWN^ÜVUF0üW]DNO�9<[$CD^`;sü:N6'- _ J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=æ;sü$Ye]DN HpC 9<OI=DT>ü�;UOIS>T�T86�F ��9�ü:]@üW]BN�7:N!^`;sü:9ÜþUN$N7W7:T>7IT>=D^<V�7WNw68CBJ!N64cd7:T>['9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^J,"�('üWT �(' ;sü)ü:]DNqN!=Q6�MQab]D9`O�[\9<S>]küäOWCDS>SUNO�üZü:]B;sü�üW]DN�OWCBJ!J!NO:OpcdCB^�;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=��eTUCD^<6L7:N�kCD9<7WNq68N=BOWNqT>ûBOWN!7:þs;süW9<T>=�OW9�ü:NOJ�^<TUOWN�ü:TLüW]DN±9<=küWN!7:NO�ü�;A7:N;�7:;AüW]DN7IüW]B;>= ;>=æCB=D9�cdTU7W[\^<Vÿ689`Opü:7W9<ûDC8ü:N6 =DN!ü �eTU7��0F�;>O�TUCD7�O�V�=küW]BN�üW9`J�T>ûBOWN!7:þs;sü:9ÜTU=æOW9�ü:NO9Ü=B6D9<J;süWNw6�M�� T>7 �3T>=�üW]B9<O)OWCDûLHpNwJ�ü)9`ObT>û�þ�9ÜTUCBOW^ÜV±=DNN68Nw6L9Ü=LüW]BNq=DN;>7bcdC8üWCD7:N>M

Number of Model Runs

Nor

mal

ized

RM

SE

rror

0 5 10 15

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

OBS: O3; CTRL: O3; No background termOBS: O3; CTRL: O3

OBS: O3; CTRL: No2

OBS: O3, NO2; CTRL: O3

OBS: O3, NO2; CTRL: No2

����� Ù����BÙ gbj!m�j@j�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr lph��nxk��mp� �ÀÂZ�±y h:lnlptlp�\t!uämp�Uh3z�twrsmnlptw���j!lp{�j!�k�|h��±j�m�mp�kh�{|rk{�mp{�j�bmp{|oqh@ß�rkt!lpo�j�|{|Þ�h�� �s� mp�kh:{|li>lph:É�j�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr��wj!��xUh���àe�>h�z:lph�j!�nhq�Ux>lp{|rk�qmp�kh�twi>mp{�oq{|Þ�j�mp{|twr�iUlptsz�h��>xUlphw�QyAh��Gh:l�j!�0mph���mp�bj�lph��n�kt�ÇÀr3xk�n{|rU���>{ �DhWlph�rsmbz�trAmnlpt�ßÐv�Å�ÂeÆ0à�j!r���t�k�nh:lp�wh���ß �b��yUà��wj�lp{Üj!�k�|h����

Page 26: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�!� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

Number of Model Runs

RM

Ser

ror(

mol

ecul

es/c

m3 )

0 5 10

1010

1011All grid pointsA subset of grid points

����� Ù�� �BÙ v toqi�j!lp{|�ntr\tu0�Uh�z:lph�j�nh�tu0Âb�±yqh:lnlptlp�Àz�j!�|z�xk��j!mph��$ÇÀ{�mp�\j!���B�lp{��$i8tw{|rsmp�Àjr��${|rkrkhWl È �����!�ätwrUh����kÅ��khb�no�j!���D�nh:mt!u0�!lp{Ü�$i8tw{|rsmp��j!lphZzW�Utw�nh�r$mptä�8hb�Utlp{|Þ�trAm�j!�|�|�$z�h:rAmphWlph��B}A�GhWlnmp{�z�j�|�����nikjrUrk{|rk�)u<lpto �lp{��$�|h��wh��|�À� ��� �>� �b��y � � ¿ }�v�Å�ÂeÆ � � ¿ �

Number of Model Runs

Initi

alO

3C

on

cen

trat

ion

(mo

lecu

les/

cm3)

0 5 101.00E+12

1.05E+12

1.10E+12

1.15E+12

1.20E+12

1.25E+12

1.30E+12

1.35E+12

1.40E+12

Cheju, assimilation resultCheju, referenceShanghai, assimilation resultShanghai, reference

����� Ù�� �DÙ v toqi�j�lp{��ntr�t!u�j!�n�n{�oq{|��j!mp{|tr�lph��nxU�|m�j!m)v �Uh«ã�x�jrk��y>��j!rk���j{��DÂÃh�z�t��Gh:lph��3{|rU{|mp{�j!� � ¿ z�trkz�h�rsmnl�j�mp{�trk��j�lphIiU��t!mnmph��j�mÃh�jz��\{�mph:l�j!mp{|trQ}kÇÀ{�mp��mp�UhZlph:u<h:lph�rkz:h��wj!��xUh��Ãj�|�ntq�n�kt�ÇÀrB� �b��y � � ¿ }8v�Å�ÂeÆ � � ¿ �

Page 27: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� �wË

�æN$J!T>=BJ!^ÜCQ68N ��9ÜüW]@7:NOWCD^Üü:Obcd7:T>[ üW]DN�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=4TAcÀ;\7WNw;A^�6B;sü:;�O�N!üMQab]BN - _ T>ûBOWN!7:þs;sü:9ÜTU=BO)J�TU^Ü^<NJ�üWNw6468CD7:9Ü=DSüW]DNqa�7:;UJ�N�� $ J;A[\ýB;>9ÜSU=3û�V±üW]DN4$ ��� & �Q9ÜSU]UübT>=�$@;A7�J�]+/8F�,��"�F�>F�;A7:NIOW]DT���=39<=+;�9<S>CB7WNI��&�)ÐO kCB;A7:NO:2�M�ab]D9`O�6D;sü�;�OWN�ü9<Oe;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:N6�9Ü=\ü:]DN8��9<=B68T�� ���:�1,�R�$@a T>c $ÿ;A7�J�] /8MUab]DN�9Ü=D9ÜüW9`;A^QT"�T>=DN)J!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=BO�;süe;>^Ü^QS>7:9<6DýQTU9Ü=kü:OÃ;A7:NbüW]DNJ�T>=kü:7WTU^8þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwO!Msab]DN�9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^B[\T868N^DýD7:N689`J�ü:9ÜTU=BOB)7; 9<S>CD7:N ��&BFAO�TU^Ü9`6�^Ü9<=DN12�6DTq=DTAüÀ7:N!ýD7:T868CBJ!N=�ZN!^<^�üW]BN)T>ûBOWN!7:þs;sü:9ÜTU=BO!M5�c�üWN7�;A=Q;A^<V�OW9`OÃü:]DNq[\T868N!^©ýB7WNw689<J�üW9<T>=BO )�6D;>OW]DNw6�^<9<=DN12b;>7WNI9Ü=�N��8J!N!^<^ÜN=kü�;>S>7:N!N[�N=kü���9ÜüW]Lü:]DNqT>ûBOWN!7:þs;sü:9ÜTU=BO!M

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1120

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

Time [GMT hr]

O3 c

on

cen

trat

ion

[p

pb

v]Model − original predictionModel − after data assimilationObservations

����� Ù�� �BÙ gbj!m�j$j�n�n{|oq{|�Üj�mp{|twr�lph:�nxk��mp�Zu`t!l � ¿ }B���!É�� tw�k�nhWlp�wj�mp{�trk�btr��\j!lpz���Ës}Q��w�A�w�QÅ��khä{|rk{�mp{�j��twÞ:twrkhIz�twrUz�h�rsmnl�j!mp{|twrU��j!mj!�|���lp{��>i8tw{|rsmp�ej�lph�mp�khbz�trsmnlptw���j!lp{�j!�k�|h����8Å��Uh)j�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr3{|rsmph:lp�wj!�Q{|�����I�Utwx>lp��� �ZrUhbrkt!mp{�z:h��Ãmp�Uh�h:â>z�h��|�|h�rsmej�lph:h�oqh�rsmÀtump�UhboqtA�Uh:�Qi>lph��U{|z:mp{|twrU��ÇÀ{|mp��mp�khbt�k�nh:lp�j!mp{|twrU��u`tlÃmp�khelpxkr\j�u<mph:lZjrkj���>�n{|���

� �æõÃòäøp�÷���ù�õÃò�����ò�ö��)÷�óD÷)ô� � õÀô�

� = ü:]D9`O\ýB;Aý�N!7M�ZN4689<O:J�CQOWO�ü:]DN@;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü3OWN!=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV ;A=Q;A^<V�OW9`O�T>cäü:]D7:N!N4689<[�N=BOW9ÜTU=B;A^);AüW[\TUOWýD]DN7W9`J3ü:7:;>=BOWýQTU7�ü±;A=B6J�]DN![\9`Opü:7WVæ[�T868N^<OM�5ä6.HpT>9<=kü�[\T868N!^<9<=DS@ýD7:Tsþ>NwOIüWT@û�N�;4ý�T��eN7�cdCB^ÃJ�TU[�ýBC8ü:;AüW9<T>=B;>^ÀüWT�TU^�cdT>7�O�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV O�üWCB689<NO�;>O�eN^Ü^b;>O�cdT>7$9<=küWNS>7�;süW9<=DS@TUûBOWN!7:þG;AüW9<T>=B;>^Ã6D;Aü:;49<=küWT@ü:]DN�[\T868N^e9<= ;�cdTUCD7���689<[\N!=BOW9<T>=B;>^Ãþs;A7:9<;AüW9<T>=B;>^8)3!kH � 6 ;A7 2�6B;sü:;;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU=�ýD7:T8J�Nw68CD7:N>M

5)= Tsþ>N7Wþ�9<N�� T>cäü:]DN@[±;sü:]DN![±;AüW9`J!;A^)üW]DNT>7:V TAcq;>6�HpT>9<=Uü3[\T868N^Ü9<=DS ;AýBýD^Ü9<N6*ü:T J�TU=kþUNJ�üW9<T>=L�n689D��CBOW9<T>=L��7WNw;>J�üW9<T>=[�T868N^<O�TAcD;sü:[\TUOWýD]DN!7:9`J�ýQTU^Ü^<C8ü:;>=kü:O�9`O©SU9ÜþUN!=©M!ab]BNÃJ�TU=Uü:9Ü=�CDTUCBO©;>=B6q689`OWJ!7WN!üWNÀ;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�[�T868N^U;>ýDýD7:TU;>J�]BNO�;A7:N�T>CDüW^<9Ü=DNw6�F;A=B6�cdT>7:[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=BObTAc�üW]DN�cdTU7:J!9Ü=BS�ü:N!7:[±OZcdT>7)689D��N7WN=kü�J�TUO�übcdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^<O);>7WN�689`OWJ!CBO:O�Nw6�M

5�O�;A=�N��D;A[\ýD^<N�TAc�üW]DNq689`OWJ!7WN!üWNq;AýBýD7WTk;>J�] �ZNq689`OWJ!CBOWOZ9<=468N�ü�;A9<^0üW]DNqJ�TU=BO�üW7:CBJ�ü:9ÜTU=�TAc�üW]DN�;U6.HpT>9<=kü�[�T868N^�TAc�üW]DNJ�T>[\ýD7:N!]BN!=BOW9ÜþUN �>H J�]DN![\9`J!;>^8üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7WüÃ[\T�6DN!^�?DaB'J$ M�5)^<S>TU7W9ÜüW]D[\9`J)68N!ü:;A9<^`OÀ9<=BJ�^<CB68N�üW]DNIJ�T>=QOpü:7WCBJ�üW9<T>=\TAc�;U6.HpT>9<=kü:OcdT>7 � =D9ÜüWN\689D��N7WN=BJ�N�üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7Wüä=�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^�OWJ�]BN![\NOI;A=B6@cdT>7qX�TkO�N=kûB7WT8J:�L9Ü=küWNS>7�;sü:T>7�O�cdT>7�O�üW9D� J�]DN![\9`J!;A^ ��9Ü=BN�üW9`J!OM� [�ýB^ÜN[�N=kü:;sü:9ÜTU=3;>OWýQNwJ�ü�OÀ9<=BJ�^<CB689<=DS�ü:]DN)ýB;>7:;>^Ü^<N!^<9N�;sü:9ÜTU=©Fsü:]DN�N �±J!9ÜN=küe689`Opü:7W9<ûDC8ü:N63J�]DNwJ:��ýQTU9Ü=küW9<=DS�O:J�]DN![\NUFU;A=Q6�üW]DNýQN7�cdTU7W[±;A=QJ�N�TAc�üW]DNqýB;>7:;>^Ü^<N!^©;U6.HpT>9<=kü)J�T868Nq;A7:Nq;A^`O�T�ýD7:NOWN!=küWNw6�M

Page 28: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

� � y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

ab]DNÀCBOWNÀTAcD;U6.HpT>9<=kü:O�cdTU7�OWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüpV�;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<O©;>=B6IcdT>7 6D;sü�;);>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=�ýD7:T>ûD^<N![±O©9`O©9<^<^ÜCBO�üW7�;sü:N6�CBOW9<=DS)=�CD[\N!7:9<J;A^O�9<[$CD^`;sü:9ÜTU=BO�T>c8;>9Ü7�ýQTU^Ü^<C8üW9<T>=q9<= 'Ã;UOpü�5äO�9`;DMab]DNÃ;A=Q;A^<V0�N6IýD7:T>ûD^<N![±O©;>7WN�9<=�OWCDýDý�T>7Wü�TAcküW]DNe^<;>7WSUN�a�7�;>J!N�$LN��8ý�N!7:9Ü[\N!=küJ�T>=Q68CBJ�ü:N6L9<=+'e;>O�üb5äO�9`;\9<=�$@;>7:J�] ,������UM;DT>7 O�N=BOW9�ü:9Üþ�9ÜüpV�O�üWCQ689ÜNwO©ü:]DNÀü�;A7:S>N!ü©cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=$9`O�ü:]DNZT"�!TU=DNÃJ!T>=BJ!N!=küW7�;sü:9ÜTU=�;Aü�Ye]DN�HpC � OW^<;>=B6�M � O�TkO�CD7WcÐ;>J!NO�T>cB;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü

þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwOq68N!^<9Ü=BN;sü:N ��9<=��BCDN=BJ�N±7:N!SU9ÜTU=BO�@BF09�M N>M�;>7WNw;>O ��]DN7WN\ý�N!7WüWCD7:ûB;sü:9ÜTU=BO�9<= OWT>[\N±J�TU=BJ�N=küW7�;süW9<T>=QO���9Ü^<^ÀýD7:T868CBJ�NO�9<S>=D9 � J;A=kü)J�]B;A=DSUNOb9<=LüW]D9`O�7:NOWýQTU=BO�NIcdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=Q;A^«MBX�NOWCD^Üü:O)OW]DT�� üW]B;Aü)üW]DNq9<=��BCBN!=BJ!Nq7WNS>9<T>=BO�;>7WN�[\TUO�ü);��0NJ�ü:N6Lû�VüW]DNä[�N!üWNT>7:T>^<T>S>9`J!;>^ � N!^`6DOFU]BT��eNþ>N!7�ü:]DN!V±;>7WN)689 �3J�CD^ÜüÃü:T$ýD7:N6D9<J�üÀcd7WTU[ ü:]DN�[\N!üWN!TU7WTU^ÜTUS>9`J!;>^89Ü=8cdTU7W[±;AüW9<T>=3;A^<T>=BN�68CDNüWT3ü:]DN$9<=��BCBN!=BJ!N$TAc�ü:CD7:ûDCD^<N!=küI689D�0CBO�9<T>=æ;A=B6@J!T>[\ýD^<9<J;sü:N6@J�]DN[\9<J;A^�7:N;UJ�ü:9ÜTU=BO!M�ab]DN$9<=��BCBN!=BJ!N�;A7:N;UO�9<=Uü:N!7�O�NwJ�ü:9Ü=DS68T>[±;A9<=LûQTUCD=B6D;>7W9<NOZ9<=B689`J!;sü:NIüW]B;AübCB=BJ�N7�ü�;A9<=Uü:9ÜNwOb9Ü=Lû�T>CD=B6B;A7:V±þG;>^ÜCBNOb9<[�ýQ;>J�übü:]DNq;>J!J!CD7�;>J�V±T>c�T��!T>=BNäýD7:N6D9<J�üW9<T>=BO;sü�Ye]DN HpC � OW^<;>=B6�M�ab]DN3J!T>=DNwOäT>ce9<=��BCDN=BJ�NUF�68N � =DN6æû�V@9`O�TkO�CD7WcÐ;>J!NOäTAceüW]DN\ü:9Ü[\N\9Ü=kü:N!S>7�;A^�T>cZ;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�OWN!=BOW9ÜüW9<þk9ÜüW9<NOF;A7:NICQO�N!cdCD^�üWT±;>=B;A^<V �!NIüW]DN�J!T>[\ýD^<N���T��!TU=DNäýB7WT868CBJ�üW9<T>=4;A=Q63ü:7:;>=BO�ý�T>7Wü�ýD7:T�J!NO:O�NwO!M

ab]DN � 7�Opü�OWN�ü�TAc�6D;sü�; ;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU= N��8ýQN7W9<[\N!=kü:O�;A7:N@J�TU=B68CBJ�üWN6*9<=áüW]BN4ü ��9Ü=áN��8ýQN7W9<[\N!=kü3cd7�;A[\N��ZT>7 �0M �æNJ�T>=QO�9`68N!7�O�Nþ>N7:;>^ÃOWJ!N!=B;>7W9<TUOF<��9ÜüW] ü:]DN�J!T>=küW7:T>^eþG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜNwOqûQN9Ü=BS'- _ T>7 +�- P F�;A=B6 ü:]DN�TUûBOWN!7:þ>N6 þs;A7:9`;AûD^<NOqû�N!9<=DS- _ ;A=B6 �sT>7;+7- P M�ab]DN�ýQN7�cdTU7W[±;>=BJ�N±T>c�üW]DNL6D;sü�;@;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU= ýD7WT8J!N68CD7:N39`O�[\N;UO�CB7WNw6 ûkVæü �ZT@9Ü=Q689<J;sü:T>7�O!F�üW]DNJ�TUO�übcdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=�þs;A^<CDNq;A=B6�üW]DN�X8$ÿ?3N7W7:T>7bT>c J�TU=küW7:T>^0þs;A7:9<;>ûD^ÜNwO!M8ab]DN�9<=D9ÜüW9`;A^ - _ J�TU=Uü:7WTU^0þG;>7W9`;AûB^ÜN�J!;>=�û�Nq7WNwJ�TsþUN!7:N6=D9<J!N!^<V$cd7:T>[Ý[\N;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü�O�üW]D7:T>CBS>] !UH8� 6 ;>7Ã6D;Aü:;q;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüW9<T>=©M>ab]BN)7WNwJ�TsþUN!7:VqTAc�üW]DNä9Ü=D9ÜüW9`;A^:+�- P J�TU=BJ�N=Uü:7:;AüW9<T>=BO9<O�[\TU7WN�689 �±J!CD^ÜüFBýB7WNwO�CD[±;>ûD^ÜV3üW]DN�cÐ;UJ�übüW]B;Aü�+�- P ^ÜNþ>N!^`O�;A7:Nq687:9ÜþUN!=L[�TkOpü:^ÜV�ûkV�N![\9<O:OW9ÜTU=BO!M

$À7:N!^<9Ü[\9<=B;A7:Vÿ7:NOWCD^Üü:O$cd7WTU[ üW]DN�;>O:O�9<[\9Ü^`;sü:9ÜTU= TAc�7:N;>^e6D;Aü:;@cd7WTU[+ü:]DN�a�7�;>J!N�� $ J!;>[�ýQ;A9<S>= ;>7WN3ýB7WNwO�N=Uü:N6�M�ab]DNN��DJ�N^Ü^<N!=küq;AS>7:N!N[\N!=küäT>cÃ[\T�6DN!^�ýD7:N689`J�ü:9ÜTU=BO ��9�ü:]æTUûBO�N7Wþs;AüW9<T>=BOI;sc�ü:N!7q;A=B;>^ÜV8OW9<OIJ�TU=BO�üW9ÜüWC8ü:NO�;A=DT>üW]DN7äþs;>^Ü9`6D;sü:9ÜTU=ÿT>cüW]DN�J!T>[\ýDC8ü�;süW9<T>=Q;A^0üWT�TU^<O�689`O:J�CBO:O�Nw6�9<=LüW]DNqýQ;Aý�N!7wM;DC8ü:CD7WNC�eTU7��G��9<^<^)cdT8J�CBO3T>=&J�TU=küW9<=kCB9Ü=DS ü:]DNÿ68Nþ>N^ÜTUýD[\N!=kü3TAcq;A^<S>TU7W9ÜüW]D[\9`J4;A=B6 OWTAc�ü �b;A7:N�9Ü=8cd7�;>O�üW7:CBJ�üWCD7:N�cdT>7

;>6.HpTU9Ü=kü�[\T868N!^<9<=DS)TAcBJ!T>[\ýD7:N!]DN=BOW9ÜþUNÀJ�]DN![\9`J!;A^>üW7�;A=BOWý�T>7Wü©[�T868N^<O�A;>=B6qTU=qCBO�9<=DS�ü:]D9`O�J�TU[\ýDC8ü:;AüW9<T>=B;>^>9<=8cd7�;>O�üW7:CBJ�ü:CD7WNüWT37:CD=�[\T>7:N�J�T>[\ýD^<N���üWNwOpü�O�;A=Q6LüWT3;>O:OW9Ü[\9<^<;AüWNq7:N;A^�[�Nw;>OWCD7:N![\N!=kü:O�6B;sü:;BMBab]DNqcdCB=B6D;A[\N=Uü�;A^�S>TU;>^�TAc�üW]B9<O8�eTU7��39`OüWT�N!=B;>ûD^ÜNäüW]BN�;UOWOW9<[�9<^`;süW9<T>=�TAc�J�]BN![\9<J;A^�6D;Aü:;�;GþG;>9Ü^`;AûB^ÜN�cd7WTU[ S>7:T>CD=B6©Fk;>9Ü7:ýD^`;A=DNUF�;>=B6�O:;sü:N!^<^Ü9ÜüWNI[\N;UO�CD7:N![\N=Uü�OÃ9<=küWTüW]DNq[\T868N!^`OM

�áø� �ò)õ��� ��ö��9��� ��òeó��

ab]DN$;ACDüW]DTU7:O)üW]B;>=���ü:]DN�Kä;sü:9ÜTU=B;A^�?DJ�9<N!=BJ!N;DTUCD=B6D;AüW9<T>=�cdTU7äOWCDýDý�T>7WüW9<=DS±üW]B9<O8�eTU7���üW]D7:T>CDSU]�üW]DN�;.�Z;>7:6LKä?�; � a�X5�$�� � $ ��,�� � �"�"&DM©ab]BN#�ZT>7 �æT>cä5�MÀ?8;>=B68CG�b;>O�;A^`OWT@ýB;A7WüW9`;A^<^<V OWCDýDý�T>7WüWNw6 û�V üW]DN�;.�Z;>7:6 KI?L; YZ5�X8'J'ÃX 5�Y ��"� �����1� �DM!�æNqSU7:;AüWN!cdCD^Ü^<V�;UJ:�k=BT���^ÜNw68S>NäüW]DNq[\TkOpü�CBOWN�cdCD^�J�T>[\[\N!=kü�OZcd7WTU[ üW]DN�;>=DT>=�V�[\T>CBOZ7:N!þ�9<N��ZN!7�O!M

��� � ��ô���ò�ø � ��w�)�)� ÄÀ� ��ln�>�ntwr j!r����ä� É«ve���Zt>� �Ãikik�|{|h�� �Zi>mp{|o�j�ev twrsmnlptw��� �Zi>mp{|oq{�Þ�j!mp{|twrB}�Ä©��mp{|o�j!mp{|twrB}�jrk� v twrsmnlpt�d��� ���������� ��

������� ����� ��!#"%$'&(�)�*&(��+(,-��&(!U}/.4j!�n�k{|rk�!mptwrQ}Ug)ve}B��ÊwË È ��A��Â)�>���Al��B}>�0�UÆQxB}>jrk� U�>åetsz�h��kj!���©� �|{|oq{�mph���oqh�oqtln��j!�|�wtlp{�mp�Uo u`t!le�8txkrk��z:twrk��mnl�j!{|rkh��$twiUmp{|oq{|Þ�j�mp{�trQ��0 1�24365*780/9:�)70�,)+(,;7�$'&(�<� � ,;7�}B���>ß È à �|�w��Êw� �����!� � }���ÊwÊ È ��>��gä�sÁä�sv�jz�xUz�{��By>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«��mp�kh:tln��u`tl�rktrk�|{|rkh�j�l ���>��mph�oq���!���GåZtrk�|{|rkh�j�l�u<xkrUz:mp{|twr�j!��j!r�j���>�n{|� j!iki>lptGjz��Q�=5*7�3>+?,@��7 � � A?�:7�}�� � �wË!Ê� �>� � �G�s}���Ê � �w��U��gä�AÁä�>v�j!z�xkz�{��0y>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«�ämp�kh�t!ln�Iu<tl�rUtwrU��{|rUh�j!l ���U��mph:oq���s�n�W�GÄ©âAmph�rU�n{�trk��mptäj�k�>{|mp{|tr�j�kz���j�n�nh���t!uBlph:�ni8twrk�nh:����5*7/3>+(,@��7� � A?�:7�}8�� � � � ��� �>� � ���s}���Ê � ��

È ��Áä� Â)�!v�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}!���!y>jr��>xQ} � � �)�!�0tmnl�jA}!jr��b~���g�j!oq{Üj!rUÉÐ�«t!l��kj!zW�Uhw�syAh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{�m«�)�Ãr�j���>�n{|�Qu<tl©��mpoqtw�niU�kh:lp{|z�v �kh:oq{���mnln���tA�>h��|�e�A{�jI�ÃxUmpto�j!mp{|zbgb{��Dh:lph�rsmp{�j!mp{|trQ��2�,-�B&(������ � ��9DCE!�FG����&(!��H !�,�}��>�wß~�Gà � �sË È �s� � ÊA}���ÊwÊwËA��>��Áä� Â)�sv�j�lpoq{|zW�kjh���}?�I�wÅ0jrU�U}GÁä�JI)j!l�j�m�j>}�W��ZrUtU}gI�wyAmnlph�h:mp��}åä�wÅ��ktrk��8tstwrkz��ktst>}�U� ���(.LtstU}Ay8�wÁZxUmp{|�Axkr��Uj>}���?. �U{|mph}ÅZ� .�jrk�>}kgä� Â)�>� ��j�whw}�Ä��k��mp��j!��}k�)� �Ulp{|h��B}U�e�k�0tmnmph:l�}k��� ���k�e�wh:ln�s}>Áä� . ��yUjz��k�nh}�y8� ÅZ�8y>jr��>�kt��o\}#�ä�*I�twr��>tU}>Â)� .*�Å�j�|�8tm�}Q���B� jr��A�s}DgI�BÅ��kt!lprsmptwrQ}Bj!r������ gI�Qv ��j!lp�whw�IÂÃh��{�tr�j!�|É«yAz�j�|h�v �Uh�oq{|z�j��ÅQl�j!rk�ni8tlnm)��tA�Uh��|{|rk�\{|rLy>xUiki8tlnmZtump�Uh��erkj���>�n{|�Ãt!u �Z�k�nhWlp�wj�mp{�trk�Àtw�>m�j{|rkh���gbxUlp{|rU�ämp�kh)ÅBl�jz�h:É��æÄ©â>i8h:lp{|oqh�rsm��E5*7LK��& ���#A(�:7=MN �:7�}U{�r�iUlph��n��}�����U�

ËA�D.*� �0� Æ��©v�j!lnmph:l��3��oqik�|h�oqh�rsm�j!mp{|trLtuÀmp�Uh$�pj!iUlpz:É�ÊÊ3z��kh:oq{�z�j� oqh:zW�kjrk{|�no {|rsmpt\mp�kh�oqtA�Uh��|��É���u<l�j!oqh:Ç�t!lp�8��Å�h�z��krk{|z�j!�lph:i8tlnm�}U�Zrk{�mph���yAm�j�mph��ÃÄ�rA�A{�lptwrkoqh:rAm�j!�D�©lpt!mph�z:mp{|twr3�Ã�wh�rUz:�s} GjrAxkj!ln�\��w��>�� ��gä� å�� gbjh��nz�xB}�Áä� Â)�Àv�j�lpoq{�z���j!h���}�j!r�� �)��y>jr��>xQ� �Z��ã�t{�rsm$�«oqiU�|h�oqh�rsm�j!mp{|twrÿtu)ÂÃtw�nh:r>�>lptszW� ��h:mp�UtA�U�$�eiUik�|{|h��æmpt~�j!lp{�j�mp{�tr�j!��g�j�m�j��e�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr±��lptw�U�|h�oq���N5 & � � !/+ � &�OP$'&(�4� � ,)+(,-��&(!/+ �Q� � A?�R��9:�p}���� È � �GÊ� � È ���A}��!�w��>�Ê>��gä� å��Gg�j!h��nz�xB}>���Ay>jrk�UxQ}Gjrk��Áä� Â)�>v�j!lpoq{|z���j!h����QgZ{|lph:z:m�j!r���jw��ã�tw{|rsm��nh:rk�n{�mp{|�>{�m���jrkj���>�n{�� tuBzW�Uh�oq{|z�j�k�>{|rUh:mp{|ze���>��mph�oq�ÇÀ{�mp�SI)��� �k�n� ��rAxkoqh:lp{|z�j!�B�j�|{��kj�mp{|twr±j!r��\j!ikik�|{|z�j�mp{�trk���E2�,-�B&(������ � ��9DCE!�FG����&(!��H !�,�} �GË�� È �wÊwË � È �w�:�U}0�����>�

Page 29: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� �Ê

���>��gä� å���g�j!h��nz�xQ�GÅ��kh�t!lph:mp{|z�j�>j!r�����l�jz:mp{|z�j!�U�Ã�ni8h�z:mp�QtuUg�j!m�jÃ�e�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr�u`t!l©�e{�l0�0tw�|�|xUmp{|twrI��tA�Uh��|��� � ��7���7�� �@� �: � ,)+(,-��&(!�@! 2��J� � �)�� +?!��%$'&(�<� � ,)+(,-�-&(!Q+ � 3>+(,@�� �P+(,-��9:�p}kmp�Uh��Zrk{|�GhWlp�n{|m���tu©��t�Ç�j>}����>�w�

��w��~��8g�j!oq{Üj!rQ}D�)�ByUj!r��>xQ}B���Dg�j!oq{�jrQ} � �8�0tmnl�j>}Qj!r���Áä� Â��Qv�j�lpoq{�z���j!h����)Å��khä�A{�rUh:mp{|zIi>lph�iUlptsz�h:�n�ntl��Aiki ��j��ntu<m�Ç�j�lphh:r>�A{�lptwrUoqh�rsm u<tle�ntw�|�A{�rU�qzW�Uh�oq{|z�j�D�A{|rkh:mp{|z������R$'&(�4� � ,; � ��+(!�� $ �� � ��9R+ � CE!#"(��! R � ��! "�}D�!� �|� È �GË ��� È ËÊA}0�!�w�w�A����A�)�)� ����gbxkrU�Gh:l�}�Áä�=��j�lnÇ�tstA�D} U� ��� �elnmpo�j!rkrB}�jrk�@Áä� ���'. {��|�ntrQ�@v toqi�j�lp{��ntr@tue�ntwxUlpz:h�j!iki8tw{|rsmpoqh�rsmIjr����ntxUlpz�h�nh:rk�n{�mp{|�>{�m��\tu�twÞ:twrkhä{|r3j�mp�>lph�h:É��U{|oqh�rU�n{�tr�j!�0j{�l)Úsxkj�|{�m«�\oqtA�>h����<CE!�FG����&(!��H !�,)+ � 0Q9:�) !/9 P+?!���� �9 � !/& � &R"(A!}>��>}Q�!Ê È ��É�!Êw�!�U}D�!�w�w�

� �>�)�)� ���gZxkrk�wh:l�}wÁä�?� j!lnÇ tstA�B} U� ����elnmpo�jrUrQ}!j!r���Áä� ���?. {|�|�ntwrQ��Å��kh��>h�z�txkik�|h��ä�U{�lph�z:m©oqhWmp�ktA��u`tl��nh�rU�n{|mp{|�A{�m«�äjrkj���>�n{|�{|r±jImp�>lph�h:É��U{|oqh�rU�n{|twr�j!�0j!{|lZÚsx�j!��{�m���oqtA�>h��BÉ {|oqik�|h�oqh�rsm�j!mp{|trQ}Ujz�z:xUl�jzW�s}8jrk�\h:Ûqz�{|h�rUz:�s�NC�!�FG�@��&(!��H !�,)+ � 0Q9:�) !/9 P+(!���QR9 �#!Q& � &R"(A!} ��>}D�!Êw� È É«�ÊwË�>}Q�!�w�w�A��:�U������Ä©�|�8h:lpr j!r�� ����yAzW�Uoq{Ü�Am�� �Ý�gZÉÐ~ j�l�zW�Uh�oq{|��mnln� �Uj!m�j4j!�n�n{�oq{|��j!mp{|tr �nz��kh:oqh�u`t!l\Ä©xk�|h:lp{�jr z��kh:oq{���mnln�@mnl�j!rk�ni8tlnmoqtA�>h��|{|rk�U�N5 & � � !Q+ � &�OBK��& ��� A?�R��9R+ � MN �:R+?��9 �A}0����Uß È à �|� � } È � � ��� � } È Ê � }���ÊwÊwÊA�� È �����Ä��|�8h:lprIjr����ä�yAzW�Uoq{Ü�Am�� �ZÞ�twrUh�h�iU{��ntA�>hÀjrkj���>�n{��©�s�)�wgeÉ�~�j!l0zW�Uh�oq{|��mnln���kj!m�jej�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twrB�=5 & � � !Q+ � &�ODK��& ��� A?�R��9R+ �MN �:�+(��9 �A}����w�>ß�gb�sà � � È �wÊ �T� È Êw�A}��!�w�A�w����>�����>Ä��|�8h:lprB}A�ä�UyAzW�Uoq{Ü�Am�}sj!r��$���>Ä©�8h����0~�j!lp{�j!mp{|twrkj�B�kj�m�jIj!�n�n{�oq{|��j!mp{|tr�u`t!l�mnlptwi8t�nik�khWlp{�zZzW�Uh�oq{|��mnln��oqtA�Uh:��{|rU�U��5 & � � !Q+ �& OBKNR& ��� A?� �-9 + � M� �:�+(��9 �A}0���w�>ß�gI� �Gà �|� È } Êw�GË ��� È } Ê �wÈ } ��ÊwÊGËs���ËA�����DÄ©���8hWlprQ}8���By>z��koq{��>m�}�jrk�±���DÄ©�8h����b��oqik�|h�oqh�rsm�j!mp{|tr\tu j$ikj!l�j!���|h����gZÉÐ~ j�lbz��kh�oq{|��mnln���kj�m�j�j!�n�n{�oq{|��j!mp{|tr��nz��kh�oqh�C�!�FG�@��&(!��H !�,)+ � 3>+(!/+G"# �H !�,N+(!��P���+ � ,@�A}���� � ���� �A�!�w�>}©��ÊwÊÊ>�� � ������Ä©�|�8h:lprQ}U�ä�8y>z��koq{��>m�} �ä�kÅ0j!�Üj!�l�j!r��B}8jr������kÄ��8h���� �wgZÉÐ�j!lp{�j!mp{|twrkj���kj!m�jIj�n�n{|oq{|�Üj�mp{|twr±ÇÀ{�mp�3jr±j�!ã�t{|rAmZj{�lZÚsx�j�|{�m«�oqtA�>h��8u`t!leh:oq{��n�n{|tr3jr�j!���U�n{|���LC�!�FG����&(!��B !�,)+ � 3 & �# � ��! "H+(!��H0/&�O ,���+(�RW}Q� È � È �wÊ � È � � }����w�A���Ê>�M�ä�GÄ©lnlphWl�j�jr���gä� �ktrAmphW�UrB� �ktxUlnÉ��U{|oqh�rU�n{|twr�j!�U�j!lp{�j�mp{�tr�j!��zW�Uh�oq{|z�j�kj�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr�tu�v ÂÃ�ny>Å0� ��mnl�j!mpt�nik�Uh:lp{|zeoqh�j!�nxUlph:Éoqh:rAmp����5 & � � !/+ � &�OPK��& �*� A(�R��9R+ � M� �:�+(��9 �s}����w�>ß�gI�w��à �|���w� È � ������� È }©�!�w�A�w��!�>��Áä�BÄ©�Gh�rU�nh�rQ���Z�U�jrUz�h��±�Uj!m�j$j�n�n{|oq{|�Üj�mp{|twr�u<tl)��mnlptrk�w���3rUtwrUÉÐ�|{|rkh�j�l)�>�>rkjoq{|z�����3 &(!�,@� � A��%�+(,@�� ��M� FG�����}Q� È �|�I�!�s� �� � È �U}���ÊwÊwËA��s�w����� �0{��n�Uh:l�j!r��\gI� U�BÆQj!ln�s� Æ�j�!l�jrU�w{�jr3u`txUlnÉ��U{|oqh�rU�n{�tr�j!�0�wj�lp{�j!mp{|twrkj�©�kj�m�j�j�n�n{|oq{|�Üj�mp{|twr�tu�zW�Uh�oq{|z�j�Q�ni8h�z�{|h������N7 5*7M 7 3 ,;�&(��& � &R"(A}����A���|��� � � �k��Ë�!�U}���ÊÊ È ���A�D.*�L. ���Zj�h:l�� ÂexUrk�whWÉ;I�x>mnm�jLoqh:mp�UtA�U�${�r tiUmp{|o�j�ez�twrsmnlpt��jrk� mp�Uh±mnl�jrk��u<tlpoqh�� j�!ã«tw{|rsm\���>��mph�o\��� � �B � �@�:9 ��3 +(,@�� �B+?,-���!} � Ë>ßÐ�wà � ���sË �A� � �A}����w�>��+�>��ve�U�Ztoqh��nz�x�jr��$�W� ���Uåbj��GtwrB� �ZiUmp{|o�j�Qv trAmnlpt��t!u �0�|t�Ç ÇÀ{�mp�\gb{|�nz�trAmp{|rAxk{�mp{|h�����5 & � � !Q+ � &�OP$'&(�<� � ,)+(,-�-&(!Q+ �Q� � A?�R��9:�p}� � Ë�� ��w� �A� � �A}������A����U��gä��Æ�jrU�nh:l�j!r�� U� Áä��~�h:lnÇ h:l��ÿ�erkj���>�n{��Itubti8h:l�j!mpt!l��nik�|{�mnmp{|rk�3u`tl$j�U�Gh:z:mp{|twrUÉ��>{ �DxU�n{|twrUÉdlph�j!z:mp{|twrÿiUlpt�k�|h�oq�IuÜlptwo"j!{�li8t�|��x>mp{|twr\oqtA�>h��|{�rU�U��$� !�,-� � � F?&G&(��� ����� � !��J ! 1 !GO:&(� �P+(,-��9R+ M�;�*&(� ,0�\�byAÉÐÂeÊ � � È }Q��ÊÊ � �� È �)�)�B�bj�joq{�j!r��B}���� ÅZ� �b�>o�jrLjr������ Áä�QÂexU�n�nh��|�d���Z{|��UÉÐtl��>h:l�}0�>{�lph�z:m��nh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{�m«�Ljr�j!���U�n{|��tu�oäxk��mp{��U{|oqh�rU�n{�tr�j!��j!{�lÚsxkj�|{�m«�$oqtA�Uh��|����C�!�FG����&(!��B !�,)+ � 0Q9:�) !/9 �+(!���� �9 � !/& � &R"(A} �GË>ß����à � �!��s� �>�!� È �s}��!�w���A��!�>��y8���Zhw} Áä� Â���v�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}��e���Zt!mpzW�U�A{��n�$�)��y>jrk�UxQ}�j!r��ÿ~ä��g�joq{�j!rUÉÐ�«t!l��kjz��kh� �eiUik�|{|z�j!mp{|twrætu)�Ãgb� � �Z u`tl��Ã{|l�0t�|��x>mp{|twr3��tA�>h���yAh�rk�n{�mp{|�A{|m���yAmpx��>{|h�����CE!�FG����&?!��H !�,)+ � 3>& �J � ��! "H+(!��B0Q& O ,���+(�RW}Q� È � È �GÊ � ÈwÈ ËA}����w�>��ËA�)�0� Æ��B�etwxUmph:�wj!oqh:l)jrk����� Æ©����{�mpz��kh��|����g�j�m�j\j�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr�xU�n{|rk�±j!r�Ä©rk�nh�oä�k�|hPI)j�|o�j!r �0{|��mph:läÅ�h�z��krk{�Úsxkh� 3>&(!�,@� � A�S�+(,@�� �DMN FG�)��©}Q����Uß~�wà � ËÊw� � � �w�w}©��ÊwÊ � �� � �D.*� ���G�exkr��>�p�Ut!lnu`h:l jrk�U� Áä�A~�h:lnÇ h:l���� � �B � �-9 + � 0Q& � � ,-��&(!S&�O��=�@�H����;�� !��J !�, 2��(F(�9:,-��&(! ���D� ! � �R��&?!���M��+J9:,-��&?!SC#" � +$�,-�-&(!��p} 0 �/� ��! "# ��0Q � �) �<��! $'&(�<� � ,)+?,-��&(!Q+ � 3>+(,@�� �P+(,-��9:�p}�~�tw���"���A��yAiUlp{|rk�h:lÃ~�hWlp�Üj!�U}������>�

�!Ê>��gä�©�eÇ�j!rk�>}©gI� . �����>xkrQ}�jr��æ��� ÅZ� �b�>o�jrB�@�erÿjx>mptwo�j�mp{�z��U{��Dh:lph�rsmp{�j!mp{|træmph�z��krU{ÜÚsxUh$u<tl��nh�rU�n{|mp{|�A{�m«�ÿj!r�j���>�n{|�qturAxUoqh:lp{|z�j�Bjw�>�Gh�z:mp{|tr��nz��kh�oqh��À{|r\j!{�lbÚsx�j!�|{|m��$oqtA�Uh��|���L2�,-�B&?�)�*�� � �-9 CE!�FG����&?!��H !�,�} �A�Gßd�Gà � � ËÊ � � ��� }©��ÊÊGËA���>�)�)� �ä� GjÞWÇÀ{�rU�n�A{d��0�,)&G9 �*+(�R,-��9 � ��&G9 � �: ��+(!��&%�� � ,; � ��!#"'�8���&(� A���Ãz�jw�>h�oq{|z��©lph:�n��}���ÊwË�A��A�w��Â)� ÄÀ� I)j!�|o�jrQ�Q� rkh:Ç jiki>lptGj!zW�qmpt���{|rUh�j!l�èk�|mphWlp{�rU�Ij!r��qiUlph��U{|z:mp{|twr$iUlpt�k�|h�oq���(����+(!��:7 2D0 3 C*) 0 ��7+��,85*7+-4+?� �-94C�! "#7|}� � � Ê È ����� � }���Êw��>��w�A�)�Ã�s~ä�#I��kj!mnm�j�mpt!�8} U� ve��ÁZ{|�|�|hw}>Æ�� ~��AÆB��ãnj!�8}>Áä� ���s��l�j�n�nh�x>l�}>~ä� Æ��sgZ�Gtlnmp�nt��8}s�)� Ä��sÂÃtszW�Uhw}Aj!r�� U�J.�j��mph:lp���Q�e�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twrt!uDik�Utmptsz��kh�oq{|z�j!�����Ijz:mp{|�GhÀ�ni8h�z:{�h:� j!r���jbz�j!�nhÃjr�j!���U�n{|��tuB�b�ÃÂby)�kj�m�j>� 5 & � � !Q+ � &�O K��& ��� A?�R��9R+ � M� �:�+(��9 �A}8���!� �|� � ËA� È �� � Ë+�GËA}���ÊwÊÊ>����>����h:r>x>mäÆ��|}0~�jx>m�j!l��LÂ)�|}�� h�h:�>o�j!rkr�����}�jr����ZtwrUtl�ve��y>h:rk�n{�mp{|�>{�m��Lt!uÀik�kt!mptszW�Uh�oq{|z�j��i8tw�|�|xUmp{|twr4xU�n{|rk�\mp�kh�j�!ã«tw{|rsmt!u©jä�n{|oqiU��{�èkh���z��kh�oq{|��mnln�AÉdmnl�jrU�ni8tlnm�oqtA�>h����N5 & � � !/+ � &�OPK��& ��� A?�R��9R+ � MN ���+(��9 ���'2�,-�P&(������ �� ��}���� È ÉÐgI���Aß�� È à �|� È } �GË!Ê �� È } �G�w�A}B�!�w��>��!�U��Â)�>g�j�|h:�s�L2�,-�P&(������ � ��9���+(,)+B2�!/+ � A(�R���p��v�j!oI�Ulp{��>�wh��ZrU{|�Gh:lp�n{�m«����lph��n��}���ÊwÊ>��� È �/.0�kÆQ{0j!r������ ����åbj��GtrQ� �ZiUmp{|o�j!��{�m���t!u©�wgZÉÐ~�j!lÃjrk��{�mp�Ãlph:�Üj�mp{|twrk�n�U{|i\ÇÀ{|mp�\mp�Uh I)j�|o�jr�è���mph:lejrk� I)j�|o�jr��noqtstmp�khWl���N7 5*7 M 7 3 ,;�&(��& � 7 0/&G9 7�}Q���wËAß È Ëw�IÉ���j!lnme��à � ��>� �s� � �U}Q���>����>��Áä� ���8�\j�lpzW�Axk�8�L2#�10G&(��!�, C#" � +(,-��&(!���+(!�� 2�!Q+ � A(�R����& OB$'&?�<� � �2B0�A?� ,; ���p�LI��|xsÇ�h:le�Ãz�jw�>h�oq{|z���xU�k�|{|�n�kh:lp��}B��ÊÊ È ��wËA��Áä� ���D�\j!lpz��Axk�8}k��� ~��8�e�tw�n�U�Gt��D}�jrk���W� ~ä�8y>�AxUm��Ajh:�D��2#�10G&(��!�,'C#" � +?,-��&(!���+?!�� � � , � � � +(,-��&(! 2 � "J&(� �@,@� � � ��!3� &(! � ��!Q�+(�� ��& ��� � �p� v ÂÃv ��lph��n��}Q��ÊwÊ�>�� � ��Â)�U��h�rkj!l��B}Uy8� ÄÀ�kv tw�UrQ}UÆ�� É��0�Uv ��j!rk�U}Uj!r��$��� ���UÆB�>��mph:l���yAmnl�j�mptw�nik�Uh:lp{|z�j�n�n{|oq{|��j!mp{|twr�tu�zW�Uh�oq{|z�j�8mnl�jz:h:l�tw�U�nh:lp�j!mp{|twrU�xU�n{|rk�qj I)j!�|o�jr�èk��mph:l�����j�lnmÃ� � �ktlpoäxk��j!mp{|trQ�L3>&(!�,@� � A4�%�+(,@�� �<M� FG�)��©}Q��� � � �� È ���A��GËs�w}0���w�>�

Page 30: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�� y>jrk�UxQ}>g�j!h��nz�xB}Dv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}8v �kj{

�Ê>�)�0�k��{|h��kh}��)�UyUjrk�UxB}UÁä� Â)��v�j!lpoq{|zW�kjh���}*�I�>Å0j!rk�>}�j!r���gä�Ag�jh��nz:xQ��� z�twoqoäxkrk{|z�j�mp{|twr$��{|�>l�j!ln��u`t!lÃmp�UhZikj!l�j�|�|h��|{|Þ�j!mp{|trt!u©j{�lZÚsx�j�|{�m«�$oqtA�>h��|��twr\��mnlpxUz:mpxUlph��$�lp{��U������2�,-�B&?�)�*�� � �-9 CE!�FG����&?!��H !�, �}��w� � �Ê>��Ë �T�Ê���>}0��w�w�A�

�w�>��Â)� ������{|h��|�Ghw}Q.*� Â)�Qv tmnmptrQ}DÂ)� Æ��/.�j�|�GtU}Dve� >��ÅBlph�oI�kjz��D}�. � ���DÆD�stwrU��}DÆ�� gI�DÁel�j�n�ntU}���� Ä��Qåe{|zW�Utw�|�|��}Q��� gä�Q��tl�jrB}gä� �)�G.�h��n�|h:�s}ÅZ� U�wÆQh�h}wj!r���U� �ä�Gv twi8h���j!r��B�U�æv twoqi>lph��kh�rU�n{|�Gh���h:mph:tlptw�|t�w{|z�j�8��tA�Uh��|{|rk�)ys�>��mph�o ÉDÂe�b�±y8��3 ,;�&(��& � 72�,-�P&(�:7 � � A?�:7�}��wÊ � �wÊ �AÊA�w}���ÊÊG�s��>�w�)�)�Ay>jr��>xQ} U� Áä�A~�hWlnÇ�h:l�} U� Áä�A� �|two\}AÄ�� U�>yAi8h�hw}AÁä� Â)�>v�j!lpoq{|z���j!h���}Ajrk� � � �)�s�0t!mnl�j>�Q� h�rUzW�Uo�j!lp�A{|rk�b��mp{�� �Zg�ÄL�ntw�|�GhWlp�u<tlej!mpoqt�nik�Uh:lp{|z�zW�Uh�oq{|��mnln��iUlptw�U�|h�oq���n� �UÂet�nh�rA�Ulptsz���oqh:mp�ktA�>���L2�,-�B&(������ � ��9 C�!�FG�@��&(!��H !�,�}*�>��� �!� È Ê �T�!�sË�A}���ÊwÊwËA��G�A�)�)�Dy>jr��>xQ}kgI�8g�j!h��nz�xQ}8jr��3Áä� Â)�Bv�j!lpoq{|z���j!h����Zgb{�lph�zWm�jrk�±jw��ã�tw{|rsm��nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«�\jrkj���>�n{��Ztu�zW�Uh�oq{|z�j���>{|rUh:mp{|zä���>��mph�oq�ÇÀ{�mp�SI)��� �k� �qmp�kh�t!ln��jr����ntu<m�Ç�j�lph)mptst�|���N2�,-�P&(������ � ��9 C�!�FG����&(!��B !�,�} �wË � È � � � � È �Êw�A}��!�w���A����>�)�)�kyUjrk�Ux�jr��$gI�Ug�jh��nz:xQ�©gb{|�nz:lph:mph��e�!ã�t{|rAmp��u<tlbyAmp{����Zg�Ä©��� � � ��F?+(,;�9 &?� � � !���9R+(,-��&(!U}D����>���U�)�)�>y>h:{Djr��$ys�Uoqh:�'. ��� åZt!mphetr\v trk�n{|��mph�rkzW�$jr��$�Z��ã�t{�rsmprUh��n� t!u0åZxUoqh:lp{|z�j�8y>z��kh�oqh����QÅ�h:zW�Urk{|z�j�8ÂÃh�i8t!lnmÀv�y>Âe��v�ÉÅ�ÂeÊ ÈÈ �ËA}Bv h�rsmph:l�u<tleÂeh:�nh�j!lpz��\{|r\��j�l�j�|�|h��©v twoqiUxUm�j�mp{�trQ}UÂe{|z�hZ�Zrk{|�GhWlp�n{|m��s} GjrAx�j�ln����ÊwÊ È �� È �/.0��yA{|lp�wh��qjrk�@ÄÀ��Å�Þ�{|i8h:lpo�j!rQ� �0{|rU{|mph��U{��Dh:lph�rUz�h$tu�j�!ã«tw{|rsmqtl�j�!ã«tw{|rsmqtuÃè�rU{|mph��U{��Dh:lph:rkz�h � 3>&(! 7 �%�+(,@�� � M� F(7|}�wÊ � È �G�G�A}0��ÊÊGËA��w�>�)�Ã�0yAi8tlnmp{|�n�nhw���Ãr�j!r�j���>�n{|�)tu�ti8h:l�j!mpt!lä�niU�|{|mnmp{|rU��mph�z��krU{ÜÚsxUh���{|r�mp�khä��mp{��@z�j�nhw� 5 & � � !Q+ � &�O $'&?�<� � ,)+(,-��&?!Q+ �=� � A?�R��9:�p}���>��� �Ê �sÊ>�w}Q�!�w��>�

�GËA��Â)�~ j!xUm�j!l��D}A���A��h�h��Ao�jrUrQ}wjr��qÆ©�A��h�rAx>m��D�eiUik�|{|z�j!mp{|twrU� t!uBjw�!ã«tw{|rsm�oqtA�>h��|{�rU��{|r�j!mpoqtw�niU�kh:lp{|zÀz��kh�oq{|��mnln� �w�nh:rk�n{�mp{|�>{�m��j!r��${�rA�GhWlp�nh�oqtA�Uh��|{|rk�>��CE!�FG����&(!��H !�,)+ � 3>& �# � �@! "H+(!��B0Q&�O ,��L+?�RW}�� È � Ë��� �AË�wÊA}���w��>�� � �����0�wj!ræÆBtstwrB}���� U� ����� xk{|��m�ã�h���}�j!r��@��� U��yAh��wh:lp���Lg�j!m�j3j!�n�n{�oq{|��j!mp{|tr tuetwÞ:twrkh�{|r@mp�Uh�j�mpoqtw�niU�kh:lp{|z�mnl�jrk�ni8t!lnmqj!r��z��kh:oq{���mnln��oqtA�>h��BÆ �bÅ ��y8��CE!�FG����&(!��H !�,)+ � 3>& �# � �@! "H+(!��B0Q&�O ,��L+?�RW}0� È � �w��� �A��wÊA}Q��w��>��wÊ>� >�G~�h:lnÇ�h:l�}GÄÀ� U�Ay>i8h�hw} U�>Áä�G� �|two\}sj!r�� . �w�ZxUrk�p�Ut!lnu`h:l��8� �nh�z�tr���tl��>h:l�Âet�nh�rA�Ulptsz��Ioqh:mp�UtA��jiUik�|{|h��ämpt)ik�Utmptsz��kh�o�É{|z�j!���>{|�ni8h:lp�n{|twr±iUlpt�k�|h�oq���E0 1�243 5 & � � !Q+ � &(! 0Q9:�) !�,-� �L9H$'&(�<� � ,-��!#"}D�!� �|��� È � �k��� � �>}©��ÊwÊwÊA�

È �>� I�� �ä��.4j!rk�>}�gI� U�DÆQj!ln�s}kgI� ÄÀ�ByA��j!���|z:lpt�n��}D�bj!���0yD� ���|}Bjrk�\�©�>�|h�U� ���Ã�*lph��A{|h:Ç twr±mp�kh�xU�nhät!u�mp�Uh)jw��ã�tw{|rsmboqhWmp�ktA��{|ru<twx>lnÉ«�>{|oqh�rk�n{|twrkj�Qj!mpoqt�nik�khWlp{�zWÉ�z��kh:oq{���mnln�$�Uj!m�j�j!�n�n{|oq{���j�mp{�trQ�/��7 5*7 M 7 3 ,;�&(��& � 7=0Q&G9 7�}B���Ë>ß È Ë!�±ßd��j!lnme��ànà � �A� � � �A�w�!��U}�!�w�A�w�

È �w�D�ä� U� ��j!rk�U} ��� ÅZ� �b�Uo�jrB}©jrk�æ�)� Áä� ÂÃxk�n�nh��|��� ��j��mqmp�>lph�h:É��U{|oqh�rU�n{�tr�j!�Ã�nh:rk�n{�mp{|�>{�m��ÿjr�j!���U�n{|��tubik�kt!mptszW�Uh�oq{|z�j�Àj!{�lÚsxkj�|{�m«�boqtA�>h��|� ��j!räj!ikiU��{|z�j�mp{|twr)mpt��ntwxUmp�Uh:lpräv�j�|{�u`t!lprk{�j>� � ��&G9 R��(��! "(��&�O�,@��'2����L+(!�� �S+?� ,;'3>+?!Q+G"# �B !�,Q2D�R� &G9:��+(,-��&?!�� �2�!�! � + � 3 R ,-��! " +(!���C 2 �#� � ��,-��&(!U}�Ê � É�. ��Ë��äßd�w�wà � �A}0��ÊwÊ � �

È �A�D�ä� U�8� jrU�U} U� Áä� . {|�|�A{�rU�ntwrB}©��� ÅZ� �b�>o�jrQ}Qj!r����)� Áä��ÂexU�n�nh��|��� �ZÞ�trkhq�nh�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«�Ljrk�LxkrUz�h:lnm�j!{�rsm��Lj!r�j!�|�>�n{|�IxU�n{|rk�gZg)��É��g*{|r±jäik�kt!mptszW�Uh�oq{|z�j�Bj!{|leÚsx�j!�|{|m��$oqtA�Uh����L2���� � & ��� � ,-��&?!%3 & �# � ��! "H+(!��H��,-�N2�� � � ��9R+(,-��&(!��41�1�1 , � ��&G9 ��(�@! "(��&�O,@���� ��� ��2 ���� $E$ 3 0S1 !�,; � !Q+(,-�-&(!Q+ � � �9 � !���9R+ � 3 R ,-��! " &?!%2��@� � & �@� � ,-�-&(!S3>& �# ��� ��!#" +(!��P1 ,-�<2L�J� � �-9 +?,-��&(!k}k~ j�lpr�jA}��xk�|�Gj�lp{Üj �|� � � ����Ê�U}0���w�A�

� �§� � � ��ò��9��òÃó��$ù�ò�����ô2� õ�ö �� ��ò�ö ùpó�� �áö �kõÃù�òeó5)= 9Ü= � =D9�ü:NOW9Ü[±;>^ÀýQN7�ü:CD7:ûB;sü:9ÜTU=\À$H � 9<=ÿü:]DN\9Ü=D9ÜüW9`;A^ÀO�ü:;AüWN ��9<^Ü^�9<=B68CBJ!N±;�þs;>7W9`;sü:9ÜTU=dÀ � 9Ü=æüW]DN\7:NOWýQTU=BOWN$cdCD=QJ�üW9<T>=Q;A^)3!02�MBa�T � 7:O�ü�T>7�68N!7);>ýDýD7:T.��9<[±;sü:9ÜTU=©F

À � e � �°�� �¢y ��� À$H�)~yI���"2v c+�c@H � H�)&yI���"2 � ��� )3! � 2

��]DN!7:N�üW]BN)ýQN7�ü:CD7:ûB;sü:9ÜTU=BO4À$H�)&yI��� 2�9<=\üW]DNIJ�T>=QJ�N!=kü:7:;AüW9<T>= � N!^`6DOe;A7:N�T>û8ü�;A9<=DN6\û�V\O�TU^Üþ�9<=DS�üW]DN�ü:;>=DS>N=UüÀ^<9<=DN;>7Ã[\T868N!^c@À$HKJc�y e8zP<7v�{�À$HKJ>| �? {8v�)&?*=\{�À$HKJ 2�| " J ² � )&?"H�2�À$H���yY�VN�y�N�� )3! �>;�2

À$HKJ )~yY�¢���(24eQÀ$HI�J )~�(2t� )3! �Aû 2À$HKJ )~yI���(24eQÀ$H ikjJ )~yI��� 24e � cdTU7��(�(g ikj � )3! �>J�2= c@À$HKJ

c>� e � cdT>7��(�(g npo@q � )3! �>6F2= c@À$HKJ

c>� e 0tU�WYXJ À$HKJ cdTU7��(�Cg rps � )3! �AN12

� =4üW]DN\;Aû�Tsþ>N " 9`O�üW]DN �U;UJ�TUûD9<;>=�TAc�üW]BN�cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>= ] F�;>=B6 " J ² � 68N=DTAü:NO)9Üü:O^L ��ü:]@7:T��qM� N$7:N�cdN!7äüWT )3! �>;�2�� )7!!�AN.2b;>OüW]DN��Y�$Á*Â��+Á/�3£Ã��Á>� �$�t ����¢�+£D;>O:O�T8J�9`;sü:N6E��9�ü:]�ü:]DN�cdT>7 �b;A7�63[\T868N!^J)��;02¥� )��!N.2�M � =4;\J�T>[\ýB;UJ�ü�=DT>ü:;sü:9ÜTU=c>À$Hc>y e�� )&H")~y�2�2�À$H¡��yY�VN�y�N � )3!L/�2

Page 31: 0 21 34people.cs.vt.edu/asandu/Deposit/stem_adjoint.pdf · 2005-10-22 · lpt t w{|z j! Bèkh U Uy>h: Gh:l j 8{| | |xk mnl j mp{ wh kj m jäj! n n{ oq{| j!mp{|t r lph nxU mp {|rjÃm«ÇÀ{|rh:â>i8h:lp{|oqh

�Z�!ã«tw{|rsmey>h�rU�n{�mp{��A{�m«���Ãr�j���>�n{|�Àtu©ÂÃh��w{|twrkj�Q�e{�l��Zx�j!��{�m��\��tA�>h��|� �>���9�ü:]æü:]DN±9<=D9�ü:9<;>^ÀJ�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>= )3!!�>û 2�M�ab]DN±68T>[±;A9<=��#) ��2�TAceüW]DN±^<9Ü=BN;A7:9N�!N6 J�TU=�þ>NJ�üW9<T>=L�n689D��CQO�9<T>=L��7:N;>J�üW9<T>=4TUýQN7:;AüWT>7� )&H�209<O©ü:;"�>N!=�;>O�üW]DNÃOWCDûBOWýB;UJ�N�� 3 )�� y � ���B��� 3�P�)�`�2�2�� ��� � 3�E")�� y � ���B�����ÃP�)�`�2�2�� � T>cUü:]DNJ-)9<^<ûQN7�ü�OWýB;UJ�N ���ÃP�)�)~y � ��� 2 �§` 2�� �J�T>=QOpü:7:;>9Ü=DNw63û�V±ü:]DN�ûQTUCD=B6D;>7WV�J!T>=B6D9�ü:9ÜTU=BO�)3!!�UJ � !!�>N12�M � =�üW]DN�6D9Ü7:NJ�ü�OWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV3;>=B;A^<V8O�9`Ob;AýDýD7:TU;UJ�]3T>=BN�OWT>^<þ>NwOeüW]DN[�T868N^ )��;02¥� )��!N.2�üWTUS>N!üW]DN7 ��9ÜüW] ü:]DN�ü�;A=DSUN!=kü$^<9Ü=BN;A7�[\T868N!^�)3! �>;�2�� )7!!�AN.2äcdT>7 �Z;>7:6 9<= ü:9Ü[\N )dcdT>7�N;UJ�] ýB;A7�;A[\N!üWN!7;A= ;>6D6D9�ü:9ÜTU=B;A^ZO�N=BO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpVæN�kCB;AüW9<T>= [$CBO�ü$û�N�OWT>^<þ>N6 2�M�ab]DN�N�kCB;sü:9ÜTU=BO )7!!�>;02¥�<)3!!�>N12I;A7:N\TAc)J�TU=�þ>NJ�üW9<T>=L�n689D��CQO�9<T>=L�7WNw;>J�ü:9ÜTU=4üpV�ýQN )7��9�ü:]æ^<9Ü=BN;A7:9N�!N6æJ�]DN![\9`Opü:7WV�2ä;A=B6ÿ9Ü= ýD7�;>J�üW9`J�N\;A7:N�OWT>^<þ>N6ÿû�V�üW]DN±O:;A[\N$=�CD[\N!7:9`J!;A^�[\N�ü:]DT86æ;UOäüW]DNcdT>7 �Z;>7:6�[�T868N^J)*,�2¥�<)7��2�ADJ�TU[�ýBC8ü:;AüW9<T>=B;>^©OW;Gþ�9<=DSUOb;A7:NIýQTkOWOW9ÜûB^ÜNqû�V37:N!CBOW9<=DS�üW]DN�O:;A[\N�[±;süW7:9D�3cÐ;>J�üWT>7:9N�;sü:9ÜTU=BO�� � ����M

ab]DNÃ;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�[�N!üW]DT86q[±;GVIûQNeCBOWN6�ü:T)ýD7:Tsþk9`68NÀ;>=�N��8ýD^<9<J!9�ü�68N!ý�N!=Q68N!=BJ!NÃT>ckü:]DNÃ7:NOWý�T>=BOWN�cdCD=BJ�üW9<T>=B;>^>ü:T�þs;A7:9<;AüW9<T>=BO9Ü=LüW]BNqýB;A7�;A[\N�ü:N!7�O!M8ab]DNq;U6.HpT>9<=kü)T>ý�N!7�;süWTU7

� � )�H�2��SeQ{8v�)~<��(2�|�{8v�� ?*=\{ � ? | " � )~?*H�2��9<O)6DN�üWN7W[\9<=DN6�cd7:T>[ ü:]DN 4�;>S>7�;A=DSUN�9`68N!=kü:9�üpV

� �° � ��y � � � )&H�2�À$HRv �+�¢�Se � �° � �¢y � �¡À$H�v � � )&H�2��+�¢� �@À$H^���#) ��2I�� �C� ��) � � 2w� )3!0&�2

ab]DNL6DT>[±;A9<=��#) � �12$TAc)ü:]DNL;U6.HpT>9<=kü�TUýQN7:;AüWTU7$9`O$ü:]DN4O�CBûBO�ýQ;>J�N�TAc � 3 )�� y � ���B��� 3�P�)�` 2�2 � ��� � 3�E")�� y � ���B�����ÃP")�` 2�2 � �J�T>=QOpü:7:;>9Ü=DNw6 û�V üW]BN�û�T>CD=Q6D;A7:V J�TU=B689ÜüW9<T>=BO+) � J � � N.2�M�K)N��küwF�üW]DN�9<=D=DN7�ýB7WT868CBJ�ü�T>cI)7! /�2 ��9ÜüW] �?)&yI���(2�9`O�ü:;"�>N!= 9Ü=� �ÃP�)�)~y � ��� 2 �§`�2 � � ü:T±T>û8ü�;A9<= � �° � ��y>��� c@À$Hc�y v �+�¢�Se � �° � �¢y*�+��� )�H�)~y�2�2�À$HPv;���¢� )3! ��2

5�c�üWN7)9<=Uü:N!SU7:;AüW9<=DS�û�V�ýB;A7Wü:Ob;A=Q6�CQO�9<=DS )3!0&�2e9�ü�cdTU^Ü^<T��)OZüW]Q;sü

� � À$H")~� 2�v �?)&� 2 ���7z�� � À$H�)&yY�.2v;�?)&yY�.2��¢�Ce � �° � ��y>� � � c��c>y | � � )&H�2�� v�À$H��

� c �%)~yI���(2R���#) � � 2Z9<O�6DN � =DNw6�;>OZüW]BN�O�TU^ÜC8ü:9ÜTU=�T>c�ü:]DN�;>6�HpT>9<=Uü�ýD7:T>ûB^ÜN[c��c>y e8z � � )&H�2 ��z c+�

c@H � H�)~yI���(2 � ) � �>;�2�%)~� 2 e � ) � �Aû 2üW]DN=

À � e �+��À$HI�Mv;�?)&yY�.2��¢�O�CBJ�]�üW]Q;sü �%)~y � ���(2Z7:N!ýB7WNwO�N=Uü�OZüW]DN�OWN!=QO�9ÜüW9<þ�9�üpV±ü:T\9Ü=D9ÜüW9`;A^�J�T>=Q689�ü:9ÜTU=BOM