'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus:...

24
Maribel FIERRO C.S.LC., Madrid 1. QÜ@-s who ruled in al-Andalus In this section, 1 have collected information on those Andalusian qüg-s who acted as rulers during the 5thIl lth and the first half of the 6thl12th centuries. 1 start hy the judges who took power at the beginning of the Taifas period; then follow the cases of Ihn Muzayn, who seems to have started his rule in 44011048, and that of Ibn Jamaf, whose rebellion took place at the end of the Taifas and the beginning of the Almoravid period. Then the q6 . s of the towns which rebelled against the Almoravids are shidied. The main question 1 am asking is: did the fact that there were qüg-s acting as rulers mean that it was thought that they were entitled to rule as qÜ@-S? In other words, in times when the question of the imamate was open and there were contending parties with different answers, was the rule of the qÜ@-s one of the answers? We shall see first how, why and for how long those judges came to rule. The3ifth/eleventh century There is no monographic study on the Andalusian judges who took power into their hands diiring the Sthlllth century. In the general histories, the rule of the qü4-s is iisually stressed as a proof of the importance held by judges in al-Andalus without further analysis. At the same time, in the extaut studies where the subject has been dealt with, there is conhsing information ahout who actually were those qü&s. To the hest of my knowledge, there were four cases of judges who ruled in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT Bakr MNammad b. Sa'id h. Muzayn of Silves, and Ihn Jahhif of Valencia. 1 do not take into ' 1 wish to thank al1 the participnnts in tlie Symposium wliere this paperwas read for thcir comments and suggestiuns.

Transcript of 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus:...

Page 1: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT

70 HALIMA FARHAT

A partir du XIII' siecle Sabta fournit la Cour de Fes les puissants secrétaires de chancellerie, prenant ainsi le relais des cités andalouses, désertees par les helles-lettres. Pour illustrer ce changement historique et culturel, Ibn Haldün prend I'exemple de la célebre famille sabtie des Banü 'Abd al-Muhayman. 11 observe que "la fonction de plume. comptabilité et correspondance revient d celui qui en a la compétence". Mais il ajoute aussit6t que "tant6t c'est le monopole d'une ce'faine ,famille, fant8t elle parme fe privil2ge avec d á ~ t r e s " ~ ' . Désormais le talent seul ne wiftit plus poiir faire carriere dans les lettres et la haute administration. Soliclarité clanique et patrimoine familial sont largement pris en considération et le talent perd la premiere place.

Maribel FIERRO C.S.LC., Madrid

1. QÜ@-s who ruled in al-Andalus

In this section, 1 have collected information on those Andalusian qüg-s who acted as rulers during the 5thIl lth and the first half of the 6thl12th centuries. 1 start hy the judges who took power at the beginning of the Taifas period; then follow the cases of Ihn Muzayn, who seems to have started his rule in 44011048, and that of Ibn Jamaf, whose rebellion took place at the end of the Taifas and the beginning of the Almoravid period. Then the q6.s of the towns which rebelled against the Almoravids are shidied.

The main question 1 am asking is: did the fact that there were qüg-s acting as rulers mean that it was thought that they were entitled to rule as qÜ@-S? In other words, in times when the question of the imamate was open and there were contending parties with different answers, was the rule of the qÜ@-s one of the answers? We shall see first how, why and for how long those judges came to rule.

The3ifth/eleventh century

There is no monographic study on the Andalusian judges who took power into their hands diiring the Sthlllth century. In the general histories, the rule of the qü4-s is iisually stressed as a proof of the importance held by judges in al-Andalus without further analysis. At the same time, in the extaut studies where the subject has been dealt with, there is conhsing information ahout who actually were those qü&s. To the hest of my knowledge, there were four cases of judges who ruled in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT Bakr MNammad b. Sa'id h. Muzayn of Silves, and Ihn Jahhif of Valencia. 1 do not take into

' 1 wish to thank al1 the participnnts in tlie Symposium wliere this paperwas read for thcir comments and suggestiuns.

Page 2: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 3: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 4: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 5: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 6: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 7: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 8: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 9: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 10: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 11: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 12: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 13: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 14: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 15: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 16: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 17: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 18: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 19: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 20: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 21: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 22: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 23: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT
Page 24: 'isidigital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/12303/1/FIERRO-QADI AS... · 2017-03-21 · in al-Andalus: Ya'ish h. Muhammad of Toledo, Muhammad h. Ismi'il h. 'Abbid in Sevilla, 'isi h. AbT